In short
Motherhood and grief after the Oct. 7, 2023 hostage crisis—arguing that love can coexist with trauma, “tragic optimism,” and moral clarity; also how Rachel Goldberg-Polin coped publicly during 330 days of trying to bring her son Hirsch home.
Guest background
Rachel Goldberg-Polin is a Chicago-born Jewish mother whose son Hirsch was taken hostage in Israel during the Oct. 7 attacks. She and her husband John campaigned publicly for 330 days; Hirsch was murdered in captivity. She is the author of When We See You Again (New York Times bestseller).
Key claims
Hate “peters out”; love outlives death. Grief can be a “disorder” (“I Still Love My Son”)—love remains even when life is shattered. “Tragic optimism” (Viktor Frankl) means staying committed to meaning despite being wounded. People should avoid “toxic positivity” and simplistic “us vs. them” moral framing.
Notable examples
Hirsch’s “why can bear any how” mantra; the tape she wore counting days (day 26 onward) that spread worldwide; her “beige life” ending on Oct. 7; and her insistence on also mourning innocent civilians in Gaza while advocating for hostages.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOExploring the Depths of Motherhood and Love
2:27 to 6:12
A deep dive into love, loss, and the resilience of motherhood.
“and our own ways of thinking by daring to ask, What if?”
The Power of a Mother's Love
6:12 to 6:43
Discussion on the endless nature of a mother's love and its recognition.
“is if love is what makes loss unbearable, is it also the thing that makes life worth enduring?”
Rachel's Early Life and Identity
6:43 to 7:20
Rachel shares her background, Jewish heritage, and family life.
“It's time to question everything with Rachel Goldberg-Polland.”
Experiences of Motherhood
7:20 to 8:00
Rachel discusses her experiences and challenges in becoming a mother.
“He was in seventh grade, so I'm a little bit of a cougar, but that was when we met.”
Reflections on Childcare and Society
8:00 to 8:20
Insights on the societal perceptions of motherhood and childcare roles.
“And John was working as a brand manager at a big company out there.”
Life in Richmond and Family Dynamics
8:20 to 10:00
Rachel describes her family's life and community in Richmond, Virginia.
“And I really didn't have any background with childcare.”
Remembering Hirsch: A Mother's Perspective
10:00 to 11:28
Rachel offers insights into her son Hirsch's character and legacy.
“and it was a really lovely, quiet, beautiful, easy life.”
Understanding Grief and Connection
11:28 to 14:00
Exploration of grief, connection, and the complexities of loss.
“So much of Hirsch's story has been told through what happened to him.”
Cherishing Memories of Hirsch
14:00 to 18:19
The speaker reflects on the unique qualities of Hirsch and the importance of recognizing loved ones while they are alive.
“Why do you want to hear why someone who's espousing opinions that are counter to your worldview?”
The Day Everything Changed
18:58 to 24:13
The narrator recounts the events of October 7th, marking a significant shift in their life and the impact it had on their family.
“Find your own Myrtle moment at visitmyrtlebeach.com.”
Show all 24 chapters
Navigating Grief and Action
24:14 to 28:00
The speaker discusses the immediate reactions to tragedy and the drive to take action, despite overwhelming grief.
“How did you choose to spring into action and be vocal versus wanting to wait and see how things go?”
The Burden of Hope and Pain
28:00 to 29:20
Discussing the emotional toll of hope and grief during trauma.
“You have tremendous faith in me, which I love because normally I think the dynamic that we learn is that we're supposed to have faith in God and yet the very first thing we're supposed to say is, wow, I'm back today.”
A Mother's Experience of War
29:20 to 30:20
Sharing the harrowing experiences of witnessing a child's trauma.
“of immense, exhausting, beseeching, begging, scraping, pleading, running, burning.”
Final Words and Last Goodbyes
30:20 to 32:20
Exploring the impact of final words exchanged between a mother and her son.
“He chose to sit up and he puts his head down in the crook of what's left of his arm.”
The Nature of Grief and Disorder
32:20 to 34:10
Reflecting on societal perceptions of grief and personal disorder.
“And, you know, in Israel, when they bury people, we don't use coffins.”
The Power of Collective Grief
35:40 to 37:50
Discussing the unifying power of grief and collective love for the lost.
“You're with your spouse at a seaside botanical garden.”
The Symbol of Tape and Public Support
37:50 to 42:00
Describing the symbolic use of tape to mark the days of waiting for a loved one.
“So when I've had these experiences speaking to people and they have the right human, empathetic, kind, merciful, compassionate, graceful response, I think it's the most beautiful personification of the human experience.”
Navigating Pain and Support During Crisis
42:04 to 45:30
Learn about the complexities of handling grief and how support can sometimes feel overwhelming.
“And we kept wearing the number until day 843 when the final hostage was returned back so his family could bury him.”
The Process of Writing Through Suffering
45:31 to 47:44
Discover why the guest wrote her book amidst intense personal pain and its impact.
“And the way you wrote it, showcase that to me, there are a lot of moments of these staccato sentences and space.”
Holding Multiple Truths in Times of Conflict
47:45 to 50:29
Understand the importance of acknowledging diverse experiences during crises.
“And she said, no, no, it's an actual term.”
Spiritual Perspectives on Suffering and Understanding
50:30 to 56:00
Explore how spirituality influences perceptions of suffering and the greater tapestry of life.
“You can see it in the way a fabric moves, recognize it in a flawless fit, and appreciate it in the details that make our styles unique.”
The Perspective of Loss
56:00 to 57:58
Explore the profound insights on grief and love derived from loss.
“tapestry that we are generally not privy to understand and see the whole entire work.”
Love as a Driving Force
57:58 to 1:02:02
Understand the transformative power of love amidst suffering and loss.
“I have friends who have lost their children to cancer.”
Finding Meaning After Tragedy
1:02:02 to 1:04:52
Learn how to seek purpose and kindness in the wake of tragedy.
“You know, I did bury grandparents, but I think that I very much expected that one day I was going to bury them and I had wonderful relationships with them and nobody had a horrible death.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. You know what quality feels like. You can see it in the way a fabric moves, recognize it in a flawless fit, and appreciate it in the details that make our styles unique. It's the standard Coldwater Creek has honored for over 40 years, derived from a rich Mountain West heritage, and designed for today in styles that are distinctively Coldwater Creek. For a wardrobe you can count on season after season, visit ColdwaterCreek.com. Shop new arrivals and save 15 % on purchases$75 or more with code IHEART. This is Andrea Gunning from Betrayal. Find home wherever you roam.
0:38At Sinesta ES and Simply Suites. Where longer stays feel comfortable, flexible, and easy. Stretch out and enjoy spacious accommodations and home-like amenities designed to help you settle in and stay productive or relaxed for however long you need. And when you're a Sinesta Travel Pass member, Staying at Sinesta ES and Simply Suites means earning points towards free nights, upgrades, and more with every eligible stay. Go to Sinesta.com to book your stay and unlock the best rates with Sinesta Travel Pass. Here today, Rome tomorrow. Join now at Sinesta.com. Terms and conditions apply. Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile.
1:18I don't know if you knew this, but anyone can get the same premium wireless for$15 a month plan that I've been enjoying. It's not just for celebrities. So do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you to Mint Mobile today. I'm told it's super easy to do at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for three-month plan equivalent to$15 per month required. Intro rate first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See full terms at mintmobile.com. Garnier is proudly partnering with the National Park Foundation, the official nonprofit partner of the National Park Service.
1:53Garnier's support of the National Park Foundation's Service Corps program is enabling young adults and veterans to help care for and enhance the national parks that we all love. Want to lend a hand? Explore Garnier's partnership with the National Park Foundation and learn how you can help support our national parks at garnierusa.com slash NPF.
2:14No one has all the answers, but when we ask the right questions, we get a little closer. Closer to truths. Closer to each other. Even closer to ourselves. I'm journalist Danielle Robay, and each week my guests and I come together to challenge the status quo and our own ways of thinking by daring to ask, What if? Why not? And who says? So come curious, dig deep, and join the conversation. It's time to question everything. When we celebrate Mother's Day, so much of the focus is on what our mothers gave us. The lessons they taught us, the sacrifices they made, the ways they shaped who we became. But today's conversation explores a different side of motherhood.
3:06What love looks like when it's asked to survive the unbearable. Now a few months ago, I was asked to speak to 450 Jewish women in Atlanta about Jewish joy. And I really wrestled with it because if I'm being honest, I didn't and I don't feel joyful yet. The wound of October 7th still feels raw. I scroll through my phone and I see anti-Semitic rhetoric. I read about Jews gunned down in D.C. and Bondi Beach. And nearly every day I walk to get coffee in my L.A. neighborhood. And I often think about Rachel Goldberg-Pollin and her son Hirsch and all of the hostages and survivors. And sometimes I would just have a little cry to myself.
3:43So when I sat down to write that speech, Rachel was already in my head and in my heart. This woman I'd never met, whose pain I'd been carrying alongside her from thousands of miles away. And then somehow she was sitting across from me. I'm still a little stunned by it, grateful beyond words for her time and her trust and her willingness to let me ask questions that I'd been holding for the last several years. For those who don't know her story, Rachel Goldberg-Polland became known to the world after her son Hirsch was taken hostage during the October 7th attacks in Israel. For 330 days, Rachel and her husband fought publicly and relentlessly to bring Hirsch home alive.
4:26The world watched a mother refuse to surrender hope in real time. Hirsch was eventually murdered in captivity. And yet, even in the wake of unspeakable tragedy, Rachel emerged not consumed by hatred, but as a voice of extraordinary humanity, compassion, moral clarity, and love. I think hate peters out. I really do. I think that the strongest force that outlives time and outlives death is love. She's also become a voice for those who are in the depths of their grief, drowning with no life rafts. Rather than trying to push this feeling away, She's embraced it as a price that she will pay for the cost of love.
5:06I read an article by the American Psychiatric Association a few weeks ago that said, if you're still breathing after six months, then you have a disorder. And I was like, I have a disorder. And I'm actually very proud of this disorder. It's called I Still Love My Son. The love is still here. Love is stronger than death. But I am disordered. She continues to shine a light on Hirsch's life while navigating the enormity of his loss. Something she writes about with devastating honesty in her new book, When We See You Again, which is now a New York Times bestseller. What I came to understand in our conversation is that almost everything Rachel says orbits this one idea.
5:46It's something she names explicitly. Tragic optimism. It's a Viktor Frankl concept, and it's the idea that you can be wounded or disordered, still bleeding, and simultaneously committed to love, to faith, and meaning. Hirsch's own mantra in captivity was borrowed from Frankel. He who has a why can bear any how. So the question we're circling today, the one at the center of today's episode, is if love is what makes loss unbearable, is it also the thing that makes life worth enduring? Today's conversation is in honor of the limitless power of a mother's love, A force that reverberates for billions of people 365 days a year, often quietly, often without recognition, and without condition.
6:31It is endless. So to all the women who mother someone or something with their whole heart, who have a mother or mother figure they love, or who feel the absence of a mother, this episode is for you. It's time to question everything with Rachel Goldberg-Polland.
6:55Rachel, before we get into your book, I really want to talk about you. You grew up in Chicago in a Jewish family similar to me, and you grew up falling in love with your Jewish heritage. You had educational and professional experiences that helped you build that part of your identity, and I was so heartened in the book to read that that's kind of how you met John. I mean, I switched into the same school that he was in when I was in eighth grade. He was in seventh grade, so I'm a little bit of a cougar, but that was when we met. We were actually the same height when we met, and I'm still that height, and he's now 14 inches taller.
7:33He's so lucky he grew. Right, me also, because our kids had a fighting chance. Did you always want to become a mom? I think that when I was growing up in the 70s and 80s, I wouldn't have thought anything otherwise, so definitely. It was something that you always had on your mind. I didn't have it on my mind. I just thought it was part of growing up, what would happen. And then when you had Hirsch, who was your firstborn, you decided to stay home with him for a little bit? We were living in Berkeley, California at the time, and I was teaching in the Jewish day school there. And John was working as a brand manager at a big company out there.
8:08And we sort of had that conversation of, it makes sense that one of us should stay home because paying for childcare would have been more than what I was making. And so we realized I should be the one who stays home. And I really didn't have any background with childcare. And it was a learning curve as it is for most first-time parents. But I was also very acutely aware that it was a magical time that was fleeting. I mean, we got into a rhythm and I really did enjoy it, but it was definitely hard. It was challenging. Challenging because you have a mind that is always going and it was hard to be home or in what way?
8:48No, I think it was just challenging because it was something new and it required a tremendous amount of patience. And there was never any off time. In my experience, you know, when I was teaching, I would show up at school at eight o 'clock and by three o 'clock I was done. But when you're staying home full time, all the time, there's very little downtime. And there's always something going on that you feel like you should be doing. So I think that that was sort of a challenge that I think is really common with people who are at home with children or people who work with children full time. I remember being at the park once and getting into a conversation with someone and they said, wow, it's the hardest job, the job you have.
9:28And then all of a sudden he said, oh, that's your son. Oh, so you don't work. And I was like a second ago, that was the hardest job there is, you know, when he thought that I was the caregiver for this child. But he didn't understand that I was this child's mother. So I think sometimes that's not as appreciated as much as it should be. The whole vocation of child care. And then you eventually expanded your family. You had two more daughters, Levy and Orly. Was your life what you had imagined at that point? I felt very much blessed and lucky. We had moved at that point. We were living in Richmond, Virginia.
10:04and it was a really lovely, quiet, beautiful, easy life. And I felt extremely kissed by the universe. I had a very lovely community that we were part of and I was working in adult Jewish education in the community there. And John had a job that he liked and our house was very comfortable because it was very affordable in Richmond, Virginia. and the kids were great. It was just a very easy, busy life. In the book, you call it beige. No, I think it's very average. I felt blessed and I felt normal. Did you want beige? I think I did. I also think, you know, I grew up, my parents are divorced. I was an only child from their marriage downtown in the city in Chicago, which I loved, but it was very different from that new construct of pretty much suburban lifestyle.
