1. Podcasts
  2. Short History Of...
  3. Arthur Conan Doyle
Short History Of...

29 Jun 2025 · 59m · 21 chapters

In short

The episode traces Arthur Conan Doyle’s life from a medical student inspired by Dr. Joseph Bell’s deductions, to the creation of Sherlock Holmes, Doyle’s brief attempt to kill off Holmes, his later return and continued writing, his real-life justice work (George Edalji), and his lifelong turn toward spiritualism after personal losses—ending with the Cottingley fairies and a tense séance with Harry Houdini.

Guest(s)

Richard Pooley, step-great-grandson of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle; runs the Conan Doyle Estate. Tim Hubbard, creative director and global licensing representative for the Conan Doyle estate and family.

Key claims

Bell’s “observation” method (experience-based inference) inspired Holmes. Doyle modeled Holmes on Bell and built Holmes/Watson’s dynamic for enduring appeal. Doyle’s “Final Problem” backlash was immediate and massive, forcing Holmes’s return. Doyle’s spiritualism intensified after WWI and grief, leading him to champion the Cottingley fairies. A Houdini séance reportedly failed because messages were in fluent English, which Houdini’s mother supposedly didn’t speak.

Notable examples

1877 Edinburgh lecture theater deductions; Hope of Peterhead Arctic whaling voyage; A Study in Scarlet (1887) and 221B Baker Street; The Final Problem (1893) and public outrage; George Edalji pardon (1907); Cottingley fairies (1917); Houdini séance in Atlantic City (1922).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:00

The Early Years of Arthur Conan Doyle

Explore the formative experiences that shaped Arthur Conan Doyle's life and works.

“This is a paid advertisement from Indeed.”
1:41

The Early Years of Arthur Conan Doyle

Explore the formative experiences that shaped Arthur Conan Doyle's life and works.

“It's spring 1877 in a lecture theater in Edinburgh Medical School.”
7:29

From Medicine to Storytelling

Learn how Conan Doyle transitioned from a medical career to becoming a renowned writer.

“Arthur Ignatius Conan Doyle is born into a family of fading privilege and rising instability.”
13:53

From Medicine to Storytelling

Learn how Conan Doyle transitioned from a medical career to becoming a renowned writer.

“See, Quince focuses on high-quality wardrobe staples made with premium materials like 100 % Mongolian cashmere that I talked about or organic cotton and merino wool pieces.”
16:38

The Birth of Sherlock Holmes

Explore Arthur Conan Doyle's inspiration and creation of Sherlock Holmes.

“Despite some early successes submitting his short stories to various periodicals and newspapers, it's still not enough to give up on the medical practice.”
19:14

Doyle's Early Challenges

Understand Doyle's struggles as a writer and the making of Sherlock Holmes.

“What does this show us about how you create a character?”
22:35

Success and Family Responsibilities

Learn how family life impacted Doyle's writing and career decisions.

“Essentially, what happened was that Doyle got fed up about 18, 19, 91, in trying to get publishers to take his books.”
24:44

Turning to Historical Fiction

Discover Doyle's shift towards historical fiction amidst personal struggles.

“Though Conan is technically one of his middle names, he starts signing his work as A.”
30:04

The Creation of Sherlock Holmes

Explore the intense moment when Doyle writes the fate of Sherlock Holmes.

“This is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.”
33:51

Public Reaction to Holmes' Death

Understand the public outrage after Doyle kills off Sherlock Holmes.

“At least not one that his mind can interpret.”
Show all 21 chapters
36:18

Doyle's Personal Struggles

Learn about Doyle's personal life challenges and relationships.

“Grand adventures set in the past, far away from the fog-bound environs of Baker Street.”
38:37

The Boer War's Impact

Discover how the Second Boer War influenced Doyle's life and writing.

“But now, world events force him away from his wife's side, in the form of the Second Boer War, which erupts in South Africa in 1899.”
42:01

Doyle's Marriage and Advocacy for Justice

Explore Arthur Conan Doyle's marriage to Jean Leckie and his campaign for George Edalji's pardon.

“Doyle is by her side to the end, but a year after her death, he finally marries Jean Leckie.”
44:44

Doyle's Fascination with Spiritualism

Learn about Doyle's deepening interest in spiritualism following personal tragedies and the impact of World War I.

“Yet, as he wins praise for exposing injustice, another interest of his begins to take center stage.”
46:43

The Cottingley Fairies Controversy

Delve into the Cottingley fairies incident and Doyle's belief in the authenticity of the photographs.

“Why did he believe in this thing so much When obviously he was not a man to be fooled?”
49:35

The Seance with Harry Houdini

Investigate the tense seance between Arthur Conan Doyle and Harry Houdini, leading to a fallout over beliefs.

“He was not a person to be fooled and to be hoodwated.”
55:21

Doyle's Last Years and Legacy

Examine Doyle's final years, including his ongoing commitment to spiritualism and his writing.

“can't be underestimated, certainly as he tracked through his life.”
56:05

The Final Years of Arthur Conan Doyle

Learn about Doyle's health, writing, and the closure of Sherlock Holmes' adventures.

“the unseen world is just as real as the one we live in.”
58:05

Beyond Sherlock Holmes

Explore Doyle's varied interests and contributions beyond his famous detective character.

“Today, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle is remembered above all for the character he tried so hard to leave behind, Sherlock Holmes.”
59:15

Doyle's Insatiable Curiosity

Doyle's relentless pursuit of knowledge and curiosity is emphasized.

“a great detective, but a whole world of mystery and imagination, inspiration and wonder.”
59:54

Teaser for the Next Episode

Preview of the upcoming discussion about the Shroud of Turin.

“Next time on Short History of, we'll bring you a short history of the Shroud of Turin.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Short History Of..., what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This is a paid advertisement from Indeed. If you're a small business, the right hire can be make or break. Hoping the right people see your job posting isn't the best growth strategy. When the pressure's on and you need the right hire, this is a job for sponsored jobs. Indeed, sponsored jobs is a boost whenever you need to find quality talent. And sponsored jobs posted directly on Indeed are 95 % more likely to report a hire than non-sponsored jobs. So spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Less stress, less time, more results. When you need the right person to cut through the chaos, this is a job for Indeed-sponsored jobs.

0:40And listeners of this show will get a$75 sponsored job credit to help get your job the premium status it deserves at indeed.com slash podcast. Just go to indeed.com slash podcast right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed-sponsored jobs. thinking about refreshing the carpet in your home now's the time to do it for a limited time at the home depot get 10 off installed carpet projects on trusted brands like life proof life proof with pet proof technology home decorators collection and traffic master plus with installation starting at just 49 cents per square foot upgrading your space is more affordable than ever at the home depot offer valid september 24th 2026 through october 4th 2026.

1:30Exclusions apply. For licenses, see homedepot.com slash license numbers.

1:41It's spring 1877 in a lecture theater in Edinburgh Medical School. The room is cold, all stone and shadows. Rows of medical students file inside, the air laced with chalk dust and the scent of damp tweed and disinfectant. Thin light filters in through the tall windows, warming the polished wooden benches, which are now filling with scholars.

2:12A young man stands up to the side of the lectern, watching the room settle. At 18, he cuts a sturdy figure, tall and broad-shouldered, with the square jaw and calm bearing of someone much older. His dark hair curls above the slightly worn collar of his frock coat. A silver watch chain disappears into his pocket, and the ink from scribbled case notes stains his fingers. As clerk to Dr. Joseph Bell, he has made a note of every patient waiting to be seen this morning. It will be his duty to muster them onto the podium when their turn comes to be examined.

2:57Dr. Bell now enters, with the energy of a man already mid-thought, scything through the room, crisp and composed. His critical gaze sweeps over the students before he mounts the podium and calls for the first patient. His clerk quietly ushers a man in. The patient looks nervous, cap in hand, boots muddied. He steps onto the stage as the clerk returns to his place, notebook ready. Dr. Bell moves with practiced ease around the patient, lifting an arm, bending to examine a foot. Occasionally he nods as though confirming a suspicion in his own mind. Then he turns the chalkboard and scratches out the word observation, which he underlines twice.

3:48The lesson today is that to properly treat an ailment, one must use intuition, logic, and attention to detail to understand the whole patient. When the doctor begins to speak, he doesn't question the man, but simply pronounces a series of observations. Gesturing to the boots, he points out the residue of red clay, which he identifies as distinct to East Lothian. Next, Bell draws his student's attention to the calluses on the patient's hand. Indicative of rope work, he says, but not thick enough for a longshoreman. Now he raises the man's hands to examine his fingers. The blackening on his fingernails isn't coal, he proclaims, but more likely lime, and the salt stains on the cuffs suggest recent sea travel.

4:41He turns slightly to face the students and pronounces his verdict, that the patient is a sailor who has been unloading lime cargo. Which, my good man, Bell says, addressing the chap directly Will likely explain the cough you've been suffering with The man blinks in stunned silence A few students chuckle nervously The clerk smiles a wry, knowing smile He has seen the doctor's performance many times before But it never fails to impress

5:21Almost a decade later, this clerk, a young man by the name of Arthur Conan Doyle, will remember how Dr. Bell's deductions cut through mystery. He will remember the hush of the theater, the awe of the onlookers, the incredulity of the patients, as their secrets are laid bare without them saying a word. And when he puts pen to paper to sketch the character of the world's most famous detective, he will recall this moment, this man, as the inspiration behind Sherlock Holmes.

5:58While his fictional detective, cold, analytical, preternaturally perceptive, may become one of literature's most famous characters, Arthur Conan Doyle himself was something far more nuanced and complex. A doctor trained in observation and diagnosis, Doyle was also a war volunteer, a campaigner for justice, a politician, and a believer in the spirit world. He battled typhoid in South Africa, led a legal campaign in England, earned a knighthood for his work in support of the British Army, and spent years trying to communicate with the dead. In his lifetime, he wrote ghost stories, political pamphlets, historical novels, and fantastical adventures.

6:45But it was a single detective, pipe in hand, who would immortalize him.

6:55So how did a young medical student from Edinburgh end up transforming crime fiction forever? What drove him to kill off, and then resurrect, the character who made him famous? And why did a man of science and reason spend so many years pursuing the supernatural? I'm John Hopkins. From the Noisy Network, this is a short history of Arthur Conan Doyle.

7:28In 1859, in a modest tenement flat in Edinburgh's Newington district, Arthur Ignatius Conan Doyle is born into a family of fading privilege and rising instability. His father, Charles, is a gifted but troubled illustrator for the government's Office of Works. A man with artistic talent and a romantic spirit who is slowly being unraveled by alcohol. His mother, Mary, is a well-read, fiercely imaginative Irish woman. The anchor of Arthur's early life, she not only holds the family together financially, but inspires his passion for storytelling.

8:14Richard Pooley runs the Conan Doyle Estate and is the step-great-grandson of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. His childhood was, frankly, pretty hard, described as genteel poverty. He moved seven times in the first ten years of his life. He moved around a lot within Edinburgh. But his family, if you look at his father's family, and to some extent his mother's family. They were well off, they were successful. His mother, who was a huge influence on him throughout his life, was very proud of their ancestry.

8:55When Arthur is around nine years old, his paternal uncles pay for his place at Stonyhurst College. The strict Jesuit boarding school in the north of England is meant to offer structure and opportunity. But for young Arthur, it's a world of cold discipline, root religion, and rigid authority. The imagination and love of literature that flourished under his mother's care is, for now, forced into quiet corners. It's a long way away, and he apparently cried all the way. He was pretty miserable, actually, there for a lot of the time, and he himself, in his own memoirs, criticized the teaching. It was very poor, in his view.

9:38He made friends there. People often wondered where did he get the name, for example, for Moriarty. Well, one of his schoolmates was called Moriarty. Another one was called Patrick Sherlock. But he didn't enjoy it. He longed, frankly, to get home. Arthur finally leaves Stonyhurst in his late teens and enrolls at the University of Edinburgh to study medicine. He pays his way through tutoring, assisting local doctors, and taking on odd jobs to scrape by. And he keeps his love of stories fired by writing plays for fellow students to perform. Then, in early 1880, an unusual opportunity appears. A whaling vessel, the Hope of Peterhead, is preparing to sail for the Arctic, and needs a ship's surgeon for the voyage.

10:32For the 20-year-old student, the offer is irresistible. Seven months at sea, a modest wage, and more importantly, an adventure. If you read the diary he wrote, it's absolutely fascinating about his experiences there, many of which influenced the stories, books that he later wrote. But he did that on a whim. He was studying at the time in Edinburgh, and suddenly, within a week, he's on a whaling ship heading off up in the Arctic and killing whales. But it's a period of his life, it's his equivalent to the gap year and I think that was a great influence on him.

11:15Life aboard the Hope is brutal. Long hours, freezing winds and the gruesome work of the whaling trade. But Doyle thrives. Alongside his medical duties, he hauls carcasses and dodges frostbite He will later say it was on the deck of that ship, surrounded by ice and blood and sky, that he became a man

11:40After completing his degree, Conan Doyle sets sail once more This time he heads southward, aboard the Mayumba, bound for the West African coast The role is familiar now, ship's surgeon, responsible for the crew's health. But Doyle contracts a severe fever, and the heat and illness nearly finish him off. He returns home weakened, but his appetite for risk is undiminished.

12:12Back on British soil, he tries to find his footing as a doctor, Though he takes up temporary posts in Plymouth, Birmingham, and Sheffield, in 1882 he strikes out on his own. Borrowing ten pounds from his mother, he opens a practice in Southsea, near Portsmouth, on England's south coast. At first, the patients are few and far between. Doyle will later joke that whenever the front doorbell rang, he'd leap to the window, hoping it was a potential patient and not another creditor. But with long stretches of quiet in his surgery, he has plenty of time to explore his love of storytelling. He begins to write, using the time between appointments to shape characters and invent plots.

13:00And in the midst of this new life, he meets a young woman called Louisa Hawkins, the sister of a fellow doctor. She is gentle, intelligent, and steadfast, and the pair hit it off immediately. They marry in 1885 and their relationship acts as a quiet anchor in his life. But it soon becomes clear that the medical practice isn't enough to sustain their household. He was married and he needed to find other ways of earning money. So he'd started writing, in fact, at university and he put on plays and things while he was at school. but he was beginning to see that he had to find something else other than medicine to make money

13:53guys fall has officially arrived and the cooler days have me pulling out those go-to wardrobe staples like those favorite pair of jeans those long sleeve t-shirts or a new edition i recently picked up from quince a mongolian cashmere full zip-up hoodie i was blown away by how soft it is and how great it pairs with almost everything in my closet. See, Quince focuses on high-quality wardrobe staples made with premium materials like 100 % Mongolian cashmere that I talked about or organic cotton and merino wool pieces. The styles are timeless, versatile, and designed to become the dependable pieces you reach for day after day.

14:27Everything at Quince is priced 50 % to 80 % less than similar brands. They work directly with ethical factories and cut out the middlemen, so you're paying for high-quality, not brand markup. And it's not just clothing. Quince brings that same approach to everything they make, from hotel quality bedding and bath to kitchen essentials and thoughtfully designed furniture. They make well-designed pieces for everyday living. So find your next fall favorites at Quince. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to Quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns, now available in Canada and the UK too.

15:01And when Quince asks you where you heard about them, let them know it was on Short History Of. It's the best way to support the show. You know, losing weight on your own can feel like a losing battle. Trust me, I know. Repeated trips to the gym, challenging diets, but there is help. Weight Loss by HIMSS offers access to the FDA-approved Wagovi pill and the Wagovi pen. Wagovi is the first ever GLP-1 weight loss medication available in a pill, and it also comes as a pen, so you've got options. With Wagovi, you can lose up to 20 % of your body weight. People lost an average of 14 % body weight at 64 weeks in a clinical trial of Wagovi alongside diet and exercise.

15:42To get started with Wagovi, just go to HIMSS.com and complete an online consultation with a licensed provider who will determine if a prescription is appropriate. HIMSS is more than just prescription. Nutrition and lifestyle guidance are part of the plan, along with access to 24-7 messaging with your care team so you've always got someone in your corner. So are you ready to reach your goals? Visit HIMSS.com slash short history to get personalized affordable care for weight loss, hair loss, sex, testosterone, and more. That's HIMSS.com slash short history. HIMSS.com slash short history. Individual results may vary and stopping treatment may result in weight regain.

16:23Weight loss by HIMSS is not available in all 50 states. WGOVI is the registered trademark of Vinovo NoroDisc, AS. To get started and learn more, including important safety information, with Govi clinical study information and restrictions, visit HIMSS.com. Despite some early successes submitting his short stories to various periodicals and newspapers, it's still not enough to give up on the medical practice. He needs to write something more popular, something that will really catch the public and publishers' imagination. Something, perhaps, with a detective. In the mid-1880s, detective fiction is still a niche genre.

17:04It's shaped by the works of Edgar Allan Poe and Wilkie Collins, whose detectives rely on intuition and chance rather than methodical reasoning. But Doyle wants to do something different. Instead of solving crimes by luck or brute force, his detective should prevail through his use of logic and deduction. He models his protagonist on someone he knows well, his former mentor at medical school, Dr. Joseph Bell. The man who could diagnose a patient's ailments and lifestyle just by watching them walk into the room. Tim Hubbard is the creative director and global licensing representative for the Conan Doyle estate and family.

17:47He was the greatest teacher, wasn't he? Because he was entertaining his students. They thought that he knew something that they didn't. But looking back now, it's fairly straightforward of how that came about, where he could look at the colour of your cuffs, if your cuffs were stained or you had certain colour of dirt under your nails or the colour of your skin. It was almost like he was guessing, but he wasn't guessing because it was just down to experience. As far as the invention of Sherlock Holmes, I think it was a huge influence. But then he built that character like no other with lots of other different influences that he was meeting people through that time.

18:35Doyle spends many hours crafting the character, who will eventually become Sherlock Holmes. Even his name goes through many iterations. and for much of his early development, the famous detective is known to his creator as J. Sheringford Holmes.

18:53The notes are fascinating. I'll give you a little bit. The line comes down from J. Sheringford Holmes. Reserved. Sleepy-eyed young man. Philosopher. Collector of rare violins. Chemical laboratory. An Amati. I have 400 a year. I am a consulting detective. I mean, it's just, I've looked at this piece of paper time and time again. Wow. What does this show us about how you create a character? He's creating here probably one of the most, if not the most famous fictional character ever. With Holmes now mapped out, his sidekick, Dr. Watson, the loyal but often perplexed chronicler of Holmes' adventures, soon follows.

19:40Doyle, at the age of 27 is about to change the face of detective fiction forever But setting the first book in London about which he knows very little presents him with another challenge Where should Sherlock Holmes live? He was in South Sea at the time He hardly knew London He'd only been there a few times And he took out a post office map And I believe he simply looked at the mat, closed his eyes and put his finger down. And it landed on what was then Upper Baker Street. And 221B did not exist. Please the world, no, 221B did not exist. He creates this. And Sherlockians, Doinians around the world have expended a vast amount of ink and time on where exactly was 221B.

20:37It never existed.

20:42He called Holmes and Watson's debut story A Tangled Skane. But it will become known as A Study in Scarlet. It's a bold adventure in which the duo investigate the mysterious murder of a man in London whilst uncovering a complex tale of revenge against the backdrop of a Mormon settlement in Utah. After just two weeks of writing, the story is finished. He sends it off to a publisher, Ward, Locke and Co. for consideration. It's quickly accepted and published in the 1887 edition of Beaton's Christmas Annual. Doyle receives the sum of£25 for the rights, just under£3 ,500 in today's money. Initial reviews are mixed.

21:32While some readers are intrigued by the novel's fresh take on the genre, others aren't immediately keen on the aloof main character. Despite the muted reception, Doyle continues to write. But it's not enough to keep the wolf from the door. Especially when, in 1889, his first child, Mary Louise, is born. With the added responsibility of a family of his own, Doyle's need to succeed as both writer and breadwinner intensifies.

22:06In 1890, three years after the first Sherlock Holmes story, the detective makes his return with a publication of a new tale called The Sign of Four. This time, the pair investigate the disappearance of a young woman's father and uncover a hidden treasure, a secret pact, and a deadly conspiracy. But Doyle's future as a writer remains uncertain, and Sherlock Holmes is still far from a household name. Essentially, what happened was that Doyle got fed up about 18, 19, 91, in trying to get publishers to take his books. He'd already written two Sherlock Holmes novels, but he wanted someone else to take over the negotiations, which he didn't think he was very good at.

22:52And this guy, A.P. Watt, came in and almost immediately found the way that Doyle should get himself published. He knew the owner of the Strand magazine, and so Watt submitted the first of the short stories, A Scandal in Bohemia, to the Strand magazine, and as we say, the rest is history.

23:22Thanks to The Strand, Sherlock Holmes finds a fast-growing, devoted readership. Fans find the partnership between Holmes and Watson particularly compelling, not just for the sharp intellect of the detective or the steady reliability of the Doctor, but because of the dynamic that exists between them. Holmes, with his cold, methodical approach to solving mysteries, contrasts perfectly with Watson's warmth, loyalty, and grounded perspective. Together they form a bond that feels both complementary and essential to the stories The relationship between Watson and Sherlock We believe is the key element in these enduring qualities And why the Holmes stories, Sherlock Holmes, Watson They keep getting depicted year after year after year And there's no slowing down

24:19And it's not just their world he is expanding In 1892, the Doyle family grows once more With the birth of a son, Arthur Alain Kingsley Conan Doyle Known to everyone just as Kingsley By this point, Doyle's reputation is becoming firmly established And as it does so, a new version of his name comes to the fore Though Conan is technically one of his middle names, he starts signing his work as A. Conan Doyle, and the double-barreled surname sticks. His success as an author finally means he can move away from medicine and focus solely on his literary career. It's a decision he makes while in the grip of a flu-based fever, but one that fills him with delight.

25:11The only problem is that he doesn't want to just write Sherlock stories. Though the readers love him and the publisher is clamoring for more, Doyle is already beginning to tire of his central character. He has his heart set on grander things. Historical fiction, real writing, not cheap detective stories. In one of his frequent letters to his mother, he admits as much. Dearest ma 'am, that's what he called her, I have done five of the Sherlock Holmes stories of the new series. I think that they are up to the standard of the first series, and the twelve ought to make a rather good book of the sort.

25:51I think of slaying Holmes in the sixth, and winding him up for good and all. He takes my mind from better things. But what author, in their right mind, would kill off a character so fruitful, so adored, so profitable. Especially when he's supporting not just his wife and children, but also his mother and siblings. No one wants to see that come to an end. Everybody was saying, for God's sake, you're making money, you're making us money. It's a huge success. And they succeed in keeping Sherlock Holmes alive for another 18 months.

26:34With Sherlock still a thorn in his creative side, he sets about establishing himself as a writer of serious historical fiction. His first major success in this genre is The White Company, a novel set against the backdrop of the Hundred Years' War. The book is reasonably well received, and thus encouraged, he continues the story into a second novel, Sir Nigel.

27:02But at home, the Doyle family are facing a major challenge. Arthur's wife, Louisa, has been struggling for a while with tuberculosis, and it's getting worse. Desperate to help her, Doyle turns to the best medical experts of the time, and even takes her to Switzerland in search of a cure. While there, they take a trip to see the Reichenbach Falls. And it is here that Doyle spies the perfect place, he believes, to close off another chapter in his life.

27:54built-in business partner can be a game changer. For millions of businesses, that tool is Shopify. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10 % of all e-commerce in the U.S., from household names like Gymshark, Rare Beauty, and Heinz, to brands just getting started. Shopify has hundreds of ready-to-use templates that can help you build a beautiful online store that matches your brand's style, and you can tackle all the important tasks in one place, from inventory to payments to analytics and more. No need to save multiple websites or try to figure out what platform is hosting the tool that you need.

28:33And if people haven't heard about your brand, you can get the word out like you have a marketing team behind you with easy-to-run email and social media campaigns to reach customers wherever they're scrolling or strolling. Start your business today with the industry's best business partner, Shopify, and start hearing. Sign up for your$1 per month trial today at shopify.com slash realm. Go to shopify.com slash realm. That's shopify.com slash realm.

29:06This is a paid advertisement from Indeed. If you're a small business, the right hire can be make or break. Hoping the right people see your job posting isn't the best growth strategy. When the pressure's on and you need the right hire, this is a job for sponsored jobs. Indeed, sponsored jobs is a boost whenever you need to find quality talent. And sponsored jobs posted directly on Indeed are 95 % more likely to report a hire than non-sponsored jobs. So spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Less stress, less time, more results. When you need the right person to cut through the chaos, this is a job for Indeed, sponsored jobs.

29:45And listeners of this show will get a$75 sponsored job credit to help get your job the premium status it deserves at Indeed.com slash podcast. Just go to Indeed.com slash podcast right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.

30:13It is December 1893 at Arthur Conan Doyle's Surrey home. Outside, winter clings to the bare trees. But here, in his study, the writer sits at his desk, a sheet of paper before him, a warm fire hissing softly in the grate. Pale light filters through the window, catching dust motes floating. His pen scratches steadily across the page, shaping the fate of a man who has come to dominate his life and work. He pauses for a moment, eyes narrowed in thought, then sets the pen down, considering his next words. On the page, Dr. Watson is in a terrible panic. Holmes's dear companion has fallen for an elaborate hoax which drew him away from the detective side at the top of the Reichenbach Falls.

31:11Now he must hurry all the way back up there in the hope of saving Sherlock from the deadly hands of his nemesis Moriarty.

31:21Smiling, Doyle lifts his pen again. His surroundings fade around him as he becomes fully immersed in his fictional world, in which Watson is about to make a harrowing discovery.

31:39High in the Swiss Alps, the melting winter snow has added dangerous volume to the wild torrent of water crashing hundreds of feet to the rocks below the falls. On the steep path that winds alongside the precipice, Dr. Watson climbs, driven by a dreadful urgency. His breath comes in ragged gasps, and every step is a battle against the steep, mist-slicked path, but he presses on. At last, breathless and wide-eyed, he reaches the clearing beside the falls where he last saw his friend. For a moment, he sees nothing but the thick mist and the furious white torrent plunging into the chasm below. Then his gaze falls on something that makes his heart stop.

32:31There, driven into a crack in the rock, stands Sherlock's familiar climbing stick. Beside it, half hidden under a damp stone, gleams a small silver cigarette case. He stumbles forward and pulls the case free. A folded sheet of paper rests inside, the ink smudged slightly by the damp. He unfolds it with trembling fingers. The falls rage beside him, but the world narrows to the words scribbled on the page. Calm, precise, and unbearably final.

33:14They tell him what he already fears. That Sherlock saw the trick, but chose to stay and fight. knowing that the only way to end Moriarty's reign of terror would be to sacrifice his own life in taking him out. With the note half crumpled in his hand, Watson steps closer to the edge. The rocks are scuffed, the soft dirt scratched as though two men had struggled there. But then, nothing more. No footprints leading away, no further clue. At least not one that his mind can interpret. Only the yawning gorge and the endless rush of water.

34:02He straightens slowly, moves to the very brink, and calls out, Sherlock. But his voice is swallowed instantly by the thundering water, throwing back a half-human, terrible sound which offers no reply and no comfort. Only the dreadful knowledge that Sherlock Holmes is, almost certainly, gone.

34:33In 1893, just four years after his creation, and after two novels and 24 short stories featuring the detective, Doyle calls time on Sherlock Holmes in a story called The Final Problem. The public reaction is instant and furious. Readers write angry letters to newspapers and to Doyle himself. Some mourn as if a real person has died, wearing black armbands in the street. The Strand magazine loses 20 ,000 subscribers almost overnight. Even Doyle's own mother begs him to reconsider.

35:14Far from freeing himself of Sherlock Holmes, He has unleashed a tidal wave of grief and fury not seen before for a fictional character. He never realized just what he had produced with Sherlock Holmes and Watson. He was too much influenced, I think, by the view that historical fiction would give him higher status. The detective novels was just below him. We've got to think about his upbringing again and where he came from as a person. and he found success, obviously overnight success, but he wasn't afraid to change his course even though Sherlock became his wealth creator. And I think that is testament to the man again.

36:01No matter how tough his upbringing was, he had this ability to turn his hand and be confident about the next chapter in his life. Despite almost everyone demanding he resurrect Holmes, Doyle stands firm. Instead, he focuses his energy on his serious historical novels. Grand adventures set in the past, far away from the fog-bound environs of Baker Street. The sad thing is that although the historical fiction were superbly plotted and he did a huge amount of research and he got all his facts right, unlike, by the way, the Sherlock Holmes novels, full of mistakes. They're boring, and the dialogue is dire.

36:46Whereas the dialogue in the Sherlock Holmes stories, and actually some of his much later stories, not historical fiction, is really good. And yet he couldn't see this. His mother could, the editor and owner of the strand could, the public could. He couldn't.

37:05At the same time, he is relentless in pursuing a cure for Louise's tuberculosis. Though little is ever written about their relationship, it is clear that he expends every effort trying to help her. He did a huge amount trying to take her to Switzerland, taking her to Egypt, taking her to places where maybe she would get better. It's extraordinary how little we know about their relationship. In his letters to his mother, she doesn't get a lot of mention. She was called Tui in the family. They had two children. Marion Kingsley, but she doesn't make much of an impression, put it that way. A far greater impression is made by another woman, however, Jean Leckie.

37:51A gifted soprano from a respectable family, she moves in the same genteel social circles as Doyle. Having met her in 1897, he finds himself increasingly captivated by her intelligence, charm, and musical talent. Louisa, though, is gravely ill, and Doyle remains outwardly devoted to her, maintaining with Jean what he insists is a platonic friendship. Even so, letters between them suggest a deeper emotional connection. And as Louisa's health declines and Doyle shoulders the burden of her care, Jean becomes a steady presence in the background of his life.

38:37But now, world events force him away from his wife's side, in the form of the Second Boer War, which erupts in South Africa in 1899. A brutal colonial conflict between the British Empire and the Boers over control of territory and gold, it changes the course of Doyle's life and writing once again.

39:06As a staunch patriot, he volunteers as a civilian doctor with the British Army, stationed in Bloemfontein in the Orange Free State. Here, he witnesses the horrors of war firsthand, treating wounded soldiers in atrocious conditions on the battlefield. Even now, though, he's still dogged by the public's love of Sherlock. In another all-too-common confusion of his name with his characters, one newspaper boldly announces, Sherlock Holmes off to the war. Nonetheless, his short stint on the front results in a new book. Titled The Great Boer War, it gives a detailed patriotic defense of Britain's actions, and will later help to earn him a knighthood from King Edward VII.

39:54When he returns to Britain, Doyle's sense of duty hasn't faded. That autumn, in October 1900, he stands as a liberal Unionist candidate for Edinburgh Central in the general election. He campaigns vigorously, appealing to patriotism and empire, but ultimately narrowly loses the seat.

40:18The silver lining is that he now has time to return to his writing. But the public still haven't forgiven him for killing Sherlock, and eventually he succumbs to the pressure and agrees to bring him back. In 1901, Holmes makes his long-awaited return to the pages of the Strand magazine in The Hound of the Baskervilles. This tale of moorland menace is a clever workaround. The story is set well before Holmes' visit to the Reichenbach Fall. Finally, in 1903, the resurrection is made official. The adventure of the empty house reveals that Holmes never fell to his death at all. He faked the whole thing, slipping away to dismantle Moriarty's criminal web in secret.

41:11Readers are thrilled. Magazine sales surge. The Strand's circulation reportedly doubles. From there, the great detective goes from strength to strength. The adventure of the dancing men, the solitary cyclist, the six Napoleons, each case adding to the legend. But for Doyle, the thrill has worn off. He begins to truly resent the character who once gave him such success, calling Holmes a lower stratum of literary achievement. But even as the world celebrates Sherlock Holmes, his creator's personal life is now marked by a significant sorrow. After years of decline, Louisa dies in 1906 at the age of 49.

42:01Doyle is by her side to the end, but a year after her death, he finally marries Jean Leckie. He was certainly absolutely besotted with Jean Leckie, and she was. You see photographs of her. She was a very good-looking woman. There's no question she was devoted to him and he to her, and she was a real force.

42:25In the same year he remarries, Doyle also finds himself helping to solve a real-life miscarriage of justice. Much like his fictional detective, he's always had a strong sense of right and wrong, and a belief that truth must be pursued, no matter how tangled. While reading the papers one day, he spies a letter written by a young solicitor called George Edalji. The son of an Indian-born vicar in Staffordshire, Edalji has been convicted of mutilating livestock in a bizarre and highly publicized case. The evidence is flimsy at best, involving anonymous letters, mysterious hoofprints, wild accusations from local farmers, and a police force seemingly blinded by racial prejudice.

43:13To Doyle, the case seems obviously flawed And, moved by the injustice, he decides to investigate Reviewing the evidence, he quickly spots inconsistencies And consults experts who determine the animal injuries were likely caused by a wild dog Not a human He also uncovers the bias against Adalji Believing his conviction stems more from his ethnicity than any solid evidence And so he begins a public campaign for Adalgi's pardon, writing articles and pressuring authorities. In fact, it was Doyle's knowledge of thalmology and eyesight. When he sat down with George Adalgi, I realized that this young man was completely short-sighted, completely myopic.

44:01The idea of him going out into a field and plunging a knife into a horse in the middle of the night, it's all obviously completely wrong.

44:15Finally, his efforts culminate in the government review of the case, and in 1907, George Adalji is granted a royal pardon. But he receives no compensation, and his conviction is never fully overturned. Still, the case becomes a national scandal, and its fallout helps lead to the establishment of the Court of Criminal Appeal later that year. It is a mark of his character that Doyle will never turn his back on what he considers a moral wrong. Yet, as he wins praise for exposing injustice, another interest of his begins to take center stage. There's been lots of evidence and writing around Doyle's fascination with spirituality, but I really believe that Doyle's interest was piqued, certainly during the atrocities and certainly after the First World War.

45:09And ultimately, he wanted to help. He wanted to help society try and find meaning with all this sort of death and destruction. And no doubt, he had experiences up to that point where he felt he was opening a window into another world.

45:29From early in his life, Doyle has shown a fascination with the supernatural. His mother, the gifted storyteller, also had a deep interest in the mystical, which she shared with her son. Over time, he has developed a sincere belief that communication with the dead is not only possible, but essential to understanding life itself.

45:54After Louise's death, and especially after the First World War, Doyle is devastated by a string of personal losses. Among them, his son Kingsley, who survives the Battle of the Somme only to die in 1918 of pneumonia, weakened by his war injuries and brought low by influenza. Grief drives Doyle deeper into spiritualism No longer a private curiosity It becomes a public cause He throws himself into the movement With the same zeal he once brought to Sherlock Holmes Travelling, lecturing, publishing He opened the psychic bookshop in Victoria He created a publishing company To the spiritualist publications He travelled the world He campaigned The piece in the middle for me is, why?

46:47Why did he believe in this thing so much When obviously he was not a man to be fooled?

46:57His quest for proof, for answers As well as the constant drumbeat of wartime deaths Inspire him with the idea that spiritualism is a new revelation Sent by God to bring solace to the bereaved It was quite clear at that time that he believed that the church couldn't help, but almost, this is probably a strong word, he was almost blaspheming because of his quest for spirituality. So, you know, certainly the establishment were trying to belittle him. And as his voice got louder and the more campaigning he did, the more sort of detached he probably became. It's this passion that draws him into one of the strangest and most controversial episodes of his later life.

47:45In 1917, in the village of Cottingley, Yorkshire, two young schoolgirls, cousins Elsie Wright and Francis Griffiths, take a series of photographs in their gardens. The images appear to show the girls in the company of small winged creatures. At first, they're dismissed as fanciful tricks But when the pictures reach a curious Sir Arthur Conan Doyle He sees something far more profound Convinced, they offer real evidence of the spirit world He publishes them for all the world to see

48:27Amongst the papers that we found I opened an envelope and inside were the prints of the fairies, the Cottingly fairies. These were the prints actually used in the book The Coming of the Fairies. But the negatives have gone, so this is all we've got left. Now I looked at those photographs and I've shown them to one or two and Tim and I have looked at them together. And you think, how could he possibly have believed that these fairies were real? You can see the pins, you can see how these two girls created these fairies and photographed them. But he did. I do not question his conviction. I think what's really important to remember is it was his steadfast belief in his own confidence and ability to try and change the world and help people that he dug his heels in.

49:24and he doubled down on this quest. And I have absolutely no doubt that he experienced things where he felt that this thing was real because he wasn't to be fooled, Doyle. He was not a person to be fooled and to be hoodwated. To Doyle, the photographs offer proof that unseen worlds might exist beyond our own. He isn't simply chasing fairies. He is championing a belief in spiritual realms. in life after death, in mysteries that science and reason have yet to explain.

50:04And he is not alone in his belief. His second wife both shares and encourages his faith in the spirit world. Together they attempt to spread the message, often to skeptical friends. Among them is Harry Houdini, the world-famous illusionist and friend of Doyle's, who is still reeling from the recent death of his much-beloved mother.

50:47technology, home decorators collection, and traffic master. Plus, with installation starting at just 49 cents per square foot, upgrading your space is more affordable than ever at The Home Depot. Offer valid September 24th, 2026 through October 4th, 2026. Exclusions apply. For licenses, see homedepot.com slash license numbers. Fall has never looked or tasted this good. Sweet Green's Fall Harvest Menu is back with seasonal favorites dressed to impress and made to be devoured. Warm roasted sweet potatoes, crisp apples, maple glazed Brussels, and crave-worthy flavors in the autumn harvest bowl, maple glazed salmon plate, and roasted bacon Brussels side.

51:27The season's most desirable menu has returned to Sweetgreen, featuring fall's best dressed. Make your move. Order on the Sweetgreen app.

51:39It's late 1922. In a dim, candlelit room in a hotel in Atlantic City, America. Arthur Conan Doyle draws the curtains, shutting out the afternoon sun. The room is stuffy, the air heavy with incense. In the center, a small table stands, strewn flowers, glasses of water, writing materials, and a lit candle. There, Jean sits, poised, serene in her concentration. conversation. Beside her, Arthur takes his seat and nods to the man across the table. The great illusionist, Harry Houdini, has finally agreed to join Arthur and Jean in a seance. Arthur knows how much his friend is missing his recently deceased mother, and he is offered to try to communicate with her to give him some comfort.

52:36Houdini cuts a sharp, muscular figure in the low light. His posture is rigid, lips tight, eyes wary beneath his furrowed brow. Now, Jean lowers her head, breathing slow and deep. Reverently, they call on the spirits to visit them, to talk with Harry. And then, Jean begins to write.

53:06Not her own words, according to those who believe, but messages channeled from the spirit realm, in a process called automatic writing. A pencil glides across the paper as Arthur watches in rapt silence. But as the illusionist leans forward, reading each line that purportedly comes from his mother, the muscles in his jaw tighten. Because the message unfolding on the page is not only peppered with references to Christian ideas of salvation, but is written in fluent English, a language of which his Hungarian Jewish mother, who died with a Yiddish prayer on her lips, knew barely a word.

53:58The illusionist stands suddenly. The chair scrapes the floor.

54:06With a single, pained, furious look, he turns and walks out. No words, no outburst, just silence. Doyle doesn't follow The séance is over And so too is the friendship So they had this séance And Houdini's mother was apparently speaking to Houdini from the dead Jean Leckie was writing it down What Houdini's mother said But it was in English Houdini's mother didn't speak English She spoke German Despite living in the States for a long time was full of stuff about Christianity. She was Jewish. So clearly it wasn't true. What the hell was going through the mind of Arthur Conan Doyle's wife, Jean? Intelligent woman?

54:59What was she doing? And for that matter, why did her husband believe so strongly in her ability to communicate with the dead? I think he probably became blindsided by just desperately wanting to help, desperately wanting to ease pain and suffering. And again, his sort of curiosity and his influence can't be underestimated, certainly as he tracked through his life. And he felt he had a duty. You know, one of the big word around Doyle is duty. He had a duty for everything and everyone.

55:41on. His belief in spiritualism remains with Doyle to the very end. In his final years, he tours tirelessly, writing and lecturing to packed halls around the world, determined to open minds to what he sees as a truth beyond the veil. Even as the critics grow louder and the friends fewer, Doyle never wavers. To the man who once gave the world the most logical detective in literature, the unseen world is just as real as the one we live in.

56:16By now he is slowing down. His health, long tested by grief and exertion, begins to falter. But he continues to write.

56:28In 1926, he sends news to A.P. Watt Of what will be the penultimate Sherlock Holmes story And his letter shows how he is still enthusiastic In his writing, sport, and life in general Despite his advancing years Number five is done Adventure of the Veiled Lodger Did it in one day With 18 holes thrown in Which is not bad for 67 It is shortish, but the quality good. You'll have the typed copy before the end of the week. I'm not at all sure about number six. London all this week. AC Day. Number six in that series will be the 60th and very last Sherlock Holmes story. The Adventure of Shoscombe Old Place.

57:16It is published in 1927, more than three decades after Holmes first appeared. With it, the detective's adventures, collected in the casebook of Sherlock Holmes, finally draw to a close.

57:35Though spiritualism dominates his focus in his final years, Doyle's pen doesn't rest entirely. He continues to write on history, on fairies, on ghosts. He publishes memoirs, defenses of his beliefs and more fiction, though none of his other writing ever achieves quite what Holmes did. In July 1930, he dies quietly at his home, Windlesham, aged 71, with Jean by his side. Today, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle is remembered above all for the character he tried so hard to leave behind, Sherlock Holmes. That sharp, indefatigable, impossibly brilliant detective has outlived his author by more than a century, adapted and reimagined for every generation since.

58:23His name has become shorthand for deduction itself. A statue of Holmes stands near Baker Street Station. Fans still leave tributes at 221B, despite the fact that the residence never really existed. But Doyle was far more than just Holmes' creator. He was a doctor, a campaigner, a war correspondent a politician. He fought for justice and grieved deeply for those he loved. His writings beyond Sherlock, his historical novels, his science fiction, even his essays on spiritualism, reveal his huge curiosity. He once said, where there is no imagination, there is no horror. Perhaps it's no surprise then that a man of such boundless imagination should leave behind not just a great detective, but a whole world of mystery and imagination, inspiration and wonder.

59:22He was constantly campaigning for causes that he believed in, and that's one of those things that fascinates me about his life. You know, we say this all the time, he was so busy, you know, whether he was writing stories, adventuring, playing sports, being a doctor, campaigning for justice. He squeezed every last drop out of his life. The one thing that I really admire him for is this wish to know more, his curiosity. Be curious. Want to know more and more. And Doyle illustrates that to a T. And that's why I admire him so much.

1:00:06Next time on Short History of, we'll bring you a short history of the Shroud of Turin. the interest in the shroud today in 2025 is skyrocketing and to have science still be so baffled by this mysterious image and still not be able to explain it it leads one to question well how could this image have been created could it be the natural effect of a supernatural event And so today, with our scientific ability, we have the ability to study and question and probe and learn. And yet we still have to have the answer that only our faith can provide. That's next time.

1:01:06readings of Conan Doyle classics like The Speckled Band, The Red-Headed League, The Man with the Twisted Lip, and more. Search for Sherlock Holmes short stories wherever you get your podcasts or head to noiser.com. Fall savings are happening now at The Home Depot. Save up to $500 on select appliances. Plus, enjoy free delivery when you spend$998 or more. From prepping to cooking to cleaning up, Frigidaire has you covered. The custom flex temp drawer switches from fridge to freezer. With more than 15 cooking modes including Stone-Bank Pizza mode, you can enjoy restaurant quality pizza in as little as two minutes.

1:01:41Then clean up with the Frigidaire dishwasher featuring the industry's fastest normal wash cycle. Shop Fall Savings now at The Home Depot. Offer value through October 21st. US only. See store online for details. Fall savings are happening now at The Home Depot. Save up to$500 on select appliances. Plus enjoy free delivery when you spend$998 or more. From From prepping to cooking to cleaning up, Frigidaire has you covered. The custom flex temp drawer switches from fridge to freezer. With more than 15 cooking modes including stone-baked pizza mode, you can enjoy restaurant-quality pizza in as little as two minutes.

1:02:11Then clean up with the Frigidaire dishwasher featuring the industry's fastest normal wash cycle. Shop fall savings now at the Home Depot. Offer value October 21st, US only. See store online for details.

From the publisher

Arthur Conan Doyle, a doctor, war volunteer, campaigner for justice, politician, and believer in the spirit world, created one of literature’s most famous characters. In his lifetime, he wrote ghost stories, political pamphlets, historical novels, and fantastical adventures.

But how did a young medical student from Edinburgh end up transforming crime fiction forever? What drove him to kill off - and then resurrect - the character who made him famous? And why did a man of science and reason spend so many years pursuing the supernatural? 

This is a Short History Of Arthur Conan Doyle.

A Noiser Production. Written by Sean Coleman. With thanks to Richard Pooley, the step-great-grandson of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. 

Get every episode of Short History Of... a week early with Noiser+. You’ll also get ad-free listening, bonus material and early access to shows across the Noiser podcast network. Click the subscription banner at the top of the feed to get started. Or go to noiser.com/subscriptions
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from Short History Of...

All episodes