Total Isolation: The Cabin in the Woods…

8 Jan 2026 · 52 min · 20 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

David Scott (19) and Scott Power (20) attempt a 12-month off-grid wilderness stay in a remote Manitoba cabin, but the cabin can’t be found after a navigation mistake. They endure extreme cold, hunger, makeshift shelters, tent stove failures, and Scott’s severe frostbite until the cabin is finally located buried in snow on day six.

Guest backgrounds

David grew up outdoors in northwest Indiana without TV, later became fascinated by wilderness survival after finding an arrowhead and reading about Native tools and survival. He worked at a camping store where he met Doc/Dr. William Forgy, who had built the cabin. Scott was also an outdoors enthusiast; both received wilderness medicine training from Forgy.

Key claims

Their isolation is total (no comms; nearest town 120 miles). The “vanishing cabin” was due to starting from the wrong point (they walked too far upriver). Small errors nearly killed them.

Notable examples

building a pine-bough shelter; kerosene stove and foil stovepipe; tent roof fire; Scott’s blackened foot and antibiotics; using a tall spruce to spot a map lake; finding a level snow line hiding the log cabin.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

A Cold Night in the Wilderness

0:34 to 3:33

Discover the harrowing experience of two young men trapped in the cold.

“A thick carpet of snow covers the ground in the wild, untamed north of Manitoba, Canada, smothering the greenery beneath it and muffling all sound.”

The Dream of Living Off-Grid

3:42 to 4:28

Explore the ambitious plan of David and Scott to live in the wild.

“idealistic 19-year-old gets the chance to fulfill his long-held dream of traveling deep into the wilderness and living off-grid for an entire year.”

The Journey to the Cabin Begins

4:35 to 10:11

Follow David and Scott as they prepare for their adventure in the wild.

“I'm John Hopkins from the Noiser Podcast Network.”

Realization of Isolation

12:38 to 14:02

Experience the moment David and Scott realize their remote surroundings.

“By the time David and Scott eventually board their plane in Thompson, it's a momentous step.”

Arrival at the Frozen Lake

14:02 to 15:10

David and Scott prepare to embark on their isolated adventure after landing.

“Papp skillfully lands the plane on the frozen surface and cuts the engine.”

Embracing the Wilderness

15:10 to 16:38

David and Scott take in the vast, cold wilderness as they commit to their journey.

“They've researched, planned, and prepped as best they can.”

The Grueling Hike to the Cabin

16:38 to 19:10

The duo faces a tough hike through deep snow as night falls.

“Although beginning their adventure in winter has its drawbacks, it also means they can transport their gear on sleds, making it much easier to move heavy loads.”

Desperation Sets In

19:10 to 20:25

After hours of walking, David and Scott realize they can't find the cabin.

“They're exhausted from plowing through the soft snow and they've had virtually nothing to eat or drink since the morning.”

The Fight Against the Cold

20:56 to 26:02

David and Scott struggle to survive in severe cold with inadequate shelter.

“It's the evening of January the 29th, 1991.”

The Tent Fire Incident

26:02 to 28:03

Just as they find warmth, a fire breaks out in their makeshift tent.

“Eventually, after a seemingly endless night, the sun starts to creep up over the tops of the trees.”
Show all 20 chapters

First Night's Struggles

28:03 to 29:51

Learn about the challenges faced by David and Scott on their first night in the tent.

“Finally, they experience the first hint of warmth since setting off the day before.”

Morning After the Storm

29:52 to 31:29

Discover how the friends cope with the aftermath of the snowstorm.

“because we'd worked too hard for things to fall apart like this.”

The Importance of Warmth

31:30 to 33:15

Understand the significance of warmth and hydration during extreme conditions.

“Normally, it would only take them a matter of minutes to set up.”

Facing Frostbite

33:16 to 34:34

Explore the onset of frostbite and its implications for survival.

“We don't have a cabin yet, but we at least have a system that seems to work.”

Managing Frostbite and Hope

35:31 to 37:36

Learn how David cares for Scott's frostbite while remaining hopeful.

“David stares at Scott's frozen, blackened foot, the toes swollen and dark.”

The Discovery of a New Direction

37:37 to 41:36

Hear about David's realization regarding their location and potential cabin.

“And so, for the fourth day running, David hikes the route between the river and Landing Lake.”

Final Push Towards the Cabin

41:37 to 42:01

Follow David's final attempts to locate the elusive cabin.

“That night, they have a hearty meal, excited by the tantalizing prospect of finding the cabin the next day.”

Finding the Cabin: A Moment of Elation

42:01 to 45:39

David recounts the experience of discovering the cabin after days of survival.

“Woke up early the next morning, had breakfast, got on the gear, and headed out.”

Reflections on Survival and Change

45:40 to 47:04

David reflects on how the experience changed his outlook on the wilderness.

“They even build another cabin a little way upstream from docks, which they call Paradise Creek Cabin, and give to the doctor as a Christmas present in December 1991.”

Lessons Learned from an Epic Adventure

47:05 to 48:58

David shares the profound lessons learned from his survival experience.

“and animation for an advertising agency.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Spring starts at the Home Depot and we are bringing the heat to your backyard this season. Fire up the flavor with our wide variety of grills for under$300. Like the next grill four burner gas grill that's perfect for hosting your spring cookout. Then set the scene and turn your outdoor space into the go-to spot the patio sets for every budget. Bring it this season with grills that deliver flavor and patios that set the vibe from the Home Depot. Start your spring with low prices guaranteed at the Home Depot. Exclusions apply. See Home Depot dot com slash price match for details.

0:34It's night time in late January 1991. A thick carpet of snow covers the ground in the wild, untamed north of Manitoba, Canada, smothering the greenery beneath it and muffling all sound. The vast, empty landscape is pristine, without a single sign of human habitation. The only source of light comes from a full moon, suspended like a crystal ball in the black expanse of a sky pinpricked by thousands of glittering stars. The moon's pale ghostly glow glints off a frozen river, which snakes across the land like a silver ribbon. It is bordered by dense, dark spruce trees, dusted with white flakes. Impassive sentinels, casting their long, eerie shadows.

1:25It is agonizingly cold and utterly still. Nothing stirs. But on the snow-covered ground, nestled among the stunted trees, is a small, makeshift shelter constructed from branches. Within this shelter are two shivering men, 19-year-old David Scott and 20-year-old Scott Power. They huddle together inside one sleeping bag, trying desperately to conserve what little body heat they have as the cold penetrates into every pore of their bodies, slowly leeching the life from them. Occasionally, one will shake the other, checking their companion is still alive. They've had nothing to eat or drink for hours, and they're physically exhausted from trudging across this beautiful, brutal landscape.

2:19But despite their weariness, sleep is virtually impossible. Laying there, just thinking about our situation, there were definitely moments of fear. Just wondering, like, am I going to see the sun come up? Are we going to live through this? Or what if one of us lives through it and the other one doesn't? You know, all of these thoughts that kind of creep in. Even if the two young men make it to the morning, dawn will quickly bring a whole host of new problems to contend with. There is no way back to civilization from here. Their only hope is to go deeper into the woods. I'm stuck here. You're kind of seeing things almost out of body, where you're kind of looking down and realizing, like, yeah, this little shelter that we've made.

3:07And this could very well be a grave marker.

3:33The End

3:42idealistic 19-year-old gets the chance to fulfill his long-held dream of traveling deep into the wilderness and living off-grid for an entire year. But when he and his friend arrive in the wilds of Manitoba, a nightmare scenario unfolds. The cabin they are planning to call home for the next 12 months seems to mysteriously vanish. They are unable to locate the only shelter available for miles, leaving themselves totally exposed in the frozen, primeval immensity of the forest. With the nearest town over 120 miles away, the two young men's romantic vision is put to the test when they are faced with disaster after disaster.

4:22Their one chance is to find the elusive cabin before it's too late. I'm at death's door. I'm in the jaws right now of Mother Nature and we have no choice but to survive. We have no choice but to work through this one way or another. I'm John Hopkins from the Noiser Podcast Network. This is Real Survival Stories.

5:06It's the morning of Tuesday, January the 29th, 1991, in Thompson, Manitoba. The small, central Canadian city serves as a hub for the surrounding area, and is considered a gateway to the wild, majestic landscape in the north of the province At one of the simple dining tables in their accommodation, two young men pick nervously at their breakfasts Staring down at their plates, David Scott and Scott Power push their food around with their forks, unable to get much down due to the butterflies in their stomachs For them, today is the start of an epic adventure. From Thompson, they will fly north into the wilderness where a small log cabin is waiting for them.

5:49It's the place they intend to call home for the next year, living off the land with a modest stock of provisions, embracing a simpler way of life. We awakened that morning and went down for breakfast and could barely eat anything just because your nerves are, they're firing, you're jumping. So breakfast was a scrap of food at best. After gulping down as much as they can manage, the two young men gather their things and make their way to the airport. They'll be flying in an otter, a type of bush plane which can be fitted with either floats or skis, allowing it to land on a variety of different terrains.

6:31But when they arrive at the small airport and see their craft for the first time, is clearly an issue. A group of workers are huddled around the plane, trying to fix a problem. The first thing I noticed was there was a crew of people around one wheel of this plane, which was connected to a ski because we're landing on snow. And they had a portable heater that was aimed at this wheel. And I believe they were thawing the hydraulics of the ski just because it was so bitter cold. According to their pilot, Hap, the area is in the midst of one of the worst cold snaps he's seen in decades. Temperatures are so low that he is forced to delay takeoff until it warms up a little.

7:18For David and Scott, it's a mere taste of things to come. It gave me an idea of like, whoa, this is, yeah, it's cold. And I'd never experienced temperatures like that. Not that David is totally unaccustomed to being out in the elements. In fact, it's been a passion of his for years. As a child, he grew up without a TV. So instead, he entertained himself outside, playing in the woods near his home, and imagining he was going on grand, heroic adventures. I grew up in northwest Indiana. I'm about 50 miles, maybe, from Chicago. It's not one of these places that just overwhelms you with these stunning landscapes.

8:00but there's definitely some beauty and some great outdoor things here as well. This was at a time when children were feral, wild cats. So going out into the woods and coming home at 8.30 at night, smelling like wood smoke and covered in mud. Then one day, when David was exploring a farmer's field near the woods, he unearthed something unusual, an arrowhead.

8:30This really changed everything for me. When I picked that arrowhead up, I realized the last person that ever touched this was likely a Native person. And for a 12, 13-year-old kid, it just kind of blew my mind. So I began reading everything I could find about these people, how they lived, how they survived in these environments, the tools they made, the things they built. And I also began to learn there was a deeper, I guess, spiritual connection to the wilderness. Around this time, David also wrote a story about running away to live in a log cabin in northern Canada. The seeds of a dream had been sown.

9:08After graduating from high school, unsure what he wanted to do with his life, he found work at a local camping store, where he met Scott, a fellow enthusiast for the great outdoors. David discovered that the man who founded the camping store was one Dr. William Forgy, a renowned adventurer and authority on wilderness medicine. There were stories that Dr. Forgy had built his own cabin in the wilds of Canada. David's imagination word. So I started hearing bits and pieces about this mysterious place, and one day this gentleman, Doc, as we call him, came into the store, and the owner said, yeah, that's the guy who built this place.

9:51And I walked up to him and I extended my hand. I didn't even say my name or introduce myself. I just said, I have to go to this place. I have to. And he said, well, you know, we'll see what we can do to get you up there. Scott was equally intrigued by the cabin in the woods. It didn't take long before an agreement was struck. David and Scott could have the use of the cabin for an entire year. After the first three months or so, Doc Forgy would visit them to check all was well and bring more supplies. Aside from that, they would be entirely alone.

10:31The expedition became David and Scott's focus for months and months. They spent their time planning, learning all they could from Doc, and stockpiling gear and supplies. But not everybody understood their vision. When I would tell people that I was going off on this expedition, And many were genuinely concerned, like, what's going to happen to your life? They felt as though if you didn't follow the normal path, things were not going to be great for you. But David and Scott won't be put off. They're too excited about the opportunity, about the unique allure of this adventure. I honestly didn't know what I wanted to do in terms of my career or anything like that.

11:14But one thing I knew was this opportunity presented itself and there was no way I was turning it down. I was just too passionate and excited about it to say no.

11:33You didn't start a business just to keep the lights on. You're here to sell more today than yesterday. You're here to win. Lucky for you, Shopify built the best converting checkout on the planet. Like the just one tapping, ridiculously fast acting, sky high sales stacking, champion of checkouts. That's the good stuff right there. So if your business is in it to win it, win with Shopify. Start your free trial today at Shopify.com slash win. Now streaming, the time traveling comedy movie of the year has arrived. Mike and Nick and Nick and Alice, only on Hulu. The film stars Vince Vaughn, James Marsden, and Asa Gonzalez in a wild action comedy about one disastrous night that spirals out of control.

12:21And here's the twist. There are two Vince Vaughns. Don't miss Mike and Nick and Nick and Alice, written and directed by Ben David Grabinski. Now streaming only on Hulu. Rated R.

12:38By the time David and Scott eventually board their plane in Thompson, it's a momentous step. The aircraft takes off, the ground falls away below them, and they travel further north. It's now that the realization of how truly isolated Doc's cabin is begins to sink in. Throughout that entire flight, I'm looking out and there is nothing. There's not a town. There is not a sign of man anywhere. And I'm just realizing during this whole flight just how remote this place is. It's almost impossible to describe. It's hard to understand unless you've stood in the middle of this place. It's in the middle of nowhere.

13:21They soar over impossibly vast swathes of snowy forest and ice-covered, glistening lakes that polka-dot the landscape. After an hour and a half, Hap points out the log cabin, a tiny structure tucked away in the dense trees below, near the banks of a frozen river. They fly over the building several times to make sure that it still appears structurally sound, then the pilot banks east towards a small lake about three miles away. Known as Landing Lake, it provides an ideal runway, and it should only take about three hours to hike from here to the cabin. In theory, at least. Papp skillfully lands the plane on the frozen surface and cuts the engine.

14:08He said, we've got about ten minutes to get your gear out of the plane, otherwise my engines will start freezing. And he certainly did not want to be stuck there. David and Scott work quickly to unload what they need to sustain them for the first few months. They hurriedly throw hundreds of kilos worth of gear and supplies onto the snowy banks of the lake, including tents, freeze-dried packets of food, camping stove, and gas. Then they watch as Hap climbs back into the plane. The pilot, before he left, did an interesting thing. He was sitting in the cockpit there, and he had his door open facing us.

14:48And he stared at us for longer than you would normally stare at somebody when you're parting ways. And I think he was doing that almost as if to give us an out. Because he knows what that country is like. He lives up there, you know, he flies up there. He understands how serious this is. And I think there was some concern there. But David and Scott have spent too long anticipating this moment. They've researched, planned, and prepped as best they can. And they're not about to back out now. They wave goodbye to Hap. He taxis back along the frozen runway and takes off into the frigid air. He is the last person they will see for months.

15:33The two friends watch the plane recede into the vast, empty stretch of northern sky. When it disappears from sight, they listen until the hum of its engine fades into nothingness. The first thing I noticed when we could no longer hear the engine was this incredible silence. It was silence unlike anything I'd heard, and cold unlike anything I'd ever felt. Swaddled in thick layers of clothing, David and Scott take in the majestic, frost-dappled brilliance of the wilderness around them. They are far from civilization. The nearest habitation is Churchill, a small port town on Hudson Bay. It's known as the polar bear capital of the world, and it's about 120 miles away.

16:23Once that plane drops you off, you've committed. You're not hiking out. We have no communication. So it's a pretty powerful moment. At this time of year, the days are short, and David and Scott only have a few hours of light left. There's not a moment to lose. Although beginning their adventure in winter has its drawbacks, it also means they can transport their gear on sleds, making it much easier to move heavy loads. After reaching the cabin, they intend to spend some time cleaning it up and settling in, before shuttling the rest of their stuff across from the lake in several trips. They load up their sleds, with enough provisions to last them a few days, put on their snowshoes, check the map, and use a compass to point themselves in the right direction.

17:10and they set off into the trees. This land is very flat. The trees grow very closely together. There are no real landmarks that you can see, so the only way to navigate is with a compass. And after about 20 steps into the trees, I think both of us realize this is not going to be a short hike. This is going to be grueling because when it's that cold, the snow is like powdered sugar. You don't float on top of it as you should with your snowshoes. Rather, you kind of punch through it and it kind of collapses on the snowshoe. They sink with every step, having to heave and haul their legs in and out of the deep snow.

17:57But the promise of reaching the cabin keeps spirits high. As they trudge on, darkness descends, bringing even lower temperatures. Soon, they are enveloped by the inky night. It's not easy to find their way in the dark, though they are helped by the light of the full moon, which glistens off the pristine snow and casts an eerie pallor over their magnificent surroundings. Finally, after four hours of walking, Scott spots the river in the distance, gleaming in the moonlight like a neon sign. Initially, the sight boosts their flagging spirits. But then I remembered something that Doc had told me, the guy who built the cabin.

18:41He said, you know, when you could see the river on that trail, when you could see the river, you're about halfway to the cabin. And I thought, that can't be right. But sure enough, he was right. And so we hiked another four hours. We've now been hiking eight hours, and we thought this was going to take three. And finally, we break through the tree line and now we're on the bank of this river. As the two friends emerge from the trees onto the banks of the ice-covered river, there is still no sign of their refuge. They're exhausted from plowing through the soft snow and they've had virtually nothing to eat or drink since the morning.

19:21Despite their attempts to insulate their water, it has frozen solid in the sub-arctic temperatures.

19:30Still, their struggles are nearly over. All they need to do now is find the cabin. David and Scott start walking along the river, scanning the treeline for any sign of the structure, and occasionally veering into the snow-covered woods. When that proves fruitless, they turn around and head in other directions, their concern growing with every passing step. One hour goes by without success, then two. And still they find nothing. The cabin is nowhere to be seen. So now it's ten hours have gone by. And this was that moment where suddenly you realize that something is wrong.

20:24Not sure how to tackle your taxes? Are you sweating the small print? You may be experiencing FOMO, the fear of messing up. The answer, using TurboTax on Intuit Credit Karma. They help you get your biggest refund, and then we help you do more with it with a personalized plan designed to help you hit your money goals. It's time to take your taxes to the max. Start filing today in the Credit Karma app.

20:55In a classroom of sodas, most stay quiet. Then there's Mr. Pibb. Sweet cherry, bold outbursts. The kind of flavor that gets attention. Bold kick of cherry. Hey, yo, Mr. Pibb.

21:12It's the evening of January the 29th, 1991. In the untamed backcountry of northern Manitoba, the sun set hours ago, plunging the world into freezing darkness. The night is quiet. It seems all living creatures have retreated somewhere safe and warm, seeking shelter from the savage cold. But on the banks of a frozen river, bordered by dense forest, two dark smudges move across the snow-covered ground. Less than 24 hours into David and Scott's trip, it's all falling apart. There is no sign of the cabin they're supposed to call home for the next year. It's as if it has vanished. Assuming they would have reached the shelter by now, the two young men left their tents back at the lake where their plane landed earlier in the day, along with the majority of their equipment and supplies.

22:06Exhausted, hungry, bitterly cold, and lacking any kind of real protection from the sub-Arctic conditions, things are looking bleak. This has now turned into a dire situation. Ideally, in a situation like that, in cold, you would build some kind of a snow shelter just because it's got better insulating qualities. But that snow, you can't pack it. You could, but it would take way too long for the snow to settle. So we made the decision to build something out of pine boughs. This shelter would not have saved anyone's life. It was the most pathetic, awful thing. But the mere act of taking action, I think, was beneficial.

22:52Once the flimsy frame of boughs is erected, David and Scott try to pile the powdery snow around it to help insulate the structure, but it just sifts through the gaps in the branches. They gather more pine boughs to lay on the ground inside their shelter and spread one of their two sleeping bags on top. Then they crawl into the other bag together and pull the open one around themselves.

23:20We're hugging each other to share what little heat we had. Laying there spooning my trip partner was definitely not something I'd envisioned. I had this dream, but in those temperatures, whatever you can do to find warmth, why? That's what you've got to do. The temperature is dropping fast. And with just a makeshift shelter and a couple of sleeping bags to protect them from the elements, the glacial winter cold is penetrating. It's 30 below freezing before they know it.

23:54Every so often, one of the men will shake his companion or mumble something to ensure he's still alive. Aside from that, there is no sound, but the hissing of their breath as it crystallizes in the air and the popping and cracking of the trees as their sap expands with the icy cold. I was frustrated because this was my big dream. We'd been planning for so long, and now here it is on the first night, things go wrong.

24:27As well as the cold, David's feet are in excruciating pain. After hours of plowing through the snow in his mutlucks, a kind of soft boot designed to be worn in cold weather. David asks Scott if his feet are hurting too. Scott says no. In agony, David removes his mutluks and begins rubbing his feet to help the circulation. Unsurprisingly, sleep is elusive, and the long empty hours of darkness stretch out between the two friends.

25:04All the activity and action is over, and now you're laying there with your thoughts, realizing the severity of this situation, realizing there's a good chance that mourning might not come, and realizing, like, yeah, this little shelter that we've made, this could very well be a grave marker.

Read the full transcript

25:26I thought a lot about my mom and dad, for example. For them to support such an endeavor, not being able to have contact with your kid, not knowing if they're okay or if they're alive for a year. That's a pretty amazing thing. So I thought about them a lot, that evening laying there. So far as they're concerned, I'm at the cabin right now with my feet up by the stove with a hot chocolate and nice and toasty warm. And here I am, I'm at death's door. I'm in the jaws right now of Mother Nature.

26:02Eventually, after a seemingly endless night, the sun starts to creep up over the tops of the trees. Weakened and numb, but relieved to have made it through, David and Scott muster their remaining strength and agree to look again for the cabin. Maybe it will be easier to spot in daylight. This time they split up, searching in different directions. But when they regroup, it's clear neither has good news. In desperation, they decide to go back to the lake where they landed the previous day, and where the rest of their equipment and supplies are. Though it's galling to retrace their steps so soon, they don't have much choice.

26:45They're unlikely to survive another night in a shoddy, self-made shelter. They need a tent. Following the trail they broke the previous day makes the journey easier. Within a few hours, they're back at the lake. They dig through their equipment to find a canvas expedition tent belonging to Dock and start setting it up. Originally, they planned to use it for occasional trips into the wilderness after reaching the cabin. Now, it might well save their lives.

27:18This tent comes complete with a small kerosene stove and a stovepipe that goes out the top of the tent. However, one of the stovepipe pieces was at the cabin. It's an elbow-shaped piece, so kind of an important one. And we knew this going in, but why would we be messing with or using a tent before actually using the cabin? That thought had never occurred to us. So we fashioned one out of aluminum foil. It was the best we could do, and clearly we were desperate. it. With their makeshift piece of pipe rigged up, David and Scott fill the stove tank with kerosene and light it. Finally, they experience the first hint of warmth since setting off the day before.

28:09They fill a pan with snow and set it on the stove to melt. The prospect of water and hot food is tantalizing. Once their basic needs are satisfied, the two men will be able to assess their situation more clearly and hopefully work out where they went wrong. Then, just as they're settling in, another issue suddenly arises. Right about the time that snow was turning to slush, the only liquid form of water for 120 miles, I heard Scott yell fire. And looking up, you could see that the top of the tent, where our little rigged stovepipe was, was in flames. David and Scott quickly throw the stove out of the tent and extinguish the smoldering canvas.

29:02Though the immediate danger has passed, so has any chance of proper hydration or a hot meal. In the ten seconds it took to avert disaster, the almost-melted slush in the pan has solidified once again, turning into ice. Though they have another tent in their pile of gear outside, David and Scott are too cold and exhausted to face the prospect of pitching it. Shivering and hungry, the two friends climb into their sleeping bags and suck on frozen fudge and granola bars until they're thawed enough to swallow. Above, the darkening sky yawns through a scorched hole in the roof of the tent. It's going to be another long, cold night.

29:51So once again, we're going to bed, not hydrated, very hungry, and at this point really pissed off because we'd worked too hard for things to fall apart like this. And that evening, because we had set the tent up right kind of on the bank of the lake there. We were pretty exposed, and we got beat down pretty good with a pretty heavy snowstorm that night. By morning, the tent had just more or less collapsed around us. When the sun rises on the third day, David and Scotts crawl out of their snow-covered, half-clapsed tent and take in the surrounding wilderness once more, as austere and unforgiving as ever.

30:35The two men need a plan. They decide to pack up their sleds with supplies and go back once again to the river. There, they can set up camp and use it as a base for exploring the surrounding area. With any luck, it should make finding the cabin easier. Once each sled is loaded with equipment, including their second tent, David and Scott hike back to the river, leaving their scorched canvas shelter behind. When they eventually reach the frozen river again, they conduct another search for the cabin, hoping against hope that they will stumble upon it. When they find nothing, they give in and decide to set up camp, not far from the spot where they spent the first night.

31:22This time, they're using a more modern tent, with flexible poles that form a dome-shaped frame. Normally, it would only take them a matter of minutes to set up. But the poles have been damaged by the extreme cold, and their weakened, semi-frozen hands make heavy weather of the process. Darkness falls around them, and the temperature plummets further. After an age, their tent is at last ready. As Scott was climbing into the tent, he turned around and looked at me for something. He was asking me a question. And his face looked really gaunt and blue, and he looked horrible. And I thought, God, I must look exactly the same.

32:11This is bad.

32:15Shivering and exhausted, they attempt to light a small camping stove. Fumbling with their numb fingers, they eventually achieved success. We decided to fire it up in the tent, which is, you know, typically you wouldn't do. But we didn't care. I mean, so long as we die warm, we'll be okay with that. The second we lit that, the inside of the tent almost inflated like a hot air balloon with hot air. And instantly it was warm. and we could start removing layers of gear and it was the most beautiful moment. Finally able to boil water for drinking and cooking, David and Scott devour their first proper meal in three days and each consume several liters of water.

33:05It's a mini triumph in the circumstances. They've successfully brought their bodies back from the brink of defeat. That evening, our spirits were definitely up. We don't have a cabin yet, but we at least have a system that seems to work. I'll be a little unorthodox, but it worked. So we looked at the maps again that evening, finally climbed into our banks and went to sleep. Now, the second you shut that stove off, like the second you shut it off, it's as cold inside as it is outside.

33:40Freezing, but with full bellies, David and Scott hunker down for the night, determined that tomorrow they will start afresh and finally locate the elusive cabin. When morning arrives, the friends feel a new determination, a new sense of optimism. David and Scott have coffee and begin to prepare themselves for a day of searching. But then, a fresh disaster strikes. We were kind of in the process of getting ready when I heard Scott call out. And I turned around, I looked, and he's holding his foot up. And his entire foot was black. He had suffered some severe frostbite. Scott can't risk going out.

34:22And this means now that a two-man team is cut down to a one-man team.

34:34is brought to you by Redfin. You're listening to a podcast, which means you're probably multitasking, maybe even scrolling home listings on Redfin, saving homes without expecting to get them. But Redfin isn't just built for endless browsing. It's built to help you find and own a home. With agents who close twice as many deals, when you find the one, you've got a real shot at getting it. Get started at redfin.com. Own the dream. This episode is brought to you by State Farm. Listening to this podcast? Smart move. Being financially savvy? Smart move. Another smart move? Having State Farm help you create a competitive price when you choose to bundle home and auto.

35:17Bundling. Just another way to save with a personal price plan. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there. Prices are based on rating plans that vary by state. Coverage options are selected by the customer. Availability, amount of discounts and savings, and eligibility vary by state. David stares at Scott's frozen, blackened foot, the toes swollen and dark. It was very bad, and for someone unfamiliar with seeing something like frostbite, it was, you know, visually kind of intimidating. Clearly, that first night in that shelter when I asked him, hey, are your feet hurting you? And he said no. He left his mukluks on.

36:01We'd done 10 hours of extreme hiking, a lot of sweat building up in those boots. And so when he went to bed, it was essentially like going to bed with two blocks of ice on your feet. And the reason his feet weren't hurting was because they were frozen. It was manageable still. But the important thing was he cannot freeze it any further or he's going to do some serious damage to this. Before embarking on this trip, both men received medical training from Doc Forgy. Ideally, they would thaw Scott's foot in warm water, but there is a significant chance that it could re-freeze in these temperatures, leading to all sorts of potential problems, including gangrene and auto-amputation.

36:51They can't take the risk. The care that we took immediately was very basic. The only thing really that we could do was make sure that he had a clean, dry pair of socks on. And that was about the extent of it, just for the sake of getting us to the cabin where we can really do more maintenance, I guess. It's now their fourth day of searching for the mysterious cabin in the woods. and the responsibility to locate it now rests entirely on David's shoulders. But before that, he prioritizes the well-being of his friend. Their medical kit contains antibiotics to ward off secondary infections that could develop as a result of the frostbite.

37:35But their medical kit is still in their canvas tent back at the lake. And so, for the fourth day running, David hikes the route between the river and Landing Lake. It's become a familiar trudge. When he gets there, he fumbles to find the entrance of their tent, which lies semi-submerged in snow. He crawls inside and locates the medical kit. He takes the opportunity to grab some other provisions as well. Then he treks back to the river, where Scott's is patiently waiting. That day, really, there was no searching for the cabin at all. But again, we're still feeling relatively positive. Despite not having a cabin, despite the frostbite, we're at least relatively safe in this little bubble that we've made.

38:28David gives Scott the antibiotics and they eat dinner before bedding down for the night. Hopefully, the morning will bring a change in their luck. David sleeps fitfully, but when dawn breaks on the fifth morning, he forces himself out of the relative warmth of his sleeping bag and lights the stove. After breakfast, he prepares himself to face the freezing wilderness outside once more. Scott wishes him good luck, and David steps out into the dazzling brightness of snow and sky. Believing they are somewhere downriver from the cabin, he decides to head upstream. He tramps across the snow, a mere speck against the brilliant white expanse.

39:13David's reasons for coming here were simple. The trip has proven to be anything but. With every day, every hour, every step that passes, things become more desperate. What might finish them first? The cold, frostbite, hunger, or exhaustion? And just as it seems another day is about to disappear without success, something catches David's eye. I found this stand of trees that was extraordinarily tall. Most of the trees up there, because the environment is so brutal, they're really stunted. They grow maybe 30 feet, something like that. These were massive spruce trees. And I thought, I wonder if I climb one of these, If I can spot anything, like anything man-made or some landmark or something.

40:04If he falls, the consequences will be catastrophic. But with still no sign of the cabin, a bold approach is needed. David takes off his snowshoes and begins to climb, the chunky branches providing slippery foot and handholds. Encumbered by his bulky winter clothing, it's not easygoing. It was a nightmare trying to climb this. But I got up a little bit above the trees, and I noticed upstream, maybe a half a mile or a quarter mile, was this small lake. And I started thinking, like, if I could find this lake on the map, then clearly we'll be able to find where we are in relation to the cabin. David climbs back down the tree and returns to the tent as the sun slips below the horizon.

40:59He tells Scott about his theory, and the two of them eagerly open their crumpled map. And sure enough, there on the map is this little tiny lake. I was amazed our maps had enough detail to show that. And the second we saw that, we thought, well, if in fact this is the lake, which we were fairly certain it was, were actually upstream from where the cabin is by about a mile. All this time, the two men had assumed they were downriver from the cabin. But if David's hypothesis is right, then they had been searching in the wrong direction. That night, they have a hearty meal, excited by the tantalizing prospect of finding the cabin the next day.

41:44And that's not the only good news. Scott's foot is showing some signs of improvement, though his big toe remains worryingly black, and they still can't tend to it properly. But if all goes well, that shouldn't be a problem for much longer. Going to bed that night, we were feeling really good about our situation. Woke up early the next morning, had breakfast, got on the gear, and headed out. The only noise to break the quiet of the wilderness is the crunch of David's snowshoes and the sound of his own rasping breath. He covers ground slowly, slushing through the deep snow as his eyes skim the forest beside him.

42:29And after getting about a mile downstream, maybe about 40 yards into the tree line and about 15 feet off the ground, I noticed this level line of snow. And if you spend a lot of time in the outdoors, immediately your eye goes, well, that's not natural. There's nothing level like that in the outdoors. David heads towards this strange sight. As he approaches, he sinks into waist-deep snow. And there, poking out from the trees in front of him, is a wall of logs. And I knew that was it. The cabin was absolutely buried in snow. Like, it would have been so easy to miss.

43:16Finally, after six days of surviving in the wilderness, David has found the cabin. He flounders through the deep snow to the building, opens the door, and cautiously steps inside. Given how their luck has gone so far, it doesn't seem out of the question that he might stumble on a hibernating bear. My first reaction was just elation at the fact that like, oh, we're okay now, we're going to be okay. And when I stepped into the main cabin, I'm looking around, this was that moment where I had this realization that this is the thing that I dreamt about. Like, this is the thing that I wrote about. All of a sudden, here I am.

44:01It's become a reality somehow. It was really a strange and exciting moment, you know, just to be there. I was so excited to tell Scott that I found myself almost jogging down this trail. So by the time I reached the tent, I was winded, and my chest hurt because of all the cold. And Scott opened up the door, and he said, well, did you find it? And it took me a while to finally catch my breath. and I told them, yeah, I found it.

44:33After nearly a full week, David and Scott make it to their new home. They're finally able to enjoy true safety, shelter, and warmth. Later, they work out the reason they became lost in the first place was a simple one. In their excitement to reach the cabin, they made one crucial mistake. They got their starting point wrong. Instead of setting off near a small stream branching off from the lake as they were supposed to, they started walking from the exact spot where the plane dropped them off, meaning they found themselves significantly further upriver than intended. A tiny error that so nearly had enormous consequences.

45:15They spend three memorable months at the cabin before Doc Forgy comes to visit them and restock their supplies. When he hears their story, he's amazed they survived the ordeal And when Doc sees the state of Scott's foot, he insists on pulling the two friends out Although he's impressed by the care they've taken so far, Scott needs a skin graft The two young men both return home for the procedure But in July, after Scott's foot has had time to heal They head back to the cabin to complete the rest of their adventure In between daily tasks, such as cutting firewood and fetching water, they also explore the surrounding landscape on foot and canoe, hunt for game and read and write.

46:00They even build another cabin a little way upstream from docks, which they call Paradise Creek Cabin, and give to the doctor as a Christmas present in December 1991.

46:14Strangely, once the experience is over, David finds that his feelings towards the wilderness have changed. David I think a lot of people that are explorers or that do these types of things don't give enough consideration to the challenges of coming out, because you go through a bit of a depression. When I came home, I discovered my passion to be in the outdoors was no longer there, not nearly to the extent it used to be. And this concerned me, you know, because it's like this was almost my religion.

46:52Though David tries to rekindle his relationship with the outdoors, he struggles. Some fundamental change has taken place within him. Around this time, he discovers an interest in computers and ends up getting a job doing graphic design and animation for an advertising agency. Yet now, more than three decades on from his Canadian adventure, he has found himself drawn once again to his old passions, and he is slowly rediscovering his love of the natural world. He attributes his survival to his age at the time, his skills and training as an outdoorsman, and his understanding that they had no choice but to save themselves.

47:33Although he already had a deep connection with the wilderness, David feels he and Scott both learned a valuable lesson from those six days in which they battled for their lives. I think we had a new appreciation, a newfound respect for just how dangerous this place can be. The smallest mistake can kill you. And so that was a profound lesson, and I think we both would agree we'd never want to go through that again, but it was the ideal way to start that trip because it put the wilderness and mother nature, for lack of a better in a new light. I think it would be rare for a day to go by for me not to think about that place.

48:17It had such a profound impact on my life and everything I've done. It was kind of a childhood dream, and it was such a great and epic adventure. So I think about it very often. And the lesson there, at least for me, was your path may take some weird bends and turns, and sometimes you just got to roll with it. I've come to realize, like, sometimes you just have to move where the river takes you, and that's how it works.

48:59Next time, we meet Sandra Younger. In 2003, she and her husband Bob have just bought a home in the mountainous backcountry outside San Diego, a beautiful, rugged region of rolling hills and canyons. Together with their pets, they are living a life of quiet contentment. Until the early hours of the morning on October 26th, when Sandra wakes to an unfolding nightmare. Fueled by strong winds, the blaze will spread at a terrifying pace. And with their beloved home right in its unstoppable path, Sandra and Bob will have just minutes to evacuate. With a winding, perilous journey back down the hills ahead of them, surviving the fire will take tremendous skill, luck, and a timely helping hand from the strangest of rescuers.

49:49That's next time on Real Survival Stories. Listen right now by joining Noisa+. Protein is now at Starbucks, and it's never tasted so good. You can add protein cold foam to your favorite drink or try one of our new protein lattes or matcha. Try it today at Starbucks.

50:10Your little one grew three inches overnight. Adorable. Also, expensive. Sell their pint-sized pieces on Depop and list them in minutes with no selling fees. Because somewhere, a dad refuses to pay full price for the clothes his kids will outgrow tomorrow. And he's ready to buy your son's entire wardrobe right now. Consider your future growth spurt budget secured. Start selling on Depop, where taste recognizes taste. Payment processing fees and boosting fees still apply. See website for details.

From the publisher

An idealistic teenager gets the chance to fulfil his long-held dream of living off-grid for an entire year. But when David Scott and his friend arrive deep in the wilderness of Manitoba, a nightmare scenario unfolds. Unable to locate their cabin - the only shelter for 120 miles - they are totally exposed. With civilisation unreachable, their only hope is to venture deeper into the woods and find the elusive cabin before it’s too late…

 

A Noiser podcast production. Hosted by John Hopkins.

 

Written by Heléna Lewis | Produced by Ed Baranski | Assistant Producer: Luke Lonergan | Exec produced by Joel Duddell | Sound supervisor: Tom Pink | Sound design by Matt Peaty | Assembly edit by Rob Plummer | Compositions by Oliver Baines, Dorry Macaulay, Tom Pink | Mix & mastering: Ralph Tittley.

For more on this story check out David's book, Paradise Creek: A True Story of Adventure and Survival.

For ad-free listening, bonus material and early access to new episodes, join Noiser+. Click the subscription banner at the top of the feed to get started. Or go to noiser.com/subscriptions

If you have an amazing survival story of your own that you’d like to put forward for the show, let us know. Drop us an email at support@noiser.com
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from Real Survival Stories

All 69 episodes
Total Isolation: The Cabin in the Woods…Real Survival Stories · 52 min
Listen in VO