

2 Jul 2025 · 55m · 23 chapters

Whether Amazon (via Fire TV/Fire Stick) is enabling sports piracy, and what rights holders and streaming platforms can do beyond blaming one device. The episode argues piracy is a symptom of broader access/value problems and requires end-to-end content security plus better monetization.
Chris Stone (community lead) and Nick Meacham (CEO) from Streamtime Sports. Paul O’Donovan, senior director/product manager at MediaKind, has 20–30 years securing sports content for pay TV operators and broadcasters.
Piracy has become “industrial scale” and harder to ignore; pirates are getting smarter and consumer adoption is normalized. Fire TV is an easy scapegoat, but the fault lies with pirates; any cheap Android device could be used. Effective defense needs DRM, encrypted license keys, entitlement checks, CDN tokenization, VPN/geo blocking, and sometimes HDMI output restrictions.
La Liga claims piracy costs $600M–$700M annually; UFC legal discussion about shutting down piracy quickly for short fights; “CDN leeching” where pirates steal streams while viewers still pay; NFL Game Pass and DAZN replays/recaps as value-reinforcing alternatives.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the increasing relevance and financial impact of piracy in sports.
“But I remember those early SportsPro Madrid summits, as it was, or sorry, OTT summit, as it was called back then.”
Guest Paul O'Donovan discusses the evolution of piracy and security measures.
“It's getting easier to break down those barriers.”
An analysis of modern piracy methods and their implications for content owners.
“So we've always taken security and content security incredibly seriously at MediaKind.”
Exploration of the responsibilities of rights holders and the impact of big tech companies on piracy.
“So to then secure this, what do you need?”
Discussion on various stakeholders responsible for the rise in piracy, focusing on Amazon's influence.
“There's multiple things I want to dive into that.”
Exploring the complexities of how Amazon Fire TV contributes to piracy issues.
“that needed to be taken to protect their asset that they were paying a premium for.”
Discussing the various strategies and technologies for protecting streaming content from piracy.
“And as, Paul, you sort of set the scene, there is a countless different ways of pirates to be able to get access to the content.”
Examining the philosophical implications of piracy in the absence of broadcasting.
“Some people view it as an absolute necessity.”
Analyzing the complexities faced by rights holders in global content distribution and monetization.
“For many, it's one person, and they're doing it as a side thing for their day job as well.”
Understanding the challenges and requirements for launching direct-to-consumer services in various markets.
“Just what are some of those challenges then?”
Explore the challenges in securing broadcast content and the role of vendors.
Understand why setting up a D2C platform for the Premier League isn't simple.
“D2C platform and make billions and billions of dollars wouldn't actually be that easy?”
Discuss the necessity and strategy of managing piracy across different tiers of sports media.
“how far down do you think and see that the need to manage piracy through end-to-end is essential?”
Learn about the importance of planning for growth in sports media platforms.
“So that basically comes down to, I think you've explained it pretty well, but I just want to summarize it.”
Analyze the misconceptions surrounding piracy's impact on broadcasters and rights holders.
“So I'm going to change this direction a little bit.”
Examine how high costs and accessibility issues contribute to piracy.
“It's actually a Swedish series, and it's basically on Spotify's journey.”
Discuss how perceived value affects consumer engagement with sports services.
“I think what Paul and Edicon and lots of other companies are doing is to try and mitigate and reduce those losses and impact and really slow down that impact or minimize as much as possible.”
Learn about features that enhance viewer experience and loyalty in sports streaming.
“I think the other one, and again, this comes down to perceived value, and I think also a degree of anti-piracy is video latency.”
Learn how specific features in sports subscriptions justify their cost for fans.
“service so that people are then not so concerned about paying the money they are.”
Explore the complexities of advertising at scale in sports streaming.
“So, yeah, once you've got over the intrinsic technological challenges, you then start to get onto the value-based challenges of how do you ensure that all your ad spots are filled?”
Understand how targeted ads enhance viewer experience and revenue.
“This isn't server one of the, but basically helps, helps serve more personalized advertising into connected, connected TVs and streaming experiences.”
Discuss how piracy influences sports media rights and negotiation strategies.
“So they don't even necessarily know or recognize they're being targeted with an advert.”
Analyze the viability of exclusive media rights in the face of piracy and evolving consumer habits.
“It's a bit like when we started seeing doping in sports, where they were always saying that the scientists were always ahead of the testing.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On StreamTime Sports, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:09Nick Meacham: Hello, everyone, and welcome back to the next episode of Streamtime Sports. My name is Chris Stone. I'm the community lead joined, as always, by our CEO, Nick Meacham. Now, Nick, I'm very excited today. One of my favorite hot topics is what we're going to be deep diving into today, and that's talking about piracy. It's a super relevant topic. I think it's possibly, for me, one of the most fascinating topics because there's so many different angles that you can dive into it on. And it's something that more and more people are seemingly, at least in my opinion, starting to talk about, Nick. I remember, this is really scary, Nick, in about a couple of weeks, I've been at SportsPro for six years.
0:42Nick Meacham: Blimey. I know, I know. Time flies. Time really does fly. But I remember those early SportsPro Madrid summits, as it was, or sorry, OTT summit, as it was called back then. We would do maybe two piracy sessions per event sort of thing back then. Really hard to get people into those rooms. But it just feels like over time, more and more people are starting to talk about it. I think recently, as of June 24th, which is three days ago, Javier Tabas, President La Liga going out talking about that it's costing the league$600 million to$700 million a year. Barney Francis, who used to be at Sky Sports, now at IMG, came out and speaking to the BBC World Business Report talking about its impending thread on the sports industry.
1:26Nick Meacham: And it just feels like more and more people are talking about it now, Nick. So we also brought along a guest today, an industry expert, Paul O'Donovan from Mediakine, who's a senior director, product manager. He's going to come and give us a little bit of the other side of the conversation as well. But Nick, with the piracy side of things, do you personally, before we dive into it, find it as fascinating as I do.
1:47Chris Stone: Yeah, I think with your point or your example around how we saw it coming to life as a topic and how it was always a bit of, and I think it still is to some extent, a little bit of a, not a taboo subject, but it's one of these ones that certain people within the industry really jump on and focus on because it's a real thing. And a lot of the data I think we shared recently, even in my recent trip into Sweden, into Stockholm, whereas it came up a number of times and the scale of IPTV use, illegal IPTV use and piracy is going bigger and bigger and bigger, it's now got to a point where now almost no one can ignore it anymore.
2:23Chris Stone: Whereas I think before there was a little bit of like, it's a problem. We're going to kind of like push it to the side a little bit and not give it much time. Just hopefully it'll maybe magically go away. And that is definitely not been the case. And I think an example we may have shared before, but That example that someone used in one of our events a while ago in the States where it was pirates who had just seen a bit of a wasted stock take loss from a supermarket where basically loss of breakage or shoplifting was the comparison. And they just have to accept there's a bit of a loss happening.
2:59Chris Stone: Well, the problem is that that is growing and growing and growing. And there's no light at the end of the tunnel on how to solve it. The pirates are getting smarter. It's getting easier to break down those barriers. And the consumer adoption and use of it is not met with any real negativity that it should be. People almost talk about it in such a comfortable manner now. Like it's part and parcel of consuming live sports that's not easily accessible through traditional channels. So it's really interesting to see how it's developed over the last few years and where it's going to get to. because it's clearly whilst people are talking about it a little bit more in some areas, I feel like we've got a long way to go before we come to any sort of solution or approach because there's the technical challenges but also the legal challenges that go along with it.
3:49Chris Stone: So lots to dig into here, but Paul is hopefully going to help us, guide us a little bit through this topic because we only know so much on this and definitely have views on it but not to the depth and technical scale that we really should.
4:03Nick Meacham: Well, I think to that, you know, starting off for you, Paul, is just you've got the opportunity to work with some really some of the biggest sports players around the world. Would you say, you know, Nick and I talking about we feel like we're seeing more and more of this conversation be brought to light in our eyes, you know, as a B2B media company who runs global events. Are you seeing more of it in terms of, you know, your customers that you're speaking to, you know, has piracy evolved to the point it's viewed as more of a industrial size threat? Definitely, yes. So we've always taken security and content security incredibly seriously at MediaKind.
4:40Because if we go back, historically, a lot of our customers were pay TV operators, broadcasters. So content security was always an intrinsic part of our solution because it had to be because we've been securing sports content for 20, 30 years now, just more on the pay TV and broadcaster side. What we've seen more and more over the last four or five years as sports streaming has become more prevalent is the increase in requirements coming certainly from the bigger tier ones around content security because they recognize that, A, the potential loss of revenue. and secondly they recognize they also need to keep up with the pay tv operators and the broadcasters on the security side of things if they're going to justify enforcing the the rules and regulations they put on them for their content security you know they can't be perceived as being being hypocritical in that area i think it's also just worth taking a quick step back to look at how content is pirated today.
5:42If we go back when I was young, 80s, you record stuff on a videotape and you might share the videotape with your friends. It evolved in the 90s and noughties to buying a dodgy DVD down the pub. Obviously, I would never have done that, but I spent time in pubs, I've seen that happen. But that was very much a non-live experience. It was effectively a video-on-demand experience. We've ended up in the world today where sports is intrinsically a live experience. People want to watch it live. They want to be able to... It's no longer the water cola moment the following day. It's the social media moment right there, right there.
6:27When there's a goal. I want to be able to WhatsApp or signal or iMessage my friends and talk about it, talk about what's going on if we're not sat there together. So as a result, content piracy has evolved and there's just a huge number of different ways of doing it. It can be taking an insecure stream and sharing the playback address. It can be hacking the keys on a fundamentally insecure your device, which can be done by a 10-year-old kid with a script they can download off the internet. To add insult to injury, it can be CDN leeching. So not only are people stealing your content, you're paying for them to then view that content.
7:08So it's insult to injury. It can be token theft where account details are either shared around. Maybe you share it with your friends or your family, or they're stolen. and they're shared on the dark web, and you can buy someone's account details for a year or off the dark web and get access to the platform that way. It can be HDMI capture, either maybe from a laptop or from a set-top box or a mobile device with a dongle attached. I mean, if you want to get really basic, you can point a camera at a TV and record it that way. and lastly again maybe one that's not talked about so much is also accessing content from outside of the region that you're entitled so you know it could be that you know rather than paying for the content in Europe you pay for the content in India or somewhere else in the world and as a result you get access to the content you know without paying the market rate that you should be.
8:09So to then secure this, what do you need? Well, you need DRM. You need to encrypt license keys. You need to check the user is entitled to the content. You need to check the apps entitled to the content. You need to potentially block HDMI output on various devices. You might want to say that on a more insecure device, maybe something which only has level three rather than level one protection, you want to stream lower quality to those devices. So you You need to recognize that device, manipulate your manifest, and stream lower quality as a result. You need to check the same account tokens aren't being used thousands of times.
8:47You need to block VPNs and access from outside of the country or the region. And there's probably a couple of other things that I've forgotten in there as well. That's just what I can think of off the top of my head. And for many content owners or services, security is just a tick in the box during an RFP. and very often that tick in the box is just can you do DRM yes tick okay great move on to the next thing so the end result is that because it's not thought about holistically because it's not thought about from an end-to-end perspective you end up having to cobble together various bits of security from many different vendors and that's where you get the gaps or that's where you don't cover a specific use case.
9:36We believe that end-to-end security looked at in a holistic manner is intrinsic to a successful service, which is what we do. That's our way of thinking on this. So when we then start talking, especially to the larger tier ones, I was at a vendor kickoff meeting six months ago with one of our larger customers. and the first topic of the day. So we did all the introductions. We all said hello. We had a coffee and had a chat. First topic of the day after that was our service cannot become a source of piracy for our own content because they took this incredibly seriously. It was at the forefront of their mind right from the outset.
10:23And this was great because it means we can then start architecting from the outset to ensure that happens. What we're seeing very often, maybe with the smaller tier ones, the tier twos, is they don't have that level of focus because they don't have that internal expertise. They don't have someone in our organization who's responsible for the security side of things. So the end result is because they don't have that experience, it's not something they think about so much. I was at a prospect recently, a very well-known brand, and they don't even have DRM turned on today. and it's because the incumbent vendor told them it was difficult and expensive and i'm kind of sadly going no it's not you tick a box and it turns on you know that's how it should be in a well architected and well designed system it should be there from the outset but because there's these perceptions that it can be difficult it can be expensive and maybe it's not no you know so necessary let's focus on things that we do understand and you know They understand very well the consumer experience, the attractive applications.
11:32That's something which is a product owner you can get your head around very easily. And I think that's actually where organizations such as MediaKai can come in and help, is we intrinsically understand the security. We take that headache away from our customers. They can then go off and focus on actually what is the, frankly, exciting stuff, which is how do you make something really engaging for your fans? How do you make it attractive? and how do you really, really engage with them and delight them with a service which they want to then go away and watch?
12:07Nick Meacham: There's multiple things I want to dive into that. But I think sort of maybe where we'll start is, you know, the big question, maybe we can drill down to more specifics is sort of where does the blame come? Because I think you mentioned there, you know, live sports is really the crux of it. And I remember, Nick, you got to speak to Rache McKnight at UFC. talking about from a legal perspective, you know, UFC fight might only last two rounds, you know, that's five minutes. So legally, can you even shut it down in five minutes? So is it the legal side of things? And, you know, we'll dive into where we think maybe blame could be split around this pie.
12:42Nick Meacham: Not to put words in Peter Scott's mouth, who I think is one of the most intelligent people I've ever spoken to back when he was at TNT Sports. He said to be the rights holders, because if the rights holders would sell to multiple different broadcast partners, you are just creating more potential chances for your content to get pirated. So it should start at the right sort. Everyone complains and moans, but it does feel like specifically Amazon has been called out. The COO of Sky explicitly called out Amazon. Barney Francis in the interview I just mentioned, I believe, talks about the Amazon fire stick.
13:15Nick Meacham: It does feel like in the last, I don't know, 12 months, Amazon specifically has been called out. I'm just curious, you know, maybe Nick, we'll start with you. Do you feel the shift to what seems to be more big tech is to blame? Is that justified?
13:32Chris Stone: It's justified. I mean, everyone's pointing fingers in all sorts of different directions. I think if you went back, we've covered it before, but what came out of the conversation between Serie A and BN Sport was a great example that BN said, if you want us to pay exclusive rights, exclusive rights deal to you, then you have to make sure that the content is exclusive and they would stop looking at content being exclusive because of the prevalence of piracy and because serial wasn't taking enough steps at the rights owner level to mitigate some of those risks that needed to be taken to protect their asset that they were paying a premium for.
14:09Chris Stone: I mean, Amazon's an easy one to point out because of the conversation around, I don't remember what they call that, fire sticks and so forth, which have become quite prevalent around IPTV use and so forth. But that is only one aspect of it. I don't think even if you turn that, you can point fingers as much as you like at Amazon, but they're not the only part of the piece of the puzzle that's causing all of this from what I can see. There's a lot of other aspects. And even if Amazon found a way to stop that, which I'm not sure how easy that would be, people would just turn to other more cloud and online-based solutions instead of that would be my guess in theory.
14:43Chris Stone: I'm sure Paul might have a bit of a view on that. Yeah, I mean, the Fire TV one, I find it quite interesting conversation. I mean, let's be quite clear, the fault lies with the pirates. They're the ones who are enabling this. And the rest of it is sort of a wider conversation. I mean, the Fire TV to me is very much like the dodgy DVD sold down the pub. It's not the fault of the DVD manufacturers or the DVD recorder manufacturers. as it was the people who were selling them down the pub. You know, the Fire TV, I think, gets blamed because it's a very convenient, low-cost dongle that you can buy for 20, 30 pounds, dollars, euros, choose your currency unit.
15:27And it's very easy to sideload applications that the Pirates have developed on there and then make that available to people who choose to buy them. But if it wasn't a Fire TV, it would just be another low-cost device. Android open source intrinsically allows you to load whatever applications you want on there. It just so happens that a Fire TV is a cheap, readily available device for people to buy. So short of locking down the device completely to prevent sideloading of applications, which I think many people would object to because they justifiably want to sideload applications onto their devices.
16:10There's a whole talk now about opening up app stores on the Apple ecosystem because people want the right to put the applications they want and the devices they've purchased. So short of completely locking that down, I'm not really too sure what Amazon can do with a Fire TV. I'll hold my hands up. I'm not the best educated on this one. Maybe there's people out there who have some thoughts on this. Maybe that's a topic for a future podcast. I don't know. I'd love to hear them myself. But certainly from my view, it's a convenient thing to blame, but it doesn't fix the underlying problem of piracy.
16:49Chris Stone: And as, Paul, you sort of set the scene, there is a countless different ways of pirates to be able to get access to the content. And therefore, you just turn off one, you plug one leaky hole in the bucket, then another hole will explode somewhere else along the way. You mentioned a whole host of different ways and measures that need to be taken to protect content, protect live content in particular. Can you give us a sense of which ways are the most prevalent or the ones that are dominating the way that this content is being pirated? Is there one that really stands out or is it pretty broad across the whole spectrum that you ran through earlier?
17:30I mean, the main one is DRM because that's the one which is generally the easiest one to implement with a couple of exceptions for maybe some vendors who are not so experienced in that space who find it a bit more challenging because they don't come from the video background. CDN tokenization is very, very popular as well. You know, the big CDNs, the Akibis, the Fasties, et cetera, have some good add-on services there that you can implement. And that seems to be the next one, which is generally used by the customers and prospects that we're talking with. Bringing on top of that, this is where we really come in looking at this from a holistic perspective, is the entitlements check.
18:12Either checking that the application is a valid application and also checking that the user themselves are actually entitled to the content. I think very often the challenge you have there is that when people are going out and doing RFPs, they'll go to a platform vendor, they'll go to a streaming vendor, they'll go to a security vendor, and they'll have to then bring these various components together. And as a result, starting to run those entitlement checks in conjunction with the streaming vendor gets quite tricky because it's not an easy thing to integrate. You know, we've gone down the route of offering this as a holistic solution because we want to make sure that we can layer these additional security checks for our customers to really secure the content.
19:07The more checks you can have, the more you can protect the content. But generally, it is DRM to start with, CDN tokenization, and then we start to layer additional checks on top of that. many other services out there will just stop with DRM license checks. And they may then start to look at things like key rotation for live content. That's, again, an interesting topic to go into. Some people view it as an absolute necessity. Other people view it as if it's live sports content, it's only really going to be up and running for two hours. by the time you've rotated the keys, you know, is it really something that's worth doing in an event-based stream ecosystem?
19:55There seem to be two very polar opposite schools thoughts there, I think, depending on what people want to sell on any particular day of the week.
20:05Nick Meacham: Well, I've got a bit of a side question here, Nick, that I asked Steve when Steve and I did a piracy podcast, and it got some people a bit fired up on LinkedIn. And the question I asked was, I used the metaphor, you know, if a tree falls in the woods and no one is there, does the tree make a sound? And the question I asked, Nick, was if no one is broadcasting it, is it still piracy? The point I was making is like college football in the UK until very recently where TNT's picked up. It wasn't broadcast at all. So the idea is, you know.
20:40Chris Stone: In the market. Yeah. In the market you're in. Correct, yes.
20:43Nick Meacham: So if no one's broadcasting in your market, is it still piracy? I think the answer is yes, but there's some people got fired up. There's definitely a yes.
20:51Chris Stone: There's definitely a yes. But whether it's more understandable why people who are desperate top-tier fans look for a way of finding it, I could appreciate that perhaps more. And it is kind of mad in this day and age that there's still rights out there that haven't been segmented away from major rights deals that don't just make that stuff available. Now, I know I've spoken to some rights owners and they're just like, oh, it's just such a minor audience that we just don't basically just don't bother doing it. And I was like, oh, this day and age, I think you could probably be smarter with that approach or a little bit more strategic than it's just not worth the hassle because of all the markets that you might be still able to reach.
21:35Chris Stone: And you put all this collection of audiences together, then you should be able to get something meaningful out of that audience reach that you wouldn't otherwise have. So I do find it surprising in this day and age, there are still lots of dark markets for pretty well-known sports with pretty high revenues that they aren't willing to, yeah, just make sure it's democratized somewhat. Maybe because of the fears of what we've been talking about. Maybe that is part of it as well. They don't want to have it available in certain markets because they know that that might open up the doors. I'm not too sure.
22:05I think, Nick, on that front, there's also the team sizes that are available at a lot of the rights holders. I think there's very often the perception that there's lots of people working this. There must be someone who sat around twiddling their thumbs who can just go away and do this. And the reality is there's probably not. But a lot of the companies that we're talking to, a four-person team looking at their entire D2C streaming ecosystem and service, four people is a good-sized team. For many, it's one person, and they're doing it as a side thing for their day job as well. you know yeah so i think a lot of this is often down to the team sizes that are available in there um and also you know there is the risk of you know if you put this content out there you know can it actually be a profitable service is this something we can make money on because if not you then have to pull it or you're going to have people even more upset um in that situation so i think the increasing simplicity of launching D2C services is fantastic.
23:20The ability to get the content out there is great, but you do also need to consider when having that conversation is, okay, exactly how can this content be monetized? And obviously, Eric Ramberg, when he was on the podcast with you, talked a lot about advertising and what can be done there. There's also additional conversations maybe about what can be done to help with sponsorship. Can you add additional value to sponsors? But fundamentally, these services have to be profitable in order to make them viable. And I think that's where a lot of the concerns coming in is once the content's out there, we have to ensure that it remains out there and is a profitable service for them.
24:04Chris Stone: So, Paul, in that example, let's say you've got a client who's let's say maybe tier two level kind of not right at the pointy end but has got different types of relationships and different types of access available in different markets um they are looking at the prospect of like okay actually we need to be we want to be available globally in all 200 plus markets depending on what you define as a market the the perception would be that for certain sports is if they're already producing a feed of content and so forth that it would be relatively straightforward, not too expensive to just open up the doors of access, so to speak, to be available, let's say through your own OTT product, as an example, be available in every market from there onwards.
24:50Chris Stone: That would be the perception. Just what are some of those challenges then? Is cost linear in that instance of that market by market that you're adding to it? Or is there more of a, the more markets you open up, does it become more cost effective for some reason. I'm just curious if that makes sense as a question. I think the more markets you're in, the more cost effective it becomes because the more subscribers you will have. And there's always some kind of intrinsic base cost or base fee of launching these services and having them in market. And the more subscribers you have, the more you can amortize that cost across more subscribers.
25:27I think what we're generally seeing is the challenge of removing the friction to access. So they need to ensure that they are working with a vendor or a platform that has the flexibility to create a large number of different packages to address different consumers in different countries. So, for example, one of our customers, they are a tier one, but there's no reason a tier two couldn't do this, has over 2 ,000 SKUs or packages available globally to allow them to address a global audience. that you want to have different pricing options in different countries. You might want to have different tiers of packages in different countries to entice people to come on board.
26:11You then start to need to look at how you can incentivize people to sign up. So is it a free month when you sign up? Is it maybe a free weekend of content? Is it things like live looking that we recently launched with one of our customers where you can watch the first 10 minutes of the game for free. And if you want to keep watching, you pay. There's a variety of different things out there that can be done. But in order to do that, you need to have a very flexible and nuanced set of entitlements. And that's something which, again, technically very similar to doing streaming at massive scale, very similar to securing your content.
26:52That's something which is quite a difficult thing to do if the underlying architecture in your platform and ecosystem isn't done well. So again, this is another set of requirements in your RFP process you need to consider. It's not just how can you help me launch in one market at one price, it's how can you help me launch in 50 markets with 10 different prices with a different set of features and functionality in each of those markets so that I can then tune my pricing or tweak things to really reach the price point that works in those markets. And that then goes back to the security and piracy side of things of, well, once you've got all these different packages out there, how do you stop someone in the UK accessing the package that's available in Indonesia or India or Nigeria, which is lower cost with less functionality?
27:49again that then comes down to entitlement checks that comes down to geo blocking that comes down to vpn blocking so you're adding a whole um other amount of work on top of that and if you're bob or barry from you know whose main job is as a broadcast engineer and you're doing this as your side job you you don't have the capabilities of doing that so they need to ensure they're working with vendors who have that intrinsic capability and can manage it for them to ensure that all these packages are out there and available and working with their marketing team to, you know, get the content out there in a way that it can be accessed, but also that it's done in a way that then makes sure the content is fundamentally secure and only accessed by the people who have the rights to it.
28:37Nick Meacham: So are you saying that Simon Jordan's claim that the Premier League could just easily set up a D2C platform and make billions and billions of dollars wouldn't actually be that easy? um i don't think it would be that easy um i mean i think anyone who's listening to this podcast who's been around in the industry for a while knows that nothing is ever that easy but yeah you know i think it could be done if they wanted to um it's not overnight though it would need to be done in a way that you know had a given premier league content is incredibly valuable It would need to be done in a way that is, I think, security first, ensures they protect their content and also ensures that they're holding themselves to the same standards that they hold their broadcast partners to.
29:26Yeah.
29:27Chris Stone: And there's no question that there's a market for it. Of all my travels there, Premier League is being consumed one way or other right across the globe. And there's inevitably a pretty massive opportunity there if that's unlocked. I'm curious, Paul, to take it a step further from the tier ones, because often piracy is typically mainly associated with the tier ones, and I think rightfully so, because they're the needle movers when it comes to consumption. how far down do you think and see that the need to manage piracy through end-to-end is essential? Is a smaller tier three sports media set of rights or an outlet or platform, do they have to treat it with the same needs and the same parameters as, say, a tier one?
30:16Chris Stone: or is there, because the demand's not to that scale, you wouldn't put that amount of effort into it or that amount of breadth into it? I think a lot of it comes down to the intrinsic value of the content as well. To secure content, there is always some kind of intrinsic cost. I think what we generally see is that if a league or a club doesn't take it seriously from the outset and then they then start to get more and more successful, and they start to get more and more subscribers and more and more viewers, at some point in the future, they're probably going to have a problem. And they've then got a choice two or three years down the line.
30:59Do we just hold our hands up and say, oh, this is going to be a problem for us, and they take the financial hit? Do they replatform, which is definitely an option, but that requires a significant amount of time and effort? Or do they think about it from the start and work with vendors who intrinsically understand this, and they can then turn on the features they want as they need them? You know, they may choose just to start off with nothing. Maybe they're not particularly bothered if that content's getting stolen to start with. I was talking to a potential customer recently. They're like, yeah, we don't really particularly mind because it gets more people interested in the sport.
31:45So they're actually, bizarrely enough, reasonably happy with a little bit of piracy because it gets the sports out there. But at some point, yeah, they're going to want to start to turn DRM on as things get more popular because they're going to want to start securing the content. Then further down the line, they're going to want to start layering on more and more security options as they start taking it more and more seriously. So the choice is really there is, do you not care about it from day one and focus on other things and potentially give yourself a big headache in two, three, four years' time?
32:18Or do you start working with vendors from the outset who actually understand this and can turn on the features and functionality you want when you need them? I would tend towards the second. Obviously, I'm highly biased because that's what we do. So obviously, I'm bound to say that. But even when we're talking to the smaller tier twos and the tier threes, not only come to us and say, oh, you know, we're doing this because we've got 20 ,000 subs. We want to keep them happy. They're always coming to us and saying, we've got 20 ,000 subs. And in five years time, we want to have 100 ,000 or half a million or a million.
32:53Everyone comes to us with grand aspirations. That's why they're doing this. They're not doing this to sit still. They're doing this to grow. So if you're doing this to grow, you need to think long term. You need to make sure that you're planning for five years' time when you've got 20 times as many fans on your platform.
33:13Chris Stone: And so just pause. So that basically comes down to, I think you've explained it pretty well, but I just want to summarize it. is effectively if you have aspirations to grow but you don't set up your own platform effectively, you will basically risk you have to re-platform and rebuild it again effectively or close to if you don't have just the construct set up from day one to at least be able to turn on those levers as and when you want. Yeah. And look, we quite like customers out there who want to do that because there's quite a few that we're talking to right now who've been in the market for a number of years with competitive solutions, and they've been very happy with them up to a point, and they're now coming out into the market and running RFPs to replatform because they recognize they've got to the point where they want to grow further, they need to secure their content more, and as a result, they're talking to us.
34:06So I'm never unhappy when someone wants to replatform. It's good for our business, but equally, if you choose a vendor from the outset who helps you secure that long-term vision, that makes your life simpler in the long run as well.
34:24Nick Meacham: So I'm going to change this direction a little bit. And we keep hearing people talking about piracies costing hundreds of millions of pounds, hundreds of millions of dollars, whatever currency you want to do. More, yeah. 28 billion, is that what the number I think gets flown? I can't remember the last numbers,
34:39Chris Stone: but it was in the tens of billions, I think.
34:41Nick Meacham: Yeah, I think 28 billion is the number that gets flown around from time to time. But one of the things behind that is they're talking about it's costing the broadcasters and that's costing the rights holders and it's this overall negative. And my opinion, Nick, and I mentioned this when we were talking about this, is I think sometimes we look at piracy as an illness, whereas I view piracy as more of a symptom. It's just one part of a larger thing. There's so many games that aren't on TV that are available. The stuff that is on TV is incredibly expensive. and then you look at it beyond there, you know, try to go to a Premier League match or an NFL match in particular in person.
35:19Nick Meacham: The cost of tickets are just extortionate. You know, we've talked about the FIFA Club World Cup, how expensive it was to go to a game there. You know, I don't know what the travel sports situation's like in the UK, but I can tell you in the US, parents are paying thousands of dollars for little Johnny to go play baseball, soccer, things like that. Sports feels like it's never been more inaccessible. And I think sometimes we talk about what's the solution to this. I think Nick, you and I are probably a bit on board with, I don't know if technology can solve this. It's not that there aren't vendors out there that are coming up with really clever and creative ways to disrupt piracy, but I don't know if that's really looking to the root of the problem.
35:56Nick Meacham: I think, Nick, we've talked about it, and Paul, you alluded to it a little bit, talking about advertising. Is that really, Nick, in your opinion, not saying it's going to be easy, not saying it can be done overnight, but does it have to stop being trying to stop pirates and more focusing on how the monetization of distribution is and i know that's a very big question big ask nick but like is do you feel like we're getting
36:18Chris Stone: more and more that i think it's that it's it does come down to the root cause of that approach and obviously we look towards the music industry and um and video uh entertainment world which has gone through its own journeys and inevitably that was how it got to a point where it had to be the model had to change for it to be viable and for basically piracy to not be as prevalent as valuable anymore in the eyes of the consumer so inevitably that seems like the most logical route to um reduce the need and the the impact that piracy does have but we've still got a long way to go to get to a place where that is achievable and both in the instance of music it was only because spotify found a way to bridge that but i uh i've watched the i think it's a documentary it's like one of those shows which is um based on a true story but it is dramatized i'm I'm not sure what the name of that is.
37:11Chris Stone: It's actually a Swedish series, and it's basically on Spotify's journey. And that was the first time I really came to grasp with understanding how the difficult bit was the negotiation of rights deals and relationships with the distributors and the producers, the companies that own basically all the music. It wasn't just creating a platform and even doing rights deals with the musicians themselves. And I think sports has got that similar predicament with the way the writer approached now. today how do you retrofit all that to get everyone on board and spotify had to go through a lot to find a way to get everyone to get on the boat so to speak so i think that's gonna be really really tricky um but i think it's the only real way that piracy would ever have a have a true sort of um what do you call like a an end point i suppose uh to what it's doing now in sports so and for now It's just going the other direction.
38:07Chris Stone: There is no light really at the end of the tunnel there. I think what Paul and Edicon and lots of other companies are doing is to try and mitigate and reduce those losses and impact and really slow down that impact or minimize as much as possible. And that's all we can really be thinking about now rather than trying to say, hey, we're going to solve it. No one is going to solve it magically. I think there's also a perceived value for fans as well. So if the cost is being perceived as expensive, that often just means that people aren't actually seeing they're getting value from the service that they're accessing.
38:51Again, this is something we saw in RFP recently where I think it was third on the list of their requirements or their challenges was there's a service in market today, but it's being perceived by the fans as being expensive. So, you know, how do you handle that? Well, if you can give them more value for money, if you can give them additional features and functionality, they're more likely to actually think, oh, yeah, I don't mind paying for this because I'm getting value for money. You know, I don't mind paying$10.99 a month for Netflix because I perceive it as good value for money. so it's also what can you do in that area to you know give fans the perception of value for money obviously you know great content is a starting point having the event available is is one thing but it's then start it's other things like you know okay highlights are the highlights available on there are they available immediately after the match you know as a fan um you know can i go in and re-watch the game if i've missed it immediately as soon as it finishes or am i having to wait three or four hours.
39:59If I could have waited three or four hours, oh, that's not good. We've recently introduced Multiview with one of our customers, which is available on all their consumer devices, including smart TVs, which is something that traditionally wasn't available because the devices didn't have the processing power. And the result is that they've seen a huge reduction in their amount of churn because all of a sudden consumers are getting what was previously a premium high-end feature on all their devices. So it's a nice way for them to interact with the sports they're watching, and they really, really like it.
40:38I think the other one, and again, this comes down to perceived value, and I think also a degree of anti-piracy is video latency. So if we think historically, you know, video latency on streaming was, 20, 30, 40 seconds, probably 30, 40, 50 seconds. So all of a sudden, you're way behind the live action, especially comparing that to a broadcast platform. So you're delayed there. If you've got, say, a friend who's watching on the broadcast platform, they've text you or WhatsApp you or signaled or telegrammed or I messaged you about the, or you've seen it on x or whatever before you've even seen the goal on your platform so again it's like oh i'm paying all this money for this but i'm learning about the goal from social media or the you know the overtake or whatever event it is so actually by bringing down video latency so it's you know broadcast equivalent or better all of a sudden that you're ahead of social media you're viewing the action the same time as your friends, the buddy you've got who's actually lucky enough to have got the ticket to the game, you're seeing it so quickly after they've seen it that all of a sudden you can have the interaction.
41:56So there's then the perceived value that you're getting a high value service as well. So there's additional things that can be done to add value to the service so that people are then not so concerned about paying the money they are.
42:08Nick Meacham: I think that's a really great example. And it got me thinking, you know, the one big subscription service I pay for from a sports perspective is the NFL Game Pass. You know, for me, Sky's obviously got it on there. I've got access to Sky, but like, I want to specifically watch the Cincinnati Bengals. So part of it is like, I can watch the team I want. It's also got NFL Red Zone, which I argues maybe the best sports product in the world. But the feature that's really important for me that I want to pay for, as I've gotten older, the less likely I am to watch the Bengals play a Monday night game where they're going to break my heart.
42:38Nick Meacham: So there's no point in me staying up till 5 a.m. But I think Delta Trey initially put into the platform and DAZN's carried on, which is where I get value, is your point, being able to watch the game afterwards. And not only do they have the full game replay, they also do a 40 minute recap where it's literally from one play in, next play in. There's no commercials. There's nothing else. And for me, my travel time into work is about 45 minutes. So the fact that I can wake up, download the game on my phone so that I don't worry about being on the tube, no service, and I can watch the Bengals game the night before.
43:07Nick Meacham: it's what you're talking about right there it's just it's an additional layer of uh service or features that then all of a sudden i don't mind the cost that i'm paying because it's not a cheap subscription but it has enough features within it and particularly that that download the game from the night before like it's just it's an incredible feature for me that justifies the cost that i spend on it yeah i think also i mean we touched on advertising earlier i think that's probably quite an important topic to talk about yeah i think eric on uh when he did the podcast with you So he talked around the other challenges of doing advertising at huge scale, how you deal with the thundering herd of 100 ,000 or a million people or devices all needing to see a target advert at the same time and how you handle that.
43:48So, yeah, once you've got over the intrinsic technological challenges, you then start to get onto the value-based challenges of how do you ensure that all your ad spots are filled? How do you make sure that you'll maximize that ad inventory so that you can maximize your revenue and offer it to as many consumers as possible? And again, that's a conversation which is, I think, anyone who's thinking about ad-funded services should be having with the vendors they're talking to. Because, yeah, there's multiple solutions there around working with multiple ADSs, the support of pre-sold and programmatic ads, utilizing house adverts, working across device-specific ADSs, all sorts of lovely stuff there.
44:32But what's often then not talked about is what you can do with the same technology to add additional value to sponsors. Because very often, you know, sponsors are looking either for more value or you have the opportunity to, you know, add sponsorship inventory. So can you use the same tech so that when someone tunes into a live game, rather than going straight into the live game, you splash up the sponsor logo or a three or five second sponsor message? You want something unintrusive. You don't want it to be the situation where someone hits play and they want to go to the live game. They're sat there watching a 30 second pre-roll advert getting angrier and angrier and losing their perceived value because they're missing the action.
45:18but you know something one two three four five seconds yeah most people will accept that so there's additional value that can be brought there from a sponsorship perspective which i think is also something very very important and the great thing is the same underlying tech can deliver this so long as you have things architected in the in the right way um uh paul you mentioned ads's so
45:39Chris Stone: for those that don't know that's you know i guess that's a dressable advertising system i think is the decision server. Yes. This isn't server one of the, but basically helps, helps serve more personalized advertising into connected, connected TVs and streaming experiences. That, is that basically? That's it. So yeah, rather than showing the same advert to everyone, you can target it. I mean, maybe a per region level, per country level, per city level, right the way down to, you know, Paul, Chris, and Nick would all see a totally different advert based on likes, dislikes, or what they know about us from a data perspective.
46:15Chris Stone: And that targeted nature, how far along do you think we are with that being adopted and used effectively, particularly around sports? Is it prevalent? It's pretty prevalent today with the larger sports leagues. I think what's good for a consumer is when it's done well, they shouldn't even know they're being targeted. Very often, unfortunately, it's done badly. So it goes to an ad break and the video stutters and you get a little buffering thing whilst everything works itself out. But when done well and when done properly, which is an area of huge focus for us, it's transparent to the user. So they don't even necessarily know or recognize they're being targeted with an advert.
46:59So the other good thing there is, you know, generally the more targeted the advert, the more revenue you'll get. You know, showing a general broadcast advert has value, but it means lots of people who are going to have no interest in it are going to end up seeing it. So you get paid less. If you can really target that advert to people who are going to be wanting to be interested in the product means you can get more money. But it means effectively you can segment your audience and you can then start to target them.
47:34motor racing, they've probably got an interest in motorbikes or motorcars. So that's a fairly safe bet to sort of have that kind of advertising on there. So I think sports especially lends itself very well to targeted advertising specifically because you've got people who are very interested in a specific topic.
47:56Nick Meacham: And then I think one of the last things that I was going to talk about a little bit, Nick, here, just talking about the impact of media rights deals. I think, you know, we look at some of that stuff has maybe been flatlining a little bit in Europe. And I think we've even seen, you know, the example with DAZN and Ligun, they, you know, reference, you know, rampant piracy being part of the reason that DAZN no longer wanted to engage, whether that's the real reason or not. It was, you know, I think it was, you know, listed out there as one of them. I think back to when I joined the company, BLQ was a big thing.
48:30Nick Meacham: And I think that had some impact over some different negotiations and things like that. But if piracy continues to be as rampant as it is, Nick, how big of an impact do you think that actually does have? Or do you think exclusive rights are going to be impacted by the legacy or the perceived impact of piracy?
48:51Chris Stone: There's no question. I think it's already having a big impact, and it can only get bigger and bigger. And I think when you couple that with the changing consumer habits that exist, the role that Netflix and streaming platforms have, the role that YouTube has in being entertainment for people to consume and having it at a click of a button with ease of access and no cost associated. Not as a direct cost associated, there is some sort of value being shared depending on if it's advertising led or not. I think it's only going to make it harder and harder for rights owners without really investing effort into piracy, to blocking piracy and mitigating piracy, that it's going to become more of a challenge for them to get those rights deals if they're not really tackling this head-on and finding ways to do everything they can to mitigate the impact, working with Paul and his team as an example, and also working more collaboratively across the wider industry to try and find other ways to, I don't know, find better tactics to try and continue to get a little bit closer to, I guess, the pace of movement you see in the piracy world.
50:02Chris Stone: It's a bit like when we started seeing doping in sports, where they were always saying that the scientists were always ahead of the testing. I feel it's a bit of that. We need to find a way to try and bridge that gap and narrow this gap of trying to chase the pirates and the new ways that they can do things and try and get ahead of the curve somehow. I know that sounds right, Paul, to you. Yeah, I mean, I guess I've actually got a question, I think, for you, Nick and Chris, is, you know, given the state of the market with piracy at the moment, do you think the exclusive media rights broadcast deals are still viable?
50:38Chris Stone: i would say that they are still i mean it's a really weird it's a really weird industry right now where you've got the some of these tier ones are generating insane growth levers but like in the us and especially because it's actually i believe it's actually driven heavily to do with the advertising landscape and the growth of that we talked to a lot of streaming and major tech companies in new york at our event there and they're also focused on using live sports is that advertising sales tool to drive huge revenues. That on top of the subscription value it provides, but advertising is really the next outlet.
51:14Chris Stone: We've seen other sports across the world outside the US that that growth is flatlined significantly. A lot of sports properties are having to give more to keep the media rights values at a level. Premier League was one of those examples last cycle where they had to give a lot more games in the package to try and ensure that Sky and others weren't willing to step away from the big checks they've been paying them for some time. At some stage, if they keep pulling away the layers to it, they're going to run out of layers to be pulling away to try and keep those revenues up, and it's going to make it really difficult.
51:46Chris Stone: So I think that's why they have to be looking at more distribution channels, more ways to get to market, their own OTT channels being much more a key part of it, and other distribution partnerships they can do to just make sure they're maximizing the reach of their content. But that means along with that is a shift away from just pure rights from deals to other ways of monetizing, like you pointed out, Paul, around advertising and sponsorship as a way, which is growing. The sponsorship industry is growing digitally, but it needs to grow even faster if it's to shift the industry along with it.
52:21Nick Meacham: Yeah, and I agree with Nick. I think it's going to be too difficult to just exclusively work with one or two partners, which I feel is what you see in the majority in the UK. I'm a massive fan of free to air I appreciate we've talked about this the NFL is king because it's largely free to air and it's advertising model I understand you can't do the same thing for the Premier League because the games aren't structured with the amount of stops and starts where you can just insert an ad but I'd be pretty willing to bet if you went out to most people in the UK and you said hey you'll be able to watch the Premier League for free but you know every 15 minutes we're going to have a 30 second in game ad where we're going to cut the commentary for the game to run some sort of small ad.
52:59Nick Meacham: I think most people would be willing to do that in comparison to, you know, having to pay what they're currently paying for Sky and everyone else. And I think I've done it where I think only like 52 % of games are currently live. Now that'll change next year when they increase the amount of games. But I do think, you know, to Nick's point, I would love to see YouTube. I know Rob Pilgrim said that the UK and European markets are different than the US. I'd love to see the rollout of like a YouTube TV type of thing over here. But yeah, I agree with Nick. I just, I don't think long-term it's viable to stay with the system that is, particularly if they're going to keep blaming piracy as much as they are.
53:35Nick Meacham: So with that, Paul, I do appreciate you coming on today. It is nice to hear from the other side because Nick and I can typically talk about what we think, but it's nice to hear someone that actually has to work and actually combat, you know, piracy hand-to-hand and you've got insights from your clients. And it is good to hear that they are prioritizing piracy now in those conversations that you're having. So we really appreciate you coming on and having this conversation with us. Thank you very much for having me. It's been a lovely conversation.
54:00Chris Stone: Thanks, Paul. Now, before you go, if you like what you heard today, be sure to rate and review and just let me know what you think on social. You can find me on most social platforms at SportsProNick. And please do spread the word of the podcast. There's no better way of marketing than word of mouth, whether that be in person or on social media. And if you don't like what you've heard, or you think we should be doing more or less of something, then reach out and let me know as I'd love to hear from you. Thanks, Streamtimers. Until next time.
Piracy is costing the sports industry an estimated $28 billion annually — and the issue is only growing more complex. In this episode of StreamTime Sports, co-hosts Nick Meacham and Chris Stone are joined by Paul O’Donovan from MediaKind to explore the causes and affects of the rising threat of piracy. From legal loopholes to changing sports distributions strategies, the trio dissects the industry's most pressing issue.Key Topics: