1. Podcasts
  2. So True with Caleb Hearon
  3. Whitmer Thomas is Still Cool
So True with Caleb Hearon

1 Oct 2026 · 1h 20m · 33 chapters

Episode artwork

Whitmer Thomas is Still Cool

In short

Whitmer Thomas discusses midlife crisis anxieties, mental health, and how fame/reviews affect family and self-perception. He connects these feelings to creative work, gratitude, and the pressure to stay “cool,” including skateboarding, transportation choices, and coping habits (NyQuil and CBD). He also reflects on how money, health insurance, and life’s ongoing problems shape happiness.

Guests

Whitmer Thomas (comedian; also filmmaker/actor; discusses comedy specials and a new comedy special; therapy; Al-Anon; skateboarding; Letterboxd review anxiety). Caleb (co-host/other guest; makes a fictionalized movie about his dad passing; talks about family emails, review backlash, and a childhood story involving a woman’s daughter; also mentions a special about his mom).

Key claims

“Midlife crisis” is partly wanting to be wanted/seen as young and cool, plus regret after dreams come true. Reviews can distort how loved ones interpret trauma. Happiness can come from being broke/early-career innocence, but gratitude must be practiced deliberately. Life isn’t a future fix; it’s managing problems now.

Notable examples

NyQuil + CBD before an interview; airplane CBD edible history; skateboarding shame vs public coolness; family sending Letterboxd reviews; Norm Macdonald telling him “this is the best time”; Caleb’s email to family about his dad-passing film; a stranger confronting Whitmer about his mom-special; dental/health-insurance “nightmare” period.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Reflecting on Past Experiences with Substances

The hosts discuss their experiences with substances and how they affect their moods.

“Yeah, I didn't get into weed at all until I was like 27.”
2:04

Improv and Comedy Dynamics

Conversation shifts to improv techniques and the hosts' experiences in comedy.

“The cultural garb that she's not supposed to be wearing.”
3:22

New York Comedy Scene

Discussion about the New York comedy scene and the challenges of navigating it.

“And then I'd see an opening for me to tell a long story.”
5:46

Life in Comedy and Its Dark Realities

The hosts touch on serious issues within the comedy community, including mental health.

“I always say when I'm here that I don't ever know where I am or how to get anywhere.”
8:00

Midlife Crisis and Self-Perception

A candid discussion about midlife crises and perceptions of self-worth.

“and then it'll just be like, oh, yeah, memorial posts.”
11:04

Family Dynamics and Creative Work

Hosts share their experiences with family reactions to creative projects.

“And I skateboard and yeah, my bones hurt.”
14:03

Navigating Family Reactions to Personal Stories

Learn about the challenges of sharing personal stories and how family might react to them.

“They're going to say things in the reviews that might not feel like what you experienced when dad died.”
14:40

The Complexity of Grief and Public Perception

Explore the intricacies of grief and how public commentary can impact personal relationships.

“And I finally wrote the email last night and sent it.”
15:16

Reflections on Comedy and Family Dynamics

Discussion on using comedy to process family dynamics and childhood memories.

“And so anyway, I was the reviews thing is so interesting because I'm like I wonder how much of that stuff they see.”
16:46

Strange Encounters and Misunderstandings

Hear a funny and awkward story about a past crush and a stranger's judgment.

“and I was like out in Alabama and I had some family thing and this lady came up to me and she's like, hey, do you remember me?”
Show all 33 chapters
19:29

Dealing with Criticism and Personal Growth

Insights on how to handle criticism and focus on personal growth in creative work.

“I give like three people in my life permission to read the bad stuff and relay in nicer terms anything to me that could be constructive.”
21:08

Midlife Reflections and Career Satisfaction

Contemplation on career satisfaction and the challenges of aging.

“And I think, I'm so curious to see the click-off rate like they do on Instagram.”
24:49

The Illusion of Success and Personal Fulfillment

Understanding how achieving dreams doesn't guarantee personal happiness or fulfillment.

“who drinks margaritas and isn't hungover for three weeks?”
28:00

Reflections on Broadway Dreams

Discussing the disillusionment of achieving lifelong dreams and the existential questions that arise afterward.

“We, I was, well, I don't want to say what we were doing, but let's just say we weren't face-to-face.”
29:40

Confronting Life's Challenges

Exploring the difficulty of managing expectations and the inevitability of life's problems.

“And she was like, right, so do we need to?”
35:12

The Journey to Happiness

Reflecting on the dichotomy of happiness during struggles and the importance of perspective.

“Yeah, I think it is all going to work out.”
38:10

Finding Joy in the Past and Present

Discussing the nostalgia of early career struggles and the importance of celebrating achievements.

“and I'll always, I think everybody will feel like unsuccessful in a lot of ways.”
42:00

Celebrating Artistic Success

Learn about the importance of celebrating your creative achievements without feeling jaded.

“embarrassed almost i was like what if what if people in the film industry who know that these always sell out see me posting about this and think i'm like i don't know that and i'm like and I'm like immature or silly.”
44:10

Navigating Vulnerability in Comedy

Explore how vulnerability and authenticity can enhance your comedic persona.

“Your comedic persona isn't like a character, you know, where maybe then the mystery is okay because you don't really want to let people in.”
47:25

Reflecting on Personal Narratives

Understand how personal experiences shape creative work and self-identity.

“I was really sad about it because I love him.”
49:20

Responsibility and Personal Growth

Discuss the importance of taking responsibility for one's actions and moving beyond childhood narratives.

“Especially with my first comedy special where, like, it caused a lot of, you know, like a big complex.”
52:55

Comedy and Authentic Expression

Discover how comedians can engage in raw and unfiltered expression while addressing sensitive topics.

“He won't ever actually let me know what he thinks of something.”
56:01

Plans for Comedy Specials

Caleb and Wit discuss the idea of doing separate comedy specials simultaneously.

“We get involved in the Austin, Texas comedy scene.”
57:03

Thoughts on Comedy Venues

The hosts share their experiences and thoughts on what makes a good comedy venue.

“The guy who at least likes to see himself as a comic, and that is important, unfortunately.”
58:29

Social Dynamics in Public Spaces

Caleb reflects on social behaviors in public settings and the importance of influential actions.

1:00:08

Biking Adventures and Unexpected Encounters

Caleb recounts a memorable experience biking with a group and the joy of community.

1:02:04

Reflections on Life Choices

The hosts discuss their feelings about friends' life choices and personal growth.

“The cross necklace is the official end of like, they've been becoming uncool for many years.”
1:04:26

Understanding Different Perspectives

Caleb and Wit explore how people cope with life through different beliefs and choices.

“how, uh, confusing and hard it is to be alive.”
1:06:10

Comedy Specials and Industry Connections

Caleb discusses how he got his special greenlit through a heartfelt letter to HBO.

“It just is like, yeah, that's my version of it is not going to be their version of it and that does make me a little bit sad and I think that's okay.”
1:10:01

The HBO Guilt Trip

Whitmer discusses how a guilt trip led to his HBO special.

“some people choose heroin, colon, como se dice, do your thing, girl.”
1:10:59

Playing True or False

A fun game segment where players answer trivia questions.

“You're going to tell me as quickly as you can if what I just said was true or false.”
1:13:47

Memorable Experiences at Lambert's

Whitmer shares nostalgic experiences at Lambert's restaurant.

“You go to Lambert's and you go, I'm still hungry.”
1:15:29

Dreams of Branson and Hollywood

Discussion on childhood dreams related to the entertainment scene in Branson.

“Well, Branson is kind of a tourist town.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On So True with Caleb Hearon, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01Wave. Or if I feel sad or upset, I don't say anything about it. And somebody will be like, are you okay? And I'll be like, what would Jack Nicholson have to say about that? Even though, like, I'm in that moment, I'm, like, devastated. Right.

0:22How you doing? I'm doing okay. Yeah? Yeah, I took a NyQuil and smoked a weed CBD thing to go to sleep last night. And so I do feel kind of like fucked up. I thought you were going to say before this, just to level out. Right before I walked in here, I took some NyQuil and smoked a CBD thing. I used to do it every time I got into an airplane. And then I was like, why do I feel depressed and awful all the time? This is like 18 to 21. Yeah, I didn't get into weed at all until I was like 27. and then maybe like a year into that I started trying to do the edible on a plane thing. It happened to maybe three flights and that first time that I was high away I didn't like and trapped in the air, I said we won't be doing this anymore.

1:06Because you can't do anything. You're just fucking sitting there like tweaking and it's like I don't want this. You're stuck and paranoid. I was just doing the NyQuil on the plane back then and I didn't smoke weed. I smoked weed the first time when I was maybe 25 and it wasn't smoked. It was like tincture, oil, whatever that shit is. Have you ever seen that? And it was on my birthday, and a girl that I had a crush on would like squeeze it onto my tongue, and I didn't feel anything after one minute. And I was like, I don't think it's working. And then she did it again, and I was high for three days.

1:40Three days. Whatever happened, and that's Nancy Pelosi. Yeah. That girl was Nancy Pelosi. Best sex of my life. Yeah. Only. That's. Are you serious? That's really beautiful. You and Nancy only doing... Yeah, she said it's the only way she gets off.

2:01I really love that. I really love that. She does the kneel afterwards. Yeah. Her little famous kneel. But she puts on the, like... The cultural garb that she's not supposed to be wearing. But it's all different. What people don't know is it's all different kinds of cultural garb that she's not supposed to wear. Like, she has an Indian headdress or a Native American headdress. Yeah. She's got all the stuff. She'll put a dot right here. She'll do it all. Yeah. That's why she's a fucking freak. It's fun. She's so fun. God, I love that girl. I haven't hooked up with her in years. What? I know. It sucks.

2:31She just got so busy with work and everything. And plus, just as you grow older, people grow apart. They do grow apart. Do you know what I mean? Like, it just sucks. Like, she and I, we used to have so much in common, but then it's like, she's in Congress. I'm a comedian. It just, yeah. It sucks. Yeah. I mean, yeah. Last time I saw her was at the Waxahachie show. and she likes their old stuff. So she was kind of bummed. She's like a big P.S. Eliot fan. Yeah, she was only playing like Tiger's Blood and stuff. Yeah. Yeah, I texted Nancy like two weeks ago because they announced they're not going to do Bonnaroo next year.

3:06And I was like, she'll be in the dumps because she fucking loves Bonnaroo. And so I texted her and I was like, hey, I heard about Bonnaroo. I hope you're okay. She didn't text back, which is fine. but yeah it just sucks because we used to go to Bonnaroo like every year man and do it what do you think about how I just conked out on the improv towards the end there and I couldn't think of anything it was completely beautiful and what the the good thing about that bit is it was dead seven seconds into it and we decided to go ahead and keep her running that's what it was like whenever I did improv I tried for like a year and I would just stand on the back line and I I would look at all the other improvisers and be like they probably got something better than me and then I'd just keep standing back there.

3:46Y 'all got it. Y 'all got it. And then I'd see an opening for me to tell a long story. Yeah. Here's where I'd jump in. I love that. I was, I don't, what was I like as an improviser, Chance? You were very smart and very tactful, but also would like randomly get extremely physical. Yeah, that's true. I would start throwing people. Yeah, well, that's because. Throw me through a window one time. Yeah, that was mostly, when I'm with straight guys, doing improv, I know what you guys like. You guys like to be thrown around a little bit. You like it to be like that. When I was with the girls, of course I would tone it down.

4:23We had an improv team for a while, Chance and I, and two of our buddies from college. They're all straight guys and me. If I got bored with some dialogue they were doing, I would just initiate a fight scene.

4:38That was beautiful. Gabby Boyd joined that team eventually. Then Gabby was in there. And then Gabby and I would do like, uh, we would do like grounded emotional scenes together. And then the boys would like sweep it and be like, or whatever the fuck. And Gabby and I would sit on the sidelines and be like, God, I wish there was more girls and gay guys here. And then eventually there was right. Then eventually there were more girls and gay guys. Yeah. And improvisation. I just had, we, Asher, we recorded with Asher Perlman yesterday and we started talking about improv and he was like, everyone just turned the episode off.

5:08And I was like, yeah. I met Asher in Chicago in 2015. I was doing stand-up up whatever that old comedy club was. Up. Up, I think is what it was called. Up? Above Second City. Oh, the Up. Yeah, yeah, yeah, the Up. Is it called the Up Room? The Up Comedy Club. Yeah. And then I did the story, the monologue at the end. Asher was so funny. Asher's a good kid. He's a good kid. He's got a bright future, good head on his shoulders. But people did just turn the podcast off, right? Yeah, for sure. They're like, we don't care. Up Comedy Club. Oh, my gosh. Well, you're in New York right now. How's it been going?

5:45It's good. I always say when I'm here that I don't ever know where I am or how to get anywhere. Where am I? Like, in New York, if this was L.A., the studio would be, like, on the corner. I think HeadGum in L.A. is, like, the most conveniently located podcast place. It's, like, Sunset and Hyperion. Yeah, where everybody is. Whereas this is in some weird warehouse and you take an elevator that doesn't really work. There's boxes everywhere and it's kind of scary. And I think I shot something here once. See, we like that. We think that grit is very charming. It is charming. We like that. It's cool, man.

6:24We think it's nice that our guests are scared and confused when they arrive. It throws them off kilter and allows us to get a more honest interview. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, everything is confusing here. So I just kind of accept the confusion. Do you ever live in New York? Not really. A lot of people think I did or think I started here just because all my friends are from here. All the most of the comics that I started with don't do it anymore in L.A. It was like peak 2012 nerd comedy. Yeah, like the Meltdown and shit. Yeah, Meltdown was great, but it was like, yeah, everything looked like every poster looked like Nintendo or, you know, that time period.

7:00Like that millennial, like didn't age well era, like cats with lasers coming out of their eyes. Oh, shit. Yeah. And I think all those people killed themselves.

7:13Hey, we have to laugh, but it is 100 % true. Truly, most of being in comedy is just reading memorials. Truly. Just getting online and someone being like, when we were in the back room of the Chuckle Fuckers hut in Indiana, I knew this guy was going to be somebody. Never really panned out, but God rest his soul. It's like every fucking day you get on Instagram, and you're like, new memorial, new memorial. Well, the difference between comics and musicians, I've noticed, is musicians complain about wanting to kill themselves all the time, and then comics, you'll have the best night of your life with them, and then they'll go home and kill themselves.

7:51Musicians are all talk. Comics do it. Comics commit to the bit. Yeah. God, it's sad, but it's so fucking true. You truly will not know a single thing was wrong, and then it'll just be like, oh, yeah, memorial posts. Call from their mom. Fuck. Damn. Sorry. It's what it's like. What do you want me? I can talk seriously about it. It wouldn't change it. It's really so, I mean, yeah, I don't think I'll ever do it, but there was a real window. Oh, absolutely. There was a time when I'd be driving to a show going, another sold-out show. If there was a gun next to me, I'd put it in my mouth.

8:29Dreams coming true. Oh, that tree looks like it could hold a noose. it could hold my car at 90 miles an hour in a beautiful way well that's not a great thing to hear just because before we started recording you told me you're going through a midlife crisis so i'm now i'm worried about my friend wait a little bit i am yeah i'm just kind of at this period where i'm like playing out every possible scenario like like where i go uh oh man i i should get a subaru outback that's reliable then i go well what if i buy it right now and then one year from now i see a red convertible where the top comes down.

9:05And then I'm in a financial crisis because, you know what I mean? Playing all those stupid little things out. Also, I've become fully embarrassed of being a skateboarder. Really? Yeah, I'm completely ashamed of myself. I can't tell you how cool and hot it is that you're a skateboarder. That's the consensus. I think everyone thinks people who ride skateboards are cool and hot. Really? Yeah, 100%. Even as they get old? Yeah, 100%. Do you see the head shaking back here? everyone's fucking bricked up thinking about the idea of it. It's cool and hot. If you saw me in New York City skating around from show to spot to spot, Caroline's, The Cellar, you know how comics do?

9:44Yeah. The way you're always at Caroline's and The Cellar. Yeah. With a skateboard under my arm. To me, I'm like, that's excruciating. That's embarrassing. Wait, I can't tell you how cool that would be. Okay. We would all like that. Okay. And I speak for the general public here. That is very cool. What I worry about you, of course, your bones are getting a little brittle. I mean, you've got to be real careful on that thing. Oh, yeah. But I don't think it's uncool. I think it's deeply cool. Maybe I'm just feeling self-conscious because I just did my new comedy special. I talk about skateboarding.

10:20And somebody in the, like I saw a letterbox. My dad won't stop sending. My whole family sends me letterbox reviews. And they don't understand how it works. and a lot of them are bad reviews. Yeah. Or not bad reviews. They'll say something like, I didn't really like it, but I think it's cool that he likes his friends. Or something like that. And my dad will send it and be like, so nice that they think it's great that you like your friends. Yeah, yeah, yeah. You miss the bad part, though. Yeah, you miss the part where they panned my work that I love. Yeah, and one of those reviews says, he seems sort of immature and it's weird that he's still skateboarding.

10:59and that's all I focus on. It's mostly nice stuff on there, but that's all I think about. It's like, damn, I am getting old. You can see it. And I skateboard and yeah, my bones hurt. And I still am like, I'm doing this thing now where I try not to dress like the kids skating. Yeah. Because I feel like, no, I need to look a little bit more grown up. I can't, because all the kids now are wearing like Von Dutch hats and true religion jeans and Ed Hardy shirts. It's like that's become popular in the skate world. And I'm just like, I'm not doing that. Too old for that. Yeah. Yeah. Well, it's funny.

11:36The two first things that came up in your midlife crisis were both just like modes of transportation. You're like, do I get the Subaru? Do I get the convertible? Am I allowed to skateboard? There seems to be a lot of anxiety about getting around. Well, it's that. And I think it's also about wanting to be wanted, like wanting people to be like, oh, that's a guy or whatever. And as you get older, it's like, I don't know, man. It's like, I don't fucking know. I don't know what I'm saying. But, yeah. You want to be wanted. Do you feel wanted? Because I perceive you as very wanted. Do you? Yeah. I go, when you pop up in my phone or when you come around, I go, everyone's excited to see you.

12:15People love you. People love your work, think you're a great artist. Like, this is the genuine perception that I hold of you, what I think of you. I think you're a great artist and somebody that I want around. And then also, that's generally all that's ever said about you is good, nice things. Do you feel that? It's nice. No, I don't feel that. It's because you're reading the fucking Letterboxd reviews. I'm not reading them. I had to say, like, hey, I don't read reviews. I don't look at this stuff, so please stop sending. And now they make fun of me, and they keep sending them, and they go, a little bird told me, you know, like, reading these things.

12:49Sensitive old Whitmer doesn't want to see these. Well, too bad. Yeah. Yeah. So I think, you know, I'm like, I don't know how I'm perceived. This is something I've been talking about in therapy where I'll, like, explain everything I just said to you. My therapist would be like, it seems like people really like you. And I go, oh, yeah, I guess. I wouldn't have even been invited to do that thing if they didn't, like, like me or whatever. But maybe it's just, like, feeling like kind of like a, you know, every time I talk about this, I look back on it and I go, wait, no, they liked me for sure. like I was such an idiot when I was a kid and couldn't figure out like if a girl liked me and then as an adult I was like man I always had a yeah I've like encountered these women and I'd be like man in fuck junior year I had such a crush on you and I just didn't know what to do and she the woman would be like yeah I remember I would sneak in through your window take my clothes off and get into your bed and you wouldn't touch me I was like oh yeah fuck okay yeah I guess that would have been a sign in some way yeah damn am it's funny the thing you were saying about um like your family sending you stuff i i had a i was up late last night really late like it was like three in the morning that i was writing this email i've been putting off forever i have this movie coming out that's about my dad passing and it's extremely fictionalized there's a lot of things that are not true to what happened or true to my feelings for different reasons like it just made sense that the second act needed this conflict moment or well you know it's fucking filmmaking yeah but i've been putting off writing this email to my family, to all of them, to say, hey, this is going to come out soon.

14:25People are going to have reviews of it. They're going to say things in the reviews that might not feel like what you experienced when dad died. Basically, just level setting and being like, I'm used to this because it's my job, but you guys are going to experience a level of this that you might not be used to. And I finally wrote the email last night and sent it. And my aunt was very, very funny and one of my favorite people in the whole world. my aunt Ashley uh responded to the email like first thing this morning and was like she said a bunch of sweet stuff and like helped me contextualize it for everybody and then she was like also I hope it's not a big deal I sold a bunch of pictures of you uh to TMZ and I was like it made me feel way better because I was I'm really anxious about I think I didn't maybe do the best job when when I put out my special and I talked a lot about my dad I don't know that I did the best job of like helping my family process the way that people were gonna because they'll see stuff online and get excited and they'll be like that's caleb and then they'll read the comments and it'll be like i'm talking about i'll say like oh my dad was a nightmare or something i'm being half serious because he was a very complicated person but also i'm being like silly and loving in the way that like my dad and i would like rib each other like he would think that was funny yeah and then people are in the comments are being like like you know god to have a dad like that would be fucking horrible the guy sounds like an abuser like shit like that and then my grandma's reading that shit and being like it just is like really not fair to them because they didn't choose this life and I did.

15:51And so anyway, I was the reviews thing is so interesting because I'm like I wonder how much of that stuff they see. When they go, the reviews kind of go one way or the other where they'll say like, you're exploring your traumatic relationship with your dad or something or they'll go he's able to make light of the passing of his eccentric father or something and I would prefer they see that kind of thing. I mean, I'm dealing with the same thing. Like, my first special, Delta La... It was all about my mom, and I, like, really roasted the hell out of my family. And in order for me to kind of, like, feel comfortable doing that, I, like, involved them in it, and I would, like, do little interviews with them.

16:34But even that, like, it's totally me paying homage to my mom and how inspiring and beautiful she was, but she, like, was also a total problem.

16:48and I was like out in Alabama and I had some family thing and this lady came up to me and she's like, hey, do you remember me? We met when you were, you know, a preteen and I stayed with you and your mom with my daughter who's your age and I think like I watched your special and I thought that it was awful to your mom and that you painted her to be like a real monster. Jesus. And I was like, what the fuck? Like, nobody has ever said that to me. Yeah. And then she goes, I go, well, that's not how I see it. And she goes, by the way, I thought whenever I brought my daughter to stay with us at your house, when you were a kid, that you had a crush on her, and you might ask her out, but you didn't.

17:39This is fucking insane. And I was like, I was in eighth grade. What are you talking about? And she goes, are you gay? And I go, I'm coming around on her. I was like, no. And she goes, okay, well, then it's weird you didn't ask my. I was like, what is this? It's almost like she wanted to be mean to me because I didn't ask her daughter out when I was in eighth grade. Yeah, and the first part of it, the stuff about the mom, I'm like, obviously I'm not on her side. But her being like, if you didn't ask my daughter out, you're gay. Of course I'm coming around. I'm ending up in a place where I think she might be a legend but that's fucking psychotic she's insane but I do love like 20 years later being like 30 years later being like not asking my daughter out was pretty gay and looking back her daughter I remember her daughter and I thought about her daughter a lot growing up because she had a hole under her pocket in her jeans and I was staring at it all day like I was walking behind her going god what it'd be like to just like feel what that skin under her pocket is like.

18:43Like, I was truly thinking about it nonstop. You had it, like, in a crush way? Or like, just... Okay, yeah, you were really into it. I wanted to know. I thought it was very brave and sexy of her to have a hole under her pocket. I should have. I told her that, too. I was like, listen, lady, in eighth grade, I wanted to fuck the hell out of your daughter. I wanted to stick my dick through that little hole and grind around. I want to fuck your daughter's jeans, okay? I was really into her jeans. I should have said that looking back. We were at a church, but still. We couldn't do it at church. Dude, that is so fucking funny.

19:17I don't, yeah, I don't want to see anything. I think God, my family, doesn't send me anything because I don't want to know anything. I don't really want to know any opinions of my work unless it's nice because there's nothing I can do now. I put it out. I liked it. I clearly believed in it. I worked really hard on it. And it's like, it does me. I give like three people in my life permission to read the bad stuff and relay in nicer terms anything to me that could be constructive. like if there's something to learn about my work that they're like oh like he does this a lot and it doesn't like help the story or whatever if there's something constructive you can take the mean stuff and filter it through the you love me filter and then give me the good notes but other than that i don't ever want to see something bad about something i made it does me no good yeah i try to avoid it totally sometimes i agree with it like like you're saying like they'll go like oh he uh you know the first five minutes was not super strong and i'm like yep you're right felt that or Or he talks about his childhood too much and it's like, I kind of got nothing else.

20:13But yeah, you're right. You know. He talks about his childhood too much. The biggest thing that happens to anybody ever. Yeah. Sorry. I don't agree with shit like that. I think that's like, it also is like, yeah, a lot of commentary from people who don't make anything. I go, okay, well, what would you talk about for an hour when someone pays you to talk? Yeah, you make something, you little hoe. I legitimately feel that way. Yeah. I don't think. And then there's like professional critics that I'm like, yeah, okay. you kind of nailed that. The second act was whatever. This, that. But the idea of like, I shouldn't talk too much about my childhood is like, I'm the artist.

20:47I talk about whatever I want to talk about and you either watch it or don't. Yeah, turn it off. Go away. Especially with my shit, it's like, okay I think if you can power through the first five minutes which has a four minute song that isn't funny I just like music. Yeah, then you're probably might enjoy the rest of it. And I think, I'm so curious to see the click-off rate like they do on Instagram. You can see when people skip it or whatever. I wish they had that on HBO. Maybe they do, because I guarantee three minutes in, people are just like, ah, fuck this. No more song. Yeah, get rid of the songs.

21:25And I meant to post something saying when the songs start, you can look at your phone. Those are for me. Songs are just for me. Go ahead and check Instagram. Email your boss back. yeah oh my god well wait earlier we didn't really get to the i did want to ask you about the uh midlife crisis thing what do you think is actually going on is there an is there a concern that you have right now about life that's like in the forefront you're like oh i'm i'm not spending my time the right way or i'm worried that things are going to turn out is there a thing i think that my life right now is is better than it's ever been yeah and that i because of that, like, it's made me a little bit selfish.

22:09And, like, I am, like, caught up in my own career and all that shit. And I've, like, started to realize that there's so many other things that I have, like, you know, mental health-wise and all that, health-wise in general, that I've sort of been neglecting. and it's stressful for me to think like, oh, it's time for me to tackle those things, you know? And, you know, like I just, I'm 38. Both my parents are addicts and alcoholics. Mom drank herself to death. And I just now started going to Al-Anon meetings and things. Like, I feel like, and I feel like I'm on the other side of all this now where I have some perspective.

22:56But the midlife crisis thing, I think, comes from finally having a career in comedy and a little bit in music as a filmmaker or an actor. And it's like, okay, I got everything I want. And it's like I used to daydream about the future. And now I think, like, oh, some of these dreams have come true. and now I'm like stuck thinking about the past and things I could have changed or maybe taken care of or acted differently about. And yeah, so yeah, I think that's just kind of it. And it's also the thing of wanting to be seen as kind of young and cool and kind of knowing that's over. but also I don't know if I actually care about that.

23:56Like the other night I went to Echo Park Rising and saw a friend's band play and I was like, what am I doing here? I don't want to fucking be doing this. Get me the hell out of here. And even when I was like 25, I lived in a big party mansion with 10 roommates and we'd have these crazy parties and I'd be like, I just want to be in bed watching South Park. Like I've never had that instinct And so now I think at like 38, I go, oh, I didn't do any. I didn't even start drinking until I was 30. So like I was like, I didn't do any of that. So maybe I need to do that before I turn 40. But then I'll have two margaritas and I'll be like hung over for three weeks.

24:38You know, maybe that's not what I need to be doing. Is it that you want to be perceived as somebody who does those things? that you want to be perceived as a cool young guy who drinks margaritas and isn't hungover for three weeks? Yeah, I think I'm desperate to be perceived as cool. And I'll often... Dude, you are. Thank you. I'm just telling you, I've got really good news for you. I have bad news and good news. The bad news is that is an illness and we're going to have to fix it. And the good news is it's working. People think you're very cool. Thank you, Caleb. So that's the silver lining in the whole deal.

25:11Now we do still have to fix it. I'm doing the work, man. I believe you. I'm with you. I think my thoughts are special and my feelings. And then I go to, like, these meetings and I go, ooh, these aren't special thoughts at all. Everybody feels this way. And it is cathartic, you know. But I – and people think it's so fucking lame. Like, I did this – I have a joke about how badly I want to feel cool. And so I'm like – I, like, think a little too much about my clothes or how far away my pants are from my shoes, which is like a skateboarder thought. and then I did like this interview in the LA Times and the headline says like Whitmer Thomas doesn't care about being cool or something like that and then it's the coolest looking photo of me of all time and I'm like this doesn't doesn't try it feels like so lame and now I understand why like most photos of comics are like them with like the mic in their mouth or like yeah going like I remember when we were taking the key art for my for my special they asked me I was like being a team player for most of it even though I hate that shit they asked me to wrap myself in the mic and like pretend that I was like tied up by it and I was like I have drawn a line we're done the photo shoot is over no I think it sounds like maybe you've had maybe you don't relate to this but it sounds like maybe the blinders were on for a little bit and there was a bunch of stuff out in the periphery that wasn't able to be dealt with because you were focused on And, yeah, like work and life and other big things.

26:44And now they're off because you've had some comfort. Exactly. It's people say money doesn't buy happiness. But I've spent until now trying to figure out how to pay my rent my whole life. So that's all I've been thinking about is how do I survive for the next month? And it's good. Like to everybody out there who's like an artist who's struggling, just know that like that's what you need. and that's so good because it keeps you present. And then as soon as you can pay rent, and it's like you can pay rent for a couple years, you are like forced to reckon with your sadness finally because you can finally think about like your own feelings without having to like, I don't have time to be depressed.

27:33I got to figure out how to get$1 ,200. Yeah. And then suddenly you've got all the time in the world and you're just like, uh-oh. Like, I got all these problems. So it does, like, it provides comfort, but then in that comfort you're like, ah, shit, I'm all fucked up and I didn't know because I didn't have any money. Yeah. I was talking to a friend recently when we went to dinner and she, you know, very, very successful, very, like, has a ton of money. It was Nancy Pelosi. It was Nancy Pelosi. We, I was, well, I don't want to say what we were doing, but let's just say we weren't face-to-face.

28:14No, I was talking to this friend and she was, she was on Broadway recently for the first time. It was like her lifelong dream. And she was like telling me like, oh, I'm a little fucked up right now because Broadway didn't fix everything and I legitimately thought it would. And I was like, really? You really, you really like, you genuinely, like, are you saying that because that's a thing to say? Or are you really telling me you genuinely held a belief that being on Broadway was going to like, make you feel like everything was fixed and she was like i really thought that and i was like oh wow i've never i actually didn't hold any of those beliefs and i feel grateful for that because i have had a lot of dreams come true and i feel grateful that i didn't think any of it was going to fix anything with me but that would be really fucked up and i think that is part of sometimes people getting their big dreams is going like well fuck what now i think i've got like 60 years left everything up until now was about this and now this has happened what uh what what do i do yeah it makes me feel really bad for people whose dream is to be on snl and then they get it at 28 and then they get fired in a year yeah it's like shit fuck yeah i mean it is i am thinking like what now and i and i also think i'm like in this this cyclone of of going like how do i uh make my future perfect to where there's never a problem yeah and it's impossible but that's like a you That's something.

29:36But I'm working on it. I told my therapist the other day, ideally I would never experience pain. And she was like, right, so do we need to? And I was like, no, no, no, I know. I'm just saying, ideally it would not happen to me. How can we numb you up here? Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, that's really real. I mean, it's like the, I don't know. It's a kind of interesting, like, I don't want to say it's an American thing. I guess I don't know if that's true. but like so many people spend their whole lives sacrificing and sacrificing and sacrificing for the idea that they're going to turn 65 and retire and then do whatever they want.

30:09I think that's so backwards and so scary to me that I'm like, first of all, you might never get to that age. Second of all, you do, and you're tired and traveling is really fucking hard and you can't walk like as long, like not like 65 year olds can't walk, but like you have pain in your knees and shit. And like, I don't know the idea of like building this perfect future that might arrive someday. and that all your decisions are playing perfectly into this is like it's a thing we do, and it's also really scary and unrealistic to me. Do you know what I mean? Yeah. Well, now I'm in this mode of going like, okay, there's no way to have a perfect future with no hiccups, but I'm trying now to figure out how to confront these things whenever they happen in a way that actually is healthy.

30:58Instead of avoiding conflict or apologizing, even though I'm the one who just got hit by a car, which is like a problem. And so that's kind of where I'm at right now. Hopefully it'll work out. And if not, I'm happy to go back to Nancy and just see if she'll take me back. See if she'll have me back. Baby girl, outside with a big radio, outside Congress. Yeah. playing a this is my fight song dude that song bangs

31:37fall is the season of doing the most coffee runs weekend plans travel days errands and somehow still trying to make it everywhere on time and with sketchers doing all those things has never been easier we recently talked about sketchers in a not so glowing light on the show in an episode with a guest who will not be named I know that's right. And wouldn't you know it, Skechers heard the call and came knocking on our doorstep. You know what? Good for Skechers. Finally, a brand with a sense of humor. You got to try their hands-free slip-ins. You just slip in and go. Don't I know it. No bending down, no messing with laces.

32:13They've got a heel pillow built into the back that keeps your foot locked in so it's still snug, just way less effort. A lot of their styles also have air-cooled memory foam, so you get pressure relief, instant comfort, breathability. Great for long days or just running around all fall doing too much, which let's be honest, we all are. And a bunch of their styles are machine washable. So fall weather, coffee spills, whatever, you're fine. Head to sketchers.com to check out all their fall styles. Sketchers hands-free slip-ins, just slip in and go. This podcast is brought to you by Squarespace. Squarespace is the all-in-one website platform designed to help you stand out and succeed online.

32:47Whether you're just starting out or scaling your business, Squarespace gives you everything you need to claim your domain, showcase your offerings with a professional a website, grow your brand and get paid all in one place. We all could use a good website in this day and age. I tell you what, and Squarespace has so many awesome features to get yours up and running. Squarespace gives you everything you need to offer services and get paid all in one place from consultations to events and experiences. Showcase your offerings with a customizable website designed to attract clients and grow your business.

33:13Get paid on time with professional on-brand invoices and online payments. Plus streamline your workflow with built-in appointment scheduling, and email marketing tools. Wow. Get discovered fast with integrated Squarespace SEO tools. Every website is optimized to be indexed with meta descriptions and auto-generated sitemap and more. So you show up more often on search engines and bring in more of your ideal customers. Head to squarespace.com slash so true for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, use offer code so true to save 10 % off your first purchase of a website or domain. Today's episode is in partnership with Manscaped, the men's grooming brand trusted by over 14 million men worldwide big news fellas manscape just dropped the new lawnmower ultra gen 6 nicole this is a product that made manscape to the global brand it is today and with their latest upgrades they've somehow made the greatest body trimmer of all time even better the lawnmower ultra gen 6 comes with two interchangeable blade heads one is the upgraded trimmer blade for keeping everything neat the other is a foil blade when you want that ultra smooth finish.

34:15Both have skin safe technology, which helps reduce nicks and cuts. If you're already using a lawnmower, this feels like a serious upgrade. And if you've never tried Manscaped before, the lawnmower Ultra Gen 6 is easily the most advanced body groomer they've ever made. Better blades, smarter features, longer battery life, an overall grooming experience that's faster, easier, and a whole lot more comfortable. Ever heard of it? Head to manscaped.com and use code SOTRUE to get 15 % off plus free shipping at checkout. That's 15 % off plus free shipping with code SOTRUE. at manscaped.com, or if you need it today, it's available now at Best Buy.

34:49You fell in love at first crunch, and now the crispy chicken crunch wrap slider is back at Taco Bell, but with a twist. It's crispy all-white meat chicken nuggets inside a slider-sized crunch wrap, but now you can enjoy them with the kick of Hidden Valley Diablo Ranch, or try the tortilla chip-coated nuggets on their own. They're waiting for you. The crispy chicken crunch wrap slider, A brand new classic is back. Only at Taco Bell.

35:16Yeah, I think it is all going to work out. But I also think, you know, like this is like life isn't some far away future where we have figured everything out. Life is actually like what's happening right now and figuring these things out and having these problems. And like, yeah, like our lives are this. Our lives are like being like, oh, fuck. I think now I think I got to work on my insecurities or now I think I got to work on my relationship or there was like a two year period where I finally got health insurance that like every three months I had to go to the dentist. We were on like a plan to fix my teeth because they were so I had cavities and shit that I hadn't dealt with.

35:51And so there were like two years where my life was like pretty much about going to the dentist. It was a fucking nightmare. It hurt so bad. I hated it. It costs a ton of money even with insurance. And I just had to be like, yeah, life is not about two years from now when the teeth are fixed. Life is about going to the dentist for a little while. And that fucking sucks in some ways. But in other ways, it's like it just has to be funny because there's nothing else to do. Yeah. Well, that's it. It's like you work so hard, you finally get health insurance. And you just, ooh, you get to go to the dentist.

36:23Yeah, what a treat. And yeah, oh, God, I don't know. Well, when do you think you're happiest? What are your happiest moments? I think right now, looking back, my happiest moments are when I'm dead broke. Yeah. And I remember when I was a kid, or not a kid, I was pretty much a kid. I was 22, I think. And I somehow ended up in a room with Norm MacDonald. I was probably a year into doing stand-up, and I was sitting in a chair in someone's office. And it was like a lazy boy, and he goes, Hey, man, he didn't even introduce himself to me or vice versa. And just the first thing he said to me, he was like, hey man you sit in that chair long enough you'll become one of the funniest people alive and i was like what are you talking about he says he was like that's chris farley's chair and uh immediately i was like like try not to cry you know and he and i introduced myself to him and he's like are you a comic and i was like uh yeah and i've he's how long a year and uh he goes i know it doesn't seem like it, but this is the best time of your whole life.

37:30You're wise because I know you're broke and you don't feel funny, but you'll look back and, and realize that like, uh, this is, you know, the most important time of your life. And, uh, just to keep kind of trying and, and I do look back and I don't know if it was the best time of my life, but I think the joy that I felt, I wasn't jaded and I was broke and like just trying so hard across the board. And now like being able, like we were talking about, being able to pay rent and all that shit, it's like it really does help. But I always think back to that conversation and, you know, there's always goals in a career and I'll always, I think everybody will feel like unsuccessful in a lot of ways.

38:16But just reminding myself to like try as hard as I can just because I guess that's what he said. So it's always in my brain and his little voice. But I'd say those are the happiest times for me looking back and just going, oh, I'm dead broke. And but now you have to make other happy times. Is it possible? Do you think that you're not nostalgic for being broke so much as missing being 22? I don't know, man. I think my life started to make sense. Maybe the most joy and happiness I ever felt was when I was like 30.

38:52and I kind of figured out who I was a little bit and what kind of comic I wanted to be and had this whole new world of friends and had finally felt like I belonged in some scene. And I've always felt kind of like an outsider. And that was the first time I didn't. So maybe that's the happiest time of my life. Maybe it was a year ago. I don't know. I think I don't know with perspective looking back now there's all kinds of like happiest moments of my life but there's something so innocent about me 22 I remember when I was a new comic people would talk about Just for Laughs new faces and everybody would be talking shit about like ah that fucker got in there and stuff and it's like this prestigious I don't even know what's still around where like if you get picked to be one of the five people like agents start calling and all that stuff.

39:48And I would be like, why are these comics so upset and jealous? Everybody's so bitter and mean. I'm never going to be like that. And then three months later, I'm the most like cynical.

40:02I'm trying to think, what's fucking John Early doing in there? Like my friend. My friend who I also think is one of the funniest people on the planet. What's he got that I don't have?

40:18people I love would like jump in front of a train for and I'm suddenly like this fucker so yeah try not to be like that anymore that's interesting but also like my peers like I'm so lucky to be a part of this killer scene you know like everybody's kinda crushing it and I don't really have any friends or people in my orbit who I think are successful or who are successful who I'm like they don't deserve that Hmm. Uh, nobody, not one. Let's say that maybe there's some in my orbit. Yeah. Yeah. Orbit, but not circle. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I just try not to think about anybody. Like I try not to think about anybody career wise too much.

41:05Cause I'm like, it doesn't, it all has so much to, I don't know. It's also up to like choice and fate and chance. Like I feel like i don't know i don't even know what to think of it like i'm like the the the point of it really i'm trying to spend as much time getting back to what you're talking about of like when i was yeah just starting out and everything felt new and fun and exciting and big and i'm trying to like like even like i was feeling embarrassed recently actually because i posted i had a suspicion i basically i felt that my movie at tiff there's only three screenings of it the theaters you know all those seats are smaller than a room i would play in toronto normally so i had a suspicion that they would sell out without me trying i didn't have to post about it or anything but i wanted to post because i'm excited and i'm proud and i want uh to build excitement for in case the movie goes on to go to theaters right and in posting about it i was feeling like embarrassed almost i was like what if what if people in the film industry who know that these always sell out see me posting about this and think i'm like i don't know that and i'm like and I'm like immature or silly.

42:12And I was just like, who fucking cares? Like, this is exciting. The fact that any person would ever spend a dime or an hour wanting to see something that you made is like something that I would have killed for when I started. And I couldn't get anyone to watch my stuff or pay for a ticket when I started. And so now I'm like, I don't ever want to take that for granted. I want to be excited about that. I want to be like excited and proud and like talk about how proud I am that my screenings sold out because it means that people are going to see my thing and I don't want to feel stupid or immature for doing that because those feelings are things that only come with like time and becoming jaded and being in this for too long that you get around to other people who are like, oh yeah, it'll sell however many tickets or whatever.

42:57And I'm like, well, no, that's actually not like a throwaway fact. I don't want to, I have felt that way and I don't want to feel that way. I want to be like every single ticket, every single person who sees your thing matters and is like exciting and something to be proud of. Do you know what I mean? Yeah, man. And people, what's weird, what's tough is like a lot of those people in that audience, you're their favorite comedian. And it's like, it's a weird thing to like realize, you know? And if your favorite comedian came wherever you're from and did a screening and you didn't know about it because they never said anything about it, it'd be a bummer.

43:35Or people want to celebrate you and get excited by the thing that you made because it's for them. I mean, it's for you too, but you're making this stuff for other people to laugh at or to enjoy. And hopefully find some sort of, especially like the subject matter of your movie, some sort of solace or, you know, comfort in watching it. And I, you know, it's one thing if it's like, I don't know. I just think that if you're proud of something, celebrate it. And also when it's something that's a little bit vulnerable, absolutely celebrate it. You're not playing a character. Your comedic persona isn't like a character, you know, where maybe then the mystery is okay because you don't really want to let people in.

44:21You don't want people to actually know that you have six kids. Yeah, that's for musicians. The mysterious persona thing is for musicians. Some of my musician friends that have one, I'm like, God, that's good. That must be awesome. My job is actually saying everything I've ever thought forever. It's way worse. It's like I always wonder that when I release like a new album or something because people know everything about me to where when people listen to a song, they go, oh, I already knew about that. Like that line, oh, yeah, I'm happy he said that out loud. I heard him say that on a podcast one time.

44:56Yeah, I just I mostly mean like I just want to maintain a new to this, not even maintained because I there have been times where I've lost it I will say like a year or two ago I think I was in a way different place with all this where like I was getting a little jaded and I was getting a little like I wasn't I don't know that I was ungrateful but I wasn't practicing enough gratitude do you know I'm saying yeah like ungrateful feels so like actively being like this is stupid to me but practicing gratitude is like even a different thing than being grateful like ungrateful and grateful I feel like put them in like states of being and practicing gratitude is like this thing that you do.

45:32And I'm trying really hard to practice gratitude for things that feel like guaranteed now, or like even like, Oh, I'm going to pay my rent next month. That is a guarantee now for at least the next couple months. You know what I mean? But I'm trying to like, every time the rent comes due, be like, Oh my God, I paid my rent this month. Or I'm trying to like, when I, when I go pop in on a show and people know who I am, even though I wasn't on the bill, I'm trying to be like, leave stage and be like, Holy shit. Like people know that I do this. Maintaining that thing from when I was 22 and living with a bunch of people and starting out.

46:08Just trying to keep that because I think losing that is so sad. Yeah. And also the other thing that I can't stand with some people who are jaded is thinking that they're the funniest person on the bill or that they don't even really have to have fun with it to go and do a spot on one of these shows. I think that I'm kind of the exact same way. I was watching Geese live, and they're these younger guys, you know, and they're performing in front of thousands of people, and it's new for them, you know, this kind of success. And I just wanted so badly for Cameron Winter, and he's, like, cool, you know, very cool, to go like, well, holy cow, I can't believe you all bought tickets to see me.

46:56doesn't really talk in between songs just like what the heck please visit the merch booth i don't ever want to lose that if i ever play in front of that many people i don't want i don't want that to go away yeah and it echoes back to being like 15 years old and my big brother like coming to see my band or me opening for his band and going like hey pal really tell them to go buy EP because I think people should listen to it and I was too embarrassed even then I was like I gotta be cool I shouldn't tell people that and then I did and I still tell people to do that like go visit the merch booth even though it's like people are gonna go to the merch booth no but that's nice I think that is good what do you think I've been thinking a little bit lately about what I think my stuff is about well I was thinking about it the other day actually did you ever read or know about Wendell Berry?

47:53Seems like somebody you would love. He was a southern guy. He was a writer, poet. He was an environmentalist. And he passed away the other day. He was like 90-something. I was really sad about it because I love him. And I love his writing. And I love the way he writes about the world. If I had to sum up a bunch of his work, I would say he wrote once that maybe he wrote this in the 60s or 70s or something. He was like, the next great divide will be between people who want to live like machines and people who want to live like creatures and that's kind of like what a lot of his work is about is the natural world and how far we are from that and what industrialization is doing to our planet um but i was thinking about what his work is about and then i was like what's my work about and i thought about a couple things but what do you think yours is about i want to change this i am but i i think like so much of it is about abandonment and like trying to preserve and prepare, or I guess prepare, um, myself from being abandoned.

48:55Like every joke is kind of protecting that or, or, or looking, or trying to get people to like me so they don't leave me or, um, or finding, you know, the new special is all about my friends who have sort of protected me over the years when I, especially in my childhood. And it's something that I'd like to kind of ditch, you know, and move on to the next thing and stop making that my entire identity. Especially with my first comedy special where, like, it caused a lot of, you know, like a big complex. When I would, after that came out in 2020, and I didn't get to tour for a couple years, but then when I finally did, people would come up to me after my show and be like, oh, you're silly.

49:41like I thought this was going to be like a one man show like serious and so I had this whole complex like I need to prove to people that I'm not just like a kind of a walking husk of like comedic trauma and then this new one is all about you know how lucky I was to have friends during my childhood and who kind of took care of me but But I think a lot of everything I'm kind of going through, maybe my midlife crisis, is preventing myself from being abandoned or abandoning someone. I'm like, oh, it's inevitable that that will happen. And now I'm like, that's not who I am, actually. Like, I've gone this far and that hasn't happened.

50:30So, like, I'm kind of trying to move on from that and think about jokes that are present. Like, an actual joke about how I feel. right now and and uh not looking back at some sort of thing or thinking about the future in some sort of way and just being like i like sitting on a bidet because it's fucking me in the ass you know that good present stuff yeah where we're at right now yeah never knew about that when i was a kid but now i know yeah the power of the bidet yeah that makes sense to me i mean it's like narrative building the way we feed into our own narratives the way we take on the narratives that people have given to us about who we should be the way that like a life in like creativity like inherently lends itself to other people handing you back narratives about yourself and then at a if you're lucky at a higher and higher volume that people are just constantly handing you back the narrative they've built of you and you're supposed to like partially take it in but also partially uh resist it um yeah the narratives that we have about ourselves are so like powerful and pervasive yeah yeah i'm always kind of trying to think of like a way to stop doing that you know and just like well why do i feel sad or maybe if i did this differently or you know kind of creating some sort of narrative and then also there's a lot of like psychopaths out there who will like construct a narrative that justifies their bad personality yeah and i I get worried a lot of times like, oh, I have these problems because this happened to me when I was a kid.

52:08Or, you know, the way I talked to you earlier, I did that because when I was a kid, you know, whatever happened. I got to tell you, the when I was a kid or my parents XYZ explanation for like very present recent behaviors. I don't know, man. After like it's one thing to say this informs the way that I see the world. And like, of course, our childhoods are the biggest thing that happened to us. but there is a certain point where you have to like take responsibility and start working i've had friends and acquaintances that have behaved so badly and just continuously over and over again be like wow i had a really bad childhood and i go so did a lot of people yeah grow up like get over it like i don't know what to tell you but at a certain point you can't just walk around being mean and hurtful to people that's i think what i'm really trying to say is like it's one thing when you're looking at the way it affects you and your feelings and your world we all should be doing that but when you're like using it as an excuse to treat other people badly after like i don't know 23 years old it's a certain point where it's just like i don't know man you're gonna have to figure that out or get away from me yeah yeah there's there really are options yeah that's totally right yeah i think it's not necessarily that i'm mean or anything i think it's more i'm i'm uh i'm the opposite where if there is if somebody's an asshole i i don't say anything i just kind of like let it happen or if i feel sad or upset i don't say anything about it and somebody be like are you okay and i'll be like what would jack nicholson have to say even though like i'm in that moment i'm like devastated right like something is not okay yeah and uh so i i there is no i'm and so it's not necessarily affecting like my friendships other than people are like, he's never serious.

53:56He won't ever actually let me know what he thinks of something. And so you're right. There's no excuse for that. And obviously it goes back to my childhood or whatever, but it's like - Oh, to be clear, I'm not criticizing you. I'm talking about people who are actively malicious to other people. My read of your situation is that you're more critical of Whitmer than you are to anyone else. And that is ultimately, I don't like that for you, but that's not really harm to other people. I don't want you to do that for you because you're my buddy but yeah I think it's the being mean to other people thing that I'm like you gotta get over that and like yeah a lot of those people also will eventually me and my pals describe those people as like our favorite funny trait with those people is that it takes them three months to realize the same thing how they affected somebody in the same time it would take a normal person like 14 seconds you get that text way yeah where you'll be like oh this guy just said this uh awful thing or did this awful thing and we'll joke like three months give him three months they should have said sorry within five seconds but give him three months they'll come back around with a 40 page text message that also kind of half like absolves their own like yeah it's yeah well i'm thinking of specific people and feeling really upset towards them should we all say their names but honestly there are plenty of times we do that on this show that i'll i'll just i'll just allow myself i'll know in the moment that what i'm saying is never going to make it out and i'll just allow myself to go 10 minutes and then afterwards i'll text chance and be like cut all of that like in the moment it felt like i needed to say it, but, you know, the larger conversation needed it.

55:45It was taking us to a place we needed to get to, but that can't go out because that was really mean. Yeah. Yeah. Hey, we're not going to say it. We didn't cut anything out. No, no. We're not going to cut names today. No, not today. Just this is raw and uncut. This is raw, uncut, unfiltered wit. Yeah. Wit unfiltered. You know what you should do? You and I both. Let's do it at the same time. Separate specials. we'll call Nina today and we'll say hey Witt and I are going to do two separate specials same idea and it's going to be like our like fuck you comic special dude I would fucking love that we both do one our own versions of it put them out at the exact same time ugh let's do it and there'll be all these articles like comedy's changing yeah you can only one of those things where you can only watch it for two days and then they take it down because everything is so fucked up that we're saying and it's like because we're being censored Caleb and Whitmer raw and uncut But slur is welcome.

56:37Yeah. Slur-heavy comedy. We get involved in that scene. Yeah. Austin, Texas. We get involved in the Austin, Texas comedy scene. Yeah, let's go. I could see us doing well in Austin. That's the sad truth is I have had friends, like our peers, who have gone to the mothership, and they're like, that was fucking awesome. Yeah. It was great. No, some of my favorite comics are like, it's the best place on earth. And I'm like, of course it is. It's run by a comic, and almost none of the other places are. Yeah. Well, a comic, but, you know, don't get me started. The guy who at least likes to see himself as a comic, and that is important, unfortunately.

57:09Oh, man. You know what I would love to do someday? Kevin Morby and I have talked about opening a venue together in Kansas City. I think it would be so fucking sick. That would be so fun. Lose money immediately and forever. You just hope you got enough money by then to just lose that money. Well, that's literally what I'm like. I'm cool with that. I'll lose some money. We could even just break even. I'd be fine with that and just be like, we make no money off this, but it pays itself. One, it would easily be the best venue in Kansas. Some of these venues, I'm like, everything here is great. Yeah.

57:41And then you go, but why is there an AI painting of Jimi Hendrix on the wall behind the stage? Right. Would it have killed you to spend$200 more on the green room furniture so that any of the pieces were sittable? Yeah. I mean, would it have absolutely killed you? Yeah. Somebody should start a venue consulting service where they go through and tell them like, hey, obviously a thousand people standing room only is not the move. Put some benches around the edges at least. Yeah, that's what I always say. Can we put some chairs on the side? Right. I made the mistake of touring for two years to only standing room.

58:21And I swear you should have seen the audiences towards the end just dwindling as people would find out that there's not going to be any seats. like people would be like now in comments whenever I announce a tour are there chairs yeah 100 % when Katie and I do our benefit show in Kansas City there's the balcony with a bunch of seats and then it's all standing on the floor and every year the balcony sells immediately and then the floor sells really slowly all the way up to the day where people are like fuck I guess they don't want to do it I guess I'll go fucking stand I did a little party here in New York screening and I didn't realize there wasn't going to be chairs and a young cool person in the front row just who is clearly like a person people look to for coolness just sat down on the floor and then everybody sat down behind her and I was like oh that's all it takes is one influential person to sit on the floor and then you realize like oh all right you've seen that video at like on the hill at the they showed this all the time in college i don't know if anyone else experienced this it's like at a music festival on a hill and no one's dancing and then like one guy runs and starts dancing do you know i'm talking about and then and the voiceover that they would show in college is always like right now he looks crazy right now he looks insane dancing alone and then one person joins him and they're like now he doesn't look so silly does he and then a third person joins and they're like it's officially a movement and then and then eventually everyone's dancing and they always show it to be like the the first follower is the most important like whatever whatever but that's what it feels like anytime something like that happens in public where everyone just goes wait well this is all made up we don't have to do this we can actually do something else yeah we can have a little fun here yeah or we can yeah we can i was in a coffee shop recently where everyone was waiting in a line that clearly wasn't the line there was like a line that was obviously getting served and then a line that was like off to the side and i just went up to the front of that and was like none of us are in line we should move to the real line everyone's like oh yeah and then we just like i was like what the fuck is like no one wants to talk everyone's scared to say it yeah we're all robots none of us are getting coffees if we don't tell you right now i would have stood in the wrong line the whole time and not said anything even if i knew there was a right line i'm always trying to make a friend in public you know what happened to me last night i was i wanted to tell you about this hold on allow me to walk in last night my friend and i are biking in manhattan we're going from dinner to the park and we what passes us is a 300 cyclists biking together and i was like should we join them i want to know where they're going and my friend was like yeah so we joined them and we biked with them whole time we're biking with them we probably bike with them for like 45 minutes whole time we're biking with them people are like pulling up next to us and being like you guys knew hey what's up i'm joe like literally like so friendly everyone was so cool we learned about at one point this like shirtless guy pulls up next to us and he goes we're doing a film festival bicycle film festival it's all films about bikes you guys want a flyer and i was like yeah and so and then we like biked with them all the way to battery park and then this guy like made a little speech that was like this was awesome thank you guys so much for coming out tonight it's all love it's all joy it's all bicycles and make sure to vote for trump yeah third we were we immediately were joking like what if this turned out to be like a pro israel and it's just pictures of us being like my friend that's beautiful by the way love that oh I almost cried three times I loved it sounds like a terrible batch of films by the way just about I cannot imagine the Bicycle Film Fest is gonna be awesome but guess what I'll probably be there you should support the scene I'm gonna bike over and also hand out flyers for your movie while you're there yeah yeah hey we're having a film festival about my dad dying it's all films about my dad dying it's one come out my friend wrote this song this is like 18 years ago when he was like 20 and they were like hey a commercial wants to license it and I was like sick what is it and he goes I don't know some sort of walk and I was like oh okay and then we saw it and it was a pro-life walk please and I don't think he even knew what that was that is so fucking funny he's also he's a guy who says he's pro-life Alabama guy yeah and then I go dude you're not pro-life you've been with a few girls who have had abortions and he goes, well they can do it's their choice, they can do whatever they want but I'm pro-life and I'm like, you described pro-choice we have a phrase for that actually you're something else it's pro-choice it's their body, they should be doing the government should not interfere with that I'm very passionate about that but if I had a baby, I would never get an abortion I'm like, that is a choice You are pro-choice.

1:03:16I was thinking the other day about the number of girls that I grew up with that were like hardcore, badass, like cool girls that once every six or seven months I'll get on Instagram and another one of them will pop up with a cross necklace. And I go, all right, that's it. There it is. The cross necklace is the official end of like, they've been becoming uncool for many years. And then the cross necklace pops up and I go, it's now official. We can close the book. We can sign the deal. It's over. Do you believe it? Or do you think they've just like when I was a kid my mom would like I remember she would wake me up on Sunday and be like we have to go to church.

1:03:53And I'd be like mom did something bad. What did she do? And do you think it's like that? I think like I actually don't have I would have thought it was so lame and I would have been so mean and judgmental about it when I was a teenager or in my like early twenties. But now I just look at it and go, yeah, I think they believe it. I think they're making peace with this whole thing the way that we all are. Same way I'm making peace with all this. Like it's, it's their version is like, they're going to start going to church because they have kids and they want the kids to be around the grandparents and it makes them feel like the kids are being top values or whatever.

1:04:25So that's their version of like making sense of how, uh, confusing and hard it is to be alive. But the part that I mourn isn't that they're like going to church and wearing cross necklaces, I think that's great. Make sense of this however you have to. Life is really fucking hard. The part that I mourn is that I think I was hoping that we would all turn out the same. Do you know what I mean? I was hoping we would all move to big places and travel the world and make art. And I was hoping that we would all be the same forever. And that's not actually possible. That's childish. That's wild, man. I got that same feeling.

1:05:03And it hits harder every year. Even as my friends find success back in Alabama opening a restaurant, I'm still like, I should have moved to L.A. with me. You'd be a star right now. Yeah. It's crazy. Like, I thought, and it's sad to see, like, oh, they don't go to shows anymore. And then I'm like, but they have these beautiful families and these careers, you know. And they just found something that brings them joy as, like, a grown-up. And, like, I'm still like, but you're miserable. right? Please? No, I love my sons. Today, one of them scored a home run, and I'm like, you're lying. You hate that little guy.

1:05:45You wish you were having lunch at all times. You wish we were having a general meeting with someone who doesn't know anything about you. No, I'm down. I'm like, whatever. Make peace however you need to make peace. I think everything's a compromise, and you decided this was best case for you. I think I'm living my best case. I wouldn't trade my situation for anyone else's. like I think a lot like if you if you gave me the option to put all my problems in a bucket with everyone else's and grab a handful at random I would hope to god that I got mine but I don't know everybody do whatever you want to do I just do feel a sadness that I'm like I had these dreams as a kid that we were going to like turn out the same and go the same places and now at like 3 p.m.

1:06:24on a Tuesday when I'm like fuck I want to ride my bike to the park and see a friend there is a part of me that's sad that it'll never be those people will never be the people that I am talking about but it's new people now. It's different people. I get to do that with my buddies now. It just is like, yeah, that's my version of it is not going to be their version of it and that does make me a little bit sad and I think that's okay. I don't think that's mean. Not at all. But the cross necklace is the emblem that I go, okay, we have officially, if there was any hope that I was holding out that maybe you were going to.

1:06:55I have a friend from high school who was like huge atheist, hardcore, straight edge. like hardcore kid just like totally immersed in the hardcore scene and now he's Catholic Christian has two kids and he's just a great guy but I do find when I'm hanging out with his him and his wife whenever I go back home I can't tell certain stories and we can't laugh about certain things when she's around and I do that does bum me out a little bit of like you don't even know this entire life that he had when we were kids and how crazy he was and and that that does bum me out but then I look at him like speaking Spanish to his kids because she's Colombian and I go but this is like a beautiful life like this this guy's like learned an entire language and he like he's also Mexican and like but when we were kids I think he like suffered a lot being in Alabama and like cops pulling him over because he had a skateboard but only really fucking with him you know yeah and now he's like embraced his culture and I'm like but look at this man I can't talk about how we used to catch you jacking off in public all the time but look at this whole life man damn cool that you earn spanish though congratulations congratulations in every regard to everyone I've ever loved still love you, send all my love do your thing girl whatever it really is not a place of judgment, it's just like we're doing different things and I'm noticing I'm noticing that things are different and I don't know how it happened that way it doesn't shock me that someone who's a militant atheist could become a militant catholic it's militant being militant about stuff is it's very easy to flip the coin it's very easy to flip the coin oh yeah all the straight edge kids in the hardcore scene like started shooting heroin a year later right you know um well because what what militant like what what militancy does for people is like this really strict type of exercising control that's their cope that's their like way of dealing with like being alive is they're like i'm straight edge i never i don't have to do that stuff and it's like you're just coping with the same thing that i'm coping with you're doing it in a different way and it's very easy to just flip that into like oh yeah now i'm addicted to heroin it's just another type of it's control it's lack of control it's it's just all coping with like being alive is fucking insane none of us asked for it uh it's going bad in terms of humanity and the planet it's like not we're not we're not doing you would think we'd way better at it by now.

1:09:43The planet's kind of like dying rapidly. And so at some point you have to make peace with all that and some people choose straight edge and some people choose heroin. Como se dice, do your thing, girl. Maybe that's the name of your next comedy special. I think the full name of the comedy special is some people choose straight edge, some people choose heroin, colon, como se dice, do your thing, girl. I love it. Nina? I'm calling HBO. The reason I think I even have this special is because of a guilt trip to HBO to Nina and Aaron, who, like, run the specials over there. I wrote them a letter. Like, they came and saw my show, and then I wrote them a letter about, like, listen, the golden one, my first special, was great, and it was a great opportunity, but now everybody thinks I'm a sad guy.

1:10:30So this next one's really silly, and it would really help my confidence if y 'all did this. And then it worked, so. So I just wrote a letter to them. I love that so much. And I love Nina and Aaron and probably Christina sitting in a room together reading this and being like, I think we got to green light it. We got to do it or else he's going to fucking off himself after a great night with friends.

1:10:58Oh, shit. I'm happy for a guilt trip. Look, we got to play a game. Oh, yeah. It's time to play a game. All right. You ready for this? Do you know what this is? Well, they said there's two questions. Oh, brother. This is true or false. I'm going to read you 15 statements. Okay. You're going to tell me as quickly as you can if what I just said was true or false. And if you get 10 or more correct, we're going to give you 50 U.S. dollars. Sick. I'm going to take that to Resorts World Casino tomorrow before I go to JFK. That's exactly right. You ready? Mm-hmm. Okay. Monsters, Inc. came out in 2004.

1:11:30False. False. 2001. The U.S. has won over 1 ,000 gold medals at the Summer Olympics. False. True. The chemical formula for hydrogen peroxide is H2O2. False. True. The longest playable trumpet ever made was 105 feet long. True. True. Gulf Shores, Alabama's town motto is better by the beach. No. False. False. It's small town, big beach. Stupid. Because you know why? Smallest beach ever. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's a sliver. It's a beautiful beach. Sliver of a beach because they built condos directly on the beach, which shortened our beaches and took down all the dunes and seagrass. So now when hurricanes blow through, it's just like, bye-bye Gulf Shores.

1:12:19Fuck. For another, you know. But anyway, terrible. We should talk about Lambert's over there. Yeah, we do. Cucumbers are 95 % water. True? True. Trader Joe's operates two stores in the U.S. Virgin Islands. False. False. None. The Brooklyn Bridge is longer than the Manhattan Bridge. True? False. Paul Wallace from Houston, Texas. False. True. Cheeseburger Randy's serves milkshakes in the summer. Oh, my God. My guy, Alex Warner. Everybody shout out Alex Warner. I don't fucking know. True. False. The capital of Brazil is Rio de Janeiro.

1:12:58True. It's the big... False. False. It's Brasilia. Thanks for giving that to me. Saturn is the sixth planet from the sun. Who do you think you're talking to here, man? True. It's true. Force equals mass times acceleration. True. True. The cube root of 216 is six. Jesus, Chance. The cube root of 216 is six.

1:13:25False. I don't even know what cube root means. It's true. Blink-182 formed in San Diego, California. Yeah, true. False. Poe, California. Oh, but that's just right outside of San Diego, man. It's the desert Poway, California. That's just, okay, fine. Give it to him, and how do you do? If we're giving him that one, nine. Whoa. That's bad? No, it's close. All I needed was ten. You almost got there, bro. Well, I think the San Diego one is. We gave it to you. Okay, thank you. We gave it to you. That got you to nine. Thank you. You got eight before that. Have you been to Gulf Shores? I've not been. How do you know about Lambert's?

1:14:00Brother. They got one where you're from? Lambert. Oh, Whitmer. when I tell you when I was at my fattest behavior I mean when I was at my fattest both in terms of literally being fat and fattest in terms of behavior like depression Chance and I and our friends were going to there's one about 25 minutes south of where we went to college in Branson like near Branson and we would go to Lambert's and fuck it up we'd take 20 people in there a lot of people don't know if you ask for a second plate they'll bring it to you they don't give a shit you go to Lambert's I don't know if they still do this and I don't want to blow their spot up.

1:14:35You go to Lambert's and you go, I'm still hungry. They'll go, I want to bring you another one. Yeah. No charge. By the way, here's a roll. They throw a roll at you. They fucking slap black beans on the table. They give you fucking okra. I would have my favorite order at Lambert's is the fried hog jowl. I would eat a whole plate of it and then I'd be like, bring her again, baby. And they bring me a 64 ounce mug of Coca-Cola. Like crazy fucking behavior. That's so good. And I loved it, and I couldn't wait. Anytime I could get someone to go down there with me, I'd eat there. I went not long ago, almost kind of as a joke, because I used to go there all the time as a kid.

1:15:11This place is trash. I've been living in L.A. now, eating at all these great restaurants, and it was just one of the best meals of my life. It over-delivered. Yeah. And the vibes are sick, and just I bought merch and all that shit. I need some Lambert's merch. I fucking love Lambert's. I want to go again soon. Is there, like, a line? Oh, yeah. Okay. Oh, yeah. Well, Branson is kind of a tourist town. Big time. When I was a kid, the girl who used to sneak into my bed naked at night, beautiful dancer, she quit high school because she got a job dancing at a magic show in Branson. Of course. And I remember thinking, he's going to be a star.

1:15:56I'm so jealous. Why didn't they ask me to come out there? Yeah. In my mind, I would be like, if I could just get to Branson. If I could just get to Branson. If you could just catch that bus to Branson, I'd be the guy. Yeah, I'd be the big guy there. It was like some guy named something rocket, his magic show. I could just be a bald knobber or whatever the fuck the big show was in Branson. Whit, thanks so much for doing it. Thank you. We got it. Do you want to tell people where they can find you and about your new special? Yeah, you can just look up Whitmer Thomas and all the things and follow them and like them.

1:16:30Yeah, go to Letterboxd and put some good reviews. Like, if you don't have anything nice to say, just don't say anything. But maybe make some good reviews and mention my family. And I just want to see, say, like, I hope Whitmer's family is reading this. I'm begging you guys, please don't ever write something about me on Letterboxd, positive or otherwise. But go on Letterboxd right now and review Witt's latest special. and write glowingly about his family, as many of you as possible, please do this, and let's just see what happens. Yeah, and watch it on HBO. Terminal crew of dudes. Yeah, hell yeah.

1:17:05Yeah. Thanks, dude. Thank you, dude.

From the publisher

Welcome! This week’s guest is the hilarious Whitmer Thomas! Whitmer and Caleb talk aging as a skateboarder, making music, a bike-focused party/film festival, Jack Nicholson’s opinions, and much more!

Join our Substack for ad free full episodes, early access to merch, our community chat, and more! https://calebsaysthings.substack.com/

Follow Whitmer! @whitmerthomas

Follow the show! @sooootruepod

Follow Caleb! @calebsaysthings

Produced by Chance Nichols @chanceisloud

Go to https://www.squarespace.com/SOTRUE to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain using code SOTRUE.

Go to https://skechers.com to shop all the Skechers Hands Free Slip-in Styles

Thanks to MANSCAPED® for sponsoring today’s episode! Get The Lawn Mower® Ultra Gen 6 for 15% OFF + Free Shipping with code SOTRUE at https://Manscaped.com!

So True with Caleb Hearon is edited and engineered by Nicole Lyons. Our social media manager is Anna Weis. All episodes are filmed in The So Trudio at Legitimate Business World Headquarters in Brooklyn, New York.

A Wave series. https://wavesportsandentertainment.com

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from So True with Caleb Hearon

All episodes