In short
Podcast Summary: The Art of Charm - Nonverbal Secrets to Building Trust | Dr. Abigail Maroño
Episode Overview In this episode of The Art of Charm, hosts Johnny and AJ invite Dr. Abigail Maroño, a leading expert in social influence and body language analysis, to discuss the science behind nonverbal communication and trust-building. The conversation explores how nonverbal cues shape our perceptions of trustworthiness, cooperation, and influence in various contexts from personal relationships to corporate environments.
Key Concepts and Discussions
Understanding Trust
- Misconceptions of Trust: Trust is often misunderstood; it's seen as something complex when, in reality, it can be simplified to feelings of safety and vulnerability.
- Quick Judgments: Human brains assess trustworthiness in just 33 milliseconds, making nonverbal cues essential.
- Destruction of Trust: Just one inconsistent action can dismantle months of trust-building.
The Power of Cooperation
- Competition vs. Cooperation: The common belief in a "dog-eat-dog" world is challenged. Trust and cooperation lead to greater success, especially in leadership roles.
- Evolved Traits: Cooperation has roots in our evolutionary history; traits that enhance trust and collaboration are essential for group survival.
Nonverbal Communication Techniques
- Body Language Insights:
- Lower Body Cues: Hidden lower-body signals may convey true emotions and are often more telling than facial expressions.
- Open Postures: Open body language, such as head tilts and visible palms, makes individuals appear more approachable and trustworthy.
- Impact of Online Interaction: Video conferencing poses unique challenges by disrupting natural communication instincts, affecting trust-building.
Building and Rebuilding Trust
- Effective Apologies: An appropriate apology must match the severity of the trust breach; a superficial “I’m sorry” can exacerbate distrust.
- Consistency is Key: Trustworthiness must be consistently demonstrated; behaviors that signal safety should be continually reinforced.
Application of Nonverbal Skills
- Practice: Incorporating nonverbal cues in daily interactions fosters trust and enhances communication effectiveness.
- Self-Awareness: Recording interactions can help individuals become aware of their nonverbal signals and areas for improvement.
Notable Quotes
- "Survival of the fittest isn't about individual traits; it's about traits that allow the group to thrive."
- "Trust is safety; it’s about feeling that you can be vulnerable without being exploited."
Conclusion Dr. Abigail Maroño's insights on the science of nonverbal communication provide valuable tools for enhancing interpersonal relationships and creating cooperative environments. By understanding and practicing effective nonverbal cues, individuals can significantly improve their ability to build and maintain trust.
Resources
- [Dr. Abigail Maroño's website](http://abbymarono.com)
- Follow Dr. Maroño on [LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/in/abbymarono) and [Twitter](https://twitter.com/abbyjmarono).
- [The Art of Charm](https://theartofcharm.com) for more episodes and resources on personal development.
Action Items
- Reflect on your own nonverbal communication and identify areas for improvement.
- Practice open body language and active listening in everyday interactions.
- Consider recording a conversation for self-evaluation and awareness.
For further insights on mastering relationships and human dynamics, tune in to The Art of Charm weekly.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:03When did making plans get this complicated? It's time to streamline with WhatsApp, the secure messaging app that brings the whole group together. Use polls to settle dinner plans. Send event invites and pin messages so no one forgets mom's 60th. And never miss a meme or milestone. All protected with end-to-end encryption. It's time for WhatsApp. Message privately with everyone. Learn more at whatsapp.com. Survival of the fittest isn't about the traits that make you as an individual survive. it's about the traits that make the group that you're in thrive and survive so those traits that enhance cooperation and build trust those are the traits that flourish and those are the ones you've evolved to have
0:57you're not going to want to miss today's tips on your non-verbal communication abby is a world-class expert on nonverbal communication and social influence. Her PhD in academic research focuses specifically on nonverbal communication, trust, and cooperation. Abby shares how your feet could be sabotaging your trustworthiness. In fact, groundbreaking research reveals the shocking impact of lower body language on first impressions. Master the millisecond signals that determine whether people trust or doubt you. Backed by cutting edge science on how we make snap judgments in just 33 milliseconds. And lastly, learn why trying to detect lies is actually holding you back and how focusing on these proven trust-building signals can transform your relationships.
1:43Welcome to the show, Abby. Great to have you. Thank you for having me. Wonderful. Our good friend Joe Navarro had recommended that you would drop by in the chat with us. He certainly has brought up your research and we were fascinated in going through your research for this show. There's a lot of ideas that align and we're certainly excited to hear some of the science behind some of the body language communication that we have been preaching on this show for the last 15 years. I am excited to get started. So we'd love to just kick it off and to get to know a bit about you. What was it about body language that got you interested?
2:20I think it was because human beings are so complicated and so individual that you can't say that anybody has a particular personality type or people do things for certain reasons. They're so difficult to understand, yet body language is a universal language. It's something that we've carried with us through evolution and we all share certain traits and characteristics and we all do similar things for similar reasons. unconsciously in terms of our body language and I just felt that was incredible that we can identify these common patterns when everything about human beings seems to be completely different and I got really interested as everybody does when they start looking at non-verbal communication lie detection and everybody wants to be a human lie detector and it took me some time in the field of studying light detection to realize there is no such thing as a non-verbal cue of deception.
3:21I wrote two research papers trying to find cues for deception and we actually I mean the studies were really interesting because we took a really unique approach to the way we looked at body language but what we were actually just seeing is high stress high stress and discomfort and then I changed my perspective when I was doing my PhD to look at cooperation and creating a positive environments so that people feel safe and feel comfortable and feel familiar with you, that they want to share information with you. And then it kind of opened up a whole world where everything seems really positive and you realize, wow, human beings are so cooperative.
4:01And that is, you know, what we have evolved to do. We've evolved to cooperate. That is how we've survived. And I think especially in academia, I've always thought of everything is quite dog eat dog. And I know that business most of the time people say you know leadership is doggy dog but it really isn't because it is all about cooperation and trust and creating a positive environment for your colleagues and your employees and that's how you get to the top by working with other people cooperatively and that really is the key to successful relationships successful business Well, we are certainly huge fans of cooperation.
4:40And I know trust is something that a lot of us have this internal barometer around. But what does trust define from a scientific perspective as? so this is an interesting question because scientists have this way of making things very confusing and they take these these concepts and then they pull them apart into okay well what's cognitive trust okay what's effective trust what's behavioral trust what's this kind of trust and they really pull them apart and make them individual but they overlap in so many different ways and I just think that it's over complicated and the way I see trust is safety you know if we feel safe if our brain says you are not a threat I trust you if I feel that I can be vulnerable and you won't exploit me that's trust now how quickly can trust be built if we look at it from that lens so trust has evolved to be very very quick from non-verbal communication we actually judge trustworthiness in 33 milliseconds so it's literally the first judgment that we make about anybody before confidence before competence anything is trust and it can be we can perceive someone as trustworthy very very quickly but we can also perceive someone as untrustworthy just like that just as quick even if we've made that initial judgment of trustworthy all they have to do is one thing and our brain says no not safe and then it's gone so it depends on again the kind of trust that you're looking at if we're having an interaction now we have a one-time interaction then all your judgments are based on me in this one interaction but then if I am very very trustworthy and you think you know I trust you you seem trustworthy and then we have another interaction and I behave slightly differently all of that trust that's built up is gone.
6:35So to answer your question, it can be built very quickly. It can be built over a long period of time and it can be destroyed very quickly and it can be destroyed after a long period of time. If you've had this very, very long, lengthy, trustworthy relationship, one thing, one simple thing, and it can be broken down just like that. With our clients, one of the main points to building trust that we discuss is what after they come through they feel very good about being more vulnerable and being more open with new people because they learn its power so they want to communicate and build that trust with everybody and what they find after they have gotten comfortable with their vulnerability that other people aren't so comfortable with their vulnerability.
7:24And what I tell them is that nature is going to play its course and everybody has a different rate of how and look for different things in order to get comfortable with people. However, the one thing that you can't do is you can't push nature. You can't expedite it, but you can remove the hurdles that are in the way for people developing trust. and for a lot of people they think that it is an additive steps in order to build trust with people when in actuality it's removing a lot of the the things that are getting in the way and keeping people from easily getting comfortable and building trust yeah and that's one thing that um i think people get wrong that they think that trustworthiness is a toolkit you know we can talk about non-verbal behaviors to show that I'm trustworthy or behaviors to show that I'm trustworthy, acts of the way that you speak and things.
8:20And they think that they can apply these and use them and then form this trustworthiness and then put them down and then go off and continue with their life. And that's not what trust is. It's not a set of steps that you can just follow and then it's done. It's something you really have to embed. You can't just say, okay, well, if I smile, they perceive me as trustworthy and that's it. And, you know, I'll apply these things at the beginning of the interaction and I don't need to worry about them later. If you're doing the behaviors at the beginning, you stop doing them, I'm going to stop seeing you as trustworthy.
8:52Just like if I, like I said before, we interact once, I see you as trustworthy another time, I don't. It's not a toolkit. It's a set of things that we understand can create a perception of trustworthiness. But one other thing that creates trustworthiness is consistency. We as human beings, we need consistency. It makes us comfortable. It makes us feel safe because it's predictable. It's not uncertain. And if we're interacting with someone and we don't know how they're going to be towards us, are they going to be angry? Are they going to be happy? Are they going to be sad? Are they going to be there?
9:26It creates uncertainty and it stops us feeling so safe in that interaction. And if someone is inconsistent and they're using these behaviors as a toolkit, they put them down sometimes pick them up, sometimes put them down another time. We don't feel safe. We can't predict how we're going to interact with them. So you're exactly right. And it is one of the most common mistakes that I think people make in the field of trustworthyness. Now, you mentioned something earlier about as humans, we are cooperative, but there is this misconception that it's dog eat dog. So can you talk a little bit about why trust and cooperation are important from an evolutionary perspective and why it is that we are predisposed to cooperation?
10:08Yeah, so I think this dog-eat-dog perspective comes from the survival of the fittest. You know, I need to beat you so I can produce offspring. It's just competition. But survival of the fittest isn't about the traits that make you as an individual survive. It's about the traits that make the group that you're in thrive and survive so those traits that enhance cooperation and build trust those are the traits that flourish and those are the ones we've evolved to have and if we think that we've evolved in this really uncertain environment where there's threats everywhere you know there's a predator here there might not be my next meal here so having these group relationships has helped our survival because you can rely on people and they can help for us they can protect us all of these things that are just essential.
11:01Also, reproduction, which is quite self-explanatory, that we need other people for those kinds of things. And we need to be able to identify who we can cooperate with. So the one way that we've done that is we've evolved these nonverbal communication tactics of showing trustworthiness. So rather than just saying, hey, you know, I'll cooperate with you, we need to instantly be able to detect who was cooperative. So we have evolved these behaviors which say I'm trustworthy so we can pick out who to cooperate with and there's a lot of argument on this topic that well that can't be the case because people could use these tactics and pretend to be cooperative and just show these trustworthy behaviors and actually be a deceptor be deceptive but the thing is because we are a cooperative species that non-cooperative isn't going to last very long because in our social group we have process so if someone isn't cooperative all it takes is one person to say they didn't cooperate and then the whole group know they're a non-cooperator so we don't need to look for you know tactics of these cues of deception that's not what we've evolved to look for we've evolved to be quick and look for trustworthiness and we see it in modern day now you know if you want to go to a restaurant what is the first thing that you do you look on google for reviews look for what people have said about it if you're getting into a new relationship and you know that they know a friend first thing you do what are they like tell me about them have they done anything wrong because we count on the gusts of other people and we see it in celebrity magazines and all of these things we we thrive on it as a species because that's when we get our information about you know who is deceptive and who is trustworthy.
12:49And that's why it's so important not to view this, as you said earlier, as a toolkit, because your reputation builds trust. And if you're just turning it on and turning it off with certain people that you view as high value, you know, we use this example in class, how you treat the janitor is exactly how you should treat the executive of the company, because your reputation matters. And that consistency is huge to building the trust that you're looking for. Yeah, and you see in corporate a lot of the time, and people say, oh, well, you know, it is dog eat dog, because they're this way, and they're up at the top.
13:25They're doing amazing, and they're not cooperative, and they stand above people. And it's like, well, that doesn't mean that cooperation isn't a better way to go. They might be successful with their manipulative tactics, but it doesn't mean that they wouldn't be more successful if they were cooperative. People are successful all the time using negative tactics but just because people are doesn't mean that is the only way to get there or the best way to get there. Just think if that person who is at the top for being manipulative decided to actually become trustworthy and be cooperative, imagine how much better they could do.
14:02And what you do see around people that have got that way and got to the top without being trustworthy and without being cooperative, you see this bad reputation around them. You see lawsuits and you see complaints and you see unhappy staff. You see staff that don't enjoy their jobs and staff that don't enjoy their jobs. What means, you know, a non-cooperative work environment, a non-productive work environment. Hey, check this out. Do you want to unlock your X factor and become unstoppable at everything you do. At The Art of Charm, we believe that boosting your charisma, connection, and confidence is key to unlocking your true inner power.
14:45We call this power your X Factor. This new approach makes getting what you want, relationships, career success, influence, opportunities, instantly easier. While feeling great and having more fun on the journey. Now, if you've been listening to the show, you know that all of our extraordinary guests know their X Factor, and we want to help you unlock your unique X Factor. Over 15 years and thousands of happy clients later, we've built the world's best communications program. In as little as four weeks, you'll be more charismatic, connect with others instantly, and boost your confidence. Inside, you'll learn how to use your body to project confidence.
15:27Use your natural charisma to persuade and influence and unlock rapid rapport building to connect with anyone instantly. We've got weekly accountability calls, high impact group implementation sessions where you actually practice everything you're learning with feedback from our team, as well as homework assignments to make sure that these new skills stick. When you're seeing the matrix, everything becomes effortless and self-development has never been more fun. Join like-minded professionals, entrepreneurs, and execs and unlock your X Factor at unlockyourxfactor.com. That's unlockyourxfactor.com.
16:08If you're still overpaying for wireless, it's time to say yes to saying no. That's Mint Mobile's whole thing. Their favorite word is no. No contracts, no monthly bills, no overages, no hidden fees, no BS. And that's why I love Mint Mobile premium wireless service for just 15 bucks a month. Ditch those overpriced plans with jaw-dropping bills, surprise overages, and all the hidden fees. Mint starts at just$15 a month. And you're not giving up coverage. Every plan comes with high-speed data and unlimited talk and text on the nation's largest 5G network. You can even use your own phone, keep your number, and bring all your contacts with you.
16:44No hassle. Mint Mobile is unbeatable at this pricing. Ready to say yes to saying no? Make the switch at mintmobile.com slash charm. That's mintmobile.com slash charm. Upfront payment of$45 required, equivalent to$15 per month. Limited time new customer offer for the first three months only. Speeds may slow above 35 gigabytes on an unlimited plan. Taxes and fees extra. See Mint Mobile for details. As the weather finally cools down, I'm swapping in the pieces that actually get the job done. Warm, durable, and built to last. And Quince delivers every time. Quince has all the false staples you actually want to wear on repeat, like 100 % Mongolian cashmere sweater starting at just$60, classic fit denim, and real leather and wool outerwear that looks sharp and holds up.
17:30I've actually got my eye on their suede trucker jacket. It's perfect for layering, and it hits that balance of casual but still put together. What I like about Quince is they partner directly with ethical factories and top artisans. By cutting out the middlemen, you get premium quality at half the cost of similar brands. And it's not just clothing. I love their sheets. They have items like bedding and travel accessories. Quince has really become a go-to for me across the board. Same here. Everything I grabbed from Quince has held up and it doesn't wreck my budget. Layer up this fall with pieces that feel as good as they look.
18:02Go to quince.com slash charm for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada too. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E dot com slash charm. Free shipping and 365 day returns. quince.com slash charm.
18:22Yeah, I think especially if you've experienced that environment, you don't thrive in a manipulative, untrustworthy environment. So although you may see that person leading, you may also find that's not the culture that you want to be a part of or a company that you want to sustain working for. Yeah, if you don't feel safe when you go to work and you feel like you can't see yourself around people you can't relax or that you know you have to do everything perfectly you know exactly how your boss wants it that puts you so on edge and it doesn't motivate you to do your best that motivates you to just get by keep your head down and get on with the job that's not we what we want our employees to feel we want our employees to go to work and strive to be their best for themselves because they enjoy being there for their colleagues and because they respect their leader, not because they fear their leader.
19:19Now, with trust being built quickly, I'd love to talk about these nonverbal cues that we're evolutionarily wired to look for around trustworthiness. But yeah, so it starts with a smile. We know how important the smile is. And the smile truly is a social signal. Think about when you go bowling, when you hit a strike. You stay completely straight face when you hit the strike. It's only when you turn around and see people that you smile. You communicate, I'm excited, I'm happy. That's what the smile has evolved to do, to communicate, to communicate, I'm not a threat, I'm happy, I'm happy to see you.
20:04This funny thing happens when we see a smile and see a true, genuine smile. so when the upper cheeks are raised and we see the dutchman eyes um it released it releases oxytocin and oxytocin suppresses that fight or flight instinct where we say you know i might not be safe i need to go or i might need to go the smile relaxes us and just says you know no it's safe it's fine um and any behavior that could expose a vulnerability so we've evolved like i said in a really dangerous environment and one part of our body that we protect is our throat which is why when we see things that scare us or when we hear bad news a lot of the time we we put our hand to our throat without realizing we protect our throat or if something has you know we've had horrible news we often kind of stroke our throat and it's that instinct to protect and they could be you know a predator or something that could harm us so when we want to show that we're trustworthy we kind of lean our head to the side to do this head tilt and we expose our neck because we're exposing a vulnerable part of our body and saying you know I don't think you're a threat I'm not a threat here's a vulnerable part to show you that I'm not a threat and dogs actually do that too and I think this behavior was first mentioned in Charles Darwin's book on the emotions of man and animals and he noticed it from his dog and he saw certain behaviors in his dog and then And it kind of, you know, we started to learn, oh, humans do these too.
21:35And then we really started to figure out, you know, this is a signal to say I'm trustworthy at the same. And also anything that is very open. So things like open postures and open palms. So if I'm talking to you, I have my palms facing outwards. You can see what is in my hands. I haven't got a weapon. My hands are behind my back. Your brain says, uh-oh, there could be something there in the hand. So always making sure that you are facing someone and have your palms out and showing, you know, I'm not hiding anything from you. And this is also why people that hide information or hold back information can be perceived as untrustworthy.
22:17So when we tell kind of half-truths and we hold a bit of information back, and bosses do this all the time where you know there's some bad news, but they're not really telling you everything. it's that we don't know what it is that they have so our brain says it's it's the worst it could possibly be so we feel uncomfortable we feel unconsciously that they are untrustworthy because it's that same feeling of there could be a threat there i can't see that there isn't a threat so my brain says there is well what's so interesting in in the work that we've done over the last 15 years is that we'll tell our clients, hey, smiling is important, but internally they feel like they are smiling all the time, yet they're not openly expressing that full face smile.
23:05And it takes us actually filming them and showing them the video for themselves to show the discomfort that they're showing in these situations where they're feeling a little bit of social anxiety, some tension and pressure. And once they realize just the simple change in that smile and showing it early and often as you communicate with someone, it leads to an entirely different interaction. So we're also wired to respond and turn and mirror back that smile and bring energy to our communication when we feel the other person is bringing that smile in and showcasing us that trustworthiness. So it really changes the tenor of the entire conversation.
23:44Yeah, it's emotional contagion. So if someone is showing you, I'm smiling, I'm happy, I'm really excited you kind of get just instant more energy from interacting with them because you take on some of their emotions just like we have all been in a conversation with an energy drain where you are excited and they are so just mellow and their tone of voice is mellow and their behaviors are mellow and then you just start to feel tired it's the same thing it's just that we mimic people unconsciously and through that we take on their emotions and we can't help it again that's an evolved um behavior and that's why i did my phd in unconscious mimicry and it really does work through emotional contagion so i read this article a while ago and it said um that people that show some anxious behaviors are perceived better um and i don't know where they got the science from that if we interact with someone and we show that we're anxious that perceived as more trustworthy and makes people more comfortable and that really isn't the case because when we show that we're anxious they feel anxious they take on that anxiety so especially in the field of non-verbal communication there is so much rubbish out there and this is an example of some rubbish that's out there and you know we do have to be very careful about what we read because these kinds of things there's other ones about you know you can tell people's personalities by how open or closed their posture is and things and when we take this misinformation it causes us to interact with people differently so if we perceive someone as hiding something because they're crossing their arms we're going to interact with them like they're hiding something or if we see someone as being defensive because they're showing certain behaviors that we misinterpret as defensive we're going to start making them defensive by the way we talk to them so we have to make sure that we're being careful of one how we interact with people because of emotional contagion, because we're passing them our emotions, but also because there is a lot of misinformation that we have to be careful how we are interpreting their behaviors and responding.
25:56Yeah, I think it's far more important to focus on what you're communicating outward than to start like you did, seeking out deception, lie detection, and reading all of this into nonverbal communication. Sure, that would be great if we could just look at someone and instantly get a 100 % accurate read on them. But what's far more impactful is actually modulating our own behaviors, showcasing these trustworthy signals with everyone, making it a part of our personality to build and grow trust with others, knowing that it improves our reputation and improves our communication. And of course, through cooperation, it gets us ahead in our career.
26:33For a lot of people as well, the ideas that they come to us for, and certainly for the the men, they want to learn to approach women, but also in a networking event to be able to walk up to somebody that they're interested in talking to and make their pitch. And for the ladies as well, they want to be able to break the chains of their social anxiety and walk up to folks that they find interesting and chat with as well. And due to that, without them realizing it, what they end up doing before they come through and learning about this is they go out of their way to make the other person feel that they can trust them, that they're not up to something.
27:16So what they'll do is they'll put their hands behind their back to show that I'm safe and they'll shrink themselves. And all of those behaviors, as you mentioned, give off a different vibe to the person that they're talking with. And they're now uncomfortable. And so they leave. And it's fascinating how easily we pick up on others body language, which also brings me to this point that you mentioned about how we're going to mimic the micro expressions that are going on and we can, and we see those when we're dealing with people, but this is something that we're now learning that we have all this technology and I can't read the micro expressions on your face through zoom through the technology and so these interactions are almost they're very surface level yeah i'm talking with my mom and and we have this opportunity to chat via across the country but it's not like i'm sitting with her on the couch and and our that nature takes over and we're mimicking in each other to understand and have an empathy that at a face-to-face level Yeah, I mean, I move away from micro-expressions as it's not really an area that I place myself in.
28:37I look more at what we can observe and things that we can see and assess for. But virtually, what I have found is it doesn't actually affect how much you can create trust. We can create trust and cooperation exactly the same virtually. it's just people aren't used to it because our brains have not had to deal with this we are what our limbic system is still you know hundreds of thousands of years ago reacting to that kind of environment we didn't have laptops back then so it's all very new and we don't really know how to respond so we act in a really unnatural way like how we are now face on that's not natural when you usually have a conversation with someone unless it's at a restaurant typically you're more to the side it's not actually if I stood straight on with every conversation it's quite intimidating but yet we do that online and again that is picked up as a bit of a threat and we typically stay really rigid as well we don't move so much and that rigidness creates untrustworthiness we don't do the head tilt and again untrustworthy and what people tend to do online is they don't have much of their upper body showing they'll have their face really close to the camera or just kind of the camera way down looking out and we create trustworthiness and comfort through our body language through our facial expressions if you are in a really dark room or have a really bad camera or the camera is at a really weird angle I can't see your facial expressions clear enough to respond to them so it's not that we can't it's that we we don't realize how effective this skill is virtually so we do it wrong and as well we actually have more of a power virtually because we have more control yeah we don't have the lower body anymore which takes away some power however when we're interacting in person we are in this moving environment where there's so much to control for and so much to think about if we are virtual I have complete control control over this square that I'm sat in.
30:47I have control over what's behind me. I have control over what I'm wearing and how I act, how much you can see and the light, you know, how close I am to natural light, all of these things. So acting is almost easier to create trustworthiness. And one thing that I always do is I have plants behind me because when we see greenery, especially leafy plants it slows down the nervous system and creates calmness um also light colors just a nice white background where a lot of people have really bad lighting or one thing that we see a lot that is really bad for truckloadiness is the filters that people put on their cameras yeah where they have the background i was in a meeting um and someone had a lego house and everything they were saying i was trying to concentrate on what they were saying but i was just thinking you're in a lego house i can't stop looking at that area around them i kept staring at it and it takes our attention away from what they're saying and our limbic system has not evolved to deal with this kind of stimuli so it's distracting and it's confusing for our brains to have this kind of interaction with these things in the background.
32:04So we just need to be aware of the power we have virtually to create this cooperative and trustworthy atmosphere and really, you know, think about it for our meetings. Think you're the only one struggling with performance issues in the bedroom? You're not. And now there's an easier way to fix it from home. That's where RexMD comes in. It's an online telehealth service that helps men get real FDA approved medications straight to your door. Everything's done online. No doctor's office, no waiting rooms, no awkward conversations. Here's how it works. First, share your symptoms, health history, and goals through a short quiz.
32:42Then a U.S. licensed provider reviews your information and prescribes medication, if appropriate. Your treatment gets sent to you with free two-day delivery. It's that easy. And RexMD team is there for ongoing care. Just send a message. What I love about RexMD? Total discretion, private consultations, and direct-to-door delivery in discreet packaging. No pharmacy trips needed. Plus, it's care that you can trust. FDA-approved medications tailored to individual needs. Over 475 ,000 men have chosen RexMD, with over 50 million tablets prescribed and delivered. This isn't just about performance. It's about feeling secure in yourself and your relationships again.
33:22Don't put your love life on hold. Take back control of your confidence and intimacy. Get up to 95 % off treatment with Rex MD. Visit rexmd.com slash charm. That's rexmd.com slash charm. See full details and usage at rexmd.com. Prescription required. Results may vary. When it comes to what your family eats and drinks, you know your choices matter. You're the expert because you know what fits your life. And getting it right starts with good information. That's why America's beverage companies are sharing more information about our ingredients at GoodToKnowFacts.org. No spin, no judgments, just the facts straight from the experts for more than 140 beverage ingredients.
34:10Visit GoodToKnowFacts.org. Well, I know with Zoom and even in this interaction, I've shrank my own screen. many of us will get caught up in staring at ourselves and then become even more self-conscious instead of being direct with the camera, removing the view of self. Obviously, when we're interacting in person, unless there's a mirror behind the person you're interacting with, very rarely do you see yourself, think about your own body language movements and how you're communicating. But Zoom has created that feedback loop, which often robs our ability to listen actively, to convey the trustworthiness that we're after.
34:47Now, you did talk about the lower body being cut off. I'd love to talk about what are those nonverbal signals that we're sending with our lower body that do help in building trustworthiness. So a really interesting study that I've recently done is looking at the power of the lower body to create perceptions of approachability. So we talked about this orientation facing someone and orientating towards them. and we know from research that when you orientate towards someone you're perceived as more approachable you're perceived as more warm and inviting and I wanted to see if okay well what about the lower body what if my upper body is facing towards you but my lower body is facing away and what about my foot specifically because we know that the lower body has an effect because studies have shown that the feet are honest so when we're nervous the rest of the body's saying I'm fine but the foot is tapping away because we think that people can't see it so if we're trying to control for our behaviors we think about my face my hands my upper body but we don't think okay I've got to control my feet we just kind of let them do their thing which is why I was really interested to see if the feet carry any effect and what I found was that using a male and a female individually as targets so they had their upper body facing towards an observer lower body either facing towards or facing away and lower body facing towards they were perceived as approachable lower body facing away they were perceived as unapproachable statistically significant but what was interesting is the sex of the target didn't matter sex of the observer didn't matter what also didn't matter was how introverted or extroverted the observer was the only thing that mattered was the foot orientation and it just shows you know tiny behaviors moving my foot towards or away from facing you can change how approachable I'm perceived and that's incredible and I did another study recently and it actually came out with this open versus closed gestures that I've been talking about but the finding was accidental because I wanted to see people's lower bodies when they were uncomfortable so when they were in an interview and the interviewee and the interviewer was you know a bit out of order said something too personal something a bit derogatory that made the interviewee uncomfortable and what we saw was this sequence of people make themselves small with their lower body when they're uncomfortable they bring their knees together they tuck their feet below their chair but it's important the sequence that occurred so if I tuck my feet by my chair and then keep my knees out that doesn't actually indicate discomfort it's doing a number of these behaviors so bringing my knees and keeping my knees and then tucking my feet and then keeping my legs closed things like this where you see multiple closing gestures that's what indicated discomfort and interestingly behaviors that we do associate with discomfort like and we have blocking display so we kind of put our hands on top of our genitals and we feel attacked and we kind of protect ourselves and we a lot of the time we do cross our arms when we feel attacked but it isn't indicative of it and that that's a mistake but it is something that we do but it doesn't mean that when we do it that is what we feel um but we saw these blocking displays in all groups comfortable versus uncomfortable because of the context so it was the interview causing some discomfort display but the tucking of the feet and the bringing the legs together that was only to do with the interviewer making them uncomfortable so again it speaks to this importance of recognizing what displayed actually mean if we said you know anytime they show a blocking display they're uncomfortable and making them feel this way if we just went off of that and said this one behavior means this one thing we would interpret it differently.
Read the full transcript
38:53We'd interpret it wrong because we don't take the context. And it's the same virtually. Interviews create more discomfort. So we're likely to see more discomfort displayed. So does a virtual environment. If somebody is showing anxious displays regularly, despite you showing trustworthiness, doesn't necessarily mean you're making them uncomfortable. If everything else is saying, I'm comfortable, I trust you, but they are showing you know a couple of displays we see those behaviors in a virtual setting because it is unnatural we just have to take it in the bigger picture are all of their behaviors or most of their behaviors showing me discomfort or is it just one and then everything else is saying comfort because if it's just the one that's likely to be their pacifier that's likely to be the one thing that's their outlet you know I twiddle my pens sometimes or you know a lot of people touch their face or jiggle their foot.
39:47And that's their pacifier. It has nothing to do with you. It has nothing to do with what you said. It's all the other behaviors that you have to take into consideration as a whole. And I think that's why it's so important for everyone to understand that, again, putting more emphasis on the signals that we send, understanding that we actually have some power. We can get people to mirror us. We can add energy and trustworthiness to any interaction versus the opposite, just observing and looking to read people based on these snapshots and tiny signals that we read online mean, oh, this person doesn't like us or this person is untrustworthy.
40:25It just doesn't really add up effectively to reading communication. It's better to start looking at yourself and projecting outward the confidence, the trustworthiness that we need to build better relationships, to build cooperation. Now, this begs the question, can we overcome distrust? So can trust be rebuilt? If we've made a mistake, if we've showcased untrustworthiness, or maybe we had a bad day and we didn't show up the same the previous way that we had shown up in interactions, can we rebuild trust? so we can rebuild trust but it depends on what broke the trust and it depends on how you go about rebuilding it and because people just say sorry and sometimes an apology is enough but an apology has to be appropriate for the condition so if say you embarrass me in public and we're really good friends loads of trust you embarrass me in public and that trust is broken down and you want to apologise.
41:25A simple apology isn't going to be enough. It has to match what broke the trust. So you taking me into your office privately and saying I'm really, really sorry, likely isn't going to be enough. It has to match that embarrassment I felt. I have to feel like you're doing something that makes you feel vulnerable or you feel embarrassed that matches how I felt. Otherwise, that apology actually has the opposite effect. So we just have to make sure that we take into consideration what broke the trust and the way we go about getting it has to equate to at least what broke the trust because if it doesn't and it's not enough it doesn't just not work it actually has negative consequences but it brings the trust even lower down so those really quick oh I'm sorry oh I didn't mean to I'm really sorry and we just throw them out thinking thinking, oh, you know, it's better than nothing.
42:19It actually isn't better than nothing. It's a lot worse than nothing because it reduces the trust even more. So it sounds like in order to rebuild trust, we have to understand how the trust was lost. It's not something that we can flippantly rebuild and it needs to match at least the way our contrition needs to match the way the person felt in their losing trust for us. Yeah and we just need to remember sorry isn't better than nothing don't throw around those stories I won't do it again sorry because that can reduce the overall trust and it can reduce your perceived trustworthiness in general too so we have to make sure that you know that saying don't tell me you're sorry show me you're sorry that it really is important that your behaviors say truly I am sorry and I'm going out of my way to do something that is negative for me to show you how sorry I am there has to be some kind of cost yourself so that that's what an apology has really been designed to do to say this is negative for me this is something that I don't want to do I'm having a negative consequence for doing this So I'm doing it to show you how willing I am to gain your trust back.
43:39So if that story doesn't cost you anything, then it isn't actually showing that you really want to rebuild that trust. Right. So it doesn't value the relationship in a way that would rebuild the trust. Now, what strikes me from all of this is the consistency that we need in our nonverbal communication. and what we've found with a lot of our clients is nonverbal communication is not something that many people even think about or are conscious of. So we use video work in our classroom to really showcase and highlight some signals so they can start to clue themselves in and be a bit more conscious.
44:17So in listening to this, we heard a lot of nonverbal signals that are important for trustworthiness. Where do you think our audience should start if they want to start bringing these non-verbals into their communication in a more consistent manner? So I think it all starts with education. Because like you said, you know, there's so much to learn that when we're focusing on ourselves and focusing on them, trying to decode them and display, it's too much that it becomes uncomfortable. We do eventually have to realize that it is a system, that we observe others and assess theirs and respond correctly and then show us.
44:52So it is this cycle we have to understand it but unless we start by first okay understanding what do signals mean learn what signals show trustworthiness and really go into the science read the literature read the research and start you know figuring out how to improve yours start implementing it start seeing a change and then start trying to assess for others but it starts with education and it is a difficult process because learning anything is uncomfortable and we think oh body language easy but it is like learning a whole new language we have to figure out what things mean and it's complicated because different cultures have different things that mean different things so depending on you know what gender what culture what context and environment interacting with people is going to change how our non-verbals are interpreted.
45:46So we have to just start somewhere, start with the basics, start reading, start getting educated on the display, and then start implementing them. Next up is a little song from CarMax about selling a car your way. You want to sell those wheels, you want to get a CarMax instant offer. So fast. Or like a month?
46:12With OfferWatch.
46:21So, want to drive? CarMax. Pickup not available everywhere. Restrictions and fee may apply. Mutine. Adjective. Used to describe an individual whose spirit is unyielding. Unconstrained. One who navigates life on their own terms, effortlessly. They do not always show up on time, but when they arrive, you notice an individual confident in their contradictions. They know the rules, but behave as if they do not exist. Muteen, the new fragrance by Miu Miu, defined by you. Well, I love that linking it to verbal language because you don't get fluent just from reading a couple books and doing a couple workbooks.
47:05You get fluent from actually implementing and practicing the language, the tenses, etc. Same thing with nonverbal communication. You get fluent by bringing it into every interaction you're having, not just picking and choosing on the job interview or the first date or when you're in the elevator and you're pitching someone. But instead, look at it as something that you can practice and hone in every interaction that you have. And what I love about it is you do get that back because of the power of mirroring. When you're adding these new nonverbal trustworthy signals, people start reacting to you differently.
47:39And it energizes you and it adds to the communication versus what many of us who aren't conscious of our nonverbal communication. we're getting into boring small talk situations. We're taking energy from the interaction and people aren't responding in kind. And of course it feels like a lot more work than really just adding that smile. Now, there is another piece to this that we hear a lot of misconceptions around and that's eye contact. And I think many people start much like you around, okay, lie detection. Now I get all into eye contact. Am I making enough? What's too much? Oh, I heard if I look away, That means I'm not trustworthy, so I have to maintain eye contact.
48:20So what are the right balances with eye contact and how can we use it to our advantage when it comes to trustworthiness? And maybe what are those myths that we can dispel for our audience around eye contact? So in terms of the myth, we think that people that look away are lying or people that look away are hiding something. And that just isn't true. People look away all the time. They might be uncomfortable. comfortable they might be very comfortable but they just don't give much eye contact um in terms of how to give good eye contact we have this um sort of optimum square and it's from the nose to the eyes square triangle sorry from the eyes to the nose and it's this this is the business gaze the eyes to the nose and that's where we look and then we kind of have a more social gaze which is from the eyes to the mouth and then that's where we look sort of in a social setting and then we have the intimate gaze which is the eye down to the chest so you wouldn't look from the eyes to the chest in a business setting but you should also avoid in a business setting looking from the eyes to the mouth you stay within that business gaze so that's kind of a good paradigm of where to look in different settings in terms of how much to look I don't think there is you know a perfect amount of eye contact to give also because people differ in how much eye contact they like to receive so give good eye contact you know regular eye contact but don't stare at somebody because that makes them uncomfortable and just recognize you know do they look like i'm making them uncomfortable by looking at them too much and if they they start to look a bit nervous don't just move your gaze away you don't have to completely turn and ignore them but just you know flip to other things and show them you're listening and then kind of look to other things and show them you're listening again so just you have to figure out how they're comfortable and how you're comfortable as well because if you're thinking okay eye contact eye contact eye contact you're probably going to miss the fact that they're like why are they giving me so much eye contact it's uncomfortable so don't think too much about it I would just stay within the correct gaze frame and then go with what feels comfortable and that is as much attention really that I give to eye contact because I think it really is again just that simple that we look for this perfect amount or perfect equation for things and we overcomplicate it and then struggle to do it perfectly and we've heard in the past that the direction that you're looking when you're breaking eye contact is accessing different brain cues is there any science around the direction that you're actually looking when you break eye contact no no So, I mean, we do look in different directions when we access different parts of our brain.
51:08But, I mean, we use 100 % of our brain, you know, most of the time. There isn't a part of our brain that isn't active at some point. So I think that sits within that myth of, you know, we use 10 % of our brain. That's saying, you know, if we're creative, we only use the right side or the left side. All of these things, same with, you know, we look in a certain direction when we're lying. They all fit within that paradigm of just myth that, you know, again, don't think too much into them because there really isn't any science backing them. Now, with all of this research that you've done on nonverbal communication, how have you brought it into your life?
51:47Is there anything that you've changed or now utilized from the research you've done in your nonverbal communication? Yes. So I am not a touchy-feely person at all. touching has always made me very uncomfortable but touching is something we have evolved to do it makes people feel very safe so because I know that that is something that makes people feel safe same with you know open gestures I was always a very nervous person very very closed off I didn't really like being you know touched at all I did not like touching other people but I learned how powerful these are so I learned to get comfortable with them and it took me time because like we said it's not a toolkit you have to actually get comfortable so I implemented what I know that that makes other people more comfortable because you know isn't that what we want when we interact with people we want to make them feel comfortable we want to make them feel good we want to make them leave the conversation thinking so nice to talk to that person I felt really good I felt safe so if you know that you do behaviors that aren't perceived well but they're comfortable to you try and learn to do the other behaviors learn to get comfortable with this stuff that make other people feel safe and you know anything it's practice and it will become a habit eventually and now I'm a lot more touchy-feely I'm very open I have my hands out a lot and I'm always kind of so armed out and things like that.
53:18And you just, you know, eventually one day you think, oh, I don't even think about it anymore. That's the best feeling in the world when it becomes who you are and how you act normally without having to be so conscious about it. But it does take some conscious effort to get there. And we all have these. I mean, that's the beauty of nonverbal communication is we have conditioned ourselves to self-soothe. Maybe it's looking at your phone. Maybe it's putting a drink in front of your chest. Maybe it's rubbing your stomach or grabbing your neck. and yeah you may have to break a few bad habits but this is something that you can practice with everyone every interaction is an opportunity for you to practice your non-verbal communication and now with the power of zoom we can do it in a more controlled environment like our home our office etc yeah and we can record ourselves and it's very uncomfortable i find uncomfortable seeing myself do anything if you watch a video or a talk of yourself it just it makes you cringe but you have to learn to kind of get comfortable with that do a talk and record yourself doing it or have an interaction with someone record it and then assess your behavior after and look at what did you do and how were they reacting to it or what did you do wrong what did you do well and learn to get comfortable with your own behaviors and um assessing yourself well that's the best part about it because the cringe actually means it's impactful so we just had a group of military special operators through the program.
54:45And they have great body language. They've obviously taken great care of themselves to be in great shape. But even watching themselves on video, they were cringing. They couldn't believe that they looked and appeared that way. And the second round of video work, instant change, because they consciously seeing yourself feeling that cringe, you want to make the change versus me saying, hey, you're not smiling enough, Abby. Internally, you're like, AJ, I'm definitely smiling. But when you see yourself on video, that you're not smiling it just carries much more weight with your subconscious mind to make that change yeah because you think when you see yourself you can put yourself in that other person's perspective and say you know i feel this way seeing myself my god that is how they must feel interacting with me and that's not how i want another person to feel i want them to feel good and comfortable and not cringe so i think when we watch it in cringe we just have to think okay do I want someone else to feel that way and what can I change so that they don't exactly such a valuable lesson well we love asking every guest what their x factor is what personality trait skill set makes you so unique Abby I think my ability just to keep going no matter how many times I fail at things I would just keep going the amount of failed studies before I got my PhD I had loads of rejections.
56:11You just keep going. Failure really just means, you know, one less failure to go until I get where I want to be. I love that. Where can our audience find more about the work that you've done, the research that you have? So you can find my profile on my website, which is abbymorono.com. You can find me on Twitter, which is abbyjmorono, or on LinkedIn, which is abbymorono. Thank you so much for stopping by. We really appreciate all these great insights on nonverbal communication. Thank you so much for having me. It's been a pleasure.
56:53I hope you enjoyed that episode. And now comes the part of the show where we showcase one of our X Factor Accelerator members. Take it away, David. It was like the start of self-improvement journey, you know, and a lot of the concepts with so much. I remember Johnny even said, like, this is going to take months to years to kick in to really get this shit. And he was fucking right. Then you start like reading more and you start seeing things more. You start like testing the waters with little ideas. For me, I lacked the confidence. And I thought that like I was a shitty engineer that I could never get a job at like a fang company or like a unicorn startup where I'm at now.
57:29and like i was sort of like oh well i'll stay in my even when i moved from pnc uh this was after aoc i still still stood in my little comfort zone but like i moved to like another bank sure i was making like 20 grand more but it was still peanuts compared to what i'm making now right once i jumped ship and realized oh it's kind of just the same everywhere just a little bit different processes and slightly different code base and slightly different architecture then i'm like okay i'll move again and then that job really sucked and i was only there for five months and like now i'm where i'm at and it's like well shit maybe i should move again really it was honestly for me the biggest difference was the lack of confidence in myself to know that i can make it elsewhere i felt like no one else would ever want to hire me because i'm i'm just this like low value person like why would anyone want to hire me i'm lucky to have this position and then versus the mindset after it's like no bitch they're lucky to have me and like it sounds easy that's a really tough switch of the mind it it takes a lot of time to do that it takes like being too cocky or being too like i fucking go and it's like whoa dude like slow down a little bit like you have someone check you it's like okay i need to go back a little bit right so yeah thank you david and it was a pleasure working with you too and good luck to all your future endeavors.
58:51If you've gotten value out of this or any of our podcasts, head on over to your favorite podcast player and rate and review the show. It means the world to us and it helps others find the show. Before we head out, a huge thank you to our producers, Michael Harold and Eric Montgomery. Until next week, go out and make this one an epic week.
59:21You're a boy, you threw your love away, like it was just a toy, and you sold the world. You sold the tragedy, cause you had your taste of black only yesterday. Yeah, but I remember you.
59:51Thank you.
From the publisher
In today’s episode, we discuss the science of nonverbal communication and trust with Dr. Abbie Maroño, a leading expert in social influence, trust-building, and body language analysis. As a PhD researcher and international consultant, Abbie specializes in uncovering the hidden cues that shape human interaction, from boardrooms to high-stakes negotiations.
Join us as we explore the science of trust and influence with Dr. Abbie Maroño as she reveals the nonverbal signals that shape first impressions and long-term relationships. How does your body language impact your credibility before you even speak? Why do we judge trustworthiness in just 33 milliseconds? And what are the hidden mistakes that sabotage cooperation and leadership?
What to Listen For
Introduction – 00:00:00
Why do we misunderstand trust, and what’s the key to building it effortlessly?
What subconscious cues determine whether someone perceives us as safe or threatening?
How can a single inconsistent action undo months of trust-building?
Why Trust Is More Powerful Than Competition – 00:10:38
Why is the “dog-eat-dog” mentality a myth, and how does trust actually lead to greater success?
Why do leaders who prioritize cooperation outperform those who rely on control and manipulation?
Body Language Secrets for Influence – 00:17:49
What hidden lower-body cues reveal your true emotions—and why do they matter more than facial expressions?
Why do open postures and head tilts make you instantly more likable and approachable?
How can you use small, subconscious movements to project confidence in high-stakes situations?
Nonverbal Communication in the Digital Age – 00:26:47
Why does Zoom and video conferencing disrupt our natural communication instincts?
How can lighting, posture, and framing drastically improve your virtual presence?
What common virtual meeting mistakes make people appear less trustworthy and more rigid?
The #1 Mistake That Destroys Trust – 00:38:49
Why saying “I’m sorry” incorrectly actually damages relationships further.
What’s the right way to use eye contact to establish authority without making people uncomfortable?
A Word From Our Sponsors
Tired of awkward handshakes and collecting business cards without building real connections? Dive into our Free Social Capital Networking Masterclass. Learn practical strategies to make your interactions meaningful and boost your confidence in any social situation. Sign up for free at theartofcharm.com/sc and elevate your networking from awkward to awesome. Don’t miss out on a network of opportunities!
Unleash the power of covert networking to infiltrate high-value circles and build a 7-figure network in just 90 days. Ready to start? Check out our CIA-proven guide to networking like a spy!
Indulge in affordable luxury with Quince—where high-end essentials meet unbeatable prices. Upgrade your wardrobe today at quince.com/charm for free shipping and hassle-free returns.
Ready to turn your business idea into reality? Shopify makes it easy to start, scale, and succeed—whether you're launching a side hustle or building the next big brand. Sign up for your $1/month trial at shopify.com/charm.
Need to hire top talent—fast? Skip the waiting game and get more qualified applicants with Indeed. Claim your $75 Sponsored Job Credit now at Indeed.com/charm.
Upgrade your space with Thuma—where modern design meets craftsmanship and functionality. Get $100 off your first bed purchase at thuma.co/charm.
Curious about your influence level?
Get your Influence Index Score today!
Take this 60-second quiz to find out how your influence stacks up against top performers at theartofcharm.com/influence.
Resources from this Episode
Abbie Maroño’s website
Check in with AJ and Johnny!
AJ on LinkedIn
Johnny on LinkedIn
AJ on Instagram
Johnny on Instagram
The Art of Charm on Instagram
The Art of Charm on YouTube
The Art of Charm on TikTok
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
