In short
Tottenham’s poor start to the Premier League season is blamed on squad-building mistakes (lack of box presence), a lack of club “process” and joined-up thinking, and mental fragility in matches—especially after conceding early. The episode also discusses whether Spurs are “too big” to sign certain players, the value of physical attributes vs football intelligence, and the “Vušković decision” (a squad/transfer choice referenced but not detailed in the transcript).
Guest backgrounds
Harry Brooks is a professional football coach working with Premier League players currently.
Key claims
Spurs aren’t scoring or winning; they collapse after failing to score in the first 15–20 minutes; the club keeps changing managers without giving them tools; spending more money doesn’t guarantee success; Spurs lack players dominant in attacking/defending boxes; physicality is misunderstood (balance/agility matters more than being big).
Notable examples
Spurs’ home defeats vs Everton and Aston Villa (3-0 down); comparisons to Brighton/Brentford player development; mention of Solanke’s fitness concerns; Buendia scoring inside the box; Brighton’s Konza/Rice passing example; Brentford’s “Sangari” and Arsenal/Man City “not good enough” recruitment logic; Langshire scoring for Middlesbrough.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOWelcome Harry Brooks
1:08 to 1:42
Harry Brooks joins to discuss the current state of Tottenham.
“Prices, values, and available markets may differ from those mentioned.”
Welcome Harry Brooks
1:46 to 2:38
Harry Brooks joins to discuss the current state of Tottenham.
“This Friday, return to theaters for Avengers Endgame Encore.”
Emotional Perspectives on Spurs
2:41 to 7:20
Discussion on fan sentiments and Harry's professional insights on Spurs' issues.
“What a way to make your Rule the Roost debut, Mr Harry Brooks.”
Analyzing Tottenham's Tactical Problems
7:21 to 12:08
Exploration of Spurs' tactical issues and the need for key player components.
“I think there's different extremes to it, right?”
Evaluating Tottenham's Current Squad
14:27 to 18:22
Discussion on the struggles and mindset of Tottenham players amidst recent challenges.
“I mean, one of the things I've sort of heard bandied about, I guess one of the things I've kind of felt when I've tried to look for answers as a fan as to what the hell is going on.”
The Challenges of Squad Building
18:22 to 22:38
Analyzing Tottenham's approach to squad building and the lack of a coherent strategy.
Presence in Key Areas of the Pitch
22:38 to 26:04
Discussion on the importance of having presence in both attacking and defensive boxes.
“the tools of what you employed them for.”
Analyzing the Villa Game Performance
26:04 to 28:04
Reviewing the performance against Aston Villa, focusing on fragility and game management.
“You know, they did have one person, but they haven't registered him.”
Analyzing Spurs' Mental Fragility
28:04 to 29:44
Discussion on Tottenham's recent performances and mental challenges.
“Now listen, De Zerbe can't just look at the players for that.”
Analyzing Spurs' Mental Fragility
29:45 to 30:02
Discussion on Tottenham's recent performances and mental challenges.
“As you celebrate the game, take a deeper look at its roots.”
Show all 22 chapters
Simplifying Football Complexity
31:00 to 40:04
Exploration of the perceived complexities in football and Spurs' struggles.
Spurs' Box Presence and Squad Decisions
40:05 to 42:01
Discussion on Spurs' lack of dominance in both boxes and squad choices.
“For whatever reason, it's not happening with Richarlison and, you know, we just have to take that as a given now.”
The Importance of Box Presence
42:01 to 43:15
Understanding the critical role players must have in attacking and defending boxes for success in football.
“So then how can they, so if you haven't got the thing that most goals are scored or conceded from in your team, how are you expecting to be successful?”
Financial Fair Play and Squad Building Concerns
43:16 to 44:42
Discussion on Tottenham's spending strategy and the implications of financial fair play.
“It almost feels like Spurs made this sort of rod for their own back this summer.”
Evaluating the Tonali Signing
44:43 to 45:55
Debate on the merits of Tonali's signing and its impact on the team dynamics.
“And also, I'm sorry, I'm not having the financial fair play excuse after the money they've just spent in the summer.”
The Role of Players and Expectations
45:56 to 48:28
Discussion on player roles, expectations, and the importance of mastering ball control.
“I sort of feel like we've got to drop Rodrigo Bentancur and play Fernandes in his correct position.”
Revisiting Player Transfers and Future Prospects
48:29 to 52:19
Reflection on Tottenham's player transfer decisions and their future implications for the squad.
“But, you know, if you ask me right now who do I think is better out of Benton Curran and Tonali, I think it's Benton Curran.”
Analyzing the Vušković Decision
52:20 to 56:00
Critique of the decision to let Luka Vušković go and its ramifications for the team.
“Perhaps behind the scenes there, it's like different things as to why he hasn't moved and maybe he's thinking one more year at Palace too.”
Evaluating the Vuskovic Decision
56:00 to 58:56
A discussion on the potential mistake of selling Vuskovic and its implications.
Assessing Tottenham's Current Squad
58:56 to 1:01:05
An analysis of Tottenham's current squad dynamics and their recent performances.
“Because soon or late, you can find yourself adrift.”
Impact of the International Break
1:01:05 to 1:02:31
Discussing the consequences of the international break on Tottenham's momentum.
“He did get called up, but he said he's not going to go.”
Harry Brooks on Youth Development
1:02:31 to 1:04:52
Harry discusses youth development and opportunities within football coaching.
“and, you know, some people don't like it, but are we going to see him again feasibly as a top draw Tottenham player again?”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Jack:Welcome back to Rule the Roost. Yes, it's one of those annoying ad read type things at the top of a podcast you're looking forward to listening to. Thanks for tuning in. Just a quick request before I start. If you want to help support the show this season, please leave me a rating on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. You can drop me a follow on Instagram at Ted Trunk or if you really fancy, head over to patreon.com slash RTR pod for extra episodes and access to the Discord community. All of these things really help the podcast to get discovered by more Spurs fans, and it keeps the show growing for the new campaign.
0:34Jack:Thanks for the support, and now, on with the show. Before the season even kicks off, soccer fans are already making predictions. Who wins the league? Who qualifies for Europe? And who's lifting the trophy at season's end? On Calci, America's number one prediction market platform, you're trading against peers in a live market, meaning there's no house. And as the probability changes, you can buy in and out of your position. For a limited time, download the CalShea app and use code CUP26 to get$10 when you trade 10. K-A-L-S-H-I, CalShea. Trade the beautiful game. 18 plus only restrictions and eligibility requirements apply.
1:07Jack:Event contract trading involves risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Prices, values, and available markets may differ from those mentioned. For more information, see calshea.com slash regulatory. Before this, there's this. As you celebrate the game, take a deeper look at its roots. The people grow in the grass, paving the lots, welding the goalposts, inspecting every football. The hardworking people that make every Sunday possible. Carhartt is proud to outfit the crews behind the game. Visit carhartt.com slash join the trades to learn more. This Friday, return to theaters for Avengers Endgame Encore.
1:51Jack:I know I said no more surprises, but I was really hoping to pull off one last one. Reassemble the team. Six stones. Three teams. One shot. Relive the experience. You mess with time, time tends to mess back. The story continues. Tony, this is a second chance. Don't miss Marvel Studios Avengers Endgame Encore. Early theaters Friday. Get tickets now. Rated PG-13. Maybe inappropriate for children at 13.
2:38Jack:Hello everybody, welcome back to Rule the Roost podcast. Bottom of the league. What a way to make your Rule the Roost debut, Mr Harry Brooks. Welcome to the show, thank you for joining me mate. I mean, is it a silly question to ask how you're getting on? I'm all right, mate. I'm good. Yeah, I'm sure we would have preferred it to be in better circumstances. But it's a long, old season. It's a long, old season. So let's see. Yeah, but thanks for having me on, mate. Obviously a big fan of what you do. So no, I'm looking forward to it. Cheers. Well, look, you know, I'll let people know, I've obviously seen you speak to Flav quite a lot down the years.
3:13Jack:I've seen you on James Alcott's pod. So I thought, you know, I'll get you into the Royal The Roots company. Neil, I saw you talking on Twitter yesterday saying that, you know, you're not, what is it, you're sort of like a bit of a persona non grata you felt like this season because people think you're a bit negative or something about everything that's going on at Spurs. I mean, what is it that you feel that you're not happy with, I guess? Because I'll say I've been getting quite a lot of stick this season already for being called negative and I feel like I'm just simply highlighting that Spurs not scoring goals or winning games is not great.
3:48Yeah, I get it. And listen, fans want to be excited. And they've had, you know, two years of 17th, 17th. I know there was the European Cup win in that, but 17th, 17th. And all of a sudden, they're spending money like they never have done before, which is what people have been wanting for so many, so many years. You know, money's been spent on players with big reputations. There's that whole Premier League proven thing that, you know, fans get excited about as well. And so I get it. I get they want to be excited. but you know it's very difficult because I'm not I don't come from a fan's point of view doing what I do know my job I work in football so I just try to look at things as black and white now I'm very emotional I'm a very emotional person but that doesn't mean that I'm just a happy clapper or a negative Nancy it's just looking at the reality of what I see and if I look at the process of how Spurs have behaved in the past two to three years including the summer just gone I think it's unacceptable and listen of course Spurs fans will hope I end up being wrong and of course it's too early to say and I'm not saying that this is how it's going to continue but if I had to put my money on it I'm not saying that I don't think we'll get relegated but I don't think it becomes perhaps the the journey overall that fans want and we could go into loads of reasons as to why I think that is um but I just think that you know if you just try to look at I know football's a a mad business and it's not the same as something else but if you just looked at if is it black and white and you looked at the behaviors of how they've run as a business and you any other any other business in the world that done that people go like you're mental what are you doing this isn't how you run a successful business in terms of performance but there's so many things that go into that and i'm just i'm just talking in reality and because people are excited and also it's twittering online everybody's going to hate you for something so it is what it is but no but i do I do get it.
5:38Listen, I have sympathy for the fans because, you know, Spurs is probably the biggest club that's underperformed so much for what it should be for years and fans are rightfully sick of it. You know, how much seasons it gets cost and they all go into it all day long. So I get why they just want to be positive and obviously it hasn't really been the start of the season for them to enjoy.
5:56Jack:I mean, that's it, isn't it? People want that escape and sometimes they just want to think it's going to be all right. It's a coping mechanism, isn't it, sometimes? but I think often people will negate the fact that people are coming at it from different angles for whatever reasons I know people always say like me doing a podcast and stuff you know you just want to like monetize it being miserable you've seen what I've I had that the other day someone said you saw what Arsenal fan tv have done and you kind of want to do that it's like I hate to break it to you but like with my viewership and everything like that I'm not I'm not retiring anytime soon like this is kind of more fun but you know from your perspective you're coming at this like you know if anyone isn't aware obviously harry is a is a professional coach he coaches players who are actively playing in the premier league and stuff right now so i guess when you're talking about this you're not doing it for like salacious clicks you're not doing it to create uh to create a bigger sort of um profile based off the back of like being negative online right it's just i don't perspective to be honest it doesn't benefit me in any way I don't know why I did it so yeah good now go on mate no I just I just I just you know like I do just look at it in terms of what I see and I'm not gonna I'm not gonna be a happy couple for the sake of it but again because I'm not coming at it from a fan's point of view you know and it is you know I'm sure listen it's probably not the right thing to say on the Spurs podcast but I care about my players more than I will ever care about a club you know so put it this way if one of my players is playing against Tottenham one day well then I'm obviously going to try and help them be the best they can be that day and whatever and so on so on but again i do i do get where fans come from you know because they just want to be as you said earlier it's spot on it's an escape and they want to be excited and they should be excited you know because it is a huge club and they were spending money um and if you can't be excited and drink then what's the point of it all so i do get it but that doesn't then mean that i'm going to necessarily change my opinion just because you know they've thrown a lot of money at it do you know what i mean yeah of course you know i I think also, you know, a wide array of opinions is sort of healthy, isn't it?
7:58Jack:I don't know. I think there's different extremes to it, right? But I kind of feel like in some ways we sort of come into this place where, because there is so much bile and unpleasant stuff online, I guess we've sort of all hunkered down into our little tribes, if you like. And when you hear somebody that says something somewhat outside of what it is that you want to accept within your bubble, then maybe people lash out a bit more than they would have done in the past. I don't know. This is probably a whole other podcast into itself, and I'm probably not qualified to be fully talking about this.
8:30Jack:But, I mean, look, let's look at the reality of Spurs right now. We're sat at the bottom of the Premier League, heading into the international break. There's been a lot of talk the past few weeks about Spurs' gradual improvement, yet we're not scoring goals. I mean, we did score two against Villa, I hasten to add, but let's say we've not gone ahead in a game yet. We haven't won a game yet in the Premier League. um we looked a bit better against liverpool at anfield the other night and i think that gave a lot of people a bit of hope um that things are going to click if you like what i put to you though harry and i'd be interested in your perspective on because when i when i look at spurs i don't i agree with a lot of the positive opinions i don't see a terrible football team if i'm brutally honest but my my worry is i see a decent football team that is lacking some of the requisite parts to be a fully functioning football team so this idea that things are going to click suddenly that we're suddenly going to have a number nine that is well suited to this system that is fully fit that is able to score a lot of goals and a backup for that player as well as well as say defensive cover Pedro Poro a few other things right it's it's not about a system clicking that's about Tottenham lacking some key fundamental parts to actually be successful right the makeup of football when people say the game has changed it it's an overstatement of course the game changes the game changes day by day but the crux of it and this sounds like a really silly thing to say but the one of the best people I ever worked with actually was it was the one that helped change Palmeiras Academy and turn them into for me the best powerful academy in the world and on the top of his um thesis he says people have forgotten that the job of football is to score more goals than the opposition, right?
10:18So the crux of what happens actually hasn't changed and it hasn't changed while the ball is still rolling. It's 11 v 11. Most goals are scored inside the box. Most goals, you know, score more goals than the opposition. And it just feels like what I look like, what I look at Tottenham is it looks like they're gearing towards how an academy team might play, where it's like, there's lots of things that may look pretty on the eye and what people may say is attractive, but when it comes to the nuts and bolts of how to win football games, they're lacking in huge key areas and they can't get away with it nowadays by just being better than opposition or by supposedly having better players than clubs because they don't Bournemouth have fantastic players and they're i think don't think they've won a game yet um you know clubs the premier league now all the clubs are rich and where players are being developed quite often the same way across the boards they end up producing similar level of players so there's very few superstars nowadays that can get you out of trouble in comparison to what the rest have years and years ago you know you could almost be a big performing club but almost be a bit i'm not saying you could get it wrong off the pitch but you could almost get away with it because you would just have players that are far better than the other teams that was spurs for a long time right you know we'd
11:30Jack:have a sharing them a berbata for robbie keane whatever that would dig us out of the trenches and we and but football's always been won by the best players that hasn't changed it's not the system that wins football like the the best systems help profile your best players and i think that people have taken we spoke this off there before and i think people have taken pep guardiola's success a bit too literally um but spurs don't have the level of players now that are that much better than the rest of them so they're missing lots of that as you said the sort of nuts and bolts of actually how to win football games um and ignoring actually what does bring success in football across the board without having players are genuinely that much better than what's around them because they're not that much better than what's around them and we've seen this is again like the Premier League tax and how I think actually clubs are going to have to come away from that because the popular one this year was Sangari at Brentford and like you know well why why is he automatically a worse player than a Tonali well he's not well we don't know he could be but he might not be but just because he's there so just because it's Brentford just because it's Tottenham just because it's Premier League just because it's Ligue 1 or whatever doesn't automatically mean that he is automatically better or worse or whatever and i think spurs have perhaps um almost played football manager a little bit uh and it's not quite um yeah it's not geared towards long-term success for me before the season even kicks off soccer fans are already making predictions who wins the league who qualifies for europe and who's lifting the trophy at season's end on calci america's number one prediction market platform you're trading against peers in a live market, meaning there's no house.
13:03Jack:And as the probability changes, you can buy in and out of your position. For a limited time, download the Calci app and use code CUP26 to get$10 when you trade 10. K-A-L-S-H-I, Calci. Trade the beautiful game. 18 plus only restrictions and eligibility requirements apply. Event contract trading involves risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Prices, values, and available markets may differ from those mentioned. For more information, see calci.com slash regulatory. Before this.
13:32Jack:There's this. As you celebrate the game, take a deeper look at its roots. The people grow in the grass, paving the lots, welding the goalposts, inspecting every football. The hardworking people that make every Sunday possible. Carhartt is proud to outfit the crews behind the game. Visit carhartt.com slash join the trades to learn more. This Friday, return to theaters for Avengers Endgame Encore. I know I said no more surprises, but I was really hoping to pull off one last one. Reassemble the team. Six stones. Three teams. One shot. Relive the experience. You messed with time. Time tends to mess back.
14:16Jack:The story continues. Tony, this is a second chance. Don't miss Marvel Studios' Avengers Endgame Encore. Early theaters Friday. Get tickets now. I mean, one of the things I've sort of heard bandied about, I guess one of the things I've kind of felt when I've tried to look for answers as a fan as to what the hell is going on. You know, we've spent all this money and we look, honestly, at times, like it looks even more hopeless than last year, which is kind of mad to say to a certain degree. But one of the sort of things that's bandied around a lot is this sense that, I guess when you look at, say, some of the players that we have like among the savio players like that these are players that are deemed perhaps not good enough for i mean quite literally for manchester city or for an arsenal or for a liverpool maybe and so the next port of call is i mean james madison's another example right tottnham is the next port of call after those teams if you're not quite at that elite kind of wedge spurs will be quite a good home for you but a lot of people are kind of seeing that as like when you arrive at spurs you've got this lovely big stadium you've got this plush training ground you probably get paid a fat salary you're in london i mean as somebody that works with players do you buy that idea that players would come to a club like spurs and think well i'm never going to be good enough for those top clubs i'm here now i've got my salary and all those other things i can kind of just coast a bit there's no rule to it um and a player players do care right it's very very rare that you find a player that doesn't care about um playing football and playing football to a high level, right?
15:51This is most of their dreams from a young boy and they've grown up to do it and they love him. And even if you just think selfishly, well, the better they do, the more success they have, the more financially prudent they'll, you know, the more financial gain they'll get. So it's too easy to say that they don't care and most players do care, but there's so much that goes into the makeup of what makes a player successful overall. And it's very rare to have a player that has the talent and the stick ability to be relentless in your ability to be good all the time. you know and usually those players go to the top of the game and i think i think you're right spurs are sort of in that weird it's not the middle ground because it's above the middle but they're in that weird element where perhaps the top top level players don't want to go and join them because of where they're at currently but they feel that they're too big to go and get the singaris so they're in that weird element where they feel like perhaps we need to get players that are willing to come but perhaps the other lot won't have but then are there reasons why the other lot won't have them i think every situation you've got to look at in isolation but um yeah spurs are in that weird situation where they probably look at like i said you know imagine put it this way right i'm a huge fan of krupy and um i don't think it would have taken that much research when krupy was playing in league two to look at him and go this kid is unbelievable like you know we can see the trajectory but imagine if spurs had signed that as their as their starting number nine when he was in league two imagine the pressure in inverted commas on the manager imagine the anger from the fans what are we doing so there are i'm not saying i'll be brutally honest i'd probably be moaning about it on here that's the thing no of course and that's but i think that's where like the the club needs to be braver and and look at the it just feels like there's a lack of process at the club and i'm not saying that every club has a process there's always going to be some element of like well things have to change you can have you can have the most locked in process you could want every time there's a manager there's of course going to be variants and change and whatever but there has to be some element of structure and process as to why we're doing certain things and it just feels at the moment very very random and that they've got a manager in that you know they almost feel obligated to back because of him saving the club last year from utter disaster and just giving him all the money but again without really kind of a process and that just isn't how any successful business or club should ever be run that has nothing to do with being against a zerby that's just not how any club should ever run of course you need to help the manager and you know give the manager the tools but it doesn't mean you throw everything at the manager and go well here you go you've got all the keys to the kingdom and do it your way no matter what blah blah blah and i'm not saying it is as black and white as that but it's certainly gone too far that way i think and yeah there just doesn't seem to be a natural process to how tottenham are going to be successful it's like they're trying to hopefully land on it by throwing enough money at it and hopefully it works and it lands on it but that's not that's not joined up thinking and you you can't be consistently successful if you don't
18:40Jack:have joined up thinking it's funny it's funny isn't it because for so long we yeah you saw Tottenham incrementally improve by doing exactly what say Brighton, Bournemouth, those sort of teams are doing you know we signed your Lennons, your Huddlestones, Dawson and also those sort of players on top a Bale or a Modric or a Berbatov players like that so our scouting used to be quite good we used to show that we could build a team quite organically and give these players an opportunity give i mean we've never been to be honest we've never been the best of giving youth team players minutes but i think we've probably been better than we have been in the last few years there's just that sort of bit to me that wonders if like i think there's i think there's a lot of moving parts to this right but i think in some ways like kane and son were they were a bit of a blessing and i don't really want to say curse but they're a blessing and perhaps they left a bit of a legacy that could be considered something of a curse in that i still just my gut feeling on is on it is that the hierarchy at the club just didn't fully understand what they had in canaan son i don't think they really realized that like the actual level of those two players doesn't come along every day you can't just go out and replace that and you'll be okay again like these are two kind of players that are otherworldly right and we've seen that from the record we've seen that from their partnership and so it feels like we sort of built this business and this infrastructure and this team predicated on the idea that we'd always be performing at that level and it's like we're always trying to chase that it's like a crew analogy we're trying to chase the high right we had the initial high and we're constantly trying to chase it as opposed to like you say after after we've had a reign like Mourinho's and maybe even Conte's right when we've given it that final throw of the dice we had the sort of the last bit of Pochettino's team we thought whether people like it or not let's give it Mourinho let's see if he can get something out of this superstar team as it dies kind of thing he couldn't and so like you say it's like they missed that cue to be like right humble pie time let's take a step back right we got this nice big ground but also let's kind of remember where we are and let's again build it feels like we're just trying to rush it and so when people say when it gets thrown at us that we are trying to be like this sort of like tesco value version of a chelsea or a man united it feels kind of harder to refute because we're just chucking money at like you say these sort of players that it just doesn't fully make sense a lot of the time let's try and like of course i'm not the financial expert i don't know how this much esteem affected things in terms of giving whatever but let's just look at the process of tottenham sports braggling's behaviors right so they had pochettino and a fantastic team and it was never built on so there was already that is like you know recipe for disaster and then they got rid of him and then they got jose in who is very much a i will win now but they didn't give him the tools to win now and then they got um espiroso santo in who was the opposite of that almost in terms of like, I'm not quite sure what Asparo Santo, what the idea there was to be fair.
21:52And then they went back to Conte and then they didn't give him the tools. And now, anyway, they've ended up in a situation now where they've gone and given Deserbi all this money that they've never given anyone else, but a manager that's never shown he can take a club from, from, you know, a grade B to an A - or an A - to an A-star. And you could not get more, like Pochettino's one style, Jose is different. then Santo is very different. Then Conte is very different. Then Poster Coglu is very different. Then Frank is very different. Then Deserby is very different. And it's like, there is no joined up thinking to any of this.
22:26And if you just take away the name of Tottenham Hotspur and just put any business like that, anybody would go, well, of course it's going to fail. Like you're just chopping and changing. And then when you do go down, whatever route you go down, you don't give that person the tools of what you employed them for. So, and again, I think they've just, But behaviours this summer just smacks of desperation if they think they've landed on whether they're right or wrong. That's just opinions. But they obviously believe they've landed on a potentially elite level manager. And they think that he is the one that can take them through that.
22:58And perhaps that is their process. And they go, no, we back this. And we'll see. Only five a time we'll see if that's the case. But I just think the process of the entire club has just been insanity. And I'm a big, I really dislike the illusion that spending more money automatically gives you more of a chance. I really dislike that. I think it's a really lazy narrative because, yeah, okay, by generally speaking, the better players cost more money and therefore the better clubs will buy them and they'll win more often. But it's not a rule. The best Spurs team I've ever seen had, you know, comparatively, a very cheap outlay.
23:33The greatest football team I've ever seen. I think 10 of the 11 players were from the academy at Barcelona. Just throwing money at it isn't the answer. It's about looking good what it is and going and i think the biggest the biggest one of the biggest lies or gaslighting situations is when people say yeah but he's experienced it's like well okay but then what i like to put to people that say experienced is that person's experience is actually proving that they're not that good or that they're at this level but they just think that because he's played a lot of games in the premier league so it's like well surely then it's better to go but actually i look at this player and i think that he has he could be glimitless how far he goes you know that's why i've got a lot of stick for it but that's why i prefer bergval to tonali i'm not saying bergval right now is a better player than tonali but tonali has had years and years and years of playing and proving he is this which is a good player but it's not for me a superstar right and now maybe he could turn into that i don't know but it's like he ticks the experience box whereas if you look at something like bergval okay there is a chance he doesn't become the consistent seven out of ten every week but if i look at something like a bergval i go but that could be something remarkably special like that and I don't think I suppose like Tottenham unless they're going to throw millions at it but millions of bringing in the absolute best players well then how are you going to usurp an Arsenal or a Man City you've got to do that by being bold and being brave and bringing in footballers and working with footballers that actually they haven't they haven't gone for but they could end up being really really special like a crew team because all of a sudden you can end up with a team that you didn't buy them when they're at their top but their top has become better than what they have rather than the experience of like well okay they've proven they're good but they've proven they're not as good as these guys you know and I think the Spurs have gone down that road of like they've done that where they've brought in players that have proven they're okay you're pretty good but not that that good um but haven't done it in a balanced way so it's like it's like they've ignored what actually makes football successful you know and call it as ugly as you want there's no box presence in either of the two boxes.
25:36How are you possibly supposed to win consistent football games if you haven't got presence in the attacking box and your defending box where most goals are scored? It's no logic to any of it. How are you possibly supposed to be successful if you've got next to no presence in the two areas where most goals are scored or conceded? It's wild.
25:55Jack:Well, and that's what worries me. That's the point of being sort of... And when I say presence, it doesn't have to be like a big unit. Presence in just terms of like these players that know how to produce in both of those boxes. You know, they did have one person, but they haven't registered him. They've still got him, but he's even registered for the squad. Yeah. It's mad, isn't it? It's mad to do that and not even replace him. But we'll get into sort of more of that stuff in a bit. I mean, let's look at the actual Villa game itself. Yes. Sorry, I went through that. We've gone 3-0 down. I mean, I know we did score two consolation goals, but again, scoring two goals a year already.
26:32Jack:When you've already shipped three at home is... not great is it really um i mean this is also let's let's not forget this is a villa side that's faced its own sort of share of issues this season ahead of this game um i mean where where where where to you did the failures arise in this game mate and i guess like let's also expand that out as well a two-part question in that it's another hefty defeat at home like how does that keep happening as well. I do agree with the Zerbe in what he said after in terms of, I don't know if it was a real quote. Was it a real quote in terms of him talking about the fragility of the team?
27:11Let me double check that for you, but I think... Whether it is or isn't, but overall, let's say that is a real quote. He spoke about the fragility of the team and listen, that is correct because it's not a coincidence that that's now two home games in a row, Everton and then Villa, where the first 15 to 20 minutes they started, you know, positively or whatever it might be and then you can visibly see the tide turn, right? Whatever happens, but that's how all football games go pretty much. You don't have a team, especially at the top level, you don't have a team dominating from minute zero to minute 90, right?
27:41So let's say a team starts excited and starts powerful and aggressive and create whatever it might be. And they're on the front foot and the ball doesn't go in the back of the net for the first 20 minutes. Okay, that can happen. It's football. And the other team might then have a five, 10 minute period spell themselves, or the game might go flat for whatever reason that can happen that shouldn't panic you and that shouldn't make you just never be able to get it back again but that's what's happening in both those games right they're the two games i've seen recently that i've seen full 90 minutes i can't pretend to have seen the full 90 of liverpool whatever but it is real fragility to start you know on the front foot and then just because you don't score in those first 20 minutes that's like oh my god now it's a disaster we missed our opportunity it's like no there's 70 more minutes plus added time left what are you doing And it's just like they've been built to score in the first 20 minutes, the players.
28:33And if that doesn't happen, then they just go, and either they do what happened against Villa and they just completely collapse and it's like 3-0, then 3-2 obviously, or it happens versus Everton where it's kind of like nothing really happens, to be honest, as it goes on. Now listen, De Zerbe can't just look at the players for that. That's on De Zerbe. He's the one that is steering the ship. But it also does go down to reason. I don't think it's a coincidence. Maybe it's an excuse, but how often this has happened with Spurs over the years. But yeah, we can talk about the tactics of it, of course.
29:06And I've made my thoughts clear of that on Twitter, or whatever it's called. But as a starting point, it is clear that there is a real mental fragility to how Spurs are as a club. And half of that you can understand because they've underperformed so badly for two years. So perhaps there is that nervousness from players thinking like, Jesus, look how bad he was underperforming. So they're always on edge. But you can't have that as an excuse. That's just the reality of the situation you're in. You've got to rise above it. And if you can't rise above it, that's the problem. Before this, there's this.
29:45Jack:As you celebrate the game, take a deeper look at its roots. The people grow in the grass, paving the lots, welding the goalposts, inspecting every football. The hardworking people that make every Sunday possible. Carhartt is proud to outfit the crews behind the game. Visit carhartt.com slash join the trades to learn more. This Friday, return to theaters for Avengers Endgame Encore. I know I said no more surprises, but I was really hoping to pull off one last one. Reassemble the team. Six stones. Three teams. One shot. Relive the experience. You messed with time. time attends to mess back. The story continues.
30:27Jack:Tony, this is a second chance. Don't miss Marvel Studios, Avengers Endgame Encore, early theaters Friday. Get tickets now. Ready PG-13. Maybe inappropriate for children under 13. Every game day, you show up for your team. Now, it's your time. We go V! We go V! Ask your prescriber about We Go V. semaglutide injection 2.4 milligrams a glp1 call 1-833-4-WEGOV or visit wegovi.com to view the medication guide and to learn more about wegovi why wait i mean i guess i'd be interested from your perspective like as somebody that works in football and stuff and it's not to at all undermine your profession but i just wonder if at times i mean would you agree that football perhaps isn't always as complex as we like to make out that it is yeah 100 that players will think you can get a tottenham you can beat him at home and thus they play with they perhaps take that shot that they otherwise might not or it just it just feels like people are quite willing to have a go at the tottenham hotspur stadium because we ourselves haven't made it that fortress football is nowhere near as complex as people make it out you know it's not and i think a lot of that is use for people maybe trying to seem smart i think it's two things online i think a lot of people try to seem smarter than so that it's almost like they are above people and how they talk um and they sort of use complicated job and make it seem like a really complicated process when actually it isn't that complicated a lot of it um and then there's the other end of the spectrum people that sort of work in the game perhaps players would have like an excuse culture because it's built in it's built in and it's like you know oh we can't do that here or this is what football's like it's like well no it doesn't have to be like that you know i got i got caned on um by a lot of arsenal fans which they're really strange um but they uh there was a there was an action in a game when it got it went quite viral of brighton pressing arsenal and of how amazing it was it was a good press but there was a moment when konza could have played quite a simple ball wasn't a difficult ball into rice in front of him who had like 10 to 15 yards of space and it's like if you just showed that to someone that has perhaps never watched football they would probably look at and go why didn't he just pass over there to him and most of the time they would be right but people overcomplicate football because they're so i think they're naturally on the back foot they wanted to be they're pragmatic naturally so they want to make sure don't make mistakes do things the way that we've been designed to do it and um yeah i think the standard of football should be far far better across the board and i think that people massively overcomplicate the game you know um and the best players we've watched the best teams that we've watched they don't overcomplicate the game actually um so there is a lot of that and teams definitely probably i think they whether it's the spurs stadium or whatever there isn't there is no subconscious fear for these players probably coming to top of the stadium and that is an issue um you know you hear about players speak all the time about you know the old sranix ferguson's lot and how you know i hear ex-players speak about they looked at players and they almost like they could tell the opposition knew they were beaten before they'd even stepped on the pitch um how true that is obviously only only players can truly answer that themselves.
33:37Let's never forget, lads, it's Tottenham as well,
33:39Jack:if we're speaking about Alex Ferguson, right? Yeah, things do stand to reason. Now, you know, Spursy is a word that hasn't just been brought out of nowhere. It's not some weird, you know, spell or curse, but it's happened because as a club, there is a soft underbelly. And soft underbelly doesn't just mean going around kicking people. Of course it doesn't. But it just means that if something goes wrong, okay no problem that's life that's football we can ride this out we can adapt and there's very little adaptability about how Spurs play at all right now I just sort of yeah it feels I don't know it just feels like there's something it feels like it's almost like a sort of meme amongst the players almost to score at Tottenham and maybe it's because my only reference point is watching these players when they play against Spurs but it just always feels like each and everyone you know you saw it Valanga the other week or Jackson here that they've got like it's almost like they've got a special celebration lined up for their goal at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium.
34:34Jack:You know, it's just that, it's that kind of, it feels like, it feels like bullying, Harry. That's what it feels like, mate. It feels like they're all bullying us. They won't leave. Just let us win at home, right? Just let us have a bit of fun. I will say this though, obviously the three points, it wasn't, it didn't make a difference, but it was vital that they call it Gallagher. I don't know if it was down as an own goal, but vital that Gallagher got that goal because they needed to get that off their back. they needed to at least score a goal so they don't have to go into the next game now listen that is you are literally scraping the bottom of the barrel there to try and find a positive in that but that is at least one thing now that they don't have to technically have in the back of their mind the next time the next game they go into but yeah nice little assist from Kuzis as well lovely assist yeah lovely yeah I think it's a I think because he's a fabulous player and he had a very difficult injury to recover from that's speaking to physios the thigh that was damaged in that way or the quad you know is a really difficult injury to perhaps come back and that's again but that is where sometimes i do feel sorry for players in the sense of i don't expect the fans on the outside to know all the in and outs but they would be surprised actually how often players do realize what's wrong and do want to be better and do want to do certain things but there's so many things that they feel like they perhaps stop some more heart or hampers it you know and it is the best players are going to rise above that somehow but it is difficult you know for players um to be good all the time because that's kind of what you have to be in football you have to be good all the time.
35:55Jack:I mean, well, let's talk about, I mean, like Solanke. I mean, he's somebody that's drawing a lot of eye out of the back of this. And again, I'm not going to act like I'm above it. I thought it was a fairly pitiful performance from him against Aston Villa. But to your point, I guess this is somebody that we don't fully know his physical state either, right? He's somebody that's been recovering from injuries for a long time. He's basically the only recognised number nine in the team now because the manager's fallen out with Richarlison or whatever. Again, that's the club putting a lot of pressure on this one player who might not be fully fit, right?
36:30Who knows? But he does look physically shot. I mean, I could not believe my eyes of that chance he got on the weekend of just how uncoordinated and heavy the footwork looked. And that was like, you know, you could say that it caught him by surprise, but that was like, the feet just looked so heavy and uncoordinated. And he does look physically shot in a lot of ways. and yeah listen I think that there's too much emphasis put on physicality in terms of the success of it um being the difference maker but there has to be a bare minimum of physicality in this league when everyone else is mobile and can run and things like that if you are a play yourself that actually doesn't have at least a bare minimum of like being able to run and when I say bare minimum still a very high level of course Selenke's still an incredible athlete but I'm talking about if you are someone that's struggling to run and the mobility whatever it that is a big big problem you know um in any league but it is it is a bigger problem this league uh but yeah you have to be able to be mobile and be able to move your feet and coordinate and balance and things like that and yeah he does look physically shot and um it's massively harming his performances and obviously spurs' performances however much goes into that i don't know if that is down to literally him recovering from injury confidence a mix of loads of things who knows but But no, he looked like he was struggling on Saturday.
37:45Jack:If we look this weekend at somebody like Brian Broby, who scored a hat-trick at the Etihad, we sort of speak a lot about the increasingly physical nature of the Premier League that I guess, let's say, Arteta's Arsenal have maybe ushered in or at least been the most popular example of, perhaps not with Spurs fans, but if you get the point I'm making, is that the sort of profile of player that you think is going to work in this system? Because I guess, I think we were linked to Broby at times in the summer. We've also been linked with Mateta. And I know I've sort of turned my nose up at options like that.
38:23Jack:But now I kind of look and think, God, I mean, it almost feels like that's what we're crying out for. I think that people look at physicality a bit wrong. They look at it as like a big, massive unit, whereas actually the most important physicality. So people would look at James Madison, and they try to try looking before the injuries right um because obviously injuries he's had some horrible injuries but people look at james madison they never look at him as like an incredible physical attributes right but actually some of his physical attributes are outstanding and very relevant football he's got an unbelievable balance agility twist and turn shift of weight um that's far more football beneficial than being a big six foot five unit that can't move now obviously listen If you can have an incredible athlete and an incredible touch and all this, then obviously it's great.
39:11But I believe that at the very, very top level, it is the quality of how your brain works and, you know, the technique that is the difference maker, you know. But you have to be able to cope physically and have physical advantages. Like, you know, before we mentioned earlier about Kruppi. I think Kruppi is a fabulous footballer. He has outstanding physical attributes. He's not a six foot five mountain. He's not going to, but he's got great physical attributes. but the thing that makes him so special is his brain, his touch, his whatever. And I think that football has gaslit people into thinking that it's all like physicality nowadays.
39:46Actually, no, that is a part of it. You've got to have it as a bare minimum. You've got to be fit. You've got to be coordinated, things like that. You've got to be able to run. Of course you do. But, you know, the best players and the best teams aren't the best players because they are the biggest or they can run the fastest. That's not what makes them the best.
Read the full transcript
40:04Jack:I mean, I guess let's expand it out then to like, you know, if we're even thinking about Spurs, we've gone into this season with only Solanke. For whatever reason, it's not happening with Richarlison and, you know, we just have to take that as a given now. Do you even look at someone like a Lanxier then and think maybe that? Because when we were getting 20, 25 mil, whatever it was for Lanxier, I kind of thought it seems like fairly good business. I see Academy in part doing what it's supposed to be doing. yeah we want to have players that are ready to play for Tottenham but also the reality of modern football is right that academies are supposed to be money printing machines for football clubs as well to a certain degree but you can't help but look at Langshire firing in goals against Middlesbrough as Tottenham refuse almost to score any and not wonder if we've made the right decision there right yeah I mean yeah I think it's whether whether it should have been Langshire or someone else whatever however you want to word it Spurs have ended up in a situation where they've spent however many millions um and they've ended up in a situation where they don't have a player that is dominant in either box and the one they do have which is dominant in the attacking box they haven't registered to play in the scores that is just the cutthroat of it whether it's well you can say for langshire is whether he's going to be good enough for the premier league or whatever it might be or tottenham like that you know who knows right now no one knows um but you can 100 say that he's someone that he he he lives for what goes on inside that box you know and of course it has to be more to the game and it's not just one on that but he at least knows that part of the game and he knows and he has his his his sort of like the way his brain works is geared towards being successful in those areas in a pitch and like i said how can you expect to be a successful football team if you can't dominate and be successful in either box it is utterly utter insanity that spurs have spent however many millions and have ended up in that position that situation it is it is disgraceful utterly disgraceful actually he does yeah it's just but just but when you when you break it down that simple right where do most goals get scored even if you're not a stats person they get scored inside the box don't they most goals are going on goals like Buendia right most goals in by hook or by crook they get scored inside the box right I think all of football can accept that as like the general situation and then if I asked any you know huge fan of Spurs it's all positive positive and I I asked them, all right, name me one player then that they currently have that is dominant and successful in attacking boxes and defending boxes.
42:30Who would they choose? I don't know anyone. So then how can they, so if you haven't got the thing that most goals are scored or conceded from in your team, how are you expecting to be successful?
42:42So why do they expect to win games? What, because they're dominating the ball and they're getting into the final third a few times? Like, it's not good enough. the process is not good enough and it needs to be simplified as you said earlier football's over complicated they've over complicated it so much to the stage where they've almost not even realized that they've left themselves without six palais of you know a good in the two most important areas of the pitch per se it's wild yeah it just yeah i find it very frustrating when i
43:15Jack:sort of really think about i don't know i even look at someone like a troy parrot that when a a relatively low fee this summer you know it doesn't have to be these players but you are right Troy Parrott throughout his as he's become established in football in terms of the higher levels he's done a fantastic he's made a good start it seems at Real Batiste done some great things in international football so far but he is a player that he knows the box he knows he has these instincts he has these things so it doesn't have to be him but how you can end up in a situation with all that money spent and you don't have a player that is it's crazy yeah it is mental and i'd love someone at the club to actually just try to explain that process in black and white don't start going about roundabout of it just ask do you think that spurs have ended up in a situation where they don't have any player that is dominant in those two areas of the pitch where most goals are scored or conceded i mean it's to your point earlier as well you know about that not every single player needs to be super expensive, right?
44:21Jack:It almost feels like Spurs made this sort of rod for their own back this summer. Because De Zerbe said, I think he said after the Villa game, oh, we would have signed a striker, but we were worried about financial fair play. But it feels like Tottenham got into this place where it's like, no, we have to spend upwards of 50, 60 mil on every single player we buy. You know? To me, that feels lazy. That feels lazy from the... It is. And also, I'm sorry, I'm not having the financial fair play excuse after the money they've just spent in the summer. I'm not getting into that. Sorry, you're not allowed that excuse.
44:51There's certain excuses. I mean, I'm not really an excuse person. I don't believe in excuses. But of course, there are reasons for why things are happening. You're not having the financial fair play card after the money they've spent in the summer. Sorry, no. You guys chose to spend all of that money.
45:05Jack:And it's also like, if that doesn't negate from the fact that, right, if it is a financial fair play issue, then it's poor planning on your part to leave the squad in this kind of position, right? Yeah, if Spurs has spent... It all leads back to that, doesn't it? if Spurs are spending zero pounds this summer because they had zero capability to spend anything then fine then there is an excuse there because they literally don't have the money so then you can say oh well we couldn't bring in the players because we literally don't have the money but they bought in what was it eight eight players and spent something like that whatever it might be and spent however many hundreds of millions so yeah poor planet um well all right let's let's let's stay on this one mate um because i've seen so like i said when i've seen you on twitter or x I think is it safe to say like you're not you haven't been the biggest fan of the Tonali signing right I think that's what I obviously sort of speak about quite a bit um yeah I actually I actually quite like him I quite like him as a player again price tags are always going to be a thing that gets spoken about as much as we can say look it's a value of a player is as much as a club wants to pay for them or you know the selling club or sell them for but I do quite like him as a player um i guess again it's like another it's like a it's a two-folded question i guess i'd be interested to know first of all like why you're not as particularly as as fond of him but then i guess sort of moving on from that i guess we can all sort of concede that we have spent 100 mil on him the manager expressly wanted him he's like one of the managers kind of pet projects if you like so he's not going to get kicked out of the team anytime soon yeah so if if we if it is to be sort of taken that he will be starting basically every game he's available.
46:45Jack:I sort of feel like we've got to drop Rodrigo Bentancur and play Fernandes in his correct position. Before this,
46:55Jack:there's this. As you celebrate the game, take a deeper look at its roots. The people growing the grass, bathing the lots, welding the goalposts, inspecting every football. The hardworking people that make every Sunday possible. Carhartt is proud to outfit the crews behind the game. Visit carhartt.com slash join the trades to learn more. This Friday, return to theaters for Avengers Endgame Encore. I know I said no more surprises, but I was really hoping to pull off one last one. Reassemble the team. Six stones. Three teams. One shot. Relive the experience. You mess with time, time tends to mess back.
47:39Jack:The story continues. Tony, this is the second chance. Don't miss. Marvel Studios. Avengers Endgame Encore. Early in theaters Friday. Get tickets now. Ready PG-13. Maybe inappropriate for children at 13. Every game day, you show up for your team. Now, it's your time. We go V! We go V! Ask your prescriber about We Go V. Semaglutide Injection 2.4mg, a GLP-1. Call 1-833-4WIGOVY or visit WIGOVY.com to view the medication guide and to learn more about WIGOVY. Why wait? WIGOVY! Yeah, if there was some magic thing in the contract where Tonali must start every single game and is undroppable, then yeah, that's what I would be doing.
48:29I would be dropping Benton Curran and putting Fernandez in there. But, you know, if you ask me right now who do I think is better out of Benton Curran and Tonali, I think it's Benton Curran. And that isn't, you know, Captain Hindsight with the games we've seen. I just think he's a better footballer than Sonali. This isn't me trying to have a go at Sonali, but I just think that the very, very best players have to be masters with the ball. What does he do on the ball that's that impressive? It's fine. It's like, well, okay, but surely we need more. Do you know what I mean? I don't know if we're talking about the very, very best footballers.
48:59But I'm one of these people where I don't really believe in setting goals that is anything other than win everything. Because why? Why would you? Why would you set a goal of being fourth? Because you're already telling yourself you're planning to lose games, right? So try to win every single moment. You know, try to score every time you guys are on the ball. Try not to concede every time you're not on the ball. Try to win 38 out of 38 games. Whatever, whatever, whatever. But I just feel like to be someone that can go and win it all and to have everything like that, which is why can't Spurs think like that?
49:32Why can't they be like that? Of course they can. to do that, I think that every player has to be a master on the ball and he's fine. He's seven out of 10. But I just don't know what he does on the ball that is like that special.
49:46Jack:I'm saying this like, I guess in a positive sense, but not a lot of people are telling you that way. I see him as like a better version of Pelinha, basically. I kind of see him as a... Yeah, but he wasn't that good for me. Well, yeah. I mean, that's kind of the point, isn't it? I think that like it's, I see him as like, I think he's decent defensively. I think like Bentancur has been good but I also sort of wonder if Bentenka has been good because he's had more of a say like a presence beside him which I think Tonali is and I do think Tonali's better on the ball than you know than Polina was but of course he's not Christian Eriksen or anything like that.
50:20What I would say with Tonali and I do get this I can see why as a manager you might look at Tonali and go I do I can count on him to be like at least a seven out of ten pretty much every game he plays and where it is so that that i will give to him he will be at least a seven out of ten but you know i do just think that that spurs should be better than that you know they should they should be better than just having the seven out of ten every game you know they should be thinking that this is a player that can and maybe tonali can come that i believe in coaching i believe that if you grab hold of tonali perhaps you can coach him into amazing things who knows um don't just accept him for his weaknesses and accept what they are perhaps you can work on him you know but But I just think that, yeah, I think that if you want to be the absolute best of the best, you should be a master with the ball at your feet.
51:04And I don't think he is quite simply, but he is a solid, you know, he can be relied upon as a fantastic professional to perform at least a 7 out of 10. And listen, I think the Spurs fans would look at it and agree, well, we haven't had many players like that over however many years. And a lot of football clubs don't have a lot of players that you can be relied on to be 7 out of 10 at least every single game. You know, that isn't, that is quite hard to find in football. So I will give that to him. I will give that to him. but I guess my perspective is that I would be looking at, perhaps it could be so much more.
51:34Jack:Yeah, yeah. I think that's fair. It's just, you know, I'm not just trying to single you out as like the anti-Tanali brigade. It's a sentiment that's shared with a lot of people. Yeah, and I'm not against him. I do get it. I do get why people like him. Listen, I like him. Of course I do. And we're still talking about the very top level of the game here. He's obviously a fantastic player. I just think that, okay, well, I perhaps wouldn't have gone for that, but that's fine. There's no wrong answer. You know, we all view football in our own way. And, yeah, I guess just for me, that isn't really what I'd be looking to go for, but this is what it is.
52:11Jack:Do you find it interesting that nobody came in with big money for Adam Morton this summer? So from Palace, because that's sort of a play. Yeah, that's wild. I mean, that is wild. I don't know what's going on with that. I can't. I'm amazed. Listen, who knows? Perhaps behind the scenes there, it's like different things as to why he hasn't moved and maybe he's thinking one more year at Palace too. Well, it could be anything. But I think he's a fabulous footballer. I love Adam Wharton. I absolutely love him. I was surprised. I was surprised City went for Anderson instead of him because I always looked at him as like, I thought Wharton was like nailed on City, to be honest.
52:41Yeah, I know what you mean, yeah, in terms of that. But I guess again, perhaps they're looking at him, maybe football's looking at him going, is he an amazing runner? Yeah, yeah. It really annoys me. But I don't know. Yeah. I don't know how many times football has to prove that the best players are the best players, not because they can run really hard and fast all the time. You know, of course, you have to be able to cope and you can't be a liability potentially. But even then, perhaps you could be a little bit of a liability and still be successful overall with it. I don't know. Yeah, I think it's mental that football hasn't just gone to Adam Wharton at the very elite level.
53:17We want you. We need you.
53:18Jack:Were you surprised to see, I guess because I'll pivot to Matias Fernandes here because I kind of guess that's who we went with instead of somebody like Wharton, the more passing number eight-ish type player. I mean, were you surprised to see De Zerbi single him out considering he's played him out of position? He's trying to force this number 10 thing to happen and I appreciate options are limited in that respect. so that's probably why he's trying to make that one happen. But I mean, I would say I personally was quite annoyed actually to see De Zerbe be quite critical of Matias Fernandes publicly after that game, especially because I don't really think he did much wrong.
54:03Jack:He just looked like a player that was kind of being shoehorned into playing out of position to a degree. It's what De Zerbe does. I don't know whether that would passive aggressiveness be the right way to sort of describe it, but it's like, he's not outwardly, you, it's one of those things where it's like, he's saying something to put blame on a player, but then saying afterwards, oh, but I still really like him, but it's like, well, no, you can't, do you know what I mean? You've put it out there that this is, but he does that with players. He's done that with Charleston a few times. I don't know why he kept talking about him.
54:32You can't just not answer. But yeah, he does, that's what the Zerbe has done. He will single out players. Yeah, I really like Matias Fernandes. He hasn't had a great start to Tottenham. I do think I agree with you. I think he's trying to be shoe-dored into this certain thing that isn't really him. Anybody who knows me knows I'm not a person that believes in positions in terms of dictating what players are, but he is a player that I think that he's better when he's kind of like the connector and the heartbeat of how a team might play and move through and up the pitch. I don't think he's really the player that is someone that's on the end of moves per se, but I think Spurs have left themselves in a situation where, again, they're looking at it and think, well, who else can they play there?
55:14Well, you know, they could put lots of players there, but also they didn't have to end up in that situation where they feel like he is the best option there. You know, it shouldn't really be a situation where it's either a recovering Madison or a recovering Kudus or a recovering Kuliszewski or him or Gallagher. Do you know what I mean? They shouldn't be in that situation, but they've put themselves there and perhaps you adapt it. Perhaps you change what you do, but De Zerbi's pretty set in his ways, isn't he, in how he plays and what he wants.
55:40Jack:Yeah, it certainly seems that way. It certainly seems that way I guess sort of one final one in terms of like when we're talking about personnel and on this theme of squad building forward planning and everything like that we did take the gamble this summer in letting Luka Vyskovic go you know a young sort of prospect that we identified pretty early gave him his loan moves he wanted first team football we thought fine basically swapped him for Van Hecker I mean like recency bias I guess but Vyskovic you would say just putting a man of the match performance against the reigning champions this weekend um whereas you know jampo van hecker had a bit of a stinkery against aston villa namely against nicholas jackson do you think we're sort of do you think we do you think we made a mistake on that one mate you know a lot of people talk about voskovic's physicality about him having a you know a slow sort of turn of pace and all that type of thing but physically van hecker's and i i actually quite like i will say up front I quite like Van Hecker I think on the ball he's a lovely footballer um you know he's lacking in the air which is disappointing because Van der Ven also is um but physically you know if if the thing that we're holding Vuscovic up for is his physicality I don't think Van Hecker's like a shining example of a say a combative centre-back I think Spurs have made a huge error i think that spurs had a potentially generational center back on their hands and they uh cut the cord um to bring in money straight away pretty much all right maybe vuzkovic does have an issue with his turn of speed and um it will mean he doesn't get to the very very top who knows who knows but um you can't guarantee anything in football but you do look at vuzkovic and go that could be generational absolutely generational and again i just think that he again he's he's a really really good footballer and i think that van hecke is a good player he's a very good player he's a very very good player with the ball he isn't that dominant um for me it's it's a kind of like a worse version of romero so it's like they've made a decision there where again kind of what i said earlier they've kind of accepted to just be a bit worse than before whereas how do we know that vuzkovic couldn't be better than all of them and perhaps vuzkovic could be someone that is elite and then you can just end up with a team with him part of it that's elite and then you've got a few other players that are elite and all of a sudden why can't you win the league or whatever it might be and I just think that they've just gone for a game just like tried and tested of someone that's good but hasn't proven himself to be elite and I don't really like that um sounds mad to say but I'm a bit of a dreamer I believe in let's reach for the stars and see if we can go even further than that.
58:27You know, and I just think that Spurs aren't behaving like that. But no, I think it was a mistake selling Vyskovic. Listen, captain hindsight, anybody can say it. But I just think that you have a potentially generational centre-back there. Generational. Like, maybe, maybe that's a player that comes around once every 10 years. Maybe. Or, maybe he's not that good. But you could, you had that player that like people look at and go, this could be insane. Don't give up on it so soon. But, it is what it is. I guess,
58:56Jack:uh harry i mean like let's let's sort of take a look at sort of like a broader tactical picture i mean like look we're not going to be able to sign any more players until january um even then who knows if we will or are able to whatever the squad is as it is right now i mean what do you think we need to do to sort of turn this form around because look clicking or not we're not winning games we're bottom of the premier league table and you know again to sort the point you were making earlier one i am often saying on here is that you cannot sleep in the premier league anymore it is not like and i don't i keep saying post-covid i genuinely think maybe even in the last three years it has just changed drastically before our eyes that the premier league is just such a behemoth right now look i mean basically english teams win every single european competition almost every single year now um at every single level it it's a mad league and i I don't think you can just write off five games and say, oh, it's all right.
59:57Jack:We'll get there in the end. Because soon or late, you can find yourself adrift. And that adds to that psychological toil, doesn't it? I think it's spot on. I mean, if we look at the... You can't just base starting 11s. There's so much more that goes into stuff. But let's say you do the social media thing where people compare starting 11s. Compare the best starting 11 of Tottenham last year compared to the best starting 11 of Bournemouth last year. There's an argument to say there were more Bournemouth players in that team than the Tottenham team. that would never have been a conversation a few years ago of course it wouldn't have been no point in my lifetime up to this point of course it couldn't be no you know and and Bournemouth's not an anomaly there like that they're showing that the teams that were seen as um Premier League teams but perhaps not the ones that are going to upset the apple carts they are not that much worse than them anymore and sometimes they are actually better than them and they are smarter they're better run and because the players are actually better they actually look at clubs like Tottenham and think well why wouldn't I finish above you with better run we have better footballers why would I not finish above you and that's the situation the Spurs have left themselves in mate I mean is this international break this thing is it a good thing a bad thing for Spurs I can't really I can't believe it yeah this is the first time it's three weeks isn't it so what a shambles that is all of football shambles the ones that run it are shambles and games gone mate games games gone yeah but it's like what are you doing through like the rhythm in football is so important and maybe they're just getting into rhythm the premier league and now they're stopped for five for three weeks crazy crazy so no i don't think it is a good thing i think it's um but then again captain hindsight maybe they come back and they need that reset you know so who knows but as a footballer you do just feel like you want rhythm and rhythm and rhythm um and obviously their players are still going to be playing go to international teams but now that rhythm with the club will have will have obviously now I'm not saying it's gone but he's now got a three week break from it so yeah I think it's a nonsense but everyone's in the same boat with that so but it won't feel good for those players looking at knowing that they're going into that international break bottom of the table No, I mean we've a lot of we've had a lot of players go on international duty as well thankfully basically all the ones that are injured have not I think Curtis has actually stepped out of international duty as well I think I saw just before we started recording.
1:02:15Jack:He did get called up, but he said he's not going to go. He wants to stay and get fit. So, yeah, you've just got to hope that maybe Madison is a bit more... It's a weird one with him, like why he's not starting games yet. Kulisevsky, you know, is another that I keep asking on here and, you know, some people don't like it, but are we going to see him again feasibly as a top draw Tottenham player again? Yeah, it's been such a weird one. Who knows? yeah that's been such a weird one but let's hope so because he's a fabulous I mean let's hope because he's exceptional you know he's a fabulous player and I'll tell you what his mindset seems to be strong as an ox because he hasn't seemed to have wilted in his belief in his process to get him back to the top and fair play to him although I don't know him but you know he seems to have dealt with this remarkably well because that is that is a tough one I mean how long would that be it'd be what 18 months or something that's a long time yeah it's a long long long old time for such a what seemed like an innocuous injury as well I mean that's a separate topic but yeah fair play to him it would be amazing if he does get back to the level that you know we know he can be it might need to be fact checked but I'm pretty sure I've seen it said though he still started a game more recently than James Madison which is kind of wow mad to say wow yeah but Harry I really appreciate your time today mate where can people follow you listen to you see more of your work and what you talk about yeah so I mean people are welcome to follow the Twitter which I just need to grab it now quickly I always get off I never actually have it on me.
1:03:42But I always forget because I don't do it. But people will want to follow the Twitter, which is Harry, no, Hbrooks underscore coach. But to be fair, what I found is quite a lot of listeners actually have sons or brothers or even daughters, whether they actually want to be worked with my company. So they're more than welcome to look into that, which is, you know, my company's RH10Football on Instagram. So that's, you know, we keep the pros and the academy players private, but we work with all levels of the game. So if anybody's listening thinks that either I want to be a bit better or help to be better or whatever it might be, or know someone does, then we're welcome to reach out to that.
1:04:14But yeah.
1:04:15Jack:Harry, mate, I really appreciate your time. Thanks for coming on today. No, you're a star. Thank you.
1:04:27Jack:Before this,
1:04:32Jack:there's this. As you celebrate the game, take a deeper look at its roots. The people growing the grass, paving the lots, welding the goalposts, inspecting every football. The hardworking people that make every Sunday possible. Carhartt is proud to outfit the crews behind the game. Visit carhartt.com slash join the trades to learn more. This Friday, return to theaters for Avengers Endgame Encore. I know I said no more surprises, but I was really hoping to pull off one last one. Reassemble the team. $6. Three zones, three teams, one shot. Relive the experience. You mess with time, time tends to mess back.
1:05:15Jack:The story continues. Tony, this is a second chance. Don't miss Marvel Studios, Avengers Endgame Encore, early theaters Friday. Get tickets now, rated PG-13, maybe inappropriate for children under 13.
From the publisher
Jack is joined by professional football coach Harry Brooks to take an unfiltered, black-and-white look at the reality of Tottenham Hotspur sitting at the bottom of the Premier League table.
We kick things off by addressing Harry's reputation for being 'negative' online, explaining why his analytical coaching perspective prevents him from blindly clapping along to the club's unprecedented summer spending. We dissect the "utterly disgraceful" squad building that saw Spurs spend hundreds of millions without securing a dominant presence in either the attacking or defending penalty boxes, leaving the team with a physically struggling Dominic Solanke as the only recognised centre-forward.
Attention then turns to the defensive and midfield gambles. Harry explains why selling Luka Vušković could be a generational mistake, arguing that Jan Paul van Hecke is simply a downgrade on Cristian Romero. We also dive into the Sandro Tonali debate, questioning whether a reliable 7/10 player is enough for a team with elite ambitions, while comparing his ceiling to the raw potential of Lucas Bergvall and discussing the frustrating shoehorning of Mateus Fernandes.
Finally, we explore the mental fragility of the squad following the collapse against Aston Villa. We debate whether Roberto De Zerbi is right to call out the team's soft underbelly, and ask if the unprecedented three-week international break will destroy any lingering rhythm or provide a desperate, much-needed reset.
Theme is Ghost Cat by Gillen
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices




