1. Podcasts
  2. Sake Deep Dive
  3. Futsushu Revisited - Sake's Uncrowned King (Still)
Sake Deep Dive

31 Oct 2026 · 1h 4m · 19 chapters

Episode artwork

Futsushu Revisited - Sake's Uncrowned King (Still)

In short

Revisits Sake Deep Dive’s first episode on Futsushu (“uncrowned king” of sake), arguing it’s the most important and misunderstood sake category because it’s the default for most production outside Tokutei Meishoshu. They discuss futsushu’s wide range, why it got a bad reputation (WWII-era Sanzoshu/Nizoshu sweetening), how to evaluate it (ingredient count; added alcohol/sweeteners), and how modern “ungraded” sake and rice shortages (Togaimai) are reshaping the category.

Guests

Julian Hausman, co-host Ryan’s replacement. Background: opened a small 10-seat sake bar in Osaka in Feb 2023; explains futsushu to beginners and connoisseurs; also a translator (not drinking sake as much now).

Key claims

Futsushu isn’t defined by “cheap carton” quality; supermarket futsushu can be good, but many are “Nizoshu” style. Ingredient lists matter more than labels. Ungraded sake is increasingly common and may dilute “classic” futsushu branding.

Notable examples

Senkin (Tochigi) as ungraded; Kikumasamune carton Kimoto; Hakutsuru Maru; Tsuru no Tomo (Niigata City, Josen-style); Nihonjo (Yoshimura Hideo Shoten, Wakayama; Nama Genshu, ~18%, works warm/chilled/room).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Handover Announcement

Ryan announces his departure and Julian's takeover as co-host.

“Good to hear it we're I think we're set for another couple of almost 30-degree days down here in Yamaguchi, but then we'll be in for the usual nice chilly autumn weather.”
2:36

Reflecting on Five Years

Hosts reflect on their journey over five years and the significance of Futsushu.

“I don't know if our listeners pay attention much to my other activities, but I am technically, and I always have been a translator more than anything.”
6:12

Revisiting Futsushu

Discussion on the importance of Futsushu and its current relevance in the sake industry.

“uh that i already did the segue no you did you did but i was i was emotional i was emotional so I'll let it slide this time.”
10:55

Introducing Julian's Experience

Julian introduces his sake bar and shares insights on consumer reactions to Futsushu.

“My opinion has only changed in the sense I'm now much more of a futsushu drinker than I was back then.”
13:00

Julian's Subcategories of Futsushu

Julian outlines his three subcategories of Futsushu and their reputations.

“And I think one of the things for me that I've found when I'm explaining sake to people or explaining about specific sake to customers and to guests is I've kind of found myself putting Futsushu into three subcategories.”
14:02

Understanding Futsushu Tiers

Learn about the different tiers of futsushu and their significance.

“It's the cheap stuff that's made by a lot of the big breweries.”
16:02

Premium Futsushu and Market Perceptions

Explore the evolving perception of futsushu and premium offerings.

“it sounds silly to almost say they're like a premium category of Futsu Shu, but we're noticing them more.”
18:07

Quality Indicators in Sake

Discover key indicators of sake quality and consumer advice.

“Like if you get beyond added alcohol, then you're starting to get into really bad headache territory.”
22:47

Historical Context of Sake Production

Understand the historical factors affecting sake production and reputation.

“But basically, the reason that Aruten sake has gotten such a bad reputation was during World War II, when rice was being rationed, the government still wanted to make sake because it's a massive source of tax income.”
28:05

Understanding the Old Tax Classification System

Learn about the historical tiers of sake classification and their flaws.

“talk about the cube to say though in the first episode and we've mentioned the cube to say though many times.”
Show all 19 chapters
31:30

Evolving Classification and the Rise of Futsushu

Explore how the futsushu category has gained importance in the modern sake market.

“you're absolutely right, Julian, it doesn't give the consumer much information.”
34:24

The Role of Togai-Mai in Sake Production

Discover the significance of ungraded rice in the contemporary sake industry.

“So maybe we should talk about Togai-Mai, because I think this is a very, very important part of this discussion.”
40:34

Navigating the Future of Futsushu and Sake Labeling

Discuss potential changes in the futsushu category and sake labeling practices.

42:00

Exploring Futsu Shu Sake Labels

Discussion on the labeling and categorization of Futsu Shu sake.

“brewers are able to take this Togaimai and brew incredible sake with it and put it into their futsu shoe category.”
44:30

Futsu Shu Awards and Competitions

Analysis of Futsu Shu participation in sake competitions and its implications.

“got something and it might be IWC and then I also think there was one, the brands Horai, Watanabe Shuzo didn't they win an award for Futsu Shoe?”
47:10

The Future of Futsu Shu in Japan

Discussion on the challenges and changes facing Futsu Shu sake and its market relevance.

“And we'll do a particular focus on what qualifies as a Futsu shoe.”
52:50

Recommended Sake Selections

Hosts suggest specific Futsu Shu sakes and share their personal favorites.

“I've got, I have a cardboard carton of it downstairs for cooking and for the occasional tipple as well.”
56:00

Exploring Futsushu: Tsuru no Tomo

Learn about the futsushu sake Tsuru no Tomo and its unique qualities.

“You have to be very careful with Tsuru no Tomo.”
57:36

Personal Recommendations: Nihonjo

Discover Julian's personal recommendation for a memorable futsushu.

“And she said, this is a local futushu from Wakayama and it was Nihonjo, as in Nihon Castle, Japan Castle.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Sake Deep Dive, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:19Welcome to Sake Deep Dive, the sake podcast for the beyond beginner. I am your host Ryan joined as always by my friend and co-host Andy Russell Andrew how you doing today?

0:33Julian Houseman: I am good Jim I'm loving the the autumn weather right now it's just right it'll be like that for about a week and then we'll be back to back to complaining about the weather but for now I am I am very good. Good to hear it we're I think we're set for another couple of almost 30-degree days down here in Yamaguchi, but then we'll be in for the usual nice chilly autumn weather. And speaking of usual or perhaps unusual, today we've got some things to announce. We've got some changes are coming to the Sake Deep Dive podcast. and uh i think the first big change is is as i'd like to announce that we've got a special guest on our episode today mr julian hausman julian want to say hi hello hi thank you for having me on i feel like i'm breathing rarefied air here a very a very very uh big thing because we have never had a guest it's always just been me and andy sitting in our respective rooms yelling at each other about the things that bother us about sake.

1:45And I hope that getting a behind-the-scenes glimpse doesn't turn you off of the sake deep dive experience. Not at all. Not at all. Looking forward to it. Yeah, particularly because the reason that we are having Julian on today is because I am going to be stepping away from the mic. this is my last official episode as a co-host of sake deep dive and uh julian's going to be taken over for me and i'm very appreciative of that you know i it's it's it's uh been a hell of a project and we definitely don't want to see it end so having a having a a wonderful set of uh lungs to to step in and and take over for me when i'm gone is a reassuring event

2:36Julian Houseman: I would just like to say first it has been an absolute privilege working with you Jim so this is we just talked about this before we we came on air we started this over five years ago and we we have barely missed an episode that entire time so I feel like we've grown in that time we're we're different people almost since that that time five years ago I was I was still in Hiroshima you were very much involved still with the sake industry but obviously you've gone on to do these amazing things in translation so yeah before we do the the official official handover i just want to say thank you very much for a wonderful five years thank you it it it was quite a uh an adventure and it has been a pleasure and and an honor and and i've i've enjoyed it but um yeah like you said things have kind of moved in unexpected ways for me.

3:36I don't know if our listeners pay attention much to my other activities, but I am technically, and I always have been a translator more than anything. And in the last couple of years, I've been translating novels, which is kind of, you translator's big dream. And luckily, very, very luckily, while the general translation industry has gone into kind of a real doldrum, I have had the great fortune of translating some, I guess the only word, the only phrase is international bestsellers. and it has become sort of a career in and of itself just dealing with the fact that the books that I've translated have gotten so much attention that that has kind of carried over to me and I am I have I have become kind of the go-to guy for a certain type of Japanese novel to be translated.

4:40And frankly, I am busier than I have ever been doing all of this, handling the translations and the requests and questions about other books and media and stuff. So it has become a really big thing for me to try to deal with. And I simply don't have as much attention as I used to. And I have to be serious about this. I don't drink sake like I used to. Something about getting older, I don't know. My body doesn't quite eat it the way it used to. So yeah, I think it just generally feels like time for me to move on and focus on other things. And I, but I wish all of our listeners the best and I will be paying attention to how it goes

5:32Julian Houseman: forward yeah well we we will hopefully be able to to call on your amazing translation services which have been so so important to this podcast yeah the translation aspect is surely going to take a nose dive with you not around but we'll we'll we'll work on the the segways as well we we don't want to let that oh we're never going to come we're never going to reach the the giddy heights that you you've achieved with your segues but we'll do our best my one indelible uh contribution to the the to the sake industry is my ability to force force a pun into uh my podcasts and and i i have to admit i'm a little bit upset that no one caught up on the fact that uh that i already did the segue no you did you did but i was i was emotional i was emotional so I'll let it slide this time.

6:26Julian Houseman: Yeah, so. You can tell us then what that was, but I did pick up on it. The usual, the unusual. Today, we are doubly unusual in the fact that we are not only bringing on a guest, but we are revisiting a topic. In fact, the very first topic. We are revisiting the very first topic that we handled on Sake Deep Dive, And that is the most common of commons The uncrowned king of the sake industry What are we talking about today Andy? We are talking about, I think, the most important topic In the entirety of the sake industry Which is Futsu Shu And yeah, you are right, that was our first ever episode Was Futsu Shu, humble king of sake It's still one of our most listened to episodes and it's as important if not more so today as it was back then so that is why we we've come full circle I guess in your Saki Deep Dive journey is that we're going to revisit that topic and see where we are today with Futsu Shu have our own opinions changed is it less relevant is it more relevant is there anything to add to the topic so yeah another first for us is that we're going to finally revisit one of our previous episodes?

7:53I think it, you know, it's probably a good time to kind of reflect on sort of why, why did we choose Futsushu as our first episode? And I think it's, it all comes down to the fact that the both of us, Andy, really quite like Futsushu as a segment, as a drink, as part of the drinking culture. And, you know, there was a bit of, I think frustration with the way it was perceived. It has been perceived by other elements of, of the industry. People sort of, I guess the sake educators and sake, uh, I don't know if pundits is the right word. People who talk about sake, the way that we like to talk about sake, maybe didn't give it the kind of respect that we thought it deserved, or at least I think that's, that's part of what my attitude was.

8:46Julian Houseman: No mine was very much the same I think it's quite possibly The most misunderstood topic In sake It's often given A really Bad reputation Without any of the nuance Without actually discussing what it is And The total spectrum Of what exists within The Futsu Shu category And like I just said there I really mean that. I think it is the most important topic now in the sake industry, the way that consumption continues to decline, the way that consumers continue to get fewer and fewer, which is particularly acute, obviously, in Japan. And I think food sushu is really key to fixing many of the woes that the industry is now facing.

9:41Julian Houseman: And it starts with changing the attitude towards food sushu and at least just raising the understanding within general consumers as to what actually it means and what it doesn't mean. Right. So I think it probably wouldn't hurt just to sort of reiterate that when we talk about Futsushu, what we're talking about is basically any Seishu that doesn't fall under the rather rigid definitions of the Tokuteime Shoshu classification system. Right. And when we first sort of broached this, I think both of us agreed that, yes, Futsushu was far more worthy of respect than people seemed to believe. that the simple fact that it is the majority of sake produced and consumed falls under that kind of catch-all term and that there is a reason that it is so fundamental to the industry.

10:49And discussing those was important to us. And I don't think our opinions have changed. My opinion hasn't changed, right?

10:56Julian Houseman: My opinion has only changed in the sense I'm now much more of a futsushu drinker than I was back then. I was still mostly buying premium sake, even though I loved drinking futsushu. now my the sake that i have at home is is primarily food sushi the majority of it is food sushi i use it for for cooking i drink the stuff i experiment with temperatures and stuff i'll have bottles open that stay open the whole all year round so it's the category that i partake in more than any other so if anything in five years i've come to have more of an appreciation of Futsu Shu. But you said this right in the first few minutes of the first podcast, Futsu Shu is more a topic of what it is not than what it is.

11:50Julian Houseman: I think that does everything to tell you how wide a spectrum exists within the Futsu Shu category. But I think it would be good as well, maybe at this point, to hear from someone else as well, because Julian, obviously, we didn't get a formal introduction. I think a lot of people will know who Julian is anyway that are listening But for anyone that isn't, it would be good to get a quick introduction from Julian Specifically tell us what Julian does Because Julian, unlike the two of us Has experience on the front of house Dealing with Futsu Shu So it would be interesting to get Julian's thoughts on Futsu Shu as well And let's see if they align with our own Well, yeah, I suppose it wasn't a formal introduction But yeah, since February last year, I've opened a sake bar here in Osaka, a very small little 10-seater sake bar.

12:47um so yeah it's been a very interesting you know coming up on two years um to see firsthand you know uh people's um reactions and opinions and you know feelings about certain styles and brands of sake um whether they're you know connoisseurs or whether they're beginners and novices it's everyone seems to have a you know a unique approach to it so yeah it's been interesting to see uh there's something, you know, there are certain reactions to Futsushu. And I think one of the things for me that I've found when I'm explaining sake to people or explaining about specific sake to customers and to guests is I've kind of found myself putting Futsushu into three subcategories.

13:37And I'd like to run these by you and see what you think, if you agree with my kind of assessment of what futsushu is these days is I've kind of put it into these three subcategories. And the third tier of futsushu is the futsushu, which I think comes to mind for a lot of people when you say the word, which is the stuff that you see in the supermarket or in the convenience store, which is often in cardboard boxes. It's the carton sake. It's the cheap stuff that's made by a lot of the big breweries. And I think that's the stuff that kind of has the reputation for having more of the additives and whatnot.

14:11uh thrown in there which and is the sake that kind of in a way possibly gives uh futsushu a bad reputation or bad name and then the second tier for me of futsushu is the futsushu that breweries made traditionally for their local environment their local community and uh most breweries that have a history tend to still regardless of what kind of sake they're making for national or international distribution they seem to still have their local futsushu which doesn't need to be a futsushu, but because it's the one that they've been producing the longest just by its nature, it's usually a futsushu in its design and brewing style as well as the way it's graded.

14:52And then the last tier of futsushu is kind of the one that we're seeing more of, is what I actually prefer to call ungraded sake. So it's sake that's where they've decided not to go with the tokote miishu labeling, and then by default it gets called a futsushu which is i think the most obvious and clear example that people see the most would be senkin in tochigi who are i guess all of their sake of it now because they don't put lists say my boy on their labels and they they don't use any of the tokote meishi or she grading all of their sake could be regarded as futsushu having said that i find it a bit you know odd and kind of cheeky to be calling the style of sake they make futsushu when it's nothing like the other two tiers that i mentioned before so i think there's that yeah that's personally the way i've found when i'm explaining a certain sake to a guest to a customer i kind of put it in one of those three tiers of what a futsushu is um and it's usually not the third tier that i'm serving but the other two um so yeah i don't know what do you think of that assessment of Futsu Shu.

16:00Julian Houseman: I know what you mean. There is now a sort of new, it sounds silly to almost say they're like a premium category of Futsu Shu, but we're noticing them more. But what I would say about that list is they've actually always been there though. This ungraded thing, I mean, you've got brands like Kenbishi that have never paid attention to Tokutei Mei Shoshu, because why would they? They're a 500 plus year old company. They're trying to make SACI the way they did at the beginning. And that is almost 500 years before the Tokutameh social system even existed. So why on earth would they align themselves with tax regulations that are only a few years old and will very likely not be relevant in the next 20 or so years?

16:52Julian Houseman: so these brands, KMBC are not alone there are other brands that have done that as well and the other thing about the supermarket the carton stuff there is some pretty bad stuff within that segment of the industry there's also some really good stuff as well I mean you have things like Sawano Tsuru and things that exist in that carton segment these are futu shoes and things And they're made by the Kimoto method. They have less additives probably than some of the top stuff that does the rounds in Japan. So yeah, that is a very good general take on the modern field of futsushu, but there's still definitely exceptions within that.

17:40Julian Houseman: There always has been really since the beginning of the Tokutei Meishu system. them it came in and the industry reacted but there was an industry before it and there'll be an industry after it and not everyone has bothered to to play by the those rules yeah it's it's very difficult to kind of pigeonhole everything into into these very neat categories I don't know what does Jim think about that I think um like I think in general uh Julian and I are on very similar wavelengths i would only challenge like you did the the the assumption that the stuff you get in the supermarket has any indication of quality i think the only thing you need to do is look at the ingredients and if you see more than three ingredients then you're probably getting into unpleasant territory and that's true of whether it's it's a local brand that's been making stuff for its market for 100 years or it's in the supermarket.

18:44Like if you get beyond added alcohol, then you're starting to get into really bad headache territory. And, you know, I think I wrote a blog about that before we even started the podcast and that my attitude towards futsushu was based simply upon that. If you get this stuff with added sweeteners, you're getting into what I call nizoshu, which is the sort of the follow-up to what started the whole problem with Hutsushu in the first place, the Sanzoshu of World War II. But even today, like if you go to the supermarket, like Kiku Masamune's game pack, the silver carton of Shibori Tate Sake is really good.

19:32Julian Houseman: It's brilliant. It's brilliant. as is their other one the most recognisable Kikuma Samuni, the Kimoto it's just literally just called Kimoto that is an absolute top quality sake and it's in cartons as well as Ishiro beans as well but you also get it in the cartons so yeah there's some proper gems in there that I mean the most popular sake in Japan full stop objectively is also in that category as well as hakatsuru maru and that that is also actually a really good sake if you but for for warming sake for just you know a cheap does does exactly what it says on the carton sake there's there's a very very good candidate so yeah i i agree like i didn't you know it wasn't necessarily uh writing off all the things that are in the supermarket and i totally agree the kiguma samurai gimpak is excellent um neon sakari is also released i think it's called kaerio there which is a blend of honjozo and daiginjo um and that's in that's the pack sake that's out there and that's excellent as well there's definitely good ones there but i think uh i mean yeah when i talked when people you know especially if someone comes to japan i think it's a it can be a tough place to start if um i mean i don't generally don't advise people you know if you're looking to buy some sake to take home um yeah maybe the stuff in the 7-eleven isn't the isn't the best thing that's going to really reward you if you're not because i think it's almost a a full circle thing when people come to sake and they they try you know maybe something that wasn't that's not really mind-blowing to begin with and they move towards more extravagant ostentatious styles of sake and then you kind of come full circle and then come back to wanting something a bit more restrained.

21:24And I think, yeah, I just think, yeah, there's, yeah, I totally agree. There's definitely some, you know, Hakutsu de Maduo was pleasantly surprised at how drinkable that is as well. It's very, very good. But, yeah, I just don't think it's necessarily the best. I don't really, yeah, I don't send people to the supermarket to buy sake, I guess is what I'm saying. I just, I think it's if you're getting into it or, you know, you're probably safer going to a more specialised sake store if you want to find good what we might call good examples of sci-fi to really get you hooked on it

21:56Julian Houseman: i think is what else yeah so that that's the third on your list then let's deal with the other two then so the the local one because like i said the futu shoe category is is a massive spectrum and that's just one one part of that so jim just said something very interesting and something we didn't actually talk about in any great detail on the original episode jim mentioned nizoshu and sansoshu so for anyone that doesn't know what those two things are let's get our money's worth out of jim before he goes so what what are you talking about there jim when you're talking about nizoshu and sansoshu and and is this linked to why futsushu has a bad rep right so let's start with Sanzo Shio, we've discussed it at some point.

22:45I think it was the Aruten episode. But basically, the reason that Aruten sake has gotten such a bad reputation was during World War II, when rice was being rationed, the government still wanted to make sake because it's a massive source of tax income. And it's also kind of an important part of the social fabric and keeping soldiers motivated and things. And so they developed a way of making sake where basically you really dilute it a lot with alcohol. That helps to keep it from freezing when you're shipping it over to Manchuria or whatever. But then it just tastes like alcohol. So what you have to do is sweeten it up again so that it tastes like yonju.

23:25And what you do then is basically dump a bunch of sweeteners and flavoring and acids into it so that it tastes more like sake used to. And by doing that, you can generate basically three times as much sake from the same amount of rice as you would have under other production methods. And so that sanzoushu basically means tripled. It has been expanded by three. That process was outlawed in 1996, I think it was. You cannot add that much different stuff to sake. You can still add lots of different things to sake, different flavors, amino acid flavors and sweeteners and things like that. but the basic limits are now down to you can only double it by sort of legal classifications.

24:17If you go over that, it's no longer seishu. And so nizoshu is doubled is what I call it. Now, keeping in mind that those are limits, they're not requirements, right? You don't have to add anything to your sake if you don't want to. And so the people that make futsushu as a big part of their products, they're free to make it in different ways. Some of those companies still do make doubled sake. They still add sweeteners and sugars and stuff. And some of those are small local breweries. Some of those sake breweries here in Yamaguchi that do make futsushu, some of them do still make that nizoshu.

24:57They still add mizuame, what do you call it? like syrup, wheat gum syrup or whatever you want to call it. And it's not great. I've tried it. Not a big fan of the stuff with sweeteners in it. But some of the local breweries never did that. Then they only added brewer's alcohol, which is, you know, aruten. And it's sort of the backbone of your honjozos and your basic futsushus. You can add more brewer's alcohol to food sushi than you can to Honjozo.

25:32Julian Houseman: Okay, so that's the baseline then for, if you want to look at it that way, I guess, the worst that it could be in terms of what's in your food sushi is it's double yielded with subsidiary ingredients, most likely added alcohol, but possibly other things like sweeteners and added acids or something along those lines. But like you just said, that's not a rule, which does seem to be the perception that people have, that because that is the maximum permissible, then that defines the futsushu category. That's a fair assessment then, is it? right yeah i think you know in in general we can say that um anything more than added alcohol is is getting into nizoshu into the sort of the double deal because if you add some brewer's alcohol you don't need to adjust the flavor too much like brewer's alcohol can actually improve flavors but if you add too much brewer's alcohol then you've got a problem it's way too dry and you need to sweeten it back up so you know there are lots of different methods that you can use to do that you know we've talked i think about uh yondan jikomi as as one of the ways that is done uh without adding you know other sweeteners or whatever but um yeah yeah again all of this is just choice like there are different tools in the brewer's toolbox yeah it's worth pointing out as well just for for our listeners that maybe don't come to japan and see these futsushu there is an unofficial hierarchy within Futsushu.

27:24Julian Houseman: It isn't a complete free-for-all that you have no idea what it's going to be like from looking at the label, because Futsushu labels, they typically don't have much information. These brands, they date back to a time where consumers weren't necessarily interested in the things that consumers are almost fixated on today for example what's the rice variety or what's the what's the rice polishing ratio or what level of alcohol is in them they go back to before the top of the initial issue the cube to say though and we did talk about the cube to say though in the first episode and we've mentioned the cube to say though many times.

28:11Julian Houseman: But for anyone that hasn't listened to those, it's the old taxing tier system, which was very simple, but also fundamentally flawed, that just had three tiers of sake. The top grade, Tokyu, then Ikyu was first grade, and then Nikyu, second grade. And when that system disappeared, brewers were suddenly left with no official, according to the tax people, no official way of explaining to their customers what the grades of these products were. Because bear in mind, really, before the Tokatemi Shoshu, Junmai wasn't really a thing as the Junmai legal classification, not necessarily just not being something made from rice, but ginjo wasn't really a thing either so what really you had was different levels of added alcohol and so the the brewers had to basically come up with their own propriety grades and that's what you'll often see on the labels of food sushi now unfortunately you can't necessarily look at it and say well because it has that grade in it it will definitely be this there is a lot of variation and it very much depends on the company that you're buying it from.

29:37Julian Houseman: But it does give you a general idea. So the Tokyu, Ikyu, Nikyu system was replaced with Tokusen, Josen, and then Kaisen, I think it is, is the bottom one, although you really don't see that one very often. And there's a couple of other ones which exist in that, which tend not to be Futsushu, like Besen and things. But that's the three standard ones. And if you see those on the label, pretty much corresponds to the old Tokyu, Ikyu, Mikyu system. and i think that for those categories well the the the kassen the josen and the toxin that uh it's up basically that's up to the brewery what they want to classify it as there's no classified you know criteria or anything for that so one brewery that they their josen might not be anything like another brewery's josen in terms of the uh the way it's made it's purely up to the brewery how they want to how they feel they want to categorize it when they stick those labelings on it yeah absolutely which is which is basically what it was before anyway in the the tokyo ikunikyu that was one of the the many flaws about the old system is that no one really knew what the standard was it was it was just a system that was determined primarily by a group of tax people getting together and assessing the sake that was sent in for them if you didn't send your sake for assessment it automatically became NICU but that of course is a story for another time but that is what triggered the the Jizaki boom which I guess is probably quite important for this conversation but we maybe won't get into tonight but yeah as it did before you're absolutely right, Julian, it doesn't give the consumer much information.

31:35Julian Houseman: But there is some patterns if you look at the big brands and things, the food sushi brands. And even when you get to, I guess, what you would have said, what you would have described as number two on your hierarchy that you made, that they are, once you know the brand, you can kind of almost guess what is going to be there. the tokusen tend to be they probably have a very low level of added alcohol and some of these are actually honjozo so much so that they're honjozo or would be if they were bothered to be classified that but the brewery will not will not pay any attention to that system so it doesn't put that on it whereas josen are going to be a bit more moderate and then kaisen as i say that you really don't see that very often on the label but that would have probably been if i'm being honest something closer to Sambai Jozo Shu which now as we just discussed is no longer permitted so it's probably getting quite close to the maximum permissible of 50 % to the weight of the white rice Yeah I still feel like your biggest guide, your easiest guide is to just count the ingredients I mean yeah Sorry I think I've never really thought about doing it, looking at it that way.

32:57But I think that's very good advice is, yeah, even if you can't read Japanese kind of thing, if you look at the back of the label and you can kind of count the ingredients there, if it looks like there's a significant number, then that's a bit of a warning sign. But yeah, I think that's good advice.

33:11Julian Houseman: So the last one on that list then that Julian has kindly brought then is the ungraded stuff. It's just not necessarily tokate me shoshu. I don't know, you guys can jump in and let me think, but I feel like this is probably in the modern industry where the futsushu category is at its most important today. Because I don't know if this is me noticing them more, but there seems to be a lot more of it coming to the market. and there's a lot of reasons for that one of which we didn't talk about it much but we did mention it which is togaimai and why togaimai has become very important in short as there's been a lot of rice shortages recently and it's become quite a big conversation in the sake industry about our breweries being wasteful by only taking braided rice.

34:13Julian Houseman: I wasn't a drinker 20, 30 years ago when the Tok-Tame-A-Shoshu system was coming in, but maybe this was as important back then. But it's something that's starting to come to light, certainly. So maybe we should talk about Togai-Mai, because I think this is a very, very important part of this discussion. I was definitely thinking about, you know, we mentioned, you know, in the past five years, How have we changed in our opinions? And I don't know that we have, but I do think that there is a shift in the industry around this idea. I think it's mostly probably an attitude towards the tokute meishuoshu system.

34:54But I haven't made enough survey and I haven't gone out. It definitely feels like there is more of an awareness or more of maybe an emphasis away from those classifications towards simply treating the sake as itself, as this kind of drink. And so, you know, I've seen more breweries sort of talk about how they use only rice. So it would be Junmai, but they don't want to talk about the rice grading or the rice milling. They just want to talk about the sake itself. And so it does sort of by default fall into that category of futsushi or that sort of that. I don't even think we should call it a category.

35:41It's just the default. and so I definitely feel like it is getting bigger but again you know this is just sort of a passive understanding so I think probably Julian you you would have more of an insight into that than than we would it's I think yeah that part of like you know the whole idea of me thinking about putting the foot tissue into those three categories is because yeah I feel there's something you know because yeah there's definitely there's seeing much more sake with uh with the brewery has decided for whatever reasons to not go with the tokote mei shou shu labeling and it's it feels a bit facetious to then kind of then offer that or refer to it as you know as a futsu shu even though like by default that is what it is but uh you know when you're seeing sake that's for all intents and purposes might be a junmai daiginjo and then people saying can you believe this is a futsu shu and And it's like, well, it is, but it isn't.

36:46And so I don't know. There's a part of me that actually wants to kind of protect the Futsushu branding in a way as a category, because I still like to think of Futsushu as being mostly that local only entry level sake that the brewers traditionally made. So it's strange to kind of think of ungraded sake as futsushu, despite the fact that that's what it falls into. And I think that another thing which is interesting is, I think one of the reasons why the foreign market or the non-Japanese market doesn't really attach to futsushu or has maybe not such a great image of it is because it's not, there's no incentive to export these types of sakes really because in a lot of countries, Australia included, they basically attract a higher tax because they've got added alcohol.

37:41So there's not, you know, doing overseas market, gymnasium is much more, it's a profitable market to be, product to be exporting basically or importing depending on where you are. So it's, yeah, I kind of feel this frustration of wanting to almost protect what a futu shoe is when you're talking about a futsushu because it feels kind of disingenuous to offer someone as i can say this is actually a futsushu when you know that it's the way it was crafted the way it was brewed it you know it's it might be something way more complex than what they have in their head as an image of what futsushu is um i'm not sure if any of that made sense no i absolutely it's a difficult one because

38:26Julian Houseman: as we've been saying throughout and what we said at the beginning Futsu Shu is a topic of what it's not Not what it is It's everything outside of Tokutei Me Shoshu And we've said many times Tokutei Me Shoshu is just a fraction of the industry It's the minority It's not the majority We kind of have this image I guess That it would be the other way around Because when we're in these echo chambers of the sake industry most people are talking about Tokote Me Shoshu, they're talking about Ginjos and Daiginjos and then you've got Jumais and I guess Honjozos occasionally gets mentioned as well, even though it is a premium category and rightly so but that's a very small part of the market, it always has been and it will be for the foreseeable future and then you've just got this massive segment which is Futsu Shoe, so I know what you're saying, there's kind of like classic futsu shu maybe we need to have a different propriety grading system where it's like premium futsu shu or or something like that and then classic futsu shu where you're telling people maybe along the lines of what jim's saying that these have only got such and such ingredients or something but the the fact of the matter is these sakes that are coming out they are they're very important for the breweries because they're they're like a release valve that the more emphasis that was put on the tokate mei shoshu system and i think we are really seeing the the dying embers of that now it's really the beginning of the end is has has started if you will for the tokate mei shoshu you can see it everywhere there's so many breweries are now saying nah we're probably not going to pay much attention to that anymore in the same way that the kubetsu seido collapsed there's just there's these gaping holes in the logic of it and and this is this is one of them i always think of one that would definitely fall into that category is gozen shu from suji in okayama they they decided that they wanted to go 100 % omachi but omachi is a very expensive rice so how do you then tackle the futsushu because you can't just take graded rice omachi and put it in your futsushu because the price would go up and that that upsets that local market because it's no longer priced the way a typical futsushu is anymore so the only way they could get around that was togaimai and togaimai is for anyone that's not aware togaimai is just ungraded rice because there's a whole separate grading system for rice as well as the sake and anything that doesn't meet this very subjective grading criteria becomes togaimai and you're not allowed to use that for Tokutemi Shoshu.

41:37Julian Houseman: So you've got a farmer that's been working all year, probably preparing years in advance for making this very specialised sake rice that has no use other than things like animal feed outside of the sake industry because no one goes into the supermarket looking to buy omache to eat it or yamari nishiki. But now with the Futsu Shoe category, brewers are able to take this Togaimai and brew incredible sake with it and put it into their futsu shoe category. So it is a release valve for them. And this first tier, I think that's probably the one that we're seeing the most of nowadays is breweries trying to work out, what do we do with this togae mai?

42:21Julian Houseman: Well, we'll just not bother paying attention to the Tok-Ti-Mei Shoshu system, but we'll be able to use togae mai. And you can still put omachi and things on the label. So you get the biggest thing. You get the omachi part or the yamadanishiki part, but it doesn't say jimai or honjos or ginjo or whatever. So I feel like maybe that's the answer is they need to start not completely changing the labelling system, but maybe just put some form of hierarchy within futsushu outside of tokusen, josen, kaisen, and maybe make it a bit more user-friendly. Because I guarantee probably a lot of drinkers, even Japanese drinkers nowadays, don't really know what Tuk-sen, Josen, Kaisen actually means either.

43:12Julian Houseman: Maybe it should be more ingredients forward on the label rather than these special selection and things. But that's just my opinion. I think another thing, I know you said a couple of times, and I totally agree, talking about what futsu shoe is, it's more of what it's not. And I think when explaining with someone, if you're trying to explain what futsu shoe is, an interesting way to think about it, because I was thinking about this, is I'm pretty sure it doesn't exist, but heaven forbid any of the awards systems, if they were to create a futsu shoe category. Oh, they have. Oh, they have? quite a few of them yeah the yeah the european ones definitely have well what's what's the criteria for a futsushu in those in those competitions probably it's just legally defined as futsushu as not outside the the tokute meishushu i think because gain i know that game pack won the london one was it the yeah definitely one there's a few that have won i feel like there's a few, definitely Kiko Masamuni, I think got an IWC I mean, listen I don't really pay attention to these competitions, so I'm the worst person to ask, but I feel like Kiko Masamuni got something and it might be IWC and then I also think there was one, the brands Horai, Watanabe Shuzo didn't they win an award for Futsu Shoe?

44:46Julian Houseman: I think I feel like that was IWC as well but yeah I really am the worst person to ask because I really don't care about these competitions so just a quick search I'm seeing yeah the International Wine Challenge has awarded Kikumasu Mune Hakkai-san Koshino Kanbai Kikumasu Mune appears to have won several of them what is it the Mon Selection also does Futsushu. Yeah. So the international wine challenge, I, I, I don't have any idea what the, uh, what the, the class, the, the, the, the, what do you call it? The conditions are, but the criteria are, but, um, yeah, they definitely have a Futsushu class.

45:34Okay. It's just, yeah. Cause you'd have to think it'd be, you know, rather cheeky to be submitting your Jumai Da Ginjo in the Futsushu class, just because you decided not to call it a Jumai Da Ginjo. Yeah.

45:45Julian Houseman: Although that's possible, it's also highly unlikely because these competitions are not, as far as I'm aware, it's not the Kampiokai where you can specially brew a sake. I'd imagine these competitions, they have to be an actual product. And like I said, the undoing of the Tokutei Me Shoshu system is going to be along the same lines as the Kubetsu Seido. There are just gaping holes in the logic of that, and that's one of them. in that these premium Futsu shoes, you really have to, the breweries have really got to be careful with what they're doing in that Futsu shoe category, because they are priced at a certain point.

46:31Julian Houseman: Futsu shoe, one of the most defining features if we are to try and put Futsu shoe in a box is price. there's an expectation a consumer expectation on price if they're buying futsushu the tokate mei shoshu system is what we've got to that that's what we have to thank for that the tokate mei shoshu system has established expectations of price that a junmai should be sorry this isn't going to make much sense to people that don't live in japan but a junmai has to be around 1300 to 1500 yen maybe it's a bit more than that nowadays and then a genjo is around about the 2000 yen and then maybe a daiginjo is about two and a half thousand yen and futsushu should be more closer to about a thousand yen if you were to simply put in asaki just to win the futsushu category that you'd have assuming what you're meaning is you're going to make it to the absolute top spec and then just put it as a futsu shoe which is your right to do that you don't have to classify it as top 10 national shoe even if it's identical to to the specification of a top 10 national shoe there's no one that's going to say you must make that a daiginjo you can you can just leave it and it will be graded as a futsu shoe so if you were to do that just to win a competition then your product the rest of that entire batch is going to have to get sold presumably at a very high price within the food sushi category so i don't really think there's much room for and i don't think breweries would really go to that level just to win an international competition of which there is so many now that they're really their significance has kind of been diluted a bit anyway so i don't think that's really an issue i think the ones that we've seen like jim just mentioned there these are proper futushu futushu that have been winning these competitions so yeah probably not a big issue but i think for example though uh you know the brewery that i mentioned before like senkin have you know famously issued all the tokute me shoshu so if they were to submit their sake would it that just everything by default have to go go into the futsu shoe category because that's what yeah i don't know whether they are submitting or you know but but there's a there's a a good idea for me and you to do a an episode then julian so look out for that in the near future listeners we're we're going to do some Saki Deep Dive investigative work on the criteria of these sake competitions, including the ones in Japan.

49:24Julian Houseman: And we'll do a particular focus on what qualifies as a Futsu shoe. I look forward to hearing your insights. Yeah, I just was kind of also with the Futsu shoe, you know, the concept of it. I'm kind of lamenting the slow demise a little bit of a lot of breweries that have undergone rebirths and rebrandings. Many of them tend to stop making their traditional, you know, futsushu, their local-only sake. I know it's still a long way from them becoming obsolete, but I think that's a sad part of the sake industry as a whole, but in particular in the futsushu category, that the slowly disappearing of local-only futsushu is a very sad thing to see.

50:19Julian Houseman: I would completely agree. I'm obviously a subscriber to Sin, which Julian writes for, and it seems like every fortnight there's a new story of a brewery that's done their rebranding, And you almost know before you even start reading that the casualty of that is going to be their beloved futsushu. Obviously, there's things going on behind the scenes for that. The sake drinking demographic in Japan has long been in decline. And it's only going to get worse. Younger people, I think that's a constant around the world. That's not just for the sake industry. But it seems to be very acute in Japan. They've had an aging population for a very long time.

51:08Julian Houseman: But once that population starts to dwindle, a lot of that culture of drinking futsushu is going with it. And I think what we're seeing, sadly, like so many other parts of the industry, is we're starting to see a gentrification, like this would be your first category on the list. These are the ungraded, the Senkians and stuff, the Futsu Shu category. definitely the level is rising the older ones, the local brands the ones that are really the embodiment really of jizake and things the things that people always say they want but end up drinking sake that are really targeted and were made for Tokyo markets and sometimes even overseas markets it is sad to see it but it does seem like it's inevitable unless there is more of a resurgence for these kind of maybe cheap and cheerful types of sake, the classic style of futsushu.

52:16Yeah, I mean, it all comes down to money, right? Like when I was researching for the book back in 2020, some of the local breweries were talking about how they really wanted to get rid of futsushu because the margins are just so low and they can't raise the prices because the local markets won't accept it. And, you know, I think that idea of rebranding is just an excuse to, like, raise prices across everything. You want to charge more money, which is, you know, that's the way the system works is they're here, they're in it for a profit, and that's the way to get it. So, yeah.

52:52Julian Houseman: Well I think it's safe to say that we're all fans of Futsu Shu here so we've still got three consumers at least but I think to wrap this up it's definitely still as relevant today as it was five years ago when we first did this and our opinions haven't really changed I think of anything myself I'm more, I'm an even bigger fan of Futsu Shu the challenge is just going to be to see if they can reverse this because yeah for sure there's going to be some fantastic brands that disappear if people don't start buying the classic stuff and it's, the category is going to start to become more leaning towards premium sake that are kind of hidden inside the Futsu Shu but that like it was with the Cubits of Sedo that was the exact reason why the cubits said it'll collapse maybe it'll be this the the touch paper that collapses the the current system and they'll have to to have a rethink yeah so jem for the last time do you want to lead us into recommended sake right so yes that uh i think wraps up the conversation so it is time of course to to get to the to the meat of it which is what sake should you be drinking what are we going to recommend and I hope you will forgive me for ignoring the ban but I'm gonna just there's been no change in the past five years and so I am going to recommend a sake that not only have I recommended before but I have been told specifically not to recommend and I'm sure that any saw this coming at least it's gokyo gokyo josen It had to be.

54:37The classic. It had to be. There's no other. There's no better. I've got, I have a cardboard carton of it downstairs for cooking and for the occasional tipple as well. I know that the brewer owner and the brewer sort of master himself prefers his own Joseon. It is just hardcore, the local jizake that you should probably try if you ever come to Yamaguchi. How about you, Andy?

55:11Julian Houseman: I am going to go for something that I would say, because I'm now obsessed with Julian's list. so I'm just going to start ranking everything by Julian's list. I'm going to go with something that I would say is number two on Julian's list. This is a proper, proper jizake, and it's Tsuru no Tomo from Niigata, Niigata City specifically. So Tsuru no Tomo is one of these brands that you really don't get it outside of Niigata, and everything, all the voices coming out of the brewery are that they're really not that interested outside of the Niigata market. The only places I've ever seen it outside of Niigata are in satellite shops.

55:58Julian Houseman: For example, there's one in Osaka. But it's specifically their futsushu. You have to be very careful with Tsuru no Tomo. The label, which is absolutely stunning, by the way, it's a proper futsushu label that has two tsuru. these are the cranes that are ubiquitous on Futsushu sake labels anyway. Think of Hakatsuru. There's two cranes and it's a beautiful old traditional yellow label. And the only difference you get between, I think it's three of their products, is they do have their own propriety ranking system. And I think you would pronounce it Johaku. So it's like Joh from Josen and then White.

56:43Julian Houseman: It's quite a rare ranking system But it's obviously What they say is their Their lowest rank The one above that It doesn't say it on the label I don't think But it is actually a Honjozo I don't know what rice they use It doesn't say I don't know what the Semaibuai is It doesn't say that either I don't know how much alcohol Is in it It doesn't say that but none of that matters It's a fantastic drinkable everyday session sake. Niigata sake tends to be Tanrei Karakuchi and most of the websites that sell it say that it is a Tanrei Karakuchi but actually Tsuru no Tomo is known for having a bit more umami than your typical Tanrei Karakuchi.

57:32Julian Houseman: So yeah, that would be my recommendation. Tsuru no Tomo from Niigata City. All right. And Julian, your first recommendation. yeah this is actually oddly enough of any category if any type of sake that we were doing futsushu is actually the one where i i have so many that i'd like to recommend um it would probably be easier for just about any other category but yeah i i'm gonna go with the sentimental uh futsushu so the one that actually converted me uh for lack of a better word for maybe about 15 years ago when i was in a sake bar in osaka which unfortunately no longer exists and the proprietress slid me over a glass and said, check this out.

58:10And I was blown away. I said, this is fantastic. What is it? And she said, this is a local futushu from Wakayama and it was Nihonjo, as in Nihon Castle, Japan Castle. And it's from Yoshimura Hideo Shoten in Wakayama, probably best known as the maker of Kurumazaka. And yeah, Nihonjo is their local futushu. It's a josen. and they probably, if you were to buy it in the area, the one that you probably see most is the Josen. It's just a regular futsushu, but they also do a Nama version of it. And that was the one that I tried. And when I opened Sake House last year, it was literally one of the first sakes that I put on the menu.

58:55And it's also been one of the ones that I've repeated on the menu, possibly more than any other sake. It's quite punchy. It's a Nama Genshu. and I think it's 18%. And I don't know a hell of a lot about the brewing process behind it, but it's just, you know, again, I hate kind of belittling futsushu, but, like, it just punches so hard above its weight for its price. And it's also one of those sakis that fits in the holy trinity of being perfect at all three temperatures, being room temperature, chilled or warmed. it's just full packed with umami and just rich and just absolutely more rich it's just one of those sakes that just keeps you bringing you back and you just just can't get enough of it

59:40Julian Houseman: so uh nihon joe from uh wakayama fantastic yeah i feel like that actually just to wrap that up i feel like that should be part of the criteria if we are going to start defining food tissue that they should be able to be drank warm room temperature or chilled. That to me is a signature feature of a good food sushi. Agreed. Agreed. Well, ladies and gentlemen, that brings us to the end of another episode of Sake Deep Tive, the sake podcast for the beyond beginner. That brings me to the end of my final episode. and I just do want to say Andy, thank you so much for the past five years it really has been a pleasure and an honor and I've learned so much from you and I think our audience has too, so thank you for that and thank you to the audience that has stuck with us through these years I hope you will stick around to see where it goes, I know I will be watching and listening because I'm sure these two have a lot in store.

1:00:52I know Andy has a lot in store that I really look forward to seeing.

1:00:57Julian Houseman: And yeah, so... Sorry, Jim, just to say thank you. Thank you very much. The pleasure was all mine. You've been an absolutely fantastic host. You've brought so much to this podcast and I've had so much fun doing it. So I would give you a round of applause, but it always sounds terrible on a podcast but I am giving you a mental round of applause for all your five years of hard work on this podcast so Right,

1:01:30and for those of you who may be interested you can still find me online I'm at my website www.jimryan.com that's J-I-M-R-I-O-N and if you're at all interested in Japanese mystery your horror novels uh i've got a lot coming out and uh yeah you can probably find them at your

1:01:53Julian Houseman: bookstore uh andy where can people find you at my website originsaki.com or of course you can find me at my tours website which is originsaki tours.com where i am currently still doing tours although only just for this year very soon it's going to be into next year so if anyone is thinking have taken a tour with me, check the dates. All right. Thank you. And Julian, tell us all about it. Well, yes, you can find me in person. If you're ever in Osaka, you can come to Sake House and come and see me where I usually have an assortment of futsushu as well as many other sake. And you can find me on Instagram there.

1:02:38And I just want to say as well, I'm very much looking forward to doing this podcast with Andy. And I feel like I'm stepping in for very big shoes because, Jim, you've done a great job, and this has always been an excellent podcast, very well-researched podcast. So I feel a certain sense of responsibility, and I think maybe Andy will agree that we'll retire the jersey and try and avoid doing the cheesy segues into each episode.

1:03:06Julian Houseman: Let that retire with Jim. Okay. We're never going to compete. So sadly, as we said, yeah, some things are going to have to die with Jim's absence. And that's probably going to be one of them. My legacy. My one legacy, I suppose. All right. There you go. Yeah. I hope everybody has a wonderful autumn. Keep your Tokuti full. Drink responsibly. And Kanpai. Kanpai.

1:03:45Thank you.

From the publisher

Join us for a very special episode of Sake Deep Dive, as it marks several firsts for our duo: the first ever return to a previously covered topic, and the first ever special guest. Julian Houseman is a sake educator and writer, as well as running his own sake bar in Osaka. 

The three go back to reflect on how attitudes toward futsūshu may have changed (or not!) in the five years since they tackled it in the very first episode. Is it still the same overlooked, undervalued segment of the sake market? Is it still packed with undiscovered gems? Listen and find out. 

And it is also important to remember that for every first, there is a last. This marks the final episode for Jim as his career takes him in new directions. But lament not! Andy and Julian are ready to keep the sake warm and the torch lit.

Kampai!

Vocab:

Kyūbetsu seidō 級別制度 - An older classification system for sake based on various subjective factors that was replaced with the tokutei meishōshu system.

Sanzōshu 三増酒 - “Tripled” sake made by adding large amounts of distilled alcohol and flavoring additives to triple the amount of sake made from the same amount of rice. Abolished in the 1990s, but some level of heavy additive use remains in the cheapest levels of futsūshu.

Tokutei meishōshu 特定名称酒 - The current system for classifying sake by rice grading, polishing, alcohol content etc.

Yodanjikomi 四段仕込み - A four-stage mash, when an additional stage is added for either necessity as in aruten alcohol addition, or for a different expression of the sake.

Recommendations:

Andy - Tsuru no Tomo Jōhaku 

Jim - Gokyō Jōsen 

Julian - Nihonjō Jōsen

Don’t forget to support us on Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/SakeDeepDive 

Also, check out Andy’s websites at: https://www.originsake.com/ and https://www.originsaketours.com

Find Jim at his website www.JimRion.com, where he mostly doesn’t talk about sake at all.

Our theme music is from 

Lotus Lane by The Loyalist - Preconceived Notions Available at https://soundcloud.com/preconceived-notions

Under a  Creative Commons — Attribution 3.0 Unported— CC BY 3.0

Free Download / Stream: https://bit.ly/lotus-lane

Music promoted by Audio Library https://youtu.be/1YVHRMVwwHg 


More from Sake Deep Dive

All episodes