


How curiosity and technology can help protect wildlife “without getting in their way,” using (1) live-streamed wildlife rehab and (2) AI-enabled bioacoustics to decode wild wolf communication.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Maya Higa shares her experience rehabilitating a hawk named Bean.
“On the show today, new ideas about understanding wild animals without getting in their way.”
Maya discusses training Bean and the impact of livestreaming his recovery.
“So what's the prescription for a bird in beans condition at that point?”
Maya talks about how her audience became invested in Bean's recovery journey.
“So I started I was live streaming for fun.”
Maya reflects on changing her approach to conservation through virtual outreach.
“How do you know that you've prepared him to survive in the wild?”
Maya shares how she founded Alveus Sanctuary and future plans.
“rescue animals and build huge animal enclosures, and we would live stream conservation education programs online so people could fall in love with our animals the way that they fell in love with being that bird.”
Maya Higa discusses her sanctuary's mission to rescue wildlife.
“where we could build really fantastic animal enclosures and rescue wildlife that didn't have anywhere else to go.”
Details on the enclosures at Alvea and their livestreaming efforts.
“It's like slinky sort of light orange with black polka dots all over and big Kit Kat ears.”
Maya explains how they engage young audiences with conservation.
“to make this bridge between the animals at Alveas and them in these wild spaces.”
Maya discusses her role as a bridge between animals and the audience.
“How much do people's fascination with the animals on display also have to do with their fascination with you?”
Exploring the cultural and ecological significance of wolves and their howls.
“And now let's listen to one particular voice from the wild.”
Learn about the innovative methods used to study wolf sounds and communication.
“And he wanted to know what the wolves were saying.”
Discover how AI is used to analyze wolf howls and what researchers learn from them.
“On the show today, new ways of understanding wild animals without getting in their way.”
Explore how wolves communicate through sounds and the significance of specific calls.
“And she got away, and she started bark howling.”
Discuss the role of AI in understanding animal behavior and conservation efforts.
“You know, there's a lot of talk about AI, AI for good, AI for nature.”
Reflect on the state of wildlife and the importance of understanding and preserving nature.
“your right forearm would be what's left of the wild ones.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On TED Radio Hour, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This message comes from Google Workspace with Gemini. One subscription that does it all. Personalized AI and premium business versions of Gmail, Google Docs, Drive, and more. Try it free for 14 days at goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. This is the TED Radio Hour. Each week, groundbreaking TED Talks. Our job now is to dream big. Delivered at TED conferences. To bring about the future we want to see. around the world. To understand who we are. From those talks, we bring you speakers and ideas that will surprise you. You just don't know what you're going to find. Challenge you. We truly have to ask ourselves, like, why is it noteworthy?
0:42And even change you. I literally feel like I'm a different person. Yes. Do you feel that way? Ideas worth spreading. From TED and NPR. I'm Manoush Zomorodi. On the show today, new ideas about understanding wild animals without getting in their way. Starting with the story of an injured hawk who helped a young woman upend how we might think about conservation. Yeah, so he was hit by a car and was found by a member of the public. The person who found him called the zoo to see if they could bring him in. This is Maya Higa. I'm a conservationist and I'm a content creator, and I'm the founder of Alvea Sanctuary, which is a wildlife sanctuary and conservation education center in Austin, Texas.
1:33When Maya was in college, she had a job at the local zoo rehabilitating birds of prey. That is where she first met Bean, the red-tailed hawk. Yeah, he was brought into the zoo, and the zoo had a number of birds of prey. So they had eagles and owls and other hawks. And because I worked there, he became my project. So he was a younger bird that probably wasn't getting enough food as is because hunting is hard when you're a year old as a bird of prey. And so he didn't have enough weight on him. And, you know, he got unlucky by getting hit by that car. Nothing broken, luckily, but did not have the strength that he needed to just take off and fly away.
2:19So what's the prescription for a bird in beans condition at that point? What did he need? So I would weigh him multiple times a day. And we had a very careful reintroduction of foods. So his diet was kind of a slow reintroduction of a combination of quail and mice and rats just to put more weight on him. So why did you bring him home? Because he was getting weighed multiple times a day and fed multiple times a day. It was really the only option for us because the zoo was a drive. So I had my falconry license. So I had an enclosure for him in my backyard at my college house. That's a whole process.
3:02There's an inspection done by Fish and Wildlife out there to get that enclosure approved. And then he was brought home and I had all of the equipment that I needed at my house. And then I started training him to come to fly to my glove. So I would feed him bits of food on my glove. I would put him on a perch and then he would fly to me and eat those bits of food. And then eventually I would have him fly from the ground up to my glove to help build muscle as well. And over the course of time, I would just move the perch further away from me. So he was flying longer distances. I mean, you're an unusual college student to have like a Falcon rehab clinic in your backyard.
3:42essentially. Yeah. Yeah. That's true. Definitely unusual. And that's why people were so excited about it. So I started I was live streaming for fun. Had nothing to do with the zookeeping or the falconry. I'm a college student. I'm a junior. I go to school in California. I'm sitting Maya already had an account on the live streaming platform Twitch where she liked to sing for people. She was here for Here we go. I was just doing covers. So it had nothing to do with conservation. But naturally on a live stream, you're live. And so there's a lot of air to fill. And so I would talk about work and I would talk about this bird in my backyard.
4:26I love animals. I am a falconer. I guess that's it. And people that were watching that stream at the time, there were, you know, a few dozen of them, maybe. There were some people that didn't believe that I had a hawk in my backyard because it's so unusual and random. Should I get him? Do you guys want to meet him? The hawk? So I brought him inside and someone made a short video of that. This is Bean. His name is Bean. I didn't name him. And then that video went viral because people were so confused as to what was going on. They're really excited about it. He was hit by a car a few months ago.
5:06I mean, I watched the video and it's pretty extraordinary. You look like a lovely young woman in your bedroom. And then perched on your hand on a glove is this fierce, like intense looking bird who trusts you immensely. Yeah. And looks so strange in like a regular bedroom. The contrast is striking. Yeah. So someone posted a clip of that on Reddit. And it started getting a lot of attention on Reddit. And then people wanted to see more of what I was doing. And so the more I live streamed with Bean in particular, the more people would make these videos and post them. Don't walk up to him like you're going to eat him.
5:51And people were so interested in what was going on, they would come to my live stream to watch the whole process. So his entire rehabilitation process happened on live stream. So he flew past me and he landed on the ground. What did they say that they were like why they were into it? I think they became interested in the arc of this bird. You know, they knew that there was an injury. They knew he was an underdog at the time. You know, he wasn't doing well. They wanted to see him recover and eventually be released. And so they were really invested in his recovery process. They liked watching him get stronger.
6:28They liked watching him hit these milestones and build muscle. And then eventually I recorded the release as well. Oh, wow. They felt like they were a part of that whole story. He's pretty angry, so I'm going to give him a good toss here. Okay, there you go. Forgive my lack of knowledge, but you did not domesticate Bean. How do you know that you've prepared him to survive in the wild? Yeah, so for him, a lot of it was physically feeling his muscle condition. You can feel it around their keel or on their chest. He was feeling really good. His weight was really good. He was flying really strong.
7:06I was able to fly him against the wind, too, at pretty significant distances, so I knew that his flight capability was really great. and he also spent a little bit of time at the end of his recovery at the ohi raptor center which is a fantastic facility that does lots of bird rehab um and they're they're able to set them up for success out there and they felt really good about his ability to hunt too and so after that he was he was ready to go so so what significance did your uh relationship with bean and then the changing relationship with your online audience have? Like what did that sort of make you think like, wait a minute, this could be something else.
7:50So significant. So this, as my, as a zookeeper, my job was outreach education. And so I would bring wildlife to schools, to birthday parties, to events in person, and I would teach kids about them. So I was that, I was the zookeeper that showed up. And then when I started doing this rehab with Bean on stream, I found myself doing the spiel. You know, the, this is a red-tailed hawk. It's like most common widespread bird of prey in North America. You know, I'm doing the kind of event spiel. But at that time, I was doing it to thousands of people at a time that I knew were all over the world on this live stream, instead of in person with maybe 20 kids at a time.
8:32And in addition to the reach and the global reach of it all too, Bean didn't have to leave my house at all or be transported to an in-person facility. And so there was a lot less stress on him. And so there was definitely a moment of that clicking of, I can do this conservation outreach education work virtually without having to bring the animals anywhere and they can reach way more people. And that's a win-win. For centuries, humans have found ways to get close to wild animals by capturing them, studying them, and putting them on display. But now technology offers different kinds of access. And so today on the show, ideas about understanding wild animals without getting in their way.
9:21Two conservationists with radically new approaches to protecting wildlife. The people watching my stream started becoming as invested as I was in his recovery. It was like they were doing it with me, sort of, which was the coolest thing that I've ever done. Here's my Ahiga on the TED stage. And then eventually, because I was reaching so many people with Bean's story, the zoo that I worked at started allowing me to bring animals like cockatoos and reptiles home to present on my livestream. So suddenly, somehow, I had turned this zoo outreach job that I had into a work-from-home situation, right?
10:01Which is awesome. But instead of reaching 20 kids at a time in a classroom, I was reaching thousands of people at a time all over the world. So this was when it really clicked for me, right? I wanted to do this for the rest of my life, but I wanted to do it at a much, much larger scale. So then two years later, at 22 years old, I came up with a plan, and the vision was to build an animal sanctuary that nobody visits, or at least not in person. So we would rescue animals and build huge animal enclosures, and we would live stream conservation education programs online so people could fall in love with our animals the way that they fell in love with being that bird.
10:40Our animals would be able to reach millions and millions of people. I wrote up this three-year business plan on live stream. This has all happened live on stream. Everybody's been, all of the community that has watched has been very involved. So I'm sitting there in my bedroom on a metal fold-out chair writing a three-year business plan with them. Were people chiming in like in the chat? Oh, yeah. Yeah. Real hive mind. Yeah. Yeah. They built it with me. So we wrote that business plan. And then it all ended up happening in three months. It was a three-year business plan and it moved very fast. The reason that it was able to move so fast is because in addition to that kind of crowdsource brainstorming, I was able to do crowdsource fundraising really successfully because there were so many people invested in this mission.
11:33So we did a capital campaign fundraiser in February of 2021 and we raised over$500 ,000 on a live stream to found the organization. And this is where I shaved my head. So one of the people watching said, if we raised half a million dollars, would you shave your head live on stream? And I was like, yeah, yeah, yes. Yes, I would do that. That's nothing for that amount of money. And we raised$573 ,000. And so I shaved my head on stream. Holy moly. So you take this like over$500 ,000 and do what? Because there's a difference between one single animal on your like, you know, laptop camera versus setting up an institute, essentially.
12:20Yes. Yeah. So after that stream, the live stream ended and I realized this this five hundred thousand dollars was five dollar, twenty dollar, hundred dollar donations from an incredible amount of people. Right. There were, you know, at the most like 90 ,000 people that were watching the live stream at one time. And so there are so many people that have just contributed these small dollar donations. And so after the live stream ended, I was sitting there like, oh, wow. A lot of people have trusted me with an incredible amount of money. And now I actually have to do it, which is what I wanted. I just didn't know how.
13:02In a minute, Maya Higa explains how she built the Alvaeus Sanctuary from the ground up. On the show today, protecting wildlife without getting in their way. I'm Manoush Zomorodi, and you're listening to the TED Radio Hour from NPR. We'll be right back.
13:30Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Rinse. A well-designed life doesn't run on default settings. You chose the walkable neighborhood. Your coffee order became oddly specific. You spent three weeks choosing your mattress. But your laundry routine? That one somehow escaped the redesign. Should that really be the one update you skipped? Consider this the patch. Rinse picks up your laundry and dry cleaning, cleans it expertly, and delivers it back. Sign up today at rinse.com. Rinse. It's time to be great. This message comes from U.S. Bank.
14:08Chief Product Officer Shruti Patel shares how U.S. Bank Business Essentials combines business checking and payments in one simple solution. We wanted to make banking really easy for small business. And all of the time and cost we can save them in their back office operations helps them focus more on running their business more effectively and serving the customers well. Learn more at usbank.com slash business. member FDIC. Support for NPR and the following message come from Legacy Box, preserving family stories by converting home movies, film, and slides into digital files. Co-founder Adam Baselugger shares an early customer experience that left a lasting impression.
14:51We had a lady walk into our office and she had terminal cancer and she walked in with her daughter. She had a massive box of videotapes and she said, I need help. I want to share the stories before it's too late. And for young guys that had just started a business, we were like, we've got to pour our soul into this business. Learn more at LegacyBox.com slash NPR. It's the TED Radio Hour from NPR. I'm Manoush Zomorodi. On the show today, we are talking about new approaches to protecting wildlife by getting out of its way. We were just talking to conservationist Maya Higa about how she founded the Alvea Sanctuary at the ripe age of 22.
15:34I wanted to have a facility that was never open to the public, where we could build really fantastic animal enclosures and rescue wildlife that didn't have anywhere else to go. So wildlife that cannot be re-released into the wild. These are either confiscations from the pet trade, so they don't know how to take care of themselves, or they're permanently injured wildlife. that can't be released. And we would bring these animals to our facility and do the same thing that I was doing with Bean, which is just share their stories, share their recovery stories, share their personalities, and just teach people about conservation through live streaming.
16:15So I will never be able to visit Alveas because it is not open to the public. But if I did, could you give me like a little tour? Like what would it be like? So it's a 40-acre facility, and we've got a wide range of species in enclosures that are kind of sprawled out across the entire property. So we have wolf dogs, and then foxes are near them. So we have two American red foxes. Their names are Finn and Reed. Past the foxes, we have Pushpop, our Salcata tortoise. and then we've got the crows after push pop and then marmosets which are these little brazilian monkeys little primates they're so cute they're like the size of a squirrel and then we pass the emus and then we get to the staff offices so that's my morning commute we've got five full-time animal care staff that are caring for all of our rescued animals we have videography out there we have editors out there we have a nutrition building a diet and nutrition prep building.
17:22And then we have a studio where we do these live streams and record content. And is the idea that each of these are in a, you say an enclosure, but is it like a crate for a dog or are you trying to make it more sort of environmentally appropriate? No, they all have different enclosures that are built out for their specific needs. So if you go into the marmoset enclosure, for example, there are just ropes everywhere for climbing and there's platforms and it's made for little monkeys. It's like the dream habitat for little monkeys that are swinging around everywhere. And then the wolf dog enclosure is massive.
18:03It's a huge outdoor space, open air, so there's no top on it. So lots of space to run. They have a pond, they have a running, And they have running water in there as well, like a little river set up. They've got dens built out in their enclosure. So all of the enclosures are very different and they're built specifically for the species that's in them. And do you live there? I do. I have a tiny house out on site at Alvaez. And so I live in the corner. My neighbors are the foxes and we are currently building a serval enclosure next to my house as well. A what enclosure? A serval. It's an African wild cat.
18:41Oh. He's our newest rescue. He was purchased at a flea market in Texas to be someone's pet, and that didn't work out because he's a wild cat. They're beautiful. Wow. So beautiful. It's like slinky sort of light orange with black polka dots all over and big Kit Kat ears. Yeah. How on earth would someone get one of these and think that they could have them as a pet? I think that some people think it would be like having a cat, but just bigger and cooler. But it's not like that at all. They don't act like domestic cats. They don't want to live inside. They can be very dangerous. This is a big, I mean, he's 35 pounds.
19:28And they can jump meters and meters in the air. I mean, it's just it's not it's not something that's literally literally not something that's made to be in our home or in our possession. And so the purpose is to give these animals a good life in addition to letting us regular people see them living their good life. So how do you have it set up to live stream? Like, can anybody look at these animals living any time? Yes. Yes. So we have live cameras in all of these enclosures. So we're live streaming 24-7 from Alvea Sanctuary. Chet, you can't tell me that's like not the most beautiful animal on the planet.
20:08Isn't that crazy? So those cameras are up on Twitch and on YouTube and people watch the animals all day long. So they watch them nap. They watch them eat their diets. They watch their training sessions. They watch them play. All the silly things that animals do when we aren't looking or when they think we're not looking, we can watch on the live cams. So, okay, so somebody listening might be like, that's cool that you were giving these animals somewhere safe to live and giving them a good life. But how does that relate to conservation? Sort of connect the dots for me. Yeah, for sure. So all of the animals have a story about their species where I can teach people about conservation and the challenges that they're facing.
20:52With the foxes, I talk a lot about the fur trade and how foxes are exploited for the fur trade. We have Winnie the Moo, the cow. And so I talk about the agriculture industry and how that impacts our planet. And then our next step for Alvaeus is joining the efforts that are already happening for endangered species breeding programs. So very soon we are welcoming Mexican wolves to our facility. There's only about 300 of them left in the wild right now. So they're critically endangered. And one of the ways that people in other facilities have been working to save them is breeding them in captivity and reintroducing them into the wild.
21:33And so Alveas is joining that SAFE program. SAFE stands for Saving Animals from Extinction. and part of our idea is having live cameras on them in the wild as well. And so we're hoping to make this bridge between the animals at Alveas and them in these wild spaces. So I'm curious, what do you see as what you want your audience to do? Is it about them making different choices in their lives or is it about something bigger than that? I think what Alveas is really good at is reaching people that otherwise aren't necessarily interested in nature and the planet. They are young people that are online, chronically, as we all are, and they're consuming live stream content.
22:21They're not necessarily the kids that are out there turning over rocks, you know, and being really into nature already. They're just young people that are on social media. We're able to meet them where they already are. and that's a really exciting thing because conservation needs a lot of people involved right now. Is that hard for some of the people who've maybe been doing conservation for decades to understand? Like, what do you mean? They're like looking on their phones and that's their introduction to conservation. Like, do they get it? I think some do and I think some don't. You know, I also would have said, to be fair, before I founded Alveas, I would have thought that in-person connection is really important too.
23:03And what Alveas has taught me is that's so clearly not the case. I think part of it too is the time spent. In working at a zoo, even me, who obviously I love wildlife and there are a lot of zoos that I really, really love. But even then you're walking by enclosures and maybe spending a couple minutes if you're really enamored by an animal and you want to sit there and watch them. But with our live cams being live 24-7, people are just seeing so much more of these animals' lives, and they have so much more time to build connections to them and feel invested in them. Where do you stand then on zoos or safaris or humans having that close-up experience of wild animals?
23:44I think there are a lot of really fantastic zoos out there. And there are a lot of AZA-accredited zoos within the U.S. that do a ton of really important conservation and do a great job. So I'm definitely not saying that we should boycott zoos. There are also zoos that are doing a really terrible job, right? So it's not so black and white. I would love to see more zoos have live cameras in addition. It makes viewing animals and becoming interested in them financially accessible, physically accessible. But I think there's a place for both models, mine and the traditional zoo model right now. How much do people's fascination with the animals on display also have to do with their fascination with you?
24:31Because, I mean, there's definitely the parasocial relationship with you, a content creator. Right. Yeah. It matters a lot. I am a bridge to these animals and to our planet. The difference between reading something educational on a billboard, you know, or in a textbook and sitting with your friend, you know, at coffee or something and them telling you something that they're really excited about. You just you care so much more about the latter. So that connection really, really matters to people. Not a lot of privacy for you. Do you feel like an animal in a zoo? That's a good question. Sometimes.
25:14Yeah. Yeah, I mean, there's a microscope for sure. That is part of being a content creator and putting my life online, but it is something I'm more than happy to do. Being a conduit for people to the planet is an honor. That was conservationist Maya Higa. She is the founder of the Alvaeus Sanctuary. You can check out Alvaeus' live streams at alvaeussanctuary.org. You can also see Maya's TED Talk at TED.com.
25:50Today on the show, protecting wild animals without getting in their way. And now let's listen to one particular voice from the wild. A wolf's howl, a primal sound that's been heard and mimicked by humans for thousands of years. People have been howling forever. I'm sure the Clovis people that came here 13 ,000 years ago were doing it. The Mountain Shoshone, who used to live in Yellowstone, they were described by trappers as being the best imitators of animals around. They could howl like wolves, they could neigh like horses, and imitate any bird. Hunters have used it to draw in wolves and kill them.
26:40Some people did it during COVID. they'd go outside their back door on the porch and they'd howl to prove to the world that they were still alive.
26:55Across cultures, wolves are symbolic. For some indigenous nations, they stand for loyalty and family. In European stories like Little Red Riding Hood, they're a reminder that danger lurks everywhere. And, of course, wolves were domesticated, becoming man's best friend and pet. But a century ago in the U.S., wolves were widely seen as predatory enemies, hunted to near extinction. In places like Yellowstone, they were wiped out entirely. So Jeff Reed, who grew up on the outskirts of the national park, never heard their howls as a child. I was born in the late 60s in southwest Montana, which we call the Absorke Mountains here, just north of Yellowstone National Park, one of the premier ecosystems in the world.
27:48And we lived outdoors all the time. Without wolves, Yellowstone lost its apex predator. The elk population surged and plant life was devastated. It took several decades until 1995 when conservationists reintroduced wolves in the hopes of restoring the park's delicate ecosystem. By the time Jeff Reed moved back to the area after spending his adult life in Silicon Valley, wolf howls were everywhere. And he wanted to know what the wolves were saying. So when I moved back, wolves were back. And I always knew that there's nothing more iconic than a wolf howl to tell you about nature. You know, I was going out and studying them just as a casual observer.
28:37And it really dawned on me that wolves are hard to study. Like you can't walk up with a mic and say, you know, what did you mean by that? And I knew a lot of the biologists who were working in the park, and they're amazing researchers. And I just started talking to a few of them and said, hey, what if we did a large-scale bioacoustics project where we put recorders out on the landscape and then really started studying what the wolves were saying, so to speak. Jeff's background in tech and linguistics made him the perfect person to build on the work already being done to understand wolves. Wolves have been researched for their sounds for a long time, and there are captive facilities, often sanctuaries, for wolves.
29:19And so you can hear them in captive centers. But we were really interested in wild wolves. Like, what are your kids saying when they leave the home and they're with their friends? That's really what we wanted to get after is how are they communicating in their natural soundscapes. Well, what were the tools that they were using before you got there? So wolves in Yellowstone are the most studied wolves in the world. So they already have this huge database, genetics, you name it, observations. They fly planes over, they put GPS collars on. And so we just started to amplify that with an acoustics project.
29:54To do that, Jeff needed to upgrade the technology. There was certain acoustic technology that you could record, but it really hadn't been innovated upon from a biologist's perspective on the landscape. And so I was like, of course we can do this, right? We do this all the time in Silicon Valley. It's just we're only doing it to make money. And so I was like, OK, let's start reinventing these devices, these camera traps and these acoustic recorders and have it record for a year. Do you remember when you first started placing these devices in the park? Yeah, for sure. You know, we're walking out.
30:33It's spring, right? Kittentails are coming up, these beautiful purple flowers. So we put these out there and I'm thinking to myself, is this going to work? Is this really going to work? What was going through your mind? Just so many unknowns. If you think about Yellowstone, it's a big landscape. It's very rugged. It's very remote. Yeah. If you wanted to put an acoustic recorder out in the middle of Yellowstone and have it record for a year, it's about three terabytes of data that you have to store for that year. Uh-huh. And it's got to live through temperatures of minus 50 to 100, 110. Wow. You don't want birds to fly away with it.
31:17All sorts of things, right? You know, we leave it near a wolf den site and we come back home and we wait a couple months. I bring the recorders home. I pull the SD cards and we've recorded over 200 ,000 hours, which would take me roughly 50 years to listen to. Okay, so the recordings worked, which was great. But then you had so much data to use. What do you do with all these hours, years worth of audio? What you do is they're recorded in one hour chunks. So you get this wave file, and I pull it up on this huge monitor, and it turns into a spectrogram. A spectrogram is a visualization of sounds showing how pitch and volume change over time.
32:05Waves go up and down. Loud sounds show up brightly, while quieter ones are more faint. A good linguist can take human speech, turn it into a spectrogram, and tell you what they said without hearing it. Huh. So the same is true for all animal communication. We're animals, too. So I'm going through these one-hour files, and I pull them up one by one, and I think I was two days in. And I pull them up on a big screen, and I look at them. And Jeff sees... Nothing. Spectrogram after spectrogram. We're not seeing anything. And I'm like, oh man. But then something big and bright and spiky appears.
32:54Finally I saw this beautiful chorus howl. He sees another chorus howl. And another one. And another one. So that was kind of the first time I said, okay, we've got something. The GrizzCam gave scientists a way to eavesdrop on wolves. But what to do with those hours and hours of howls? How to make sense of them? When we come back, crunching the data with the help of AI. Today on the show, new approaches to understanding the wild. I'm Manoush Zomorodi, and you're listening to the TED Radio Hour from NPR. Stick around.
33:46Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Rinse. A well-designed life doesn't run on default settings. You chose the walkable neighborhood. Your coffee order became oddly specific. You spent three weeks choosing your mattress. But your laundry routine? That one somehow escaped the redesign. Should that really be the one update you skipped? Consider this the patch. Rinse picks up your laundry and dry cleaning, cleans it expertly, and delivers it back. Sign up today at rinse.com. Rinse. It's time to be great. This message comes from U.S. Bank.
34:23Chief Product Officer Shruti Patel shares how U.S. Bank Business Essentials combines business checking and payments in one simple solution. We wanted to make banking really easy for small business. And all of the time and cost we can save them in their back office operations helps them focus more on running their business more effectively and serving the customers well. Learn more at usbank.com slash business. Member FDIC. This message comes from Quo. You're on a job, in a meeting, slammed, and a customer calls. If nobody picks up, they go to your competitor. That's why over 90 ,000 companies choose Quo, the business phone system built for busy teams.
35:06Smart call routing sends calls to the right person. Shared numbers let your team cover for each other. And an AI agent picks up when nobody can, capturing every lead so nothing falls through the cracks. Always say hello with Quo. Try it free at Quo.com slash NPR. It's the TED Radio Hour from NPR. I'm Manoush Zomorodi. On the show today, new ways of understanding wild animals without getting in their way. And we were just hearing how wolf researcher Jeff Reed built new technology to capture the sounds of wolves communicating in Yellowstone Park.
35:50i love it so much there's so much going on yeah
35:58what is happening like so i i hear the like oh but then there's like also a little one who seems to be like telling somebody like a story as well i don't know what were we listening to when you first start hearing these chorus howls they kind of sound like a cocktail party and when you first walk in you kind of hear all this chatter right and you're not necessarily listening to any one person you're just hearing this noise humans and other animals are really good at isolating sound in this kind of chorus and so we can pick out a person in a room and focus on their voice and so with some time you start being able to pick out individual voices and the easy one is the howl right you heard the howl that started at the beginning yeah And then you start hearing these other sounds, right?
36:44And that's what we were interested in is, what are these other sounds and who makes them? Why are they making them? And these are all the questions we're just starting to raise. And we're figuring out a few things, but I'll be dead by the time the younger biologists really start decoding all of this information. To move way faster, Jeff and Yellowstone biologists turned to, yes, you guessed it, AI. They had to begin by training a new model. The first thing we built were some AI tools to go find the Howells in all of these recordings so that we can gather more data. I did it manually for 200 ,000 of them and then built an AI model from that so that now as we're recording across half of Yellowstone, we can more easily go get their voices, so to speak.
37:37The tool can quickly find and classify different howls collected over months. It also picks up on things that Jeff and the biologists might never notice. There are clustering tools and other tools that are machine learning based that allow us to use software to say, what are we missing as humans? What might be another way to look at this howl? The AI is seeing patterns in it that there might be some functional behavior associated with it. These battery-operated devices use AI to record only the sound and motion that matters to the scientists, saving them time and money. Jeff Reed explains more from the TED stage.
38:20And researchers have already determined that wolves can identify one another just from their howls. But we do not know yet if they have names like Teddy or Rachel. or if it's more like you picking up the phone and recognizing that person's voice. Now, this is where it gets interesting to me. A chorus howl is when a pack or family of wolves communicate as a group, often to signal that this is their territory. And in this video, a wolf from the pack is off-camera howling but being totally ignored by his packmates until something happens.
39:00As soon as the alpha female howled, the rest of the wolves looked at her and the chorus began. And as it kicks off, the wolves come together in this mosh pit of dancing bodies making different types of calls. The entire event lasts about 60 seconds and then everybody goes about their business. So taking this example of the chorus howl, like break it down for me, how AI helps you understand what the wolves are doing and saying to each other. So there are two things the researchers are really looking at with chorus howls. The first is a chorus howl will start where one wolf is howling and then the rest of them will join in.
39:40But when a wolf's howling, it doesn't always turn into a chorus howl. So the question is, who's deciding we all need to chorus howl together? And we've got a little bit of evidence that suggests it's the dominant wolves, once they join into a howling event then the rest of the pack joins in so we're very interested in who decides that this whole territorial chorus howl is going to start the other thing is we're working with google deep mind to see if we can count wolves just from their chorus howl then can we just use audio recordings to know how many wolves were in that pack chorus howl and what One researcher, Kira Cassidy, figured out was that wolves can counterestimate the number of wolves howling in a rival pack, and they make a decision.
40:35If they're outnumbered, you wouldn't want to get killed. You leave the area. If you're not outnumbered, the wolves often approach that rival pack because they know they're outnumbering the rival pack. Now, wolves also bark, like your dog. But unlike most dogs, wolves combine barks with other sounds into sentence-like structures. And in this video, a female wolf uses a bark, howl, after being chased and nearly killed by a rival pack.
41:09There's real range in that one. Yeah. So you hear two things in there. You hear a bark and you hear a howl, but the howl is highly modulated at the end. And so what I was trying to get people to think about was, is this a form of combining two different sounds together to form some new function? Like if you take the word cry and you take the word wolf separately, you combine it together, cry wolf. They slightly change their meaning when they're brought together. We've known about this bark howl forever. The bark is an alarm, and the howl is, here I am, at least as basic function. And they'll make this when there's a serious threat.
41:56That one you just heard was a particular female wolf that was just chased by another pack and was about to get killed. And she got away, and she started bark howling. And the idea I'm throwing out there for us to think about is the bark is an alarm. Like there's a threat and the howl is trying to get attention to your pack mates and say, here I am. So come help me. So she was in distress. Well, for sure she was in distress, but was she trying to communicate something more than just distress? Come help me. I'm not saying that's exactly what wolves are doing, but I am saying these are two different sounds they make.
42:34They combine them together. is this a basic form of recursion or combinatorial meaning? And recursion is what most linguists would say today is what's unique about human languages. I want to talk about a wolf who sounds rather special, 907. 907 is definitely a special wolf. She lived 11 years, and the average age of a wolf in Yellowstone National Park is about three and a half years. Oh, that's it. Yeah, they would live as long as a dog, but the wild is a different place, right? So your lifespan's shorter. She lost one of her eyes when she was about four. Later in life, she had a limp. She surely had arthritis, broken bones, and whatnot.
43:24but she lived to 11 and she holds the record in Yellowstone National Park for the most puppy litters. Oh wow. She always had puppies every year. She's kind of what got me into this project. I'd listened to her howls a lot and just fell in love with her. You fell in love with her. What was it about her? These wild animals who we pretty much exterminated from the lower 48 with poison and you name it. They earn a lot of respect with hunters like me because they're surviving on the landscape. The number one cause of a death in Yellowstone is another wolf. Outside of Yellowstone in non-protected areas, it's humans.
44:09You see how they take care of their pups, how they take care of family members, and you can't help but look at your own family structure and realize that there are personalities. black sheep in the family, the high achievers. And she was just like, I called her the queen of Slough Creek, which is where her natal den was. Okay, let's listen to 907.
44:47it is soulful and mournful that's what it sounds like to me but what do you hear what else did you hear besides the howl the howl was easy she's crunching around and then And I liked how there was like a, ooh, I see like a bridge sort of action. There's a tempo to it. Yeah. So those vertical bars you're seeing after the first howl was her walking around on shale rocks right next to a fir tree that had the recorder in it. And then what was the sound at the end that you heard?
45:26Baby wolves? That was her breathing into the recorder. So she was so close to the recorder. Yeah. If you imagine yourself sitting there, she'd be breathing on your cheek. So her howl was very flat. We call it a flat howl. But there's still, you know, it rises and falls. The typical wolf howl in Yellowstone is 350 hertz, which is about middle F on your piano keyboard. In other words, 907 was a stout girl, bigger than your average female wolf. And her pitch was about 320 hertz, where the average wolf would have been a little higher than that. And then other wolves will do a whoo, well, it'll rise and then fall.
46:12And research has shown that wolves can identify one another from their howls. And there's at least two ways they do that. One is where the pitch ends at the end of the howl. So where it tails off, that lower pitch is a good way for another wolf to know, oh, I know who that is. And the other is how loud it gets throughout the howl. Is it ridiculous to think that she's saying, I'm here, I, like the I, they're like, oh, yeah, it's 907. Or that she's calling her own name, that she's telling people that she's there? Context always means something to language, right? You don't know what someone said unless you know the context often.
46:56What had happened a half hour before this recording is a herd of elk came running right by this recorder, and they were being chased by the pack. She was very old at this time, and for some reason, like, I don't want to keep going. She stopped, and the rest of the pack chased the elk, and they were about a mile away. And then she howled. And so I think your intuition is getting close. She's letting them know, here I am. This is me, right? 907. They're like, okay, 907's back over there. We're up here. And what happened after this set of howls, she howled like this for half an hour. Oh, wow. But in that, on the spectrogram, I noticed a distant, faint line.
47:39And that was one of the other wolves howling back at her. So she knew where they were. They knew where she was. And that was the communication. So it's like getting lost in the grocery store and you're like, yo, where are you guys? I'm over here. And they're like, we're in aisle 11 kind of thing. Exactly. I love that. Where are you, mom, dad? I do want to just pull back. You know, there's a lot of talk about AI, AI for good, AI for nature. Do you get excited when you talk about the artificial intelligence aspect of being able to analyze all these hours of wolf calls that you have? Or do you think people just want to talk about the hot new thing and that's why they insist on this part of the project?
48:27It's both. I think AI is a tool that can help us understand animal behavior. But it's not the end all. I don't foresee a Google Translate for wolfish, right? Because what you're really trying to do is get in the mind of a wolf. And that's different than just transcribing their different types of howls into the basic functional units. And to what end is this conservation? Is this simply expanding human knowledge of other species? These devices that we're building can do a lot of things. A lot of people don't know that poaching happens all across America, across the world, but even within our national parks.
49:14Still. Yeah, still to this day. Two wolves were poached last year on the northern border of Yellowstone. Why can't we solve for poaching? Because this is a national heritage, right? It's everybody's national park. And so one of the reasons we're building these devices is to locate gunshots on the landscape and help law enforcement protect these resources for the public. But then there are a lot of other reasons that tie to conservation. One of them is simply building the digital wild. Human language across the globe is losing its words and grammar for nature. It's slowly going away because as we move to the cities and we don't experience the wild kingdom, we're seeing changes in our lexicon, so to speak.
50:11There's no turning back the digital age. And so one of the things we can do with these camera traps and these sound recorders is bring this digital wild and storytelling to people, kids who are sitting at home, and bring them a little closer to nature. you tend to protect what you love and you only love what you understand. Now look, I don't know if AI will ultimately decode animal communication but I do know this, there has to be animals to decode. If your body represented the total weight of all the world's land mammals today your right forearm would be what's left of the wild ones. The rest of your body is us, our livestock, and our pets.
50:59As for carnivores, things like lions, tigers, and wolves, it's less than my pinky. The challenge we collectively face as real humans, not artificial ones, goes far beyond individual opinions on wild wolves. It's about the future of wildness itself. Wolf. Do you have a name in wolf? I don't know, Jeffrey, if that's a ridiculous question. For me? Yes. Like if you were to go out into the field and you were to say like, hey, wolves, it's me, it's Jeff. I'm collecting the spectrograms and the recordings. Yeah. Well, what I do, I howl. And I've gotten good at imitating 907's howl. So I howl like her.
51:45Why don't you do it with me? So just try to keep it flat. Okay. And then try to get your pitch around 320 hertz. Okay. I'm going to count to three, and then we're both going to do it. One, two, three.
52:06Perfect. That felt good. Yeah. I feel like I'm a member of your pack now, Jeff. Thank you. Yep, or I'm a member of yours. Thank you. That was Jeffrey T. Reed. He's a computational linguist and the founder of Grizzly Systems and the Cry Wolf Project. You can see the wolf-howl spectrograms and hear more sounds from Yellowstone at thecrywolfproject.com. Jeff's full talk is at TED.com. Thank you so much for listening. This episode was produced by Katie Monteleone, Phoebe Lett, and Theo Geeran with help from Matthew Cloutier. It was edited by Sanaz Meshkinpour and me. Our production staff also includes Rachel Faulkner-White.
52:50Our executive producer is Irene Noguchi. Our audio engineer was Carly Strange. Our theme music was written by Ramteen Arablui. Our partners at TED are Sal Khan, Logan McClure-Davda, Helen Walters, Roxanne Hilash, and Daniela Ballarezzo. I'm Manoush Zamorodi, and you have been listening to the TED Radio Hour from NPR.
53:15Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Dataiku Agent Management. Most enterprises can count every device, every login, and every contractor. Almost none can count their AI agents. Take control of your agentic workforce with one view across every platform and tool, showing what's driving revenue, what's drifted, and who signed off on it. Visit Dataiku.com. That's Dataiku.com. This message comes from Angie. Angie has been helping homeowners find skilled pros to get their home projects done well for over 30 years. For everything from minor repairs to major remodels, find reviews, pricing and booking at Angie.com or on the Angie app.