


TechLife episode covers three tech stories: (1) the “man who saved the internet” during the PHP security crisis, using a Jenga metaphor about foundational code; (2) listener Q&A on the UK national supercomputer at the University of Edinburgh, including heat reuse, renewable power, what happens to Archer 2 users, and immersion cooling; (3) comedian Olga Nehmer’s dispute over synthetic-AI women deepfaking her jokes and driving huge views.
Louis Irwin-Jones, COO at yourhippo.com (online training for ~250,000 care-home staff); Andre Suri, PHP project volunteer in the Czech Republic who packages PHP security fixes into binary releases; Professor Mark Parsons, Director of EPCT, National Supercomputer Centre, University of Edinburgh; Olga Nehmer, New York Comedy Club comedian whose material was used by AI accounts.
PHP underpins ~70% of the internet; sites like Wikipedia/Amazon/WordPress took precautions; Andre’s packaging bottleneck delayed fixes; rogue actors could exploit leaked vulnerabilities; Archer 2 will be replaced by a more power-hungry but fully renewable system; heat pumps and water-loop projects may reuse heat; immersion cooling is efficient but has vendor warranty limits; AI joke theft sexualizes content and redirects followers to OnlyFans.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion about the PHP programming language and its significance to the internet.
“Code, computing and comedy are on today's set list.”
Exploration of the potential impacts of the PHP vulnerability on the web.
“Governments, businesses and organisations around the world are scrambling to prevent possible cyber attacks after a major security flaw was discovered in a programming language behind much of the internet.”
Interview with Louis Irwin about his company's response to the PHP issues.
“Yes, Chris, a lot of people will never have heard of it before last week.”
Insight into Andrei Suri's role in addressing the PHP vulnerability.
“I mean, that's kind of an interesting thing, isn't it?”
Discussion on the importance of maintaining internet infrastructure and community support.
“that had caused such enormous disruption.”
Insights into the role of AI in both identifying vulnerabilities and potential attacks.
“So was there anything else you wanted to add?”
Learn about the focus on the UK national supercomputer and listener interactions.
“is just about to fall out if there's nobody there to hold the tower up.”
Hear insights from Imran about the supercomputer's role in scientific research.
“A few weeks ago, Tech Life's Imran Rahman-Jones reported on the UK's national supercomputer, hosted at the University of Edinburgh.”
Mark Parsons discusses how supercomputers manage heat and its reuse.
“I'm the Director of EPCT, the National Supercomputer Centre at the University of Edinburgh.”
Understanding the power consumption of the new supercomputer and its reliance on renewables.
“using ground source heat pumps, but that's much more of a research project.”
Insights into what happens to older supercomputers once they are decommissioned.
“science will continue one way or another.”
Exploration of immersion cooling as an alternative to traditional cooling methods.
“I mean, the other thing is you actually pay less at the start because the vendor will calculate how much it's worth at the end of the five year contract.”
Final insights from Mark Parsons on supercomputing and listener engagement.
“it is an efficient way of doing it, much more efficient than air cooling, for example.”
Hosts invite listeners to engage and share their thoughts on technology.
“questions and if you want to ask us anything about what you hear on the show or you just want to tell us about some interesting tech in your life, you can email or WhatsApp us.”
Discussion on AI-generated content taking from comedians and its implications.
“Olga Neymar is one of the comedians whose jokes were appropriated by the bots.”
Hear about Meta's stance on AI content and the challenges of moderation.
“I could only speak, I guess, for myself, but I love comedy because I thought it's a place where, like, it doesn't matter what you look like.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Tech Life, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Get more with BBC podcasts wherever you listen. Be the first to listen to your favourite shows like Evil Genius, Good Bad Billionaire and You're Dead to Me with a subscription to BBC Podcasts Premium on Apple Podcasts. You can also enjoy a range of our podcasts ad-free with an Amazon Music subscription.
0:26Welcome to TechLife, the programme about how technology affects all our lives, all around the world. Code, computing and comedy are on today's set list. We'll dissect the race to patch security holes in the PHP programming language, which underpins much of the web. Shona McCallum talks to the volunteer whose work to distribute fixes had him hailed as the man who saved the internet. I am responsible for all these people and I can't fail them. And it is nice to hear how many people are thankful for the work I do. Imran Rahman-Jones returns with answers to the flood of listener questions we received after his report on supercomputers.
1:10I mean, four years isn't really that old in computing terms, I don't think. So what happens to the old supercomputer? The answer to that a little later, and we hear from a comedian battling synthetic AI women copying her jokes. One of my bits, I, you know, it got a half a million views, but then the AI girl got eight million views.
1:54Well, let's begin with something a bit radical, a live audio illustration. Fellow Tech Life presenter Shona McCallum is in the studio and you've bought a very blocky game with you. Well, that's right. These are building blocks, quite like the game Jenga. I'm sure you may have played that before. You have to stack them up on top of each other and then you have to, once you've made the tower, pull them out. Do you want to give it a go? We've stacked it up. I've stacked it up. Oh, there it goes. Hang on, wait, wait, wait. Okay. I was going to say I stacked it up perfectly for you there, but anyway, we've one block down.
2:30Okay. Give it a go. So I'm going to try and pull a block out very carefully without making the tower fall over. There we go. Fantastic. Right. I'm going to pull out some from the bottom as well. And of course, there is a reason that we're doing this, Chris, and that's because we're trying to illustrate the interdependency of the various bits of software that power the internet. Yeah, with each bit of code built on top of other bits of code, until at last we have this giant stack of bricks, this giant edifice that we call the web. But that tower of code, a bit like these stacked blocks, all depends on the blocks at the bottom.
3:11And last week, one of the blocks was at risk of being pulled out. Right, let's have a go here. A bit more jeopardy now because I'm right at the bottom of the tower. Ah, it's still standing.
3:28Blocks everywhere. And of course, taking out one of those lower blocks completely collapsed the whole thing. Yes, and we are, of course, talking about the big story of the week where much of the web, it was feared, was at risk of collapsing. Governments, businesses and organisations around the world are scrambling to prevent possible cyber attacks after a major security flaw was discovered in a programming language behind much of the internet. Around 70 % of the internet could be affected with potentially tens of millions of websites that use the PHP code taken offline while a fix is found. In this case, PHP was the critical foundational block, a programming language dating back to the 90s.
4:14But there was a security weakness that could open the door to cyber attacks. Organisations took sites offline as a precaution. Wikipedia, Amazon, online forums and blogging platform WordPress have reported issues. Well, let's find out more about PHP with Shona. This metaphor of blocks, they're all over the studio now, is a riff on a cartoon by Randall Munro, in which the tower of modern digital infrastructure depends on a tiny foundational brick. The cartoon was widely shared. Lots of people found parallels with PHP. But first, take us back. What is PHP, Shona? Yes, Chris, a lot of people will never have heard of it before last week.
4:57PHP is a computer programming language that's been around since the 90s. When you visit a website, log on to an account, buy something online or fill in a form, there's a good chance that it's PHP that's working away behind the scenes. And what's interesting is that PHP is open source. That means that the code is freely available for people to use, improve and build upon. But it also means that keeping it running and secure depends on a community of developers, some of whom do this work in their spare time. And that's where your Jenga analogy comes in, Chris. Something that most of us have never heard of turns out to be absolutely essential to propping up the internet we use every day.
5:38Well, businesses using PHP had to race to apply fixes. Louis Irwin was one of those. He's chief operating officer at an online training company called yourhippo.com. We provide online training to about 250 ,000 staff across care homes, that sort of thing. And you're a listener and you got in touch. You emailed me because you wanted to tell us about your experiences. I did. Yeah. So, well, let's begin with that then. What was it like for you and your company? Yeah. So I found out quite early in the morning and it was an immediate kind of all hands on deck. Everyone stop what they're doing and let's get around the computer and work out what we actually need to do here.
6:24and we did actually end up having to take all of our systems offline for a good few hours which was super scary we've never in the kind of 10 years we've been running this business we've never had to intentionally take ourselves offline and then once php did release the fix it was then a scramble with us and the rest of the world to get that fix in place what did you find caused you the biggest problems when it came to fixing this quickly? So one of the key issues that we found was these smaller almost choke points along the chain from PHP releasing the fix all the way through to us getting it.
7:06So a good example of that is a particular maintainer called Andre, and there was a good few hours where we were waiting for Andre to package up the PHP fix and make that available. I mean, that's kind of an interesting thing, isn't it? Because, you know, it's not Andre's fault, in a sense, that his tech is incredibly popular. And it's great for your business that it's open source. It's free, isn't it? And, you know, loads and loads of people use it. So you saw this as a bottleneck. I mean, Andre has also been described as a hero, as somebody who got the fixes out. Andre is definitely a hero. Definitely a hero.
7:50I think as a community of developers, we need to have our eyes open a bit more to the fact that the bottlenecks almost are that critical national infrastructure that needs to be there in the time of a crisis. and Andre is brilliant and every open source developer in this world is brilliant but you wouldn't necessarily rely on an open source developer for a nuclear power plant or your water companies. In your email to me you sort of set out that you had a concern about what might happen in the future. What concerns me is if you can imagine a rogue actor instead finding this vulnerability, and perhaps not just finding this one, but building up a library of vulnerabilities that the world doesn't know about, but they do.
8:40If they released all of those onto the public internet at once, we would see something much more serious than what we saw with PHP. That point Louis made about getting fixes from Andrei. He's referring to Andrei Suri, a programmer based in the Czech Republic, who worked to quickly make the fixes available. Shona, you've been talking to him. Yes, and he really is one of those unsung heroes of the internet because for years he's been doing something that's incredibly important but not particularly glamorous. So the PHP project, whatever they release, I take it, create the binary packages out of that that people can install on the servers.
9:22And the process is useful for people because they would have to, all of them would have to compile their source code. But what I'm doing is I'm doing this once and then I provide a very convenient way how to put it all together. And remarkably, he does most of that in his spare time. So when these security flaws were discovered, the work he'd already done meant the fixes could be rolled out much more quickly. He was very quick to play down his own contribution. He wanted to give credit to all the other developers and security experts involved. Of course, there are only a few of them. And he was remarkably calm about something that had caused such enormous disruption.
10:04Unfortunately, the information about the upcoming vulnerabilities leaked on the internet. So on Tuesday evening, I got aware this is quite severe and I don't have that much time to prepare the packaging of the PHP that I provide to people. Is there any moment in this process where you thought perhaps, you know you couldn't get the patches ready on time not really not really i had the time to prepare and uh i know what i am doing yeah so i plan ahead anyone can do my job but not anyone has the amount of experience to be able to do that efficiently the other part is that people trust me that I will provide them with secure packages and I will provide them on time.
10:55How does it feel to have been described as one of the people who helped save the internet this week? It's kind of fulfilling because I sense my work has a purpose. At the same time, I feel that not enough credit has been given to other people who has been part of this. like the PHP project people. So it's not one man's job. It has been many people who contributed to this sort of secured version of PHP got distributed to the people. But you acknowledge how important your role has been. Yes, I believe I, but it comes with responsibility. You know, the feeling is more like I am responsible for all these people and I can't fail them.
11:50And it is nice to hear how many people are thankful for the work I do. Well, Andre obviously wants to share the credit for this much more widely. But did he get any kind of reward for this? Well, he has been compensated to an extent. He takes donations online and he told me that he's made a year's worth of donations last week. That's about US$10 ,000. But there's still the question of what happens if people like him are not around to create these fixes. So he's working on succession planning. But he also has this message to everyone working in tech. This is not just something that magically works behind, but it needs to be taken care of.
12:35Like you take care of other tech, like cars. This is something that needs to be maintained. So was there anything else you wanted to add? I would like to send thank you to all the hardworking system administrators who had a very hard week and had to update and they were very stressed. So I'm sending, you know, hugs to them and hope this will not happen very soon again. So Shona, what are the lessons to be learned from this? In some ways, it's a good news story. AI was used to find the flaws before the hackers got to them. But there are other considerations. Absolutely. I think there's two things to say here.
13:17First, AI has shown to be so useful in cybersecurity. It's helping researchers discover weaknesses in software that might otherwise go unnoticed. And it's helping them do that much faster. But there's the flip side to that. Hackers can use exactly the same tech to find weaknesses and develop attacks. And the second lesson brings us right back to these wooden blocks, which are now all over the studio floor. Big tech is investing billions in developing even more powerful AI. But some of the basic software that keeps their products up and running is still maintained by volunteers. So if AI is going to find more vulnerabilities, they're going to need more resources to fix them.
13:58Because there's not much point in discovering that one of those blocks is just about to fall out if there's nobody there to hold the tower up. There we are, Shona McCallum there, and indeed Shona McCallum's blocks. helping us tell that story. And if you've got a thought on some of the issues raised there, please do get in touch with us.
14:48This is Tech Life on the BBC World Service with me, Chris Vallance, and with you, our listeners. A few weeks ago, Tech Life's Imran Rahman-Jones reported on the UK's national supercomputer, hosted at the University of Edinburgh. It yielded a super-sized response from you, with lots of questions arriving to our email and WhatsApp. So Imran has come out of the production booth and is here to talk us through the answers. Yes, Chris, I've made it back into the main studio. A reminder of that episode on the supercomputers. So we got to go inside the supercomputer, which is used by scientists to crunch these huge calculations for their research.
15:27And we also saw the even more powerful computer being built next door. But we did get all these listener questions. So because of that, I thought it would be best to call up the boss at the supercomputer to get him to help answer them. Hello, I'm Professor Mark Parsons. I'm the Director of EPCT, the National Supercomputer Centre at the University of Edinburgh. So our first question is from our listener Olive and she wants to know what happens to the heat. Clearly there's a lot of heat generated by the supercomputer data centres. Is this heat reused, example, to provide heating to local communities via district heating system?
16:06I would be disappointed to discover that a lot of heat is being expelled into our already overheated atmosphere. Thank you. Over the last few years, as high temperature heat pumps have been invented and become into much more use, we've looked at ways of reusing some of our heat in nearby university buildings. And there's a project at the moment that's connecting our water loop to the energy centre at the veterinary medicine part of the University of Edinburgh, which is quite close to us, where in future their heating will come from our hot water. We're also looking at an idea where we use local mines to store our heat during the summer by heating the water up in them and so the water can be taken out by nearby villages and some towns using ground source heat pumps, but that's much more of a research project.
16:58Okay, and on that kind of same theme, This one's from Angus. It's talking about that supercomputer we saw being built next door, which I think is due to be finished next year. Hello, Tech Life. Thank you for producing the special programme about the Archer 2 supercomputer up in Edinburgh. Since the new supercomputer, which will replace Archer 2, will use five times more electricity, could you tell us whether it will run on renewable power? Also, with Archer 2 switching off before the new one is ready, what happens to the researchers in the meantime? And could that gap be avoided next time? Yes, it's likely to be four or five times more electrical power.
17:39So it'll be, again, fully renewable electricity. That second question about the gap, is that something you can try and deal with? And what happens to the researchers who are currently using it? So the true answer is I would prefer Archer to have continued on until the end of 27 but that wasn't possible so what we've done working really close with UKRI who own all these computers is they've invested in a new set of smaller systems called national compute resources and most of the existing users in Archer 2 have been given time on these national compute resources so while we won't have as much capability of Archer 2 hopefully much of the science will continue one way or another.
18:23Hi Tech Life, Bill Scott here from just outside of York in the UK. Really enjoyed your episode about the UK supercomputer but it led me to wonder, I mean four years isn't really that old in computing terms I don't think, so what happens to the old supercomputer? Could it be broken up for parts? Could it be recycled? Could it be sold on? Let me know. Yes. So this is an interesting area. When you buy a supercomputer, when UKRI buys the national supercomputer, they have a choice. They can either dispose of it themselves or they can leave the disposal rights with the vendor, the company that sold them it.
19:05And nearly always the disposal rights vest with the vendor that sold it. And that means that the vendor can either resell the system for spare parts. I mean, the other thing is you actually pay less at the start because the vendor will calculate how much it's worth at the end of the five year contract. OK, another question about the cooling technology. And this is a possible alternative from our listener, Ian. My question takes me right back to the wonderful BBC programme Tomorrow's World, where one of the presenters picked up a small television and placed it into a tank of what they call non-conductive liquid, explaining that the television worked more efficiently in the liquid.
19:48And I've been thinking about this since then and wondered if this could be used to cool data centres. This feels like a real solution to reducing power consumption and increasing efficiency, and I'd love to know what you think. Yes. So nowadays, this is a cooling technology that is used. It's called immersion cooling, where you basically immerse the computer blades I showed you when you're in the data center in the general look like large chest freezers, which are filled with this liquid that bubbles away. and the heat's taken out in this liquid, there are limitations to how densely you can pack the computer blades in them.
20:30Plus, many GPU and CPU vendors will not provide a warranty for those chips if you're using immersion cooling to cool them. So while it is used in some data centers, we don't use it ourselves, it is an efficient way of doing it, much more efficient than air cooling, for example. but immersion cooling and water cooling provided you're cooling everything in the blade using water cooling and pipes is the same level of efficiency nowadays brilliant well mark thank you so much for your time thanks for having us at the computer a few weeks ago and thanks for answering our listener questions my pleasure well thanks to all the listeners who sent in their questions and if you want to ask us anything about what you hear on the show or you just want to tell us about some interesting tech in your life, you can email or WhatsApp us.
21:21Imran, do you want to do the honours? Yes, you can email us on techlife at bbc.co.uk or send us a WhatsApp. You can even send a voice note like we just heard. The number is plus 44 330 1230 320.
21:46Now, a number of female comedians recently told the publication Deadline of their anger that their jokes had been used without permission and put in the mouths of synthetic deepfake AI women in skimpy clothing, with the videos attracting millions of views on social media. Olga Neymar is one of the comedians whose jokes were appropriated by the bots. Here she is in real life telling part of a joke at the New York Comedy Club. The clips provided courtesy of El Centro Entertainment. Nice guys, oh, they're so boring. I was on date with a nice guy. He's talking about his meditation and his yoga. I was like, ah, should we get a third glass of wine?
22:26He's like, ooh, they're trying to get me drunk. And here's the AI version, which was posted on another Instagram account. Nice guys are, ugh, they're so boring. You know they are. I was on a date with a nice guy. He's talking about his meditation and his yoga. I was like, oh, should we get a third glass of wine? He's like, ooh, you're trying to get me drunk. That was the same bit of Olga's joke being read. You might say murdered by an AI generated woman wearing tight fitting clothing, presumably as a way of getting more views. Olga sees this as theft. And as she explained to me, joke theft is a serious business.
23:09you're like stealing I guess my intellectual property I would say and it's like these jokes are the jokes that get me to go on the road and one of my bits I you know it got a half a million views but then the AI girl got eight million views and now I perform it on shows and I feel like they're gonna be like oh she stole that ai's bit but i've been working on that joke for 10 years they just take your writing and they put it on a bop that like you know they have a big chest and like you know little the dress risque it's kind of as you said uh a kind of curvy sort of curvy and and not wearing many clothes and they're taking my jokes they're not delivering it really well and they're getting millions of views and there's men that are writing in the comments like oh you know they want to do things to those girls they think it's like a real person They're not even listening to the joke.
24:24So not only do you have to suffer the anger that's generated from seeing somebody else take your material and use it without your permission. Also, if you like, it's a kind of sexualized version of your act. Yeah. But then what happened with that account, they got rid of the account. They shut it down and they said, follow us on OnlyFence. So they're using these girls to get followers from joke writing to go have an OnlyFans. And I don't know. That's that's that's all I know. Do you think this could potentially sort of discourage young women from getting into comedy if they think, you know, their work is going to be turned into some bot that appears on sort of websites, you know, like OnlyFans?
25:14I could only speak, I guess, for myself, but I love comedy because I thought it's a place where, like, it doesn't matter what you look like. It's just like, are you funny? Could you deliver a joke? Could you make people laugh? And I stopped posting as much because it just feels like, I feel like I'm the top writer for AI. You know what I mean? And I'm not going to be. No, really, it's very upsetting. Like one of my jokes, I promise you, I was doing the joke for nine years a certain way. And I just, it was working, but it wasn't, now it really works. And I just got it, the perfect wording. And then next thing you know, it's like, I don't even, it's not even my joke anymore.
26:01Part of your complaint is against the tech companies as well. I mean, what would you say to those companies? I'll say, I want to use your platform. I appreciate that you're giving me a space to get my voice out there. And there's so many positive things about, you know, Instagram. But also there's a lot of problems. But I guess with every great thing, there's also bad things. So I would say, what do you suggest? How could we fix this? Olga Nehmer there. Well, we asked Instagram's owner, Meta, about some of the comments made in our interview. They sent us a three-week-old comment from Instagram's boss, Adam Masseri, that was left on another comedian's social media post, a male comic, who this happened to.
26:49Masseri wrote, I don't think it's practical for us to try and ban AI content from the platform. It's going to be harder and harder to identify, and it's not all bad content, though, yes, there is plenty of slop. But we are very invested in trying to drive more traffic to original content creators. And if an AI creator is ripping off content wholesale, it would be good for us to work out what we can do about that. I'm not sure what it would be, but I'll make sure to talk to the team and look into it.
27:24Well, we're just about out of time for this week's programme. If there's anything you've heard that sparked a thought about tech you'd like to share, you can drop us a note. Our email is techlife at bbc.co.uk or you can WhatsApp us on plus 44 330 1230 320. Today's Jenga Taravan episode was produced by Imran Rahman-Jones and knocked over by me, Chris Fannes.
28:01with BBC Podcasts, wherever you listen. Be the first to listen to your favourite shows like Evil Genius, Good Bad Billionaire and You're Dead to Me with a subscription to BBC Podcasts Premium on Apple Podcasts. You can also enjoy a range of our podcasts ad-free with an Amazon Music subscription.
A week ago, few outside of the tech world had heard of PHP. Now, after vulnerabilities were discovered, it’s an acronym many more of us are familiar with. With the help of insiders, we tell the story of the PHP crisis. Plus, Tech Life speaks to a comedian whose jokes were taken and retold by an AI avatar – which then went on to get millions of views online. And after we visited the UK’s national supercomputer a few weeks back, we answer some of your questions with the centre’s director.
Presented by Chris Vallance Produced by Imran Rahman-Jones
(Image: Ondřej Surý, wearing glasses and a checked shirt, smiles at the camera on a video call.)