In short
Tottenham’s failed transfer for Crystal Palace midfielder/attacker Eberechi Eze to Arsenal, the frustration over Tottenham’s negotiation pace, and a deep dive into Tottenham’s academy/loan strategy and standout youth prospects.
Guests
John (“Lilywhite Rose”), a long-time Spurs youth/academy watcher and Q&A contributor; Matt (host).
Key claims
- Arsenal “snuck in” and completed the Eze deal after Spurs’ protracted haggling, despite reports that terms were agreed in principle on 10 August.
- Tottenham’s repeated pattern of dragging negotiations (compared to Gibbs-White, Madison, and Havertz timing) leaves them vulnerable late in the window.
- The Eze miss may strain Tottenham’s relationship with CAA Base because Eze is a major Base client.
- Tottenham’s wing depth is strong; the club should prioritize a number 10-type addition, but the guest doubts an £80m Savinho-type solution.
- Possible alternative: explore Lucas Paquetá (market opportunity after betting allegations cleared).
Notable examples
- Eze: linked to Spurs since 2018; described as an “eye test” big-game player.
- Kudus: praised as a rare, high-impact signing (Ajax schooling cited).
- Academy/loans: Alfie Devine loan with option to buy; Jamie Donnelly seen as more likely to break through; Archie Gray and Bergvall praised; Mikey Moore/Rangers loan discussed.
- Luka Williams-Barnett: highlighted for prolific U18/U21 output and potential debut path.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOEze Transfer Frustrations
1:41 to 1:56
Explore the disappointment surrounding Eze's transfer to Arsenal.
“It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks.”
Eze Transfer Frustrations
2:56 to 6:24
Explore the disappointment surrounding Eze's transfer to Arsenal.
“I guess, look, I think we know where this positive has to start.”
Implications of Losing Eze
6:26 to 10:40
Discuss the broader impacts of losing Eze and potential future strategies.
“that a significant injury for an Arsenal player ends up in Spurs missing out on one of their top transfer targets.”
Future Aspirations and Reactions
10:40 to 14:00
Examine the potential moves Tottenham might make following the Eze miss.
“He said, Gibbs-White contract 28 days ago, Madison's injury 17 days ago, Havertz injury one day ago.”
Assessing Tottenham's Transfer Strategies
14:00 to 18:12
The discussion focuses on Tottenham's transfer options, particularly regarding Savinho and potential alternatives.
“You know, this is an ex-Arsenal CEO that's now at Tottenham that's seen his equivalent at Arsenal now swoop in and do that deal.”
Kudus and the Impact of New Signings
18:12 to 21:04
An evaluation of Kudus' performance and the implications of new signings for Tottenham's future.
“So as long as we can continue that, you know, fine.”
Alfie Devine and Jamie Donnelly's Future
21:04 to 26:36
A deep dive into the futures of academy players Alfie Devine and Jamie Donnelly in relation to Tottenham's squad depth.
“Are you um are you surprised by I mean I I was slightly surprised that we'd loaned out Divine again this summer.”
Academy Player Mentality and Development
28:00 to 29:49
Explore the contrasting mental toughness and development of academy players like Alfie Devine and Jamie.
“So Alfie, you know, coming out of Warrington, ex-Wiggin Academy, he's very, very mentally tough and physical.”
Evaluating Recent Academy Signings
29:50 to 33:15
Discussion on the value and potential of newly signed academy players versus existing academy talents.
“Are you seeing the value in that thus far, or do you think we could be still getting good value had we not dropped 30 mil on Archie Gray and we were playing somebody from our academy?”
Player Loans and Their Impact
33:16 to 35:48
Analyzing the strategy and outcomes of loaning out players to ensure their development and experience.
“And he's very highly rated, Keeley, wasn't he?”
Show all 25 chapters
Future Prospects of Young Talents
35:49 to 42:00
A look into the potential and future roles of young talents like Mikey Moore and Luka Williams-Barnett.
“Do you think his trajectory is still, you know, he's on his way to being a top player?”
Youth Talent Comparisons: Luka vs. Max
42:00 to 45:14
Discuss the potential of young players Luka Williams-Barnett and Max Doman, plus the challenges of comparisons.
“then absolutely we could see some of these younger guys get a chance to make their debut.”
Youth Talent Comparisons: Luka vs. Max
45:18 to 45:40
Discuss the potential of young players Luka Williams-Barnett and Max Doman, plus the challenges of comparisons.
“It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks.”
Academy Player Development Insights
45:40 to 54:28
Explore the experiences and earnings of young scholars at Tottenham Hotspur Academy.
“Another one who looked amazing absolutely amazing at youth level was Alex Pritchard.”
Navigating Academy Changes and Recruitment
54:28 to 56:00
Delve into the changes in Tottenham's academy staffing and recruitment strategies.
“So there are still gaps they need to fill.”
Changes in Tottenham's Academy Leadership
56:00 to 57:00
Exploring upcoming changes in Tottenham's academy and the impact of recent departures.
“but I think we could see a lot of changes in Tottenham's academy again very, very soon in terms of the leadership team there.”
Coping Mechanisms for Transfer Frustrations
57:00 to 58:20
Discussing personal coping strategies related to transfer disappointments, particularly focusing on Kudos.
“Dan, so at Hixie Dan says, what's your planned coping mechanism for when the SA transfer inevitably falls through?”
Market Opportunities in Player Transfers
58:20 to 1:00:30
Analyzing potential transfer opportunities for Tottenham, including players from top clubs.
“that let's hope it rushes Tottenham into getting another player.”
Comparing Player Departure Reactions
1:00:30 to 1:02:30
Comparing the public's reaction to Isak's and Kane's departures from their respective clubs.
“You know, I don't see how Asensio, when he did what he did, doesn't get a squad role at PSG.”
Harry Kane's Legacy and Emotional Impact
1:02:30 to 1:05:30
Reflecting on Harry Kane's legacy at Tottenham and the emotional weight of his departure.
“It's quite obviously because he's sad about it, you know?”
Memorable Moments and Iconic Photos
1:05:30 to 1:08:10
Sharing iconic memories and photographs that capture the spirit of Tottenham and its players.
“I mean, you think it's quite simply, he's not just one of the greatest Tottenham players of all time.”
Daniel Levy's Negotiation Style and Market Impact
1:08:10 to 1:10:01
Discussing Daniel Levy's negotiation tactics and their effects on Tottenham's transfer dealings.
“And I think, does this summer impact our future dealings with Nottingham Forest and also Crystal Palace?”
Discussion on Levy's Reputation
1:10:01 to 1:11:26
Exploration of Daniel Levy's standing in European football and personal relationships within the industry.
“get one over the club and made it his mission to get one over Spurs in return, right?”
John's Insights and Future Events
1:11:26 to 1:12:56
John shares where to follow him and discusses upcoming events for Spurs.
John's Insights and Future Events
1:12:59 to 1:13:15
John shares where to follow him and discusses upcoming events for Spurs.
“outdoor protection plan starting at$49.99 a month.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Jack:Welcome back to Rule the Roost. Yes, it's one of those annoying ad read type things at the top of a podcast you're looking forward to listening to. Thanks for tuning in. Just a quick request before I start. If you want to help support the show this season, please leave me a rating on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. You can drop me a follow on Instagram at Ted Trunk or if you really fancy, head over to patreon.com slash RTR pod for extra episodes and access to the Discord community. All of these things really help the podcast to get discovered by more Spurs fans, and it keeps the show growing for the new campaign.
0:34Jack:Thanks for the support, and now on with the show. Get business done with the new American Express Graphite Business Cash Unlimited card. With unlimited 2 % cash back on all eligible purchases, unlimited 5 % cash back on flights and prepaid hotels booked through American Express Travel Online, and a flexible spending capacity that can grow with your business, you'll have the confidence to keep building. Apply today and earn a welcome offer of$1 ,500 cash back after you spend$50 ,000 in qualifying purchases on your new card within the first six months of card membership. Terms apply. Learn more at go.amex.
1:09This episode is brought to you by Welch's Fruit Snacks.
1:12Jack:Back to school season can be tough on parents, but choosing a snack you and your kids can both get behind doesn't have to be. Stock up on Welch's Fruit Snacks, made with whole fruit and now made with no artificial dyes. It's a snack kids already love, and one you can feel good about giving them. Go back to school with Welch's Fruit Snacks, now made with no artificial dyes.
1:37Jack:This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required, compatibility and availability varies 18+.
2:20Jack:Good morning, everyone. Welcome back to Rule the Roost and welcome back, John, a.k.a. Lily White Rose. Welcome back to the show, Matt. I mean, what day to be recording, first and foremost? Yeah, before we get into the difficulties of the last 24 hours, thank you very much for having me back on. I think the last time we recorded was the back end of 2023. I mean, how time flies. And I think you used a photo of that famous, I think it was a 2-2 draw at Man City with Kulu dropping some interesting moves amongst his celebrations at full time. So, yeah, pleasure to be back on. It's been a while and lots to get into this morning.
2:56Jack:I guess, look, I think we know where this positive has to start. Obviously, the news came out last night that Arsenal have hijacked, although we'll get into that, hijacked the Eze deal. He seems to be going there. We've dilly-dallied and it's come back to bite us again. I guess I just wanted to know first and foremost, Matt, how are you? Where's your head at? Because I'll say a lot of the questions turned from, you know, academy-focused questions to suddenly, you know, where's the nearest building I can jump off of with regard to the SA stuff? Yeah, look, it's obviously incredibly disappointing for the club, first of all.
3:39You know, after the Morgan Gibbs-White situation and how that played out, to again so publicly be so near and not get a signing over the line. and I think a signing that would revolutionise the style that Thomas Frank wants to play. I think there's an absolute position that would have slotted either Morgan Gibbs-White or Eberici Eze in that starting XI that makes a big, big difference to the way the team plays, gives that team some identity, some character to English homegrown lads as well with proven Premier League experience. So to publicly not get over the line again is one thing. I think something the club couldn't afford to happen in light of the Morgan Gibbs-White situation already happening this summer.
4:18But to then lose out to Arsenal is obviously that double-sided blow. I think Eze would have been a fantastic signing for us. He's somebody that I've wanted for a long time. I think I dug out some tweets from 2018 when I was aware at the time that Tottenham were trying to involve him in a swap deal with QPR for Luke Amos. If you remember Luke, Academy player doing QPR. So Tottenham have been aware of him a long time. David Pleat has heavily pushed the drum for Eberichi for a very long time. each summer we're seemingly linked to the player each summer the price tag goes up and up and up and it seems like we were prepared to pull the trigger this time but for Tottenham to not get the deal over the line seemingly by haggling over a few million it is very frustrating I know there's been reports subsequently that Arsenal actually had agreed terms on Sunday the 10th of August or as far back as then but didn't push that interest we were led to believe because they were trying to get people out the door before they did Interesting they haven't got anyone out the door.
5:17But the frustration comes from the fact that Arsenal have seemingly gone in, got the deal done, are fine with Palace's terms of him playing in that conference league qualifier later today, whereas we seem in and are in about that. I think the money involved for the level of player was fine. I think pushing out the boat a little bit more would have been fine. So it's very, very frustrating for Tottenham and Tottenham fans today because I think Eze would have been an outstanding player. an opportunity for him to come to Tottenham and not only be a guaranteed starter in a World Cup year, but also to be the sort of poster boy of the club.
5:50We are lacking that now following Son's departure and obviously Harry Kane a couple of seasons before that. And I think Eze would have been the real face of Tottenham. And I think a Tottenham team that are going to do well this year regardless in a World Cup year would have really championed his position to not only be in an England squad, but also start for England. Going to Arsenal, you know, they've obviously spent 50 million plus on Noni Maguireke this summer. They've already got Saka on the wings. They've already got Odegaard. So, you know, the guaranteed starting thing, I don't think he's so much there for Eze at Arsenal, but I think he's an outstanding player and will find himself in the team one way or the other because he is that good.
6:25Jack:It's quite ironic, isn't it, that a significant injury for an Arsenal player ends up in Spurs missing out on one of their top transfer targets. I mean, this is in reference to the Kai Havertz injury yesterday that seems to have pushed Arsenal a bit further or made them hasten their approach for Eze. As you say, Miggie Delaney has revealed this morning, anyway, his sources saying that Arsenal had agreed to deal in principle with both Palace and Eze on the 10th of August. And it seems like at that point, they've just been kind of stalling, kind of kicking their heels in the background. And Parish has essentially used Spurs to get Arsenal to firm up their interest to a degree, which obviously as a Spurs fan, I find frustrating, but it's just a chairman doing what's best by his own football club, isn't it really?
7:20Jack:I've sort of, I've had a little joke on Twitter about saying, I hope Palace get relegated, but really you can't hold much of a grudge because it's exactly what Spurs do to other clubs all the time. We play the market to make sure our best interests are realised. And I mean, I agree entirely with you, John. The thing that's tough about this is obviously losing him to Arsenal. I think we can't take away from the tribal element of football. I know everybody now wants to be very intellectual and very above all this type of stuff, but on a certain level, it just really stings that it's Arsenal, again, coming in and taking this player that we've, I think for the past few days, been pretty low-key, kind of assured that we were going to be signing.
8:04Jack:I had in the back of my mind, Eze will be a Tottenham player next season. I know it looks like the deal's a bit protracted. It feels a bit back and forward, but I reckon we'll get this one done. And for them to come in and do this in a sort of like a worst case scenario, I saw people sort of saying in a worst case scenario, imagine if Arsenal come in last minute and nab him. And to see that happen is obviously gutting. The point that you're making about us having another kind of face for the club, especially with Son Heung-Min going, Kane having gone previously, Hugo Lloris, those kind of the big stars that we've had down the years, not really having anyone like that.
8:38Jack:Romero, probably the closest thing to that. now let's let's give him his dues um but still having having a bit of star factor in there would have been would have been really quite important for the club as is like giving us giving us all a lift giving the players a lift giving the club's image a bit of a lift like you say bringing a bit more light to this summer after going through the sort of the embarrassment of the Morgan Gibbs White deal and I but what I will I mean the the one thing that I will say is now I'm not I'm not trying to like act like I'm above all this I'm not trying to make this feel any better because the situation is very frustrating I feel it everyone feels it I'm not trying to take away from that the only thing I would say is that when I was when it was looking like we were likely to be getting Eze I thought I'll have I'll have a little look at him a bit closer I have a look at his stats and I'll see how he has been performing and what there is is he's obviously a very good player but to this point and I know it's in the context of playing for Crystal Palace he's he's not exceptional at anything is what I would say and I mean I think there are certain intangibles there he's a big game he's like he's got big moments in him he's a big game player and sometimes that's all it needs I think the famous example of this is a lot of people if you look back on like Didier Drogba's return it doesn't look that impressive really his sort of goals and assists and everything but I think anybody at watch Didier Drogba knew what an incredible player he was what a talent he was so I guess maybe my point is Ezra is is something of an eye test player and I don't think that's an entirely bad thing but I think there's also something that we probably need to just maybe just take a step back and focus on in the respect that there will be challenges that come with taking a step up to a club like Arsenal even as there would have been to a club like Spurs there's going to be a lot more focus on him now he's going to be required to be consistently brilliant really to just as you say fighting for a place in that Arsenal team he would have still probably had to fight for a place in in this Tottenham team we do have a number of players that are all sort of vying for similar positions at the moment so you know it's gutting it is gutting but I think it's I'm not I'll be honest I'm not completely doom and gloom about it I'm frustrated I'm frustrated about the situation the way it's played out but you know there's already there's already talk that we're we're sort of lining up Bilal El-Kanus from Leicester that we're going to swoop in kind of be a bit like all right then Palace you want to play funny games with us we'll do that with you we'll take the player that you were going to replace Ezzel with and as again like I say there was just that that intrusive thought in the back of my head when we were going to sign Ezzel I was thinking what's the betting that Bilal El-Kanus ends up being a better player than Ezel when Palace bring him in you know and I'm not I'm not saying that's definitely gonna be the case but still you know there's I think there's still hope this just hinges on this brings me to my next talking point this just hinges on the club actually acting decisively dusting themselves off from this and thinking we need to make a statement here because and I'll let me just share this with you mate because James James Moore yesterday tweeted, and I thought this was pretty much perfectly on the nose.
11:55Jack:He said, Gibbs-White contract 28 days ago, Madison's injury 17 days ago, Havertz injury one day ago. And this is obviously nodding to the fact that Daniel Levy, who is apparently not involved in negotiations anymore, is quite clearly still involved in negotiations and has dragged his feet over this deal. Yes, Arsenal have snuck in. Arsenal maybe had an agreement in principle. But if Spurs had just thought, we want this player enough that we're going to get it done, we're going to get this deal done, I dare say we probably would have signed him because I don't think Arsenal really would have come in as firm had Havertz not gone.
12:35Jack:And this is a repeated pattern of behaviour, isn't it? We always hear stories that the club are changing, they're changing tack, they're changing the approach. But here we are, you know, a week and a bit away from the end of the transfer window. And we're still seemingly kind of scrabbling around in the dark, chasing after various different targets, missing out on our top targets because of, you know, protracted negotiations and things. And it just feels like it's never going to end, doesn't it, mate? I mean, where are you at with it all now? I mean, I think there's two further massive side effects of this Eze deal not happening.
13:12The first one being Tottenham's comfy relationship with CAA Base. Now, Eze is a massive client of CAA Base. Tottenham, historically, have had, you know, they've been their go-to agents for both the academy players and also, you know, senior players in the squad. Sonny was with Base and Ange Bostococco was with Base and Pedro Poros with Base and many others. So I think that alleged, you know, preferred relationship with Base, the reaction Levy will have to this deal not going through, the player going to Arsenal, and if what Miguel Delaney says is correct, them having the deal in place in principle since the 10th of August and Tottenham seemingly being unaware of this will not go down well in those relationships.
13:50I think that's a really interesting point and we'll see how that plays out moving forward. The second point is, you know, how does Vinay Venkaciam feel about all of this? You know, this is an ex-Arsenal CEO that's now at Tottenham that's seen his equivalent at Arsenal now swoop in and do that deal. That doesn't leave him, you know, in a position of strength, authority, showing strong leadership in front of Levy and others at Tottenham. This deal has been able, in the world of social media, leaks everywhere, has been able to keep this under wraps, that they have this agreed, I'm looking at my calendar now, 21st August, this agreed 11 days ago, allegedly, as per Miguel Delaney's story, and nobody knew that.
14:32I get what we said earlier about Steve Parrish wanting to keep his club's best interests at heart, but you'd think somewhere along the line this would have got out. So I think that leaves Vinay, you know, position a bit under scrutiny as well. But, you know, as we touched upon earlier, you know, with where this leaves the club, there's a point I want to touch on. I've seen reports this morning that we're now going to be preparing to offer up to 80 million euros or pounds for Savino. Just on Savino, I don't quite see that, if I'm being honest with you. We talk about, you know, the club needing to react now.
15:04But I equally don't see 80 million on Savino being the answer to that. Let's just remember for a second. They signed Savinho last summer for around£30 million or euros from their feeder club, Troyes, in France.
15:20City probably had their worst year last year for 10 or 15 years. You look at his stats. We talked about stats earlier. Was it four goals and a couple of assists here and there? Eight assists, I think it was. I don't see the cumulative value in that he goes from a£30 million player based on that season and the year City had to suddenly we're being quoted£76,£80 million. I just don't see that. Compare that to Kudos,£55 million in free instalments and the impact he's already had and looks like will continue to have. And then buying Savinho for£80, I just personally don't see that. I also see that we're heavily stacked in the wing positions already.
15:59I probably think it's our strongest position in terms of the number of players we've got there that I think can perform and, given more opportunities, can offer more. compared to that number 10 position, where I think we should be putting all our efforts into, and we seemingly have done with Gibbs White and also Eze. So, difficult moment to top them in the transfer market. They have to come up with something else. I've got to be with a left-field suggestion. He's not a number 10 by any stretch of the imagination, or not a complete number 10 by any stretch of the imagination. But I do wonder if we go back to West Ham and look into Paqueta now.
16:34He is a player that I think earlier on in the window, once he was cleared of the allegations around the betting or his family betting, that he was ready for a new challenge. The fact that we've managed to do a deal with West Ham this summer already for the first time since Scott Parker all those years ago, I do wonder if there's more value in going after Paquette, who is a Premier League proven player, who's got leadership skills, that whenever I've seen play, especially against Tottenham, I've been very impressed with. And he might be one that also thrives in a bigger club environment, as I think we're seeing with Kudos already.
17:06And I just wonder if there's value to be had more in that deal, you know, or if that's a deal we should be looking to explore. I don't know what you think about that, Jack.
17:15Jack:I mean, it's definitely an interesting one. I think the main, you know, when you just said that name, the main thing that sort of sung for me was just baggage. Do you know what I mean? Like the baggage, he's clearly a very, very talented player. But I was thinking, I wonder if Spurs will just be like, I don't know. I don't know if we want the worry of all that stuff around him. Yeah, but let's remember that before this betting stuff came out, he was all very set on going to Man City for about 85 million quid. I just think now there is a real market opportunity to get way below that value. You slot him into your midfield and suddenly you look around and think, we've got three proper players in this midfield.
17:54Make an impact and maybe all play together at a higher level.
17:58Jack:I'd entirely forgotten about the Manchester City thing as well. The level he was playing at. I'm sold. I'm sold, John. you've sold me already mate that's it I remember now he's been proven unavailable you know yeah I mean on on Kudis as well you've just touched on him there I think we were sort of talking off air just just before this and the point you made that really resonated with me is just the actual the level that Kudis seems to be at like he's he's vastly better than I thought he was to be honest yeah has has honestly sort of I guess just like subconsciously softened the as they blow from me a bit because I, you know, I do think we need to add more further talent to this squad, but equally I really wasn't expecting Kudus to be quite as good as he is.
18:46Jack:So as long as we can continue that, you know, fine. But I mean, again, this is, this just all plays into that idea, doesn't it, mate? Like the club are seemingly just kind of moving all over the place. It would just be nice if we could just be, you know, we had that little window didn't we where we signed kudos and then it looked like we were getting gibbs white in a couple of days later and i suddenly thought we're finally doing it we're finally being decisive we're finally going out there spending money getting the targets we want quickly like no fuss no nonsense no messing about and just it's completely flipped on its head it's got it's gone completely the other way isn't it yeah i mean there's also another if you look at it from another way there's another argument that we've actually missed out on several targets this summer.
19:32You could say, and I'm not saying this is right or wrong, or the players we've actually signed in hindsight I think are better than those we've missed out on, but there's an argument to say, would Thomas Frank have wanted his captain from Brentford, Norgaard, and it was very quickly established that he was going to all storm, prefer to go to Arsenal, so we lost out on him. Would he have preferred Mbwemo, you know, someone that he's worked with again, and it was very quickly made clear that he'd rather go to Man United, despite the fact we can offer Champions League football, we're in London, he could have probably stayed in the same family home he's in now, etc, etc.
20:01and instead we've got Kudos. Now, don't get me wrong, we talked off air. For me, Kudos seems, as we said, like one of those rare players that slipped through the market for whatever reason of Liverpool or Man City. He looks like one of their players. When we played Bayern Munich away, he wouldn't have looked out of place playing for Bayern Munich. I mean, I actually think very, very quickly, he becomes not only one of our best players, but also widely regarded as one of the best players in the Premier League as a whole. I think you're getting two players in one. You're getting this powerful, dominant midfield player, effectively that can hold off two or three at once then play a pass and also a sort of quick tricky winger it's unheard of to get a quick tricky winger that's also incredibly big powerful and strong um it's a very very rare commodity and we seemingly struck gold with kudos and we talked about you know the money of savinho you know 80 million and we got kudos for 55 you know i think that is very good uh business and a very good deal so it's obviously i'm delighted with kudos coming in and I think that is a you know how good he is and how good I think he will become I think also the fact they had that that schooling at Ajax as well you know he plays a big part in that you know historically we've done very very well with our signings have been through at Ajax and I think him having had that period at Ajax before West Ham stands him in really good stead in terms of his mentality his football upbringing and that kind of stuff.
21:20Jack:Are you um are you surprised by I mean I I was slightly surprised that we'd loaned out Divine again this summer. I sort of thought he's, what is he, he's 21 now. I think I still sort of had this idea in my head he's a 15-year-old kid that he stays as a 15-year-old in stasis forever, right? When I had a look, I was like, he's 21 now. Surely he's knocking on the door. He's done quite well when he's been on loan. People still seem to speak pretty favorably of him. And obviously, I think we did loan him out before the injury to Madison. I guess let me reframe this to you. Do you think, had we not loaned him out and Madison had gotten injured, we might be seeing more of him this year at Spurs?
22:04Jack:If your business runs on five different apps, 12 browser tabs, and one spreadsheet that everyone's afraid to touch, it's probably time for Odoo. Odoo is an all-in-one business management software that connects every part of your business into one powerful, easy-to-use platform. So instead of wasting time switching between disconnected systems, your entire business works together in real time. Your team moves faster, your data stays accurate, and you can actually focus on growing your business. Let one unified system run your entire business. From the first opportunity to the final payment, everything works together in one place.
22:45Jack:Whether you're a small business or managing a large operation, Odoo gives you one flexible platform built to grow with you. Learn more at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com. Get business done with the new American Express Graphite Business Cash Unlimited card. With unlimited 2 % cash back on all eligible purchases. Unlimited 5 % cash back on flights and prepaid hotels booked through American Express Travel Online. and a flexible spending capacity that can grow with your business, you'll have the confidence to keep building. Apply today and earn a welcome offer of$1 ,500 cash back after you spend$50 ,000 in qualifying purchases on your new card within the first six months of card membership.
23:27Jack:Terms apply. Learn more at go.amex.com. This episode is brought to you by Welch's Fruit Snacks. Back-to-school season can be tough on parents, but choosing a snack you and your kids can both get behind doesn't have to be. Stock up on Welch's Fruit Snacks. made with whole fruit and now made with no artificial dyes. It's a snack kids already love and one you can feel good about giving them. Go back to school with Welch's Fruit Snacks, now made with no artificial dyes.
23:59It's hard. I'll touch on another player in a minute. I think was actually more likely than him to break through this year. But on Divine, I mean, he started the first preseason game away at Reading. And that was quite a statement. Only him and Mikey Moore from the academy players started that first half amongst a team of, you know, senior pros. So I think Frank definitely did have a look at Alfie Devine, you know, training and everything else. Obviously, he's come off the back of a season in the Belgium First Division last year where he did relatively well. He's had championship loans before and done well there.
24:33But the fact that this Preston loan includes, and we don't know what the value is, but it includes an option to buy. Although Tottenham didn't announce that, Preston were very quick to announce that on their social media pages. Does it really?
24:43Jack:Yeah. Wow. That tells me, and look, we don't know what the option to buy is. Maybe it's 8 million, 10 million quid, and Preston can never afford that. We don't know, right? But say it's not, say it's£4 million or something like that, and this all goes well, they will snap him up for that, knowing he's got that experience in the England Academy set-ups, he's widely regarded in youth circles. But he is getting to an age now where he needs a permanent base, and maybe he was up for that. And the fact that he started already in the Championship and scored a goal and doing well and seemingly integrated.
25:12That's one part of it. But I think on the other axis, Tottenham have looked at it and have thought to themselves, Jamie Donnelly is a couple of years younger. For me, he's the more talented of the two players if you just compare them as one-offs. And I think when you look at Jamie in interviews, the mentality is there already as a kind of seasoned pro. I'll give you the example for the Luton game. I think Jamie was told about three minutes to kick off that he'd be not only starting, but also starting at left back. Just got on with it. No dramas, you know, just straight in there, come off the bench, but you're starting, but you're going to be at left back.
25:47No dramas, gave a decent performance of himself. So I think the mentality is there already with Jamie. They got him contracted till 2029. He's now at Stoke, straight away got a really high level assist. I don't know if you saw it in his second game. You know, three players around him, took his time, played the pass, you know, couldn't miss for the attacking player, run onto it. So I think they've made a decision. They see Jamie as the one more likely to break through than Alfie. And maybe that's why they've agreed to that option to buy in Alfie's loan deal. But I think it's, you know, the stranger one for me is that when Madison got injured, obviously, you know, Jamie was out there, you know, on the tour.
Read the full transcript
26:24And only two days later, I was heading up to Stoke for the medical to sign for them. so I'd say it's more likely that Jamie would have stayed around but even then Thomas Frank must have been given assurances you imagine by the upper echelons at Tottenham whether that be Johan Langer, Daniel Levy, Vinay I'm not sure but whoever it was would have said to him look we're going to get you somebody else and obviously we've had this very public pursuit of Eze now play out without success so the fact they've loaned out Jamie already Alfie's out on loan it leaves you to the point where they're going to have to buy somebody I think longer term Jamie is ahead of Alfie in terms of the pecking order at Tottenham and how they see those players.
27:00Jack:I hope that because we had a question from the Crumpet, Crumpet who asked, will Donnelly make it with us? And I think the thing for Donnelly, I can't say I've watched him extensively, but when I watched a bit of like Orange Cop run and stuff like that, you could see, and from everything we were hearing about it, he was one of the best players in that league. I know people will say, oh, he's only doing it at that level, but he was comprehensively one of the best players in that league that year and in that team. He's quite clearly a very, very talented player. Even just from little glimpses of the goal, the David Beckham-esque goal he scored against Manchester City in the FA Cup.
27:40Jack:It was Manchester City, wasn't it, in the FA Cup? Yeah. So, I mean, that is promising. And I guess, do you think, is there an element of this at all a physicality thing? You know, Donnelly is a bigger lad than Devine, isn't he? do you think that plays into it at all is that something of a consideration when you compare the two of them? Yeah it can do but you know It's a bit old school I know but still To play devil's advocate on that I remember Alfie Devine as a 17 year old being completely taken out by Danny Drinkwater in a un-21s match, I mean like two footed off the ground, you don't see many 17 year olds that then get up grab Danny Drinkwater around the neck and square up to him, completely ready to kick off with someone that was old enough to be his dad and was a Premier League winner at the time.
28:29So Alfie, you know, coming out of Warrington, ex-Wiggin Academy, he's very, very mentally tough and physical. Whereas Jamie, and I'm sure he won't mind me saying this, one of his dad's tricks when he was younger, Jamie was always one of the better players in his academy teams growing up and in his grassroots teams. but he didn't have that toughness in him so the reward instead of you know money for scoring goals was 10 pounds if you get a yellow card um to force him into situations that he was uncomfortable with because Jamie didn't have that natural aggressiveness in his game um so he used to get 10 pounds picking up yellow cards because it would force different scenarios and whatever and that's that's all part of building somebody that you want to then you know develop into professional footballer you need all the attributes to do it so that that that mental physicalness wasn't there with Jamie but he's definitely got it now as we've seen you know over his course of his league one last year 50 odd games whenever he played um you know many situations we have to be physically strong as a 19 year old boy 20 year old boy playing against 26 27 28 year olds who have played 300 odd games in that league and the fact that he was one of the best players in the division
29:38Jack:shows you that he's got that toughness now I just want to ask you and I don't I hope people would listen to this and take this in good faith because I'm not trying to draw you into like bashing any of our players or anything but just because obviously you are heavily invested in the academy and one of the sore points for a lot of Spurs fans I think is the lack of minutes that are afforded to academy players and everything like that that we see over the past few years at Spurs how are you like how do you perceive the development of say Archie Gray, Lucas Bergvold even Papo Matassar players like this these young promising players that we are signing from outside of the club.
30:18Jack:Are you seeing the value in that thus far, or do you think we could be still getting good value had we not dropped 30 mil on Archie Gray and we were playing somebody from our academy? Yeah, look, I think all three of those players, especially, you know, I appreciate Archie Gray was more money, but, you know, Sar for, was it£12 million or whatever, you know, what signing is proven to be and outstanding external scouting and recruitment, you know, getting that over the line the way we did. Same with Bergvau,£8 million. I mean, what a signing, you know, I think he's going to become and he's going to carry on being.
30:54Archie Gray obviously was more money, but then he paid that English tax, the fact that he was well known and on the shortlist of basically every major club. We obviously got the deal over the line when he was already doing the medical at Brentford. So I think that stands him in good stead with Thomas Frank straight away. And we've seen that, you know. Clearly, yeah. He likes him, doesn't he? He likes him. and I think that's important for him at the stage of the career he was and I think where there was some second guessing by Tottenham fans on is he worth the money and is he going to amount to what they thought he was going to.
31:20I think the fact that the manager absolutely likes him is massive for him and I think we will see a much improved Archie Gray this season. Equally, I know there is this feeling of, you know, since Harry Kane we haven't really produced anybody but you've got to remember we started a Champions League final, whatever you think about him, with Harry Winks and on that night he was our best player in the Champions League final. In my opinion, I was sat there, row one, and Winks, for me, was the best player. He was sold for£10 million. We saw Oliver Skip sold for around£20 to£25 million. So the academy has been generating some money, not as good as the other clubs, Chelsea's, Human City's, but that's a bigger issue.
31:55That comes from those clubs getting these kids at 14, 15, 16, paying huge sums of money and paying huge sums of money to the family and buying them houses and the kids and the siblings go through private schools. It's just a different operation completely to how we operate at Tottenham. But, you know, I think this year the correct decision has been made in terms of we're in the Champions League. You're going to need your strongest squad all the time. It's better for Jamie Donnelly, for Mikey Moore, for George Abbott, for Tyrese Hall, Alfie Dorrington, for all the others, Will Langshere, to go out and get 50, 55 games than get five to eight games coming off the bench at Tottenham.
32:34Whereas we had the Europa League last year and we saw that to some impact. We all remember that famous win against Elfsborg with Mikey Moore, De Molotje and Dane Scarlett all scoring and how fantastic that was. We were seeing the likes of Will Lancia scoring at Galatasaray. You know, we were going to Furnos Farros in that atmosphere and starting Mikey Moore and Will Lancia. So we saw, you know, a fair bit of the academy last year under Angie Inferno, in my opinion. We saw Alfred Dorrington make his Premier League debut coming off the bench at Southampton. But, you know, there are other signings that I think are maybe more questionable.
33:05When we signed Kinski, for example, as a 21-year-old, the same age as Josh Keeley, and we're now seeing Josh excel, as I expected him to do at Luton. We let go of him for a million pounds plus a decent sell-on. We're signing Kinski for 11. And he's very highly rated, Keeley, wasn't he? Always was. He always was. And the fact that now he's in the Ireland main squad, and the plan is that he battles with Kelleher for that number one position for Ireland. So there are some other angles you can be frustrated with. But I think the decision to loan out the 11 players this summer very quickly as well, as soon as they're back off the tour, you know, in the space of eight hours, we had all those loans lined up and they were ready to go.
33:43And they're all seemingly getting a lot of minutes already. So I know there was a question going to come in about the lack of minutes and how well these loans are planned out. But the fact that a lot of those players joined those clubs on Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, with the league season starting on the Saturday, and they all featured, whether or not they started or came on, every single one featured, tells me we have picked the right loans and we have got far, far better at finding the right loans for our young players.
34:09Jack:Because Mikey Morgan to Rangers in particular, I feel is, I know people will say like the SPL is the same level as the Championship or League One even, maybe if they wanted to be particularly disrespectful about it. But playing for a club like the size of Rangers, the pressure, the expectation, the weight of history, the size of the stadium, the support, is a massive move for a young player like that, isn't it? and he seems to be thriving so far from everything I've seen outside. Mikey is incredibly confident, has an amazing family network around him that will drive him, will support him. You'll often find six, seven, eight more family members, you know, going to watch him even up in Rangers.
34:46I've noticed that already, making the big journey up from South London. So he's got a great network around him. He's got all the tools there to thrive and I'm sure he will. We've got to remember, he is so young. It's because he's come on the scene. He literally turned 18 last week or the week before But to go and play for Rangers, as you said, 45 ,000 people or whatever it is up at Ibrox supporting him and behind him, and the expectation is to win every game you play. The only disappointment I'll say so far about Mikey Sloan is that first leg of that final Champions League playoff game. You know, I was really banking on him getting those eight Champions League games and the experience that would have been, you know, maybe Rangers going away to the Bernabeu or Bayern Munich or whatever it might be.
35:24And that experience, you know, even if you're losing those games, just being a part of that is massive. so that was particularly disappointing that they lost, I think it was 3-1 huge ask to go away to Belgium and turn that around now, obviously I'll be hoping they do but I can't really see it so that's a disappointment that he's not going to have those European games but he's got to go and the other issue he's got is that the Rangers' best player is seemingly this guy Gassama that also plays left wing so it'll be interesting how that pans out because they've got Gassama on the left wing they've brought a guy called Ant-Man on the right wing that's also very good so Mikey might have a battle to get into the team but he did start the league game on Saturday just gone got an assist as well I know it was a bit of a Tom Carroll for Gareth Bale level assist but they all count so yeah we'll have to see how he gets on but I back him to do well and I think it'll be a really good loan other than next year I'm sure he'll go on the pre-season with Tottenham and they'll make a decision is he ready to come into the team as an 18 turning 19 year old or will his former Rangers have attracted a Premier League loan they'll have to make that decision.
36:29Jack:Do you think his trajectory is still, you know, he's on his way to being a top player? Because that's kind of how he was introduced to us all, wasn't it? Without question. I think, you know, we always saw that in his first, you know, set of academy games. He was playing youth champions league games, which is an under-19s tournament as a 15-year-old. And we talk about players that have got strength and build and toughness. Mikey absolutely has all of those in London. You know, when he's not playing football, He's boxing in gyms in South London. He's a physical boy. Proper Millwall. Proper Millwall, you said it.
37:04So, yeah, with Mikey, I still see his trajectory like that. I think when he played in it, I think it was under-17 Euros, I think it was the summer before last, and he was the standout player for England in that team with Ethan Nawari. Whereas Nawari has broken into that team at Arsenal so well, hasn't quite happened for Mikey. I think he was so, so unlucky when he had that virus that let him be out for four months. When we had a lot of injuries in the team, I think that was a real door opening for him. You know, he still made 16 appearances for Tottenham last year, which is amazing for a 17-year-old.
37:35But I think he would have made many, many more had he not, you know, had that virus that brought him out for so long.
37:42Jack:And he was good value as well. That's the thing as well. And like you say, that's the thing. When he's coming on in Champions League games, you're forgetting how young he is and how rare it is for Spurs to be trusting a player this young as well with that. So it's all worthwhile context. We've got some good questions here, John. So I think this is the right time to bring up this young man. So Andy Perry has asked on Twitter, how far off first team level is Luka Williams-Barnett? Could we see him making his debut this season? And how good could he be? Okay, so we talked about Mikey Moore there.
38:20To put Luka's season last year into context, I mean, he completely outscored Mikey Moore's levels at the 18s, which were highly regarded as, you know, people were speechless at how good Mikey was. Luka then came into the side playing either as a number 10 behind a central striker or off the left-hand side and was just not only scoring, but like ridiculous goals. I'm talking like chipped goals from the halfway line against West Ham and at Cobham against Chelsea. And, you know, just obscene levels of goals and performances that were really consistent as well. Sometimes you see these sort of diminutive, skilful players and they kind of have one or two games where they're amazing and out of this world and then they have a couple where they dip.
38:57The fact that he has now seemingly just moved into the under-21s despite being an under-18s first-year player and he's then going up to Sunderland away on the back of a seven-hour coach journey up there. He's scoring, looking outstanding on the pitch, tells you a lot about him. He's another one, very, very good family upbringing around him. Spurs grabbed him from Luton at a really young age so yeah a top player and Tottenham fan as well I know there was some sort of misconception about Chelsea utter online nonsense he's a massive Tottenham
39:29Jack:fan that wants to make it a Tottenham I mean that's nice isn't it again it's like I know it's tribal and stuff but it's good to know that there are players who actually care about bleeding for the shirt and all that type of thing right yeah 100 % and Luka is another one of those so So, you know, he's got a very, very high ceiling. I think this year will be more about establishing himself in the under-21s. And I think he will, as we've seen already, they basically moved up eight players from the under-18s straight into the under-21s. So we're going to have a young team in the under-21s, but we've got a young, exciting team.
40:04And I'll just run through the eight that have moved up. So you've got goalkeeper Sam Archer, defenders Malachi Hardy and Jani Byfield. Obviously, we've seen Jani with the first team this summer. very, very young as well. You've got Harry Bryan, who's currently injured, but won the Scholar of the Year last year as a left-back. Then you've got midfielders George Feeney, Teenan Thompson on the left wing, who we saw in the first team against Wickham and got himself an assist and looked really lively. You've got Ellis Lehane up front. And then obviously you've got Luca Williams-Barnett. So there's a core group of eight that all know each other, that have played together for a number of years, all moving into the under-21s at once.
40:39And at one point away to Sunderland, I think they were 5-1 up. The game finished 5-3 in the end on Monday night, but the UN21s had a really difficult year last year, having loaned out a lot of their better players and found themselves near the bottom of the table. They've already started with a big win away from home. They've got another game on Friday coming up, up at Steven's Lamex. And obviously, if you can get to that, please do. The players always really appreciate the support of fans. But yeah, I think we're going to see a really exciting year this year. And I think Luke will be a big part of that.
41:06You know, could I see him making his debut in the Carabao Cup were we to get a favourable draw at home? Well, yeah, of course, I could see him, you know, being involved in the squad for that. But I think, you know, with the Premier League and also the Champions League this year, I think opportunities for the younger players will be fairly limited. And that's why we've seen so many loaned out to ensure they get 50 games under their belt this year. And Luka is just that bit younger. So I think for him, a season of progress would see, you know, making, I don't know, say 30 games for the under-21s, grabbing himself, you know, 10 to 15 goals and, you know, getting on the first team bench and hopefully, you know, making that debut in the Carabao Cup or something.
41:44But obviously, look, the Carabao Cup is another one where a couple of years ago, I was hoping to see a few young players play. You get Fulham away in round two. I mean, how incredibly unlucky that is. You know, you get a really top Premier League team, first, second round. We haven't even been in the second round for a number of years. So it just depends who you get. You know, if you get a favourable draw at home, then absolutely we could see some of these younger guys get a chance to make their debut.
42:05Jack:Where would you, I mean, obviously, I know a lot can change at this point, but obviously the comparisons are already being made with Luka Williams-Barnett to Max Doman at Arsenal, who is a year younger than actually than Luka, isn't he? But obviously, Doman's getting a lot of hype. There's a lot of talk that he's actually going to be integrated into Arsenal's first team this season at 15 years old. Where would you kind of benchmark Luka against somebody like Max Doman? Yeah, I think Max Doman, you know, I hate to use his word, but he's one of those generational talents that comes through every sound there.
42:39The fact that I saw a bit of Arsenal's pre-season friendly against Newcastle, and he was just running with no fear against guys like Joe Linton, that's about eight stone heavier than him, and a full international and proper Premier League player, just running it in with no fear, taking the ball past him, he won a penalty in that game off Joe Linton as well. So the fact that he was instantly making an impact, I think he won another penalty in one of Arsenal's pre-season games against the Athletic O 'Gilbao. he seems like somebody that is just going to take the league by storm if everything goes right for him off the pitch and if he's got a good network around him and that kind of stuff so I think he's on a different trajectory at the moment but equally I struggle with the comparison sometimes with one player to another, they're each on their own journey they make their own breakthrough when the time's ready to do so But the difference, you know, at Arsenal, I hate to say it, the fact they've integrated Noweri, Lewis Miles Skelly, now seemingly Max Dallman, you know, they seem to be really nailing that.
43:42And that is tough to see as an avid youth watcher of Tottenham as I am, to see how well they're doing at that.
43:49Jack:this is the thing it's that awful bit in me when i think about like you know a successful young 15 year old sort of lad who's going to potentially have a glittering career and there's that horrible little bit in the back of my head it's like i hope he doesn't make it you know it's such a such an awful way it reduces you to think about somebody on a you have to try and sort of think about on a human level good luck to the kid but also not while he's wearing their shirt hopefully madrid come in and get him or something like that get business done with the new american express graphite Business Cash Unlimited card.
44:20Jack:With unlimited 2 % cash back on all eligible purchases, unlimited 5 % cash back on flights and prepaid hotels booked through American Express Travel Online, and a flexible spending capacity that can grow with your business, you'll have the confidence to keep building. Apply today and earn a welcome offer of$1 ,500 cash back after you spend$50 ,000 in qualifying purchases on your new card within the first six months of card membership. Terms apply. Learn more at go.amex.graphite.
45:14Jack:This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required compatibility and availability varies 18+. um it does i was hoping for you to uh ease the pain of it there mate because i've just seen a lot of people basically saying that arsenal might have the english messi on their hands which is uh which is worrying me a bit but hey um andy perry he also said uh on this as well because i just thought this was quite interesting is who's the best academy player uh you've seen in your time since following the the younger age groups hmm yeah interesting question i mean what what i always go back to as one that I thought was fantastic when he was coming through the team and also I can't believe the way his career stagnated but we've seen interviews since and you know he had other vices away from football would be Stephen Corker it's a bit of a left field choice but you know I remember you know him in academy level games was so so dominant he then very quickly progressed into the Tottenham first team started away for us away to Lazio as a young boy kept a clean sheet there in the Europa League game got in the England set up I think he actually scored on his full England debut as well but then I appreciate that he said he had some vices with gambling and they kind of fall off from that but Stephen Corker is always one to me who had every single attribute that we now see in these modern day defenders he was tall, he was lean, he was powerful he could carry the ball, he could play a pass he was a danger from set pieces so he was one for me who not only that I think he was fantastic at youth level but also that transition and the way sort of the career hasn't pushed on as I thought it would is Stephen.
47:14Another one who looked amazing absolutely amazing at youth level was Alex Pritchard. He was sold for£8 million in the end which was a very decent sum of money but he used to be absolutely incredible and he'd score all sorts of goals and amazing to set pieces and was a really good player as well.
47:34Jack:But he came up with Kane and all that lot as well, didn't he? And I remember when we used to like when Fighting Cock used to do all like the 1882 games and go and watch all the young players it would always be the Alex Pritchard show. You would see him and he would look unbelievable. Like seriously seriously top drawer, didn't he? He still had a good career, that's the thing. He went£8 million which at the time was a lot of money. At the time he made one sub-appearance under Sherwood for a couple of minutes towards the end of the season and then we've got eight million for him so that's when the academy was doing their sales like chelsea are doing now obviously prices have inflated over time but we were selling players really well then another player from that same cane team um was adam smith and i know he goes under the radar now he still plays for bournemouth now he's got like 300 odd appearances that's an academy player that we produce and he's a solid player as well solid pro and there is a world where you think it was there any you know we talk about his lack of homegrown options now and club-trained options, was there any world where we could have kept him as a backup right-back this entire time?
48:37And he just comes in, you know, say when Kyle Walker had been injured or say when Kieran Trippier had been injured or Serge Aurieras, or as we move on through the right-backs we've had, Pedro Porro, etc.
48:47Jack:Same way we do with Ben Davis, right? Exactly that. Exactly that. And as we do with Brandon Austin as the third goalkeeper, was there a world where, you know, probably not, he wouldn't have wanted that because he looks back on his career and thinks I've had made 300 appearances, He's probably Bournemouth's all-time Premier League appearance holder. So he finishes with a decent career. But that's another player we produced that people would just kind of forget about. Yeah. I was surprised we didn't bring back Carl Walker-Peters this summer as well, to be honest. When you look at the difficulties we have with registering players, the fact that he can play right-back or left-back, was Dominic Solanke's best man at his wedding.
49:23He's obviously still very tight with a lot of the boys at Tottenham, including the new ones like Solanke. I found that slightly strange as well, I've got to be honest with you. I think it would have been the right time to bring him back and allow Ben Davis maybe to move on to Wrexham as he was heavily linked with earlier on in the window.
49:41Jack:Got a good question here from Mittal who says, what is life like for a 16-year-old who joins as a scholar? Do they have five days a week training? Do they still have some form of education? Do they live in digs? What does the average 16 to 18-year-old earn at Tottenham? Yeah. Earnings changes based on the player. There used to be a strict guideline if everybody got the same. When Tottenham lost Jadon Magomar and Sam Amo Amayor to Southampton a couple of years ago, Tottenham ripped up that strategy. And I know now they're offering scholarships to players even as young, and a guaranteed scholarship even as young as kind of under-14s.
50:19So they've totally changed their tap to match what Man City, Chelsea and other clubs are doing. That was led by Fabio Paratici when he reviewed the structure at Tottenham. So the money some players are getting is different from others. So there's not a set of guidelines anymore. You imagine the Luca Williams Barnett, the Jani Byfield, the Malachi Hardys, the England Youth Internationals are getting more than some of the others. Oliver Boast, who's just been signed from Leeds this summer for a million pounds. You imagine he's getting more than some of the others, but I don't know. The average week, so they train Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Friday.
50:52obviously have matches on Saturdays Thursdays they have a day of full education so on Thursdays it was Stuart Lewis but it's now his replacement Joe Staunton they seemingly are not there and the players go into Hotspur way and education is put on for them for a whole day and they do a full day of basically learning skills so as if you come out with football there's other pathways available for you because obviously look it's every year at that level, you're getting reviewed, you're getting reassessed and you're kind of unsure if you're being kept on. However, that has changed, as I said, with players as young as 14 now, some of them, I think there's a goalkeeper, Mikel Jack, there's this young striker, Asher Houghton, Sinclair Houghton, that I already know are on four-year deals, which is a massive, massive change and it gives them a real guarantee of longevity at Tottenham and stops other clubs from being able to poach them.
51:48Jack:with players like you know i'm just interested to know like what your understanding of the way the academy works and everything with say a player like boast i mean a million pounds is a is a significant sum of money for for a young player right you know take a take aside like an archery gray when we're talking about signing somebody directly for the academy how is the case made to get the money essentially to just to sign a player um who's that young to play academy football? I think this summer, it wasn't a kind of proactive signing, if I'm being honest with you. I think it was a reactive signing too.
52:23Tottenham had a very talented young player called Dexter Oliver, who was in the same position as Boast, or sometimes a little bit deeper as a kind of number 10. Last year, he couldn't get in the team because of Lucas Williams-Barnett's form. And I think that led to him and his agent exploring, let's not sign the scholarship of Tottenham to be part of their intake for this year. Let's see what else is on offer. And he's gone to Manchester City. He's currently going through the FA's seven-stage review because obviously Tottenham offered him a deal and didn't want to lose him. And he's chosen to go elsewhere, hence the lack of official announcement on that yet.
52:56So I think when Tottenham lost Dexter, they reacted by thinking to themselves, we played in this under-16s Nationals tournament. Who completely tore us apart? Well, it was Oliver Bost. Every parent I spoke to in that age group have told me that Oliver was the top player in that tournament. And for Tottenham to have approached him, they feel like they can get a player out of Leeds. They feel like they're above them in the pecking order, can offer more money, can offer a better deal to the family. And there's obviously a space in the team with the departure of Dexter Oliver. But as you said, yes, a lot of money.
53:28And that will be a decision made by, you know, firstly, the scouts at Tottenham will approach Simon Davies, the head of the academy. And I'm sure those discussions then happen with Johan Langer, Fabio Paratici and probably even Daniel Levy when you're talking about a transfer of around a million pounds a lot of money but the recent successes when bringing players in for decent sums of money speak for themselves you know I think Will Langshear was signed for two million pounds at a similar age which was seen as a lot of money but now he's you know starting in the championship scoring goals scored for Oxford this weekend we've seen Josh Keighley obviously joined for a decent sum of money there's another Irish boy Mason Melia who will be joining in January move delayed due to Brexit rules that he can't join until he's 18.
54:11But he's already on about four goals in the League of Ireland senior level. So that's actually worked out incredibly well that he's still there and playing. It's like a lone move, you know, when he's getting that game time. So I think Tottenham have got much, much better when recruiting for money. However, there have been some disappointments. They've recruited a couple of lads from Man City's academy that within five minutes of watching them, I think I and many of the other people that watch these academy games could tell weren't at the level of our existing players. So there are still gaps they need to fill.
54:43Like in any industry, there's always improvements that need to be made. But I think Oliver Boast is seen as, when he's a starting striker for England at that specific age group, I said, ran Tottenham Ragged at this national tournament and was highly regarded as the best player there, or one of. They saw that as an investment worth making and a gamble worth making.
55:02Jack:Halliman Tottenham says I would like to ask do the significant influences of Dan Chapman, Simon Jones and especially Simon Davis compare to John McDermott yeah totally different ideologies I think the first guy's name was Jack Chapman, he came from Southampton everything I've heard so far is that he hasn't actually brought anybody in of his recommendations so I wonder how long he'll actually be at Tottenham. Simon Davies obviously came in from Manchester City and we've seen a raft of Manchester City players join the academy that to me have all not been up to the level of our existing player base.
55:43So I also wonder there how long he'll be at Tottenham. So I think we're going to see changes again fairly soon on that front. Whereas John McDermott was there for a significant period of time, was very strict on his wage structure and principles. Obviously, that's gone out of the window, Fabio Paratici, but I think we could see a lot of changes in Tottenham's academy again very, very soon in terms of the leadership team there. So I've kind of watched this space for that one because I think there'll be more changes soon.
56:11Jack:And a sort of a follow-up question to this was, are the losses of Dean Rastrick, Chris Scudder and Chris Perkins significant in terms of youth scouting, et cetera?
56:24Chris Perkins was effectively relieved of his duties following the signings of those Manchester City boys I've just mentioned. So he was brought in, he brought those lads, he was seen as the full guy for them not being up to the required level. And Chris Perkins is no longer at the club. Dean Rastrick, who's left a highly experienced, well-regarded in academy circles and is of the sort of old school style, which can still take you a long way. So as I said, I just think there's going to be lots of changes behind the scenes at Tottenham with the academy coming up because some of those guys haven't delivered as well as Tottenham would have hoped they would have done.
57:04Jack:Let's move on for... Dan, so at Hixie Dan says, what's your planned coping mechanism for when the SA transfer inevitably falls through? And he actually sent this before the SA transfer fell through, so that's why. It hasn't come through before. Yeah, I'll give him the props. But the coping mechanism for me personally is going to just be reminding myself of how good Kudos is compared to the level I thought he was going to be. The fact that I think that he's very quickly going to be regarded as one of the best players in the Premier League. The fact that by the end of this season, if he carries on the trajectories on now, I think his market value will be double what we paid for him.
57:43And I don't mean that. I think if he carries on as he is, I think the fact that we touched on earlier, that you get the ability of two players rolled into one, I just think it's fantastic. Massive, massive point on kudos is that, amazingly, Ghana didn't qualify for AFCON.
58:02Jack:I knew they didn't, didn't they? Yeah, Pagarin. Ghana are normally one of the absolute winners to win that tournament. The fact that they haven't qualified as well. So when many other clubs are losing their players for AFCON in January, we're still going to have kudos there for what's always a massive part of the season with loads of games quickly piling up is another huge plus to him. The final coping mechanism will be that let's hope it rushes Tottenham into getting another player. But as I said, I'm not sure if Savino for 80 million, I think Savino's a good player, but I don't think he's an 80 million player.
58:33So let's see what else they can do. And I mentioned Paqueta earlier as a kind of left fielder option that I think would be very good.
58:39Jack:If we're talking 80 million pounds, like breaking our record transfer. I want it to be someone with a bit more profile. And maybe that makes me a bit basic. But I'm sure Savino is a great player. I'm just... I don't think it gives the club the same lift as even signing... Had we signed Eze, you know? Yeah. But I think there is... It sounds... Tottenham fans won't want to hear this, but I don't think you put yourself in a bad position in the market if you sort of take the cast-offs or those that don't make it at Real Madrid, PSG, Bayern maybe. You know, look at how good Asensio was for Aston Villa.
59:16They got him in January last year. I'm not quite sure why they haven't got him back yet because no one else has got him. But what a difference he made. He had a kind of like Van der Vaart-style immediate impact on that Villa team. And it lifted them, you know, into finishing as high as they did in the table. It allowed them to sell Jean Duran for 100 million or whatever they got. you know so there are market opportunities out there if you pick up from the absolute best clubs and I know you know we've not talked about him as yet on this pod but I think Paulinho is going to be a fantastic signing for Tottenham I really really do you know he's someone that buying forked out 46 million or whatever literally 12 months ago and we're now picking him up on loan with an option to buy we don't even have to buy him we could use him for 12 months Archie Gray learns shed loads off him over the next 12 months and towards the end of the season and we start filtering Archie Gray in instead of Paulina, and we just send him back.
1:00:08So there are great market opportunities there. I mean, I think Paulina will be very good, and what will probably happen is we'll agree a deal that's significantly less than the£30 million agreed price at the moment, like we saw with Matisse Tell, where it was at£50 million, and then we got him for£30 million. I think there'll be some leeway there when Paulina will be, you know, that year old next year. But there are good market opportunities to get out there if you're willing to take a punt on some of these players. You know, I don't see how Asensio, when he did what he did, doesn't get a squad role at PSG.
1:00:37I know they're stacked on the wings with Barcola and Douay and Caval Skellier amongst others. But I just think Asensio is a great player and it shows that you can get, you know, fantastic players from these massive clubs.
1:00:50Jack:Think about, I mean, I can't remember exactly who they signed him for, if I'm truth be told, but when you talk about bringing a certain profiler player, look at Wolves even bringing in an old Giaumatinho and how much of a lift he gave him. And it also, it was particularly painful because it just made me, it reminded me of the summer where we didn't quite manage to get that deal done. And it was a very, what could have been kind of thing, wasn't it? Michael at Dyer Spotless Bow says, please compare Isak getting pelters for forcing his way out whilst Kane got cheered on to leave Spurs. Is it simply because he hasn't gone golfing with Gary Neville?
1:01:29Jack:I mean, I know this is obviously framed in quite a comedic fashion there by Michael, But there is something in that, right? We definitely felt the weight of the British footballing commentariat saying Harry Kane has to leave Tottenham. It's right that he's going on strike. He deserves a big move. He's going to win nothing at Spurs, blah, blah, blah, blah. We don't need to revisit all of that. Whereas in Izak, it's unanimous condemnation. And look, I'll say up front, I think the way Isak is handling this situation is ill-advised, to say the least. I don't think it reflects very well on him whatsoever.
1:02:08Jack:But I do notice there is a distinct difference in the way these two things are spoken about, aren't they? I think the legacy those two players leave on their two clubs and what they've done today are totally different. Harry Kane is an academy boy that came through at Tottenham, became our all-time top goal scorer. England's top goal scorer did so so much for Tottenham renewed his contract for six years in 2019 with no dramas no talks of going anywhere else whilst we were playing at three different stadiums in one year and all that sort of thing I've really struggled actually even in light of how the outpouring of love towards Sonny I've seen some use as a dig at Harry Kane and I'm just not on board with that whatsoever for me Harry Kane is our greatest ever player certainly in my lifetime of watching Tottenham and gave so much for the club and I think it would have killed him you know watching us lift that Europa League there's nobody that would have liked to have done that more than Harry Kane and it's sad that it aligned like that because I would have loved to be in the bedroom and have that photo of Harry Kane lifting that trophy this boyhood club would have meant the world to him and us as fans I found that difficult Just to jump in there John as well because I do feel that was the one thing because I did sort of feel after that, you know, when everyone was like, why isn't he congratulating us on the Europa League?
1:03:31Jack:Why hasn't he done it yet? It's like, come on, man. It's because he's sad about it. It's quite obviously because he's sad about it, you know? Yeah. In a conflicted way, I'm sure he's, whatever, I'm sure he's happy Spurs won the Europa League. You know, as a fan, I'm sure he's happy, Christ, Tottenham got over the line and whatever, but he would have loved. And even when you saw Kyle Walker, he did an interview. He doesn't have that same affiliation that Harry Kane does, but he still has an affiliation to Tottenham, make no mistake about that. Go out of his way and say he would have given up one of his Premier League titles just to have been a part of that Tottenham team.
1:04:00And I remember Kyle Walker even maybe three years into his Man City stint, Tottenham were playing the semi-final against Chelsea at Wembley in the FA Cup. And he was saying, my God, I hope Tottenham get this over the line. I hope Tottenham win. They deserve it. Their fans deserve it. So Kane would have absolutely been torn at watching his boyhood club literally a year after he's left getting over the line. And for me, the Europa League is a much bigger trophy than the Bundesliga, in terms of its stature in world football. So that would have been tough for him to see. And that's why he wasn't immediately at the social...
1:04:34And he's not that character either. You have to respect people who are different. They've got different personalities. He's not a... He's not James Madison, is he? He's not James Madison. He didn't play, but has to be the main event of everything. And has to be... Put the camera on me. I'm not digging out James Madison for that, but they're just different people. They've just got different character quirks, as we all do as humans, you know? So this whole thing of, oh, why isn't he immediately uploading a load of pictures with Sonny and saying, well done, congratulations? He did it, but in his own time, you know?
1:05:05And I was pleased he did it. And I had a dig, you know, I said, well done, King. I knew you wouldn't forget about this or something, you know? Because so many Tottenham fans were bashing him and whatever. When he's done fucking loads for this club, and for years was the figurehead of this club and gave us, you know, he could go to Juventus away and score. He could lead the line for us at Real Madrid away. You know, he was fantastic for Tottenham and I find it difficult when people criticise him.
1:05:33Jack:I mean, you think it's quite simply, he's not just one of the greatest Tottenham players of all time. He's just one of the best players of all time, Harry Kane. And it's, I think it's quite hard to come to terms with the fact that we didn't win anything with him as well, right? And I think what irritates me most about it is that there's a lot of narratives that follow him of like, well, we got to lots of finals and he never scored in any. Thierry Henry never scored in any finals. Mo Salah never scored any non-penalty goals in finals. Big players get marked out of finals. Big game, like teams, opposition teams build their whole strategy around stopping Harry Kane scoring a goal in a cup final.
1:06:12Jack:It's not on him. Yeah, I'm much the same with you, mate. I might just have the odd comedic, bitter dig about it, but he's somebody I will always feel very defensive over and somebody who's undeniably given me some of my best memories in my entire lifetime as a Spurs fan. That photo of him coming off the picture on the last game against White Hart Lane when he's being mobbed is iconic to me. It's one of the most iconic Tottenham photos of all time. so you know and it's just that story will it won't ever be matched you know I saw not long ago there was that comparison made between like well it was always more exciting watching Gareth Bale than it was Harry Kane it's like that's just recency you're just focusing on the last few years where it was horrible for Tottenham at large the first few years of Harry Kane breaking through like the mask goal against Arsenal the goals against Chelsea the goals from all over the place that he would score all the time seeing this kid come through the academy me it was incredible it was it was so exciting normalizing scoring at anfield and arsenal way you know every season you know just that sort of thing just just a point you made there just iconic photos that stick with you just one i want to i've got a framed one downstairs here uh of an iconic photo it's which i always love and always think about so it's a corner sorry free kick that we score from against arsenal um when they're in that sort of cranberry kit we're under Martin Yole at this point and you've got Ledley powers in the header and scores so you see Ledley rising like a salmon to head it into the bottom corner, he puts us 1-0 up him and Dawson wheel off celebrating I think the game finishes 1-0 but the image is just fantastic so in one angle you've got Ledley rising and then next to him you've got me though basically holding Sol Campbell like that with his arms behind his backs we cannot move and it's just the most Tottenham perfect photo of all time and Ledley powering in the header just beautiful stuff I love it love it I want to there's a few questions about the Eze thing but I think we've spoken about Eze quite a lot
1:08:18Jack:here's a good one from Kirstie Fitchett who says at what point in the summer do you think the other clubs got together to make sure their owners chairmen CEOs made sure Tottenham don't make any decent signings this summer yeah I mean it does seem you know it's obviously a joke but but you can see something there. And I think, does this summer impact our future dealings with Nottingham Forest and also Crystal Palace? Two more clubs that maybe now we can't shift unwanted players to or sign their best players from. Let me ask you a minute. Do you think at all what we're starting to see? Because we've often heard, I'd say we've heard for at least the last decade now, Daniel Levy's a very difficult operator, but he's very shrewd.
1:09:03Jack:He gets the job done. So as much as the press, I think, take swipes at Daniel Levy, I think they are often very quick to praise him as well. I think it's an equal measure a lot of the time. Do you think we've sort of arrived at a point where there's been this legacy that's followed Levy, his style of negotiating, his hardballing, if you like? And do you think we've just arrived at a point where on a personality level, other chairmen just don't like him? and they just don't want to, they don't want to give him the satisfaction of, because it felt, for example, Maranakis in particular, that Morgan Gibbs-White deal felt so personal.
1:09:43Jack:It was clearly, he took it so personally. He was so wound up by the fact that Spurs had found that there was a release clause by, you know, whatever. We don't need to go over all that again. But he just seemed so personally furious about the fact that we might get one over him, get one over the club and made it his mission to get one over Spurs in return, right? Yeah, I mean, whilst you can absolutely see that line of thought, then you have to remember that Levy has been elected to be the head of sort of the European clubs board. So he is obviously widely respected in the game for his business acumen of maybe getting the best deal for clubs.
1:10:25I don't know what that European, but he's very friendly with the owners of PSG, for example, and others that are happy for Levy to be the head of that European Commission or European, you know, Chairman's Board or whatever it is. You know, and obviously they will have watched him build that stadium on very favourable rates compared to what clubs are getting now. They will have watched him, I think he's the longest serving chairman in the Premier League because I think naturally over time, you know, you've been in that role for such a long time, there is the ability to upset people and you're always the common figure there.
1:10:56You're always standing there. but I presume some of them have respect for him in terms of the side away from football and what he's done to grow Tottenham's profile and that kind of thing but I think as you said there is definitely a personal feeling with Levy and we've seen it played out so many times in the press with Alex Ferguson and Pep Guardiola making comments on it before so I think it's just part of being somewhere for so long as to why he has that reputation John
1:11:26Jack:it's been an absolute pleasure to talk to you today mate I really appreciate you giving up your time where can people follow you if they're not, I mean they're already following you but if they want to Yeah we're on X or Twitter as it's commonly known at lilywhite underscore rose and the same for Instagram as well Anything to look out for in the coming weeks at all? Yeah look I think we've got the we're going to have the Champions League draw I think that's really soon back end of August so we're coming into that now I think that will be exciting for the club and that tallies with the return of the Youth Champions League so obviously when you have those match days we'll also have the Youth Champions League earlier on in the day and that's an amazing opportunity we talked about Luca Williams Barnett and others earlier that's your chance to see where these players are really at playing against the best young players of Real Madrid or Barcelona or Bayern Munich whoever we're drawn against the fixtures match so yeah great opportunity to I'm sure those games will be on Spurs play as well so great opportunity to watch those young players see how they're getting on and make your own judgments on where they are.
1:12:24Jack:John, thanks very much, mate. Legend. Thanks, mate. Speak soon.
1:12:51Jack:contracts. Save 50 % on your new system with professional monitoring at simply safe.com slash Spotify or with promo code Spotify. Outdoor deterrence requires a simply safe active guard outdoor protection plan starting at$49.99 a month. Visit simply safe.com slash licenses for alarm license information. Tennessee two zero one two. Hey, it's Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. Now I was looking for fun ways to tell you that Mint's offer of unlimited premium wireless for $15 a month is back. So I thought it would be fun if we made$15 bills, but it turns out that's very illegal so there goes my big idea for the commercial give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch upfront payment of$45 for 3 months $90 for 6 months or$180 for 12 month plan required $15 per month equivalent taxes and fees extra initial plan term only greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy see terms
From the publisher
Jack is joined by John (aka Lilywhite Rose) for this week’s Thursday Q&A, where the frustration of the collapsed Eberechi Eze deal takes centre stage. With Arsenal swooping in at the last minute, was this another case of Daniel Levy’s drawn-out negotiations costing Tottenham, or is there any comfort to be found in missing out?
John brings his expertise on Spurs’ academy to the table, discussing the progress of Alfie Devine and Jamie Donley and whether either could have played a role in solving Tottenham’s need for a number 10. Listener questions also spark debate on Luca Williams Barnett, Arsenal’s Max Dowman, and the best young talent John has ever seen come through the Spurs academy.
The pod closes with a spirited defence of Harry Kane because some things never change.
Theme music is Ghost Cat by Gillen.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices




