The Big Madueke Debate (and More Transfer Nonsense)

10 Jul 2025 · 1 h 16 min · 32 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Arsenal Vision Post-Match Podcast episode focused on the “Nani Madueke debate” amid transfer rumors, plus broader “transfer nonsense.” They discuss why fans are reacting strongly, the football case for Madueke (direct wide threat, transition energy, low-block breaking), and the cost/“Chelsea factor” and opportunity-cost arguments versus other targets like Victor Osimhen? (not mentioned) and specifically Eberechi Eze and Viktor Gyokeres, plus Rodrigo. They also briefly note Christian Nørgaard’s signing and other transfer/club news.

Guests/backgrounds

Elliot Smith (host; Arsenal Vision; runs transfer-related content and mentions Patreon/Transfer Daily). Phil Costa (co-host; “you look swole” banter; argues squad-building, price logic, and process). Clive (co-host; tactical/energy-focused analysis; emphasizes needing multiple wide profiles and squad depth; discusses UEFA/financial constraints for Chelsea). No other guests are clearly identified in the transcript.

Key claims

Madueke’s awkward mechanics don’t negate elite directness: 95th percentile progressive carries and 98th percentile carries into the box; compared to Salah-style shot zones and “relentless” threat. Reaction is driven by Chelsea rivalry, reported fees (around £50m), timing, and opportunity cost (fans wanted Eze/Gyokeres/Rodrigo). Fan sentiment shouldn’t decide transfers; it changes after early performances.

Notable examples

Chelsea past Arsenal signings (Willian, Sterling, Havertz, etc.) used as “Chelsea strand” context; Wolves/Southampton goal split (Madueke’s five goals vs those teams); Salah/Saka analogies for cutting inside and shooting angles; UEFA registration constraints mentioned as a reason Chelsea must sell.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Nani Meduake Merchandise Announcement

1:30 to 2:19

Discussion about new merchandise related to Nani Meduake and Arsenal's transfer history.

“Rice Trousa Saga Herder guard, white Ho-ho!”

Analyzing Nani Meduake's Transfer Links

2:19 to 3:21

Exploration of the potential transfer of Nani Meduake, including excitement and various perspectives.

“the way people are reacting to the rumors of us being linked to a pretty talented and somewhat interesting 23-year-old player.”

Introducing Phil Costa

3:21 to 4:50

Phil Costa joins the discussion, providing insights and humor about transfers and recent player performances.

“You can use code AVP50 and get 50 % off your first month and realize that more Clive, more Tim, more Paul, more Phil, and a tolerable volume of me is something you need in your life.”

Barber Talk and Transfer Daily Insights

4:50 to 5:52

Casual banter about haircuts leads into a discussion about the Transfer Daily and player analysis.

“You can check out that episode if you haven't listened to it already.”

Fan Reactions to Nani Meduake Links

5:52 to 7:40

Discussion on the intense fan reactions regarding the potential signing of Nani Meduake and the historical context.

“I talk to other human beings who aren't just faceless trolls on the internet.”

In-Depth Analysis of Nani Meduake

7:40 to 13:20

Detailed analysis of Nani Meduake's playing style, metrics, and potential fit for Arsenal.

“just in the last few years, we can all talk about Willian, even though he paid himself off, it was an expensive mistake, up to a point.”

Closing Remarks on Player Evaluation

13:20 to 14:00

Wrap-up discussion evaluating the necessity of energy and directness in potential player signings.

“You want to add on to Phil's excellent description of Nani Madweke as Mohamed Salah in Mark II?”

The Importance of Energy in Transfers

14:00 to 15:10

Discusses the significance of relentless energy in players and how it impacts the team's performance.

“and you save your energies when you transition.”

Analyzing Player Contributions and Profiles

15:10 to 17:00

Explores the need for diverse player profiles to enhance team dynamics and address competition demands.

“We played 58 games, we knocked out the FA Cup in the third round, so we could easily top 60 games.”

Evaluating Noni Madueke's Potential

17:00 to 20:20

Delves into Noni Madueke's statistical performance and his potential role in the squad.

“and we're one goal up and we need to have a transition ability, I am all for it.”
Show all 32 chapters

Concerns Over Backup Options

20:20 to 22:30

Discusses the implications of relying on backups and the necessity of solidifying forward options.

“We haven't used a left footer off the left.”

Strategic Squad Planning

22:30 to 25:00

Examines the importance of strategic planning in building a resilient squad capable of competing.

Tactical Evolution in Football

25:00 to 28:03

Looks into the tactical changes required for the team to adapt and evolve in modern football.

“And is this the thing to do instead of the other options?”

Assessing Arsenal's Transfer Strategy

28:03 to 29:53

Explore the dynamics of Arsenal's transfer negotiations and strategic decisions.

Chelsea's Financial Constraints and Arsenal's Opportunities

29:53 to 31:36

Discuss Chelsea's financial situation and how it impacts Arsenal's transfer market strategy.

“A few things, because with Chelsea, I think we should point out, Chelsea have been disciplined by UEFA.”

Evaluating the Potential of Nani Madueke

31:36 to 34:06

Analyze Nani Madueke's potential fit and impact on Arsenal's squad.

“sooner because we got to integrate them.”

The Influence of Mikel Arteta on Transfers

34:06 to 37:51

Examine Mikel Arteta's role and influence in Arsenal's player recruitment process.

“and it's about Mikel Arteta I want to ask you two questions about Mikel and I don't want to ask them in a loaded way but I think they should be asked one, he is, it is reported really driving the ship on this signing.”

Collaborative Decision-Making in Player Signings

37:51 to 42:00

Discuss the importance of collaborative decision-making in Arsenal's transfer strategy.

“We know that's clearly happening here because I don't think Mikel Arteta's first choice, as you rightly point out, is Victor Jokeres.”

Assessing Fan Sentiment and Player Value

42:00 to 44:25

Discussion on the impact of fan sentiment on player acquisitions and the value of potential signings.

“Should it matter that fans really want Eze and would love it?”

Coaching Changes and Their Implications

46:12 to 49:49

Discussion about coaching changes, focusing on Heinze and Cuesta's impact on Arsenal's dynamics.

“Just watch the YouTube comps of him going nuts on the touchline.”

Evaluating Norgaard's Role in Midfield

49:49 to 51:42

Analysis of Christian Norgaard's potential contributions and fit within Arsenal's midfield.

“One of those things that if you go too deep talking about it, you're well out of your depth in terms of what information is even available to you.”

The Importance of Experience in Midfield

51:42 to 56:00

The discussion emphasizes the value of experienced players like Norgaard to support younger talents.

“All I heard was Eze Rodrigo, Eze Rodrigo, Eze Rodrigo, Eze Rodrigo.”

Analyzing Arsenal's Tactical Style

56:00 to 57:54

Discussion on Arsenal's playing style and tactical needs for improvement.

“As soon as you get presented with the name, you say, oh, he's actually quite good.”

The Role of Substitutes in Match Dynamics

57:54 to 59:48

Exploration of how substitutes can influence game outcomes, especially in draws.

“Of those four games, some of those didn't deserve to lose.”

Debating Eze vs. Rodrigo

59:48 to 1:01:16

Comparative analysis of potential signings Eze and Rodrigo and their fit in the squad.

“given the number of Arsenal podcasts, but like we've got a lot of new stuff to discuss this season.”

Rodrigo's Situation at Madrid

1:01:16 to 1:04:30

Discussion on Rodrigo's struggles at Real Madrid and implications for potential transfer.

“and when asked whether it was related to his future shabby alonzo said nope just a technical decision.”

Eze's Tactical Fit and Emotional Connection

1:04:30 to 1:07:34

Discussion on how Eze could fit into Arsenal's tactics and the emotional aspects of his potential signing.

“It was just so smooth and so well handled.”

Concerns Surrounding Odegaard's Form

1:07:34 to 1:10:04

Addressing potential concerns regarding Odegaard's recovery and the need for squad depth.

“And I don't like looking back in my football, but a lot of us remember 2008 Arsenal, lots of creative number eights, number 10s in our team.”

Creating Competitive Mindsets in Arsenal

1:10:04 to 1:11:22

Discussion about the need for a competitive nature in the team.

The Importance of Player Commitment

1:11:23 to 1:11:42

Analyzing how a player's desire to be at a club can enhance performance.

“It was a really nice interview, actually.”

Saka's Evolving Role in the Team

1:11:43 to 1:14:06

Exploring Bukayo Saka's role and potential movement to central positions.

“But it's a question that I've seen out there.”

Concerns and Expectations for the Squad

1:14:07 to 1:15:38

Addressing the challenges and changes needed for Arsenal's squad.

“And the third-best position is on the other side where Decan Rice is playing.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00You're listening to this podcast, so I know you've got a curious mind. Here's a helpful fact that you may not know yet. Drivers who switch and save with Progressive save over$900 on average. They make it super simple. Pop over to Progressive.com, answer some questions, and you'll get a quick quote with coverage options tailored to your choices. Plus, you'll see which discounts you may qualify for, like the online quote discount or savings for paying in full. In fact, 99 % of Progressive Auto customers earn at least one discount. See if you could save when you switch to Progressive. You'll feel good about making a savvy choice.

0:39Visit Progressive.com and see if you can enjoy a little extra cash back. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company & Affiliates. National average 12-month savings of$946 by new customers surveyed who saved with Progressive between June 2024 and May 2025. Potential savings will vary. Hey Chicagoland, the Wayfair store is in your neighborhood at Edens Plaza and Wilmette.

1:01Elliot:Finally, you can feel the fabric, sit on the sectionals, and even open the refrigerators. Plus, our in-store designers will help you bring it all together with free one-on-one design support for any project on any budget. Yep, we said free. Oh, and did we mention the cafe? So what are you waiting for? Come see all that's in store. Visit the Wayfair store today at Edens Plaza and Wilmette. Wayfair, every style, every home Saka Rice

1:36Trousa Saga Herder guard, white Ho-ho! Everything's going right Arsenal's so good, they're scoring by mistake

1:51Look, I don't want to be called a marketing genius but we finally decided to return to offering merchandise. Our first group of products, Nani Meduake themed. This is the Arsenal Vision Post-Match Podcast. My name's Elliot Smith. You can block me on Twitter. Yeah, we've got Nani mugs. We've got Nani shirts. We've got Nani hoodies. All your Nani gear is here. Come to our store. Oh, I've just been told our store is out of business. Yeah, look, it is a fascinating moment in Arsenal transfer history. the way people are reacting to the rumors of us being linked to a pretty talented and somewhat interesting 23-year-old player.

2:27Now, he's from Chelsea, so we know that that plays a role. I am so excited to talk about this, not because I'm excited about the player, and I will give you my views on that, but mainly because I'm so excited to discuss the different angles from which you can analyze potentially adding Nani Medweke. We're also going to talk Christian Norgard, who is now an Arsenal player. we're going to talk about Ebrecha Eze Rodrigo who Xabi Alonso and Real Madrid hate so much that now I think I should hate him too that's kind of where I'm at on that we scouted Eze and Medueca yesterday love for you to check that out Clive ran the rule over those players while I said things like ooh look at what Eze just did so if you want that kind of content you can have it we have a transfer daily every single day they get funnier and funnier as the days go by and we'll have a special edition Friday night Clive tomorrow with a special celebrity guest joining us.

3:19So I'm very excited about that. It's all happening on Patreon. You can use code AVP50 and get 50 % off your first month and realize that more Clive, more Tim, more Paul, more Phil, and a tolerable volume of me is something you need in your life. But you know what you have in your life right now? You have Phil Costa. Hello, Phil Costa. Hello, mate. How we doing? You look swole, mate. What's going on? Do I? Oh, thank you. You look a bit swole. It's a flattering color on me, this green. So that's why I've worn it, basically. You're going to sell more Arsenal kits that way, let me tell you. Get the film merch, not the nonny merch.

3:50I will tell you, though, if you've been following the Transfer Daily, you know that one of our regular names that we check on that is Mykonos Barber, who had all the insight on Sesco. And I would suggest maybe, just maybe, you're creeping up on time for a visit to Mykonos Barber. Would you agree with that? I'm waiting. Look, it's an important weekend. I've got friends visiting this weekend, so I'm going to wait until Thursday. Sorry, next week, next Thursday, to get it fresh and marinated ready. this is the rookie move someone had to tell me this you get the haircut the week before the time you want it to look perfect so not if your barber's good mate oh shots fired at my barber and uh given what i spend on that person i'm concerned okay uh here a man who has not visited a barber in a long long time is also here his name is clive hello yep i felt a bit left out

4:38Elliot:hello hello don't worry you youngsters have your little chat amongst yourself um have you like did you used to go to the barber i did when you went to the barber did you get the barber in lutein called lloyd's famous man bless him and um the queue was massive mate wasn't that many barbers for uh sort of caribbean people and um so yeah that's why i used to get me flat top in there so there you go oh flat top i love it kid and play that's what i think of now i'm gonna be already you are yeah um or i guess will smith had it too at one point didn't he i'm not that i'm not that ridiculous but yeah you know that's similar style right so there you go well you know i mean the less said the better okay um let's dive into something that's almost as ridiculous and that's the reaction to the nani medueke leaks we will we will talk look christian norgaard is an arsenal player we need to talk about that but it's like again similar to the supermendy thing we've already covered it and if you missed it we did an episode with a brentford expert uh mike from the ealing Road podcast came on and I think you spoke brilliantly.

5:42You can check out that episode if you haven't listened to it already. And if you haven't, you just lost five points of Arsenal Vision podcast credibility. So, you know, just something to think about. Clive, I want to dive into the analysis of the player. We will do that for sure. I just want to ask you, have you, can you think of an Arsenal transfer, an attacking player, someone in this price range, anything like this, where the reaction has been so vociferous and maybe I'm using, again, social media driving too much of my experience, but I'm also in WhatsApp chats. I talk to other human beings who aren't just faceless trolls on the internet.

6:17It seems like people are pretty upset about this. Have you been surprised by the reaction? I know you didn't love the links when they first came out, but this is as intense as I've seen it in a while.

6:27Elliot:Yeah, it's all about timing, isn't it? When you hear the news. And when the links first came out, I thought we were getting other players. And then you just got to piece it all together, really. and there's lots of strands to pick out here. Do you want me to do the Chelsea strand? I mean, the Chelsea. Yeah, I mean, and that would be a good place to start. I think it makes sense. But to be fair, I think there were people that were against Kai Havertz, but I don't feel like they were against Kai Havertz to this degree. Yeah, I think the Chelsea, I'll just stay with the Chelsea side of the thing because footballistically you can build a case really easily for why we'd want to do this.

7:05Elliot:So we'll come, we'll no doubt come on to that. So I'll just stay with Chelsea for now. Chelsea is a sworn enemy, right? And we spent many years behind them, watching them win all of the trophies that we would have got if it wasn't for Roman Abramovich's money, right? So now we're in a situation where we no longer need to be begging and borrowing of Chelsea. We are seen as a superior team. You know, we're the team that's had more points over the last three years. We're in the Champions League more regularly. And we don't need to be knocking on their door. but we still keep knocking on their door.

7:39Elliot:So you look at the history of knocking on their door, just in the last few years, we can all talk about Willian, even though he paid himself off, it was an expensive mistake, up to a point. We can look at others, you know, Peter Cech, you know, playing in the Europa League final and then three minutes later, going back to work for Chelsea. Not great, because he had four goals in his net. Do you know what I mean? There are things there, looking at Dav Luiz, I think Dav Luiz was okay, and that's where we were at that time, you know, but we've got the fresh memories of you know kai havert some people don't like him don't like the fact that we paid the money we did for him they always report the top end price never the breakdown just a top end price to hammer us then you had last year we had sterling you know i was hopeful for sterling that he's coming he can barely raise a gallop and we even though it's a bargain it's sort of like we we carried that weight and then we get to later that stage of champions league we can barely use him you know so people are frustrated they see chelsea getting 90 odd million quid in their bin for playing in a world club cup championship and then they they buy too many players and what happens we come along and reportedly offer them top dollar and profit on a player that they don't even really like i sort of said to you elliot the other day i said we say he's a bit of a d-head right and um and i sort of said to you hey mate to other teams ben white is a bit of a d-head but actually he's our d-head and my son is always smarter than me he said yeah but dad he goes we like ben white they don't like madame weke does it mean i thought oh damn he's done me again and he's right right so um he's right and this is the issue we see we see things around attitude, discipline, and then you think price, and I know the price is being stuffed in our faces at the top end, and people have seen other players that could potentially not come because of it.

9:35Elliot:They're making those sums. And bingo, you have the perfect social media storm, right, based on some information and incomplete information, and that's where we are. Okay, let's take it out of the metaverse for a minute here. uh now i'm going to get legal letters from mark zuckerberg great uh but let's let's talk about the player specifically then i want to come back to the order of signings and how that sometimes influences reaction to them as well by the way clive if you keep invoking all the brilliant knowledge your son is giving you coming out of the pot i'm gonna have to add him to the contributor list so just yeah you can tell me that i'm always always want to learn things from put him in the show notes um phil let's talk about the player and let's not talk about him as a chelsea player And let's not talk about his attitude and the fact that he once fought with Cole Palmer about taking a penalty or, you know, said Wolverhampton was a shithole or any of that.

10:29Let's just talk about the player. This is a six-foot-tall 23-year-old who has a top speed that at least has been measured as up there as the fastest in the league, who I think is a bit bandy-legged, you might say, right? The legs are all akimbo. They're going in all directions, but he still completes a decent percentage of his dribbles. He's a phenomenal ball carrier. he likes to get his shot off you describe this player very direct very big very fast 23 years old and you think and people reacting like this so what is it about this player that people have such hesitations about because the physical tools are definitely there but we just scouted him and i have to admit aesthetically he looks like a player whose left leg and right leg haven't often met each other if you know what i mean yeah you you guys noted this on the on the scouting pod but his mechanics are really awkward I mean he's very upright when he runs he's quite gangly he doesn't always look in control but you can see how quick he is over the first five or ten yards and also he's quick over longer distances as well which is something we've lacked I think some running power in behind or some people who are willing to go beyond the last line of defense in transition I mean you mentioned the ball carrying he's in the 95th percentile for progressive carries he's in the 98th percentile for carries into the box so this is a really high level player for those particular metrics and they're big numbers and actually they're Mohamed Salah numbers in that he isn't always the smoothest dribbler but he is direct he is penetrative and he always finds himself in the penalty area to create danger or even shooting opportunities for himself and and why does that help us because those qualities are major factors in helping break down low blocks which we have struggled with over the past two seasons so I think that's an instant kind of draw that maybe Arteta or the scouting team or the coaching staff will have will have taken towards Maduweke because he's very direct he doesn't really care when he loses the ball because he just keeps going so that's that's immediately what stands out with Maduweke to me anyway that he can get into the box he does it a lot he does it quickly um and also I like I like where he's taking shots from um and I think that's come on a lot over the last two seasons he was taking some really bad shots from distance on his wrong side of you know when he first joined Chelsea but now he's in that nice little quadrant of the corner um again where Mohamed Salah takes those shots and I think that could be useful for Arsenal because we've got someone else who likes to do that as well by the name of Bakayo Saka.

13:07So I don't think he's near the level of Bakayo Saka, but I'm just saying there are things there that are analogous to the player, which we can maybe, or bring us towards an understanding of why we're looking at him. Get ready for our next Instagram reel. Phil compares Madweke to Mohamed Salah. Clive, do you want to add on to... I had a half abuse last time. You want to add on to Phil's excellent description of Nani Madweke as Mohamed Salah in Mark II?

13:33Elliot:yeah i think i um i don't quite agree no way joking i think uh so yeah so let's have a it's a football conversation isn't it it is and where is football going right so what do teams do they all now are up and they mid block your three lines bosh low block there you go that's it everyone's doing the same thing why do you do it because you You don't reveal your key part of the goal, and you save your energies when you transition. So everyone's doing the same thing. So what you need on the edges are crazy dog fools that can challenge people, want to be relentless. We had a discussion this week about Jokeres, and it's quite easy to see his relentless nature of always going and going and going.

14:19To find energy in a transfer is really hard.

14:24Elliot:So when you, everyone can play. we've got different techniques different profiles etc etc when you see people with boundless energy that is a really valuable thing i looked at madwaki and i looked at his size 14 feet going pointing outwards trying to trap the ball one time he traps it one time he doesn't trap it but next minute he's going back again he's going back again he's going back again and that relentless energy equates to something called threat and we need to threaten back lines a lot more we need to threaten and blocks a lot more through more than one player. You know, that's the key thing.

14:59Elliot:Now, I just saw a beautiful article in the Athletic this morning, but it's in my mind anyway. We played 58 games last year, I think on game 69. They're still playing last season while some teams are flying away for preseason. The game is relentless. We played 58 games, we knocked out the FA Cup in the third round, so we could easily top 60 games. I know we love Pakai Saka, but he's not playing 60 games. right he's not doing neither is Martinelli but Kai Saka last year played 20 games in the Premier League right so we have to think differently about how we approach this season because last time I looked at my timeline there's anybody on there doesn't want us to be in the latter stages of every competition no one's prepared to give up the league cup or the FA Cup want to win that we didn't win a trophy people say you've got to win a championship you're going to manage to lose this job and we never even won it I think we've been to three semi-finals that's a Premier League We've not won that since I did have a flat top.

15:55Elliot:And basically, we've got to win that as well next season. So how are we going to do it? No, seriously, how are we going to do it unless we add to the group? And we add to the group profiles of players that can do the things that we do, particularly in wide areas, the way we build up, multiple profiles that bring different skill sets to the group. We need four proper wide players. You know, that's the minimum for me, you know? And so that's how we're going to get to Latter-day. That's how we're going to protect people from operations. We've got two of our forwards that we rely on on the back of operations.

16:34Elliot:Now, I've moaned about this. So when we come up with a player that can solve some of those solutions, I'm not going to moan yet. Let's see what the final pie looks like. I'm not going to moan yet. I'm not promoting this player, but I'm promoting what he can be. and what he does for us. If he allows Bakayasaka to stay healthy and if he allows Ethan to be in the interior, I am all for it. If we have a situation where we're late in the game and we're one goal up and we need to have a transition ability, I am all for it. If we're playing a team where we've got a big Champions League game at the weekend and we want to rest Bakayasaka because we want to beat that team, I'm all for it.

17:15Elliot:You know, it's a much bigger issue. The football is changing and we have to change our thought process. We've done the Chelsea angle. We haven't done the cost angle yet, Elliot. I know that is also an issue and it is an issue. It does shape people's opinions. I'm much more comfortable talking about football because I can see it. Sorry, mate, one last thing. I'm not watching it, but I've seen highlights of PSG. When we did see them last year, how are they playing? What do they have in forward areas? Multiple wing forwards. right so again what man city added multiple creators and carriers we have to embrace this because this is where the game tactically is taking us towards yeah by the way i still think we played psg really well oh brilliant throw that out there with everything we were missing and you see how good they are because they're really really good they absolutely dismantled real madrid and we'll get on to that when we talk rodrigo down the line but we're going to stick with the big medueke debate a couple of data points i should mention by the way yes his data as good.

18:18He had 2 ,000 minutes this season in the league and 1 ,000 minutes before that. This is still relatively small sample size. And two seasons ago, half his appearances were essentially as a sub. This season, five of the 27, I think, starts or so were, yeah, five of his 32 appearances were subbed, right? And the other 27 were starts. So there's some sub effects in there. There's some beating up on lower opposition. And I know what people are going to say, well, we need to beat up on lower opposition. Not dismissing it, not remotely. Some people would say, well, Gilchrist beats up on lower opposition.

18:52Yes. Meduake did it to the tune of five goals against Wolves and Southampton. Gilchrist does it to the tune of 50 goals against that lower opposition. Meduake had seven goals. Five of them were Wolves and Southampton. That doesn't dismiss that he did it. It's just a data point worth bearing in mind. You see long Baron spells throughout the season where he didn't contribute as much. I think an interesting aspect of this, Phil, is what role he would actually play because there is no world where I think this is the right transfer for a backup to Saka. No world at all. It's too much money. It's something you need to do.

19:31When you look at the teams that win shit, their best players just play all the time and they don't have 50 million pound backups sitting behind them. If I said, who's Mohamed Salah's backup? You couldn't name him. because he plays on average two Premier League games a season. You know, now you can say, oh, is it Diaz or is it, you know, is it, who is it? Who is it really? You know, Nunez, I don't know. The point is, you don't spend huge on that. But I do agree with Clive that you need a group, probably four, more likely five, really good high-end forwards. And so if it's Jokrash, Kai, Saka, Martinelli, let's say Leo goes.

20:07Jokrash, Kai, Saka, Martinelli. if that fifth guy is Nani Medueke instead of Eze or Rodrigo I think that fundamentally is where the frustration is coming in so I want to ask you about him as a left wing option if he is literally the bye instead of an Eze or Rodrigo and I think that is where people start to get really worried because if we had Eze and Jokres in and he wasn't in after them I think there'd be a little bit less or a lot less animated response to it so we know he can play off the right that's principally what he's done when we looked at the scouting video he played off the left a decent amount.

20:39He played off both flanks. We haven't used a left footer off the left. That's been a thing Mikel has really resisted doing. At times on this pod, we've said, why can't Martinelli and Saka switch sometimes? Change it up. Let Saka drive to the byline off his left. Let Martinelli go to his strong foot, you know, to the byline. Like, we haven't really wanted to use a left footer off the left. So it seems weird all of a sudden that we now decide to do that with this player. Do you think he is a true left-wing option for us who could be coming in to sort of take a place for Martinelli and or Leo? Or do you still see this principally as a right-wing depth move?

21:16I think it's a depth move. I think he's coming in because he can play both sides. And even only until recently was he only being played on the left. I think it was the last 10 or 11 games of Chelsea's season last year where he was playing on the left. So for me, I don't really agree with your Saka point because, you know, he can play every game as long as he's fit. But what if he isn't? You know, we lost him for three months last year. And I think the whole point was that we had nobody in reserve. And also... Can I have two answers to that? Just super quick. I want to let you continue your point.

21:46Answer number one is, I think whoever we buy, if Bakayo Saka misses another three months, we don't win anything next season. Don't fool yourself. If your best player's out, you don't win stuff. It doesn't matter if you have Nani Madweke. you don't win the title playing Nani Madweke over Saka my other point I wanted to say to that quickly is I think there's a chance and I know Ethan Winery is looked at as an 8-10 option that's where his future is and I'll let Clive speak on that in a moment but if you said to me right now there's going to be 8 Premier League games Saka doesn't play and you can give those games to Nani Madweke or you can give them to Ethan and see if he goes supernova and if he doesn't you have to move one of your left wing options over I still think I'd rather see if Ethan becomes the star we know is in there so those are my two quick answers to you about what if saka misses time but please carry on with your point that i've rudely interrupted i apologize not at all and i would be absolutely fine giving them to ethan but i don't think that's the plan because a we're looking to sign madueke and b all the talk has been about him moving centrally so i i just think we need a stronger group we haven't had that we had nathan butleroyodeji kieran tierney ismail Caviar on the bench last year you know with Raheem Sterling coming off the bench we need to strengthen in in some way and I'm not saying this player should be Madueke by the way because even though I like him I wouldn't spend the reported 50 million pounds on him whether that's wrongly reported or there are add-ons involved or anything like that I don't know but the the number where being drip fed is 50 million pounds and even then I'm a bit like would I do that but I can see the logic of him coming in because he can play on the right he can play on the left and also it's more about his style and what he brings to the team I mean also with Saka do we want him playing 90 minutes every week you know it's not just about the start it's about how much of the game he's able to influence could it be an hour could it be you know 70 minutes and then we have another fresh option to bring off the bench when you're playing every three or every three or four days that that could mean something towards April or May when it's crunch time you know and we think oh I'm glad we had Madueke to take who knows 500 minutes off Saka during those that first half of the season it could it could add up it could mean something so I don't think if we sign Madueke he's coming to be Saka backup I just think he's coming to be part of the group and let's be honest none of us are entirely convinced about Martinelli or Trossard because if an offer comes in I think we'd all we'd all sell them if the number was right so could he be an option on the left I think he's certainly different I mean you even saw in the scouting pod that he was quite happy to go to the byline he's very quick over those short distances he can hang one up to the back post but he can also do the soccer style of cross where he just gets it floats it in onto the penalty spot so I see flaws in this player I really really do and he wouldn't be my first choice by any means because there's a whole world out there and the fact that we've gone back to Chelsea is just a bit boring and uninspiring but the club have obviously seen something in him um and I think you know Clive was absolutely right to mention the Chelsea factor you mentioned the timing because even though we've done a lot of good stuff already we're all ready to be wowed by some big money signing who are taking us to the promised land you know Jocheres, Rodrigo, Eze and Madueke is a bit of a reality check right and he brings us straight back down to earth in an obvious way and we don't like that so i think that is another narrative that's gone into the deal and you know i again i don't see him coming to be a backup i think if he's good enough if he's training hard enough he will play if he's not if there are other people in better form he won't play so it's just it's a squad game and we need we need to rewire our brains a little bit because it's not it's not a starting 11 sport anymore you know we have to We have to future prove ourselves beyond that.

25:38No one disagrees with that, by the way. I think it's opportunity cost, right? It's what could we do instead of this? And is this the thing to do instead of the other options? I have seen reporting that said, for Chelsea to do this, the fee has to start with a five. And I'm completely fine with that. You give them 5 million and it's done. Look, that starts with five. Starts with five. You can't argue with the logic. Clive, you want to enlarge Phil's brilliant points there that he will widely agree with?

26:09Elliot:Yeah, I mean, I've sat here for three years talking about this. We've got to move away from first 11s. What did we end up doing? Talking about first 11s because we haven't got enough players, right? So now we're trying to add to the players. We may buy seven players this window and everyone's got the amp. My goodness, mate. Let's have a bet we would have done that before, you know? You know, at season's end, we wouldn't have done. And you made a point there earlier earlier about traveling down the left-hand side as a lefty and we haven't really done that before but we haven't really had a center forward before that might be in the box that wants people to cross with their strong foot on the outside and not just telegraph inverted crosses you know to false nine types do you know what I mean we're gonna have somebody who's gonna be spinning to that near post to tap it in or cross a six-yard box and so everything changes right and that's what we're trying to do aren't we we're trying to evolve offensively and so yes we don't want to move sack away from his absolute killer best side where he's one of the best in the world no we want to keep him there but maybe we get a left footer from the other side and you can get what you want which is a by byline winger that gets and cuts back crosses to our big six foot number eights do you see what i mean all center forward so we're opening up tactical options and i'm just looking at it logically football wise i don't think you can dismiss it and if we take our you know we'd be a bit more mature and adult about it you can't look at this player and dismiss him he's an england international he's known to the league you know i like rafa leal for example i don't know anything about him really apart from youtube i don't know if he tracks back everything i look at he's walking around mate he must be the walking world championships i like him do you mean i really like him i like bakayoko i saw him once against us for psv and he ripped kivio on you well i don't know what his form is like recently the price was 17 million doesn't say to me that's arsenal do you mean you know even rodrigo i like rodrigo i've watched him he looks he looks crushed at the moment mentally you know why am i gonna say well i know what he's gonna do i don't know by the way i see something there i know he's known to the league last time i looked the words win now is all over the club so you're managing risk aren't you you're managing risk of the players that you have their health two operations in our front six by the way their health or three sorry because we've got an acl as well right so when we're like smoothing our nose up we're adding to the group we're adding to the group now if this is the group then the pitchforks come out didn't they earlier and then we can have a chat that's true but this is not the group for everything that we've read you know and your favorite player could be coming in and suddenly it opens up another tactical option and we're feeling different a center forward lands always feeling different now potentially someone goes looking at a fourth player so i i'm i'm all right with it the bit that concerns me a little bit if i'm honest with you is that i want to see us drive a hard bargain do you mean that that's what i want to see us do it feels like sometimes and it's only reports we we sort of buckle to chelsea and we don't need to buckle to them you know and we don't not anymore there was a time when they had all the money and they were like superior their best team in the world basically that not anymore we don't need to buckle to them we're fighting for every two they have to sell they have to sell or they can't register new players in the in the uefa competitions exactly so when you read things and we don't know if it's true when you read things and our first offer is right up there thinking hold on a minute lads come on lads but we don't know do we we really don't know it's just we've been drip fed this and it's driving us to distraction for me just gotta be really really careful until we see what actually looks like because i don't wanna you know other people gonna have their reaction fine and i had mine earlier didn't i when it first kicked off it was a laughing reaction but you know but when you think about it football wise i can see that i can see it i can i can't deny i can Well, it was on Friday night, Clive.

30:10You had this on Sarenhand. You're going to get different analysis. A few things, because with Chelsea, I think we should point out, Chelsea have been disciplined by UEFA. And the way the discipline works, and the publicly available information is opaque a little bit. So all the accountants listening, and I know there are many of you, and we do love you and thank you for your service. They must have, from their A list of players submitted with UEFA last season, they must have a net profit on the sale of a the the elimination of cost in the a-list versus what they bring in in other words if they bring in more cost than they move out they cannot register those players for the champions league this season so why are we going to get our feet held to the fire by a club that desperately must clear wages and players or they can't register Jamie Gittins.

31:05They can't register João Pedro. Literally, those players will not play in the Champions League if Chelsea don't move some players out. I would sit there with my arms folded and say it's 30 plus 10, you decide. Because I don't see anyone else banging down their door for Nani Meduake. And also there's no rush from our side, because he's going to have his holidays now anyway. And, by the way, I don't regard the addition of Nani Meduake as a must-be-ready-for-the-start-of-the-season kind of addition. You know, Jokeresh is that kind of addition. If we're going to replace Martinelli with a Rodrigo or an Eze, they got to be in a little sooner because we got to integrate them.

31:40Or if we're going to replace Leandro Tassard. If Nani Meduake is truly a depth option and a luxury depth option, fine by me, but negotiate. I don't care if that happens late August. And I will say, look, do we need a bigger squad? Of course, I know people say that. But when I look at the teams that I think are really good, I don't see seven forwards. I see four really good ones or five really good ones at most. Six. I hate to invoke PSG. Six forwards.

32:04Elliot:You need six forwards. You need six. Yeah. You need six. But the teams that win stuff don't play six forwards. They just don't. Not with real minutes. You know, Liverpool played four forwards with any real number of minutes. You know, real minutes. And I think, like PSG, it's Barclay, Kvara, Due and Dembele. Beyond that, they don't really trust or rate the guys they have. They have Ramos. They have five forwards. They have Ramos. They have five fours in a league where they're jogging around. We're not jogging around. I think you need six, Clive. I absolutely agree you need six. But I think, for example, if you said Ethan is number six, I think that's a hell of a number six.

32:40And again, please, let's not reopen it. I get it. That's not the position he's seen as going forward. But where I'm going with this is, if you tell me it's Martinelli, Eze, Kai, Jokeresh, and Saka, that's a hell of a group. And if you want Ethan to be the other one who can play some wing minutes, I'm totally fine with it. If you say, we need one more in that group. It can't be Ethan. That's not his role. Do we need to spend$50 million from Chelsea on Nani? If it's 30 plus 10, then it starts to be a thing that you say, wow, we've really increased. And this is where I think people are going to judge.

33:15If it is Eze plus Jokeres plus Nani, I think it's very, very hard to argue that we haven't done good business. If it is Rodrigo plus Jokeres plus Nani, again, very hard to argue. If it's Jokresh and Nani, I think people are going to feel we have not gone to the quality that was available in the market. And I will further say, I think this is where people have had their heads turned. There was that beautiful shining moment on the Hill this summer when we were linked with Eze plus Rodrigo. And now it's Eze plus Nani or Rodrigo plus Nani. And I realize that's not as exciting. if you really believed it was going to be Eze plus Rodrigo you may be over invested in transfer window hype you know what I'm saying I don't think Arsenal were ever going to do that plus a striker but there is a slightly less comfortable conversation to be had here Phil but I think it's one worth picking up on and it's about Mikel Arteta I want to ask you two questions about Mikel and I don't want to ask them in a loaded way but I think they should be asked one, he is, it is reported really driving the ship on this signing.

34:22And two, I think this is a troubled player that has some issues that we've seen and we've discussed technically and in terms of his capabilities. Is this Mikel potentially having slightly too much power consolidated in himself at the club where he can say, I want this 50 million pound guy at Chelsea and there isn't a pushback. And two, is he doing what all good coaches do? Overrating his own coaching ability that I can fix him thing, right? I can turn this guy into, we've had some reporting, He thinks he can make him a top left winger. So can you just address those two questions? And Clive, I'll come back to you on this as well.

Read the full transcript

34:54Is this a bit of an over-consolidation of power in the manager? Is this just what happens with every manager? And is he putting a lot of faith in his own coaching ability, which is sometimes a trap coaches can fall into? I think every manager will have players that they like and think they can get a tune out of. But if you think he genuinely has too much power at the club, then why do we employ other people? What is the point of having a sporting director? What is the point of having a scouting team, a recruitment team? What is the point of having any of these guys at the club if Arteta is just going to go, yes, I want him and let's get him.

35:31There will obviously have been thousands of pages of PDFs of stats, deep dives of positional information of his background. As soon as Arteta says, I want that player, there are thousands of different things to consider. And I'm sure all the various teams at the club, whether you're a tangible number guy or a people guy, you would have done your research. And for me, that's just a crazy statement because I'm sure that Arteta does have some influence at the club because he's the manager, you know, so he's well within his rights to recommend players, to want players, to identify players. but then it doesn't mean that every time he does it they're just going to say yes sir you know i you know that there's no great rush to appease the great the great arteta you know he's just he's just there doing his job and finding players that he likes so would madueke be a player that i identified no but they've obviously seen something in him collectively as a group that feels worthy of spending however however much we we want to spend whether that's 30 40 50 i don't know where we're going to end up um it sounds like towards the higher bracket of the deal but you know it's it's just I I can't get behind the the idea that he's got too much power at the club because he should have power but also I I trust the people around him enough to say you know maybe I don't have total and entire belief in this player but there is a sneaky suspicion of mine that they're almost going signing for signing because obviously Berta might have been pushing for Giocares and And then Arteta might have been pushing for Maduweke.

37:06And they said, well, let's meet in the middle and see what happens. We get one each and we'll see at the end of the year. We'll see who the fans hate most. Yeah, exactly. It's your head on the spike, mate. So that's how I see it. I don't think he's this overruling, sovereign figure at the club. I just think he holds an influence. And it's up to the people around him to say yes or no, or we agree or we don't agree. And judge those pros and cons together. I hope so anyway. If there's anything else happening, I'd be a little bit worried, but I don't believe that. I think a successful club is one where the manager wields a tremendous amount of influence, especially over footballing decisions like which players to bring in, but where there is a collaborative process that involves people who he trusts and respects enough to listen to them.

37:51We know that's clearly happening here because I don't think Mikel Arteta's first choice, as you rightly point out, is Victor Jokeres. so I think it is a case of Andrea Berta has had influence over Mikel and they've collaborated and they've reached a decision on something that can get done and get done in the time frame they want on a player that probably wasn't Mikel's first option and this may be a case of Mikel saying I like this player here's the vision I see for him the team have run the data we do know that a lot of very data literate people seem to really like Nani Medueke that there are some things out there that suggest he's undervalued, not price him in undervalued, but underappreciated in popular perception.

38:28And so I don't think the process is breaking down here. You know what I mean? I do think he has a, I want to save them kind of mentality to his coaching, but he's a coach and Clive will know about this. You want to fix people. You know, if you see talent, yeah, that's it. So I think it's - Clive still wants us to sign Mudrick. But that's a great example. No, I did not. Never.

38:52Elliot:yes you did i remember seeing you on a podcast mate yeah that's a great example it's a great example of somebody i was that player sesco and your career probably the most youtube clips i ever watched in my life and i got to a point i can't wait to get this player in Madrid what good player he'll be but at that time it was 30 something and then it went up and he went up and it went up and then the end of oh my god what's happening here right so and chelsea jumped in right so um so yeah i'm going back to where you started earlier i want michael arteta to have influence because what i don't want is people saying well did arteta buy that player even when we lose again that's far worse i want to have influence because i want to have total influence and get all the players that he wants and if it works great if it doesn't work we can all say well actually that's this is why you know so for me i want the influence like um you know this is why i feel a little bit embarrassed actually because if we ever saw the data they've probably got on this player it'll probably it'll probably shock us they're probably metrics that we can't even imagine you know the publicly available stuff that we see is great in the world but i would love to see what they see you know honestly i bet it's like out there something crazy you know it would just be amazing you don't make these decisions just to upset people you don't make decisions i i honestly think you know i can remember seeing i'm gonna bring his name up now right just because things change when you see people i remember when um obviously laminya mal came into fruition at barcelona and they had rafinha i thought what are they gonna do with rafinha they're moving to the left-hand side look what happened you know he's right near the ballon door he's a flyaway runner with a left foot crashing shot what if we do something like that with malo weke what if we turn him into something like that straight lines on your strong foot suddenly you look different don't look as awkward but it becomes an option with something we don't have today we literally don't have it you know we can't play even out there that's not him he's a small space really tidy feet player with a shot primarily on from the right hand side of the pitch that's what i've seen so far you can cross on the inside channels on on the left eight but i don't think that's what he's going to be and so we need that right so we need to mature that so i'm open to that evolution i really am i just we need we talked about processes here but we don't have no visibility of them we're just taking reports and saying your crazy's burtas guy and it may have a hint of truth in it you know i think what we can say based on really good reporting is that they bring a lot of players to the table and then decide which direction they're going to go you know and i think that's a group effort thing and that's what i want that's what i want to believe that it's a team full of data people scouting people people do background checks etc and they come to this they come to this position and then they take it up to the board and they decide it's worth to spend we sat here and we didn't go for the 65 minute volley walkings in january that tells me we've got our best robust processes in the club to say that wasn't a good value proposition at that time we didn't like it because we wanted our striker but we know there are processes in place so i i'm i'm okay with it i kid it i'm okay with it right now on this date let's see what we end up with you know this is that's the key in this what are we going to end up with i think there's a question whether fan sentiment should matter?

42:29Should it matter that fans really want Eze and would love it? And a lot of fans really don't want Meduake and would really hate it. And I'll level with you. I don't think fan sentiment should matter. And the reason is fan sentiment lasts as long as the first good performance in the Arsenal shirt. That's how long it lasts. When he scores the winner at Old Trafford on the opening day and runs off to celebrate with the away fans, he's one of us from that moment. And I'll give you the perfect example. I remember when we were linked with Aaron Ramsdale and people were outraged. We weren't very good at that time.

43:05Now we're trying to buy a keeper from a relegated team, a twice relegated keeper. What are we doing? Hate this move. This club doesn't know what it's doing. Everybody's an idiot. Six months later, he's a fan favorite and such a fan favorite that then when we decide to upgrade on him, people are outraged that we're pushing him out of the club. so fan sentiment is important because we are the club but it's so malleable and changeable over such a short period of time that i don't think it should matter obviously in the decision the club makes because here's the funny thing we could sign ese and two stinkers into his season people are going to be going we passed up on rodrigo for this what we think so you know i love that we're passionate because that's how football matters.

43:48But I don't think that what we think should drive the decision making, as long as the process looks good. And I'll level with you, whatever I think of the player, and I have been clear, this isn't a player I would go for. And this isn't necessarily a deal I like. But he's a 23 year old with tremendous physical tools. And aesthetically, he's not great. And there's some questions about some behavioral stuff. You know, he's a little out there in terms of social media behavior and stuff like that. But at the end of the day, he's a tremendously physically talented 23-year-old that's played at the top level of the Premier League.

44:19If the price is right, that's a player you have to at least give the club a chance to go get and see how it works out. We got to talk about a lot of other stuff. We got to talk about Eze and Rodrigo and Gabriel Heinz joining the coaching ranks, and we have to talk about Norgard, who we actually signed and announced. And all of that pales in significance to telling you how to run an e-commerce business. Because if I don't do that, what if you run the wrong e-commerce business? What if you run a bad e-commerce business? And then on my deathbed, I'll be there and going, people failed at e-commerce because I didn't tell them about Shopify.

44:54My last breath. My last breath on this earth. Well, you know what? That's not going to be my last breath on this earth because I am going to tell you about Shopify, damn it. It's the e-commerce site that lets you sell on Instagram, sell on Facebook, sell on TikTok, lets you have the cart management taken care of so that when someone has something in their cart but they haven't checked out, it says things like, hey, you left this in your cart. Would you like to buy it? And when you sell it, you don't have to worry about the taxes and you don't have to worry about the shipping. You don't have to worry about writing a single line of code.

45:21If you can decide what pictures to upload and what descriptions to write, Shopify can literally even find you the products to sell. It can do it all. It can help you with your supply chain. Business term. It can do all of that and give you the analytics to understand how your business is performing. but most importantly, it lets you focus on what you're good at. And it focuses on the e-commerce. And so on your dying bed, on your deathbed, you go, my life was a success because of Shopify. See? See how we turned that around? The story became a happy story of you dying a successful e-commerce titan of industry.

45:59Established in 2025 has a nice ring to it, doesn't it? Sign up for your $1 per month trial period at shopify.com slash arsenalvisionalllowercase. Shopify.com slash

46:12is that enough of that indeed Phil I hope your next ad read on the football vision pod is just like that my friend all that reminded me of was that Benzema tweet when it was like to Elliot's followers he passed away last night and his last word was Shopify make of that what you will this is his wife Babs yeah

46:37um okay clive uh can i ask you just a super quick question that i don't want to go deep on question that doesn't mean well we just um because we don't we don't have a ton of of time to spend on things that aren't transfer related it is okay july but you know for the record but um gabriele linesa you have any quick thoughts on that i have to admit this is an appointment that makes total sense because he was a mentor to arteta and he's a huge close friend of arteta But in terms of the dynamic in the group, it's a big shift. He is a madman. Just watch the YouTube comps of him going nuts on the touchline.

47:09There are reports at Atlanta United that he trained the players to death in violation of their collectively bargained agreement on training. You're losing a Carlos Cuesta who was the player's coach, the conduit for transmitting Arteta's message to the players in a way that they could hear. And now you're getting a guy who's completely nuts, but, you know, who Arteta trusts and really has a close relationship with. So do you have any quick thoughts on Cuesta out, Heinze in, and how that might change the dynamic in the group?

47:36Elliot:Yeah, I think Cuesta started off as an individual coach, didn't he, Arsenal? He's only about 27 when he was doing that, no surprise. He can't be holding group to that age. He started out, he learned to read, and he was a coach. Those are the two things he had to do when he was seven years old. And as Steve Brown moved on, he went probably more into sort of group training, I'm guessing, you know? And so he just developed. You don't get to be a manager of a Serie A club just by being an individual coach and a nice speaker, right? So he's obviously developed under Arteta's wing. So I think what I do find interesting, Elliot, we're going back to your earlier question about Arteta having too much authority.

48:17Elliot:It's quite interesting. Two of the main people that's coming in, Berta and Heinzer. Well, they are not little flowers, are they? They are super intense workaholic machines. that want to win he's almost surrounding himself with people like him so if you want a nice easy life you keep them keep the nice people right you keep them around you just everyone says yes yes yes yes he is almost like he wants to challenge he doesn't want to be the cleverest person in the room he wants to turn if you want to get better that's exactly what you want how you're going to learn how you're going to develop right who's going to develop him eddie's moved away i think that relationship maybe it's already out of date but has come in more wisdom ryan's is coming he's older more wisdom you know i think it's good that's how you learn that's how you develop right the players now the most important thing relationship to the players not relationship to me relationship to the players maybe the relationship to harvard webb probably gonna be quite important but um but i'm glad we're bringing in experience we're trying to win this stuff right we're trying to we're trying to win by doing the same stuff hasn't quite got to say i'm not saying i'm blaming the people that have left but it hasn't quite got to say so we're trying to win so what do you do you have your lessons learned meaning and you change things and you try to get better that's what they're doing yeah um phil do you want to go quick on that because like i said i i don't think it needs to be discussed much in part because i just don't think we have enough visibility to these kinds of things to speak to it accurately.

49:50It's like injuries for me. One of those things that if you go too deep talking about it, you're well out of your depth in terms of what information is even available to you. But do you have quick thoughts on Heintz? I would just point anyone to read up on some of the funny track record he had in MLS because it's not the best reading, but it also could mean absolutely nothing. Yeah. Honestly, I don't know too much about him. I know that he had a very impressive playing career he did manage as well for a few teams and actually despite his kind of spiky uh aggressive exterior he was actually quite an ambitious coach um quite an attack-minded coach he compared his football to Marcelo Bielsa or he took a lot of inspiration from Marcelo Bielsa obviously not to the same effect we all know that it was a pretty disastrous time at um atlanta united was it where he was kind of sacked very quickly after eight defeats in a row or something silly but you know I think he's he's a personable guy but a very driven and committed person which I think is what is what Arteta is you know quite intense wants to achieve their goals he's very keen on discipline and culture and and how you hold yourself and stuff like that so I think a lot of those views align with with Arteta and what he wants but also I don't think there's a there's any issue of him not wanting to to disagree or argue with him I think he'll want to get his point across where he wants to so I think it's good change change is important in football I whether it's your your playing staff or your coaching staff or whoever sporting directors CEOs it could be anyone but I just think fresh perspectives and motivations can really help a group and considering where we've ended up in the last few years just just falling short um maybe this is just another thing to to kind of consider when it comes to the mental side of things because tactically and physically, I really think we're close, but maybe just an added perspective somewhere could make a difference.

51:44Okay. That's enough of that. Let's talk transfer again. Gosh. I wasn't even listening for it.

51:52Elliot:I thought it was great. No, honestly, didn't hear any of it. All I heard was Eze Rodrigo, Eze Rodrigo, Eze Rodrigo, Eze Rodrigo. So let's talk about Norgard. Phil, I'll stay with you just for a second. we've rebuilt our entire midfield in one window party in georginio out norgaard and zubamendi in i can't decide if i think norgaard is just the safety option to have an experienced leader in the dressing room who plays on the rare occasion he's needed or if he can give more than that because candidly to listen to mike from the ealing road podcast talk about it this is one of their most important players in a very good premier league side and he has a lot of good football left in him, according to them.

52:34Is this a guy who's going to play the 700 Jorginho minutes, or could we maybe be underestimating just how valuable he could be to us? I think he's coming in to do the Jorginho thing. What Jorginho did for us two and a half years ago, he's coming in to be that guy. I really don't think there's a need to overthink this deal. I think Arsenal can bolster their midfield depth with a proven Premier League player for relatively little spend. I think Brentford had a chance to get a decent fee for a player. They could send him off after six good years of service. The player himself earns a good opportunity to play at a higher level and win things that maybe that wouldn't have been available before.

53:13I think it's fine. He's very combative. He's very aggressive. He leads by example. I know Thomas Frank spoke of him very highly in terms of how he manages himself and others around him on the pitch and off the pitch which I think Arteta will appreciate and also there was a big void to fill when we lost Jorginho and Partey that is a lot of experience a lot of know-how to lose right and I think obviously the argument is can we go younger can we bring in someone who's a bit younger that can develop and maybe hold a resale value moving forward but I think this is absolutely perfect he's still 31 so that's three three potential years left in him at Arsenal maybe even more if he's like Fernandinho levels of successful but look at his defensive numbers they're outstanding look at his physical metrics they're always in the top 10 top 20 in the league so he's still got lots to do lots to play for I think he'll play more than than 700 minutes then you know basically what Jorginho offered us last year I'm happy no fuss two players out two players in job done I really don't have anything else to say about it it's just very sensible we really don't need to overanalyze it is my opinion.

54:29I'm sort of of the same opinion except football is weird. And I think Zubomendi is a wonderful player, but he's coming into a new league, new physical demands, getting used to that extra half yard that's not there anymore. You saw Marino struggle with it. Marino's a dual monster who came into the Premier League and suddenly everything was a half yard closer to him. And he looked slow at first. And I think he picked up the tempo ironically. once he started to play as a striker. And then you saw that he started to come to terms with the tempo of the Premier League. But I don't think it's outrageous to believe that Norgard might be a very important player at the start of the season to help Zubimendi integrate without all the pressure of playing every game at Premier League tempo right away.

55:15Especially, are you going to put Zubimendi into the cauldron of Old Trafford? I mean, United stink, I get it. But opening day, like... Why not? You know, Christian Norgaard has gone into Old Trafford and won games there. I'm saying that as a presumption. I don't know if Brentford won there, but I just assume because everybody has. Everybody's won there. I'm probably safe. But you know what I mean? So, Clive, do you think that there is a possibility that, you know, maybe it's opening day, maybe it's not, but the point that, like, a guy who's been to these stadiums and won in these stadiums and knows what the tempo is like might be a really useful guy to have so that Zubomendi doesn't feel like he has to step in and immediately be one of the best central midfielders in the Premier League from day one?

55:53Or is he just good enough that he'll do that? I'm overthinking it.

55:56Elliot:Yeah, I think it's just an easy signing. I think it's a very smart signing. Obviously, the data on him is really good. As soon as you get presented with the name, you say, oh, he's actually quite good. He's interceptions and tackles. He's right up there. And I think we have a lot of Brentford in our style, funny enough. You know, Jamie Carragher sort of said, I still turn into Stoke. Mate, just say Brentford. you know that's the what we how we focus on set pieces our goalkeeper delivery into wide areas into a striker over the top of the press that nearly got us to the Champions League final by the way by beating the PSG press and so we have a lot of Brentford about us in our play style I think they're a fantastic club what they've achieved and so he just he just steps in there and does that job I think um we have this young player that's come in with one of the best in number six in the world every time you see him on the international stage he looks absolutely fantastic well not every game in the Premier League is like the international stage and and some games may not suit him for the full 90 and so you have somebody to come in and rob holding it late in the game we drew 14 games I don't know how many last season I don't know how many from when we were leading you know and um probably seven or eight I believe top of my head yeah to fix that didn't we so how do you fix that you have a you have the rob holding type player in the middle of the pitch that says enough of that you lot you're not coming through here you know what i mean can i can i add something on that because someone messaged me earlier on twitter tor jensen i think is how you pronounce his name and he says from a danish perspective one of nor god's qualities that will benefit arsenal is that he's an excellent substitute he's won 18 out of his 35 denmark caps coming from the bench and he's frequently been able to change the game for us through dictating the tempo of the game.

57:39So it's kind of exactly what you said.

57:41Elliot:I was exactly, you know, controlling a game. There's 14 draws. I was going to have a chat with Scott about this to analyse those 14 draws because that's a lot of what we're trying to fix here. Do you know what I mean? Because that's a lot of points. We only lost four games last year. Of those four games, some of those didn't deserve to lose. Do you know what I mean? So 10 men, etc. So yeah, it's the draws we have to manage. you know striking and holding you know i mean that's what you need to to fix so i'm comfortable with him well also i was going to say i mean i'm not sure i'm not sure how much he plays to denmark but there's some big international breaks next year and we've got some big players in our squad that have got some big games trying to get into world cup squads and they're going to be coming back from those international breaks and we may have to have a different view on a saturday morning thank you BT Sport for a game do you see what I mean and suddenly someone who hasn't had big international minutes will be really valuable in that game that's a good point you know so so we look at Supermendy you know Rodri's not at his best yet quite rightly after an ACL when Spain play he's going to play do you know what I mean and when we come back from those games we're going to need we're going to need to look after him right so back to what you know it's a squad game don't stress too much just make sure they're all good enough because you know what i don't want to have mate if i'm honest yeah where i sit on the emirates i sit right where the subs warm up and there's many many a time i've seen four left backs warm up on that sideline and that's not not good mate it's not good i'm gonna come reno center forward so we're trying to fix this stuff aren't we so yeah it's all good yeah i think i like this group that we built with Zubimendi and Norgard.

59:30It is definitely a weird situation to go into where you don't have anyone to play central midfield who's played a minute of central midfield before for you going into a season. So we're going to learn a lot. One of the things that's kind of fun, just as a podcaster, speaking on behalf of all the podcasters listening, which is probably like 90 % of the listeners at this point, given the number of Arsenal podcasts, but like we've got a lot of new stuff to discuss this season. When the games actually kick off, when the ball starts rolling on the grass, we're going to have a new striker. We're probably going to have a new left wing and right wing and two new central midfielders.

1:00:00It's going to be exciting, you know? And we've needed it. Until the first game we don't win, and then it'll be a crisis and everyone needs to go. Okay, so let's get back to the rumor mill. Eze and Rodrigo. I love Eze. I think early in the window, I was leaning more towards Rodrigo if it had to be one or the other. And the reason is he's younger. He's just six months older than Martinelli. By the way, in a previous pod, I said he was younger than Martinelli. I got my June and January mixed up. Rodrigo born in January, Martinelli in June. So he's six months older than Martinelli. When he played off the left for Madrid, his metrics and his video, excellent, excellent.

1:00:39Rodrigo's coming off a down season. We played off the right in a largely dysfunctional Madrid team and something by their standards anyway, trying to integrate superstars in Mbappe and Jude and Vinny, you know, and really taking a backseat to that. There are rumors that there are work ethic issues there. And I have to say, when a club hates a player, you start to wonder why do they hate him so much and like no one hates anyone as much as shabby alonzo hates rodrigo that's what i'm convinced of uh he didn't get off the bench in the three nil i want to be a four nil thrashing at the hands of psg the other day they were three nil down before i could even get the fop mob app open and they got thrashed and he didn't get off the bench and when asked whether it was related to his future shabby alonzo said nope just a technical decision.

1:01:21In other words, no, the player's just shit and I don't trust him. It has not been a good summer. The rumor's now where they want him to go. Phil, I can't help it. Them hating him so much is leaking into my brain. Going into the summer, it was clear to me. Get the 24-year-old who's very, very talented, off a down season, but with the pedigree. We've done well with this with Ozil and Odegaard, and you get this guy and he's going to come in with a lot to prove and play off the left where he's great and he's just going to take us to the next level. But they hate him so much now like now i'm like well i do love ese um do you have a strong lean they don't hate him neither do it's the same with chelsea and madueke they want him out the door because he's a sellable asset okay can i just clarify one thing just one thing real quick yes they absolutely straight hate the guy they hate him with every fiber they're being please carry that's very real madrid uh online of you um yeah so he's a sellable asset and they're not going to sell vinicius they're not going to sell Mbappe so who's the next guy in line unfortunately for for Rodrigo it's him because they've got Arda Goulet they've got Franco Mastantuono they've just signed Dean Housen they're about to sign Alvaro Carreras from from Benfica so that's a big outlay exactly so there's a lot of a lot of money there to recoup and he's the obvious sale right so So whether or not teams want to meet the reported 90 million price tag is one thing, but he is the clear candidate for sale.

1:02:48And I think there is a potential opportunity there for Arsenal or even City or Liverpool or whoever to come in and steal in. I still think he's an outstanding player. But if we do sign Madueke, for me, I don't see the need to have both of them. I see that unless we lose somebody. If we lose a Martinelli or a Trossard, then the dynamic changes. but if things stay as they are plus a madueke i think it's more important to have the central threat that sa offers plus the wide threat that he offers as well see phil when i was 20 and i bought my volkswagen jetta i was like there's no need for me to get the ferrari because i have the jetta now so you know it's the same thing if you have nani madueke what the hell do you need rodrigo for um absolutely um so yeah that's kind of how i see i think sa offers us offers us a little bit something special something special in central areas that ability to carry the ball I think he takes shots I think he's a little bit different to a Declan Rice or Mikel Marino who normally typically play in the number eight position he plays it differently to Erdegaard as well who's a lot more close space one two scooped passes over the top whereas Eze is a lot more I'm going to run through you kind of Morgan Rodgers style and and and whack shots basically so I just think his profile is more exciting and different for us.

1:04:09Whereas Rodrigo, if we signed him, it would just be another really good wide player who can play on both sides, scores a few goals, but do we need another one without sales? I just don't think so. Clive, did you see how he handled that? So he saw my facial expression. He saw there's a dumb joke coming. I'm going to pause. I'll let Elliot say whatever ridiculous shit he's got teed up. And then I'll go back to the serious analysis. It was just so smooth and so well handled. Thank Thank you. It's not my first time on this podcast. I would have taken a pity laugh, but it's fine. It's not like my ego's at stake here.

1:04:42Clive, how about that? Do you agree with what Phil has said? I mean, you know I love Eze. I have to admit, if we got him, I'd be super fascinated to see what the domino effects are of where he plays. Does he just become a left-wing option? Does he sometimes play left eight and Rice moves back or Rice moves over or Odegaard comes out. There's so many interesting possible ways you'd use an Eze unless we're just galaxy braining it and he'd be converted to a left wide forward, which he's done for England as well, by the way. So what do you think of Phil's points and where an Eze might fit in versus the more natural, I'd say, fit of Rodrigo at left wing?

1:05:19Elliot:Yeah, I think he's a harder fit for us, but actually turn that around. Maybe that's what we need. If we have the others that have those positions sorted out, you have sprinters in wide areas on both sides and martin nelly stays which i'd really hope he does stay i think the trust side essay thing i link that in my mind if i'm honest with you um i link that sort of player that sort of more creative wide man who can drop inside into a 10 second striker type thing i have those two linked but um i think as i said to you earlier this week i think it'll be a nice present to the fans that signing to bring some joy back to the timelines shall we say you know to see somebody who obviously wants to be here would suit our club down to the ground it's the right time in his career he's done his job for palace they've won their first trophy in history he scored the winning goals all the way through to the final almost it felt like beautiful story i want to see it happen i almost don't care about a tactical fit the emotional fit is perfect and last time i looked when i sit in that stadiums and i'm three pints deep you see the emotions I care about, and the players on the pitch and what they can do for me and how I feel about them.

1:06:27Elliot:You know, I just want him to be there and we'll work it out later. I don't want him to cost anybody. I want to make sure Ethan feels confident that he's going to get playing time. That's really important. You spend 10 years developing that player, not to just fancy a 27-year-old and then stop his career. I want to make sure that he has room to develop. That means he's got to be a left-hand side or a number 10 option on occasions, whether start or finishing at games. And we just had the season of watching our skipper have a really tough year. A really tough year. And what did it cost us? It cost us quite a lot.

1:07:04Elliot:Where people were saying, we've lost central creativity, we don't fill those spaces, blah, blah, blah. Not going to listen to that and then say, well, let's do nothing about that then, should we? Or should we get somebody that travels into those areas, receives a ball, got a really strong body to roll off people and bang shots. Yeah, mate, where do I sign up for that? Don't know where he's going to play, don't care. It's how he connects to other players. He's on their IQ level. I absolutely believe he is. And he'll only benefit us. And I don't like looking back in my football, but a lot of us remember 2008 Arsenal, lots of creative number eights, number 10s in our team.

1:07:43Elliot:And that team didn't win anything, but we all remember it. because it's beautiful to watch. And that's what the game is. So let's get back to that. Can I stay with you, Clive, for just one second and ask a question that I hope people don't regard this as me worrying because I don't do that. What? Why the laughter? But I think it's at least worth asking, is there any aspect of the essay links that would lead you to think there are some lingering, even minor concerns about Odegaard, either his physical recovery or returning to the level of the prior couple of seasons. Because look, Odegaard was rightly one of the, named as and considered one of the best players in the Premier League full stop the season before last.

1:08:32This past season, when he came back from injury, he never hit the level. He had, I think he was improving a bit, but he never hit the level that we know he had in him. And I just wonder if the SA links could be almost an insurance policy against any concern that Odegaard might struggle to return to that level do you think there's any of that here or is that just putting two and two

1:08:55Elliot:together getting 22 uh probably yeah it's what we do right is that we worry about things and um you know I do yeah and uh I just want to see us push each other you know I want to see us on a podcast pre a game trying to pick the 11 and we can't pick it and we're arguing about the last game that we saw that went so well and a player came on and scored two goals but is he going to start the next game i don't want to be worrying about um if michael marino is fit enough to play a game of football up front that's not fair on him and that's not where we should be i don't really want to be seeing kieran tini come on against ruinted in the champions league quarter final as a left winger you know this is the stuff i need to fix in my head you know and um and then that's my priority and you know what we're an elite football club playing at the elite competition in the world last in the champion league last year we came third out of 36 so we're right at the top day we got to the semi-final one of the best four teams in europe and basically our xg the winners that everyone's oologizing over we didn't have enough firepower did have enough in our locker and so you have to look at that and say i don't really care anymore about somebody i need to create competition and a competitive nature top end of this piece because everyone wants to be here i saw the christian norgaard interview today and he's 31 and his chief executive spoke about said he deserves this move he deserves a chance to go and win trophies we're so focused about the top for and where we are there's a whole professional game trying to get to this top end level and even at 31 he's arrived here at the elite level i'm so pleased for him he can have a chance to compete cares about his minutes he's right there turning up on our coach with our people with our fans much bigger entity traveling around europe champions league music mate that's what everybody wants right and if they don't look at the play well then they won't play but last year we couldn't say that didn't play well we're just hoping they'll be okay on saturday you see what i mean we need to fix that's what we're trying to fix earlier i'm really adamant about this we just need to change our mindsets you know it's a different game now it really is any quick words to add back to that phil before we go to our last quick question i have for you here not really i I think that was it.

1:11:23It was a really nice interview, actually. If you haven't seen it, anybody listening, it was really good. He spoke really well, and he said it was a dream come true to be at Arsenal. So I think you can't underestimate the power of wanting to be somewhere because I think that can give you an extra 5 % or 10 % when maybe your expectations of people might not be so high. Yeah. One thing, Phil, I wanted to ask you about is Saka's role. maybe I'm squinting to see it but um last season towards the end Saka seemed like he was occupying some more central locations than we've seen before yeah and I just sort of wonder if we might see Mikau play with that at times and if Meduake comes in could you see Saka and Meduake at times play together where Saka does start to take a full-time role as a more central player I'll confess, I actually don't see that and don't even necessarily like that because I think it means he has to work even harder at times and do a role that doesn't just let him get the ball and beat a man and influence the game in the final third.

1:12:27But it's a question that I've seen out there. Could Saka start to occupy more central locations? Could he move inside? Do you think that's something that could happen? what i hope is that we provide him with enough support and we put enough threat in the team to get him off the touchline away from four defenders who are constantly around him because i think you're right we did see it towards the end of the year last year um popping up around the edge of the area i mean we all remember that real madrid game the declan rice free kicks how did he win the first one you know he came inside off of the left back drove into the central space and they and they were worried they were scared so they fouled him I think it was David Alaba who fouled him you know he is so dangerous in any area of the pitch and actually when he first broke through my initial thought about his ceiling was that he would be a kind of Angel Di Maria style number eight um I don't know if you remember how he played for Carlo Ancelotti in 2014 in that kind of box-to-box role I really saw him a little too young but tell me it happens man don't worry about it um i could tell you i could tell you know yeah so so that's what he reminded me of and i thought he would end up being somebody like that but now i just think his game is so polished on the wing that he will primarily be be occupying those areas with the typical ben white overlaps with the odegaard uh link coming close to him but of course if we're against the deep block at home in need of a goal why can't he come off the touchline why can't he be on the edge of the area you know I think he's got more than enough capability to to link to shoot to to pull players away from him which could free others as well in a different moment but I don't think he'll be starting centrally no.

1:14:08Clive do you want to add to that?

1:14:09Elliot:Yeah the day Saka gets into the 10 I think it'd be wonderful I just don't think we need to do it in our current group of our current construct you've got players queuing up in that area that's maybe a reason why Nathan's not signed yet. We're about to buy a centre-forward. What's Kai's second-best position? It's probably right in that slot. And the third-best position is on the other side where Decan Rice is playing. So that's a worry because it's a senior player in the group. And so, again, it's all about the options, isn't it? And when you're there and you're watching a game, it's quite clear what you need to change.

1:14:42Elliot:And the biggest fear you have is when you turn around and it is Nathan Butler or Deji, and you can't change it. You know, that's the biggest fear, not the fear of, oh, I wonder if they could all fit in. I honestly don't care, right? I don't care because what I do care about is watching loads of different TV shows saying Arsenal are always going to come second, Netflix FC, blah, blah, blah. If I'm anyone near the club, I'm thinking we need to fix this shit. We need to sort this out and at least give us the tools to achieve and not hold back a little bit. and I think we did last year, maybe good reason for it, PSR-wise, et cetera.

1:15:24Elliot:But if you're going to show that sort of fiscal discipline in January and in the summer, that's another story. If you're going to do that, then come the moment in the summer, do your work. It seems as though we're doing that. My biggest fear when I turn around is that there's a giant spider behind me. I think we should leave it there. I don't know that there's much else to cover today, and it is one of these things. I'm always nervous that I'm going to hit stop record. I'm going to open up a browser and see Arsenal have signed this random player. We didn't even know we were linked with him. If only there was another way for you to talk about transfers earlier.

1:15:58Well, there will be a transfer daily coming later today. You're not going to want to miss it. And tomorrow, Friday Night Clive will have a special celebrity guest appearance. You're not going to want to miss that. So come join us. Come be with us. We want to be with you. Come be with us. And then we can be together. It'd be a beautiful thing because we love you. Phil, love you. Thanks for being on. Maybe the real Madueke was the pods we made along the way. Check Phil out on the Football Vision podcast where you'll get more of that kind of stuff. And Football Vision is doing their own transfer stuff, but they're doing, get this, look, I'm not saying I get it, but they're doing analysis instead of whatever the hell I do on the Transfer Daily is.

1:16:43Clive, always a pleasure, my friend. Talk to you tomorrow on Friday night, Clive. Thank you very much. Friday night Clive starring Clive okay my name is Elliot Smith block me everywhere we love you people you're just the best people the prettiest most handsome youngest virile intelligent people and we just generally appreciate you and want good things for you which means Ezay and Rodrigo Nani out I'm kidding we love you and we'll talk to you after ourselves and we'll talk to you we'll don't know

1:17:33Elliot:Hey Chicagoland, the Wayfair store is in your neighborhood at Edens Plaza and Wilmette. Finally, you can feel the fabric, sit on the sectionals, and even open the refrigerators. Plus, our in-store designers will help you bring it all together with free one-on-one design support for any project on any budget. Yep, we said free. Oh, and did we mention the cafe? So what are you waiting for? Come see all that's in store. Visit the Wayfair store today at Edens Plaza and Wilmette.

From the publisher

On this edition of the ArsenalVision Podcast, Elliot is joined by Phil Costa and Clive to break down the potential Noni Madueke transfer from all the angles. There’s also discussions about Norgaard, Eze, Rodrygo and Gabriel Heinze joining the coaching staff. Chapter timings below.

Chapters:

00:00 Intro Music
04:44 Reaction to Madueke Transfer Rumors
08:58 Madueke Player Profile
34:03 Arteta’s Transfer Influence
41:36 Should Fan Sentiment Matter
45:51 Coaching Staff Change: Heinze In
50:53 Christian Norgaard Signing
59:27 Eze vs Rodrigo Debate
01:07:03 Odegaard Fitness and Eze Insurance
01:10:25 Could Saka Play Centrally
01:15:57 Closing Remarks

Signup for our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/arsenalvisionpodcast (Get 50% off first month with code AVP50)

You can now gift a Patreon membership https://www.patreon.com/arsenalvisionpodcast/gift

Interested in advertising on this podcast? Email sales@bluewirepods.com


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

More from The ArsenalVision Podcast - Arsenal FC

All 175 episodes
The Big Madueke Debate (and More Transfer Nonsense)The ArsenalVision Podcast - Arsenal FC · 1 h 16 min
Listen in VO