In short
The episode covers the House passage of a Trump spending/budget bill after a “bruising battle,” with Democrats unable to stop it. Topic: the bill’s impact on health care and Medicaid/Medicare, the narrow GOP margins, and the political messaging around it ahead of the 2026 midterms; plus a later segment on DOJ pressure on election workers and a cultural segment on comedy/cancel culture.
Key claims
CBO estimates the bill adds $3T+ to the deficit, cuts over $1T from healthcare/Medicaid, and could boot 10–12 million from coverage; Democrats argue it breaks Trump’s vow not to cut Medicaid/Medicare/Social Security.
Notable examples
Hakeem Jeffries’ record 8+ hour House speech; two GOP defections; parliamentarian stripping; GOP “Lazy Gamer”/“welfare queen” style defenses.
Guests
Douglas Brinkley (Rice professor, presidential historian, Pulitzer-winning columnist) and Eugene Robinson (Pulitzer Prize-winning columnist). Later guest: Melissa Murray (NYU Law professor). Final interview: Larry Charles (creator/producer; Curb Your Enthusiasm, directed Borat/Bruno; memoir Comedy Samurai).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOTrump's Budget Battle Overview
0:11 to 1:00
Explore the contentious passage of Trump's budget bill and its implications.
“John Fugelsang calls Live Laugh Love a brilliant, infuriating, inspiring read for anyone who wants to understand modern Christianity.”
Trump's Budget Battle Overview
1:30 to 5:00
Explore the contentious passage of Trump's budget bill and its implications.
“Trump and Republicans are celebrating however tough this was, longer, slower, more defections than they wanted.”
Hakeem Jeffries' Historic Speech
5:00 to 10:00
Discussion of Hakeem Jeffries' record-breaking speech and its impact.
“And we're joined by Douglas Brinkley, presidential historian, Rice University professor and Pulitzer Prize winning columnist Eugene Robinson.”
Political Maneuvering and Outcomes
10:00 to 12:30
Analysis of the political strategies and outcomes of the budget bill passage.
“But legislatively, he's done that approach.”
Consequences of the Budget Cuts
12:30 to 14:00
Examine the expected consequences of the budget cuts on social programs.
“after-school programs, going after, you know, so-called food stamp programs, as they used to be called.”
Initial Reactions to Budget Discussions
14:00 to 14:29
The hosts discuss the initial reactions to the ongoing budget discussions.
“It's an astonishing thing to see, but that's what they're attempting.”
Initial Reactions to Budget Discussions
15:25 to 16:27
The hosts discuss the initial reactions to the ongoing budget discussions.
“I was diagnosed with ankylosing spondylitis, which caused back pain and stiffness every day.”
Democratic Pushback Against Trump Budget
16:34 to 19:06
Analysis of the Democrats' strong opposition to the Trump budget and its implications.
“House Democrats are a hell no on this legislation.”
Discussion on Messaging and Strategy
19:06 to 23:40
Experts discuss the need for effective messaging from Democrats in light of the budget cuts.
“Walk around any town in America, big, large, red, blue.”
Upcoming Guests and Topics
23:40 to 24:26
Preview of upcoming guests and discussions related to the implications of the current political climate.
“We are on the case with the professor, and by the end of the hour, the creative mind behind Curb and Seinfeld is here.”
Show all 20 chapters
Upcoming Guests and Topics
24:28 to 24:59
Preview of upcoming guests and discussions related to the implications of the current political climate.
“Kristen Kobes Dume's new book, Live, Laugh, Love, The Secret History of White Christian Women and the World They Made.”
Concerns About Election Integrity
26:29 to 28:00
Discussion on the potential threats to election integrity and democracy in the current political landscape.
“One question that hangs over the entire MAGA period that we're in is whether the usual checks on power in our democracy will still hold.”
Manipulation of Elections and Political Intimidation
28:00 to 31:10
Discussion on Trump's tactics to influence elections and intimidate opposition.
“If Trump and his allied Republican Party were to be on a path to losing or actually lose, there is evidence they want to abuse power to pull off what they failed to do in 2020, steal the result.”
Legal Challenges and Weaponization of the DOJ
31:10 to 34:20
Insight into the DOJ's actions and the implications for democracy.
“We're back with NYU Law Professor Melissa Murray as the Justice Department goes all in on efforts to apparently intimidate or threaten elections officials who were one of the front lines we remember from 2020.”
Supreme Court and Executive Power
34:20 to 36:20
Analysis of the Supreme Court's role in curbing executive power.
“No longer will we have rogue judges striking down President Trump's policies across the entire nation.”
Comedy's Role in Politics and Social Commentary
36:20 to 39:50
Exploration of how comedy addresses serious social issues through humor.
“could you share a life, a home, a marriage with someone with opposing political views?”
Larry Charles on Humor and Cultural Conversations
39:50 to 42:05
Larry Charles discusses his experiences in comedy and its impact on culture.
“Comedy Samurai, 40 Years of Blood, Guts, and Laughter and he returns now to the beat with the stories to tell.”
Reflections on Comedy and Career
42:05 to 44:13
Explore insights on comedy, career challenges, and personal growth from a seasoned comedian.
“You got a picture of Bush in your dressing room?”
Key Lessons for Aspiring Comedians
44:13 to 45:20
Learn the essential elements of starting a comedy career and the importance of instinct and resilience.
“I'm going to try to have you finish a couple sentences, and then we'll let you get out of here.”
Reflections on Comedy and Career
45:27 to 46:30
Explore insights on comedy, career challenges, and personal growth from a seasoned comedian.
“The book is Comedy Samurai, 40 Years of Blood, Guts, and Laughter.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Sponsored by Live Right, publishers of New York Times bestselling author Kristen Kobes Dume's new book, Live Laugh Love, The Secret History of White Christian Women and the World They Made. Dume uncovers the roots of today's Instagram-ready culture of white Christian femininity. John Fugelsang calls Live Laugh Love a brilliant, infuriating, inspiring read for anyone who wants to understand modern Christianity. And Dume, one of our boldest historians and finest writers of nonfiction. Live, Laugh, Love. Available now.
0:58Offer not available in all states. Terms of plaque. See Fanatics app for details. Welcome to The Beat. We begin on Capitol Hill. We're House Republicans. After some defections have passed Trump's spending bill. This is that big budget clash we've been following. It heads to the president's desk, where Donald Trump will be signing it into law tomorrow. We have the nonpartisan estimates here. The CBO says the bill adds$3 trillion plus the deficit. It'll slash over a trillion from healthcare and Medicaid. 10 to 12 million Americans ultimately could be booted off their health coverage. Funnels a lot of money to ICE and border enforcement, 100B over there.
1:32Trump and Republicans are celebrating however tough this was, longer, slower, more defections than they wanted. Ultimately, as they say, a win is a win. They set out to pass this thing. They lost some votes along the way. They even had some parts of it stripped by the parliamentarian. But they won passage today. Not without a fight. House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries was on a war path discussing the risks and the problems in the bill. and doing what Democrats have done increasingly in the second Trump term, which is find different ways, sometimes symbolic, sometimes even physical, to get up and show that they're fighting and to command some attention, even against Donald Trump, whose entire skill set is PR and attention.
2:16You're looking at some of the thunderous applause there as he continued on the record-breaking speech, eight hour plus, the longest speech in the history of the United States House. This began around 5 a.m. this morning.
2:55Next November, extraordinary levels of corruption. Got some folks in this town, they go to church and they pray on Sunday. P-R-A-Y. Say it. Say the truth. And then they come to Congress and pray P-R-E-Y on the American people. I'm not down with that kind of faith. No matter what the outcome is on this singular day. Say it. What the hell? Fight forward. We're going to press on. Say it. Press on for the rule of law. Press on for the American way of life. Press on for democracy. We're going to press on until victory is won. I yield back. I yielded, but only after breaking the record. That marathon address went down pretty well, considering the Democrats are losing the budget battle here, which is expected.
3:50They don't have the same number of votes as Republicans. Some congressional math is just that. But you see here, Leader Jeffrey's flanked by Democratic colleagues who seemed genuinely energized. Yes, politics is full of show, but you see here, there was some real enthusiasm today about waging this battle any which way they could. The Democrats did not have the votes to stop the bill. There is no magic strength or strategy that was gonna change that. It was only a question of whether Republicans were going to lose enough of their own. And they lost some in the Senate and ultimately two in the House.
4:26Now, Jeffrey's intention was to force Republicans to also vote in the daytime Politico reports, using, again, the procedural levers they have to not stop the bill, but make sure that this still landed in the daylight with so many Republicans who are worried this is the kind of vote that might cost them their jobs if enough constituents realize what it does and what it does to health care, etc. The bill ultimately passing by four votes with, as mentioned, those two Republican defections. That is how we end the week going into American Independence Day weekend. And we're joined by Douglas Brinkley, presidential historian, Rice University professor and Pulitzer Prize winning columnist Eugene Robinson.
5:08Gene, your thoughts on what is now the ending of this round, the budget plan going to the White House tomorrow. Well, look, this ended the way I always thought it would end in terms of the legislation being passed. The Republicans do have the majority in the Senate and the House. And Donald Trump wanted this bill passed, this big bill. It is big. And so it was going to pass. I mean, that was going to happen. The unexpected note was Hakeem Jeffries' speech. His eight-hour-plus speech was an extraordinary thing in the House. And it certainly did serve to cause this vote to be held in the daylight and to bring attention on the fact that these majorities are very narrow in both the Senate and the House that Republicans have.
6:10And this is a deeply unpopular bill. When people learn what's in it, they don't like it at all. And so to that extent, to the extent it was possible for Democrats to be successful today, they were successful. They were not able to stop the passage of this legislation that they believe and I believe is going to hurt a lot of people. Mm-hmm. Professor Brinkley? You know, 218 Republicans, 214 Democrats, as Eugene's pointing out. It's close. And that's what the next election is going to be all about. This is the opening tomorrow opens the election for 2026. There's just no doubt about it. there were shocks this week or tension-filled moments.
