

2 Oct 2026 · 49m · 22 chapters

The hosts debate Taylor Swift’s “Encore Edition” (four new songs: “Patient Zero,” “Babylon,” “Pink Clouding,” “Cleveland!”), arguing the tracks are catchy but possibly “mid,” while her larger “total work of art” persona keeps evolving. They also cover: Waymo driverless cars entering public spaces (e.g., a Denver farmer’s market), Portland’s Dignity Village homeless community, and a Massachusetts lesbian bar (“The Last Ditch”) that dropped KN95 requirements and collapsed amid controversy. They add pop-culture chatter about Sydney Sweeney possibly converting to Judaism and Barbie’s “Jewish Barbie” controversy.
Matthew Jordan (Harvard professor; PhD studying the history of technology). Joseph Kahn (music-video director; called in—directed Britney Spears’ “Toxic,” and said his favorites include “Wildest Dreams” and “Blank Space”).
Swift’s songwriting engine and world-building transcend “good vs bad,” but “Cleveland!” reflects increasingly suburban, performative love. Waymo regulation must adapt; cars are quiet and hard to ticket. Dignity Village may reduce state costs and self-govern, but can still develop internal conflicts. The Last Ditch failed because community buy-in for masking was too divisive.
VMAs “Patient Zero” video with Dakota Johnson; “Cleveland Heights” references; Waymo in Denver farmer’s market; Dignity Village includes communal kitchen/courtroom and love-triangle disputes; Last Ditch mask policy change; “Toxic” and other Kahn-directed Swift videos.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Hosts discuss the mixed reactions to Taylor Swift's recent music release.
“Even Britney Spears came up through these kind of Disney, you know, like, came up through the machine.”
Matthew shares insights on Taylor Swift's new songs from her latest album.
“And today, to break it all down, we bring in our resident Taylor Swift expert.”
Matthew outlines the emotional journey listeners experience with new Swift releases.
“of her latest album, Life of a Showgirl, which was not the most critically acclaimed album she's ever had, not her best era, although you could argue that she is beginning a new era with it.”
Discussion on the challenges Taylor Swift faces as a pop artist evolving her sound.
“And it's just like you famously said Taylor Swift makes good Taylor Swift music.”
Exploring how Swift's changing narrative affects her relatability with fans.
“You can make some great music in the 60s and then take a 20-year break and then release a great album in the 80s.”
Analysis of the song 'Cleveland' and its narrative structure in Swift's music.
“Zach Galifianakis was a billion times funnier.”
Hosts discuss the evolution of themes in Taylor Swift's recent music.
“of these two people at like the top of their respective craft finding each other but i'm not sure people look at Taylor Swift and think like, wow, this, she's just like me in a way that they did before.”
Discussion on the backlash Swift faces and how her older work is viewed differently now.
“which is kind of the tone of a lot of these songs.”
Explore Taylor Swift's compulsive songwriting and her struggles with self-judgment.
“I mean, it can get very, the vitriol can get very, very high.”
Discuss Taylor's cultural significance and her unique position in the music industry.
“I'm actually not, you know, Britney Spears from Louisiana.”
A live call with music video director Joseph Kahn discussing his work with Taylor Swift.
“We love Joseph Kahn and we love what he's managed to make.”
A discussion on Waymo technology and its implications for society.
“and friends not because he loves you, but because he loves feeling so loved by them.”
The hosts share humorous thoughts on transportation and the future of driverless cars.
“They should put the soap people at the end so that when the Waymos do lose control, that's what stops the Waymo.”
The hosts introduce their guest Matthew Jordan and express their excitement for his presence.
“We're going to try and keep the energy up even though Matthew has left us.”
The hosts discuss rumors surrounding Sydney Sweeney's potential conversion to Judaism.
“She was photographed with her boyfriend, the music executive, Scooter Braun, attending Rosh Hashanah services at Temple Shalom in old Greenwich, Connecticut.”
A discussion about the controversy surrounding a Jewish Barbie doll's design.
“And they did come out with a Jewish Barbie.”
The hosts share humorous anecdotes about their own bat mitzvah themes.
“What do you think her butt mitzvah theme will be?”
The hosts discuss the self-governed community Dignity Village and its implications for homelessness.
“This I would file under unpopular culture because people might not know about it.”
The hosts discuss the challenges faced by a lesbian bar in Greenfield, Massachusetts.
“Can you tell me about the last-ditch bar in Greenfield, Massachusetts?”
Explore the lively atmosphere and expectations at a popular gay bar.
“To be clear, Marie's Crisis is like the greatest bar in the world.”
A candid discussion about Madonna's career and the pressures of aging in the spotlight.
“talked about we talked a lot about taylor swift and her sort of uh the anthology the world the world of Taylor Swift.”
Delve into the artistic contributions of influential figures like Monet and their lasting impact.
“I was gonna say, Michael Jackson might be the only person who every one of his albums is as good as the last one, like Taylor Swift, and has a couple duds, but not really.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Second Thought, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:01Fall never arrives all at once. First the air, then the light, and slowly the things you love begin to find each other. A jacket meets a dress, a hoodie slips beneath a blazer, an old cap finds a new scarf. Because you don't simply step into the season, you create it layer by layer until it finally feels like fall. Find fall your way at Ross.
0:30Even Britney Spears came up through these kind of Disney, you know, like, came up through the machine. We saw it. We saw Ariana Grande. We saw Sabrina Carpenter be on all of these shows and then become who they are. And Dan Adut. I mean, I was on a Disney show. I was on Kicking It and Look at Me Now.
0:48Welcome back to Second Thought, your place for hot takes on popular culture and a healthy dose of unpopular culture. I am Suzy Weiss, here with Dan Adut. Hi. Today we are going to get into Sydney Sweeney's Yenta era, a self-governing homeless community in Portland, Barbie's controversial new doll, the Waymo that drove itself into the farmer's market, and more. But first, this past weekend, ladies and gentlemen, we got a new batch of music from the queen of pop herself, Taylor Swift, and everyone is all over it, mostly tearing it apart. And today, to break it all down, we bring in our resident Taylor Swift expert.
1:26He did not write the book on Taylor Swift, but he did TA a class on it. Yeah. It was at a school outside Boston, if you've heard of it. His name is Matthew Jordan. MJ, Matthew, thank you for being here today. What an absolute thrill. Thank you for having me. I'm so glad you're here because I'm going to take a backseat to this conversation. Don't worry, honey. You just sit there and look pretty well while daddy goes to work. on route into this podcast studio, Dan said, I love Shake It Up. Yeah. Shake it up. Shake it up. Dan. That's so sweet, honey. That was really good, by the way. I'm trying. We're really proud of you.
2:04Now you know how women feel talking about anything. God, forgive me. That's the equivalent of saying I love sports ball. Yeah. That's horrible. Forgive me. I'm the diversity hire. I'm trying my best. Taylor Swift released four new songs. It's the Encore Edition, of her latest album, Life of a Showgirl, which was not the most critically acclaimed album she's ever had, not her best era, although you could argue that she is beginning a new era with it. The new songs on the Encore edition, which she is sort of known to put out these like deluxe editions, diss two, whatever, they include the song Patient Zero, Babylon, Pink Clouding, and Cleveland with an exclamation point.
2:42Absolutely. She also unveiled the music video for Patient Zero featuring Dakota Johnson at the VMAs, which we will also get into. Matthew, what were your thoughts on the encore? Oh my God, he's having a seizure. I can't, he's having a stroke. He's literally glitching. Did you let him? Baby steps, baby steps. You got this. You can start from the top. Thank you so much. Let me just say what a thrill it is to be here. Yeah, it's just a beautiful night. It's just an honor to be nominated. Matthew, start from the top, babe. Patient zero. There's a kind of Stockholm syndrome that one experiences with any new Taylor Swift release.
3:20Yeah. It starts with, who asked for this? Why are we going through this at all? No one was requesting these songs. So who is this for? It then moves into step two, which is, it's this kind of nostalgia. It's like you remember how good it once was. Right. And then you listen to these songs and you think, This doesn't hold a candle. It just doesn't. And then you see all the, you know, your memories of listening to past Taylor Swift songs in the car and, you know, in your life and in your most dear moments. And you think, how is this? Why are we doing this? Then it moves into phase three, which is now you're brushing your teeth and it's in your head.
4:01Oh, yeah. Now against your will, Cleveland, exclamation point, is just coming to you. What a crazy title. Spontaneously. Now you're thinking, what is in the heights? What is going on? Now you're on Google Maps going, what is she singing about in the Cleveland Heights? Then phase four, which is maybe three days into this experience, which is Masterpiece. And I wish it didn't work this way. I wish you could simply critically evaluate this music immediately as good or bad. But the way that I feel about this is that at this point, a Taylor Swift release, it's transcended the axis of good versus bad.
4:42Yeah. And it's just like you famously said Taylor Swift makes good Taylor Swift music. Taylor Swift makes Taylor Swift music. Right. Taylor Swift has for the last 20 years been just through the power of her own personality and and pen and an acoustic guitar and a vision and a dream been creating a body of work that she is adding to. and therefore it's all neither good nor bad. It's just the latest in this contribution to culture that is the body of work of Taylor Swift. And so do I like it? Do I hate it? I don't know. Are they stuck in my head? Absolutely. From a completely dispassionate perspective, which I can't have.
5:23I'm in too deep. Are they good songs? I don't think so. But they're fine. Okay, can I give you the dispassionate tape? Yeah, please. So I'm not a huge Taylor Swift head. I enjoy her music. You know what they're called. I thought that shake it up was shake it off. Okay. Am I still doing it wrong? You got it backwards, but that's okay. You get what you're saying. Where I think the issue is, is I think pop stars are never supposed to change. They're supposed to just give you the same shit over and over. Did you see Madonna opening the VMAs? That's a real gerontocracy. But okay. They need to haul her ass away.
5:59It was elder abuse. But she was like doing what she does. She was doing Madonna. She was doing Madonna. Everybody got up and dance. Yeah. Taylor Swift is trying to do something different and everyone freaks out because they're like, no, we know you for the breakup songs. And so I guess it's like it's very hard to evolve as a pop star. I think that's very true. And also pop stars are held to standards that no one can match when we look at other artists who we venerate. So like the great artists currently living who are old and whose careers are storied and whatever. Bob Dylan, Paul McCartney, Billy Joel.
6:34These are not people who ever had like a 20-year run of great music, right? You can have a seven-year run of great music. You can make some great music in the 60s and then take a 20-year break and then release a great album in the 80s. And yet, you know, and that's okay. You know, you can still be Bob Dylan and do that. Taylor Swift has been building this body of work. And by the way, the body of work is not just the music. It's her entire life. May I drop a pretentious academic term? Do it. Gestamp kunstwerk. That is a German term. They're not coming for you, I promise. Show me your papers. It means total work of art.
7:11It means the idea that - Like the gestalt of the work of art. The full thing is the work of art. It's a term from the Bauhaus. But it means that the art is not just the music. The art is the fashion, the persona, the cover art, the world building, the relationships. She's created this entire universe and has built it over two decades. It does evolve. And even when the music is bad, the kind of narrative can still be good. It's like you can still get married to the football star. That is part of the art of like the life of Taylor Swift. And the music, you know, can ebb and flow. Sometimes the music is extraordinary and the narrative is very controversial as it was during the, let's say, 1989 era.
7:50Now it's like very, it's very narratively satisfying. She gets to cheerlead her husband and show her ring from the box with Tom Cruise at the football games. It's wonderful. And the music is kind of on autopilot, maybe a little bit. Well, that's, I think, a really good point. Because as much as she has had these different eras and she's sort of done pure country, more pop, whatever era you're in, it's always about love. It's always about, I'm like, you know, so down bad. I have this crush on this guy. Oh, my God, we're together. wait there's something wrong he broke my heart now I'm gonna get back from him pettiness revenge falling in love all of these are kind of you're always gonna find that note but I think what people are asking now is can you make great art can Taylor Swift make good Taylor Swift music if she's just simply in love you know she can't like oh you think no this is the equivalent of like when a fat comedian loses weight and they're like can you still be funny it's like no No, because that was his thing.
8:53Zach Galifianakis was a billion times funnier. He's skinny now. He has a plant show on Netflix. Between Two Ferns? No. Oh. That was his fast show. That was amazing. His skinny show is literally him planting a garden. So I think there is that thing of like, she has sharpened this knife on sort of heartbreak. And revenge and vengeance. And there is something to, you know, this is a new thing she's doing. Right? I mean, correct me if I'm wrong. Being simply in love. Yeah. Why don't you break down Cleveland for us? Because I think that's the most like there's lines like the whole point, like all you need to do is find someone who doesn't find you completely insufferable.
9:28And I found mine. Yeah. And like hate all you want. I found my man. And he showed me Cleveland. To be fair, I dated a boy in Cleveland. Her last lovers were London. Absolutely. They were in L.A. They were Cleveland. A little tough to write about. I mean, how many times are you going to go to the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame? But her. Like how many times you go to Chagrin Falls. You go to the original Jenny's Ice Cream. wow, this started here? You're out of stuff to talk about about Cleveland. You got popcorn at the fucking waterfall. LeBron James, there's probably LeBron James. He's there somewhere.
9:58He's actually a South Beach. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Stephanie Burt, who wrote, who was a literary scholar, talks about how Taylor Swift's success is due in part to the fact that she is both aspirational and relatable. She is on this journey of ascension through fame from her teenage years, but remains this relatability, because she's not cool. she does she holds these grudges she never pretends she's not an insider she has this kind of um populist appeal very populist appeal um so aspiration and relatable and i think that what has happened in the last few years is that she has ceased to be either she's like she's maybe too much of a billionaire she relatable not really she kind of achieved this high school dream of like marrying the guy on the football team which he did like at the highest level you know in terms of these two people at like the top of their respective craft finding each other but i'm not sure people look at Taylor Swift and think like, wow, this, she's just like me in a way that they did before.
10:53And I think the song Cleveland is an example of this like attempt to go back to this like hyper relatability, namely like we are driving through the suburbs. Taylor Swift has become increasingly suburban. In 2014, it was welcome to New York. And now it's, you know, in 2019, it was London boy. And now it's Cleveland exclamation mark, you know? So it's becoming increasingly it's about to be albuquerque and you know there's these like cute clips of her and travis driving through but it's like i think people can see through the thing that it's like this is a kind of performance of like suburban love right you know you had like a you had a police escort yeah like what are the vehicles around this one that you're not you know that you're not showing us um in these clips but i mean the song itself is just like you know my baby took me to Cleveland, you know?
11:42My baby likes what he likes and he likes me. And I think that Taylor has moved in these more recent songs less to this mode of song that's about what she loves in the other person and their qualities. We don't really know any of Travis's qualities aside from the fact that he has a very large penis as explicated in the song would and that he likes playing video games with his friends in the song So High School. That's kind of it. Her previous songs were really like painting a picture of these people. Travis, he's kind of, you know, like a - It's like the specter. Yeah, the specter, he's like - Maybe he's not, he's a fucking jock.
12:17Like what do you expect? Yeah, I know exactly. Like read poetry on the weekends, he plays video games and has a big dick. That's like - That's the thing. That's the job description. That's exactly right. So it's shifted to this like, not here's what I like about him, but here's how he makes me feel loved, which is kind of the tone of a lot of these songs. How good does it feel to be accepted? How good does it feel to be dating someone who makes Cleveland Heights, you know, feel magical? Romantic, yeah. And it's like not, it's not obvious to me that those messages like resonate in the same way.
12:45I mean, it's just rage sells more than just like tranquility. Yeah, like winning is boring. Yeah. But also like, to your point, like the earlier songs, I know she doesn't like, it's called the paternity testing when you try and figure out which song is about what, about who. But All Too Well, the 10 minute version about Jake Gyllenhaal, where it's just like dagger upon dagger. Call me up again just to break me like a promise. So casually cruel in the name of being honest. It's like, whoa. You know what I mean? It's like, you know that. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Speak on it. I'm a crumpled up piece of paper lying here because I remember it all too well.
13:20Exactly. And it's like this batch of four songs. Yeah. What's it called? Nostalgia as a weapon to hurt yourself. Okay. The self-harm of never being where you are. That doesn't really track. You know what I mean? Like she has these things that are designed to take the same place of these previous one-liners that cut so deep. And it just feels a little dull. And I think for that reason, the fairest assessment is that these are just like okay pop songs. You know? Yeah. Like some are kind of good, catchy. Are any of them in the pantheon? Absolutely not. The thing that's weird is like the amount of like flaming, roasting, like Taylor Swift is...
14:02I mean, it can get very, the vitriol can get very, very high. No, of course. There's also a huge amount of revisionist history on her old work. When the album Reputation came out at the time, it was like widely panned. And now it's viewed, you know, in the light of history as like some kind of masterpiece. So, you know, the same thing could happen here. That's not, I don't think it will with these particular songs. But it's also, I think there's something good about being able to just like publicly evolve. she cannot help but create right yeah and so she is just like whether it's good or bad she is going to make music and going to make art tell us about her process what do we know about like how she how she writes music taylor swift is burdened by the need to turn everything into music and has been since she was a teenager and so she is just like a compulsive songwriter she writes a lot of these songs very very quickly um but it's like constant constant constant she has these notepads and she talks about how different songs are written with different types of pen, metaphorically, the real pen and the glitter gel pen.
15:04She thinks of herself as a writer when she announced her marriage to Travis Kelsey. It was your gym teacher and your English teacher were getting married. She said if she wasn't a singer, she would wanna be a high school English teacher. So she thinks of herself as like this literary figure. And so it's constant for her. And I think that she has always had a very poor quality filter for her own music. She doesn't even know which of her own songs are good. When she released All Too Well, she learned it was a good song by performing it at the concerts. And then the crowd sang it with such passion back to her that she was like, I guess this is a really good song.
15:45So she's very bad at choosing singles for these albums because she's like a poor judge of her own work. Which I find very interesting. Because she's compulsive about it almost. Exactly. And so she surrounds herself with these people who the fans sometimes accuse of, you know, enabling her worst instincts or not editing appropriately. She puts out these albums that are too long. But there's no question that like when Taylor Swift's pin is at its best, she is like among the greatest to have ever done this medium of writing popular music. But I think that's what happens when you're just like this engine of songwriting.
16:19If you look at like you mentioned Billy Joel before or like U2 you go to their concerts everyone's still yelling like sing piano man Totally Like first album stuff Totally It doesn't seem to me like it's like her first album is the best one and everything else is kind of denouemented It's easy to talk about like we will look back on the career of Taylor Swift in such and such way It's kind of just getting started like this is a 36 year old She hasn't had kids She hasn't had her first divorce She hasn't had her second divorce There's a lot to get through There's a lot of fodder yet to be thing And now she's pivoting Perimenopause I can't wait you know Hot Flash Taylor Swift is going to be extraordinary for the culture you know that's going to be the name of the album Hot Flash Hot Flash oh write that down yeah that's really good it's so true Red was 2012 yeah that was like an epic album and then truly 1989 2014 2014 what was 2016 there was none in 2016 2017 Reputation 2019 Lover then the two pandemic albums Folklore Evermore just like people also the fan base waxes and wanes.
17:19She falls out of favor with her own fans and then falls back into favor when she writes an album like Folklore that just like reminds people of her brilliance. I think the world changes. She changes. She can evolve with the times. As she takes in new like inputs from the world, her music changes accordingly. Right now her like inputs are Travis Kelsey. And so like that is producing these outputs, which I think are generally kind of whatever. The song she wrote for the Toy Story movie was fantastic. Oh, I haven't listened to it yet. It was honestly a really wonderful song. she kind of went back to more country type of energy.
17:50I knew it. I knew you. Really, really wonderful. She's trying to be a filmmaker. She invented an award at the VMAs in order to award her. So that they could show the patience. Well, that is part of the legacy is like the business acumen. I'm actually not, you know, Britney Spears from Louisiana. You're brushing the dirt off me and putting me on stage and into a Diet Pepsi commercial. She is the businessman. A hundred percent. And she is just like this template of kind of full stack ownership and creative control over your own art. She charted, and this is why I say it kind of transcends good versus bad.
18:23It's just like this is a totally singular figure who has charted a totally singular path into galactic superstardom on the strength of this Shakespearean level craft at the art of songwriting. and this like fierce tenacity, age 15, knocking on studio doors in Nashville to the, you know, selling and owning of her own records. She is so shrewd and like even - She's bigger than the Super Bowl. When watching the VMAs, it was like there were two VMAs going on. It was the Taylor Swift VMAs and then you brought up Sabrina Carpenter. It was Madonna, Madonna brought up her and Charlie XCX. And for a second you would think like, oh, Taylor Swift must feel so left out of like the cool girls table.
19:08And then you realize like, oh, even if Madonna invited her up, I don't even think she'd go. You know what I mean? She's actually bigger than all of this. Beyonce, Lady Gaga, Rihanna. Miley Cyrus. It's all kind of separate from Taylor Swift. And I don't know if that's like a country thing. She kind of is her own universe, I guess. It reminds me of like the world of, I don't know, startups. Competition is for losers. It's like when you become your own thing, you are no longer like playing the game of the incumbent. and I think Taylor Swift so became her own thing. She's the Uber of Taylor Swift.
19:39Yeah, that's, many are saying that. You're not the first to make that remark and that is part of her brilliance and that's why like you can't help but marvel. You can, like you cannot help, but even if the music is bad or mid or doesn't be your standard, the fact of this artist, you know, working in this way is just like something, you know, worthy of the attention that it garners because this is just a kind of larger-than-life figure of our time. I want to get you on the record for a few things. I'm ready. MJ. Let's hear it. What do you think this next era will be about, and do you think it will end in a divorce album?
20:16Well, it sounds like she is very invested in becoming a filmmaker. She's directed many of her own music videos. The All Too Well music video, it's pretty good. I don't know. What did you think of Patient Zero? I thought it was fine. I wasn't super blown away by it. I thought it was pretty like, you know, humblebrag my buddy directs a lot of her music videos. Okay, what? Yeah, okay Speak on it. Joseph Kahn. We can have him on the pod if we want. That would be amazing. We can call him right now Should we do a call? Yeah, let's do it. Let's do a call. Let's do a call. We do love doing these on-air calls Ask him what he thinks of patients here Joseph Kahn What's up you are on the podcast second thought right now.
20:58Hi, Joseph. That's my co-host Suzy Weiss And our guest today is a professor of Taylor Swift at Harvard. How you doing? Oh, my God. Anyway, I was telling them that my friend would direct a lot of her videos, and we're talking about... Patient Zero. Patient Zero, and wanted to get your take if you wanted to give it. I think Chivo is one of the best DPs in the world, so I thought it looked really great, you know? Can I ask if you have a favorite Taylor Swift music video, period? Oh, yeah. What's your favorite one that you directed? I mean, it's a tie. It's probably between Blink Space and Wildest Dreams.
21:36Wow. Those are, those are classics. Yeah. I mean, I do like Look What You Made Me Do, too, because it's so big, you know, and pop. So, I don't know. Like, I do, I do like, I like each one of those videos for different reasons. Yeah, that's awesome. Is she good? And she's good to work with? Yeah, absolutely. Like, she's a phenomenal hard worker and super polite and very, very thankful to everybody she works with. So there's a reason I think she's so successful is because she plays all those cards extremely well. I mean, the word professional rarely ever gets placed with artists these days because you don't really think of it that way.
22:11But she is a true professional. Amazing. Joe Kahn. Amazing. Thank you for your contribution. Thank you, Joseph. Good talking to you. We love you. Thank you. Thanks, guys. Take care. Bye. Joseph Kahn. We love Joseph Kahn and we love what he's managed to make. That was amazing. How'd you meet him? We worked on a project together. You were on one of the animatronic horses in the Wildest Dreams music video? I would just bring him his matcha. That's awesome. Do you have one of the songs from Encore that's especially stuck in your head? Pink Clouding is a kind of sequel to the song Getaway Car. And I find that chorus like undeniable.
22:48What's the chorus? And extremely, I was pink, boom, clouding through the middle of it. uh, uh, uh. That's some classic Swedish Max Martin, Shellback, like just, just the words don't even matter. That's just earworm, melodic, rhythmic, you know, stripped down to perfection. That's been coming back to me a lot. People seem to like it. I think it's, I think it's fine. And I do feel when I listened to Patient Zero that some of the motifs of the men described in that song, I was read to filth, as they say, by some of the, you know, I bet he charmed your parents, and friends not because he loves you, but because he loves feeling so loved by them.
23:27Didn't Max Martin produce Britney? Yeah, absolutely. I mean, Max Martin came out of the gate with, Oh, no, no. If you tell us something about Britney Spears. Joseph Kahn directed Toxic. Oh, wow. So this guy. Why'd you hang up? He directed the Toxic music. Because here's the thing. As we all know, Taylor Swift, her thing is songwriting. That's what she's really good for, in addition to the world building and all this stuff. She's not the greatest singer in the world. she's not the greatest dancer in the world. Britney Spears was an unbelievable dancer, especially in the Toxic Music video. Unbelievable performer.
23:59Unbelievable performers, right. Well, that's an interesting thing because even Britney Spears came up through these kind of Disney, came up through the machine, right? Justin Timberlake, all this kind of thing. I think it's like, it never ceases to amaze just how self-made Taylor Swift was relative to so many of these people. It's true. You look more into their biographies. Not even their biographies. We saw it. We saw Ariana Grande. We saw Sabrina Carpenter be on all of these shows and then become who they are. And Dana Dude. I mean, I was on a Disney show. I was on Kicking It and Look at Me Now.
24:35Fall never arrives all at once. First the air, then the light. And slowly the things you love begin to find each other. A jacket meets a dress. A hoodie slips beneath a blazer. An old cap finds a new scarf. because you don't simply step into the season. You create it layer by layer until it finally feels like fall. Find fall your way at Ross.
25:06Let's talk for a second because the viewer might think at this point that you are in fact only committed to Taylor Swift, but you actually have, let's not call it a day job. What would you call it? I mean, it's an activity. I'm participating in. I'm doing a PhD. I study the history of technology. Speaking of technology and being in the history of it. Absolutely. There are Waymos taking over this country. Let's talk about it. Let's get into it. Why do you do that? Why do you do that? Let's get into Waymos. These goddamn Waymos are taking over this country. And obviously, they're very big in the Bay Area.
25:41Are they in LA yet? They are in LA. They're about to come to New York. I've seen a couple of them in the streets. Really? Yeah. Okay, well, one drove through the farmer's market. Where was this? Where did this happen? Oh, Denver. The Denver farmer's market. And it was sort of obviously like this bizarre spectacle of this driverless car going like sort of very gently going through the farmer's market like, oh, right this way. But he was like going through the stalls. He it. But it's also this legal gray area because there's no driver to ticket. And I don't know if you can ticket like the Waymo Corporation.
26:12And even if you could, it's like$25. It's like, well, I mean, the scale is so different. So I was curious, Matthew, if a Waymo drives through a farmer's market but no driver was there to ticket it, does it even make a sound? Waymos are remarkably quiet. Are they? Waymos are— I've never been in one. Oh, Susie. Yeah, they're great. You've got to go ride a Waymo. They're awesome. It's really magical. Waymos are remarkably quiet, and you just feel like you're in the future in a really amazing way. What I do think is interesting about this is there is like a full court press in the kind of regulation of these new set of technologies, right?
26:47And this is true of every technological revolution that has ever happened when the train and the horse-drawn carriage and the automobile and the internet, any mass-scale transformative technology. So what's going to have to happen is that our norms and our laws, regulation, insurance is a huge one, are all going to have to adapt to this new technology. But this kind of thing, as a historian, has happened every single time. The horse-drawn carriage. Who's at fault? The horse? The horse breeder? No, they had to ask these very similar kinds of questions. Oh, that's so interesting. The car is very different because the car is very different than the train.
27:22The train has one conductor and a thousand passengers. The car has, there are millions of cars, each of which have few. So the whole regulatory regime is like decentralized. It's totally decentralized. The Waymo is an interesting case because we've kept the decentralization of the number of automobiles, but we've changed the owner to now go back to this like train streetcar version where there's only one owner. Can I say, though, there are some people that I wish did get mowed over in that farmer's market. Anyone at the farmer's market, if you're not selling food, you don't belong there. Wait, okay.
27:56If you're selling soap. Way more important conversation. Shut up. If you're selling soap at the farmer's market, you deserve to get run. They should put the soap people at the end so that when the Waymos do lose control, that's what stops the Waymo. You think only food. Only food. I like the people who sell candles. Fuck them. I like an essential oil, perhaps. So you're saying sometimes they do like ponchos, like a thick woolen poncho. You've decided to design jewelry and now you think you can be next to the radicchio. Who are you? It's ridiculous. There's nothing seasonal about your dumb earrings.
28:30Okay. So you think there should be like a seasonality metric. But honestly, like there's always like a goat milk station. No one's going there. No, that's okay. That's okay. Okay. That's part of it. So food, it's food. Like there's frozen duck. It's a farmer's market. It should be something that a farmer makes. A farm. A farmer's market. It's not a market. It's a farmer's market. Farmer's market. Right. I think that's what the Waymo was complaining. The Waymo and I. Were you controlling the Waymo? Yeah, I was like, meh. Yeah. Remote control. Unless it was an Islamist Waymo, and it was actually doing a terrorist attack.
29:01It was a jihadi Waymo. Unless it was a sleeper cell. Any last words on Waymo? Humans driving cars will never truly go away, but it might go the way of the vinyl in the sense that it's kind of an old-timey way to travel. but yet we still have trains you know like we still have the streetcar many modes of transit can overlap and sit on top of each other at the same time um i'm very interested for the world that we rebuild for the driverless car yeah driving cars will be just like a thing that signals that you are an annoying date like vinyl right it's like yeah i just i grind my own beans for the coffee it's like we get it we get it you drive yeah i i just like that feeling of you know the wind in my hair.
29:39Shut up, dude. Shut up, loser. Get in the way, Mo. Matthew Jordan, thank you for joining us on Second Thought. What a thrill to have you. The best. This has been an absolute pleasure. Thank you. Oh, my God. We love you. Thank you for being here. Okay, wow. We're going to try and keep the energy up even though Matthew has left us. Oh, my God. He's really such a fabulous guest and we thank him. I feel like I need methadone for when he leaves. This is like cold turkey. I know. I know. It's literally like a speedball. But we have so many good stories to talk about. First on the docket is Sydney Sweeney.
30:18Our girl. Sparking rumors. We really could have a Sydney Sweeney segment every week because there's something always going on. Yeah. And this week, it's that she may, in fact, be converting to Judaism. She was photographed with her boyfriend, the music executive, Scooter Braun, attending Rosh Hashanah services at Temple Shalom in old Greenwich, Connecticut. Dan, here's what I might take. We need this. We absolutely do. We need a win, brother. We need this big time. We need this so bad. I think this will change the whole anti-Semitism conversation. Although, I don't know. People might hate Jews more.
30:53Yeah. They might hate them more. Because we've now gotten our tentacles around her. Do you think Sydney Sweeney would make a good Jew? I think she'd make a great Jew. She's an entrepreneur. Yeah. You know, she knows how to sell, sell, sell. Yes. She's in show business. She's in show biz. She could do commercials. Yeah. I just like... It's like her coming out of the mikvah in slow motion. Right. That would be amazing. I mean, I don't know if she's going to be like a Yenta kind of Jew. I don't think she's going to be moving to Muncie anytime soon. But I think in general, this is as good a pickup since, maybe since Marilyn Monroe, maybe since Ruth.
31:35Yeah, I agree. Since Sammy Davis Jr. Oh, huge one. Typically Jews tell the converts three times not to do it. Yeah. Not to do it. You don't want to do it. Yeah, you don't want this. You don't want this. It's so crazy. Nobody wants this. Nice. I feel like in this case the rabbi is going to be like, we can get over that formality. We're good. Yeah, yeah, yeah. We need you right now. I know. It's important to play hard to get, but this would be huge. Yeah. This would be amazing. I hope that it starts a cascade of converts. Yes. We need numbers. Enough of this pushing people away. Yeah. Come join the party.
32:13Come join the party. Water's great. It's been a great year. Sydney Sweeney, if she became Jewish, would be the Jewish Barbie. Yeah. She'd be MVJ. And they did come out with a Jewish Barbie. Oh, boy. Did you see this? No. There's like a Jewish Barbie doll and people are up in arms because it has a slightly bigger nose than the other Barbie dolls. I mean, it's still absolutely gorgeous. but people are saying it's anti-Semitic. I don't think it's anti-Semitic. Our noses are not, we have bigger noses. Exactly. You don't. I don't know what the fuck happened to you. Honey, you know what happened to me, Dr.
32:42Lange in 2011. You got Dr. Lange. Yeah, what do you mean what happened to me? I'm sorry. What happened to you? I said, Jennifer Aniston, please. And then they did it. What do you mean what happened? I should have gotten Dr. Lange. It's too late for me to get Dr. Lange. Way too late. You can't be a guy in your 40s being like, look at my nose job. I had a deviated septum. No, you can't. You have to be like a teenage girl who's feeling, who just goes away for the summer, if you know what I mean. Yeah. I think it would only have been, it would have only been an anti-Semitic Barbie doll if you like pressed her Star of David and it was like, there's a sale at Neiman Marcus.
33:18Can we sit at a different table? Does this have dairy? Like, if like. I order this well done. Wait till my father hears about this. like then that would actually be maybe anti-semitic but she doesn't say anything which is a gift if it was a real jewish barbie doll she wouldn't stop talking she'd be mouthy she'd be mouthy yeah she'd have an opinion on everything she'd be a mouth breather is the mouth open on the she would have the nose tape to go to sleep that would be like the accessories that they sell you um but yeah sydney sweeney she is if she were to become jewish i nominate her as the jewish Barbie doll.
33:57What do you think her butt mitzvah theme will be? Butt mitzvah. It's going to be her ass out.
34:04Okay.
34:08Sometimes I'm quicker than I could even imagine. I think it'll be like casino theme. I like a classic. What was yours? A piano. Totally normal. That's not a theme. That is a theme. That's an instrument. No, everyone, all the tables were different notes. Like A minor? How did anyone find what they were? Yeah. Are you a C? Are you D sharp? Are you F? My friend's bat mitzvah theme was Chinese takeout. That's a great theme. That's an awesome theme. What was your theme? Mrs. Shit on everyone's theme. Everyone, pull the car over if you're listening to this in the car. Here comes Susie's theme. What was it?
34:51My dad didn't let us have themes. The theme of every bat mitzvah should be being Jewish. Okay, there you go. That was the theme. There you go. Cool. Was being stupid. Awesome communist bat mitzvah you had. There was no themes. None of us were wealthy. And you lash out at us? I know. It's because I'm jealous. I would have killed for piano. I would have killed for piano. For any of it. For candy. Piano. It would have been awesome. Pool party. Luau. I wouldn't have cared. It was a great bat mitzvah. But everyone, it was conspicuously themeless. Oh, my God. The theme of your bar mitzvah. It's the parsha.
35:33It's the toiling that we went through as a people. God damn it, Dad. Literally. Give me a piano. Yeah, come on. Come on, let's do cards. Let's do s'mores. Camp. A lot of people had camp ones. That was awesome. This is a great story. This I would file under unpopular culture because people might not know about it. This week, the New York Times reported on a self-governed community of homeless people that has gathered in Portland, Oregon. Their community is called Dignity Village and has everything from a communal kitchen, a courtroom, and inner community love triangles that they kind of had to litigate in one of their monthly meetings.
36:14Residents are required to contribute 10 hours of work per week to the commune and can only use substances in private spaces. Dan, what is your take on Dignity Village and do you think this might be a solution to the growing houselessness problem in America? Are you texting? I mean, what am I saying here? No, I'm looking up the article because there were so many great lines in it that I want to talk about. There were great lines in it. But look, it's funny because I went into this thinking, oh, this is going to be like another Chaz. Oh, yes. I thought this was Chaz 2.0. Chaz Chop. Which we all know was like ridiculous.
36:47But this is actually awesome. Oh, it's incredible. First of all, they all get along better than you think a bunch of vagabonds would get along. Yeah. Tramps. They figure out their problems. They have elders, which I'm assuming are like 26 years old. I mean, they're just doing what we all do. Most of us don't live in homeless shelters. And they're like, yeah, we don't want to live there either. We're going to do our own thing called a society. But the most important thing is that the cost for the state is like infinitely lesser than it is for like shelters and whatnot. The first line of this article, it's like Dickens.
37:27One evening a few months ago, the awkward details of a love triangle spilled out in a humble plywood structure next door to a municipal composting facility in Portland, Oregon. I love that. Dude, Pulitzer. I think it's going to work so well that in five years they're going to be like, we've got to do something about this homeless problem. in Dignity Village. They're going to have like an HOA. They're going to get, they're going to have horrible infighting about whether to divest from Israel. Like it's just going to be the same problems that we have in our communities within Dignity Village because it's like your hedges are a little tall.
38:01You know what I mean? Like they're going to get into the same problems everyone does because they're just, you know, acting normally in a way. I want everyone, if they care about this subject, and it's a very interesting subject, to listen to the podcast called Street Fight from our friends at Reflector. And it's really interesting and sort of follows the arc of how we went from sort of hobos and tramps to men who lived in flop houses in corners of the city. And then now to the problem of homeless encampments and masses of unhoused people. So it's a really good listen and I highly recommend it.
38:35Wow. When were they called Bums? That was my favorite. Yes, Bums was probably like... 90s, 80s, 90s? that was after because hobos are the ones who ran the rails yes and then bums sort of stayed still but bums kind of like stayed in like the kind of wrong side of town wrong side of the tracks yeah and they like lived in flop houses and like were alcoholics basically that's such a good word yeah bum yeah bum yeah bum yeah bum they should do another episode with Dignity Village because I'm I'm very hopeful around Dignity Village we are very big fans of DV we're very big fans of Dignity and Villages and Villages yes yes we are Fall never arrives all at once.
39:16First the air, then the light, and slowly the things you love begin to find each other. A jacket meets a dress, a hoodie slips beneath a blazer, an old cap finds a new scarf. Because you don't simply step into the season, you create it layer by layer until it finally feels like fall. Find fall your way at Ross.
39:42This episode is brought to you by Palmolive. Family time isn't just the big moments. It's weeknight dinners, sitting around the table, everyone talking all at once. So when the plates are empty and the sink is full, use Palmolive Ultra. Palmolive's most powerful formula removes up to 99.9 % of grease, leaving your dishes sparkling clean. And the new convenient pump makes cleaning even easier, so you can spend less time tackling dishes and more time together. Shop now at palmolive.com.
40:14Dan, I know you've been following this story very closely. Can you tell me about the last-ditch bar in Greenfield, Massachusetts? Yes, I can. There is a lesbian bar in Western Mass that required KN95 masks. This is like up until last week. But when the owners made Saturday night's mask optional because they were struggling financially, the community basically imploded. They were accused of ableism, eugenics, they held accountability sessions, and most importantly, one of the owners had stepped away to go to clown college. It's an amazing story. Everyone should not only read it in the Boston Globe where it went totally viral, but of course, listen to our friends, Katie Herzog and more minorly, Jessie Single, talk about this on their show, Blocked and Reported.
40:59They have been doggedly following this story for weeks. On the ground. Boots on the ground. Boots on the ground. Lesbian boots on the ground. Exactly. That's the only kind of shoes that they're wearing on the ground. I got to say, I feel bad for these lesbians. I feel bad for these lesbians, both of the lesbians. I feel bad for the masked ones and the unmasked ones. Right. I don't know what it is about lesbian culture where they're all loving the mask. Well, that's a longer podcast. Is it? We could get into it. What is it? Why are they? Well, I mean, the long and short of it is this ain't happening at gay bars.
41:31Right. Gay bars were never masked. They know what they want. But women, I think in general, and maybe especially queer or lesbian women, have like a heightened sense of community, mutual aid, wanting to lift up the most marginalized among them. All sort of really beautiful instincts, but maybe not the best ones if you want to have a successful nightlife establishment. Right. And gay guys don't give a fuck. The gay bars, when you walk in as a straight, they kind of roll their eyes. when you like you go to Marie's Crisis like it's almost like we're looking at the gays like they're like a like like you're at the zoo well I actually go to sing because Marie's Crisis is a show tunes bar and last time I was there I was doing just that and some guy turns to me and goes we can hear you we can oh we can actually hear you oh
42:22I was like great it's like you go and you assume like gay guys love like a straight girl with something to say No, they don't. No. They want you to get out. Yeah, they want you out. To be clear, Marie's Crisis is like the greatest bar in the world. But like you really got to go in knowing your stuff because they're doing deep cut, sawn time. It's not just Little Mermaid. I know. It's not just Hamilton. Marie's Crisis is run like the Navy. Marie's Crisis, that will last past world wars. Okay. This lesbian bar, what's it even called? The Last Ditch? How long did it last? Eight months? This is just the fate of these places because they require too much buy-in from the community.
42:59Yeah. I mean, gay bars, it's a fascist authoritarian regime in there. It's cash only. You're going to play by our rules, and we will not hesitate to kick you out. The opposite was going on here at The Last Dish is the impression I was getting. What do you think will happen next with this gay bar in Massachusetts, this lesbian bar? I just want to say I want to go visit it. I want to do field reporting. We should send you out in the field. Lesbians, it's time to take your KN95s off. It's time. Put the cane down. Put it down. Have some fun. You'll be fine. Catch a cold. Catch a cold. Have some soup.
43:36I think it's about long COVID. I don't think it's about catching colds. Long COVID. Yeah. How come only depressed lesbians are getting long COVID? Am I right? Yeah. Yeah, it's true. I feel bad. I mean, but also, if you're really afraid, just meet outside. Meet in someone's backyard. Have a drink out there. let the last ditch unmask and get wild and crazy there was an amazing um line in the piece that was like we should have a lady gaga night that would bring people out someone goes gaga's a zionist oh gaga's canceled gaga's a zionist perfect i mean you're not i mean if you do want do you want a lesbian bar in greedfield massachusetts you're gonna have to take off the mass become a gay male bar and invite gaga in that's how they're gonna survive man could you imagine being a lesbian zionist immunocompromised you have nowhere to go nowhere to go nowhere to go come here come to second thought come here bring your bring your mask ass over here did i say it right a lot of good stories this week wait what else did we have there just has been that we talked about we talked a lot about taylor swift and her sort of uh the anthology the world the world of Taylor Swift.
44:54We talked about Barbies. We talked about the homeless encampment, Dignity Village. We talked about The Last Ditch. Also kind of a homeless encampment, undignified village. And I've had so much fun. I have too. And to Madonna, I just want to say, take some Advil. Take some Advil. Take your face off. Hang it up. Hang it up. Take the Spanx off. Whatever leggings you're wearing. Spanx, honey. Take the splints. Take the barbed wire. this is past Spanx Dan this is not Spanx she's like my mom's age and she's getting thrown around by a big black guy in the bathroom someone's going like this like a basketball with her I mean the duct tape whatever it is keeping you together just you've earned it you are everything you are everything you did it just be the dame be on the throne you don't have to do this anymore although part of me is like let's see how much longer you can go yeah keep going it's true like do it until you you're gonna die on that stage well because she really has that dog in her yeah she's not like oh i play a pop star on tv i am a pop star yeah i mean underrated she dated like taylor swift always talks about who she dates madonna's been jean michel basquiat yeah richard gear i think i don't know why i think that if it's not true she was like everyone michael jackson my god crazy crazy Talk about a career.
46:16I was gonna say, Michael Jackson might be the only person who every one of his albums is as good as the last one, like Taylor Swift, and has a couple duds, but not really. But not really. Yeah. Okay, well, they're kind of like touched by God, I guess you could say. But that's the thing. I mean, it's true what MJ was saying. We have 50 more years of Taylor. If you think Taylor's going out, she's going out like Madonna. She should. It's funny. I kept thinking about this, but I was like, this is gonna be too smart, and then Susie's going to cut it out of the episode because Dan's just here to be a clown.
46:44But Monet, when he was on his deathbed, like the prime minister of France was like coming in and like putting a canvas in front of him. He's like, keep going. Yeah, like one more. These are national treasures you're making. And we just like put canvases in front of him. Is that true? Yeah. And he was like, you must keep going. That was the plan for like France's debt. Like their central bank was in trouble. It's like, we got 20 more minutes on Monet. Get him some oil paints. I love that. That's actually brilliant. Yeah, it's pretty cool. I think that's, I mean, what could be a... What could you hope for more as an artist than the prime minister being like, I need more.
47:17That is awesome. Okay, well, on that little factoid, I think it's time to sign off. I am Susie Weiss. I'm Dana Dute. And this has been Second Thought. Thanks for listening to this episode of Second Thought. If you're listening on Apple or Spotify, please give the show a follow. And if you have a second, consider leaving us a five-star rating or write us a nice review. It really helps us out. You can also get my weekly culture column by subscribing to the free press at thefp.com.
48:08season. You create it layer by layer until it finally feels like fall. Find fall your way at Ross.
Last week, Taylor Swift released four brand-new songs—and the public immediately panned them. What happened to the world’s biggest pop star, and what are we to make of her latest pivot? This week on Second Thought, Swift expert Matthew Jordan sits down with Suzy Weiss and Dan Ahdoot to break down all you need to know about The Life of a Showgirl: Encore Edition, and what the response reveals about her fandom.
Then, Suzy and Dan move on to another groundbreaking pivot in popular culture—this time from Sydney Sweeney, who may soon be converting to Judaism. Suzy explains why the bodacious actress would make a fine Jew, and why her conversion would mark the tribe’s greatest acquisition since Ruth.
Plus: a rogue Waymo hits the farmers market. Barbie’s big-nose scandal. And a dose of tough love for the mask-wearing lesbians in Massachusetts.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices