Spurs’ Attacking Issues - Players or System? | Odobert Debate & Peak Bale vs Kane vs Modric | Windy from The Extra Inch (Q&A)

9 Oct 2025 · 1 h 11 min · 29 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Debate on Tottenham’s attacking “fluidity” problem—whether it’s mainly personnel/skills (lack of a playmaker, technical quality in midfield) or system/coaching. They also discuss Thomas Frank’s Brentford-style set-piece focus, Spurs squad balance, and compare Spurs managers’ styles (Mourinho/Conte/Ange). Plus Q&A: Kane vs Bale vs Modric, results vs performances, and January/summer transfer expectations.

Guests

Windy Miller (host/Spurs pod contributor; emphasizes admin/organization skills and community-building). Nathan (mentioned as the more tactical/analytical footballer; studies matches closely). No other named guests appear; most “guests” are Discord/X questioners.

Key claims

  • Spurs’ final-third clunkiness is likely a personnel issue: need a line-breaking playmaker (e.g., Madison/Wharton-type) rather than blaming the system alone.
  • Set pieces are a major positive; Frank treats them as integrated, not a separate “special training” block.
  • Rotation is praised; criticism includes repeated use of a Benton/Capellini-style double pivot that “doesn’t work.”
  • Odobert is promising but raw; Sarr is valued for off-ball defensive reading more than on-ball creativity; Tyrese Hall’s development was mishandled.

Notable examples

  • Kudus and Xavi Simons are used as examples of how central creativity changes play.
  • Odebert–Xavi Simons interplay vs Leeds; Odebert and Simons were PSG academy teammates.
  • Kulusevski and Madison described as key “glue”/best players; Kulusevski’s ability to hold off multiple defenders.
  • January transfer talk centers on signing Adam Wharton quickly (and avoiding protracted deals).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Analyzing Tottenham's Season Start

2:25 to 5:25

The hosts reflect on Tottenham's season start, player performances, and coaching strategies.

“Just, you know, in basic terms, we have more men behind the ball when we're in possession of the football.”

Set Pieces and Tactical Approaches

5:25 to 9:50

Discussion on the importance of set pieces and tactical differences in Brentford's play.

“I always have done when Rory Dallap used to do it.”

Personnel vs. System: A Deep Dive

9:50 to 12:40

The hosts debate whether issues are due to player skills or the tactical system in place.

“he was at brentford for years and years and years they knew exactly what was expected of them in multiple systems formations against multiple types of opposition.”

Young Players and Team Dynamics

12:40 to 14:00

Exploration of the potential of young players like Odebeir and their impact on the team.

“Maybe if he pops up with a couple of goals in the next few weeks, people will just suddenly change their tune because goals matter.”

Understanding Player Chemistry

14:00 to 15:00

Learn how past experiences shape players' on-field dynamics.

“of positions the understanding that one person needs to hold the width and and the other can sit in the pocket inside, I thought was really nice.”

Assessing Sarr's Skillset

15:00 to 18:00

Explore the strengths and weaknesses of player Sarr in the current squad.

“I think he is, the way I've described him on the pod, is a small spaces player.”

Tyrese Hall's Development Journey

18:00 to 20:50

Discuss the career trajectory and potential of Tyrese Hall.

“he's kind of coming to the fiery line for me just by dint of not being that player.”

Investigation into Forest Twitter Mysteries

20:50 to 22:00

Delve into peculiar rumors circulating within the football fan community.

“Like football fans are so good at investigative journalism.”

Listener Questions: Favorite Spurs Moments

22:00 to 22:30

Reflect on memorable and challenging periods of supporting Spurs.

Listener Questions: Favorite Spurs Moments

23:25 to 23:40

Reflect on memorable and challenging periods of supporting Spurs.

“Whether you're a small business or managing a large operation, Odoo gives you one flexible platform built to grow with you.”
Show all 29 chapters

Highs and Lows of Spurs Support

24:19 to 28:00

Examine the emotional rollercoaster of being a Spurs fan over the years.

“Yeah, I think if I'd gone to all the Europa League final stuff, which I do regret not going to in some ways.”

Reflecting on Spurs' Recent Pressures

28:00 to 29:43

Discussion on the media's portrayal of Spurs and its impact on the team and fans.

“Whereas Conte, his whole thing was, I'm so above this club.”

Criticism and Support for Managers

29:43 to 31:33

Exploring the challenges faced by managers like Ange and Mourinho from fan reactions.

“But yeah, some people like really drank the Kool-Aid with Ange and sort of saw him as some kind of purist who was there to save football.”

Analyzing Ange's Tactical Challenges

31:33 to 32:50

Insight into the tactical difficulties faced by Ange and the criticisms surrounding his approach.

“And so I really didn't enjoy doing the reaction pods, and that probably showed through the way I was approaching them.”

Personal Reflections on Managerial Success

32:50 to 34:20

A discussion on personal feelings towards Ange's tenure and the struggles at Nottingham Forest.

“It's like, you weren't even, you know, come on.”

Self-Reflection on Podcasting Skills

34:20 to 36:25

Windy shares his thoughts on his role and contributions to the podcast and community.

“I think he is quite ego-driven and he would love to be able to ram it down people's throats and say, look, I can do what you said I can't.”

Debate on Players Who Could Transform Spurs

36:25 to 38:38

Discussion on which Spurs legends at their peak would improve the current squad.

“But I am really reliant on the fact that I'm very good at doing admin.”

Results vs. Performances: A Spurs Dilemma

38:38 to 40:47

Weighing the importance of results against performances for Spurs' season.

“If, in a Tottenham sense, if by the end of the season we finish fourth in the league, but performances continue to be average, what would be your take on Frank?”

The Evolution of Spurs' Football Philosophy

40:47 to 42:00

Discussion on the changing style of play and the balance between attacking and defensive strategies.

“But at the same time, I think we've got enough individual quality here.”

Tottenham's Tactical Evolution

42:00 to 45:20

Explore how Tottenham's playing style has evolved and the implications for success.

“You know, this kind of idea of like, this club is built on these notions of, you know, not waiting for the opposition to die of boredom and game is about glory and stuff.”

Player Impact on Season Success

45:20 to 47:00

Discuss the return of key players and their potential impact on the season.

“I think we could be waiting for a when it clicks moment that never comes.”

Arsenal Rivalry and Player Comparisons

47:00 to 48:40

Analyze the current state of the North London rivalry and player quality comparisons.

“You see, Arsenal are favourites for the Premier League and the Champions League, Wendy.”

January Transfer Window Speculations

48:40 to 50:20

Explore potential transfer moves and their implications for Tottenham's ambitions.

“I want us to give a good account of ourselves in our Northland and Derby.”

January Transfer Window Speculations

51:01 to 51:28

Explore potential transfer moves and their implications for Tottenham's ambitions.

“It can help you with practically anything on the web.”

Future Squad Enhancements

51:29 to 56:05

Discuss the number of players needed to elevate Tottenham's squad quality.

“And I, like, everyone seems to be like...”

Youth Player Development Challenges

56:05 to 1:02:09

Discussing the pressures and challenges young players face in development.

“Yeah, well, not so much nowadays, because unfortunately I don't have as much time on my hands to watch as many youth games.”

Reflections on Fumbled Youth Talent

1:02:10 to 1:06:39

Examining past youth players who failed to reach their potential at Spurs.

“I would say quite clearly the best player in world football right now.”

Current and Former Player Comparisons

1:06:40 to 1:10:01

Comparing the career paths of current and former players from Spurs.

“He's coming towards the end of his career, you know.”

Discussion on Football Skills and Players

1:10:01 to 1:11:47

Learn about the skills of various players and their positions in football.

“And there are quite a few ballers amongst our listeners.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00If you're a small business owner, you'll know just what it's like to be the chief everything officer. HR, payroll, employee benefits. Well, Gusto can do all of that for you. Gusto is online payroll and benefits software built for small businesses. It's all in one, remote friendly and incredibly easy to use. It's quick and simple to switch to Gusto. Just transfer your existing data to get up and running fast. Try Gusto today at gusto.com forward slash locked on soccer and get three months free when you run your first payroll. That's gusto.com forward slash locked on soccer. The world's biggest soccer tournament has arrived and you can trade the entire tournament on Calci.

0:38On Calci, you can trade every match from the opening stage all the way to the final. On Calci, you're trading against peers in a live market, meaning there's no house. And as the probability changes, you can buy in and out of your position. For a limited time, download the CalShe app and use code CUP26 to get$10 when you trade 10. K-A-L-S-H-I CalShe. Trade the beautiful game. 18 plus only restrictions and eligibility requirements apply. Event contract trading involves risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Prices, values, and available markets may differ from those mentioned. For more information, see calshe.com slash regulatory.

1:08The entire summer of soccer is on prize picks. All 48 countries in every matchup. And if you rep your side before the round of 16 on prize picks, you can win a trip to the finals in New York. It's the biggest tournament ever, which means there's even more opportunities to cash in while you root for your favorite national sides and global soccer stars. Download the app today and use code CUP26 to get$50 instantly in lineups when you play your first$5. Download the app today and use code CUP26 to get$50 instantly in lineups when you play your first$5. PrizePix, America's number one sports picks app.

1:57hello everybody welcome back to rule the ruch podcast the international break might be on but the podcasts don't stop do they windy miller how are you doing mate good yeah i'm all right i've a bit groggy had a slightly sleepless night with a teething baby so i'm not feeling 100 % but um yeah I'm I'm good to go I think it's interesting isn't it the podcast don't stop the international break always gives you a little dilemma as to what to tackle on the podcast and people have different expectations about what they want from you some people see it as an opportunity to go deep on a particular issue and some people want a break from your pod I think yeah I I sort of I want to try and treat them a little bit like you know towards the last few weeks of term when you were back in school yeah the teachers would like they'd commit to about 10 minutes of teaching and then just put a tape on yeah absolutely yeah I mean let's let's you know I think that's that's the vibe isn't it that's the vibe um well let's you know let's let's dive in with the uh with the the housekeeping bit first and foremost then mate how are you uh how are you feeling about the season for anybody you know I mean I'm pretty sure everybody listens to this probably listens to the extra inch but still how are you how are you feeling about frank um i see nathan's picking up a few pelters at the moment for should we say a less than an effusive take on thomas frank's tenure so far is he that's i i'm kind of a bit detached from social media at the moment so i've not kind of picked up the pelters um mostly because i just occupy our discord bubble and i would say there's a good number of people that are very team nathan on that one personally I am really pleased with the start we've made I really like Thomas Frank as a person I think he seems super super sound I think he's very

3:55realistic I think he is honest in his assessment of where we are I think he's not an idiot he doesn't think that we're you know a fully functioning team at this point I would say it's very reasonable to have some concerns about how we move the ball through the thirds of the pitch because it doesn't always look great see it's clunky at best but there's loads to be really happy about I think the defensive structure just to the eye test looks so much more palatable to your average fan. Just, you know, in basic terms, we have more men behind the ball when we're in possession of the football. And that allows you to be able to defend more cohesively as a team and gives you a platform on which to build.

4:50Now that does come with its downsides, but for the moment, I think that's the right decision. Set pieces are amazing. I love the focus on set pieces. I think we've seen some ingenuity. I think we've seen some quite pragmatic choices, but it's working well so far. And I think that's an area where we'll continue to improve as well. So, yeah, I think there's some really good stuff going on. With the set pieces, I kind of feel like it's almost one of those things that we just wanted to cling on to something to hate Arsenal for additionally. and because they got really good at set pieces we sort of as a fan base got this set pieces of shit aren't they i don't like those and now we're doing quite well at them we're like uh well i don't know how to feel about this really i just feel like we were just leaving points on the table like it's it's really so and said this whole thing which was set pieces are just a part of the the way we play more generally and we don't need to focus on um training in a particular way for set pieces because you know we approach the game in this particular attacking um sort of breaks off mode of of playing football set pieces are a part of that whereas frank is very much no this is a separate part of football we will have for every time the ball goes out of play we will have a particular way that we want to bring the ball back into play and i think that approach is way more sensible in terms of understanding that there's a chance to firstly reset as a team but also to utilise various strengths across the pitch that aren't just you know we have really good ways of progressing the ball actually no we've got someone who can throw the ball a really long way we've got someone who's really good in the air at the near post so let's make those work for us not against us it's I appreciate that long throws are a very sort of early noughties Bolton, but they do the job sometimes.

6:57I love them. Genuinely, I love it. I love watching it happen. I always have done when Rory Dallap used to do it. Yeah, exactly. You know, proper football man football, you know. Touching on something you were talking about as well, about the lack of sort of fluidity in the final third. Yeah, yeah. I've been toying up the idea here that it's potentially more of a, say like a skills issue a personnel issue versus a systemic one how do you kind of feel about that because I say that mainly because I look at Mohamed Kudus it's not like Frank's putting a handbrake on him um when Xavi was playing centrally against like definitively playing centrally should we say against Leeds the other day he suddenly looked influential it opened up a lot of our play and yeah it was a bit of a stuttering start there were a couple of moments you know a few through balls that could have been played through to tell and the Rabonna, Rabonna gate, all that type of stuff.

7:50But still, I quite like a young player. He is very young still. And I think people forget that who is still adapting to the Premier League, who feels emboldened enough to take risks on that kind of number 10 position. But still, I mean, what do you make of the sort of the sense that when we say adds more quality into that final third, say, you know, Had we a Harry Kane or somebody up front, our system might look a bit more fluid. Harry Kane's a bad example. I mean, he's quite clearly probably the best player in the world at the moment. Just on that, have you seen his 99 percentile in pretty much everything that's been shared this season?

8:30He is ridiculous. And obviously he's playing in a farmer's league. Sausage farmers. I'm with you on the systemic versus personnel stuff I'm having the same kind of internal monologue around that my gut feel at the moment is so when I think back to Thomas Frank's Brentford and I think about the strides they took forward they all happened when Mikkel Damsgaard came into the team I don't think they changed an awful lot in the way they approached football they just suddenly had a player who linked things together knitted play together got on the ball had touches passed and moved was creative with his passing and vision and so my suspicion is it is a personnel thing and we just need to have better players in order to um be a more fluid cohesive team I want to say better I mean better at you know turn the dial on certain technical aspects rather than other aspects so you're not going to necessarily get a 100 better player but you'll get a player that's more attuned to playing forward passes line breaking passes perhaps and then you you suffer for that and perhaps a lack of defensive awareness and you you know that's something they'll have to um grapple with but um i do think systemically once the you know he was at brentford for years and years and years they knew exactly what was expected of them in multiple systems formations against multiple types of opposition.

10:04We're not there yet. So this is really early days still. So there is definitely some system enhancement that can happen and I think will happen. And we should give him a good chunk of the season before we start to judge him on the system. But I also think, you know, get a deep-blown playmaker or at least a playmaker in at number eight and suddenly you see a transformed Spurs team. get Madison back in the squad and that really helps. You know, Kulosevsky's been a big loss. I think we've had to play Richarlison way more than we'd have wanted to so far. So having the option of Solanke will really help as well.

10:44Which I think is, as a fan, it's easier to kind of,

10:50it's easier to accept what you're seeing if it isn't exactly what you want. if you know that there are a couple of jigsaw pieces missing that you can just kind of slide into place and everything looks good again. I'm really interested to see how he lines up once Maddison, Kulusevsky, Solanke, everyone's back basically, how he finds that balance. And I know it's a squad game. I know this whole thing, the idea of a starting XI is redundant, but it's kind of not though as well. You know, like you're still going to have your best XI. I think that's always going to be a thing. His rotation has been amazing, by the way.

11:30I didn't mention that at the start. I'm really impressed with the way he's rotated the squad. I think my main criticism, I would say, is how many times does he need to see that the Benton Copellini double pivot just doesn't work? Like, come on, mate. And, you know, again, cards on the table. Like, I'm not like a Thomas Frank stan, but I like what much like what you said I like where we're going I like the fact we're not losing lots of games I think there's there's an impressive amount of control to a lot of what we do um and I and I I generally quite like Frank's demeanor I think he uh you know it's that really like centrist dad take but yeah he's like the adults are here now you know that type of like you know the sensible man is here and uh I don't mind I don't mind that for a bit and I get why it rub some people up the wrong way but full otto english wasn't it isn't it nice the quiet or something like that but i i don't mind that you know it's uh it's okay um wilson odabaugh he's like he's somebody that you know people are very very split on i'm i'm of the opinion that he seems like a pretty promising but raw young player whereas some people are quick to say he's useless get rid how do you feel I'm with you it's funny I think he's one of many pretty useful raw young players we've got and I would include Bergvau in the same category but people aren't spit on Bergvau but they are on on Odeber I don't know what that's about really maybe it's about the fact that Odebeir hasn't scored many goals.

13:18Maybe if he pops up with a couple of goals in the next few weeks, people will just suddenly change their tune because goals matter.

13:28The thing is, he came with a bit of experience at Burnley. So there's a sort of expectation that he will be a bit more fully formed. But he's 20. He's 20. He's the same age as Matisse tell who everyone is happy to accept is is raw and unfinished um yeah I think he's he's got loads of potential um really liked what I saw between him and Xavi Simons against Leeds I thought the kind of close uh interplay one and two touch pass and move football that they displayed the rotation of positions the understanding that one person needs to hold the width and and the other can sit in the pocket inside, I thought was really nice.

14:11And it didn't surprise me when Nathan told me on the pod this week that they were at PSG together. And yeah, they played together in the same academy team because you can tell there's an understanding between them. That is really interesting. I didn't know that at all. Yeah, I wasn't aware. Because, so Simons came through at La Masia and Odebert at PSG. I just assumed that their kind of formative years in high level sort of ticker tacker academy football approaches would have led to them having a similar understanding of the way football should air quotes be played. And that would make sense alone.

14:54But the fact that they've actually played together in their in their younger days, yeah, it makes total sense when you see their interactions on the pitch. But yeah, I really like Odeber. I think he is, the way I've described him on the pod, is a small spaces player. He's not someone who's going to carry the ball 40, 50 yards, as we've seen someone like Gulaszewski do, albeit at a snail's pace. um odberi is much more he's kind of explosive in small spaces and tricky in small spaces but then needs someone to bounce off to kind of play him through or play him into space or he's the one that sometimes plays the ball into space um and sometimes those players can go a little bit underappreciated i think i like it they uh they were scolding in ticker tacker proper football and now they're getting in the mix waiting for a throw from Big Kevin Dancer.

15:47Drive the bull, Wilder Bear. Throw it in. A bit wallop. De Messe and Trace on Discord says, well, he first of all says, have a tête -à-tête about Saar. And he said, well, maybe I can put this more into a question. Who would you rather have in the squad right now, Saar or Tyrese Hall? Do you still hate Sarr? No. I think the thing is with Sarr, I've never hated Sarr. You hated him. You had a picture of his face on the dartboard, all that type of stuff. I love him as a person, by the way. I think he's an adorable human being and does so much for Senegal more generally, but I think the city where he's brought up, township where he's brought up, he is building a medical center.

16:46Just absolutely incredible. What guy? I think I have underappreciated Saar's skill set because I have an inherent bias towards players that are kind of highly technical in their passing ability. that is a bias that is internalized to me and I completely accept and I will always prefer someone who wants to get on the ball have touches have creative vision creative passing sorry is not that player he's a transition player he's really really really strong off the ball um how many times have we seen him chase back and stretch out one of his legs in the perfect time to get a nick on the ball and take it away from an opponent just as they're about to make a through ball or have a shot whatever he's so good at reading the game in a defensive off ball manner I think his on-ball abilities are more limited uh obviously he he's pops up with some fantastic goals is a really good finisher especially first time uh but he isn't someone who just wants the ball at his feet all the time um dictating play and I do think we've lacked a midfielder who can do that and so he's kind of coming to the fiery line for me just by dint of not being that player.

18:10I think he is much more suited to Frank Ball. When he played the first couple of games as kind of a pressing 10, it looked like Frank was going to get the best out of him. And then he had a couple of poorer games and then he's been out of the team and that's partly, I think, due to injury. But maybe it's also because he wanted to squeeze some more creativity into the team as he was using Bergvau in that position and now Simon's and hopefully Simon's will continue to play there so I don't know what that means for Saar um on the point now about Saar or Tyrese Hall uh Tyrese Hall is an incredible prospect absolutely brilliant player and should have been on loan last year I know a few things about the way Ange treated Tyrese Hall and I think he's absolutely fucked it and I think Tyrese Hall is now probably a year behind in his development.

19:00And hopefully he'll kind of get his confidence back and become the player that he should become. He's flying at Notts County at the moment, scored a few goals recently, playing as a number 10, which I'm quite surprised about. I thought he was going to be a 6th. They seem to love him as well. You see the odd bit that comes through on social media, right? Because his quality, he just oozes class on the ball. And I've just been saying I have a bias towards players that want touches, want to feel the ball at their feet, want to pass the ball, want to carry the ball. That's Tyrese Hall. He is my kind of footballer.

19:33The few times we've seen him, like, for Spurs, I think, did he play in the FA Cup game? Did he come on against Tamworth? I can't remember. I know he played the post-season friendly against Newcastle and did really well in that game and everyone was kind of buzzing about him on the social. And there were, like, full match highlights of Tyrese Hall, people saying star boy, etc., etc. And then he played a couple of the preseason games. He had a really poor showing. I think it was against Rangers. And there was an incident with Ange, which I can't talk about, but there was an incident with Ange. And since then, he was thrown to the wolves, essentially.

20:07Just some of his teammates stayed with the first team. He got shoved back into the development squad. It's clearly, anyone who's watched Spurs under 21s will see how that has impacted his confidence levels. And it's taken a long time to rebuild those. and I do think he is he should have been with the first team squad all of last season and or on loan kind of probably League One team he's now gone to League Two I think there's a conversation about whether we move him to a League One club in January or whether we do what we did with George Abbott last year and leave him in Notts County for the whole season that's a really tough decision but we'd love to see him in the squad next year I think he's class I don't know if you've seen but talking about like Ange ITK stuff what seems to be going around forest twitter at the moment is some sort of uh ITK they all call Ange what's it fingers and it's something it's something to do and I can't I've honestly I've been going down rabbit holes trying to find what the actual root of this is but it seems to be there's been some sort of incident already with a player and it revolves and having like what's it dust on his fingers and i don't know what it is and i'm desperate to find out but oh my goodness yeah i do find it quite funny how can we maybe it's maybe we need to put a call out on the podcasts to anyone who's got a friend that supports forest and might know the the background to do some investigative journalism.

21:43Like football fans are so good at investigative journalism. Like the way they track planes when players are about to sign. The way they take sneaky photos and share them on Reddit and suddenly it explodes. Like we need to know what WhatsApp is about. That sounds incredible. And if it is something like bad or offensive, I apologise in advance. Yeah.

22:06um chumbucket7988 on discord says in the last decade what's been your favorite month of supporting spurs and what about the least favorite the entire summer of soccer is on prize picks all 48 countries in every matchup and if you rep your side before the round of 16 on prize picks you can win a trip to the finals in new york it's the biggest tournament ever which means there's even more opportunities to cash in while you root for your favorite national sides and global soccer stars. Download the app today and use code CUP26 to get$50 instantly in lineups when you play your first$5. Download the app today and use code CUP26 to get$50 instantly in lineups when you play your first$5.

22:46PrizePix, America's number one sports picks app. If your business runs on five different apps, 12 browser tabs, and one spreadsheet that everyone's afraid to touch, it's probably time for Odoo. Odoo is an all-in-one business management software that connects every part of your business into one powerful, easy-to-use platform. So instead of wasting time switching between disconnected systems, your entire business works together in real time. Your team moves faster, your data stays accurate, and you can actually focus on growing your business. Let one unified system run your entire business. From the first opportunity to the final payment, everything works together in one place.

23:31Whether you're a small business or managing a large operation, Odoo gives you one flexible platform built to grow with you. Learn more at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com. Tee off on the Turkish Riviera. Europe's premier golf destination. With championship courses in Bilek and Antalya, luxury all-inclusive resorts and year-round sunshine, it is the perfect getaway under the Mediterranean sun. Play immaculate fairways designed by golf legends, then unwind beside stunning beaches and five-star hospitality. Search Turkey on TripAdvisor now to book your ultimate golf holiday in the Turkish Riviera.

24:19I can say quite, I'd say honestly, like it's tough, but if I'm being brutally honest, that period of time, it probably wasn't a month, but the period of time between the end of Ajax to the Champions League final, I've never felt anything like that as a Spurs fan. I was walking on clouds. Yeah. Yeah, I think if I'd gone to all the Europa League final stuff, which I do regret not going to in some ways. It was a difficult period with my daughter at the time and it didn't feel like the right time for me to go for two or three days and just be gone. I reckon that would probably have been my favourite if I'd been there.

25:04But yeah, I think I'm in agreement with you. that the post Ajax euphoria because we loved dad so much as well and we just want so we just wanted that for him like he'd had a bad season we'd had a bad season yet he had got us the Champions League final felt incredible it really did I think you're right like there were other points the year before was great as well Manchester City Ajax that would have been in a in the same month right wouldn't it right you know yeah it's it was it was a that was a that was a wild time to be alive as a Spurs fan I've got to say yeah yeah it was something else yeah I didn't yeah because there was some there were there were a whole bunch of periods under Poch where there were stretches of it just feeling incredible you just felt so proud to be a Spurs fan whenever you had conversations with other non-Spurs fans, they will be complimenting on the type of football Spurs were playing and almost in admiration of, jealous basically, that we've got Poch and we're the ones playing this level of football and it felt so good.

26:15So I think that, yeah, in terms of the least favourite,

26:23God, several moments in the Mourinho. Mourinho, yeah. Several moments under Mourinho felt really bleak. But then Conte's second season felt awful. Horrible. I mean, I think personally for me, like some of when Ange went bad, like that Everton game, the Leicester home game under Ange and some of the subsequent discussion around those performances just felt so rudderless and hopeless because this guy was meant to be the antidote to Mourinho and Conte and we looked awful we looked absolutely awful I think and he he he had like he was rattled as hell as well yeah like with Mourinho and Conte they were never they were they were rattled in the sense that they were uppity about being questioned how dare you question me but Ange was like fully rabbit in the headlights rattled i think that the saving grace i mean obviously the europa league and that stuff but outside of that the saving grace to me with ang is that like even when even when it went to the bottom and i i completely like fell out with him towards the end like i couldn't stand his attitude for the most part but what i would say is there was still a sense with him that he was despite everything despite the fact he was falling out of fans falling out of players he was still kind of fighting for spurs like yeah absolutely there were the odd moments when you'd see it in like press conferences and stuff like that when he just laughed and he was like you lot love doing this to tottenham don't you you know when when it was kind of the press doing the whole spurs are going to bottle it spursy this and that it actually wound him up as well yeah true yeah it was nice to see he could see it from our perspective as in like you don't give this club a break and And it is on you lot.

28:20You do this. Whereas Conte, his whole thing was, I'm so above this club. I'm so, why am I even here? He used us as a shield for himself. It was just like it was just a, you know, it was just like himself warming up, wouldn't it? Like, you know, for whatever it is in Napoli, where he's obviously doing a good job. He's just a nasty bit of work, Conte, isn't he? He's not a very nice bloke. Not a fan at all. Don't take me back there. um cm on discord says as uh this is probably relevant to what we've just been talking about as angiball crawled towards its grave last year um how badly did windy want to headbutt an oncoming train rather than do another reaction pod only to be criticized for being too negative how did how did you find the uh because i i've i've sort of made the comparison windy and you've been in pretty sure you've been in the crosshairs of both but I I have found a a cult-like thing around Ange that I would say I found pretty unpleasant on a personal level last year when I when I aired and I would say like I wasn't sat here I'd never once said anything about like he's an Aussie what does he know about football he's a fat this or that none of that I was never abusive towards Ange I always had a certain level of respect for him I just criticized what I was seeing in front of me you wouldn't think that from some of the pushback I've got but I mean you got you got you got really bad stuff from the Mourinho era right oh god yeah yeah yeah the Mourinho era was like the Mourinho cult fans and I think also like literally an army of bots um genuinely I think probably his agency either had sock puppet accounts or bots.

30:04That was insane. The cultists from Mourinho were mad. But yeah, some people like really drank the Kool-Aid with Ange and sort of saw him as some kind of purist who was there to save football. And if you didn't appreciate that, you were somehow responsible for the demise of football as a sport. And the thing is I was so supportive of Ange so fucking all in on him because I really wanted it to work and there came a point where I was just like I am lying to myself now and I can't continue doing that. I can't keep watching what I'm watching and pretending that this is good or has the foundations of being good and so it probably was quite a quick like pull myself out of this like this is madness we can't just keep putting up with this um and so I imagined for listeners it probably felt quite almost like I did a handbrake turn and suddenly changed my tune so I was doing these reaction pods where you know we had the same performance over and over again and it was bleak and there was very little going right and it was the same defensive incapability being exposed over and over and over again.

31:21And it wouldn't always end in goals, but it would end in dangerous shots or teams pretty much playing one pass down the middle of the pitch and being in on goal. That's not an exaggeration either. It was farcical, wasn't it, at times? Honestly, it really was. And so I really didn't enjoy doing the reaction pods, and that probably showed through the way I was approaching them. and so I understand why people got their backs up if they were very pro-ange a lot of people were very supportive and just said you know well done for getting some content out about that mess kind of thing uh there were a couple of people who really did not enjoy them but also hate listened to every single one and and told me that they didn't enjoy it um I mean there's a couple of people like one guy was just dming me all the time saying that I was just uh completely biased against Ange.

32:11I was, I think he was sort of speculating that I was down on Ange because he was an Aussie, like you just said, which wasn't the case at all. Like, I didn't have any of that snobbery about him. I still don't. I don't think he's failing at Forest now because he's an Aussie. I think he's failing because ultimately his system has been found out by tactically astute managers that know how to play against him. Like, yes, you create an overload in the middle of the pitch. Great, we're going to create overloads elsewhere and you're going to have to deal with that one of the things i always used to like getting was uh sorry sorry he's an aussie and he's not an english manager i'll be like mate i don't know how to break it to you like i'm not here pine him for eddie howe do you know what i mean like yeah um sam halladice i don't know i wouldn't wouldn't mind a little uh runner dice ball here and there you know every now and again um yeah it's a funny one but uh yeah i i take a lot of pleasure it's really difficult because i'm taking a lot of pleasure from forest's downfall because of maranakis and because of the sort of the the way their fan base tried to sort of engineer a rivalry between the two of us last year you know you're having like 14 year old kind of yeah blue tick twitter accounts being like you know this is for the FA Cup in 90s.

33:32It's like, you weren't even, you know, come on. I don't remember it. I'm twice your age and I don't remember that. What are you going on about? Like, shut up. But I don't, I genuinely, I don't, I find it, I would say like, you know, my gut reaction to sort of seeing like Ange being in peril and stuff right now already. I'm just kind of like, it's just unpleasant. I don't, I don't like, this is a guy that did, for all that it's worth, he did bring us a Europa League. Absolutely. And I do have overwhelming, like, on the balance of it, I have fond memories of him. So, you know, it's just... Yeah, I'm very grateful.

34:08Exactly. Very, very grateful, even if he's not 100 % my cup of tea. Extremely grateful for what he ultimately did for the club, like the monkeys off the back. It's a strange job to take, though, the Forest one. That Forest team and Flux in that way and the personnel and... That's him, though. I think he is quite ego-driven and he would love to be able to ram it down people's throats and say, look, I can do what you said I can't. Maybe that's the Aussie part of him. Maybe. Do you know what I mean? Maybe, yeah. And I've got a lot of Australian friends, all right?

34:44Joe Dash on Discord said, is Windy as reliant on any single skill as Xavi is reliant on his right foot? hmm I probably am probably am actually I like sometimes sometimes with the podcast I think I listen to to Nathan analyzing football and I think I have no place I have no place being here talking to you about football at this level because you study it you work on it every single day and I listen to Bardi he goes to every single match uh home match that is he's not an away goer um and he turns up for the terrible kickoff times and he's so committed and I don't do that and I haven't done for a good number of years now and I feel a bit of an imposter but the reason I'm there and and the skill that I rely on is the fact that I I'm a really good organizer I know I always have been I'm like I just I run you sell yourself really short there mate but still that's when I when I say I run the show like obviously I host the show and I think hosting is a skill in its own right but like I run the show behind the scenes as well I do all the legwork with our podcast I I help build community I reply to emails I organize advertising I I link everyone together I pay all our invoices.

36:19I liaise with the accountants. I do all the stuff behind the scenes to make the podcast the success it's been. But I am really reliant on the fact that I'm very good at doing admin. I would also say in the dynamic of the extra inch though, Wendy, you're a delightful segue between the proper football man of Bardi, and he won't mind me saying that, and the nerd of Nathan. You know, it's just, I think your awareness of having almost a toe in either camp is, you know, is good. You have a good level of self-depreciation. This is starting to feel like a counselling session, isn't it? In Thomas Frank terms, I've got high levels of emotional intelligence, and I think that helps.

37:02I'm good at eating crisps. That's what I would say. That's a good skill. It's got me far. Yeah. What's it, Fingers? It's about me. That's why I was interested. Nick Abaker on Discord says, and this question, as I've told him, is very unfair. Which player, if we could add them right now, at their Tottenham peak, would improve the current team the most? Kane, Bale or Modric? I mean, that is not particularly fair. I think you could make a case for any of them.

Read the full transcript

37:42I mean, okay, you slot Gareth Bale at his Tottenham peak into the way we're playing now, and suddenly you've got like Mohamed Koudis, but better on the other side of the pitch. And it doesn't matter if you can't progress the ball through midfield because you've got Gareth Bale who just run past every man they put on him and spank one into the top corner. We'd probably win the league. I genuinely feel that, you know. Honestly, you put Kane in the team. every set piece becomes double the threat we become even better at defending set pieces because he was an incredible near post screen and he will feed off scraps but he'll make those scraps count you put Modric in the pitch and maybe we become a proper team that can progress the ball through the middle and we become much easier on the eye I think probably Gareth Bale if I'm honest just to the nature of the football we're playing yeah that's where I might sort of gut feel went as well because he was just a machine though bail you know like everything physically technically you know the mentality like how how many late goals did bail score as well like winners that's ridiculous ridiculous ridiculous half horse of a man um middle on Twitter or X says, and this is a good one, Randy, this is a good existential one.

39:12If, in a Tottenham sense, if by the end of the season we finish fourth in the league, but performances continue to be average, what would be your take on Frank? I guess what I'm asking is, what's more important to you? Results or performances?

39:31If we finish fourth, my take will be irrespective of how we've played to get there that that is a successful season and that absolutely guarantees Frank a full second season uh we need to be in the Champions League to to progress as a football club it means more money it means better players etc etc also fourth will genuinely be an incredible achievement I think with the competition the league has to offer right now um performances are really important for me not just because I like to watch good football. Aesthetically, I want my team to be playing good football. I enjoy matches more. I think also, really importantly, typically if you play better football, you'll get better results.

40:17Typically. There are outliers to that. But my hope would be, and I'm happy to kind of put faith in Frank, that we'll start with the results and build the performances later. I don't think that's an unreasonable position. So I'm really happy to stick with Frank. Like if he finishes, as long as he finishes top six this season, I feel really optimistic about next year. I've got to say as well, I do keep saying it on there, but I do feel like that sort of the performance level in terms of by the eye test, it's overstated quite how bad it is. Yeah, I agree. You know, I'm not sat there watching these games thinking, god this is a bore fest like I was with Mourinho like I was at late stage Conte you know I am sat here thinking this is all right yet we are you know we're definitely kind of setting out a kind of a you know a foundation which is to stop the other lot scoring that kind of outweighs us scoring first.

41:26I can kind of see that to a degree. Yes, I will concede that. But at the same time, I think we've got enough individual quality here. That's it, isn't it? Watching Mohamed Kudus week in, week out is unbelievable. And what I do understand the argument is, what if he goes missing for a few games? What do we have then? I do get that, but I prefer to kick the can down the road and just be like, this is quite nice for now. But I do think, you know, there is, and I'm not saying that you're doing this, Mittal, but like at the moment there is a kind of, there is a sort of sense of like purity testing people at the moment.

42:02You know, this kind of idea of like, this club is built on these notions of, you know, not waiting for the opposition to die of boredom and game is about glory and stuff. That is true. But you also have to bear in mind that like Tottenham Hotspur aren't free from the way football as a sport is going. and if we want Spurs to be successful then there probably is going to have to be a level of like acquiescing to a popular narrative which is being a bit more conservative in the way you approach football matches which seems to be kind of flavour of the month right now and probably has been for about a decade really I mean Pochettino was again was free-flowing and played some beautiful football because we had some absolutely exceptional players.

42:50But I still feel that one of the core things that Pochettino was doing was adding a lot of rigidity into what we were doing. 100%. How many times did we grind out results? There were periods, we did play some incredible football, there were periods where we played, there were several away games where we scraped 1-0s in the direst of circumstances. It was tedious to watch, but we were grateful because we'd had periods where we weren't winning anything away and suddenly we had a bit of steel and backbone. And I think that's what Frank can bring. I think given what we've all been through, where we've lurched between these complete polar opposite styles of managers, the win now is Conte Mourinho, who will just want to sign established older players to get the job done as quickly as possible and forego any kind of interest in developing players to the other extreme, and who kind of wants a five-year blank slate because he wants to completely revolutionise the style of football from top to bottom in the club.

43:52Frank's somewhere in the middle. Like, Frank is, like you say, fundamentally slightly more conservative, but he's not playing a Mourinho-style brand of football, but also that the coaches that Frank has working for him are proper coaches. They want to improve and develop players. They're not just there to teach them a narrow system. It's about, and look at Destiny and Doggy's improvements already this season. You've seen the training videos of him focused on getting to the byline and hitting cutbacks. And then we've seen that put into practice on the pitch. I think that's incredible, like where you can see the benefits of coaching almost immediately.

44:30And there'll be so much of that going on that we haven't seen recognized on the pitch yet. and we'll see glimpses of players improving throughout the season and you will appreciate that in Frank and Cochran and the rest of the backroom staff, we've got genuinely brilliant coaches and I think that's really exciting. I also don't think it's like an attempt to do some gotcha nor is it whataboutism to also highlight the fact that to get the Europa League over the line Ange did revert to a more conservative style. Yeah, it's true. And we all enjoyed that. we all loved winning the Europa League we all loved the parade and we love being in the Champions League now it's 100 % you know all killer no filler on Blue Sky I think we've kind of answered this but I'll read out the question anyway cards on the table I'm frank in I'm very happy with how things are going but what's your gut feeling on how this season plays out is there a big improvement in overall performances or is this another Conte situation where we're all waiting on the when it clicks moment that never comes?

45:41I think we could be waiting for a when it clicks moment that never comes. But meanwhile, while we're all waiting, I think we'll continue doing pretty well. And I think the fact that we've got players coming back into the team at midpoint in the season, don't underestimate the impact that will have. It's not just the sort of quality on the pitch. It's the level of character and persona of the players that we've got due to come back. So Kulosevsky is massive. How many times did Kulosevsky drag us through matches single-handedly over the last 18 months? Physically and also spiritually, give the ball to Kulosevsky, you know it's going to stick and he's going to make something happen.

46:26He can literally hold off two or three players at once consistently for 90 minutes and he would drag himself off the pitch at the end and look exhausted for having done that but he is a big player for us madison i think is our best best player aside from romero huge huge huge player huge personality um hope he's back sooner rather than later so like don't underestimate the impact that the players suddenly becoming fit and adding another sort of layer to the squad we'll have I think we'll have a second wind because of that uh so yeah I'm really really happy that we'll have a solid season this year I think we'll with the rotation we've seen I think we'll compete on multiple fronts Champions League might be a struggle because it's you know so quite so high quality and unless we sign a couple in January I think we might struggle to continue competing in the Champions League but um broadly speaking in the domestic competitions, I feel really optimistic.

47:28You see, Arsenal are favourites for the Premier League and the Champions League, Wendy. Is this the year we're going to have to suck it up and take the inevitable bullet of them winning something massive? I don't even think they're that good. I think Jokeres might be a bit of a fraud. I think he's awful. I think he's really, really bad. I mean, he's going to score goals because they're going to create opportunities for him, But I still, yeah, I'm sort of with you. I still think, I don't look, for example, I don't look at them and think they have a bail. If they had like a bail, if they had a Salah, somebody like that, I would be, I'd be way more worried.

48:11But rivalry aside and everything, I just, I'm just not quite buying that Saka's on that level. Yeah, I think so. He's a great player. He's a great player. Yeah, he's not that level. Agreed. They have an incredible defence. Yeah. And depth to their defence as well, which is also really important. But I agree with you. I don't know they've got enough to get the job done. I really hope so. Do you know what? I'll tell you what I really want more than just their downfall. I want us to give a good account of ourselves in our Northland and Derby. Because it's been too long now. It's been years since we've actually really...

48:51To be fair, the 2-2 at the Emirates in Andrew's first season was good. But still, there's been some We're going to miss Son in the North of the Derbys. He always seemed to have played a really important role. Just miss Son in general. He's killing it at LAFC even though he's... I'm really happy for him. I think one thing I do find quite mad though is physically he just looks done, doesn't he? Sonny. And I was like, God, we were having to play high press in the Premier League for two years at least. We didn't manage him very well. Poor old Sonny. But he got the trophy. He walked off into the sunset.

49:34Left on a high. Sunset, exactly. Danny Rojas on X says, and his at is Peter Porker 91, which I found quite funny. he says what is something that could happen in january or the summer that would convince you that the new executive team is serious about change are all batteries the same that's like asking if all soccer players are the same take messi the most decorated player ever is there any other player who has achieved that no just him now take duracell is there any other battery with power-boost ingredients inside. No, just Duracell. Remember, goats only trust goats because they're built different, and Messi only trusts Duracell.

50:28This episode is brought to you by Google Health. Stop chasing someone else's definition of health. What matters is what's healthy for you. Google Health offers a new kind of coach, built with Gemini for effortless tracking, sleep insights, and holistic coaching tailored to you. Visit googlestore.com to learn more and start a new relationship with your health. Requires Google account, Google Health app, internet, and Google Health premium subscription. Features subject to change. Availability and results vary. Not intended for medical purposes. Works independently of Gemini apps. Check responses for accuracy.

50:58This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web. Like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block. or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required, compatibility and availability varies 18+.

51:28Something like, something mad like signing Adam Wharton, I think. And I, like, everyone seems to be like... And doing it, like, quickly, not a big protracted deal. Absolutely. Just bang. 100 mil there you go we can sign adam wharton there is no reason why we can't sign adam wharton we've got the money to do it we can offer him the wages we are a significant step up in the level of club that we're we're a champions league club the facilities are incredible there's no reason why we can't sign adam wharton so when you see like we want him i've been told we want him we've we've asked about him we've asked to be kept informed of what's happening with him I hope and think we should sign him I've seen a lot of people doubt whether we can whether he'll go to a bigger club now there is no reason why we can't sign a player of that level it's absolutely the kind of player we should be signing we tried to sign Eze we nearly made it happen Wharton's like the same as Eze essentially get it done if we follow it up I mean I think for a player like Wharton surely like and in a sort of it's not even an egotistical thing for him but surely the fact that we're actually willing to part with 100 million pounds say willing to give him 200 250 grand a week which you'd imagine it would probably take should be a signal to the player like as an individual enough that this club are serious the fact that we'd already signed xavi seamans this this summer um would be big i mean he is he is one of those players that would actually really excite me if spurs made a statement like that and signed him it would be really exciting yeah um but for me it wouldn't it wouldn't just be about that one of the big things for me would be just get business done quickly get it done decisively yeah i don't want any more of these month-long protracted transfer deals where fabrizio romano's already told us about it weeks ago and then back and forward back and forward back and forth we hear from various people you know paul o 'keefe will come out with well deal's not actually that close because of these things that are happening you know we don't we don't want that whole cycle again i just want spurs to be in a place where we just seem to be just buying players you know quite normally and getting it done i think that's a brilliant point you sort of become because it's the way we've done business for so long you sort of assume that there's no other way of doing business but of course there is yeah it's wild isn't it yeah junior um on blue sky says how many required players does windy think we need to add for the technical level of our squad to be sufficient enough to compete with the best teams in the league for honors it's a good question really good question I think, so two midfielders, like I've said Adam Wharton, but there needs to be another one as well.

54:30We need to enhance the technical quality of midfield. Weirdly, I think Benson Cora's got the technical quality. He's just a massive coward in possession. Does my head in. So two top-class midfielders that can move the ball forward consistently would be a massive improvement. I think probably another striker, if I'm honest, to compete for honours, to compete for the Premier League. I don't think Solanke and Richarlison are there. Really like both of them a lot. But I think, yeah, like not quite going to score the number of goals you'd require to win the league. You know, you're competing with Haaland and Isaac.

55:18it's a high bar and then I think probably one more centre back and a left winger so four one, two, three, four, five players to win the league there you go Spurs just the five Paul Hagginson on Twitter says, and this is a really good one in this age of instant gratification how do we manage the expectations and development of players like Mikey Moore and Luca Williams Barnett because I see now because Mikey there's there's no hiding like he's having a disaster loan at the moment on at Rangers they they seem to despise him Rangers fans and they're making him essentially like the pariah of what is a clearly awfully managed team and just an awful team in general um but you know it's it's the young english starlet who's obviously the problem up there so whatever you know exactly let them but i'm seeing quite a few spurs fans now be like he's clearly not good enough he's clearly not good enough he's 18 years old like he's 18 i'd like i i i don't get this i'm i'm really not you know we're seeing sort of similar they're a few years older admittedly but see also tell an odder bear who are being written off already for coming into a team that has been say a circumstance that's been less than perfect and now a lot of people seem to have already moved on from mikey moore a lot of clamoring for luca williams barnett to come in but what happens when he has a few tricky games because that's going to happen like the step the step up to like men's senior football is massive from the level that luca williams barnett has been playing at I'm not doubting that the kid is he's clearly clearly very talented but the point I would make is that like a lot of the compilations a lot of the type of goals a lot of the Maisie runs that he's making at youth level we were all fawning over Mikey Moore doing the same a year ago a couple of years ago like I just think you know let's let's get a bit of perspective you know but I mean how do you sort of feel about this in general window because this is like you This is your bread and butter, isn't it, really?

57:34Or was? Yeah, well, not so much nowadays, because unfortunately I don't have as much time on my hands to watch as many youth games. But I still dip in and out where I can and keep my ears to the ground. I think what you have to remember about Mikey Moore is, for the last few years, he's been the best player of his age group in the country. That's not an exaggeration. He then got ill last year, which hampered him a bit. and now this loan hasn't worked out because Rangers are an absolute shit show. Russell Martins had done a legitimately really terrible job and I think a new manager will help Mikey Moore a lot.

58:13I was a bit sceptical about that loan.

58:18I don't know. When you hear he's going to play a lot, you think, great, that's what you need. Just go and play football and then you start to think a bit more about it and I'm not sure it was the right move, but whatever, it's happened. And so there's two things. The access that Spurs play covering all the under 18 and under 21 matches gives fans is amazing. It's so nice to be able to watch the youth matches. But with that, with great power comes great responsibility. And we as fans need to accept exactly what you've said, that firstly, development isn't linear. and just because a player is killing it in those leagues doesn't mean you can then translate down to the Premier League and expect immediate success.

59:04And there is a clamour for the next Harry Kane, which adds a layer of pressure to Moore and Williams Barnett, which is unfair on them and will hamper their progress. Both of them are brilliant, brilliant prospects, as is Jani Byfield, as is Luka Gunter. as is Tyne and Thompson. We've got some real top-class players coming through, but they're going to need a lot of time. There's so many things that can go wrong in players' developments. The wrong choice of loan set Kane back two or three times, and then suddenly he got the right choice of loan and things started going well. Kane wouldn't have been a Spurs player if Adebayor and Soldado hadn't been injured at the same time.

59:50You just need sometimes the stars to align because generally managers are really bad at integrating young players still. So there needs to be a lot of patience with these players who are top class. Whatever Maury's showing right now, he is a huge, huge talent. He has an enormous amount of ability and potential. He's exciting, isn't he? He does look really good. Maury's a really good player. The thing that I would always say and have said about Maury from day one is in the under-18s sometimes, because he was levels above the other 21 players on the pitch, he would try and do it all himself. And he didn't utilize his teammates as well as perhaps he could have done.

1:00:43And I think that it's quite hard to go from that to being the small fish in the big pond. And like, you have to rely on your teammates, first because they're better than you, but also because you need them to kind of put you in positions in the pitch where you can thrive. So I thought that was always going to be a tricky development stage for him. Maybe this setbacks he's having at Rangers long term will be of benefit to him. they can be character building they can make you more reflective and learn about yourself as a person and a footballer it sounds much like uh another player we had before winder exactly exactly like as long as it's managed well as long as it's handled well as long as the conversations with him and the level of support from spurs for more are there it doesn't have to be the worst thing in the world uh please trust me that Mikey Moore is a class player even if he has 20 bad games for Rangers and just give him some give him some leeway give him some space to develop in his own own time if if he's not 22 until he breaks through that doesn't matter I just want to touch on that point about Harry Kane as well because it has been put back to me well you can't always use Harry Kane as the yardstick he's one of the best players of all time and I agree with that but it's it's not so much to say that Mikey Moore is going to go on and have the same type of career that Harry Kane has had it's merely just illustrative to the point that young players will have ups and downs in their as you say their development development is not linear um and we we just have the we have the perfect example of that in Harry Kane who is quite clearly, I mean, I don't mean this to be hyperbole.

1:02:33I would say quite clearly the best player in world football right now. He's, on current form, untouchable. He just, I don't know, he's astonishing. I could do every single podcast talking about Harry Kane, but let's not. Nick Smith, this would be a good one, Wendy, and I wonder if the answer is going to be Josh Onoma. which of our fumbled youth players would be starting in the current team if we'd managed them better oh god I loved Olimar he was so good at youth level and just didn't translate but the thing is there was there was clearly a I never saw like again I never got the like the angry kind of he's useless type reaction to him because every time I watched him play I would say there were flashes of brilliance in a lot of what he'd do his touch his ability to kind of turn on the ball and progress it forwards.

1:03:23I always felt like he was trying to do something. I always felt like he was quite brave in the few instances that we saw him get to play for Spurs. It just, for whatever reason, it never really happened for him. Yeah, I completely agree. I mean, it's very normal for clubs to have youth players that they fumble. This isn't just a Spurs thing. But we have let some real quality. fall by the wayside is the wrong phrase. Like we've enabled players to not fulfill their potential. I think Marcus Edwards is the really obvious one. He was so good. And I still think Marcus Edwards has got on to have a reasonable career.

1:04:06He was really good in Portugal for a number of seasons. And now he's a Premier League player again. And I'm really pleased. I'm really pleased that that's the case for him. I'm not sure he'd have been the perfect candidate for what Thomas Frank's doing. I suppose he's a bit like Odderbeer in some senses, but a left-footed version. Who else? Who'd be really good in Frank? Madaweke, maybe. Madaweke, I loved. We didn't see much of him at Spurs because he was an under-16 player, but there were videos. There are youth tournaments that, I don't know why, but they'd always be available on YouTube. and so you'd get to see like glimpses of 14 and 15 year old players in these under 16 tournaments and Madiweke look quality for Spurs and when he left I was gutted he would be amazing actually he would he that's a great shout um who else who else I mean I think we're on the cusp of fumbling Donnelly who I think is class and I think Donnelly would have a should have a role in the squad by this point.

1:05:14Instead, he's on the bench at Stoke and not getting any minutes at the moment. I'd have had Donnelly in the squad this season, honestly. I think he'd have done a job. What do you think happened to old Alex Pritchard in terms of his development? Because I think if we're to remember sort of, you know, the heady days of back in the day, Wendy, I think I actually, I think I first met you at the Kings Meadow, a Kingstonian game for a pre-season game. Yeah, that sounds right. And we had John Bostock playing for us at that point as well. But I saw you down the years at a few different sort of, you know, be it 1882 or whatever.

1:05:54Yeah. What sort of year games? And I always remember you were always a massive fan of Alex Pritchard. And he was, I mean, he was by far the best player. It always looked like at that level anyway. And this is the sort of same team. It had like Mason, Kane, Townsend, all these types of players. involved in it right um but he never quite did it at spurs did he no he's had a good career but do you know as pritchard got older i think i my takeaway on him was that he's not quite at premier league level um and won't quite make it to at spurs as a sort of premier league player class player, like really good to watch, really fun to watch tempo setter, could score goals from nothing, set-piece specialist really, really good player who's gone on to have an excellent career played loads of championship games, loads of League 1 games he's now at Sivaspor I was just looking at that, yeah In the Turkish Super Liga.

1:07:04Yeah. He's 32. Yeah. Suddenly, Alex Pritchard is 32. He's coming towards the end of his career, you know. Yeah, I'm wondering. I bet he's playing number 10 there. Let's have a look. Because he's sort of veered between playing wide, playing central, and, yeah, it looks like he's mainly playing number 10 there. I'm pleased for him. I'm pleased for him that, yeah, he's not. he doesn't look like he's actually a regular one who's injured but has mostly played in the middle of midfield for them you see Andros Tanzan's playing in the just not quite of a level you see Andros Tanzan's now playing in the Thai Premier League yeah yeah that was a shocker I mean how old is he now 33, 34 33 yeah I think probably similar age isn't he so what a team that was man those lads seeing them all sort of come through.

1:08:01What a time to be alive. Do you remember the song, the video of them singing in the changing room? I do. What was it? Yes. Oh, God, man. Wow. If you haven't seen that as a Spurs fan, look up Spurs youth team, stand by me. It's like there's a few blasts from the past in that video. Yeah. It's good as well. I forgot about that, man. They do a good version. Yeah. I guess I'll just ask you this one just finally before I let you go, Andy. Tez on Twitter says, how are you lining up a fighting cock extended family 11? What position are you having? I'll be a shit-ass midfielder, mate. Nice, nice. In my sevener side nowadays, I play as a defender.

1:08:56mostly because I need time in the ball in my 40s and I don't get it in midfield with all the youngsters I play with. So I kind of just read the game and mop things up and make blocks and deceptions and then just keep it simple. So I reckon I'd be... If we can play three at the back, then I'm playing one of the outs. Do you know what? I reckon I could play in the middle of a back three and do a reasonable job. I'm not going to get my head on much. but I'm going to intercept and then make play from the back. I don't know if many people know this, but I don't know if you even know this. You know Flav, I don't know about now, he was a pretty handy footballer.

1:09:39I have been told. Flav is decent. Yeah, I have been told he's a good player. Bardi's mentioned that. Bardi's also a very good footballer. Is he? Yeah, really good. The thing with Bardi is he has got immense athleticism, but he has technical quality as well. So when we do the extra inch live shows, he always hosts a seven-a-side, five or seven-a-side beforehand. And there are quite a few ballers amongst our listeners. But yeah, Bardi can always hold his own. He's a very good player. Where's he playing? What sort of position? Midfield. Does he? Okay. So is he a metronome? Up and down. Oh, so he's a SAR?

1:10:19Yeah, he's a SAR. but I'd say like higher technical level. He's an old Benzincor. He's what Benzincor was under contract. So Bardi is better than Saar, is that what you're saying? He's better than a Premier League footballer. Yeah. Flav's a baller. Just letting you all know that. He gets a bit embarrassed when I brought it up when I was on there a few years ago. But yeah. There you go. Windy, mate. It's been an absolute pleasure. thank you for thank you for lighting up this international break a bit for me and I hope for everybody else listening what have you got coming up on the extra inch this week and in the near future do you know I don't know Nathan Nathan keeps his cards quite close to his chest with what he's working on which I enjoy because it means when a video pops up I get a little surprise I get a little happy surprise as well we'll have the standard weekly pod out we've got a massive backlog of listener questions which we'll try and play plough through.

1:11:21But Nathan, Nathan's always cooking something. So yeah, let's see what he's got planned. 10 reasons why you should hate Thomas Frank. The video by Nathan A. Clark. That wouldn't get through the layer of moderation that Barney now will provide. That's love with you. Bye-bye. Take care.

1:11:48Hey, it's Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. Now, I was looking for fun ways to tell you that Mint's offer of unlimited premium wireless for$15 a month is back. So I thought it would be fun if we made$15 bills. But it turns out that's very illegal. So there goes my big idea for the commercial. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for three months,$90 for six months, or$180 for 12-month plan required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. Initial plan term only. Greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy. See terms. The grill is shot. The chairs are held together by optimism.

1:12:21And what happened to the rug? Sounds like your outdoor setup is not ready for patio season. Fix it all with Wayfair. Shop Wayfair for grills, rugs, furniture, and more. With 20 million five-star reviews, room of choice delivery, and experts set up on qualifying orders, it's never been easier to do more for less. Get 10 % off your first eligible purchase. Hurry to Wayfair.com or download the app now.

From the publisher

No Spurs this week, but plenty to talk about. Jack is joined by The Extra Inch’s Windy to take stock of Tottenham’s season so far. Is Thomas Frank genuinely builing a brighter future, or is his system limited? They debate whether the team’s attacking issues come down to personnel or system, and share thoughts on Wilson Odobert's ability and potential dividing fans right now.

Then it’s onto listener questions:– How should we manage expectations around young players like Mikey Moore and Luca Williams-Barnet?– Which fumbled academy prospects could’ve made it if handled better?– Who of Kane, Bale or Modric at their Tottenham peak would transform this side most?

These and many more. Theme is Ghost Cat by Gillen
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from Rule The Roost - A Tottenham Hotspur Podcast

All 213 episodes
Spurs’ Attacking Issues - Players or System?Rule The Roost - A Tottenham Hotspur Podcast · 1 h 11 min
Listen in VO