11:04I'd never lived in a single family house until moving to Richmond. And having three kids to me felt like a huge family coming from being an only child. And having this very, I think, healthy, normal relationship with John felt like a real blessing. I really appreciate the way you speak about him. The word like real partner comes up for me a lot when you talk about him. So much of Hirsch's story has been told through what happened to him. And I'd love to know about your son through your words. How do you describe him? Well, I try to be very careful when talking about Hirsch because I think that in general, especially when there is a tragic death of someone young, we tend to mythologize and lionize and heroicize them, which a dear friend of mine who's a writer, Monty Friedman talks about the heroization of young people ends up actually flattening them.
12:07It hollows them because they're defined by sort of their final moments and it negates everything that came before. So I try to be very careful within that framework. That's so thoughtful. Well, I think that I've seen it since October 7th, 2023 with every single young person and old person, by the way, who was lost since then, somehow, all of them are heroes, all of them. And I think that there's something that at a certain point, you know, when you start saying a word over and over again, and then the word doesn't have a meaning anymore. And so I'm careful, because I do think that every single person was a unique person.
12:49We have this saying in Judaism that every person is a world unto themselves. And so everyone was a whole entire world. That doesn't mean that every single person was perfect. And obviously, I adore Hirsch. He was the person who turned me from a daughter, a friend, a wife into this new being of mother. I think it in many ways changed the DNA of who I am in the world. Look, he was funny with a dry sense of humor that was sarcastic without being mean, which is very hard because usually sarcasm comes with meanness, but there wasn't meanness. He was very curious, hungry curious in a way that I try to sort of emulate because he wasn't threatened.
13:34He was curious by people who were different than he was. And I feel like I'm not like that. I would like to be more like that. I think we generally sort of corner ourselves into these echo chambers, especially now, and we hand select who we hear our news from, who is in our pocket on this screen, who we read, who we interact with. And he would say, I want to understand why he thinks like he thinks. And I remember even saying to John, why? Why do you want to hear why someone who's espousing opinions that are counter to your worldview? But that was really different. And I also think that he was a radical listener, which is so hard to come by.
14:16So that's something that I thought was special about him. And he had this quiet, gentle respect for John and me that I really appreciated. I always appreciated while he was alive. And I'm thankful that I recognized it because sometimes I think we don't realize what we have until we don't have that treasure. And I was very aware and John was very aware. So we're thankful that we were cognizant of that. There's something you shared in the book that I just loved reading about him. He had this thirst for travel. And so he was going to go on this two-year trip around the world. And he had gotten to do sort of a mini trip to Europe.
14:56And he was going to these dance festivals. And you said, are you sure you want to do this alone? And he said, mama, if you go in a clump, you stay in a clump. It exemplified so much of what you're sharing. He was so open to the world. And what's interesting about that is that's why the photos that we had to use after he was stolen on October 7th, we had this problem because we're actually not a big photography family. I'm really now impressed with families who do that because we had this big problem needing to get his photograph out there and we didn't have any recent photos of him. And so my daughters, who of course I know nothing about social media, but they started to write to all of these festivals that he had gone to the summer of 2023.
15:41And all of these people who had met him started to send us photos. And those are the photos that were used during the struggle to get him home because people had met him from all over the world. And that was really beautiful. And we're still in touch with a lot of these people who met him during that nine-week trip that he took on his own with his teeny tiny backpack and two pair of underwear. And he said, Mama, don't worry, there are rivers. And I thought, how does that justify only taking two pair of underwear? And what rivers in Europe? I mean, he did see actual proof. There were rivers, or maybe there were more streams, or like a little creek.
16:19I got to hear you speak in New York at Temple Bethel. And you were talking there about the importance of a name, and that we sort of live into our names. And so when you say Hirsch's name, what do you want us to hear? First of all, the name Hirsch is actually a Yiddish name that means deer, the animal. And after Hirsch was killed, my daughter Libby bought me a small little deer that I keep on my bedside table. And I travel with it. I have it in my bag here. And I think about what qualities does a deer have? Because what you're referring to is that in the Jewish tradition, we actually believe that parents are divinely inspired once in their lives.
17:01and it's the moment they give their children their names. And that's why sometimes we know stories where people say, I was going to name him Solomon. And then all of a sudden when the rabbi said, and his name is, and they said, David. And we believe it's entwined with what your path will unfold to be. And so I think about how a deer is a gentle animal, that it's life and very sort of unassuming. it doesn't need all the bells and whistles. It's a modest animal. And I think that there are echoes of Hirsch in that. And I think of deer as being very innocent.
17:48You know what quality feels like. You can see it in the way a fabric moves, recognize it in a flawless fit, and appreciate it in the details that make our styles unique. It's the standard Coldwater Creek has honored for over 40 years, derived from a rich Mountain West heritage, and designed for today in styles that are distinctively Coldwater Creek. For a wardrobe you can count on season after season, visit ColdwaterCreek.com, shop new arrivals, and save 15 % on purchases$75 or more with code IHEART. This is Andrea Gunning from Betrayal. Travel smarter, not harder. And America's Best Value In by Sinesta.
18:25with convenient locations from coast to coast and value-packed comfort at every turn. It's a practical choice for road trips, quick getaways, and everyday travel that keeps things simple without sacrificing comfort. And when you're a Sonesta Travel Pass member, staying at America's Best Value Inn means earning points towards free nights, upgrades, and more every time you stay. Go to Sonesta.com to book your stay and unlock the best rates with Sonesta Travel Pass. Here today, Rome tomorrow. Join now at Sinesta.com. Terms and conditions apply.
19:24dream about it. Find your own Myrtle moment at visitmyrtlebeach.com. From sauce to dust to nuggets, it's Taco Bell's new Diablo dusted crispy chicken nuggets. Are they mild? If they were mild, then I have to change the name to little rascal nuggets or minor nuisance nuggets. Definitely Diablo. New Diablo dusted crispy chicken nuggets, a brand new classic. Only at Taco Bell. at participating U.S. Taco Bell locations for a limited time and while supplies last.
20:01I had only gotten to know Hirsch through the photos you shared and his room that you shared. And I loved reading about more of who he was in the book. He sounded like a really beautiful soul. Can you bring me back to the moment when your beige life ended? because you mark this striation in the book between the before and the after. So when did your beige life end? So it was very quick, and it was on the morning of October 7th. It really sort of starts the night before, because on the evening of Friday, October 6th, Hirsch and my daughters and John and I all walked to synagogue together. We're a family that goes to synagogue both Friday night and Shabbat, Saturday morning.
20:46And Hirsch had said to us, after we go to synagogue and we were going to friends for Shabbat dinner, he said, Anir and I are going to go do something fun. Anir Shapira was Hirsch's best friend. They were actually a trio. There was Hirsch and Yanni and Anir. And so Hirsch had brought his camping backpack with us to synagogue and to our friends for Shabbat dinner. He had been regaling us at dinner, all the friends sitting at the table with tales from being in Europe at these trance music festivals. And at 11 o 'clock, he kissed me right here. He leaned over my right side and he kissed John. And he turned around in the doorway and looked at me and said, love you.
21:28See you tomorrow. It was very casual. And he left. And the next morning, John left for synagogue at 730, which is quite early. And so the girls were still asleep and I was going to wake them in a little bit. and we were going to meet him at synagogue. I was still having a cup of tea. And all of a sudden, around eight o 'clock, there were bomb sirens that started to go off in Jerusalem, which tragically now is extremely normal. But then it was completely out of the ordinary. And so I ran to wake up my girls because I knew there must be bombs falling somewhere. And we got into our safe room. Israel, since the mid-90s, any construction requires that residences have a safe room, a bomb shelter in the house.
22:14And so the girls and I went into our safe room, which ironically is Hersh's bedroom, and I sealed the window. It has like a steel-enforced door, and I sealed the door. And the protocol is that you wait 10 minutes, and if you don't hear anything suspicious, then you can come out. Now, I don't use technology on Shabbat, so it was Saturday morning. I didn't have a phone, TV, radio, computer. I didn't have anything open to know what was happening, why the sirens were going off. I waited 10 minutes. I didn't hear anything suspicious. So I said, girls, we can come out. But I know that Hirsch and Anir are somewhere outside sleeping.
22:53It's an emergency. I'm turning on my phone to make sure the boys are OK. I turned on my phone. I want to say maybe it was 823. I have it written down. And 11 minutes earlier, two consecutive WhatsApp messages had come into the group that Hirsch, John and I have just the three of us from Hirsch. The first one said, I love you. And the second one said, I'm sorry. And I immediately tried to call him and it rang and rang. And then I wrote, are you okay? Let me know you're okay. I'm leaving my phone on. Let me know you're okay. Those still to this day don't have the two blue checks that show that they were read, obviously.
23:30And I knew immediately that we were in trouble. John came running in because they had closed the synagogue because of all these bomb sirens that kept going off. I handed him my phone. I said, we're in trouble. And that was it. We sort of stepped through this very large wooden frame of the lives that we had lived up until that point. I say, you know, I was born in October of 1969 and everything from that date until October 7th, 2023 was now over, completely over. And I was now in a different place. And I've been in varying cues of different places since then, but that life of the before is completely over.
24:13You and your husband, John, and specifically you became very vocal. How did you choose to spring into action and be vocal versus wanting to wait and see how things go? What was your decision-making process? Well, initially the families of the 251 hostages who were stolen on October 7th, everyone went into primal reflexive action, meaning whatever felt authentic in that moment to do is what people were doing. There was not a lot of thought. There wasn't sort of, let's sit and brainstorm and make a collective plan. We were all instantly traumatized. Everybody had footage of their people being tortured, their people being killed.
24:59People had footage of their children being killed and their dead bodies being dragged away. We had footage of Hirsch being loaded onto a pickup truck with his dominant left arm blown off. We could see his jagged bones sticking out below his elbow. He had tied sort of a tourniquet with a t-shirt or something around the upper part of his arm. These are things that you are never prepared to see. No parent or loved one wants to see anything like that. And you're not rational. And instantly we were all in action mode, but everybody responds differently. I have a very good friend who's a nurse. And she said, you know, when people are in pain in the hospital, she said, there are the people who are clenchers.
25:45There are people who are screamers, the people who hit her when she tries to help them. There are people who are stoic. I saw that in the hostage family cohort that everyone responded differently. And once we knew he was alive because a girl who was in the bomb shelter with him, who he didn't know before that, the Nova Festival, she was rightfully having a complete panic attack. And he was trying to calm her down. And he put her head in his lap. And he put his head on top of her sort of protecting himself and her head was in his lap. And she is the one who ended up telling us, I watched him walk out.
26:27He's alive. She said, I watched him walk out with Orlevi, Eliak Cohen, and Alon Oheil. Those four boys walked out. As soon as we knew that, We wanted the world to know that. And we wanted the people who took him to know. We know you have him. We know he's alive. And we had been told by everyone, it's important that they know that he's American. He's a civilian and that the world is watching. I would love to say, oh, it was this very grand plan. I felt like I had a branding iron on my back. I was doing everything under severe, intense, mental, psychological, spiritual, religious, emotional torture.
27:09You talk in the book about what the torture did to your body. You said you never got your period again. How were you surviving every day at this point? While he was still alive, John and I were working 18 to 20 hours a day, running all over the world, talking to whoever we could talk to, meeting with whoever we could meet with, and trying desperately to move the needle on this horrific situation that so many people were suffering from. And definitely every morning when I would open my eyes, there would be a moment where I would feel overwhelmed with angst and misery. And I was used to saying the line that many Jewish people say upon waking, which I always say since I was a girl and learned it.
Read the full transcript
27:54and it's a line that says, I am grateful to you, creator of the universe, for giving me back my soul. You have tremendous faith in me, which I love because normally I think the dynamic that we learn is that we're supposed to have faith in God and yet the very first thing we're supposed to say is, wow, I'm back today. You have faith in me. I'm not done. My soul's back. So I would say that line and then I would say, hope is mandatory. It's not a suggestion. It's not advice. It's mandatory. Go. And I would fling the covers off and I would say, pretend to be a human. Just pretend. You don't have to really be human.
28:33You have to pretend to be a human because I wanted to lie on the floor in the fetal position weeping, but I knew that he was in agony somewhere and that wasn't going to help. And so we really pushed ourselves. You know, we were exhausted and miserable and truly tormented. I mean, I've aged so much in the last two and a half years, as has John, as you mentioned, I say it in the book, like I'm very honest about it. I mean, my body died. I never got my period again. I've never colored my hair. So I had gray in my hair before, but I have a ton of gray in my hair. And, you know, I've never worn makeup again.
29:07I've never worn jewelry again. Like I'm very much a wounded, damaged person. I'm very much a disordered person, but I think that it makes sense given what we went through. And then, you know, that was 330 days of immense, exhausting, beseeching, begging, scraping, pleading, running, burning. And then the angels of death came to our door to tell us that Hirsch had been murdered. So, you know, that was going through yet another big frame into this other very unknown place. When you saw him and you saw that video of him being loaded onto the back of a truck and his arm had been blown off by a grenade.
29:52I know you were so happy that he was alive and to know that, but what was it like to see your son that you had cooked in your belly with no arm? It was shocking and confusing. And I only watched it once. John actually watched it many times because he derived a lot of strength from it. He said he's walking on his own two feet. No one was dragging him. He uses his non-dominant arm to get himself up into the pickup truck. The other young men were lying down. They were very badly wounded. He was obviously very badly wounded. He was also burned. And yet he was sitting up. He chose to sit up and he puts his head down in the crook of what's left of his arm.
30:37John derived a lot of strength from that. And interestingly, there is a continuation of that video that I only saw once. And it was after he was killed. On the ride to Gaza, one of the gunmen who had stolen him grabs him by the head. He has his head down. He's lost a lot of blood, so he was probably very lightheaded. Grabs him by the hair and pulls him up and says into the camera, take a selfie with me. And what I love about that moment, and I've only seen it once, is Hirsch looks right into the camera. Defiant. Yeah. I loved it. Even though I was horrific. He was obviously in complete shock and horror and trauma.
31:20He had just witnessed 18 young people get murdered in a five foot by eight foot tiny shelter. I mean, picture your bathroom with 26 people smashed in, including Anir, who had been standing in the door trying so hard to save these people, throwing out grenade after grenade as they were coming in. And finally, they killed him. And Hirsch saw that. And we also know that those two texts that we got from him were after his hand was blown off. And so he thought he was dying. And I think about that was how he chose to say goodbye, that a lot of parents tragically had recordings of their children screaming.
32:01screaming i mean imagine how the structure of your being in this world changes when you hear your children screaming as they're dying and that's the last thing you hear he chose not to record to us he just said i love you and i'm sorry because he knew we were going to be in terrible pain i was just going to ask you what do you think the i'm sorry was he knew we would suffer terribly and he's right and interestingly i know this is jumping ahead but someone pointed out to me and And I didn't realize I had done this, but they played it for me that at Hirsch's funeral, when they were putting him into the ground.
32:37And, you know, in Israel, when they bury people, we don't use coffins. So he was just wrapped in a shroud, which is like a sheet. And you could really see the contour of him. And as they were putting him into the ground, his body, I went like this and I screamed, I'm sorry. I don't remember doing that. But someone said that there's a symbiosis. That was the last thing he said to you. And that's the last thing you said to him. So amazed by you. You never cry in interviews. It's so rare. Well, I think it's actually really sad because it just shows how broken I am. Like it's a very human, healthy response.
33:13But I also think that I've cried so much. You know, I'm not all here. Part of me is already in the world to come with hers. And so I'm not normal. And I referred to it earlier that I read an article by the American Psychiatric Association a few weeks ago that said, if you're still grieving after six months, then you have a disorder. And I was like, I have a disorder. And I'm actually very proud of this disorder. It's called I Still Love My Son. The love is still here. Love is stronger than death. But I am disordered. I mean, I think of in Chicago growing up, there were always those parking meters.
33:50I don't know if they have them here in LA, but they were always broken. And so my mom would always leave a note on the parking meter saying, the meter is broken, don't give me a ticket. And I feel like the meter was disordered, like it was out of order. And I feel like that, like I am broken, don't give me a ticket. And dis in Latin means the opposite of. So I'm the opposite of order. I mean, it's not that I'm unique, because there are millions of people who have buried their children. But that does feel the opposite of the order that I would have preferred.
34:30You know what quality feels like. You can see it in the way a fabric moves, recognize it in a flawless fit, and appreciate it in the details that make our styles unique. It's the standard Coldwater Creek has honored for over 40 years, derived from a rich Mountain West heritage, and designed for today in styles that are distinctively Coldwater Creek. For a wardrobe you can count on season after season, visit coldwatercreek.com. Shop new arrivals and save 15 % on purchases$75 or more with code IHEART. Travel smarter, not harder. At America's Best Value In by Sinesta. With convenient locations from coast to coast and value-packed comfort at every turn.
35:10It's a practical choice for road trips, quick getaways, and everyday travel that keeps things simple without sacrificing comfort. And when you're a Sinesta Travel Pass member, staying at America's Best Value Inn means earning points towards free nights, upgrades, and more every time you stay. Go to Sinesta.com to book your stay and unlock the best rates with Sinesta Travel Pass. Here today, roam tomorrow. Join now at Sinesta.com. Terms and conditions apply. Picture this. You're with your spouse at a seaside botanical garden. The moss hangs low, but your spirits are high. And you've never felt more in love.
35:51This is when it hits you. That Myrtle moment. It's the second everything clicks. When you realize Myrtle Beach is more than a getaway. It's right where you belong. Don't just daydream about it. Find your own Myrtle moment at visitmyrtlebeach.com.
36:12And now, another appliance triumph from your friends at Grand Appliance. Meet Chad. With the laundry piled high, Chad's washer died days before a two-week vacation with his family of five. But Chad didn't panic. I just called Grand Appliance. They recommended a large-capacity Samsung option with a super-speed wash mode that washed everything in no time. Best of all, it was in stock, and they delivered it next day. Another crisis averted by Grand Appliance. Shop GrandAppliance.com to learn more.
36:45I've watched, I think, almost every interview you've done. And no matter how long a journalist has been doing their job, Anderson Cooper, Bionna, no one can get through an interview without crying. And I'm really wondering how you feel watching other people in pain over pain that only you can really understand. I actually really think it's a beautiful human response. I think people really grew to love Hirsch and love a lot of people. We love a lot of people that we've never met. And during the really shocking, sticky, tricky days that we were trying so desperately to save Hirsch and these other hostages, the world grew to love a lot of those hostages without ever having known them.
37:32And 46 of those hostages who were taken alive were killed in captivity. And there are people all over the world who grieved for them and continue to grieve for them because they grew to love them. And I think that there's something really powerful and uniting about that, that you can love people that you never met and you can grieve people you never met. So when I've had these experiences speaking to people and they have the right human, empathetic, kind, merciful, compassionate, graceful response, I think it's the most beautiful personification of the human experience. You started wearing a piece of tape every day that Hirsch was gone.
38:15It was 330 days. And what began as a marker became something that the world really came to recognize. Do you remember the first day that you put it on? I put it on the first day on day 26. And it was because it was driving me to insanity that we were doing 10 to 15 media clips a day because we speak English. So we became very much sort of an easy go to. There were plenty of families that were speaking many different languages because, you know, the original cohort was from more than 30 different nationalities. There were Christians, Jews, Muslims, Hindus and Buddhists. So there were people speaking all over the world in all different languages.
38:59But because we were English speakers, we were speaking a lot to the international English speaking media. And the first question was always, how many days has it been since you've spoken to your son? And I just thought, I can't take this anymore. I remembered being a little girl in Chicago one night wandering out of bed. I couldn't sleep. And I wandered into our living room and my dad was watching the news. And it was ABC News. And there was a show called Nightline. And there was a man, an anchor named Ted Koppel, who had this big head of gingy red hair. And he had behind him numbers. and I said to my dad what is that number and he said that's the amount of days that hostages have been held in Iran and he explained to me and I was nine years old I was a little girl and he explained to me because I didn't know what a hostage was and I didn't understand what had happened and I thought back to that and I thought I'm going to be the human nightline Ted Koppel counter and I went and got tape and I also thought there was something very accountable Everyone had to do what felt good to them.
40:07You know, some people wore a necklace, some people wore a bracelet, some people wore a ribbon. Everybody did what spoke to them. To me, it was very important to show the failure of another day, that the number changed every day, that my prison number changed every day. I was in prison and I remember on day 88, which I talked about in the book, that I was speaking to a group of college students and a young man raised his hand. and it was the most gorgeous question, but it broke me. He said, what can we do to ease your pain? And no one had asked me that in 88 days. And I started crying and I put my hand on the number and I said, and it sounds so naive now thinking back.
40:52I said, if God forbid we get to day 100, please don't make me be the only person on earth wearing this tape. And by the afternoon, the woman who had organized that trip sent me a picture on WhatsApp of the 100 students on that trip. After lunch, they were all wearing 88. They had started on that day. And we had on day 100, over a million people sending us pictures, selfies of them. And they had started wearing the tape and starting on day 100 around the world. And, you know, this crossed all barriers. It was people of all different backgrounds, all different belief systems, all different brands and textures and colors and faiths and philosophies.
41:38And everyone was just trying to come together in this painful, out-of-the-ordinary situation by doing something symbolic of saying, we are with you and the days are moving. We were trying so desperately hard and we continued wearing that tape. We buried Hirsch on day 332. And you can see pictures of us, you know, standing there burying him and we're wearing the number. And we kept wearing the number until day 843 when the final hostage was returned back so his family could bury him. You say on day 88 that student asked you how they could ease your pain. And I can imagine that the outpouring of support from people near and far must have been helpful and overwhelming and just a mix of feelings.
42:30Did you feel supported by people? Were you frustrated by what people were saying to you? Could you even deal with somebody else's feelings? I was very grateful. I think all of us, all of the families were tremendously grateful at the outpouring of really kind, benevolent people saying, what in the world can we do? We really want to help. I personally had a problem, which I still do to this day. And I admit that it's my problem. I actually remember when I was in high school and my mom said, now, if you ever break up with someone, you always have to say, it's not you, it's me. She said, it will be them.
43:06But you can't say that because it will hurt them. But I am telling you this problem. It really is me, which is people would say to me, how are you? And to this day, it's the most excruciating, confusing question that I get. because when Hirsch was being held, I felt like my leg was in one of those old-fashioned bear traps, like these teeth were chopping into my skin and tearing my tendons. And for someone to say, how are you? I felt was like cruel and perverse, but really they meant it in a very innocuous, even kind-hearted way. I didn't know how to answer and I still don't know how to answer.
43:46I say, do you not see that there's a knife sticking out of my heart right now? I mean, how can you ask me how I am? It's like walking by someone in the middle of being raped and saying, how are you? Like, it just seems so perverse. And yet people don't see it. It's not their fault. And I said, someone asked, what does this book do? And I said, I think I'm trying really hard to show you this knife. Like, how do you explain to someone who's been blind their whole life what blue is? It's very difficult. But I'm trying to show you blue. I'm trying to show you this pain. And I do have to figure out how do I answer that question.
44:27Recently, I was talking to a journalist who said, how are you? And so I thought, OK, I'll tell the truth. I said, I'm suffering. And he went, no, really, how are you? And I said, I'm really suffering. So then we hated each other. And we had to start, you know, this conversation. But I thought when you're asking someone in grief, mourning, loss and suffering how they are, you're putting them in a situation where either they tell you the truth and then you feel terrible or you're making them lie. And they have to say, oh, OK, I'm getting there. I'm, you know, one day at a time or, you know, trying to breathe or whatever.
45:04Again, this is part of my problem because I know another mother who lost her daughter since October 7th. And she told me that when she goes to the grocery store, if people don't ask her how she is, it hurts her. So, you know, it's a really tough tightrope for kind, caring, sensitive people to try to walk. I want to ask you about how you wrote the book because you mentioned that you were writing it in the pain. And the way you wrote it, showcase that to me, there are a lot of moments of these staccato sentences and space. I almost felt your breath sometimes in that space. Why write the book in such dire pain?
45:47I think it was very much honestly self-serving. I was choking. I was drowning in suffering, in severe, thorny, molasses-thick suffering. And I was choking. Like, I felt like I was barely alive. And John said to me, you need to get this out. I mean, I was literally, like, my throat felt closed. And so I think in a way it was giving the Heimlich to myself. And I'm very honest about it in the book. You know, I said in the beginning, I am still underneath this truck. Like I've managed to get one arm out and I'm typing with one finger, hunt and pack. I have no perspective. I have no panoramic distance from this trauma, from this hit.
46:30I know there are people who wait and then they're able to sort of collect their thoughts and really give a real sort of comprehensive and smooth explanation of what they're grappling with. I didn't have the time or the privilege of the time of that because I was drowning. And so that's why I'm also careful. You know, this is not a memoir. This is not a tell all. This is not he did this and she said that. This is not I was down here and beaten down and now I'm up here. You know, this is the road to recovery and resilience. None of that. I wish. It's not what it is. I think it's what a lot of people want it to be, because people want all of us who are broken to be better.
47:19And that idea, I think, is so complicated because, again, it comes from such a good nugget of a place. And yet I was speaking to this young woman who was explaining to me, oh, that kind of rhetoric of, you know, you'll get there and you're going to be better. This forced betterness, this forced language of resilience is actually toxic positivity. I was like, oh, my gosh, you're a genius. And she said, no, no, it's an actual term. I didn't come up with it, but I had never heard it before. So I put it on to her and think she's a genius. And then I walked home obsessed with this idea, which I think we do a lot because we're so scared of pain in Western civilization, in our culture.
48:03So afraid of pain that, you know, it's block it out. This is probably part of the opioid crisis is like we don't want to feel anything bad. And I think it's actually emotionally barbaric. It's emotionally gaslighting to people who are really in pain. And I'm not just talking about people who've buried people core to their identity and existence. I'm talking about people who all of us are carrying something that's very painful. That's part of the human enterprise. That's what happens to us. So I went home and I Googled what is the antidote? What is the opposite of toxic positivity? And I find this term that's called tragic optimism.
48:44And I was like, oh my gosh, beauty. I love it. That's me. because I am an optimist, but I am enrobed in tragedy. And I'm okay with that. And then, of course, you may have heard me talk about this, but I said, who came up with that, right? Because like, wow, that's my new identity. Who coined that term? And it was Viktor Frankl, who you know I loved. Well, Hirsch loved Viktor Frankl too. While he was in captivity, he would say, he who has a why can bear anyhow, which is a line from Viktor Frankl's book, Man's Search for Meaning. You learned from another hostage, Orr, who had three days with Hirsch in captivity, what his spirits were like.
49:27And Orr said that he was laughing at some points and really emboldening people with Viktor Frankl's line. Did you feel a sense of pride? I did. And I also felt a sense of comfort and consolation, knowing, first of all, that he wasn't broken. My assumption was that he was broken. You know, I'm his mother. I see this horrible video. I know from intelligence sources, they were telling us that they were starving, they were being tortured, any little bits of information that we were getting, which was not very much. And it was months apart. So my assumption was that he was broken. I knew he had this horrible injury.
50:06And then to hear from Orlevi, whose name means light, to hear that Hirsch made him laugh. Hirsch shared his mantra from Viktor Frankl, which is actually a riff on something Friedrich Nietzsche originally said. And then having Ellie Sharabi also talk about Hirsch sharing that mantra as well with him. It gave me back a little piece of another piece of being here in this world.
50:41like. You can see it in the way a fabric moves, recognize it in a flawless fit, and appreciate it in the details that make our styles unique. It's the standard Coldwater Creek has honored for over 40 years, derived from a rich Mountain West heritage, and designed for today in styles that are distinctively Coldwater Creek. For a wardrobe you can count on season after season, visit coldwatercreek.com, shop new arrivals, and save 15 % on purchases$75 or more with code iHeart. Travel smarter, not harder. At America's Best Value In by Senesta, with convenient locations from coast to coast and value-packed comfort at every turn.
51:19It's a practical choice for road trips, quick getaways, and everyday travel that keeps things simple without sacrificing comfort. And when you're a Senesta Travel Pass member, staying at America's Best Value In means earning points towards free nights, upgrades, and more every time you stay. Go to senesta.com to book your stay and unlock the best rates with Sinesta Travel Pass. Here today, roam tomorrow. Join now at Sinesta.com. Terms and conditions apply. Picture this. You're on the beach with the whole family. The sun is shining, the water is warm, and your kids are finally getting along. This is when it hits you, that Myrtle moment.
52:02It's the second everything clicks. When you realize Myrtle Beach is more than a getaway. It's right where you belong. Don't just daydream about it. Find your own Myrtle moment at visitmyrtlebeach.com. And now another appliance triumph from your friends at Grand Appliance. Meet Jan. Her fridge died days before a dinner party, but she didn't panic. I just called my guy at Grand Appliance. He recommended a large capacity GE profile option with fingerprint-resistant stainless steel and a convertible middle drawer. I can optimize for meat, beverages, snacks, or wine. Best of all, it was in stock, and they delivered next day.
52:43Another crisis averted by Grand Appliance. Shop grandappliance.com to learn more.
52:53Something that stood out to me and so many people watching you as you went through the 330 days is that you were able to carry multiple truths at one time. You would cry out for the pain that you were feeling, your pain for wanting to get her home. And you would also cry out for the pain that the mothers in Gaza were feeling. And it was particularly striking, not just because I think that was so hard for anybody to do in that moment, but you had a son in Gaza being held captive. Why was it important for you to speak that way consistently? Well, I think that we are endowed with intelligence and insight and wisdom, and we actually have the ability to hold multiple truths.
53:44And this adversarial paradigm that we have constructed, that it's them versus us or team A or team B, has not served us well. And I wanted people to try to really not allow that line to be demarcated. I, from the beginning, was saying it's not like such a crazy statement. It's just that I think maybe it was a voice that was not so commonly heard. But I was saying, I am extremely worried and concerned about the innocent civilians in Gaza. And, not but, and I'm extremely worried and concerned about the innocent civilians in Gaza. who were dragged there on October 7th. You can hold both of those ideas.
54:28And I actually had read a piece by a journalist early on before I went to speak at the UN the first time on day 18. And he said, if you only cry when one side's babies die, it means that your moral compass is broken and therefore your humanity is broken. And I remember thinking, I really pray that I don't know how long this is going to take, but I don't want my humanity broken. And I was thinking recently because I was reading an article and there was a picture and it was of someone who did not look like me and he was not from my neck of the woods. And I started crying because it was a picture of someone who had lost his family.
55:09And I was so relieved. I thought, well, thank God that my moral compass is still calibrated. It doesn't mean like I'm this awesome person. I'm a normal person. It's just calibrated. Like when you start with weighing something that the scale should start in a fair and balanced way. And it was for some reason, something that people were very surprised to hear. I'm going to ask you something. And if you don't want to answer, I understand. When people ask you why this happened to your son, what do you say? You know, I'm a religious person, a person who really feels a closeness to this idea of God.
55:50I think that's a really loaded term, God. We all have different ideas of what that means. But I feel very much that we are all one little stitch in a massive tapestry that we are generally not privy to understand and see the whole entire work. We can't see everything. And so we see our little circle that we have our vision honed in on, and we don't have perspective. And I think a lot about how growing up in Chicago, my mother took me to the Art Institute often. She really wanted me to be cultured. And her favorite painting was by George Seurat, and it's a pointillist painting. So she would put me, now they have ropes.
56:35You're not allowed to go as close as we used to go. I actually think they put those ropes up because of us. They were like, that lady keeps putting her daughter right next to the painting. And she would say, what do you see? And I would say, oh, it's blurry. It's just, it's pixelated. I wouldn't say it's pixelated, but I'm telling you, it was just pixelated. It was just dots of gray and red and blue and green. And I couldn't make sense of it. And then she'd say, close your eyes and take 15 steps back. I don't know why 15, but that was her number and open your eyes. And then I would see this magnificent masterpiece in front of me.
57:06When you're very close to something, you just see the confusion and the chaos. I feel very blessed that I had Hirsch. Only blessing. What happened for those 330 days before he was killed was obviously twisted and torturous and so much anxiety and misery and very difficult to describe in words. And yet I also realized it was a privilege to try to save him. I realize that now because usually in life, you know, when we really love people, we say like, I would do anything for you, but we very rarely have to. And we really tried to do every single thing we possibly could, things I still can't talk about that we did.
57:46And then he was killed. And not everyone has had that opportunity before they lose someone they love to share them with the world to try so hard to save them. Many people have done that. I have friends who have lost their children to cancer. They tried so hard to save them. And I am able to see, even with this excruciation of suffering and mourning and loss and grief, that there's a how to the why that I have to carry and figure out. And I know that I could have just been a mother to two vivacious, dynamic, delicious daughters, which is what I have now. I have very good friends that also just have two daughters.
58:27They're perfect. They're complete. Nothing's missing from their family. But we got this additional, magnificent, glorious cookie for 23 years and 334 days. And I will pay with the pain that price of having had that transcendent gift. And so why did it happen? That I don't know. I'm not privy to that. But I really believe that it is part of a plan. It doesn't exonerate or give a pass to the people in power and in places of influence who could have done things to save him. It doesn't give them a pass. But I really believe there's a much larger picture. And I am thankful that's how I see it. Because I think that even with all the suffering that I'm bearing, it would be almost impossible if I didn't have that kind of perspective on what I see as having happened to us.
59:27Viktor Frankl's name comes up in the book and is intertwined with Hirsch's story. And my grandma was a Holocaust survivor. And I picture Hirsch's face. I feel he was killed because he was Jewish. It was. And, you know, in Yad Vashem Holocaust Museum that's in Jerusalem, in the old entry hall, it's now been redone. There used to be a quote on the wall that said, a person who's killed because he is Jewish is called holy. If you're only killed because of that one reason, it's holy. And I think that Hirsch very much was holy. I think that the beautiful six were holy. Eddin, Carmel, Alex, Amog, Ori, who he was killed with were holy.
1:00:10I think the 46 who were killed in total in captivity were holy. I think the people who were killed in the Holocaust were holy. And that's also a hard word, holy. You know, we'll say things like, oh, it means hallowed or sacred. Really holy in Hebrew means separate, different. And they were separate and different. You write, our spirits were mangled and our hearts were stolen. Our life was stolen. There is nothing like the feeling of putting someone you carried for nine months inside of your body into the ground. I noticed when you talk about the pain, you touch your chest very often. My therapist said that too.
1:00:45Really? Yes. What does it feel like to carry this around every single day? I think it's exhausting and confusing and a gift because it is that love. And I'm very aware that pain is grief and grief is love that continues to grow after the person is gone. And that's really beautiful. And that is never going anywhere. The love that is stronger than death. That's really just this absolutely shining idea. and I love that because I think I talked to Anderson about this that I think hate peters out I really do I think that the strongest force that outlives time and outlives death is love it's such a privilege so I'm not good at this I'm very turned inside out and I'm ugly in terms of like pulsing and oozing and bleeding I'm a wounded animal because I love him and I love him this second and he's right here.
1:01:48You can feel him still. Oh, for sure. All day. I mean, and that's what's exhausting. I mean, John and I talk about that all the time. Again, we're not unique. Millions of people. I'm only familiar with bearing a child. I've been blessed. I haven't buried parents. I have half siblings who are alive. You know, I did bury grandparents, but I think that I very much expected that one day I was going to bury them and I had wonderful relationships with them and nobody had a horrible death. So this is a really challenging weight that I will always carry. And what I'm trying to try to aim for and aspire to is to figure out how do I carry it a little less clunkily and a little bit more gracefully, but I will always have it.
1:02:34And I I actually feel really privileged. He who has a why can bear anyhow. Is it insane to ask you what your why is now? We're trying very hard to figure it out. I mean, I think to me, it's clear that part of our why is to pick up Hirsch's why and keep running. Even though I think he did his why, that's why he's not here anymore. You know, and I say at one point in the book, because when the final hostages came home who were alive, A lot of people said things to me of the genre of, it should have been harsh, it's not fair, how is it not him? And I said, he's not supposed to be here. And the way I know he's not supposed to be here is that he's not here.
1:03:16You know, I also get a lot of solace from this idea that the patriarch of Jewish mysticism, the Baal Shem Tov, was once asked, why do souls come to this world, this messy, tricky, difficult, complex place? Like, what is the point? Why are we here? And he said, every soul comes to this world so that one day that soul can do one act of kindness for one other person. And that's it. That doesn't mean you don't have to be doing thousands of acts of kindness throughout your life. You do. And to improve things and to live a life of meaning. But it means that really there is one thing in your lifetime, one thing, and it could just be smiling at someone who no one's gentle with.
1:04:05and I thought to myself, could it be that Hirsch did his kindness when he was two and we were living in Berkeley, or when he was six and we were living in Richmond, Virginia, or when he was 15 and we were living in Jerusalem, or when he was 23 and he was in a tunnel under Rafa? I don't know, but it occurred to me maybe I already did my kindness when I was 12 years old, so why am I still here? And I realized maybe someone else has to do their one kindness to me. when I'm 88. So I have to stick around because that's the synergy of this enterprise of being interwoven in the human tapestry of life.
1:04:45And what I do know for sure is Hirsch did his kindness and he did his why. Rachel, thank you so much. Thank you, Danielle.
1:04:59Okay, you know what time it is. Today's a good day to have a good day. I'll see you next week.
1:05:19Okay, laundry stinks. Literally. I mean, you could just keep buying new underwear. Not that I've ever done that. Or maybe sort your clothes into piles based on how re-wearable or filthy they are. Or just use Arm & Hammer Deep Clean. It's made for real life stings and stains. So even if you don't do laundry the quote right way, Deep Clean will knock it out. I mean, it is from the number one liquid detergent brand that tackles more loads than any other. Come clean with Arm & Hammer Deep Clean. Number one claim based on total wash loads sold. You know what quality feels like. You can see it in the way a fabric moves, recognize it in a flawless fit, and appreciate it in the details that make our styles unique.
1:06:05It's the standard Coldwater Creek has honored for over 40 years, derived from a rich Mountain West heritage, and designed for today in styles that are distinctively Coldwater Creek. For a wardrobe you can count on season after season, visit coldwatercreek.com, shop new arrivals, and save 15 % on purchases$75 or more with code IHART. This is Andrea Gunning from Betrayal. Travel smarter, not harder. An America's Best Value Inn by Sinesta. With convenient locations from coast to coast, and value-packed comfort at every turn. It's a practical choice for road trips, quick getaways, and everyday travel that keeps things simple without sacrificing comfort.
1:06:44And when you're a Sinesta Travel Pass member, staying at America's Best Value Inn means earning points towards free nights, upgrades, and more every time you stay. Go to Sinesta.com to book your stay and unlock the best rates with Sinesta Travel Pass. Here today, roam tomorrow. Join now at Sinesta.com. Terms and conditions apply. Jardians has a big story to tell. Discover Jardians Empigliflozin 10 or 25 milligram tablets. Visit Jardians.com, call 1-888-968-6648, or talk to your doctor to see if Jardians is right for you. The little girl with the big story to tell. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.
From the publisher
On October 7, 2023, Rachel Goldberg-Polin's son Hersh was taken from the Nova Music Festival into Gaza. For 330 days, she and her husband John fought to bring him home; meeting with world leaders, speaking at the UN, and wearing a piece of tape on their chests with the changing number of days he'd been held captive. Hersh was murdered in captivity on day 330.
In this raw and unforgettable conversation, Rachel sits down with Danielle to talk about her new book When We See You Again (NYT bestseller). She opens up about the reality of living inside grief, the pressure society places on people to “heal,” why she rejects toxic positivity, the philosophy of “tragic optimism” that now guides her life, and why she refuses to let her humanity break.In this episode, she shares:
- The final two texts Hersh sent his parents and what they meant
- Why Rachel calls herself "disordered"
- The story behind the tape that millions of people around the world started wearing
- "Toxic positivity" vs. "tragic optimism" — and the Viktor Frankl quote that Hersh lived by
- How Rachel held space for the suffering of mothers in Gaza while her own son was held there
- The one question she still can’t answer: “How are you?”
- Why Rachel says motherhood changed “the DNA” of who she is in the world
- The Jewish mystical idea that reframes why we're here at all
- What it means to mother a child who is no longer in this world
- Why Rachel says “hope is mandatory” even after unimaginable loss
- "Every soul comes to this world to do one act of kindness." The teaching that helps Rachel make sense of Hersh's life and her own
Grab a copy of Rachel’s NYT bestselling book When We See You Again here
Follow Rachel + her family on Instagram here
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
