In short
Allie Rowbottom’s novel Lovers XXX (set in 1980s Los Angeles) explores the “golden age” of pornography after VHS, focusing on women’s agency vs exploitation, and how consent, money, drugs, and lasting media complicate moral debates. It also compares porn’s cultural role to modern platforms like OnlyFans and the internet’s shift toward “amateur”/gonzo content.
Guests
Allie Rowbottom, Los Angeles-based novelist and Free Press contributor; previously reported/wrote for Playboy’s adult-video coverage and interviewed talent agent Mark Spiegler at AVN/“Oscars of porn.” She also wrote Jello Girls (memoir about Jell-O and patriarchy).
Key claims
Empowerment is person-by-person and not answerable in totalizing terms; VHS-era stardom let performers (e.g., “video vixens” on box covers) command money and visibility. Internet porn and platforms can be both harmful and enabling (OnlyFans as empowerment for some). Porn’s “pictures last forever” problem mirrors other irrevocable life choices (including her own memoir).
Notable examples
Christy Canyon, Ginger Lynn, Amber Lynn, Portia Lynn, Candida Royale, Sharon Mitchell, Annie Sprinkle, Nina Hartley; character “Winnie” writing an LA Weekly-style “week in my life” expose; Judy Sill (Laurel Canyon singer) as inspiration for “Jude”; World Modeling talent agency (Sherman Way) and Jim South; Andrea Dworkin’s quote about pornography as “orchestrated destruction.”
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VODiscussing Lovers XXX
0:06 to 0:30
Allie shares her experiences writing Lovers XXX and its themes.
“I was sick of flipping my pillow every five minutes, so I finally switched out my whole sleep situation for Cozy Earth, and I really don't know what I was waiting for.”
Discussing Lovers XXX
1:07 to 1:55
Allie shares her experiences writing Lovers XXX and its themes.
“Some people are saying Lovers XXX, and sometimes I just say Lovers.”
Exploring Pornography's Golden Age
1:57 to 3:16
Discussion on the allure of the 1980s pornography scene.
“Los Angeles, 1980s, videotape just came out.”
Women's Empowerment in Porn
3:21 to 4:52
Exploring whether porn is empowering for performers.
“And that, of course, would come from they're making more money than they ever could.”
The Paradox of OnlyFans
4:59 to 7:13
Debate on whether OnlyFans is a positive or negative platform.
“certainly a lot of testimonies from people who have had negative experiences.”
The Nature of Empowerment
7:14 to 8:00
Discussion on empowerment related to plastic surgery and storytelling.
“I think there's an element of that, yeah.”
Research and Reality
8:01 to 11:34
Allie shares her research experiences and thoughts on strip clubs.
“and just been like, I'm writing for Playboy.”
Cultural Mechanisms in Literature
11:35 to 14:03
Exploring cultural themes in literature and their impact.
“Yeah and maybe do something that you feel predisposed to or enjoy doing.”
Exploring the Shades of Self-Branding
14:03 to 26:44
Discussing the intersection of self-branding and the sex industry.
“So plastic surgery influencing, for example, porn.”
Exploring the Shades of Self-Branding
26:48 to 27:39
Discussing the intersection of self-branding and the sex industry.
“that most topics deserve more honesty and more depth than they're getting.”
Show all 28 chapters
The Permanent Nature of Published Work
27:40 to 28:00
Considering the lasting impact of published work on identity and memory.
“you've, you know, we've written that will last forever.”
Reflections on 'Jello Girls'
28:00 to 28:50
The author discusses their complex feelings about their memoir 'Jello Girls'.
“that way about stuff i've written yeah and it's just like i mean that like my first book i don't want to take it back but i have like a kind of a little bit of a fraught relationship with it and like.”
The Jello Curse Explained
28:50 to 30:10
Exploration of the so-called 'Jello curse' and its implications for women in the author's family.
“life as an jello heiress yep yeah you're like well and jello is another american institution plastic surgery pornography jello these are great american institutions in that order in that order Exactly.”
Marketing and Evolution of Jell-O
30:10 to 31:30
The evolution of Jell-O as a product and its various marketing strategies through the decades.
Cultural Impact of Jell-O
31:30 to 34:34
A discussion on Jell-O's place in American culture and its various uses over time.
“That's like, and do you get paid every time I eat one of those?”
The Jello Curse as Patriarchy
34:34 to 34:54
The author relates the Jello curse back to broader themes of patriarchy in their narrative.
“But just to close the loop on the Jell-O curse, the Jell-O curse is patriarchy.”
Moving Back to New York
34:54 to 36:07
Discussion on the author's feelings about moving back to New York from LA and observations of the city.
“for a long time and I was just getting grossed out by L.A.”
Observations on LA Culture
36:07 to 37:45
The author's reflections on the unique aspects and challenges of LA culture and lifestyle.
“Like I just know very, even as I love it and some parts of it, I just feel like, oh, I'm not from here.”
Playboy's Distinction in the Industry
37:45 to 40:04
Exploration of Playboy's cultural significance and its distinction from pornography.
“presided over by Jim South, who was also very famous.”
Modern Perspectives on Gender and Porn
40:04 to 42:04
Engagement in a dialogue about changing perceptions of men and women in the context of pornography.
“I don't think it elicits in men the response that we're hoping for.”
The Evolution of Female Portrayals in Porn
42:04 to 43:11
Explore how female portrayals in porn have shifted over the years.
“And the guy's like, you know, come on, do it.”
The Rise of MILF and Female Empowerment
43:11 to 44:16
Discuss the popularity of the MILF genre and its implications for masculinity.
“sort of show them the ropes and explain sex to them.”
Cultural Reflections on Porn in Media
44:16 to 45:21
Examine current media representations of porn and its societal implications.
The Impact of Celebrity Sex Tapes on Careers
45:21 to 46:48
Analyze the effect of sex tapes on the careers of celebrities like Kim Kardashian.
“Well, it's a great story arc to be like my name and likeness was released without my consent.”
The Pendulum of Sexual Representation
46:48 to 48:41
Discuss the cultural oscillation between sexual absence and prominence in media.
“I mean, I'm not like completely abreast of it, but I would say probably.”
Navigating the Complexity of Pornography in Literature
48:41 to 50:35
Delve into the challenges of discussing pornography in literary contexts.
“I would never write a book that I think should be for everyone.”
The Gendered Dynamics of Beauty Standards
50:35 to 52:46
Explore gender differences in societal beauty standards and self-improvement.
“I'm kind of fascinated by this book because I've never read something where I feel like turned on in like a porny way, but also I'm like intellectually stimulated.”
Reality TV and Self-Objectification
52:46 to 53:44
Investigate how reality TV shows relate to self-objectification and fame.
“or like a reality show where the whole point is watching people sort of fight and hook up in bathing suits.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Every summer, I rediscover that my body's preferred sleeping temperature is that of an industrial freezer. Anyone else? I was sick of flipping my pillow every five minutes, so I finally switched out my whole sleep situation for Cozy Earth, and I really don't know what I was waiting for. The rib-knit pajama set is incredible. It's best worn after a full day of sweating in muggy New York City to feel instantly refreshed. These PJs are made from viscose and bamboo and are genuinely breathable. Cozy Earth stands by everything they make. There's a lifetime warranty and 30 days of hassle-free returns if something's not right.
0:30Head to CozyEarth.com and use my code SUZY, that's S-U-Z-Y, for an exclusive 20 % off. That's code SUZY for an exclusive 20 % off. And if you see a post-purchase survey, mention that you heard about Cozy Earth right here. I might put out a jerk-off video of myself and see what that does for my career. That would be good. Give it a try. Give it a try. Why not? Welcome, everyone, to Second Thought. I'm Suzy Weiss. I'm Dana Dute. And today we are joined by a free press favorite, the bard of Los Angeles, Allie Rowbottom. Allie, welcome to Second Thought. Thank you so much for having me. What's the title of this?
1:06Because I've been reading it on the train and been getting some weird looks. I call it Lovers XXX. Some people are saying Lovers XXX, and sometimes I just say Lovers. I was reading it at the dentist's office, and I was in the waiting room, and there was like a very salacious scene that I was reading. And I'm just there alone, and then I hear, Dan, the doctor's ready? and I like dropped my phone because I felt like I got caught. I've never read this type of book and I was absolutely riveted and I could not. One with chapters? One with chapters and no pictures. How was that for you, Dan? It was so good.
1:41I was telling Susie right before we started that this, the way you captured LA made me feel like the last time I felt like anything like that was seeing Pulp Fiction. Yeah. Thank you so much. Wow, I'm going to store that one away. Please do. You really can't put it down. Why did you want to write about the golden age of pornography, as it's called? Los Angeles, 1980s, videotape just came out. What was it about this moment that attracted you? You know, it was a couple things. Like, I started this novel as a, like, same structure and same basic premise, but it was set in the 60s in Laurel Canyon for two singer songwriters, like folk singers.
2:21I was listening to Once Upon a Time in the Valley, the Lily analic podcast and i was like okay this is just like 25 years later but it's so compelling and hot and sexy and all of the things that make me want to listen and i was like if i could make this world on the page i think people would want to read about it and i also like in aesthetica that was set in 2017 and 2035 and i just wanted to go back in time after that i didn't want to have to write another iphone novel i needed a break that makes a lot of sense yeah 100 i want you to read this is from the introduction and I just think it's so read the highlighted bit.
2:57Women like Christy Canyon, Ginger Lynn, Amber Lynn, Portia Lynn, Candida Royale, Sharon Mitchell, Annie Sprinkle and the indomitable Nina Hartley had lived adventurous lives at the intersection of what I find most compelling as a writer. Women's agency, empowerment and sexual expression forged within the intricate ancient systems built by men for the purpose of oppressing us. so I guess the question there is just is porn empowering oh I don't think I can answer that question that is a person by person answer I think well I guess is it empowering for the performer do you think it depends on the performer I guess so wow you're gonna evade that question I I don't know and I mean I didn't write this book with an answer in mind same with aesthetica I just write around the question and I'm going to look at it from a couple different perspectives but I think it's ultimately it's it's unanswerable I mean I imagine you spoke to many people in this field while you're researching this book what are some examples of people who were empowered by it and some examples of people who were not empowered by it so the women that I just read the names of were really my entree into this time period and world and something that compelled me about, you know, their stories, which they've been quite vocal about, was their insistence on the empowering aspects of this work.
4:24And that, of course, would come from they're making more money than they ever could. Unlike in earlier iterations of pornography, as you describe, they're the stars, not the male directors. They're the ones who can, you know, command the large prices and they're video vixens. They're on the cover of the box. Is that what they were talking about? Yes, they were. And that was like early 80s O-centric. So the transition from film to VHS really brought this level of, you know, empowerment to some performers. And of course, like when I heard that, I was like, oh, that defies my expectation. I want to examine it.
4:58There are certainly a lot of testimonies from people who have had negative experiences. Typically, the people who are very insistent on the empowerment element of porn are people who are recognizable and who had those big careers and then for whom it worked out yeah it worked out yeah and then there's like probably thousands of performers who are not recognizable by name who who don't have that story and that we just don't hear from so in the book i wanted to make sure that even though i had this character of jude who had a really positive for the most part experience in the industry there was another side to that coin and that comes through the character of Winnie.
5:36And Winnie, I don't want to give away too much, but at a certain point in the book writes this expose for the LA Weekly, you know, a week in my life as an adult film actress. And it's so, it's almost like something you would see today. Someone being like, here's my expose. And I think a lot of people talk about, there's a line of argument that says, if porn only ended in the 60s, 70s, 80s, everything would be different. If it stopped with your, you know, your dad's hustler or penthouse in a box in the garage, and that was the extent of it, and you weren't, there was no internet aspect where you could be pushed to more and more extreme content, then maybe we wouldn't be in the sexpocalypse we're in now, or like whatever you want to call it.
6:23Do you think there's merit there? Or was there always a moral panic about the porn? I mean, there was certainly a moral panic at the time. I think it's easy to look back and have that sort of rosy colored glasses, nostalgic feeling. And I think that is really rampant right now. Just this idea that like the bodies were more natural. There were scripts. There was more of an artistic flair to the production, all of that stuff. But and to a degree, I do think that, you know, the Internet has been responsible for a lot of like shitty stuff. But at the same time, like with the rise of OnlyFans, that has been an empowering platform for a lot of adult performers.
7:03So I wouldn't want to say like, you know, porn reached its apex of empowerment in the 80s. I don't think that that's true. Do you think OnlyFans is a net positive? Oh, good question. Or net negative? like these are not Allie Rowbottom who by the way before we get to that great question have you like you do have a porny name me don't you think actually this is a good story um I reported from the ABNs for Playboy the adult video network or news uh words for Playboy um this past January Oscars of porn Oscars of porn and I interviewed Mark Spiegler who's one of the most famous talent agents in the business and um told him my name and he said that same thing he was like Maybe we'll name a girl after you.
7:46Oh, my God. Oh, does he name them? I think there's an element of that, yeah. I'm sure that there are people who name themselves as well. Wait, I'm curious about this guy. Is he, like, super charming? I was a little starstruck. I had, like, approached him at the Dunkin' Donuts down in the lobby and just been like, I'm writing for Playboy. Can I interview you? And I'm sure he's very used to that, you know, mode of approach, and he was very gracious. but at the same time there are aspects of his presentation that feel very like all the cliches are true. Only fans net positive, net negative. I mean I don't deal in totalizing theories.
8:22I can't do a net positive, net negative. It's just not in my nature. It's like beside the point to me. That's what makes the book so good because you sort of do this, you give the same treatment to plastic surgery. Is this empowering or does this make women a further slave to, as you put it, the systems that men put in place to oppress us. Yeah. And I can't say I can't answer that. I still can't like personally in my life. I can't answer that. I can ask the question though, like at multiple junctures in my life and reassess and feel differently about it. And like, yeah, it's just so important to me and my fiction not to write from that place of certainty.
8:58I feel like whenever people ask me like where I get my comedy from, I'm like, I have an awful imagination. It's all just things that happen in life. And then I write them. Do you have a great imagination or are these all pretty true to life stories because it's so specific in such a way where I'm like someone can't just come up with this or maybe you can I mean I have a I have a great imagination I think not to pat myself on the back please do um uh this book is heavily researched I mean they both are and my first book jello girls as well and a lot of the time like especially with aesthetica and it's sort of yet to be seen with certain elements of lovers but like stuff that I imagined came to fruition like came to be real um years later so a lot of the time it's really just like using that novelist mind to be like okay well like what is like the logical next step if this happens what then would happen next what would the pendulum swing back exactly like you can imagine it if you're looking at history as I do with lovers but then also like you know transposing it onto the future and with a with esthetica for those who haven't read it the swing back is this idea that in the near future there will be a procedure where you'll be able to undo all of the plastic surgery you did in order to make yourself younger you'll explant your implants that you got to make your boobs bigger and and they'll be able to make it so you've aged naturally right have you seen influencers be like i'm throwing everything out you know i'm going a natural.
10:30I'm getting, you know, the fillers dissolved from my lips. I mean, definitely have you? I've seen that. I've seen it a lot. Yeah, it is happening a lot for sure. I want to read a bit from the op ed that Winnie, one of your characters, writes about her experience. And she quotes the feminist Andrea Dworkin. Sure. So I'm going to read that out loud. The feminist. Actually, I'm gonna have you read that out loud. It's your book. Happy to do it. Yeah. The feminist theorist Andrea Dworkin writes that quote pornography is the orchestrated destruction of women's bodies and souls rape battery incest and prostitution animate it dehumanization and sadism characterize it it is a war on women serial assaults on dignity identity and human worth it is a tyranny it's pretty compelling theories that's a totalizing theory but it's like it's hard to prove it not true because just there's so many examples of all of those things.
11:27Sure but there's so many examples of the opposite too. Right. Maybe not quite as many but there are. Where you're able to sort of pull yourself out of your station and create a life for yourself. Yeah and maybe do something that you feel predisposed to or enjoy doing. Did you spend a lot of time in strip clubs researching the book? Oh yeah. I have spent quite a bit of time in strip clubs. Not necessarily thinking it was research for the novel. Are you a strip club person? I wouldn't say I'm an ardent strip club person, but I do enjoy maybe like a yearly sojourn. Yeah. A yearly pilgrimage? Yeah.
12:02Like last year for my wedding anniversary, my husband and I went to a strip club and I got several lap dances and it was nice. That sounds fun. In Los Angeles? Here, actually, right down the street at Sapphire. Okay, because there is, we were talking about this before, I think in LA there's a law where if they're naked, no alcohol is served. I think that's true as well and if they're wearing clothes then you can serve alcohol which is why Jumbo's Jumbo's Clown Room um that's the sort of leftist strip club right it's like the worker owned yeah it's really like sex positive strip club the hipster one yes yeah it is it is so hipster at this point like it's been around for so long it's like a parody yeah it's friend of the pod recently Jumbo's Clown Room yeah please I do love Jumbo's amazing dancers great service do you think there's more freedom around the stuff on the West Coast?
12:51Like, or do you think the East Coasters are a little more buttoned up? Like, jumbos, no thank you, I'll go to the Yale Club. I do think so, yeah. Yeah. I mean, generally. Wait, really? Because you can have booze in a strip club on the East Coast, but you can't on the West Coast. I just think, like, more, like, vibe-wise, the East Coast does sort of retain that, like, puritanical, like, and maybe some of it is, like, you know, this idea of, like, New York as the intellectual epicenter of the world in LA as like Hollywood skin factory. And that stuff is hard to shake off. I mean, it's been interesting with this novel.
13:29I've been sort of surprised by how difficult it's been to get coverage in some places and stuff because of the pornography element, I think. Oh, really? Yeah. I just, I think it's so tame. I mean, compare it to actual pornography. Right, I mean, it's like a literary treatment of porn. And it's interesting to examine, you know, I mean, this is my whole thing is I'm interested in big mechanisms of culture that we don't necessarily talk about because they're seen as lowbrow or pertaining to women and silly women at that, women that we can like make. So plastic surgery influencing, for example, porn.
14:07Yeah. So to me, it's like, well, why wouldn't I take it seriously, especially because so few people do? Well, that's what I found so sort of beautifully jarring about it is that I don't think I've ever read about this kind of, you know, underworld taboo in such a beautifully written prose. Like in such a like it was a very highbrow, lowbrow mix for me that was like really kind of exhilarating. I'd never I'd never read anything like it. Thank you. I think there's been a lot of talk about like, well, aren't we all selling ourselves? Like if you're on Substack, you're taking bits of yourself and selling it.
14:45Or if you are trying to have a brand on Instagram in a way, you are selling yourself. And what I love about this book, it explores the shades and then the bright line. Where is the bright line among all of the shades? And I was just curious if that's something you were thinking about too. Like are, you know, if you're selling your sexuality, are you a sex worker? like a you know a popular Instagram influencer for example who knows she gets more likes if she posts a picture in a bikini? No I don't think so but I do agree that like and I've experienced this myself in my writing career is that like stuff that wouldn't necessarily feel like part of the job of being a novelist has kind of become you know that sort of self-branding, self-packaging, self-promotion which for better for worse I've taken on yeah um and I think you know many people have regardless of industry but I don't think that makes me a sex worker for sure no you know I I read um Chuck Losterman's book the 90s oh yeah one of the defining uh like ethos of the 90s was don't sell out do not sell out you can't be a sellout like there was this big thing with like Like I think Pearl Jam once, Ticketmaster like tripled their prices and they're like, you sold out.
16:02And like they shut down the concert. And I feel like that pendulum swung so much where it's like you have to sell everything. You're selling your cameo videos. You're selling merch. Everyone's got merch. Anyone's got merch. And everyone is like. Everyone has a beauty line. Everyone has a bathing suit line. Sell as much as you can. I was talking about this with someone the other day who's a Gen Xer. So grew up in the 90s. And we were talking about how greed isn't a bad thing. Like greed isn't necessarily a bad thing. He's like, whoa, you guys are nihilists. Like because when he was growing up, the whole message was don't sell out.
16:36But there's other sins, you know what I mean? That you could choose to not indulge in or indulge in. So I think like deciding that greed is the worst one and it's worse than lust or worse than I'm pointing you lust or gluttony or the a million other things. It's like, I don't know, like maybe they're all bad. And maybe it's like, you know, an individual choice, like what what feels right to me and my moral system versus someone else's. Yeah, I get that. Let's take it a step further, though. Like if your daughter wanted to become a sex worker or a stripper. That's always a question. That's a question.
17:14Well, I don't have one. You were like, I just needed to avoid this this question. So I don't have a daughter. I don't have one. But, you know, like, I mean, and it's impossible, I think, to answer that question honestly. given that fact but is it cherry in the book also has these uh cherry lynn why are they why are they all named lynn i just like it is it like a middle of the country kind of like midwest thing yeah there were three of them at least ginger amber and portia lynn lynn in the 80s so funny i had the opportunity to meet ginger in las vegas in january and she was incredible and she was signing merch at the AVN Awards.
17:55So I got my signed photograph that's hanging in my house. What are those awards? In Vegas, I think they have these events where you can go meet your... It's a con, kind of. Yeah, it was like that. There's an expo, and then at the end of the week, there's an award ceremony. Dan goes to cons. I do. I recommend it. I would like to go to AVN again. I had a great time. I go to the Cobra Kai Con. I haven't been to the AVN Con. But people line up to get a picture of it. But I'm curious. Like, I mean, there's something. I don't know. It feels like if there's a bunch of guys lining up who've like jerked off to me that are like, I want to like touch you.
18:31I don't know. That feels so creepy to me now. Well, in the book, there's moments where she's like, I feel like the queen of the world. And other moments where she's like, ew, this vulnerable. Like, I feel so vulnerable. And at one point homesick when she realized that a man recognized her from porn. I said in my Playboy piece about the AVNs that like an alien touching down might sort of mistake this for a goddess worshiping culture. Because the women are very much, you know, elevated and treated like queens, but they're never unaccompanied by a male escort. Right. And things might be different if they were unaccompanied.
19:09We don't know. But it was an interesting dynamic for sure. I found it really fun. And I felt like as a woman sort of traversing the expo floor, like I felt safe. I felt like adored. It felt great. And like interacting with men in those situations, it's just like, okay, well, like it's all laid bare. Like we all know why you're here and what I mean to you. We don't have to pretend. Interesting. interesting by virtue of the fact that like the naughty thing is being said out loud it can be kind of like freeing and it's like we all know why we're here versus if you're in a really repressive situation i'm thinking of like a sunday school something that is what people find extremely erotic how did the worlds of drugs and alcohol and the other vices how does that kind of um seep into the tie-dye of the world of pornography there's a lot of cocaine in this book so maybe we'll start there well i just think it has to be historically accurate yeah and there was a lot of cocaine in the adult industry in the 80s in every industry in the 80s yeah i mean it was again like similar to porn a driving force culturally um so i couldn't omit that i had started it thinking i was writing about a character loosely based on judy sill um tell will you tell us who judy sill is so judy sill is or was a singer songwriter in los angeles in the 60s um in that sort of laurel canyon crowd who did not really break out and see the level of success that like someone like a joni mitchell who winnie is loosely based on um there's a rugged road.
20:57Yeah. An incredible. I mean, you listen to the music and you're just like, yep, that's it. Like, I imagine if you're a musician, you listen to that. You're like, I give up. Like, this is insane. Yeah. And she was like, she was super mystical. Like, she was really into like, weird religiosity and like, odd sex cults and stuff like that. Christianity. One of her big songs is Jesus Was a Crossmaker. Beautiful song. She started out like, she had gone to reform school and then like she was robbing liquor stores to feed her heroin addiction um there's a great piece I think in Rolling Stone that sort of like goes into her backstory um and she was you know somewhat rediscovered in like what was I like 2015 maybe as a person who never really got her to yes exactly and I believe she died in a motel room yes you know of an overdose yeah sure but But, you know, when I was writing Jude as like that character, like it felt important to have that element and to have addiction be, you know, something that held her back.
21:59And that was a vice for her and a fatal flaw, if you will. So it just felt natural. And I think like, you know, it's so important to give characters obviously something that they want and that they desire. and at the same time with Jude it felt like fitting that she wouldn't entirely know what that was like maybe it's Winnie maybe it's Laird and drugs like maybe it's this sort of like vague amorphous idea of like what it means to be an artist and keeping in mind that she's 18 in the first half of the book there's like there's that sense when you're 18 of like I want something I want to be someone but you don't quite know what it was and that felt important to me especially because I wanted it to happen and this does happen in the book that like when she shoots her first adult film she feels like this is what I was on top of the world yeah this is I found it this is my thing and maybe she's wrong readers will find out maybe she's right but um I wanted that felt like a sort of a radical experience to give a character of like having sex on film and being like, whoa, I actually really loved that.
23:14And I'm really good at it. I'm really good at it. That defied my expectations of what it would be like to shoot an adult film for the first time. I think it makes it the critiques of it more fulsome when you show that it's actually awesome to be high on cocaine. You know what I mean? It's like, there's a reason people keep going back to it. Like it's an unbelievable high. Yeah. Yeah. Someone was saying to me, like, I don't think I would like cocaine and I was like well it goes into those receptors in your brain that make you like things a lot so you probably would like it right you would like it at first and then maybe the next time you would like it a little less and a little less and a little less and a little less I think that's like chemically yeah proven that it's just like a drug of diminishing return I think a lot of this book and maybe even Aesthetica too is like taking something that like is on its face great to its logical demented conclusion, whether it's sex, money, drugs, like do you see yourself kind of wanting to maybe scratch the scab until it bleeds?
24:16Yes. I think, you know, as like an artist, as a novelist, you kind of have to. You have to go to like the most extreme place and the place where there's most conflict. What's the most misunderstood thing about porn that people don't understand? Oh, great question. Ooh, just one. I mean, I think. No, we'll take five. Yeah. As many as you got. Okay. Well, I think that it can be fun. Like, I mean, to me at this point, that feels like obvious because I've spent a lot of time researching this world. But when I started, it wasn't as obvious. And certainly at other times in my life, that did not feel obvious at all.
24:59that felt like would have been a huge surprise and probably quite threatening to me. Because you felt that all of these people are being taken advantage of or being exploited, don't actually want to be there? I think it, especially like in my late teens and early 20s, like, yeah, it felt like that was an easier way to sort of just like slot this entity that felt threatening to me into this place of like, women are victims, this is disempowering. And a lot of that is just naivete. and being young and wanting that like totalizing theory to make me feel comfortable. Like being a little moralistic.
25:36Yeah, being moralistic. And same with esthetica. I mean, in my like late teens, I was super like plastic surgeries for bimbos. I was just like. Interesting. Yeah. I mean, I talks. Yeah. I say it openly. I'm a talkser. Dan's a proud talkser. Proud talkser. Anything else? They call that bro talks. Oh, yeah. I scrotox. smooth out your balls no you don't no i don't that's crazy i don't think that's a real thing um like it could be though i guess like in my head like the best argument i mean there's lots of arguments against porn sex work the whole thing but the idea that even if you consent in the moment you cannot take it back ever like it's just being copied over and over ad infinitum this thing that you did that you can't take back.
26:31And I think that's pretty compelling. That's what Winnie says. She says pictures last forever. Yeah, pictures last forever. And oh God, no one's told her about video. Right, well, at that point, well, I don't want to spoil anything. So. And now a quick word from our sponsor. At the Free Press, we're pretty obsessed with one big idea that most topics deserve more honesty and more depth than they're getting. So I want to tell you about a podcast that's doing exactly that. It's called Unpacking Israeli History. If you follow the news about Israel, you're getting headlines. But headlines are just a tiny slice of a long, complicated, and fascinating story without the depth or the context that you deserve.
27:10On Unpacking Israeli History, Dr. Noam Weissman dives deep into the events, the people, and the moments that shaped Israel with genuine empathy and a willingness to explore multiple perspectives. And when he brings in guests like the philosopher Mika Goodman or the journalist Haviv Reddick Gur, they only add to that depth. It's deeply researched storytelling for people who want to understand Israel rather than confirm what they already think. And in today's climate, that's rare. Find Unpacking Israeli History on your favorite podcast app or YouTube and subscribe today. But what do you make of that argument that just like, it's just like, well, there's things that you've, you know, we've written that will last forever.
27:46I just think this idea of like a sex worker thinking or saying i have to see this thing that i don't want to exist i can never take it back yeah but that just feels true of everything like you said i mean i feel that definitely feel that way about stuff i've written yeah and it's just like i mean that like my first book i don't want to take it back but i have like a kind of a little bit of a fraught relationship with it and like. Jell Girls? Yeah. Why? It's so personal. It's a memoir. It's so personal and it was my first book I published. I didn't know a lot about what it means to put yourself out there that way and then like you know the story will never ever go away and that I would tell the story differently now than I did then.
28:35But I have to just be like that's okay. Like that book is a it's a time capsule it's a time in my life it's part of who i was then and so it's part of who i am now even if i would write it differently now i'm not writing it now so i just have to be okay with it can we still talk about it yeah we can talk about it it's called jello girls yeah it's about your life as an jello heiress yep yeah you're like well and jello is another american institution plastic surgery pornography jello these are great american institutions in that order in that order Exactly. The greatest exports. So talk to me about the jello curse.
29:14What is the jello curse? Well, in the book, it's sort of framed and my mom did believe in this as this sort of amorphous curse that impacted the women in her family. In the book, I sort of say like, but maybe the curse is just patriarchy um because you know she did have this idea of it but it felt very vague and it wasn't until I read I think in like an Adrienne Rich book where she defines patriarchy as this sort of invisible force that um has its fingers and everything and affects us all uh to varying degrees that I felt like oh okay this makes sense to me that's what my mother was describing but what the literally what she was describing was the fact that women in your family had benefited from this jello money but then had a string of bad husbands got sick what was the well it was actually presented to my mother as a kid as this uh curse that befell the men in the family there was a lot there were several suicides there was a lot of alcoholism and just like general misery um as oftentimes a comp a company's great wealth um great great wealth also i want to add i i believe your ancestor your grandfather your great grandfather it was my great great uncle by marriage okay still counts yeah bought the patent for jello for 450 yes from its inventor from its inventor yes which is like how manhattan was bought with like 15 bucks and a few shells or something you know i mean it's one of those it's a it's a striking oil it is just sort of stumbling upon this epic thing yes and he struggled to market the product and then sort of found it's his niche in traveling salesmen taking the product around to women at home and selling it to them as this sort of convenience food item that really took hold especially like during world war ii as like a food stretcher so you could like you know put some leftovers in jello and make a bigger meal out of it because it literally like expands um and you know those salads that you see where food is sort of floating in there it disguises like more volume less food yeah interesting oh my god jello also had a moment like 10 years ago where it like came back everywhere as a diet food as it no but like in like fine dining or like in like oh yeah restaurants like a dessert like i've seen i I see a lot of like these cube shots in jail, like a jello shot.
31:50That's like, and do you get paid every time I eat one of those? No, no. So my great, great, great uncle by marriage, order Francis Woodward sold jello in the twenties to craft. I forget for how much, because it's been a long time since I researched and wrote that book, but like, yeah. So that was sort of the end of like my like extended family's ties to it. But the marketing of Jell-O was this liberatory product. I mean, it has been. Yes, it's changed. Like, it's literally so malleable that – and as a, you know, marketing tool, it's like, yeah, it was a food stretcher in the 40s. And then it was like a diet food in the 50s.
32:32Sure. It was like cool, like, convenience product that helped housewives make fun stuff easier. And then – And now it's for a colonoscopy prep. Exactly. Now, yeah, now it's to give your dog pills. The Cosby moment. That's right. The Cosby moment. That was not Jell-O's best moment, I would say. No, definitely not. Yeah. So it's had many lives. Would Cosby put the drugs in the Jell-O and feed it to other people, or he just liked Jell-O? No, I think he was the spokesperson for Jell-O. He was the spokesperson for Jell-O. He sold Jell-O pudding pops primarily, I think, to kids. I've never had Jell-O.
Read the full transcript
33:10It freaks me out. There's also gelatin in it. It's a poor product. So it's not kosher. Or it's an exclusionary jello. Not all jellots in his pork. It could be from beef hoops as well. Well, probably not anymore. They've probably found a synthetic thing to make it stick together. And there's also a jello that is like seaweed based. Yeah. That good, good kosher jello. What is a more American, maybe like Frosted Flakes or I'm trying to think of like the truly American foods, a Twinkie. Yeah. Hot dogs. Hot dogs. The Big Mac. A Big Mac. Yeah. But in terms of like a pantry staple, I don't know if you do better than Jell-O.
33:47Yeah, it was metaphorically rich. Subject to write about. I think the best Jell-O product out there is the Magnolia's banana, the vanilla wafer banana pudding. She uses vanilla flavored Jell-O, the Jell-O pudding. Okay. We haven't even talked about pudding. Thank you for asking the tough questions. And the Jell-O pudding is amazing. I used to eat a lot of it in college as like a diet food, like the sugar-free Jell-O pudding. Oh, that's a fulsome dessert, I would say. That was the original Skinny Cow ice cream bar. Yeah. It was like 60 calories full of chemicals. Oh, yeah. It's not a Maha food.
34:32Not a Maha food. Can we go back to the book for a second? Yes, please, please. Yeah, you're like, enough Jell-O. But just to close the loop on the Jell-O curse, the Jell-O curse is patriarchy. Yeah. Oh, in my telling of it, yes. Okay. The Jell-O curse is patriarchy and porn is the female friends we made along the way. So I just moved back to New York from L.A. Oh. And I was in L.A. for a long time and I was just getting grossed out by L.A. Yeah. And there's a paragraph here that made me so happy that I left L.A. Because you just captured, like, that ick that I felt. Would you like to read it? There's a lot of – you're very good at, like, the gloopy physical ick factor.
35:17Oh, thank you. Do you remember this paragraph? Do you like this paragraph? Yes, I do. I was like, oh, this is, like, my favorite paragraph. I like this paragraph, too. And I'll also say, like, I think not being from L.A. has been really helpful to me when it comes to writing about it. because it's like, you know, I didn't go to LA until maybe my early 20s when I moved there for grad school. You were a little sheltered. Yeah, I mean, yeah, I grew up in rural New Hampshire. Oh, wow. So, yeah, de facto sheltered, and I was an only child, so. But you have to be an outsider, I feel, to be able to observe it like that.
35:49I think so, too. Because people who grew up in LA, they're like, yeah, no, no, this is gross. This is just LA. Yeah, totally. It is, I think, with an outsider's eye that I come to the city and I had never, and I've lived there on and off for maybe 15 years now, but I've never felt fully at home there. Like I just know very, even as I love it and some parts of it, I just feel like, oh, I'm not from here. Yeah. I know that intrinsically. Yeah. Yeah. Okay, here we go. Sherman Way on a Monday at the start of a new year. Delinquents and dilettantes, weirdos scattered on every block wearing hats and polyester suits and suspenders and work boots.
36:31Cherry Lynn in a mini dress though it was winter and cold. She drove a white Mustang with a top down and the heat cranked up, Jude shivering in the passenger seat regardless. To an office in a small two-story complex painted white but stained with exhaust and mold that made Jude think of her mascara when she cried, sad streaks. A sign out front said global talent in big letters above a painting of a blue and green world which made Jude wonder about Winnie's writing. Could a talent agency help with that? It's so good. It has everything. It has like the spookiness of LA's so haunted. Brought me to tears.
37:12So good. It is so good and it's also like oh they're a talent agency. Maybe they'll help with her novel like you see those signs everywhere and the globe like i could see it i'm like if or like you know headshots free headshots you're like what's your grind what are you doing with these three shots yes like maybe you'll make it that place is based on um world modeling which is no longer but was a very famous adult talent agency in i guess in sherman oaks um somewhere in the valley uh presided over by Jim South, who was also very famous. And the character of Tom Best is based off of him. Oh, cool.
37:53Oh, interesting. If you look him up, you get a picture. Just to give you a sense of the hierarchies in this book, Playboy is like the snooty magazine. Yes. And Hugh Hefner is like this buttoned-up conservative. Yeah. Is that how he was seen back then? Because you couldn't do porn and be in Playboy. Was that right? That was true at the time. He had a bit of a, you know, he very vocally said that what he was doing was art and he was very you know sure to make sure that nobody thought that playboy was pornography and i think like actually just um two nights ago i was at a screening of star 80 hosted by the whitney review and my friend christine brachet um star 80 being the dorothy stratton biopic and dorothy stratton being a famous playboy playmate who was murdered horrifically, raped and murdered by her abusive ex-husband.
38:45And yeah, we screened the film and Hefner is in it, portrayed as this snob who, you know, saw Playboy's art. And this is true. And I think, you know, one of the questions I got afterward pertaining to this book and to Dorothy was, is it possible to do pornography and then break out, you know, and go into mainstream work the straight world the straight world and i think like with playboy if it's possible it's most possible with playboy like pamela anderson even someone like dorothy stratton like um it feels more okay to us culturally to pose for playboy and then go on to do other stuff right and of course like there's so many amazing writers hunter s thompson charles wukowski were all writing for Playboy.
39:36That's right. Yeah. It has that legacy of, I mean, people joke like, oh, who reads Playboy for the articles? But it's like people did back then. And now, you know, it's coming back. So. My friend Magdalena Taylor is an editor at Playboy. She has gone viral. Oh, really? At Playboy? She's fabulous. She just went viral for a piece that she had in the New York Times that said, I forget what the original headline is. It was like, actually loving men is great and it was kind of like hetero optimism piece it's like you actually don't have to be so down about liking men you don't have to do you feel like there's like kind of a new puritanism afoot I guess is my question around like you know being a man hater or just sort of thinking that when maybe women are being victimized there's like a puritanism about that you mean like it's puritanical to look at men as all bad or something I wonder yeah I mean I don't know about the puritanism but I do think that there is this trend of being just like men are the problem men suck we hate men all men do better all that stuff and I just I don't see what the point is or what like we actually think is going to be resolved by that um because shaming people online and grouping them into you know large groups and then pointing the finger at them and telling them they're the problem doesn't really get us where we want to go.
40:57I don't think it elicits in men the response that we're hoping for. I think men love it. I think men love people. You're so bad. You're horrible. Tell me more. There's probably that part too. In the porn world, what is, what do they make of amateur porn? And by amateur porn, I mean the reality porn that probably isn't reality, like casting couch stuff and stuff like that. Yeah. Youth is like a big, barely legal. The book, the first line of the book is June is 18 only just. So I think like what Dan's getting at is like you don't really want a veteran porn star. That's not what's sought after. Is that what you're saying?
41:35Well, there was a paragraph. There's something that Sherry says. Am I pronouncing it right? Sherry. Sherry. That Sherry says when they see this, there's a girl who does her first anal scene and she's just like quiet throughout the whole thing. And she's like, she doesn't have it. You have to act like you want it basically. You have to want it. You have to want it. Yeah. And I was thinking, I was like, that's kind of the opposite of what the trend is now. Like, I feel like there's a lot of porn out there that's like the girl who's like, I don't think I want to do it. And the guy's like, you know, come on, do it.
42:07Like the demurring minx, maybe. And then it's like she does it and like, or she's in pain. And like there's this like trend of, when did that happen? The pendulum swing of like, the girl looks like, has to look like she's enjoying the sex. and then the girl has to be like choked out and look like she's hating, hating life. I would say just in a very general sense that that is like an internet intervention. But I think it probably started a little bit. And this sort of idea of gonzo and amateur porn started with like Girls Gone Wild era, like in the 90s. Yes. And probably started, you know, like a little bit before then in the 80s.
42:45And gonzo meaning we're going to go on the street and you're no, like, take a regular girl and she's going to flash us. Yeah. The idea that barely legal still reigns supreme is not true. Like, MILF is the most popular category. Really? Yes. Wow. By a long stretch. Get out. Yeah. And, you know, I asked this writer, Noelle Perdue, what she made of that. She's a porn historian and just an incredible thinker. and she was saying like it has to do with a crisis of masculinity and men wanting a strong leader to sort of show them the ropes and explain sex to them. Like Angela Merkel. Yeah. I'm sure there's Angela Merkel porn.
43:24Maggie Thatcher or something. They just want a strong female leader. I love that. But that's very closely connected to what you were saying in that women kind of have too much now and they have a lot of the power and men feel powerless and so this kind of... This like is exploiting. It's like they're being taken care of yeah or they you know they like that you know that's fine that's so interesting like a mature woman is kind of what's what's in vogue yeah and when i spoke to mark spiegler about that he was saying like you know a woman at 40 really is self-possessed and knows what she'll do and what she won't like as a performer as a professional there's a lot of agency that comes with age and it's cool that the industry is honoring that yeah that's true in life too yeah definitely the book is coming at a moment where there's a lot of depictions of uh people doing porn soft core hardcore in pop culture you have that show margot's got money troubles about based on a novel oh really el fanning plays this single mom who turns to camming yep to make money you have the new season of euphoria where the sort of centerpiece is cassie uh becoming an OnlyFans star and you know she just so she wants adoration from as many people as possible and she's sort of willing to do anything to get that.
44:43Why do you feel like we're in a moment where we're not only obsessed with watching porn which I'm sure is being consumed to the tune of you know billions of hours a year but the psyche of the person who decides to make it? I mean I would don't know but I feel like the internet has sort of reached this nexus point where like there's so we're so image focused we're so image based like we have gotten to this place where like sex work is normalized in as much as like only fans is a huge cultural machine so it makes sense to me that like there's a curiosity of what's going on behind the scenes like i mean i think that's always true like i'm always interested in what's going on behind the scenes but like especially now because it we're so saturated with images and we're so saturated with sex that it's like the only thing left is the psyche yeah one of the reasons that it's hard to go from porn to like straight the straight world and straight work is because like people have already seen you in your most unguarded like intimate moments ostensibly so like what why else would we watch kind of that's sort of a nihilistic way to look at it but it's like there is so much more there is that like inner subjectivity that's what's compelling now especially when there's like so much artifice to everything would you say that kim kardashian though was the first person who kind of bucked that trend because like that sex tape made her it like gave her a jump into the kingdom yeah but i mean paris hilton too right yes paris hilton too But maybe so I guess maybe if you're going into reality, it can possibly help, but not in scripted.
46:27Well, it's a great story arc to be like my name and likeness was released without my consent. And now I will weaponize my name and likeness to take over the world. Right. Right. Especially when it was like, you know, quite possibly a very intentional move. Right. Yeah. Well, there's a lot of debate there. Yeah. Did she release it on purpose? Where do you come down? I don't know. I mean, I'm not like completely abreast of it, but I would say probably. Yeah. But then why did she know that it would work positively when there's all this evidence that... I mean, I'm sure there's just like you described the nameless porn stars.
47:02I'm sure there's a lot of women who had tapes released thinking it would... Well, actually, I don't know. Thinking it would take them to superstardom and it didn't. Right. I don't know. I don't know. I might put out a jerk-off video of myself and see what that does for my career. That would be good. Give it a try. Give it a try. Why not? Okay, so in addition to the genre of Margot's Got Money Troubles and Euphoria, which sort of depicts behind the scenes but also the content of making this pornography, you also have the romanticcy, which you described, and these shows that women are obsessed with, like Bridgerton, which is sort of like a sexy historical drama or heated rivalry which is uh what's the food for joshi i think that's the japanese term for women who are obsessed with men who are in gay relationships oh so i haven't heard that yeah it's like when a woman is obsessed with like gay guys um it's like you're making the kendall's kiss that was the cover of the new york magazine story about it uh but I'm curious what you think of like this narrative soft core flood I think that we're seeing to me that feels like the pendulum swing from like the absence of sex that was sort of like headline worthy in the early 2020s like oh Gen Z isn't into sex and they're very puritanical and they don't want to see sex and trigger warnings for everything and all that stuff it's like well at some point you know people want to see sex and romance i think and and so that you know that's just like human nature that's the pendulum swing yeah i feel like it's so funny when when when we go away from sex and it's like you know it's going to come back right so it's like who's going to bring it back right it is the most lindy thing yeah in the world it's like built into to the body yeah and so much of it is like what's going on culturally what's going on globally like are we stressed like you know like early 2020s like it was a stressful time not that it's not stressful now but it's like you know it makes sense that people were feeling oversaturated by sex or whatever or like instagram like reached its apex and then people were like no more like i'm sick of images like i'm sick of sex everywhere i go every post that kind of stuff well that's think sex is so much more accessible now right it's everywhere it's tough you know it's like as a writer it's interesting like yes the romantic genre is having such a big moment and like there's a lot of sex in those books probably more so maybe than even in lovers but like lovers because it's overtly about pornography even in like an given like an elevated treatment it's going to be a tougher sell for some people like it's it's just never going to be probably as popular as a book like that because it's looking carefully at the subject matter instead of just replicating it yeah it's not like let me take you into this fantasy universe it's like let me force you to look at exactly what you're looking at and a lot i've seen like a lot of goodreads reviews for it just be like this is a deeply difficult book like this is not going to be for everyone which is true.
50:18I would never write a book that I think should be for everyone. But like, even though I said like anyone who wants to read it should read it, but it's not for everyone. Like not everyone's going to like it and that's on purpose. Look, I think the reason why some people might shy away from it is exactly why I loved it. I'm kind of fascinated by this book because I've never read something where I feel like turned on in like a porny way, but also I'm like intellectually stimulated. it yeah like it's i don't think i've ever read anything like it so i really really love it and i i hope that people who think they might want to not want to read about a book about porn think twice it's just a whole world i didn't even know about too it's like yeah video vixens and like when these women were on top of the world but really were they yeah yeah well it's to me it's always like if you want to understand the present you look to the past and that's kind of why one of the reasons I started this book it's just like okay well like how do I understand where we are currently in terms of desire in terms of sex and how it's sold like let me let me go back to like the one of the big technological revolutions that changed how porn was distributed and made from film to tape yep and then it went tape to digital yep and then to dvd dvd to internet were you predicting the rise of looks maxing in aesthetica i mean looks maxing was already a thing when i was writing aesthetica there are references to looks maxing in aesthetica but it's just it's just having a moment right now but it's been around yeah you know like men have been doing all sorts of crazy stuff i've been mewing since the 80s you've been mewing since the 80s yeah well part of me just thinks like looks maxers and that whole world it's just like yeah well like this is a woman's game you know what i mean like don't even try and compete when it comes to being self-conscious about your looks and ascending they're they're doing it though they are and they're bringing the masculine verve to it like they're doing it in a sort of like optimizing efficient way that's so aggressive when they're hammering their faces exactly well women want women are just like want to be done behind the scenes maybe and then they're just like you know oh, I just wear sunscreen.
52:28I just keep out of the sun. Like that's like part of the line. Oh, my gods are like, I bang my face with a hammer. And women are like, I go to the plastic surgeon and he breaks my jaw. Yeah, with a hammer. Exactly. It's much more civilized. I know it's really dark. Where does something like Love Island or like a reality show where the whole point is watching people sort of fight and hook up in bathing suits. Where does that fit in? in the Ali Rowbottom's taxonomy of adult imagery and pornography. Oh, that's so interesting. You know, I don't think I've really watched Love Island, like maybe once or twice.
53:05Oh, wow. Enough to get the sense of it. I mean, I think it's the same as any of this. It's performing the self and performing like a personal brand a lot of the time. Like I would imagine with Love Island, like The Bachelor, like there's this ulterior motive of fame and notoriety just from going on a show like that. It's not really about looking for love. So I don't know. I mean, I think that thirst to be seen and to be someone and in many ways to self-objectify and sort of try to get something out of it, that feels on brand for me. Allie Rowbottom, thank you for coming on Second Thought. Yeah, you're so welcome.
53:48Thanks for listening to this episode of Second Thought. If you're listening on Apple or Spotify,
From the publisher
Is porn empowering? Is it a scourge? And either way: Was it better in the ’80s?
In this episode, Suzy Weiss and Dan Ahdoot sit down with writer Allie Rowbottom to dig into her new novel, Lovers XXX, set in the cocaine-fueled “golden age” of Los Angeles’ adult film industry. They discuss the evolution of pornography from VHS tapes to OnlyFans and why feminists remain deeply divided over whether porn liberates women or exploits them.
Plus: the dark side of Los Angeles, the differences between East and West Coast strip clubs, and the enduring American greatness of Jell-O.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