6:56I thought perhaps Lisa Murkowski on the heels of a book coming out and the press she was getting have stood up to President Trump in a Profiles in Courage. I was at the JFK Library this year. They gave Profile in Courage award to Mike Pence. I thought Murkowski would be that person. But in the end, the fossil fuel industry controls her out of Alaska, and she didn't want to mess with them, and she didn't want to be the bane of all of the disdain from the MAGA world. So she folded her tent. And at that point, I had seen a foregone conclusion that it would get through Congress. I will say Mike Johnson seems to be delivering on what he needs to do.
7:38He did a prayer session. He huddled. Donald Trump then went and got on the phone and they did what they needed to do to get this passed. But Johnson is now a significant speaker pulling this off. Yeah, you mentioned that. I'm curious, Gene, because you followed this over so many eras. It does seem that the White House operation has learned over time that they are using the president's time and advocacy strategically, as Doug Brinkley just mentioned, that there are many extreme radical and indeed, according to many courts, unlawful activities by this White House. We actually cover that in the news frequently.
8:21But there's also a learning curve on this process, which, however controversial, is not illegal. This is not the abuse of federal forces or some other controversy we've covered. And it seems that in comparison to term one, they are more organized. And from what we can tell, the president is more engaged when called upon to deal with legislating something he's never shown a great personal interest in. Yeah, they have definitely learned, and they have learned when the president should engage directly with members of the House or the Senate. He's clearly learned how to do that. He's learned what buttons to push.
9:02They used both carrots and sticks. It was a lot of carrots with Murkowski, a lot of benefits for Alaska, A lot of sticks with some others. And they've learned that there are a few votes that they can just sort of write off. They weren't going to get Rand Paul on the Senate. They, you know, they're not going to get Massey. Massey is always going to be a problem in the House. But they've learned a lot. And I agree with Doug. You have to say Mike Johnson is a much, much more effective Speaker of the House than certainly I expected him to be. And then I think almost everyone expected him to be. He is getting results.
9:46The president wants it passed. He gets it passed. Yeah, and he's proven to be a little bit like Bruce Lee, where you have to be water first. Some people criticize that and say, oh, you have no firm position. I don't know what you think about anything. We can have that debate. But legislatively, he's done that approach. And that's different than McCarthy was in these spats. They may not have been of his choosing, but he couldn't get out from under them. He was in public open warfare with what were admittedly difficult members of the caucus. Matt Gaetz no longer there. But he and Boehner and Paul Ryan before them would have these rolling public battles with those flanks.
10:25And Johnson, partly because you don't, I say it not with any disrespect, deliberately not trashing him. But you don't really know where he is on these things. And then sooner or later, he tries to land the plane. It's sort of the job. I mean, that's what LBJ did on a very different legislative agenda, one for civil rights and a fair deal. Our guest today, I want to point out on the substance, we talked about the maneuvering, but this cuts this budget. A trillion dollars out of Medicaid,$150 billion from Medicare and Obamacare. 10 to 12 million people booted off coverage. And that is a direct, obvious breaking of Donald Trump's vow, meaning what he said before, if he knew he was going to do this, were outright lies, including to his own supporters.
11:14Can you guarantee that Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security will not be touched? Yeah, I mean, I have said it so many times, we're not going to touch it. We will not cut Social Security, Medicare, or Medicaid benefits. We're not cutting Medicaid, we're not cutting Medicare, and we're not cutting Social Security. So what do I tell 663 ,000 people in two years or three years? when President Trump breaks his promise by pushing them off of Medicaid. The last voice, one of the Republican defectors, Doug Brinkley, it's very clear there that Donald Trump's mastery of PR and politics is these are widely unpopular plans, including on the right.
11:56So he broke a promise or was lying the whole time. How important is that as we live in an era where people want to retreat to their own spin or facts. But the fact is he broke that vow. It's going to matter when people get hurt. You know, all economies go up and down and it's going to depend Donald Trump's fate or the fate of 2026 of what our economy does. But what's shocking to me is that Trump is the one carrying out the sledgehammer to the great society of Lyndon Johnson, going after, really, Medicaid, Medicare, PBS, NPR, Wild and Scenic Rivers, you know, after-school programs, going after, you know, so-called food stamp programs, as they used to be called.
12:42He's the one. He's the Avenger. And that he's pulling off, it's really quite stunning. I'm not quite sure Trump has the gall to really go after the FDR heirlooms, to go after Social Security and a lot of what FDR did was infrastructure of that time also. But boy, are they trying to dismantle what LBJ did because the right in America feels Johnson got those Senate votes, congressional votes out of 64 and just signed, signed, signed things. And now they want to undo it. So this is a big U-turn in American history that just took place. Trump going backwards in time and trying to negate many of LBJ's accomplishments.
