Why Skeptics Don't Care How Right You Are | Social Intelligence Briefing

0:00Bruce Poon Tip:Johnny, real talk. Upwork is the reason we've been able to grow the way we have. 100 % website, SEO, marketing consulting. We found specialists for all of it. And the results blew us away. Here's the thing nobody tells you. The fastest growing businesses aren't doing more. They're delegating smarter. You don't have to hire full time to get world class help. Upwork lets you find, hire and pay expert freelancers across 125 categories. Web development, data, marketing, business ops. It's all there. You browse profiles, see their past work, and get matched fast. Business Plus gets you the top 1 % of talent, and AI-powered shortlisting finds your person in under six hours.

0:46Contracts, payments, handled in one place. You stay focused on the business.

0:51Bruce Poon Tip:We've used it for over a decade to ship fast and keep our company growing. It just works. Go to Upwork.com and post your job for free. That's U-P-W-O-R-K dot com. Do it now. I got to say, starting this podcast was terrifying. So much work going into something we weren't entirely sure would work out. What if no one listens? What if we make fools of ourselves? Now we know we were right to believe in ourselves and make that leap. And it helps when you have a partner like Shopify on your side. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10 % of all e-commerce in the U.S.

1:29Bruce Poon Tip:From household names to brands just getting started. Hundreds of ready-to-use templates help you build an online store that matches your brand style. AI tools write product descriptions and enhance your product photography. Get the word out like you have a marketing team behind you. Easily create email and social media campaigns wherever your customers are scrolling. Shopify handles inventory, international shipping, returns, and beyond. Award-winning 24-7 customer support whenever you get stuck. everything in one place. It's time to turn those what ifs into with Shopify today. Sign up for your $1 per month trial at shopify.com slash charm.

2:08Bruce Poon Tip:Go to shopify.com slash charm. That's shopify.com slash charm. You bring the stronger case, more data, a tighter argument, the one slide that finally closes the gap. You walk into that meeting sure that this is the one that lands. and somehow you walk out having lost ground you didn't even have when you started. That one's things different too. You didn't bring a weak case. You brought your best case and a guy across the table just folded his arms a little tighter. And notice what you did going in. You actually did the responsible thing. You didn't wing it. You went and you got proof because everything you've ever been taught says that's how arguments are won.

2:49And the better your homework got, the harder he shook his head. Nobody warned you about that one.

2:56Bruce Poon Tip:And here's the part that should really bother you. What just happened in that room has almost nothing to do with how good your evidence was. Today, we're sharing with you why more proof can actually lose you the argument and the one move that actually flips it. This is for anyone who's walked out of a meeting thinking, I had the numbers. I had all the numbers and I still lost.

3:26Bruce Poon Tip:Now, here's the mistake almost every sharp analytical person makes with a skeptic. Somebody pushes back. So you go get more evidence, a better chart, a stronger comparison, a case study that actually proves you're right. You bring it back in and it doesn't just fail to move them. Sometimes it makes them dig in even harder. Because they weren't grading your evidence yet. They were still deciding something else. Do you get what they're actually worried about? That's exactly it. A skeptic isn't sitting there weighing your data. There's a completely different test running in the background. And it's this.

4:07Bruce Poon Tip:Does that person understand what I'm actually worried about? Or are they just here to win? You can stack more proof on somebody who hasn't answered that question yet. And it doesn't read as more persuasive. It reads as somebody who talks before they actually listen. And here's the trap. From your side of the table, more evidence. It feels like respect. You're doing the work. You've been thorough. You're taking them seriously. But from their side, it feels like the opposite. It feels like you've already decided. And now you're just piling on proof so that they have to agree with you. Now, a few weeks back, we told you when you're leading a room, say the conclusion first.

4:52Bruce Poon Tip:Own it. Don't bury the lead in 12 slides of setup. Now that's still true, but a skeptic isn't a room you're leading. A skeptic is one person who hasn't decided to trust you yet. With a room, you lead with your conclusion. With a skeptic, you lead with a question. Knowing which situation you're actually in, well, that's half the actual skill. That's the whole trick, right? Same toolbox, different tool. you grab the wrong one and you look pushy. So why does more evidence backfire like this? There's real research on it, and it's not what most people expect. A.L. Steffel and Epley, 2018 Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.

5:34Bruce Poon Tip:They ran something like two dozen separate experiments on what's called perspective taking. That's when you sit there and imagine your way into someone else's head, guessing what they must be thinking or worried about so you can build your pitch around it. It sounds smart, right? Get in their head before you talk. You'd think so. But across those experiments, imagining your way into their head did not make people more accurate about what the other person actually thought, felt or wanted. Sometimes it even made them slightly worse. And here's the part that trips everyone up. It made them more confident they were right without making them any more accurate.

6:17So guessing what somebody's thinking doesn't just fail to help you. It tricks you into feeling more sure about the story you made up in your head.

6:28Bruce Poon Tip:That's the whole finding. What actually increased accuracy in their research wasn't imagining. It was asking. The researchers call it perspective getting. You ask the person directly what they think and you listen to their answer. That's the entire fix. And it's the opposite of what most analytical people do under pressure. Here's the plain version. The version of the skeptic that you built in your head, the one that you've been arguing with in the shower for two days, that guy is fake. You made him up. Rehearsing against them just makes you look more sure of yourself, but not more right. And there's a second piece that matters just as much.

7:11Bruce Poon Tip:Hwang Yeomans, Brooks, Minson, and Gino in 2017, also Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, they looked at live conversations, including a speed dating study out in the field. The finding was simple. People who asked more questions, especially follow-up questions, were liked more by the person across from them. Follow-up questions, not just any question. Right, because if follow-up questions prove you actually process what they said. Anybody can ask questions off script. A follow-up question means you are listening closely enough to notice something worth asking about next. Asking a good question isn't you stalling.

7:51It isn't you being soft. It's literally how people decide you're somebody worth trusting.

7:58Bruce Poon Tip:Now, one more if you want it. Gordon and Chen in 2016, exact same journal, they studied couples and they found that feeling understood by your partner protected their relationship when conflict happened. Disagreements did far less damage to how satisfied people felt when each side felt the other one actually understood their position. Right. So it's not about winning the fight. Feeling understood is what keeps the thing from breaking, even when you still disagree at the end of it. Now let's put all three together and you get one clear picture. Guessing what the skeptic thinks makes you more confident, but no more correct.

8:37Bruce Poon Tip:Asking questions, especially follow-ups, is what actually builds trust in the moment. And feeling understood is what survives the disagreement, whether or not you ever fully agree. None of that happens by bringing another slide, which means some of the time you spend tightening your deck actually belongs somewhere else. It belongs to writing down the three questions you're going to ask before you show anybody anything. You can't out-research your way into somebody's head. You just got to ask. I like keeping my money where I can see it. Unfortunately, traditional big wireless carriers also like keeping my money.

9:17Bruce Poon Tip:Crazy high bills, bogus fees, free perks that cost more in the long run. Stop overpaying for wireless just because that's how it's always been. Mint Mobile exists to fix that. Premium wireless plans starting at just$15 a month. All plans come with high-speed data and unlimited talk and text delivered on the nation's largest 5G network. Bring your own phone and number. Activate the eSIM in minutes. Start saving immediately. No long-term contracts. No hassle. If I needed to switch carriers, Mint Mobile is exactly what I'd use. The math just works. You're getting the same network quality and keeping a lot more of your money.

9:54If you like your money, Mint Mobile is for you.

9:57Bruce Poon Tip:Shop plans at mintmobile.com slash charm. That's mintmobile.com slash charm. Upfront payment of$45 for three month, five gigabyte plan required, equivalent to$15 per month. New customer offer for first three months only, then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See Mint Mobile for details. All right, now walk me through this happening to somebody because I think people need to watch it before they can do it. Give me the scenario, Johnny. All right, let's do it. So picture Priya. She runs operations for a midsize company and she's been building a case for three months to automate her invoicing.

10:36It's slow, it's manual. People make mistakes on it every week. So she's got the whole thing mapped out.

10:44Bruce Poon Tip:Got it. So she walks in prepared, loaded. She's got a cost model, an error rate comparison, in benchmark numbers for two other companies that made the same switch 30 pages easy she sits down across from roy the director who has to sign off and she starts laying it all out ah roy is the skeptic in this story well roy's been burned before different system different year and it broke bad enough that landed on him he doesn't say that part out loud he just starts looking for the holes What about the transition month? What if the vendor changes their pricing? What about two accounts that don't fit the standard format?

11:27So what does Priya do? Well, she answers every single one. Good answers too. And she's got a slide for it. But watch what happens. The more holes she patches, the more holes Roy finds. And it's not that her answers are bad. It's that Roy's not actually listening to her plan anymore.

11:47Bruce Poon Tip:he's testing something else he's testing whether she gets what he's actually scared of and she never asks she just keeps handing him more proof and by the end of the meeting he says well let's revisit this next quarter which we all know yeah we all know that means no so she walks out with a better deck and a worse outcome than she walked in with Okay, now run it again. Same Priya, same Roy, same exact meaning. But this time, she knows the move. Walk me through it. This time, she stops after her opening and she asks him one question instead of handing him a slide four. She says, before I go any further, which part of this, she says, before I go any further, which part of this is the part that actually keeps you up at night?

12:39Bruce Poon Tip:That is step one. Ask about their constraint, not your pitch, not what not what do you think of my plan? What actually worries you? Right. And Roy doesn't expect it. He kind of stumbles into it. He says something like, well, I guess I'm worried about the transitional period. But, you know, if something breaks during the switch, I don't know. And that's not the real answer yet. That's actually step two. Reflect it back to Roy in your own words better than he just said it. So Priya says back to him, it's not really the transitional period. It's that if this breaks, your name is on it. And watch what that does.

13:23Bruce Poon Tip:She just said his fear out loud more clearly than he had actually said it himself. And Roy pauses. And then he says, well, yeah, kind of. Kind of doesn't count. That's the part people miss. Yeah, doesn't count either. Sure doesn't count. You keep refining it until you hear one specific word. Exactly. And that's the word you're listening for. So not yet. Not sure. Exactly. Because exactly means something very specific just happened. It means you said their own position back to them more clearly than they've ever managed to say it themselves. That's the tell. When you hear it, something in the room changes.

14:11It's a complete shift. They stop bracing against you. And that's the whole thing up until exactly they're playing defense. The second they hear their own worries said back to them cleanly, they're not defending anymore. They're just listening.

14:28Bruce Poon Tip:So Priya keeps going. She says, so it's less about whether the system works and more about whether you're the one holding the bag if it doesn't. Roy says it exactly. Only now does her evidence get a fair hearing. Not before, now. Yeah, let's take this outside the office for a second because this isn't just a work move. I've actually done this one myself badly until I learned better. My father-in-law needed a second opinion before a doctor's appointment. I hit him with articles. I hit him with every reason I could think of. every single time he just got more locked in to not going to the doctor because I was stacking evidence on somebody who hadn't decided I understood him yet.

15:10Bruce Poon Tip:So I stopped and asked instead. I said, what's the part of this that worries you the most? And he didn't say it was what I thought it was at all. He said he was scared of being laid up for months on end when he's supposed to be helping with our new granddaughter. And it's not a medical objection. That's a completely different fear wearing a medical costume. So I said it back to him. It's not really about this being risky. It's about missing the time with your granddaughter if you're down for the count. He said exactly. And that's the first time he actually let me talk about a second opinion at all.

15:47Bruce Poon Tip:So now you get it exactly. So what do we do with this? Because knowing you've been heard and knowing what to do are actually two different skills. Right. You don't go back to your case. Not yet. You land one sentence, small and specific, and it starts inside their worry, not inside your pitch. So for Priya, once Roy says exactly about it being his name on the line, if the transition breaks, she doesn't launch back into her 30 page deck just yet. She says something like, so if we can make sure your name never touches a failed rollback, here's the version of this I'd actually run. isn't that brilliant?

16:30You see what she did there? She didn't pitch the automation. She pitched the thing he's scared of. And for your father-in-law?

16:41Bruce Poon Tip:Well, I said, so what if the doctor said, you can actually get back on your feet to help us? Would you hear a second opinion then? And he said, yes, of course. And that was the first time I'd heard that in a few months. Now that's the whole payoff move. One sentence. It starts with their constraint, not your case. And it offers to protect the exact thing they just told you they're afraid of losing. And notice the order of everything we just walked through. The pitch actually came last. It came after the question, after the reflection, after the exactly. That order is the entire skill. Right. You're not selling them on being right anymore.

17:20You're selling them on not getting burned.

17:23Bruce Poon Tip:And now ask, reflect, land. That's the move. And it works on its own. But inside Theos, it becomes a full protocol built on a principle we call calibrate. Don't control. Right. It's the DAO, not a switch. You're adjusting the room and the frame around you. You are never trying to control what's going on inside somebody's head. That's the difference between manipulation and skill. and it's built on everything we teach. Once you have calibrate down, don't control as a principle instead of just one trick. You actually stop needing a new script for every skeptic you meet. You're just running the same dial differently depending on who they are.

18:07Bruce Poon Tip:There's a version of you for this boss who won't budge, for the client who's gone quiet, the room that made up his mind before you ever walked in. And we don't have time to walk you through the full protocol today, but that's exactly what we go deep inside of Theos. Now here's your homework. Pick one skeptic in your life this week, a boss, a client, maybe an in-law like me, whoever it is who keeps saying no to something you're sure is right. And before you pitch them anything, ask one constraint question. What's the part of this that keeps you up at night? Then reflect it back and keep refining it until you hear the word exactly.

18:48Exactly. Not yet. Not sure. Exactly. And if you don't get there on the first try, that's okay. Ask again. That's the asking, right? The asking is the move.

19:01Bruce Poon Tip:A bonus round. And this one's a little uncomfortable. Count how many follow-up questions you ask in your very next disagreement with someone. And if the answer is zero, that's not a small thing. That's the whole diagnosis right there. Now, a few episodes back, we showed you the 90-second scan for reading a room. This is the one-on-one version of that same discipline. Watch first, talk second. And this is exactly why Johnny and I built Theos, the elite operator system. It's the same training we've taught elite military and special operators over the last 12 years. It just launched first time ever we're actually opening it to civilians.

19:37Eight weeks, 18 meta skills total, ask, reflect, land is one small piece to all of it. Theos teaches you the whole system. Calibrate, don't control, and everything underneath it. Not stuff you nod along to, stuff you actually use the next time someone crosses their arms at you. The promise is control.

19:58Bruce Poon Tip:You read the room or the person in 90 seconds and you decide how you want to play it instead of them deciding for you. First cohort is 15 civilians, just 15. And we're running it ourselves, same as we ran it for the operators. It's application-based, so that means we picked the 15. If you've got a skeptic in your life right now, the boss, client, the in-law, the one you keep losing ground with no matter how much proof you bring, that's exactly the sign we're looking for. Apply now. The link is in the show notes. Go find your exactly this week and we'll teach you the rest.

20:46Thank you.