1. Podcasts
  2. Search Engine
  3. Ask Me Anything: AI, Reply All, Secret Projects
Search Engine

20 Nov 2026 · 47m · 21 chapters

Episode artwork

Ask Me Anything: AI, Reply All, Secret Projects

In short

An “Ask Me Anything” episode where Search Engine hosts answer listener and Reddit questions about podcasting, editorial choices, AI coverage, and behind-the-scenes work.

Guests/backgrounds

No guest interviewees. Hosts are PJ Vogt (host of the day) and Shruti Pimaneni (normally editor; hosting today). Garrett Graham (senior producer) is briefly called in to answer a mattress-store question. Emily Molter crunches listener-demographics numbers.

Key claims

Listener questions are still central, though the show sometimes does “explainers” that resemble journalism. AI coverage is framed as necessary and undemocratic in impact; the show aims to explain rather than predict. Podcast economics are harder due to weaker ad value and scattered audiences; Incognito Mode covers 30–40% of operating budget. AI transcription reduces tedious work.

Notable examples

Waymo driverless-car episode and audience reaction to an anti-tech politician; data-center activist coverage; mattress stores as low-cost showrooms with long-lasting inventory; listener downloads from Bahrain and Togo.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:19

AMA Introduction

Hosts introduce the concept of the Ask Me Anything episode and set the stage.

“Okay, so I want to start, just like riff me an intro, will you?”
4:34

Listener Questions on Show Direction

Hosts discuss listener concerns about the show's direction and answer questions.

“So the first question from user Tommy Two Hands.”
5:44

Exploring Un-Googleable Questions

The hosts explore the nature of un-Googleable questions and their relevance.

“Yeah, and just to, sorry, tell me if I'm being defensive here.”
9:07

Life Between Shows and Hosting Styles

Discussion on the challenges faced between shows and differences in hosting styles.

“I think a lot of these Reddit usernames are, like, auto-generated.”
11:08

Understanding Listener Misinterpretations

Hosts reflect on listener misunderstandings of their stories and content.

“I just wanted to ask what your life was like in the interim between ReplyAll and Search Engine.”
14:01

Understanding Storytelling and Audience Perception

Discusses how storytelling can be misunderstood by audiences despite their appreciation.

“Having the ability to write and really spend time making sure that every word is the right word, it gives the stories a weight, which I appreciate.”
16:42

Exploring the Mystery of Mattress Stores

Delves into the business model and viability of mattress stores and their role in online sales.

“And it made me feel like I wish I'd done a better job.”
19:17

Audience Engagement and Show Dynamics

Discusses how audience engagement influences the show's content and decisions.

“Guys, a lot of these questions are four different questions.”
21:14

Podcast Economics and Staffing

Covers the challenges and changes in podcast economics and the show's staffing structure.

“Listeners would be interested to hear about how the economics of a podcast has evolved and what it's like out there today.”
23:25

Researching Listener Questions

Explains the process of determining whether there's enough information to answer listener questions.

“And the question is, like, do we actually know how to do that?”
Show all 21 chapters
26:23

Addressing Criticism on AI Coverage

Engages with listener criticism regarding the show's approach to AI and corporate interests.

“There has been a bunch of pushback on how you have approached stories about AI here on Reddit.”
28:00

Concerns About AI and Society

Exploring the societal impacts of AI and the concentration of power in its development.

“I think it was a place where it was like, oh, what people are hearing is what we think we're saying.”
29:58

Communicating AI's Complexity

Discussing the challenges of properly communicating the complexities of AI technology.

“My biggest feeling with AI, my biggest critique of it is that it feels profoundly undemocratic.”
31:38

Heartbreak Stories in Storytelling

A personal reflection on the challenges of storytelling and creative expression.

“And it's not like I'm actually really happy with it as a story.”
32:51

The Quirk of Using Gmail for Business

An amusing take on why a personal Gmail address is used for professional outreach.

“that did not get any votes, but I find to be a really funny question.”
34:08

Subreddit Dynamics and Listener Engagement

Examining the relationship between the show and its subreddit, including feedback and participation.

“In the PJ and Shruti have lunch incognito mode episode, I seem to recall that you two, though especially Shruti, is speaking pretty negatively of this subreddit.”
36:34

Listener Demographics and Global Reach

Insights into the geographical diversity of the podcast's audience and listener statistics.

“And I'm happy that we are on or more active in the subreddit because we got all these questions from there.”
39:24

Platforming Different Voices

Discussion on the ethics of platforming diverse voices and perspectives in media.

“Super Helical, any regrets for giving anyone a platform?”
42:00

Navigating Advertising in Tech Media

Explore the balance between ad support and journalistic integrity.

“like disruptive, fucked up in some ways and beneficial in others and our job is to cover it.”
43:11

Listener Questions About Intro Music

Discuss a listener's humorous interpretation of the show's intro sounds.

“That's a bong sound in your intro music, right?”
44:35

Mental Health Reflections

Reflect on personal experiences with OCD and mental health awareness.

“So we're about to run out of time, but let me just keep going.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Search Engine, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Hello, Search Engine listeners. Before we start the show this week, in case you missed the news, the Search Engine merchandise store is up and online. We have limited supplies of our new T-shirts, our new tote bag, and our much sought after, usually out of stock sweatshirt. There are discounts available for our incognito mode listeners. You'll have a code in your inbox. But the store is open to all. We have hired some very talented designers, and the merch looks genuinely great. This is a perfect gift for the holidays, all the holidays, even Thanksgiving. Pick up a Thanksgiving search engine gift for your family.

0:35Sruthi Pinnamaneni: We will have a link in the show notes. I do want to warn you, we are already starting to run low on some of these items. So if you're thinking about search engine merch for the holidays, I would genuinely move soon. After these ads, our episode this week. This episode of Search Engine is brought to you in part by Mubi. Mubi is a global film company that handpicks an incredible selection of international films, modern masterpieces, and unforgettable documentaries. Right now, I've been enjoying one of their latest releases, Making Marie Antoinette. Back in 2005, Sofia Coppola was granted unprecedented access to shoot at the Palace of Versailles at just 34 years old.

1:10Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Her mother, the late Eleanor Coppola, captured 80 hours of behind-the-scenes footage that sat unseen for two full decades. Now that material has finally been crafted into a breathtaking documentary, it offers an extraordinarily intimate look at Elena Cananero's iconic costume design, the immense pressure of directing as a young woman, and this rare moving dynamic of two brilliant generations of women behind the camera together. It's the kind of film that stays with you long after the credits roll, inspiring you to talk, read, and dream about cinema in a whole new way. You can try Mubi free for 30 days at Mubi.com slash search engine.

1:44Sruthi Pinnamaneni: That's M-U-B-I.com slash search engine for a whole month of great cinema for free.

2:19PJ: Are we, uh, it's rolling? It's rolling. Okay, so I want to start, just like riff me an intro, will you? I'm riffing you an intro? Well, yeah, you're going to riff an intro to this episode.

2:31Sruthi Pinnamaneni: You're sitting in the host chair and you're abdicating, first you were like, can you prep your questions? I was like, no, you're interviewing me. Then you were like, can you riff an intro? You are in the host chair.

2:40PJ: Will you please just riff an intro because it's literally your job? Okay.

2:47Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Okay. A few weeks ago, we asked our listeners to send in questions for an AMA. I wanted to do this because people always have questions about how we're making the show and the choices we make about how to do it and just podcasting in general right now. And I guess finally because I like it when other podcasts do this. So we're doing it. We ask for questions. I know we got a lot of questions. I wanted to come into this fresh. So, Shruti, you normally the editor of the show, but today, host of the day. You went through the questions and you picked which ones you thought would be interesting.

3:22PJ: I was thinking that these conversations feel more fun to me as a listener when it feels like there's like a tightrope element, like we've removed your ability to choose and curate.

3:33Sruthi Pinnamaneni: You want there to be anxiety and danger.

3:34PJ: I want to remove both your and my ability to choose and curate as much. So it's more like you're just on stage and you got an answer. You want it to be ask me anything.

3:47Sruthi Pinnamaneni: You don't want it to be like ask me a series of questions I pre-screened because I think I have charming and safe answers to them.

3:53PJ: Yes. And you did two things. You both put a call out on our show and people emailed us. You also put a call out on Reddit and a bunch of people dropped questions into the thread. Those questions are excellent. They also have the benefit of, like, certain questions have been upvoted, so we know a lot of people have those questions.

4:16Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Oh, that's good.

4:16PJ: So we're just going to go through as many questions as we can off that thread. I'm going to set a timer for 40 minutes.

4:25Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Oh, we're going to go through, like, three questions.

4:27PJ: No, I'm going to – I'll hustle you on.

4:29Sruthi Pinnamaneni: You'll keep it moving.

4:29PJ: Okay. Okay. Lightning. Okay. Ready? Let's go.

4:32Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Yeah.

4:32PJ: Go. All right. So the first question from user Tommy Two Hands.

4:37Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Tommy Two Hands.

4:39PJ: Maybe I'm just missing it, but it seems like the show is drifting away from the original concept of un-Googleable questions and just more into interesting journalism. Are listener questions still being answered?

4:52Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Oh, yes. Listener questions are definitely still being answered. In fact, not to point a finger in another direction, I feel like listener questions in my inbox are slowing down a little bit, and I would like people to send more. But no, our favorite questions to answer are listener questions. We're working right now on a few listener questions.

5:08PJ: A number of our recent episodes are listener questions, so I'm a little surprised.

5:13Sruthi Pinnamaneni: People always feel I like to make, we both like to make variety shows where the show has some big umbrella premise, but then it can do a lot of different things inside of it. and I find that to be the most fun from a sort of creative freedom perspective but it means that people often have the perception that the show is drifting away from the direction they prefer where the way I tend to see it from my seat which I'm not sure is more accurate is like no the show is just doing one of the other modes and it'll be back to the other thing like sometimes it'll be I mean this was in the premise that we wrote for the show when we started sometimes it's topical news stuff sometimes it's totally off the news sometimes it's personal stuff that I just care about or we just care about and oftentimes there'll be listener questions.

5:55PJ: Yeah, and just to, sorry, tell me if I'm being defensive here.

5:59Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I feel like we're coming off the jump really defensive about a very mild question. Wait, hang on. Tommy Two Hands, I'm sorry. We will be doing more listener questions. If you have questions, please send them. I really love listening questions.

6:09PJ: But let me just say, I am looking at our feed.

6:12Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Yeah, he's, what is he now? Just, for instance. Tommy Two Hands now.

6:16PJ: Bollywood Dreams was, a listener wrote in about a question about his father who was making a Bollywood movie, or was he? Or even just before that was a listener question about why is everybody going to Japan?

6:29Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Also, Jensen Huang was actually, we didn't put the listener in the top, but that was a question that came from a listener.

6:35PJ: Yeah, and not to be, again, I would never.

6:38Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Ask us anything and we'll yell at you.

6:41PJ: But to sort of go back to this person's question, is the show drifting away from the original concept of un-Googleable questions, which is a different thing than listener questions, and just more into interesting journalism. Do you want to take that, BJ?

6:55Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I don't know. Maybe. Maybe. Yeah, totally possible. I think it's a mix of both.

7:00PJ: I think the question, for instance, why is everybody going to Japan, is a question that all of us had on the show. Like, it feels like people in our lives or we ourselves are drawn to Japan, and why is that? And so when we see it in our inbox, Our brains light up. And I think the distinction between un-Google-able questions and interesting journalism—

7:22Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Do you know an un-Google-able question? Somebody, a journalist tweeted that they had Googled who won the 2020 election, and Google's, like, cheapo version of its AI that they try to give you when you do search was dissembling on that question.

7:35PJ: Wow. Wow. Disturbing.

7:38Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Yeah, other than I Googled it. Yeah. It was like Joe Biden.

7:40PJ: I think there is, though, there's like really quirky, really obscure questions or a question that everybody has that like the answer is just historically hard to find. I think of our show, though, also as providing helpful explainers at the right time. Like the moment where President Trump decided that he would just depose the sitting president of Venezuela that felt like a moment where we on the show had questions about the history of Venezuela, how we got to the moment that we had. yeah

8:16Sruthi Pinnamaneni: you know so it's I think maybe I agree and I think what the listener might be perceiving is that like sometimes what it feels like is a good thing to do for our listeners and the thing we want to do for ourselves anyway is like the news will feel like it is on episode 7 of season 3 of a show that you missed a few episodes of and we like doing just sort of the like whoa whoa whoa whoa can you just explain to me how we got to this moment can you like back up and like there's times where I think all of us have the impulse of like Like, the news might be worthy, but we don't want to pay attention to it for six months.

8:48Sruthi Pinnamaneni: And then there's other times where, like, the hive mind of the show gets very glued to the news. And, like, it goes in and out. Right now, I am feeling drawn to the news. And in three months, perhaps, I won't be.

9:01PJ: A next question from 4, F-O-U-R, 44U, Glenn Coco.

9:07Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I think a lot of these Reddit usernames are, like, auto-generated.

9:10PJ: As someone who listens to a lot of podcasts, sometimes while doing my job, It's weird to think about podcasting being someone else's normal office job. What does a really great day of working on the show look like? What's something that's difficult or tedious or annoying about the job that most people wouldn't think about?

9:26Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Oh, that's a good question. Best days for me, I mean, speaking for myself, are just like when there's a great interview. Like when it's just like, oh my God, I can't believe that person said that. Or like I thought it was going to be like this and they had a totally different story to tell. And like you can like start to hear the episode already from the tape. Those are the best days. Like walking out of a really good interview that changed my mind about something makes me feel like as alive as I know how to feel. And then also, but it's like still an office job. It's just like you got to send emails and write emails and go to meetings.

9:54Sruthi Pinnamaneni: And sometimes you can tell in the meeting everybody's on a different window on Zoom. And you're like, why are we in this meeting? This could have been like a five-minute email. Not internal, but like we have like external meetings.

10:06PJ: What's annoying about the job that most people wouldn't think about?

10:12Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Um, it's weird to have a job where, like, next week there has to be an idea and you might not know the idea yet. And, like, you live in a constant state of, like, like, sometimes people will be like, where do ideas come from? And I'm like, I wish I knew that. And, like, we've had a lot of ideas collectively, but there's a real yawning terror at the idea. Like, yesterday you left the office without wearing a bike helmet. And I was like, what are you doing? If you hit your head, there's no show. Like, if you fall down and you hit your head, I don't know how to make search engine without you editing search engine.

10:44Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Like, but if I fall down and hit my head, there's no show. Or like, if just like something changes in the neurons of my brain, like the room I don't know where it is, where ideas come from, I think the yawning terror of where's the next idea coming from is something that maybe people wouldn't think about. And criticism online. I don't like that.

11:04PJ: I think people think about that. That feels expected. Okay, next question. This one from AlarmedSize3104. I just wanted to ask what your life was like in the interim between ReplyAll and Search Engine. Also, this person is sneaking in a second question, tut tut. Also, what are the differences, good and bad, between hosting solo versus with Alex?

11:26Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Oh, that's a good question. Should I take both of them, one of them, neither of them?

11:30PJ: So what was your life between ReplyAll and Search Engine? I don't know.

11:34Sruthi Pinnamaneni: It was really difficult. it's really difficult and confusing and I felt like my brain was like smashed to smithereens and I was trying to put it back together and like put it back together not to the way it was to something else and it was really really hard um and every year I get further from that year the more like grateful I feel for it which is like I would have punched me in the face if I had said that to me then like hard um so it's really confusing and um I've tried to write about it and it's hard to write about, but trying to write about it feels really worthwhile.

12:08PJ: What are the differences getting bad between hosting solo versus with your former co-host? I...

12:17Sruthi Pinnamaneni: The upside of co-hosting is like podcasts are always about relationships. Even a solo show is about relationships that the listener never really sees, like between the editorial staff and the host and the listener and the host and their guests. and having a relationship at the center of a show is just like, it gives the show a kind of like energy and bounciness. And even on a week where maybe the story is not that sparkly, the relationship can kind of carry it. And so it just gives a show something that I think can be really special. And I think it is one of the things that made Reply All special in a way that like is not recreatable.

12:55Sruthi Pinnamaneni: It's like if the show has a relationship and if the relationship isn't there, the show can't be there. but I really like solo hosting I don't feel like alone because the show is a product of five people's minds and there's just like

13:12Sruthi Pinnamaneni: by the end Reply All felt like a lot of people pulling in a lot of different directions and not in a constructive way always like decreasingly so and like I feel more creative freedom working this way than I did there And I feel like, yeah, I just, it's like more work because you don't have another person like who's going to be up next week or whatever. But I prefer it. Yeah.

13:42PJ: I think that also when you have multiple hosts, and I say this as a producer, the joy, like you said, is being able to rely on the bounciness and the vibes in the room to carry a story. and working with you as a solo host, there's a lot more weight on the writing. Having the ability to write and really spend time making sure that every word is the right word, it gives the stories a weight, which I appreciate.

14:13Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Yeah, there's like a precision of tone you can get writing. And it's not because I have so much control because I'm writing. It's like the show has so much control because we pick the sentences where when you're making a show that's built out of rapport, You just can't steer it in the same way.

14:27PJ: All right. Next question. Long Dog. Long Dog. Oh, that's the person's name. What's a story you've done that you think was maybe misunderstood by listeners, even if they loved the episode? Has anything been taken in a completely different direction than what you expected?

14:46I like that they're asking what's been misunderstood, even if they like the episode.

14:51PJ: It's not just, like, misunderstood. Understood.

14:53Sruthi Pinnamaneni: We're boxing this just to search engine, right?

14:55PJ: You can do whatever you want. I'll box it to search engine.

15:01Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Yeah, there's like a, there hasn't been one where people loved it in a way that was like different than our intention, which happens sometimes. Like I've had that experience in the past where people like love something that I had reservations with or they loved it differently than I intended them to love it, which like, that's fine. It belongs to the listeners as much as people make it. But sometimes I feel like I've done stories. Let me think of a really specific example. Oh, I'll give you an example. I'll give you an example. Our Waymo episode about driverless cars. I feel like I tried to walk into the question of automation versus labor.

15:37Sruthi Pinnamaneni: The people making these cars say they're safer. People driving taxis say they're a threat to their jobs. And that's a complicated question. And we're going to have a lot of questions like that. And I tried to really, like, pry my mind open with, like, enormous invisible biceps. And there was a politician we interviewed from Boston, city councilor, who was, like, very much kind of, like, anti-tech. Was, like, kind of incurious in a way that is against the ethos of search engine, I guess. And, like, I think if you hear where the reporting lands, like, I didn't agree with her point of view. But in the room, I really enjoyed her.

16:14Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I found her to be like human and open and unguarded in a way that like politicians aren't always even like the populist ones. And like I disagreed with her, but I really liked hearing her embody her point of view. And I felt like listeners had a more like negative reaction to her. They were like really angry with her. And it made me think like, oh, there's something I didn't capture about this person as I experienced her. And it made me feel like I wish I'd done a better job.

16:46PJ: Okay. Environmental Toe1388 asks, what's up with mattress stores? There are tons and tons of stores, and I literally don't see people in them. I literally have researched it, and they say it's really cheap to buy, and then you can make a good profit. But I still don't think selling a mattress once a week would pay for rent. So, main question. What's up with mattress stores?

17:11Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I don't offhandedly know the answer to that question.

17:13PJ: You know who does know the answer to that question? Who is, like, researching this briefly for a story on the show is Garrett. Wait, I'm going to call Garrett.

17:26PJ: Hello? Garrett. Excuse me. We got a question that is, what's up with mattress stores? Yeah, yeah, man. Yeah.

17:34Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Garrett, our question is why, how do mattress stores exist basically?

17:38PJ: Yeah.

17:39Sruthi Pinnamaneni: This was a question from like year one search engine that we briefly considered trying to make an episode out of. I think we were looking for like the right mattress store or like the right mattress kingpin in New York that we could follow around and like make a character profile out of. But I did like learn a little bit about the financials of mattress stores. Like mattresses don't go bad. So like your inventory kind of exists forever until you sell it. And when you do sell it, the margins are like incredible. You make a lot of money per unit of mattress sold compared to the cost of producing that mattress.

18:14They also have like one employee on the floor. Like they really just don't have all that many costs associated with running the business besides rent, I think. And so I think that they can survive on selling relatively few mattresses. But we also like kind of judge the success of the business based on like how busy the store seems. And I think we're kind of missing a lot of the business that's happening online. Like people are buying mattresses on the Internet and these stores serve as like showrooms and kind of like billboards for specific mattress brands.

18:50Sruthi Pinnamaneni: brands or I don't know. But what I do know is that these mattress stores don't need to be, you know, dishing out a lot of inventory to remain financially viable. And there's probably a lot of business going on behind the scenes that we don't see just by like walking into a mattress king on a Tuesday afternoon. Okay. That seems like a pretty good answer.

19:11PJ: Garrett, you're a gift. Thank you. Okay. That's all I got. Bye. Bye.

19:16Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I like that you can just call Garrett and he has an answer.

19:20PJ: Okay. A question from Kipmo.

19:22Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Kipmo.

19:23PJ: Yeah. Guys, a lot of these questions are four different questions. That's cheating.

19:27Sruthi Pinnamaneni: If they ask four questions, you can pick which one you want to ask. There's a lot of questions here.

19:32PJ: Okay. What is your process for trying to decide, quote, is this something your audience, our audience would find interesting? Or is it something that only PJ finds interesting? End quote.

19:42Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Oh, I know. I ask you guys to do it. You guys repeatedly either shoot me down or pretend like you're going to do a booking but don't do a booking.

19:49PJ: Do you, to answer that question, it's exactly what happens with Trump. Other people on the show are the audience, and we get to just choose. Yeah. Hang on. Okay. Do you ever worry that the show is slipping into becoming Reply All 2.0? I don't know what that means, but do you ever make an effort to find stories that would definitely, all caps, not be a Reply All story?

20:09Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Yes. Yeah, I get a real, I feel, I mean, not as like a knock on Reply All, but like it makes me very happy when we do stories that I think wouldn't be Reply All stories because your job is to keep growing.

20:21PJ: Do you worry that the show is slipping into Reply All 2.0?

20:25Sruthi Pinnamaneni: No, I don't know exactly what that person means when they say that, but if people who like Reply All find Search Engine, I hope that there are parts of the show that feel like familiar pleasures to them and parts that feel new. And I would feel sad if either half of that wasn't the case.

20:40PJ: This person also snuck in a totally unrelated question. This is out of line. If AI manages to replace many jobs and professions, what do you think humanity should pursue to find new purpose and meaning in life?

20:52Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Oh, God, if you can figure that one out. It would really help with my step-teens. I don't know. I don't know. I feel very alarmed that in times of technological change, oftentimes you would not want to be the person living in the first 20 or 30 years of it. It would be much better to be living once things settle down.

21:11PJ: A question from Lee Suggs. Suggs?

21:15Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Suggs.

21:15PJ: Can you open the books on podcasting? Listeners would be interested to hear about how the economics of a podcast has evolved and what it's like out there today. How are ad sponsorships? How do you negotiate those deals? Do you need more staff or less staff than prior shows? Does AI help?

21:31Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Oh, okay. Economics have gotten harder because ads are less valuable, listeners are more scattered, and there's just like less cultural interest in podcasting. And it's supplemented with listener subscriptions. Like, this show, I always say this as copy, and I think people don't believe me. The show works because people do incognito mode. It's a tiny, tiny, tiny fraction of our listeners. And it ends up being, like, 30 or 40 percent of the show's actual operating budget. That's the reason it works. And, you know, you can make a living but not a killing. Does this show need fewer? For a second, I was like, are they saying, like, we should fire someone or something?

22:06Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Is this, like, The Apprentice? The show certainly doesn't need fewer people. AI definitely makes it easier. I mean, like, the job that I did when I started in podcasting was transcribing, like listening to 17 hours of audio and typing up all the words that were said in that. And everybody uses robot transcription for that now. I think it's like everybody gets to do so far the more interesting parts of their job and spend less time doing the more boring parts of their job. And that's great.

22:35PJ: Yeah, and we have a small staff. It's basically, it's me, PJ, Emily, Garrett, Armin, who is our incredible sound genius, engineer who's into some music on the show. He's not full-time and he's remote. So I would say full-time there's four staff members. And there's also, we have the fellows on the show. So right now that's Piper Dumont. Yeah, I think we are purposely keeping the show staff small. It's in some ways easier to run the show when we're tight-knit and all here. We also have office culture still. Like, we do work out of an office together. Yeah, but I—yeah.

23:18Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Were you going to say one more thing? I feel like you were going to say one more thing.

23:21PJ: No, I was thinking about the question of do you need more staff.

23:23Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I think sometimes I have a fantasy of Search Engine being a much larger, like, magazine-type show. And the question is, like, do we actually know how to do that? Because it's really—it's much easier to build a functional small culture than a functional medium-sized culture, in my opinion.

23:39PJ: Yeah, and listener Leigh Suggs, we do try to open the books on podcasting. We do—

23:45Sruthi Pinnamaneni: If you're an Incognito member, you can hear so much about the internals of our show. You can, like, almost any question you have besides, like, our EIN or whatever you can get.

23:55PJ: Okay. Listener, a pleasant hello.

24:00Sruthi Pinnamaneni: That's a nice name.

24:02PJ: How early in the research reporting process do you realize there's not enough information to answer a listener's question? And conversely, do you ever find an answer to questions so quickly and easily you decide not to turn it into a full episode?

24:13Sruthi Pinnamaneni: All the time. All the time. Constantly. It's like the thing that most often happens is someone else sends a message and I'll be like, that's an interesting question. Somebody this morning over email was like, what happened to the bees? There was like a few years ago, everybody was like so worried about the honeybees. Was that like a fake thing or did we solve it or whatever? And I like read about it for half an hour and it was like, well, there's like an answer there, but it just wasn't. It was just, it wasn't that there wasn't enough of an answer. It was that the answer wasn't enough of a story, I thought.

24:43Sruthi Pinnamaneni: But that one was kind of on the, it was kind of interesting what happened to the bees. They're still in trouble. It's just the honeybees are not in trouble. It's like the less cute, the less photogenic bees are struggling. And there's not one villain. It's like because of a lot of different reasons. And so it's still a problem and it became a harder story to tell. And because it became a harder story to tell, it became a harder problem to solve. And because it became a harder story to tell, I was like, do I want to tell that story? Maybe not.

25:08PJ: Do you realize sometimes that there's not enough information to answer listeners' questions. Yes, there are some stories that we really, really want to answer, but we don't know the answer yet. And if you can't figure the thing out, like PJ did a call-out about a story we're kind of obsessed with, that's a Dartmouth and requires...

25:27Sruthi Pinnamaneni: We need people. We still want to solve this. If you have at any time, including now, been a member of the secret society, the Sphinx, write to us. We will keep you anonymous. We have questions. We have questions. I think you know what the questions are.

25:43PJ: Oh, we have a spicy question here involving Reddit and AI. So I think that this would be a moment that you could put in an ad break and we'll come back.

25:51Sruthi Pinnamaneni: After the break, something that will make me uncomfortable. I can tell by the way you're looking at me.

26:22PJ: Okay, we're back. Another question. Okay, hit me. A question from IsThisHandleTaken?

26:30Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I guess so.

26:31PJ: There has been a bunch of pushback on how you have approached stories about AI here on Reddit. The general feeling seems to be that you were soft on AI companies and corporate interests and dismissive of AI and data center protesters. Has the team discussed the criticism? And if so, are you going to take a different approach going forward or do you think the criticism is unfounded? We do discuss the criticism on the show. We discuss.

26:56Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Our show is very into discussing outside of criticism. I think, generally speaking, I like half agree with that. I think that it's weird. our data center episode, which is listeners, well, we've done a bunch, but the third data center episode we did, which I think is the one this listener is talking about. It's funny. It was a very sympathetic portrait of anti-data center activists. The conclusion of the episode was that the AI companies are steamrolling local communities in a way that is undemocratic and won't work in the long term. And I think there were a couple of places where I expressed myself badly and I did sound like dismissive to concerns that I'm actually very sympathetic to.

27:36Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Should we like re-listen to the episode and was like, I think this here is like where you're coming across?

27:40PJ: Because it was a, I think, again, like you said, sympathetic to anti-data center activists and trying to understand their position. But sometimes when you were as an interviewer just occupying your imagined version of like, oh, this is what a tech person would think here, it might have come off as sounding like that's what you believed. And so we actually, yeah, we, I think.

28:04Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I think it was a place where it was like, oh, what people are hearing is what we think we're saying. Maybe the problem is us. Like that was, that was one where I thought the internet criticism was warranted. Like I was just like, oh, if you're being misunderstood as a communicator, like you have to look at that. Yes. But I feel like deeply worried about what AI will do, like to society. I feel like, I feel worried about jobs. I feel worried about meeting. I feel worried about, like, teenagers in school. Like, I kind of wish it would just, like, stop right now. Like, we could sort of get our arms around it, which doesn't seem to be what's happening.

28:38Sruthi Pinnamaneni: The soft on the companies thing, I just don't agree with. Like, I feel like we, the view of the show is this technology is really important. It is being rolled out in a way that feels, the power is very concentrated among a few people. it's a really really scary and important and big story to cover and it's something to be curious

28:58PJ: about and not just like it's probably the biggest story of our time yeah i think arguably it is and

29:04Sruthi Pinnamaneni: like this show is not going to be like all an ai show but i think there are listeners who the the specific kind of skepticism they want is that this is a flash in the pan thing that's going to go away that's the only part of the debate that i'm like i just think the evidence doesn't support it i don't want to spend time engaging with it there's plenty of media that does support that idea and like you can find it.

29:24PJ: And when you say flash in the pan, you mean people who think that AI is a hoax. Like it's like crypto. Like it's not a useful technology. It's not. It never will be.

29:31Sruthi Pinnamaneni: No one's really going to use it. It's going to stop tomorrow. And I think that's like diminishing, but I used to get a lot of that in my inbox. I'm just like, it's just not what I believe. And I don't think it's responsible to cover it that way. I think the way to responsibly cover it is this could absolutely be a financial bubble, but the technology is here. It's going to be transformative. It will be transformative in ways that are bad. Hopefully it'll be transformed in ways that are good. And our job is to be really curious about it, explain it to our audiences so they can make up their minds.

29:58Sruthi Pinnamaneni: My biggest feeling with AI, my biggest critique of it is that it feels profoundly undemocratic. Like it feels like change that's being foisted by a few unusual people on like our entire society. And so my understanding of how to participate in this democracy is to try to provide information and ask questions. So that's what we're trying to do.

30:15PJ: Yeah. And one other thing I want to say to this person is that it's tricky because while we don't always do a deep dive on the Reddit criticism of specific episodes, I have noticed that sometimes Reddit can be very harsh on an AI episode. But then we get, like, a lot of listeners writing in to say that it was helpful or, like, those episodes perform really well also just in terms of numbers. And so it makes me think that people want explainers about these subjects. They want to know what's happening inside Anthropic. They want to know, like, what was the hugging face attack?

30:55Sruthi Pinnamaneni: That's what we see our job as this year, is more like doing explainers and less like making predictions about what's going to happen. And I do think, I think you're right, Trithia. Like, I think that the Reddit view on AI and the view on our inbox and AI are different. Both views are concerned, but it's a very different kind of concern.

31:12PJ: Okay. Okay. From ConsciousFood9828. Hi, PJ. Love the show. Do you have a, quote, heartbreak story that after much work time and effort never quite planned out? Never quite panned out, I think this person means.

31:27Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Well, I always just tell myself they're still going to pan out.

31:29PJ: Yeah, exactly. I'm always like, ah, it just needs another year.

31:33Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I mean, I guess if there's one, there's a story that I've been working on for five or almost six years now that's about the internet and psych wards and ancient Athens. And it's not like I'm actually really happy with it as a story. It's not like, oh, I need one more person to talk to me kind of a problem. It's that I don't think it's a podcast. it's like it's a story about the things the internet does that I don't want on the internet it's a story I want to tell as a monologue to a room full of people and the part that I've been stuck on hasn't been writing it anymore like that took a long time it's been I don't know how to take a monologue and make it into a piece of theater and so I've just I've been having a hard time because I want it out of me and in the world and I I just need to figure out like I understand podcasting much better than I understand like theater so that one it's not a heartbreak story but it's like it is weighing on me a lot.

32:29PJ: PJ, you sound very serious.

32:31Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I really, that thing is like, I don't know, it's like sometimes like I'll be in like a taxi and the taxi will make a scary swerve and I'll be like, I have to get that story done. Like it's really, I really want to get it done.

32:46PJ: I hope for your sake and for the shows that you get it done. Okay, I want to pick the one that did not get any votes, but I find to be a really funny question. Okay. Intelligent Cake asks, Why are you giving out what appears to be a personal Gmail address asking advertisers to contact you? There's no way you don't have a proper domain for your company, right?

33:08Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Okay. I just like there to be fewer email addresses. So I have like a real – I have an email address that I use for everyone I've ever met in my life since college and every booking request and all – like I don't have a professional work address. I just literally have my inbox. But pj85 at gmail.com, to be clear, is not PJ's. That's the second, the first time in my life I voluntarily made a second email address. And that's for everything show related. So like questions, advertisers.

33:40PJ: And you just think it's funny to have a Gmail as that. We have a proper domain. We have a website.

33:45Sruthi Pinnamaneni: But I don't want to use it. I find it funny. I just find it funnier. I just think it's like, I appreciate jankiness. All right. The 85 was like me giggling to myself because it's like such a lousy, it's like I couldn't get the email address, so I put my birth year after it. It just made me happy. I'm sorry. It pleased me.

34:04PJ: The small things in life.

34:05Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I'm an elder millennial.

34:07PJ: Apprentice 57. Hey there. In the PJ and Shruti have lunch incognito mode episode, I seem to recall that you two, though especially Shruti, is speaking pretty negatively of this subreddit. Should they even cast it as a what do we do about the subreddit? Although she walked the phrasing back a bit right after. Later last year, you and some search engine staff started participating more directly here, like with the AMAs. Was that coming out of the what do you do about the subreddit question? Great question. I don't remember saying what do you do about the subreddit. But what I do remember saying is that I was interested in doing a story about subreddits and how there is this arc of this fandom organizing around something like a piece of music or an artist or a podcast.

35:01PJ: And then slowly the fandom turning against that entity. And I find that turn really interesting. and I think I said, like, I don't want to do a story about our subreddit, which I feel like, you know, has had something of that arc with us. And I think that's what this question is referencing.

35:22Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Yeah, and I would say, like, the subreddits you were interested in were more, like, I feel like our subreddit is, like, sometimes cantankerous about us and you were more interested in subreddits that really did feel like they turned into, like, reverse fandoms of things. The other thing I think we talked about in that conversation was there'd been a moment where our own subreddit had gotten negative in ways that were not specifically about the show that we were uncomfortable with. We had like a very young child on the show. This person was like 12 years old. And not everybody, but some people on the subreddit were going after this kid for the way he talked.

35:58Sruthi Pinnamaneni: And I was like, I just felt like that was beyond the pale. And you felt like that was beyond the pale. And like people should be able to critique a podcast, but like, I think we just kind of all agree on that. And yeah, after that, I think we talked about it and we were like, let's just participate a little bit more because generally speaking, proximity creates like humanity. And I think that's been good. I think it's totally been good.

36:20PJ: We never want to be a subreddit where people can criticize. Like that obviously is the purpose of this space. You know, one of the purposes of the space. Yeah, it's been, I think, better since. And I'm happy that we are on or more active in the subreddit because we got all these questions from there. All right, moving on. Oh, okay, here's one from Danny YR. I've sent an email, but I'll ask you just in case. My email said, greetings from Australia. I'm curious to know what your listenership looks like geographically. I'm guessing I'm not your only Aussie listener, and I'm guessing Americans take the lion's share of numbers.

37:00PJ: But do you have a few Bahrainian listeners? Any from Denmark, Togo? What surprised you most on your listener demographics? So we have a platform that we use and we can see where people are listening from. I knew that I was going to ask this question, PJ. So I asked Emily to crunch the numbers so that I didn't need to and didn't need to ask you to do it in real time. So I'm going to call her. Emily, I don't have you on speed dial.

37:32Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Who's on your speed dial, Shruti?

37:34PJ: Garrett.

37:35Sruthi Pinnamaneni: That's it?

37:35PJ: I mean you, my kids. Hello? Hi, Em.

37:42Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Hi, PJ. Hi, Shruti.

37:43PJ: Hello. All right, you heard the question. Do you have any Bahrainian listeners? So I've checked our numbers. I can report that we've had 524 downloads this year from Bahrain, putting it at our 115th country. In terms of listenership, the United States is the number one place where our listeners are listening in from. Australia is number four. 5 % of our listeners are listening in from Australia, which I think is fantastic.

38:15Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Denmark, 0.7 % of our listeners are listening in from Denmark. That's 10th. Great dance. Yeah. And we have listeners from Togo.

38:26PJ: According to our metrics, we have 45 downloads this year from Togo, putting it at the 190th country on the list.

38:34Sruthi Pinnamaneni: That could easily be one to three people. If you are the one to three people listening in Togo, please reach out. I want to know. I want to know. Absolutely.

38:44PJ: And yeah, I think the thing that surprises me the most about our listener demographics is that we have listeners. It seems that nearly every country, if not every country, or we have some bots that are like, I don't know, bouncing around to various VPNs in nearly every country. But yeah, I am fascinated. I would love to hear from our Togolese listeners. Garrett has just asked if we have any listeners from the Vatican.

39:09Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I think I recall that we have like one. Yeah. We have one, and I think we all know who we're hoping that is. Yeah.

39:19PJ: Thank you, Emily. Of course. Bye. Here's one. Super Helical, any regrets for giving anyone a platform?

39:30Sruthi Pinnamaneni: No. I don't know. Let me be more generous. I think I used to think more about who should be platformed and who shouldn't be platformed. And the second, when Trump was elected a second time, I was like, I don't think the logic of not platforming people works. I think that the other thing is like one of the things I really love about Search Engine is that the show is a place where people who believe different things can show up. And they can even show up and not necessarily be here to talk about like the thing that I disagree with them about. Like we had an episode where I talked to this writer who I would call anti-woke or center-right.

40:07Sruthi Pinnamaneni: She doesn't prefer to use any of those labels, but she'd taken an ayahuasca and it made her not want to do her complaining about wokeness podcast anymore. And I thought that was a really interesting human experience. And I related to the questions that were just normal questions in that. Like, I'm not an anti-woke podcaster, obviously, but like the idea that you would take a psychedelic and it would make you question the meaning of your own life. It was like, that's so interesting and funny. And the question itself, the story itself is almost like the punchline to a joke. I just want to talk to that person.

40:37Sruthi Pinnamaneni: But I don't think that I need to talk to Sarah Hader and be like, and here's all the places like you and I might disagree politically. Like that feels to me more about signaling things to the audience about how on side I am than it is about what I understand my job to be, which is to be curious and to ask questions. And like, you can go too far. You know, there's like podcasters who have made a great career out of going too far in that direction. But for the most part, I like having lots of people on search engine. And I like asking them the questions that I want to ask them.

41:07PJ: Do you worry, this is from Hog Enthusiast.

41:10Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Yes, I do.

41:12PJ: Do you worry AI will lead to the collapse of modern society? And if so, why do you do ads for Anthropic?

41:19Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I think that it's possible that AI could lead to the collapse of modern society. And I've gone back and forth on allowing AI ads on Search Engine or not. The reason I've decided, like, let's say yes to this one is I think turning it down is kind of like turning down advertisements from internet companies. Like, social media was vastly destructive and vastly useful and vastly socially transformative. And I think that is the most likely outcome for AI. I don't actually think it's going to end the world. I don't think it's going to bring us to a utopia where Elon Musk gives us Musk bucks and, like, we're on vacation all the time.

41:57Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Like, I think it will be, like, most big transformational change. like disruptive, fucked up in some ways and beneficial in others and our job is to cover it. I believe that we can have a show where for 60 minutes every week we say exactly what we think is true and don't worry about the consequences from Anthropic or anybody else. And that in the middle of that show for 60 or 90 seconds, we can run ads where we read the copy that the company's asked us to read. Like I think that you can have ad-supported media that is not enthralled to the companies that advertise. And the reason I believe that is because while the show needs ads in general to live right now, I kind of prefer it didn't, but it does, there's no one advertiser that is a very large part of our budget.

42:44Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Like our biggest advertisers tend to be like more like the companies that want to send you sweaters. And even those, like any single one of them, we can afford to lose. So that's the calculation I made. I know there are listeners who, like, it just makes them feel uncomfortable to hear AI coverage and AI ads. I get it. But the reality of making a tech show is, like, this is what we need to do to survive, and this is the policy we've built around it to protect our journalism.

43:09PJ: Yes. Okay, PJ, here's one.

43:13Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Uh-huh.

43:14PJ: An emailed one. That's a bong sound in your intro music, right?

43:21Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Is there a bong sound in the—

43:23PJ: I don't— They mean bong like cannabis paraphernalia.

43:28Sruthi Pinnamaneni: They don't mean bong like gong.

43:29PJ: This is very easy to clear.

43:31Sruthi Pinnamaneni: I think if this listener is hearing a bong sound in our intermusic, this listener needs to put down their bong.

43:39PJ: Hi, Armin, can you hear me? Yeah. Is it okay if I put you on speaker? Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Okay, cool. So we're doing an AMA, and we got a question that only you can answer, which is, a listener asks, with the degree of certainty I find confusing, that's a bong sound in your intro music, right?

44:02Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Oh my God, okay.

44:07I mean, no.

44:09Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Yeah, I think that's all. Do you know what sound they think is a bong, Armin? I imagine like at the beginning, the gears like revving up, maybe. Okay. Oh, yeah. That could be like the burble of a bong. Okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I understand why they're confused. I don't. But that's okay. We love questions that give us an excuse to call you. Thanks, Ironman.

44:33PJ: Bye. Okay, bye. So we're about to run out of time, but let me just keep going. Okay. I re-listen to Old Replyle frequently, says NiceWeather650. It snuck by me the first time, but you opened my favorite episode, The Case of the Missing Hit, noting that you had just discovered you had, quote, pure O OCD. I'm curious if you still have pure O, if you consider it regular OCD, how it's been managing it, whatever you're willing to share.

45:06Sruthi Pinnamaneni: It's funny. I think one of the ways I'm different at 41 than 35 or 36 is, like, I'm much more, like, I think I'm more skeptical of applying diagnoses and labels to myself. but the thing that that diagnosis described is still like a very, very, very, very, very prominent feature of my brain as like Shruti, the person who has to deal with my looping and obsessive mind more than most people I think you would attest to. How do I—do you think my brain's any better than it used to be?

45:37PJ: Nope, we'll never find out.

45:47PJ: Okay, that's everything. Thank you for everybody who sent their questions.

45:51Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Yeah, thanks, everybody.

45:58Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Those were the anythings that we answered this week. If you were curious about my mental health, so am I. Thank you to this week's host, who normally is our show's editor, Shruti Pimaneni. If you'd like to hear Shruti on mic more often, shoot us an email.

46:34Sruthi Pinnamaneni: Search Engine is a presentation of Odyssey. It was created by me, PJ Vogt, and Shruti Pinnamineni. Garrett Graham is our senior producer. Emily Molter is our producer. Theme, original composition and mixing by Armin Bazarian. Our production intern is Piper Dumont. Our executive producer is Leah Reese-Dennis. Thanks to the rest of the team at Odyssey. Rob Mirandi, Craig Cox, Eric Donnelly, Colin Gaynor, Maura Curran, Josephina Francis, Kirk Courtney, and Hilary Shuff. If you have a question for Search Engine, shoot us an email, pjvote85 at gmail.com. If you're a business and would like to advertise on Search Engine, shoot us an email there too, subject line advertising.

47:10Sruthi Pinnamaneni: If you're a listener and would like to hear a version of this show without ads, you can sign up for Incognito Mode. That's our paid feed. You can find a link to subscribe in our show notes or just go to searchengine.show. Contributions from our Incognito Mode listeners are what help us keep this project running. If you would like a cheaper way to support us, you could rate and review us on Apple Podcasts or follow us on Spotify. That is what the robots want. Thank you, as always, for listening. We'll see you next week.

47:41Thank you.

From the publisher

This week we answer any and all listener questions, no topic off limits! Guest host Sruthi Pinnamaneni brings your questions to PJ. 

Check out the new Search Engine merch!

Sign up to be an Incognito Mode member!

More from Search Engine

All episodes