13:28Okay. Yeah, including civil rights, including on the premise of the civil rights legislation that Lyndon Johnson got through. You know, we've seen continued weakening of the Civil Rights Act, the Voting Rights Act, Certainly, there's apparently no enforcement contemplated of the Voting Rights Act going forward by Trump. So, yes, it is an attempt to negate the Great Society and civil rights accomplishments of LBJ. It's an astonishing thing to see, but that's what they're attempting. And we'll see how long they get away with it. Yeah. Both of you are staying with us. This is one of those days where we're tracking through what happened on the Hill.
14:22But we have a lot more coming up. Doug Brinkley, Gene Robinson, we're back together in 90 seconds. Sponsored by Live Right, publishers of New York Times bestselling author Kristen Kobes Dume's new book, Live, Laugh, Love, The Secret History of White Christian Women and the World They Made. Dume uncovers the roots of today's Instagram-ready culture of white Christian femininity. John Fugelsang calls Live, Laugh, Love a brilliant, infuriating, inspiring read for anyone who wants to understand modern Christianity. And Dume, one of our boldest historians and finest writers of nonfiction. Live, Laugh, Love.
14:59Available now. Every bet you place on Fanatic Sportsbook earns fan cash. Win, lose, or push. Plus, new customers can bet and get up to$1 ,000 in fan cash. Fanatics, the only sportsbook to reward every bet. Must be 21 plus. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or 1-800-MIG-IN-SEC. CT, call 888-789-7777. MA, call 800-327-5050. NY, call 877-8HOPE-NY. MD, visit mdgamblinghelp.org. Based on leading U.S. sportsbook analysis July 2026. Offer not available in all states. Terms apply. See Fanatic's app for details. Hey there, I'm Kat. I'm a college athlete. I was diagnosed with ankylosing spondylitis, which caused back pain and stiffness every day.
15:40With Cosentix, I'm able to stay active. Cosentix Secukinumab is prescribed for adults with active psoriatic arthritis, ankylosing spondylitis, or non-radiographic axial spondyloarthritis. available in both IV infusion and self-injection. Don't use if allergic to Cosentix. Get checked for TB before starting. Increased risk of infections and lowered ability to fight them may occur, like TB or other serious bacterial, fungal, or viral infections. Some were fatal. Tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms like fevers, sweats, chills, muscle aches, or cough, had a vaccine or planned to, or if IBD symptoms develop or worsen.
16:16Serious allergic reactions and severe eczema-like skin reactions may occur. Learn more at 1-844-COSENTICS or cosentics.com. Move and feel better. Ask a rheumatologist about Cosentics.
16:34House Democrats are a hell no on this legislation. We were a hell no last week, a hell no this week, a hell no yesterday a hell no today that's like five hells and five no's uh leader jeffrey's there on that war path uh the speech was literally historic and that like cory booker before him the democrats here have used these moments to break records longest house speech ever targeting the trump budget democrats do think it'll be a big issue in the midterms and the writing is on the wall with how many republicans are already publicly saying they're going to lose over this. Now, as part of their defense, Republicans have tried to basically convince 10 million plus people that they're not necessarily going to be affected.
17:25That's the lie. Or that only bad people, lazy people will somehow be affected by these health coverage cuts. Take a look. They shouldn't be going to a 29-year-old guy who's living in his mom's basement, choosing not to work. They're living in their mom's basement, playing video games. I'm sorry, you got to go get job. Not for 29-year-old males sitting on their couches playing video games. The able-bodied person I'm talking about is the 25-year-old who's sitting on his couch playing Xbox. Who knew there were this many millions of 20-something disaffected men playing video games, always in a basement?
18:02Nobody ever plays like on the first or second floor with a window? This is obviously what is called a talking point. It's one of the many reasons that people get so annoyed with politics, because you're trying to maybe listen for a second and see what the explanation or the defense is to this very controversial plan, which, by the way, violates what Donald Trump vowed and pledged over and over, what we showed you earlier, that he wouldn't cut Medicaid, but he is. And then everybody gets up with the same talking point, which is designed not to explain or to govern, but to obfuscate and to spin.
18:34There simply aren't enough 30-year-old dudes, 29-year-old dudes, 28-year-old dudes in the basement to cover all these cuts. But there is a larger pattern here. Reagan talked about, quote, welfare queens. MAGA has updated it with Lazy Gamer. Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan talked a lot about how virtually half the country, 47%, were just taking. Whereas if you're listening to these kind of right-wing attacks and then you think about your own life and all the people in your community who are working so hard at regular jobs, retail, restaurants, buses, public service, nurses, teachers. Walk around any town in America, big, large, red, blue.
19:19This stuff doesn't really make sense. Sure, there are some people on the margins of society. Some of them might need help and might need public assistance, but there ain't 10 million plus people sucking off the proverbial teat of Medicaid because they are in their mom's basement playing Xbox. With that in mind, I want to bring back Doug Brinkley and Gene Robinson. Gene, your thoughts on this sort of updated version of the famed welfare queen. Right. So it was bad when Reagan did it. It was inaccurate. It was a misrepresentation of reality. It's much worse now because our society has become so much more unequal.
20:04These are people who are working. The vast majority of people who receive Medicaid benefits, who are not senior citizens in nursing homes, the vast majority of able-bodied working age people on Medicaid are working. They're just working either for a minimum wage, which our Congress refuses to increase to a living wage or something near that. And they simply don't have enough money to afford to live in this country. I mean, that's just the reality. And people know that. People see it around them. People experience it. So that is not going to ring true, I think, with the Republican constituency the way it did in Reagan's day, simply because it's much less true now.
21:00Doug? yeah you know i would think back um to you know newt gingrich's contract with america where some of this all really began and the republicans have uh professionalized their messaging and we talk in terms of mago or even you know i have no other way to call it but the big very big bill you know and their language um you don't have um you know the you know alcatraz you know alligator alcatraz I think Democrats have to start sloganeering. They've got to like get their messaging down. It's great to make the history books for the longest speech, but you've just got to do that, you know, kind of like AOC does when she's on Instagram, those quick hits that move things and talk things.
21:45And then you have to ask who really just got hurt. Who's getting hurt the most by this? And I think rural America has taken a big hit. A lot of MAGA rural towns that we just to rep with, they're already having poor, there are no doctors, there are not enough nurses, there's no access. Trump just, in my mind, threw rural America, you know, under a bus in favor of these big corporate entities or people that are his donors. And so the Democrats have to really get out there like Andy Beshear does in Kentucky, a red state, and talk about the need of public education at local schools, health care, and bring it home.
22:26And don't say a red or blue state. We're on our 4th of July here. They're all American states. Democrats should engage in Iowa. They should engage in New Hampshire, Nevada, and anywhere and everywhere. Less pollsters, less DNC bigwigs, and just a little bit more of I love America common sense and get into the back roads of America and talk about what this has just done and then use optimistic phrasing like Theodore Roosevelt or FDR would do about the better days are coming. Bill Clinton, you know, the man from hope, you know, Barack Obama, you know, yes, we can. People are moved by optimism, not just fear.
23:08And the failure, I think, of the Biden years was the believing that you just preach fear, democracy's dead, and that will bring people out, and you have to deal with the future. Yeah, Bill Clinton and Obama both talked about hope. As you say, Clinton's 92 campaign song, Don't Stop Thinking About Tomorrow, a banger. But to your point, one that said, hey, our better days might still yet be ahead. Fitting thoughts here as we inch towards America's birthday. Doug Brinkley and Gene Robinson, thanks to both of you. Thank you, Murray. Appreciate it. We have Professor Melissa Murray coming up Because we are watching scrutinizing, and sometimes that helps hold the line as the DOJ takes Donald Trump's discredited failed efforts to overturn the 2020 election and now wants to threaten election workers with indictments which could interfere with our future elections.
24:01We are on the case with the professor, and by the end of the hour, the creative mind behind Curb and Seinfeld is here. This case has been turned over to our library investigations officer, Mr. Bookman. Bookman? The library investigator's name is actually Bookman. It's true. That's amazing. That's like an ice cream man named Cone.
24:26Sponsored by Live Right, publishers of New York Times bestselling author Kristen Kobes Dume's new book, Live, Laugh, Love, The Secret History of White Christian Women and the World They Made. Dume uncovers the roots of today's Instagram-ready culture of white Christian femininity. John Fugelsang calls Live, Laugh, Love a brilliant, infuriating, inspiring read for anyone who wants to understand modern Christianity. And Du May, one of our boldest historians and finest writers of nonfiction. Live, Laugh, Love. Available now. Three o 'clock. Kids are home. Your to-do list isn't done. New Kraft Mac and Cheese Power Mac was made for days like this.
25:06Kraft Mac and Cheese Power Mac packs the same irresistible, creamy, cheesy flavor you love, now with 17 grams of protein and 6 grams of fiber. Fuels you up, keeps you going, because your day doesn't stop. Kraft Mac and Cheese Power Mac. Find it at your favorite retailer. The best thing ever keeps getting better. Join me, Cindy Lauper, with Chef Michelle Bernstein and Dr. Panico to talk about psoriasis and psoriatic arthritis, the potential connection and risk of developing permanent joint damage. Cosentix secukinumab is prescribed for adults with moderate to severe plaque psoriasis 300 mg dose and adults with active psoriatic arthritis 150 mg dose.
25:51Don't use if you're allergic to Cosentix. Before starting, get checked for tuberculosis. An increased risk of infections and lowered ability to fight them may occur, like tuberculosis or other serious bacterial, fungal, or viral infections. Some are fatal. Tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms like fevers, sweats, chills, muscle aches, or cough, had a vaccine or planned to, or if inflammatory bowel disease symptoms develop or worsen. Serious allergic reactions and severe eczema-like skin reactions may occur. Learn more at 1-844-COSENTICS or cosentics.com slash Cindy.
26:29One question that hangs over the entire MAGA period that we're in is whether the usual checks on power in our democracy will still hold. We hear about the Medicaid cuts backfrying on Republicans in the next election, but that means there will be a free and fair election, which is not a guarantee nowadays. Nowadays, we have a president who pardoned people who staged an insurrection to overthrow an election, attacking police and who fomented it and who pushed false voter fraud claims. One of the lines against that that held in 2020 was election workers and courts not succumbing to pressure, threats of violence or even an outgoing president with all of his assembled powers, which when you think about it is really something.
27:14Fast forward to today, and that individual, Donald Trump, now in office, has a Justice Department that is exploring ways to charge election officials, state or local, if the feds under Trump determine that they want to. They have excuses about computer systems and other sourcing about this, but let's remember, we're talking about the people who lost the election and wanted to have the alternate outcome, meaning steal it. so their references to computers or anything else can't be taken that seriously. And the move is not based on new evidence data or legal authority, the reporting notes, but the actually unsubstantiated argument that elections are easy to prey on with voter fraud or foreign manipulation.
27:56Again, this is a smokescreen. Everybody understands what's going on. If Trump and his allied Republican Party were to be on a path to losing or actually lose, there is evidence they want to abuse power to pull off what they failed to do in 2020, steal the result. This is an attempt to manipulate elections. And as always, the Orwellian propaganda is to hide behind terms like safe and secure voter fraud when, again, we all live through 2020. You can divide American politics between the people who understand the actual result of that election and the people who don't or won't. The Times reports that sources have referred to how lawyers are struggling to even find a criminal statute that would match Trump's demands.
Read the full transcript
28:41And this is a pattern, weaponizing different parts of the government and the DOJ to turn everything upside down or the law enforcement agencies become a handmaiden to lawbreaking. Trump is also attacking one of these new Democrats who's been a rising star pretty quickly, New York City's Democratic nominee for mayor, Zoran Mamdani, threatening to arrest him if he obstructs ICE from arresting immigrants in the city. And there's been high-profile targeting of Democratic officials. Congresswoman McIver faces these criminal charges for that unusual kind of scuffle clash outside of an ICE facility where she says she was doing oversight as a member of Congress.
29:21And we've spoken with her and some of these other Democrats facing what many view and legal experts say is the abuse of prosecutorial powers against the opposition party. Do you view it as excessive force or an effort to intimidate the opposition party? Look, personally, I think it was excessive, but that's a tone and approach that this administration has chosen to take. They'll go to any extent, especially any extent of cruelty, to make an example. And I am that example. This is clearly being driven by a desire to do what was said earlier, to hurt people, to embarrass people, to humiliate folks.
29:59And they'll go further than that if they can. They'll go further than that, and they have these probes open. Some have fallen apart. Charges dropped against Baraka, as you see there. Others seem like a long-term effort to make noise without actually going through with it. James Comey in the middle has been a formidable figure. A lot of people in law enforcement would be disturbed by a fake case against him, but he's under a at least open probe. For an Instagram post about seashells on the beach, it's a whole thing, a whole pile of nothing. And other individuals that you see on there are targeted.
30:33people said, what happens when we pass the line? Well, in some of those cases, we're past it. And now they're laundering and discussing plans to go after the election officials who last time stopped their effort to steal an election they lost. We are here in the red zone, whether we want to be or not, whether we're busy with summer plans or not. Scrutiny, democracy, a free press, these things go hand in hand to protect our democracy. Professor Murray is here on that exact quest. Next.
31:11We're back with NYU Law Professor Melissa Murray as the Justice Department goes all in on efforts to apparently intimidate or threaten elections officials who were one of the front lines we remember from 2020. Your view of this New York Times reporting, Professor? Well, again, I think this is very much aligned with the efforts to weaponize not only the institutions of government, but the DOJ itself in the service of this administration. But I think this is about a bigger project, fueling distrust in democratic institutions. As you mentioned in the report, it's very unlikely that they're going to be able to find a statutory hook to do this, even if they did have a statutory hook that would allow them to indict individuals for not safeguarding elections appropriately.
31:58They don't really have the manpower right now in the Voting Rights Division to be able to do that. Lawyers have left in record numbers since this administration started. So what this really suggests is that this is about the public, about fueling distrust in our democratic institutions among the public so that if in the midterms there is a massive democratic victory, they can just say that this has been stolen, this is fake, just like they did on January 6, 2021. And we're seeing the same kind of thing with this administration's response to the courts, this idea that we are going to sue the entire district of Maryland on the view that lower court judges are somehow acting outside of the scope of their authority and should not be trusted.
32:47Yeah, you mentioned that. Here's the headline on that. This lawsuit against Maryland judges viewed by many as an ominous message was a judge's attempt to preserve due process for those challenging deportations. It's a different it's a different war path. And by going forward on some, not all, but some cases like the congresswoman that we showed before we came to you, that's clearly going to affect people. Not everyone wants to spend several years in these kind of draining, expensive fights, and not every institution will stand by the people who do. That's a great point. These lawsuits likely will not work out in favor of the administration, but they are draining, they are resource consumptive.
33:33And more importantly, in this moment where the administration has cracked down on law firms, forced law firms into settling with it, the term that the president has used, it means that legal resources that are available to represent individuals pro bono have really dwindled. So this entire landscape has been changed at a time when the administration is also weaponizing the rule of law in important ways. So all of that, I think, has to be understood. This is all happening as part of a coherent project, not isolated episodes. You've been providing your legal take on a recent Supreme Court ruling.
34:11Here's what the White House press secretary thinks about it. Well, I think taking power away from these absolutely crazy radical left judges is a tremendous. This is such a big day. No longer will we have rogue judges striking down President Trump's policies across the entire nation. Not one district court judge can think they're an emperor over this administration, his executive powers. I should say the attorney general and the president, not the press secretary. But both of them thrilled with a result that a while back you wouldn't have expected you'd ever get. What does it tell you that Donald Trump's extreme, some people call it maximalism, has slowly been embraced by the MAGA wing of the Supreme Court?
35:02Well, again, it's really important to talk about this on the eve of the 4th of July. The framers of our Constitution did not understand the office of the executive to be one of unfettered authority. The president had powers, but it was also an institution that was going to be checked by two other institutions, the judiciary and Congress. You know, right now we know that Congress has pretty much abdicated the field in terms of being a meaningful check on this precedent. That has left the courts. And these lower federal court judges have been doing that. They've been issuing these injustices. They're very narrow rulings.
35:35Many of them have been issued by judges that were appointed by Republican presidents and by this president himself in his first term. So the idea that these are rogue judges who are lawless and leftist is just not the case. These are judges who are following the law, following the Constitution. And both the law and the Constitution says the president can't dismantle a federal agency without congressional intervention. The president cannot simply fire everyone without some kind of congressional intervention. So they're doing their jobs. And this kind of rhetoric is just fueling distrust of all of these institutions.
36:12Yeah. Professor Murray, as you said, important on the eve of the holiday. Thank you so much. I'll tell folks that coming up, we are going to look at something that combines the question, could you share a life, a home, a marriage with someone with opposing political views? And what can we learn, even in sometimes dark times, from political comedy and the genius mind behind Curb, Seinfeld, and Borat? You try to sell me old things. You think I am stupid just because I am fine? No, sir. This is an antique. This is an antique shop. Do you think, you know, when they...
36:58I'm sorry.
37:03My friend, he can make a glue. I don't think you're going to be able to glue that stuff back.
37:13Social media is a huge part of our politics and lives, whether we like it or not. It has supercharged this canceling craze, partly because the people run these internet companies to profit off of your outrage or what they call rage bait. And it spreads supposed outrage that really might have died down in other eras. Now the calls to cancel people and entertainers have brought their own backlash with conservatives tapping their own round of outrage for the outrage that allegedly went too far. And maybe all this outrage fatigue can bring us back to a simpler time when jokes were just jokes. And skilled comics knew how to mock something possibly sensitive, say, straight men wanting people to know they're straight, while also ensuring they don't want anyone to think they're homophobic.
38:00That is actually the politically tinged storyline from a Seinfeld episode so iconic, it still goes viral as an internet meme and is quoted 31 years later. Not that there's anything wrong with that. Jerry, did you wash this pill? Yeah, I washed it. It looks like it hasn't been washed. So wash it. You hear the way he talks to me?
38:32You should hear how my boyfriend talks to me. What? We're not gay. Not that there's anything wrong with that. No, of course not. I mean, it's fine if that's who you are. Absolutely. I mean, I have many gay friends. My father's gay. That line and theme echoes now, even as creatives say it can actually be harder to get even well-intentioned material greenlit in Hollywood. Seinfeld, of course, was led by Jerry Seinfeld, Larry David, and Larry Charles, one of the show's original producers who wrote that very episode, oversaw story, production, advanced that same comic universe in a way, with seven years executive producing and writing Curb Your Enthusiasm, then directing two groundbreaking Sacha Baron Cohen films, Bruno and Borat, which tested the limits of comedy and decorum, deploying humor to raise hard questions about nationalism, hate, and, as you see in this shot, anti-Semitism, including how easy it was in that partly real movie to invite or provoke seemingly everyday Americans to share virulent hate and stereotypes about Jews just as Bruno explored the casual bigotry against a host of targets.
39:40Larry Charles has been driving some of these vital conversations in culture and politics for four decades. He certainly has stories and he's rounded them up in a brand new memoir, Comedy Samurai, 40 Years of Blood, Guts, and Laughter and he returns now to the beat with the stories to tell. Thanks for being here. Oh, my pleasure. Thanks. Great to see you again. Great to have you back. Thank you. We'll get to the book, but you look at what you play with there in that show episode that's still quoted about, hey, now there's anything wrong with that. In what I mentioned in Borat, you have, oh, how easy it was to scratch the surface and find all sorts of hatred.
40:18Yes. And you do it through humor. Tell us about that. Well, first of all, you talked about cancel culture and these things. Here are things that are 30 years old that still resonate today. Why is that? Because the audience has a need. They didn't even know they had that need. And this show, like Seinfeld, like Borat, taps into a need the audience wasn't even aware of and suddenly gives them the catharsis that laughter can bring. You and Sacha Baron Cohen are Jews, not that we're making a list. Right. There's a whole bunch of Jews involved in all this stuff. All these Jews. Yes. For better or for worse.
40:50What Sacha Baron Cohen explored then, and I don't know how it would go if you tried to make Borat today. Right. Was that you can find anti-Semitism really quickly in a lot of America. Well, you could find hate and anger everywhere. Yeah. And it's really under the surface and it takes very little scratching to bring it to the surface. Bruno, another movie we made, really pointed out how much homophobia exists in the world and in this country particularly. And it was a much darker movie as a result of that because people felt more comfortable getting physical with Bruno. With Borat, there was kind of a, even though he's an anti-Semite, a rapist, a misogynist, incestuous, all these things, there was a tolerance for him.
41:32There was an innocence about him that gave people, gave him a little more slack. Bruno being flamboyantly gay, people immediately felt okay jostling him, hitting him. Politics. Okay. People love this episode, which at the time, Larry seemed maybe he was overly partisan. Mm-hmm. But by now, I don't think this would be unusual among MAGA faithful or liberal Democratic faithful. Right. When he finds out a woman he really liked is, by the way, not an extreme MAGA, but just, I believe, a Bush Republican. Yes. Let's take a look. Yes. What's that? What? What's that? What? Is that Bush? Yeah.
42:18You got a picture of Bush in your dressing room? Yeah.
42:32You're a Republican? Yes, Larry, I'm a Republican.
42:46You were EP-ing that episode. Yes. Pardon the cliche. Was it ahead of its time? What is funny about that? Well, again, Larry's a horny guy, and he sleeps with Palestinian women. He sleeps with Hasidic women. You know, you look at all those episodes, he sleeps with a wide range of women. It's funny that the Bush woman, so to speak, is the one that he sort of lost his ardor for. I want to read from your memoir. You talk about this idea of being a comedy samurai, that you were given nothing, handed nothing. You'd have to take it. and when others needed help, you'd be there without hesitation. A soldier, you had a job to do.
43:23When it was done, you moved on. Every project, a village in need of saving. Nothing less than save it is what you would do. Rescue it from death by killing. Really taking the metaphor far here. Yeah. But with laughter. What did you learn over all these years? You're now able to reflect back on it. You certainly have a theme in this comedy universe we've just explored, pushing boundaries, not being obviously afraid to take on, well, at the time, weird projects. What'd you learn? Well, having no fear, trusting your instincts. And also, at this point, I have the perspective of having tremendous gratitude for the luck, the synchronicities that have crossed my path, things that have presented themselves to me that I had no idea were going to happen, that I was able to be wise enough in that moment to gravitate in that direction.
44:13I'm going to try to have you finish a couple sentences, and then we'll let you get out of here. Okay. Okay. Wish me luck. The most important thing about a joke is... The punchline. What I learned about Larry David working with him was... He's a much wiser man than the character on the show. That makes sense. My favorite project was... Maybe Larry Charles Andrews' World of Comedy that I did on Netflix. I'm not a practicing Jew, but I dress like one because... I accept the mystery of the universe. For someone watching in today's world who wants to grow up and do something like you did, the most important thing about starting a comedy career is...
44:57Trusting their instinct and not being worried about failing. Failing is part of the equation. Failing is part of success. You cannot separate them. That is the yin and yang of a career. And if people read Comedy Samurai, they will... They will laugh. They will cry. They will scream. and they will learn something about themselves in the process, hopefully. They'll scream during the reading of the book. Yes. That's a strong pitch. Yes. Larry Charles. Gotta get out there and do it. Very smart, funny man. Thank you for coming back here. The book is Comedy Samurai, 40 Years of Blood, Guts, and Laughter.
45:34You can go online and get Comedy Samurai now wherever books are sold. And you can see that full interview. There's even more to it at msnbc.com slash ari. As we head into Independence Day, a programming note. Tomorrow you can see a special TV edition of the Nicole Wallace podcast with our own Rachel Maddow. It's the best people and it's at 8 p.m. Eastern tomorrow. That does it for us. Happy holidays. Happy 4th. Real talent is defined by what people can do, not where they learn to do it. So by stopping at the education section of a resume, you might throw away the perfect hire. Skills First Hiring helps you see talent others miss.
46:14like more than 70 million stars skilled through alternative routes. Let their story unfold and gain a competitive advantage because hiring managers who start with skills are 60 % more likely to find a successful hire. Hire skills first. Learn why at tearthepaperceiling.org Brought to you by Opportunity at Work and the Ad Council.
From the publisher
MSNBC’s Ari Melber hosts “The Beat” on Thursday, July 3, and reports on the House passing Trump’s budget and new reporting from The New York Times about how the Trump administration is plotting fresh ways to distort vote counting. Melissa Murray, Douglas Brinkley and Eugene Robinson join. To listen to this show and other MS podcasts without ads, sign up for MS
NOW Premium on Apple Podcasts.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See https://pcm.adswizz.com
for information about our collection and use of personal data for
advertising.
