In short
Tottenham survive relegation (finish 17th) and the episode debates what changed under Roberto De Zerbi, plus Peter Charrington’s letter and Spurs’ recruitment/ownership strategy for next season.
Guests
Jack Pitt-Brooke, a Tottenham supporter with close proximity to the club’s environment (describes press conferences and internal perceptions). No other guests are named in the transcript.
Key claims
Relegation would have been financially and operationally disastrous (broadcasting, commercial, ticketing, jobs), and a “Championship reset” is rejected as unrealistic. Spurs didn’t fully grasp the danger until late (fans saw it earlier, e.g., after Chelsea; club was slow to act in Nov–Jan). De Zerbi’s main impact was psychological: fixing mental collapse seen in matches like Palace and Atletico. His emotional intelligence and motivation work earned player buy-in.
Notable examples
De Zerbi’s first training session around 3 April; Spurs’ Sunderland move (Romero to Solanke to Bentancur to Colwill/Mawani); 11 points from last five games; Porro and Van de Ven’s turnaround; Charrington’s “club not for sale” and “build back” promises; debate over Daniel Levy’s tenure and recruitment approach.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOReflecting on Spurs' Bizarre Season
0:45 to 2:36
Discussion of the emotional highs and lows of Tottenham's season, ending in 17th place.
“It wouldn't be celebratory, but I can't help but feel a bit that way inclined.”
The Risks of Relegation
2:36 to 5:30
Exploring the potential consequences of relegation for Tottenham and the financial implications.
Club Management and Fan Perspectives
5:30 to 8:32
Analyzing how club management responded to the situation and the disconnect with fan sentiments.
“Because it seemed clear to everybody that Spurs was sinking massively at Christmas time.”
The Turnaround Under De Zerbi
8:32 to 11:08
Examining the positive impact of manager Roberto De Zerbi on Spurs' performance and morale.
“I guess to your point though, as you say, they did go out and get to Zerbi.”
Emotional Intelligence of De Zerbi
11:08 to 13:54
Discussion on De Zerbi's emotional intelligence and how it has influenced his management style.
“And it was just nice watching, like, kind of properly coordinated, progressive attacking football where, you know, the ball is passed from one Tottenham shirt to another Tottenham shirt to another Tottenham shirt.”
Analyzing De Zerbi's Emotional Intelligence
14:01 to 17:00
Gain insights into the emotional intelligence and management style of Roberto De Zerbi.
Romero's Return and Its Implications
17:01 to 19:06
Explore the implications of Cristian Romero's return and his management relationship with the club.
Player Transformations Under De Zerbi
19:07 to 22:36
Discover how players like Van de Ven and Poro have transformed under De Zerbi's guidance.
Spurs' Future with De Zerbi
22:37 to 23:56
Discuss the potential future of Tottenham under Roberto De Zerbi's management.
“And I think a lot of players will fall into that category.”
Charrington's Letter to Fans
23:57 to 26:30
Examine the key points from Peter Charrington's letter to the fans regarding club ambitions.
Show all 18 chapters
Ownership Challenges and Strategic Questions
26:31 to 28:00
Analyze the challenges faced by Tottenham's ownership and future strategic questions.
Tottenham's Recruitment Strategy and Managerial Direction
28:00 to 29:00
Discussion on Tottenham's recruitment strategy and the role of manager Deserby.
Reflections on Daniel Levy's Tenure
29:00 to 31:00
Analyzing the impact of Daniel Levy's management on Tottenham's recent performance.
“They want the club to be a success because it always felt that Levy's chairman's notes were just, it was a bit like Thomas Frank saying, you know, one thing is for sure, we are going to lose games.”
Comparing Tottenham and Arsenal's Strategies
31:00 to 34:10
Contrasting the strategic approaches of Tottenham and Arsenal in recent years.
“I don't think you can sit there in a stadium like Spurs have and charge the amount of money like Spurs do and try and plead poverty, really, which I think was sort of Levy's shtick a lot of the time.”
Evaluating the Need for a Clear Football Strategy
34:10 to 36:30
Discussing the necessity of establishing a clear strategy for Tottenham's football direction.
The Importance of Leadership and Team Morale
36:30 to 42:00
Exploring the significance of leadership and morale among Tottenham players under a new manager.
Evaluating De Zerbi's Strategy for Spurs
42:00 to 45:48
Discussing the implications of De Zerbi's management on player selection and youth development.
World Cup Plans and Spurs' Future Outlook
45:48 to 47:24
Jack discusses his upcoming World Cup coverage and the prospects for Spurs.
“But to start a new season with him, I don't know.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Jack:This podcast is part of the Sports Social Podcast Network.
0:30Jack:and a splendid Kinski save later on.
0:33Jack Pitt-Brooke:A rare clean sheet and rare seeds of celebration for finishing 17th.
0:39Jack:Hello, everybody. Welcome back to Rule the Roos podcast. I did say if Spurs were going to stay up, I wouldn't be jubilant. It wouldn't be celebratory, but I can't help but feel a bit that way inclined. Jack Pitbrook, how are you, mate? How has this season been for you with your now adopted team, I'm sure, of Tottenham Hotspur?
1:00Jack Pitt-Brooke:Yeah, it's been a bizarre season. I think the most bizarre thing about it is that at the end of last season, I told myself, well, that was totally bonkers, but it can never happen again. There would never be a weird season like that where Spurs come 17th and then everybody's buzzing at the end of the season. And there we were yesterday afternoon. huge celebrations at the tottenham hotspur stadium you know fat um people close to tears amazing sense of unity and togetherness in the stadium and outside the stadium i thought the the coach welcome which i was actually part of accidentally was unbelievably good so incredible vibes like one of the best days of vibes since that stadium has been opened in 2019 yeah at the same time they also came 17th and i sat there and i started to think hold on a second this is the same as last year it's not exactly the same obviously because last season there was bill bow and a trophy and ang and stuff so like there's been different events along the way but the outcome is kind of the same right 17th place 17 league defeats everyone's delighted everyone loves the manager everyone feels together and happy and hugging and and i just thought like what why do we go through all that bollocks this season you know i don't like you know thomas frank daniel Levy um Igor Tudor like all the amount of nonsense that's happened at Spurs this season and we've ended up in the same place and I kind of thought about that for a minute and then I thought if I think about this for too long I am going to go insane uh so uh so yeah I am uh uh it's been it's been a kind of an emotional journey this season and uh I'm quite pleased that Tottenham aren't playing a competitive game until like the 15th of August or whatever it is considering how
2:40Jack:much I go on about Spurs week after week after week day after day really trying to sort of extrapolate my thoughts on this podcast I was genuinely surprised by the the almost physical weight I felt lifting off me as soon as the final whistle went that even as much as I tried to confront what was happening to Spurs head-on there was clearly so much of it that was just internalized or I don't know maybe it's just a general residual layer of stress but I mean I think like it's just what was so massive for me is that I completely understood the arguments that Spurs were still set up to be able to ride the storm of maybe getting relegated or whatever but I didn't really want to go into those uncharted waters like this there was such uncertainty and such high risk attached to a club of this magnitude because it's it's double-edged right isn't it jack wouldn't you say for a club of this size to go down as much as people will say well you generate all this money from non-match day events the overheads are so much bigger for a club like spurs that i really honestly think we could have been in real trouble had we gone
3:49Jack Pitt-Brooke:it would have been a disaster it would have been a complete disaster i don't buy that i just i never really brought this argument that it would have been anything else like i don't think the fact is like it would yeah like i suppose do make money through other means but they also have huge operating costs like my colleague chris weatherspoon has written about this at length in the athletic yeah you know it would have put a huge dent in obviously like premier league broadcasting revenues would have gone commercial would have taken a hit ticketing would have taken a hit it would have been terrible and i know and some people make this argument which is oh well what tottenham need is a big reset and a big clear out and the best way to do that is to go into the championship but then you can have a full reset and a full clear i'm sorry that's nonsense it's complete nonsense it's like that's not how football works it's not how life works like if you're it's not true to say that if you go into the championship you can start making like wise long-term strategic decisions uh and then you can like really get back to like first principles of what you're trying to do that's not true at all if you're in the championship you're thinking right we've got a 200 million pound hole in our finances how are we going to fill it we need to get back to the premier league what's the best way to do that as soon as possible if anything your thinking becomes more short term not more long term so the idea that spurs needed it as a reset it's just bollocks i'm sorry it's just bollocks it would have been a terrible thing if they've been relegated um it would have cost the club huge amounts of money and i'm you know we're not talking about i'm not talking about like the lewis family's back pocket here i'm talking about you know the job threat to actual people who live and who work for tottenham hotspur they would have been the ones impacted it's not about like the lewis family having to put money having to put money in it's about it's about jobs on the line um so yeah it would have been terrible and frankly i'm very pleased it's not happening
5:29Jack:do you get a sense jack given your sort of proximity to everything at spurs that that was fully appreciated because you know a lot of us down the months fans at least have ranted about the way in which the club has been run um we all have our sort of opinions we can get on to peter Sherrington's letter in a minute but we all have our sort of ideas as to what the Lewis family have done what Vinay or Johan Langer have done or haven't done if you like and it sort of felt like you know I think a lot of this comes down to Johan Langer saying we don't want to panic by in January and just seeing how basically everything was a total catastrophe from that point so do you think it's fair for fans outside at least from what you've picked up from people at the club that people at the club didn't fully grasp the danger that they were in?
6:18Jack:Because it seemed clear to everybody that Spurs was sinking massively at Christmas time.
6:23Jack Pitt-Brooke:Yeah, I mean, I guess it depends how you date it. I mean, I suppose some people might say, well, you know, I guess my view, which is probably in line with a lot of people, is that, well, a lot of Spurs fans knew, I think, as early as when they lost at home to Chelsea at home, a lot of fans thought this is really bad like this is really like miles worse than the table suggests they're not playing any football at all the players and fans are totally disengaged with this and it's going to go this is going to go really badly wrong it's already started to go badly wrong and i think clearly the club didn't see that with the exception of piratichi who did see that at the time um and it was piratichi who was really like the voice say internally say well well we should this guy's not this guy's not the right fit we should do something else i mean that's not to say pirachi is like massively off the hook because pirachi said oh yeah well have you guys considered eagle tudor uh i mean that turned out when they did get him in in uh in february um but no i mean i think i i think it's probably fair enough to say that if you look at the way they they stuck with thomas frank particularly after the west ham game where i think it i am sure i can't prove it but i'm sure that daniel levy would have made a change after that west ham game um that maybe they're a bit slow slow to make the change um and you know Igor Tudor obviously didn't work out but I can kind of see the logic at the time in a world where you can't get to Zerbi at that point and there's no other options equally there's like there's an alternative view on this which is well actually the club kind of did do things differently they did push the vote out like Conor Gallagher is Tottenham's best played player like they broke the wage structure to sign Conor Gallagher now you may or may not think that you know some people might have different views on how good Gallagher is but you can look at that as a sign that they did realize the severity of the situation equally to Zerby like Zerby's obviously on a very very healthy salary and again I suppose you could you could look at that and say well look they are they did realize they did realize how bad this was but I certainly think around that like November December January time I think it is in my mind like fair to say that they didn't quite grasp grasp the severity of the situation.
8:33Jack:I guess to your point though, as you say, they did go out and get to Zerbi. The big gamble that they have made has worked out because Tottenham's turnaround. I mean, I don't know how you felt, Jack, but I was pretty convinced after the Palace game back in March that it's going to happen. Spurs are gone. I just, I don't see where the fight is anymore. And I mean, Forrest in particular, after losing 3-0 at home to Forrest, I just thought, we're gone. like that's that's 100 % it and I know there's all the conversation about relegation fights and us not having been in that position and not understanding I think we probably have a better appreciation for it now how much things can change game by game but it just felt overall that there was no fight left in the squad it felt like there was it almost felt at times like there was no ability in the squad yet Roberto Dezerbi has if you look at some of the stats at least has turned Tottenham from one of the worst performing sides in the country into one of the not the best but still in the in the top half of clubs in the country by lots of metrics I think
9:39Jack Pitt-Brooke:yeah I think he's I think there is no praise is too high for the job that Deserby's done I think that I think the most important thing that he's done is fixing the mental block that the players had or that the players developed under both Frank and Tudor because over the over the course of Tudor's time, my overall impression was these guys' heads have completely gone. Like, look at, like, the way they collapsed in the first half of the Palace game, for example, or conceding four goals in, what, 24 minutes against Atletico Madrid, or even the Forest game, where they were, like, on top and dominant, and the crowd were behind them, and they collapsed and lose 3-0 at home.
10:16Jack Pitt-Brooke:Like, I thought their heads had totally gone, and De Zerbi seemed to realise that exactly right, like, he realised that fundamentally this was a psychological issue, and therefore we'd have to have a psychological solution and he got into the players heads and by doing that he had like that was the first thing he had to do that was the necessary first step before he could get into football with them uh it's not like they played like full deservedly ball is it they just played i think a fairly simple but very well organized and disciplined game under him lots of players who we know are good players went got back to playing at their top level again so i'm thinking Poro, Van der Fenn, Benton Kerr, Adoghi in particular.
10:52Jack Pitt-Brooke:Did Spurs play great football in the last few weeks? Not really. But I think they probably played as good a football as they could ever have dreamed of given the circumstances, given the injuries, given the limitations in the squad and given that De Zerbi, I think he took his first training session on like the 3rd of April or something. It's mad.
11:08Jack:And there were glimpses at times, weren't there, in some games when you saw some passing moves suddenly where you think, like this is quite mental but I haven't seen Tottenham knock a ball around like that since the early days of Ange like almost almost two years ago now
11:22Jack Pitt-Brooke:yeah there was one so I went to the Sunderland game his first game and after about 10 minutes I think about 10 minutes there was a move where like Romero because this is the game he got injured Romero it's like Kinski rolled out to Romero and Romero like zipped a forward pass to Solanke and Solanke showed for it like um uh trapped the ball laid it off to I think Benton who popped off to Colin Mawani like Solanke spins and runs in behind and then Colin Mawani knocks it down knocks it forward and Solanke runs on to the end of it and like they they didn't score anything but I watched and thought that's the best move I've seen Spurs put together all season and they're like 10 minutes into the Deserby era and then again like in the certainly in the there were moments in the I mean the Wolves game is pretty bad but the Brighton and the Villa games where he wouldn't be like it's not it was nothing kind of too radical but it was just they would move through they would move from kinsky into the opposition box without you know always with spurs players on the ball some of the play would be really good they were suddenly able to kind of get in and out of tight spaces or just the ability like having bentaker back in the team made such a difference because he would take the ball in a tight he would take the ball in a tight space and then he would just kind of pop it straight off to someone who was, you know, a few yards either side of him who could then drive forward.
12:43Jack Pitt-Brooke:And it was just nice watching, like, kind of properly coordinated, progressive attacking football where, you know, the ball is passed from one Tottenham shirt to another Tottenham shirt to another Tottenham shirt. Because, I mean, how much have we seen that this season? Even, like, Thomas Frank, even the good bits were just kind of corners or, like, Porro chipping the ball down the line to Kudas over and over and over and over again. So, and that is like, so like, think of the uplift that De Zerbi's had in Tottenham's football in a world where, yeah, there's no Kulusevski, Madison can only play 20 minutes.
13:16Jack Pitt-Brooke:There's no, you know, Solanke's been injured, Kudas has been injured, Odderbeer's been injured. There's like problems, there's so many problems in that squad. And yet he still managed to get them playing, I think, a pretty good level of football. And suddenly you watch that and you think, oh, actually, this guy, this guy really knows what he's talking about.
13:34Jack:I've been quite surprised by, and look, you know, I don't know the bloke and I've probably based my opinion on him before he signed off of a perception that he was hot-headed at Brighton and ended up falling out with them and left. see also Marseille and there may be sort of other factors I've gone into that I think the the stuff with Stellini on the on the touchline when he was Brighton manager probably you know gave me some sort of perception as to who he might be but I've actually been really struck by the emotional intelligence of the bloke is that something that you know given that you're in press conferences in with him a lot um is that something that you've you've noted I feel like he's been such a cool head pretty much throughout this entire thing yeah i think that's i completely
14:23Jack Pitt-Brooke:agree with you i think that's the most that's probably the thing that surprised me the most actually is that his reputation is kind of this is it's a bit unfair but bear with me i think his reputation is a bit like conte but with more passing like conte but with like more more more progressive football um and somebody did say to me actually the other day that there may in fact be a degree of xenophobia in the way that people talk about to deserve in the sense that like because he's italian people think ah you know another hot-headed italian um and i don't doubt that he is passionate but i also i do think there is clearly an emotional intelligence there and i think that's massively brought out by if you look at his approach all the way up until this week basically all the way up until after the chelsea game um his approach was basically build up the players like kind of support the players cheer on the players tell the world how good the players are remind the players of how good they used to be you know these stories about like making a compilation of like colin miwani's best moments and sitting down with it and trying to remind him that he's actually a really good footballer all that kind of stuff like i i didn't you know i wasn't like a huge expert on to zerby and obviously watches brighton teams a bit but i didn't know i'd be lying if i said i knew a lot about his methods and this stuff has really taken me by surprised i genuinely didn't know that he was he was so good at this stuff but i think it's been a complete masterclass right like it's like this has been a job about sort of psychology and motivation more than anything else and i think that on that psychology and motivation he has been absolutely brilliant like just listen to the way the spurs players talked yesterday after the game about deserve it like it's clear that they absolutely they absolutely adore him and i think it's been it's been so impressive in in that sense and i just hope that he gets i hope he gets the credit from like people outside of spurs world for the job that he's done i know that some of the chat this week has been like oh of course we're gonna stay up the top now i think that's bollocks like anybody who watched spurs in march particularly we were dead mate we were dead so gone their heads were so gone like they just watch anyone who watched like there's two things that i keep coming back to it's like the palette conceding three goals in 10 minutes at home against palace and conceding four goals in 20 minutes away at Atletico.
16:34Jack Pitt-Brooke:Like that was a team who were gone. Like they were completely mentally finished. And so for him to fix that and then get that team with a front line of like Tel, Richarlis and Conor Mewany to get that team to get 11 points in his last five games or whatever it was and say in the Premier League, that is an unbelievable piece of management.
16:51Jack:Were you there for what it was with him? I think it was Tom Olnutt. He was having that funny thing with him yesterday. What was that about?
16:59Jack Pitt-Brooke:oh so he was like having been in the room when it happened it was definitely i think it was jokier than it may look on clips but he at the start of the press conference when he came in he started joking around saying oh where's the guy i think i've come i can't remember exactly what he said it was something like oh where's the guy who always asks the negative questions where is he and it turned out that he meant tom all night and then we were like looking at each
17:21Jack:other like i hope he didn't mean me you know like when they stand up at the front like
17:24Jack Pitt-Brooke:points at somebody in the crowd uh and then someone said uh i think another journalist said are you here to oh um tom's just watched tottenham for a long time and then does everybody said no no i don't want to fight i'm not here to i'm not here to fight i just want to say i just want to shake hands and then he came in and they like shook hands and had a laugh i think it was it was genuinely just it might have looked a bit odd on the clip but it was kind i think it was as would say it was just banter it was it was just him wanting to have a laugh because he knows that you know a lot uh i think i'm right in saying that after he said after the brighton game where he said oh we can win five games in a row which i mean we can come back to this but i think that is like the turning point in the whole season i think like i think in a subsequent press conference tom will not ask him a question and deserve he read that as like a challenge to whether or not right they could they could win the five games so i think he i think he just wanted to like have a have a laugh with tom about like oh you know maybe i was right about this one but it's not like having been in the room it wasn't a confrontation it was more of a kind of it was more of a laugh basically that's a bit of a climb down because i
18:31Jack:ranted and raved about romero in my in my midweek pod it feels as though it you know i think maybe the the player should have should have known a bit better but it also feels like the club maybe inadvertently green lit him going and didn't really think about the optics of that is that is that the sort of the impression you've had from it because look whatever it is I'm glad he came back yesterday and I think it was the right thing for him to do um and I think he deserves yeah that that's swallowing your pride that's coming back and doing it because everybody's moaning at you he could have very easily just said forget about it I'm gonna leave this summer but he came back and he was there with his team um and Belgrano won the league as well unfortunately for him but well happily for him I'm sure but do you have much of a read on sort of
19:17Jack Pitt-Brooke:what happened there it seems like such a mess yeah i don't i mean it's slightly complicated by the the fact like the medical treatment that he needs to get ready for the world cup and i think i'm right in saying he's been working with the argentina um doctors who who he worked with last season i think when he was coming back from that remember that quad injury that he got in the chelsea game in the middle of last season um which he then came back from in like february i think february march um and he worked with the argentina doctors then so yeah it's a bit it's a bit complicated i don't want to i mean look the fact is i don't know the ins and outs of the conversations that romero and his team have had with tottenham about what exactly he was allowed to do or not uh i'm pleased he came back i think it would have been you know i'm pleased that he experienced that occasion it's a bit of a i mean he obviously got booed by some fans when he got shown up on the big screen at the end which i think was probably to be expected um uh but yeah it's it's a slightly thorny one but without knowing without knowing the ins and outs of those conversations i don't really want i don't know if i can kind of uh judge on it too much
20:24Jack:it seems though just i guess from the from the bits we've heard both him and mickey van der ven who have both seemingly had one foot out the door whether or not it's just them trying to cash in on a bit of a goodwill out of the back of yesterday it feels as though at least anyway from mickey especially the tone has shifted considerably since roberto de serbi has come in is that a feeling you've gotten from the players in general madison as well was talking about this yesterday in the in the mix zone wasn't he just about pretty much how amazing de serbi's been for the transformation of the spirit and everything around the club yeah i think the two most
21:01Jack Pitt-Brooke:interesting players on this are deservey sorry the two of vander fenn and poro because these were guys who i thought played pretty badly for the first sort of two-thirds of the season um who often looked a bit grumpy who had rows with fans like vander fenn had that row with fans of bournemouth poro it's often kind of you know was like there was clearly like a bit of antagonism between him and him and some and some fans here that is instant with bergval at the end of the fulham home game i think um in the middle of the pitch like at the end of the game yesterday or when van defends relationship with the crowd seems to be completely repaired both those two have been so good the last few weeks i think it's been a bit of a reminder that just because they were playing badly doesn't mean they're bad players there's always a lot of spurs fans who say poros shit he's not shit he's actually really no he's not he's really good like i thought he was my player of the season for last season he works really hard he's always fit he's never injured he runs all day his delivery is pretty good he's not like the best defensive right back I've ever seen but I think he's good enough to be in the Spain squad uh he might have a world cup winner's medal in two months time and I I think he in the last few weeks he's reminded people how good he is like his competitiveness he wins like he goes for every 50 50 he never stops running and I think that I think the way those two players have turned it around in the last few weeks does show you just how much buy-in there is to the new manager because the fact is like a lot of these players i don't just mean romero and so i don't just mean porin van de ven here a lot of players they join tottenham kind of in the hope that they will get to play like big club football like if you join tottenham it's not really because you you're convinced you're not going to get paid the most money and you're not actually going to win that many trophies really like if you want to uh but you join tottenham i think because it's a big club which has a certain way of playing and you want to play for a good manager and play like on the front foot attacking football.
22:54Jack Pitt-Brooke:And I think a lot of players will fall into that category. And I think that having Deserby in there, my view on this is that a lot of those players are like, yes, this is the kind of football that I want to play. This is the sort of football that I hope to play when I join Tottenham. And so I think that that is really central to a lot of players, not just those two, but like, you know, older and younger players as well. Really kind of... kind of clicking with what Spurs, with what De Zerbi's wanted them to do in the last few weeks?
23:27Jack:I'm not sure which way to go first on this, Jack, because I want to kind of, I want to look ahead to sort of the future that Spurs could have with Roberto De Zerbi because I don't think it's too bullish to say that it is exciting, despite the fact we've just had two 17th place finishes. there is it's exciting right um but i guess no let's let's go with let's go with the ownership first because look if if there's going to be a bottleneck on tottenham's ambition it's always going to be the owners and the ownership model as it is with any football club this isn't a uniquely tottenham problem um peter cherrington the non-executive chairman has today written his his letter to the fans i know people were very upset with the fact that nobody had written anything in the in the program yesterday to fans um i can kind of understand it if i'm going to be honest because i think the tone of said letter shifts so drastically um dependent on the result yesterday and dependent on what happens but obviously peter charrington has outlaid the fact that number one the club is not for sale um that they are invested in the essentially the the model that they've put in um and is in progress right now um that there's going to be more hires and stuff or people to arrive in the summer or everything like that the fact they are going to continue to invest in the first team in the academy in the women's team that they have a commitment to essentially reclaiming some of Tottenham's soul they've they've obviously been doing their research I don't know whether they've been listening to pods or reading tweets or reading blogs or whatever but they they certainly seem to have a good temperature check on what the fan base has been saying that the club has lost sight of the footballing operation and lost sight of its soul now they've made a lot of big promises and these sort of promises have been made previously but maybe I'm just a sucker it to me it feels like this might be and maybe it's wishful
25:34Jack Pitt-Brooke:thinking this might be a bit different this time yeah i i think it's all i think he's kind of said the right things in this letter for me the most interesting part of this letter is i think it's the most that we've heard like justifying the decision to sack daniel leaving so there has not been you know like over the course of this season vilay van katesham has generally spoken on behalf of the ownership but he has he has not in his public communications he has not really spoken a lot about the decision to sack Daniel Levy there was that one the fab meeting in March he did lay out some findings on the issues with the running of the club in recent years which is clearly read I think as like this is the things that Daniel Levy got wrong but that was you know that was to the fans advisory board that wasn't really in public but in this case when Peter Charrington who's obviously like a long-term advisor to the Lewis family was placed onto the board in march of last year by the lewis family before he became non-exec chair in september after levy sacking when he talks about um uh we recognize that something seismic had to change spurs the lewis family stepped in and authorized a full reset like that's the that's really the most detail we've heard from anyone on like the question of why why did the lewis family sack daniel levy last september so i thought that was really interesting for me um i think the stuff on what they the stuff on what the ownership like where they where they want to go next where they want to take spurs for me this is the biggest question right because they've you know they have now got through this season i didn't think they would uh there was definitely points where i thought they were like spurs were going to go down and that would obviously be a huge issue for the ownership that hasn't happened but i think that now that they've stayed up the big question is well what next like what is your right lewis family what's your strategy from here what are you what you're trying to do with spurs where you're trying to take them and there's a bit here where in the letter where charrington says um we will build we will build a squad led by roberto's head coach with the right blend of experience youth and leadership to compete at the highest levels of premier league and european football now i guess the big question is like underpinning that line in that letter like what is what is going to be their approach to well recruitment are they going to go younger players are they going to go older players are they going to go are they going to look in the premier league are they going to look around the world are they going to buy from france are they going to buy young players are they going to buy players with resale value you know they're going to go for loans and frees those are the big strategic questions i don't really know i think i've got we've got learning a little bit about what they're going to do on this you know the fact that they bought gallagher um on a big salary in january suggests that like they are going to aim a bit higher in terms of salaries for experienced players but for me those are the big questions that I've got right is I kind of I see what they want I see like in outline what the ownership say they want in terms of the football strategy but underneath that there will be lots of specific questions about what they're going to try and do um and I guess that will really be the story of the summer as well particularly when it comes down to recruitment and particularly it comes down to you know to what extent does does Deserby get what he wants does he is he going to become a kind of like eddie howe una emery type figure at spurs that is like a good old-fashioned all-powerful manager who gets what he wants um so though um obviously like they you know they love to serbi there's a very positive letter about the deservey uh you know charrington writes deserve he signed as men's head coach for five years a reflection of our belief in his ability and our commitment to build back to where we need to be he is passionate committed and positive in everything he does and represents the kind of football and ambition the Tottenham Hotspur should stand for like clearly they love this guy right because he saved their Premier League status he saved them a sort of 200 300 million pounds hole in the finances but I guess there's I guess every fan will read that and think well how exactly like what exactly is the plan in fine detail for this summer how exactly is it going to work out and the one the one other thing that a few people have said to me today about the letter I think like like I said I think it's good it's good that they have sort of owned the decision to sack Daniel Levy in a bit more detail but what there isn't necessarily is accountability for the stuff you mentioned earlier right like why did they not move why were they not aggressive enough in january window why did they leave thomas frank in charge until february why did they get igor tudor in for six games when the ship was clearly taking on water those sort of things so there's definitely a few there's a few points in there where fans might say well what about the other you know what about the other mistakes that you made it's not as simple as it's not as simple as saying oh well you know we inherited a bad mess from Daniel Levy like obviously things have things have gone wrong since Daniel Levy sacking um but yeah that's that's broadly what I think about the about the
30:16Jack:latter I think the main thing I guess just to sort of qualify my perhaps pathetic misguided optimism about it all is that I think it's the first time I've heard an official communication from the club that directly says they want to challenge at the top of the league again they want to challenge for the top European honours. They want the club to be a success because it always felt that Levy's chairman's notes were just, it was a bit like Thomas Frank saying, you know, one thing is for sure, we are going to lose games. Levy always kind of carried with him this edge of, we're going to try, but it's always going to be difficult for Spurs to be successful because it's so competitive out there, which I think after a certain point just didn't really wash anymore.
31:02Jack:I don't think you can sit there in a stadium like Spurs have and charge the amount of money like Spurs do and try and plead poverty, really, which I think was sort of Levy's shtick a lot of the time. Yeah, it's weird. It just got tiresome.
31:19Jack Pitt-Brooke:I kind of, when Levy was in charge, I never really, I didn't massively buy the argument that they should be more focused on football and less focused on Lady Gaga playing at the stadium and NFL, all that stuff. But I think over time, I'm kind of coming around to that viewpoint. I'm kind of coming around to the viewpoint that there was insufficient focus on trying to win. Because I think at the time, I was maybe a bit too sympathetic to the kind of Levy argument, which was actually like, we're working really hard on a budget to be competitive. Teams have got a lot more money than us. And we're having to do things our own way.
31:53Jack Pitt-Brooke:We're having to build our own stadium. We're having to make money through the stadium. And so my view was like, well, they're trying to do things differently. they don't have an Abramovich or Sheik Mansoor or anything like that but I think over time I'm starting to think well actually maybe there was a validity in that criticism the idea that under the Daniel Levy era they weren't that interested in they weren't or they weren't sufficiently interested in like how can we be the best team that we can be so I'm kind of coming around to
32:20Jack:it a bit I do feel that like I just think one of the main things I think of Levy's tenure and whether it's him whether it was Cullen whether it's the whole group he had around him it feels like there was no sense of needing to nurture something it's almost like I think they sort of bucketed things off as in like we have a huge fan base that's really engaged that always fills up the stadium check that's done we don't need to care for that anymore it's like they couldn't really multitask they couldn't really spin plates um and and I sort of say this because I look at the careers of the Tottenham careers of Harry Kane and Son Hyun Min or even just that Pochettino team the 16-17 Pochettino team that I always hark back to.
33:04Jack:Agency's points brother. Well mate it never felt like there was a sense of this is a really incredibly unique thing we have here not unique but it for Tottenham it is like we actually have a Tottenham side at least the nucleus of a Tottenham side that actually could win the lot here if we if we and that's really rare and that's really really hard to get and i just kind of felt like he never really grasped that and i feel like you know you you you look at you look at arsenal right and you look at kind of everything that they've sort of done over the past few years the the way in which they've tried to continue to engage with their fan base and it's you know it's paid dividends and i think my other hot take is as well if i'm being brutally honest i also feel that like levy and everyone didn't really appreciate actually how much sporting success is a huge commercial gateway as well i think they kind of felt really that winning stuff is just a nice to have for fans and what actually matters about a club is having all this stable infrastructure whereas like again i've got to say arsenal have completely proved that to be just incorrect um yeah it's kind of depressing to
34:16Jack Pitt-Brooke:think it's not that's the right word it's basically like i think the first few years of potch at spurs and the first years of arteta arsenal like there's a lot of similarities of continuities there in terms of the type of manager the type of squad what they had to do
34:30Jack:and stuff and and the progression of said exactly and the trajectory you know uh is really really
Read the full transcript
34:36Jack Pitt-Brooke:clear and it's like it's no coincidence like potch and arteta are really close like pochettino i believe tried to get arteta into his coaching staff when arteta retired from playing and obviously Arteta ended up getting a city instead but like there's no like Pochettino and Arteta we'll have talked about this a million times and they're like they're obviously quite quite slightly different coaches but they're quite similar people I think and you know there's no point even saying this but obviously Arsenal continue to back Arteta with like more money and more quality you know 105 million quid on Declan Rice Pochettino got nothing and then you know Pochettino burns out after five and a half years with no trophies and Arteta's now won the Premier league and is in the championship final um so i think that like you know the lessons to draw between those two cases are incredibly obvious right um i also think on levy though as well at i also don't feel like he kind of understood i'm i was never sure that he really understood like what a good football strategy looked like like pochettino was great for him because he kind of worked with budget he was a team player like he didn't criticize the club in public really until the end he loved developing young players he like through a combination of luck of like a bit of luck and some good judgment had some brilliant young players to work with like ericsson kane delhi uh son who were either bought you know either bought on the cheap or from the academy or whatever and so he was he was like the perfect manager for levy but i'm not sure i don't really not sure if the club kind of understood how lucky they were to have pochettino i don't think they did I think that's proven by the fact that a didn't back him and be replaced with Jose Mourinho um and so I feel like and certainly from that point on it's obvious that like Levy didn't have a football strategy and you know that that more than anything contributed to the drift of the like you know what what you might call the sort of Daniel Levy post Madrid era the Daniel Levy stadium era where Spurs never really had a plan and I think ultimately it's that it's that it's probably that sort of five or six years adrift that contributed to his sacking last september
36:39Jack:jack um it's a very hot day i don't want to take too much time let's do some more questions okay all right then well i guess let's let's look to next season looks by all accounts spurs have acted quickly we've got andy robertson and marcos senesi coming in in the next few days or you know next few weeks or so um but what do you think spurs need to do like what what's the first thing that Spurs need to do next season what should they be aiming for and how do they achieve that
37:07Jack Pitt-Brooke:with Roberto Di Zerbi at the helm um well first thing they need to do I think is come up with a strategy come up with the football strategy is that stuff I was talking to you earlier about recruitment like I need they need to know what they what they're trying to do in the marketplace because like just you know they so all we know really is that they they think they they think the squad needs more experience they're probably right I think it probably does need more experience but you know there's quite a lot of there's been quite a lot of experience on the pitch the last few games you know it's very noticeable that like deserve he's stopped using graham bergval as starters he's brought back benton cohen polini in the middle i think there's been quite a lot of experience there but i just think it's those big strategic questions they need to answer them and then they need to they need to go from there i think like they've kind of they're not really i mean in ideal world you do the strategy first and then you get the manager to fit and then you would like execute with the manager but obviously they got that they kind of got the manager in while they were just like in like trying to stay up mode and now i guess they kind of need to figure out the strategy from here uh so yeah i guess like a strategy for the marketplace is probably the most important thing and then and this is so obvious but we have to keep saying it they need to go and buy better players and better expensive players and they need to in my mind not buy not please no more like premier league proven players for 50 60 million quid because that strategy has been bad it's been really bad like they spent hundreds of millions of pounds the last few years on players who have not really made top of them much better you know richard and johnson slanky could us you know all that sort of 50 60 million quid each and it's not worked so less of that i think would be my preference then i think they bought they need to get back to try to sign in dombele's you know i bang on about in dombele on twitter a lot and like you know don't get me wrong i'm not saying dombele was a good signing but he was the right idea of signing right you signed a 22 year old from leon who's one of the most in-demand young players in europe with a huge upside and like maybe he'll be the best player in the world maybe you'll sell him to real madrid for 100 million like and it didn't work out but it was worth trying the problem is because it didn't work out tottenham then went down the sort of like brennan johnson richarlison strategy and that that hasn't worked so i would get i would i would go for fewer fewer brennan johnson type
39:16Jack:signings and more and donble type signings do you i mean look there is obviously there's obviously going to be a lot of discourse especially around the signing of andy robertson pretty much within you know the context of what you've just said there about a transfer strategy i know not everybody likes it but i can kind of see it right it seems again maybe this is just a trite observation but it seems like the club has lacked quite a few leaders in the in the past
39:45Jack Pitt-Brooke:couple of seasons it has like leaders but i think a lot of those that does not that's not how it looked yesterday like yesterday there was a lot of they all stood up yesterday didn't they yeah like van der fan i just think like so much of our perception of like is a player good is he a good bloke is he a good leader all that stuff so it's like these things are not really permanent a lot of them are kind of viewed through the prism of whether or not they're they're playing well in form happy confident and a lot of that is dependent on the manager it's like and i think that the fact is like there's a lot of spurs players who looked useless for a lot of this season and who now look good again and that's because they've got a good manager who's able to get through to them and motivate them and so things like i think questions about character sort of the questions about character are much less permanent than they feel it was the same when poch came in around remember when it's like during the sherwood half season the whole vibe around spurs was oh this is like the worst dressing room in the world this is totally toxic they'll never like these guys will never make a decent team and then they get a manager who can and like and to be fair pochettino did get rid of a lot of players in the after the first few months right he did get rid of kabul kapu adabayor lennon assuricotto i'm sure there's some others
40:56Jack:i've forgotten so he did like there was a clear out though there was yeah there was a clear out
41:01Jack Pitt-Brooke:don't get me wrong but equally yeah there was a lot of guys who didn't get cleared out who people thought were useless under sherwood who then really good under pochettino like to case in point is for tongan and people used like for tongan used to get hammered under the show under sherwood right yeah people used to say he was rubbish and useless and feckless and stuff and then it turned out it's like oh then he was like brilliant for spurs the next six years so i would like anyone saying that like current spurs players like clearly like a terminally bad lad and bad bloke will never never make it at hot and i'm like i just don't think it's that simple i do think that if you get a manager in place who the players really believe in and really love like suddenly
41:36Jack:the players look better i mean lorice's autobiography he he spoke about that and that you know he was signed from liona's france's next great hope as a in a goalkeeping sense came to spurs and was just after a few months like what the hell am i doing here what is this club um wanted to leave and then they pretty much said to him just just wait we've got like we've got this guy coming in pochettino he sat down i think they had a phone call i think they had a phone call and lorise said after one phone conversation with pochettino he was like yeah i want to stay here this guy is this guy's gonna be good and you know who knows who knows how much they dramatize these events for to make an autobiography a bit more interesting but it's as you say the the turnaround since pochettino came in was you know it was remarkable and hopefully we'll see the same with uh with players like van de ven who look you know looked like he was desperate to leave at one point and is already sort of talking about next season and what the club might be able to achieve um can you see them can you see them bringing in i guess these sort of questions will go on all summer and we'll be having conversations about this but the vuscoviches the mikey moores do you think somebody like deserve he is gonna want to cast an eye over these before letting them out go again or you know because vuscovich is already on record saying he doesn't want to play for spurs yeah he wants to play with his brother and all that type of stuff um do you think we'll be i mean i doubt deserve your care about that will he if he thinks the kid is good then he's gonna
43:05Jack Pitt-Brooke:want him about the place isn't he yeah like this is one of the big unknown questions of the summer isn't it and beyond is to what extent does deserve you want young players um because like spurs's survival has not been built on young players like he had like graham burke you know graham burke had a few sub appearances here and there and he's spoken very nicely about them but they've not been starting games have they in the last few weeks no um so Bergvall
43:30Jack:especially has kind of been sidelined I feel and like they both they both started the Sunderland
43:36Jack Pitt-Brooke:didn't they in his first game I think that's what I think I'm right in saying that I think you're correct as well Graham Bergvall in the middle and then he's clearly gone in a more experienced direction um so I guess the like we I suppose you know Tell's young and Tell's started all the game so that's worth bearing in mind but I don't know how much how much you'll want young players in the team next year obviously Spurs are not going to be in Europe next year and that means that like if they mess up in the Cups they could have a 40 game season like United did and if you have a 40 game season then you actually don't need so much of a big squad and if you do have if you have that few games maybe that moves the dial on like do you want Vyskowicz and Moor to be here or do you want them to be playing every week somewhere else so I don't know this is one of the big like i said earlier about strategy this is one of the big strategic questions that that he's going to have to answer i think between now and august i mean you'd also probably say how
44:28Jack:quickly it is that he wants success or or not but i don't know that's not always the the clearest path is it because you know you sort of you look at again you look at arseul bringing somebody like downman in or you look at city bringing in o'reilly and they've been two of their better players this season so there's this idea that fostering sort of youth bringing you through into the team is not conducive to success isn't always true although the two examples i've just listed there are both truly exceptional talent so it it's i guess it is kind of different i mean
45:03Jack Pitt-Brooke:it depends also like one they have like he does at least have a long-term contract and like generally i think managers managers with a short-term contract and short-term focus are never really going to bring through young players right because if you've got if your managers if the manager's job's on the line he's going to be thinking how do i how do i keep my job how do i get another contract or isn't it like deserved because this five-year contract they gave him it might be i'm just kind of speculating here it might be that that that allows him to look more into the future a bit and to take decisions that are more like where do i want spurs to be two years from now rather than like three weeks from now i don't know so maybe that'll that'll change the dial but i think that give given the fact he's not used that many young players recently and given the fact they're not in europe next season my guess at this point would be towards young players going back online rather than being part of the squad i think one of you know one of
45:57Jack:the big interesting ones for me is going to be kinski next year if kinski is our number one or if we target a trafford for example because it by all accounts it seems like vicario is halfway out the door already maybe that'll have changed with um deserve becoming in and i'm not just trying to you know fall back on cheap they're both italians so maybe he's going to use him stuff but you know it might have just changed the entire complexity of the squad and the way it's built um i am actually just on the andy robertson thing personally speaking i am kind of surprised that we still be going ahead with that i got it i kind of understood the idea of bringing him in in the January transfer window when it looked like we were really struggling and just needed maybe some personalities in there.
46:46Jack:But to start a new season with him, I don't know. I do kind of struggle with that one a little bit. But I guess the thing for me now is if that's what De Zerbe wants, then you just kind of have to give that to him and you just have to trust him that he is making the best sort of decisions. I mean, I guess just sort of... in closing jack what's the uh what's the next few weeks look like for you mate is it world cup you
47:14Jack Pitt-Brooke:reporting on the world cup or very different very different now that spurs have stayed up um yeah i'm going to the world cup i cover england when i'm not covering spurs so are you going out there yeah i'll be in kansas city waiting for the base and then well the first three games which i imagine i imagine we'll get through the group uh croatia and dallas ghana in boston and then panama in New Jersey. So yeah, I'm going on the 12th of June and I'm looking forward to it.
47:40Jack:Get ready for the heat, mate. It's going to be pretty brutal out there. Yeah, yeah.
47:47Jack Pitt-Brooke:Sorry. To be honest, I'm struggling at the moment. I'm going to be absolutely cooked by the time I'm in the US.
47:52Jack:But get cooked in the US. England win the World Cup. Harry Kane lifts the World Cup. Wins the Ballon d 'Or. Then you're ready. Jed spent sports personality for the year. That's it. That's it. After his match-winning assist, to Harry Kane for the final and then you come back for next year when Tottenham have their redemption arc and we win the double. Is that too greedy? Can I say that? Well, Premier League and FA Cup. Given they're not in Europe,
48:18Jack Pitt-Brooke:I'd say maybe, let's aim for domestic trouble and take it from there.
48:23Jack:Jack, thank you very much, mate. I appreciate it and I hope, you know, I do hope you've managed to find a bit of headspace in the next few days ahead of the World Cup because I imagine it's been a pretty full-on season.
From the publisher
Jack is joined by The Athletic's Jack Pitt-Brooke for a monumental episode of Rule the Roost, as we finally breathe a massive sigh of relief: Tottenham Hotspur have stayed up. We kick things off by discussing the bittersweet nature of our survival, admitting that while we shouldn't really be celebrating avoiding the drop, the sheer emotional release makes it impossible not to. The conversation quickly shifts to the magnificent job done by Roberto De Zerbi. Having spoken to him in recent press conferences, Jack Pitt-Brooke shares his firsthand reflections on the manager's immense emotional intelligence. We dissect how De Zerbi managed to take a squad that looked completely dead in the water and turn them into a combative, resilient unit for the final stretch, and ask the golden question: has this late surge inspired the likes of Cristian Romero and Micky van de Ven to actually stay and fight next season?
Attention then turns to the boardroom, as we unpack the open letter issued to fans today by non-executive chairman Peter Charrington. Reacting to his promises to address the deeply rooted issues that led to consecutive seventeenth-placed finishes, we debate whether his vow to compete at the very top once again provides genuine cause for optimism or if it is simply more cheap talk from the hierarchy. Finally, we look ahead to a pivotal summer, outlining exactly what the club needs to do to achieve that promised success and setting our realistic, grounded aims for next season.
Theme is Ghost Cat by Gillen
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices




