1. Podcasts
  2. Strict Scrutiny
  3. Will the Blue Wave Come for SCOTUS?
Strict Scrutiny

9 Nov 2026 · 1h 42m · 35 chapters

Episode artwork

Will the Blue Wave Come for SCOTUS?

In short

The hosts celebrate a “blue wave” election outcome while arguing that Supreme Court rulings helped distort the electoral process and that Supreme Court reform is necessary to protect democracy. They connect election news to SCOTUS reform, discuss a major recent case, and frame the DOJ’s Dobbs-leak inquiry as another example of executive power.

Guests (on-stage)

Sherilyn Ifill Eiffel, former president and director-counsel of the NAACP Legal Defense Fund; founding director of the 14th Amendment Center for Law and Democracy at Howard University School of Law.

Key claims

  1. The Supreme Court weakened democratic safeguards by striking down campaign finance limits, gutting parts of the Voting Rights Act, blocking challenges to partisan gerrymandering while enabling new redistricting, and facilitating voter suppression (e.g., New Hampshire student-ID limits; FCC discounted political ad rates; approval of unreliable voter-verification databases).
  2. Competitive authoritarianism remains authoritarian even after electoral wins.
  3. St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy is about a claimed constitutional right to use public funds to discriminate against gay and transgender people.
  4. Supreme Court reform should be on the accountability agenda; elections are “portals” to fix broken institutions.

Notable examples

  • Mississippi felony disenfranchisement: 70,000 disenfranchised; two-thirds Black; court previously rejected a challenge.
  • St. Mary: Colorado universal pre-K; schools receiving funds can’t discriminate based on sexual orientation/gender identity.
  • Oral argument examples: Justice Sotomayor pressed that Catholic schools could reject children based on parents’ homosexuality; Kavanaugh argued “win-win” school choice; Alito advanced a theory linking anti-LGBT rules to anti-Catholic discrimination.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:15

The Blue Wave Discussion

Hosts discuss the unexpected timing of the blue wave and its significance.

“As you know, Strict Scrutiny is your podcast about the Supreme Court that is about to get reformed.”
4:21

Connecting Elections to SCOTUS

Exploration of the recent elections and their implications for the Supreme Court.

“We love that the Blue Nami blew the lid off this fascist, sadist, terrible, racist regime.”
5:59

The St. Mary Parish Case Analysis

Analysis of the Supreme Court case regarding public funds and discrimination.

“And we are going to do our part to help move things along by talking SCOTUS and democracy and SCOTUS reform as really an imperative for democracy.”
15:43

The Distortion of Democracy by the Supreme Court

Discussing how the Supreme Court has distorted democracy through various rulings.

“So with that note, let's focus on the election.”
17:44

Challenges Faced by Voters

Exploring the obstacles voters faced in overcoming the Supreme Court's actions.

“It blew up campaign finance regulation, which cleared the way for individuals like Elon Musk to pour hundreds of millions of dollars into this election, much of it in the great state of Texas.”
22:47

Implications of Election Outcomes

Discussing the implications of recent election results and linking them to SCOTUS actions.

“Competitive authoritarianism is still authoritarianism.”
23:42

The New Rules of the Road

Speculating on the new political landscape and mandates following the elections.

“All right, another election slash SCOTUS crossover before we turn to the recaps.”
28:01

Discussion on Political Mandates

The hosts discuss the implications of the Democrats' political mandate and past guests of the show who have run for office.

“I mean, she says she's not a political pundit.”
33:11

Oral Arguments Analysis

The hosts analyze the Supreme Court case St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy and its implications on discrimination and funding.

“Yeah, this is going to be depressing, guys.”
42:02

Discrimination and Religious Freedom Debate

Explore the nuances of discrimination against LGBTQ+ individuals in legal discussions, particularly in relation to religious freedoms.

“John Roberts, is going to write an opinion saying something along the lines of, the way to stop discrimination against religious conservatives is to start discriminating against gay people.”
Show all 35 chapters
52:21

The Need for Supreme Court Reform

Discuss the importance of Supreme Court reform in the context of democratic accountability and power balance.

“Corrupting our democracy works best when we forget that we, the people, are in charge.”
56:00

The Fragility of Democracy and the Supreme Court

Discussing the precarious state of democracy and the Supreme Court's role in it.

“I mean, one way I kind of think about this is we have to learn lessons from what the Biden administration didn't do and their errors.”
57:20

Learning from the Biden Administration's Errors

Examining the lessons from the Biden administration's approach to accountability and governance.

“they come back worse and stronger, right?”
58:40

Reforming SCOTUS: Necessary Steps

Identifying multiple levels of reform needed for the Supreme Court's confirmation process and ethics.

“They are about actually getting into place the people who will make the policy that channels the will of the sovereign people, right?”
1:00:40

Corruption and the Supreme Court's Hostility

Highlighting the Supreme Court's opposition to anti-corruption measures and its implications.

“But this Supreme Court is going to be a major obstacle to the effective passage of most of the policy preferences of the people who chose the majority of members in Congress as of January.”
1:01:50

Historical Consequences of Supreme Court Decisions

Reflecting on the historical impact of Supreme Court decisions on democracy and civil rights.

“I know the consequences that were felt by black people in this country.”
1:04:40

Public Education on Supreme Court Matters

Discussing the need for public engagement and education on Supreme Court reform and democracy.

“like voters rejected so much of what the Roberts Court has done because it wasn't just see corruption.”
1:07:40

Institutional Value and Supreme Court Legitimacy

Exploring the need for Supreme Court reform and its implications for institutional trust.

“And I do think that it is now a position that should unite radicals who want to completely tear down our institutions and protectors and guardians of our institutions.”
1:10:00

Institutional Confidence in the Supreme Court

Discussion on public confidence in the Supreme Court and its leadership.

1:11:40

Assessing Chief Justice Roberts

Debate on whether Chief Justice Roberts deserves the label of institutionalist amidst criticisms.

“Even when they're saying things I think are crazy, like I respect the court as an institution.”
1:13:20

The Supreme Court's YOLO Energy

Exploring the Supreme Court's aggressive actions and the need for reform.

“Like if we leave this loaded weapon on the table, we are doing ourselves a disservice.”
1:15:50

Confronting Reality in Democracy

A call to process the dangers faced by democracy and the need for accountability.

“It was not wanting to be confrontational.”
1:17:30

Ending on a Light Note

Transitioning to a game about Supreme Court justices in a light-hearted manner.

“And as promised, as promised, we're going to end with a game.”
1:18:20

This or That: Supreme Court Edition

A fun game comparing positive election outcomes with humorous scenarios for justices.

“One is going to be something warm, fuzzy, rainbows and ponies goodness, things that we're happy about after the election.”
1:24:01

Discussion on Political Ads

The hosts discuss the impact of various political ads and their creators.

“Well I should say first of all the person responsible for that ad was really Patrick Gaspard.”
1:25:10

Mashups and AI in Politics

They talk about a mashup video and a Vogue cover featuring political figures.

“The work wear guy on Blue Sky lusting after the cut of John Ossoff's jib or Donald Trump lusting after John Husted's deflated peaches.”
1:26:25

Reflecting on Election Results

The hosts reflect on recent democratic victories and their implications.

“We should shout out at Quantidini on Threads.”
1:28:47

Long Game in Politics

A discussion about the importance of patience in pursuing political change.

“breaking down completely baseless cases that nevertheless were holding up the show.”
1:33:11

The Call to Action

A compelling moment about the obligation to continue working for change.

1:34:26

Favorite Things and Personal Milestones

The hosts share their favorite moments from recent elections and personal experiences.

“And as always we will end with our favorite things.”
1:36:11

Community Engagement and Reflections

The hosts reflect on their interactions with listeners and their impact.

“I think it was this morning, maybe it was yesterday, but if you're listening on Monday, I think Friday's M.”
1:38:00

Reflections on Election Night

The hosts share their excitement and reflections on the recent election night results.

“And so shout out to Argent who made our blazers, which we love.”
1:38:32

Engaging with Students on the Constitution

The hosts discuss their experiences talking with students about the Constitution and amendments.

“I'm also loving Min Jin Lee's American Hagwon.”
1:39:20

Gratitude and Acknowledgments

The hosts express gratitude to various individuals and groups for their contributions and efforts.

“And we were talking about the Constitution.”
1:41:14

Momentum for Change

The conversation emphasizes the importance of continuing efforts to drive political change.

“the country see the horrors that this administration was perpetrating.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Strict Scrutiny, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Strict Scrutiny is brought to you by Americans United for Separation of Church and State. Americans United is here to remind us, regardless of what the front page headlines say, our nation promises everyone the freedom to live as themselves and believe as they choose, and our laws should not allow anyone to use their religious beliefs to harm others. But we know that promise is not yet fully realized. It will take all of us working together across the country to educate our communities about the importance of church-state separation and mobilize people to protect it. That's why Americans United for Separation of Church and State have started their supporter toolkit.

0:31This document has everything you need, whether you're brand new to grassroots organizing or a seasoned pro. And there's no time like the present to get involved. It's never too late to join the fight to protect our First Amendment freedoms. Learn more and download the toolkit at www.au.org slash supporter hyphen toolkit. Saving money on everything for your next bathroom project? Now at Minari's. Upgrade your bathroom with Max. With more than 1 ,000 showers, bathtubs, and surrounds, you're sure to find exactly what you need to add luxury and style to your bathroom. Save big in our entire selection of Max bathroom products.

1:11Plus, check out our weekly flyer on Menards.com for all the great deals happening now. Save big money at Menards. Mr. Chief Justice, may it please the court. It's an old joke, but when a man argues against two beautiful ladies like this, they're going to have the last word. She spoke, not elegantly, but with unmistakable clarity. She said, I ask no favor for my sex. All I ask of our brethren is that they take their feet off our necks.

2:04Hello and welcome to Strict Scrutiny Live from the Howard Theatre at Crooked Car.

2:15As you know, Strict Scrutiny is your podcast about the Supreme Court that is about to get reformed.

2:25And the legal culture that will enable that reform. We need all of you with us for this effort. We are your hosts. I'm Kate Shaw. And I'm Melissa Murray. And I'm Leah Littman. And my pronouns are she, her, they, them, Texas, Georgia, Abdul El-Sayed, John Ossoff, I'm not done, Peggy Flanagan, Annie Andrews, Gina Hinojosa, Sherrod Brown, James Tallarico, Roy Cooper, Amy Acton, Sam Molino Sucks, and other things that will be appearing in my email signature, including pronouns that haven't even been fucking invented yet.

3:09Shorter, Leah Littman. Our pronouns are she-dem.

3:18Honestly folks, I've got to be really clear with you. I'm a little surprised that this blue wave didn't materialize sooner because I distinctly remember the president's gay son, the one who was having the torrid affair with the King of England's gay son, putting forth a whole plan to turn Texas blue. Do you remember that? Yes. Some of you are looking puzzled and wondering why Don Jr. entered the chat. Read a book and the book is called Red, White and Royal Blue by Casey McQuiston. And now that we've turned Texas blue, I just want to note Ted Cruz you're next.

4:12As you all can tell we are so so happy about the blue wave the blue tsunami the blue Nami that we decided to get dressed for it. Right? So, yes. We love that the Blue Nami blew the lid off this fascist, sadist, terrible, racist regime. Indeed. All the is. Yes. Yes. So this really, we could not think of a better night than tonight to be here with all of you. So thank you for coming out. What a thrill. It was a gamble to schedule this for the Friday after the election, but it has panned out extraordinarily well. So here is the plan for tonight and a little bit more broadly. We're going to start by talking about the election.

5:03We're going to luxuriate a bit more in it, and we're also going to connect it to the Supreme Court and some breaking news. And then we are going to briefly recap the big case the Supreme Court heard last week because we couldn't obviously just luxuriate in this high for long. We had to come back down to earth. The case, of course, is St. Mary Parish versus Roy, and it is about whether there is a constitutional right to use public funds that the taxpayers give you to discriminate against gay and trans people. Boo. That's right. There isn't. Exactly, because you listen to this podcast and you read books.

5:42Exactly. But spoiler alert, as she's told you, there isn't, but that will not stop our favorite non-Talarico Christians on this court from trying. The Blue Nami has not yet reached the Supreme Court, but it's coming. It's coming. And we're going to talk about that too. And we are going to do our part to help move things along by talking SCOTUS and democracy and SCOTUS reform as really an imperative for democracy. And yes, you can clap for that. And to do that, later in the hour, we are going to bring to the stage one of our icons and sheroes, the great Sherilyn Eiffel. You can definitely clap for her.

6:25And then, right, I'm just road mapping here. Because this live show falls happily in the season of joy, we are going to end with a little game. It is called Name Your favorite biblical divorcee who is not who is not lame duck Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton. That's too easy. You need to name a different one. No, that's actually not the game. That's not the game, but the game is actually genuinely very fun. You're going to love it. So stay tuned. But before we start, I'm going to add a trigger warning because trigger warnings and land acknowledgements are now required for everything because elections have consequences.

7:04So here it is. I'm going to be full-on nasty woman, mean girl, petty bitch because a lot of people eminently deserve it. Welcome to Woke 3 haters. It's a lot of big chick energy. We should acknowledge that there are those in the leadership who would like for all of us to be a little more high-minded about all of this in the face of all of this winning like we should be gracious. No you hoes! No no no. That of course was a shout out to Harmeet Dillon who announced this week or last week her retirement from her position as Assistant Attorney General for Civil Wrongs. Yes, we wish her well. No, we don't.

8:06Some folks on the interwebs speculate that Ms. Dillon may be trying to clear her schedule in order to lawyer up in advance of some congressional hearings, to which we just say, you know what they say, MAGA. Make attorneys get attorneys. And I will say this for Harmeet, you are hoes, Dylan. Unlike one Haley Stevens, Harmeet realized that rats are supposed to leave a sinking ship, not hop aboard it. She did warn you. She warned you. It's very, very important for me personally that it be known I was an OG hater of Haley Stevens before the rest of the country was. Everyone can attest. Can confirm.

8:59When we have boy problems or bad boyfriends, we don't try to take the Senate and the country with us. But speaking of rats and ships, on Friday we learned White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles is making her exit. and Pee Wee German, I mean Stephen Miller, has been elevated to take her place. Boo indeed. Now if you're booing because you don't like the nickname Pee Wee German, don't worry I have other options for you. There's Deportation Gollum. Gollum Goebbels, the Third Reich's least fuckable intern, incel of the apocalypse.

9:51I'm not done. I hope no one here has terribly delicate sensibilities, but I guess buckle up. I'm just going to say, I think it is absolutely insane that the man slash thumb, who was the architect of the mass deportation plan, Operation Metro Surge, and the Trump 1.0 family separation policy, all of which clearly fueled everything that we saw on Tuesday night. The end result of all of that is that he got promoted. Like truly failing up. That is the lesson they took from the election to which I say open the schools open them it does kind of feel more seriously like a giant fuck you to the electorate I mean I do as Democratic leadership really I think wrestles with how to respond what note to strike in this moment this is something that they should take into account as they plan their next moves because these are not the actions of a chastened or humbled president who is open to conciliation this is a declaration of intent to double down and to do the most awful things and I think democratic leadership needs to respond accordingly yes the executive orders seem like they are about to get more fascist and more dangerous which is a cry for meaningful checks and accountability immediately that is like this appointment of SS stormtrooper Schmeagel you know I'm gonna channel my inner Kate Shaw.

11:29I'm gonna find the bright side here, the silver lining. One upside of Stephen Miller sticking around and getting promoted is that the internet can continue to refer to his wife as the Bay of Pigs.

11:46Just as it refers to Cheryl Hines as the marvelous Mrs. Measles.

11:58All right, well, true to form, I'm going to take us back to a more serious place for one moment. But actually identify, I think, a serious upside of this kind of Miller elevation, which is that Miller and his policies, I think, actually give the broad left democratic coalition and something very concrete to organize around and against, to focus the mind in a way that seemed to work pretty well in the midterms. And so I will take this announcement with full awareness that very, very bad things will happen. But from the perspective of organizing, galvanizing, mobilizing the public, in particular with an eye to 2028, I actually think that that is a genuine silver lining.

12:44Strict Scrutiny is brought to you by Smalls. Here's something that isn't fake news. Some cat foods contain so much carbohydrate filler that they're closer to a granola bar than a prey animal. Dry kibble can be 30 to 50 percent carbs, despite cats having almost no dietary need for them. But there's more. Did you know most cat foods out there use meat byproducts and cut their food with cheap grains, fillers, and artificial ingredients? Basically stuff that isn't great for your cat. Big pet food does this because it's cheaper. But what they save on cost, your cat pays for with their health. And it's never worth it.

13:15Our pets are our babies. I know. But Small's is different. Small's Fresh Cat Food is protein-packed recipes made with preservative-free, 100 % human-grade ingredients you'd find in your fridge. And it's delivered right to your door. Small's works because it's different. Their fresh recipes are made with at least 80 % animal protein. And they're gently cooked to retain all their nutrients and flavor. Cats use protein as their main energy source. More protein means more fuel and sustained energy. And that better balanced diet leads to less shedding, fewer hairballs, and more silky shine. Smalls cat food leads to high protein and improved hydration.

13:47That equals strong bones and toned muscles. So kitty is going to be ripped and toned. Heck, soon the president might be talking about your cat's ass. It's going to look so great. Forbes ranks Smalls the best overall cat food. And BuzzFeed says, quote, my cats went completely ballistic for this stuff. After switching to Smalls, 88 % of cat owners reported overall health improvements. Are you spooked by commitment? You can try Smalls risk-free. They'll refund you if your cat won't eat their food. Your cat's health and longevity starts with what they eat. For a limited time, because you are a Strict Scrutiny listener, get 60 % off your first order, plus free shipping and free treats for life when you head to smalls.com slash strict.

14:24One last time, that's 60 % off your first order, plus free shipping and free treats for life when you head to smalls.com slash strict. Strict Scrutiny is brought to you by MidMobile. Remember being a kid around the holidays and anytime you would ask for something, mom would always say, wait until the holidays. Well, with Mint Mobile's holiday deal, there's no waiting. Right now, this second, all of their plans are just$15 a month. Mint Mobile took what's wrong with wireless and made it right with premium wireless for$15 a month. All plans come with high-speed data and unlimited talk and text delivered on the nation's largest 5G network.

14:56You can even bring your current phone and your number. Choose from three, six, or 12-month plans and say goodbye to a monthly bill. It's so easy. Sign up online and get premium wireless service for just 15 bucks a month. So what are you waiting for? To get your new wireless plan for 15 bucks a month, go to mintmobile.com slash strict. That's mintmobile.com slash strict. Cut your wireless bill to 15 bucks a month at mintmobile.com slash strict. Upfront payment of$45 for three months,$90 for six months, or$180 for 12 months. Plan required. $15 a month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. initial plan term only.

15:31Greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy. Capable device required. Availability, speed, and coverage varies. See MintMobile.com.

15:43But enough of those tools. Back to me. I will be encouraging all of you to indulge your instincts to revel in the kind of joy that can only come from the absolute worst people having the absolute worst of times, and to put that energy toward a collective effort to bully our new democratic majorities, not just in Congress, but in many states as well, to use their powers for the good of our democracy. As an amuse-bouche for the kind of vibe I'm talking about, think of Representative Jamie Raskin, incoming chair of the House Judiciary Committee, announcing that the law firms that struck deals with the Trump administration can expect subpoenas in the new year.

16:39What do we say? Make attorneys get attorneys. So with that note, let's focus on the election. I think we've been doing that. Yes and no. We will, I think, toggle between the serious and the petty. We contain multitudes. But in terms of sort of where we are right now, obviously this is a moment of well-earned joy and relief. And as we have already said, we want to luxuriate in all of the winning. But in addition to focusing on the Supreme Court, we also just don't want to overlook this really important point, which is that in order to do this, to create this blue wave, the people had to overcome a lot, including a hugely distorted electoral landscape.

17:24That was partly, indeed, largely the work of the Supreme Court. It was partly the work of this president, but it was also produced by the direct actions of the Supreme Court. And we will just tick through a few of the ways that the court is responsible for the deeply distorted democratic process. So what has the court done to distort and degrade our democracy? It blew up campaign finance regulation, which cleared the way for individuals like Elon Musk to pour hundreds of millions of dollars into this election, much of it in the great state of Texas. Happy now you live in a state with a Democratic Attorney General Day to Elon cyberfucked Cybertruck Musk, by the way.

18:10This lady would like a subpoena directed to Elon, please, and a glass of Pinot Grigio go-to-fucking-jail. I'll have what she's having. We should also note that the court blew up the Voting Rights Act and its protections against racial discrimination and voter suppression. The court left portions. This is something that didn't, I don't think, get enough attention, but it left portions of the president's insane election interference executive order in place, including the provision that prioritized investigations and prosecutions of state and local election officials for the high crime of doing election administration, which the administration then tried to act on.

18:55You should also not forget that the court previously said that federal courts could not address partisan gerrymandering. And then they went and cleared the way for the mid-cycle extra-partisan gerrymandering redistricting effort that attempted to further deprive voters of the power to choose their elected officials and instead allowed elected officials to choose their voters. In addition to that, the court also facilitated voter suppression in the Granite State, New Hampshire, permitting the New Hampshire Secretary of State to limit the use of student IDs for voter verification. And then the court let the Federal Communications Commission give discounted rates for political ads to political parties, even though the GOP already had oodles of cash on hand from their emotional support billionaires.

19:50They did not need a discount. And then, on top of all of that, the court allowed the administration to use an unreliable database for voter verification. I mean, disenfranchisement. One additional matter relates to Mississippi's U.S. Senate race, which is a true nail-biter between Scott Cologne and Karen Hyde-Smith. the neoconfederate Karen who refused to return a blue slip for Cologne's nomination to a federal judgeship. Cologne returned the favor by running against Hyde Smith and now seems poised to beat her and become yes and become the first black senator from Mississippi since Reconstruction.

20:44Petty Pace, Petty Pace And he's now up more than 2 ,000 votes

20:53We had honestly really hoped that we would have a definitive call by tonight And at the last count he was up by I think over 2 ,000 votes And I actually genuinely don't understand why she hasn't conceded It seems clearly to be over Why is she not conceded? ma 'am this is a Wendy's and Karen Hyde-Smith would like to speak to the manager I guess that's why. AKA the federal courts. But on the nail biter bit there are 70 ,000 people in Mississippi who are disenfranchised because they have a felony conviction and two thirds of those disenfranchised are black. A few years ago the Supreme Court turned away a challenge to Mississippi's felony disenfranchisement provision.

21:40And that provision was originally adopted at a state constitutional convention where the president of the convention said, quote, we came here to exclude the Negro. Yeah. History and tradition. Weirdly, the folks who are always so troubled by the history of black people being thwarted in the exercise of their Second Amendment rights were entirely unbothered on this occasion by Mississippi's history of thwarting black people on the exercise of their right to vote. In this Supreme Court's conception of the Constitution, bullets, but not ballots, get constitutional protection. So anyway, all of this to say, this sort of, this is, you know, an under-inclusive recitation of many of the court's interventions to degrade and undermine democracy.

22:28But all this to say that just because the voters overcame many, many obstacles to get to the result that we got on Tuesday does not mean that the Supreme Court's actions were no big deal, right? The people should not have to crawl over broken glass to cast their votes and participate in democracy. Competitive authoritarianism is still authoritarianism. So let's say it again for the folks in the back. So voter turnout here was massive enough to overwhelm the various distortions in the electoral landscape, but the distortions were there. They are still there. They were real, and the court's rulings once again were a huge factor in creating them, which only makes the fact that they were overcome all the more incredible.

23:09So having heard just that partial list, raise your hand if you have been personally or collectively impacted by the Supreme Court's effort to undermine democracy. That's what I thought. So let's say it again with our whole chess. The Supreme Court did these things. Supreme Court reform has to be on any pro-democracy agenda. And we are going to dig into court reform at our panel tomorrow.

23:37And that will also be available as a bonus episode for those of you listening. All right, another election slash SCOTUS crossover before we turn to the recaps. Jody Cantor and Michael Schmidt at the New York Times report that the Department of Justice is stepping up its criminal inquiry into the leak of the Dobbs opinion. Huh, okay. Okay. It is unclear what, if any, crime may have been committed by Martha Ann. With a Martha Rita in the library, allegedly. But obviously, not having any clear evidence of any criminal activity has never stopped this Department of Justice before. So watch this space.

24:31I have to say, my initial reaction upon reading this story was, I guess, live by the unitary executive, die by the unitary executive? I mean, in Trump versus United States, that's the immunity decision. these guys, the Supreme Court, those guys, decided the Constitution basically means there is no stopping a lawless executive, even one who abuses the investigative and prosecutorial power. And, well, I guess sometimes that lawless executive comes knocking at the door of one first street. Chris Geidner, who runs the indispensable law dork Substack, floated the following theory, and we think he's on to something.

25:09So Geidner posted, quote, quote, galaxy brain. Trump has Blanche indict Alito so he can replace him in the lame duck.

25:22This, this is, um, this, I think if I'm using the meme properly, is something like unitary executive coming home to roost, like the me sewing, me reaping meme. Does that, is that, is that, is that me fucking around me finding out? Yeah. Maybe that one's better. Enjoy those depositions, Sam and Martha Ann. But with the caveat that we are not political pundits, we'll leave that to our friends at Pod Save America, Hysteria, etc. You know, I did want to try and offer my own best take on what the Democrats' mandate is. So I prepared some notes to try to get this right. I'm pretty sure that the voters decided that as of tomorrow, or at least as of January 2027, the Supreme Court will be automatically converted into a Planned Parenthood facility.

26:09Vaccines will be dispensed by drag queens who will also be conducting the new mandatory DEI and critical race theory trainings. Transgender witches will be enforcing the new billionaire tax that funds Medicaid, increasing the minimum wage, public education, housing, and the conversion of data centers into government-funded child care and elder care facilities. Abortions and non-monogamous polycule tarot card readings will be available at targets nationwide, courtesy of Elon Musk and Harlan Crow. All of the months will be Black History Month and Pride.

26:53All football games will be converted into gay or bisexual or COVID-conscious lesbian hockey games. Every game of every sport will begin with a land acknowledgement to be read by Fifth Circuit Judge and aspiring Justice Jim Ho, or if he's too busy auditioning, Kid Rock. The chick song, Not Ready to Make Nice, will be the new national anthem and the Pledge of Allegiance in Texas. Everywhere else, the national anthem will be the cover of All the Things She Said from Heated Rivalry. or Kendrick's not like us options because we're pro-choice that's the first part of the mandate the second is like a little bit more specific remember Susan Collins I'm a little concerned I'm a little concerned that she only called Troy Jackson to concede and didn't call and concede personally to every single woman of reproductive age in these United States

28:00And in conclusion, I maintain that one part of the Democrats' mandate is that when Susan Collins packs up and leaves D.C., she has to take Brett Kavanaugh with her.

28:12Pretty sure I got that right. Any questions? I mean, she says she's not a political pundit. Come on. I've been mainlining those gluten-free, vegan, gay Islamic vaccines since Tuesday night.

28:28Wow. All right. So while we are decoding slash announcing the new rules of the road, we would like to acknowledge one more irrefutable and irrevocable law of the land, which is that if you are a guest on strict scrutiny and you go on to run for office, you win your election. It's a fact. So Roy Cooper, Julianna Stratton, Ellie Savitt, Anita Earls, While he was never a guest on Strict Scrutiny, we should note that Leah and I were both guests on Abdul El-Sayed's crooked podcast, America Dissected. Note Leah's shirt if you haven't seen it. The shirt says it's Senator Abdul.

29:16This episode of Strict Scrutiny is brought to you by Alloy Health. Here is something nobody tells you. The skin changes that start in your 40s aren't just aging. They're hormonal, specifically estrogen loss. Estrogen naturally helps maintain collagen, support elasticity, and keep skin hydrated. As estrogen declines, that means skin gets thinner, drier, and often more reactive. And then there are the dark spots that midlife likes to stack up. All that means your expensive cleanser, retinol, moisturizer, none of them were designed to solve what is a hormonal problem. I can tell myself all I want that my skin looks the way it does because of the Supreme Court and being an associate dean.

29:51But the reality is, some of it is hormonal. And because I, unlike some Supreme Court docentes, believe in science and don't want to let my skincare regimen go, I've accepted that. You've already heard me talk about M4 skincare from Alloy, made specifically for estrogen-deficient skin. Now, Alloy has launched two new prescription treatments. There is Copper Peptide Cream RX that is made for women, perimenopause, and beyond. It smooths the thin skin on your face and neck, improves firmness, and visibly improves redness and flushing. Now there's also hyperpigmentation treatment, Rx. It's a three-in-one cream for your face and chest.

30:23It helps fade dark spots, sunspots, and uneven patches by targeting the overactive pigment cells behind them while leaving your normal skin tone alone. Here's how it works. You complete your intake. It's just a simple online form. Then you get your prescription because you'll be matched with a menopause-specialized physician who will review your intake and prescribe what's right for your skin. Plus, you get$0 unlimited messaging with your doctor. Finally, it's delivered to your door because your prescription ships straight to you once it's approved. No pharmacy trips and no hassle. Try Alloy's new prescription treatments, copper peptide cream RX and hyperpigmentation treatment RX, or add them to your M4 routine.

30:59Head to myalloy.com and use the code strict to get 20 % off your first order. Your menopause specialized doctor will help you build a skincare plan for your needs. Plus, you get$0 unlimited messaging with your doctor. Head to myalloy.com and use code STRICT to get 20 % off your first order. This code is valid on products only. These are compounded products not subject to FDA approval. STRICT Scrutiny is brought to you by 3-Day Blinds. We're coming up on winter, which means it's time to hibernate. And when I go to hibernate in my fluffy dancing monkey pajamas and their slippers, I need my privacy.

31:35And 3-Day Blinds is here to help. There's a better way to buy blinds, shades, shutters, and drapery, and it's called 3-Day Blinds. They are the leading manufacturer of high-quality custom window treatments in the United States. And right now, if you use my URL, 3dayblinds.com slash strict, they're running a buy one, get one 50 % off deal. We can shop for almost anything at home, so why not shop for blinds at home too? 3-Day Blinds has local professionally trained design consultants who have an average of more than 10 years of experience, and they provide expert guidance on the right blinds for you in the comfort of your home.

32:07Just set up an appointment and you'll get a free no obligation quote the very same day. If you're not very handy, the expert team at 3 Day Blinds handles all the heavy lifting. They design, measure, and install. So you can sit back, relax, and leave it to the pros. Shopping for your home from your home, that's the best. Especially being able to shop for something as major as blinds. I love that 3 Day Blinds makes that possible. They give you thousands of options that fit any budget or style. 3 Day Blinds has been in business for over 45 years. and they have helped over 2 million people get the window treatments of their dreams.

32:37So they are a brand you can trust. Right now, get quality window treatments that fit your budget with 3-Day Blinds. Head to 3dayblinds.com slash strict for their buy one, get one 50 % off deal on custom blinds, shades, and drapery. For a free, no charge, no obligation consultation, just head to 3dayblinds.com slash strict. One last time, that's buy one, get one 50 % off when you head to the number three, D-A-Y, blinds.com slash strict.

33:10All right, that was really fun. Now let's turn to oral arguments. Yeah, this is going to be depressing, guys. So we are going to relatively briefly cover the biggest case the court heard last week, St. Mary Catholic Parish versus Roy, a case that involves, as Melissa already mentioned, Colorado's universal pre-K program, which provides parents with free access to preschool education. In order to be eligible for the state program and the state funds that come with it, participating schools may not discriminate against prospective parents or students on the basis of certain characteristics, including sexual orientation and gender identity.

33:47And St. Mary's Catholic Parish, along with five, possibly six, of the Republican justices took that personally. It seems that the parish believes that requiring conservative religious schools to abide by a generally applicable non-discrimination requirement violates its constitutional right to free exercise of religion. To put it differently, not only is Saint Mary's constitutionally entitled to public funds to subsidize religious education, it is also entitled to discriminate against gays, lesbians, bisexuals, and transgender people while also taking those public funds. Sounds constitutional to me.

34:28They apparently did not get the message that gay marriages are now performed during first period and homeroom and that drag queen story hours are offered every hour on the hour at Chick-fil-A, which is now known as either Chick-fil-they or they-fil-A, take your pick, assholes. Woke three. Are we living too close to the sun, guys? There's no such thing as living too close to the sun. You gotta lib, love, laugh. Okay, back to the case. You guys are cynical, okay? Really cynical. This case really is about a constitutional entitlement, an assertion of a constitutional entitlement to discriminate against LGBT people using public funds.

35:21That's what the case is about, and Justice Sotomayor basically got St. Mary's lawyer to admit that in this clip. Your bottom line is, let's get to it, your school can reject a child because their parents are homosexual. I would say the bottom line rule is Catholic— Is that the bottom line? The bottom line is if it's a public benefit— Let's get to the bottom. I'm asking you a direct question. your Catholic schools will reject the child merely because their parents are homosexual. I would say if it's the sincere religious exercise of the petitioner, then I think that would be permitted. As we mentioned in our last episode, and as Justice Jackson repeatedly underscored during the argument, St.

36:07Mary's is not really asking for equal treatment, because equal treatment would be complying with the generally applicable non-discrimination mandate that every other participating school complies with in exchange for receiving these public funds. What St. Mary's is asking for is actually different special treatment. Yes, yes. Okay and at oral arguments Justice Sotomayor, Justice Jackson, Justice Kagan made clear that if we followed St. Mary's logic to its conclusion it would allow religious entities to claim a free exercise violation if as a condition of public funding or under some other general rule that the government could adopt, they were asked to refrain from discriminating on the basis of race or sex.

36:53And the lawyers for the parish and the Trump administration, which predictably joined St. Mary in arguing for a constitutional right to discriminate, tried to swat away these objections by just declaring by fiat that race and sex are just different, right? Kind of like the Federal Reserve is just different. I can see it now. Race and sex are uniquely structured quasi-private entities that follow in the distinct historical tradition of the first and second banks of the United States. That sentence makes about as much sense as the one the court used to describe the Federal Reserve Board. I truly love that only in D.C.

37:37could that joke land the way it just did, but it really did. Thank you. Never changed. We love you. But, you know, we are pretty sure we know how the court is going to come out in this Colorado St. Mary case. Once again, the Republican appointees really kind of phoned it in to the argument because, you know, when you have six votes, five, definitely, probably six. You don't even really have to try. They just let you do it. They just let you do it. Take a listen. And then just to follow up on Justice Barrett's question, do you think strict scrutiny as announced in Sherbert by Justice Brennan and in Thomas and then again in our series of public benefit cases more recently is a reasonable construction of the original meaning?

38:23So just to pick up on that, as a matter of original meaning, you're saying that the free exercise clause is more than simply a protection against explicit discrimination against religious groups. Yeah, I mean, shorter, Kavanaugh, Gorsuch, Barrett as well. The original meaning is basically whatever I want the law to be. Wouldn't you say, counsel? Yes, definitely. That's sort of the TLDR. Zero juice, these guys. really the Vivek Ramaswamy and Ken Paxton of Supreme Court justices. You can guess which is which. Neil is Vivek and Brett is Ken. Yeah, there were a few other, actually many, maddening things about this argument as well.

39:05Yeah, so one is that Justice Alito decided to hard launch a new theory of discrimination. He began with the observation that under the court's current case law, it would be unconstitutional if the state excluded all Catholic pre-K schools and would be unconstitutional if the state excluded all pre-K schools that offer Catholic teachings. Okay, fine, descriptively. But then, Sam Reasons, isn't it also unconstitutional for the state to exclude pre-K schools that refuse to recognize same-sex marriages, and also unconstitutional for the state to exclude schools that discriminate against the children of parents in same-sex marriages, because the state should know that that would negatively impact Catholic preschools.

39:45How do you like they slash them apples? You know, look, like John, Clarence, Sam, Neil, Brett, Amy, I'm merely interpreting the law and the mandate and the law of WOKE 3.0 is that even food has pronouns. Also, Mississippi is Mr. Sippy or Mix-a-Sippy. Yeah. You're not dreaming big enough, Leah. Let's go really huge. Why don't we just, in this new WOKE 3.0 era, let's change Mississippi's postal code from MS to MX. Let's do it. But back to Sam's new theory of discrimination, one issue with it is that not all Catholic schools require affirmation of the belief that marriage is between a man and a woman.

40:32And that means the state isn't discriminating against Catholicism as such, since there are Catholic schools able to participate in the program and actually participating in the program. But it's also never, ever, ever been the law that if policymakers know that their policy will negatively affect a certain group, that that fact without more means that the policy is illegally discriminatory against the group. That's never been the case. In fact, to the contrary, as Sam Alito very much knows, there are many, many Supreme Court cases saying knowledge of a policy's likely effects is not sufficient alone to establish discrimination.

41:11For example, the court has said it is a-okay to create a hiring preference for veterans, knowing that at the time, men were 98 % of the veteran pool and the policy would definitely disadvantage women applicants. Also, as Sam Alito knows, like when Republicans engage in partisan gerrymandering, they know it has a predictable effect of depriving black voters of political opportunities, and yet he doesn't seem to think that that is a problem. But because Sam's new theory of discrimination is so like in an entirely different stratosphere than law, Justice Kagan had to do a little cleanup on Isle Alito.

41:47And so she explained that it was, quote, not like this is another way to get at Catholic people. It's like we believe in anti-discrimination principles as applied to sexual orientation. Like, that's what the state is doing. So in the last episode, Leah joked that we are not that far from the point where Chief Justice John Roberts, is going to write an opinion saying something along the lines of, the way to stop discrimination against religious conservatives is to start discriminating against gay people. We were just joking, but apparently we were manifesting, because that's basically what Justice Alito is implying with his theory.

42:32He's basically saying that being anti-LGBT rights and being anti-marriage equality is so inextricably intertwined to Catholicism that it's not possible to prohibit discrimination against same-sex marriages without discriminating against Catholicism. So the way to stop discrimination against religious conservatives is actually to start allowing discrimination against gay people. Did I get it right? I mean, no. As far as it goes. That's wrong, but you know. You described it. Did I get it right in this stratosphere of law that we're now in? Sure. Regrettably, yes. Okay, so at another point in the argument, we were treated to this claim that we should just allow discrimination, just a little bit of it, because what's the big deal?

43:19It's not like discrimination is really harmful, if you think about it, because the kids of gay parents can go to other schools, and they should just live and let live. Here is Coach Kavanaugh making that point. Why not seek the win-win? I mean, I raised this in a full oral argument where there's a clash of rights, obviously, the free exercise right on the one hand, the same-sex marriage right recognized in Obergefell on the other. But there are 2 ,000 schools. There are only 34 Catholic schools. There are plenty of opportunities to respect the rights of the religious believers and respect the ability of LGBT parents to find among the 2 ,000 schools appropriate fit for their children.

44:10Who's going to tell him it's lib and let lib, not live and let live? Also, it's not a fucking win-win. and like hearing Brett Kavanaugh talk sounds like seeing Haley Stevens chewing on water. It's just bizarre but I don't know who needs to hear this except I do it's Brett Kavanaugh like he needs to hear this like that's not how anti-discrimination law works. People don't get to discriminate because the victims of their discrimination are free to seek better treatment elsewhere, that would be like saying we can do a little Jim Crow light because there is some other school, some other restaurant, some other hotel for black people to patronize.

44:59Exactly. And Kavanaugh also sort of made a variation on this argument. Yes, you can definitely clap for that. The bar is in hell because basic legal argument gets applause. Yes. And when it's contrasted with Brett Kavanaugh. So he also gestured toward this kind of related idea that same-sex couples wouldn't want to send their kids to schools that don't believe in same-sex marriage anyway, and therefore would choose other schools. So again, NBD, like no problem. Problem. So Colorado's excellent lawyer, truly superb, Helen Norton, pointed out, you know, sometimes parents choose schools based on location or other factors of convenience and allowing schools to discriminate against gay parents would restrict those parents ability to choose schools based on those factors.

45:50And also this is also not how anti-discrimination works. I probably don't want to work for a big misogynist but that doesn't mean an employer gets to engage in sex discrimination because women don't want to work for him. America's favorite father of daughters then went on to suggest that allowing discrimination against gays, lesbians, bisexuals, and transgender people is necessary to protect girls. Yes, Brett Kavanaugh has one gear, and it is bastardizing feminism, so let me tell you about it. During the argument, Coach K focused on the fact that Colorado allows single-sex preschools to participate in the universal preschool program.

46:38Wasn't this impermissible discrimination, asked Coach K. After all, if you were the father of daughters and the closest preschool was an all-boys preschool, that would be inconvenient. Wouldn't that subject your daughters to impermissible sex-based discrimination? Again, shorter Brett Kavanaugh, the fact of single-sex preschools means that Colorado must be required to allow schools to discriminate on the basis of other characteristics, such as sexual orientation and gender identity. And again, newsflash to our favorite father of daughters, anti-discrimination laws do not prohibit all discrimination on the basis of every possible characteristic.

47:20Title VII, for example, prohibits discrimination on the basis of race. it does not prohibit discrimination on the basis of being dumb. And that does not make Title VII unconstitutional. Also, Melissa, you on a related note really called it when we previewed this argument, which is that Coach Kavanaugh was extremely concerned, per usual, about anti-Catholic discrimination, which, to be clear, would be totally fair if he was equally open to and concerned about other sorts of historical discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation, say, or race. Here he is again with Colorado's really excellent Helen Norton.

48:04The director of the program, by all accounts, dutiful public servant, but was asked at the trial, are you aware that Catholics have historically been discriminated against? And she answered no. I was surprised by that answer and curious if that's Colorado's position. Not at all, Your Honor. And it's Colorado's position that the equal opportunity requirements help religious families. They ensure that Catholic families are not turned away from the UPK school that best meets their needs because of their faith or because of any other protected characteristic. And a history of discrimination against Catholics is among the reasons that requirement is so important.

48:53Honestly, there's a lot of oral argument stands in the room, clearly. Fire up the oral argument and listen to it, if you can stomach it. I mean, a lot of it's tough, but Norton really is extraordinary in it. So if you like that clip, listen to the whole thing. You'll also have to listen to Knuckles being dragged across the table. So, you know, up to you. There's just no way to sugarcoat it. It doesn't look great for Colorado in this case. Or the Constitution. Or the Constitution. So between Brett, Sam, Neil, Amy, to say nothing of Clarence. You know what? Let's actually say nothing of Clarence.

49:33It doesn't look promising. That's all I'm going to say. The argument was a pretty depressing way to start Tuesday, but then we the people turned it around. With that in mind, I have one note for Brett, Sam, etc. Enjoy this victory for Catholic preschools because the war on Christmas is about to replace the war on Iran. I went to Starbucks this morning and my cup said happy holidays. It's already started. And that's because this was not just a blue tsunami. It is a blue wormhole, something you pass through and then come out on the other side in a completely different dimension.

50:22Strict Scrutiny is brought to you by Quince. Yes, Quince Pilled, here we are. Because the best pieces in your closet are the ones you can count on, whether you're heading to work, going out, or keeping things casual. And this time of year, Quince makes finding something great for everyone else just as easy. This holiday season is where I'm shopping for myself and everyone on my list. So Quince focuses on high-quality staples made with premium materials like 100 % Mongolian cashmere, 14 karat gold, and Italian leather. All timeless, versatile pieces that feel special to unwrap and become everyday favorites long after the holidays.

50:55Their cashmere sweaters start at just$60, and the lineup doesn't stop there. premium down jackets, wool outerwear, and cashmere accessories. Everything you and your loved ones need to stay warm and look put together all season long. Everything at Quince is priced 50 to 80 % less than similar brands. They work directly with ethical factories and cut out the middlemen, so you can give luxury quality pieces without the luxury price tag. I have so many Quince staples, I could fill an entire episode with them. Where to start? One, I love their washable silk tees. I mean, they're washable and they're fancy and they move super well.

51:28I'm also totally obsessed with my Mongolian cashmere sweater with the winged arms. It's in baby blue and it's so soft, but the cut also elevates the piece. So it's like a cool sweater. I also have the Mongolian cashmere boxy crew in the brown and blue stripes, another great piece that will just slightly elevate a more casual look. They make it so easy to dress yourself. And honestly, I would struggle with that without them. And when it comes to gifting, Quince has a lot more than clothing. Think fine jewelry, leather bags, hotel-quality bedding, chef-grade cookware, and five-star luggage. Basically, plenty of ways to find something special for everyone on your list.

52:01Give the gift a quality this holiday season. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns, now available in Canada and the UK, too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know. It was strict scrutiny. It's the best way to support the show. Corrupting our democracy works best when we forget that we, the people, are in charge. I'm Stacey Abrams, voting rights advocate and host of Assembly Required. In my podcast, I'm talking with some of the sharpest minds in politics and in civic activism to help us figure out how to fight authoritarianism and win.

52:43My podcast doesn't just diagnose problems. We give actionable steps to help you feel a little more connected and a lot more empowered to make change in your communities. So check out my podcast, Assembly Required. New episodes drop every Tuesday on YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.

53:12I think we have spent ample time in the Coach Kavanaugh dimension. So let us go through this blue wormhole and enter a new delightful dimension, the Sherilyn Eiffel dimension. Stricties, please join me in welcoming to the stage the great Sherilyn Eiffel.

53:36You all know who she is. Sherilyn Eiffel needs no introduction, but let me offer a very brief one. Sherilyn is the former president and director of counsel for the NAACP Legal Defense Fund.

53:53And she is also the founding director of the 14th Amendment Center for Law and Democracy at Howard University School of Law.

54:06H.U. That was weak. H.U. In addition to all of that, she is one of the smartest, coolest people in this entire game, and we are so delighted to welcome her back to Strict Scrutiny. So, Sherilyn, right after the court's decision gutting what remained of the Voting Rights Act in Louisiana v. Calais, you went on The Daily Show and called for Supreme Court reform. And then right before the election, in your must-read Sherilyn's newsletter, you wrote about the importance of maintaining, quote, democratic discipline to urge accountability and block abuses of power. And you reminded us that doing this work means that, quote, Democrats must begin to lay the foundation for structural transformation that can better support a reimagined and resilient democracy.

54:58Hearings on Supreme Court reform should be scheduled in 2027 to begin to educate the public and to explore with experts the variety of measures that have been proposed okay we recognize an answering this question could take up this entire show but why Supreme Court reform why does the court have to be a part of any agenda focused on accountability and blocking abuses of power yeah first of all just I'm always so thrilled and honored to be with all three of you together which is like the super treat so thanks so much for having me shout out that there is a bar which I didn't know in the back I think the lady needs a drink for yeah well I didn't want to be the one to say it um no it's it's a it's an important question and I just keep hammering it because I'm worried you know we have all around us collapsing institutions that's how we ended up here the institutions that undergird democracy to undergird healthy democracies are collapsing right and so that could be the media that could be faith institutions it's certainly our political system without question but it is also the supreme court and if we delude ourselves into thinking that electoral victories you know are victories that are in and of themselves they are portals they are preparation they allow you to make the other kinds of changes that you need to make right so if you have a certain kind of election and you elect certain kinds of people then you can pass legislation that regulates the tech industry right you can pass legislation that ensures separation between church and state there are all these things you can do that's what elections are for but one of the things that it's for is to allow you to have the power to shore up the other branches of government that have shown themselves to be weak and cracked at their foundation, and the Supreme Court is certainly one of them.

57:01Yeah. I mean, one way I kind of think about this is we have to learn lessons from what the Biden administration didn't do and their errors. And I think they had the view that you kind of summarized, which is we won the election, let's just look forward. And lesson of history, right? If you let fascists go and don't hold them accountable, they come back worse and stronger, right? Like from Trump 1.0 to Trump 2.0. So then it's this lesson of, and are we just going to say, oh, we won an election. The Supreme Court is going to be fine now. On that note, if we are focused with this new supermajority in Congress on accountability, how does that cash out in terms of SCOTUS reform?

57:46Well my own view is that there are multiple levels of SCOTUS reform and I think you have to take them in stages. Some parts of SCOTUS reform that leads to my mind that I've been wrestling with and I'm writing about that have nothing to do with legislation. It has to actually do with the rules by which we confirm Supreme Court justices. So those are rules of the Senate Judiciary Committee. So breathalyzer tests? Perhaps. Okay. But I just, I mean, I think the Supreme Court confirmation process is broken, and it's not separated from the other problems that we see with the Supreme Court. I don't think that we have, that we are giving ourselves the best opportunity to get the personnel that we need for a 21st century Supreme Court in a country that purports to be at least one of the most powerful in the world.

58:36I just don't think so. I think when a Supreme Court is confronted with the the threat of partisan gerrymandering and the threat that it makes to democracy which the court concedes that it's like anti-democratic and then looks at solutions and says that's all gobbledygook because they can't figure it out that's evidence that you don't have the right person when that person thinks that the only way to end discrimination based on race is to end discrimination based on race right that is that is a statement I think we tend to attribute to particularly the conservative justices everything to ideology and I increasingly attribute a lot of it to limitation I think they're just limited I don't I really think they they are not equipped to be able to solve the kinds of problems that they have to solve in a country of this magnitude at this time so that's one thing and that's that's not even legislation and then of course it's you know ethics and then it's grappling with adding seats to the court which is you know I think not a hard thing to do honestly and then this question of you know term limits that's a little bit more tricky but I think in stages it's important and you have to get started on it right away because one of the problems is this this job is too enjoyable like no one is watching no no one can tell you what to do and that's nice on one hand and I I'm all for the independence of the judiciary but I also think that like nothing happening to you when you don't file your financial disclosure forms is a problem yeah so we have to figure out ways to make it a little less comfortable yeah can I and and I think we want to follow up I think and on some of the specifics but maybe just to quickly ask you a little bit more about the kind of first answer you gave which I think was so correct so elections right they feel great right now, but they're instrumental.

1:00:32They are about actually getting into place the people who will make the policy that channels the will of the sovereign people, right? Like that is the point of the whole enterprise. But this Supreme Court is going to be a major obstacle to the effective passage of most of the policy preferences of the people who chose the majority of members in Congress as of January. And so maybe to just ask one specific question. So the numbers on the kind of polling on corruption as a motivating issue, as a top campaign, as a top electoral issue for voters was really striking, right? This is something that people said both before and after the election was either their first or second most important issue.

1:01:12This is an issue that can seem really abstract but doesn't right now to people. So you can imagine a Congress doing a lot to actually try to legislate to respond to the problem of corruption. But this Supreme Court has been just single-minded in its hostility to anti-corruption federal statutes. It has struck down law after law. It is clearly skeptical about any law that would purport to do anti-corruption work with respect to the justices, but even elected officials more broadly. So I guess just to sort of put a finer point on the problem, is the court going to allow the Democratic mandate that we saw last week actually to take effect?

1:01:50No, they're not. And I think this is really important and it just has to be faced and it's very pragmatic because I get people who say to me, well, you know, we can't just keep changing the court because you don't like the substantive decisions that they're making. You know, because I'm a student of Reconstruction and the 14th Amendment and I know what the Supreme Court did to essentially gut that constitutional amendment in a series of decisions that over 30 years essentially turned the 14th Amendment into a dead letter and the 15th as well. And I know what flowed from that. I know the consequences that were felt by black people in this country.

1:02:30I know what it meant to have 5 ,000 lynchings between the 1880s and the 1930s. I know what it meant for black people to be assigned to share cropping and domestic work as their lives and to be left out of even New Deal legislation that would have changed their lives. So I know what it means to be a second, feel like a second-class citizen or to feel like you can't make a better future for your children. I know what happened to those people. Now if what you're telling me is that in a democracy as citizens we can see that happened and we have to accept that it will happen again without doing anything about it because we don't want to seem like them or we don't want to seem like we're not being ethical in terms of the court I just I reject that I think if we see the path that we're headed down and that path involves terrible pain terrible pain and and dislocation for people and also the destruction of the core of our democracy I don't think we have to sit idly by and watch it and in this case this court the corruption piece is a great example every time I think about the fact that a majority of the justices that sit on this court are justices who were in the dissent in a case called Caperton versus Massey that was about judicial corruption you know state and if that case comes before them again they would definitely rule the other way they would say it was okay for a state Supreme Court judge to have that kind of connection with you know mine owners as they did in West Virginia in that case every time I think about that I'm like they're not gonna do it they're not gonna allow it to happen and we don't have to sit idly by and just watch that.

1:04:11We can decide for ourselves as a people that there is objectively something called democracy and that this court has been in the business of restricting, not expanding democracy, and that that's not okay. I think we could get to do that. Yeah.

1:04:35One of the reasons like I loved your call for hearings to begin immediately on Supreme Court reform in 2027 is that in addition to the exit polling on corruption, Kate, that you mentioned, like, I really think looking at the bigger picture, it feels like voters rejected so much of what the Roberts Court has done because it wasn't just see corruption. It was the abusive immigration enforcement, right, grabbing neighbors and family members off the streets and disappearing them. The racial discrimination, right, not just the racial profiling, but the dismantling of the Voting Rights Act and mid-cycle redistricting, you know, and the court allowed them to do that.

1:05:15The court gave the Trump administration an unprecedented 25 straight wins on the shadow docket. And so they have enabled, right, the very things that voters rejected. And I think hearings could really draw a connection between those two. Yeah, and I don't say that we should be cavalier about Supreme Court reform. I think it's important. I am actually an institutionalist myself, which is why I support Supreme Court reform, because I think tremendous harm has been done to the institution. People in a democracy have to believe in something. You know, I don't think it's naive that, you know, people want to have confidence in the Supreme Court or want to believe that their president is a person of integrity.

1:05:51I think we have been harmed. I think it feels terrible. I think we have been spiritually harmed by having as the leader of our country someone that is so base and having that person on the world stage saying the things that they say and being the way that they are. I think that harms us as a country, as a democracy, and we feel it. That's why we feel sick. And so I think I know how I felt after Louisiana v. Calais and Allen versus Milligan the the two cases that you know essentially completed the job of dismantling the Voting Rights Act not just because I've been a voting rights you know lawyer for a long time and and and there was a part of it that just felt like wow 35 years of a career what was you know what was that you know that that felt very pain personally painful but it's also true that we I take very seriously what it takes for people to participate in democracy movements you know around around the world and if we recognize that the civil rights movement was a democracy movement the most successful democracy movement of the 20th century to be honest and completely changed this country and you know the many sacrifices that went into that the people who lost their lives the people who were injured all of that and to see a court take but you know we consider to be the most successful statute to emerge from that period and dismantle it in this way it's it's the it is really harmful you know it is it isn't it is not just oh we don't have the Voting Rights Act it is it is a rebuke of history it is a rebuke of sacrifice it is a rebuke of a democracy movement it is a rebuke of one of the high points of the history of this country so I I just think we have to be serious about what is facing us and confronting us and now we have to go about taking it on and the reason I say hearings is because and I said to educate the public because it's not a small thing and we need to be having these conversations not just in the Howard theater but like you know we need to have C-SPAN like showing the conversations that we're having about what the history is about why this is consistent with what we should think our power is why we don't have to feel completely disabled before the Supreme Court why they are part of our democracy and not above it you know all the things that we need to understand and the powers that Congress currently has even if you know Justice Alito thinks they don't have any power period you know I think we need to educate the public because you do need the public support for something like this and so we should have those hearings so maybe we'll ask a couple of specific questions about you know we will go deeper as we said earlier on some of this tomorrow but just to underscore one thing you said about institutionalists I really do think this is such an important point that I think that there was an impression for some time that this was a radical position, Supreme Court reform.

1:08:48And I do think that it is now a position that should unite radicals who want to completely tear down our institutions and protectors and guardians of our institutions. I actually think we can all agree that the Supreme Court desperately needs reform and that reform is consistent with the Supreme Court exercising the constitutionally appropriate amount and kind of power. So constraint legitimates power, actually, I think. I don't think it's about stealing their legitimate authority. I think it's about correcting this outsized authority that they have asserted. And so I do think that people who identify as institutionalists like you, and I do also, I really do think that there is value in people who come from a lot of different places converging on the imperative of Supreme Court reform.

1:09:33Well, and there's a narrative part to, Kate, like taking back the language. Why do I not get to be an institutionalist? People say that John Roberts is an institutionalist. He is an institutionalist. Oh, oh, okay, okay. It's not the same. It's not the same. It's not the same. I mean, I just think if you were a CEO and you had a company that started out with a stellar reputation, right, that it was the one company that most Americans believed in, and you for the first time in the history that we've been kind of polling these things, now you're underwater that a majority of Americans don't have confidence in the Supreme Court right and if you were the CEO of that company and there had been something that had never happened in the history of that country before a leak of massive proportions that suggests someone in there does not respect either your leadership or the mores and traditions of the court and then you did an investigation yourself of that and then years later there was another leak like just recently right about the original shadow docket opinion right I mean I'm just saying if we just took it out of the like hallowed frame of the Supreme Court are you an institutionalist because people are saying like we don't have confidence in you because we found out that you all were like going to Alaska and having glacial martinis with millionaires and flying in and that and that seems like a problem and because some you know one of this one of your spouses was flying flags upside down that suggested making common call like you're not going to put your foot down you're the you're the chief and you're not going to be like let me tell you what's not going to happen sam right or whatever right let a black woman be chief justice i'm just saying let a black woman be chief justice that part i'm just i'm just saying i don't think that you get to just say like you're an institutionalist because people just say that like you have to actually show it and and so I think we have to also pull back the language why do we get to be the the crazy radicals and they get to be and he gets to be the institutionalist I don't see it that way I come into the court I disagree with so much of what they do I still feel a little something when I go up those stairs I still go listen to arguments I still I still dress conservatively when I go into the court I sit there and I listen I don't roll my eyes and mouth not true.

1:11:59I just, I... So who is the real institutionalist? Even when they're saying things I think are crazy, like I respect the court as an institution. So I'm not going to allow myself to be herded into some category while they take the high road of being institutionalist because the evidence is not there.

1:12:19You don't get up and say, well, do you have a drinking problem, Your Honor? No, no, okay. Yeah, me either. Weird.

1:12:29it's such a good point though if John Roberts had been a CEO of a public or a private company and suffered these kinds of knocks on his watch we would be singing that you about to lose your job catch this beat it would be a whole different thing I mean like life tenure is working for him we all know deans and other people have lost their jobs because of stuff like this so I get that that he has lifetime tenure, but I don't have to also add on to that, that, oh, yes, he's a great institutionalist when this is the record. So another thing we ought to think about is this court has shown us what real YOLO energy looks like.

1:13:08You know, when you have your supermajority, you only live once. Like, you got to do it. That's kind of the energy we need to adopt in this moment, right? So how do we push for more, to imagine bigger, better at a time when the risk is if we don't push on court reform right now, the Supreme Court just sort of lays there like a loaded gun. And we saw this happen before. We saw this happen when the Democrats won the midterms and the court sort of backed away from demolishing the Voting Rights Act and they decided Milligan and then they came back three years later and like totally crushed it. Like if we leave this loaded weapon on the table, we are doing ourselves a disservice.

1:13:56I mean Jesus, John Roberts has been trying to kill you know the Voting Rights Act since 1982. That is like what you know talk about it comes back. It's like it doesn't go, it waits, it lurks, it crouches. But I guess I would say something else as well. You know I take my lessons from reconstruction and I think that because I do think it is that serious what we have seen in this country and at some point after we've passed a few years and we've all had some therapy we will be able to actually face how freaking dangerous this has been and how scary it has been and how many people have suffered as a result and how many years of our lives have been taken with just the uncertainty and just the grotesque nature of what we have been compelled to experience and accept so I think that we if the only reason we would not swing for the fences is because we have not been able to process and confront that reality and and so I think we really do have to in very short order process that reality this is not normal this is super scary really terrible things as have happened and we haven't even had the worst you know happen yet and I pray we won't.

1:15:14So I think we just have to take responsibility. And I think we're seeing other countries do this. I think we saw the new leader in Hungary who's like, let me tell you what's not going to happen. I think that we can't be scared off by things like people saying, we don't want to get even, we don't want retribution. We do want accountability. Again, it's backwards. It's backwards. We get tarnished with this language that's supposed to scare us off from doing what we're supposed to do and we're not accepting the fact that we had a long period of no accountability that I think actually has something to do with the moment that we're in we you know we saw Abu Graib and we saw the excesses during the Iraq War and you know I go back to and I ran contra hate dating myself but yes you know there's all that's like we you know the pardon Gerald Ford like we this is what we do we blow past these things without really without true accountability and so I and how has that worked out for us like how is it possible and so that's the question I always ask if your democracy is strong how does some guy get to come down an elevator like you know with his wife in a white dress and just steal your democracy in just like two years like how does that happen it means you weren't strong so we have to actually recognize that what we thought was strength you staying above it all was actually not.

1:16:34It was weakness. It was not wanting to be confrontational. So I think now we have to be mature enough to recognize, and it's not fun. I'm actually not a confrontational person. I like to, you know, I like to binge, you know, slow horses. I don't want trouble. You know what I mean? But, you know, notwithstanding being a civil rights lawyer, I feel like trouble comes to me. I don't go looking for it, you know? And so I just think we tend to be non-confrontational, but some real terrible shit has happened, and we cannot let it go, and it's still ongoing. That's the worst part. It's happening right now while we're sitting in the Howard Theater.

1:17:12So we don't really have the luxury of taking the high road, and it has not served us well at all. So we gotta go about swinging for the fences. Game? Okay. Okay, so that's a good note to end on. for the substantive part. Yes. And as promised, as promised, we're going to end with a game. So when we were planning for the live show, we thought we'd play a game of how to give a Supreme Court justice the boot and brainstorm ways we could get Thomas Alito, Kavanaugh, Gorsuch, Barrett, or the chief to quit after January 2027. Ideas included forcing Alito and Thomas to work on their favorite holidays, January 6th, or requiring all justices to take a breathalyzer and pass an IQ test.

1:18:02That one would address Brett. But here's the thing. We were so overcome with this odd feeling. I think it's called joy and hope and excitement. So we changed things up last minute. So we're going to play a different game. The name of the game is called This or That. And here's how it works. We will give you two choices. One is going to be something warm, fuzzy, rainbows and ponies goodness, things that we're happy about after the election. And then the other thing is going to be some kind of peppermint petty, petty LaBelle, schadenfreude, bad things happening to bad people stuff that also makes you maniacally happy.

1:18:49And we're going to ask Sherilyn to choose between the two.

1:18:58We're going to find out how non-confrontational you really are. Here's an example. All right. This doesn't count. This is just an example. It's like a hypo. Okay. The state of Georgia electing the first black woman governor, Keisha Lance Bottoms.

1:19:21or Karen Hyde-Smith likely losing her... Cindy, Cindy, Cindy. Karen. Karen. Karen. Karen.

1:19:31It's actually neo-Confederate Karen. It starts. Yeah. Karen Hyde-Smith likely losing her Senate seat to Scott Colombe, the guy she blocked from becoming a federal judge under Joe Biden.

1:19:49Scott Colombe enters his Petty LaBelle era. Okay. So you get it? This or that? I got to have those both. I got to have them both. I can't this or that. No. No. Oh, no. I got to have this and that. This and that. This and that. She can have both of those. Okay? Okay. Okay. I'll start it off. All right. Watching MS Now on election night and hearing former strict scrutiny roadie turned MS Now anchor Christopher Hayes chortling off camera wow oh my god every time a Democrat flipped a seat did he really do that yes yes yes he did or watching Fox on election night and hearing Brett bear and his hair caught on a hot mic asking Fox staffers, how are we going to spin this bloodbath?

1:20:58That one is easy. I'm going with Brett on that one. I'm going with Brett. Okay. Sorry, this is too much fun. Too much fun. Too much fun. Okay. Okay, I'm next. Okay. This. Okay, first of all, she kept these secret from us. I did. We don't know what these are going to be. I've got two, and I'll do the easier one first, the nicer one first. Okay, okay. This. Oh, this is so we couldn't save you from yourself. Exactly. These are unedited and unfiltered. You guys have no idea how many things they took out of the show notes that I put in. No idea. Okay. So many things. This. This. Okay. Dems flipping 13 state legislative chambers, winning eight new trifectas, and flipping so many state Supreme Court seats that there are chances of progressive majorities after the 2028 elections on the North Carolina, Ohio, Texas, and Montana Supreme Courts.

1:22:01This. Or that. After January 2027, Samuel Alito will likely need to stay on the Supreme Court for at least another six years, or else one Melissa Murray will automatically replace him.

1:22:21Damn, damn.

1:22:25That's a tough one. Even I'm torn. This is sick and diabolical. I'm sorry. I have a grandchild. I can't be like making these crazy choices. You said we had to do hard things for our democracy, Sherilyn. Okay, but that still leaves five in the majority. So I'm going to go with this. I'm going to go with the first one. That's fair. That's fair. Great choice. Great choice. Sorry, Melissa. That's okay. I only want the hearings.

1:22:57Okay, here's mine. So this, that the young staffers responsible for, like hopefully soon to be Senator-elect Scott Cologne's epic campaign ads, you guys have seen these, the choose another protein ad, the... I'd rather pick another senator. So good. The Senators ad in which Cologne plays two smoke and stack type characters. It is epic. Find and watch if you have not. Okay, so the prospect that they will, the staffers responsible, I guess his brother did the senator's ad, but the young staffer responsible for the protein ad and colleagues will hopefully, if there's any justice, soon be running all social media slash communications for congressional Democrats.

1:23:47That would be so good. Or that the person responsible for Vivek Ramaswamy's despicable ad deploying Amy Acton's estranged mother against her is likely without a job today.

1:24:04Well I should say first of all the person responsible for that ad was really Patrick Gaspard. Yes, for the protein ad. Oh I thought you meant the Amy Acton ad. No, no, no. The protein ad, it was executed by the staffers. but it was Patrick's mind. I shouldn't mean that. We love Patrick Gaspard. Beloved Patrick Gaspard who came up with the Pick Another Protein one. I don't think being out of a job is really enough for the staffer who did the Vivek thing. Some of this, yeah. No, we're going to need more. You're going to have to up the game on that one. I'm hoping that there will be more. Yeah. I don't know.

1:24:43Never get a job? Yeah. Is that? Yeah, I'm not like going, like I'm anti-carceral enough that I'm not I don't want to lock the person up but never can show their face. We didn't say he had to be locked up we just said he had to be unemployed okay and electoral but also indefinitely okay all right okay so if we up the ante to that. I'm ready. Melissa you want to give yours? Okay. I don't like yours. Yes you do. What? Okay. The work wear guy on Blue Sky lusting after the cut of John Ossoff's jib or Donald Trump lusting after John Husted's deflated peaches. Well, since the second one, the that, causes me to heave.

1:25:34I'm going to go with this. I'm going to go with workwear. Separately, and it does bear discussing. Did that really happen? Did you hear him talking about that? Leah made me a mashup. I created a mashup of videos for her to watch. Yeah. I think that was last episode. You got to listen. Can I just one second, though? We'll pause the game for a minute. Did you all see that Vogue cover? I did. I did. With Barack and Abdul and Zoran. Sometimes AI is okay. Okay. And John Ossoff with those cunty little Zadikus Finch glasses. Like, if that's what AI is doing, I say open the data centers. Open them all.

1:26:22All of them. Every single one. We should shout out at Quantidini on Threads. Oh, yes. Who started the Senator My Boo campaign. But didn't finish it. Because it's getting finished right here. Yeah, but she's a serious person who raised a lot of money for Asaf over the last year by objectifying him.

1:26:54You love to see it. We do. I think, Leo, we should let you end. Let me go, and then I think is there going to be an epic point to land on? Okay, yeah, you can go, and then I'll end, and then we'll close. Okay, so my next this or that. It's not spicy. but it's I guess true to form. This is re-elected North Carolina Supreme Court Justice Anita Earle's vaguely chariots of fire style victory video on social media. It was a little bit like it was awesome and so joyful. Okay or and this is this is petty this is the that. The fact that the democratic victories were outside of the margin of litigation almost everywhere and even actually where they were close, I guess Mississippi TBD, but most Republicans decided to just take the L, which further underscores actually, I won't even say anything about the current president, but I was actually going to make a point about North Carolina, which is it underscores how vile something we talked about a lot on the podcast was, which was Jefferson Griffin's ham-handed efforts to litigate his way to a victory on the North Carolina, he was in the previous cycle, ran for the North Carolina Supreme Court.

1:28:04Do you remember this? We've memory hold it, But this remains one of the most galling things. He's a sitting jurist and he was trying to litigate his way up to the North Carolina Supreme Court after having decisively lost by offering some novel theory after the election that would have thrown out tens of thousands of votes. Anyway, the fact that nothing that egregious happened this cycle actually underscored just how appalling his conduct was. And so that is my petty, that to contrast with Justice Earls. That's a good one. Well, first of all, I love Anita Earls. I grew up with her as a civil rights lawyer.

1:28:36Amazing, amazing lawyer and jurist. Really great win. Loved seeing that video. But yeah, that actually felt good, just seeing the margin by which people want. We didn't have to go through the shenanigans. You all didn't have to spend the next three shows breaking down completely baseless cases that nevertheless were holding up the show. We're going to break down other completely baseless cases. Right, exactly. Plenty of material. I will say, I am going to do, I mean, my husband's here, he's going to drive me home, so he doesn't know this yet. But I'm going to ask him to drive by on M Street, the home of Blanche Kelso Bruce, the last elected senator from Mississippi during Reconstruction who served a full term.

1:29:17I just think there's something so wonderful about the Scott Colum victory in particular that just makes me so happy. and so even though they're counting ever so slowly I just know how it's going to turn out and that just means so, so much. Do you think they're counting like one Mississippi to Mississippi?

1:29:48So Blanche Bruce actually factors into my this or that. Oh no. Yeah, okay. This. Annie Andrews, the newly elected senator from South Carolina, will hold the seat previously held by Confederate secession apologist John C. Calhoun and segregationist Strom Thurmond. James Tallarico will hold the seat of Lyndon B. Johnson, the Democratic president who signed the Civil Rights Act and Voting Rights Act and after that said, I think we may have lost the South for your lifetime and mine. But in the first election after SCOTUS nullified the remaining provision of the Voting Rights Act, a majority of the former Confederate states will send a Democrat to the Senate in January.

1:30:39There's no or. When Scott Cologne becomes the senator-elect from Mississippi, the next part was going to be the first black senator after, you know, the last black senator from Mississippi was Blanche Bruce, who was actually born enslaved. And Scott Cologne winning the Forest District, named for Nathaniel Forest. started the KKK. So that's the this. I would read the other part of the this, but I will start to cry. It's Alex Preddy's mom posting a picture of her son as a young kid with a thank you to voters and the I Voted stickers on the memorials for Renee Nicole Good and Alex Preddy. That's the this.

1:31:23I want both of those. It's all of it. You get to pick all of it. Because that is the statistic showing Republican candidates performed worse in areas and districts where Trump held rallies and it's definitely it's definitely the this it's definitely the this and that Democrats won districts with cheesecake factories oh my god that is great I love I love what you put together for the this because it just it's you know I keep talking about the long game you know Ernie Suggs piece about you know the forebears of Keisha Lance Bottoms having been enslaved and you know I talk all the time about having to play the long game and talk to my kids about it and they don't want to hear it because they're not interested in the long game which is really what's great about young people you know that they're impatient no it's true that's that's how things get done because they're impatient and they don't want to hear your arc of whatever they want it to happen now but it doesn't change the fact that it is true and in in church we say something about running on to see what the ends gonna be and I'm always telling my kids that like you just you got to stick around you got to stick around I tell them and when it goes it goes fast I said I lived through you know we thought baby Doc remember baby Doc in Haiti we thought forever Marcos in the Philippines then you just woke up one morning I mean Ceausescu came out to give a speech and somebody heckled him and then the next thing we knew they were dragging him through the streets we were like what what happened right so I just think when it goes it goes fast and you do have to stick it out and I asked everyone that and I would ask this you know audience that too is it okay with you are you still prepared to do the work even if you may not get to experience it you know it's gonna happen you know what the ends gonna be but you may not get to see it are you okay with that can that be okay for you and I think that's what we're being called to in this moment like someone did it so certainly I could sit on the stage you know and and so I could be a lawyer so you could live where you live so you could be married to who you're married to so you could live in the house that you live in despite the covenant that probably is still in the deed and all that stuff and they didn't get to see the outcome and so all of that everything that you said is just a reminder that we have the obligation obligation to keep going even if we don't get the joy of seeing the end of the game because I feel absolutely confident I don't have any doubt of what the end is going to be no doubt and if I'm not there to see the end it doesn't change the fact that the end is the end you know and it's going to be better than what we have now.

1:34:22This is why she's the greatest. Please give it up for Sherilyn Ifill.

1:34:34And as always we will end with our favorite things. So I have to say on the Sherilyn right like long game being okay note like as i was preparing for this note i was like i'm so happy and i knew and we've talked about this before that like i was okay we were okay doing this podcast knowing that like supreme court reform right democracy reform like might not happen in our lives and our professional lives and on tuesday i felt like oh my gosh it might happen and that was just so incredible so incredible so that's obviously on the list of favorite things other things Barrett Adair's election night Instagram post if you don't know her go check it out she's incredible she's gonna be a crooked con it's hilarious okay Stacey Abrams Ayanna Presley Debbie Dingle and Mallory McMorrow telling Hayley Stevens to go pound sand and dragging her for Phil.

1:35:42Governor-elect Amy Acton not picking up the phone.

1:35:50When Vivek called her to concede and adding that she doesn't plan to speak to him. We stan a boundary queen. Also a hello to some stricties in the wild I saw. Luke at Kroger and Ben at Albee. Always delightful to hear from you. I will add a few. I think it was this morning, maybe it was yesterday, but if you're listening on Monday, I think Friday's M. Gessen column in the New York Times about just not accepting an autocrat's worldview about kind of a politics of division and then tweaking it. This just goes to the kind of, I think, deep debate that's going to unfold within the Democratic Party.

1:36:32Do you try to make some changes on the margins or do you fundamentally oppose the autocratic worldview that you vanquished? And obviously, Gessen is in the latter column and makes a great, great case in defense of it. A couple of other things we haven't talked about. The young voter numbers. Incredible. Incredible. We teach law students. We tell our students all the time. I mean, just young voters voted like this in every election. The world would look really different. It's just so exciting. Halloween in New York City plus Election Day meant like just a couple of days of like terror and elation and just stress eating candy that turned from full body clenching into full body joy and then getting to be here at the end of the week with all of you and with Sherilyn and can I shout out what Sherilyn gave us these pocket constitutions I don't know how you get one let me but they're they're not full constitutions they are pocket constitutions of the most important part of the Constitution, which is the Reconstruction Amendments.

1:37:35With a little reading list at the end that you should check out. So I don't quite know how to get these, but like, you know, they're out there. Check out 14th Amendment Center for Law and Democracy. I'm sure it has many of the resources, you know, that are listed here and watch out for the programming there as well, for sure. And finally, Melissa called an audible and said, as art director, we need to change our outfits and dress as a blue wave tonight. And she was to wear a forest green drab blazer. It's like, no girl. And so shout out to Argent who made our blazers, which we love. All right.

1:38:08Those are my favorite things.

1:38:11Favorite things, election night, 2026.

1:38:18We just haven't felt this good in a really long time. Yeah. I mean, it's been pretty shitty. Yeah. So that was great. I genuinely couldn't even go to sleep. I don't think I've been up that late since the Obama administration, truly. So it's great. I'm also loving Min Jin Lee's American Hagwon. I think this may be one of the, this may be the great American novel. I mean, I think it's that great. So please. Yesterday, I spent the evening at Princeton talking to the youth about the Constitution, the Princeton Pre-Law Society. And I met some stricties in the wild. So let me shout out Tori, Ariana, Jamie, Maria, Melissa, Teddy, Issa, Dabby, Hannah, Andres, Alex, Anthony, and Noah.

1:39:04They were terrific. And then this morning, I had the great pleasure of spending time with the 7th and 8th graders at the Holy Trinity Episcopal School in Prince George's County. And these were some very well-read 7th and 8th graders. And we were talking about the Constitution. They each picked an amendment that they liked and they were so, like, they knew more about the amendments in the Constitution than Brett Kavanaugh.

1:39:34And one of them picked the Ninth Amendment and said it was her favorite because the Ninth Amendment is basically like going to the grocery store with a list. Everybody knows that you're not limited to the list because you forget things that you're going to need. And you're not going to want to come back. So that's true. The future looks bright. So thank you so much to Holy Trinity Episcopal School and their indefatigable head of school, DeAndre Calhoun, for inviting me. Thank you. All right. So just a couple thank yous before we go. Crooked Con, we have so loved getting to have some fun with all of you tonight.

1:40:13Thank you so much to all of you. Thank you to our producer, who was our forever producer, even though he's technically moved on to bigger and better things, Michael Goldsmith for helping staff us here tonight, as well as Adrian Hill and Ilona Minkowski, Melody Rowell, always making us sound our best and saving us from most of our worst, maybe not all of it, and to Sophie Eisenstadt and the rest of the Crooked team for making Crooked Con possible. What a gathering.

1:40:39And just a few more as we amp up for Thanksgiving under Woke 3.0. Stacey Abrams, again, for doing the work to make a blue Georgia possible. So incredible. Also, the organizers who did the work to make a blue Texas possible, despite being told it would never happen when it didn't materialize the last few cycles. Well, as Sherilyn so beautifully put it, you don't always get to see the fruit of your labor, but actually this time you did. It just took a couple cycles. And thank you so much to all of them. To the Minnesotans who showed us we can get through this together and in the process made the country see the horrors that this administration was perpetrating.

1:41:23To all of the southern state voters, especially the black voters who organized and showed up despite people saying the South would never go blue and it was not worth investing there, Senate Dems send some money to Louisiana next time challenge in Florida too.

1:41:44Thank you to Argent Workwear for helping us physically embody the blue wave tsunami wormhole. And finally, thank you to everyone who made this moment possible, this moment and the moments that have preceded it this week. This feels so good. It's overwhelming. It's amazing. And we can continue it. So please keep going. Don't stop. Can't stop. Won't stop. That energy. And before we go, we would like to know, can we take a selfie with you?

1:42:28Strict Scrutiny is a Crooked Media production. Our show is produced by Melody Rao and Farrah Safari. Music is by Eddie Cooper. Our team includes Alona Munkowski, Matt DeGroat, Ben Hethcote, Adam Lippert, and Eric Schutt. Our production staff is proudly unionized with the Writers Guild of America East.

1:43:04that I'm proudest of is that video we made of Yvette Ramaswamy grunting while hitting baseballs. No, wait, sorry. The thing I'm proudest of is the work we do through Vote Save America. See, we don't want our shows to only leave you feeling anxious about the state of the world. We want to give you something you can actually do about it. Just this year, our listeners have raised millions of dollars and filled thousands of volunteer shifts to help candidates and causes in the 2026 midterms. And we have no plans to slow down as we head into 2028. As far as I know, there's no other media company that does what Crooked does.

1:43:36We make entertaining, thoughtful content that brings people into politics, and then we give them a direct way to get involved. And if you believe in that mission, one of the best ways to support us is by becoming a paid subscriber. Your subscription helps us keep making the shows you love and building a media company that doesn't just talk about politics, but helps people change them. And if the mission sounds great, but you feel like you need some sweet subscriber benefits to get you over the finish line, we've got you covered. Subscribers get ad-free shows, plus excellent exclusive podcasts, newsletters, and much, much more.

1:44:06So thank you for listening and supporting what we do. Head to crooked.com slash friends today to learn more and become a subscriber.

From the publisher

Post-blue wave and on the eve of Crooked Con, Kate, Melissa, and Leah break down what went right on election night, and how the Supreme Court did its very best to prevent it by disenfranchising voters and enabling Trump’s lawlessness. Then, some executive branch news both welcome (see ya, Harmeet Dhillon) and horrifying (the ascension of Stephen Miller to chief of staff), before a breakdown of the biggest case SCOTUS heard last week. Is there a constitutional right to use public funds to discriminate against gay and trans people? Brett Kavanaugh seems to think so! Finally, Sherrilyn Ifill, founding director of the 14th Amendment Center for Law & Democracy at Howard University, joins to talk about one of the most important tasks for Democrats ahead: Court reform.

Favorite things:


Take the Strict Scrutiny survey.

New Strict merch available here.

You can now listen to Strict Scrutiny for CLE credits in California, New York, Texas, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Virginia, North Carolina, Georgia, Washington, and Oregon! More info at crooked.com/strict_cle

Get tickets for STRICT SCRUTINY LIVE on November 6th in Washington, DC: Crookedcon.com

Buy Melissa’s book, The U.S. Constitution: A Comprehensive and Annotated Guide for the Modern Reader

Buy Leah’s book, Lawless, now out in paperback

Follow us on Instagram, Threads, and Bluesky

For a transcript of an episode of Strict Scrutiny please email [email protected]

More from Strict Scrutiny

All episodes