In short
Paul Eastwick argues modern dating is “broken” because online dating and social media distort how people perceive desirability, themselves, and commitment, exaggerating selection and gender differences while reducing real-world social skills and community.
Guest background
Paul Eastwick is a social psychologist who has studied attraction and close relationships for about 15–20 years. He wrote Bonded by Evolution.
Key claims
- Online dating exaggerates desirability hierarchies versus face-to-face, making “idiosyncratic” matches harder to find.
- Apps push a market/scorekeeping mindset (“dating marketplace”), encouraging people to exaggerate themselves for more matches and to keep apps on, undermining commitment.
- Social media and apps amplify gender stereotypes; in-person selectivity is far less extreme than app selectivity.
- Healthy masculinity is less about dominance and more about gentleness/pro-social traits and community.
- Compatibility is built over time; relationships unfold step-by-step, not via fixed “short-term vs long-term” categories.
- AI-written profiles and AI-assisted flirting further reduce authenticity and intuition-building.
Notable examples
- Speed-dating research: women’s “yes” rate drops from about 1/3 in person to about 1/20 on apps.
- Advice to turn apps off to reduce motivated reasoning and distraction.
- Example of an AI-written dating profile detected from the first sentence.
- “Do not fear the friend zone”: men with more actual female friends have better romantic prospects via introductions.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOThe Impact of Online Dating
2:56 to 6:42
Explore how online dating distorts perceptions of desirability and connection.
“I think this subject of love, connection, dating is probably one of the areas where there's the most conflicting advice.”
Social Connections Over Dating Apps
6:42 to 11:15
Discover the importance of forming social connections beyond dating apps.
“you know, if they can improve their confidence and some of their social skills, they'll do better when meeting people for the first time.”
The Challenges of Commitment
11:15 to 14:03
Discuss the hurdles of committing in relationships amid dating app distractions.
“And, you know, it's like we end up spending all this time on nonsense.”
The Impact of Dating Apps on Commitment
14:03 to 14:53
Explore how dating apps can hinder real romantic commitments and distract users.
“you, I mean, especially if you're doing it willingly by keeping the apps going, you're hindering that process that your mind wants to do.”
Frustrations with Modern Dating
17:27 to 19:19
Discuss the feelings of inadequacy and frustration with dating apps in today's market.
“And some of them have even gone so far as to just give up on dating with the frustration on these apps that a select few, get all the matches, get all the messages, get all the dates.”
Reconnecting Offline in a Digital Age
19:19 to 21:42
Learn about the importance of in-person socialization and ways to reconnect without apps.
“We lose the tendency to like just kind of flex our social muscles when we spend all this time online.”
Generational Differences in Social Media Use
21:42 to 23:26
Examine how different generations view social media and its impact on identity.
“And so all of this is so fascinating to me.”
Authenticity in the Age of AI and Filters
23:26 to 26:07
Discuss the distortion of authenticity in dating due to AI and online personas.
“Her and I were looking at each other laughing.”
The Madness of Outsourcing Dating
26:07 to 28:00
Understand the pitfalls of outsourcing dating experiences to technology.
“And to your point, almost all of that attraction comes from the authenticity.”
The Role of Intuition in Dating
28:00 to 30:40
Explore how intuition influences dating and relationship building.
“It's all about what their feelings inspire on you and how they make you feel about you.”
Show all 22 chapters
Perceptions in the Dating Market
33:23 to 36:29
Discuss the misconceptions in dating regarding gender roles and societal expectations.
“Part of avoiding that experience also leads to buying into this idea that women only want money and men only want looks.”
The Complexity of Relationship Trajectories
36:29 to 39:06
Understand the unpredictable nature of relationship development over time.
“We're seeing people put off marriage and having kids later and later in life.”
Rethinking Relationship Categories
39:06 to 42:00
Challenge the binary thinking about short-term and long-term partners.
“So one fascinating thing, I mean, the way I got into studying this particular topic was that I was really mystified by this really common distinction.”
Rethinking Compatibility in Relationships
42:00 to 45:10
Explore the idea that compatibility in relationships is more about creation than finding a perfect match.
“Everything psychological is dimensional.”
The Evolving Role of Men in Dating
46:04 to 53:08
Understand the shifting expectations of men in modern dating and the importance of gentleness.
“Well, that hunter metaphor is what a lot of men think they're supposed to be in the dating landscape.”
Navigating the Friend Zone
53:08 to 56:00
Learn how to view the friend zone as an opportunity rather than a setback in dating.
“I'm doing a lot here to try to win an attractive mate.”
Navigating Vulnerability in Friendships
56:00 to 1:02:05
Learn how embracing vulnerability can enhance your social connections.
“I would actually like to be friends with this person.”
The Impact of Online Dating on Relationships
1:02:05 to 1:06:30
Discover how online dating shapes our social interactions and perceptions.
“And the thing that where that's hard for people is that, well, what that means is that if that coffee date, that 20 minute coffee date, you were kind of, eh, that means you got to do the second one.”
Changing Perspectives on Masculinity
1:06:30 to 1:08:55
Explore modern views of masculinity and the importance of community and vulnerability.
“Well, as we close, I'd love to get your perspective on masculinity, because I know it has created a lot of confusion for the men who take our training and it's become a hot topic.”
Promoting Healthy Masculinity
1:08:55 to 1:10:01
Discuss how to redefine masculinity towards healthier expressions and relationships.
Discussion on Alternative Media and Book Announcement
1:10:01 to 1:10:56
Learn about different media sources and Paul's upcoming book.
“alternative media sources that promote different ideas.”
X Factor Member Showcase: Daniel Bosing
1:10:56 to 1:11:59
Discover Daniel's experience with the X Factor Accelerator program and its impact.
“And now comes a part of the show where we showcase one of our X Factor members.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00We're leaving today and entering a world of Mickey Mouse waving, princess meeting and greeting, lightsaber clashing, the Twilight Zone Tower of Terror dropping, Banshee flying, Space Mountain launching, galaxy rewinding, fireworks igniting, World of Other Worlds. For whatever you love, infinite worlds await at the most magical place on earth. Walt Disney World Resort. Spring starts at The Home Depot, and we are bringing the heat to your backyard this season. Fire up the flavor with our wide variety of grills for under$300, like the Next Grill 4-Burner Gas Grill that's perfect for hosting your spring cookout.
0:43Then set the scene and turn your outdoor space into the go-to spot the patio sets for every budget. Bring it this season with grills that deliver flavor and patios that set the vibe from The Home Depot. Start your spring with low prices guaranteed at The Home Depot. Exclusions apply. See homedepot.com slash price match for details. When we think about how we evolved to be men, I think there is a tendency to think in the terms that you just described. We are supposed to dominate and we are supposed to lead and we are supposed to intimidate. And this is how we win and achieve success. It is exactly backwards, because if you look at the evolutionary trajectory.
1:26So now I'm talking about hundreds of thousands of years, millions of years. It was not the case that the strongest, most dominant ones were the ones who were more likely to survive. In fact, it was the opposite. It was the smaller ones. It was the gentler ones. It was the ones who were good around kids, the ones who were less aggressive that the females tended to prefer. We lost our sharp canines. That's because we don't fight for mates in the way that our ancestors did six million plus years ago. We men got smaller relative to females over the course of the last several million years because we were selected for our gentleness around offspring.
2:20Johnny:All right, let's kick off today's show. Today, we're talking with Paul Eastwick. He's a social psychologist who spent 20 years studying attraction and close relationships. You'll learn why online dating makes finding connection harder than face-to-face meetings. Paul wrote Bonded by Evolution, and the big takeaway is form social connections for their own sake, not just to date. Paul shares why online dating exaggerates desirability hierarchies, how relationships change who you are, the networking approach that actually leads to romance, and what healthy masculinity looks like today. Welcome to the show, Paul.
2:56Johnny:It's great to have you. Yeah, thanks so much for having me. I think this subject of love, connection, dating is probably one of the areas where there's the most conflicting advice. I know. And I think a lot of it is culturally, traditionally passed down to us by our ancestors and our family. So we're excited today to really dig into the science and what the latest and greatest says about this exact part of our lives. But I'd love to hear first from you a little bit about the project and then maybe what surprised you the most in writing this book. I've been a social psychologist studying attraction and close relationships for about 15 to 20 years.
3:38It's really what got me excited about, you know, the use of experimental and observational methods to study psychological topics in the first place was this idea that this totally mystifying and omnipresent process, right? I mean, you know, maybe you're single and you're looking for somebody or maybe you're in a relationship, but these issues are always with us. And that realization that we could use scientific methods to study this whole idea was it was just very compelling to me so yeah you know this book is really the outcome of 20 years of like studies trying to fit the pieces together trying to figure out which pieces of the conventional wisdom work which like kind of half work but need to be contextualized and which are just like completely off the mark.
4:31Johnny:The book goes through a lot of these different areas, but I'd love to hear what was maybe the most surprising to you in your own life. One of the things that became more and more clear as I was doing this book and as I've been looking at the research is how much the online landscape is really twisting and exaggerating, I think in a bad way, the way that people pursue partners, the way we think about how valuable we are, the way we think about our worth. And it just really has some negative knock-on effects. For example, yes, in initial attraction context, it is certainly true that some people are more desirable than others, but you can actually quantify that.
5:20and when you look at online dating it's so much more dramatic than what we see when we meet face to face face to face like yeah there's some agreement about who's desirable and who's not but boy is there a lot of idiosyncrasy oh like this is a person that really appeals to me even if they might not appeal to you and online dating makes it harder to find some of those unique idiosyncratic connections so that that and a number of other things about the online space it It works for many people, but boy, it can make it tough for a lot of other people.
5:54Johnny:That really is for most of us where it's amplified this idea of the dating marketplace and really shifted our view of ourselves, our own attractiveness based on responses from these algorithms that are judging us as well as the participants in online dating. And then also this feeling, this need to then exaggerate things about yourself to try to up your ability to become more attractive and get more matches. And now we're seeing the apps, you know, verifying height and trying to verify these details because we've all started this exaggeration. You can think about improving your own attributes.
6:30OK, so if you improve how desirable you are and look, there are lots of ways to do that. I think some are probably more helpful than others. there's there's like good experimental evidence that for men in particular, you know, if they can improve their confidence and some of their social skills, they'll do better when meeting people for the first time. But for a lot of people, that's tricky. And I think what we've lost is a bit of this, you know, the skills related to forming social connections for the sake of forming social connections. so not necessarily worried about like oh i'm going to try to like chat this person up and get their number okay like we get locked into that and that's what online dating reinforces but there are other ways like you just like meet a new group of people and spend time hanging out with them you're not going to date any of them but by broadening your social world they're going to introduce you to people who will introduce you to other people who will introduce you to other people and that's where you're going to form romantic connections.
7:35So it's like we think about it in this very market-oriented way. It's like a very mercenary way of going about it, like I'm shopping for something. But I would like to encourage people to remember you can have social connections for the sake of social connections and in many ways that will sort of be the engine that pulls you along and eventually introduces you to more people and more romantic connections. and there's a couple things at play and i you know to be specific about it i think that's it's already been alluded to which is the hardware has remained the same in all of us but our software has been manipulated yeah it's a good way of thinking about it like you know i spent a lot of time pointing this out in the book we spent our time evolving hundreds of thousands of years ago in a context where you didn't get to meet that many people.
8:27You were living in small groups and you're small. Yes. And by small, I mean, like, I don't know, like 50 people and you're going to meet some other small groups along the way. But you just don't have that many romantic options. But what you do have is lots of opportunities to spend time with these people. So inevitably, everybody like kind of gets to know everybody. Now, if we lived in a pure market, a pure mating market, well, what that would mean is that, OK, the desirable people will find each other and then everybody else like kind of settles and is always looking to trade up. That's the common metaphor that's existed for a long time in our culture.
9:11But what actually happens when you look at real people who get to know each other is that those strong market forces, they kind of fade as people get to know each other. And it's replaced instead by all of this idiosyncrasy. So as people get to know each other over time, it's like you find somebody who's a good fit for you. And the extent to which, you know, everybody's, you know, finds them consensually desirable, it just matters less and less. That's an opportunity for many, many more people to find a partner and be happy with that partner than if we all lived in like this ruthless dating competition.
9:48Johnny:And ancestrally speaking, there was a cost to waiting for the perfect person. Yeah. Seeking this true love idea, this concept that obviously Hollywood fosters on us. So I think for many of us now, the apps have amplified it more because it's like any one of those little idiosyncrasies that we experience online or in person that we don't like. Well, we're quick to toss that person to the side and say, oh, well, I got 10 more matches when I get home. I've got a show where we talk about movies. It's called Love Factually. And we talk about how these ideas are reflected in movies. And so we spent time on materialists last year because, boy, did that, I think, reflect this idea and also critique it at the same time.
10:32But it's very common for people to feel like, hey, there's a million options out there. you know i feel good about myself like i'm a catch i got nice qualities i should be able to dial up the perfect partner for me i should be able to hand over a checklist to somebody and say find me that and you know in the scientific research that looks at whether that matters the answer is really not really like i if i'm a matchmaker i can give you what you drew up on paper but the odds you're going to be into that person as opposed to somebody else I pulled from the pool. It's very, very small. So we really get locked in our heads about what it is we're looking for.
11:16And, you know, it's like we end up spending all this time on nonsense.
11:20Johnny:Then we have the grass is always greener, right? So once you do start dating and the courtship phase, that app is still going in the background. That thought of, OK, well, there are still other options. I was a catch, makes it very hard for us to then commit to that one person. And we see this in our clients, this lone wolf who joins the X Factor Accelerator focused on his career is like, well, I'm going to find a partner. And then it's a little bumpy road with some dating. And it's like, well, I'm just going to cast that aside. And we're in the same camp sharing, hey, work on your social life, work on your ability to connect with people in general, and you will have more optionality and the apps will be fun and not required for you to be successful.
12:03Johnny:And then the frustration is, well, well, I've cast all these people aside. I've gone on hundreds of dates. You know, we've seen these blogs pop up 300 dates, 600 dates to find this person. And there's this inability to just settle and say, Hey, you know what? I'm ready to commit to this person. There's another piece of that as well, which is when do you turn the apps off? And there was a recent trend on social media where people were posting up their partner's tinder profiles and and uh pranking them with them like why are you still on this well is that another discussion that we're supposed to have what on inclusivity do i just turn it inactive or do i delete it or no or and the most common uh refrain that they were like listen i haven't been on since we met but it's but you're still active it's still there on the first on the first fight, you're going to open it up just to see what's going on.
13:01It's a real temptation. If you look at people who are in ongoing relationships, they do a remarkable thing. And, you know, it sort of fits into this broader category that we call motivated reasoning. And essentially what that means is that, you know, you kind of have a desired conclusion and you shape the facts and your perceptions of the world that drive toward that preferred conclusion. Well, when people are in relationships, that preferred conclusion, I mean, I understand this like is shocking to some people, but it's preferred conclusion is this person's great. And I would like to keep this thing going.
13:39And they will use all sorts of motivated reasoning tricks to think that their partner is the greatest to contextualize their bad qualities. This is this is a great thing that people do. People would never be able to form relationships and maintain them otherwise. But if you have structures in your life that dangle other appealing alternatives in front of you, I mean, especially if you're doing it willingly by keeping the apps going, you're hindering that process that your mind wants to do. Of course. It's hard to say exactly when the right time is to turn the apps off. But you're in many ways, like holding your own romantic opportunity with this person back to the extent that you're keeping it on there.
14:31So, you know, there are many like tips and tricks that people can do if they feel like I'm having trouble committing, but I'd like to be able to commit, but I keep getting distracted. And for people who are in that kind of situation. I mean, just get the app off of there. If it doesn't go well, you're going to be able to find other opportunities, whether it's through the apps or through other means.
14:53Johnny:Johnny, I didn't realize how much a mattress could change my nights until I switched to Lisa. That soft sink in moment when you lay down, but the support is there, you wake up feeling aligned. Sleep is everything. You can eat right, you can exercise, but if you're not sleeping well, none of it matters. Lisa has a lineup of mattresses tailored to how you sleep. Each one is designed with specific sleep positions and feel preferences in mind. From night one, you'd feel the difference. Premium materials, full body support, no matter how you sleep. Lisa mattresses are designed and assembled in the USA.
15:28Johnny:Free shipping, easy returns, 120 night sleep trial. New York Times Wirecutter name them the best hybrid mattress, West Elm features them as their go-to mattress partner. They also donate thousands of mattresses each year to those in need and partner with CleanHub to remove plastic waste from our oceans. Go to Lisa.com for 30 % off mattresses plus get an extra$50 off with promo code CHARM exclusively for our listeners. That's L-E-E-S-A.com promo code charm for 30 % off mattresses plus an extra$50 off. Support our show and let them know we sent you after checkout. Lisa.com promo code charm. Picture this late at night scrolling through your feed.
16:16Johnny:You see the product you've been looking for. Add to cart, check out, and your wallet is across the room. Then you see it, that purple Shopify button. All your saved info. One tap, done. That's Shopify, the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10 % of all e-commerce in the US. Hundreds of ready-to-use templates help you build an online store that matches your brand style. AI tools write your product descriptions and enhance your product photography. Shopify handles inventory, international shipping, returns, and beyond. Award-winning 24-7 customer support whenever you get stuck.
16:59Johnny:Everything in one place. That purple shop pay button is why Shopify has the best converting checkout on the planet. Less abandoned carts, more sales for you. See less carts go abandoned and more sales go with Shopify. Sign up for your$1 per month trial today at shopify.com slash charm. go to shopify.com slash charm. That's shopify.com slash charm. One thing that we found with a lot of our clients who are frustrated by the apps is that it has distorted the marketplace in a way that they feel that their mate value because they're not getting matches, they're not getting the dates that they would like has completely diminished.
17:42Johnny:And some of them have even gone so far as to just give up on dating with the frustration on these apps that a select few, get all the matches, get all the messages, get all the dates. And if you're not in that select few, you're completely left behind. And I think that's really hard mentally for men to deal with. Like they feel like they're losing out on paper. And as we're constantly having to put more of our attributes on these apps to try to win favor, we feel even more judged. And the cost of rejection is zero on an app. Whereas in person, that rejection of you walking up and striking up a conversation, there's a lot more tied to that.
18:21If we can point to anything that our, you know, phone and internet culture have done is that we're a lot less kind to people we don't know. And the apps are certainly contributing to this. I think there are ways for people. I mean, it depends on where you live, obviously, because if you live in any kind of like modern urban environment, there are surely ways of reconnecting with other people that don't require the internet. Like some of it feels quaint. Some of it feels like it's from a bygone era, right? Like join an ultimate Frisbee league. I'm sure people still play ultimate Frisbee. That was not just in the aughts when I was out of college, right?
19:06These things are still around, but there are other things too. I mean, you can take classes, dancing, cooking, like whatever something is that you can get behind and do it for the sake of doing it and being around other people. It's like we lose that. We lose that practice. We lose the tendency to like just kind of flex our social muscles when we spend all this time online. And often socializing feels good even if there's no romantic prospects involved. It's just like good to be around other people. And I think the thing too is that when you do those kinds of live in-person activities, people are kinder to each other i mean they're not perfect but they're a lot nicer to each other and you feel a lot less judged than you than you do when you're just putting yourself out there online gen z is all about social media and that social media now has become a part of their identity that is something that they use as i may not be all the most confident person in the world but I got a hundred thousand followers on Instagram.
20:10Yeah. That's a completely new variable that we've never dealt with before. And you could even argue that what attribute does that actually have in your own personality? And, and if it has a large attribute, how much of that can be pulled away in an instant? It's a great point because, you know, tendency I've classically had a tendency to think about you know you've got your real life world and your online world and that the the pressures and the norms and the psychology of what it's like to interact with other people in person snap you into that mode and I'm not thinking about my Instagram for a little while but I'm saying this as somebody who like barely has an internet presence and is Gen X.
21:02And so I actually, I don't know what, how exactly one extracts oneself from the fact that, you know, I've got this other persona that lives online. And, you know, maybe that means like, oh, I can't be talking to people like you, or I can't be hanging out with people like you, because that's not what my online persona does. To the extent that that's happening, And this is, you know, the sort of generational nature of all of this. I feel like the science is kind of just actually getting going on this. But I don't know what that would mean. But but if you're right, that people can't snap out of their online persona, it's not good.
21:41Just for reference, I'm I'm Gen X as well. And so all of this is so fascinating to me. And and I had recently been to a day like rock and roll festival that was going on. And my friend and I both have social media presence due to our jobs. And I have the experience of recently blowing up this year. All within a span of just a couple months, which was insane in itself. And I didn't even, as a Gen Xer, I'm confused what really that even means, right? while we were out mingling, hanging out, talking with the other folks at the festival and dealing with some of the younger people soon as they found out that both my friend and I had social media presence their first question was how many followers do you have?
22:37And it was the weird like and then being judged on that was so bizarre and this is you know there was a bit of this with millennials but this is a a gen z thing and then it's certainly going to be a gen alpha thing it's kind of terrifying and um it really is like a whole new because it's not it's not just like oh like the most attractive most socially skilled people are the ones that are gonna have the biggest biggest internet prices it's not just that we're like we're commodifying uh putting a a number on an aspect of popularity that has always existed it's it's it's something new and um and yeah i i really i mean this is this has been one of the parts of this whole project has made me realize like oh people may disagree about like oh like what is the nature of gender differences and mating like but everybody agrees like oh my god get back to hanging out in person and like try to try to put the phones down as gen x my my friend and i are both rock and rollers so going out to a concert and looking stylish is part of the whole thing and then you can't stop that that's what we would always be judged on the concert the show in itself is a fashion contest right like everyone's dressed up going out all out and having a lot of fun doing it so to be disregarded for what I'm wearing and to be judged on my social media presence.
24:08Her and I were looking at each other laughing. We're like, man, things have changed. These little cultures that groups of people create where certain things are valued and certain things are not valued. I mean, like that's been around forever. And like, that's OK. Like, you know, in like I was I was in bands, but I'm talking about like marching band. So I was in marching band in high school, but like, I don't know. There were like things you did to make yourself more appealing to the other band geeks. Like, sure. Like, you know, maybe it's, you know, you gotta, you gotta roll step with the best of them, but.
24:45You gotta have those rudimentaries that down. Yeah, sure. I can't be out of line. Like I'll get made fun of. So, so, so everybody kind of navigates those things, but it stayed, It stayed close. Right. It was not like you were going to do something that was going to harm your reputation with like a quarter of a million people or something along those lines. So so we're good at this. We're good at adapting to whatever our little local rules and norms and rituals are. We can create our own local norms and rituals. But but the the broadening of this thing and having these, you know, worldwide spotlights on people, I think it's still going to be a little while before we really understand what we've done.
25:31Johnny:There's also been a distortion of authenticity. So from the filters, the way we present ourselves online, and now with the rise of AI entering our communication, especially digital communication, you can have an AI bot who helps you chat better on the app and be more flirty and be more charismatic in ways you couldn't have before. And you're now creating this duality of like, well, my online persona, the videos, the photos that I'm posting, you know, this idea of catfishing, it's now amped up even more because we're replacing our personality with AI bots dating for us and finding matches. And to your point, almost all of that attraction comes from the authenticity.
26:11Johnny:It comes from the in-person moments, not the value judgments that we're making and certainly not the areas that we're expanding to be more inauthentic. even with our own clients. Sometimes I'm asked to go over their dating profiles to give them some feedback and to help them out on that. And recently I had gotten one. And after reading the first sentence, I stopped and I wrote back, did you have AI write this? And he's like, yes. And I was like, if I can figure that out in one sentence, the women on here can, because that's now what they're seeing all over the place. So guys out there listening to this, M dashes in your profile.
26:59This is genuinely terrifying. It's terrifying because like, look, I totally get that. Sometimes you might need to spend money to meet more people. Right. There can be lots of reasons for that. But the idea that you would outsource the process of dating to some other entity, to whether it's do your work for you or to do the evaluation for you. Like, but that's the whole, it's the whole point, people. The whole point is to experience what is it like to be around this other person. You cannot moneyball this. Like you have to spend time interacting with people and feeling something or not. Like that's your cue about whether something is worth pursuing.
27:56It's not their stats on paper. It's not like this is the best person I can get. It's all about what their feelings inspire on you and how they make you feel about you. So like trying to outsource all of this, I mean, it's just it's just madness. You're robbing yourself of gaining intuition and your intuition. Listen, I work with Claude every day and Claude doesn't have my intuition. In fact, Claude relies on my intuition for it to work better. and and and so that intuition is something that is going to need to develop and you have to create that for these young kids who we know what gen z and millennials did growing up with technology that you and i didn't have paul and gen z more engrossed in it now we're going to have generations gen alpha who grew up with ai how much of that intuition that we all have developed will be robbed from them and then what does what does that then as a society produce dating is a trial and error process and that is true whether you're talking about what is it like as like you are looking for a partner in general you're gonna have a lot of things that don't work out.
29:27It's also true if we talk about a particular relationship, you hit it off with somebody, there's still a ton of trial and error in how you move through that process. This is a developmental thing. Like we start kind of fumbling our way through this when we're 13 and, you know, in through high school, we make a lot of mistakes and do a lot of dumb things. But but there's no shortcut for going through that because all of that trial and error gives you an intuition for yourself, for what you're into. You try things that don't work. You you make mistakes and then you try to just adjust a little bit the next time.
30:09but right i've not seen any evidence yet that the ais can substitute for our own intuitions in that way that there's any kind of thing that could mimic me could then go out into the world make mistakes on my behalf i guess and then find somebody and then every day we bring that person into my life everything's going to be perfect like it sucks but but you have to go out and make the mistakes yourself and form the intuitions yourself. You can't shortcut this.
Read the full transcript
30:43Johnny:A thoughtful wardrobe comes down to pieces that mix well and last. That's where quince shines. Premium fabrics, considered design, everyday essentials that just feel effortless to wear. Lightweight cashmere sweaters, short-sleeved Mongolian cashmere polos, Linen bottoms, tees, and 100 % Pima cotton. Versatile pieces that make your wardrobe work season to season. Quince works directly with top factories and cuts out the middlemen. You're not paying for brand markup or fancy retail stores. Just quality clothing. The cashmere is 100 % Mongolian. Same stuff luxury brands use. The Pima cotton is long staple.
31:25Stays soft. Doesn't pill. European Jersey linen is breathable and lightweight. Everything is built to hold up.
31:31Johnny:I got to say, these linen shorts have become my go-to. They don't wrinkle like cheap linen does. They work with everything and they didn't cost a fortune either. Stop overcomplicating your wardrobe. You don't need a closet full of options. You need the pieces that work. Right now, go to quince.com slash charm for free shipping and 365 day returns. That's a full year to build your wardrobe and love it. Now available in Canada too. Go to Q-U-I-N-C-E dot com slash charm for free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince dot com slash charm. I like keeping my money where I could see it. Unfortunately, traditional big wireless carriers also like keeping my money.
32:16Johnny:After years of overpaying for wireless, I got fed up with crazy high bills, bogus fees, and free perks that just cost more in the long run. Stop overpaying for wireless just because that's how it's always been. Mint Mobile exists. to fix that. Premium wireless plans starting at$15 a month. And all plans come with high-speed data and unlimited talk and text delivered on the nation's largest 5G network. Bring your own phone and number. Activate with e7 minutes. Start saving immediately. No long-term contracts. No hassle. If I needed to switch carriers, Mint Mobile is what I'd use. Ditch overpriced wireless and get three months of premium service for 15 bucks a month.
32:58Johnny:If you like your money, Mint Mobile is for you. Shop plans at mintmobile.com slash charm. That's mintmobile.com slash charm. Upfront payment of$45 for three month, five gigabyte plan required. Equivalent to$15 per month. New customer offer for first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See Mint Mobile for details. Part of avoiding that experience also leads to buying into this idea that women only want money and men only want looks. And we have these gender differences that that we have to cross the chasm of. And we have clients who are like, I just have to earn more to be more desirable in this dating market.
33:42Johnny:And they'll put aside their social life to earn more. They'll put aside even dating to earn more because they feel like and with the funhouse mirror of social media, seeing who's popular and what they're sharing. Well, the guys with the most money, the fanciest cars are the ones who get the beautiful women and the beautiful women only want the eight pack based on what I'm seeing on social media. There is absolutely evidence that social media and the dating apps in particular exaggerate gender differences, exactly like the ones you're talking about. Probably the most dramatic one is, you know, look back back when i was in graduate school we conducted speed dating research studies you know so speed dating was big and we said this looks like fun yeah right yeah it's coming back honestly because people want to be off the apps good thing because what you're what you see i mean we ran all these speed dating events for these undergrads and you know i don't know like i think sometimes people think like oh it's like a meat market it's like it's not what it is at all it's people struggling to find something to talk about in four minutes.
34:48And yeah, having the right social skills, being able to like navigate a conversation with somebody to find something to talk about in that short period of time is a really useful skill. And those people tended to do better. But generally speaking, men and women can connect in that short period of time if they're doing it in person. And so the most exaggerated gender difference online is that, look, if at our speed dating studies, men say yes to the partners they're meeting, like it's like 50 50. And that's true on the apps as well. But for women, when they're meeting men in person, it's more like like one third, two thirds, one third get a yes, two thirds get no.
35:28But on the apps, it's like one in 20, they say yes to. That's dramatic. And that suggests that there's a real tendency to be super selective, focus just on the quantifiable qualities that somebody has. And that is not how dating is supposed to be. And it is not the way we have classically done it, whether I'm talking about 20 years ago or I'm talking about, you know, 200 ,000 years ago.
36:02Johnny:It's frustrating to be experiencing that. You know, I was fortunate myself to to find my partner without an app before the apps really took off. But that's the norm right now. Yeah. Right. That that is the norm when when people are single looking for people is to experience that one out of every 20. And if you are the 19 that are said no to, it's really hard to then find your value to find motivation to date. And now we're seeing the declining birth rate. We're seeing people put off marriage and having kids later and later in life. And this is exposing a real issue societally for us. The rise of singles, how this is connected to our use of social media is totally fascinating.
36:46I mean, my semi hot take on a lot of this is that I, I doubt that the rise of singles is being linked to men's like lowering educational, lowering income prospects specifically. And the reason I say that is because when you look at people interacting face to face, there is no gender difference in the extent to which attributes like appealing like ambition or successful those attributes are just as appealing for men as they are for women so i think if these men you know maybe they got an associate's degree instead of a bachelor's degree like they're gonna do okay if they're meeting people and so the problem where we're you know if we're looking at things like declining birth rates and saying why is this happening I am much more worried about the tendency to just spend time online, the tendency, the tendency to retreat into online worlds or just using online dating and finding yourself in the pool of 19 out of 20.
37:54That's what I would worry about more. I think, I think we can, we can probably do a lot just by helping people. Yeah. Even some of these men that are feeling a little bit left behind, if we can get them out there and socializing again, I think that will go a long way to fixing some of this i agree good luck with getting them out there i know that's the real problem right right it's like it's like what does it take to get people to get people outside again but i think but but the funny thing is is like it's one of these things where when you do it you're like why did i put this off like why did i put off joining this league like this is fun there seems to be organic movements that are propelling that and hopefully you know they they catch fire because, you know, that's how you're going to build intuition.
38:41That's how you're going to build character. That's how you're going to learn.
38:45Johnny:I love to unpack relationship trajectories because I feel like this is another one of those areas where we feel like things should be linear and they should be moving based on what we see in other couples, based on what we see in Hollywood, what we see culturally. And in actuality, that's not what the science shows. It's amazing how idiosyncratic these trajectories can be and how very hard they can be to predict. So one fascinating thing, I mean, the way I got into studying this particular topic was that I was really mystified by this really common distinction. It exists in the science. It exists in like really nasty forms online.
39:28mine, but it's that this idea that, oh, some people are good for a short term relationship and other people are good for a long term relationship. And so what that implied to me was that, like, well, you should meet somebody and kind of figure out, like, I don't know, like, which category are you in? And then as soon as you figure that out, then you pursue one kind of relationship with them, but not the other. And as I, like, reflected on my experiences and other people experiences, there's so much like, well, I don't know. Like, I'm kind of into them. Like, I'm attracted to them. But I don't know, could we make this work?
40:08They seem different from me in these core ways. I wonder if that's a problem. And you spend more time with them and you kind of figure it out as you go. And it was this very new way of thinking about how relationships unfold, that it's this step by step process, like almost like a ratchet but it's like a ratchet that can unravel at any second where you both people are just trying to figure out what is this thing and what we kind of discovered was that short-term relationships flings even one night stands that's the part that can be a little surprising to people all of these things are like you know you got partway through this process and you were like, this is OK.
40:52I'm maybe like into you sexually, but I'm going to tap out like this is this is actually not something I'm super enthusiastic about, whereas long term relationships tended to be these relationships where you just you just kept going. Right. I mean, you know, you met at a club and it was fun. And then all of a sudden you're like, actually, I like spending time with you. Like, let's go to Ikea. And these this process is very, very common. But the tricky thing about it is like you don't always know where things are going. You kind of just have to ride it out.
41:28Johnny:Many of us want that certainty, right? You want to know. And that's why we're so quick to fall into these traps online, the alpha beta, the hookup versus the stable, dependable guy, you know, and much of us then turning that on ourselves and the self-judgment in that of like, oh, I guess I am just the hookup guy. You know, the last three opportunities I had were just ended in a fling or I couldn't get past the first date. This can be pretty demoralizing. Like when whenever you feel like other people have put you in some kind of category, people aren't categories. I mean, you're just like full stop.
42:04Like, that's not what we are. Everything psychological is dimensional. And and there are many, many, many different kinds of dimensions. I mean, it's such a psychological given what I'm saying that it's amazing to me. We even flirted with the scientific idea of there being like, oh, you know, CADs and dads are, you know, good short term and good long term partners in the first place. It's just not true whatsoever. But it can be hard to snap out of that categorical, that categorical way of thinking, whether it's about yourself or whether it's about other people. It can be very, very tempting.
42:47Johnny:It's important to look at it in a more layered way. you know what you're talking about here like they just chose to keep going the relationship actually became long term because both parties were like hey i'm i'm liking this i'm going to keep going well we are layered as well so part of our dating experience should be showing our layers looking for the other person's layers finding those layers that actually lead to us moving forward but along with that many of us feel like we're on this search for compatibility like i just have to find the match, the one that like fits my jigsaw puzzle piece perfectly.
43:23What's so tricky about this search for compatibility is that that is often what it feels like. And it's not totally wrong, but where the metaphor breaks down is that you're not looking for somebody who was like pre-crafted to fit you. that ultimately is going to be frustrating and probably won't work. It's better to think about this slow construction of a thing that subsumes the two of you, the relationship that is bigger than both of you. You're creating something that you want to work and that that's actually where most of compatibility comes from. it's a uh i think if you think about this idea it's um encouraging also a little bit surprising because it suggests that geez under the right circumstances you mean i i could have made it work with anybody like if i just had constructed the right thing i'm not exactly saying that but i'm like kind of saying that because i do think again to go back to like ancestral context you didn't have many choices.
44:32But what you did have was time to construct things. And with enough stops and starts and enough trial and error and enough like building intuition, people can get pretty good at building relationships with other people that work well, that give you both what you need. And so a lot of times, like when people are struggling out there, I like to remind them like you're not like hunting for buried treasure as much as you're kind of an architect with no blueprint. And if you think about it that way, I think it's people will find it becomes a little bit easier. Score more with the college branded Venmo debit card and earn up to 5 % cash back with Venmo stash.
45:17Got paid back with the Venmo debit card. You can instantly access your balance and spend on what you want, like game day snacks, gear, tickets, and more. The more you do, the more cash back you can earn. Plus, there's no monthly fee or minimum balance. Sign up now at Venmo.com slash college card. The Venmo MasterCard is issued by the Bancorp Bank N.A. Select schools available. Venmo stash terms and exclusions apply at Venmo.me slash stash terms. Max$100 cash back per month. My day kicks off with a refreshing Celsius energy drink, then straight to the gym. Pre-K pickup, back home to meal prep. Time for my fire station shift.
45:50One more Celsius, gotta keep the lights on. When the three alarm hits, I'm ready. Celsius. Live. Fit. Go. Grab a cold, refreshing Celsius at your local retailer or locate now at Celsius.com.
46:04Johnny:Well, that hunter metaphor is what a lot of men think they're supposed to be in the dating landscape. They think that evolutionary dating advice says we are the dominant predators. We have to be alpha. We have to go out after what we want. And you offer a very different picture of what this actually looks like scientifically. When we think about how we evolved to be men, I think there is a tendency to think in the terms that you just described. We are supposed to dominate and we are supposed to lead and we are supposed to intimidate. And this is how we win and achieve success. some of the scientists in my sphere also talk in these terms i think this is in some ways exactly wrong it is exactly backwards because if you look at the evolutionary trajectory so now i'm talking about hundreds of thousands of years millions of years if you look at what happened to the males and the men, okay, the male hominids who lived a million, two million years ago.
47:18It was not the case that the strongest, most dominant ones were the ones who were more likely to survive. In fact, it was the opposite. It was the smaller ones. It was the gentler ones. It was the ones who were good around kids, the ones who were less aggressive that the females tended to prefer. We lost our sharp canines. That's because we don't fight for mates in the way that our ancestors did six million plus years ago. We got smaller. We men got smaller relative to females over the course of the last several million years because we were selected for our gentleness around offspring. We were selected to be parents.
48:03You don't want male chimps parenting. You don't want male gorillas parenting. They're not trustworthy at all around infants. Men can be pretty good as parents. So that's our trajectory. Our trajectory is to, you know, to be protectors. Yes. But also to be, you know, people who are helpful for our families and our social groups and to feel valued by our social groups. It's not to like go out and kick ass like that's that's old stuff. It's certainly not that men can be great parents. It's that men need to be. Yeah. But when it comes to the evolutionary piece of it, there's so many variables that we have to take into account that play themselves out today as well.
48:48Why is there a population collapse going on in all of these first world countries? Well, it's because we don't need to be nurturing of a tribe that can protect us and help us and achieve success. that has always been there. And in the case of every society is rising, it had always been the dense cities that stopped having children while the rural areas and the, and the people that needed to depend on each other in the tribe. And again, you need to be an understanding and gentle man to survive in the, in that atmosphere, because it was about community that allowed you to be successful and out there on the range?
49:33I think this is an important piece of it that's very easy to lose because in modern urban environments, it's very easy and kind of paradoxically, but it's very easy to retreat, right? It's easy to retreat from a sense of broader community. I'm very fortunate. I live in Sacramento. Sacramento is an unusual place because I sometimes feel like I'm in an identifiable small neighborhood, even though technically I'm in a, you know, a mid-sized U.S. city. It's kind of a remarkable thing. But a lot of dense urban centers don't feel like that. You don't know your neighbors at all. And that can make this very challenging.
50:15And it pulls us toward things that aren't about, you know, that aren't about family that are about these more external trappings of success. And so when the external trappings of success become the draw rather than community, family, giving, et cetera, I do. Yeah, that can be a major problem. Just another example of that. I go to visit my father in the summer and I and I grew up in a small town outside of Pittsburgh in the foothills of the Appalachians. And I would stop at the dive bar on my Sunday walks, just have a beer or two in the middle of it before going home. and the bartender that I was always chatting, visit with, she knew everybody's life that went on in that town.
51:02And she was telling me so-and-so hasn't come in lately. They had a heart attack last month. I have to check in on them. That sense of community blew my mind because I had lived in large cities since I've been an adult. And you're not going to hear that too often in any mega city. And that, which goes to what you were saying, which is you can hide in the big city. There's too much going on. Everyone else has their own dramas to be dealing with where it's the small town. Hey, I'm waiting for a drama to get involved with. I can't, being involved in other people's lives in those in that situation just brings so much purpose and meaning this is going to sound like so quaint and so like like steven spielberg but like in in my little part of the city um basically everybody walks their kids to school it's like a neighborhood school and everybody walks their kids there and a lot of like things get done i don't know how to put it any other way like things get done and things get discussed among the parents as they're like walking their kids to school.
52:21And it feels like such a bygone era. I mean, I'm very, very fortunate that I get to be a part of something like that. But it really does foster a sense of like we're in this together and like, oh, I meant to check in with you about this. Like those kinds of interactions are really important. And when we just like when we all retreat, we really lose something valuable.
52:43Johnny:What we have lost in a lot of ways is that communal norm. And now we've seen the rise of scorekeeping. And especially if we're serially dating, you know, we can feel like we're being taken advantage of and we have to track how much effort's being put in. And we we search for equality over the actual person that we are a great match for and we are worth committing to a relationship with. And I've had numerous clients over the years get frustrated that they feel like, hey, things aren't even for me. I'm putting myself out there. I'm paying for dates. I'm doing a lot here to try to win an attractive mate.
53:20Johnny:And I'm on the long term. I'm losing because of it. It's tough. And it's tough when you feel like the world is it's like has these gendered rules that are stacked against you. I hold out hope that there are still many pockets out there which are less gendered. I mean, I think that if we're talking about like serial first date after serial first date, that's probably going to contribute to more of this tension, more of this sort of, you know, zero sum. you know men are trying to get this from women and women are trying to get these things from men and the genders feel like their intention as opposed to mixed gender networks I'm so fond of these studies showing that you know if you look at men's romantic prospects the more women friends that they have and I do mean like actual friends like not people that you want to date or that you're trying to date, but actual friends, these men have the best romantic prospects.
54:30And it's, it's, again, it's not because you're going to date these women. It's that they're going to introduce you to people who are going to introduce you to people and you're going to date them. And that, that doesn't feel zero sum. In fact, you might be helpful, like introduce and hurt us some people that she might hit it off with. Boy, if we can create social circles like that, I think we're all going to find ourselves in a much, much better situation.
54:57Johnny:Well, with that, the friend zone is something that men actively avoid. And the second that they feel that they're in the friend zone, they will cut that woman out of their life. Yeah. And it's not about, hey, I can't pursue you anymore. It's like, I don't even want to be friends with you because you put me in this friend zone and you're actually arguing that there's an asset and it creates more optionality and opportunity for you. So it should be celebrated instead of rejected. Do not fear the friend zone. You are going to be OK. Now, the friend zones sucks if you are super into this person and you can't imagine being with anybody else.
55:39And, you know, I've got I've got stories in the book where I like teetered on the edge of this where I was so into this person and it felt so painful to to just be friends with them. It felt like I felt insulting. I felt like a failure. But it's like I took a deep breath and I took a couple months away and realized, yeah, but she's pretty cool. I would actually like to be friends with this person. And it was really eye opening in many ways. Like then she introduces me to all these other people. and like my social skills grow it ended up being totally fine but it's it it is almost like you have to like go through this like river of vulnerability first where you let yourself like feel the rejection it feels crappy and you push through to the other side and you discover what it means to be friends with somebody anyway even if there's no romantic prospects there so So like, don't be afraid of it.
56:48Go go through it, work through it. And if you get to the other side, you'll discover like, oh, my social possibilities can expand. Maybe with this person, you know, playing a peripheral role. And that is OK. There we're not at men are not at war with women and vice versa. Like we can all help each other out. Help us here.
57:10Johnny:Like, where is the data at currently? because I feel like right now what is told and sold to us by these online dating apps who are obviously making a lot of money harvesting our data around dating is that that is the surest way to find that person. That is the surest way right now to get that match. Whereas obviously, traditionally, we were finding it through weak ties. We were finding it through network effects more than any app or marketplace. And it was certainly not about lying about our height and changing what we look like with filters to get there. And yet because of that, it's now become so pervasive that men are rejecting those social ties.
57:48Johnny:They're choosing to forego socializing, thinking that, well, that's not how I'm going to find this partner. And I really want to start a family. I really want to partner. The best data I've seen these days, certainly consistent with the idea that online dating is the most common way that meet people. Sorry, the most common way that people meet each other now. It has not displaced the other ways. It is still true. The people meet through friends and they meet through work and they meet through all these other avenues. Those avenues aren't gone. They're like second and third place and the margins are close.
58:24So you can use the apps, but the other ways still exist. I think a lot of what has happened is that, look, the average online dating user spends 90 minutes a day on the apps. That's like a lot of time. I can tell you 25 years ago when I was single and looking, I wasn't spending 90 minutes looking for a part that doesn't even like compute. Like I might be hanging out with friends at a bar. Does that count as my 90 minutes? 90 minutes sitting there on your phone swiping, doing one thing. So we're spending an inordinate amount of time on a process that really has no other rewards other than, well, you're using your phone and it feels addictive.
59:09So that's the thing that has changed and that has really captured our brains. But the other avenues are still there. My hope is that people are going to figure out how to, if they can't throw their phone into the ocean, and I get it, you can at least supplement the online ways with the old ways. And I like, yeah, right. I mean, I'm, I sound like a Gen Xer, but like, don't forget to go out and socialize and meet people and spend time outside as well, even if you're going to be using the apps. But, but I think, I think we're going to get there. My guess is that online dating will still be around, but it's going to like plateau It's something like, OK, this is how a third of couples meet.
59:58But two thirds are coming from the old ways.
1:00:00Johnny:One thing that I'd like to shift at least our audience's view on, and I think this is really interesting science, is the apps right now are first impression only. They are split second decisions happening. You get one strike and you're out. In person, the research shows that third impression actually matters the most. You get three strikes. So when we are now reorganizing our life around the apps, we are mathematically actually robbing ourselves of more opportunity than we realize. And I know the in-person rejection stings. I know we try to avoid it because it feels like it has even more social consequence, but it's less likely in person because people are giving us way more benefit of the doubt.
1:00:46Give people three impressions for your own sake, because honestly, you don't know how you feel actually all that well after meeting somebody one time, especially if that one time is like, OK, I swiped yes on you and we're meeting for coffee and I have 20 minutes before I got to get to my meeting. and so like give me the stats go go go like your impression of that person is not stable i mean that's how we talk about in the science it's not stable and what that means is that there's a lot of potential for change if i made you meet them a second time and our impressions get more stable over time i mean if you've been with your partner for 10 years on 10 years plus one day odds are your impression is going to be pretty similar to what it was the day before.
1:01:42But but it's sort of like this. You got to sort of get up to this plateau of stability to know whether you like somebody or you don't. And so that's where I say, like, three dates is like pretty good. Right. I mean, 10 10 dates, you'll really know. But three dates is way better than one for knowing how you feel about somebody. And the thing that where that's hard for people is that, well, what that means is that if that coffee date, that 20 minute coffee date, you were kind of, eh, that means you got to do the second one. It doesn't mean you cut people off if they don't exceed some high threshold on the first one.
1:02:20It means you give everybody three chances. And again, there are portions of our social world that force that where you're going to meet this person three times, whether you want to or not, to the extent that people can do this while dating and still feel safe and they've got the time, I strongly advocate for giving people that many chances.
1:02:40Johnny:There's one thing that I'd love your perspective on, and we've seen the rise of it again, going back to this categorization of people, especially since we work in self-development and many of our clients want to improve themselves, is the rise of attachment theory. and then the judgment we place on ourselves, labeling ourselves as I'm anxious this, I can't be who this partner needs. So I have to work on myself first. I have to fix my anxious attachment before I can go get that partner. Working on your issues, it's just kind of a good idea. I mean, again, therapy, thumbs up, go for it. Is it a prerequisite?
1:03:26I think the thing that we kind of miss, And look, attachment theory is absolutely core to my world. It's core to the science. We use it all the time. But these styles, they're less stable than we think. Or maybe another way of thinking about it is that we all contain multitudes. I know what it's like to be avoidant. I would call myself a secure person. But I know what it's like to be avoidant. And I know what it's like to be anxious too. And my relationships with different people, especially at different points in those relationships, could have been any and all of those things. And it's our close relationships that change how we view ourselves.
1:04:04Like I view myself as a secure person today, but that's because I have a long-term secure relationship now. You talked to me 10 years ago, you talked to me 20 years ago, I might've seen like an avoidant mess or an anxious mess. So it's like therapy is good, but a lot of times the way that people change is through getting involved. in close relationships, giving other people the opportunity to change how you see yourself. And it can feel very upsetting and it makes people feel very vulnerable, but it's an important part of the whole process. When I hear attachment theory, it leads to all of this of self-discovery when we can think about our ancestors and what did they have?
1:04:50Well, they said the stars were aligned this way when we met that night. And that's how I knew that we were there forever. We didn't have attachment theory, right? They didn't have all these other things. What they had was, you know, going by what the cosmos had told them in that end moment and making that stick. That's, and they stayed together.
1:05:19Johnny:And I think the greatest impact on behavioral change is actually relationships. It's not just focusing on the relationship you have with yourself. I've had some of the biggest insights through failed relationships where I recognized I was anxious attachment. It was not through me just reading books, consuming podcasts and talking to a person. It was through me actually going through the experience of a relationship, trying to build something greater together with this person. And I think when we rob ourselves of that and we become so self-focused and only aware of what we are working on, we actually are not creating the opportunity to get as much work done on ourselves as we could by experiencing the messiness that is dating.
1:06:04Sometimes when we look at other people go through relationships and they change, it can be tempting to be like, what the hell? That's not who you are. I know who you are. I knew you before this relationship. That was you. This is some nonsense. it's not it's not really how it works like we are very flexible i think i think it's an amazing thing that we can change with our relationships as long as people are cued in to what feels good to them and whether they're becoming the person you want to be if your relationship is making you the person and you're like who am i becoming that's a warning sign but if you're becoming a new person you're growing and changing and developing new interests and new identities through a relationship.
1:06:50That's like the whole point. And I just like it's OK to change. It really is.
1:06:58Johnny:Well, as we close, I'd love to get your perspective on masculinity, because I know it has created a lot of confusion for the men who take our training and it's become a hot topic. And there's a lot of different views, views that'll get you canceled, views that will win you a lot of followers online. to Johnny's point and win you infamy for the wrong reasons. But what what should we be looking at when we talk about masculinity through what lens? What what are these important attributes in your opinion? The stoic version of masculinity is getting a lot of play these days. And I'm not I'm not here to hate on the stoics, but I think like the ethos of like, I'm an independent warrior and I will, you know, pursue through intimidation and domination.
1:07:49Not a fan. Being a part of a community, contributing to something, feeling valuable for what you give to others. That's a really important part of masculinity. So I think I think we can just pivot a little bit from the this old classic, like mid 20th century way of thinking about masculinity where you don't show emotion and you're just strong like showing emotion is really important actually having real relationships with women if you're a heterosexual guy is very very important women are not the enemy we can all help each other out um i think by pivoting in that direction it's it's um a version of masculinity that's ultimately going to be a lot more healthy And it's going to give everybody, you know, more of what they're looking for.
1:08:40We're blessed to be in a position where we can hear the best argument of other positions. And we've never that wasn't given. We didn't have that access before. So before you start looking at the lead characters who gain all the headlines for saying the most outrageous stuff. You know, find the other arguments. find what most importantly find what what allows and empowers you to be at your best because if you're not cut out to to be the brash raggy uh guy because that's what you're told you need to be it's it's like you're going to experience a lot of hardships but when you find a philosophy or an ideology that empowers you to uh to add skills to be of more value that there's nothing that can stop you and unfortunately some of those ideas don't get the media play intention that they deserve.
1:09:55Well, you have X spaces. Yeah. You, uh, you have YouTube. There's alternative media sources that promote different ideas. I suggest you go find, uh, what gives you the most strength. That's a great point. Could not have said it better.
1:10:14Johnny:Well, thank you so much for joining us, Paul. Where can our audience find out more about the book and argue with you online about everything you share. Yes, yes. So the book comes out on February 10th and the book's called Bonded by Evolution. You can get it wherever you buy books. If you want to hear more from me, check out the Love Factually podcast where my co-host and I, Eli Finkel, we talk about how the scientific principles of romance and attraction appear in the movies. Thank you again. Great conversation, Paul. Thanks so much for having me.
1:10:56Well, I hope you enjoyed that episode as much as we have. And now comes a part of the show where we showcase one of our X Factor members. Take it away, Daniel.
1:11:05Johnny:My name is Daniel Bosing, and I'm a manufacturing engineer. My overall experience with the X Factor Accelerator program has been excellent due to effective teaching and a supportive community of like-minded individuals. Since joining, I've cultivated deeper connections with my friends, family, and colleagues by implementing the conversational techniques learned in the program. These deeper connections have made my life more fulfilling, both personally and professionally. I would recommend joining the X Factor Exciter program because the excellent teaching and consistent accountability ensure you will grow into the person that you want to become.
1:11:43Daniel, it was a pleasure working with you too, and good luck with all your future pursuits. If you've gotten value out of this or any of our podcasts, please head on over to your favorite podcast player and rate and review the show. It means the world to us and it helps others find the show. Go out there and have an amazing, amazing week.
1:12:18You're a song of a tragedy Cause you had your taste Of black on the easy day Yeah, but I remember you Oh yeah, I remember you
1:12:40The UPS Store is making packing and shipping Easter gifts quicker than ever this year with UPSA How quick? Quicker than a walk around the park. Quicker than eating all the Easter candies. Quicker than finding a golden egg that you know is stuffed with cash. When you ship UPS Air at the UPS Store, your items arrive on time or your money back. Guaranteed at no extra cost. Exclusively at the UPS Store U.S. retail locations. Send Easter joy on time at the UPS Store. Visit the upsstore.com slash air guarantee for full details. Terms and conditions apply.
From the publisher
AJ and Johnny sit down with Paul Eastwick, relationship scientist and author of Bonded by Evolution, to unpack what modern dating has gotten wrong — and what the science actually says about love, attraction, and connection.
They explore how online dating has distorted our view of desirability, why the search for “the perfect person” makes us miserable, and how real connection comes from shared time, not algorithms. Paul breaks down how our brains evolved for small-group bonding — not endless swiping — and reveals the truth about compatibility, attachment, and the misunderstood “friend zone.”
From evolutionary psychology to modern dating anxiety, this conversation is a masterclass in how to build real relationships in a world built on comparison.
Chapters:
00:00 – Why love advice is so confusing05:00 – How online dating rewired attraction10:00 – The confidence gap and lost social skills15:00 – The danger of treating dating like a marketplace20:00 – Algorithms, ego, and authenticity in the AI era30:00 – How relationships actually form and last
35:00 – Compatibility is built, not found
40:00 – Why men should stop fearing the friend zone45:00 – Redefining masculinity and modern love
A Word From Our Sponsors
Stop being over looked and unlock your X-Factor today at unlockyourxfactor.com
The very qualities that make you exceptional in your field are working against you socially. Visit the artofcharm.com/intel for a social intelligence assessment and discover exactly what's holding you back.
If you’ve put off organizing your finances, Monarch is for you. Use code CHARM at monarch.com in your browser for half off your first year.
Indulge in affordable luxury with Quince. Upgrade your wardrobe today at quince.com/charm for free shipping and hassle-free returns.
Grow your way - with Headway! Get started at makeheadway.com/CHARM and use my code CHARM for 25% off.
This year, skip breaking a sweat AND breaking the bank. Get your summer savings and shop premium wireless plans at mintmobile.com/charm
Curious about your influence level?
Get your Influence Index Score today!
Take this 60-second quiz to find out how your influence stacks up against top performers at theartofcharm.com/influence.
Episode resources:
Bonded by Evolution: The New Science of Love and Connection
Love Factually
Check in with AJ and Johnny!
AJ on LinkedIn
Johnny on LinkedIn
AJ on Instagram
Johnny on Instagram
The Art of Charm on Instagram
The Art of Charm on YouTube
The Art of Charm on TikTok
meetings, collaboration, leadership, communication, productivity, visibility, AI at work, remote work, workplace culture, career growth, The Art of Charm
AI, automation, purpose, identity, future of work, Zack Kass, The Next Renaissance, technology, leadership, creativity, meaning, human connection, emotional intelligence, optimism, The Art of Charm
Paul Eastwick, dating, relationships, love, attraction, compatibility, attachment theory, online dating, Tinder, Bumble, match, masculinity, connection, psychology, The Art of Charm, AJ Harbinger, Johnny Dzubak
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
