1. Podcasts
  2. SmartLess
  3. "Dustin Hoffman"
SmartLess

9 Nov 2026 · 1h 8m · 21 chapters

In short

Dustin Hoffman discusses acting craft and career reflections, including how performances are shaped by directors/editors, his approach to internal honesty, and specific behind-the-scenes stories from major films. He also talks about eye contact, training influences (Strasberg/Meisner/Duvall/Hackman), and the making of Tootsie, including casting and makeup/voice challenges. He promotes his book Look at Me (released Nov 10).

Guests

Dustin Hoffman (two-time Academy Award winner; starred in The Graduate, Kramer vs. Kramer, Rain Man, All the President’s Men, Marathon Man, etc.). Other speakers are the SmartList hosts (not clearly identified in the transcript excerpt).

Key claims

Good acting can’t be fully defined; it’s about being fresh “in the moment.” He often doesn’t watch completed work because it’s painful and because editors/directors choose takes. He describes eye contact as intimate and explains how he learned to minimize it for roles.

Notable examples

Rain Man—he panicked on day one, then Barry Levinson showed him a monitor moment; he later used minimal eye contact. Tootsie—he fought script/production issues, worked on believable makeup for two years, studied voice choices (including avoiding a falsetto), and credits Elaine May for solving the third act quickly. He recounts meeting Bill Murray at Frank Price’s birthday party and how Murray’s costume improvisation helped define the roommate dynamic.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:50

Showering and Toothbrushes

The hosts discuss quirky habits surrounding personal hygiene.

“I was thinking about this the other day.”
4:19

Memories and Pools

The hosts share nostalgic memories related to pools and childhood.

“You don't pee in the pool anymore, do you?”
6:05

Introducing Dustin Hoffman

The hosts introduce the guest, the iconic actor Dustin Hoffman.

“So Willie gave me a book a while ago called The Silent Patient.”
7:52

Dustin Hoffman's Career Insights

Dustin shares insights about his career and personal reflections.

“And I can tell by the way you enjoy each other that you're making a lot of money together.”
14:01

Dustin's Acting Challenges

Dustin Hoffman shares his struggles during filming and the improvisation techniques he employed.

“And he picked the one that he thought would be best, and so I went with him.”
16:54

The Nature of Eye Contact

A discussion on the significance of eye contact in human interactions and acting.

“that's also another characteristic of this guy?”
19:02

The Improv Experience

Dustin reflects on uncomfortable experiences in acting classes and their impact on performance.

“And the first day was that, was that you had to pick up somebody in the class that you didn't know, and you had to stare at each other for like two or three minutes, which is a really long time in silence.”
21:43

Reflections on Acting Icons

A nostalgic look back at the early influences of actors like Brando and their impact on Dustin's career.

“It wasn't Rob Hudson or Tab Hunter or all these good-looking leading men.”
24:19

Brando's Unique Talent

Dustin elaborates on Marlon Brando's acting prowess and techniques that defined his legacy.

“Can I be what we all call in the moment, literally in the moment, in the present as you're doing it?”
29:19

Exploring the Depths of Acting

Dustin Hoffman discusses the nuances of acting and what makes it feel authentic.

“Like, what is generating that kind of originality and subtlety and honesty?”
Show all 21 chapters
30:28

Dustin Hoffman's Journey in Film

Hoffman shares insights about his early career and significant roles.

“Well, my first thought is I've been doing it for over 50 years, and these questions, the answers to these questions have changed over the years.”
33:08

The Making of Tootsie

Dustin Hoffman recounts the challenges and creativity behind the film Tootsie.

“Well, no, the tiger makes out was your first.”
36:58

Improvisation and Collaboration

Hoffman discusses improvisation in Tootsie and the contributions of key collaborators.

“I would shave as close as I could, and it would still, you could see the beard line because the follicles are underneath your skin, and you can never get rid of it.”
42:04

Dustin Hoffman's Insight on Sidney Pollack

Dustin Hoffman shares his experiences with director Sidney Pollack and how their creative tensions led to brilliant improvisation.

“and still alive, but she's brilliant in one way, but she doesn't know that she's wearing pants that her fly is unzipped or that she doesn't have a coffee.”
54:03

Dustin Hoffman's Memoir Writing Process

Dustin discusses the challenges and reflections of writing his memoir, including the importance of memory.

“that you've written this book, which I'm really excited about.”
56:00

Reflections on Memory and Aging

Dustin discusses the challenges of short-term memory and aging.

“there is such a thing as short-term memory.”
56:40

The Process of Writing a Memoir

Dustin shares his experience co-writing his memoir and the support he received.

“Did you have somebody that would help you sort of jog these memories?”
58:40

Memorable Experiences in Filmmaking

Dustin recounts experiences working with Sir Lawrence Olivier and the challenges they faced on set.

“but what surprised you about the things that you remembered?”
1:05:10

The Evolution of Acting

Dustin and the hosts discuss the evolution of acting and its impact on the industry.

“I say to actors or anybody when did you know you wanted to be an actor how old were you how did that happen and I said that to him And I said, you hear actors say things like, oh, I knew I had a gift.”
1:10:00

Dustin Hoffman's Impact and Inspiration

The hosts reflect on Dustin Hoffman's significant influence on their careers and the acting community.

“and it's wrong, because I studied with Strasberg, who started it.”
1:12:30

Memorable Performances and Movies

The hosts discuss their emotional connections to Hoffman's performances in films like 'Kramer vs. Kramer' and 'Rain Man'.

“And some of those people end up on this freaking show.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On SmartLess, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This episode of SmartList is sponsored by Google Book. So this may not surprise you, I have a lot of thoughts in my head. And my dream is to just blurt them out and somehow get them down on paper because my brain works way faster than my hands. That's where Google Book comes in. It's a whole new kind of laptop. No more typing, you just talk. And the Rambler feature cleans up your ums and uhs and all the times you change your mind. Basically, it turns messy thoughts into tidy text. Visit googlebook.com for details. Available in select countries and languages to 18-plus users. Check the responses for accuracy.

0:42Will Arnett: Did you ever notice the best deals are just obvious? Like hotels.com. What do they do, you may ask? Hotels on the internet. And a lot of them. Like hundreds of thousands. I don't know why I just turned into Sean Hayes. Plus, if you join for free, you can save up to 20 % instantly with member prices and you earn rewards every time you book. So your next trip basically starts paying for itself. It's simple and you get more out of every stay. Sign up for free and book today. Hotels.com. It's all in the name.

1:23If car shopping feels like a whole thing, buying your car online on AutoTrader makes it way easier. Really. Shop tons of cars online, compare prices, check financing and trade-in options from wherever you are, start online, test drive at the dealer, and finish wherever works for you. Your info stays with you, so there's no starting over. Plus, you're working with local dealers with real people there to help. Buy your car online on AutoTrader. Really.

2:00The place you call home is important to you. So, it's important to Allstate. Because home is where you make all your memories. Things like inviting your friends over for game night and discovering that one of them takes charades way, way too seriously. It's these memories that make a house feel like home. If it's important to you, it's important to Allstate. Switch to Allstate, and you could save hundreds on home insurance today. Not available in every state. Potential savings vary. Subject to terms and qualifications. Allstate North American Insurance Company and affiliates. Northbrook, Illinois.

2:42Ah, good morning! Good morning, everybody. This is your cold open. Let's get started. Welcome to Smartless.

2:54Smart. Lys.

3:01Smart. Lys.

3:07Smart.

3:09Sean Hayes: Lys.

3:12Sean Hayes: Can I ask you guys a question? Can I ask you? Yeah. I was thinking about this the other day. How do you feel about brushing your teeth in the shower? I'm not down with that. Oh, I used to love that.

3:20Will Arnett: I don't know anybody who does that.

3:21Sean Hayes: I know a lot of people who do that.

3:23Will Arnett: Yeah, and people shave too in the shower.

3:27Sean Hayes: Shave I kind of get. It's already happening. You got a mirror suction to the wall or whatever. Oh, do you? Really? Hang on, do you? That's interesting. But brushing your teeth, to me, it's like buying groceries at the pharmacy. Like, no, I don't want to buy milk.

3:44Will Arnett: And it's a bit of a waste of water, right? It takes a while there. It's a lot of water. Do you turn off the faucet when you brush your teeth in the sink? Great question. Thanks, man. Great question. I have an interview show on the computer.

3:59Sean Hayes: Have you been nominated for interviewing? I have not. Has anybody you work with been nominated for interviewing?

4:04Will Arnett: Yeah, yeah. A guy that I did, I actually did a show where there were three of us. And then one guy was singled out. Okay. And he ended up being the weakest link. We ended up firing him years later. But anyway, we'll be back with 2030. after these messages.

4:21Sean Hayes: What about... I do... Wait, do you pee in the shower at all? Yeah, pee in the shower, sure. Fine. Totally fine.

4:28Will Arnett: You don't pee in the pool anymore, do you?

4:31Sean Hayes: No.

4:31Will Arnett: Because you guys used to pee in the pool, right? You guys seen a couple of pool peers. I've peed in your pool. Have you? No, you've never been in my pool. I have once. Really? Yeah. Shawnee, you've never been in my pool. I've never been in it. I've been in yours, I think. No, I haven't.

4:46Sean Hayes: I've been in yours. Remember, Shawnee, when I was living in above your garage for a while? Wait, why? Hang on. Shawnee, that was almost 20 years ago. Yeah, and then I'd come home.

4:55Will Arnett: Wait, Will, why have you lived in my house and you've lived in Shawnee's house? What's the matter with you?

4:59Sean Hayes: Free. Yeah. Are you noticing a trend here? Uh-huh. Yeah, that's so true. I know. I'd come home and be like, where's Will? Look out. He's like splashing around in the pool in the back. Well, I was living in New York, and so I'm out there, and I'm like, look at these people got a pool out here in California. It's a beautiful day. I want to try to make. Remember when you were a kid and you knew somebody who had a pool and you'd be like, oh, my God. Yeah. It was huge.

5:22Will Arnett: Or pool table, right?

5:23Sean Hayes: Like a billiards table.

5:25Will Arnett: Yeah, or pool table, yeah. And you'd never – I never understood why my friends never played on their pool table all day long every day.

5:32Sean Hayes: Yeah, or somebody would have like a pinball machine. You're like, can we just play that now? And they're like, I guess. Yeah. I think pool is kind of like poker where like if a 10-year-old can do it, it's not that hard. Like a 10-year-old can play poker. Right. I don't know. Once you learn Texas Hold 'em. Like, you can play pool, too, right? I guess. He got nominated. He got nominated. I know.

5:57Will Arnett: We should include that he did not win. And if we went into the numbers, it was probably a distant fifth in that round. But I do want to say, wait, sidebar. Oh, yeah. Let's go. So Willie gave me a book a while ago called The Silent Patient. I'm almost done. Yes. The Silent Patient. and it was started because I was like envious of Will. Like he reads all the time. I was like, I kind of want to be a person that reads. Look at all these books. I don't read them. Yeah, I don't either. So now I want to start reading. I wonder if our surprise guest reads.

6:28Sean Hayes: Well, you know what? Now that we're there, our surprise guest, A, do I pretty much guarantee that he does read and B, he's just written a book himself. Oh, really? Yeah, which to add, which is insane considering to add to everything that he's ever done. His credits are almost without compare. He is a two-time Academy Award winner. He has starred in some of the greatest movies that I've ever seen. And, you know, once I start listing him, you're going to know. But I'm going to go in no particular order just because I'm going to try to confuse you, but I won't. I'm going to go All the President's Men, Marathon Men, The Graduate, it.

7:14Sean Hayes: Kramer versus Kramer. You guys, it is one of the great, all-time great actors and somebody I'm completely thrilled to meet you guys. It's Dustin Hoffman. The best. Is that better? Okay. Anyways, hello, gentlemen.

7:30Will Arnett: Now, Dustin, how come you're not my guest? What happened here? I don't even know how this happened, period. Oh, I do. My daughter, Allie, told me about this show. Hi, Allie. I literally hate all this mechanized stuff. I can't even work on iPhone, and you guys know how to do this. And I can tell by the way you enjoy each other that you're making a lot of money together. And I asked before the show started how much you're making, and I could not get an amount from your producer. Human beings are like that. They'd rather admit their infidelities than tell you how much money they get for something.

8:12Sure. That is true.

8:15Will Arnett: Dustin, how are things? It's great to see you, my friend. It's wonderful to see you. I mean, really wonderful. I'll just say, I think we met when we were doing Magorium, right? Yes. Yes, Mr. Magorium's Wonder Emporium. Right. And I remember we had a scene together, and I thought, oh, this guy's a new guy around the block. Let me see if I can help him. And I said, he knows what he's doing. I had no idea you were a child actor. Yeah, it started early and I haven't been able to shake it. I hope I'm around and doing it as well as you're doing it and be as relevant as you are. I mean, it's just like the career, Dustin.

8:57Will Arnett: Do you take a moment ever to pat yourself on the back privately? And you're just talking to us. No one's listening. You can admit it. Do you allow yourself to be proud of what you've done and the talent that you've shared with all of us? You want the truth, right? Please. It's close to it. I think, well, you guys are successful yourselves, so you can ask yourself the same question. Because with me, the truth is I always, it's like another person. I say, who is that guy? Right. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. You know, don't you do that yourself? Yeah. Yeah, and the media is somewhat responsible for that.

9:40Will Arnett: They have a job to do, so they create a bit of a profile too that they perpetuate or mold or adjust or destroy or build up. But, yeah, you go home and you just got you all day, every day, wherever you are. And so, yeah, there are two different things. But, you know, the product that you participate in, that you help to create, are you able to get some separate? Well, you know, like, well, I'm just saying, Well, let me finish. Like, you know, as a consumer, right, as an audience member, you end up watching or participate or buying that product. Like you watch the movies that you make, yes? And are you able to appreciate as a viewer, as an audience member, like, I like that stuff.

10:24Will Arnett: He's got my taste. I like what he does. You enjoy watching yourself. You still want an honest answer? Please. I don't know about you guys. Well, I don't know if you guys do something where you can look at it right after you've done it. I guess these podcasts you can listen to. Sure. But originally when I do a movie, I would always see the rushes first, right? And then I would complain about, you know, to myself, I did that wrong, I did that wrong, I want to do another one. And then you see the completed movie. and it's a drag actually because for a very real reason you try to do your best work when you're making a movie and you're not in the cutting room and someone else decides which take is your best take which is far from the truth and it's painful why did they use that take when you first see it and then I just never look at it again Yeah, yeah, yeah.

11:27Sean Hayes: But also there's that thing, it may not be your best take, but also at that point you've kind of, you have to give yourself up to the idea that for whatever, for better or for worse, that whoever's the director and the editor they're putting together and they're like, this serves the story better or this serves the movie better. Not necessarily, this might not be your best take, but this helps us in this way. And sometimes I get what you're saying is it's sometimes a hard pill to swallow. You're just like my wife. You're defending the other side. No, I know, of course. It always does that. Don't you know, there's an expression my friend tells me, which is that experts come from out of town, which is you can tell somebody something and then somebody else will say, and they'll go, hey, so-and-so said, and you're like, I've been saying that forever, and it's, yeah, experts come from out of town.

12:16Sean Hayes: You know, Dustin, I'm reminding, we're kind of all over the place here, but it just occurred to me hearing you say that and talking about looking at your work or looking at the rushes and saying, I could have done that better. I remember hearing your story and confirm if it's true. I remember somebody telling me, back when you were making Rain Man, which I thought was, you know, obviously like everybody else was incredible performance. And as a young guy who wanted to be an actor and watching that performance, thinking like, wow, like you can, somebody doing this in this way, like it was just mesmerizing, transforming really.

12:50And somebody told me that you would come home every night and think, Jesus, what the hell am I doing

12:55Sean Hayes: and I don't like what I'm doing. Was there any truth to that? Because that really affected me as a young actor hearing that story. Was there any truth to that? You still want the truth, right? Yeah, 100%.

13:05Will Arnett: Just until the 30-minute mark. Then the last half is lying. See, your rhythm of talking is very good because you're very, very good. I'll try to equal that. Okay. You could try. The first, I mean, I researched this part for probably almost two years because Tom Cruise kept getting movies that he had to make and then we'd say, okay, we'll start after he makes that movie. And they were bad movies that made a huge amount of money because he was in them like Cocktail and he was good. So I had all this time and I loved doing research and I actually met two guys who were brothers. One was very handsome like Tom and he was a great football player.

13:48He's 19. and his brother, Kevin, was a role model in terms of the part I played. I had two guys I found out of all the ones I met. And I said to Barry Levinson, who was brilliant, I thought, I said, which one? And he picked the one that he thought would be best, and so I went with him. And so the first day of shooting, we were shooting I think outside an elevator or something I can't even oh car we're outside and we're looking at a car and I am I look at the rushes I am so bad I literally said to my wife who was there I'm quitting and this was on the day this was on the day shooting it was before the rushes because there was monitor I said I don't know what I'm doing and I didn't I said half of it sounds like Midnight Cowboy and other sounds like Papillon.

14:45I literally didn't know. After all this research, I could not do anything that I felt had any. And Barry was brilliant, actually. He said, well, why don't you do this? He says, let's go see the rushes, the dailies, and see if there's anything that you like. And I went and we looked at it, and there was like one moment. I said, there, you just have a feeling. I said, there's the guy. He says, so do that. I says, I can't. So here I am in a car with Tom Cruise, who was extraordinarily generous and helpful. He's a really decent human being, despite his good looks. And we're in the convertible, I guess, and we're driving, and I cannot do the scene.

15:35because Barry Levinson said, do the scene, but it's 10-minute things of film, you know, roles of film. They're using film. And he says, and when we run out of film, just improvise. There's a hidden camera there because there was no room for the director. So it's just Tom and I and a hidden camera and we're acting away. Then we run out and he says, okay, just improvise because he's watching on a monitor and maybe he can use some of it. And as I said, there's a camera coming up this way, there's a camera that way, camera that way. So he's got a lot of positions to choose from without anybody operating them.

16:11And Tom starts doing all this wonderful improvisation, asking me questions. I don't have a clue how to be so-called the character so I don't know how to answer. And I go back afterwards and I said, Barry, I'm out of here. I cannot play this guy. I don't know. He says, come here, come here, come here. I think you found him. I said, what? He says, come here, look at the monitor. And he played it. And what I did without knowing it, and it wound up being in the movies, every time he said something, I kept saying, yeah, yeah. Yeah, because I didn't know what to say. He says, that's the guy. That's really cool.

16:48Wow, wow, wow. That's amazing. And is that the moment you realized also when you figured, oh, if I don't look at him, that's also another characteristic of this guy? Because through the whole movie, you barely made eye contact. No, no, no. I decided to do that before. Before, okay. I had my role models. But what you do, I think what you should do as an actor, is that you notice things and then you try to ape it and then you try to find what's in you where you do that thing that that guy is doing. And there was a couple things. And one is I realized, not just me, but we human beings don't make eye contact because it's too intimate if we're talking to people that we don't know.

17:28Like on an elevator, you don't even look at people. or if you do, it's briefly and then you look away. There's an intimacy I think in eye contact.

17:38Sean Hayes: Jason, stop staring at me, by the way. It should be... You know, Sean, I was going to say about that this is just a quick sidebar. Am I talking fast enough? No, no, no, it's amazing. This is a dream come true. What if I want to do this for three hours? Yeah, no problem. We've got plenty of film. Whatever, we've got plenty of film. I had to do one of these, you know, I started of this new gig and I had to do, for the company, I won't say who, they had to do, you know, because they're owned by corporations now, you have to do a sensitivity training video. You have to do a what? Sensitivity training video, like a half hour thing that you have to show up for on Zoom, right, for this thing that I'm doing.

18:18Sean Hayes: And they said, one of the things you can't do is you can't maintain eye contact. Longer than three seconds is considered, can be considered too much. I'm I'm not kidding. Really? Yes. Too much in terms of what? It's too intimate. It's too intimate. Longer than three seconds. So whether you're looking at a guy or a girl, more than three seconds means you're up. Yeah, HR's going to call you. Is there a little intimacy in our future? Yeah, so I'm making this limited series down. And the showrunner, she came up to me the other day. She had a note. She starts going, she goes, you know, well, I think in this scene, I go, one, two, three.

18:55Sean Hayes: I said, I'm sorry, your time's up. This is getting too intimate. That's really funny. I took some classes at Second City in Chicago, you know, the improv place. Oh, yeah. And the first day was that, was that you had to pick up somebody in the class that you didn't know, and you had to stare at each other for like two or three minutes, which is a really long time in silence. And it was the most uncomfortable thing I've ever done in my life. I'm like, hello, sir, nice to meet you. And then we ended up staring at each other right in the eyes. Yeah. It was crazy. I studied with Strasburg, and he had his own version of that because I know what you're talking about.

19:30And with Strasburg's cause, you stand up in front of whatever, it's 50, 60 students, and you had to sing a song and you had to make contact with one or more of the students in front of you, but you had to elongate my country. And you literally saw people start crying that we're doing this because there was something unmasked at them. And it was, oh, and the teacher would get up sometimes and you had to be totally relaxed. And they'd pull your arms up and they'd drop down. Some guys were so tense or people, they didn't realize it. They kept going, oh, they said they didn't realize. Did that ever happen to you, Jason?

20:13Wow.

20:13Will Arnett: No, I was just sort of imagining like that. The song exercise, that's what it was called. I did it.

20:17Sean Hayes: I did it. I studied at Strasburg. I did. I remember doing that, Dustin. Wow. Yeah. Yeah, I did. It's pretty crazy. Speaking of studying at Strasburg, so one of my favorite sort of things that I've learned about you over the years, because I've looked you up often, an embarrassing amount of times, is that when you were starting out and you were young, and my roommates and I used to always talk about this when we were living in New York studying at Strasburg in the early 90s, that you were roommates with Robert Duvall and Gene Hackman back in the day. No way. And that, yeah, and that, because we looked up to you guys and we were like, these guys, these guys all live together.

20:59Sean Hayes: They were doing it. And in some way, it allowed us to dream. We were friends and we hung out together and we were unemployed for almost 10 years. Yeah. Wow. And for us, we were like, not that we thought that we could be you guys, but it gave us hope because you were guys that we looked up to and we thought, these guys are really doing it. And how much, when you guys were back in those days, did you ever allow yourselves to think that you'd have the careers that you would? Did you talk about it? Never. No. Never, never, never. Well, because in our day, there were actors that had a different look.

21:39They didn't look like members of the audience. When we came about, suddenly the taste changed. It wasn't Rob Hudson or Tab Hunter or all these good-looking leading men. And suddenly there was this explosion that happened. You know, Jack Kerouac living in the moment, the 60s. And suddenly the public wants, at least with men, I don't think it was true with women. Women always ought to be beautiful. But the men wanted the stars, so-called, to look like them. The guys in the audience wanted to see people on the screen that looked like them. So we never thought about that. But what we, so, and we argued, we fought bitterly over whose teacher was better.

22:23Mine was Strasburg. Duval was a great teacher, Sandy Meisner. And George Morrison was, you know, Gene Hackman's. And, I mean, there were violent fights. I mean, Duval was standing out and saying, fucking bullshit. Sense memory, it's all bullshit. Meisner, it's improvisation. It's all improvisation. We were like angry. Right, right, right. And we didn't expect anything. what we wanted. Oh, the one thing we agreed on was who was bad, who was not having a good performance, the opposite of what critics would say. In those days, if you were British, you automatically got a good review. Every critic said, oh, that's a great actor.

23:05But the truth is what we agreed on is what was bad, and that was a unanimous feeling that we had. We were very critical of, well, that's a good moment. That's a good moment, you know, in our own work or within. I feel like I'm getting boring, so I'll share. No, no, no, no, no, no.

23:24Sean Hayes: But at that time, when you guys, and you guys were kind of like this next generation of actors, and you came and you studied with Strasburg, and you were saying Duvall studied with Sandy Meisner. At that time, when you were looking at movies, who were the guys that you did look at and go, Brando, Brando, Brando, Brando, Brando, Brando, Brando. That's it. Yeah, yeah, for sure. That was our hero. That was our god.

23:49Will Arnett: And if a gun was to your head and you had to give a description of what it is that sort of defined the quality, the high level of his talent, what would it be? Can you define what it is to be a good actor or what it looks like? Good question. Yes. I don't think it's different from you guys. can I do it in a way, a scene or a moment or the movie or the character, can I do it in a way that's never been done before? Can I do it in a fresh way? Can I be what we all call in the moment, literally in the moment, in the present as you're doing it? Kazan wrote a book and he talks about Brando on the waterfront and apparently Rod Steiger is his brother.

24:43It's a brilliant, brilliant scene. There's so many good actors today that never heard of it. Oh, yeah. Is he the guy that was in The Godfather? No, he was in On the Waterfront. There's no sense of history. And he's in the back seat with Rod Steiger and Rod Steiger pulls a gun on him. It's written that, well, you know what I'm talking about. And he can't do the scene. And he goes up to Kazan and he says, I can't do the scene, he's my brother. I know he's got noculation. And Kazan says, do it the way you feel it. And here is this brilliant, brilliant scene then. And if you guys aren't familiar with it, please watch it.

25:20He's in the car in the backseat. Roz Stiger pulls it, got on him because he's ratted. That's what it's about. Brando has ratted on somebody, which is another story. And he says, Charlie, Charlie. And he puts the gun, he just moves it lovingly almost away. And he said, Charlie, you're my brother. I can't imitate him, but there was such love in it. It's one of the most extraordinary things. And as Kazan said, only Brando would have done it that way. I know what he said. He says his pauses were more powerful than anybody's acting. His pauses, the amount of, the depth of information, the emotional information that was in him.

26:07Let's go.

26:08Will Arnett: and we will be right back. You know what stood the test of time? No, not bad haircuts and pretending to understand wine. For centuries, law has remained a remarkably consistent way of making our promises stick. A word becomes an agreement, an agreement becomes a contract, and a contract becomes bound by law. Now, Harvey, the AI platform designed specifically for legal work, is helping write the next chapter of that legacy. And Harvey's already pretty well established in the legal world. More than 200 ,000 lawyers, 80 % of the AmLaw100, and 20 % of the Fortune 500 are building with Harvey, accelerating review, sharpening negotiations, uncovering insights, drafting first responses, and more.

26:56Basically, Harvey is helping legal teams spend less time on repetitive work and more time on the big picture stuff. This is how the future of agreements as being crafted now. Harvey, learn more at Harvey.ai. That's Harvey.ai. Harvey does not provide legal advice. Users should always independently review and verify any output provided by Harvey.

27:18Will Arnett: Did you ever notice the best deals are just obvious? Like hotels.com. What do they do, you may ask? Hotels on the internet. And a lot of them, like hundreds of thousands. I don't know why I just turned into Sean Hayes. Plus, if you join for free, you can save up to 20 % instantly with member prices and you earn rewards every time you book. So your next trip basically starts paying for itself. It's simple and you get more out of every stay. Sign up for free and book today. Hotels.com. It's all in the name.

27:59Sitting in traffic, huh? watching an old lady with a walker make it further up the road than you have in the last 15 minutes. And of course, your gas tank is in the perfect spot between not a problem to stranded on the highway. Hit your booking point, book with Southwest and enter airplane mode. Experience award-winning reliability, fly with the best crew in the sky and never worry about change or cancellation fees. Now tell that old lady to slow down. Kids live around here. Southwest Airlines, enter airplane mode.

28:38Ready for a college degree, but your dog is giving you the side eye while silently judging your life choices? You need to check out Southern New Hampshire University. Their online programs make it possible to earn your degree without sacrificing sleep, sanity, or Scooby snacks. And there's real support from actual humans if you want that. So you can focus on what matters most, your dog. No, your future. Get the degree your dog approves of. Apply today at snhu.edu slash smartless.

29:15And now back to the show.

29:18Will Arnett: Do you feel like that, you know, like, I don't know, the pauses come as a result of what? Like, what is generating that kind of originality and subtlety and honesty? Is it, would you recommend that an actor really key off of what's going on internally as opposed to trying to focus on what you are showing externally? I mean, I guess, I don't know, I guess I'm not looking for the definition of what good acting is, I suppose, even though I asked for it, because it's such a hard thing to say. You're not looking for what? I mean, yeah, I mean, you can't really define what is good acting. I guess you kind of know it when you see it.

30:01Will Arnett: But for you, when you find that you're in a great place and that it's feeling good and honest to you, and even when you watch the rushes and, yes, I'm hitting, what do you feel like you're doing really well? Are you staying internal? Are you doing it for you? Are you conscious of the camera? Do you know? Like when does it feel right? What is it that you feel you're tapped into when you're doing it right? Well, my first thought is I've been doing it for over 50 years, and these questions, the answers to these questions have changed over the years. I mean, for the first few years, I was so frightened of the camera.

30:41And that's, you know, actors always say, you know, when you're off camera, you're helping the other actor sometimes if the camera's just on the other actor. And you say, God, why couldn't I have done that when I was on camera? You do your best work when you're off camera because you're relaxed. You're in the moment. And all that self-consciousness is taken away from you. The other part of it is you don't know. And it takes so long. In fact, just recently I was in a movie and I said, oh, I know what I'm going to do. Because it's endless in terms of thinking of new ways to do it. I'm just going to go.

31:19I have no idea what this movie is about. I have no idea what this character is about. It was with a great director, Coppola, and it was Megalopolis, and I didn't want to beat it. I said, I don't know who the fuck this guy is. I said, but he says, no, but he needed me in it. So, okay, I'll do it. Had a few days. And I had no idea, and I said, I know what I'll do. I'll just walk out during the scene, and he had multiple cameras, and I'll just, as you said, just be in the moment and not care. not care about anything and just be oh look at that look at that cameraman they're always saying you're in my eye line actors always say to another actor if the actor's on camera and he's looking at someone and he doesn't want to see him you're in my eye line they want him to move or the camera I said stay there don't move I want you in my eye line

32:14Will Arnett: it's real who's going to know that I'm talking to you that you're just standing out there. Yeah. Right. You know, there's...

32:22Sean Hayes: What did you take... Your first... It's actually your second movie, The Graduate, right? The Graduate is your second because you'd made... Was it The Tiger Makes Out was your first film? Yeah. Yeah. I'm crossing the street. I'm crossing... I did it because my friend Murray Shiskal, who was a co-writer with me on Tootsie, we've been friends for years and years and years and years. He was my mentor. I never knew about art before. I came to New York and met him. He took me to modern art, building all this art. He said, that's so-and-so. Can you tell me who that painter is? You learn who the painter is just by looking at the painting.

33:02He told me what literature to read. I mean, he was, my God, he was everything to me. And what he's, tell me the question again. I got a good answer.

33:11Sean Hayes: Well, no, the tiger makes out was your first. Oh, so I do the tiger makes out because he had written it for the theater first. They were one-act plays. The Typists was one play, the other play was called, and The Tiger, The Typist and The Tiger. By the way, he was a phenomena because he had written Love on Broadway, spelled L-U-V, and it was with Alan Arkin and, God, I should remember the actress's name, I'm ashamed of myself, and directed by Mike Nichols, and it broke the barriers. It suddenly introduced an avant-garde into commercial theater that was terrific. Anyway, so I do it. I'm crossing the street and I'm supposed to be saying, Rosie Krieger, goodbye Rosie.

34:03We've broken up or something. Goodbye Rosie Krieger. Goodbye Rosie Krieger. And the camera's on my back. The camera's not even close and I cross the street and that's it. And my parents see it. And they say, you were great in that scene in the park. I said, I wasn't in the scene in the park. They actually thought I was in another scene where the camera was like that. No way. And then you give them the graduate. What I wanted to say was it's interesting we're talking about all the acting and like Jason said was what makes a good actor and all that. And all I've thought about this whole time was, and forgive me because I'm sure you get asked about it every day of your life, is you actually played an acting teacher in Tootsie.

34:46And I just think it's ironic that we're talking about all of our insecurities as actors and finding characters. And there you are on screen teaching acting to this class in Tootsie, which is one of the greatest movies of all time and one of the greatest performances of all time. Thanks. Well, how do I answer this? Murray Schiskal and I wrote this movie and we couldn't get it right. There was a part of it that we somehow didn't. The third act, we couldn't make work. The culmination of it and what we wanted to do. This was not about playing a woman. This was about the intention that what started the whole movie is how most actors don't work.

35:37I mean, that's, you know, years and years and years go by and you can't even get your first job. Yeah, you could be in some community theater, but a job, you know, a real job you don't get for years and years. In fact, in my day, that was a signal that you were a good actor. The better actor that you were, the more unemployment there was. The ones that got work, again, were these actors who gave what we call result performances. They were predictable. And so I wanted to show how hard it was to get a job. So we created an artifice. Terry Gar, brilliant actress, I love her deeply, and then she departed too soon.

36:25It came about that she can't do auditions. We somehow made that work. Oh, well then I'll play your part and maybe I'll get a job. and somehow it just escalated from that point. Columbia Pictures, who I worked with before, and I said to them, I do not want to do this unless I can be believable in makeup, hair, as a woman. I do not want to walk down the street and have people turning in real life and say, who's that guy in drag? And it was very hard to get the makeup right. I can give you a long answer to this. You can edit it. But we have a beard. I would shave as close as I could, and it would still, you could see the beard line because the follicles are underneath your skin, and you can never get rid of it.

37:15And the makeup always looked fake. And then I thought, well, what about those people in Japan? I mean, this is over two years. Columbia agreed, okay, I don't have to make the movie until I'm believable. And there was these, what do they call them in Japan? The men that play women, they have a certain kind of makeup, and I tried using that makeup and it didn't work. Anyway, ba-ba-ba-ba-ba, we finally, with assortment of things, find a way. It's also the lighting, what kind of lighting I would need. And suddenly they say, okay, you're believable. And I have the, you know, took a long time to get the right kind of outfit because I have a 16 1⁄2-inch neck and that looked very masculine.

37:54So that dictated that I had to have an open blouse and so, et cetera, et cetera. I wanted to test it. My daughter Jenna, who's I think 52 now or something, she was like in the eighth grade and she was at school, I think the UN school downtown. And I said, I know, I know when they're all out in the back. I'm going to go there and test it out. And I went there in costume and I started talking. I went up to one of her teachers and started doing this best I could. And I got away with it. She was furious. and she came up to me. She says, get out of here, Dad. How can you do this to me?

38:33Will Arnett: Wait, so she recognized you. Your daughter recognized you? Oh, my God, yes. She was furious. And, oh, the voice, I can tell you very quickly about the voice. The voice was hard. And, you know, as an actor, you don't want to do what's been done and what was brilliant was something like it hot. They were brilliant. It was a brilliant film. But they were doing a very, it was a farce. So they were allowed to be a little less unbelievable because it's a style of farce. And they're doing falsetto. And I said, I don't want to do a falsetto voice. It sounds like those guys. And to me, this is very interesting.

39:10UCLA is near where I live. And I was able to go talk to voice experts that worked at UCLA, whether they help people at a STEM or whatever, but they exist. And this one person said to me, you know, one thing is that when women in those days particularly, this is in terms of the women's movement, this will be interesting. In those days, when women say something, it's almost as if they're asking for permission to talk. So they tend to end up, well, do you want to know something very interesting? Do you want to know? And they're up, men are always declaring, and this is the way it goes, and this is what I meet.

39:51And the woman will say, well, this is maybe what I, and I'm thinking, and I said, well, how am I going to, They say, well, he says, people in the South tend to do that. Well, you know, it's so interesting because what they do is they wind up up. And that was how the voice, which I, wow, you know, never really perfected. But you do the best you can. I think you did. Is that, you know, that's what made her Southern. Yeah. Is to wind up up instead of down.

40:20Sean Hayes: I think you perfected it pretty well. And that movie was, I mean, I echo Sean, one of the great performances and directed by the late great Sidney Pollack. I love your scenes with Sidney Pollack who acted in it, who played your agent in it. Hilarious. Your scenes with him when you come in and reveal yourself is one of my favorite scenes. And he's like, what are you doing? Have you lost? I forget. The Russian Tea Room. The Russian Tea Room. That scene between you two guys is one of the great, You talk about in the moment. Real, in the moment scenes between two guys and a guy who know each other well who's saying, what the, have you lost your fucking mind?

41:01Sean Hayes: And the other guy's like, hey, I'm doing it. That's improvised because he hated that I was improvising. By the way, the unspoken person who really saved this movie was none other than Elaine May. And Burt Field, I didn't have an agent. I hated agents because whenever I wanted an agent, needed an agent, there was never anybody. So suddenly when you're established, everybody wants to, fuck you. So I didn't have an agent. And I had a personal friend and an attorney, the late Burt Fields, wonderful man, and he said, I mean, we're trying for a year and a half. We have some of the best writers having tried this besides Murray and me, Larry Gelbar, but nobody for my money can solve it.

41:48and he says, have you tried a woman? And I was embarrassed to say, I can't believe we never tried a woman. He says, well, I have a client, Elaine May. He says, why don't you try her? She comes in, I'll say very quickly, she's a brilliant, brilliant human being and still alive, but she's brilliant in one way, but she doesn't know that she's wearing pants that her fly is unzipped or that she doesn't have a coffee. I mean, she has her own universe. and she said I'll tell you she read it within 24 hours and she said I'll tell you right now the Jessica Lange character is the one you're in love with she should be a drunk she should have a terrible boyfriend she should have a place in the country this is after 24 hours and she should have a father who falls in love with you in the country and that's how you get out and on and on and on it's never happened but she just had it and knew it and I still forgot the question.

42:48But she made that happen. That's amazing. That's so good. Oh, she was brilliant.

42:54Will Arnett: We were talking about the Sidney Pollack scenes and improvisation, but yeah, go ahead. No, so the Sidney Pollack, he and I fought every single day. Yeah, I saw the behind the scenes of that. Yeah, we hated each other. We loved each other and completely got along when we were shooting. We hated each other when we were working on the script. He hated Maurice Shiskell. I would come in with Maurice Shiskell's version for the day we're going to talk about. He had his own writer or more than one who were working. Everybody was trying to get the script right. And that's when we fought. Once we agreed, he was brilliant.

43:33And he did improvise ultimately, and he didn't want to. And that's not only the Russian tea room, do I think he was quite wonderful? In his office. In his office. Yeah, yeah. Incredible scene. It's all, it's improvised. And when you change from, you know, Dorothy Michaels, you're like, it's me, Michael Dorsey. And it is, George. It's really me. He just kept changing between Michael and Dorothy. It was great. Amazing. And he's brilliant. And I said to him, he never acted before. I think he started out as an actor, but he didn't believe in himself as an actor. And I said, we couldn't cast that part, at least to my satisfaction.

44:13And I said, Sidney, why don't you? We're trying a week after. I mean, we spent a lot of time rewriting, spent a lot of time trying to cast, get the look right. It's like a year and a half. Columbia said, take as much time as you want. It was Frank Price, thank God. And who was the head of Columbia and who started out as a waiter. Wow. Very interesting. Anyway, so take as much time as you want. Now I'm forgetting where I was. You're talking about Sidney Pollack. You're looking for the character. Yeah, so Sidney Pollack, so he's acting brilliantly on the money, and he was absolutely brilliant as the agent.

44:48And I said to him when we couldn't cast it, Sidney, you should play the part. Our arguing in life is exactly what these guys are doing on the screen. He said, no, no, no, I won't. And he lived in New York, and I lived in L.A., and I literally sent him roses every few days saying, please be my agent, love, Dorothy. and he kept saying no one after the other one after the other and he finally said yes and he was great. Oh, the irony here is he got all the work he could get afterwards, all the parts that would have come to me first suddenly came to him first.

45:22Will Arnett: Well, Dustin, speaking of casting, how did you land on Bill Murray? Was that somebody's idea? Was it the studio? Because that was early on in his career, right? Well, but he had been somewhat... He was a comedic actor.

45:35Sean Hayes: He was known as a, just like as a sort of a comedy guy. Did he come from Second City? I can't remember. Yeah, Second City and SNL. And so he had. Oh, SNL, right.

45:44Will Arnett: Yeah. But like, was that a piece of casting that the studio wanted you to think about? That's a good question. Or was it, or did it come from Sidney or the casting director or you? Was somebody a fan? I'm trying to remember. Yeah. Oh, I know what it was. I didn't know him. Yeah. And there was a birthday party for Frank Price. Yeah. The guy who was the head of Columbia. Right. And we all went to the birthday party. I think it was in New York. And we go there and, you know, ba-ba-ba-ba-ba. And then Lisa and I, we come outside. And outside is, you know, I don't want to be inside anymore. It's this guy, Bill Murray.

46:22Right. And we just, and I think he brought his Volkswagen. He's waiting for his car. And we just got to talking. And I had said to Lisa, because we had been working on Tootsie, you need a roommate. Elaine May says, you need a roommate. I said, how can I have a roommate? Someone my age in the movie is not going to have a roommate. He's going to be living with a girl. I mean, who has a roommate? It's just it didn't make sense to be that age. I mean, you live in a less expensive apartment in a hovel so that you could be alone. And then we got home and the next morning I said to Lisa, He said, that guy that I met last night, he could be my roommate.

47:04Wow. I believe him. Right. We just got on right away. We just had a sense. And so, yes, he got, and Sidney, of course, didn't want him. He wanted someone else with a part. He had to be talked to. And he says, Bill Murray, he's not an actor. He's a comedian. He's just done SNL or whatever. He's not a real actor. Back, back, back. So he finally agrees, and Bill Murray gets the part. And we have a building where we're shooting, I think on 22nd Street, a real apartment. And we wanted to have the roommate's bedroom on one side and my bedroom on the other side. So there was a distance between us. So there was a sense of not living as, quote, roommates.

47:47And they had fashioned his room or styled it. And he went in with Sidney. And Sidney, on purpose, didn't have him shoot his scenes until the last three weeks of shooting because he didn't want to take a chance. He was having such a rough time with me that he didn't want to have another guy that he was going to have a rough time with. And we're on the street first day and we're walking down the street and like rehearsing the Fifth Avenue scene and he sees a costume truck, which is our costume. Oh yeah, we're supposed to shoot. And he goes in there and the costumer had, you know how they do, they have their big truck at one of the hardest jobs in movies.

48:28I think there's no harder job than millions of choices. And he walks in, he just grabs this, that, the other, and he puts it on, and the costume goes, no, but what? And he walks out, and he just fashioned himself in the most ludicrous way, you know, whatever it was, orange pants, and he says, this is my costume. And Sidney is out about to argue with this guy, you know. And so that was it. Wow. So everything had to go through me because he didn't fuck around Bill. Oh, by the way, I have to tell you one thing, is that we became friends. What a wonderful man he is. But we went to see, he really is, and we went to see, in those days, I think we went to see a fight together or something, the Mass Garden, I can't remember, and we're coming out and we're in the lobby before we get out, and this guy keeps coming after me for an autograph and a video or whatever it was.

49:30And I'm in the middle of a conversation with Bill. And I said, well, I can't because I'm in the middle. But, you know, I always say yes because you get rid of people quicker if you just sign the autograph. And he keeps, and out of nowhere, Bill grabs him by the lapels and throws him against the wall. I mean, whoa. And he gets right in his face. I said, and this is not the Bill Murray that we know. And he says, you say one more fucking word. And you go, I mean, like that. And I said to him as we walked away, I says, Bill, where'd that come from? He says, you know, I'm Irish. I got five brothers and I'm from Chicago.

50:10What can I even say? I mean, that's the way it was.

50:13Sean Hayes: That's so good. My God, my God. There's so much we want to get. I want to get to. Oh, God, I want to ask you so many more questions. I know I can hear all the stories. By the way, it's so brilliant. Yeah, just as a, it's so brilliant to have the roommate. Of course you needed to have the roommate to give you that context of where Michael Dorsey's coming from, right? Yes, in other words, I'm sorry, Elaine says, are you going to have a voiceover? I says, no, we don't want a voiceover. Well, someone has to know what your thoughts are. Yeah, yeah. That's why he's there. Yeah, it's brilliant. It's brilliant.

50:44So you can express, I don't know if I can do this. I don't know what, you know.

50:47Sean Hayes: Yeah, yeah. We'll be right back. Investing with Schwab might remind you of one of your friends. Yes, the one who is smart, good at finances, and loves having it all. That one effortlessly cool friend who likes to mix and match their style by dressing up and down at the same time. You know, that suit and sneakers kind of thing. One minute it's tailored jacket energy, the next it's casual Friday energy, but somehow it always works. Because when you invest with Schwab, you can invest your way. Keep it casual by making your own trades here and there. Or keep it classy and put on your fancy pants with full-service wealth management.

51:30Sean Hayes: Or be like your buddy and do a little bit of both. Because sometimes you want to be hands-on, and other times you'd rather let someone else handle the details so you can get back to building an outfit that says, board meeting up top, weekend vibes down below. Visit schwab.com to learn more. That's S-C-H-W-A-B dot com.

51:55You know what stood the test of time? No, not bad haircuts and pretending to understand wine. For centuries, law has remained a remarkably consistent way of making our promises stick. A word becomes an agreement, an agreement becomes a contract, and a contract becomes bound by law. Now, Harvey, the AI platform designed specifically for legal work, is helping write the next chapter of that legacy. And Harvey is already pretty well established in the legal world. More than 200 ,000 lawyers, 80 % of the AmLaw100, and 20 % of the Fortune 500 are building with Harvey, accelerating review, sharpening negotiations, uncovering insights, drafting first responses, and more.

52:38Basically, Harvey is helping legal teams spend less time on repetitive work and more time on the big picture stuff. This is how the future of agreements is being crafted now. Harvey, learn more at Harvey.ai. That's Harvey.ai. Harvey does not provide legal advice. Users should always independently review and verify any output provided by Harvey.

53:02This episode of SmartList is brought to you in part by Skinny Pop Popcorn. Sometimes when you're in the snacking mood, it's easy not to have to think. Snacking should be simple, like Skinny Pop popcorn. It's made with quality ingredients and still delivers delicious flavor. Start with original Skinny Pop. It's made with just three simple ingredients so you don't need a science degree to understand what's in it. Feeling fancy but not too fancy? Give white cheddar a try. The sweet and salty kettle is always a family favorite and the butter variety, it never fails for nights that involve a couch, a screen and absolutely nowhere else to be.

53:38No matter the pick, Skinny Pop delivers light, airy, and endlessly delicious popcorn you can feel good about. Almost every night at my house is movie night, and that's when I grab the butter Skinny Pop. It's so delicious. Deliciously popped, perfectly seasoned Skinny Pop. Popular for a reason.

54:00And back to the show.

54:02Sean Hayes: I mentioned at the very top in the intro that you've written this book, which I'm really excited about. And talk a little bit about that. Your book, Look at Me, which is available, according to when this episode airs, it's available tomorrow, November 10th. Yeah, November 10th. You've written this book, Look at Me. Walk us through a little bit about that process of writing this book and what it was like kind of going back and going through all these things. As Jason pointed out, just this incredible career and life that you've had. Well, you know, you guys are asking basically brief questions and I'm giving long answers.

54:48No, we love it. You're supposed to. That's the seer hour. I have notebooks, you know, regular kind of notebooks that you buy in a store, you know, just regular notebooks, you know, you can get thin lines or wider lines. and I have maybe 30 notebooks over the years where I said this is the notebook where I'm going to write my, I had to know the difference between an autobiography and a memoir. Autobiography just means, you know, from, oh, I was born this, this, this, this. And a memoir has to do more with memories, your memories. It doesn't even have to be chronological order. And so I always would say my name, and I would say another thing, and I was given this name for this reason, two sentences, that's it, I can't do anymore.

55:37And I always thought it was a notebook, so I would buy a new notebook, a different kind of notebook. I'm looking for the right notebook, and here's all these notebooks piled up with two sentences on them. Then there's other memoirs being written, and I'm an old motherfucker, fart person, And if I don't do it now, you know, because I barely remember anything now, there is such a thing as short-term memory. And I always like to say things where other people, you know, it's like any of us say, did I eat breakfast this morning? Oh, yeah. You know, we all have that happen. I'm the worst. And when you're older, it's worse.

56:20Did I take a crap this morning? I literally can't remember. And I have notes now where, you know, I have a note in the kitchen saying, had my coffee at such and such a time. In the bathroom, there's a little note there saying, you know, took a crap at such. I have to go see where the notes are to know, you know.

56:37Will Arnett: Well, then what was the process like then writing the memoir? Did you have somebody that would help you sort of jog these memories? Thank you. Yes. And, well, first of all, the brain is an interesting instrument. I think it's, you know, the largest organ in the body. and we know the least amount about it. Before very recently, I think AI is solving stuff like that more quickly. However, we were told, I remember, we only understand 10 % of how the brain works. What about the other 90 %? So what happened with me and it's happened to others is with this lack of, I mean, with this short-term memory problem, Whoa, the brain opens up and suddenly you remember something that's 50 years ago.

57:25You remember the name of something. And somehow Simon and Schuster somehow had, I don't know if they got a hold of me or I got a hold, but, you know, Luke Janklow or something, they wanted a memoir. And they suggested, I said, I have not been able to do it. and they suggested this woman and she was my savior and she and I co-wrote it and what she did, which no one else first of all she put everything on a what we used to call a tape recorder but everything was there she'd ask me questions, she'd go home with hours and hours and hours so you can see how long I can talk and she would have it all transcribed to written and then she would edit it and then she'd come back and she did something I thought was quite extraordinary.

58:17We'd talk, talk, talk, talk, talk. She asked questions, wonderful questions. And then after some of the questions, I'd give her an answer and she would ask me questions about my answers. Yeah. And that was brilliant. And that's what opened up this world because we repress a lot, a lot of stuff we don't want to remember.

58:38Will Arnett: I'm sure you would say a lot as an answer to this question, but what surprised you about the things that you remembered? Was there a memory that came back to you that was particularly more welcome than any other? Something that you were surprised that you remembered? A lot of them. Well, look at me. I'll tell you why it's called that. Is that okay? Yeah. Okay. I worked, I was doing a, I knew Bob Evans, who was at that time head of Paramount, and he was brilliant, even if he had, you know, an ice cube full of cocaine halfway out of his nose. He was a brilliant producer. I mean, Love Story, Godfather.

59:31I mean, he had a string. He knew, he knew about which film should be done. and he approached me because Marathon Man, I think, was being done by Paramount and he approached me, you know, that I should do it and I said certain things and he said, and I know who should be the Nazi character, Zell. It should be Sir Lawrence Olivier. I mean, how could he have come up with that? He went to London and he asked Olivier to do it. Olivier said, no, we didn't want to do it. The poor man was ill. He had gout. He had different forms, I think, of cancer. He was on a lot of medication. And he knew he was ultimately terminal.

1:00:23I never understand what that means because we're all ultimately terminal. But anyway, he wanted money. He had no money. he'd spend a lifetime doing a lot of stage work. And here this guy is saying, I'll give you a million dollars. And he decides to do it. And I know he had one of the sons was at UCLA. He used to come visit him every day. And so here he is. And parenthetically, this guy would do, I mean, in his day, they did repertory theater there. So in one week he would do Hamlet, Macbeth, King Lear, knew all three of them word by word, tremendous kind of equipment you have to have to have been a repertory actor.

1:01:11And here he is and he comes to work the first day and we are shooting and he can't remember two sentences together because of the meds. And he's in pain because of the gout. It's this much bigger. and he never complains and Schlesinger, brilliant director John Schlesinger is there and then he figures okay we have wide shots and we get closer and closer and then finally they get right on him and I would try to coach him off camera and then he started he would do takes because he was a stage actor so one of the things about having a craft as an actor to be a stage actor, a good one, you have to be real for the people in the first row and you have to be as real for them as you are for the people in the last row of the balcony.

1:02:09That's called craft. I wasn't great at it. But that's what the great actors, stage actors, could do. And here he is now on a close-up and he's like talking to the rafters and he's acting big. quote, not good, but quote, big. And I start to walk up to Schlesinger, who's British? And he just goes, I know, I know, I know. I know what you're going to say. I'm not going to tell the greatest actor in the world that he's over the top. If you want to tell him, you tell him. Bad accent. So we have a break. We're outside, and we go behind a tree, and I say to, I couldn't call him, I didn't want to call him Sir.

1:02:53I didn't want to call him Sir Lawrence. I didn't want to call him Larry which a lot of people call him so then I called him Lordage and he liked that oh by the way his performance and I told him your performance in The Entertainer is one of the great performances I've ever seen on screen have you guys ever seen it? no I haven't, I've never seen that and he plays a guy with a certain kind of cockney accent and he's like a song and dance man from outside of London and almost campy and fey. And I said to him, when I started working with him, I said, that performance you gave in The Entertainer is one of the most brilliant.

1:03:33And he said to me, that's me. That's where I'm from. That's what I started out doing. Wow. Tap Danzy, trying to get a job. He says, Sir Lawrence, the Shakespearean actor, that's the act. Wow. That's interesting. That's not, but this is me. so I say to him I said why don't we just run the lines a little bit you know how we run the lines we just try to get the lines back before we're on a break and we start to do that and then I say you know what when we go back now and do your close up why don't you just do one where you're you know it's like when we just run the lines just do it like that like you're just reading the lines aloud and he gives me a long look and he's you know, that close, long look.

1:04:25And he says, are you saying to me that I'm over the top? That's what they say, which means like ham acting. And I'm like Woody Allen. Oh, no, I... And I said, pause, long pause. One of the greatest moments of my life, he looks at me and he says, thank you. Wow. And we were very close friends from that moment on. and I asked him about parts he had done we just became great friends and one of the things I said to him was let me ask you something I always say this I probably said it to you guys how did you know you wanted to be what you are I say to actors or anybody when did you know you wanted to be an actor how old were you how did that happen and I said that to him And I said, you hear actors say things like, oh, I knew I had a gift.

1:05:23I was born with a talent or I wanted to share my all this. And every time I'd say something, he'd say bollocks, bollocks, bollocks, which is a British term. Instead of saying bullshit, they say bollocks, which is a combination of balls and cock. Literally, it's bollocks. That's their way of saying bullshit. Bollocks, bollocks. And I said, then what's the real reason? And he comes up to me and he looks me nose to nose. He says, the real reason we act? I says, yes. Look at me, look at me, look at me, look at me, look at me, look at me. And I got chills. Wow. That's what it is. And that's why the name of the book is the name of the book.

1:06:00And that's all of us. Yeah. Whether we're writers or painters or whatever, it's a way of saying I'm here, I'm alive, I exist. Look at me. See me. Even if it's not literally. Yeah. Wow. Wow.

1:06:16Will Arnett: Incredible. this is this will be a hacky a hacky segue but we have certainly seen you uh a whole bunch uh and and we're all the better for it for so so long dustin i mean yeah as i said at the beginning the the amount of work that you've done and you've never been terrible yeah i mean oh no don't say that no no that's just not true i mean i've not acted as much as other people gene hackman i mean he didn't like his home life so he probably did five movies a year everything he you know they say yeah i'll do it but i barely did one a year i was so particular more particular than i should have been because after the graduate hit you know suddenly i'm getting all these scripts and most of them are are not good and uh in fact i would say to lisa my wife i would say you know this script doesn't work and she says you know what it took her years to say this it was so smart she says don't take a part because of the script.

1:07:19Forget about the script. The script changes. The minute you say you're doing it, you and the director, you work on it, it becomes a different animal. When you start shooting, it's a different animal, usually. I said, then what should determine whether... She says, the director. The director. I had already turned down Fellini. I had already turned down Ingmar Bergman. This is what a schmuck I was. Wow. because the material, I thought, had problems. She doesn't work with the director. Right, I agree. Anyway. Well, Justin, you chose wisely.

1:07:54Will Arnett: Yeah, and thank God, whatever you've done, thank God you've done it because, I mean, I'm sure I speak for Will and Sean, but I will definitely just speak for me. It is because of you I do what I do. No, don't say that. No, no, no, it is 1 ,000 % true. When I started acting, I was 10, so this was 1979. So you can remember whatever you were doing then was a time. What year was it when you were 10? 1979. Oh, 79. And so all through the 80s. Kramer versus Kramer. That's Kramer. I mean, but you, Robert De Niro, and Al Pacino, you were it. And thank God that you guys had, you know, what you were talking about earlier with you and Duvall and Hackman talking about, you know, You weren't just getting the roles because all the leading men were taking all the big roles.

1:08:47Will Arnett: And then you guys, the character actors, became the leading men. And you changed what the definition of good acting was. It was no longer this sort of performative, posing, sort of eye candy leading men. The new bar was, well, you've got to act. You've got to bring character acting level of performance to the leading man part. And so all those movies that I was watching that you guys were doing, you know, you mentioned, you know, Papillon before. And, you know, it's just thank you for doing what you did. Thank you for changing what we define as good acting. And you are the gold standard. And you continue to be.

1:09:31Will Arnett: And the fact that I got a chance to work with you blew my mind. The chance that you're on our little podcast here blows my mind, too. And I love your friendship. I love hearing the things you say, and just thank you from the bottom of my heart. Yeah, it's true. Can I disagree with you, or is that a sign off? No, you can't. No, you can't disagree. Yeah, you can't take it. I do disagree. I do, because we didn't invent it. There always was good acting. It wasn't called method acting, and every actor has a different interpretation of what method acting is, and it's wrong, because I studied with Strasberg, who started it.

1:10:07There was Spencer Tracy, brilliant actor. Yeah. Kim Stanley, a brilliant actress, was just brilliant. I mean, there's always been great acting. But for us.

1:10:20Will Arnett: But for us, you know, you were it and you are it. And I just can't thank you enough for working as hard as you've worked and for being as talented as you are.

1:10:34Sean Hayes: Thank you. And I will say, Dustin, to echo Jason, what Jason said, not just, you know, obviously for us, the three of us, you've been an incredible inspiration. But I can tell you, like I said, that my roommates and I in the 90s when we were starting out and we were not alone, you were such an inspiration for so many, like Jason or like Sean or like me, but so many others who don't have this platform to be able to say it and to tell you that, that what an inspiration you were and what you did, it was fuel for us to see what you guys were doing, to see what you were doing. You were the gold standard and are the gold standard for us.

1:11:10Sean Hayes: I was one of them. I was one of them. There's Pacino and, you know, Dog Day Afternoon, Serpico. There's De Niro. De Niro, yeah. But that was it.

1:11:18Will Arnett: I mean, three. That was it. That's it. Maybe. And so, thank you. Oh, come here. Let me show them. Okay, this way I can end it. Who's got dogs? I do. We all do. Who else? I have had dogs. Oh, wow. What kind of doggy is that? That's a mutt, a rescue dog that Allie found downtown when he was a teeny little puppy, and he was under a car, and it was raining, and it was at night, and he had no ID on him. And she gave him to us, and we've had him now for 10 years. And we had to name him, and we couldn't figure out a name. And Lisa, suddenly we were looking at, and we saw a book that the great rabbi friend of ours, Leonard, had written.

1:12:04and she says, how about Leonard? And his name is Leonard. This is Leonard.

1:12:09Will Arnett: I love it. Leonard Bierman was his name. Give Mr. Bierman a kiss for us and say hi to your beautiful kids and your beautiful wife, Lisa, please. Thank you. I hope I get to see you guys in real life. Likewise, Dustin. Thank you for your time.

1:12:23Sean Hayes: I mean, it's just been wonderful. What a thrill. Thank you so much, Dustin. Thanks, guys. Thanks, Dustin. Thank you, buddy. Wow, wow.

1:12:30Will Arnett: wow yeah it made me a little emotional you know you you think about it which i don't know we say it all the time but yeah but we're just we're so lucky that that we get to talk to people that affect us so so deeply like you know i mean i don't think uh any one of us are are jaded um we certainly appreciate these we have heroes we've got these people that we look up to we're we're The three of us are huge fans of so many different people. And some of those people end up on this freaking show. I know. And we get to ask them questions on a peer level. And he goes beyond hero for me. As I said, you know, he was part of the reason I do what I do.

1:13:16Will Arnett: And it just, it gets me a little weepy to be able to speak to him. And as you said, we'll have the opportunity. we have an opportunity to say to them directly how much they mean to us. And it is such a gift. So anybody listening out there that might feel the same way, we do it for you as well. It's just such a privilege to be able to spend this time with these people. Yeah, I totally agree.

1:13:42Sean Hayes: Me too. And I meant that like it's so true. We did. I know this is like the fourth time I've said it, but because it's hitting me because it is important. like how many times we as a young actor was like fucking dustin hoffman yeah totally all the time how much we talked about his performances and moments you know you talk about mo hey did you see that thing he did in that moment he had you know we talked about the tootsie that his scene with sydney pollack and the i mean that whole movie is full of incredible moment but like that we got to talk to him about the russian tea room scene yeah i know we got to talk to Dustin Hoffman about the tea room scene in Tootsie Man.

1:14:22Sean Hayes: I know.

1:14:22Will Arnett: We didn't even talk about Kramer versus Kramer. Kramer, I know. I maybe cried harder in that film than any other film I've ever seen. Yeah. And just based on his looks, just the way that he looked at her, the heartbreak he had with her in the courtroom scenes. That movie. And the tenderness with his boy. You know, it's all performance, you know. I mean, yes, the script obviously was beautifully written and the film was well-directed, obviously. I mean, I think it won Best Picture, didn't it? But just his ability to be a human for all of us as a proxy, sitting in the audience, just kind of living through these moments that he does is just such a talent.

1:15:03Yeah, there's many performances I think we can all point to that made us want to do this. And Kramer vs. Kramer was one of them. Rain Man was another. And I remember seeing Rain Man going, if I can just, if I could be even a fraction of that good, like I'd kill to play something like that. Like all the, like there's so many parts, even in Hook. I was like, he played Captain Hook. I was like, that's so cool. You know, like he's completely transformed in the way he talked and the way he moved. And I don't know, it's just, he's incredible. Anyway, you know, well.

1:15:35Will Arnett: Such a sweet man and so funny. And Lisa, his partner of so, so many years, is such a wonderful person and his kids are fantastic and talented in their own right as well. So that was awesome.

1:15:50Sean Hayes: Thank you, Will. Yeah, no, thank you. And I'm going to say in honor of the great Dustin Hoffman, I'm going to just say a really simple, bye. Oh, a tasteful bye. Oh, very introvert.

1:16:03Will Arnett: Hey, everybody out there in the audience, bye. Bye, bye, you guys. Bye, bye, baby. Smart.

1:16:17Smart. Less.

1:16:22Sean Hayes: Smartless is 100 % organic and artisanally handcrafted by Rob Armjarf, Bennett Barbaco, and Michael Grantary.

1:16:35Smart. Less. Being safer on the road starts with the person behind the wheel. That's Mazda's philosophy when designing every vehicle. Their proactive safety features help keep you more aware, connected, and engaged during every drive, which means your car does more than help protect you. It helps make you a safer driver, which helps protect everyone. That's why Mazda has been named Consumer Reports' safest new car brand. To learn more, visit mazdausa.com. Consumer Reports does not endorse products or services.

1:17:19Sean Hayes: Keep your family safe with help from Menards. From smoke and carbon monoxide detectors to fire extinguishers and more, KIDA Home Safety Products keep your family protected in case of emergencies. KIDA detectors feature enhanced sensing technology that reduces false alarms and gives you faster alerts.

1:17:37Will Arnett: For more time to get out safely, check out all our KIDA safety products on Menards.com. Plus, view our weekly flyer for more great deals happening now.

From the publisher

We’re in the moment with Dustin Hoffman. Questions on answers— what we used to call a “tape recorder,” memory, quitting, running lines with Sir Laurence, and of course: who’s got dogs? “What’s in you where you do that thing that that guy is doing?” … on an all-new SmartLess.

Subscribe to SiriusXM Podcasts+ to listen to new episodes of SmartLess ad-free and a whole week early.
Start a free trial now on Apple Podcasts or by visiting siriusxm.com/podcastsplus.


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

More from SmartLess

All episodes