Manhunt Underway For Charlie Kirk Shooter

11 Sep 2025 · 42 min · 15 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

MSNBC coverage of the manhunt for the shooter who killed conservative activist Charlie Kirk at a political event in Utah; later discussion of political rhetoric around violence and a separate segment on newly released Jeffrey Epstein emails.

Guest backgrounds

Jim Cavanaugh (former longtime ATF agent); Bobby Chacon (former FBI special agent); Steve Dettelbach (former ATF director under President Biden); Jason Leopold (Bloomberg reporter who obtained Epstein emails).

Key claims

The FBI released two public images of a college-age suspect; reward up to $100,000; authorities believe the shooter fired from a university roof, jumped off, then fled into nearby neighborhoods. Officials recovered a .30-06 bolt-action rifle and are analyzing it for fingerprints/DNA and ballistics; investigators also collected footwear impressions and palm/forearm imprints. Guests argue the evidence chain (projectile, cartridges, DNA) is central and that leadership must coordinate messaging without tipping off the fugitive. Dettelbach says the suspect will be caught and highlights joint operations, ballistic tracing, and intelligence-building.

Notable examples

timeline (arrival ~11:52 a.m., shot ~12:10 p.m.); suspect described as wearing all black (helmet, mask, tactical vest possible); FBI warning not to use AI to enhance released photos. Epstein segment: Bloomberg reports 18,000 Yahoo emails, including discussions involving Ghislaine Maxwell and plea negotiations.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Overview of the Shooting Incident

0:00 to 0:24

Details surrounding the shooting of Charlie Kirk and the ongoing investigation.

“Lattice is the first comprehensive HR platform where people and AI succeed together.”

Overview of the Shooting Incident

1:01 to 2:24

Details surrounding the shooting of Charlie Kirk and the ongoing investigation.

“I'm Ari Melber, and tonight we're following the manhunt that continues for the shooter that killed conservative leader Charlie Kirk at that event in Utah yesterday.”

Insights from Law Enforcement

2:24 to 4:25

Discussion on the law enforcement response and investigative leads.

“There's also now the dispatch audio, which reveals what it sounded like that very moment the authorities first thought they had a description of this suspect.”

Expert Analysis on Evidence

4:25 to 7:59

Experts analyze the significance of the recovered weapon and other evidence.

“someone who ascended in his 20s to being on a level of knowing, really spending time with, through his forums and events and through his podcast, all the senior people in the Trump administration.”

Reflections on Crime Scene Dynamics

7:59 to 14:00

Discussion on the chaotic nature of the crime scene and public reactions.

“I want to bring in Jim Cavanaugh, former longtime ATF agent, and Bobby Chacon, former FBI special agent.”

FBI Warnings and Press Conference Delays

14:00 to 18:56

Learn about the FBI's approach to public communication during ongoing investigations.

“The FBI is warning people, do not do that.”

FBI Warnings and Press Conference Delays

19:33 to 20:08

Learn about the FBI's approach to public communication during ongoing investigations.

“If you found out we weren't alone, if someone showed you, proved it to you, would that frighten you?”

The Ongoing Manhunt and Law Enforcement Strategies

20:08 to 27:52

Understand the strategies law enforcement uses in a manhunt and the complexities involved.

“What do you see as important in the manhunt, the photos out, the incredible interest and national security imperative of finding this individual?”

Introduction to Epstein Story Break

28:00 to 28:36

Learn about a major break in the Jeffrey Epstein story as new emails emerge.

“And while we have stayed on this story quite continuously, we will turn to a major break scoop in the Jeffrey Epstein story.”

Discussion on Political Violence

29:50 to 32:58

An analysis of the climate of political violence in America following the shooting incident.

“So many have understandably looked at this as possibly or likely an act of political violence.”
Show all 15 chapters

New Revelations on Epstein's Emails

32:58 to 36:29

An exploration of new emails from Jeffrey Epstein that offer insights into his operations.

“and when we come back, we do turn to other stories, a huge breakthrough.”

Interview with Jason Leopold

36:29 to 42:04

An interview with Bloomberg's Jason Leopold about the significance of the newly uncovered emails.

“We know the names Many of us were abused by them We are tired However We are not going away We will not stop or give up.”

Exploring the Manipulative Behavior in Emails

42:04 to 44:31

Discussion on the findings from emails related to a manipulative figure and their implications.

“No, as our reporting shows in this story, you know, he was berating and manipulating, calculating, emotionally abusing the women who had worked, you know, with him.”

Manhunt for Charlie Kirk's Shooter

44:31 to 45:11

Details on the ongoing investigation into the shooting incident involving Charlie Kirk.

“We're following the investigation to the person who shot and killed Charlie Kirk yesterday.”

Manhunt for Charlie Kirk's Shooter

45:42 to 47:07

Details on the ongoing investigation into the shooting incident involving Charlie Kirk.

“if you get a lump or swelling in your neck.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Lattice is the first comprehensive HR platform where people and AI succeed together. It helps every employee grow faster, every manager lead more effectively, and every company unlock their people's full potential. Stop settling for HR tools that hold your company back. Build a future where technology doesn't replace people, but actually elevates them. No regrets. Ready to see the power of people plus AI? Visit Lattice.com slash no regrets. That's L-A-T-T-I-C-E dot com slash no regrets.

0:56digital platforms now with no subscription required, also in theaters. I'm Ari Melber, and tonight we're following the manhunt that continues for the shooter that killed conservative leader Charlie Kirk at that event in Utah yesterday. Officials have indicated there are multiple leads. The FBI has now released images of who they view as a suspect. You see him here. This is an individual that, of course, people are looking for in Utah and any nearby area, the reward up to$100 ,000 simply for information. Investigators did see on the roof of the university building this morning. They're seen there out in Utah as they work to track movements and any other information they can gather.

1:41Officials say that after firing that deadly shot, which killed Kirk, the shooter jumped off this roof, they believe, and then fled amid the chaos into surrounding neighborhoods. We do have good video footage of this individual. We are not going to release that at this time. We are working through some technologies and some ways to identify this individual. The suspect blended in well with a college institution. We're not releasing many details right now, and we will soon. But right now we're not. But that individual appears to be of college age. authorities there just speaking about what they learned and when we might see more of the actual underlying video.

2:24There's also now the dispatch audio, which reveals what it sounded like that very moment the authorities first thought they had a description of this suspect. It's going to be wearing all black, black long gun, black tactical helmet, a black mask, possibly wearing a tactical vest and jeans. This was an event where many people were coming to experience a public presentation about political issues on a campus. So many people had video going for their own live video, which is how some of this first came out on different social media platforms. Other people were taking videos. Kirk himself had shared videos moments before the event began.

3:09And so those videos in today's world also provide clues which law enforcement may use. There's video from before the shooting that also appears to indicate that someone dressed in all black was perhaps, or dark material, best you can make it from this view, was laying or crouching there on that roof. That's according to video posted to X. Another witness posted a video of chaos right after the shooting, and it does appear to show what could be a person on that roof all the way there. You see them there in the pause. They were seen to be moving across that roof. Authorities also indicating a weapon recovered at the scene.

3:48It's a high-powered bolt-action rifle. That rifle was recovered in a wooded area where the shooter had fled. The FBI laboratory will be analyzing this weapon. Investigators have also collected footwear impression, a palm print, and forearm imprints for analysis. Mr. Kirk was a prominent figure. He was, as we showed last night, someone who had been anointed to speak at the RNC, who was probably, no exaggeration, the most prominent young Republican figure in the MAGA era. someone who ascended in his 20s to being on a level of knowing, really spending time with, through his forums and events and through his podcast, all the senior people in the Trump administration.

4:36And so there is a personal aspect to this, while also the people in their actual duties are going to continue to do law enforcement and executive leadership. So FBI Director Patel, who posted some misinformation or information that was soon less than accurate yesterday, is heading to Utah and his role as FBI director, Vice President J.D. Vance, who knew and campaigned with Kirk at one point, will be meeting with family and friends, which is fitting. They all know each other years back. We're told the casket will then be flown on Air Force Two to Phoenix. We have our experts standing by while we begin first on the ground in Orem, Utah.

5:12MSNBC's Steve Patterson reporting there. Steve, what can you tell us? Ari, the latest we have in this investigation came in about 20, 30 minutes ago. It's a press release from the Utah Department of Public Safety, essentially with the headline that you've already mentioned. There are multiple leads. There is not a suspect in custody. This comes in the context of a news conference that was delayed multiple times throughout the day and then finally delayed indefinitely with the guys that there were rapid developments in this case. Those developments, obviously syncing up with the fact that the FBI director was also landing on the ground as well.

5:50But this really is the only information that we've gotten since an update that came at about nine o 'clock this morning. So still so much to learn. What came in this press release was sort of detailing a lot of the information that we had known already. Obviously, the photos that are now out to the public, obviously more about the search itself. The FBI offering that hundred thousand dollar reward seems to indicate that they are still maybe possibly in the initial phases of this investigation, that they really required the public's help, any photos, any video to help track down the suspected person, that those images did come from a campus security camera.

6:27That's new information that was obviously taken during the events or right after the events, the horrific events that took place at about noon yesterday. And then as part of that, this timeline that this person of interest arrived on campus likely at about 1152, The shot took place at 1210. Between then, he went up the stairs to that vantage point about 200 yards away, hopped off of the roof, escaped through campus. And they believe into a nearby neighborhood where a lot of the thrust of the investigation has been focused, because obviously there may be eyewitnesses. There may be somebody with a report of what happened.

7:00There may be even some of that doorbell cameras. So typical now in these neighborhoods that may have captured something. And so they've been canvassing those areas. It's also really been centered on the only really tangible piece of evidence that we know has been recovered from the scene, which is that high powered bolt action rifle. We're now hearing from this press release as well that there were that they are saying there were reported inscriptions as part of the detailed photograph of the ammunition or the weapon itself. But they are waiting to release more details on that because it didn't necessarily come from authorities themselves.

7:35And so we are back to the point where, you know, authorities are asking the public for anything that they may know. They just recently released another post on X asking for anybody who knows anything to, of course, respond as quickly as possible. And that no detail at this point, even hours on, is too small for investigators to learn. All right. This is Steve Patterson. Thank you very much. I want to bring in Jim Cavanaugh, former longtime ATF agent, and Bobby Chacon, former FBI special agent. Jim, we were discussing this around this time last night, what it would mean to get the weapon. Your breakdown of that now that authorities have it.

8:15Yeah, well, it's a tremendous piece of evidence. It's right in the middle of the case. In other words, the projectile that went through Charlie Kirk has been recovered. They know it's a.30-06, and now they have the.30-06 rifle. And it's the middle, and now the suspect is the other end of that string. So, you know, if you can get fingerprints, which the FBI laboratory will work diligently to get those, very likely can be on the cartridges that are in the magazine, you know, that feed the bolt-action rifle. Sometimes they wipe the rifle down, but they don't wipe down the cartridges or the magazine.

8:55There can be DNA from sweat, from touch. There can be hair. And, of course, you can trace the gun. And they're already doing all that. I'm sure the urgent trace is in. Then they have to follow those leads. And it was wrapped in a towel, Ari, so that can be full of sweat DNA. So that's a tremendous lead. I doubt this person is any kind of sophisticated criminal. It may be their first homicide because of the way this is, you know, targeted and the motivations that are, you know, bubbling up. The person, you know, this is a lot of, we talked about terrorism and political assassination. And what's important here is just where the killer decided to kill Mr.

9:34Kirk, you know, right at his rally while he's sitting in his spot in front of thousands of his followers and fans. He could have tracked him down to his home or killed him on the street. No, he wanted to kill him right there, right there in front of everyone. That's the theater of the murder, the theater of the assassin here he wants or she. I would say the image, we can talk about that, but I'm not sure it's a man. I've looked at it extensively. I've done this a lot on many major cases. Is it a man? I don't know. I can tell you for sure it's a disguise. The wraparound sunglasses and the flag shirt with the eagle, this is all a disguise.

10:19Because at the rally, Mr. Kirk, he's wearing a shirt that says freedom. All his followers are very patriotic. They wear a lot of clothing with the flag, and they're patriots, and they talk about that frequently. And that's kind of the way his followers are. And this guy's trying to blend in with his followers. This is a disguise. And when you look at it that way, you know, you can't rule out, could this be a female? You know, you cut your hair, you put on those sunglasses. I'm just saying, you can't rule it out. We don't have enough. No, and you're reminding. Yeah, I was going to say you're reminding folks as well how an investigative team would look at this and you really take in all the information as neutrally as possible and you compare it to other information that you're getting in.

11:07And this is what they've released. Authorities have other information they've said, the video and other things they have not released. Whereas, as you know, Jim, there are people in life or on the Internet who have a quick, hot take interpreting what they're seeing on the screen without realizing that some people doing crime, as you say, are not dressed in their natural Monday outfit. They're doing something to blend with the area they're in. So any inference based on that, as you say, could be misplaced. I want to bring Bobby in and play a little more from Bo Mason discussing just what a horrific scene it was there yesterday.

11:42Take a listen. Having walked through the crime scene, through the hallways of this school, through the classrooms, I can't imagine what the people on scene felt as well. A horrific event where some of them barricaded in classrooms, some of them ran in fear.

12:01can't overstate the tragedy and the horrific event that yesterday was and how we will work to bring to justice the actions of one individual. Bobby, your thoughts on that and the hunt? Well, I mean, tragically, we're talking about this on the day where, you know, having the anniversary of another tragic event. You know, I was a first responder in New York City on 9-11. I was there. I watched those towers get hit. I watched them fall. I watched them fall onto my friends. And so, yeah, it is a chaotic scene. And you don't know if one shot is going to lead to four shots, 10 shots. We know what happened in Las Vegas.

12:41So anybody in that crowd is probably terrified of the next shot. And so you run anywhere. Sometimes you run towards the bullets because you don't know where the sound is coming from. There's a tremendous amount. Sometimes people get actually injured and killed just through the stampede to get away. And so I'm sure it was a and what happens in the process is, you know, there's a crime scene that now gets, you know, I mean, but the public safety is always number one. But, you know, now you can't recreate something when they're obliterated like that. But but certainly they've had some big breaks and certainly, you know, this was looks like now one perpetrator, one intended target, target victim.

13:19And unfortunately, one shot was taken and and killed the victim. And so it looks like he had an escape route. He had pre-planning. He had a towel that he knew he was going to wrap that gun within when he disposed of it. So he was planning something, which is disturbing because it means he probably planned to get away. And so he could be anywhere by now. Now, the two photos you're showing are the only two official photos that the FBI has released. And they're warning people, do not run these photos through AI. Do not try to enhance them yourself and re-release them. You know, there are a lot of people on social media chasing likes, chasing comments, and they get pictures like this and then they try to enhance them and they try to dig up something in that enhancement.

14:02The FBI is warning people, do not do that. Do not try to enhance these photos and re-release them with something else you think you see in that photo. Let the experts handle it. Let the investigators handle it. They'll release additional photographs, video, whatever, when they think it's strategically beneficial to the investigation. Yeah. Yeah. Jim, I want to put up just some of the headlines of when we were together last night. Again, these situations are always fluid, but that's why government officials tend to err on the side of caution. Even today, if you don't have everything ready, you delay a press conference before giving one that might add to the problem.

14:39First, do no harm. The FBI director struggled in that yesterday in what appeared to be a rush to do his own social media. And we know we're in an era where things are changing and how people and governments put out information. about the Reuters headline there, Director Patel scrutiny over the inaccurate claim and accurately saying the killer had been caught. That was the initial implication of his post on X, contradicted by local officials, leading to hours of confusion before the FBI then clarified, as we also later reported, two people have been questioned, both released following the incident.

15:12Jim, in the spirit of what we do in journalism, right, we report it as we know it and we correct it when we need to. What lessons are there for what are newcomers? I mean, the director and the deputy of the FBI have less experience than most people have had in those posts previously. I'll just say the president won an election. He can put in who he chooses. He has he has that power. He won it. And yet, Jim, what do you think the best case improvements might be on that for for these federal agencies? Both of you, of course, having done a lot of time in this kind of work. Right. Well, I do think the director's got his sea legs back today, and I do think you can look at this and see that the attorney general's handled this very well.

15:54You haven't seen her out front, and I guarantee you she is getting a briefing minute by minute from FBI and ATF in Washington, and yet she is, you know, handling it right. And I think the director is getting his sea legs. Look, I've been at so many of these. When you're a special agent in charge, you gather the other agents and chiefs and heads of the troopers, and you have a huddle, basically. I mean, I've done this so many times. You have a huddle, and you say, okay, this is where we are. These are the things we can't let out. We've got to save these. Only us and the bomber, us and the sniper, us and the killer will know this.

16:32This we can't let out. This is locked, but we've got to put some stuff out to help us. Let's put out this and this. maybe we can get a call from the public. And this is the message we're saying. This is what we're going to say in unison. And I used to say to the guys, we'll do a presser and we'll all say this and then go back where we usually go to a joint operations center. So we're all around each other all the time. But, you know, if you're out on the street and you get talked to by a reporter and you're the chief of police, go ahead and talk to them. The public wants to hear from you. You're the chief of police.

17:07Or if you're the FBI, SAC. But we all know what our collective message is. So we're not going to mess up. We're not going to let out something. But we're not going to go and do no comment. We're the leadership of the joint operation, and we've got to speak. And so that's the successful way to do it. I think the FBI director now is flying out there. He'll be with those commanders. And that's the proper thing. If he wants to be involved in that, then that's the proper thing. And to do it together and to be together. And so he's learned. He's learned it in a day. Yeah, you're saying, I mean, if you want to be that engaged, then you go to the agents on the ground and you're on the site and that might be best practice.

17:49And again, it can be live and learn for people with less experience. But it was striking and it goes to the value of experience at a time where there's been all kinds of debates in Washington about who should be running what and how much change you want at once. Jim Cavanaugh and Bobby Chacon, I want to thank both of you for rejoining us on this tough story. again after last night. Thank you. Later in the program, thousands of Epstein emails are out. We have the journalists who actually obtained them with an extraordinary scoop in that story that keeps on going. A lot of import that's coming up.

18:25We also have historian Doug Brinkley here. We'll be back in 90 seconds.

18:38grow faster. Every manager lead more effectively and every company unlock their people's full potential. Stop settling for HR tools that hold your company back. Build a future where technology doesn't replace people, but actually elevates them. No regrets. Ready to see the power of people plus AI? Visit lattice.com slash no regrets. That's L-A-T-T-I-C-E.com slash no regrets. A morning walk, some bird watching. It's another easy Sunday. UnitedHealth Group makes these ordinary days possible with partners like the University of Tennessee Health Sciences helping communities manage their health closer to home.

19:1654 % of participants have lowered their blood pressure, meaning fewer heart attacks and more Sundays at the park. This might feel like an ordinary day. To UnitedHealth Group, it's the healthcare system working better for everyone. Learn more at unitedhealthgroup.com slash commitment. Watch Disclosure Day at home now with exclusive bonus features. If you found out we weren't alone, if someone showed you, proved it to you, would that frighten you? Well, now the truth belongs to 7 billion people in an original event film directed by Steven Spielberg from a screenplay by David Koepp starring Emily Blunt, Josh O 'Connor, Colin Firth, Eve Hewson, and Coleman Domingo.

19:56Find Disclosure Day on major digital platforms now with no subscription required. Also in theaters.

20:08Former ATF director under President Biden, Steve Dettelbach, joins us now. Welcome. What do you see as important in the manhunt, the photos out, the incredible interest and national security imperative of finding this individual? And so I say as time goes on, there's two things that are happening. First, as time goes on, there's more time for the suspect to get further away from the scene, to hide better, to do all those things, right? But as time goes on, the other thing that's happening is law enforcement is developing more and more information about that person that's going to help us to find him.

20:47And let me tell you something. this individual is going to be caught at some point. That is going to happen. And you can see the beginnings of the fruits of that paying off, right? You can see the fact that there's now a picture that they're able to circulate to enlist the public. That's the traditional law enforcement tools. They're offering a reward. They're organized, right? Now they're in a joint operations center. You heard Jim Cavanaugh talk about this, right? They're meeting, they're delegating Utah State Police, FBI, ATF. Now, the marshals are involved. And then you have the follow-the-gun technology that we talked about that you just heard about before, right?

21:24This ballistic technology that enables that huge piece of evidence to be used for the investigation, to do a trace, an urgent trace, which I'm sure is already underway or done. And also, if there's an expended cartridge casing to use the National Integrated Ballistic Information Network and millions of ballistic fingerprints to try and link that to other potential crimes. So DNA, all the list of things are also being developed at the same time. And, you know, at this time, there can be this tremendous understandable, it's horrible, it's understandable desire from the public to know what happened and catch this person immediately.

22:06And unfortunately, that's not the way the world works. We have to be patient in terms of letting the law enforcement professionals do their job. And I am telling you, they're going to catch this perpetrator. We have this timeline that's been prepared. As you say, a lot of information coming together over the course of the last day and a half. 11.50 a.m., they believe they have the arrival. going to the roof access, which they got. 12.10, that shot, we knew that yesterday. And then the additional information that was not immediately apparent, crossing the roof, jumping the building, and then fleeing into the neighborhood where, again, without speculating, based on past examples, you would say an individual who'd planned this may be fleeing with what as their next step.

23:00Well, I think you have to learn more about the person to understand that, right? I mean, what they're doing is developing the contacts that this individual has, where he's from, where he might be going, looking at his patterns of life, all of those things. At the same time as they're conducting this manhunt physical search, they're doing these things to build the intelligence on this individual in the hopes that that will give them more information about where to best search. because I don't think I can say, certainly, you know, there's an old saying in Washington, those who know don't talk, those who don't know talk, right?

23:35I'm talking. I don't know what information they have. None of us knows. It's in that joint operations center inside the investigation that they know. And I will tell you, having been a director of ATF when a lot of these went on, I remember Lewiston, Maine, for instance, there was a significant period where there was a manhunt for that shooter. The public often has to be in the dark at some level because you don't want to somehow tip off the fugitive as to where you're going to be looking or that you know where he might go, right? And those things can happen unless the trained professionals, as Jim Cavanaugh said, are the ones making the decisions about what goes out and what doesn't.

24:18Because it is so easy with all the pressure and interest to make a mistake and to say something that does confuse people or worse yet, that gives the suspect an advantage for some period of time. How do you think the FBI leadership is handling it thus far? And could they learn from precedent and best practices? No, it's not for me to, in the middle of the game, aren't you our quarterback while they're trying to protect the public. I just say, for me as ATF director, when I went through these, I viewed my role during this critical period of time as understanding on a very routine basis, getting briefed about everything that was going on, number one, and number two, making sure I was there to give the right resources on a real-time basis to the people who were at ATF and FBI and at the local partners conducting the investigation.

25:11And then there comes a time for after action, and then there comes a time for understanding what could have been done better. But now is not that time. And one thing, since I haven't talked about this publicly, just how horrible for the people who were there, for the families, for everybody who knew the victim of this crime. But also, I want to say that since this crime occurred, this horrible incident, 120 Americans have lost their lives to firearms violence if this is an average day, 120 other people. And so we are going to catch this individual, Ari, but we have to find out how to solve this violence problem and this political violence problem, which seems to be getting worse and worse.

Read the full transcript

25:55That is not going to go away when we catch this individual. And those are the real problems that people in leadership positions and the government and law enforcement need to get serious about solving. Yeah. And you speak from the experience of having actually done the work at ATF, which deals with firearms and trying to bring to bear the full resources, as you mentioned, of the federal government, while there are open questions over whether the actual legal architecture at the state and federal level allows our government to protect us and do that, or whether the gun violence problem carries on.

26:31As you say, that level of gun violence daily. We've had several other shooting incidences just in this day and a half, Some of them understandably crowded out by this terrible murder, assassination, according to the governor. Go ahead. Right. You look at Minneapolis. You look at these horrible incidents that we see. And I guess the one thing that as a policy matter I hope we can all agree on is that the agencies, ATF, FBI, marshals, state and local law enforcement that are out there doing this need to be funded. This kind of, when people see this kind of effort that's going on right now, that doesn't come for free.

27:11And, you know, efforts to somehow diminish or cut or change budgets of these agencies that are out there protecting us and investigating these cases are crucial. And they should be, it should be a nonpartisan issue. You look at the things that Jim Cavanaugh told you that ATF and FBI are doing right now. Those agencies need to be given the support that they need to do this for each and every time, whether the person is prominent or not, the federal jurisdiction is implicated in one of these horrible crimes. Yeah. Former ATF chief Steve Dittleback, thank you very much. Appreciate it. Appreciate everything you said.

27:50I'll tell folks what's coming up as we try to make sense of this difficult time, this history we're living through. Doug Brinkley, the acclaimed historian, is our special guest coming up. And while we have stayed on this story quite continuously, we will turn to a major break scoop in the Jeffrey Epstein story. As thousands of new emails come out because of journalism, that reporter who broke the story joins us. Stay with me.

28:21There's only one Ozempic. Hello, I'm Ozempic. Because this ad is 30 seconds, I can't get into everything I'm FDA-proof to do, so I'm just going to play my jingle again. But first, ask your doctor about which FDA-approved uses of me, the Ozempic pen, may be right for you. Call 1-833-OZEMPIC or visit Ozempic.com to view the medication guide and learn more about Ozempic semaglutide injection, 2 milligrams. Only Novo Nordisk makes FDA-approved Ozempic. Now here's that jingle again. There's only one Ozempic. This is a Monday.com ad. The Same Monday.com helping people worldwide getting work done faster and better.

28:58The SameMonday.com designed for every team and every industry. The SameMonday.com with built-in AI, scaling your work from day one. The SameMonday.com that your team will actually love using. The SameMonday.com with an easy and intuitive setup. Go to Monday.com and try it for free. Yes, TheSameMonday.com. Traditional home security only alerts you after a break-in, and that's too late. SimpliSafe is changing that. Stop. This is SimpliSafe. Police are on the way. We don't just alert. We stop crime before it starts. SimpliSafe. Plan starting around a dollar a day. Save 50 % on your new system with professional monitoring at simplisafe.com slash sxm or with promo code sxm.

29:44Outdoor deterrence requires a SimpliSafe Active Guard outdoor protection plan starting at$49.99 a month. Visit simplisafe.com slash licenses for alarm license information. Tennessee 2012. one two authorities have not located arrested the main suspect or shooter who murdered charlie kirk and yet we have already seen a lot of reactions understandably about the wider climate of political rhetoric of hate speech of politicians who seem to condone violence and the actual past incidents that have been confirmed as political violence or terrorism. So many have understandably looked at this as possibly or likely an act of political violence.

30:26The governor, for example, spoke about that last night, even though those of us who deal in facts and the news have cautioned everyone, we don't even have the shooter yet, let alone a proven motive. Many lawmakers, though, in this moment where they're not going to just wait for all the other information to come in and want to say something about what we're living through, have condemned this kind of political violence. Political violence in any form against any American is unacceptable. We can settle disagreements and disputes in a civil manner and political violence must be called out. It has to stop.

31:00Violence is never the answer. This is just wrong. You can be angry about politics, but you don't express that violently. The last speaker there, a Republican, was infamously targeted for political violence. And we have seen this as a rising problem. Democratic lawmakers in Minnesota this summer in June shot and killed at their own home. Also this year, we saw Governor Josh Shapiro, a Democrat and a prominent Jewish politician, had his home set on fire while his family was inside. That was deemed by authorities domestic terror. There was the effort to assassinate Former President Trump during his campaign rally, one of the most direct attacks on a president or former president in the last several decades.

31:48Speaker Pelosi, who'd been targeted, of course, by many haters and others who even stormed the Capitol looking for her to do her violence on January 6th, saw her home invaded and her husband brutally attacked by a man with a hammer. A group of Republican lawmakers shot in 2017. At the time, Mr. Scalise, the congressman who we just heard from condemning this type of violence, he was in a tough way in critical condition. Many people, of course, cheering on his recovery. So this is more prevalent today. DHS has assessments that show politically emotive violence is a top concern, a growing measurable problem right now.

32:28Threats against federal officials surging last year. And it's not just a jump. it's tripled since 2017. We wanted to give you that overview of the facts, even amidst the thing that some politicians aren't saying right now, because they have their mode and their duty and they want to sound like they're on the spot no matter what happened to find justice for yesterday. But as for what yesterday was, the authorities haven't found the killer nor determined a motive. We're going to finish a break, and when we come back, we do turn to other stories, a huge breakthrough. thousands of new emails from deceased sex trafficker Jeffrey Epstein.

33:07We have the reporter with the scoop.

33:16For all the calls to release the Epstein docs, a whole new tranche just came out today, and it's not the ones people were expecting. Bloomberg got 18 ,000 leaked emails. These have never been public before from Epstein's personal email. account. He was using Yahoo. And it sheds new light on his predatory tactics. It also continues to reinforce what the DOJ under Ms. Comey, the now fired prosecutor, showed in her prosecution of Ghislaine Maxwell, that she was a big part of this criminal enterprise, not, as she said in her interview, some sort of hanger-on as people did consensual things. Now, as for the president, who has been so suspicious about this, who vowed to do transparency and then broke that vow.

34:05Well, there's not a lot of clear new information that shows what Trump was up to with Epstein, although we know from prior information that they had a kind of social relationship. You've seen the photos. Bloomberg reports these newly released emails do demonstrate Maxwell's knowledge of the legal jeopardy Epstein faced all the way back in that first case that we've reported on from the 2000s in Florida, and that Epstein negotiated a plea deal in 2008. He sought her advice. Quote, question, which one do you prefer? Lewd and lascivious conduct or procuring minors for prostitution? Quite a grim question if you're choosing among those cases.

34:42Maxwell responding, quote, I suppose lewd and lascivious conduct, I would prefer lewd conduct with a prostitute if possible. Now they're discussing the plea deal, not whether he did all of the above, Of course, the way the conversation goes, they don't sound shocked that they're in this situation. Remember, in her Trump DOJ interview, she downplayed her relationship with Epstein at that very time. So when he's going to go to jail, he says, can you stay around and manage everything? Yeah. And do you do that? I do. Okay. And then we'll come back to that. We'll not manage everything, no. I mean, there are other people at this point.

35:21My specific role then was very, very diminished. however one thinks of a diminished role compared to the past. Bloomberg finds they exchanged over 200 messages in six months of that first year. Trump's name does come up in three minor instances. That's the Bloomberg word, and they've obviously gone through all this quite carefully. In 2007, Maxwell wrote reporters may have interviewed Trump about Epstein's case. You have to assume they went to Donald Trump, she notes. That's neither here nor there on Donald Trump's role. Many of Epstein's emails also discuss the predatory manipulation of those young women and sometimes girls.

36:01From a legal perspective, it includes minors, according to, of course, the case. He and Maxwell discuss how to recruit and groom those young women and then discredit anyone who became an accuser. NBC has not obtained these emails or independently verified the Bloomberg report, we should note. And the revelations come as Epstein's survivors have been speaking out. Accountability is what makes a society civilized I would like to announce here today Us Epstein survivors have been discussing creating our own list We know the names Many of us were abused by them We are tired However We are not going away We will not stop or give up.

36:52Jason Leopold, the senior investigator of Bloomberg reporter, joins us now, the lead on what is a clearly big break in understanding more about this sordid case, Epstein's Inbox. That's how Bloomberg put it. Thanks for joining me. Thanks for having me on, Ari. What do these emails add to the public understanding about this case? It adds a lot. As you noted, we have 18 ,000 emails. And in the emails that we highlighted here, in this very lengthy story about Ghislaine Maxwell's partnership with Jeffrey Epstein, which was far closer than the public knows, you're getting an opportunity to see just how close they really were.

37:41Right up until Jeffrey Epstein was was getting ready to report to prison. They discussed fertility, shared fertility treatments. They talked about the the legal case. You read some of those emails about what when Jeffrey Epstein was asking her what she would prefer, what she thought that he should potentially plead guilty to. But also just how much she helped to kind of run the the business of Jeffrey Epstein in within these emails. we also uncovered an accountant's spreadsheet that tracked nearly$2 million in spending, which amounted to some gifts, some cash payments to victims, to very prominent public figures.

38:45There was a car for Alan Dershowitz, which he told us was for his wife. There was a watch,$11 ,000 Rolex watch for Tom Barrack, who's now the ambassador to Turkey. He told us he never received a watch. So you're getting an opportunity to see details about the business dealings. But also, disturbingly, there is a lot of information there about Jeffrey Epstein's callousness toward these young women, these underage girls. You know, there's one very disturbing, chilling email in which he is berating this woman who is working for him because she doesn't want to engage in fun sex things. Um, so, you know, between Jeffrey Epstein and, and kind of getting a sense of what, what he sounds like through these emails, uh, in his own words, uh, and the way in which Ghislaine Maxwell was really trying to, uh, uh, promote Jeffrey Epstein in social circles, uh, you learn quite a bit.

40:03What was Epstein's main business? He clearly had a knack or an almost con man's ability to get himself in all sorts of rooms around all sorts of people. We know how many have distanced themselves later. But given the nature of the sex crimes that were already exposed, it would appear that some people had knowledge of it. That's what the birthday book shows. Some people, we can't name names without, you know, a legal and investigative process, but some people understandably were probably closer to it and may have partaken in it. He has the whole island and he has all these other allegations. And then there's this wider concentric circle.

40:40And I'm wondering if you found the emails show any of this where he seems to be pulling people in to sort of credential himself as he goes along continuing to abuse others and make it, I guess, harder for him to ever actually face accountability for it. That seemed to work for some period of time. well you know as we noted in the story there there is uh you know many emails which which uh show an intense lobbying campaign that much is public that took place behind the scenes what's uh what's kind of fascinating about it is uh uh is seeing how it played out as far as the business uh you know that that's obviously a question that remains unanswered uh in terms of the source of his wealth.

41:26What I can tell you is that we're continuing our reporting around that. But really, it is, you know, getting a sense of kind of what the day-to-day was like. I mean, I also want to - Let me ask you on that. You mentioned, because the reporting talks about it being at times mundane, and we've seen throughout history references to the banality of evil, to use the famous phrase from Hannah Arendt, but did you also find any hint that through the email and other references that he was ever threatening or blackmailing others to maintain his own criminal web? No, as our reporting shows in this story, you know, he was berating and manipulating, calculating, emotionally abusing the women who had worked, you know, with him.

42:20And, you know, for all sorts of different reasons. So that much comes through within our reporting. I also just want to note that, you know, there are mundane issues, excuse me, mundane emails that, you know, that were, you know, that we found in there, such as his Amazon purchases, which honestly, I found fascinating, if you will, just in terms of getting a sense of what he was thinking. You know, there's purchases for Nabisco Nilo Wafers. There are purchases for an FBI agent's costume, a prostate massager. You know, something... I got one more. I got one more question for you before I lose you, which is we've talked much about what your reporting showed.

43:13One thing the emails don't show is a bombshell about Trump, which is fine. You follow the evidence. You do have a reference in September 06. This was after Epstein was charged. And there's 51 politicians and other executives on the list. And it says, please review lists and add or remove peeps from Maxwell. Quote, remove Trump. Epstein responded. Was he the only person removed? And what did you make of that? There was one other person removed. I mean, we reached out to the White House for comment on it. And the White House responded by stating, as we noted in the story, that this was fake news.

43:54But remove Trump means what? We don't know? You don't know? that we haven't been able to uh you know further uh uh find out what that you know what that means it's uh yeah as we note in the story yeah fair i appreciate you following it just as far as it goes uh striking because what was then as you say one of only two names removed later becomes a president who both oversaw um the doj when he was prosecuted and and has now been very secretive about the rest of it, but I appreciate your reporting and walking us through it. Jason Leopold at Bloomberg. We'll be right back.

44:37We're following the investigation to the person who shot and killed Charlie Kirk yesterday. The authorities continuing to search. The FBI looking for an individual matching the imagery we showed you. They're turning to the public for help. These images of this person of interest is a $100 ,000 reward. Investigators seen on the roof this morning where the authorities say the shooter fired. Video on social media before the shooting does also show what looks like an individual right there on that roof. We will continue to follow the manhunt and let you know how authorities are seeking public help to identify this individual.

45:11We'll be right back.

45:19These can be hard times to just watch the news Keep track of what's going on We appreciate you spending time with us If you want to connect or ask me anything You can always connect with me online at these various sites And make sure that you're taking care of yourself and the people around you Take a break when you need We will be here on MSNBC and on The Beat at 6 p.m. Eastern. I'll see you tomorrow.

46:34Thank you. if you get a lump or swelling in your neck. Stop ZipBound and call your doctor if you have severe stomach pain or a serious allergic reaction. Severe side effects may include inflamed pancreas or gallbladder problems. Tell your doctor if you experience vision changes before scheduled procedures with anesthesia. If you're nursing, pregnant, plan to be, or taking birth control pills, taking ZipBound with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Side effects include nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting, which can cause dehydration and worsen kidney problems. Talk to your doctor. Call 1-800-545-5979 or visit zetbound.lily.com.

From the publisher

September 11, 2025; 6pm: MSNBC's Ari Melber reports on the ongoing manhunt for the person who shot and killed conservative activist Charlie Kirk. Plus, new revelations on the Jeffrey Epstein scandal are rattling President Trump. Former ATF Director Steven Dettelbach and Bloomberg's Jason Leopold join.

To listen to this show and other MS podcasts without ads, sign up for MS NOW Premium on Apple Podcasts.


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

More from The Beat with Ari Melber

All 321 episodes
Manhunt Underway For Charlie Kirk ShooterThe Beat with Ari Melber · 42 min
Listen in VO