1. Podcasts
  2. Radical with Gabriel Gatehouse
  3. Climate Violence: Has Peaceful Protest Failed? (Andreas Malm)
Radical with Gabriel Gatehouse

5 Nov 2026 · 49m · 21 chapters

Episode artwork

Climate Violence: Has Peaceful Protest Failed? (Andreas Malm)

In short

Climate activism and whether “peaceful protest” has failed, arguing that governments focus on climate symptoms (e.g., wildfire response) while continuing fossil-fuel “drivers” (new gas/oil/coal). The episode also discusses tactics: “radical flank” sabotage/property destruction of fossil-fuel infrastructure alongside mass nonviolent protest, plus rejection of geoengineering as symptom management.

Guest backgrounds

Andreas Malm is a Swedish author and climate activist. He is a senior lecturer in human ecology and associate professor at Lund University, with research in environmental history. He has long organized in climate, Palestine solidarity, and anti-fascist movements. He wrote Fossil Capital and How to Blow Up a Pipeline.

Key claims

The UK’s climate policy is symptom-fighting (AI wildfire unit) while approving new fossil projects (North Sea gas field Jackdaw) and rolling back renewables. Climate politics is in “despair” and “paralysis” because people normalize disasters and lack a clear path to action. Sabotage should be targeted at fossil infrastructure, not violence against people. Geoengineering (solar radiation management) is dangerous and would enable continued emissions.

Notable examples

UK wildfire “AI Cobra unit”; suffragettes’ property-targeting; abolition of slavery requiring militant struggle; France’s sabotage experiments; civil-rights “radical flank” (Malcolm X vs MLK); Colombia’s Petro government beginning to phase out fossil fuels, later losing to the far right. Malm also describes being refused UK entry due to a Home Office “not conducive to the public good” decision, likely tied to a Palestine Action-linked talk.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:50

Andreas Malm's Entry Denial

Malm discusses being denied entry into the UK and its implications.

“You seem to be walking past a large bookcase.”
3:00

Climate Activism and Its Roots

Malm explains his radical idea about addressing climate breakdown.

“I have positions on Palestine too, but it seems that this travel ban was induced by a talk that was scheduled between me and Huda Amouri, who is one of the founders of Palestine Action.”
6:12

The Drivers vs. Symptoms of Climate Change

Malm highlights the difference between drivers of climate change and symptoms.

“So the drivers presumably are fossil fuel emissions.”
7:22

Fossil Fuels and Capitalism

Malm discusses the connection between fossil fuels and capitalism.

“So we're going to we're going to talk about your idea with an open mind and a critical lens.”
11:10

Violence and Sabotage in Climate Activism

Malm clarifies the discussion of violence in climate activism, emphasizing property destruction, not harm to people.

“Well, I'm not one of those people who would say that we can only get through this mess and survive if we first abolish the capitalist mode of production.”
13:12

Nonviolent Movements and Their Impact

Malm explores the success of nonviolent movements in climate activism.

“This is a discussion exclusively about property destruction, damage to things, as a potential part of the tactical repertoire of the climate movement.”
14:01

Climate Movement Tactics and Historical Context

Explore the admissible tactics in the climate movement and historical examples of successful movements.

“In this particular moment, there was a discussion about what tactics are admissible for the climate movement.”
15:00

Abolition of Slavery and Militant Tactics

Discuss the abolition of slavery, its ties to violence, and the lessons for today's climate activism.

“about various different movements, the abolition of slavery, you mentioned.”
18:25

The Ethics of Nonviolence and Sabotage

Examine the moral and strategic implications of nonviolent protest versus sabotage in the climate movement.

“Then we come to the question of whether nonviolence, which, as you point out in your book, has been largely accepted by the climate movement as the way to go.”
20:35

Current State of Climate Activism

Analyze the current decline in climate activism and the impact of recent global events on public focus.

“And, you know, it's alive and a vibrant French traditional political contestation that we see, of course, manifested in the streets of French cities, more or less as we speak.”
Show all 21 chapters
22:44

The Need for Diverse Tactics in Climate Action

Discuss the necessity of combining peaceful protests with more radical tactics in addressing climate change.

“There are a lot of factors explaining this.”
28:30

Episode Introduction

Introduction to the conversation with Andreas Malm.

“If you are, you might want to check out another episode on a related topic with the conservationist Chris Packham, who called for a war on climate change.”
28:55

Radical Flank Theory in Social Movements

Discussion on the role of radical groups in social movements and their impact.

“the civil rights movement succeeded, you write, because it had a radical flank, that the establishment feared more than the demands of its peaceful flank.”
30:10

Sabotage as a Tactical Approach

Debate over targeted sabotage of fossil fuel infrastructure as a climate action.

“It shouldn't just be random destruction.”
32:22

Public Perception of Climate Change

Exploring why people feel powerless to affect climate change despite visible disasters.

“Say, okay, this is just how we live nowadays.”
33:35

Government Action and Energy Transition

Discussion on government actions regarding climate change and energy policy.

“I mean, since you wrote the book, we've had, for example, in the United States, the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022, hundreds of billions of dollars poured into clean energy infrastructure.”
36:15

Navigating Despair and Collective Action

Talk about combating climate despair through collective action.

“It's still growing around the world, including in China and India.”
37:24

Geoengineering and Climate Mitigation

Critique of geoengineering methods as a response to climate change.

“And for a few hours or even days, you could actually close down a lignite coal mine and its power generating station.”
42:05

The Risks of Geoengineering and Termination Shock

Learn about the potential dangers of geoengineering and the concept of termination shock in climate science.

“aerosols to compensate for the warming, the radiative forcing as it's known, of the CO2 to annul the effect of increasing emissions.”
43:58

Fossil Fuels vs. Renewable Energy

Explore the economic implications of fossil fuel reliance versus the benefits of transitioning to renewable energy.

“Yeah, he says this because he knows the dangers.”
47:24

Hope and Progress in Renewable Technologies

Discuss the advancements in renewable technologies and the challenges in climate politics today.

“how do you persuade voters in democratic countries that this is the case and they must pressure their governments into doing it.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Radical with Gabriel Gatehouse, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Gabriel Gatehouse: This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Decisions made in Washington can affect your portfolio every day, but what policy changes should investors be watching? Washington Wise is an original podcast from Charles Schwab that unpacks the stories making news in Washington right now and how they may affect your finances and portfolio. Listen at schwab.com slash Washington Wise. That's schwab.com slash Washington Wise. Hello. I don't know if you've noticed, but we like to have our guests in the studio on this show. There's a level of connection and understanding you get when you're physically in the same space as someone that you just can't achieve on Zoom.

0:49Gabriel Gatehouse: And when you're tackling difficult, knotty, controversial subjects, that's important. So we have a rule. If you can't make it into the studio, you don't get on the show. We have people travelling from all over the country, all over the world. But this week, life threw us a curveball. This week's guest has been refused entry into the UK.

1:23Gabriel Gatehouse: This is Radical, the show where we discuss radical ideas and speak to radical people with an open mind and a critical lens. Andreas Malm is a Swedish author and climate activist. He's a senior lecturer in human ecology and an associate professor at Lund University. His radical credentials are perhaps best summed up in the title of a short book he wrote in 2019. It's called How to Blow Up a Pipeline. Andreas Malm, welcome to Radical. Thank you so much, Gabriel. It's a real honour to be with you. It's very nice to see you. You're so radical that you're walking. Where are you, first of all? You seem to be walking past a large bookcase.

2:08Yeah, I'm in my home in Malmö, unfortunately. I have been looking forward to going to London, as I always do around this time of the year, since almost two decades. But this time I was prevented from entering the country. So I have to be at home in Malmö in Sweden, which kind of sucks.

2:29Gabriel Gatehouse: What do you know about why you were refused entry or why your visa was rescinded? The only reason stated to me in this email I received from the Home Office is that, I quote, your presence in the UK is considered to be not conducive to the public good, end quote. This, I understand, is a phrase that has been used before when at least a couple of people this year have been denied entry into the UK. And then this has been associated with their positions on Palestine. I have positions on Palestine too, but it seems that this travel ban was induced by a talk that was scheduled between me and Huda Amouri, who is one of the founders of Palestine Action.

3:18Gabriel Gatehouse: You were denied an ETA, right, or an ETA, an Electronic Travel Authorization, which is like a kind of fast track overseas entry into the UK. did they tell you that you could still apply for a visa? They did, but when I tried to contact the embassy in Stockholm to initiate this process, it appears impossible. You end up in a jungle of automatic phone messages that leave you absolutely nowhere. And I spoke to the British correspondent of the main Swedish Daily. She told me that she had to hire a consultant to work with the embassy in Stockholm to get her a visa. ETA is a formality. I received it most recently in May when I traveled to the UK just to discuss geoengineering at how the light gets in festival.

4:02And I got it immediately without any kind of trouble. I have now reapplied for an ETA. I haven't received the response. I assume it will be turned down because the ETA that I had was revoked. So are you going to try and apply for a visa? If I can find out how to do it, yes.

4:19Gabriel Gatehouse: So you were due to speak at an event with the founder of Palestine Action, which the UK government has prescribed as a terrorist organization, even though that is currently being challenged in the courts. Do you assume, because the Home Office has said they don't comment on individual cases, do you assume that is the reason why you were refused entry? Yeah, that's what I assume. And that's the general assumption here. Everyone else kind of assumes that this is what's happening. And not your climate activism. Well, no. I mean, I wrote the book, How to Open a Pipeline. It came out in 2021. It's a pretty provocative title.

4:59Sure. But yeah, it's meant to be provocative, but it never prevented me from traveling back and forth to the UK and lecture at the main universities there and give public talks and do research and participate in conferences. This is what I've been doing for years.

5:14Gabriel Gatehouse: Yeah. nor have my writings about Palestine caused troubles of this sort. Well, what we want to talk to you about is your climate activism and specifically the radical idea, really, that is suggested by the title of your book. And we're going to get into it in a lot more detail. But could you just, in a couple of sentences, what is it exactly? What is your radical idea? Well, if you take the meaning of the word radical, it means going to the roots of something. So the radical idea here is that if we want to get the problem of climate breakdown under any kind of control, we need to go to the root of the problem.

5:56So shut down the drivers of climate breakdown, not fighting the symptoms. And what you see happening in countries like the UK right now is a focus on combating the symptoms of this crisis while letting the drivers continue to spiral out of control.

