1. Podcasts
  2. The 404 Media Podcast
  3. Can Data Center Development Be Stopped?
The 404 Media Podcast

2 Nov 2026 · 53m · 16 chapters

Episode artwork

Can Data Center Development Be Stopped?

In short

Data center development and the backlash against it—how big tech and allied energy interests respond with secrecy, legal pressure, and “panic” counter-narratives; and how communities can resist via transparency, zoning changes, moratoriums, and alternative visions of land use.

Guests

Kyle Keeler and Nate Ochen, researchers studying community responses and activist history around energy and environmental conflicts, including narrative strategies used by developers.

Key claims

Big tech underestimated local pushback and is using NDAs/secret deals in small towns, plus media/think-tank narratives that frame opposition as “panic” or NIMBYism. These narratives downplay water, electricity, air-quality, and job claims while shifting blame to regulators. Developers also try to reduce community power through utility/political capture and by making projects “critical infrastructure.” A “tech nuclear nexus” links data centers to nuclear expansion arguments, framed as colonial/social-control dynamics.

Notable examples

Meta in Richland Parish (promised benefits, rent increases); hyperscale secrecy in small towns; Delaware River data center and lawsuits over zoning; Easton, Pennsylvania warehouse fight; XAI Mississippi power/air-quality concerns; Google water-use allegations; Fermi (Rick Perry) nuclear project with no compute clients; Texas Amarillo nuclear/water controversy; Heatmap Pro/Heatmap/Shipkey as “intelligence” for developers; Standing Rock as a model for critical-infrastructure policy; Yucca Mountain and Havasupai/Paiute uranium-waste conflicts; Navajo Nation radon cancer impacts.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:09

Community Pushback Stories

Hear stories of communities resisting data center developments and their struggles.

“I've noticed this thing as we're talking about data centers, where there are these two tiers of data center.”
3:06

The Hype Behind Data Centers

Explore the hype surrounding data center projects and their implications.

“The data center on Delaware River is currently suing the township because the township zoning laws don't say that there can't be any data centers.”
6:00

Narratives Around Data Centers

Discuss the narratives being shaped by companies in defense of data centers.

“Not sold one bit of compute or gotten a promise of selling one bit of this compute that's going to be constructed.”
8:01

The Panic Narrative

Analyze the emerging panic narrative surrounding data center development.

“And one's like the nuclear angle and the other's the narrative angle.”
11:01

Key Players in the Narrative

Identify key players influencing narratives around data centers and their development.

“Trust the tech overlords that are in charge of everything.”
14:01

Critique of Think Tanks and Climate Change

Explore how various think tanks downplay climate change and its impacts.

“The Breakthrough Institute loves to do this.”
24:52

Community Resistance to Data Centers

Discussion on the power dynamics and community responses to data center developments.

“They do see a lot of dismissal of the water and the power concerns.”
28:00

Introduction to Heatmap Pro and Its Impact

Learn about Heatmap Pro, a platform for developers to understand local opposition in project planning.

“They have a platform called Heatmap Pro, which developers pay for.”
29:12

Astroturfing vs. Grassroots Movements

Understand the difference between genuine grassroots movements and astroturfing in community organization.

“And at some point in there, when Nate and I originally looked at this, it was just talking about energy development.”
30:20

The Tech-Nuclear Nexus

Explore the collusion between the tech industry and nuclear development, highlighting historical injustices.

“So this brings us, I think, pretty neatly to the history and recent history.”
Show all 16 chapters
32:17

Environmental and Social Impacts of Nuclear Development

Discuss the environmental injustices linked with nuclear waste disposal and its impact on Native communities.

“And you can see that from the extraction side.”
35:09

The Role of Government and Industry in Nuclear Issues

Examine how government policies and industry practices affect nuclear waste management and Native lands.

“And that long history will continue if we do begin this nuclear renaissance.”
38:03

Challenges for Communities Facing Data Centers

Learn about the difficulties communities face when dealing with data center developments and their impacts.

“But with the recent executive orders and the recent gutting of the EPA, it's become even harder to hold these companies accountable, right?”
40:02

Strategies for Community Resistance

Discover effective strategies for communities to resist unwanted developments and build solidarity.

“and it's being fought out in court right now.”
42:00

Community Strategies Against Data Centers

Learn about community strategies to oppose data center developments, including transparency and zoning laws.

“It's this PR guy named Patrick Slevins, who's a NIMBY strategist is what he calls himself.”
46:04

Imagining Alternative Futures

Explore the importance of alternative narratives and community engagement in land use decisions.

“And I mean, during this last warehouse issue in Easton, the coalition that was fighting the warehouse's lawyer said during a roundtable discussion we had, change your zoning laws.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The 404 Media Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00I think it's fair to say that big tech did not expect the data center pushback. These companies that are used to kind of coming in and doing whatever they want, building whatever they want, are now having to answer hard questions about water use, electricity bills, noise. Local municipalities are passing laws to slow down or regulate this stuff all over the country. It's become one of the big political issues going into the midterms of 2026. So to fight that, they're using NDAs, they are signing secret deals in low-population cities, and also they're trying to shape a counter-narrative about why we need data centers and why they need to be built in specific locations and how they're going to power them and how they're going to take care of everybody's worries and concerns.

0:49And the way that they're shaping this counter-narrative is following a pretty familiar playbook. The people who have studied community responses to nuclear energy, to climate change, to the fracking boom in Texas and Oklahoma. They've seen all this before, and they're going to talk with us today about it. I've got researchers, Kyle Keeler and Nate Ochen, and we're going to get real deep into some activist history today on 404 Media. I've noticed this thing as we're talking about data centers, where there are these two tiers of data center. There are the Larry Ellison Oracle Stargate thing, the XAI thing in Mississippi, Google's building theirs, Amazon's building theirs.

1:33A lot of these big tech companies are transparent or more open with where things are being built, what they're doing. But then there's all of these other ones. And it's usually in a town of like 20 ,000 people. Some developer comes to town, the LLC has been set up in the last six months, and you ask them, who's the client for this? Who's going to be using this compute? And they either say they don't know, or they just won't tell you. They'll say it's secret sometimes. And that seems to be most of the data centers that I've encountered, especially the ones in these small towns with big community pushback.

2:08And I'm wondering if you all have seen the same thing. There's one that's been opened up, or that's been planned, right down the road on the Delaware River. They've done something similar to what we see with the hyperscalers, like what we see in Richland Parish, one that just opened up from Meta, where they have the energy company attached. They bought up these hundreds of acres, but it's, pardon the cliche, it's one of those situations where they believe if they build it, they will come. And that's very similar to other development that has met community pushback out here. There are a few warehouses that were planned right in Easton, where Lafayette is, and the community banded together.

2:49The community showed up at all the city council meetings. The community said no. This warehouse wouldn't tell anyone who was going to come in and use it. The assumption was Amazon. Now the community is in a prolonged battle with that warehouse developer because it got voted down, but now the developer is suing the community and the council. The data center on Delaware River is currently suing the township because the township zoning laws don't say that there can't be any data centers. So, you know, this is a situation which I'm sure we'll talk about where these community efforts have to be long term battles because these people have the money, they have the power, they will continue to do everything in their power to fight back against these communities.

3:33I would just add really quick that it's interesting that the history of data center development does not look like the construction of these hyperscale, really massive multiplexes that they're constructing now, like the Hyperion example. We just haven't seen that before. This seems that's rather new. And then as Kyle was saying, it does suggest something as far as if one large hyperscale center is built, what does that mean for the surrounding area? What does that mean for people who live in that place? Is it then all of a sudden sacrificed and it has to become a data center alley or like a large region that's just committed to that technology?

4:07Or what possibilities are available there, including what kind of possibilities for resistance from the community side? If you're talking about like what happens to the community around it, I'm reminded of Michigan where they're building, that's where they're building the Oracle one where Gretchen Whitmer was digging with Larry Ellison. One of the small farming towns around there, in this very heated and emotional data center meeting, kind of admitted that this is probably the end of this community, if this thing comes in. They were already struggling to keep their families in the area and pass farming on from generation to generation.

4:44And this is just basically going to be the nail in the coffin. And a lot of people are taking, people that live in that community are taking huge buyouts and leaving. and it was already a small community. And now if this thing ever actually gets constructed, which is like a whole other part of this, it's just going to be, you know, it'll be another Virginia. It'll be another data center alley, right? Did you hear how this played out in Texas with the Amarillo one? Do you know about this one? No, that's not one that I've been following. This one's really fun because it's another one of those that's like aspirationally, it's the Kevin O 'Leary, it's the, you know, hyperscale, enormous one.

5:21It was a company called Fermi. It was co-founded by Rick Perry. The plan was to build four new nuclear reactors in the desert in West Texas. The big controversy in town was they were going to get their water from Amarillo, and they're going to pay double. Amarillo is already pulling their water from an aquifer that's not looking great. and the person, Toby Neubauer, I believe is his name, the CEO of Fermi, came in and said, we're going to pay you double the going rate. Y 'all can figure out your water concerns elsewhere. Billions of dollars. It has investors. They kind of trust this guy. They've started construction.

5:58They're building out there. Come to find out Fermi has no clients. Not sold one bit of compute or gotten a promise of selling one bit of this compute that's going to be constructed. to anyone. The investors found out and were deeply upset. And he's been removed as CEO because it's this billions and billions of dollars for a project that they can't sell to anybody at the end of the line. And I'm seeing there's this rush to build these GPU warehouses. And then there doesn't seem to be a thought about who's actually going to use the compute. And it's all hype, essentially, in that case. Yeah, it's all speculation.

6:40We see this time and time again with all of these industries, right? Hype will carry the fracking industry. Hype will carry the nuclear renaissance. Hype will carry the green transition, right? And that's where we also see this language of inevitability. These are coming, so you're just going to have to deal with them. And that language of inevitability, whether clients actually show up, creates material realities for these communities that these communities then have to deal with, right? And that's where I think that we have to pay attention to the narratives that continually get trotted out by these companies and who's picking those narratives up and allowing them to run with it.

7:20Right. It's one thing to it's very important to report on what Meta has done in Richland Parish, Louisiana. But then the next day, if the organization that reports on that, New York Times, turns around and provides Mark Zuckerberg a microphone to say that there's a concentration of AI power and he's not a part of it and that's unfair to him, that's a problem. We need to stop letting these people set the narrative and instead allow these communities who are on the ground to set the narrative. They're the ones who are being affected. They're the ones that see the day to day. They're the ones who have to live their lives in the shadow of this.

7:59So there's kind of two big lines of thought I want to walk down with you based on that. And one's like the nuclear angle and the other's the narrative angle. I think I want to chase the narrative angle first. So that's what y 'all are both working on right now. That's the kind of current area of study is we're seeing the counter-narrative around data centers start to take shape. The defense of the data center as a project takes shape. And it's very similar to other counter-narratives that have shaped. And it's also being run by some of the same characters. So who are your favorite characters? And what's the story they're telling?

8:39The first one that we see is just a xenophobia narrative. Either from the standpoint of, we have to do this because China's going to do it, right? Which we saw with oil and gas. We can't decarbonize because then China will beat us. Or if people push back, that's Chinese propaganda, right? You'll see that that's low hanging fruit. We don't have to spend a lot of time on that. Kevin O 'Leary gets on Fox News and screams about that. And it's not worth really paying attention to because it's so out there, right? The other one is economic development. These communities are promised things. Meta gives teachers a$50 ,000 raise in Richland Parish or a $50 ,000 annual bonus, and also everybody's rents go up and people have to move out of the area that they've lived their entire lives, right?

9:26We saw this with the fracking industry. When they moved into the Marcellus Shale region, hundreds of thousands of jobs were promised. By the time people are left with polluted water and water tables, the actual independent academics go in there and take a look at it and they go, these job numbers were overinflated by over 100%, at, right? The two most interesting ones that Nate and I have been seeing are this idea that these communities are NIMBY, made up of a bunch of NIMBYs, and also this narrative of panic, which is the one that we've seen rolled out in the last probably two to three months.

9:57In July, it really hit its zenith, or June and July, it really hit its zenith. So Nate, I don't know which one of those you want to dig in on, but go for it. Give me panic. Yeah, panic. Exactly, right? panic and we hear that and then the emotional response should be oh well then people are just crazy and we need to set them aside they don't have valid points but yes we've been very interested in that question to panic um kyle and i have traced it back to at least 2023 when we started to see it circulate a little bit online but really this last year it's taken off and within that right it's just a dismissive move to say essentially those the injustices that that could be could be created by data centers are not valid and that the world shouldn't worry about them Kyle and I read that really, though, as fear about the fact that there's so much public opposition to this development in the first place and really an effort to exert this kind of meta narrative template over everything and suggest that, no, what's going on right now in this country is totally fine.

10:57Keep moving forward. Keep building in the mouth. Everything's going to be OK. Trust the economic systems. Right. Trust the tech overlords that are in charge of everything. and it'll all be fine back to that kind of eco-modernist thinking that we're hearing. But we're seeing a lot of different narrative threads emerge within that discussion and discourse of panic, things like dismissing water consumption and saying, well, actually, data centers don't really use that much water. But oftentimes, those types of comparisons are built around these really inaccurate projections, saying something like running, you know, like a small amount of water, which was still like 800 million gallons, which could be used to irrigate farmland, right, or is typically used to irrigate something like a golf course.

11:43So we hear that often. There's also a similar discussion about electricity and downplaying electricity consumption. Oftentimes, what people are pointing to in these narratives of saying things like, well, it's really the state's fault. It's the regulatory apparatuses that are failing us. It's not the data centers in the first place. And often those are drawn upon comparisons between different states like critiques of California and New York, for instance, as being these states that do a very poor job regulating electricity and then looking at places like Texas, which apparently have a better system in place.

12:15And then finally, we see jobs, the job discussion come up, which is fascinating because there isn't data to suggest or support that artificial intelligence, Gen. AI in particular, is going to support job growth. And they often acknowledge that, but they still say, like, listen, at the end of the day, it seems like it's going to be something that's beneficial for jobs. So it's interesting to see this meta-narrative that's being exerted over on the top of everything right now, and quite concerning because it's ultimately dismissive of these very real, very valid, we know all these concerns, right?

12:48These are well-documented. Academics have written about this. They're not engaging with the academic literature at all. And so it's interesting to see how these things are circulated. And there are, as you suggested, Matthew and Kyle, you hinted to, these kind of key players that are involved in all of this right now. Yeah. And to build off that, Nate, I think what we were originally seeing was water panic in relation to data centers around 2023, right? But then over the last couple months, it is just data center panic. And the data center panic language, the first place that we saw that, correct me if I'm wrong, Nate, was a publication called The Daily Economy, which you do a little bit of Googling from The Daily Economy, you find out it's the American Institute for Economic Research, which is based in Great Barrington, Massachusetts, which is known for the Great Barrington Declaration, which was essentially calling COVID a panic, right?

13:43So these people are very well versed in taking these large issues that are very harmful to people, especially the most vulnerable among us, and saying, this is a panic. You need to stop worrying about it. It's also got a few of the major players in calling climate change a panic and telling people to calm down about climate change, right? The Breakthrough Institute loves to do this. They were one of the first organizations to say that the government should be subsidizing gas fracking because gas is natural. That's a PR term too. One of their co-founders, Ted Nordhaus, another guy named Michael Schellenberger is also a co-founder.

14:19Michael Schellenberger is a total crank. Ted Nordhaus still works for the Breakthrough Institute and is their president, has been known to call climate change more like diabetes than cancer. So downplaying the material effects of climate change on communities, their deputy director Alex Trembath is a guy who has written about mining, saying mining only takes up small areas of the earth. I'm not sure why we're worried about it. Well, because people live there, Alex, and maybe they have something to say about it. The other thing that they like to do, any of these think tanks, right? The American Institute for Economic Research is part of the Atlas Network.

14:57They've got a big group of free market think tanks, including this Alliance for responsible citizenship, which is Jordan Peterson's think tank, which Michael Schellenberger always gives the keynote at every year. They really like to push for deregulation, generally, across the board, right? Which would be very helpful to the data center industry, whether it's this nuclear energy, whether it's all the gas generators that are going to power these smaller data centers or the hyperscalers, right? Like you said, Matthew, we'll get into the nuclear stuff, but there's a question of whether or not that's ever actually going to be rolled out.

15:33And if it is, they'll ever shut those gas power generators down, right? And then probably the last one, the person who's usually referenced the most in these panic articles is a guy named Andy Masley, who's a former high school physics teacher and now writes articles through a grant funded by Coefficient Giving, which is an effective altruist charity organization run by Dustin Moskovitz, who's a Facebook co-founder, right? So all of these circular citational networks from people who are non-experts in any given environmental field saying that this is a panic and that it shouldn't, it's not something to be worried about, right?

16:15Ted Nordhaus is a political pollster, Michael Schellenberger is a PR guy. Andy Massey is a guy with a bachelor's in physics who regularly looks at unpeer-reviewed papers as the gold standard of research pointing out the issues with data centers. Masley famously is the one that caught the error in Empire of AI. Yes. Right? The decimal place was wrong. I mean, he wasn't incorrect in that assessment, and the author acknowledged it, and they've taken time to edit the book, correct? Mm-hmm. So I know what the answer to this question is, but does Masley have any kind of point then about water and AI?

16:58Pointing out that issue with Karen Howe's book does make sense, right? She made an error. But what that does is it allows us to completely shift focus from everything else that Karen Howe pointed out about the levers of power at play in AI, right? About the human rights abuses in training AI models that you all at 404 have done such an awesome job covering. And it focuses on this one issue, which then gets repeated. There was just a YouTube video put out by The Hill and Robbie Suave, who's a writer at Reason Magazine, again, pumps out a lot of data center panic articles, always has Ted Nordhaus on their podcast, right?

17:39It has the abundance characters on their podcast, where they had a research fellow from the Bitcoin Policy Institute to talk about how it's a panic, as if the Bitcoin Policy Institute would not benefit from more data centers, where they focused on Karen Howe's book, but only that one point. right? The other thing that they don't do that Andy Masley won't do is yes, you figured out one Aaron Karen Howell's book. There are a multitude of books and there's a multitude of research out there about the environmental issues with AI. We don't tend to focus on those and we tend to act like they don't exist.

18:16Kate Crawford's Atlas of AI, for example, I have not heard a critique of that excellent book from any of these corners of the internet. The thing that Masley really likes to do is point out this data and then present it in such a way to make it look as if it's not a big deal or present it in such a way to make it look as if these issues do not matter to the communities who are being affected, right? But there's always a seat at the table for someone who's going to suck up to power and who's going to do their work for them. We see it with Barry Weiss running CBS News right now, right? I don't think that I'm going out on a limb here to say that Andy Masley is pretty much the Barry Weiss of data centers and AI.

18:56There's no real skill there. There's no real expertise there. But there is the ability to suck up to power and say what people in power want you to say and act as if these systems of power don't force themselves onto communities and fundamentally change the way that people are going to have to live their lives. This message is sponsored by Raycon. It's almost Black Friday. And this year, the decision is easy because you can get up to 50 % off site-wide Pet Raycon. No overthinking it. My go-to is Raycon's Everyday Earbuds. Whether I'm listening to music while I get things done or catching a podcast while walking my dog, they're always in my daily rotation.

19:32It's phone, keys, wallet, and my Raycons. The noise cancellation lets me block out daily distractions and really lock in whether I'm tackling my to-do list or just want something quiet. Great sound, all-day comfort, easiest yes of the season. You also get multi-point connectivity, so you can pair with two devices at once. That's really important if you're going between a laptop and a phone or the phone and a desktop, that sort of thing. There's up to 32 hours of battery life in the case, and a 10-minute quick charge gives you 90 minutes of playtime. And when you need to hear what's going on around you, which I do when I'm walking around LA, awareness mode lets you listen to things that are going around you while you're listening to music or a podcast.

20:14I really have been using these everyday earbuds basically every day for the last few years and I really like them. Go to buyraycon.com slash 404 to get up to 50 % off site-wide during Raycon's Black Friday sales. That's buyraycon.com slash 404 to get up to 50 % off site-wide during Raycon's Black Friday sales. Thanks Raycon for sponsoring. This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. If you could permanently delete just one thing from your brain. Just one thing that's taking up too much mental space. What would it be? Maybe it's some awkward interaction from childhood. I had a lot of stuff that happened when I was a kid that's so embarrassing and so profoundly terrible that I'll just be walking down the street and boom, it pops into my brain.

20:57It's like this horrible and truthful thought that I don't want around anymore. Well, if you need someone to talk to about that kind of thing, BetterHelp is there. Insurance options may now be available nationwide with BetterHelp. With insurance, Many members pay$15 or less. Some pay$0. They have quality therapists, BetterHelp's therapists. They are licensed. They are experienced. They have at least three years in the field and 1 ,000 hours of on-hands experience. They've got all of the required education and certifications. And now, BetterHelp is now in network with more than 125 health plans with many co-pays as low as$15 for eligible members.

21:39And if you don't have eligible insurance or live outside the U.S., you can still get 20 % off your first month. So sign up and get 20 % off at BetterHelp.com slash 404media. That's B-E-T-T-E-R-H-E-L-P dot com slash 404media. Wait until the holidays is a reasonable response when someone asks for a game console. It's a less compelling reason to keep paying a phone bill you're already annoyed about. Mint Mobile's holiday deal is available right now. All of their plans are$15 a month for the initial plan term. I've been using Mint Mobile for about a year now. And the only thing I've noticed is that my wireless bill is a lot cheaper than it used to be.

22:21And I don't worry about it nearly as much. All plans include high-speed data and unlimited talk and text on the nation's largest 5G network. You can bring your current phone and your number too, so you don't have to turn saving money into a whole new phone project. Sign up online and choose a 3-, 6-, or 12-month plan paid upfront. That's one recurring monthly bill so you can stop thinking about for a while. So what are you waiting for? To get your new wireless plan for$15 a month, go to mintmobile.com.json. That's mintmobile.com.json. Cut your wireless bill to$15 a month at mintmobile.com.json.

23:00Limited time offer, upfront payment of$45 for three months,$90 for six months, or$180 for 12-month plan, plan required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra, initial plan term only, greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy, capable device required, availability, speed, and coverage varies. CementMobile.com. Holiday shopping gets a lot easier when you stop trying to find the most surprising object anyone has ever unwrapped. A really good sweater can have a much longer useful life than whatever novelty thing seemed funny at midnight the day before Christmas. Quince makes the kind of staples people can keep reaching for.

23:40100 % Mongolian cashmere, wool outerwear, premium down jackets, and Italian leather. Their cashmere sweaters start at just$60. I am wearing Quince trainers right now. I love these shoes. I wear them almost every day. They look nice at dinner, but they're also really good for traveling, walking long distances, all that sort of thing. I have Quince t-shirts, I have Quince linen, I have shorts, pants, you name it. Everything at Quince is priced 50 % to 80 % less than similar brands. They work directly with ethical factories and cut out the middlemen, which helps keep those prices down. And if your list extends beyond sweaters, they also have fine jewelry, leather bags, hotel quality bedding, chef grade cookware and luggage.

24:21I have Quince bedsheets, a Quince rug. I say this almost every week, but every time I talk, I basically get a new Quince thing. I have Quince socks. I have Quince shoes. So give the gift of quality this holiday season. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns now available in Canada and the UK too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know it was the 404 Media Podcast. It's the best way to support our show. They do see a lot of dismissal of the water and the power concerns. But it does not take very long for me to learn that it's a lot harder to build a power plant than it is a data center.

25:05It's a lot harder to get one online. And that the shortcut that's being taken, as you mentioned earlier, is, well, we'll just make gas turbines. We can have those ready in a couple years and we'll get them on there. And, you know, where you have gas turbines placed, like in Mississippi on the XAI, not great for air quality out there. And there's also, Google has been caught lying about its water use on some of its data centers, I believe. And there's people that live next to data centers in Georgia that have problems with their water pressure, their water quality. So it's not as if there is not real things happening in the communities around these places that give people reason to be upset.

25:46Material and immaterial, right? Material and immaterial, yeah. When you say immaterial, what do you mean? One of the things that Kyle and I have been talking about, looking into, is just the way that data center development and AI development in general, it works by stripping power away from communities. So if we see, for instance, the privatization of utility companies, people no longer have a say in their local utilities. You could argue whether or not they had a say in setting prices before, but once they become privatized, they certainly do not after that point. Also, we're seeing like it's rather easy in some instances for local politicians to be voted out and then to be replaced with the people who are going to do the bidding of whoever wants to come in and do that kind of development.

26:30And so that's another another reality. But it seems like it's getting harder and harder for everyday folks to push back in some settings, some situations. And what we're seeing is really an effort to try to consolidate power and make it more difficult for that kind of resistance to take place, especially across different communities, which is something that we're very interested in. Is that true, though? Because I feel like I'm seeing this massive pushback at the community level against these data centers. There is organization going on. These communities are talking to each other, and they're organizing, and they're learning the different techniques that will stall and will remove these things.

27:11I think that's absolutely true. But I think that the effort coming from the tech developers is to try to, as much as possible, chip away at the ability of everyday people to make those kind of decisions and to really function in a democratic way. That seems to be the strategy, at least, or one of the strategies. And what we're also seeing in our research are not just these narrative constructions of this being a panic, right, to push back against what is a growing movement, right, but also some tech-based platforms to help developers kind of weasel their way into communities, right? The one that we found during our past research that we're still talking about is the organization or the news organization Heatmap Pro, which is ostensibly an environmental publication, or Heatmap.

28:11They have a platform called Heatmap Pro, which developers pay for. And then actually, I'll pull up their website right here and read from it. I've got it pulled up right here. Local opposition is the number one threat to your project pipeline, permitting battles, zoning moratoriums, unruly county board meetings. Grid expansion is moving fast, but local resistance is moving faster. Developers, investors, and advocates are losing projects, not because of bad economics, but because of bad local intelligence. Heatmap Pro is the premier intelligence platform for community-supported development, Built by the team behind Heatmap News, named Adweek's hottest sustainability media brand, and winner of 2025 National Magazine Award for Service Journalism, Pro brings together expert journalism with predictive analytics and proprietary data.

28:59So yeah, it is a local news map about hyperscalers and energy companies that visualizes resistance and risk at a local level. That is fascinating. I had not heard of this. Yeah. And at some point in there, when Nate and I originally looked at this, it was just talking about energy development. Then once we published our paper, I went back and looked at it, they had added data centers. And it says somewhere on there on that web page that it will help you create a grassroots movement. That's not a grassroots movement. That's called astroturfing. But that's run by a journalist, Robinson Meyer. He worked at The Atlantic.

29:43Then he founded Heatmap. He runs a podcast called Shipkey with Jesse Jenkins, who used to work at the Breakthrough Institute. And they're very closely tied to the Breakthrough Institute. They're very closely tied to the Abundance Agenda. there's not really a technological fix that the Shipkey podcast will not cover in a positive manner. They've talked a lot about carbon capture, which all of the research on carbon capture says that it's greenwashing, right? Carbon capture is not going to work. It's something that's been talked about by data center developers, that they will, you know, offset their carbon by carbon capture.

30:20Again, with Heatmap Pro, we begin to see kind of this circular group of folks, whether it's in the media or whether it's in the think tank sphere or whether it's in the development sphere, who are all kind of working together to create these narratives about what kind of future they think we should have and they want you to think we should have, which fundamentally takes away from a collective future that these communities might imagine together or that we might all imagine together that's outside of this technological development. So this brings us, I think, pretty neatly to the history and recent history.

30:59The first paper I read from y 'all was about the kind of the intersection of all of this stuff with nuclear energy, because we've seen a lot of this, a lot of these techniques and a lot of these arguments before. and now, hey, we're living in a nuclear renaissance. Tell me about this first paper. Absolutely. So the idea, right, is that, oh, building all the data centers, you have to have a way to power them. So the only way to actually get enough energy and reliable energy is through nuclear development. And so Kyle and I were interested in exploring the connections there between the development of data centers and then also of the growth, the supposed growth of the nuclear industry, what we're calling the tech nuclear nexus.

31:43And really the collusion there between energy companies on one hand and then big tech companies on the other. And we could also incorporate and wrap up the federal government, too, as a part of that project. Which is essentially what we're arguing. We're saying, listen, this kind of collusion between industry and government is an example of settler colonialism. It is essentially perpetuating this project of destroying to replace, destroying Native communities and also non-Native communities, and then seeking to install these other forms of social control in their place. And so that's what we're essentially arguing in that paper.

32:19And you can see that from the extraction side. So you can see it from mining uranium that could be needed to support nuclear development. That's not even getting into the weeds about why nuclear is a bad idea and why it's complicated. but like you see that from the extraction side all the way up to the disposal of nuclear waste which also ends up back on native lands and so we're pointing out that these are systems that are essentially built on colonial logics and colonial ways of thinking and that they also then perpetuate all of these environmental social injustices where do we put our waste our nuclear waste from our power plants currently and where are we going to put the nuclear waste from the power plants that we plan to build?

33:01We have no idea, right? What nuclear propagandists with the Breakthrough Institute will tell you is it'll be stored in dried casks. They'll put it right outside of the nuclear power plants and then don't worry about it. They've also talked about shooting it down into the core of the earth and then not worrying about it again. Most of these nuclear plants are on fault lines, right? Because they also need a massive amount of water to cool. So again, we're getting back to the water question, right, if this nuclear development actually is rolled out. So when those fault lines become active, that's going to cause an issue with this dry cask storage, as it's called, right?

33:41They're trying to open up nuclear depositories and repositories. Yucca Mountain was recently the one that everyone talked about probably about 20 years ago. That project was shut down. Breakthrough Institute wants to continually bring Yucca Mountain back. That's a mountain that's sacred to the Paiute peoples, right? They fought that for a reason. They don't want nuclear waste. They don't want their homes to be dumping grounds because historically native communities have been dumping grounds for nuclear waste. And native communities are also the communities where the majority of uranium is held in the United States, right?

34:15This is because those communities were removed from their homelands to these areas where uranium is. And when they were removed, those areas were viewed as wastelands where nothing was. And then what you know it, They found uranium there and the federal government in partnership with private industry wanted to go back and get that uranium. They promised, most famously, the Navajo Nation that they were immune to radon related cancers, especially lung cancer. Then decades later, Navajo Nation has a radon based cancer rate that's around 50 times higher than national average. And this is to say nothing about the other radioactive and uranium-tainted diseases that Navajo Nation still lives with, like Navajo neuropathy, which is a birth defect caused by pregnant women ingesting uranium-contaminated water, right?

35:08So these are, I know you asked about the waste issue, Matthew, but I wanted to make sure that I touched on the fact that there's a long history here that's generally not discussed when we discuss nuclear power. And that long history will continue if we do begin this nuclear renaissance. It's already started on Havasupai land. We used to have a cabinet level position in the country, nuclear waste negotiator. Have you all heard of this? Do you know about this? There were only two of them. There was one under Bush Sr. and then one under Clinton. The one under Bush Sr. got into a lot of trouble. You can probably guess where he wanted to bury the nuclear waste and whose communities he was attempting to negotiate with.

35:47And he gave a speech in 1991 before the National Congress of Native Americans, or American Indians, National Congress of American Indians. And he said, basically, like, you people are good at this. You've got a long history of, you know, being good at land stewardship. quote, with atomic facilities designed to safely hold radioactive materials with half-lives of thousands of years, it is the Native American culture and perspective that is best designed to correctly consider and balance the benefits and burdens of these proposals. I find that really striking, and I think really speaks to what you're talking about.

36:23There is this kind of like bizarre inborn racism on the part of the people doing the negotiation for nuclear waste. And it's this other thing where no one wants the waste. No one wants the waste. And they almost always win the fight to not have the waste. And so what ends up happening, as you said, is it gets mixed with concrete and then stored into a pillar right outside of a nuclear power plant. And that's kind of the solution we've got right now, right? because there is a long history of companies that are in charge of nuclear issues not being great with how they steward these things and maybe not being super safe.

37:01And I worry now, as we're in this nuclear renaissance, that we are going to cut even more corners if we even actually build out this nuclear capacity. And we will because the, again, think tanks who have been pushing this nuclear renaissance for the last 20 years are some of those same ones that I spoke about wanting total deregulation. If they get their way, it's just going to be open season on native lands. There's already the pinion plane mine reopened on Havasupai land. That uranium is transported through Navajo Nation, which breaks agreements between Navajo Nation and the federal government about uranium transportation.

37:39And then it gets refined at White Mesa Mill that's also on native land. So at every step in the process, That's what happens. And that's going to continue to happen because, especially given the federal government that we have right now, it's going to be all of these industries will be totally deregulated and the EPA has been gutted in such a way that there will be no recourse once something takes place, right? What I'll also say is, whether it's data centers or these nuclear issues, part of the importance of developing strong communities throughout these histories is so that they can push back when these industries are cited in their towns, right?

38:19But with the recent executive orders and the recent gutting of the EPA, it's become even harder to hold these companies accountable, right? If we look at Cancer Alley in Louisiana, they used to measure the emissions and the pollution in their communities with relatively cheap devices. Those devices are no longer admissible in court. So if that's taking place there, the exact same thing is going to happen where these data centers are. The exact same thing is going to happen where this nuclear extraction and this nuclear waste is cited. Why aren't they admissible in court? They're quote unquote, not strong enough.

38:56They've always been strong enough. You can show the data that you need to show this pollution caused these health outcomes in these communities, but it's a handout to industry from our current federal government and this administration because they know that that has worked. When you say it's not strong enough, you mean it's not good enough evidence? That's what they're saying now, as of the last year. Yeah, so this is also why it's so important to make sure that whether it's a data center or anything else is not cited in these communities because once it's there, the community has fewer and fewer avenues to fight back.

39:29And that's why communities don't just need to band together where they're at, but as you pointed out, work together and form cross-community networks of solidarity, not just at the data center sites, but I would argue at the site of this uranium extraction, at an environmental, communities who have experienced environmental injustice already, such as Cancer Alley in Louisiana, because these are the same levers and systems of power and groups of people who have committed these injustices on those people for decades. Last week, I believe, as we're talking, and it's being fought out in court right now.

40:05We'll see what happens. The EPA has basically given power generation connected exclusively to a data center and not part of the grid, a carve-out to not be part of the Clean Air Act, meaning that these gas turbines can just kind of belch and do whatever they want as long as they aren't connected to the wider grid and are just connected to a data center, which would be kind of like a get-out-of-jail-free card for the XAI Center in Mississippi that has many of its turbines across the border. Okay, setting that aside, What do you see that's working with communities? What has worked in the past? Because you've talked about how a lot of this stuff is very similar to fights against nuclear power and these warehouse fights that you've seen, these kind of warehouses built on spec.

40:47What works at a community level? How do you stall these things? How do people actually make sure that they don't get built if that's what their community wants? And what do you do about the narrative poison that's in the air? throughout the history of environmental justice organizing, it is strong communities and strong community communication, right? If you have a strong community, if you speak to your neighbors, if you've built the relationships that are necessary to have a strong community before this rolls in, that's where the organizing begins, right? This is the only way that you resist this power is to have a strong community and strong relational lines amongst that community.

41:28It takes a lot of time to look at everything that these organizations are doing, especially when one comes to your community. For example, the data center that's right up the road from us, we got a text message two weeks ago. I think I sent it to you, Nate. It was from the Critical Infrastructure Project. And it said, these data centers power your YouTube. They power your email, all of the different PR language. You click on it, you go to it. It's just a bunch of AI slop writing. And then you look it up. It's this PR guy named Patrick Slevins, who's a NIMBY strategist is what he calls himself.

42:09And he's written a bunch of books about NIMBYs and how to beat them. They're all AI generated, by the way. He just tosses out AI stuff. But you need to have those networks of community communication and ways to discuss with one another when this PR comes to town too, is what I'm getting at, right? Because like I said, I wanted to build on something that I said earlier. Not only once these data centers, once these projects get cited in communities, not only is it much harder to fight them in court, but it's much harder to fight them through protest as well because of the way that critical infrastructure is protected after the first Trump administration and the way that terrorism charges are leveled against protesters when they speak out against what is deemed critical infrastructure.

42:53with data centers being deemed critical infrastructure now, that makes this that much harder. But we can look to the successful organizing at Standing Rock for the reason why that critical infrastructure legislation is in place, right? So having this pushback across history and looking at what was successful when other polluting industries come to town can strengthen communities in the present? I think there are two key pieces that are probably less commented on as far as from the things communities could use to productively push back against this kind of development. One, I think, is finding ways to achieve greater data transparency and just information transparency in the first place.

43:41Some of that comes down to just local city representatives and leaders and whether they are able to get that information from the companies that are proposing the data centers in the first place. But I think that the more information that can be shared, the better kind of decisions you can make as a community. This is part of the challenge where I think a lot of people have addressed and have at least acknowledged that. It's also part of the problem when it comes to actually reporting on these issues. Right, Matthew, I'm sure you're very familiar with this. And also just talking about the problems of water consumption, electricity consumption, the fact that that information is not forthcoming.

44:15So that's like one thing that comes to mind. If there are ways that communities can push on those levers and basically get more data in the first place and dampen the amount of misinformation, that kind of noise that's coming at them. The other thing that Kyle and I have talked a decent amount about, came up both in that article that we wrote and then some of our current thinking, is just the need for alternative narratives. The folks who are perpetuating discussions about panic, right, they in many ways lack the ability to see different kinds of futures. For them, the future is still an extractivist, colonial, capitalist one, and that's the only way that we can move ahead.

44:54And Kyle and I are really interested in types of opposition that propose different ways of thinking about land use. Is the best use of land to, you know, for example, to take two acres of agricultural land out of production, even if it's still problematically like being used at an industrial scale. But like, is that the solution to take it out of production and build a warehouse on it that can then you could fill with computer equipment? Is that really the best thing? And then also, I think other questions for us include things like wealth equality. Like, what would the world look like if, you know, wealth was evenly shared among different groups?

45:30What kinds of alternative narratives can come out of that? So for us, part of this is also like a lack of imagination and ability to think about that. But it's also a strategy, too. We're recognizing that people who are perpetuating this discourse of panic and development are really interested in just steering the boat on that one track and keeping everyone's eyes focused on that. And so community opposition maybe gives us the chance to think about different kinds of narratives, different kinds of futures that are actually could get us out of that rut, get us out of that mess. Moratoriums seem to work.

46:05Yeah, moratoriums. And I mean, during this last warehouse issue in Easton, the coalition that was fighting the warehouse's lawyer said during a roundtable discussion we had, change your zoning laws. So before these come to town, start pushing on that moratorium and start changing those zoning laws. These companies that move in are, of course, then going to sue. But when they start suing and they start that legal battle, that gives time to start looking into all of that information, making those records requests that Nate was talking about and starting to get that data and that transparency out there.

46:45Because now you know who's coming to town and what their plans are. The zoning one is very interesting because that's reporting on stuff that was happening in Kansas this week. I don't know if y 'all saw where the person was arrested for clapping during the city commission meeting. And that was all a zoning meeting. I talked to them for a while and they told me that it's going to be like 35 steps before this thing is built. And right now they're on step five and it is all just around zoning. It's getting things like basically agricultural land rezone into industrial land. It's all this prairie land out there in Kansas that's being rezoned industrial.

47:18If you throw a ridge into one of those, just takes one or two of those places and it kind of brings the whole thing shuttering to a halt. Maybe for long enough for the speculative bubble that it is perhaps around all of this to pop and for the winds to shift. Yeah. When we think of agricultural land and even some of the PR framing frames it as, well, there's enough land or don't you understand that industrial agriculture is bad for the environment too? Which of course we do. There's mountains of research on that, right, in our field, we're well aware. But what would the community like to do with that land that's already zoned agriculturally, right?

47:55Could the community create a community farm? Could they provide for one another with that land, right? Does it necessarily have to be industrial agriculture? Have we asked the community what they would like to do with that land, right? As opposed to, hey, this is the future, get out of the way. And that anyone that stands in their way is told by these people on the internet who have never been to the community, have never discussed with anyone there, hey, what you're doing is bad for the environment too. Industrial agriculture is a poor use of land. Right? I think that, like Nate was saying, this is partly a crisis of imagination and a crisis of narrative and a crisis of an inability to think differently about our collective futures.

48:37And agriculture is one of the best ways that I can think of to start imagining an environmentally just future because we all have to eat. We all come together and build relations around food. So creating that food from the ground up and becoming a community alongside that food is a real way to start imagining different futures that don't have anything to do with what Sam Altman and Elon Musk think. I think that's a really beautiful last word to go out on. Most of my podcasts end very depressingly. So I will take a non-down note ending for once. If that is all right with the both of you. Yes, that's totally fine with me.

49:17Love it. Where should people look to read your research? And do you have any idea when the next paper is coming out? We both have personal websites. I think we both are on LinkedIn. Both of our websites are just our names.com, right? Yeah. Yeah, pretty straightforward. And then as far as timeline on the paper, who knows at this point, it'd be great to have something come out in the fall. But Kyle and I are, you know, we chip away at these things. Part of the reason, and we don't need to go down this route, but part of the reason we published the last piece is because we had difficulties getting traction in some of the more popular publications.

49:51We pitched it to a whole range of popular pubs and there was no interest expressed in it. And so we're like, we're just going to write this thing up as an academic piece, send it off to one of the top geography journals, and they accepted it. And it was a very straightforward system. But that's something else to get into at another time. We really want to dig into that. Right. And that's also why we're so appreciative of you all, 404, having this discussion, right? Because I think that part of this lack of imagination, part of this crisis of imagining different futures is because these stories aren't discussed and these stories aren't told.

50:26and the work that you all do, telling these stories, poking holes in everything that's happening out there right now, and then kind of sitting here, the three of us imagining what a different future might look like, I think is really, really, really important. And it's something that the general public needs to hear and think about a lot more. A better world is possible if you will only dream it. It's the first step. Yep. Yep. Thank you both so much for coming on to the 404 Media Podcast. Thank you, Matthew. Thanks, Matthew.

51:26And another way to support us is to leave a five-star review. It really does help people discover the show. Or, you know, you can just tell someone you liked it and send them a link. This has been 404 Media. We will see you again very, very soon.

From the publisher

Big tech didn’t expect the community pushback around data centers. Developers accustomed to building whatever they want with minimal oversight are facing hard questions about land use, water rights, electricity bills, and noise. To push back on local activism, data center builders are using an old playbook pioneered by the nuclear power and oil industry.

On this episode of the 404 Media podcast, Kyle Keeler and Nate Otjen talk with Matthew about how big tech is trying to take control of the narrative around data centers. Keeler is a professor of environmental sciences and studies at Lafayette College. Otjen is a professor of sustainability and environmental studies at Ramapo College.

Youtube Version: https://youtu.be/hK_aIf9GEd4

Subscribe at 404media.co
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from The 404 Media Podcast

All episodes