1. Podcasts
  2. Tech Life
  3. Journalists silenced online
Tech Life

3 Nov 2026 · 27m · 12 chapters

Episode artwork

Journalists silenced online

In short

How tech platforms’ copyright tools are allegedly abused to silence independent journalism online; plus rail-safety tech and a Tolkien-in-tech segment.

Guests/backgrounds

Imran Raman-Jones (BBC Tech Life reporter). Ollie (Instagram creator targeted via fake copyright claims). Zakaria (listener reporting similar abuse in Somalia). Abdallah Mumin (Somali Journalist Syndicate secretary general; kidnapped and jailed in 2022 for advocating media freedom; now in exile in Nairobi). Marika Dudunia (Studio Monitor investigative journalist in Georgia). Ian Jeffries (Association of American Railroads CEO). Chris Valance (Tech Life presenter and Tolkien fan). Ludwig Wicke (founder/conductor, 21st Century Symphony Orchestra).

Key claims

Fraudulent copyright strikes are used to suspend accounts and delete critical reporting; platforms sometimes reinstate after detecting abuse but don’t explain initial suspensions.

Notable examples

Somalia—~30 documented takedowns; Abdallah imprisoned; alleged attackers paid (e.g., $5,000; $700–$1,500). Georgia—Studio Monitor YouTube channel hit by three strikes; a claimant solicited payment; Georgian ruling-party figures amplified the takedown. Rail—AI/wayside sensors and inspection portals; grade-crossing tech and apps for first responders. Tolkien—tech firms named after Middle-earth (e.g., Palantir, Sauron).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:30

The Impact of Tech on Journalism

Discussion on how tech platforms stifle independent journalism and public access to information.

“Listen on bbc.com or wherever you get your podcasts.”
2:10

Case Study: Copyright Abuse in Somalia

Examination of copyright exploitation in Somalia, targeting independent journalists.

“Instagram users were being targeted with fake claims of copyright which would suspend their accounts.”
4:55

Consequences of Silencing Journalists

Discussion on the dangers faced by journalists in Somalia and the implications for public information.

“And what we have seen is that particularly the news content that has been removed, that is critical to the government authorities.”
7:20

Georgia's Struggle with Press Freedom

Exploring similar issues faced by journalists in Georgia, including misuse of copyright strikes.

“And they are often critical of the government.”
9:48

Tech Platforms' Responses

Review of responses from tech platforms regarding the abuse of their reporting systems.

“But then they did reinstate them after detecting abuse of their system.”
10:46

Transition to Rail Industry Innovations

Shift to discussing the technological advancements in the US rail industry.

“And a reminder, this story came from one of our Tech Life listeners.”
12:04

AI and Safety in Railroads

Exploration of AI technologies used in railroads to enhance safety and prevent accidents.

“the US is preparing to celebrate 200 years of its rail industry next year, but its freight operators are looking forward as well as back.”
14:00

Innovations in Railway Safety Technology

Exploring new technologies to enhance railway safety and prevent incidents.

“One, we've expanded the network of wayside detection that's measuring wheel health.”
17:04

Tolkien's Influence on Tech Culture

Discussing the intersection of Tolkien's works and modern technology companies.

“But first, it turns out there's quite a fellowship of Tolkien fans in the technology world.”
20:51

Tolkien's Views on Technology

Reflecting on Tolkien's perspectives regarding technology and its impact on humanity.

“And I think it's really interesting to reflect on what he might have made of all these tech businesses.”
Show all 12 chapters
21:57

Conducting Live Orchestra with Film

Exploring the challenges and techniques of synchronizing a live orchestra to a film.

“Now, bringing Middle Earth to the concert hall requires some technical wizardry of its own.”
28:17

Exploring Ideas in 'In Our Time'

Discover the themes and interesting questions presented in 'In Our Time'.

“In Our Time is a world-class seminar every week.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Tech Life, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30time. Listen on bbc.com or wherever you get your podcasts. Tea or coffee? Love a cup of tea. Welcome to Tech Life on the BBC World Service with me, Shona McCallum. Today, what happens when independent journalism is stifled using tech platforms' own reporting tools? People are losing access to important information. They are not getting the opportunity to hold powerful authorities accountable for what's happening in the country. Then, as the US railroads approach their 200th birthday, we look at some of the modern tech which helps keep them safe. An inspection portal almost looks like a tent that a train will run through.

1:14And it has hundreds of cameras and other sensors on it. And it detects every aspect of a train. And the Lord of the Rings, a hundred-piece orchestra, brings Middle Earth to life every night. playing the score for The Fellowship of the Ring in sync with the film. When he stands on the floor with the feet, he makes duck and I have to be exactly on that beat. And then I meant, I'm too late. And then I realised, oh, my movie is a little bit, one frame is enough from these 25 frames. I feel that in a movie.

2:09We're starting today with an update to a story we covered a couple of months ago about extortion on social media. Instagram users were being targeted with fake claims of copyright which would suspend their accounts. Then they were being charged ransoms to remove the claims and reinstate their accounts. Here's Ollie, one of the creators, who was targeted. All the takedowns will be from the same email. So either they own every piece of content on the platform or it's a sign of exploitation that somehow the system doesn't detect. That story was reported by TechLive's Imran Raman-Jones and he's here with me now.

2:47Imran, Ollie got his account back, but that wasn't the end of the story. No, so after that went out on TechLive, Another listener, Zakaria, got in touch from Somalia, saying a similar thing was going on with independent media outlets there. He wrote to us on WhatsApp saying, fraudulent copyright strikes and fake takedown claims are being weaponised on social platforms to silence independent journalists, delete reporting and censor news outlets. And it turns out that I was looking into a similar story in another part of the world, which we'll get to in a bit. So let's start with Somalia. What did you find there?

3:23The situation there is unstable with Somalia in a civil war since the early 1990s. And there are lots of rival factions, which include the government, militias, local groups and pirates. At the same time, the freedom of the press is severely restricted and it can be very dangerous to report there. I got in touch with Abdallah Mumin, Secretary General for the SJS, the Somali journalist syndicate, which is a collection of independent journalists. And his story shows some of the danger journalists face. In 2022, October, I have been kidnapped and then put in prison. And then I've been put on trial just for advocating for media freedom in my country, Somalia.

4:10And I'm not the only one. Abdallah now lives in Nairobi in Kenya. Effectively, he's an exile as a result of some of his reporting. And as well as physical attacks there, there are attacks on independent journalists' ability to get information out to readers in Somalia. And SJS has documented around 30 examples of tech platforms' reporting mechanisms being used to take down posts or suspend journalist accounts, including using copyright claims. When we emailed Meta recently, we found that they have restated these accountants and they have never explained why on earth in the first place that these accountants were suspended.

4:54They never explained to us. And what we have seen is that particularly the news content that has been removed, that is critical to the government authorities. Yes. It's also worth saying Facebook is really important to a lot of journalists in Somalia because, well, it's used by a large chunk of the population, but also a lot of the journalists can't afford to run their own websites and Facebook is free to use, but it also offers the chance of monetisation, which can be a source of income to some of these reporters. So you can see why journalists want to publish there. Yeah. And also because it's used so widely, it's where journalists often contact their sources as well to speak to for stories.

5:36Plus there's the public interest argument. Here's Abdallah Moomin again. When independent media loses access to their primary publishing platforms, the Somali public in general is the one to suffer. People are losing access to important information. They are not getting the opportunity to hold powerful authorities accountable for what's happening in the country. What do we know about who are actually making these fake copyright strikes against the journalists? From what we know, they are usually based in South Asia, and they're paid by other people to make these strikes. So the SJS found one who charged 5 ,000 US dollars for an attack against a media organisation.

6:23And then there was also another person they managed to get in touch with who had a Bangladeshi phone number. He was writing messages to some of the local journalists who were also providing information to us. And what we saw is that he was claiming that he was the one who was behind to attack the journalist's account. And he was soliciting for payment between 700 USD to 1 ,500 USD in return for stopping the attack. Abdallah and his colleagues suspect the Somali government is paying the people behind these attacks. but we can't independently verify this. I did ask their Ministry of Information about this, but I haven't heard back.

7:06So that's Somalia. What else have you found? OK, so let's move to Georgia in Europe, which is another country with quite restricted press freedom. And there's an investigative news outlet there called Studio Monetary, which covers politics, corruption, organised crime and things like that. And they are often critical of the government. And a similar thing happened with some of their stories on YouTube, where copyright strikes were used to take down their content. And this is Marika Dudunia from Studio Monetary. YouTube told us that we had one option, which was we can write to a person who wrote that complaint.

7:46And we are 100 % sure that those people had nothing to do with anything, with copyright. They were just people who were hired. Of course, this is a group of investigative journalists, so they wanted to investigate. And they started chatting to the person who was making those copyright claims. They first posed as a potential customer and then they admitted who they were. He wanted me to pay him money so he can take back his complaint and YouTube can restore our channel. He said, I work in a group, but he didn't tell me how many people are in that group. he said like yes I am from India do you have any problems I was like no I don't I just wanted to ask you like from where you are and then he told me that there are other groups as well but we are the most powerful.

8:39So a similar question to the Somalia case then who is paying these people to do this? Again we don't know for sure but some people do benefit from this so Marika says there There were some government-friendly media outlets and even actually a politician from the ruling party who was posting online about the takedown of Studio Monetary. They said it showed the tech platforms judged Monetary's output to be untrustworthy. But of course, this was not a judgment from the tech companies. It was just a response from the outlet being hit by these fake claims. Whole propaganda was very happy. So it was a good example for us.

9:17Like we really saw that day who wanted us to be silent. And again, we did ask the Georgian government for their response to this story, but haven't heard back from them. But you can see how both those cases in Georgia and Somalia are very similar in both stories. The tech platforms are really important for getting out independent news, but their systems can be misused as well to suppress that kind of reporting. And have the tech companies said anything about this? Yeah, so YouTube said they took down the monitory videos because they got three copyright strikes. But then they did reinstate them after detecting abuse of their system.

9:57And they sent us this statement. We work hard to strike a balance between providing easy to use tools for reporting copyright issues and protecting creators, viewers and copyright holders from abuse of our tools. When content is rankfully removed, we act quickly to restore the affected channel or video. And here's the statement Meta sent us. We have reviewed the accounts shared with us and restored those that were removed in error, and we are looking into the wider set of accounts flagged in this report. Meta takes any abuse of its reporting channel seriously and is constantly strengthening its defences against bad actors.

10:35When we are informed of content or an account that was removed due to a fraudulent report, Meta always seeks to reinstate the content or account quickly. Really interesting stuff. Thanks Imran. And a reminder, this story came from one of our Tech Life listeners. If you want to tell us what's going on where you are, send us a WhatsApp. It's plus 44 330 1230 320. Or you can email us on techlife at bbc.co.uk. In Our Time is a world-class seminar every week. Why was Jeremy a lonely snail? What were lines doing in York in the third century? I'm Misha Glennie and every week I'm joined by expert guests to explore the ideas that shape our world.

11:19It's one of the first times really that you consistently see someone painting teeth. I know that sounds bonkers. If I was going to define mathematics, I would say it's the study of structure. In our time, listen on bbc.com or wherever you get your podcasts. Tea or coffee? Love a cup of tea.

11:54You're listening to Tech Life on the BBC World Service with me, Shona McCallum. That's our cue to bores our next story. the US is preparing to celebrate 200 years of its rail industry next year, but its freight operators are looking forward as well as back. They're using technology, including artificial intelligence, to help spot faults before they cause accidents. The Association of American Railroads says 2025 was a record-breaking year for freight rail safety and that tech has played a part. Ian Jeffries is its president and chief executive. He began our conversation by describing an AI inspection portal, which checks trains as they pass through.

12:39An inspection portal almost looks like a tent that a train will run through. And it has hundreds of cameras and other sensors on it. And it detects every aspect of a train as it goes through reams of data, reams of pictures. It listens. It's listening to the wheels. It's taking pictures of wheels to identify potential anomalies, things that could become cracks, things that could signal risk of failure. And then it's feeding that into a larger back end system. Now, I was reading about in February 2023 in Ohio where there was a Norfolk Southern freight train that derailed. Investigators now say the accident was preventable and that there were several sign and signs, warning signs before the crash in East Palestine, Ohio, which spilled toxic chemicals into the area.

13:34And 38 wagons came off the track. Residents were evacuated. Investigators are focusing on an overheated wheel bearing on the train's 23rd car. According to the report, defect detectors placed along the tracks recorded three separate increased temperature readings before the disaster. I'm just wondering, you know, what has changed since that point in time? We've taken pretty dramatic steps forward over the past three and a half years. One, we've expanded the network of wayside detection that's measuring wheel health. Two, we've expanded broader inspection portals that are measuring the entire train health as they're going through.

14:16Three, we are now able to use AI to help drive those analytics that identify attributes that may signal potential failure earlier. And we've reduced thresholds as an industry to when trains need to be stopped based on wheel bearing heat. On the response side, a first responder in the US has the opportunity to have an app on his or her cellular device that when a train goes by, you enter the car number of one car on a train and it'll tell you everything in the train, how to respond if there's an incident, whether or not there's hazmat and who to contact if there is an incident. So what tech solutions could prevent collisions where roads cross railway lines?

15:03And if a vehicle gets stuck on a crossing, can tech detect it early enough to prevent a train approaching? So grade crossing safety is probably the biggest safety challenge we have in this industry. I think right now there are about 2 ,000 people killed a year on the railroad, and that is almost entirely at grade crossing collisions or with people trespassing on the track. It's about having the best technology and systems at existing crossings, but also warning systems as well. So many of us use Apple Maps or Google Maps, working with tech providers to really drive awareness that you're approaching a grade crossing or a grade crossing might be blocked via mobile technology tools for the driver.

15:48We've also approached autonomous automobile manufacturers and developers about can the automobile detect and not allow a driver to proceed unless the crossing is clear. For railways elsewhere in the world, then, including countries with a lot smaller budgets than the U.S., how affordable and practical is introducing more technology into the railroads? I think that's where shared knowledge is so key and research and development, sharing best practices, sharing what we're finding with other practice leaders around the world. And so our R &D folks, very involved in the international community, sharing best practices, sharing lessons learned, sharing research, because at the end of the day, it's a joint effort.

16:39Thanks to Ian Jeffries, the head of the Association of American Railroads.

16:52From rail tracks to sound tracks now. In a moment, we'll hear how a full orchestra brings Middle Earth to life, playing Howard Shore's score for the Fellowship of the Ring in sync with the film. But first, it turns out there's quite a fellowship of Tolkien fans in the technology world. TechLife's other presenter and Tolkien enthusiast Chris Valance is here. Hi, Shona. Yes, guilty as charged. I'm embarrassed to say how many times I've read those books, but I absolutely love them. It's nice to talk to you about Lord of the Rings, a shared passion of ours. And we're talking hobbits, elves, wizards.

17:26So where does Silicon Valley come into all of this? Well, this is the amazing thing. I mean, I doubt J.R.R. Tolkien, the author of The Lord of the Rings, The Hobbit, this man who was a World War I veteran, the former Rawlinson and Bosworth professor of Anglo-Saxon, I doubt he could have seen. that there was going to be a mania for naming tech firms after things in his books. But there are lots of tech firms. I mean, we'll start with one of the best known, Palantir, the controversial data analytics firm. It takes its name from the seeing stones, the Palantiri in the books. These would enable you to see far off places and things.

18:08And it's kind of an interesting thing for a company like Palantir, whose business is, in a sense, pulling together lots of data and analysing it and identifying things. And has been involved in targeting in the war in Iran and the war in Ukraine. You know, to have that idea of sort of seeing things far off is quite interesting. You've been to Palantir, haven't you, Chris? Yeah, in the interest of journalism, I should say. I wasn't just going there for sightseeing. But it is interesting because I went into their offices and when I began the interview with the UK boss of Palantir, I sort of said, you know, I think I asked him about the rooms and were they all named after Lord of the Rings?

18:52And he said, yes, yes, they are. Yes, they are. And I think the room opposite was Grey Havens. And then he sort of said, this one isn't, though. It's called Weathertop. and then I had to sort of admit that I was such a nerd about the books and liked it so much that Weathertop actually features quite prominently in the books. The chair of Palantir's board is Peter Thiel. He's one of the co-founders. He also is behind Mithril Capital. Mithril is another name from the books. That's the metal coveted by elves and dwarves, silvery, incredibly hard. It saves Frodo's life in The Lord of the Rings. And there are a couple of other mithrals as well.

19:32There's a mithral that's a kind of cloud company. And there's also Mithral Medicine, a biotech company that was acquired by Anthropic that works on treatment for muscular dystrophy. So there we are, we've got those. And then there's Andural Industries. Andural is Aragon's sword. And Andural Industries is a defence contractor. And the interesting thing is in the invented elven language of Quenya, and Ural means flame of the west. So that's quite a loaded name for a defence company, isn't it? And then this is the pick of the bunch. This is the one I really like. There is a company called Sauron.

20:12Sauron is the villain of the piece, if you like. He's the Dark Lord. And this company is described by TechCrunch as a military-grade home security system for tech elites. So you've got your home surveillance system named after the Dark Lord, the unblinking eye, the lidless eye. It's quite a name for a surveillance company. Yes, the all-seeing eye of Sauron. And what about Tolkien himself? It was quite a journey from the Oxford colleges where he worked to the offices of Silicon Valley. Yes, it is. And I think it's really interesting to reflect on what he might have made of all these tech businesses.

20:59You can read his books and you can see a real love of nature. And you can also see a certain amount of hostility, if you like, to the mechanized world. And, you know, that's understandable, isn't it? You can maybe say that he went through the mechanized slaughter of the First World War. And in his books, he explicitly says that he is concerned about machines. And he sees the ring as a kind of like a machine for control of other people. And ultimately, that machines will control their users too. Which, you know, as we get into the age of AI, that sort of idea, perhaps it becomes more resonant. And also I think anybody who's ever been unable to put their phone down, sort of addicted to it, will sort of maybe see some uncomfortable parallels with the way the ring has a grip on characters in the book.

21:54Absolutely, just draws you back in. Right, thanks Chris. Now, bringing Middle Earth to the concert hall requires some technical wizardry of its own. How do you keep a live orchestra perfectly in time with a film through every epic battle, furious chase, and even in those very quiet moments. Well, Ludwig Wicke is the founder and conductor of the 21st Century Symphony Orchestra. He's been conducting live film performances around the world for almost 20 years. He began by explaining what makes the experience different from watching the film in the cinema. The orchestral life is a little bit more prominent, but you still can hear the text and the speeches and everything in the movie but the music is more in front of you and I think all this to see 90 piece orchestra, 100 singers that's such a gorgeous experience I think it's a new way to see the movie So take us to your conductor's podium then what's in the screen in front of you and how does it tell you where you need to be in the music?

23:07I have a conductor video and this is created by Howard Schor's team and me and we decided to have a flash on every downbeat, on every bar so I know always I feel with my eyes I'm correct but I'm not stressed to be on every beat like if I would have a click in my ear. And then I have streamers. The streamers is a green one. It says to me, now the music should start. And the red one says the movement is finished. That helps me a little bit for the orientation. Of course, I know the score very well. So it's only a safety. So tell me about the musicians then. Are they receiving electronic timing cues themselves or is everyone synchronised because they're following you?

24:08They follow me and I can shape the music. I don't have to act like a machine. I can shape the music. I can speed a little bit. I can take it back a little bit. Like a live performance of a symphony. And the musicians follow me and that works very fine. Also the choir, the soloist, everybody. If you do get ahead of the film or you fall behind, how do you bring it back without anyone noticing? That's a good question. That happened in the beginning more. Not now, I'm quite good trained with that. But when I get behind or when I miss something, that happens, I'm a human. So I'm experienced to speed up very slowly the orchestra and the choir and everybody.

24:58But that happens very rarely. Has there ever been any tech fails during a performance? At the beginning, yes. We had many times the conductor video struggled, started shattering, started to go black. I had every experience. That was very stressful sometimes. Now they play it from digital, from a hard drive. The time when we started, it was a tape. We realized sometimes that the conductor video was a little bit slower than the movie. I realized that when I give a cue and there are special things I know exactly to hit when he stands on the floor with the feet and makes check. And I have to be exactly on that beat.

25:49And then I meant I'm too late. And then I realized, oh, my movie is a little bit. One frame is enough. from these 25 frames. I feel that in a movie. What's your favourite bit of the soundtrack, just out of interest? There are many. But one of the most beautiful moments is Moria, when they come to the big hall. The music is gorgeous there. It's wild and sound, sound full, full orchestra. That's one of the most beautiful plays. and what I also love is Gandalf's Fall. That's a very tender sound of a man's choir and about that is a high soprano singing first, like crying and then the children, boys' choir come in with the same line.

26:43That's also very beautiful. Obviously when people go to a concert, quite often they'll applaud the music. Do you find people applauding during this performance? It's that cultural difference. It depends on which country you are. In New York, they applaud every actor who arrives on the screen. There are countries, nobody applauds. But at the end, it's always a big applause. I think for many classical musicians, it's a very great new experience. it's much much more energy than most of the classical concerts the people are really very happy and they they show you that with applause it's always a big applause and that was Ludwig Wicke he's the founder and conductor of the 21st century symphony orchestra

27:42well we've reached Mount Doom and we're waiting on some giant eagles to take us back to the shire Remember, you can get in touch with us, email techlife at bbc.co.uk or you can WhatsApp us on plus 44 330 1230 320. Today's Tech Life was produced by Imran Raman-Jones and presented by me, Shona McCallum.

28:17In Our Time is a world-class seminar every week. Why was Jeremy a lonely snail? What were lines doing in York in the third century? I'm Misha Glennie and every week I'm joined by expert guests to explore the ideas that shape our world. It's one of the first times really that you consistently see someone painting teeth. I know that sounds bonkers. If I was going to define mathematics, I would say it's the study of structure. In our time. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts. Tea or coffee? Love a cup of tea.

From the publisher

Independent journalists around the world are falling victim to fake copyright strikes against their content on social media, especially when their stories are critical of powerful figures. Then we look at how AI has been brought into safety on US railroads. Plus, the tech which helps a live orchestra keep in time with screenings of Lord of the Rings.

Presenter: Shiona McCallum Producer: Imran Rahman-Jones

(Image: Silhouette of a man on a phone in front of a large window. Credit: Getty Images.)

More from Tech Life

All episodes