1. Podcasts
  2. Tailenders
  3. Emergency Podcast: Sandpapergate Returns!
Tailenders

11 Nov 2026 · 44m · 18 chapters

Episode artwork

Emergency Podcast: Sandpapergate Returns!

In short

Tailenders’ long-awaited crossover with Australian cricketers to revisit “Sandpapergate” (ball tampering) and its ongoing fallout, including recent claims tied to Usman Khawaja’s book and Cricket Australia’s continued denials.

Guests (backgrounds)

Sam Perry (“Pez”) and Ian Higgins (“Higo”), both former grade-cricket “Tailenders” guests/UK-based cricket figures; Jimmy Anderson (England fast bowler) joins via conversation; Usman Khawaja is discussed as the key figure whose chapter/book is driving renewed attention.

Key claims

2018 bans were imposed on David Warner (can’t captain again), Steve Smith (can’t captain for two years), and Cameron Bancroft (nine months) for ball tampering with sandpaper; the official line was only three people knew. The episode argues Cricket Australia and players have perpetuated the scandal via omission/denial, making it worse than the original tampering.

Notable examples

Port Elizabeth incident where sandpaper use allegedly helped reverse swing; Mitchell Starck/Cummins-era statements denying knowledge of foreign substances; comparisons to the Houston Astros sign-stealing scandal.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:25

Anticipation for the Crossover Episode

Hosts discuss the significance of the crossover episode ten years in the making.

“And then it's all fallen by the wayside.”
2:00

Welcoming Sam Perry and Ian Higgins

Hosts introduce guests Sam Perry and Ian Higgins, discussing cultural differences.

2:55

Explaining Sandpaper Gate

Discussion on the Sandpaper Gate scandal and its implications.

“Gens, thanks for having us I don't know why you want us on this week What's happened?”
4:53

Current Context of Sandpaper Gate

Exploration of recent developments related to Sandpaper Gate and its impact.

“So in 2018, Australia and Freeplay specifically were given lengthy bans for bringing Sandpaper onto the field for tampering the ball illegally.”
6:19

International Perspectives on the Scandal

The hosts discuss the broader implications and global interest in the scandal.

“did not know brackets about the way Bancroft was caught.”
7:46

Media Reactions and Public Perception

Reflection on media reactions to the scandal and its perception in Australia.

“We could only dream of a sandpaper gate situation in England, which everyone would care about as much anymore.”
9:10

Contradictions in Morality and Accountability

Hosts examine the conflicting moralities surrounding the players involved.

“I'm just this middle manager guy in Hammersmith in a jumper going on the BBC because they just wanted any Australian they could possibly get to just use as a human pinata to go, why are you guys such cheats?”
10:16

The Ongoing Legacy of Sandpaper Gate

Discussion of the long-lasting effects of the scandal on cricket.

“And there's all these other conflicting moralities in Australia about like the virtues of speaking up or the virtues of staying silent and going to the grave with things.”
14:00

The Web of Denial: Cricket Australia and Sandpapergate

Discussion about how Cricket Australia is handling the sandpaper scandal and the implications of denial.

“It's like, guys, just say, look, we knew they were using sandpaper, like the team was using sandpaper to doctor the ball.”
17:20

Cultural Impact and Reactions to Ball Tampering

Exploration of the cultural consequences of the ball tampering scandal and the reactions from players and fans.

“We all knew that it was farcical in some degree.”
Show all 18 chapters
21:04

Reflection on the Consequences of Sandpapergate

A deep dive into the long-term effects of the sandpaper scandal on players and the sport.

“it's a laugh that Faft de Plessis just had mints.”
28:00

The Impact of Sandpapergate on Players

Discussing the emotional and financial consequences of the sandpaper scandal on cricketers.

“He's getting photographed by himself in a bar, et cetera.”
29:50

Cricket Australia's Handling of Scandals

Exploring Cricket Australia's treatment of players following the sandpaper scandal.

“And we've talked about Jimmy specifically and his treatment and the Ben Stokes thing and Joe Root suddenly being captaining and all these things and Harry Brooke not being looked after and Ben Duckett being filmed.”
32:02

The Role of Bowlers in the Sandpaper Event

Analyzing the involvement and response of bowlers during the sandpaper incident.

“And I'm just talking to people behind the scenes, ITK Styles, Fabrizio Romano, people are saying that like Cricket Australia couldn't make the bowlers do what they wanted to do anyway.”
34:00

Usman Khawaja's Perspective

Examining Usman Khawaja's views on the sandpaper allegations and their implications.

“I'm not sure if it went the way that he thought it would go, which isn't to criticize him necessarily.”
36:28

Comparing Scandals: Astros and Sandpaper

Drawing parallels between the Astros cheating scandal and the sandpaper incident in cricket.

“He is held to a higher standard than lots of other players based on his heritage and his surname.”
38:30

Brian Devine's Controversial Ban

Discussing the unusual punishment of Brian Devine and implications for cricket governance.

“Can we talk about Brian Devine getting two years for clicking his fingers?”
42:00

Cricket Australia Leadership and England's Future

Discussing changes in Cricket Australia leadership and England's prospects in cricket.

“That includes what we've seen from Usman, and our position hasn't changed on that.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Tailenders, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30giving you the chance to experience the precision and performance of the grid on the open road. Cadillac V-Series, distinctive luxury performance, engineered to thrill. Discover the V-Series lineup at Cadillac.com. Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department, ever, so carve up turkey and spiral-cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high fructose corn syrup. Gourmet Thanksgiving flavours with the quality you want.

1:09Only at Whole Foods Market.

1:14Hello and welcome to Tailenders! Hello, thank you for having us on Tailenders, your weekly, loosely, cricket-based podcast. Sharky, please insert guitar sound here because you want me to hear it. Today is a very special episode. Ten years in the making. It has been ten years. We've had promise of this. And then it's all fallen by the wayside. There's a time difference. But there is no cultural difference. These two podcasts, I feel, are a lot. Well, there is and there isn't. There's quite a big... I think in the podcast world, these two podcasts are aligned spiritually, cosmically. This is the long-awaited Tailenders grade cricketer crossover episode.

1:58I'm delighted actually do you know what before we introduce you properly me and Fee were both just panicking because to call you by your full names feels like it feels like calling a teacher by their real names but if we use your nicknames your names that you use we can't do it because we're not Australian so please welcome Sam Perry and Ian Higgins aka Pez and Higo it doesn't work it's like me and phil were just going i was walking into the into the spare room i went what the f*** are you gonna say because it's like saying ned flanders yeah or like chandler from friends so here you go i had it two hours ago i had it just popped in my head do i call him ian

2:47is that what i'm gonna call him well we're here here you go pizzer welcome to tailenders Thank you so much for having us Gens, thanks for having us I don't know why you want us on this week What's happened? I don't know what's going on But no, honour and privilege I do notice that you took the S off Higos' nickname as well, Greg Which is something that I notice English people do a lot Which is probably the first cultural difference Yeah, but Higos or Higos Or I guess I could call you Higgs Botham um ryan higgs but i just think those anyway jimmy anderson's here say hi to jimmy hi jimmy anderson hey jimmy anderson good to see you again hello guys how are you business is booming let's just put it like that uh people are interested what we have to say for once it's only taken 10 years but yeah what do you guys want to talk about uh well this is i mean look actually that's that's the first thing i want to talk to you about is that we listen to great cricketer but i particularly find myself listening when australia are losing and i know that that is a running theme that is something that you you see the spikes you see you see where your listeners are you see that we all want to hear you sad hear you angry i was locked in to the dailies during the Bangladesh series.

4:13I was listening. You know what? I love them so much. I listened to them on 0.5 speed just to make sure that it was all going in. Same with South Africa. Same with the latest one about this sandpaper situation, which I cannot believe is still going. And I know that you've talked about it on your latest episode, But can you both give us a quick explainer for listeners who probably weren't even born when Sandpaper Gate first happened in 2018? It feels so long ago. So can you give us an explainer as to what happened then? Good luck. And then we'll talk about what happened now. All right. So in 2018, Australia and Freeplay specifically were given lengthy bans for bringing Sandpaper onto the field for tampering the ball illegally.

5:03That was David Warner, who was told he could never captain the Australian team again. Steve Smith, who was the captain at the time, received a one-year ban, also could not captain for two years. Cameron Bancroft, who was the man seen stuffing said sandpaper down the front of his trousers, received a nine-month ban. And the official word after the investigation was that only three people knew, and we all believed it. Only three people knew. And then somehow we are where we are now. Peasant Mubbie, you want to pick up where we are now? I just want to add in as a caveat that it's very clear that Australia only commenced doing this in South Africa and they had never ball-tampered prior to this, particularly in 2017-18 in that Ashes where they bowled really well, but that was all natural swing.

5:55so yeah and then and then today i don't know if anyone's heard but uzman kawaj has written a book and um and he has a chapter dedicated to sandpaper where he kind of gives uh oh it shines some sunlight onto how it all actually went down and in the subsequent days those who've benefited from their, you know, the punishments to three players have continued their line that they did not know brackets about the way Bancroft was caught. And I won't speak about anything else. So Cricket Australia and the players who still maybe have some truth to tell, insisting that they have nothing else to say. One of the biggest missed opportunities, this whole thing, I think, is that Uzi didn't print that bit of his book on sandpaper.

6:46Oh, lovely. It would have been, that chapter would have been so much better if it was on some rough surface. The other thing I want to quickly add is that when this went down, it was, you'd never seen anything like it, like a political scandal. Steve Smith wept in front of cameras. David Warner attempted to look like he was weeping in front of the cameras. And Bancroft had a similar situation as well. and they were hounded out of South Africa. So at the time from England, it was like, so we're always trying to sell cricket to people in England, right? And what I find is this is when people get interested in cricket, when it's nothing to do with the cricket, but you can sell them a scandal, a moralistic issue, and something that is kicking off that a lot of people care about elsewhere.

7:34So the interesting thing about Sandpaper Gate in Australia is that it sells cricket surviving to us in some ways because it's erupted so big over there. We could only dream of a sandpaper gate situation in England, which everyone would care about as much anymore. Do you know what I mean? There's a sentimentality to it with Atherton in the 90s with this sort of thing where the fading dream of test cricket, when back in the day that was as big as whatever it was, a politician doing X, Y or Z. still feels like that in Australia. So there's a kind of like, there's a fizz to it. Do you know what I mean?

8:14From all around the world, because it tells us, oh, cricket's a big deal still. It really gets back to the original principles of the game, which was for England to civilise other people and tell them how to behave. And so when you've got Australians misbehaving, that's the greatest way to sell the game. I mean, it could be an MI6 PSYOP, the whole thing. I was working in London at the time when sandpaper went down, like the exact time I was in a birthing class, an NCT in Clisold Park, and kept going to the bathroom to read the phone rather than learn how my child would be born. And I've never had – the great cricketer was only – it was a nascent thing at the time.

8:58I've never had more media requests in the UK than at that time. I was leaving my actual job because the BBC had sent a car to Hammersmith to take me to the studios. I'm just this middle manager guy in Hammersmith in a jumper going on the BBC because they just wanted any Australian they could possibly get to just use as a human pinata to go, why are you guys such cheats? And it was awesome, very happy to play along. But it's amazing that it continues. news i am staggered that cricket australia around these um you know let's just say the the bowlers have continued the line of like now just didn't just didn't really know no one's come forward and you're like oh sweet so we're going to perpetuate this sort of um these denials you know by omission and but like they they they're saying they don't know about it in the hope that it goes away but paradoxically that is the thing that's going to keep it going so yeah they're stuck and i can i mean i don't know i don't know for you guys is this bigger than man city just in terms of the fun um like like where's it ranking it's really interesting question because there's a there is a level of similarity with the thing that's people are talking about city is the lack of contrition that's the thing that people are really into but they're showing no contrition so the idea that these people that we would even associate as being good solid moral people the idea that they've secretly lied and thrown people under the bus the possibility of that do you know what i mean it's really it's so it's it we're all so confused here there are so many contradictions like like this morning the conservative newspaper the australian has um added david warner to a list of woke players like what what's woke sanctimonious So David Warner's in the gun in The Australian for being woke.

10:56That's where we're at at the moment. And there's all these other conflicting moralities in Australia about like the virtues of speaking up or the virtues of staying silent and going to the grave with things. It feels like the spirit of cricket conversation a little bit, like people will just bend it to suit whatever's in their particular interest at the time. Like Usman Khawaja and David Warner are friends. How does that work? But are they? Yeah, I think on the latest episode, you said that they are opposites. They are opposite people, but they seem to be odd cut. Warner seemed, he was like, finally, someone's saying what we're all thinking.

11:34Or finally, someone's blowing the lid on this thing. My whistleblower is Usman Khawaja. Who's going to ask Jimmy the first question and what is it going to be? What is the first question? I think you should ask Jimmy the first question, either of you too. I was going to actually make a point about the Man City thing. And I'm much more invested in this than the Man City stuff. yeah this is this is like great viewing for us english fans yeah but but if you get if you get shake mansoor crying in a press conference then i am watching the out of that don't worry about that you know what i mean but this is the thing all these things can happen and probably will happen and actually that's the main thing that i can't get my head around is i feel sad for Uzi because he's like a lovely man who we love on this podcast and he gets thrown under the bus all the time and has done his whole career and everyone's waiting for an excuse to have a go at Khawaja and this is another way of people having a go at him but also it's really funny it's and it's been funny for ages and it'll be funny long after we're all dead it's really funny it's yeah the those punishments if you look at them now in a post-covid world where we've got insane presidents and mad stuff.

12:49And those punishments are truly unhinged. They are batshit. If you look at it now in the cold light of day, those press conferences, which I watch quite often, they are ridiculous. But it seems like you want more of it. You want to flog yourselves again. You want to go there again? Because if you want to go there, I'm watching it. I mean... Sorry, I was going to ask a question to you two guys like it feels like cricket australia obviously tried to sort of bury it i think at the start and now that is coming to bite them on the arse is that do you think that's the case do you think it's like are they gonna see some sort of punishment like it was i think it's becoming quite clear by the way i've not jimmy jimmy i've not seen as animated as this for about seven, eight years.

13:46Ironically, what happened? This is it though. This is the good stuff. This is why we've got you on. I'd like to take this question from Jimmy Anderson to a former great cricketer. Thanks, Jimmy. You're not chirping when you're getting wickets now, Jimmy.

14:08so like there's this inception thing that went on where cricket australia punished a cover-up where smith and bancroft etc lied in the original press conference they punished a cover-up by erecting a cover-up and so they're continuing to perpetuate by skirting between raindrops and denying specific weird technical things rather than somebody just saying okay we knew about sandpaper we knew about it that it was a thing we were using did i know that bancroft went too far on the field and went against our plan no that was dumb Cameron and you should be punished for that but they now seem to be stuck in a web of omission and denial and I only reserve my own views on the basis that they haven't fully spoken yet perhaps there's an explanation so you have to give them a chance but the early kind of exit polls seem to be that they still want to dodge the raindrops and go, oh, I didn't know about this specific thing at this time.

15:19It's like, guys, just say, look, we knew they were using sandpaper, like the team was using sandpaper to doctor the ball. I reckon they'd have three or four days of everyone going, well, well, well, you know, Alan Brazil, Gabby Bonlahore, talk sport, it'd be a field day for a couple of days. I'll jump on, I'll be part of it. And then it would go away. But for some strange reason, they refuse to acknowledge any information or awareness of anything and that is what is making this ridiculous and fascinating Australia goes on with it because they're digging themselves a heart because they've gone too far now so there'll be lots of internal conversations happening as we speak about what do we do I saw um Mitch Stark's interview and like my my my thoughts when it came out eight and a half years ago where that there is no way a world-class bowler i'm looking at from my point of view you know batters we've seen what batters are like with their bats they're so anal about them they clean them they're polishing them in the corner like it's a trying to get a genie out of a lamp and as a bowler that is your bat that's your that's the only tool you've got to try and help your team win so when i when i played you know every bowler that i played with whether it it was Brodie, whether it was younger guys, they would be so anal about the ball.

16:45Like I want it to be in this condition so I can have the best chance of taking wickets. So the thought of a bowler getting the ball back, looking at it and going, oh, it's just, that's normal. I did have to scratch my head at the time. So then seeing Mitchell start, I guess it's too far gone now. It's eight and a half years. You can't now go, oh yeah, right. Like, you know, it's like, where do you go? I think the punishments were so severe that I think people around the world are scared to talk about anything now in fear of reprisal that happened again. And that's sort of adding to a bit of the confusion about what's happening in Australia because I think a lot of people are over this and we've sort of, everyone was happy with the, you know, the official version with the, you know, with the official report that came out.

17:34We all knew that it was farcical in some degree. But I feel like now that it's happening again, no one's actually accusing Osman of a lie. No one's actually saying like that didn't happen. People are just saying like, why are you doing that? Why are you saying this? Why are you doing this now? So the acceptance is there that this like, yeah, what he's saying is correct. But it's more like people are more playing the man, like this is a dog thing to do. You're putting your mates under the bus. he's stabbing him in the back, et cetera. Not that like what he's saying is factually incorrect. And I think like with the players now, they've got themselves in such a web that's so tangled up in it that there is fear that their careers might end early, that the suspensions might come back again.

18:19But, Jimmy, perhaps you might be able to help the entire world cricket and those who've participated in ball tampering. Maybe you could share with us how you guys tampered with the ball in 2017, 18. I mean, because everyone in Australia seems to be in agreement that the whole world was doing it. So perhaps in like collegiality, just for the world, how did you guys do it specifically? That is so brave of you, Pez. In what year? Go through the phases. Which one? Which era? Like the Beatles, like Suits era, just moving to the late 60s. Which type of tampering? I think we were pretty average at trying to do anything with the ball you know if we if we try to get the ball reversing we try and use the wicket ends and you know pretend we're throwing to the keeper and throw it on the half volley try and throw in the foals that's about as well well well you know as bad as I can remember it we've got all we need move in move in move in yeah go to jail Jim have you heard of this one because I was listening to um I've got to jail I was listen to a cricket out which is fantastic people should listen to that if you haven't which is a sort of sibling what you call it sibling podcast sibling entity of great cricketer anyway Gideon and Pete were talking about uh the old one they used to do is the quarter inch seam is you used to lift it up a little bit and it would reverse but it'd be easy to put back so when you gave it back to the umpire you'd sort of flatten the seam and they wouldn't detect anything have you heard of that one.

19:50Yeah, but that doesn't make the ball reverse. You need a lot more going on than that. That's a rubbish one. You literally have to get a knife down the quarter seam and try and like prise it apart. Oh, you've done that, have you? He's tried it. He's got the knife out. There were players who grew claws, weren't there?

20:12So you kind of had a knife for just like a natural one in the claw of your finger. Oh, I've just been nudged by Sharky. One second. In 2021, Cummins, Mitchell Stark, Josh Hazelwood and Nathan Lyon issued a joint statement saying they did not know that a foreign substance was taken onto the field. End of statement. Host Thanksgiving with industry leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever. So carve up turkey and spiral cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 brand. And guess what?

20:51All their delectable pies are made with no high fructose corn syrup. Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want. Only at Whole Foods Market. You were laughing on the latest episode about how South African cricket, it's a laugh that Faft de Plessis just had mints. like that's but this is the thing it's like i think looking back on it now who cares this is it was made so serious this is entirely a problem of cricket australia's making because now no no wants to be honest anymore because the careers are on the line and money's on the line and advertising deals are on the line because they're going oh i don't want to say we can't say anything because even if i did want to say so they probably do want to say yeah we knew about it but they can't because of this all all of this again so what what happens yeah i think i think the the first principles of how this all became a total disaster and a mess is it wasn't so much the tampering but it was the lies that came after and the cover-up worse than the crime kind of thing and there was a general feeling in australia that that particular team had gone completely off the rails um under darren lehman in terms of its conduct and in australia i think there was about 40 to 50 years of buildup in the country of disappointment and anger about how this team really played with an air of, you know, hostility and ugliness and a win at all costs attitude.

22:19And so this was like the straw that broke the camel's back. The fact that they lied about it and covered it up was the end of it. Not helped by the prime minister at the time, Malcolm Turnbull, who knew nothing about cricket waiting in as well. But what's disappointing is that it actually has, it feels like, I don't know how you guys say it from England, but from around that time, there has been some kind of a cultural reset in Australia, fronted by Cummins. The team conducts itself well. It still manages to win. There's this strange experiment where Australian teams win games of cricket without sledging the opposition too much.

22:50So it seemed like we were past it. But now in a great twist, one of the beneficiaries of silence in Cummins has become the face of the reset, but is he part of the conspiracy? Oh, that's a good story. But as Hugo says, I feel like Cricket Australia and the players who may have questions to answer, they've sort of got their fingers in the air. And I think the sense is that perhaps the public doesn't have that big an appetite to re-litigate this or to deal with the moral quandaries they're in. I think they're going to try and ride it out, you know, as you saw from Stark's comments yesterday as we go to air.

23:30and yeah, I think they're just going to hope that people are going to get over it and we're just going to play against New Zealand. We're going to sweep it under the rug. Let bygones be bygones. Sleeping dogs lie. Keep making money and you can all write your books as well and not make much money off that either. What insight with the players, Jim? Is there like a level of victory or anything? Lots of people feel the same, do you think, like on the circuit? Do you think players and staff would want them punished more? No, I don't think anyone cares. No one really cared that much at the time, I don't think, from an opposition point of view.

24:06Obviously, I think we had replayed them the year before, maybe 2021 would have been in Australia. and there were sort of you know question marks around that like I think it was Stark at Perth after a overnight downpour got the ball reversing so the outfield was wet and everything we're like this is a bit odd and he bowled that amazing ball to Vince that knocked off stump out the ground so there were sort of question marks and then obviously like from the outside we just thought yeah they've been punished probably rightly so they've been caught doing it but again there's also then questions i'm sure surely other people knew but it's so long ago now that i don't think anyone really is that fussed for you what you said earlier towards the start of the episode interested me that you think that this is sort of unique in that australian way that this is the biggest scandal but if you look about all the episodes we've done sort of over the last ashes the ben stoke stuff the endless nightclub like the nightclubs is our version of this going going going out and getting arrested this is this is the english version of it and that all of that was there were cover-ups again the harry brooke thing made everything way worse and they didn't say that he was in an altercation in that nightclub before why why don't these people get that actually we maybe i'm wrong but we just we actually just quite like watching cricket more and why are they, why do they not, I feel sort of let down by the ECB over the last few years because it just feels like they've just, we don't even know why Stokes is retired, really.

25:49I feel like we need to know why all this. And it's the same with the sandpaper things. I just, just be honest. We can all just get on with our lives because we're really busy and stressed and we just want to watch cricket because we really enjoyed the test series against South Africa, for example. Hugo, you were out there. The cricket is the best bit. This is funny. It's a sideshow, but the cricket is the best bit. Please, will somebody think of the cricket? I disagree. I think the soap opera is far more fascinating. Well, I guess I listen to your podcast more when you... I think what Peza said is right, though, about the buildup of sort of 50, 60 years of Australian aggression.

26:29And if your team is winning, then it's like, nah, we are the good guys. And then you just – I think probably a factor of getting a bit older as well and just zooming out of what this silly game actually is in your life. And you're like, it's actually embarrassing. And the Australian cricket team is such a bastion of – it's such an important part of Australian society. Like in terms of like what it means, like when Australian plays their test matches, it's your school holidays, it's your summer, it's your childhood, it's your relationship with your family. It's all these things intertwined. It's very – I know England have that as well.

27:02I suppose Australia have a little bit more with like Christmas as well, Christmas and New Year's. We had two Test matches where everyone's off work. You don't know what day of the week it is. I think that's also why we have such a great relationship with Test cricket as well. I think Australia and England probably are the last two bastions of that format. But what's interesting to me is that we all accept that the punishment for Sandpaper was ridiculous. And had they all just come out and accepted it, this would have been probably like a few-week thing back in 2018, which was a footnote in some of these players' careers.

27:37But what's probably worse, what's probably actually worse, which we don't seem to really care about, is that three guys had their lives absolutely, were severely, severely impacted. I wouldn't say destroyed necessarily. I'm sure it was extremely difficult in that period of time. They had their lives severely impacted for years. You know, they went all around the world and copped absolute abuse everywhere. They were followed in the streets. Steve Smith went to New York. He's getting photographed by himself in a bar, et cetera. It's extremely traumatic. And what, to me, might be a worse crime is that, like, there were at least eight, probably more like 20 other people that knew about this.

28:19And they were like, you're just going to have to cop for that, mate. Because, by the way, I'm going to get millions of dollars of endorsements. Now, I agree with Jimmy that so much of this is just in the past. And this is a thing that happened nearly a decade ago. And we all agree, Lance Armstrong style, that everyone was doing it. And Australia were just slightly better at it than others. And South Africa were better than Australia at it, but we didn't find out what they were doing. So, you know, it's this really complex thing where, yeah, it's really unfair that three guys. And by the way, Warner specifically, he would have lost tens of millions of dollars in endorsements.

28:52Now, I know you're not really supposed to care about millionaires losing millions of dollars, but I'm sure in a dressing room, that would be a factor, like how much money Steve Smith and Cameron Brankoff lost his contract eventually. He did come back into the side, but yeah, Warner was like, he was in so many commercials in Australia. Now, maybe that's just not, maybe that's not that important. But my overall point is that these guys' lives were so severely impacted. And if there was like 20 people plus that knew about what happened and those three guys took the fall for it and didn't say a word until this came out, you know, this past couple of days, that's pretty cooked, I reckon.

29:29But that's sort of what I'm getting at, which is this is sad for the fans because we're losing out watching these players and we don't want to watch our heroes go through this stuff. That's not nice. You want to see them getting, you know, beaten properly on the field. but you don't want to see them sort of suffering as humans. And also there's a duty that Cricket Australia and the ECB, we've talked to Jimmy about this, it doesn't feel like they're looking after the players well enough. They're throwing them under the bus. And we've talked about Jimmy specifically and his treatment and the Ben Stokes thing and Joe Root suddenly being captaining and all these things and Harry Brooke not being looked after and Ben Duckett being filmed.

30:07Yeah, and they're all cricketers, but they should be looked after and they feel as if they're not being looked after. I wondered if that was something that you were going to mention, Jim, because it just feels like, yeah, it's sort of funny that the sandpaper thing, but then you're right. It is sad that these guys have been dragged this much. I was just going to say, I think out of the three, Bancroft's the one who's probably been the most damaged. Warner and Smith went on to have successful careers internationally and at franchise and state level. Bancroft, yeah, got back in the side a little bit, but I feel like no one can tell whether he would have gone if that hadn't have happened.

30:43He'd have been a mainstay in Australia's top six, but he had a much worse chance after that because missing the cricket that he did. And then I think psychologically, it's got to do something to you. It's got to damage you. Even when you come back in the team, you're like, are people thinking about that? Are they going to be talking about that when I'm out in the middle batting? So I do feel for all of them, but particularly him, because I feel like he was the one who got thrown under the middle of a double-decker bus. He actually made 77 in the sandpaper test in the first innings, so could have been a turning point.

31:18I'm not sure what happened to him after that, but yeah. I mean, I think as well that Cricket Australia narrowed this investigation so much to ring-fence the punishments around three guys thinking that that would be sufficient for the public appetite. And at the time, it felt like it was too much, right? But they actually did a disservice to the rest of the team by kind of implicating them in silence over everything else that went on and it put the players in a bind. Now, there's a weird situation. I don't know what you think about this, Jimmy, but eight years later, the current Australian men's team, this is just my perspective, but it feels like the bowlers are almost the whole team and they're almost bigger than Cricket Australia in a lot of ways, maybe as business as they are.

32:02And I'm just talking to people behind the scenes, ITK Styles, Fabrizio Romano, people are saying that like Cricket Australia couldn't make the bowlers do what they wanted to do anyway. And the bowlers are kind of their own entity. And even if Cricket Australia advised them to simply say, look, we did know sandpaper was like a tool of implementation, even though we didn't know how Bancroft got caught, that the bowlers have too much power to, you know, to say it anyway, which is amazing because if you read Usman's book, and he did write a book, he actually lists, like he actually has this, you know, he's very careful not to say outright that the bowlers knew about sandpaper.

32:48It's deliberately vague, right? But he then also tells the story of the second test in Port Elizabeth, as it was then known, which is before Cape Town, this moment where they take sandpaper onto the field when the umpire drops the ball. Bancroft, you know, gives it such a going over that you can see swirl marks on the ball. And Australia take four for 28 with reverse swing. And at one point after a wicket in the huddle, one of the bowlers says, can we stop? It's going too well. And so I'm paraphrasing, right? And so if Usman's recollection, because we're talking about recollection now, but if his recollection of that story is right, But how did the bowlers say we didn't know?

33:32It's like, what? What do you mean? Like you were all laughing at how you were saying it was going too well, if anything. So they're really stuck at the moment. And I don't know if they're advising themselves to just, you know, is it Costanza style? It's not a lie if you believe it. Have they repeated it themselves so many times? Are we getting into this? I don't know. But it's farcical. It's ridiculous. and because they keep denying it will keep going that's the paradox of the whole thing yeah i think you i mean you two calling them for many years the cartel has not not helped things if they're now if they're if they're believing this i think this is this is part of the you're part of the problem i think you've been you know big time yeah they are they are that can we just talk about us before we let you go because i want to just get your take on why you think he's talked about this now and I'm not even probing down the he's trying to sell books because we all know that's not you know he's got more to lose really has he got a lot more to lose actually because he's you know he's always a principled man and he's always stood up for what he believes and he's always he's always fought those battles that he wants to fight and I love him for that but what's what do you think is going through his head now do you think he's slightly regretting that chapter I think it's blown up more than he expected.

34:56I'm not sure if it went the way that he thought it would go, which isn't to criticize him necessarily. This might seem like a bit bleeding heart, but I think that his intentions are primarily around justice and getting things off his chest. I think he's been pretty clear about that from the start. Those who questioned the timing, and that's from the person in the street through the, Elisa Healy said it was, the timing was stinky um i don't think you know this idea that like he had to be perfectly pure in the way he lifted the lid on this otherwise it's invalid is is also ridiculous i mean he's been clear usman that of course he wasn't going to do it while he was playing because it would have threatened his employment you know as simple as that i mean so many of us haven't said heaps about sandpaper because it probably threatened our employment we all swallowed the lie you know or the, you know, whatever it is, the denial to some extent.

35:52Of course, there's been a calculation from him that is partly based on looking after his employment and also ensuring that he's clear of it. And I think that's the thing as well. People get a bit riled about Osman because he does present as a little sanctimonious at times and maybe he is. He is impure in his own ways as well. But it's strange that we focus so much on that versus the substance of what he is actually saying. We don't want to see that. We're good in Australia at that, at not wanting to know things. And so that's the wrestle that's going on at the moment. He is held to a higher standard than lots of other players based on his heritage and his surname.

36:35And that is definitely true. he has to prove himself in lots of different ways and you know that's that's just that's just part of what's going on there as well i think but you're you're chatting to him on sunday on the next episode aren't you that's that's that is amazing i mean that is that is must listen that is box office what are you going to talk to him about uh i think he's i think he just bought a new yacht so he's want to know about that it's a super yacht he's parked in well actually in Sandpaper chapter, he does refer repeatedly to his troubles with reverse sweeping, Kesha Maharaj. So I just wanted to talk about the courage to employ that reverse sweep.

37:15Use the flat band instead of running his wrist over it. Do you guys know the Houston Astros baseball scandal? It's so interesting it happened exactly the same. Do you know about that, Jim? I told you about it. We spoke about that. You probably have. Roughly about 10 years ago, the Astros won about five pints in the astros wonder world series and when they look back at all the videos someone was banging a bin twice every time an astros hit had got a curve and they like went further and further into it and the whole organization from everyone that worked in the ground in the dugouts from the top the players everyone had brought in like this year we're going to cheat and we're going to have buzzers and things and every single time and we're going to like have cameras on the catcher doing the signs and the ball every time a curve gets thrown you're going to get a dong dong from the dugout so you know what it is and they were sensational that year at hitting curves and there's a famous footage of all two there he's running to win the world series and he's running to get home and he's just because they're about to mob him he's gesturing don't don't take my top off remember don't take the top off because they're like there was all the thing was they were all bugs but it's really interesting that it was it's very similar time to the australia sandpaper gate but the difference there is everyone decided we're all going to take everyone just went when they unveiled it the whole organization went we did it literally every single person from the offices to in the grounds everything just everyone just came clean probably would have gone away if everyone had just said we did it we're sorry that that was bad it would have gone away way quicker because you can't you can't rest 15 players and the backroom staff and, you know, what are you going to do?

39:01Can we talk about Brian Devine getting two years for clicking his fingers? Oh, my God. He's got a bigger punishment than all of them. That is wild. What, he's been banned? Two years. Yeah. They were banned for two years. Two years. Wow. Just a blood click in his fingers. The whole team should take responsibility and the wicketkeeper should write the book. Can we, you should ask Todd Greenberg what he thinks of that.

39:31Todd, would you investigate that? We're just flat out trying to get a day three in a test match in Australia. Can you book Brian Devine to chat to Khawaja? That's what we need. That's actually not a bad shout. I think we can reveal exclusively on Tailenders because this came through this morning, But some might know that when this first went down, we were in touch with his club and said that we would be happy to fund his legal costs. And also we got in touch with the league to say that we'll also fund training for bad umpires. And we heard nothing out of it, disappointingly. But overnight, we believe we received correspondence from Mr.

40:16Devine saying that he's happy to chat. No way. Sorry, your client, Mr. Devine. He'll be referred to as Mr. Devine from here on. So that's to stay tuned as well. We're very grateful for all of these opportunities that come up as a result of experiences playing, you know, in the hotbed of grade cricket in Sydney in the mid-2000s. But, yeah, we have Usman on Sunday and if it is Brian Devine, hopefully it's not, that would be funnier. That would be funnier. He's funny. We will endeavor to speak to him too. Oh my God. What a mad. You're right, Higo. It is embarrassing that we like cricket. I think it is.

41:03It is the most embarrassing. It might be the most embarrassing thing in the world. I'm too deep now. I'm in too deep now. I can't change. We've been doing this for 10 years. How long have you been doing grade for now? 10 years. Right. It's too late. this is what is it sunk cost fallacy we're just going we're going now we keep going

41:28hey on the subject of todd greenberg he released a statement yesterday just to say we don't see any compelling reason what's his voice like give me his voice i'll try and do it what is it what's his accent uh we uh is it yeah not bad not bad yeah yeah it's pretty tight we We don't see any compelling reason to open the investigation or revisit this again. We have said we're comfortable with the outcome of the investigation based on the information we've received. That includes what we've seen from Usman, and our position hasn't changed on that. It's important to know that back at that time, players were urged to come forward, and they had the opportunity to do so over these past eight years, and that remains the case.

42:14There you go. Just to cover it off, Sharkey. Russell Crowe is the, is the CEO of Cricket Australia. Yeah, he's, might as well be. Yeah. Wow. Just actually, maybe the, just switch, just shuffle the deck. Brian Devine to be in charge of Cricket Australia from now on, because he's got a couple of years to really build something beautiful. That's insane. Um, I, um, we've loved having you on. Thanks so much for, um, for, for chatting to us. that finally the great cricketer tailenders collaboration happened. Can we make this happen again? Because look, our paths will cross. I mean, probably literally you'll be over here next summer.

42:58I hope we should do some stuff. But this does, this does really swing things in England's favor, all this. It's really good. A Bangladesh, the Bangladesh thing, the South Africa thing, this thing. it's you know england looking kind of boring and stable again a little bit maybe could be could be a spicy march could be a great ashes oh everything everything is coming up england yeah england are winning the ashes yeah i mean if you can't do it from here that's very problematic because you're not a clown show anymore um we are now the clown show we're the clown show it only takes it only takes one clown it only takes one yeah but you've got a you've got a like a normal professional man as the coach now.

43:45And same with the captain. And we're old and falling apart. We're fraying at the seams. It's time, isn't it? Yeah, but we said that last winter. And they bring Jimmy out of retirement and they say, Jimmy, do you want to hit the winning runs in a test match for the first time? And he'll say, I'm 44, yes. let me have it England win 5-0 Australia employed on themselves we moved to New Zealand New Zealand become worse but our rugby is good so

44:28Peza here you go thank you so much for being on Tailenders we have loved it and we will we'll catch up with you very soon and a massive Tailenders go well cheers Cheers. Thanks, boys.

44:43For more than a decade, British boxing has been shaped by two men. The crushing lip from Titan Fury. Oh, what a win up a good from Anthony Joshua. Two completely different personalities, two extraordinary careers, and one fight that just won't go away. There has never been a fight like this in the history of British boxing. Never. This is the story of how we got here. And how the AJ Fury rivalry redefined boxing forever. This will split the country. Half Fury fans, half AJ fans. Five Live Boxing, Fury v Joshua. Listen on BBC Sounds.

45:29Welcome to the Haunted Library. Join me, Colin Morgan, as I read Frankenstein by Mary Shelley. A story of science and ambition, loneliness and longing, and what it truly means to be human. Listen to The Haunted Library wherever you get your podcasts, or find us on YouTube.

From the publisher

Sandpapergate is BACK! And with it the first ever Tailenders-Grade Cricketer crossover episode, with Ian "Higgos' Higgins and Sam "Pez" Perry dialling in from their podcast Down Under.

Why is this scandal making a comeback eight years later? Is David Warner now woke? Does clicking your fingers deserve a bigger punishment than ball tampering, and is all of this good news for England in the Ashes?

More from Tailenders

All episodes