

Stuff You Should Know covers Frank Lloyd Wright’s Taliesin estate in Wisconsin and the August 15, 1914 “Taliesin Massacre,” when Wright’s mistress Mama Borthwick and her children were killed and several employees were murdered and burned in a fire set by handyman Julian Carlton.
No episode guests are interviewed. Hosts Josh Clark and Charles W. “Chuck” Bryant and Jerry (co-host/producer) discuss the history.
Taliesin is described as Wright’s “masterpiece” (prairie style, ~21,000 sq ft, 524 windows, no gutters). Wright’s earlier scandal is emphasized: affair with Mama Borthwick, leaving his wife Kitty in 1909, and later building a home for Mama with Darwin Martin’s $25,000 seed money. Carlton had weeks of violent, erratic behavior (axe, threats, rumors of being fired). The massacre: Carlton slaughtered Mama and her kids, set the dining room on fire with gasoline, then killed escapees at windows; 7 of 9 died.
survivors Herb Fritz and David Lindblom; Carlton later found in an asbestos-lined boiler room after attempting suicide with hydrochloric acid; Wright learns via a call from Chicago: “Taliesin is on fire.”
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
The hosts discuss upcoming personal events and introduce the Taliesin massacre topic.
“We're inching toward the end of the year.”
Exploration of Taliesin as Frank Lloyd Wright's architectural legacy and its significance.
“And this is Stuff You Should Know, the long-awaited Frank Lloyd Wright edition.”
Discussion of the unique features and principles of the prairie style in architecture.
“I think it said that it's his autobiography written in wood and stone, that it's just him.”
The hosts share their thoughts and feelings about Frank Lloyd Wright's architecture and styles.
“because he wanted icicles to form on the eaves of the roof so he could look out of those 524 windows in the Wisconsin winter and see all the icicles hanging.”
Exploration of Frank Lloyd Wright's affair and its impact on his life and career.
“Like Fallingwater is one of my favorite houses in the entire world.”
Explore Frank Lloyd Wright's tumultuous personal life, including his affair and the consequences for his family.
“So he seems to have been unfulfilled professionally and kind of took it out on his family in about the worst way you could possibly take things out on your family short of cutting them up with a machete.”
Uncover the circumstances leading to the horrific events at Taliesin involving Frank Lloyd Wright's mistress and her children.
“We'll leave the way back machine out of this one, okay?”
Learn about the horrifying events of the Taliesin Massacre and its aftermath.
“That's some old-timey rug cleaning if I've ever heard of it.”
Explore Frank Lloyd Wright's struggles and relationships after the massacre.
“So this murder really, and of course the fire, really, really took a toll on Frank Lloyd Wright.”
The hosts discuss their visits to Frank Lloyd Wright's architectural sites and his influence.
“It was during that time he did Taliesin West, which like I said, Yumi and I went to, we went out to Scottsdale and visited with our friends Blair and Aaron out there, who are Scottsdale peeps.”
The hosts share updates about their new book, its content, and illustrations.
“And since I said after the pandemic ends, let's optimistically go on to listener mail.”
The hosts express gratitude towards listeners who support their book and discuss its accessibility.
“But if you can't, if you're like, I just don't have the money right now, or I don't feel like spending the money.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Stuff You Should Know, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human. I turned off news altogether. I hate to say it, but I don't trust much of anything.
0:12Chuck Bryant: It's the rage bait. It feels like it's trying to divide people. We got clear facts. Maybe we can calm down a little. NBC News brings you clear reporting. Let's meet at the facts. Let's move forward from there. NBC News reporting for America. No one's journey is the same. That's why Delta SkyMiles moves with you. Whether it's earning miles on coffee runs and flights, redeeming miles for concerts and vacations, SkyMiles membership fits into your everyday, letting you do more of what makes you, you. It's more than travel. It's the membership that flies, dines, streams, rides, and arrives with you.
0:56Because when you have a membership that's as unique as you are, there's no telling where your journey will take you next.
1:07That sound? That's the National Squash League. Pro teams, the world's best players, and rallies so fast you'll forget to breathe. Season 4 is in full swing, and every match streams free on YouTube. Big hits, bigger rivalries, and a front row seat from wherever you are. Watch every match for free on YouTube. Search National Squash League and hit subscribe or follow live updates on Instagram at nsl.sport. Hi, everybody. We're inching toward the end of the year. It's December 10th, 2020 in COVID time. And we are here to tell you about the episode, or at least I'm here, the Taliesin Massacre. It's a massacre that happened at the, perhaps Frank Lloyd Wright's greatest work, Taliesin in Wisconsin.
1:56And I picked this one because, geez, by this time, I will have long done this in real time but I am going and have went to the Green Bay Packers the Atlanta Falcons at Lambeau Field playing the Green Bay Packers and I knew this game was on the calendar and I went with my good friend Adam Pranica of the greatest generation and my good friend from high school Robert Chahade and we all met up in Green Bay with Adam's uncle Uncle Pete Pranica by the way who is the voice of the Memphis Grizzlies So I can say this with confidence, even though it hasn't happened yet. I know I had a great time talking to Uncle Pete because I've long wanted to meet him.
2:35And I'm a big fan of the NBA. My mom's from Memphis. And so I know he had a lot to talk about. It's kind of weird because I know this is all true, but it hasn't happened yet. But on my list, I don't know if I made it or not. I guess time will tell. I wanted to go see Taliesin. I know we're playing golf at Whispering Pines. And I know that went well. I don't know how I shot yet, but I know that Whispering Pines is lovely. And it had to be great unless it was pouring down rain. But who cares? Play in the rain. But like I said, maybe I'll follow up and let you know if I actually made it out to Taliesin.
3:03I'm not sure if the calendar had enough space. But at the very least, I was well prepared with my knowledge of the Taliesin massacre. And you will be, too, if you listen right now.
3:18Welcome to Stuff You Should Know, a production of iHeartRadio.
3:28Chuck Bryant: Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh Clark, and there's Charles W. Chuck Bryant, and Jerry's here. And this is Stuff You Should Know, the long-awaited Frank Lloyd Wright edition. Sort of. Yeah, kind of. I mean, you know, it's not a full biography, but it definitely covers some of his—a very dark period of his life. Oh, yeah. One of the darker periods that any artiste could have. And make no mistake, Frank Lloyd Wright was an artiste. He was an artiste of architecture. Yeah. How many houses of his have you seen or buildings? I've seen a bunch. I've been to Hollyhock in Los Angeles. I've been to a Usonian.
4:15Chuck Bryant: I can't remember which one in Washington by the one of the – I can't remember what other historic house it's by. They moved it. There's a Usonian in Alabama, Chuck, in Florence, Alabama, which is really neat. Been to Falling Water. Been to Taliesin West. I think that's it. Yeah. I've been to a handful myself. I've been to one in Tulsa and a couple in L.A. Of course, the Guggenheim. I think we've both been there. I have not. I have not. Oh, really? Yeah. All the times you've been to New York and all the museums, you never stepped foot in the Guggenheim? It's true. I've never been in the Guggenheim, sadly enough.
4:54Chuck Bryant: I saw a movie where there's a shootout in the Guggenheim one. I highly recommend going to the Guggenheim. It's great. Okay. I thought it was George Costanza that designed the Guggenheim, not Frank Lloyd Wright. That's right. He always wanted to be an architect. That's right. My favorite line for that episode is when he talks about the redesign plans of the Guggenheim, and they go, really? He goes, yeah, it really didn't even take that long. That's right. Yeah. He's saying that he was the one who redesigned it. Like it's impressive that it was just a really quick job. Right. Yeah, that's a classic.
5:31Chuck Bryant: But we're not talking about the Guggenheim today, Chuck. We're not even talking about Hollyhock House. We're talking about specifically Taliesin, which is widely regarded as Frank Lloyd Wright's genuine bona fide masterpiece, like his greatest work ever. I think it said that it's his autobiography written in wood and stone, that it's just him. And not just him in a specific time and place, but for decades worth of work, his earliest work to his latest work, all showed up and appeared over time at Taliesin. Yeah, I mean, there's a lot there. It was his home at times. It was his studio, a school.
6:17and 800 acre estate. This was family land. It was his favorite hill in Wisconsin in the River Valley there where his Welsh grandparents originally homesteaded. And so it was very personal to him. So he did things like make the roof so it doesn't leak water into the offices below, like some of his other properties.
6:42Chuck Bryant: Exactly. Yeah. He wasn't one to just move his desk, right? Right. So this particular house, and it still is, it's a huge, enormous house. I think it's 21 ,000 square feet. It's a classic example of what's called the prairie style, which is a style of architecture considered to be the first genuine American style of architecture that Frank Lloyd Wright founded back in, I think, the 1890s, maybe the late 1890s. 1990s. And it has, it takes its inspiration from the surrounding environment. It's meant to blend in with the environment, work with the environment rather than to dominate it. So there's a lot of horizontal lines, a lot of natural materials, a lot of woodworking.
7:26Chuck Bryant: And taliesin is very much in that style. I think it has 524 windows, which is a lot of windows. And it also has no gutters. There's a lot of cantalevered roofs which kind of overhang pretty far, so there isn't necessarily a need for gutters. But I read that Frank Lloyd Wright specifically didn't want gutters because he wanted icicles to form on the eaves of the roof so he could look out of those 524 windows in the Wisconsin winter and see all the icicles hanging. Do you like the prairie homes, that style? Yeah, yeah, I do. My problem with Frank Lloyd Wright's work is that it's so dated and old-timey that it almost makes me a combination of scared and nauseous.
8:19Chuck Bryant: You know what I'm talking about? Sure. Have you ever looked at a wicker wheelchair from the turn of the last century? Yeah, yeah. You just kind of get the creeps from it for some reason. Okay, you get that same feeling. I mean, this, you know, he did the bulk of his work a hundred years ago. Right. You know, somewhere in that range. But it was also like, it was also very technologically advanced. And like, he was just doing some really interesting stuff. So the way that a very dated, once technologically advanced piece of work can kind of cull that weird feeling out of you. But at the same time, I'm like in genuine awe of the stuff he did.
9:00Chuck Bryant: Like Fallingwater is one of my favorite houses in the entire world. Sure. I mean, it's gorgeous. I mean, it's just amazing. What about you? Do you like the prairie style? I like them all right. They're fine. Some of them, and, you know, I have some here in the neighborhood that pop up every now and then. Some newer builds are in the prairie style. And I like them more than some other kinds and less than some other kinds. Let's just say that. You like craftsmen? Well, sure. I live in a craftsman. That's my favorite. it but i like craftsmen too i think they're good i i mean i love a highly slick modern home i don't want to live in one but i love them i would not want to live in one either those are hit or miss with me like some of them are just too just god awful some of them are just when they hit the nail on the head you're like wow that's one of the best houses anyone's ever designed and built but they miss it's almost like documentaries and horror movies there's a lot of them but only very very few like are truly great that's my that's my impression of modern homes yeah i'm into we're into architecture though as a as a couple emily and i and we watch a couple of great well us too uh it's a triad well i guess throw yumi in there and i guess we'd be a quadrad but uh we we have a couple of shows that we love to watch that are uh there's one called grand designs on netflix that i highly recommend uh and oh man what's the other one there's this cup not a married couple but a pair that travels the world.
10:28Chuck Bryant: The Great British Architecture Bake Off? No, that's not it. I can't remember what it's called, but Grand Designs is really good. I mean, and they follow these, you know, sort of impossibly built houses designed and built by these incredible lunatic dreamers who are obsessed with sort of a thing. It seems to be the common thread is these obsessives. And it leads to something beautiful and great, you know, usually. For sure, yeah. So one of the things about Frank Lloyd Wright is that he is, including during his lifetime, he's considered one of the greatest architects to ever live. Certainly the most popularly well-known, maybe, I guess you'd put it.
11:11Chuck Bryant: Like anybody who's ever heard of any kind of architecture, even vaguely, is probably familiar with Frank Lloyd Wright. Agreed. So when he put all of himself into Taliesin, he was building a home for himself. And I think it was completed in 1911. And like it's worth pointing out, he was returning to his childhood home, to the valley where his clan like settled. Like if you look around Spring Green, Wisconsin, everybody's got the name Lloyd in there somewhere. Like his maternal ancestors settled that area. And he was literally building on this hill, his favorite hill when he was a child, like you were saying.
11:51Chuck Bryant: But he was doing this in the midst of one of the biggest scandals like any architect's ever gone through. Yeah. So as you'll see through this show, and if you know anything about the man, Frank Lloyd Wright had a bit of a wandering eye and a bit of a philandering habit. And he had an extramarital affair with a woman named M-A-M-A-H, Mama Borthwick. I don't know. I've been testing it out, too. I said Mama. Mama? Sure. Borthwick. And she was, you know, they met in 1903. Wright was in his mid-30s at the time. He was already really famous as an architect. and he was commissioned to design a house for her and her husband, Edwin Chaney.
12:39And they were, it was going to be built there in Wisconsin, pretty close to Chicago, where Frank Lloyd Wright was at the time. She was pregnant in her mid-30s at the time with her second child and got really involved in sort of working with Frank Lloyd Wright very closely. And that sort of, you know, the classic story, at first it starts out platonic, One thing leads to another. And before you know it, they're bumping uglies.
13:06Chuck Bryant: That's right. Smashing, as the younger kids say from what I understand. Yeah, I just heard that for the first time the other day. Didn't know that was a thing. So it's a thing now. So Frank Lloyd Wright by this time had six kids of his own. And he had made a name for himself like around Chicago, building homes, designing homes for the well-to-do, especially in the Oak Park neighborhood. apparently just between 1900 and 1910 he designed 50 prairie houses so he'd made a name for himself but apparently by the time I think 1908 was when he no 1907 when they started their affair by the time 1907 rolled around he was getting kind of tired of doing the same thing it's kind of like he was cursed like this this school of architecture that he developed was so popular that he, that's all anybody wanted.
14:00Chuck Bryant: And he had gotten bored with it by that time. So he seems to have been unfulfilled professionally and kind of took it out on his family in about the worst way you could possibly take things out on your family short of cutting them up with a machete. Yeah, by 1908, it was a pretty much well-known open secret in Chicago and of that high society in Chicago that this affair was going on. And he was sort of looked down on from his friends and his neighbors and his peers, different colleagues. His poor wife, Kitty, was long-suffering because she kind of stood by his side anyway. And he realized that he really wanted to leave his family.
14:45And he did so. He said, I did not know what I wanted. I wanted to go away. And he did. In September of 1909, Frank left with her, went to Europe, left his wife and his six kids behind. And here's one of the more selfish quotes I've ever seen from a husband and father. And this was in his autobiography. So when family life in Oak Park in that spring of 1909 conspired against the freedom to which I had come to feel every soul entitled, I had no choice. Would I keep my self-respect but to go out a voluntary exile? So he really felt, and you know, those were his words in his autobiography. So he wasn't, he had no illusions about himself, but he very much felt that, you know what, I'm Frank Lloyd Wright and I'm a man and I deserve this by my right.
15:39Chuck Bryant: Yeah. So those are two key points. He's a man, so he deserved it. But more than anything, He was a legend in his own mind, which was sustained and verified by the public at large. But he was Frank Lloyd Wright. So more than anybody, he deserved to go do whatever he wanted. And, you know, whatever the consequences were for other people emotionally, to hell with that. One other thing that I think is worth pointing out is that he had money problems basically his entire life, despite the fact that, I mean, this man designed the Guggenheim. He designed some of the most iconic buildings and houses in the United States.
16:17Chuck Bryant: And he had money just coming in by the truckload, but he would spend it as fast as he could get it and then some. So at this point in time, when he left his family, he apparently left them in financial straits as well. There's a biographer named Paul Hendrickson. Paul Hendrickson, I'm sorry. And he points out that there was a$900 grocery bill that was laying on the kitchen counter when Frank Lloyd Wright walked out on his family, which, I mean, at least pay the grocery bill so the family that you're leaving in a lurch can eat, you know? Yeah, so his mistress left her two kids with her husband.
17:00She went on a train to New York City, met Frank at the Plaza Hotel. They had a few days there of, I guess, smashing. And then went to Europe, and he was famous the world over, so it's not like he could lay low. Very famous face, very famous dresser of fine clothing and those hats. So he didn't exactly blend in anywhere he went. So he was found out in Berlin. Chicago Tribune had a headline that said, Leave Families, semicolon. Nice little switch there. elope to Europe. And this whole time, poor Kitty, she says, it appears like any other ordinary mundane affair with the trappings of what is low and vulgar, but there's nothing of that sort about Frank Wright.
17:44He is honest and sincere. I know him. My heart is with him now. I feel certain that he will come back. And that's one of the saddest parts about all this is she was sort of like, he's just philandering a bit and he'll come back to us.
17:57Chuck Bryant: Yeah, it is sad. But also, you know, whatever his kids were thinking too, Like, well, I guess dad didn't love us enough to stick around. Another, I think, kind of telling clue about Frank Lloyd Wright's enormous arrogance was he called his and what are we going to call her, Chuck? Mama? I'm calling her Mama. Okay. His and Mama's flight to Europe after abandoning their families, he called it a spiritual Hegira. And I had not seen that word before. And it turns out Hegira, H-E-G-I-R-A, is what Muhammad's exodus from persecution in Mecca was called. And he left Mecca to go to Medina where he founded Islam.
18:49Chuck Bryant: And to Frank Lloyd Wright, this is what he and his mistress were doing when they abandoned their families and fled to Europe. Yeah, he thought a lot of himself. He was an SOB, man, plain and simple. I don't, like, he's a classic example of, like, having to compartmentalize the genius of the work and just the complete horribleness of the person, you know? I know. I know. But it can be done. It can be done. And I disagree with anybody who says, you know, there's certain exceptions, I'm sure. But anybody who says, well, this person held some pretty terrible views, so we shouldn't pay any attention to their work from that point on.
19:27Chuck Bryant: I disagree with that. I think that there are tons of exceptions to that rule, although there are tons of exceptions to the exceptions to that rule, too, if that's not confusing enough. Well, I think it's a personal decision. If someone wants to never gaze upon falling waters again, then that's their choice. Totally. It's not like I'm going to, you know, grab them by their hair and like making them look. But I would disagree with them in a lot of cases. Yeah, like Manson's music. Fantastic. Just beautiful stuff. Really good stuff. For sure. So Frank Lloyd Wright returns to Chicago in 1910. Meemaw stayed behind.
20:08she stayed there in Europe for another year because she was getting a divorce from Edwin Chaney and so she stayed there wrapping that up Frank moved back with Kitty he had no intention of staying and I think it was pretty clear to Kitty at this point because she said Mr. Wright I wonder if he made her call her that Mr. Wright reached here Saturday evening, October 8 and he has brought many beautiful things everything but his heart I guess and that he has left in Germany. But he came back a bit of a pariah.
20:40Chuck Bryant: Oh, just a tad. They were pariahs before. There was a woman who grew up living next door to Mama and her children. And she, years later in her diary, recounted a time when her mom refused to give Frank Lloyd Wright cream when he came over from next door to borrow some and said that they were sinners and she wasn't going to help them out at all. So when they left for Europe, made headline news for leaving their families. And then he returns, moves back in with his family just long enough to plan his next home for him and Mama. Like, yeah, the people in his social orbit did not take very kindly to that.
21:21Chuck Bryant: Professionals, neighbors, friends, gossip colonists, basically everybody in the Midwest who had anything to do with anything, like were rejected him and Mama. Yeah, and to boot when he gets back, because he needed seed money for his new home, he had a benefactor named Darwin Martin. And he said, hey, listen, I want to build this great cottage. And this affair is long over. And this is going to be a cottage for my mom. And I promise it's not going to be our little smash shack. And so give me$25 ,000 to get this project going. He got it. He moved into the home with his mistress. And I think by Christmas 1911, they were officially living together there in Greenspring.
22:09Chuck Bryant: Yeah, he said, thanks, chump. Thanks for the money. And because just trashing Frank Lloyd Wright as a person is a lot of fun, I want to add this detail too. Darwin Barton, his benefactor, over the course of Frank Lloyd Wright's career, lent Frank Lloyd Wright 75 grand total. and when the stock market crashed in 1929, Darwin Martin lost everything. Like he was flat broke, went from an extraordinarily wealthy man to just flat broke for the rest of his life. Frank Lloyd Wright never repaid any of that money, but he made sure that when his autobiography came out that Darwin Martin got a free copy.
22:52Chuck Bryant: Oh, that's nice. Yeah, he really pulled that out at the last minute, didn't he? All right, so let's take a break, and we'll come back and talk about things taking a turn for the worst a few years later in August of 1914.
23:08Stuff you should know. Dosh and Chuck.
23:16Stuff you should know. That sound? That's the National Squash League. Pro teams, the world's best players, and rally so fast you'll forget to breathe. Season 4 is in full swing, and every match streams free on YouTube. Big hits, bigger rivalries, and a front row seat from wherever you are. Watch every match for free on YouTube. Search National Squash League and hit subscribe or follow live updates on Instagram at nsl.sport.
23:48Chuck Bryant: Morning, Carmen. Hey, Carmen. Morning. Quick question. Just one second. Sorry. Carmen's worked at this office for 20 years. She knows everything, which is why Carmen has to help with, well, everything. Hey, Carmen, what did Faye pitch in 2023? Who owns the Nordic account? Oh, uh, where's the printer? But Carmen's revenue report is due in five minutes, so she shows them WorkIQ. Hey, Copilot, who owns the Nordic account? And what did we pitch them in 2023? Get the context you need with Microsoft Copilot. Work lives on. No two journeys are alike. That's why SkyMiles is designed to move with you wherever life takes you.
24:25It flies with you on new adventures, family getaways, and business trips. It dines with you on special nights out, streams with you for every binge watch, rides through your daily routines, and helps you turn every day into memories that last a lifetime. The best part? The miles you've earned along the way can be used for what's next. Your next spontaneous weekend escape, upgrade to premium seats, dream vacations, and so much more. SkyMiles takes you further. It unlocks access to exclusive one-of-a-kind experiences that make membership feel rewarding way before takeoff and long after landing. Because SkyMiles is about more than travel.
25:02It's a membership that helps you journey towards more. When your membership is as unique as you are, there's no telling where your next journey will take you.
25:23Chuck Bryant: Okay, Chuck, so let's just go ahead and get in the way back. Well, I don't want to see this. We'll just talk about it. We'll leave the way back machine out of this one, okay? So on Saturday, August 15th, 1914, around lunchtime, actually exactly at lunchtime, Mama Borthwick, Frank Lloyd Wright's mistress, longtime mistress, was sitting down for lunch on a terrace at Taliesin with her two kids. To his great credit, Edwin Chaney, her ex-husband by this time, was not interested in keeping Mama from seeing her children as punishment. So they went to visit pretty frequently. And this was a time when they were visiting.
26:05Chuck Bryant: So the three of them were sitting down to lunch. John, I think he was 10, and her daughter Martha, who was 8. And Mama, Mama, were sitting down to lunch on the terrace. Okay? Just put that in your pin. Put that pin in your hat and smoke it. So, wow, really mixing metaphors. So they're out on the terrace inside in the dining room. There are five of Frank Lloyd Wright's employees, Emil Burdell, Thomas Brunker, David Lindblom, Herbert Fritz, and William Weston, and then Weston's son Ernst. So they were all sitting down to eat. I think put a pin in maybe both of these scenes. And we'll tell you a little bit about the handyman of the property named Julian Carlton.
26:49who, in the weeks and months leading up to this date, had been acting really weird. He was aggressive. He was getting in arguments with other people. He was acting very strangely. He started sleeping with a hatchet and a sack beside his bed. He was married, and his wife verified this stuff. He was talking about killing people, and there was rumor that he was being let go and that he and his wife already had basically a train booked to Chicago to look for other jobs. So this is sort of the mindset of what's going on with Julian Carlton at the time of this lunch.
27:27Chuck Bryant: Right. So Julian was actually, so he was a handyman, but at this point he also helped his wife Gertrude. When she was cooking, he would serve. So he served lunch to Mama, and then he served lunch to the five employees in the dining room. And then as they started to eat, he approached William Weston, the foreman of the whole jam. William Weston was a pretty important guy around Taliesin and asked if he could go get some gasoline out of the shed, I guess, because he was going to clean some rugs with it. With gasoline? With gasoline, yes. I guess that was a thing back then. Sure. That's some old-timey rug cleaning if I've ever heard of it.
28:07Chuck Bryant: But so Weston said, sure, of course, go ahead. And things went downhill really quickly from that moment on. Yeah, so I appreciate you leaving this part to me. Carlton comes back. Oh, I'll fill in. Don't worry. He's got the gasoline, and he also has an axe. And the sequence is a little bit unclear. I've seen both ways of which happened first. But he slaughtered Mama Borthwick and her kids on the porch and then poured gasoline under the dining room doors and trapped them in the room and set the dining room and therefore the house on fire with everyone trapped inside. It gets even worse than that, though.
28:52Chuck Bryant: After he had slaughtered Mama and her kids with the axe and set the house on fire, he went around to a window, a dining room window, where the people who were trapped in the dining room that had just been set on fire were jumping to safety from. And as they jumped to safety, he ran after them and killed them with the ax. He would finish them off. Sometimes they were on fire and he would hit them in the head with the ax and killed them. And there were nine people who were dining that day and he managed to kill seven of the nine. Three people survived the initial assault, the fire and then the picking off with the ax.
29:33Chuck Bryant: The first guy who got away was named Herb Fritz. He was a draftsman, a younger guy. I think he was still a teenager who went on to become an architect, I believe. But he was the first one to jump through the window. And so he was able to get pretty far away from Julian Carlton before Carlton noticed that people were jumping through the window and came around to pick him off with the axe. That's right. William Weston got out of the window. Carlton hit him with the axe, thought he was dead, but he wasn't dead. In the meantime, Fritz, like you said, he didn't even, Carlton didn't even know he was gone.
30:07So he actually managed to get to the neighbors and contact authorities, which ended up being, you know, ended up sort of saving a lot of the house because they helped put it out. And the other guy who managed to at least get out the window was David Lindblom. He escaped with Fritz.
30:23Chuck Bryant: So Fritz and Lindblom, like when they ran to that house, it was like a half a mile away, which is really significant that Lindblom was able to do it because he was burned so badly that he died from his burns. And yet one of the last things he did on earth was to run a half a mile to get help at the nearest house with a phone. Yeah. So, you know, people get there, they put out the fire. Hours later, Carlton was discovered in the basement of the house in an asbestos-lined boiler room. He went down there to die in the fire, but also doubled up by drinking a bottle of hydrochloric acid to make sure he did the job, and neither one of them worked.
31:05He actually survived both of those things.
31:08Chuck Bryant: I actually saw that he was in the furnace because he was trying to survive the fire, and he didn't drink the acid until he knew he was discovered. Oh, see, I saw the opposite, that he went down to the furnace because he wanted to die in the home. Huh, yeah. The reason the furnace made sense to me that he was trying to survive in the furnace was that if he couldn't escape from the house, that would be the safest place because it was the middle of August and the furnace wasn't on. So it would have conceivably protected him or else it would have turned into that bronze bowl torture thing. You know, the bronze bowl that you put a human being in and light a fire under the bowl?
31:44Yeah, I remember that.
31:45Chuck Bryant: Sounds like a pretty horrible way to die. Either way, yes, it should be restated that Julian Carlton drank what he thought was a lethal dose of hydrochloric acid. Like that's how he chose to try to end his life. Yeah, so there was never any motive really rooted out. Clearly, looking back now, he suffered from some kind of mental illness. I don't think you can just all chalk it up to a grudge over being fired because of his behavior over the previous weeks and months. And, you know, it's just one of those things. It was a time where they weren't diagnosing things like that. So he clearly had some form of mental illness, I think.
32:24and they never conclusively determined a motive. But like I said, his wife testified that said, you know, we were headed to Chicago. We were going to get work. And he ended up dying, but he couldn't eat basically because he had torn up his stomach lining and his throat so badly with that hydrochloric acid. He died seven weeks later in jail from starvation.
32:46Chuck Bryant: Yeah, another interpretation I saw is that he had purposefully starved himself because the acid didn't work, that it wasn't just that he couldn't eat, but that he wouldn't eat, and that he died from self-imposed starvation. Either one's pretty terrible stuff. Just a brutal, brutal crime. Yeah. And I mean, I agree with you. I think he clearly was mentally ill, not just from the act that he carried out, but also the fact that he'd been ranting and sleeping with an ax for weeks leading up to it. But I think his perceived treatment or outright treatment around taliesin, And coupled with the idea that they had been dismissed and that was going to be their last day is, I guess, what drove them over the edge.
33:29Yeah. So, Frank, you mentioned or you've noticed we haven't mentioned him. He was in Chicago at the time. He was working, kind of finalizing everything on the construction of Midway Gardens there in Chicago, working with his son, John Lloyd Wright, who is his second oldest. and in the autobiography of John Wright called My Father Who Was On Earth said he remembered an unnatural silence when the phone call came in except for his father's labored breathing. And then he came back in the room and he said, What's happened, Dad? And his father said, John, a taxi. Taliesin is on fire.
34:06Chuck Bryant: Right. And if you're not too big on Frank Lloyd Wright, you might be like, well, what about the people who were murdered? In his defense, he apparently hadn't learned about that yet, and he learned that there were some gruesome, grisly murders of a lot of people he cared about from reporters who were shouting questions to him as he was going to the train station to take the train from Chicago over to Spring Green. Yeah, so Chicago newspaper headline reads, The End of Lawless Loves. You know, sort of a sensational and cold way to treat these murders, I think. Yeah. But they had been, you know, they had been all over their affair for years now.
34:48Chuck Bryant: And then, Chuck, one other thing about Julian Carlton. Have you ever been on that site, findagrave.com? Yeah, sure. Okay, so I was on findagrave.com. Part of the purpose, for those who don't know, is like to kind of memorialize, like leave a tribute or something to the person, the dead person. And sometimes it's very sweet, but other times it's very awkward. And this was an awkward case because there was like a little icon that clearly shows up on every page on Find a Grave. But it said, what's one thing you'll always remember when you think of Julian? I'm like, probably the axe murder slash arson, the killing of seven people.
35:26Chuck Bryant: That's what I'll always remember. He could really get a stain out of a rug. Right, with gasoline. Yeah, very, very good at that. You want to take a break? Yeah, let's take a break and we'll talk a little bit about Frank's later years right after this.
35:45Stuff you should know. Josh and Chuck.
35:53Stuff you should know. That sound? That's pro squash. Some of the fastest rallies in sport played inches from the crowd. The National Squash League is back in full swing for season four. The sport is heading to the 2028 Olympics for the first time, and you can see it up close right now in a city near you. Watch every match for free on YouTube. Search National Squash League and hit subscribe or follow live updates on Instagram at nsl.sport. So, everyone on board? You can't see it, but everyone in this room is nodding.
36:29Chuck Bryant: They all agree the launch plan's perfect, but Julie has an idea how it can be even better. So she asks Copilot Cowork to help her overnight. Hey, Copilot. Gather the past three months of retail sales reports, surface key insights, and build a deck outlining a partner strategy by tomorrow morning. Morning, team. I found a way to improve the plan. Check slide four. Get help with complex tasks with Copilot Cowork. Microsoft Copilot. Work lives on. No two journeys are alike. That's why SkyMiles is designed to move with you wherever life takes you. It flies with you on new adventures, family getaways, and business trips.
37:06It dines with you on special nights out, streams with you for every binge watch, rides through your daily routines, and helps you turn every day into memories that last a lifetime. The best part? The miles you've earned along the way can be used for what's next. Your next spontaneous weekend escape, upgrade to premium seats, dream vacations, and so much more. SkyMiles takes you further. It unlocks access to exclusive one-of-a-kind experiences that make membership feel rewarding way before takeoff and long after landing. Because SkyMiles is about more than travel. It's a membership that helps you journey towards more.
37:42When your membership is as unique as you are, there's no telling where your next journey will take you.
38:00So this murder really, and of course the fire, really, really took a toll on Frank Lloyd Wright. For the next, you know, 20 years, he really struggled with his work. He struggled for his freedom from the press, obviously. I mean, he was always in the press, but it was worse now than ever. And he did not suffer long romantically, though. He took up very quickly with a woman named Maude Miriam Hicks Noel. She went by Miriam. And she was an artist. She was a morphine addict. She was a fangirl. They had a terrible, terrible abusive relationship. It seems like kind of both ways, like a bit of a Sid and Nancy type thing going from everything I could read.
38:50Chuck Bryant: There were terrible people on both sides. Yeah, so he met when she was very young. She said he hadn't been with me 10 minutes before he said, you're mine. And they had a 10-year courtship that was very, very dysfunctional, very miserable. And when he got divorced in 1922 from Kitty, he decided at some point to marry, I think about a year later, to marry Miriam with that old mistake, thinking things would be different once they get married. And that's not at all how it went. They ended up splitting up, I think, six months later, something like that. Yeah. He said that to oppose her now in the slightest degree meant violence.
39:30Chuck Bryant: That's how bad the relationship had become. So it was – I get the impression from this biographer, Paul Hendrickson. The book he wrote, by the way, is called Dreams and Furies of Frank Lloyd Wright. And it's like 600 pages, I believe. But he does not paint a very flattering picture of Miriam at all. No. No, not at all. And like I said, they were not good for each other, it seems like. In 1924, after his divorce from Miriam, he gets married a third time to Olga Ivana. Her name was Olga Lazavich Hinzenberg. She was married. She was a dancer. They met at a ballet where she was performing. And they actually had another kid.
40:21Frank had a seventh child with her, a little girl in 1925. And Miriam comes back, though, and kind of tries to wreck their marriage, too.
40:30Chuck Bryant: Yeah, she, like, when they had their baby, she showed up at the hospital and made a scene, which is a pretty nasty move. She refused to give him a divorce. She, like, would talk to the papers about him. um she she uh teamed up with uh Olga's ex-husband or soon-to-be ex-husband um she she definitely worked against him but I guess eventually either got bored or was bought off or just kind of went away because from what I can tell uh Olga and Frank managed to carve out a happy married life for themselves from the 1920s, yeah, 1924 when they got married onward. I guess once Miriam left the picture, they were able to kind of settle in until Frank's death in 1959.
41:19Yeah, and Miriam actually got him arrested at one point under the Mann Act, M-A-N-N, which was a law, federal law that prohibits transport of women and children across state lines for the purposes of debauchery or prostitution. And I'm not really sure how that happened. It did not stick, obviously. He spent a couple of nights in jail and then the charges were dropped. But he went into a long dry spell work-wise, did not get hired a ton over a certain period of time. And then from the 30s to 59 when he died, he did some of his best work, maybe perhaps of his career.
42:00Chuck Bryant: Absolutely. It was during that time he did Taliesin West, which like I said, Yumi and I went to, we went out to Scottsdale and visited with our friends Blair and Aaron out there, who are Scottsdale peeps. And we went to Taliesin, and it was just, Chuck, dude, have you been to that one? Haven't been to Taliesin West, no. It's really, really cool. Just the little, just so many details about it. And there's a lot of fountains, which is really refreshing in the desert. It's just a really great, neat little place for sure. And a little, I use that in the absolute wrong way. It's pretty big. It's a charming place for sure.
42:40Yeah, and of course he did the Guggenheim after that. Falling Water was in there. Yeah, so it was a very productive period of his life. Maybe should we do more on Frank Lloyd Wright in the future or is this it?
42:54Chuck Bryant: No, no. We'll do the in True Stuff You Should Know style and just chip away at different parts about his life and then do a full biography on them years down the road. All right. That sounds good. I thought of another place I went, a Frank Lloyd Wright place. There's a Florida Southern College, or university, I'm sorry, is a Frank Lloyd Wright design campus. It's amazing. I'll have to check that out too. You should check it out. There's like this really great covered walkway that you walk around everywhere, and it's really neat. You just feel immersed in Frank Lloyd Wright. It's not just one building or one house.
43:27Chuck Bryant: It's a whole campus. I love it. If you want to know more about Frank Lloyd Wright, then just go out after the pandemic ends and start visiting some of his houses. And since I said after the pandemic ends, let's optimistically go on to listener mail. No, no, sir. No listener mail today. I think today we should take a little bit of an opportunity to talk for a few minutes about our book. Everyone's been really patient while we've plugged the pre-sale of this book. I think by the time this comes out, the book will be out. Is that right? Is this after the 24th, probably? Yeah. Jerry can make it so.
44:08I think it is, but if not, it's just before. And I finally got the books delivered to my house in hardcover edition, and I got to hold it in my hand, as have you. And, dude, it's great. I'm really proud of the work that we did along with Flatiron. Our co-writer Nils, who's just an amazing dude.
44:29Chuck Bryant: Yes, and our illustrator Carly Monardo, who did just an amazing job throughout the book of bringing like just passages that you didn't even think of just suddenly kind of came to life through illustrations. Yeah, I mean, there's an illustration of Momo. There's an illustration of my daughter. There are nice little Easter eggs in there. You know, we haven't talked a lot about the contents of the book. We had a lot of fun with the notes at the bottom, the footnotes. it's really became kind of a fun part of the book. We mentioned, I don't even, I lost count how many podcasts we mentioned, but we've notated those in the end.
45:07Chuck Bryant: Yeah, and there were plenty that we missed. Like I did another, like I shouldn't have done this, but I did another like fine tooth comb, like just scrape through of every word in the book. Of course you did. To see, you know, what podcasts we needed to link to. when I was like, oh man, I found like 50 of these so far. And I emailed and was like, is it too late to add footnotes or podcast footnotes? And they're like, yes, that time has come. So maybe in the second edition. Yeah, exactly. Can we get these reprinted? I have the number here, actually. We have listed in the book, or referenced in the book, we have 274 references to other podcasts.
45:49But here's a few of the chapters. We did one on Murphy beds, one on back masking one on aging one on donuts that's a great chapter
45:59Chuck Bryant: I love that chapter what else? kamikaze demolition derbies it's like stuff you should know in book form it is definitely and as we've said none of these are just like an entire podcast it's more like we took maybe the history of something or just one aspect of one of the things and kind of dove into it and fleshed it out like that So hopefully we'll be able to turn these into full-size podcast episodes one day. That's kind of our intent. But even if we don't, I think the book really covers them in an enjoyable way. Totally. Jack Kevorkian. That was a good one, too. Keeping Up with the Joneses.
46:37That's one of my favorite ones.
46:38Chuck Bryant: Yeah. There's like 27 just amazing chapters in there. Each one's better than the last. And then, astoundingly, it starts back over and somehow chapter one is better than chapter 27. But, you know, if you haven't bought it yet, I highly encourage you to. It makes a great gift, even if the person doesn't even know who we are. It's in the great tradition, I think, of the great bathroom readers. You can pick it up at any point in the book and read any chapter. And it's just a lot of fun. My daughter even likes it because of the pictures, and she loves looking at the back and going, there's you and Josh.
47:13I know.
47:14Chuck Bryant: It's very cute. It is cute. So one other thing I want to say is, like, we really appreciate you guys who have already pre-ordered the book or who will buy the book or who bought the audio book that's available to you. But if you can't, if you're like, I just don't have the money right now, or I don't feel like spending the money. I just like the podcast. That's fine too. Like we're not mad at you. But we appreciate the people who have supported us by buying the book. So thank you very much to everybody who has or will buy our book because that's very kind of you and it means a lot to us. And you can look forward to a kids version coming soon.
47:50Chuck Bryant: Yes. Right? Yeah, eventually we're taking the same 27 chapters and kidifying it, but without being patronizing. So yeah, that'll be a really cool book. Right. No, we're taking the swear words out. The chapter on Mezcal didn't make the cut in the kids book. I know. I think, I mean, I think this book is appropriate for kids as young as like probably 12 years old. It's not like it's dirty or anything. It might just be a little advance for younger kids, but we're going to make sure that the younger kids have their version too. Yes. It'll make every 12-year-old who reads the adult book really want Mezcal.
48:27So anyway, thanks to everyone who's bought it. It's called Stuff You Should Know, an incomplete compendium of mostly interesting things. You can get it wherever books are sold. Of course, we encourage you to buy from independent bookstores if you can to try and keep them in business.
48:39Chuck Bryant: Yep, for sure. I guess that's it, huh? That's it. Okay, well, thanks, everybody, for hearing us out about our book spiel. And if you bought the book or the audiobook, thank you. If you can't, again, we love you anyway. So don't worry about it. And if you want to get in touch with us, you can send us an email to stuffpodcast at iheartradio.com. Stuff You Should Know is a production of iHeartRadio. For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.
49:22That sound? That's pro squash. Some of the fastest rallies in sport played inches from the crowd. The National Squash League is back in full swing for season four. The sport is heading to the 2028 Olympics for the first time, and you can see it up close right now in a city near you. Watch every match for free on YouTube. Search National Squash League and hit subscribe or follow live updates on Instagram at nsl.sport.
50:12Morning team. I found a way to improve the plan. Check slide four. Get help with complex tasks with Copilot Cowork. Microsoft Copilot. Work lives on. Buick knows confidence changes how you move through the world. That's why Buick designs SUVs with striking style and was named the most dependable mass market brand by J.D. Power. From the head-turning Buick and Vista to the seven-passenger enclave. Experience the Buick SUV lineup at Buick.com. Buick. Exceptional by design. Puig received the fewest reported problems in its segment in the J.D. Power 2025-2026 U.S. vehicle dependability studies based on 2022-2023 models.
50:47For J.D. Power 2026 award information, visit jdpower.com slash awards. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.
Everyone knows who Frank Lloyd Wright is, but did you know there was a grisly massacre at his home in 1914? Find out all about it in this classic episode.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.