

Why Republicans lost in Tuesday’s “catastrophic” elections, framed as a multi-factor “death by a thousand cuts” rather than single-cause hot takes. Core claim: voters saw Republicans as unserious and focused on pocketbook issues, especially the economy and rising prices.
Josh Holmes (host); Comfortably Smug (co-host); Michael Duncan (co-host); John Ashbrook (co-host). Backgrounds mentioned: long careers as political professionals; Ashbrook has political experience dating back to Watergate-era politics.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the reasons behind the Republican party's perception as unserious.
“We're going to find a way through all of this.”
Discussion on the reasons behind the Republican party's perception as unserious.
“why you listen to the Ruthless Podcast, because nobody else would ask that question.”
The hosts reflect on the catastrophic results of the recent elections.
“And you get relatively few people in this line of work.”
Discussion on the political landscape and failures leading to election losses.
“But, like, we're going to find a way through all of this, and there's no better place on all of the internet to do that than here.”
Discussion on the challenges Republicans face in upcoming Senate elections.
“You gentlemen are true experts in the Senate.”
Analyzing how the Republican Party reinvented itself after major setbacks.
“Like there was a party there that looked extraordinarily different from the one that had left office in 2008.”
Exploring the turnout of suburban and rural voters in recent elections.
“I'm going to vote for this communist who I agree with on nothing because I just don't think you have our best interest at heart.”
Discussion on the economic issues that influenced recent election outcomes.
“You can go everywhere and figure this out.”
Examining claims about foreign policy issues affecting Republican losses.
“I mean, let's get some more perspective on that.”
Discussion on how foreign policy, particularly in Iran and Venezuela, affected voter perception and Republican losses.
“And that thing is the reason why we lost.”
Exploration of how domestic economic issues overshadowed foreign policy in the minds of voters during the election.
“The 4 %—we won fucking—we lost a Senate seat in Mississippi, for Christ's sakes.”
Insights into how the recent election shapes the landscape for future Republican candidates in 2028.
“They don't give a shit what you're doing overseas.”
Discussion on the importance of internal debates within the Republican party and the dynamics of the political process.
“We're not like, you know, zombie Biden's handing it over to Kamala.”
Analysis of how candidates position themselves and the implications of their messaging strategies on public perception.
“It's not about finding a cohort of the electorate and being like, well, I think if maybe we figured out a way to do this one thing, we could actually figure out a coalition to win.”
Examination of how Democrats capitalized on economic messaging related to tariffs and trade during the election.
“But I'm fundamentally with you in the end.”
Discussion on the history and implications of tariff policies and how they affect rural versus urban voters.
“And they're mad about if diesel prices go up, then everything that's being shipped around this country, the price of that's going up, it's an economic issue.”
Reflection on the quality of candidates in recent elections and what that means for the future of the Republican party.
“between the years of 2018 and 2024, the combined total spending by both parties, whether negative or positive, was less by over a magnitude of 10 than the Dems spent 2026 on negative.”
Discussion on the impact of candidate quality and a guest's live update from the White House.
“I don't know if President Trump said this directly, but they talked about candidate quality.”
Analysis of candidate quality in recent elections and its implications.
“I mean, the candidates are there because you endorsed them, right?”
Exploring how economic decisions affect candidates and voter sentiment.
“But look, I think if you're combining all of these things and you're talking about candidate quality, what you're doing is pushing off some culpability.”
Discussion on the challenging political environment and its effects on candidates.
Debating the reliance of candidates on endorsements and campaign strategies.
“know like yeah no no it's there are Democrats I got I have to repeat it there were Democrats who suspended their campaign three months ago who won.”
Understanding how wave elections influence candidate success and failure.
“And so like, it's true, but not the cause.”
Analyzing how perceptions of corruption can sway voter decisions.
“successful sophisticated like thoughtful lawmaker like the the iq imbalance on that race haunts me 20 years later right it's about to be so stupid oh it's so dumb like but you get that in waves You had it in 80.”
Reflecting on the election outcomes and the path forward for Republicans.
“You probably saw these ads all over the place for the entire fall, Democrats saying, we need to prevent members of Congress from being able to buy stocks.”
Explore the reasons behind the Republican losses and potential paths forward.
“It feels like the only way that you can get somebody in West Texas to vote for a lunatic like James Tallarico is to believe that the corruption of the current government is so significant, he'll do anything else.”
Discussion of the emotional responses and implications of the recent elections.
“Welcome back to the Ruthless Variety program.”
A reflection on the pitfalls of overestimating public support in politics.
“Like they think – the funniest thing in politics to me, maybe just in life, is someone with overconfidence in an area where they clearly lack any sort of – Dude, you've got 100%.”
Analyze how Democrats might misinterpret voter reactions post-election.
“He's running for president because he thinks there's an audience for that.”
Discussion about the challenges facing Democrats and their future strategies.
“If they don't fuck it up, they'll fuck their cousin.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Ruthless Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Why did Republicans lose? We are under the hood. Like we're about to give you some stuff you're not going to hear anywhere else. People out there with very hot takes about, say, well, the Iran war is the reason or gas prices are the reason or the economy writ large is the reason. And it's like it's not that they're wrong. It's just that it's that and everything. You have to be honest with yourself about an actual assessment of where you stand, where things stand and what went wrong. Ultimately, at the end of the day with the American electorate, they saw the Republican party as unserious. Yeah.
0:31And it's like, nobody cares if you jump for the triple lutz if you don't stick the landing. But it does provide you an opportunity to take it down to the studs. And if you're honest about it, rebuild and provide a much better product, which in all honesty is a good thing. We're going to find a way through all of this. And there's no better place on all of the Internet to do that than here. We're going to be OK. Car crashes injure over a million of us every year because we're human. For over a decade, Waymo's been building a driver that's safer. Statistically, 10 times safer in the cities we serve.
1:16Not because humans aren't enough, but because they're everything. Based on over a 94 % reduction in serious injury or worse crash rates. Learn more at Waymo.com.
1:52why you listen to the Ruthless Podcast, because nobody else would ask that question. The only political podcast worth listening to is the Ruthless Podcast. It's time for our main event, the Ruthless Podcast. Well, it ain't good, folks. Good Thursday to you. Welcome back to the Ruthless Variety Program. I'm Josh Holmes, along with Comfortably Smug, Michael Duncan, and John Ashbrook. The good news for you, the listener, is the good Lord invented the Ruthless Variety program precisely for moments like this. We were talking about this a lot before the episode. Clearly, some time to reflect on Tuesday's elections, which were catastrophic would be a decent -
2:36Michael Duncan: They were the worst of our lifetimes. Yeah. I mean, Ashbrook was around for the Watergate in the 70s. Yeah. Post-World War II. Yeah. Also, in 1934, was it 34 that FDR got elected? Third time? that had been tough that had been tough yeah three straight losses to fdr was that was that was difficult um but look we uh are made for this in large part because this is the environment that we all grew up in politics for and we were talking about you're gonna see a lot of folks that were like stalwarts like big conservative influencers all of a sudden start caring a little bit less about things now that it's sort of unpopular you're telling me they don't want to save america anymore oh could it be could it be you're not you gotta be kidding huh no i mean but there is there's gonna be some of that and you're gonna see look the best part the only good part i should say about really bad elections is people show their ass they tell you exactly uh where they're coming from who they were paid by and why, or where they see their political allotment, you know, that they sort of locked down that is entirely self-serving.
3:55And you get relatively few people in this line of work. We had the good fortune of spending an entire career, successful, thankfully, in this line of work and got into this with Ruthless and talking to all of you because we want to do we thought it would make a difference and so we kind of don't give a shit about calling things out about exactly the way that they are and what i've noticed i think the most jarring thing and i put something on x about it most jarring thing is the hot takes oh man which is the the beginning it's the first phase of the show your ass mentality which is like i care about this thing.
4:39And this thing just so happens to be entirely corresponded with the way I make a living. But that's the reason why we had bad things. And conversely, the people who lost that didn't care about my thing. Yeah. I find it to be sort of like sham wow politics, where it's like, I can solve this problem in the next 90 seconds if everybody just does what I say. And And it's immature. It's people that don't understand politics. In our career as political professionals, we had to dig out of some huge holes. You look at what Barack Obama did in 2008, the victory that he had, the margins that he rolled up in places like Indiana.
5:25Historic election. So much of our careers as professionals was determined by that and digging out of that. But that is not a thing you solve with a hot take. It's not a thing like, oh, well, I'm just going to look at the crosstab of this poll. And then, you know, we just do this one thing and then everything's solved. That's not how politics actually works. It takes years. It takes cycles. It takes the determination to put your head down and do the work to win. It's going to take six years to dig out of this. But we're built for that. Like we enjoy that. I just want you guys who are listening and watching this to realize it is sad, obviously, that it was a shellacking on Tuesday.
6:09But, like, we're going to find a way through all of this, and there's no better place on all of the internet to do that than here.
6:16Michael Duncan: And I also want to point out a couple things. First off, for our longtime listeners, you know Ruthless started October of 2020. November of 2020 was no fucking, like, you know, walk in the park. That was not a blast to be a part of. And then we were built in that nuclear winter of 2021. Yeah. Because those are basically just getting hunted in the streets. COVID 2020 in January 6th. And we're like, we're going to do a podcast and we're going to do it three days a week. You know, I mean, like, that's what I'm saying is like, we really are. This is our DNA. Yeah. We're going to find a way. Yeah. But look, a big part of suffering the kinds of losses that we did, and just to put this into perspective, I never thought I'd look wistfully back on 2006, which is – Think about that, dude.
7:11since Watergate, the worst performance either party has had in a midterm election. This was almost half again worse in terms of if you look at the national popular vote of where people settled in all these congressional races and whatnot. As of current, it's about 13.5 % advantage for Democrats. 2006 was like eight, right?
7:39Michael Duncan: Think about that, folks. So, but having spent 20 years in the business, it's not like a bunch of people in Texas just woke up and decided to be libs or a bunch of people in Mississippi are now like, yeah, man, that El Sayed's got it going on. Like that's not the way that these kinds of cycles work. It is, as you've said, Duncan, a death by a thousand cuts. There are a million things that go into it. But fundamentally, like you don't need to be anything other than a human being with eyes and ears and the ability to relate to someone else to understand that getting people to vote against their ideological makeup requires them to say about these are the things that i care about not only do they not care about those things but i feel like the current folks that are in power care about themselves.
8:35Right. You know, it also requires genuine curiosity. You know, you have to be honest with yourself about an actual assessment of where you stand, where things stand, and what went wrong. As honest as it can possibly be, and the answers aren't pretty. Nobody's tweeting those answers because they don't make them look good on Twitter. but until you get to the bottom of what went wrong you can't understand where you need to go and what you need to improve on so that you can win the next time or you can get a little bit better the next time it takes a lot of patience too yeah and i think you were that's what you were getting at a minute ago yeah when when i say death by a thousand cuts i know there's people out there with very hot takes about say well the iran war is the reason or gas prices are the reason or the economy writ large is the reason.
9:25And it's like, it's not that they're wrong. It's just that it's that and everything. They're component parts. They're like narrative.
9:31Michael Duncan: Did that result happen as a result of the Iran war or did it happen because of gas prices or did it happen because people feel like everyone is getting rich in the government, but they're not making any headway? And the answer is yes. Yeah. Not like that, it's yes. It's yes to absolutely everything. When I say death by a thousand cuts, which is a shame because the Trump administration has done so many great things. But I think it's been overshadowed by the screw ups. You look at like immigration secured the border. Yep. Absolutely fantastic. A generational accomplishment. Never been done before, by the way.
10:12Michael Duncan: But then have the number at the border. Right. Who crossed legally be zero. That's never happened before. Right. And it was done. Right. Right. But then, you know, ICE shoots a guy in Minneapolis and Kristi Noem puts a bedroom on a private jet. Yeah. And we're doing Vogue photo shoots in camo. Right. At detention centers. And you're overshadowing the success with the screw up. Yeah. Right. You could look at the military. We executed one of the most sophisticated operations in Venezuela to kidnap a brutal dictator in two hours, discombobulated him and brought him, extraordinarily renditioned him to the United States.
10:48A amazing accomplishment for the American military.
10:52Michael Duncan: Quite possibly the most precise and successful military operation in the history of humanity. Yeah, exactly. But then you got the Pentagon talking about live streaming a public execution. Right. Right. You got a wheelchair. The secretary is talking about like we need more high T war fighters. And it's like, how about some drone interceptors in the Strait of Hormuz? Yeah. Like, how about some like common sense things that are going on? And so then like the screw ups start to overwhelm the success. Look at D.C. Look at like it's another perfect example where Donald Trump has done incredible things in the district, like making this place livable again.
11:30The National Guard. It's safe to walk the street.
11:32Michael Duncan: Folks, like in 2021, 2020, like there were people in Georgetown at three in the afternoon getting robbed at gunpoint for their coat. He cleaned out all the fentanyl addicts from Union Station. He got the fountains working in the city again for the first time in like a decade. Right. I think longer than that. Yeah, longer than that. But then what happens? well on election day donald trump is doing a press conference down at the reflecting pool which like is like they hired some buddy as a contractor who screwed up the thing you can say goomba yeah we can get a right a goomba yeah i think italians some some goomba screwed up the rehab of the reflecting pool right and it's like so now all the good that you did is now overshadowed again because now we got the picture of this guy by a screw up yeah and like i think ultimately at the end of the day with the american electorate they saw the republican party as unserious yeah and it's like nobody cares if you jump for the triple lutz if you don't stick the landing yeah you did totally right so look we're going to tell you an unvarnished truth it cannot be argued because these are the facts these are the exit polls this is the poll this is the data that came out of this election we're just going to lay it out there and then we're going to talk a little bit about some of the theories of the case and why we think that doesn't encapsulate what we just sort of preface this with which is this larger painting that the republican party is going to have to work its way through here and this is not a one-year project no not a two-year project if you're talking about losing senate seats in places like south carolina texas and kansas right six-year project because as bad as 2006 was they didn't fucking lose texas
13:23Congress has talked about permitting reform for decades. Now it's time to actually do it. America's demand for energy is rising rapidly. And at a time when American families can least afford an energy shortage, critical projects have been blocked by unnecessary delays in red tape, driving up costs and limiting innovation. Some politicians are trying to block this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to overhaul the broken permitting process. But America can't wait any longer. We need access to reliable, affordable American energy. We need to streamline approvals. We need to cut red tape and unleash our abundant natural resources.
14:02We have the historic opportunity to make it happen. It's time to pass permitting reform to secure American energy dominance for generations to come. Because when America builds, America wins. Learn more at permittingreformnow.org. Paid for by the American Petroleum Institute.
14:25Michael Duncan: I don't want to put you on the spot, but real quick, something to discuss about that. You gentlemen are true experts in the Senate. I saw Governor DeSantis giving some discussion on how dire a situation it is in terms of – so for folks at home, Senate elections are staggered. where it's essentially every two years it's like a third of the senators are put up each senator's term is six years so like when people like talarico and abdul sayad get in that's like six years so it's not just like 2032 you won't get a crack at them but then you have to think about okay even if let's say we elect a republican in 2028 as president would they be capable of getting a Supreme Court pick done because we've had this horrendous group of libs elected as senators who are going to be there for six years.
15:21Yeah, even if you can push the sun back up in the sky and resurrect the party to retake the White House in 2028, you're still dealing with the ramifications of 26. Johnny, what are you saying? The Senate map in 28 is not impossible for Republicans to run the table on, but it's very difficult. Republicans would have to flip seats in states like georgia where we just lost it's a warnock will be up in 28 states like arizona where it's mark kelly the democrat incumbent running again so those are challenging states that republicans have won before but you can't you can't look at the 28 cycle as that's the one where we get the senate back for sure what de santis is saying is not wrong it's not impossible to get it back before then but he's he's not wrong these seats are very important but counterpoint to that and because i don't want people to lose hope in this thing no no i and and that's not my intention if we nominate a good candidate who runs a good campaign right state of georgia and there's a national message that people are upset with how democrats are conducting themselves over the next two years you know a lot of them are saying oh we're going to cut your gas prices we're going to give you free health care and all they're tweeting about is how they're going to go after the trump administration well i guess that's not going to reduce anybody's gas price i guess
16:34Michael Duncan: disappointment and also to be clear i real quick is like i know the reason to santis's point is house because he wants to run we all know like the two things that happen in the midterm is one party gets control of like either or both chambers of congress and then a bunch of people are like now i'm running for president so i'll we all i'm clear-eyed on desantis is clearly running and that's why he's pointing that out but my but all i'm saying is that the point of senate senate elections matter yeah it's not like a house race like i am confident that if our party can get our shit together, we can storm back and take the house because so many jokers, so many joker dems got elected in this wave last night.
17:15Michael Duncan: I think we can smoke the shit out of them in two years if we get our act together. It's the Senate that's scary because they got six. Okay, but here's the hope, okay? 2008, we get boat raced by Obama. 2010, we won a Senate race in Illinois. Yeah. In Illinois. And we're talking about Arizona, we're talking about Georgia, and I understand And in very normal environments, those will be very difficult races. But politics changes so fast. It does. I just want to, before we get into these results and kind of break this down a little bit, I just want to caveat that last point because I think it's a really important one.
17:50Politics do change really fast, and it does reflect a leadership and a change. We've made the case here for years that nobody wins a Republican nomination surfing somebody else's wave. It's got to be its own thing. It's got to be different. And I think this is a good example of that when you talk about the 8 to 10 situation. The Republican Party after eight years of Bush really reinvented itself fast. Now part of that was out of necessity because you had this calamity of an economic recession that nearly bankrupted the global economy coupled with a deeply unpopular Iraq war and a president that people were just sort of fatigued with.
18:31but he left he was gone and in 2009 you started anew with like the grizzled few who survived the 06 and the 08 knife knife in their mouth ready to fight gorillas right but they also had the capacity of meeting the electorate where they were yeah which is huge anxiety about the economy about the foreign policy that was being conducted, about liberals sort of feeling their oats and running amok, trying to just take away your healthcare, trying to spend trillions of dollars of money that they didn't have. Like there was a party there that looked extraordinarily different from the one that had left office in 2008.
19:22By 2012, it was unrecognizable. By 14, you had reconstituted what was a dominant political party in the United States of America. And the Republicans best represented from 2014 till current day where the electorate is. Now, those are setbacks along the way. And 18 wasn't a good election. 22 wasn't particularly good. But they were all well positioned because it was a newer, updated version of a Republican party. Yeah. We find ourselves in a situation where the Republican voters in states around the country said, go fuck yourself. I'm going to vote for this communist who I agree with on nothing because I just don't think you have our best interest at heart.
20:10Michael Duncan: Can I ask a quick question about that? Has anyone seen exactly what turnout numbers are looking like when you've got like suburban voters and when you've got rural voters? And if this is a case of Republicans staying – It's not that. Yeah, no. It's the flip, isn't it? Yeah. They were like – They turned out. I'm done with it. I am showing up to vote and I'm not voting for Republicans. Yeah, the big fear coming into this election was the same one that was in 18 to a certain extent in 22, that you couldn't turn out a MAGA base without Trump on the ballot. You can, but they might not vote for you.
20:46Yeah. Right. And I think that was the lesson certainly a lot of folks in Texas up and down the ballot figured that out.
20:52Michael Duncan: Those rule numbers in Texas were just shocking. Well, you look at a guy like Ken Paxton and the whole modus operandi of the Ken Paxton candidacy was he is the grassroots candidate. He's won multiple times statewide. I understand John Cornyn is a safe pick, but this guy is going to mobilize the grassroots in particular, the MAGA base and the rurals in Texas. And that is going to launch him to the Senate in this race in the general. And then you look at the breakdowns in some of these rural areas. I was looking at Brandon Gill's district, which thank God he's still one. But you look up at Cook County there by the Oklahoma border and he outperformed Ken Paxton by like four points.
21:29Yeah. And it's like, damn. So then what was the point of that? That's supposed to be your own thing. Yeah, you can't. It's kind of like office space. It's like, what would you say you do here? If you don't do that, what do you do? You can't lose by association. You cannot lose all of the opportunity for center-right Republicans at the same time that you're not overperforming with these lower propensity rural voters. They did both. But they did both. One just Texas. One just Ken Paxton. You can go everywhere and figure this out. Here's a couple of things that you need to know. So in graphic one, that is Trump's first term.
22:14For our audio-only listeners, this is a graphic showing the president's approval rating and his handling of the economy. The top line is where the American people were during his first term going into that 2020 election. The red line underneath it is the American people's approval rating of his handling of the economy in the second term. Do you notice anything there, fellas? So for – again, for audio only –
22:44Michael Duncan: The huge open alligator mouth. Yes. So the first term is basically hovering between 0 % to 10 % approval. That's first term for Trump on the economy through his entire first presidency. The second one you see, it just, it heads south. And then it seems like there's two major inflection points. One is the Liberation Day tariffs, which really seems like it kicked off the net disapproval, which went to like negative 10. And then Iran war adds like another 10. And then you're at, what is that? Negative 36, 38? 1936. Yeah. On election day. What I don't know, and I'm curious what everybody's opinion of this is.
23:27Like, are we looking at correlation or causation? No. So correlation in this sense would be an economic number that is a direct similarity to overall approval. And you hate the guy, so you're going to say – Yeah. And that happens a lot in politics. It happens less so economically when people feel like they're doing okay, right? I remember the first term, for example. Great. I live in an area where I'm surrounded by Democrats in Northern Virginia. And I distinctly remember a couple of guys talking at a table next to my wife and I were having dinner. And they were talking about, oh, man, I hate Trump.
24:08I can't do – he's the worst guy ever. But my portfolio looks pretty good. Yeah. And so for that reason, you know, we'll see what happens. Handling of the economy. That's where you get the break. And they had that in the first term. His approval rating was much lower than his approval of handling the economy. The economic satisfaction was in a different fundamental place than it was here. So you're like, OK, well, that's not good. Clearly, you don't want to be minus 36 on your handling of the economy. Always know midterm elections, economic concerns overshadow almost everything else. So let's take a look at the exit polls.
24:44Fox News did an exit poll on the top issues facing the country of people who voted on Tuesday. Surprise, surprise. The economy is the runaway winner on that, right? 39 % of all voters said it was the most important thing to them. Interestingly, not a huge partisan split on that bad boy. 52-46 in terms of Republicans saying –
25:09Michael Duncan: 46 Republicans and 52 Democrats. This is so fascinating to me because you also look at these like healthcare at 8%, immigration at 14%, foreign policy at 4%, economy 39%. Yeah. I mean it's just – it's a huge discrepancy. And like on the immigration point, you get some mixed stuff in there because you've got some Democrats who are extremely concerned about ICE, right? But you've got some Republicans who want to continue an aggressive immigration portfolio. That seemed to work out. The immigration issues seemed to work out for President Trump, instrumental in his 24 victory. Not a huge factor here, though.
25:52The economy's it. Most interesting to me in this, and I looked at several exit polls, not just this one. That 4 % for foreign policy, that's the lowest of all of the issues. So, look, I want to introduce the argument that we saw the vice president put on the table, the first words that he had to say about why we lost an election. He talked about a number of different things, I think, well, in terms of not being able to communicate economic news to the American people. We didn't have a sound economic message. He made some critiques about polling and the way that they were sort of observing the electorate, not seeing this sort of tsunami coming.
26:38But then he just listed a couple of things and he's like, I think we all know why we lost. And I'm like, I'm reading this. I'm like. So tell me. So tell me. We'd love to know. Yeah, because I'm looking at the exit polls. The economy is it. And there's no data on any campaign. But by the way, we've looked at a ton of internal stuff. over the last month and a half, stuff that's not public. There's nothing that can argue with the fact that the economy was doing the driving on all of this stuff. It's not even close. In every race, I don't care what state you're in. He says, we all know what we lost.
27:14It's the Iran war. Okay. Well, that's interesting, right? I mean, let's get some more perspective on that. And then he goes on to say, it's also our relationship with Israel. There is not a single thing, and I mean this sincerely, I'm not trying to be a dick to the vice president. I love the vice president. I think he's done a terrific job. There is not a single piece of data in any poll, in any exit poll, in any voter interviews, nothing, zero, that suggests that that is a primary issue for why it is that Republicans lost something. It's not, it doesn't exist. But you have the vice president of the United States saying, we all know why we lost.
27:52It's this thing. And it reminds me a little bit of the consultant thing and the thing that you get on X after an election, which is like, I care about this thing. And that thing is the reason why we lost. Yeah, everything becomes the skeleton key for fixing the problem. Yeah. And so like you have to kind of dig deeper into that. We all know where he's at. He's a much more independent sort of libertarian minded foreign policy person than the president of the United States is. And he's made that pretty well known, I think. but he's obviously someone else that's looking at 28 and he's trying to figure out where that lane is and how do you box things out this is a very bad outcome for a vice president to try to pick up the mantle for the party and say i'm going to be the nominee i also think this is a situation
28:47Michael Duncan: where is this a confusion of cause and effect because here's the thing he asked the correlation and causation totally that's i was like such a good question from duncan here's the thing is like how do voters feel about the foreign policy of what happened in venezuela that's fucking great that was what 12 hours yeah how do they feel about iran they care about the price of diesel and gas has gone up what they see as a result of iran it's like what we talked about the beginning episode it's like is this the reason why yes right but it's always a bank shot it is the economy certainly you could make the case uh the war on iran didn't help because of the economy like you can big shot the thing the war in iran is in this particular thing is an accelerant right to your already established anxiety about the price of gas the price of everything but it's not it's not like american people woke up and they were like i hate republican foreign policy i get let's just put the exit poll back up let's put it back up a grand total put it back up four percent of voters And 50 % supported the Republican position, 47 Democrats.
29:58They actually won the 4%. The 4 %—we won fucking—we lost a Senate seat in Mississippi, for Christ's sakes. There was an issue set in the top five that the Republicans won. It was foreign policy, right? Like, I'm not arguing for or against whether Iran—like, I think it complicated things a lot. Don't get me wrong. And for a president who had a campaign message of no foreign adventurism, like that confuses people. And I can understand why that's problematic. That is 4 % of the American electorate that showed up on Tuesday said foreign policy was their thing. And of that, Republicans won it. I do think that to the extent that the Iran war is unpopular, it's because of what Smug said.
30:42It's also because people have questions. They're like, I have problems paying for my groceries and it seems like the leaders in Washington are focused on something overseas rather than solving my problem here. So it's a question about misplaced priorities and you can have an argument about whether it's misplaced priorities. Anytime you go to war, it's not going to be popular. But we said this, but it also corresponds with everything else, right? And I made this argument I think on the show a couple of times over the summer that people were struggling with inflation. They were struggling with a whole bunch of like what felt very jittery in the economy and trickling down to the lower and middle class of people who are just like, I don't feel great about anything right now.
31:26And then you'd have the president like in constant foreign travel and discussions with like Vladimir Putin or Middle Eastern discussions about Iran or Qatar or whatever. And I just – it was very uncomfortable with that backdrop because the only thing that these voters cared about – and I knew it because it's a midterm election. It's always the same. They don't give a shit what you're doing overseas. They really don't. So to the extent that it becomes a problem, something like the Iran war relationship with Israel, it's that you're spending a moment thinking about that and not thinking about my job and my paycheck.
32:02Yeah. Yeah. One other thing I think it's worth saying is if you're watching this or listening to this, you have to recognize that after Tuesday, 2028 starts.
32:18Michael Duncan: Yes. And you're going to read a lot of things. You're going to see a lot of things that look like criticisms of various people. I'm not here to criticize JD. We love JD. You mentioned it earlier. But there will be camps established now, whoever it is who's out there pushing a narrative and an agenda, right, because they want to position their guy or gal for 2028. So just as a consumer of news and information, like operate from that, that you know that these people are out there trying to win the next election. One thing about that, too, is for our longtime listeners, you may remember during the 2024 Republican primary for president, we had every candidate here.
33:03Michael Duncan: Every. Because we believe a healthy thing for a party is to let the party and the voter have the argument. Yeah. We're not like, you know, zombie Biden's handing it over to Kamala. Right. Yeah. And like, no choice. It's going to be here because that's bad for. Honestly, dude, it's kind of my favorite part of all of politics. It totally is. Is the food fight internally and figuring out what you do. And what I love about being a Republican and a conservative and part of this movement is that we're willing to do that every single year. And the Democrats never do it. It's also the luxury that we have sitting on this desk and doing this at this particular moment in our lives in that we are under the hood.
33:43Like we're about to give you some stuff you're not going to hear anywhere else. Like we know this. but we also don't have a vested interest in a specific outcome so we're not going to color
33:55Michael Duncan: this analysis you're not going to hear this as like i'm going to say everything because i want desantis to enter i'm going to say you know what i mean like yeah and i think that's important because everything it particularly online feels like there's thumbs on the scale and dollars moving and things moving that you're like oh that's an interesting analysis i wonder oh it seems exactly the same as this candidate can i say one more thing on the jd tweet and again i love jd this is not trying to be a criticism it's just why are you going this is the truth real like i love jd because it feels like a fucking itch i gotta scratch yeah and that is like here's the thing i don't love about it and it's not about his diagnosis of the case which is wrong i'm happy to say that sure to me it feels beside the point it's like i don't want my vice president doing the doing the charlie cook routine yeah yeah like things things are things are right and true or they're not yeah you know we don't spin we don't put our our our finger up and say this is what the american people want and would change our politics for it yeah because we believe in things in this movement and we articulate what they are and we try to convince people to do it.
35:10That's called vision. Yeah. It's not about finding a cohort of the electorate and being like, well, I think if maybe we figured out a way to do this one thing, we could actually figure out a coalition to win. It just feels small. I'm sorry. It just feels small. It is. It is all of that. But it's also if this is the under the hood part. We know that they're doing these things for presidential positioning. We know that it is important to the vice president to give him space in the foreign adventurism category. It's fair. They leaked out stories immediately after the invasion of Iran about how uncomfortable the vice president was.
35:54The first person anecdotes in New York Times, in the Wall Street Journal, and all these places about how the vice president was the last person to argue against all of these things so we we know that they it's important to them to establish that identity yeah what it also does is contrast that with somebody like marco rubia or ted cruz or even ron de santis where he's got a lane that he's comfortable in but he's got a president that he's serving under that is kind of messing up that lane a little bit right if if jd is a part of the foreign adventurism in iran he can't cleanly run in that lane but if you're doing the kind of thing where you come out after an election where it is clear as day what happened and what voters were concerned about and you're like it was actually iran well it kind of re-establishes his cat his credibility in some ways to try to preserve and box out people that he sees as potential competition in that lane.
36:59I mean, that's just what's happening. But I'm fundamentally with you in the end. I don't want that. Like, I know you're running for president. Politics is politics. You got to try to convince people of all kinds of things. And there's strategic elements to it. Just don't do the Charlie Cook routine from the vice president's office. The Naval Observatory does not need to be meet the press.
37:20Michael Duncan: I disagree. I'm going to stand with JD. JD's for jail, Duncan. I'm against this. But it's just wrong. Here's a layer that will help supplant what this is all about. Graphic four. This is huge. This is a graphic from the Wall Street Journal that did an overview on ads mentioning the words tariffs or trade protectionism. This was long a Democratic issue, of course, came back into vogue for the Republican side with the rise of Donald Trump. And he spent some money talking about it on air. This cycle, tariffs or trade protectionism, there was$58.3 million spent mentioning those words all by Democrats.
38:14And all negative. Attacking the shit out of both of you.
38:18Michael Duncan: There was zero dollars spent by Democrats saying it's positive. There was zero dollars spent by Republicans saying it was positive. It was$58 million dumped saying that trade tariffs are bad. And here's why this matters, folks, is because we took you through those two previous graphics talking about how the number one issue was the economy and how like, yeah, they're not mad about the Iran war. They're mad about the gas and diesel prices going up as a result of the Strait of Hormuz. And they're mad about if diesel prices go up, then everything that's being shipped around this country, the price of that's going up, it's an economic issue.
38:53Michael Duncan: And so tariffs, they are not like, OK, I want to make sure that America can start reindustrialization. They're like, no, I don't want my prices to go up because everything's already too damn expensive. And so the Democrats capitalized on attack because it all came down to the wallet. And we never return serve. Never return serve. Never once. And I mean, that's what that thing illustrates. Yeah, I was just going to say, I mean, Smug, I thought, put it really well. I mean, the reason why they spent that money on that issue is because they saw the economy as the number one issue among voters. And Democrats played on the anxieties of people who maybe voted for Donald Trump at least once, if not three times in rural areas and places like you were talking about in Texas and other parts of the country where the tariffs meant something very different in a farm economy.
39:42It was a reality that in suburbia and Washington, D.C., you only hear about sort of academically. But in rural parts of the country, tariffs meant something different. Democrats knew that and so they were playing on the anxieties of these voters and told them that if you want relief from this – they were lying to them because Democrats – under no circumstances are Democrats going to actually do anything about it. They had no solution. They didn't need it. And they're not even interested in helping. They're just running ads, playing on anxieties of people. I'm just –$58 million on one topic is a lot of money to spend, especially if you look at the history.
40:21Put that graphic back up. If you look at the history of advertising on the issue of tariffs and trade, I mean going back, very little.
40:32Michael Duncan: I'm doing some quick math. between the years of 2018 and 2024, the combined total spending by both parties, whether negative or positive, was less by over a magnitude of 10 than the Dems spent 2026 on negative. Now, the reality of it is - It's like some Rain Man shit right there. He just looked at it and counted the toothpicks. This is a great episode. What is that? This is a great episode. Who is a Zen? I need another Zen. Thank you. The reality of it is that if this graph went back into the early 2000s, they'd find that Democrats spend an awful lot of money on the tariff issue from the other position in the state of Ohio.
41:15Sherrod Brown himself ran endless ads in the early 2000s saying that jobs are being shipped overseas. We need to revisit the tariff and trade policies. And then President Trump comes along and takes that message from those early 2000 Democrats and delivers it to people who are very familiar with it. It's a populist message. And the abstract sounds pretty good. But when you actually put them into place and it turns into attacks on flow into people's farm economies, different – completely different feeling. Yeah. No, I think that's right. But it's also something that the president unilaterally did.
41:55right? Which leads to a second argument I think President Trump made. On election night, the White House made it. I don't know if President Trump said this directly, but they talked about candidate quality. Yeah. Also, when Ayesha came on our show, our live stream and gave us - I hope I won't call that. That was incredible. It was incredible. When she was at the White House and was giving us all of this initial react from the White House, it was just amazing information in real time to get a window in to how this news was being absorbed in the White House. It's just great. I'm so glad she came on.
42:30Michael Duncan: What a value add. Yeah, that was awesome. I mean, she's the best. She's the best. To bring that to our live stream, because, I mean, my jaw dropped. Yeah, it's incredible. I mean, it's wild, first of all. Like, you know, hey. It's like a hot dog meme situation. I mean, the candidates are there because you endorsed them, right? I mean, that's what they are. But also, I would argue, from a candidate quality perspective, we did better than we used to do. We didn't nominate a cousin fucker. We didn't do a cousin fucker. We didn't have a jihadist. And we didn't have like the rest of these. I don't even know who the new South Carolina senator is.
43:04Never even saw her. Yeah. Tranny Annie. That's the only thing. Only thing I know is what Trump said. I mean, her face never showed up. Doug, it's one of the most depressing things about this entire election is like there are literal like phone book senators now. Yeah. I mean, people you couldn't even pick out.
43:20Michael Duncan: Dude, totally unvetted. There was a Democrat in Iowa who was elected who suspended their campaign in September. They suspended – in Iowa, they suspended their campaign in September and they won. And like some like reporter got in touch with them and they're like, I didn't – no, I ended my campaign. You're telling me for the first time. No, you will go to work. But look, I think if you're combining all of these things and you're talking about candidate quality, what you're doing is pushing off some culpability. Let's be honest. Yeah. That's what it is. You're pushing off some culpability for the result.
44:03But if you look at the advertising on tariffs and trade protectionism to the tune of 60 to zero, 60 million to zero for Democrats, they obviously made some headway on that argument. And then you look at the top issue facing voters and they said it's that. It's that. They won that argument. It's also a decision, a set of decisions exclusively made by the president of the United States. So like you look at a candidate like Ashley Hinson in Iowa, radically better candidate than her opponent, Turek, who ultimately won, was a great congresswoman, worked her tail off throughout. But she is saddled with an environment not of her own making on the economy, on tariffs and trade that resonate very, very deeply in the state of Iowa that she never voted for.
44:59And so, like, there is culpability in that. It is not just Donald Trump's on the ballot. He's not on the ballot. No, there's decisions here that were unilaterally made, far outside from war and peace, that ultimately that's the reason places like Iowa or Kansas are even in the discussion. They wouldn't be in the discussion.
45:25Michael Duncan: the reason so i don't know so someone run uh chat gpt or claude on our shows and be like how frequently did they say the environment on ruthless and there's a reason why because when you look at this electorate which was so pissed off about their own pocketbook and how much they're paying for stuff and relative to what they're seeing out there they're like wait why am i seeing all these like people doing great and i'm suffering then there's tariffs that 60 million dollars Dems are putting to remind them that like you know everything's more expensive for this and zero dollars are answering that and it is almost like this environment wasn't just like a negative environment this was like Republicans had to go out and fight in Chernobyl dog yeah like you've got it's like you've got 10 seconds with the shovel and then you're gonna croak yeah you know like yeah no no it's there are Democrats I got I have to repeat it there were Democrats who suspended their campaign three months ago who won.
46:23I would say on the candidate quality issue, it is very funny to endorse all the candidates and then complain about candidate quality. But the candidate quality argument is interesting because it can be both true and not the cause. Yeah. Like it is undoubtedly true in the Trump era that we've lost a lot of institutional knowledge in the Republican Party and how to run successful campaigns. Yes. And that there's a lot of Republicans who've gotten very lazy in thinking, oh, I just get an endorsement and a true social from the president. No, so I saw that critique from our friend Alex Bruchowitz, who is like, you know, the truth is, is that a lot of candidates in the Trump era have become super lazy.
47:01It's true. Super reliant. You see that in fundraising numbers. He's right. He's right. But it's not the point everywhere, right? Right. Like candidate quality does matter. But when you have a wave election that is really about everything, it is the thousand cuts election. you've got people like Ashley Henson who ran a great campaign and they suffer the same fate as Ken Paxton who couldn't like find two nickels to raise for himself and needed$200 million from SLF just to stand a chance to lose by double digits. You know what I mean? And so like, it's true, but not the cause. That's a hundred percent right.
47:38But also like, I think you could look at individual races and say that candidate quality could have changed the outcome well yeah like like donald trump didn't make doc marshall not hire a campaign manager fair right fair right yeah you know darlene graham could have raised more money right they could have but but but but reel that back i mean if we're if we're just going open kimono we might as well talk about it do it right i mean look lindsey graham never had an easy race for for senate in south carolina he was an incredible human being in terms of his force of personality. He was everywhere all the time.
48:12He did everything that you needed to do and worked his ass off doing it. Never beloved in South Carolina. His untimely passing, right as he had won a primary and gotten everything going in the right direction where you didn't have to worry about South Carolina, she comes in obvious choice to replace him in the interim. Somewhere along the way, the Trump administration makes a determination that she should be the permanent replacement how or why they made that decision i don't know it wasn't on data i can tell you that much it certainly wasn't candidate quality i know that much she did a debate where she said like foreign policy is not my thing right so so like look she seems like a very she's a good
48:57Michael Duncan: response i mean i'm gonna run down it's not my thing bro why are you asking me this shit she feels like she seems like a very nice woman i know yeah you know what i mean but this is the fucking big leagues yes we don't just put somebody's cousin troy jackson into the into the the field and expect them to win even in a state that you reliably win like this is the big short of a presidential election this is the thing that is the most difficult to obtain can i say man i think the greatest argument for i don't think candidate quality mattered is troy jackson being susan collins because you had well it happens in wave elections you saw jeff merckley in oregon who's still there beat uh gordon smith who was like a incredibly smart like very successful sophisticated like thoughtful lawmaker like the the iq imbalance on that race haunts me 20 years later right it's about to be so stupid oh it's so dumb like but you get that in waves You had it in 80.
49:59You saw a little bit of it in 2002. You saw it in definitely in 2006. Yeah, definitely in 2008. Lesser extent in 14. And there was some of that that washed out in 2018 from that huge Democratic House class of people. It's a fucking dumb asses that like can't hack it. So I think that's fine. Right. I mean, but wave elections get some of that dumb shit. The only way you can cut against the wave is having somebody who people think is like a serious person. You have to have your own identity. You can't just pretend to be Trump. But here is where – and this is the last graphic I want to show from these exits – was my lesson from 2006.
50:40You can have a bad environment and you can have a bunch of decisions that didn't go your way. Iraq war, Katrina, Harriet Meyer's Supreme Court nomination, the vice president shooting his friend in the fucking face. Like, you know, the worst set of news cycles you can ever imagine. Mark Foley diddling the pages. Like the worst stuff that you've ever seen in that 2006 election cycle. But how do you get people to vote entirely opposite from their ideology? A perception of corruption. That's the only way to do it. Pop up graphic five. 90 % of voters that showed up on Tuesday said government corruption was a crucial or major factor in their vote for Congress.
51:36Now, they break this down in terms of how people ultimately voted, if it was crucial, 63 % of those were Democrat. And clearly, when you're dealing with 90 % of the electorate, you're dealing with roughly half that are Republicans. Not a factor was 72 % Republican. So clearly, this over-indexed a Democratic side. and that is i think the thing that we've talked about the least on the ruthless variety program that i was doing a couple of panels before the election and i was like this is the one thing that i'm watching because it's the only thing that you can get in a place like texas kansas mississippi or south carolina to get people to be like you know what i'm fed up yeah i'm done like i don't agree with these people on anything but at least they're not trying to rob me we talked about all the money that democrats spent on the issue of tariffs they spent an awful lot of money on the Stock Act issue.
52:28You probably saw these ads all over the place for the entire fall, Democrats saying, we need to prevent members of Congress from being able to buy stocks. The truth of the matter is, Democrats defeated the effort to do the Stock Act. I mean, that's, it's a great irony here is that they get, once again, they're playing on people's anxieties and interests and they're never going to do anything about it.
52:51Michael Duncan: They did not need to offer solutions. They just needed to point a finger at the problem. But the other problem is, is that down the stretch, there wasn't a day that went by where a national news publication didn't talk about the billions of dollars that somebody who was tangentially associated with the Trump administration got on some weird contract. And then you had this bizarre, like Rick Grinnell and Alina Habba fight play out on the front pages of the New York Times and the Washington Post for two straight weeks about who was scamming who and who was making$50 million from some country you can't pronounce.
53:21and like all these things were happening in real time. I got a hot take on this, dude.
53:25Michael Duncan: Like, so about Alina Habah, I think she's gotten a bad rap because here's the thing, man. If I could make 50 mil in 24 hours, of fucking course I'm doing that shit. Are you fucking serious? What country was that? It was like some like Turk or some fucking Venice. I can't pronounce it. Listen, man, like I don't care what country it is. As long as it doesn't extradite, I'll do some shit for 50 mil. You know, like who's turning that down? Like, I don't think that's like a character judgment. 50 million is an insane amount. I don't think that people can wrap their heads around what 50 million in this economy.
53:55Michael Duncan: Like 50 million, like your great, great grandkids, grandkids are set. Generational wealth. Just the compounding interest on this. So Alina, I stand with that. And listen, you know where to get some good contracts. Hit me up. to get to 90 percent of voter concern on the issue of corruption that captures a number of republican leaning voters when you say corruption they immediately think somali fraud in minnesota in maine and places that have become famous yes but no i mean that's why this graphic is so important yeah you still have 35 percent of republicans in there that think it's a crucial issue and those are probably the somali fraud all the stuff that dojan covered and everything else problem is you have 63 of the electorate that is a democrat persuasion at least who they voted for they think it's the predominant issue you lost the thing by 30 points it's not a close balance it's not like half the republicans went in and thought it was the smallies and half the democrats came in and thought it was the trump administration no two-thirds of the electorate thought it was the trump administration and that that is ultimately the problem like look i'm not here to litigate whether or not any of this shit's true or not i mean god knows you're gonna have to deal with that and i think that's a crucial part about this is like this is what the voters that's what the voters are saying right and it's not we kind of glossed over a lot of this because we were so i think at least speaking for myself so used to the four-year first term where every single day there was some completely quixotic, bizarre allegation about - Russia gave.
55:35Trump kid or something, all of which were entirely untrue, made up stuff. So I just kind of let that shit fly over me in this second term. Well, it turns out the voters didn't. They looked at it and they have some concerns, very real concerns. And I marry that up with my life experience in the first sort of material election I was doing national stuff in, in 2006. And it feels similar. It feels like the only way that you can get somebody in West Texas to vote for a lunatic like James Tallarico is to believe that the corruption of the current government is so significant, he'll do anything else.
56:19And I think that's, it's an undervalued component. Nobody's talking, you're not going to get that on conservative media. Nobody wants to talk it. Nobody wants to touch it. It was an issue in that Senate race. It was. I mean, the Democrats attacked him in like incessantly on corruption issues. I mean, I don't know that they ran ads on anything other than that in that Texas Senate race. Yeah. But I just think that the larger backdrop clearly cascaded far beyond that particular race and played a formative role, at least according to exit polls that you just can't, you know, We can't really get back.
56:53So, I mean, look, there's a lot of rebuilding. I don't want to leave it totally on a sour note. We're going to be okay. Yeah. This is not a permanent situation. We didn't wake up with Sharia law. You know what I mean? Like, we didn't fundamentally change from a center-right country on Tuesday. What we found out is that they don't believe that the current party in power represents that. they don't believe that we are doing the center right thing that we all thought we should do that's problematic but it does provide you an opportunity to take it down to the studs and if you're honest about it rebuild and provide a much better product which in all honesty is a good thing
57:37Michael Duncan: and can if i can say the the silver lining which is also a warning at the same time is thank god this wave didn't happen in a presidential year because there is still that stop get we still have the supreme court you're right as a stop gap because if this it happened in a presidential year dude like then there's no stop for medicaid for all and all of a sudden that that is the socialism it's in the door but that's what they're gunning for in two years yeah so learn the lesson now before we get it handed to us in two years, and then it's the socialism. Then it's too late. Yeah. There's going to be a lot more lessons learned, some recommendations from the Variety Program, having gone through this a couple of times as we go along.
58:22But it brings us to our question of the day. All of you live this. I'm sure you had as depressing an evening as we did in a lot of different ways. When you like and subscribe to the Ruthless Variety Program, we ask you a question. You give us your responses. We read absolutely all of them, And we'll get back to you with sampling the very next episode. Our question today to you, why did Republicans lose? Interested for all of your thoughts, as we always are, because I think it's probably different in a bunch of different states and a bunch of different perspectives. Coming up, Democrats, they're going to overread this shit.
58:55Yep. You know they're going to do it. It's already started. We have some incredible clips right after this. Okay. Welcome back to the Ruthless Variety program. what we wanted to do is make sure that we package this segment with your favorite Democrat.
59:10Michael Duncan: What a piece of garbage this guy is. The visceral reaction that Smug has to this cat. Like this guy. He hates him so much. Because for like, man, for like over a decade it feels like I've been telling my friends in Silicon Valley that this guy's a snake. It's so genuine. And a piece of garbage. God, I hate him. And he, I mean, I think I already talked. Ro Khanna showed up in my DMs trying to be like, let's have a discussion. I was like, dude, you're a bitch. What are we going to talk about? I hate you. How do you not understand this? Every time you have to understand this as a listener, every time that this guy's name shows up in a show sheet that Wolf gives us, I auto green light it just because I can watch when I say his name.
59:50Smug is like – there's a purple vein that comes out in the middle of his forehead.
59:55Michael Duncan: He embodies – he's a phony. He's a liar. He hates him so much. He's like, we're going to fight the billionaires. He has a trust which has multiple luxury golf courses bequeathed to his children. They're like generational golf course trusts. And he's like, I'm going to fight the wealthy. What I love about him is he's also completely delusional. Yeah. Like this is a human being who has no idea their lack of ability to persuade. Like they think – the funniest thing in politics to me, maybe just in life, is someone with overconfidence in an area where they clearly lack any sort of – Dude, you've got 100%.
1:00:33Adequate stuff, right? Where it's somebody in politics who are like, I'm going to give this speech because I'm the best speech giver. And then you give it and they're like, dude, everyone fucking hates this speech. Like this is this guy's – he believes that he is sort of like outsmarted the electorate.
1:00:50Michael Duncan: He's running for president because he thinks there's an audience for that. He thinks that there's an audience for it. But he also thinks that like the whole thing that built him from the beginning being like, well, I'm just sort of your moderate business friendly Democrat who sort of understands new age technology and the new economy and all that stuff. Like he's like, well, that doesn't work with the El Sayed Democrat Party. So now I'm just going to be a goat fucker. Yep. But he thinks that he's smooth by doing it. So he's like, I'm going to get on that presidential stage because I'm going to convince everybody that I'm the OG goat fucker, despite the fact that like 18 months ago I was singing the moderate tune.
1:01:31That's what I find so fascinating about this guy. Check out clip one. Tonight, DEI is back as America celebrated diversity and inclusion. likely three black governors the first latina governor in texas the first muslim american senator the first gay senator i love this america it's not first of all it's not the first gay senator well we know it's just pure cinema right there that's just incredible and so that's also
1:02:03Michael Duncan: part of the silver not even close not even close not even like the self-admitted sitting senator Tammy Baldwin in Wisconsin. It's like, no, but he's like wrong on multiple. The thing is that like, this is also a silver lining. He's such a fucking idiot. They have so over, like they have completely misread this. They think that like, oh no, all of a sudden voters decided they are for all the lib bullshit. Yeah. No, they were against the economic environment. They weren't for the lib bullshit. The bullshit's what got you idiots in trouble in the first place. Please run back that playbook. Another reason to have no fear, dear listener, that however fucked up we appear right now and our ability to sort of execute remedial political tasks, which I understand your skepticism because this wasn't good.
1:02:57Democrats will figure out how to fuck this up in short order. Like they really will. They're incredible at it. Yeah. If they don't fuck it up, they'll fuck their cousin. But I also think it's kind of funny that he immediately goes back to sort of the corporate dem message on something. When the prevailing DSA desire is no communism. We want to destroy America. And he's like, God, DEI is back, everybody. And they're like, get out of here. We're going to bring this shit down. Yeah, totally. And then like if you would have ended that by saying like, and no Jews. that would have been like then we really know he's serious because like he's not even he's not
1:03:38Michael Duncan: even gonna be top five in california running for president no by the way he's not a serious person he's just not um i don't know if i had a conversation with a couple of people and they were like look i'm not depressed like this is a bad outcome but like we'll rebuild and we're going to be better and this is like an opportunity to just get things right and kind of restack bricks which is my opinion about all of this they're like but the one thing i can't take are the victory speeches they're like man if you hear those things you just are reminded how crazy these people are because in a moment of elation they let they drop the veil yeah right all the things it's the full abby spamburger in 30 seconds right in front of you they're like i told you i was moderate i fucking lied yeah you know what i mean like they just do that and none captured that for me better than El Syed in Michigan.
1:04:33Clip two. My name is Abdul Rahman Mohammed Sayyid.
1:04:43And I am so proud and honored to stand here as your senator-elect from the great state of Michigan.
1:04:56up until right about now you might have noticed i always say inshallah or god willing whenever the outcome of this race was mentioned but today tonight we can turn that inshallah into alhamdulillah
1:05:15Michael Duncan: and that's what it was all about dude it's like i'd like to introduce you to the real me long live the ayatollah he's like so i know everyone voted for economic reasons i mean literally is what he just like that's an important point to make is because they did not run on a message that connected to voters voters voted against something yeah they're reading this as like oh we we they love this let's serve this up i don't think that's gonna work and And also, this comes off as so corny. And a significant base of this vote is the left-wing lunatic, the awful, the left-wing white female college educated who are like, oh, that's so cool because he said four Islamic words.
1:06:11Michael Duncan: And so that means it's good. You know what I mean? The whole DSA of anti-Western civilization is like, oh, he's saying the Islamic words. I love this. Love it. Like it's some like novelty. Yeah. Yeah. Except he's looking out of the crowd and he's like, they do love the Intifada. Yeah. You know what I mean? And that's where I'm being hyperbolic, obviously, but that's where Democrats are going to land on this deal. Yep. Is that they're going to come rushing into Congress thinking like they love Medicare for all. They love pure socialism. They love like a prosecution of the president of the United States and all the people in the White House.
1:06:45They love all this stuff. No, dude, you're just the other guy. you know what I mean you're just on the ballot with somebody they couldn't vote for
1:06:53Michael Duncan: Schumer or whoever else is stuck holding the reins of these Senate Democrats are going to have to deal with maniacs like this guy being like every day you have to pass Medicare for all this is what the American people wanted every day he's going to be attacking Schumer being like why don't you pass Medicare for all this is what the American people want we haven't talked enough about it we're going to get a chance in the lame duck to examine the management concerns that Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer are going to be going through that guy's gonna be a nightmare he's gonna be a problem for him he's gonna be a nightmare i mean couldn't happen to a better bunch right you know i hope he causes all the problems i think he is um anyway we're gonna have a lot more of that we're gonna have fun time friday tomorrow we're gonna give you all that we'll continue to try to have as good a time as we can under the circumstances and we're gonna play king of the hill on we're playing yeah we moved king of the hill because we figured you needed a long form here yeah uh so we'll do that on friday and then And like, look, we're going to rebuild this thing because we actually give a shit.
1:07:49Yep. And we're not being paid to give a shit. We've just spent our entire lives in this space. And we've seen some dark times. In fact, some more challenging times than this. And we're going to be in this for the long haul. We're going to have some laughs along the way. Thank you for joining all of us on the Ruthless Variety program. With that, fellas, I think we did it.
1:08:06Michael Duncan: I think so. Absolute banger of an episode. Gentlemen, thank you so much to our listeners. Remember, if you have not yet, go to the YouTube and hit that subscribe because it's more fun in video. So until next time, minions, keep the faith, hold the line, and own the libs. We'll see you on Friday. Stay ruthless.
1:08:41you
Ruthless breaks down the Republican Party’s devastating midterm losses, examining how economic frustration, tariffs, government corruption concerns, and campaign missteps contributed to the Democratic wave.
Plus, the fellas challenge JD Vance’s election analysis, discuss what Republicans must do to rebuild, and react to victory speeches from Ro Khanna and Abdul El-Sayed as Democrats prepare to take power.
#RuthlessPodcast #Midterms #Politics
0:00:00 Intro
0:04:11 Why Republicans Suffered a Historic Midterm Defeat
0:08:00 Trump's Policy Wins Overshadowed by Administration Controversies
0:14:22 Republicans Face a Difficult Six-Year Senate Rebuilding Effort
0:20:32 Texas Voters Reject Ken Paxton as Trump's Economic Approval Plummets
0:23:26 Exit Polls Reveal the Economy Was Voters' Biggest Concern
0:25:42 Did JD Vance Misread the Reasons Republicans Lost?
0:37:15 Democrats Spend $58 Million Attacking Trump's Tariffs
0:41:00 White House Blames Candidate Quality for Republican Losses
0:50:28 Government Corruption Emerges as a Major Election Issue
0:59:27 Ro Khanna Celebrates Democratic Victories and the Return of DEI
1:03:57 Abdul El-Sayed's Victory Speech Signals Trouble for Democratic Leaders
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices