4 Principles of Influence from a Hostage Negotiator | Scott Tillema

12 May 2025 · 1 h 1 min

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Podcast Summary: The Art of Charm - Episode with Scott Tillema

Episode Overview In this episode of *The Art of Charm*, retired SWAT hostage negotiator Scott Tillema shares his four-part framework for effective influence and negotiation. Drawing from his extensive training by the FBI and Harvard, Scott discusses how these high-stakes negotiation tactics can be applied in everyday situations, such as workplace conflicts and personal relationships.

Key Concepts

  1. Negotiation Partner vs. Opponent
  2. Shift in Mindset: View your negotiation partner as a collaborator rather than an adversary.
  3. Collaboration Over Competition: Successful negotiations depend on working together to achieve a mutually beneficial outcome.
  1. Common Mistakes in Leadership
  2. Influence Misconceptions: Leaders often believe that coercion or authority will yield compliance; however, genuine connection is vital.
  1. Tactical Breathing Techniques
  2. Mental Preparation: Use breathing techniques (e.g., box breathing) to maintain calm during high-pressure conversations.
  1. Embodiment of Skills
  2. Beyond Learning: The transformation occurs when one embodies negotiation skills rather than merely learning them.
  1. Timing & Delivery
  2. When to Speak: Knowing the appropriate moment and how to deliver your message is crucial for effective communication.
  3. Importance of Tone and Timing: The delivery often matters more than the content itself; how you communicate can significantly impact the conversation.
  1. Pillars of Respect
  2. Four Elements of Respect:
  3. Fairness: Ensure all parties feel treated justly.
  4. Empathy: Show genuine concern for the other person's feelings.
  5. Autonomy: Offer choices in dialogue to foster a sense of control.
  6. Recognition: Acknowledge the other person's contributions and feelings.
  1. Tactical Empathy
  2. Understanding Emotions: Tactical empathy is about recognizing and validating emotions rather than manipulating them.
  3. Influence through Listening: The best negotiators are skilled listeners who connect with the other party's emotions.
  1. Learning from Failures
  2. Reflection on Past Outcomes: Analyzing past negotiations, especially failures, can provide valuable lessons for future interactions.
  1. Non-Verbal Communication
  2. Awareness of Body Language: Recognizing non-verbal cues in oneself and others is crucial for effective negotiation.
  3. Avoid Reading Body Language Aloud: It can create discomfort and disrupt the flow of conversation.

Episode Takeaways

  • Influence is Built on Connection: Establishing rapport is the foundation of influence and negotiation.
  • Practice Makes Perfect: Engage in active listening and negotiation practice outside of high-stress situations to develop these essential skills.
  • Flexibility and Awareness: Adjust your approach based on the emotional state of the other party and be mindful of your own emotional management.

Conclusion Scott Tillema shares invaluable insights into negotiation strategies that emphasize emotional intelligence, empathy, and effective communication. By applying these principles, listeners can enhance their influence and improve their relationships in both personal and professional contexts.

---

For more insights and resources from this episode, including Scott Tillema’s work, visit the [Negotiations Collective website](https://negotiationscollective.com) and connect with him on LinkedIn.

If you're interested in further developing your interpersonal skills, consider checking out other offerings from The Art of Charm, such as their networking masterclass and social intelligence assessments.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Rinse takes your laundry and hand delivers it to your door. expertly cleaned and folded so you could take the time once spent folding and sorting and waiting to finally pursue a whole new version of you like tea time you or this tea time you or even this tea time you said you hear about Dave or even tea time tea time tea time you so update on Dave it's up to you we'll take the laundry rinse it's time to be great this episode is brought to you by State Farm. Listening to this podcast, smart move. Being financially savvy, smart move. Another smart move, having State Farm help you create a competitive price when you choose to bundle home and auto.

0:45Bundling, just another way to save with a personal price plan. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there. Prices are based on rating plans that vary by state. Coverage options are selected by the customer. Availability, amount of discounts and savings, and eligibility vary by state. This is the outcome that sticks with you. this is when you look back and remember, is there something more I could have done? Something more I could have said? Could I have said it in a different way? Did I need different or better or more coaching? Because I look back and know that, hey, this is an outcome that I potentially had the power to change.

1:29All right, let's kick off today's show. Today, we're talking with negotiation experts, Scott Tillema, about his four-part framework for influencing anyone in high-pressure situations. Scott is a retired SWAT hostage negotiator. He received his training by the FBI and Harvard University and has over 20 years in law enforcement expertise. In 2023, Scott dedicated his career to serving others in a new way as a corporate trainer. He's a founding partner of the Negotiation Collective and speaks on how to use the same powerful, life-saving negotiation principles and techniques to create business success.

2:02Today, we're gonna chat about why emotional management trumps logic in any negotiation, see how tactical breathing can help calm you when those stakes are high, and find out why timing your message matters more than the words themselves. Welcome to the show, Scott. Great to have you. Great to be here. Thanks for having me. You have a unique background as a SWAT hostage negotiator. And I'd love to start with just learning a little bit about what piqued your interest in high stakes negotiations. Yeah, it's an exciting field. So if you are the kind of person who doesn't enjoy a boring job or sitting at a desk or something that's going to be the same all the time, this might be a career consideration.

2:42I brought in my background as a a major in behavioral science, a master's in psychology, a real interest in the brain, how people think, how people make decisions they make, and brought this to a career in law enforcement and said, you know, how can we put this all together in a way that's going to be interesting and exciting for me and impactful to the people we're serving and landed on hostage negotiation. Did you find yourself drawn to high stakes negotiations before your career? like as a kid or growing up? No, I think I was a very boring person, very predictable, very nice, normal, middle-class family growing up, nothing too exciting.

3:23So I think the idea of a shot of adrenaline every time you go to work was a pretty cool feeling. Yeah, I can only imagine. And for many in our audience, they're not in such high stakes negotiation situations. But I think for a lot of us, we have a misunderstanding around negotiations, being a competition, one side winning. I'd love for you to unpack just your view of what an active negotiation really should be. Yeah. And I think that that's very normal to say, I want to get more. I want to win. I want this outcome. But when it was proposed to me, the idea of the person you are going to be talking with is your negotiation partner, not your opponent, not the other team, not those people over there.

4:06This is your partner. It really changed my mindset of how I need to come into these conversations because truly we need to work together to get to an outcome that we otherwise couldn't get to. So we kind of move away from, hey, I'm trying to win this, but rather how do we together get to this outcome? And then I studied the work of Dr. George Colreaser, who is a psychologist, professor of leadership, and he talks about bonding. Everything he talks about is around bonding and connection. And I really brought this piece in to say, how do I connect? Because if I want influence, influence begins with connection.

