In short
The episode argues that the Jeffrey Epstein scandal is worsening political damage to Donald Trump and splitting the MAGA base, moving the story into mainstream culture. It cites polling (Economist/YouGov: 46% think Trump could be involved; 23% unsure) and points to cultural backlash: punk band Dropkick Murphys dedicating “First Class Loser” to Trump; Rolling Stone and HuffPost coverage.
Key claims
Trump/DOJ are withholding “receipts” and misleading about Epstein materials; Congress should oversee and obtain files rather than DOJ releasing them; the uproar is already a distraction from other policy.
Notable examples
Senator Kennedy pressuring AG Pam Bondi; Democrats invoking an obscure law to force release; calls for grand jury transcripts; Geraldo Rivera criticizing Dan Bongino/Rogan-style misinformation; discussion of alleged immigration enforcement targeting free speech and Latinos.
Guests
Asher Angappa (former FBI special agent; Yale senior lecturer), Geraldo Rivera (journalist/TV host), Gary Steingart (bestselling novelist; author of Absurdistan, Super Sad True Love Story; Vera or Faith).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOEpstein's Impact on Trump’s Base
0:00 to 0:47
Exploring how the Epstein scandal affects Trump's support among his base.
“Most ice cream is good, but not Jenny's.”
Epstein's Impact on Trump’s Base
1:10 to 2:30
Exploring how the Epstein scandal affects Trump's support among his base.
“The mainstream discourse, the way we understand what's happening in our country and culture, includes seriously disturbing questions about what Trump's own podcast allies call a cover-up.”
Cultural Reactions to Trump
2:30 to 4:20
Discussion on how cultural figures are responding to Trump amid the Epstein scandal.
“And this is going around and it's not just in the world of politics.”
Public Perception and Polling
4:20 to 6:10
Analysis of polling data regarding Trump's involvement with Epstein.
“Government portion is a lot of folks thinking that Trump's administration has lied and acted shady about this.”
Political Accountability and Lies
6:10 to 8:10
Discussion on accountability in politics regarding the Epstein case and Trump's actions.
“Part of this is about what you think happened.”
Demands for Transparency in Congress
8:10 to 10:47
Exploring calls for transparency and the role of Congress in the Epstein case.
“Senate Homeland Security Committee has a means to get information from the feds.”
Demands for Transparency in Congress
10:50 to 11:38
Exploring calls for transparency and the role of Congress in the Epstein case.
“I'm pretty confident talking into a mic.”
Expert Insights on Epstein and Justice
11:38 to 14:03
Discussion with Asher Angappa on the implications of the Epstein case and justice.
“If adults aren't going to protect our kids, who is?”
Analyzing the Epstein Crisis and Its Political Ramifications
14:03 to 17:08
Discussion on how the Epstein crisis is affecting MAGA and political dynamics.
“What do you think is the right substantive approach if we forget all of this political intrigue.”
Geraldo on Trump and the Conservative Media Landscape
17:08 to 19:32
Geraldo reflects on his experiences with Trump and conservative media figures.
“But first, the Epstein crisis has divided MAGA in ways that were thought impossible in years past.”
Show all 19 chapters
Bongino's Struggles and the Realities of Government Work
19:32 to 23:15
Discussion about Dan Bongino's challenges in his role and its implications.
“I am observing that he seems genuinely surprised and thus shares on public TV.”
Immigration Policies and Their Impact on Society
23:15 to 25:26
Exploration of the current immigration policies and their effects on communities.
“to be happening in the Mideast does happen and he brings about the expulsion of Hamas from Gaza, I think that he'll get the Nobel Peace Prize.”
Cultural Significance of the Puerto Rican Day Parade
25:26 to 27:38
Geraldo shares memories and the cultural importance of the Puerto Rican Day Parade.
“But me personally, I've always gotten along with and been curious about what people know after all of their life experience.”
Cultural Significance of the Puerto Rican Day Parade
28:10 to 28:33
Geraldo shares memories and the cultural importance of the Puerto Rican Day Parade.
“Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start?”
Trump's Alleged Abuse of Power
29:05 to 33:38
Discussion on Trump's actions and their implications for governance and justice.
“There is plenty of discussion about Donald Trump's policies, his ideas.”
Introduction of Gary Steingart
33:38 to 33:51
Introduction of novelist Gary Steingart and his perspective on censorship.
“The anti-Putin, anti-Trump, brilliant novelist.”
Art, Free Speech, and Totalitarianism
33:51 to 38:43
Gary Steingart discusses the impact of censorship and authoritarianism on art and free speech.
“Donald Trump's government, the big government programs, are going after journalists, the press, and others who might just speak truth to power in ways that this government doesn't like.”
The Media Landscape and Free Expression
38:43 to 42:01
Discussion on the media's role under Trump's influence and the effects on freedom of expression.
“While at the same time, of course, censoring books like, for example, Toni Morrison, right, which is something a high schooler would read.”
The Chilling Effects of Censorship
42:01 to 45:30
Explore the dangers of self-censorship and victimization in society.
“There's a Russian term, a Soviet term, called writing into your desk, meaning that you know that what you write is going to offend the authorities, so you write into your desk so nobody else will see it.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Most ice cream is good, but not Jenny's. Jenny's ice cream is more like an obsession. What you get from over two decades of tasting and tweaking and throwing it out and starting over, chasing flavors until they feel alive. That might sound crazy, and that's because it is. Jenny's. Often imitated, never duplicated, always splendid. A rug shouldn't just fit your room. It should make your home feel finished. Ernesta creates designer-quality rugs custom-fit to the exact size of your space, so every room feels beautifully pulled together. Explore Ernesta's range of options, all ready to be custom-cut, finished, and delivered to your door in as little as two weeks.
0:42Start with five samples for just$10 and get$50 toward your rug when you order. Visit Ernesta.com today. That's E-R-N-E-S-T-A dot com.
0:51Gary Shteyngart:Welcome to The Beat, everyone. I'm Ari Melber. We begin right now with how the Jeffrey Epstein scandal continues to not only spiral out of control of Donald Trump, the White House and their political operation and allies, but is really feeding a larger question over whether the famously loyal MAGA base is, in a sense, over. Is this a new chapter where post-Epstein, Donald Trump cannot just count on this kind of what has been very loyal support on most issues, most talking points, most defenses, particularly in that new digital podcast space we've been covering? This is now beyond D.C. politics or MAGA.
1:28Gary Shteyngart:The mainstream discourse, the way we understand what's happening in our country and culture, includes seriously disturbing questions about what Trump's own podcast allies call a cover-up. Now there's pressure from a Republican senator and heat from Democrats. Now look at Trump's reality. A crowd on hand for a punk rock show, The Dropkick Murphys. We've covered before how things matter in culture and what we might call daily life, separate from the quote news or DC politics. And you can see that you don't need to explain this story to the country. Rock fans, other folks who might not be glued to old school linear television, They know exactly what is going on and the questions looming about this long relationship between Trump and Epstein.
2:15Gary Shteyngart:At the show, they dedicated a song called, quote, First Class Loser to the president. This next song is dedicated to a guy who wears orange makeup, his pants and his diapers. Great woman. It's called First Class Loser.
2:59Gary Shteyngart:And this is going around and it's not just in the world of politics. outlets that focus on music and culture and sometimes kind of look away from the daily DC stories see this as a big music story. Rolling Stone with the headline you see, Dropkick Murphys Make Trump Their Honorary, quote, First Class Loser. During Warped Tour set, HuffPo referring to them as the iconic punk band ripping Trump through a song that people can sing along to. As for the political nightmare, about half the country now thinks something that, again, this is polling, not proven, but they think that Trump is so suspicious on the story, the way he's been acting, the cover-up, the lies, the gaslighting, as Joe Rogan put it, that 46 percent, when asked by The Economist with YouGov, a magazine and a website, say they think Trump could be involved in the Epstein crimes.
3:48Gary Shteyngart:Another 23 percent just say not sure. A third of Republicans now say Trump was involved or are not sure. Now, there is not a legal process that has found Trump culpable anyway involved in the very serious crimes that Epstein was both charged with when he died, that Maxwell and others were convicted of. Donald Trump has had other legal troubles. That's been well covered and well known. He admitted to certain things on the Access Hollywood tape in his words. But this is a sign of why it is so much larger than just the government portion. Government portion is a lot of folks thinking that Trump's administration has lied and acted shady about this.
4:32Gary Shteyngart:Then the history portion is that this happens to all swirl around an individual who was tied to many prominent people. Not only Donald Trump, but Donald Trump was one of them. Republican Senator Kennedy going after what I mentioned there, the first part, the governing choices of the Trump administration on this important case. Over recess, do you agree at all that this Epstein issue is going to be a distraction from talking about the benefits of the one big, beautiful bill? Well, the Epstein mess is already a distraction. And it's not a political issue for me. It's a moral issue. If adults aren't going to protect our kids, who is?
5:13The Justice Department has dug up more snows than they could kill in terms of their handling this. I think we're beyond the point where they can say, look, trust me, there's nobody else. Now the American people will receive receipts.
5:29Gary Shteyngart:At the top Republican senator, he's talking about Attorney General Pam Bondi. He uses the term Justice Department maybe to soften the blow, but he's talking about what they're doing now and what they misled on now and saying that you can't trust someone who offers receipts and then hides them. That's this Trump DOJ. It's not five years ago. Daily Beast reports Trump officials worried that the scandal is growing as Trump's crowd size shrinks. The Post says Trump's advisors are not under any impression that the storm has passed. Here's one quote from a White House official. I wouldn't say it's blown over.
6:05Gary Shteyngart:Very small segment of the base. It's never going to die down, no matter what. A kind of a fait accompli attitude about this. Part of this is about what you think happened. And part of this is about the process of information, of learning. That's why some people have taken a kind of schadenfreude or gotten a kick out of so many MAGA fans, supporters, and big loud voices, suddenly sounding like every other critic of Donald Trump over the last many years. Critical of the lies, critical of the stonewalling, critical of the very extreme way that Donald Trump does propaganda. We have never had a modern president, for example, lose an election.
6:43Gary Shteyngart:He clearly lost. He was the loser of that election in 2020. Then lie about it forever and be a part of a rally that led to a sedition crime spree. so people have gotten used to or normalized maybe how often there are these lies coming out of Donald Trump's mouth and in the MAGA side they have a playbook where they attack other people you know about it they shoot the messenger they attack the press we know all about that but now they are the messenger in the press and they Megyn Kelly Joe Rogan and others don't like it and Senator Kennedy's calling out the lies and so we're in this interesting sort of through the looking glass moment even apart from the important underlying sex crimes where you're seeing a very different reaction to the same old Trump.
7:23Gary Shteyngart:They just don't like it happening to them. So they're asking for information or demanding interviews. Well, imagine that. A politician and president who's waged war on the press quite blatantly is now facing calls from his own side to be honest and to engage with journalists or release the darn evidence. Republican committee chair in the House has not signed the subpoena that apparently they wanted to use to tell their side, their supporters, they were going after the information. Of course, if you haven't signed it, what's the holdup? He's required by committee rules to do so, and so we don't know when that's going to happen.
7:59Gary Shteyngart:Again, Washington games, we've told you about someone wants to get out of the way of the angry anti-Epstein mob who's a Republican, so he talks about a subpoena, but that doesn't do the thing. And I want to be clear with you, we know about this because of the work of reporters like this story at the Washington Post who are going into the details, not just playing a soundbite of him on TikTok, talk claiming he's going to get to the bottom of it if he's not. That takes work. That takes investigative work. In the Senate, Democrats are trying to invoke a fairly obscure law to force a different way to get these Epstein materials out of the Trump DOJ, which is very clearly hiding them despite the many now broken promises to release them.
8:38Gary Shteyngart:Senate Homeland Security Committee has a means to get information from the feds. No comment yet on whether that will add to the pressure or how the White House will deal with it. So we have an uproar. We have Democrats here clearly joining this. Some of them have a long record of looking for transparency on this issue. Others may just be doing what you do in politics, which is seeing an issue that is splintering the Republican Party and jumping in. You have Republicans breaking with Donald Trump on this issue in the Congress more than any other this year, more than the big mega bill where some of them said they didn't like what he was doing, but they didn't use their powers or votes to stop it.
9:18Gary Shteyngart:More than ICE, where we've seen some libertarians say it's bad to have these kind of federal agents and federal powers used to access. More than grocery prices and inflation, where Donald Trump has just completely fallen down on the job and not done the thing that he said all last year was so important, take every possible step to lower inflation. The trade war is certainly not doing that. And we have punk bands using their language, protest anthems of 2025 applied to Donald Trump with that flickering video in the background that I showed you of Trump and Epstein, which brings us back to what is a conflict of interest, not necessarily legally ever a crime, but a conflict of interest that this now deceased sex trafficker had so many social ties to this president who is now overseeing the rejection of the transparency that he promised about someone who used to be his party mate.
10:15Gary Shteyngart:I want to get into this with a very special guest who has worked inside the federal government, knows exactly how this stuff works. Next.
10:27Finding the right size rug can be hard. Enter Ernesta. Designer quality, custom sized rugs cut to the exact size of your room and delivered in as little as two weeks. Not sure of the size or the material? Start with five samples for just$10 today to see them in your own light and match to your decor. Plus, get$50 toward any rug of your choice. Visit Ernesta.com today. That's E-R-N-E-S-T-A dot com.
10:52Gary Shteyngart:I'm pretty confident talking into a mic. Hey, I'm doing it right now. But home projects? I second-guess everything. Is that noise normal? Is that water damage? Who do I even call? That's where Thumbtack comes in. Just upload a photo or voice note and it uses AI-powered search to match you with the right top-rated local pro. So instead of guessing, you get clarity and can hire with confidence. For your next home project, try Thumbtack. Hire the right pro today. She loves it freezing. She loves it hot. The Pod by 8 Sleep ends the argument for good with independent temperature zones that keep both of you sleeping deeper.
11:32Try it at 8sleep.com.
11:38If adults aren't going to protect our kids, who is? So Justice Department has dug up more snakes than they could kill. They're going to have any terms of their handling of this. Now they're going to be able to save receipts.
11:53Gary Shteyngart:Republican Senator Kennedy hitting the Trump DOJ. We're joined by Asher Angappa, former FBI special agent and senior lecturer at Yale. your views on where this story is now headed. Well, Ari, you know, I was listening to your monologue, and one of the things that I think is worth highlighting is that this story has what everybody understands. It's sex, it's true crime, it's politics. And I was thinking, you know, would you be able to give a one-sentence summary of the Whitewater scandal to your viewers right now? Probably not. I'll tell you something. We got plenty. We've got. Can I tell you something?
12:34Gary Shteyngart:We got plenty of viewers who don't remember what the Whitewater scandal was, period. You're talking about the original Clinton's land deal that eventually led to other investigations. And your point is that this Epstein thing, everybody understands what this is. Everybody gets it. It's it's simple. It's the kind of thing and it's it kind of crosses party lines. What I think what is interesting here with the clip that you just played with Senator Kennedy is that really the right venue for this information to come out is Congress. us. If we are to take the Justice Department at its word, and it's not just this Justice Department, it's previous Justice Departments, that there is no one else in these files that can be charged, which is not to say that there's nobody who might have done anything sketchy or wrong, but the bar for charging people with a crime in the Justice Department is and should be high.
13:28You know, it's not their job. It's not a part of their mission to just release files out into the public just for public, you know, transparency and education. They, you know, but Congress does do that. So, for example, you'll remember the hearings that Congress had about Larry Nassar and the way that the FBI handled that investigation and the U.S. Olympic Committee. So this really, I think, should be something that the Justice Department should be providing to Congress. And that's where I think the right kind of transparency ought to come. And the fact that it's getting all jammed up is it's very weird.
14:08Gary Shteyngart:When you look at how the FBI handled this originally and you have that experience and now there's this call for grand jury material, even after the now infamous Trump DOJ Pam Bondi memo said nothing else is warranted to be released. What do you think is the right substantive approach if we forget all of this political intrigue. As you mentioned, past justice departments, including, of course, hypocritically, the Trump DOJ, had already closed the book and said this didn't reach the extraordinary situation or exception where you would start releasing that kind of stuff. Well, the attorney general, by the way, didn't request grand jury material, only grand jury transcripts.
14:52And reportedly, the grand jury transcripts have testimony from a single FBI agent. And I think in the Maxwell case, maybe also a police detective, basically summarizing the information, much of which is already known. So, you know, that is also sort of a red herring because the wealth of the information is going to be in the Department of Justice's possession. You know, all the interviews that they did with victims, all the people that they have talked to.
15:21Gary Shteyngart:Sure, but I guess I'm asking you. They've caused many different investigations. I'm asking you, what, if any of that, would you release as part of an FBI, DOJ law investigative approach or none of it? I don't think that the Justice Department is the right body to release it, right? Their approach is always to charge someone with a crime or really keep their mouth shut. Because when it's coming from the Department of Justice, what you're doing is creating like a cloud of suspicion, right? This is why, you know, when James Comey came out and started editorializing about the Hillary Clinton investigation, a lot of people got mad.
16:05It muddies the waters. Whereas I think I do think that there is a channel here, but I think the channel is for this to go from the Justice Department to Congress. And then you don't know.
16:18Gary Shteyngart:And you're making you're making a nuanced distinction. The DOJ has its policies in most cases, and there's reasons for that. But in a healthy democracy, a co-equal branch oversees the DOJ. And some of the questions now are over the DOJ's handling the in-custody death, the video, so that a co-equal branch doing oversight could review that material and bring some independence. The DOJ has the classic governmental problem of saying, well, how high are you going to look into this if it goes up to what? The AG or above. So I take your distinction there. Ashram Gappa, always good to see you. Thank you.
16:53Gary Shteyngart:I've got a lot coming up, including a famous, internationally famous critic of both Putin and Trump. The bestselling novelist, the creative Bon Vivant, Gary Steingart, is here in person on Press Freedom. And the right wing conspiracy theories that are ricocheting back on so many MAGA leaders. We have a story on that. But first, the Epstein crisis has divided MAGA in ways that were thought impossible in years past. Geraldo knows all about that world and is here back with us tonight as Joe Rogan absolutely hammers Trump on another front. And then they're kicking students out that like write articles they don't like.
17:34Yeah, that's nuts. Crazy.
17:43Gary Shteyngart:We are back with Geraldo. Hey, Aldo Rivera, a longtime journalist celebrated across five decades. So you bring a lot to many stories. We know that you also have known Donald Trump a long time and you've been in that conservative universe. You were at Fox where you dealt with 22 years. Yeah. And you had dealt with some of these people. And, you know, I'm a First Amendment guy, so everyone can say everything. But not everyone who's ever said everything should be running every investigative agency. Right. These are different skill sets. you yourself have stood up to or clashed with Dan Bongino. And I want to show some of that as well as how he sounds these days, because the job is getting to him.
18:23Geraldo, you do this every time. This is such garbage. You play this emotional game with the audience and use your position of responsibility to put out misinformation and BS. You know, stop attacking me, punk. You did it on the police thing. Address the issue. Do you have the guts to address the issue and not address it? This is not about me. Do you have a point about the issue? your position of authority here. I'm sick of you, Bongino. I'm sick of you. You're a punk. I gave up everything for this. I mean, you know, my wife is struggling. If you think we're there for tea and crumpets, well, I mean, cash is there all day.
18:56We share it. Our offices are linked. He turns on the faucet. I hear it. He's there at, he gets in like six o 'clock in the morning. He doesn't leave till seven at night. You know, I'm in there at 730 in the morning. I stare at these four walls all day in D.C., you know, by myself, divorced from my wife, not divorced, but I mean, separated, divorced. And it's hard. I mean, you know, we love each other and it's hard to be apart.
19:18Gary Shteyngart:So as he says there, he's these government jobs, especially something as big as being a senior FBI official, turns out you work all day. You work a whole day every week, sometimes, although you might have to work nights and weekends. You don't sound very sympathetic. I am observing that he seems genuinely surprised and thus shares on public TV. This isn't him ranting to a friend shares on TV as if it's still a revelation. These are hard jobs and they're perhaps different than what he was suited for. There is no doubt but that the glamour of that job, basically the top cop in the country, was alluring to Bongino, who had been a failed congressional candidate after all and a very ambitious guy.
20:00And also when you talk about the grand scheme of things and the mega universe and all the rest of it, it's one thing when you have to actually do the job and someone is missing in Nebraska or there's a, you know, something else in Wyoming. And it's a, you know, it's a really hard job. And I really fell for him. I saw that. I saw that live and I, I worried that he was coming apart at the seams. And, uh, you know, I always thought if anything, you know, we clashed heads, uh, in one, one, uh, run of Hannity, 30 of 31 days, uh, you know, had that kind of emotion. Uh, is he up to this job? I, I, you know, I think that he is he has a good heart and easy for me to hate him.
20:42But I don't. Is he up for the job? I don't know. Technically speaking, I believe that, you know, it is a very complicated job. It's a job that you have to play well with others. You have to play well with others.
20:58Gary Shteyngart:And yeah, you're not sure if he's the guy. You have to work behind the scenes when the cameras are off. Most deputies don't do any interviews, which we know because we try to get him. We're happy to have him do interviews. But he's going out back on Fox, back on other environments where he seems more comfortable than what he called the all day work of helping run the FBI. But he is part of this extraordinary phenomenon whereby Donald Trump stamped most of his administration with media people, mostly from Fox. So I happen to know so many of them. Yeah, you do. And, you know, I want to give them the benefit of the doubt.
21:35I don't think that Bongino has screwed up yet in a cosmic scale way. I think he's done things that are embarrassing, perhaps. I think the Epstein situation that you're going to talk about later is a classic example of being caught between your rhetoric and your poetry and the reality. And I feel for them because now they have to. It's not Joe Rogan. It's reality. Yeah, exactly. You know, and what's he going to do?
22:01Gary Shteyngart:Is he up to the plate? It's reality. And he was reportedly clashing with everyone and upset about himself rather than the country or the victims or any of the number of concerns. He was upset that he doesn't look consistent with what he said on his podcast. You mentioned Rogan. And I want to show you something I know you've been passionate about, which is having a thoughtful or humane immigration policy. sure uh rogan big trump guy everybody knows that this is new and him breaking on the way they're treating students at these schools and then they're kicking students out that like write articles they don't like yeah that's nuts crazy yeah isn't a university supposed to be a place where someone's allowed to express themselves and have non-violently yeah deporting people because you don't like who they're criticizing like that gets kind of shifty he's speaking to something that's been documented.
Read the full transcript
22:51Gary Shteyngart:I will mention the administration has denied it. They've tried to claim, but lost on some court cases, that they're just enforcing immigration laws, which they can do. But there's strong evidence that they're using it to attack people's free speech and First Amendment rights. Students in this country are allowed to participate in the full life of this country. Your thoughts on that and Rogan hitting Trump on that? Well, I think that of all the things the president has done, I believe that if what happens, if what appears to be happening in the Mideast does happen and he brings about the expulsion of Hamas from Gaza, I think that he'll get the Nobel Peace Prize.
23:28But I also think that this is the most humiliating, harmful, racist government policy I've ever seen executed. The targeting of Latinos is something that is, Ari, it is absolutely appalling. They walk around now, the laborers on Long Island, worried that because they are Mexican, they're going to get scooped up and their lives are going to be ruined and they're going to be exported, deported to Africa someplace. I think it's really disgusting. It's lowbrow. It's something that I believe is shameful in every regard. These people, I mean, it's one thing to have a tough border. Stop them at the border.
24:11Again, all the rhetoric, I don't care, build a wall 100 miles high if you want to. But if people have been living here for some time in a peaceable way, in a way where the law and order, God fearing, you know, they love their families and they're working hard working. They're not part of the public. Why are you bothering these people? Why are you going after these people? Why are you targeting these people? I'm telling you, places like East LA, you know, very heavily, 10 % of LA is undocumented. East LA is probably 50%. East LA is going to build a wall around itself to keep the Migra out, to keep the immigration officers out.
24:49And why in the world are they wearing masks? Why are they wearing masks? The cops don't wear masks. FBI doesn't wear masks. Nobody wears masks. Nobody, because they're doing something honorable to protect the people. And yet only immigration officers wear masks. Yeah. It's because they're embarrassed by what they're doing. It's not for fear. It's for embarrassment that they are scooping up Juan and Maria, the meat packer and the poultry processor or the babysitter of a lawnmower and they're they're ruining their lives i think
25:19Gary Shteyngart:it's horrible yeah well you're speaking very clearly about it and it's i know you care about it and you of course know a lot of the folks involved in this including the president himself so i know they're listening uh you've agreed to stick around we have the novelist gary steingard coming up and i want to hear both your views about these attacks in the free press but before we do that you know i always like to have a little fun with you at the vault okay i've always and i'm not referring only to your experience. But me personally, I've always gotten along with and been curious about what people know after all of their life experience.
25:49Gary Shteyngart:So I'd be at a wedding and I'm talking to like the oldest grandma at the wedding. I don't know. That's just how I am. So whenever we get you, I think let's look back. Sure. Okay. This is Geraldo and J-Lo. And J-Lo. Oh my goodness. Last summer's 41st annual National Puerto Rican Day Parade was the sexiest, biggest outboring of power, politics, and pride. Older generation stars like Tito Puente and brand new superstars like Jennifer Lopez. How do you feel today? I don't know who's going to be the next president, but they're going to have to learn Spanish. And why this cycle, Senator, is the Latino vote being courted?
26:31It's a simple matter in many cases of demographics.
26:36Gary Shteyngart:25 years there, you're mixing the culture with the politics. What does that look like looking back on it? First of all, the Puerto Rican Day Parade is the biggest party in the country. It's the biggest parade in New York. A million people participate, a couple of million watch. Everybody's kissing everybody. It's a wonderful, wonderful experience. And it does go from J-Lo to, you know, to the whoever's running for office. This year I ran into, you know, Governor Cuomo. Eric Adams had chats with them. They all have to come. The Puerto Rican, I've been the grand marshal of that parade. This, I think, was my 25th appearance.
27:15It's a time where you really show that you belong, that you love people, that there's great affection, that it's sincere. And they give it back. They give it back. Yeah, and we need that.
27:27Gary Shteyngart:All right. You're sticking around. We have novelist Gary Steingart on. I mentioned this is on free speech in America these days and the backlash over some organizations folding to Trump. I have a word for them next.
27:58All ready to be custom cut, finished, and delivered to your door in as little as two weeks. Start with five samples for just$10 and get$50 toward your rug when you order. Visit Ernesta.com today. That's E-R-N-E-S-T-A dot com.
28:12Gary Shteyngart:Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today. Spring nights can't decide if they're hot or cold, and neither can you too. The Pot by 8 Sleep is a smart mattress cover with dual-temperature zones, so one side of the bed stays cool while the other stays warm.
28:48Autopilot adjusts automatically as you sleep, and it's clinically proven to boost deep sleep by 27%. Better sleep for both of you. No compromise even. Try the pod by 8sleep at 8sleep.com.
29:05Gary Shteyngart:There is plenty of discussion about Donald Trump's policies, his ideas. Do you agree with what he's trying to do for the country? And then there's a whole other category, which is the alleged and sometimes documented abuse of power, twisting the government against its actual goals, not for policy or even conservative ideology, but just for outlandish power grabs. Consider, for example, how a Trump ally with no expertise very publicly helped oust an FDA expert and an NSA lawyer, a national security official, just because of her close ties to the president. You wouldn't think it fair if at your job someone came in and just because they knew the CEO, they could get people fired for no reason.
29:45Gary Shteyngart:And these jobs are pretty high stakes. Then you have other loyalists going into the government. The Senate has now confirmed someone who is best known for being Donald Trump's criminal defense attorney. But now, instead of arguing for Trump to judges, he will be one. Lifetime tenure. In any other era, this would have been a very controversial appointment. It was close. But with three whistleblowers already issuing documented complaints about him, the Senate, instead of taking time to review that or take the process seriously, including the idea that he said in front of witnesses, they were going to defy court orders, tell the courts F you and see what happens.
30:22Gary Shteyngart:Instead of investigating that, the Senate just rubber stamped him on Republican votes. He's also accused of misleading lawmakers about the deal they struck in New York for Eric Adams. He has vaguely or sort of generally denied some of this. Here's what top Democrats are saying. The nominee so patently unfit to be a federal judge in the long history of our republic. Things like this haven't happened. There is yet another whistleblower about his prosecutorial misconduct, and the Republicans just don't want to hear it. To put someone on the bench that has shown such disrespect for the rule of law, for the ideas of justice, they're not worthy for that position.
31:08Gary Shteyngart:Now, those are specific examples involving individual people. And sometimes it's easier to kind of track what's going on with people rather than organizations, which are generally faceless. Most people, including Republicans, didn't vote for or think Laura Loomer would be calling the shots over a national security. And yet here we are. Then you have the concern as Trump targets those larger organizations and entities I mentioned. And that includes corporations, which is very anti-free market. Most honest free market pro-capitalist individuals don't think big government should be shaking down companies to change what they would otherwise do.
31:43Gary Shteyngart:We also see, of course, all the universities and then the law firms. Most of those law firms, by the way, are working on behalf of big corporate clients in Wall Street, but they're still getting the shakedown. And you have potentially a settlement with Harvard. That's been discussed. That's the potential amount. Big, larger than the other settlements you see. It's approaching a billion dollars. The Times, approaching a billion dollars when you put it all together. Columbia, 200 million. media companies paying out for lawsuits. And Trump is happy about the payouts. He's open to getting potentially money out of Harvard.
32:19Gary Shteyngart:That's the new headline today. And there, one of the universities has said they were fighting. But remember, we already have a lot of information about how this works. You can have a strategic debate if you're an organization or law firm thinking only about yourself. You can have a more ethical or public service debate about what this means for everyone touched by your organization in the country. Or you can just go back and read Sun Tzu, The Art of War, or Donald Rumsfeld, who said weakness is provocative, meaning be careful how often you show your weakness to a bully or a tyrant. Because after some of those law firms cut deals with Trump that were supposed to end the shakedown, the goalposts started moving.
32:57Gary Shteyngart:One professor knowingly observing that in the Times, they thought they made a one-shot deal, the administration, that's Trump, thinks they've subjected these firms to indentured servitude. There is very little evidence that buckling to these kind of shakedowns means they'll go away. Like anyone who's ever watched a mafia movie or dealt with the mob, if you start paying for protection, you very rarely are allowed to stop, which makes you wonder, who are you paying for protection from? I wanted to tell you that and give you that kind of peace of mind for anyone in any organization thinking about how to play this.
33:36Gary Shteyngart:We're going to fit in a break, but we come back. The anti-Putin, anti-Trump, brilliant novelist. Look at that headshot. Gary Steingart, back on the beat tonight.
33:51Gary Shteyngart:Donald Trump's government, the big government programs, are going after journalists, the press, and others who might just speak truth to power in ways that this government doesn't like. Trump has gone after public broadcasting funds and endangering the way local audiences might learn about things happening in their community. I think President Trump is fundamentally reshaping the media landscape. We're going to continue to see consequences over the coming months and years as this industry sees a pretty big reshuffle take place. The changes are expected to cause hundreds of local stations to significantly scale back or shutter, often in rural places where there isn't any other local news source, Axios reports.
34:35Gary Shteyngart:The White House says the whole system is rigged against them, so they're just rigging it back or making up for that. But the wider context is something that you might only learn about through news, which is a bit of a paradox if local news and other information is being pressed and squeezed, because what we understand about what's happening in our country does inform what we do about it. And this seems to be an effort to use big government to put a thumb on the scale. It's an attack on the First Amendment of the kind that some honest conservatives used to oppose. With that in mind, we've convened a special discussion Acclaimed novelist Gary Steingart has been a critic of Vladimir Putin Donald Trump knows a bit about censorship And is the kind of novelist who writes about sometimes controversial and hard subjects He has the acclaimed novels Absurdistan and Super Sad True Love Story He's a finalist for the National Book Critics Award in 2014 A Times profile notes he's eclipsed many of the supposedly more serious novelists who came of age when he did with that photo, which, quite a photo, Gary.
35:36Gary Shteyngart:I don't know what happened. Looks like you rolled right out of bed. Is that you? That's me. Right on the way to the writing desk. His new novel, Vera or Faith, is about a Korean American girl who grows up in a sort of not-so-distant, future, dystopian, negative America and really captures a childlike perspective in a way that many novels struggle to. As we all know, a lot of books live in the adult world. and guess who's Bazzac as Jay-Z and Scarface once said Geraldo second segment tonight television personality journalist spanning multiple networks if you don't like the media then you must really hate Geraldo because he's worked for them all every big network right every big show and we thought you would also be fitting to talk about this and also bring the perspective of your time of course in what I think were sometimes right of center outlets as well as others Welcome to both of you.
36:28Gary Shteyngart:You guys feel good together? Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. Easy. Gary, let's start with something you've been very vocal about, which is what you learned looking over at the Russian experience, not just Putin, but the history of it. What does that do to art and free speech? Well, it's incredible. I grew up in a system with a lot of censorship. There were very few books you could read from abroad. I remember the one book that I was allowed to read was Mark Twain, Tom Sawyer, but it I had an introduction by one of Stalin's henchmen, which was a very fun introduction. Stalin wanted to purge all the, you know, whatever, Mark Twain, etc.
37:05But I'm very worried about the kind of confluence I see between America and Russia. One thing Russia has always done is create its own. It doesn't just want you not to know the truth, but it tries to create a kind of alternate reality. You mentioned earlier, of course, January 6th and the way Trump continues still to deny that. It also, you know, you think about Kash Patel's children's book, which also turned things upside down, obviously. So it's a very scary time. I mean, the book is set from a point of view of a 10-year-old, and I have an 11-year-old myself. And I think when you grow up in a totalitarian or authoritarian society, it stains you no matter what happens to you later on.
37:47I mean, I still have a sense of distrust, a sense of lack of belief in certain systems, because when you grow up without knowing what the truth is, you spend the rest of your life wondering who you are and how you belong in a society.
38:03Gary Shteyngart:Does that bread cynicism benefit the autocrat more? Absolutely. What's interesting is when I was growing up, I knew all the I was seven, eight years old. I knew all the members of the Politburo by name. You know, the politics were always around you. And my son, he's 11 years old, him and his friends, they talk about Trump all the time and about Trump's henchmen. It's almost like that's the idea is that they become ubiquitous. And that's the only reality, you know, even if you have parents who are saying, OK, this is not great. It's the only world, you know, because it finds its way, just like in the example I mentioned about Kash Patel writing children's literature about it.
38:38It finds its way into everything and it creates its own reality. And that, to me, is very worrisome. While at the same time, of course, censoring books like, for example, Toni Morrison, right, which is something a high schooler would read. But still, denying people the ability to read, you know, the truth about the African-American experience. That, to me, is shocking. And so Soviet at heart.
39:00Gary Shteyngart:And, Geraldo, some people make peace with this by saying it'll happen to them. And maybe they have some outlets they really don't like. but it's happening to Fox News' sister outlet, Wall Street Journal. It's happening to right-wing or conservative voices online or being attacked by the government power of Donald Trump. First of all, I have to say that it's freaking me out that I'm sitting next to the man. I just read an article where he opposes circumcision. So I have to get out of that particular framework. Yeah, please. I tell you one thing. Working for Fox was eye opening, Ari, in many ways, because what I saw were people who earnestly believe their their point of view about the world and public TV, which is alarming, of course, and and and I think will ultimately be harmful to America's right to know stuff.
39:59But when you look at PBS from the point of view of a Fox person, it's clear that PBS is of a certain mindset. And I don't care how liberal you are, how open minded you are or how right wing you are, whatever it is honestly viewed. PBS is an outlet that favors liberalism. Why? Because reporters are optimists. Reporters are, you know, people who have a heart, who want to be involved, the compassionate people. They want to change the world.
40:31Gary Shteyngart:But editorial freedom is going to land somewhere on the spectrum. The question today now is whether both PBS and The Wall Street Journal should be frivolously sued or attacked for that freedom. I am. I refuse to feel sorry for The Wall Street Journal. Why? Because The Wall Street Journal can take care of itself. You know, I'm not asking you to. The Burnax can take care of themselves. I'm not asking you to bake them a cake. You can save that for what he wrote about. But I'm saying that we have to, as both journalists and citizens, and here we have an artist, a writer, confront what's really happening.
41:03Gary Shteyngart:And by the way, if it works well enough, you won't hear about it in 10 years if it goes the other way. Personally, I am feeling very lucky that my former friend, the president of the United States, has not really been angry at me in a way that he manifested it in a public way. I've said things about him even today, earlier in the program. Yeah, you were strong today, but do you worry that he would abuse power against you? I absolutely was worried about it, and he has not in any way, shape, or form communicated to me, even through mutual friends, the Geraldo layoff or anything like that. I get to say what I get to say.
41:43Well, look, one of the things I've been doing in the last couple of weeks is frantically trying to find my certificate of naturalization because I feel I know how this story often works out. I've known friends in Russia who are completely silent on social media and every other mode that they can. There's a Russian term, a Soviet term, called writing into your desk, meaning that you know that what you write is going to offend the authorities, so you write into your desk so nobody else will see it. That's the danger that I think is a danger for any society.
42:13Gary Shteyngart:And it becomes a chilling self-censorship. It becomes a chilling self-censorship. And that's something that I am absolutely worried about. And I know that others are, too. You know, everyone I know who's an immigrant is searching for that. I think you should be. And I think that that therein lies the biggest sin of the Trump administration, how they have victimized a population that is so vulnerable and defamed them, libeled them, you know, made, you know, grotesque caricatures of them. But I still think that I'm glad that you're looking for your certificate of naturalization because I tell people that ask me, be afraid and lawyer up, you know, don't take anything.
42:59Right.
43:00Gary Shteyngart:And it's it's really striking to start with your memory of Soviet Russia and that oppression and hear you again, someone who has those credentials across the press, including Fox, join that concern. Before we go, I want to mention the book. You know, the Washington Post had this turn of phrase about another one of your great novels here. And I happen to be a reader and a fan of many of them. Thank you. That you allow us to feel the toothache under the laughter. Yeah, thank you. That's very sweet. So in this book, Vera, the title character, she is 10 years old, but she's growing up in a system where there's a constitutional amendment that gives certain people who are exceptional five-thirds of the vote.
43:36and they are people who can trace their heritage to the Revolutionary War. This book came out July 8th. July 9th, J.D. Vance gave a speech saying people who can trace their heritage to the Revolutionary War are exceptional Americans. He's not yet saying that he's going to give them five-thirds of a vote, but it's incredible. Usually, when I write dystopian fiction, it's set 10 years ahead. This took one day for it to come true. I know Usha Vance is a huge reader, so maybe it's a short book. Maybe she sped read through it and said, hey, J.D., I have an idea. You know, let's make them exceptional Americans.
44:07But the whole problem here is, and this has been the problem in America for a long time, is the way certain Americans are more American than others. That's why I wrote this book, because I have a son, and I want him to be, you know, respected for who he is, not based on where he can trace his heritage to. And that's, I think, what this whole administration is doing.
44:26Gary Shteyngart:Yeah, and I have 30 seconds voicing a child character with full complexity. How do you do it? You've got to have children. I never thought I'd have a kid. And I used to not like them, but now I really, really like them. How about that? There's such a great return on investment with kids because they say the most amazing things. I used to think kids were stupid, but they're really not. And now I find them much more interesting than a lot of my friends. So it's basically your kid is how you did it. Well, in a way, I also, I mean, it's not him. He's a boy. This character is a girl. But listening to some of his friends, especially the girls, girls mature much earlier.
44:59So there's more of a kind of emotional well to draw from. and also the book is a little bit about New York's educational system because it takes place here and as a survivor of Stuyvesant, I can talk about that.
45:10Gary Shteyngart:You've had several hits. When are you going to have a clunker? I feel like you've had several hit books in a row. I'm ready. I'm ready for it. I want to fail. I've got to figure this out. Failure. Well, hold on. You are known to some as little failure. Yes, my mom's nickname for me growing up. That tells us a lot. Gary Haraldo, thanks. The novel again. And in our faith, we'll be right back. That's hilarious. Thanks for spending time with us. Hi, I'm Angie Hicks, co-founder of Angie. And one thing I've learned is that you buy a house, but you make it a home. Because with every fix, update, and renovation, it becomes a little more your own.
45:48So you need all your jobs done well. For nearly 30 years, Angie has helped millions of homeowners hire skilled pros for the projects that matter. From plumbing to electrical, roof repair to deck upgrades. So leave it to the pros who will get your jobs done well. Angie, the one you trust to find the ones you trust. Find a pro for your project at Angie.com.
From the publisher
MSNBC's Ari Melber hosts "The Beat" on Wednesday, July 30, and reports on the Epstein scandal spiraling out of President Trump's control, increasing backlash to Trump's power grabs and Trump's escalating attacks on free speech. Gary Shteyngart, Geraldo Rivera and Asha Rangappa join. To listen to this show and other MS podcasts without ads, sign up for MS
NOW Premium on Apple Podcasts.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See https://pcm.adswizz.com
for information about our collection and use of personal data for
advertising.
