

17 Nov 2026 · 1h 12m · 26 chapters

What motivates founders to start startups, what “bad” motivations look like, and how Lux Capital evaluates founders’ credibility, execution, and leadership. Wolfe argues that emotional “sins” (envy, greed, pride) can become productive fuel when paired with a moral compass, while Silicon Valley-style mindfulness can dampen societal progress by removing “disaffected” drive. He also emphasizes solving “what sucks,” authentic mission storytelling, and CEO jobs: set vision, secure resources (fundraising), and model behavior.
Josh Wolfe is founder of Lux Capital, an investor with offices split between New York and Menlo Park. He discusses his own upbringing in Coney Island, Brooklyn, and his investment/portfolio experience interviewing many founders.
Best founders have “something to prove” (a chip on the shoulder) rooted in real pain, not just status. Investors and talent are attracted to “I'll show them” energy. Great execution beats timelines/budget; credibility snowballs. Founders must avoid dishonesty/fraud; “Mother Nature can’t be fooled.”
Palmer Luckey (fired from Facebook; builds defense/hardware via Anduril-like mission; “chips in pockets”); Elon Musk (capital fundraising and timeline constraints; Wolfe criticizes Tesla/SolarCity accounting truthfulness); Oprah Winfrey, Elon, Bezos, Larry Ellison (pain-to-progress examples); Trevor Milton (fake-it-before-you-make-it); Impulse (Sam D’Amico engineering persistence); Hadrian (Chris); Reflect Orbital (Ben); Anduril’s Australia operations/GoShark; Osmo founder Alex Wilchko; Control Labs (gesture via neuron sensing).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on good and bad motivations for founders, including insights on jealousy and pride.
“station in life that they resent, and they want to take that person down, which I can see is a negative thing, rather than self-actualizing to go do the thing for yourself.”
Exploration of how personal pain and hardship can motivate successful entrepreneurs.
“Now, ideally, you want that paired with a moral compass so that you don't go off the rails.”
How successful founders recognize and address problems in their industries.
“doesn't matter how much money they make, how much fame they get, what sort of status they achieve, it's still there.”
A detailed look at Palmer Luckey's journey and motivations in founding his company.
“We backed Palmer in the founding days of Vanderbilt.”
Discussion on the common traits of successful founders and their internal drives.
“We've backed him in Erebor, which is a bank.”
Examination of Elon Musk's methods and the perception of his ambitions in business.
“If you take someone like Elon today, he's able to start companies very differently than he could have 20 years ago.”
Discussion on ethical concerns regarding honesty and accountability in startups.
“And I think that people are drawn to the fact that he sets what seems like ridiculous goals.”
Exploration of founder dishonesty, self-deception, and ethics in startups.
“dishonesty, particularly accounting and some of the representations, not about, oh, we're going going to have this in six months and it might take two or three or six years.”
Discussion on the importance of honesty in engineering and iterative processes.
“There's deception in sports, there's deception in politics, there's deceptions in business, and we deceive ourselves.”
Insights on how meaningful stories and authenticity drive successful startups.
“I think the vast majority of people don't want to work on something that doesn't matter.”
Understanding intrinsic motivations behind founders' decisions and actions.
“When a founder comes in and says, I just want to change the world.”
Learn about the key risks and interpersonal dynamics that impact startup founders.
“And I always think about these as risks, right?”
Explore the significance of execution, competition, and storytelling in entrepreneurship.
“that has the technical genius, can recruit people and tell the story, can raise money, can negotiate and sit across the table.”
Discover the pressures founders face and the importance of resilience.
“And I really admire and I respect and I trust him.”
Learn about the dynamics and advantages of co-founding teams.
“Again, the Andrel founders, you know, there's four core people, much broader group, but Matt and Cole have a great dynamic.”
Understand how successful founders approach risk and failure.
“when we were talking about the virtues of CEOs and leadership and why they might go awry.”
Explore how naivety can lead to groundbreaking innovations.
“founders who are genuinely great and they keep on talking about basically making these like low probability bets, but in, you know, putting all their chips behind them, but then they work and then they work consistently.”
Examine the significance of self-belief among entrepreneurs.
“Now, when you actually say like, what is that risk?”
Learn about the strategy of under-promising to build credibility.
“He doesn't sound like us, the accent or whatever.”
Understand the challenges of publicly criticizing founders and companies.
“Ben at Reflect, I think was the same thing.”
Discover how founders' ambitions evolve as their ideas develop.
“other partners like, I think we should fund this particular company.”
Explore how founders' ambitions evolve and the significance of larger market valuations.
“Typically what happens is they start out with some idea or some problem that they want to go tackle.”
Discuss the importance of understanding founder motivations and character through personal interactions.
“And I think that the best founders don't want to go and solve small problems.”
Analyze the lessons learned from the FTX situation and the complexities of risk assessment in investment.
“There's been other instances where we felt the inverse, where we had that Pampers effect after a pitch where we're like, holy shit, this guy is amazing.”
Delve into the necessity of trust and ethical considerations when backing founders and startups.
“Very few founders or very few investors have experienced what it's like to go through a blow up.”
Learn about the importance of unique capabilities and fundraising strategies for startup success.
“Products, they don't work, they get discontinued.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Relentless, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Today I'm sitting down with Josh Wolfe, the founder of Lux Capital. Josh, I want to start this off on the idea of like seven deadly sins. What are good motivations for founders and startups and what are bad motivations?
0:11Josh Wolfe: I love that you think of me and you think of the seven deadly sins. You know, I think Warren Buffett would have said that like of all of the sins, jealousy is the worst. But as I think about them all, and I can't actually name them, but it's like gluttony, sloth, envy, jealousy, greed. He would say that jealousy is the worst because it doesn't get you anything. But I actually reject that premise because I do think that when people are jealous, they are highly motivated to do something about it. The viceful part is maybe that they want to take the person who is successful or doing something in a position of status or station in life that they resent, and they want to take that person down, which I can see is a negative thing, rather than self-actualizing to go do the thing for yourself.
0:53Josh Wolfe: But I think all those things are intrinsically these emotional motivators that get you out of a state that is status quo, stasis, and basically propels you to escape that feeling, to want to get rid of that feeling. And so greed is desiring something that somebody else has. I was greedy in a sense that was also maybe born in envy and jealousy because I did not grow up with money and I saw people who had money and I was deeply envious of them. And I looked at them and said, particularly for kids who were born into wealth, which I was not, to see that they had means, resources, had traveled the country, had a passport, went outside, had cars, went on ski vacations.
1:30Josh Wolfe: And I wanted that. And it wasn't deserved. It was in some case given to them, silver spoon or inherited, palpably felt in college when I saw these kids. And I said, wait a second, I'm smarter than them. Isn't this supposed to be all about merit? And so if I'm achieving better or doing more or more intelligent, then I should be having that thing. And then I realized like that's not necessarily how the game works. And so that was a big motivator for me. Pride is another one, right? Where it's like a sin to be prideful. But I think people should be proud. They should be proud not to the point of hubris, which of course, every great narrative from Odysseus to the present has a chronicle usually leads to somebody's downfall.
2:09Josh Wolfe: But I think that these sins tend to be great motivators for human progress. This is one of the great disagreements I have with half my firm that is in Silicon Valley. Half of Lux is in New York, half of Menlo Park. And the Silicon Valley ethos, if I had to caricature it in extreme, is about mindfulness and meditation, which is amazing for the individual. It's good that people can find a sense of stoicism and peace and calm amongst the chaos of everyday life, but it's actually terrible for society. You want, for progress, troves of disaffected people that are like, that sucks. I hate that person.
2:45Josh Wolfe: And I can't believe that they just raised a round. And that is the great motivator. And so I always like to say that chips on shoulders, put chips in pockets. And the number one trait that I look for in founders, and even for people inside of Lux, is somebody with something to prove. Now, ideally, you want that paired with a moral compass so that you don't go off the rails. But I find that that is the number one determinant of success. somebody that really has something to prove, that grew up in an area where they were the only minority kid, whether they were gay or black, in a mostly white, homogenous neighborhood of Friday Night Lights football.
3:21Josh Wolfe: They had a broken family. Their father wasn't there. They resented their father. I think maybe we might personally share that. And it's a great motivator to basically be an embodiment of the most powerful words, which are, I'll show them. Whether the them are your high school peers, a family member, somebody that doubted you, a teacher that said you would never amount to something. endless examples of some of the most successful people in history that are studied. And we study them for their virtuous traits, but it is the sinful pain that people felt. You look at Elon Musk, who I've been publicly critical about some things, you wouldn't wish his childhood on your worst enemy.
3:54Josh Wolfe: Oprah Winfrey, this great patron saint in the media, had a horrific childhood. Brother, drug addict, raped people with AIDS, like just horrible. Jeff Bezos adopted, Larry Ellison adopted. All of these people thrive not in spite of that stuff that they suffered, but because of it. So if you can find that source of pain, and I have found that the people that hold that pain, people are like, you know, let it go and find peace. And again, for the individual, it's good. It's healthy. It provides mental sanity. But for society, you want those troves of disaffected people that feel some sort of internal pain.
4:29Josh Wolfe: It is the fire that burns inside of them. And it doesn't matter how much money they make, how much fame they get, what sort of status they achieve, it's still there. And you can see it in people that are 60, 70, 80 years old, and they still are competing and they're still fighting. And if you get to the root of why, if you keep asking why, why, why, it's like that hurt child at 10, 12, 15 years old, whatever it is. And I actually think that that is the thing that has propelled all great and horrible things in societies. Initially, I think you're very right about like chips on shoulders, put chips in pockets, But I think at some point along that cycle, it becomes like a self-competition game.
5:05What are the best motivations across starting with nothing to your running$100 billion company?
5:11Josh Wolfe: Well, the best motivation for any founder, which sounds cliched, but is like solving somebody else's problem, doing something that doesn't exist or sucks. I would say that the most sophisticated words that you can look for, you know, you don't need a PhD for, but are two words, which is what sucks. And you identify what sucks, then you can positively with motivation go and solve that problem. and ideally through some technological secret or some scientific breakthrough that nobody else has so that if they also want to solve the problem, they are disadvantaged and you're advantaged. If you take one of my favorite examples of this, Palmer Luckey.
5:40Josh Wolfe: We backed Palmer in the founding days of Vanderbilt. Palmer is the embodiment of a chip on his shoulder. You know, his background is unconventional, his style is unconventional, and he actually has a very strong, I think, through line philosophically about what he believes. And I think it's very like moral and libertarian and consistent. He's fired from Facebook because he had totally contra views at the time around Donald Trump. I was never a Trump supporter. But watching that when he was fired because he had these, at the time, heretical views, he then goes and is sort of out in the wild and is like, what am I going to do next?
6:14Josh Wolfe: And he recognized that there's this rising threat of sovereign aggressiveness from our adversaries, that there is no secret Stark Industries lab that is developing the most cutting edge defense capabilities. So he says, I'm going to go build that. We think like there's some James Bond Q. We think that the national labs at Los Alamos and Sandia are developing these cutting edge technologies, but it really wasn't. So there was no cavalry that was coming in. The big bureaucratic defense players were neither tracking the cutting edge talent that were developing cutting edge tech, nor coming up with the innovations that other countries out of necessity had to do.
6:49Josh Wolfe: So he said, I'm going to start this company. And effectively, what Palantir had done for software, he was going to do for hardware. And over a brunch or breakfast, we debate about what it was. Trey Stevens, who's the chair of Anderle and a friend and partner of Founders Fund said, hey, I'm going to be starting this company with Palmer. And without him even finishing the sentence, I'm like, I'm in. Palmer started with a mission, but he had this chip on his shoulder. And people today will be like, dude, let it go. Whether he's picking fights with podcasters or third rate journalists that, you know, dissed him 15 years ago.
7:22Josh Wolfe: Or Paul Graham. Yeah. Or Paul Graham most recently. And he will literally on a principled basis, call people out if he feels that they are lying, if he feels like they disrespected him or misrepresented what he said and holds them to account. And people are constantly like, dude, let it go. And I'm like, no, keep going. Because it is this fire that burns inside of him. He's a billionaire multi-times over. We've backed him in Erebor, which is a bank. We've backed him in Mod Retro, sort of a combination of nostalgia and just exquisitely sophisticated attention to detail and design of consumer electronics and Andrel and there'll be many others.
7:59Josh Wolfe: And in every one of these things, he looks at something and says, that sucks. Nobody else is doing it. I'm going to do it. He's attracting the talent, attracting the capital, but the fire in him is, I think, a beautiful, virtuous thing. And the important caveat is that it has to be paired with that moral compass. Because if you have somebody that has that fire and something to prove and a chip on their shoulder, you have endless accounts and examples of frauds and terrible behavior, and you just need that moral compass to be paired with it. Now, sometimes to your point, your question, at some point in a company's development, does it become self-defeating if you have that, or are you competing with yourself in that sense?
8:34Josh Wolfe: And I think it starts with that spark of, I'll show them. It starts with that spark of what sucks, and you're going to go solve it. And then people believe and see that fiery animus in you, and they're attracted to it. Investors are attracted to it. Talent is attracted to it. But then, and I think this is the brilliance of Palmer. Elon is 56, and he runs many, many companies. Palmer's 34, but he's been really brilliant at finding extraordinary talent to run the companies for him. And most of the people say, you don't want Palmer running these companies. You want him coming up and ideating with the brilliant, sometimes seemingly harebrained ideas that many people are going to doubt and be skeptical of and then be like, he was right.
9:10Josh Wolfe: And so I think for him, it's have that internal fire and that power and that animus, pair it with the moral compass and get extraordinary talent, like in the case of Andrel, Brian Schimpf, in the case of Mod Retro, Torn, that can run the company and execute sort of that vision. If you take someone like Elon today, he's able to start companies very differently than he could have 20 years ago. And the like talent pool that he has and access to capital and everything is very different. He's also got that this like built trust with the world, where if he says that he's going to go to something absolutely fucking insane, by default, people are going to be like, okay, maybe this maybe this kind of works, or he's going to actually do it.
9:48When you're meeting with someone that has, I don't know, not that same kind of track record, and not that same ability to raise money or attract talent. How do you decide whether or not a vision is worth believing in.
10:00Josh Wolfe: I think you over time develop a judgment to see that somebody has, again, that sort of animus and that fire. I think, again, I've been very critical about Elon for like Tesla related things and accounting and subtle nuances, but it is undeniable. He is a, the greatest capital fundraiser in history. Number two, his social currency, which is unmatched. He has a negative cost of capital. To your point, He can say, I'm going to start whatever, a flamethrower, tequila brand, boring company, invasive brain machine interface, literally anything. I've actually been upset that he didn't start something in nuclear because I know he was very focused on solar, but had he said, the world needs nuclear energy and it should be an American nuclear company, man, the talent and the capital that would have flooded behind that, which would have been a great virtuous thing, zero carbon, large baseload power for the United States, rather than letting China develop nuclear plants all over the world and creating dependencies on the CCP.
10:56Josh Wolfe: I think that would have been one of the greatest strokes that he could have done. But his ability to mobilize capital and talent is undeniable. I will say nothing bad about that. There are times where I question his relationship with the truth about certain things. And then people's counter would be like, no, he's just early, but he isn't wrong. And I think that people are drawn to the fact that he sets what seems like ridiculous goals. And I think this is actually another great virtue. It was a conversation I was having with David Epstein, who's an author who wrote The Sport Gene, and then most recently, a great book called Inside the Box.
11:29Josh Wolfe: Instead of thinking outside the box, think inside the box. And he talks about the virtue of constraints. And in conversation with Bill Gurley, who is a retired partner of Benchmark and a fellow trustee of the Santa Fe Institute and a brilliant mind, brilliant student of human nature, he was saying, you know, in reading David's book, one of the great virtues that I realized about Elon is that the constraints that he puts on people. In some cases, because of artificiality of time. Somebody will say, we're going to do whatever. We're building subterranean apartments on Mars. And they're like, yeah, that'll take four years.
12:03Josh Wolfe: And he will say, with the stern, indignant, high expectation setting absurdity, I need it in four months. And of course, it won't be in four months, but it definitely won't be in four years because he has set an expectation. You need to figure this out. Use ingenuity, use your resources, hire people, find outside vendors and get it done because otherwise you're going to lose your job. And so a combination of ambition, greed, and fear, going back to these vices and the sins, I think is actually a great thing. We started doing this once I was discussing with Bill Gurley and David Epstein about this with little things, something in the office.
12:37Josh Wolfe: Somebody's like, oh yeah, it'll take two weeks to fix. I'll be like, I need it in two hours. And they will figure it out in two days. And so I think that there's a virtue of putting artificial constraints on time and setting a high expectation and people will get it done. Was your biggest gripe with Elon just purely the timelines? No, my gripe with him was around Tesla and SolarCity and the accounting shenanigans that, in my view, he was, today don't matter because he got away with it. But back then, for a variety of reasons and my own childhood and whatever, I care deeply about truth. And it's okay if you're BSing.
13:13Josh Wolfe: It's okay if you're exaggerating. But if you're not being honest about certain things, to me, it triggers watching like a Sunday TV preacher, you know, that's getting the flock to follow and just bilking them for their money. There was this horrible guy in New York. His name was literally Creflo a dollar. And he talked about all the prosperity gospel, you know, but you just see these people and they have their shit eating grins and you know that they're lying to the people. And the people have pain or suffering or want to believe in naivete and they're being exploited. And so that was sort of my quip was almost intellectually competitive.
13:47Josh Wolfe: It's like, I know what you're doing and what you're saying and why you're saying it. Like I see the game and it upsets me that people are falling for it. In the end, you know, who suffered? What was the crime? Who lost money? Nobody, right? And so my biggest gripes were really more about the dishonesty, particularly accounting and some of the representations, not about, oh, we're going going to have this in six months and it might take two or three or six years. It just, it felt financially dishonest. I've studied a bunch of like company failures and like where founders went wrong or like, you know, the history of fraud.
14:17And generally when I find someone that commits fraud once, this is like a systemic thing or that they do like across time. They don't just do it once. And like, you know, Brim Madoff kept on being a fraud all the way up to like$50 billion or AUM or something. And of course it wasn't real, but people believed it. And he for someone like elon it almost feels like to me in my mind he either would do it at one point or wouldn't do it do you kind of understand what i mean yeah um that it was like selective like if he needed to do it or like generally like have you ever come across a fraud that only did it in one aspect of their life and then like did it once one time and then never did it again
14:58Josh Wolfe: i'd have to go through and really catalog this but um but i i do think that there is a reward incentive. If somebody does something wittingly, right? Not accidentally, but wittingly, and you know that you're duping people and you get away with it and you reap rewards or benefits, that positive feedback loop has been there where you're like, I can do this again, right? There are people that do this virtuously where they are honest liars, which are magicians, and they get rewarded because people are like, oh my God, that's amazing. But they're telling you it's a trick. You know, you watch Penn and Teller with the cups and balls trick.
15:31Josh Wolfe: Not only are they telling you it's a trick. They are using transparent cups as they are doing this to show you how skillful they are at deceiving you. And all you have to do is basically suspend the willful disbelief. And there's something that's beautiful about that. And there's something that's beautiful about magic in general, to me, as somebody that is obsessed with science and technology and thinking about how you engineer something. I still marvel at the magic of certain Apple devices. And I certainly marvel at today, the geniuses in AI. But... When you are not being honest with the audience, whoever that is, an audience of investors, about the deception, and there's a big difference between somebody that's like, we're going to develop a weapon system and it's going to be the most important in the world.
16:17Josh Wolfe: That's ambition. That might even be entrepreneurial naivete. But if you say we're developing an autonomous electric truck and we're driving it down the mountain, but you actually have it in neutral and you're letting gravity do the work, Trevor Milton went to prison. I think that there are things like that that founders do and can get away with, the sort of fake it before you make it. By definition, anybody that is starting something is starting something with some vision and some ideal and saying with utmost confidence, which you have to do as an entrepreneur. You have to do as a starting off investor.
16:50Josh Wolfe: If you're raising a fund, you're like, this is what we're going to do. And you may have the authentic conviction internally and you're exuding that to others and they are believing in you. The entire word of credibility, credit. It's the root of credere, to believe. But there's such a thin line between somebody that like wittingly knows that they're lying and somebody that is just really ambitious. And to me, there's always been this through line, partially because of where I grew up in Coney Island, Brooklyn. Somebody's always trying to run some scam. Somebody's always trying to cheat you. Somebody's like always...
17:21Josh Wolfe: And so you grow up sort of squinty-eyed and distrusting of people and human nature. And I always say to this day, science and technology and human progress. I am so along that, but I've always been more tepid, if not cynical, about human nature. My favorite line from Shakespeare are there's daggers in men's smiles. Again, we evolved to deceive each other in endless ways. There's deception in sports, there's deception in politics, there's deceptions in business, and we deceive ourselves. You could argue that some of the best entrepreneurs actually self-deceive themselves in a way that, and there's a brilliant evolutionary biologist, Robert Trivers, who I think recently passed, who studied the, why do we self-deceive?
18:00Josh Wolfe: Like why is this evolutionarily selected for? And it's fascinating. But I think some of the best founders, entrepreneurs, some of the best politicians believe their own bullshit. And so are they actually lying? No, they're just really good self-deceivers and it's an adaptive mechanism. But being able to discern that thin line between somebody that is wittingly bullshitting you and lying to you, and somebody that is just sort of bullshitting themselves and has ambition, that's an important distinction of the difference. Generally, when I've come across the people that are genuinely great and go build great things, I have never come away feeling like they were bullshitting other people or themselves.
18:36Like I do, typically, they will have like a deep understanding of their problem, a deep understanding of why there's an issue, and also a deep understanding of how to solve it, or at least some path to solve it. And they may figure out other solutions along the way of working. But from what I can tell, they almost always feel like they're being honest with themselves.
18:58Josh Wolfe: Totally. You have interviewed a lot of our portfolio company founders. You look at Sam D 'Amico at Impulse. He is a serious engineer. And there are times where I might not agree with some of the strategic choices he's making. And there's other times where I'm like, that's absolutely genius in what you did. But I just completely trust him for exactly that reason. I don't think he's going to lie to me. I don't think he's going to lie to customers. I think he has a level of detail and attention. Chris at Hadrian, same thing. Ben at Reflect Orbital. You know, I'm thinking about people that have been on your show.
19:28Josh Wolfe: And Ben is like maybe the most peripatetic, energetic, you would argue sort of ADHD, but doesn't like he just, he can't stop thinking about technology. Like in his spare time, if he's waiting for launch capability to be able to launch these satellites that are going to reflect the sun, you know, certain parts of the day. He's like, what else can I build? And there's something in that I would love to see the time lapse montage of Ben as a kid through like Ben in his teenage years. I know he like worked on stuff when he was like five, six years old, had access to all kinds of tools at a young age.
20:01Josh Wolfe: But that's like a special kind of mind that is absolutely engineering oriented. And most engineers are trying to figure out how do I get to that asymptote of truth? You know, the thing is going to work or it's not, I'm going to design the system and I'm going to have certain specifications and it has to be down to the eighth of an inch or the tenth of a millimeter or it's not going to work. And you have to be honest about that because if it's off, you fail. The product fails. And that's the kind of iterative feedback that I think in hard engineering and hard products you get. When you're dealing with consumers, you know, you could BS yourself.
20:36Josh Wolfe: You could launch something. Consumers, and I'm thinking about like apps and retail and that kind of stuff. and people could just want to buy things because other people are buying them. But it's sort of the old Feynman quote, like, Mother Nature can't be fooled. People can be fooled, but not Mother Nature. And I think the best engineers and the best product developers realize you cannot lie to physics. You need to know the physics. You need to know the engineering. You might make a mistake. It might be a happy accident, and you might stumble on things. endless breakthroughs in medicine and biotech and pharma came from the basic insight that followed the words, huh, that's funny.
21:12Josh Wolfe: Vulcanized rubber, penicillin, Viagra, you know, these are all happy accidents. But I think that intentionality of somebody that's basically like, here's my hypothesis that this is going to work. And then if it doesn't work, how do we go and error correct? And error correction is what basically leads to all progress. One thing that I've been thinking about recently is I think stories and like the mission of a company is incredibly undervalued. I think the vast majority of people don't want to work on something that doesn't matter. And people can kind of like inherently feel whether or not something matters.
21:42It's kind of funny when you have 200 companies like going through YC and every single one of them has a mission. And every single person probably believes that their mission really, really matters. but then if you think about something like you know isaiah from valor atomics where he's just like i want to make the world's energy like that's that's a very different mission than like i want to make short form clips totally you know and i think people can kind of feel that how do you like construct a mission that other people are really excited to believe in um can i get up for a second yeah all right i'm gonna show you all right so this this object what does that mean to you what does it mean to me is this like a uh dollar holder or something yeah like a piggy bank Yeah.
22:22It's a wooden piggy bank. It's an object.
22:24Josh Wolfe: It's meaningless to you. This is deeply meaningful to me, this totem, this object, because it has a story in it. And my grandfather, so my parents split when I was super young. My mom and I moved from California where I was born at two, moved in with my grandparents. We lived in a two bedroom, one bath apartment, and my grandfather delivered the daily news at night. My grandma was a retired meter meter. My mom was a special ed public school teacher and I was an only child. And this was my first piggy bank, which was the Daily News piggy bank. It was wooden. It's got to be 40 years, 50 years old.
23:00Josh Wolfe: And the only thing that's missing is the little plug on the bottom to prevent the change from going out. But like, this is where I first would store my little quarters and pennies and whatever that I would collect. And my grandfather gave me this. He would go out at night and he would deliver the newspaper and my mother and I slept in one room. My grandmother slept in the other and we had one bath. And that was my life until I was roughly 18 years old. But this object to me is deeply meaningful to anybody else that sees this object. They look at it and they're like, I don't really care. But I really think about the fact that objects and companies embody meaning and mattering, two words that you use that I think are really important, because of the stories that get imbibed into them.
23:38Josh Wolfe: And it's sort of like inception, you know, but that to me is what makes something meaningful. When somebody's just like, yeah, I'm doing this app or whatever, Like you can feel if the founder has authenticity about what it is. Palmer and Andrew, like he is obsessed with, I want to create weapon systems, not just like defense. He's not being cowardice, but like, I want to create weapon systems that advantage the warfighter and deter war because we have such superior weapon systems, right? And somebody's like, yeah, I want to get behind that. Like that feels meaningful. And it's also relatively singular because there aren't a lot of companies that at the time were working on it.
24:13Josh Wolfe: So those are two things. One is the scarcity of it. Two is the authenticity of a story. And three is the status that you can anticipate and speculate, just like you were speculating about buying a stock or buying something in crypto market or making a bet on, you know, poly or poly market or calci. It's the same feeling of like, I'm speculating that I'm going to accrue more status if I do this thing. And people might not be totally honest about that. But five, six years ago, you were taking a risk to go and work at Andrel when it was less than 100 people. Today, 11 ,000 people. And today, it's a little less risky.
24:45Josh Wolfe: And there's some founder out there that is starting to tell a story about something that sucks, some reason that they're going to go do it, and there might be less than 10 people. And then you're making the forecast, oh yeah, I can see this company getting really big, and I can see this being really important, and I want to be there at ground zero. It is no different than the people that discover bands when everybody else is listening to pop music on the radio, or back in the day on MTV, and you find the off-the-beaten-path band that you know is going to be cool, not only because you like it, but because the status is going to accrue to you.
25:11Josh Wolfe: Same thing with a fashion brand. Same thing with a neighborhood in real estate. Like every domain has something where you can make the bet, the speculative bet to go long something or someone because you think it's going to accrue status to you. And that often starts with a simple story. Like what is the story of this band? What is the story of this neighborhood? What is the story of this brand of clothes? What does it represent? What is the story of this company? What is it going to do? I have a allergic reaction to one kind of storytelling. When a founder comes in and says, I just want to change the world.
25:41Josh Wolfe: And my first instinct is bullshit. I don't believe you. I believe people that are like, I want to prove people wrong because everybody said that this wouldn't be possible. Some technological achievement. Or everybody else is developing this, but I have a totally contrarian view and nobody believes me. And that's why we always like to say at Lux that we believe before others understand. I love finding that. And it's no different to me transcending these boundaries between music or art or real estate or fashion or tech. It's finding that person that's like, got this crazy idea. Nobody else believes in them.
26:11Josh Wolfe: We get the opportunity to believe in them. And it's out of going back to like the sins, greed and avarice, therein lie the virtues of progress, that I think it's going to accrue capital and currency socially to me, that my status will increase because I was there in the founding days. And so I can be sort of intellectually honest or self-reflective about that, but that's where I think it starts. Storytelling has to be authentic because there's so many people that mirror stories that have been told to the point that they're cliched. But I've had so many people that come in and sometimes it's authentic and sometimes it feels so forced, especially when you hear multiple times that somebody says, I really wanted to start this biotech company because I had an aunt who suffered from some, and I'm like, I don't know if I believe you.
26:56Josh Wolfe: And maybe I'm too cynical in some of those instances. I can tell you from a sad number of people who become experts in a special or rare disease because their kid or a deeply close loved one suffers from it, they become the smartest in that space relative to anybody. And you know that that motivation is real. Like when people are like, yeah, I'm quitting my job to go do this thing. Like that is a true story. And so if you can find those things, which again, start with these intrinsic motivations, my co-founder, Peter He is exceptional at understanding. He doesn't want to talk technical diligence.
27:28Josh Wolfe: He doesn't want to talk about your first year forecast. He doesn't want to talk about, he just wants to talk about like, why are you doing this? What's your motivation? And not in a challenging way, but like to just really understand what drives you. And 90 % of the time he gets out of a meeting that I might not have been in. And he's like, I understand this guy or girl. And that to me, when Pete identifies the intrinsic motivations that are authentic and real about why somebody wants to do something, it's typically we're going to invest. And if it's BS and like, they're like hand wavy or they're saying the things that you, they think you want to hear, it just, it falls really flat and hollow.
28:02If you had to think about founders where in your experience through the years of, of building Lux went awry, like there was some story and narrative that they had that was believable, but then for whatever reason, they just like fell off the tracks? What happened with those?
28:19Josh Wolfe: Probably five things. And I always think about these as risks, right? And they're universal for companies, but you got financing risk, tech risk, product risk, people risk, market risk. And then you have what I consider the sort of handful of jobs of a CEO. And you can call that a founder CEO, but it's not always the case. CEO has to set a strategy and a vision. Great. Okay. And that can be abstract, but it has to be like very specific. This is what we're going to do the next six months, the next two years, the next five years. They've got to deliver the resources. So they have to hire people, extraordinary people.
28:47Josh Wolfe: And if you don't hire extraordinary people, again, it's a cliche, A's hire A's and B's hire C's for a very simple reason, which is that great people want to be around great people. And if they see people that they think are mediocre, either they want to leave and go do their own thing because they feel like they're carrying the weight disproportionately, or they just don't respect them. And I would say that you have three things, which are what I call art, admire, respect, and trust. If you admire, respect and trust somebody, it's true of my wife, it's true of my business partner, it's true of the partners here, then you have a great relationship.
29:18Josh Wolfe: And if you sort of admire and respect them about certain things, certain abilities, but you don't trust them, it's not good. If you trust them, but you don't really respect them because they don't have a great work ethic or they're not hustling or whatever. And so you need all three. So you take those sort of three different things, the job of CEO, the key risks of a company and sort of these interpersonal dynamics that I think lead to good positive outcomes. Financing risk. Number one thing, can they raise money? If you can raise money, which often follows from being an extraordinary storyteller, getting people to believe, credere, credit, literally parting with capital, handing it over to you.
29:53Josh Wolfe: I used to call it the Pampers effect when we would sit across from an entrepreneur, and this came from our late partner, Larry Bach, who coined that term. It's a little off color, but he's sitting across from the entrepreneur and he's trying to keep it cool so that he doesn't lose leverage in a negotiation. But he's sitting there like wetting himself, being like, oh my God, oh, you have to back this person. And you can sort of feel it palpably, but he calls it like the Pampers moment as though you were wearing like an adult diaper. And so the first is storytelling, which leads to the ability to fundraise, which leads to the ability to recruit.
30:19Josh Wolfe: So those are two of the things which are deliver the resources as a CEO. If you are an amazing founder, you might be a technical genius and you might have solved the problem or you're a scientist that came up with a breakthrough, but you can't raise money. You've lost the ability to have two things, options and time. Because if you have capital and something doesn't work, you have time. You can figure it out. If you have capital, you have options. Maybe you're going to buy something. Maybe you're going to aqua hire somebody. Maybe you're going to, I call it pirouette instead of pivot because I found pivot is so cliched, but you're going to go into some different strategy.
30:47Josh Wolfe: Okay, so that's the first, which is storytelling, which leads to fundraising, which leads to options, which leads to time. And if you can't storytell and you can't fundraise, you don't have those two things and you are constrained and you are basically at the whim of your bank account. If people lose confidence in you, your team, in part because of internal storytelling, in part because of leadership, in part maybe you took a risk, maybe you made a personal sacrifice. I'll give you another example. We have an old fund about this. We have an old fund, and there's a company which we don't really believe in.
31:14Josh Wolfe: It's like a 10-year-old fund. But one of the partners here deeply believed in the company. And we look at our reserves as a fund manager, and we say, do we want to put good money after bad? And it takes a lot of discipline to basically say no. He said, you know what? If it's okay, I'm going to check with the LPs and get approval. And on their behalf, I will make the personal investment to help save the company and give it another shot or whatever. And we were like, okay with that. But like LPs love that. It wasn't personal gain. It was him expressing a belief and doing what he felt was right to help the company succeed.
31:43Josh Wolfe: And he was willing to take personal risk. That is a beautiful thing that set a tone of leadership to say like, I deeply believe in this and I'm willing to put my personal money to try to make it work. So I would say the number one thing is, can you raise money? Number two things, are you making the decisions? Are you exhibiting the behavior? Not just as the founder and CEO. When we hear about Elon sleeping on a factory floor, whether whether that is like exaggerated or legit, it sets a tonal A, you know, for the conductor of the orchestra to basically be like, this is how we behave. It's what I do as a father, by the way, is anytime my kids are doing something since they were little, I'm like, that's not how the wolf family behaves, or that's not what the wolves do, or this is what the wolves do.
32:22Josh Wolfe: One of the things that I insist my kids do, just as a quick aside, and I noticed this, I'm sort of like revealing this publicly, but at every dinner I'm at, no matter what restaurant it is, because I started it as a busboy because I worked terrible blue collar jobs and I want my kids having blue collar jobs so that they say I don't want to do that. I'm constantly looking up at every reception, every wedding, every bar mitzvah, every seated thing. And I make eye contact with the person that is filling my water glass. And I just say, thank you. Just to acknowledge them because they're not just like some servant.
32:49Josh Wolfe: And almost nobody at any of the tables that I ever sit at ever does that. And I tell my kids, watch. Same thing like you get out of an Uber, you get out of a cab. Just treat people with dignity. They are people that are just trying to make a living for their family. They came from shitty circumstances. They're trying to do better. And you might have been born and my kids were born in different circumstances than I was, but just do that. So how you lead and how you model behavior for your employees, for your kids, for your friends, for your peers, I think is critically important. I am imperfect at this, but it's something that I'm mindful of.
33:17Josh Wolfe: So I think that those are the biggest things, raising money, being able to tell stories that lead to the latter or the former modeling good behavior. When things go awry, you've either run out of money and you can't raise capital. You've lost the faith or the confidence of the people that work for you. Your product doesn't work, right? You got out-competed. I love people that are obsessively competitive. A huge pet peeve is when there's news of some competitor. And again, ideally, the stuff that we fund, there's very few competitors. We don't do software where there's 50 competitors. It tends to be less than five.
33:47Josh Wolfe: And ideally, you've got intellectual property and patents and a Nobel Prize behind something that at least sets a deterrent. It isn't always like legally guaranteeing that you alone have the monopoly right, but at least that's a deterrent like, oh, we're going to have to contend with this. The faster you can raise and weaponize capital, the more you have a moat to deter other people. But I like founders that are like obsessively competitive. And when I hear the following words from a competitor, from a founder talking about a competitor, and they say, oh, yeah, it's validating. Oh, that drives me insane.
34:20Josh Wolfe: I don't want to hear that competition is validating. I want you to tell me how you're going to crush them, how you're going to destroy them, what the strategy is that is going to take their people, take their customers. And I don't want you to be like, oh yeah, it's validating. There's room for all of us. So that's another way that I think companies go awry is you should be hyper-competitive. Again, you go to Andrel, they are hyper-competitive. Now they do want to see the ecosystem grow, but if there's a former employee that has taken IP or like they're going after them, you watch Matt Grimm, who's co-founder and COO.
34:51Josh Wolfe: Man, if you are trying to raise some SPV to get allocation into Anduril and you're like, he is calling you out publicly and basically like shaming you and, you know, putting a casting shadow of disgrace. But those guys are all like, they admire, respect, you trust, trust each other, but they are hyper competitive. Have you ever met a great founder that didn't have this sort of like wartime personality? Yes, but they're typically complimented by somebody that can do that. Yeah. So you might have somebody that is a technical genius, but they need somebody that's going to be the fundraiser. And so whatever titular title, they get their president, COO, chair, they're complimented by somebody that can do that.
35:31But as far as CEOs, it's always someone that wants to wake up and go to war.
35:36Josh Wolfe: But sometimes they're the CEO, sometimes they're a chair, sometimes they play a different role. There might be like ego dynamics with the founder, but it isn't always embodied in one individual that has the technical genius, can recruit people and tell the story, can raise money, can negotiate and sit across the table. In some cases, it depends on the industry too, because you need a certain kind of mindset and experience in corporate development or business development when you're doing biotech deals that a 19 or 22 year old is not going to be able to do. They might be able to have invented some insane intersection between AI and biotech and have a product, but oftentimes you need somebody that has a little bit of experience and understands the cycle in pharma and biotech.
36:12Josh Wolfe: Same thing with aerospace and defense. like when you have a head of international that is super savvy and understands the way that other sovereign sovereigns and countries and foreign military sales work like that's a level of sophistication that can execute but they're not the people that are necessarily raising the money or recruiting or running operations or standing up offices or setting up supply chains or setting up manufacturing lines every one of those things over time becomes a discrete siloed capability that's part of a team that you need to be able to recruit for and the best founders also recognize I need help with this.
36:43Josh Wolfe: I'll give you another example. Alex Wilchko, who's the founder of Osmo, which was a serendipitous thing because I had this obsession about certain what I call directional hours of progress. Directional hours of progress for me started almost 20 years ago, 18 years ago or something, around nuclear energy. The directional hour of progress was we went from carbohydrates burning wood as society to hydrocarbons cracking oil and natural gas to uranium. And the undeniable hour of progress was energy density per unit of raw material. So to me at the time, you have famous VCs like Vinod Khosla and John Doerr that were talking about like biofuels and ethanol.
37:17And I was like, those are biofools.
37:20Josh Wolfe: It makes no sense. Why are you going to go back to this low energy density? We should be going nuclear. I try to rebrand it elemental energy because if we discovered nuclear power today, people would be literally running around and be like, oh my God, this is the most amazing thing. Zero carbon, large baseload power. The cost of the uranium is like a disproportionately small cost of the total operating cost. But there was a zeitgeist that just didn't exist. But that was a directional hour of progress, and it led me to say, okay, what sucks in nuclear? The biggest unsolved problem is what do you do with the waste?
37:47Josh Wolfe: We looked around for a high-tech company to invest in. Nothing existed, so we started a company to do high-tech nuclear waste. So that was one. Second directional hour of progress was human-computer interaction. This led to Control Labs. And the idea here, I came up with this story internally first, before we went externally. And the story was what I call the half-life of technology intimacy. And it sounds weird, but in each half-life I'm about to describe, you got more intimate or your technology got more intimate with you. Not in a perverted way, but just in a physically observable, empirical, true way.
38:22Josh Wolfe: You had an ENIAC mainframe computer. You physically went and pulled levers and touched it. Then the next half-life, that was 50 years ago. Then 25 years ago, you have a desktop. And the desktop either is a tower mainframe or a horizontal hard drive. and you flick the button and you turn the monitor on, you got the keyboard, you're tickling the keys, you have a mouse under your palm. Next Half-Life, 12 and a half years ago, the mouse and the keyboard give way to a trackpad and a laptop. And now it's touching your thighs, literally on your lap. And then the next Half-Life, six and a quarter years ago, you have your phone and it's the dominant thing, 18 hours a day, cradled in your hand.
38:55Josh Wolfe: First thing you touch in the morning, last thing you touch at night. Then you have watch and AirPods and technology starts to conform more to your body and your corpus as opposed to you hunched over a QWERTY keyboard. And so I'm like, well, what comes next? And you watch your kids doing Dan Tan's Revolution with 3D depth sensing cameras for like Xbox or PS5. And I'm like, gesture. But gesture, it turned out, was not going to be camera-based. It was going to be reading the neurons in the 15 ,000 nerves that innervate the roughly 14 muscles in your hand. And that became a company Control Labs. And we backed this guy, Reardon.
39:23Josh Wolfe: And Reardon literally had shared this same sort of ethos about the directional arrow of progress. So we identified it in there. Anytime you can identify that sort of directional arrow of progress, it leads to not the company or the founder, but a high probability like this is the way that things are going. And so we're constantly looking for those. How do you think about like truly great execution? Under promise, over deliver. So you say you're going to do something and not only do you achieve it, but you achieve it in less time or with less capital. And you do something that somebody thought was impossible or improbable.
40:00Josh Wolfe: with less resources than anybody thought was possible or probable. So again, just because it's front of mind, I think about Anderil standing up operations in Australia, and they were competing with Boeing, which had an ORCA program. And Anderil had this program called GoShark. And actually, as we're talking, news broke yesterday that Iran had captured one of these autonomous subs. It was an older model. It's not relevant for the thing. But they were able to manufacture and stand up a 60-person office, a multi-billion dollar contract that was awarded from Australia for freedom of navigation and seas against the Chinese Communist Party and China's encroachment around Australia's sovereignty.
40:37Josh Wolfe: And they were able to do it in record time. And that set a credibility, again, credere, of execution where other people were like, yeah, we saw what you did in Australia. And so that became social currency for every incremental win in different domains in different regions. And as they look at exploring in the Mideast and Europe and elsewhere, I think that kind of credibility is like a snowball for them. So good execution is beating timelines, beating budget, and showing that you can just deliver. Erwin Jacobs, who's founder of Qualcomm, one of my early investors, a legend, had this very serious high expectation thing for engineering and never publicly talked about what they were going to do, but just internally, this is the roadmap, this is what we're doing, and just held people to task.
41:27That was hardcore execution. Is there any specific examples of you saw one of your founders pull off something that should have been absolutely impossible? Yes. Yet they were able to do it anyway.
41:38Josh Wolfe: Yes. There's been times with Sam at Impulse in the early days. There were a lot of people that were like not super thrilled or excited about the category. And there were times where he was like running on fumes and he has repeatedly pulled a rabbit out of the hat and successfully not only developing the next product on less than anybody thought possible, you know, but he was able to attract investors time and time again. And I really admire and I respect and I trust him. but that was one where I was like, yeah, I don't know, like, you know, we might have to step in here and bridge the company, but he just kept delivering.
42:10Josh Wolfe: And I, and I think there's like a balance between the founder feeling that pressure that there is no cavalry coming, that it's on you and then him just delivering. But yeah, there, there's a lot of times when we have just seen a pattern where it looks like the founder is not going to pull it off. And we don't want to be the ones to say, look, I think it's time because you never know. It's like, you know, it's darkest just before the dawn kind of cliche. But sometimes people find this such fire and they're like, I'm not going to fail. And it goes back to the, I'll show them. I'm not letting those people who are like, yeah, good luck.
42:41Josh Wolfe: Or the people that passed on me be like, I told you so. So it's fighting that I told you so with, I'll show them. Super powerful. And I think you can find that. Like you can see that in people. It might be like sort of quiet, you know. I'll give you another one who I think has this. Matt DeJong at Fortel. It used to be called Chromatic. Us and Founders Fun and Thrive backed them pretty early, and they were basically taking cutting-edge AI, cutting-edge hardware for next-gen hearing aids. Now it would become this raging success. He's got this very Jobsian quality, the Steve Jobs quality. You can see he's polite and reserved, but has this fire in him.
43:19Josh Wolfe: And he's paired with his partner, his co-founder, Cole, who's a great complement and a great balance to him. And that's another thing, actually. We think about like the heroic singular founder, but you really want in some cases a duo or a stable triad where they compliment each other. Again, the Andrel founders, you know, there's four core people, much broader group, but Matt and Cole have a great dynamic. Yeah, I think some of our best companies, you know, you look at Ramp, you know, Eric and Kareem, like great dynamic. People that compliment each other and can balance each other at Lux. I always joke, I'm always in black like you.
43:58Josh Wolfe: And Peter, my co-founder lived a different childhood, a little bit happier. People say I have resting bitch face. He's much more like my wife, Lauren, with like smiley, you know, sort of teeth showing. And he expects since he's often the best in people and I see the worst, that old daggers and men smiles. And he will constantly say like, what if it works? What does the press release look like sort of Jeff Bezos style in two or three years if this company is successful? And I have this quote internally that failure comes from a failure to imagine failure. And it's my own psychological protective mechanism as a kid, always expecting the worst, which actually made me happier and does make me happier, even though I'm not pleasant at cocktail parties, because I'm always expecting the worst.
44:35Josh Wolfe: So my surprises are upside surprises. Whereas if you always expect that things are going to be great, you're setting yourself up for disappointment. That doesn't mean that I'm not like an optimist, but it's like a conditional optimist versus a complacent one that is like expectant and thinks like, oh, things will just come to you. But you're like, no, I have to go and do this thing in order for it to happen. Otherwise, it's not going to work. So I always go back to those failure points when we were talking about the virtues of CEOs and leadership and why they might go awry. Financing risk, technology risk, market risk, product risk, people risk, every one of those risks that you can identify.
45:05People have this misplaced notion of entrepreneurs as these great
45:08Josh Wolfe: risk takers. No, they're not risk takers. The best of them are risk killers. They look at something and they're like, how do I kill that risk? I don't want to take that risk. And every risk that you kill, a subsequent investor should pay a higher price because it has become a less risk enterprise. And so a Series B or Series C stage investor that's following us should demand a lower quantum of return because they're taking a lower quantum of risk. And so I think about value creation as risk reduction, which is anticipating failure, which is sort of a negative mindset. And Pete and many other partners here think pro-socially and positive.
45:40Josh Wolfe: What if we add these people to the board? And what if we open these doors for corporate development and business development? And what if we get them these sales? And I think you need both. And people joke that Pete invented the airplane and I invented the parachute, then it's a good yin yang. I know that people vastly overestimate risk just generally, like we experienced loss twice as much as we experienced gain. But there's also this interesting dynamic where I've met a number of founders who are genuinely great and they keep on talking about basically making these like low probability bets, but in, you know, putting all their chips behind them, but then they work and then they work consistently.
46:12And you think to yourself, well, if they're actually low probability, Like some way that you're, you know, working through some problem in your head, somehow this low probability bet in your head is actually a much higher probability bet because it continually works. How do people think about this? Like why do people vastly overestimate the risk of things?
46:29Josh Wolfe: Well, I think, you know, you go back to like Danny Kahneman who happened to be a friend and he studied a lot of this in the heuristics and the biases of why we miss underestimate risk. And I think similar to the discussion about sins and vice, misunderestimating risk, which you can call entrepreneurial naivete, is a virtue. You want people to basically be like, I think this thing could actually work. Because it's only really older people and grizzled through experienced people that are like, that won't work. Like, I've tried that for 30 years. Like, it's never going to work. And it's also dangerous to say, like, this time is different.
47:04Josh Wolfe: But all the great things, great music, great innovations, great fashion breakthroughs, great technological breakthroughs, great literature, great movies. They all happen from young people that are like, no, no, I'm going to go do this and I'm going to do it differently. So I love what you would call sort of positive black swans, low probability, high magnitude events. And that to me is the essence of all progress. It's somebody saying with arrogance of the highest order, this is the way that things should work and going and taking that risk. Now, when you actually say like, what is that risk? People were like, oh, you took a risk when you started Lux.
47:37If you actually looked, I had less than$10 ,000 in savings.
47:44Josh Wolfe: I had my grandmother at age 21 or 22 that was helping to pay my rent with two other roommates. Two years later, I would meet the girl of my dreams who I've now been married to for 20 years with three beautiful kids. And she's like, okay, let's go through our finances. I'm like, I've got less than$10 ,000 and I have a lot of debt. and she's like, okay, I need to go for a walk and have like a panic attack. But she saw like the ambition and she's like, I need a five-year plan. I'm like, I don't know, we're going to have a lot of money. And it worked out, right? But she was taking a bet on me and a risk on me.
48:16Josh Wolfe: And I was taking a risk and a bet on myself, but I believed in myself deeply. And that, by the way, is another fascinating thing. There's a great paper by Deepak Hegda, who's a NYU professor. And we co-authored an op-ed recently, but I read this paper and I was so taken by it. And it was about Akarov's Lemon Law. And why are there so many immigrant entrepreneurs? And the truth of it is, first, they come from very little, but more importantly, the market often does not see the signal that they see in themselves. And so you had Indian, Chinese, Israeli, Pakistani immigrants that came here that didn't fit the mold.
48:53Josh Wolfe: And they believed in themselves, but the market of people that might invest in them or hire them at the classic places were like, yeah, he's not one of us. You know, she doesn't look like us. He doesn't sound like us, the accent or whatever. And those people were like, no, no, they believed in themselves. So they bet on themselves. And so I think that's a great virtue as well. I don't know. I just kept on coming into this situation where I'd hear someone say that like, I think there's like a 10 % chance that X works and then it works. And then they tell about, you know, talk about the next thing that's a 10 % chance and some of that might be willful like to people just massively and downplaying right but i actually think by the way it gives you enormous credibility right if you go and say like this is a short thing i know it's going to work people like this dude's full of shit but if you're like look and i believe this pretty much in everything that we do like when i pitch a company internally i'm like the odds are low that this is going to work but if it does work the magnitude the payoff the pot at the end of the rainbow is going to be very big.
49:52Josh Wolfe: And that's what we're looking for. And so you want something where the vast consensus believes that the odds are lower than you do. And the things that most people do have higher perceived consensus odds. Not that the actual objective odds, to the extent that they are knowable, are higher or lower, but it's what other people believe that other people believe. And so if we think that everybody else thinks it's a lower probability, but we actually believe it's a higher probability, that's a great setup. And I think most founders actually believe, I think we could pull this off, but it's the right thing to say.
50:26Josh Wolfe: Ben at Reflect, I think was the same thing. It's like, look, I don't know if we're going to be able to build this. My first thought is he knows he'll be able to build this. But it's much better to discount yourself and get credibility under promise and over deliver, then set some high expectation and be like, we're definitely doing this. It's 100 % going to work and then fail, you've lost credibility. You've lost people's belief in you. So the best storytelling tactic is actually to let people underestimate you and prove them wrong, to set expectations low so that if it doesn't work, if the launch fails, if the product, literally physical space launch fails, or a product launch fails, people are like, all right, we have another bite at it.
51:07Josh Wolfe: it also helps you raise money. If you say like, look, we want to raise enough money because we're going to need three launches. The first one is very likely to fail. When Sean McGuire, who you've interviewed and I both backed Ben at Reflect, we funded it knowing that we're going to launch and the first one or the second one might fail and we're okay with that. But the third one might work. And so there's base rates and precedents in different industries that you look at that. If you have somebody that's overly optimistic, oh, we're going to launch. It's definitely going to work on the first try, that makes me worry.
51:36Josh Wolfe: But if somebody else is more worried than me, I can sleep well at night knowing that they're not. On the case of Elon, being vocal about him and even voicing criticisms, it's a difference between having them privately and having them publicly. It completely changes your ability to fund his future companies, I think. Oh, for sure. No, there are people that have worked at Tesla that have overtly told other partners here, yeah we wouldn't take Josh's money because he was so skeptical or doubtful on that. How do you how do you think through that because like if you take that person specifically if your job is to back rate companies and make rate returns he's one of the best people at building massive companies and it is like a huge it's like a huge um handicap effectively.
52:22Totally. Do you say things publicly? Look the virtue of a partnership is you have differing views
52:27Josh Wolfe: My brand and name personally are tightly coupled to Lux. And so it has created situations where we have been at a disadvantage about that, where other partners like, I think we should fund this particular company. And the people might be in reciprocal spite being like, oh yeah, you talk shit about that? Like, no, right? And so it's a price to pay. The other price to pay is harboring quiet beliefs and not being honest about it. So everybody that follows me on Twitter or sees me publicly knows exactly what I believe, whether it's about Israel versus Palestine, whether it's about US, whether it's been in past stuff about politics and my own views that have changed about some of those things where I sat on the political spectrum or where my political spectrum has moved even where I've stayed.
53:07Josh Wolfe: Like nobody will be like, oh, that guy's dishonest. So for me, going to this virtue that I hold about truth, it is costly to be honest. It is costly. You gain things and you lose things. But I've had other entrepreneurs that are like, I'm so glad that you're speaking out about this and people are attracted to it. Or even in some cases with Elon, some people are like, I'm so glad that you called BS on this particular thing. And so you win some, you lose some, but I go to sleep knowing that I feel honest with high integrity about what I believe. I have a lot of partners that are like, dude, I wish you would just shut up about that, but it's dishonest.
53:42Josh Wolfe: And so for a public figure like that, I would never do that for like, you know, some random entrepreneur. There are people that like attack, you know, those kinds of things. There are entrepreneurs where I'm like, I think that guy's a total fraud, but I'm not going to publicly go out and say it. But if you're a public CEO, you're there for criticism. And by the way, there are things that I absolutely admire and praise Elon about. In some cases, political views, patriotism for the US, SpaceX, X. It really was siloed specifically to Tesla and accounting issues I had, but for many years, deeply publicly critical about that, because I felt like he was not being truthful and honest.
54:21Josh Wolfe: So, you know, we contain multitudes. And I think that there's a virtue that it should be costly to me. So having public views that cost me something make them authentic and real. Yeah, I was talking with someone specifically about this, where I'm not going to name who, but they basically called someone else out that people really care about and like. And I was like, the only way that you really gain reputation in public is through doing something that is costly to you. Yeah, it's real. Like in a major way. Totally. Otherwise - Look, Sean, by the way, did this, right? Like he came out and publicly was like, I'm giving Trump$200 ,000 to$300 ,000.
54:59Josh Wolfe: And Palmer did that, you know, years ago. And it doesn't have to be just like being pro-Trump, which is definitely a counter consensus or a controversial thing, particularly in some subset. But if you speak your mind and you explain why, there are gonna some people that just have a pledged fealty and alliance to like a tribal identity around a person, a technology, an industry, a political party, a religion, an ethnicity, whatever it is. But I sort of admire that. If somebody disagrees with me, but has a cogent logical view about why they feel super strongly and think like I'm completely idiot or wrong about that, like I respect that view.
55:33Josh Wolfe: And I've had some, they're, you know, Gavin Baker, deeply respect. And he has disagreed with me publicly and privately about certain things. David Sachs, deeply respect and have disagreed publicly around certain things. But yeah, there's people that I think if you have a cogent view, then I admire the honesty when people speak their minds, particularly when it's backed up by reason. In my experience, the very best founders don't actually start out like insanely, insanely ambitious. Typically what happens is they start out with some idea or some problem that they want to go tackle. And then over time, their ambition just seems to grow as things seem to work.
56:15How have you kind of experienced this with your own founders?
56:18Josh Wolfe: In the past few years, I will say for sure, if you had to put quantitative ambition together, it was rare to have a company that was worth more than$10 billion. Just statistically, it was rare. Now we have multiple companies that are north of$50 billion and approaching$100 billion and some that are worth several hundred billion dollars. And that was internally even a mindset change to see that shift, almost like a financial Overton window. And so I actually do think that back in the day for us, it's like, oh, could this be a billion dollar company? And now that's inconsequential. Like no one cares.
56:52Yeah.
56:53Josh Wolfe: And I mean, our fund sizes are larger. So there's like an economic truth to that. But any one company has to be able to return the fund and ideally multiple times. And that wouldn't have really been possible 10 or 15 years ago. But the outcomes, and you could say this is equity, inflation, dollar deflation, the fact that we have multiple multi-trillion dollar companies. If you would have said that to somebody 20 years ago, they would have been like the entire market capital of the US is$10 trillion back in the day. So it is wild to see that. And I think people's high ambitions of what is possible.
57:25Josh Wolfe: We just had a publicly announced acquisition of NVIDIA with Hugging Face. And I can't talk about the specifics of the deal other than what's been reported. But But this is a company that we funded six and a half years ago, a bunch of French founders, PhD mathematicians, computer scientists on the rooftop in Brooklyn who started with a chatbot and then evolved into the world's largest repository for open source. And they've had an extraordinary outcome. I think it's extraordinary for open source. I think it's extraordinary for the world. I think it's important. But had that been a$500 million or a billion dollar outcome, it just wouldn't have been important.
57:58And by the way, I think it's worth a lot more than$12 or$13 billion. And I think NVIDIA is very wise to buy it.
58:09Josh Wolfe: I think it's great for the country. I think it's great for the world. But those kinds of outcomes, I think, have to get more and more, much larger. So, yeah. But I do think that the founder's ambition starts with, let me solve this problem. And I think that the best founders don't want to go and solve small problems. They don't want to open a restaurant. They want to do something that scales. You know, I mentioned before Reardon, who did Control Labs, and then now we're backing him in a new company called Flourish, which is changing sort of the economics of AI. And he was addicted to this feeling because he created Internet Explorer inside of Microsoft.
58:42Josh Wolfe: And he went from six people seeing this thing to billions of people using it. And with Control Labs, people used to say, well, do you want to develop this for, you know, paraplegics or quadriplegics or people that can communicate with their mind? And he's like, I would love for people to use that, but I want a billion people to be using this. And so his ambition was, I want this in and on the hands of billions of people. And so that ambition, which is going back to like meaning and mattering, is I don't want this to be small. I don't want some niche to use this. I don't want some small subset.
59:12Josh Wolfe: Like I want to be huge. And I want to create history. And I want everybody to have this. Like that feels really good. One thing that I've started doing recently is like shadowing founders in order to gain context and build trust and all these different things before an interview actually happens. Do you do anything on that side that other investors just don't do? I don't know what other investors do. We spend time with founders, again, starting with like Pete's line of questioning to understand their true motivations and like see them outside of that 45 or hour minute formal presentation when they're performing.
59:47Josh Wolfe: But walking down the street with somebody, grabbing coffee with them, seeing their mannerisms, seeing how they interact with other people, seeing... We do this crazy stuff called risk gaming, where we take these near-term prognostications of tech and apply them to the geopolitical issues. We assign roles to people in those situations. We had Chris Donahue, who's a four-star general, former head of European Army Command, partnered in a risk game with Alex Wilczko from Osmo. We made Chris the head of a startup, which he had never done, and we made Alex the head of government procurement, which he had never done.
1:00:17Josh Wolfe: You see people playing these different roles and it reveals lots about their character, their reasoning, the way that they think about something that's totally unfamiliar, where it's not rehearsed, they're not doing a pitch, they don't have their talking points, you know. And so I like seeing those kinds of situations because it reveals intellect, reveals character, reveals ability, reveals EQ. So a lot of it's just spending time with somebody not talking about the business itself, but what drives them, what do they care about, shooting the shit about news, you know, general stuff and seeing how they respond.
1:00:46You ever had a situation where you thought that on the first interaction, someone was just not very good. And then over the course of like a month or two, or at least a few other interactions, you realized like, holy shit, I was completely wrong.
1:00:57Josh Wolfe: We had this with one of our companies, SailDrone early on, where there were two founders and one was extraordinary engineer, but not a great pitcher. And he was the first one to pitch us. And then the second one came in and we were like, where were you? And we ended up doubling down on the next round because were like, he's a better fundraiser, but it doesn't take away from the engineering or the product or the vision. But so that was one. There's been other instances where we felt the inverse, where we had that Pampers effect after a pitch where we're like, holy shit, this guy is amazing. Don't let him leave the room.
1:01:31Josh Wolfe: Bear hug him, surround him, flood the zone with every one of our founders. Don't let a competitor meet him. And they proved to be like terrible at execution. terrible at execution and wouldn't listen to the board and after a while you're just like like that was a misjudgment they could raise money and they had great product design sensibility but could not run a company and um so yeah we make mistakes you came to talk about ftx yeah we uh sam was super smart um i think ftx itself was a good business and i think we like everybody else had no idea that there was a siphoning of capital and cash is there actually if you had to take him as a specific example was there anything that you could have known like just having it through interactions with him like one time one time i watched this interview with him where he was talking about how he wanted to hire people and he was like yeah at one point I was thinking about, you know, there might be this like unusual, super valuable talent base that no one else was interested in working with because they were like horrible to work with, but extremely effective.
1:02:41And I was like, but if I if I look at every other great founder in history, they're like, work with amazing people. Like, don't work with people that you trust.
1:02:50Josh Wolfe: And others know more detail or intimately, but I don't actually know that that's a bad characteristic. If you have a role for somebody where you're like, they're an extraordinary contributor in their capability, but they're not a nice person or they're not somebody, you know, we've had to offer and partners and do things where we thought they were actually like, okay, investors, but maybe culturally, they were holding down younger people or they were not positive contributors like culturally. But I think in his case, super smart, probably hired extraordinarily super smart people, but probably did not have that moral compass or that elder statesman or frankly, governance or board to correct that behavior.
1:03:28Josh Wolfe: For us, it wasn't quite a flyer, but it was a small amount of capital. And it was really a bet on him and the fact that this business was printing money. What we didn't know was that it was printing money and then being siphoned. And I think in the end, most investors will end up, you know, reasonably well with it. And that anthropic stake, you know, proved pretty prescient. But that's the funny thing, too, about him. It's like there's a number of things that he did that were incredibly good decisions. Yeah. Look, if you told me 10 times out of 10, would you make that bet on that kind of individual?
1:03:58Josh Wolfe: I think we would. I think we would bet on the spiky high beta person. The difference maybe is like we would want a little bit more influence on governance of control rather than treating it like an external flyer. But going to low probability, high magnitude events for us, like it was an inconsequential relative, you know, out of a billion dollar fund, I think it was a$5 million investment. So it was inconsequential financially, but it was more consequential reputationally. Very few founders or very few investors have experienced what it's like to go through a blow up. Yeah. What is it like? Like what does it feel like sucks.
1:04:32Josh Wolfe: It depends why you're blowing up. Did you blow up because, you know, somebody did something wrong? Like, that's the autopsy when it really sucks because you're like, how did we not see this or find this or whatever? If you blew up because the market changed and biotech is out of favor now or you try to go public and the offering price below what you wanted or but like true disaster isn't just technological failure. It's usually moral failure. And again, going back to the number one thing that an entrepreneur has to do is like raise money and be able to tell stories to raise money. And then you need those stories to be true.
1:05:08And he was clearly like one of the best money raisers out there. What was strange to me too, is like, he could have just raised the money. I think he could have just raised the money in like a legitimate way.
1:05:17Josh Wolfe: No, I think, I think if the business would have run legitimately as it was without like the off balance sheet stuff and the trading and whatever, I think he probably would have been in the upper echelons of like extraordinary entrepreneurs. Charlie Munger for a long time talked about, he's like, someone should write the book, Why Smart People Do Dumb Things. Yeah. And it felt very similar. I've had a few experiences where I'm like, wow, this person is incredibly intelligent. Like, why the fuck did they do that? I think the book has been written since like the dawn of like the Greeks and Icarus flying too close to the sun.
1:05:50Josh Wolfe: It's excessive hubris. It's some of those deadly sins that are taken in excess without some tempering internal voice or an external one that tells you don't or stop. And we have had some of those entrepreneurs come pitch that we have actually not funded where I'm like, they are super smart, but they are like sub 25 prefrontal cortex, not developed, no compliment. People are deferring to them. And I'm like, they are either going to end up billionaire or in jail and i can't underwrite which and so in some of those cases just stay away if you ever have a situation where like for me i would basically just default to if i don't trust this person i just would not do anything with them even if there might be a massive i i ironically like i don't think i would vocally say some of the things that you've said about elon but then i would also just not like take the actions you know with my own money or with my own time yeah are you comfortable backing someone or willing to make that decision if it's kind of like a question mark on the i don't know i wouldn't say ethics side but just like you don't deeply trust someone i i think we have aired that if we don't trust them we won't back them but i think even with spf uh i think we're like he's super smart he's quirky you know mildly autistic um but there's something sort of special in the business and we did trust that so um but you know that's the great virtue of venture is you make mistakes and ideally they're ones that aren't consequential or costly.
1:07:15Josh Wolfe: And then sometimes you underestimate your own judgment in certain people that were like these quiet people that had ambitions and suddenly like they surprise you to the upside and it makes it all worthwhile. Over the course of like, let's say hugging faces, you know, history, six and a half years, you've been at for a very long time. What has been your feeling towards the company and about the outcome that you thought was likely throughout time on that one specific company. I think we always felt it was going to be very big. And some of that was external signal of, you know, partners that were either trying to invest or had made overtures.
1:07:49Josh Wolfe: I think Clem had a very steady hand. If anything, I think there were investors that might have felt like, don't you want to transact now? You know, and there were multiple times. And he sort of kept building. And I think they really believe that their true north was this global community. and hundreds of thousands of people that were developing on this platform. And when we first funded, it was not clear with open source other than like the classic Red Hat, Linux, you know, how are you going to monetize? And it was a similar thing with Runway ML. People were like, how are they going to monetize?
1:08:25Josh Wolfe: And you believe in these people that in many ways were like a mix of artists and computer scientists in both cases. both have extraordinary taste. One European French sensibility, one South American sensibility, respectively in Clem and Thomas and Julian and in Chris. But I think they are true believers in the virtue in both cases of community, adoption, solving problems for people, delivering magic. And I think that they believe that that's going to continue to compound. And I think in both cases, it will. Hugging face post acquisition and runway, you know, for the next few years. Hugging face is a very interesting example.
1:09:07When I talked with Clem, he just seemed very focused on trying to create goodwill and create something valuable kind of generally for the world, but not trying to monetize. And like this is something I'm very focused on is just like create, you know, something that's super valuable for founders and not try to make money from it. I think if you do something that is valuable, eventually people at the thought of losing it will pay for it.
1:09:32Josh Wolfe: And so if you're like, you know, I'm thinking of, I bet you if you announce in like a few months, I'm thinking of like not doing the podcast anymore and not doing the series. And people are like, no, you got to do it. And suddenly like people will be like, we'll fund you in a Patreon thing or, you know. So I think that once people come to get habituated on a particular technology or community, it's very hard to take that away from them. And, you know, it's classic sort of loss aversion in some sense. And so if you feel like there's something that's part of what you do every day, you know, people have this all kinds of products, right?
1:10:02Josh Wolfe: Products, they don't work, they get discontinued. You have like this loyal fan base. It's like, no, like, you know, we'll pay for it. Put it on Kickstarter. But I think that is true of Clem. I think there was an authenticity about building this community and a deep belief in the virtue of open source. And it happened to coincide with this big global debate about closed models and sovereignty. And I think he's on the right side of history. Do you have any specific business models that you really love? I like monopolies. I like things that technologically you can do something that nobody else can do for some period of time.
1:10:34Josh Wolfe: And that that monopoly technologically compounds with capital and you can weaponize the capital. and it compounds with talent. So if you start with a capability that people would look at and say, that's not fair. They have that. Nobody else does. I love that. That's a great starting point. And then if you have a great storyteller and a great fundraiser, you can bring the financial capital and the human capital and you just sort of compound this competitive advantage. It's very hard to catch up. So that's a business model. It's not about subscription versus freemium. It's just start with some capability that nobody else has.
1:11:09Josh Wolfe: and then raise a ton of money that weaponizes capital, that gives you the optionality and the time and the hedge. And then with that capital and the equity value that particularly if you have a cadence of fundraising, people can see, I want to get in now because if I don't join the company now, it's going to be too late. So I think the best companies just in terms of building the company are fundraising every one or two years. They're doubling or tripling the valuation on fundamentals because they've delivered something and it creates this runway success and it attracts financial capital, human capital, investors, talent, outside interest, partners.
1:11:45Josh Wolfe: And you go from a little company that people are doubting and don't believe is going to make it to one that feels going from impossible to inevitable. So that to me is perfection.
Josh Wolfe is a Co-Founder and Partner at Lux Capital. Lux has backed many great startups including: Anduril, Impulse Space, Physical Intelligence, Cognition, Applied Intuition, Databricks, Runway, Ramp, and Erebor.