4:45And if we want connection, connection begins with a dialogue. So I need to be able to sit with someone, have a real conversation, be able to talk, be able to listen and connect with this individual who may be suffering a significant crisis in their life. And sometimes that's tough to do, but I found out that's the only way because we're not going to force people. We're not going to push people. People need to be able to make that decision to say, I am going to choose this outcome that we're trying to get. And for many of us in our life, negotiation is typically with our partners, with our family, friends, coworkers.

5:18Yeah, we think about the high stakes negotiations around buying a house or a car or maybe negotiating your salary. But for the most part, we're negotiating every day just in our daily lives with people we are connected with. And if we take it as a I win, you lose or you're my opponent strategy, we're going to fray a lot of those important relationships in our life. For sure. For sure. And how many of us oftentimes give the very worst of our communication to the people who matter most in our lives? And it's, you know, not because we're bad people, but we work all day. We've been working all week.

5:51So by the time we get home in the evening, by the time we get to the weekend, where we should be performing at our very best in negotiation, in conflict, in communication, they sometimes get our worst. Well, I think very many people listening probably wouldn't assume that you're trying to connect with someone who takes a hostage. So walk us through what you would do to prepare for these situations when, you know, obviously we're not trying to connect with criminals. Yeah. So I don't do the international hostage taking, kidnapping, ransom kind of thing. I think that's more like a business negotiation where someone's taking a hostage because they want something.

6:27But in the U.S., thankfully, hostage taking doesn't happen frequently. And when the SWAT team is called is usually because we have an individual who's in crisis. Maybe they're armed and barricaded or sometimes maybe they take a hostage because maybe they're robbing a store and they didn't intend to take hostages. But the police drove by and oh, I don't know what to do. Or it's a domestic type situation within the family where it's an emotion driven event. And in these cases, it may not even be clear to the person who is in crisis what it is they want here. and when they're in such a heightened state that becomes a little bit unpredictable and a little bit dangerous so the first thing I want to do is try and lower that tension and I think there is an expectation that when the police show up and you're on the phone with somebody that is going to be like it is maybe in some of the movies where you're going to do this I'm going to tell you what to do and we're going to have that confrontation and how disarming can it be when I show up and say hi my name is Scott I'm with the police department I'd like to help is everybody okay in there.

7:30And I come in with a collaborative tone. In addition to the actual words that I'm saying, it can really change that mindset because they're expecting a certain thing. And maybe sometimes they just need that time to come down a little bit. I'm not going to come in and start telling them what to do or demanding anything from them or even asking them, hey, what are your demands? I mean, rarely do we ever have somebody who wants some demands. People don't even know what they want because they're so overrun with emotion. So if you want to be good at this, we have to understand how we handle emotion, both our own emotion and our own excitement, as well as the person that we're going to be sitting down and having a conversation with, because these are all emotionally driven incidents.

8:15And in order to, to bridge this gap, to get an understanding of who you're talking with, what is it that they need? What, uh, what are they communicating? what's not being said, all of those things is tactical empathy. And it's funny because I do a lot of content creation for the company. And when I'm posting videos about creating empathy, when people see that there's an actual science behind it, they start freaking out, right? I had recently gotten called somebody who teaches dark empathy. So when I saw your term of tactical empathy, I was like, well, that's much more appropriate. Because all this is, is having an education on how these things work and then using them to our advantage.

9:14That's afforded to everybody who's willing to look into these skills. And as AJ and I have been telling people and teaching people for the last 18 years, they're easily learnable. So if you're not willing to grab an understanding of interpersonal communication, how people relate and just wish magic that it happens, that's on you. Why do I have to be the bad guy? Why do I have to get painted as the nefarious dark psychology expert? I have a mission too, just as you do. And as long as I'm not using it for nefarious purposes or trying to hurt others, I have a life, a job, and a family that I want to be working for and I have to create for them.

10:08So I'm going to use everything in my power to make those things happen. Tactical empathy is about having an understanding of what needs to be done and using science and human connection as a means to get it. Right, because very practically, you can't solve a problem if you don't know what it is. And so often we come in and I project how I feel and what I think to you and your situation. And we wonder, well, why didn't that work? Because, well, I don't know you. I don't know your situation. I don't know what struggle you're going through right now. So I will argue to people, the enemy of empathy is problem solving.

10:52We jump right in and we start solving problems. Why are we solving problems? We shouldn't be solving problems right now. We should be listening and working to understand. And if nothing else, it's just self-serving because if I want to get through this, if I want to get a good outcome, if I want to get to where we want to go, I need to understand the situation. And it's so powerful when we're truly empathetic, when we want to hear, when we want to sit with somebody, we're not solving their problem. We're listening to them and they feel, hey, this is the first time that somebody cares. Somebody actually gets it.

11:27Somebody is interested in hearing my perspective. that goes a long way in reducing some of that tension. And I think that this is the key skill for anybody in leadership. This is why you should study hostage and crisis negotiation, because you want influence, influence over people externally, future clients, marketing sales. You want influence internally over your teams. How do we get the best out of people? They want to show up for work. This is a place they want to be and give their very best. We want influence. How do we do that, it's through connection. And with that gathering information.

12:02So I think so many of us default to trying to learn tactics and strategies to one up or get the other side to change their mind. But in reality, the person with the most information typically is the one who has a source of power in that negotiation and can guide it towards a win-win scenario for everyone. 100%. Your power in negotiation is information and options. So many people think it's tactics at the table. The best negotiators are smooth talkers. And yes, there's an element of that. You know, we can discuss that a little bit, but your real power is information options. What does this person want?

12:36What can we offer them? What are their interests? I know what your position is. Your position is no, or you want this, but what do you really want here? What is the interest behind it? Now we're starting to open doors. Yeah. And I think so many of us look at negotiations in those key moments and we're then putting a lot of pressure on ourself by not practicing these skills outside of those difficult conversations and outside of those moments where the stakes are really high. So what's your approach to really building these muscles of empathy and active listening to be able to garner the information you need in those key moments?

13:09For sure. And there's eight skills of active listening. This is what the FBI teaches their negotiators or any negotiation class teaches their negotiators. And it stuns me that we have people who are titled as negotiators who don't know these skills of active listening. And I'm not yet convinced that the eight skills of active listening are really going to make you that much better of a listener. But it really demonstrates to the other person that you're listening. And that's the value that now you feel that I'm listening. And yes, along the way, I'm gathering information and options. And people ask me, well, how do I practice this?

13:44I will tell you later today, you are going to get a spam phone call from somebody. They're trying to steal your credit card number, maybe your granddaughter is in jail in Mexico, whatever their scam of the day is, I want you to take that call and have a conversation. And you're not allowed to hang up until you've gotten through the eight skills of active listening. You should have enough time to Google it and figure out what they are, jot them all down. And as you go through this conversation with this scammer, I want you to check that off. Oh, you sound frustrated. There's a nice emotion label.

14:14Check. And we're going right through the list and you're going to practice. And And in five minutes, you're going to be so impressed that you just got another chance to practice your eight skills of active listening with somebody who's trying to scam you. And then when you get done, you say thank you and hang up and wait for the next. Yeah. Unfortunately, that next call is coming as well. It's coming. You answered the first.

14:40You know, that sinking feeling when your brilliant idea gets ignored in a meeting only to be repeated by someone else minutes later. And then you receive slack seeking more of their input. Or when you see less qualified team members building effortless relationships with leadership while you feel invisible. The problem isn't your intelligence or technical skills. Harvard research confirms what we've seen with over 11 ,000 professionals. Technical expertise only accounts for 15 % of your success. The real difference maker is social intelligence. And here's the trigger moment that most analytical minds miss.

15:16People aren't making decisions about you based on your competence. They're making decisions based on how you make them feel. After nearly two decades working with engineers from Google, Microsoft, and Amazon, we discovered something we call the technical success paradox. The very qualities that make you exceptional in your field are working against you socially. Your analytical mind is trying to solve people problems with the wrong operating system. That's why we developed the social calibration method. the first system that leverages your analytical strengths instead of fighting against them.

15:50Imagine walking into your next meeting and immediately commanding attention without saying a word. Picture leadership inviting you to high-level discussions and implementing your ideas without hesitation. And your social calendar filling with invites you actually want to attend. This isn't about changing who you are. It's about applying the same systematic approach that made you technically excellent to mastering both professional and social dynamics. Visit theartofcharm.com slash intel for a social intelligence assessment and discover exactly what's holding you back. That's theartofcharm.com slash intel because your brilliance deserves to be recognized in the boardroom and beyond.

16:28If you're still overpaying for wireless, it's time to say yes to saying no. That's Mint Mobile's whole thing. Their favorite word is no. No contracts, no monthly bills, no overages, no hidden fees, no BS. And that's why I love Mint Mobile premium wireless service for just 15 bucks a month. Ditch those overpriced plans with jaw-dropping bills, surprise overages, and all the hidden fees. Mint starts at just$15 a month. And you're not giving up coverage. Every plan comes with high-speed data and unlimited talk and text on the nation's largest 5G network. You can even use your own phone, keep your number, and bring all your contacts with you.

17:04No hassle. Mint Mobile is unbeatable at this pricing. Ready to say yes to saying no? Make the switch at mintmobile.com slash charm. That's mintmobile.com slash charm. Upfront payment of$45 required, equivalent to$15 per month. Limited time new customer offer for the first three months only. Speeds may slow above 35 gigabytes on an unlimited plan. Taxes and fees extra. See Mint Mobile for details. As the weather finally cools down, I'm swapping in the pieces that actually get the job done. Warm, durable, and built to last. And Quince delivers every time. Quince has all the false staples you actually want to wear on repeat, like 100 % Mongolian cashmere sweater starting at just$60, classic fit denim, and real leather and wool outerwear that looks sharp and holds up.

17:50I've actually got my eye on their suede trucker jacket. It's perfect for layering, and it hits that balance of casual but still put together. What I like about Quince is they partner directly with ethical factories and top artisans. By cutting out the middlemen, you get premium quality at half the cost of similar brands. And it's not just clothing. I love their sheets. They have items like bedding and travel accessories. Quince has really become a go-to for me across the board. Same here. Everything I grabbed from Quince has held up and it doesn't wreck my budget. Layer up this fall with pieces that feel as good as they look.

18:23Go to quince.com slash charm for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada too. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E dot com slash charm. Free shipping and 365 day returns.

18:41Yeah, I know in those moments where adrenaline has now been injected, right, it's hard to garner these skills. But there are other moments outside of even the scam calls where we can really work on active listening. And that active listening starts to elicit the information that creates the options for us in a negotiation and an opportunity for us to find that win-win in any situation. So when you're getting ready for one of these high stakes conversations where you know emotion is going to be running, what is your personal checklist to help you prepare? Yeah, and this is around the concept of managing yourself first.

19:17And I push this to every leader, every conflict resolution, every negotiation class that we teach. A huge principle is this, manage yourself first. Because there's nobody out there that needs a class in conflict resolution. When somebody is yelling at you, should you start yelling at them or should you take time to listen? We all know or we should know the basics of conflict resolution. So this is really an exercise in self-management. So can I manage myself? And part of this is having that stress inoculation of having practiced and done it before. If this is your first important conversation where there's going to be consequence based on what's just going to be discussed, this is probably not ideal for you.

19:58But are you willing to sit down and practice not only going through your talking points, but have you practiced and prepared your delivery of how you are going to say it? Because it's easy when we're on the couch thinking about what we're going to say or in the shower, if we're talking out loud or wherever you might do your practice. But when it's game time and you have somebody sitting across from you and the pressure's on and they might be crying, they might be yelling, they might be standing up and moving around. How are you going to respond? Do you have that awareness of how you function under stress?

20:29So number one, take some time in practice. Like if this is a serious business for you, where you stand to gain or lose millions, tens, hundreds of millions of dollars, this practice has to be part of your routine. But when we get into it, for me, tactical breathing or box breathing is a big thing where we count in for the we breathe in for the count of four, hold it for the count of four, breathe out for the count of four, hold it for the count of four. And this just instinctively kicks in. I remember I was responding to a call of an active shooter at a shopping mall once, and I was a rank of lieutenant, meaning that I was going to be somebody in charge once I got there.

21:06And instinctively, as I was racing to the mall with three tactical officers in the car, I remember kicking right into this tactical breathing or this box breathing to make sure that I can think and process this information rather than move to this instinctive fight or flight space. In a negotiation, we have to be able to listen. We have to be creative. We have to be able to have room for empathy and connection. And we can't do that if we're overwhelmed. Even with our clients and our X-Factor Accelerator, all of the macro points, there's six macro points to our conflict resolution. And by the time we get to the conflict resolution section, we have already practiced each one of those macro points in its own separate thing together.

21:57So now that when we're now doing a conflict resolution, they've had practice with each of those steps and now they're seeing how they all stacked together work through a resolution. and we all know that certainly everybody in this conversation knows what happens if i know that i have a negotiation tomorrow and i'm like oh i'm just going to listen to an art of charm podcast on negotiation tonight before i go to bed and i'll be good to go tomorrow that's not how this works because as you mentioned there is a lot of tension and pressure in the unknown and and until we are comfortable with that tension of pressure in the unknown.

22:42We're not going to remember those six magic steps to Art of Charms conflict negotiation. You're not going to be able to walk through each one and be able to focus on the micro points of what you're looking for and listening for within each step. All of that comes in our implementation sessions, which is why you want to pick up that phone and see what the scam is of the day. To practice. Practice. Yeah. And what you say is so true. I remember my first negotiation. Now, I was trained by the FBI. We went through the class. You did the role plays. You did the skill building. But I remember that first negotiation.

23:24I was overwhelmed with stress. It was a guy who was reportedly holding a woman hostage. Police thought they heard duct tape and a bullet being racked into a gun. And all of a sudden, there like, here you go, kid, you're our lead negotiator. Like I just had that moment of, I can't believe this. And it was overwhelming that there's a lot of stress and pressure here. And you know, it takes some time to get into that flow. It takes some time to be on the phone a few times before you kind of settle in and say, Hey, I've got this. So it's not only building the confidence, but knowing the skill and being comfortable with that ambiguity and that unpredictable, whatever is going to happen next, you know, all right, I can, I can get through this.

24:07Well, there's also a power that's unleashed there as well. So if you understand all those steps, and then all of a sudden you see how stacking together makes it powerful to walk through a resolution for, for our folks, after we go through that session, it's now look in your life for any sort of contention or disagreement or anything that you would like to see fixed that needs to be tweaked and go use these steps. And it's quite funny because everyone starts making their life instantly better because all of a sudden when they take that class, they realize they had already learned all the steps.

24:46Now they're seeing how the pieces all fit together towards a resolution. And now they're eager to use it. And all of a sudden, everything in their life starts to get better. And it's a lot of fun. I certainly know as I was learning conflict resolution, at the time that I was learning it, I was still managing a bar and a rock and roll club. So there was plenty of conflict for me to get into every night to walk through these. But after the second or third time through and realizing the power that I had just unleashed, I was looking for conflict to find resolution because I just wanted to continue sharpening these skills because I felt so powerful using them.

25:33And it's like for a lot of people, if you're not implementing these things that you're learning on all of these podcasts and all of these books, you're missing out on actualizing your true potential. And I love what you said here. It makes your life better because these professional development classes that people go to, these skills don't end at five o 'clock. They don't just turn off because this is a process. If at first people give up on this because it's awkward, it's clunky, it doesn't work well the first time. The process, we're moving from something you don't know to something you do know.

Read the full transcript

26:07And once you know it, we're moving from something you know to a skill that you have, which is a really good step. But now over the next months and years, we take that last step and it becomes who you are. And once it becomes who you are, then we can drill down. And now I'm going to study the non-verbals. Now I'm going to work on my own posture, facial expressions. We're really starting to put the cherry on top because I've managed myself. I built the skill. It's who I am. And now I can be really present with somebody. And these are the people who can just, they get you to say yes, because they're that good.

26:43And it's not only the transformation within yourself when you implement all these skills, it's the transformation of your reality around you when you put them in the place to change it. I think a lot of people have a blind spot around how much their emotions rule the day in these situations. They think the decisions are made logically, their own decisions they logic, and then other people are acting logically in the decisions that they make. But what we're talking about here is getting comfortable managing your own emotions so that you can have the influence to manage other people's emotions. And I think that's a real blind spot for a lot of us because we like to think we're just logical and everything after we make that decision, we can logically say made sense.

27:25When in actuality, a lot of what's going on with this release of adrenaline and the emotions you're carrying into these difficult conversations, maybe getting cut off on your way to work or having a disagreement with your partner, and then you have to show up and manage a conflict between coworkers. Those emotions rule the day. A hundred percent. In our training classes, we'll do a poll, you know, are you more emotional? Are you more logic and reason? And then we segue into an exercise where people are stunned at their own outcomes where it's clearly an emotional decision. This is an outcome. And I say, all right, now let's go back and add some time and add some thought to this.

28:01And their heads are exploding going, I can't believe this is the outcome that I chose. And they realize it's all emotion based. And what we talk about is the book Man's Search for Meaning by Viktor Frankl. And that very famous passage in there where he talks about between stimulus and the response, there is a space. And in that space is your freedom to choose your response. And that's your growth. That's your power. And how can we add more time between stimulus and response so we can bring back some of that logic and reason which we need? And some of the studies that show that we're all emotional, they say that we then go back and justify our emotional response using logic and reason to make ourselves feel better and look smarter about the emotional decision that we just made.

28:46Yeah. And I think we try to suppress or ignore those emotions instead of actually doing the more important thing, which is labeling, getting comfortable with understanding them. And then that allows you to be more comfortable with picking up on those emotions and others. Because a lot of what we're talking about here is not just managing our own emotions, but you got to manage the other person at the other side of the table's emotions, whether it's the conflict that they're heading off or whether it's the fierce negotiation they're in with you. Their emotions really matter in the outcome. For sure.

29:14And when you get to that point where you can manage yourself and then manage that other person, now you're leading. Now you are leading the negotiation. You are going to get to better outcomes nearly 100 % of the time when you are in the driver's seat. And there's negotiation trainers out there that talk about, let's separate the person from the problem. And I'm convinced that they've never actually done a negotiation because how many of us are so invested in everything we do, whether it be our work, our personal life, our relationships, that when something goes bad, we simply don't care. Like that doesn't happen.

29:46Like you feel that when there's a failure, you feel that when there's a bad outcome and we don't like that. One of the best books out there, I really enjoy this book, is called Beyond Reason, Using Emotions When You Negotiate. Dan Shapiro from the Harvard Program on Negotiation, love this one, talks about five core concerns. And it really validates the idea that we are emotional people and we should use this to our advantage. So that's a big first step is understanding and getting comfortable with your own and then moving into understanding the other side. And then in your four principles framework, you have three other principles that I'd love to cover.

30:21The next being timing. So what is timing? And let's unpack that for the audience. How can we use that to our advantage? Yeah, timing is your strategy piece, knowing when to deliver the message. So for example, I'm negotiating with a guy, I'm the lead negotiator with a man who's armed and barricade. He says, I'm going to kill you. And then he starts shooting. So we got shots being fired out of this house where he's armed and barricaded. My goal here is to get this guy out peacefully without violence. So as he's shooting at me, is this the time to say to him, pardon me, sir, I think you should put the gun down and surrender.

30:56It's comical because you know it's going to be an absolute flop failure because there's no way that this is going to be effective. But why? Maybe I got to say it in the right tone, but more importantly, I have to say it at the right time. So the timing thought is, am I in the best place to deliver this message? Am I centered? Am I where I need to be? And is the person that I'm talking with, are they in a position where they can even receive this message? Can they even process that? We're negotiating with a man. He was holding a woman hostage. And you can hear in the background, he's vomiting as he's negotiating with the police negotiator.

31:35And this is the moment where we look around and be like, is anybody concerned that maybe he's got a stomach bug or early strain of COVID? Clearly, that's not the case. He's so psychologically overwhelmed. He can't even control his own body right now. So let's be mindful and thoughtful about when we deliver the message. But so often people just, they can't wait to talk. They're just waiting and waiting, waiting. And, and they're just, they just want to say whatever they need to say rather than being thoughtful. And we couple this with understanding as the first principle to say timing, have I done what I was supposed to do first, understand the situation, understand the person, this is your power.

32:13And now am I going to be thoughtful in when I deliver the message? Let's be real. We all know someone who just has it. They walk into a room and people notice. Conversations spark. Friendships happen effortlessly. Opportunities seem to find them. And if you're honest, you probably felt the opposite too. Standing there feeling invisible, awkward small talk, and watching somebody else effortlessly connect while you wonder, what do they have that I don't? We call it the X factor. And here's the truth. It's not luck and it's not something you're born with. It's a learnable skill. And when you have it, everything gets easier.

32:53Whether it's making new friends, connecting deeper with people you care about, or even landing unexpected opportunities, your X Factor changes your life. Inside the X Factor Accelerator, we help you unlock that hidden magnetism through live coaching, real-world social calibration practice, and a community of high performers building the same skills. You'll finally start attracting the right people into your life naturally. No more wondering why some people get all the invites, dates, introductions, and second chances. Because when you have it, they come to you. Rate us up sitting on the sidelines and start living fully connected.

33:30Apply now at unlockyourxfactor.com. Spots are limited, and once we're full, that's it. Go to unlockyourxfactor.com now. Your future friendships, your future relationships, and your future self will thank you. Think you're the only one struggling with performance issues in the bedroom? You're not. And now there's an easier way to fix it from home. That's where Rex MD comes in. It's an online telehealth service that helps men get real FDA approved medications straight to your door. Everything's done online. No doctor's office, no waiting rooms, no awkward conversations. Here's how it works. First, share your symptoms, health history, and goals through a short quiz.

34:08Then a U.S. licensed provider reviews your information and prescribes medication if appropriate. Your treatment gets sent to you with free two-day delivery. It's that easy. And RexMD team is there for ongoing care. Just send a message. What I love about RexMD, total discretion, private consultations, and direct-to-door delivery in discreet packaging. No pharmacy trips needed. Plus, it's care that you can trust. FDA-approved medications tailored to individual needs. Over 475 ,000 men have chosen RexMD, with over 50 million tablets prescribed and delivered. This isn't just about performance. It's about feeling secure in yourself and your relationships again.

34:48Don't put your love life on hold. Take back control of your confidence and intimacy. Get up to 95 % off treatment with Rex MD. Visit rexmd.com slash charm. That's rexmd.com slash charm. See full details and usage at rexmd.com. Prescription required. Results may vary. When it comes to what your family eats and drinks, you know your choices matter. You're the expert because you know what fits your life. And getting it right starts with good information. That's why America's beverage companies are sharing more information about our ingredients at GoodToKnowFacts.org. No spin, no judgments, just the facts straight from the experts for more than 140 beverage ingredients.

35:36Visit GoodToKnowFacts.org. You talked about this a little bit earlier. I'd love to talk about delivery because often it's more important how we say it than what we're actually saying in these moments with all the emotion that's running through the difficult conversation. 100 percent. Gary Nesner, one of the first or the first chief negotiator of the FBI, always talks about in his debriefings with people that he's had negotiations with. he'll always say this line. People will tell him, I really don't remember what you said, but I really like how you said it. And that's what people remember. We create feeling in others with our delivery.

36:19And in a real setup with a SWAT negotiation, it's not like you see on TV. On TV, you got Denzel Washington, he's looking good. He's on the cell phone strutting up and down Fifth Avenue, like he's looking good. But in the real world, it doesn't work like that. I am sitting right across from a coach or a secondary negotiator who is doing nothing but managing my delivery. And with that, we're looking at the rate, the rhythm, the pressure, the volume, the tone of what's being said. And in real time, I got somebody who's making adjustments to my delivery as we're having these negotiations. And it's powerful because you get excited.

36:57So we're starting to pick up the speed and the momentum. And sometimes you just need someone to give you that cue. hey, let's slow it down here a little bit. Or let's turn down the volume here. Let's take the pressure off the words. And now we're giving an entirely different feeling to somebody else just based on the delivery. My content really isn't changing at all, but the delivery changes and it's an entirely different feeling from someone sitting across the table from me. And that cadence is so powerful. You can use that to your advantage. We often don't realize internally that our cadence is picking up and having that outside perspective of saying, hey, slow down is so impactful in these moments.

37:38Do you have any checks for yourself internally in these moments to help guide you if you don't have that coach in the room with you? Yeah, well, well, two things. First of all, practice and have this opportunity to work with somebody who can say, here's where you get going. As soon as you get interrupted, you get a little louder, you get a little faster. As soon as you get frustrated, here's what happens. So understanding yourself and getting that feedback, but ask somebody, ask someone, you know, and trust, this is going to be a great moment where you can sit down and ask someone, Hey, under stress, under pressure, how is my delivery in conflict communication?

38:16And there's a person out there who's been waiting a very, very long time to give you this feedback of how you engage with them when the pressure's on. So get that. Get that feedback. Get that practice. And it's going to change. It's going to change your person effect, how people experience you just based on little adjustments of your delivery. And people are going to love it. If we're coupling it with the first principle of understanding, being a better listener, being thoughtful of when we deliver the message, and now we're starting to put these pieces together with being thoughtful of our delivery elements, people are going to experience you in a whole different way and they are going to love it.

38:58I'm sure my wife is itching to have that conversation for feedback with me. There's something she wants to tell you. Absolutely. Now, the last piece of the framework is respect. And I think oftentimes we are looking for the resolution and we're not thinking about the respect. But in these difficult conversations, most likely we're going to have to do business with this person again. We're going to have to work with this person. We're going to live with our spouse. So respect is a big part of the difficult conversation, but it's often overlooked because we're seeking resolution. I think it almost begins with that mindset of respect.

39:30And it's more than just being respectful. because when I ask somebody, how do you demonstrate respect to someone? I'll get the yes, please. No, thank you. Yes, sir. No, ma 'am. The politeness. But respect for me is going deeper to understand what's driving human behavior. And when I drill down on respect, there's really kind of four elements that I look at. It's fairness. Do people feel that they're being treated fairly? Empathy, which we kind of let off that conversation with. Does someone feel like someone cares about them. Autonomy is the freedom to make my own decisions. And are we giving them some element of autonomy and then recognition, which is a huge driver of human behavior, a huge driver of engagement, are people being recognized in the way that they want to receive it.

40:23And sometimes I'll get challenged on this one. Okay, I'm negotiating with a guy who's holding a knife to his throat. And he's been sitting there for 30 minutes. I've been telling him, drop the knife, put the knife down. And he's just simply not doing it. What is there to recognize? And I said, let's brainstorm. Let's do that scenario and come up with 10 statements of positive recognition and we can do it. How about thank you for not hurting yourself. I appreciate that you've taken time to share your situation. Thanks for not insulting my mother. We can come up with a whole bunch of different pieces of positive recognition, even when seemingly somebody isn't doing a whole lot.

41:02Let's look for what we want to have happen in the future and give a little bit of that positive feedback and see if we can connect these pieces, these elements of fairness, empathy, autonomy, recognition with that respect trigger inside of them and have them feel like they are a partner in the outcome of what's about to happen. Can you unpack the autonomy piece of that a little bit more for us? So this is the freedom to make our decision. So I tell people, hey, do you want to, in like a business negotiate, here's our offer. And the answer is either going to be yes or no. But what if we give three different packages and three different options for them to consider here?

41:40So now they, well, I really like this. I really like this. I really like that. You have some freedom in my world. I've arrested hundreds, if not thousands of people, they're handcuffed behind their back. We get them back into the lockup facility. I'll ask them, hey, I'm going to take these handcuffs off and get you a little bit more comfortable, but I still need to handcuff you to this bench. Would it be more comfortable for you if it's your right hand or your left hand? Seemingly, it's a small piece, but instead of me telling them what to do and having full control over them, hey, you know, maybe my right hand or maybe my left hand.

42:13In either case, I don't care. They're not going anywhere. They're still going to be locked down. But these little moments where we can offer them the freedom to make a decision is really, really powerful. And to maybe go further, there's a whole list of like unwritten rules in each of our workplaces, each of our fields. And imagine this, you're on an airplane and you got the window seat. You know your airplane ticket says you have the window seat, but it doesn't say you are in exclusive control of the four cent window shade. But you know that you are. Everybody knows that. If I'm in the window seat, I control the window shade.

42:50Because what happens when the person over on the aisle reaches across? I'm looking out the window. I'm flying wherever I'm flying, looking at this beautiful sunset. And this person reaches across and closes my window shade. I'm going to lose my mind, right? It's like, what are you doing? Like, this is mine. You are in my space. So sometimes a power imbalance can be an autonomy trigger. When you are the boss, you are HR, and maybe you're coming in and working with somebody and the power isn't quite even, the person can feel triggered just because I want the freedom to make my own decisions or micromanaging.

43:25I'm coming in and I'm telling you what to do. That's an autonomy trigger. Get out of my space, let me do my work. And it's powerful even for parents to be able to guide your children with a range of choices, all of which are acceptable to you, but create them the freedom to make the choice. They're gonna follow that direction a lot better than you barking orders at them or only giving them one option, a favor. We're going to give more if it's our idea. That puts you in a position where you have to know what the outcomes are that you would like to see and work towards them. Going in without that and then hoping that the other person maybe has that is not going to allow you to feel very confident in that negotiation.

44:08It's not going to allow you to drive to a resolution And it's just two people then staring at each other going, maybe that person will take care of it. Well, maybe this other person will take care of it. But if you have those things aligned up beforehand, you can go in excited. You can go in with a game plan. You can have an understanding and a plan of what goals need to be met in order to reach the ultimate goal and ultimate resolution. That's it. Brilliant. I know where I am and I know where I want to go. And I think those are really good starting pieces for a negotiation. Now, we might not be able to see the path on how to get there because I don't know you.

44:51I'm not sure how this is going to go. The best negotiators believe in what is possible. I know where I am. I know where I want to go. And I've got the skills and tools and structures, techniques to help guide the process through whatever you might throw at me. And I'll remind people that when somebody gets loud or they get disrespectful or they call you names, this might be them out of control, but it might be them very much in control. And this could be a technique designed to mess with you a little bit. Because I want to find out, as soon as I can start having you react to things, now I'm starting to take control of this.

45:26So this could be nothing more than a tactic. We have to be that good. Know where you are, know where you want to go, and be willing to go into the unknown with somebody else. And if you're not dealing with somebody who has the best intentions, regardless of what sort of negotiation it is. Once they see that you are being reactive, like a child understanding that now his parents are getting a divorce and he can will them against each other, they will. It's just, that's just how it works. For sure. People are going to take advantage of you out there. And that's a sad reality. I don't like the naive approach that we're all going to win and we're all going to get something and have a great outcome.

46:07People are waiting to take advantage of you. Let's be smarter than that and show up. If nothing else, protect yourself, protect your team. And people have a very accommodating style of negotiation. And I say that's a very nice, but let's not employ social norms in a business setting. These are business norms and have the mindset of, I don't negotiate for me, I negotiate for we. And that right there can change your entire mindset to say, as soon as you come up to an agreement, now you have to turn around to your team and explain to them the outcome that we just got. And it changes your mindset to say, I'm going to work harder.

46:45I'm going to get more for me and the people I serve and love.

46:54When did making plans get this complicated? It's time to streamline with WhatsApp. The secure messaging app that brings the whole group together. Use polls to settle dinner plans. Send event invites and pin messages so no one forgets mom's 60th. And never miss a meme or milestone. All protected with end-to-end encryption. It's time for WhatsApp. Message privately with everyone. Learn more at whatsapp.com.

47:46Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. These skills are common knowledge now, and you can get this training anywhere, and we certainly work with our clients. So not only do they understand the power of these, but they can protect themselves because others will use these tools if they know they can get away with it. And that's why you should not shy away from understanding interpersonal relationships and the mechanisms that drive them. That's it. Negotiation, conflict resolution, influence. These are huge skills that we need to have. Yeah. Because the old concept of knowledge is power is gone.

48:28We're all experts. If you got chat GPT on your phone or your computer, I can give you any paper on any topic in five minutes. Yeah. If you don't have the ability to be smart about something, you're failing in your process. But how do we connect with others? How do we get better outcomes? This is still a skill. It's still an art. How can you do this? And the best leader is going to be the best leaders and everybody else by a mile. There's going to be such a divide between the people who can connect and get to the outcomes with other people and the people who are just pretenders. That gap is going to continue to widen.

49:06And I want to encourage everybody. Let's be in the leadership zone. I think there's a lot to be learned from failure in these situations as well. So we've discussed what to do, how to approach it, and hopefully led our listeners to success. But let's unpack those previous failures. Do any stand out in your mind? And what are the lessons that we can take from failures that we've had in conflict resolution negotiation in the past to become better for the future? For sure. And anybody who is in the negotiation space who says, well, I haven't had a bad outcome or I've never failed, either number one, they haven't done it or number two, they're not trying hard enough.

49:40Because in business negotiation, you should be hearing no. I want people to be telling you no, because then you're asking for a big enough thing here. But to answer your question very specifically, yes, we've had bad outcomes. One of them that comes to mind is i was uh negotiating with a man who had a gun to his head and i was face to face and usually we do this by the phone but because of the circumstances of the situation i was in his basement he was sitting in his basement and i was in his basement with him and there was some distance and here he is holding a gun to his head and as the negotiator my job is to get him to put that gunned down.

50:21And I had some different strategies that I was using. And it turned out that this was not a successful negotiation. You know, without getting into all the details, he did not put the gun down and we did not get a peaceful resolution here. And this is the outcome that sticks with you. this is when you look back and remember is there something more I could have done something more I could have said could I could I have said it in a different way did did I need different or better or more coaching because I look back and know that hey this is an outcome that I potentially had the power to change and in my world we know that we can get these bad outcomes where somebody hurts themselves, they hurt others.

51:14We know there's bad things that could come. And because of that, we take our preparation very seriously, that we know I'm the only person that I can fully control. I can work to nudge or influence or move others in the direction we want them to go, but I control me. And if there's going to be a bad outcome, it's not because I am uneducated or unprepared or not experienced enough. If we get a bad outcome, it's simply because that's a choice the other person made. And it allows us to move forward from that and not be consumed when we get these tough outcomes to say, I have failed. Did it give us an outcome that we didn't want significantly?

51:54And that's what motivates us during practice. Every time we sit down and we prepare and learn and educate with a team, it's because we're driven by the fact that we know if we don't get a good outcome, somebody is going to get hurt. And the frame, you know, what if I'm wrong, I think is such an important perspective to take in these scenarios, not only the life-threatening ones, but in those negotiations that didn't go your way. What were those preconceived notions, suspicions, ideas that you brought to the table that you thought maybe was their problem or maybe was the solution they were looking for?

52:27And as you start to unpack where things went wrong, start to ask yourself, was I actually asking the right questions? Was I seeking the right information or was I making assumptions that ended up hurting the negotiation? And the people who make assumptions are probably going to be at a disadvantage. And in this particular case, I knew that he had been released from the hospital maybe nine days earlier. And I don't know if maybe I didn't know that up front or I learned that later and just kind of glazed over that information. But I remember in this negotiation with him, I was trying to convince him to go to the hospital because I know that everybody expects that we're going to put the handcuffs on and take him to jail.

53:08and they're going to be sitting at the police station. And that's kind of a lousy place to be. Nobody really wants to be there. But my thought was, if I could get him to agree to go to the hospital to do a wellness check and evaluation, psych evaluation, physical evaluation, this is going to be very preferable to going and sitting in a jail cell somewhere. And at the time, I was very lucky that I had a very healthy life. I had never spent a night in the hospital before. but now I have had the pleasure of spending 21 straight days in the hospital last year and I realize that's not a place that anybody wants to go.

53:43If you've ever been in the hospital, you know I don't want to be there. I would probably prefer to sit by myself in a jail cell than be having somebody coming in and taking my blood and poking me with a needle and waking me up at three in the morning. So here I am trying to convince him, let's go to the hospital. But what if I'm wrong in that? What if I had a coach that came up to me and said, hey, What if this isn't the right strategy? What if this isn't the right approach? Let's try something different. It's not about me. It's not about my ego. It's not about me being right. Everything we do is about the outcome we're trying to achieve.

54:17And so often people won't ask themselves a question. What if I'm wrong on this? Because we think we might be embarrassed. It's not about you. It's about the outcome. And if we can set ourselves aside for a minute and say, hey, team, come together and give me some thoughts on this. Maybe we can get to better outcomes. One of the cherries on top that you stressed earlier was nonverbal communication. And we've seen this in our own clients, that it's a big blind spot. Oftentimes internally, we feel that we're showcasing different nonverbal signals than we actually are under tension and pressure. And we actually film our clients in these high stakes moments to practice for them to see, okay, now I'm trying to flirt or I'm trying to talk to a stranger.

54:57I'm in a conflict with someone. What are those nonverbals that come up that maybe I didn't realize or were blind spots for me? How do you approach delivery of nonverbals in these situations where those emotions are running high? This is where things have changed, at least in the police SWAT negotiation world over the last five or 10 years, because traditionally everything we did was by phone. Just because it's safe when I can talk to you from three blocks away. and if I'm on the phone, then I can have people around me and I can have this coaching and be passing notes back and forth. But the world has changed significantly in the last 10 years.

55:32Even five years ago, if I were gonna be on a Skype with somebody, this must be some stranger in a foreign country or something because it's not really something that we do. But now are we spending our whole life on Teams or Zoom or doing video chats with people around the world? All the time, everybody is in the professional space. So this is a very normal thing. And is this going to change how we communicate? And for sure. And that comes down to even the uniforms that we're wearing. We wore the green like army man SWAT uniforms. I was like, I don't know if that's very warm and approachable and friendly.

56:07Might I look a little bit more approachable if I were wearing a polo shirt or a T-shirt or something where we can have a bit of a conversation. So what we see is so powerful. And what I love in the nonverbal space, I like studying Joe Navarro. I like this group called the Behavior Panel, four guys that came together during COVID and they got this YouTube channel. Now they're on Dr. Phil and they talk about and they go deep like these are the best of the best. They're looking at your pupil dilation. They're studying your blink rate. And I said, wow, that's pretty good because I was a detective for five and a half years.

56:38And all we do is interview interrogation. I was like, these guys are top notch. But for the rest of us, I really suggest two things. Are we looking for clusters of behavior? You know, I'm talking to you and I'm leaning back, my palms are open and I'm maybe exposing my neck. Signs that this person could be comfortable. I'm giving you all the vital organs. You can see the hands, you can see the neck. These are generally considered pretty comfortable spots. And then are we looking for changes from baseline behavior, particularly in your teams with people you know well and you know this is normal?

57:13You know, is there a change in something that I'm used to seeing or we're seeing something that I'm not used to seeing? And anybody who tells you, well, I can use this nonverbal thing and tell you that's a lie. I don't know that that's a pretty bold assertion. I'm going to challenge you to say it's going to make me curious. If I see somebody kind of move to this nonverbal where they're going to protect their neck, it's going to make me curious what was just done, said, or thought that maybe made them feel a little bit uncomfortable here. Then let's go back and probe this a little bit and be curious about it and see if we can line up some more of what's being said with some of the nonverbals that we see.

57:52And one last tip on the nonverbals. Please, please do not ever let anybody know that you are reading their body language. I had a I have a colleague who will tell you oh you just uncrossed your legs I can tell you're comfortable with this it's so invasive when somebody says I'm reading your mind based on your body language like it's a really offensive thing you're like get out of my brain you're not allowed to be here but practically if you tell me that you're reading my body language I'm going to start doing weird things that you've never seen before and you can't google fast enough what is this nonverbal mean?

58:30What is he doing over here? And what does this mean? So now you've lost whatever advantage you thought you had because you told them, hey, this is what I'm up to. Thank you for encouraging our listeners to check this out on YouTube so they can see all of those nonverbal signals you were giving us. Thank you for joining us. Where can our audience find out more about the work that you do, Scott? Yeah, negotiationscollective.com is our homepage. We offer negotiation and conflict resolution training courses. I love giving keynotes to a variety of audiences and conferences and people around the world.

59:02And I'm a real person. I'm on LinkedIn. I still manage my own LinkedIn. If anybody wants to connect, connect, tell them you heard me here and I'll send you a note back. Thanks for having me. Take care. Thank you, Scott.

59:24What a great episode. And now comes the part of the show where we showcase one of our X-Factor Accelerator members. Take it away, Dave. It was like the start of self-improvement journey, you know, and a lot of the concepts with so much. I remember Johnny even said, like, this is going to take months to years to kick in to really get this shit. And he was fucking right. Then you start like reading more and you start seeing things more. You start like testing the waters with little ideas. For me, I lacked the confidence. and I thought that like I was a shitty engineer that I could never get a job at like a fang company or like a unicorn startup where I'm at now and like I was sort of like oh well I'll stay in my even when I moved from PNC this was after AFC I still still stood in my little comfort zone but like I moved to like another bank sure I was making like 20 grand more but it was still peanuts compared to what I'm making now right once I jumped ship and realized oh it's kind of just the same everywhere just a little bit different processes and slightly different code base and slightly different architecture then i'm like okay i'll move again and then that job really sucked and i was only there for five months and like now i'm where i'm at and it's like well shit maybe i should move again really it was honestly for me the biggest difference was the lack of confidence in myself to know that i can make it elsewhere i felt like no one else would ever want to hire me because i'm i'm just this like low value person like why would anyone want to hire me i'm lucky to have this position and then versus the mindset after it's like no bitch they're lucky to have me and like it sounds easy that's a really tough switch of the mind that it takes a lot of time to do that it takes like being too cocky or being too like i fucking go and it's like whoa dude like slow down a little bit like you have someone check you it's like okay I need to scale back a little bit.

1:01:16Thank you for the kind words, Dave. And it was an honor and a pleasure working with you too. And good luck to you and all of your future endeavors. If you've gotten value out of this or any of our podcasts, head on over to your favorite podcast player and rate and review the show. It means the world to us and it helps others find the show. And before we head out, a huge thank you to our producers, Michael Harold and Eric Montgomery until next week. Go out there and make it amazing. Yeah, I remember you. You were the bad boy. You threw your love away. Like you were just a toy. And you sold the world.

1:02:03You're a song of a tragedy. Cause you had your taste of black on the yesterday. Yeah, but I remember you Oh yeah, I remember you

1:02:25Next up is a little song from CarMax about selling a car your way. You wanna sell those wheels You wanna get a CarMax instant offer So fast Wanna take a sec to think about it Or like a month? Wanna keep tabs on that instant offer? With OfferWatch. Wanna have CarMax pick it up from your driveway? You wanna get it, touch it. You wanna do it all. So, wanna drive? CarMax, pickup not available everywhere. Restrictions and fee may apply.

From the publisher

In this episode of The Art of Charm, retired SWAT hostage negotiator Scott Tillema shares his battle-tested four-part framework for leading difficult conversations, defusing high-stakes conflicts, and influencing others with clarity and confidence.

Trained by the FBI and Harvard, Scott now brings these skills to the boardroom, equipping leaders with the same life-saving tools he once used in crisis negotiations. Whether you're navigating a tense meeting, resolving conflict on your team, or having a hard conversation at home, this episode will show you how to lead with calm authority.

Scott reveals why tactical empathy is more powerful than persuasion, how to control your emotional state when the pressure’s on, and what most people get wrong about timing, tone, and respect.

[00:00:00] Introduction

[00:02:47] Why your negotiation partner is not your opponent — and how that shift changes everything

[00:10:50] The biggest mistake leaders make when trying to influence others

[00:16:02] How to mentally prepare for high-pressure conversations using tactical breathing

[00:22:34] The transformation that happens when you stop learning and start embodying

[00:27:15] How to know when it’s the right time to speak — and when it’s too soon

[00:30:46] Delivery over content: Why how you say it matters more than what you say

[00:34:19] The four pillars of respect that drive every meaningful negotiation

[00:38:40] How autonomy — even in small doses — creates buy-in and trust

[00:43:22] A high-stakes negotiation that failed — and what Scott learned from it

[00:49:04] Why you should never tell someone you’re reading their body language

You’re negotiating all the time — with your boss, your spouse, your coworkers. If you want influence, connection comes first.

The best negotiators aren't master persuaders. They're master listeners.

Tactical empathy isn’t manipulation. It’s leadership.

People don’t respond to logic — they respond to tone, timing, and emotional safety.

Respect isn’t about politeness — it’s about fairness, autonomy, recognition, and empathy.

Conflict isn’t a threat. It's an opportunity to lead with poise and purpose.

Tired of awkward handshakes and collecting business cards without building real connections? Dive into our Free Social Capital Networking Masterclass. Learn practical strategies to make your interactions meaningful and boost your confidence in any social situation. Sign up for free at theartofcharm.com/sc and elevate your networking from awkward to awesome. Don’t miss out on a network of opportunities!

Unleash the power of covert networking to infiltrate high-value circles and build a 7-figure network in just 90 days. Ready to start? Check out our CIA-proven guide to networking like a spy!

Indulge in affordable luxury with Quince—where high-end essentials meet unbeatable prices. Upgrade your wardrobe today at quince.com/charm for free shipping and hassle-free returns.

Ready to turn your business idea into reality? Shopify makes it easy to start, scale, and succeed—whether you're launching a side hustle or building the next big brand. Sign up for your $1/month trial at shopify.com/charm.

Need to hire top talent—fast? Skip the waiting game and get more qualified applicants with Indeed. Claim your $75 Sponsored Job Credit now at Indeed.com/charm.

Curious about your influence level? 

Get your Influence Index Score today!

Take this 60-second quiz to find out how your influence stacks up against top performers at theartofcharm.com/influence.

Negotiations Collective website

Scott Tillema’s website

Scott Tillema on LinkedIn

AJ on LinkedIn

Johnny on LinkedIn

AJ on Instagram

Johnny on Instagram

The Art of Charm on Instagram

The Art of Charm on YouTube

The Art of Charm on TikTok

What to Listen ForEpisode Takeaways:A Word From Our SponsorsResources from this EpisodeCheck in with AJ and Johnny!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from The Art of Charm

All 254 episodes
4 Principles of Influence from a Hostage NegotiatorThe Art of Charm · 1 h 1 min
Listen in VO