6:13Gabriel Gatehouse: So the drivers presumably are fossil fuel emissions. I mean, that's the driver, right? Yeah, exactly. What are the symptoms that you're talking about? Yeah, well, for instance, wildfires. So you had a very bad summer in the UK, similar to in France and many other parts of the world, of course. And now the Burnham government has said we're going to create this new AI Cobra unit for spotting wildfires early on so we can fight them better. That's an emblematic example of fighting the symptoms. And at the same time, the very same government is approving a new gas field, Jackdaw, in the North Sea. And also it appears rolling back expansion of offshore wind and other kinds of renewables.

6:52This is letting the drivers continue to spin out of control. The radical thing, which is also the only reasonable thing to do, is to conclude, okay, if this summer was bad with the wildfires we had, just imagine what it would be five or ten years on from now if we continue to open new gas fields. We have to shut down the drivers if we want to get this under control, which means no new fossil fuel extraction whatsoever. Rather, phase it out completely.

7:21Gabriel Gatehouse: I'll just quote a little bit from your book. you write so here is what this movement of millions should do damage and destroy new co2 emitting devices put them out of commission pick them apart demolish them burn them blow them up yeah yeah i good well let's i mean not i don't mean good i mean uh we've got that clear um i I would like, if possible, just to set a little ground rule for this conversation, because otherwise I think we're going to get into legal trouble. So we're going to we're going to talk about your idea with an open mind and a critical lens. Could we try to avoid, please, breaking the law, which means telling people how to do this kind of stuff?

8:10Gabriel Gatehouse: I think can we steer clear of the sign of tricks of the trade side of this? Otherwise, I think we're going to get into trouble. I don't even know if I have any tricks of the trade to share, to be honest. Good, good, good, good. Well, that's all clear then. Good. Andreas Malm, tell me a bit about yourself and how you got here. What's your background? What led you to this place? I have been an activist in various social movements and ecological movements for a long time. I was a journalist for about seven years and then I started my PhD studies in 2009. and since then I've been an academic. I'm an associate professor of human ecology.

8:52Most of my research is in environmental history. So insofar as I'm an activist these days, I'm fundamentally an armchair activist. I mean, I do research, writing, I give talks. But before I started doing all of this, of course, I was an organizer in the climate movement and the Palestine solidarity movement and anti-fascist movements in Sweden.

9:15Gabriel Gatehouse: You wrote your PhD thesis on the use of coal in the British cotton industry in the early 19th century as the kind of the roots of global warming. This is a book called Fossil Capital, and it asks how did we end up in this mess with this dependence on fossil fuels? And unfortunately, it's very clear that this dependence started in one single country, which is Britain. That's where you first develop this alloy, this combination of self-sustaining growth and fossil fuel combustion. And this, of course, happened in the Industrial Revolution. And a key moment was the shift from water power to steam power as the main prime mover in industry.

10:00And the spearhead of the industry at that time, as everyone knows, was the textile industry. So my book is an investigation into what caused this shift. Why did manufacturers adopt steam power as a source of energy rather than water power, which was the traditional source? And the main conclusion that I have is not that water was more expensive and that steam was cheaper. rather it was the other way around but but steam power in the end generated more profits for large companies which is a little bit similar to the situation we're having today where renewables are across the board a cheaper source of electricity but they don't generate anything near like the profits that you get from fossil fuels particularly not in a moment like this when you have again record profits accruing to the oil and gas companies this is a high price and your Your big picture thesis essentially is that fossil fuels and the whole modern economy are so intertwined that untangling them really requires a dismantling

11:08Gabriel Gatehouse: of the capitalist system. Is that a fair kind of assessment? Well, I'm not one of those people who would say that we can only get through this mess and survive if we first abolish the capitalist mode of production. I think that is putting the cart before the horse. I think that if you want to take down fossil capital, so that means stopping the accumulation of capital from the extraction of fossil fuels and their combustion, then you're facing a very big challenge. These are very powerful class interests that you need to confront. and any insight into the basic problem here of climate breakdown implies this.

11:55I mean, if we actually want to leave fossil fuels in the ground, and this is what all the climate science tells us we have to do, then that means you cannot make any more profit from them. This means the end of BP, ExxonMobil, Saudi Aramco, and all the other big capitalist corporations that do profit exactly from fossil fuels. That's the challenge. Now, if you were actually to do this, to pull this off, then you would almost by definition make a very deep intervention into capitalist power. But where that leads us in the end, we don't know. But, you know, abolishing capitalism as a whole is an even bigger task.

12:37Gabriel Gatehouse: Okay, so you're limiting your ambitions in that sense. Now, this book and this title is essentially about the use of violence to achieve an end to fossil fuel extraction and consumption. And in other words, sabotage, right? That's what we're talking about. Are we clear that we're not talking about violence against people? We're very clear about this. This is a discussion exclusively about property destruction, damage to things, as a potential part of the tactical repertoire of the climate movement. Okay. Now you spend quite a bit of the time in this book exploring the ways in which nonviolent protest movements have actually been quite successful in drawing huge numbers of people into the climate movement.

13:41Gabriel Gatehouse: Can you talk a little bit about the nonviolent side of things first? So first I should point out that this book was written at the kind of tail end of the cycle of climate mobilization that we saw in our countries in 2018-19. And it kind of ended with the outbreak of the pandemic in early 20s. So people might remember the moment of Greta Thunberg, Fridays for Future, Extinction Rebellion. It seems like almost another epoch. In this particular moment, there was a discussion about what tactics are admissible for the climate movement. And many would argue at that time that it's only exclusively peaceful civil disobedience that constitutes kind of the outer limit of what the movement can do, based on the idea that anything else, including damage to things or property destruction, would harm the movement and not be conducive to its goals.

14:41And I challenge this reading. I think that if you look into social movements over history that have, in some sense, achieved their aims, there's virtually always a component of more militant tactics than just absolutely peaceful civil disobedience.

14:59Gabriel Gatehouse: Yeah, you write very interestingly, for example, about various different movements, the abolition of slavery, you mentioned. Can we talk about the abolition of slavery, slavery and the abolition of slavery a bit? because you make the link between slavery and fossil fuels in the sense that slavery, like the fossil fuel economy, was at one point an integral part of the economy of a whole bunch of nations, and yet economies became decoupled from slavery, slavery got abolished, and that was achieved. But what you're saying is it wasn't done through exclusively peaceful means. Well, no, I mean, if you know anything about the abolition of slavery in the U.S., you know that it required a civil war, which caused more deaths, more American deaths than I think all the wars that the U.S.

15:59has fought since then to end slavery. That's not to say that I advocate a civil war, but the idea that slavery was abolished by peaceful means is patently untrue. The abolition of the slave trade in Britain and slavery as such was, of course, preceded by massive uprisings in the British slave colonies, Jamaica and the others. And these uprisings included, of course, quite a lot of violence from enslaved people.

16:30Gabriel Gatehouse: Yeah, because it is often said that Britain abolished the slave trade voluntarily. But what you're pointing out is that that misses this history of slave rebellions in the Caribbean and elsewhere. Yeah, it definitely misses that. There is this kind of peace washing in some history writing where you just erase the moments of popular militant struggle. and imagine that slavery was abolished by some well-meaning white people in Britain and forgetting that it required decades and not centuries of very, very hard-fought battles by the enslaved people themselves in the colonies in the Caribbean and elsewhere to even push this issue onto the agenda.

17:12Gabriel Gatehouse: And you also write about the suffragettes who were perhaps closer to the kind of thing that you're advocating. They targeted property for destruction. I'll just read a little extract from your book because it's quite a comprehensive list of the kinds of things that the suffragettes were doing. You're quoting Diane Atkinson's Rise Up Women, a book that gives an encyclopedic, you say, listing of militant actions. suffragettes forcing the prime minister out of his car and dousing him with pepper, hurling a stone at the fan light above Winston Churchill's door, setting upon statues and paintings with hammers and axes, planting bombs on sites along the routes of royal visits, fighting policemen with staves, charging against hostile politicians with dog whips, breaking the windows in prison cells.

18:01And these are regarded as heroes today, the suffragettes. I mean, that's the kind of national consensus that they They pushed through a major social progress in ensuring votes for women. But very, very few of the instances of major social progress have been achieved without a component of struggle.

18:25Gabriel Gatehouse: Then we come to the question of whether nonviolence, which, as you point out in your book, has been largely accepted by the climate movement as the way to go. whether that is a moral or a strategic ideal. Can you pull that apart for us a little bit? The purest pacifists in the climate movement nowadays often frame their position in a strategic manner, which is to say that we believe that it's only absolutely peaceful means that can bring us closer to the goal. they don't frame it necessarily in ethical terms as the as in that is the only right thing to do morally speaking but as in okay what we've learned from the past of social movement struggle is that is it this is the only admissible tactic and this is this is what i question now of course there are deeply ethical aspects to all of these things one is you know it's always wrong to harm another human being.

19:35Most of all, you know, to harm the physical body of someone, inflict pain or even death on someone. This is wrong, morally speaking. If that is ever to be permitted, you have to have this wrong eclipsed by a massive gain that would justify inflicting this kind of harm on someone. So this is why, of course, I would guess most philosophers are not pacifists. They would say that in particular circumstances, it is morally justified to use violence against another human being. But when it comes to questions here for the climate movement, my position here is that there is nothing to suggest that violence against human beings would benefit our cause and bring us closer to the goal.

20:24But what might be the case is that sabotage, property destruction, could be useful as part of a diversity of tactics. Not the only thing that we could do, but maybe one of the many things that we could do. And since my book came out, this, I think, has been demonstrated, particularly across the channel in France, where the environmental movement has experimented with sabotage on a pretty massive scale that, of course, has a much deeper political root. And, you know, it's alive and a vibrant French traditional political contestation that we see, of course, manifested in the streets of French cities, more or less as we speak.

21:10So, you know, circumstances are different in different countries. But from the French experience, it is clear that, yes, sabotage, destroying things can actually bring us closer to our goals as climate and ecological actors.

21:23Gabriel Gatehouse: So, and we should distinguish two things here, because as you yourself write, that the non-violent strategy has drawn in and was incredibly successful around the time that you were writing the book, 2018, 2019, in drawing millions of people into the climate movement. So, you know, XR really did expand the numbers of people who were prepared to go out and protest nonviolently. I think we'd both probably agree that it put the climate question on the agenda in a way that it really hadn't been before. what you're suggesting the sabotage is obviously um well number one it's illegal and the the sanctions for somebody engaging in that are obviously a lot more serious um you know people could go to jail for quite a long time people have gone to jail um and so if we're talking about tactics you you you have an aim that you want to achieve how do you square that with the with the idea that well these tactics might put people off they might reverse the gains that non-violent protest um have brought yeah so let me just preface this by saying that these discussions are now considerably more abstract and hypothetical than they were even just four or five years ago because there is so little climate activism happening right now we've almost experienced something like the death of climate politics during the 2020s.

23:02Okay, just pause for a second.

23:03Gabriel Gatehouse: Why do you think that is? There are a lot of factors explaining this. One is that the climate disaster has been overtaken by other disasters. First, the pandemic, then the invasion of Ukraine, then the onset of the genocide in Gaza. I'm just going to pause you for one second there. So when people use the word genocide, obviously a panel at the United Nations has called it that and a bunch of a whole group of genocide scholars have called it that. I should say that the Israeli government and lots of people who support the Israeli government dispute that particular characterization of the disaster and terrible stuff that's happening there.

23:45Gabriel Gatehouse: I'm just saying that so that we can keep this in. Perpetrators of genocide rarely say this is what we're doing. Anyway, what happened in Gaza was and is another disaster. You have what's going on in Iran. You have the AI data centers. You have one thing after another being thrown against us that have caused the climate issue to drop on the agenda. And, of course, what you have in Europe and other parts of the world is the rise and rise and rise of the far right, which says that, no, it's not the climate that is the problem. The problem is all of these non-white people who are in our countries, and we should get them out, that will deal with the sources of our afflictions.

24:25This is the political force that has been ascending over the past years, and it has completely shifted the balance of forces in climate politics. And then, of course, the repression against the climate movement is another factor where people have been given very draconian prison sentences, not for any sabotage, but just for blocking cars on highways or even just discussing doing so. and yeah many many other factors are are combining and leaving us in the moment where you know each summer seems to bring greater disasters and everyone can see this i mean everyone in the uk could feel the extreme heat this past summer see the yellow lawn see the disappearing rivers and so on and so forth it's in our face but we still can't get to the point of trying to shut down the drivers of this, which again, everyone knows what the drivers are.

25:23But instead, it's a discussion about how do we adapt to this? How do we get these symptoms under control? How do we discover the wildfires fast enough? How do we have enough AC and things like this? That's where the discussion is at this moment.

25:39Gabriel Gatehouse: And it is incredibly noticeable that basically we're in a situation where the science agrees on what we need to do. It's sort of generally accepted. we need to stop burning fossil fuels and yet nobody seems capable of no political movement no government seems capable of doing it quite as fast as clearly the science suggests that we ought to. I want to dig into that a little bit later but just to stick with your thesis about the use of sabotage and sabotage versus peaceful protest. Are you saying that sabotage should replace peaceful protests or that these two things should happen in tandem? Yeah, they should happen in tandem.

26:22And I think I've written my book that the bulk of our activities in the climate movement will remain and should remain peaceful as in demonstrations that can be attended by everyone. But what I argue is that there probably also should be a radical flank that goes one step further. And I think this argument, in a sense, is stronger today than when I wrote this book, because the climate crisis gets more severe all the time. So the paradox just deepens. How is it that these drivers are just continuing? So we're pouring more and more fuel on this fire every year without there being a significant popular backlash that includes actually trying to take down this infrastructure that is destroying this planet in its habitable state.

27:16Investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market. You can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything. Maybe you go for some free-range self-directed investing. Or perhaps you pick up a few farm-fresh trades while you peruse. You can even get help from a dedicated advisor. That's full-service wealth management. Mix, match, and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, you can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. Imagine buying a toy for your kid, but it doesn't come with batteries.

27:51That sucks. But honestly, it's even worse when you buy business software. You end up with fragmented, disconnected systems that cost a fortune and don't talk to each other. Odoo completely changes that. Odoo comes fully complete, with all your business apps perfectly integrated and working together seamlessly. It's everything your business needs in one place, saving you time, headaches, and serious money. Stop paying for missing pieces. Go to odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com to learn more.

28:29Gabriel Gatehouse: I hope you're enjoying my conversation with Andreas Malm. If you are, you might want to check out another episode on a related topic with the conservationist Chris Packham, who called for a war on climate change. Subscribe to the Radical Podcast on BBC Sounds, if you haven't already. But now let's get back to Andreas Mal.

28:54Gabriel Gatehouse: On the subject of the radical flank, you write in your book that during the civil rights movement in the United States in the 1960s, the civil rights movement succeeded, you write, because it had a radical flank, that the establishment feared more than the demands of its peaceful flank. So basically Martin Luther King succeeded because there was Malcolm X. Yeah, I think you see something similar happening in France right now. And the students say this, OK, we are now in a position where we can negotiate with the government. And these are students who some of them even belong to Macron's own party.

29:30But they say the only reason that we that, you know, our demands are being heard and we're at the negotiating table is because of everything that's been happening on the streets, all the riots that we've seen. This is why we are here. That's how power politics in this country works. they will say in France. And this is a pattern, of course, that is repeated in an enormous amount of situations where you have social struggles that require the threat of quite serious turbulence in society for those in power to care and to listen about the concerns of ordinary people.

30:07Gabriel Gatehouse: I mean, since we're talking about what's going on in France at the moment, what's been going on in the past few weeks, you write in your book and and this was written what seven years ago now um so maybe your your view has changed but you write in the book um quote we would not want a situation where people went around throwing bricks into cafes and toppling school walls and slitting jackets on a whim just for the hell of it um which does sound a lot like what's going on in paris at the moment You say that the targets of sabotage should be picked very carefully. It shouldn't just be random destruction.

30:47What I advocate in the book and what parts of the climate movement have actually practiced since it came out is targeted sabotage of fossil fuel infrastructure. not random shutting down of ordinary people's lives as in you know this was a very common tactic in the climate movement a few years ago just going out on streets and blocking anyone who was in a car which pissed quite a lot of people off sometimes understandably so but imagine for instance next summer is even worse which is very likely than the last summer in terms of extreme heat waves and droughts and wildfires. And you have some activists in France or in the UK actually shutting down fossil fuel infrastructure, platforms, pipelines, something like this, and communicating clearly to people that, okay, if you think this is bad, then imagine what's going to happen if we just continue like now.

31:52We need to shut these things down to avoid a situation where these wildfires and heat waves and droughts make life completely impossible in our countries, then I think you stand a decent chance to break the paralysis around the drivers that we're having right now and focus political attention in the heat of the moment on what is causing this, in the end, intolerable breakdown of the climate system. I think this is what needs to happen, but it still hasn't so each summer is a new season of disaster without this this paralysis being broken why do

32:30Gabriel Gatehouse: you think it is that it still remains so hard to make people care about this issue enough to put enough pressure on their governments to act faster than they currently are when people feel and see and experience the climate disasters as in the past just in the past summer in Europe? I think a lot of people feel despair. People also normalize it. Say, okay, this is just how we live nowadays. We felt it last summer. We're going to feel it again. It's bad, but what can we do? And people don't see any clear venue of action. People might very well feel quite upset about our government failing to get the situation under control, but they don't have any vision of how they would influence governments, because governments on this question seem immune to influence.

33:31Gabriel Gatehouse: Can I just push back slightly on this assertion that governments haven't done anything? I mean, since you wrote the book, we've had, for example, in the United States, the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022, hundreds of billions of dollars poured into clean energy infrastructure. I think globally, renewables last year surpassed coal in global electricity generation just. So it's about a third each, but renewables are slightly more. China's coal-fired power generation dropped below 50 % for the first time this year. And also, there has been a shift in investment. So you write in your book, basically, you say, follow the money.

34:17Gabriel Gatehouse: If you look at where the money is going from global investors, they're still going into fossil fuels, which tells you that the people who are very clever, who know what's happening, don't believe in government's sort of climate policies. But actually, if we look today in 2026, there has been a shift and about two thirds of global capital is going going into renewables and only one third into fossil fuels. I hear your urgency and the kind of assertion that this isn't fast enough, but is it not fair to say that the world is moving in the right direction? Unfortunately, no, I don't think so. I wish you were right, but I don't interpret the data as suggesting that there is, on the whole, an energy transition happening in this world.

35:08an energy transition is what we need that means taking the actual production and consumption of fossil fuels down towards zero and replacing it with renewables that is happening virtually nowhere there are trends in that direction here and there in parts of the world economy and there was one country who actually pursued this as a policy and that was colombia under the petro government that actually started closing down the production of oil and gas and coal. But the general trend in the 2020s, particularly in the US, is for an all out acceleration of the extraction of fossil fuels. This is the policy of Donald Trump that has even managed to revive the coal industry in the US.

35:59And speaking of coal, which is Britain's gift to the world, the dirtiest of fossil fuels, 2026 is likely to hit a new all-time record of total coal production. So we're here in 2026, and we can't even have the level of production of coal stagnating. It's still growing around the world, including in China and India.

36:23Gabriel Gatehouse: I just want to try and get some clarity on these figures, because the figures I just quoted, you suggested it was going in one direction, and the figures you just quoted me suggested they were going in the other direction. I think what we're talking about here is is i'm talking about a reduction of coal and fossil fuels as a part of the total and you're saying but the overall numbers are still going up exactly the figures that you're citing suggest that there is a shift in shares but that is an energy addition yeah so if you continue to grow fossil fuels but you grow renewables even faster that that is an all of the above approach where you expand all sources of energy that doesn't make any difference to the climate.

37:00It doesn't matter how many solar panels and wind turbines you build, if you also keep opening coal mines and coal power plants and gas fields and oil terminals. And this is unfortunately the general situation in the world where we have an energy addition, not a transition.

37:15Gabriel Gatehouse: I hear you on that. Let's get back to despair. Let's get back to the question. You've got a whole chapter in here entitled fighting despair and i think that you know it feels to me that one of the the big problems with this issue is it just feels too big people feel too powerless um and so you know it feels more realistic easier to focus your attentions on uh smaller crises or just the the daily crisis of paying the bills and staying alive. How do you fight despair? My own despair over the climate issue used to be successfully combated by these moments of collective action when we would take over fossil fuel infrastructure, notably in Germany, notably coal mines, and close them down, not through sabotage necessarily, but through radical militant collective mass action.

38:12And for a few hours or even days, you could actually close down a lignite coal mine and its power generating station. And you would feel that, okay, we have the empowerment here. We have the experience of, as a collective, actually being capable of getting to the root of this problem and cutting off the root or closing down the driver, even if it's just for a moment. Unfortunately, that isn't happening anymore, even in Germany, where it used to happen, because the climate movement there too, sort of fizzled out for various reasons. the despair around the climate disaster will only be broken when people get back into action find a way to get these drivers closed down i keep coming back to this but that is the that is the central you know break that we have to make now the the reality of this situation if

39:03Gabriel Gatehouse: we're talking about also getting people on board and bringing people with you is that you know if you shut down a coal mine like that you're also going to shut down a whole bunch of jobs for local people in that area how do you avoid that how do you avoid alienating those people working people from your cause yeah that that was a big knock that was not cracked successfully by the climate movement in germany because the trade unions and the coal industry remained basically hostile to the climate movement here and this included workers in the in the mines particularly in eastern Germany and Lausanne.

39:42In France, there have been some pretty impressive initiatives from workers in oil refineries and other parts of the oil industry to envision a transition that would be beneficial for them too. So in France, you've had seeds of alliances between affected workers and the climate and other types of environmental activists. And I don't think that's impossible to envision. So I don't think this is impossible by definition, but it is hard political work that requires, of course, a sensitivity to the concerns of ordinary working class people in these sectors. This is something that the environmental movement has struggled with always.

40:23And we're not making major progress because we're not making major progress anywhere. But I don't think it's inconceivable that it could happen because we have cases of it happening here and there.

40:36Gabriel Gatehouse: Which brings us to the question of, are there things we can do in order to mitigate this warming, as well as the things that we ought not to do, which is very clear, which is emitting CO2 from fossil fuels, but are there things we can do that can help mitigate what's happening? And a while back, we had an academic scientist here on the program called Professor David Keith, who is an advocate of geoengineering, solar radiation management, which essentially is spraying sulfur dioxide into the stratosphere, dimming the sun for a period of decades, possibly, thereby achieving a reduction in the amount of warming that we see.

41:26Where do you stand on those tactics? a good question so my most recent book together with William Carden is called the long heat climate politics when it's too late and it has a whole part on it about solar geoengineering which we don't like we think it's a bad idea fundamentally it's the embodiment of of combating symptoms not causes this is extremely dangerous for a lot of reasons and David Keith for what knows this because he studied it closely. If you have this parasolar umbrella in space that blocks incoming sunlight and you keep emitting CO2, then you have to inject larger doses of aerosols to compensate for the warming, the radiative forcing as it's known, of the CO2 to annul the effect of increasing emissions.

42:22So higher doses all the time. And then you might starts seeing some very serious negative side effects in various parts of the earth system everything from collapsing monsoon to crops starved of sunlight to sun you know solar panels not working any longer because there isn't enough incoming radiation and stuff like this you have this continuous buildup of co2 in the atmosphere and at a certain point geoengineering comes to an end, perhaps because the side effects have become too bad or because someone decides we're not going to do this anymore or because there is a mishap, a failure of the technology or whatever.

43:03And then you have what is known as the termination shock, where all the underlying force of the CO2 is activated in a snapback that causes temperatures to rise maybe by one, two, three degrees per decade. So imagine this as a cauldron that is boiling. The water is boiling more and more and it keeps boiling and to keep the water down you have to put a lid on and you have to you know apply more force to keep the lid in place and then at a certain point the lid is blown off and then the water just you know overflows the cauldron and yeah this is the logic of the termination shock that is an existential danger to human life and i think the great danger that we're facing here is that this would just give us another excuse if geo engineering works to leave the drivers in place because we seem to be able to combat the symptoms but then the drivers will just continue and it just postpones the disaster i i hear your argument

44:02Gabriel Gatehouse: and and and many people make this argument just to be fair to david keith he said very explicitly that of course um you know any kind of solar radiation management or geoengineering does not cancel out the need to reduce carbon emissions. They should go hand in hand. Yeah, he says this because he knows the dangers. But would Donald Trump know the dangers? I think the more likely scenario is that any actually really existing politician, this would be in the US, who implements geoengineering, would see it as a substitute for mitigation. You write in the book, you encapsulate this sort of dichotomy very strongly by saying it is easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism.

44:48Gabriel Gatehouse: Easier to imagine the deliberate large-scale intervention in the climate system, geoengineering, than in the economic system. It's also easier for some to imagine learning to die than learning to fight. I mean, you put it that way, and it's very stark. Isn't one of the problems that we've come to here when discussing, you know, the perils of, let's say, geoengineering, and the fact that no government seems to be able to move fast enough to meet the moment, is the fact that, in democracies at least, people are not sufficiently motivated to make their governments do what many believe is necessary.

45:35Gabriel Gatehouse: And also, they're not sufficiently motivated to go through the economic pain that will probably come as a result of having to do all the things that many believe are necessary? I think the misconception here is that a transition away from fossil fuels would be the source of economic pain. I think it would alleviate economic pain. Now we are in a situation where renewables are across the board cheaper as a source of electricity than fossil fuels. So the big irrationality and cause of pain here is that we dig ourselves deeper into the whole of fossil fuels. But the perversity of the system works like this.

46:09You have now again, absolutely astronomic profits in the oil and gas companies due to the high prices caused by the Iran war this year, very similar to in 2022. This means that private capital is flowing into the production of fossil fuels because that's where you get the largest profits. So BP and all the major private energy producers, they are again doubling down on fossil fuels. Banks are allocating their capital to new investment in fossil fuels, precisely because it's so expensive. You know, the cheap thing to do, but also the thing that wouldn't generate these profits, would be to invest in renewables and have them replace fossil fuels.

46:51This would be pain alleviation. This would be an answer to the cost of living crisis that we're seeing across Europe and other parts of the world, of course. That would be the transition. It's not happening because there's so much money to be made from fossil fuels. And the more expensive they are, the greater these profits, the more money you can make on them, and so on and so forth.

47:11Gabriel Gatehouse: If what you say is true, and in fact, both economically and ecologically, that the sensible thing to do is renewables, and this will lead to a win-win situation of great prosperity, how do you persuade voters in democratic countries that this is the case and they must pressure their governments into doing it. The experience that I would point to, even though we've just lost that experience, is the one in Colombia, where in 2022, just as the world pivoted towards fossil fuels because the profit bonanza induced by the invasion of Ukraine, you had the victory for the first time of a left that won the presidency in that country on the promise to start closing down fossil fuel production in that country.

47:58And Petro did this during his four years in power. He ended being a very popular president because he also improved ordinary people's living conditions. This was an amazing experience to see, and it caused a lot of excitement and inspiration. And you had, towards the end of Petro's term, this international conference on facing out fossil fuels in Santa Marta in Colombia, drawing on the Colombian experience and seeing how it can be internationalized, because this is the model. Unfortunately, and this is maybe a source of even deeper despair, despite these four years accomplishing all of these things in Colombia, the far right won the election, who are planning to start fracking and boosting fossil fuel production, just as in Argentina or in Venezuela.

48:50So it ended very badly. But we had four years that showed us what can be done. When it comes to climate in 2026, it is difficult to point to positive signs. The positive signs that we can see, and you've already mentioned them, are about the quite extraordinary development of renewable technologies and their rollout in parts of the world economy and the drop in their prices and their increased efficiency and how people, particularly poor people in countries like Palestine or Pakistan or installing solar panels to try to survive and do it as cheaply as possible. These are the good signs. But when it comes to climate politics, it's very difficult to see where the contributions are being made at this moment.

49:39It's very difficult to be hopeful about what's happening right now. Things need to change very fundamentally before you can feel a major source of optimism about the future.

49:50Gabriel Gatehouse: All right. Well, Andres Malm, author of How to Blow Up a Pipeline, thank you very much for being at the end of a Zoom line, not in the studio, but at the end of a Zoom line to share your radical idea with us. Thank you very much, Gabriel, for having me, even though it had to be online like this. And that's it for this week's episode. Please get in touch. Let us know what you think. Write to us at radical at bbc.co.uk and we will be back with another episode and another radical guest very soon. But for now, it's goodbye from me and stay radical.

50:31Gabriel Gatehouse: Life Changing on BBC Radio 4. It just felt for a moment like the world had stopped. And this feeling like I couldn't come up for air. The series about life's turning points. I've got to wake up every morning, even though the most heartbreaking thing ever has happened. Extraordinary accounts of loss, trauma and transformation. And we stood up and we told these stories. You could have heard a pin drop. And that's when I realised that this was something that mattered. Life-changing with me, Dr. Sian Williams. Listen now on BBC Sounds.

51:33of scattered notes into a report and it does the work and hands back something finished that you can open and edit. Claude can now draft a dock or deck right in front of you and Claude Design now lives right inside Claude. Describe the website or prototype you're picturing, attach your design system and it comes back in your own design language ready to edit right on the canvas. It works with your files and the tools you already use like Gmail and Slack and whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model, or strategizing your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter.

52:08For problems worth solving, get started with Claude at claude.ai.solve. That's claude.ai.solve. And check out Claude Pro, which includes access to all of the features mentioned in today's episode. claude.ai.solve.

From the publisher

Environmental activists have long been committed to non-violent protest, but as global emissions continue to rise Andreas Malm thinks they should change their tactics. The climate scholar, and author of 'How to Blow Up a Pipeline', thinks the destruction and sabotage of fossil fuel infrastructure is now a legitimate and necessary weapon in the fight against climate change.

One of the most controversial figures in climate politics, Andreas argues that decades of marches, petitions and symbolic protest have failed. He tells Gabriel Gatehouse how he draws on examples from history - like anti-slavery campaigns or the suffragette movement - where violence played a key role in bringing about change (although he does not advocate violence against people). If governments refuse to phase out fossil fuels quickly enough, Andreas argues, then damaging the infrastructure driving climate breakdown may be morally justified.

But can such illegal acts be justified, and how do you convince activists to commit them, risking lengthy prison sentences in the process? Plus, would destruction garner support or resentment from everyone else?

Producer: Ivana Davidovic Series Producer: Simon Tulett Technical Producer: Dafydd Evans Senior News Editor: Sam Bonham LISTEN: Listen to Radical every Thursday on BBC Sounds or wherever you get your podcasts. You can also listen on your smart speaker. Just say: "Ask BBC Sounds to play Radical". WATCH: You can also catch Radical with Gabriel Gatehouse on YouTube at www.youtube.com/bbcnews. GET IN TOUCH: • WhatsApp: 0330 123 9480 • Email: [email protected] • Or join the conversation on social media using the hashtag #BBCRadical

More from Radical with Gabriel Gatehouse

All episodes