Trump Claims To Ban MS NOW, CNN, Politico From WH

18 Sep 2026 · 42 min · 21 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Midterm election kickoff and political dynamics; Trump’s claim he’ll ban MSNBC, CNN, and Politico from the White House; a separate “Epstein 2.0” push to force release of remaining Epstein files; and an AI “theft” controversy tied to Microsoft/OpenAI and a New York Times lawsuit.

Guests

Che Comanduri (Obama campaign veteran) and Maya Wiley (former NYC civil prosecutor, mayoral candidate, CEO of the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights). Later guest: Congressman Ro Khanna (California Democrat).

Key claims

Early voting and economic pain (gas prices, household bills) are hurting Republicans; Democrats are framing Trump as “old/out of touch.” Trump’s “ban fishing” comment is mocked as rhetorical confusion. Epstein 2.0 would compel release of remaining files and allow state AGs/survivors access. Trump’s press-access ban is presented as potentially unlawful under First Amendment precedent. AI training is described as “astonishing theft,” including paywall hacking allegations.

Notable examples

John Kennedy campaign remarks; an Iowa Republican skipping Trump-Vance appearances; ICE detention/racism and health-care impacts; Leon Black contempt and withheld NDAs; Microsoft exec calling AI “theft”; alleged NYT paywall hack.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Midterm Election Climate

0:05 to 0:21

Discussion on the local midterm elections and their implications.

“With Progressive Boat Insurance, you can choose coverage for most mistakes you or other boaters could make, helping you float carefree all season long.”

Midterm Election Climate

1:00 to 4:55

Discussion on the local midterm elections and their implications.

“If you're counting, this is the first official day of in-person voting in the whole midterms.”

Trump's Economic Challenges

4:55 to 6:41

Analyzing Trump's impact on current economic conditions and voter sentiments.

“Che, I mentioned that it goes from the kind of mood of midterms, and some of us follow it closely, to the actuality.”

Democratic Momentum

6:41 to 8:02

Exploring how Democrats are gaining traction in midterm elections.

“And, you know, James Carville said the most powerful word in politics is new.”

Public Sentiment on Trump

8:02 to 13:21

Evaluating public opinion on Trump's governance and its electoral impact.

“Well, look, I think it's very clear that you would rather be a Democrat than a Republican in this midterm cycle.”

Conclusion of Discussion

13:21 to 13:52

Wrap-up of key points discussed with guests Maya and Che.

“This is not something to joke about, but it's also something where even if they don't vote against Republicans, will they turn out?”

Introduction to the Show's Topics

14:00 to 14:40

Ari Melber previews upcoming discussions about AI and Congressional actions.

“We have a report and a legal fact check on that coming up tonight.”

Bipartisan Push for Epstein Transparency

16:07 to 16:42

Ari discusses lawmakers' efforts to push for transparency regarding Epstein files.

“We reported tonight the voting has begun in some places, and that makes this particularly bad timing for Donald Trump to watch his Epstein nightmare roar back to life in a big way.”

Interview with Congressman Ro Khanna

16:42 to 19:26

Ro Khanna explains the new bipartisan legislation regarding Epstein.

“Republican Tom Massey, who risks and lost his seat over fighting Trump on this and other issues, is still at it, showing everyone what it means to actually use your power in office, not just bow out.”

Contempt Proceedings Against Leon Black

19:26 to 22:35

Khanna discusses actions against Leon Black and the implications for justice.

“People are busy with a lot of different things out there.”
Show all 21 chapters

Survivor Stories and Legislative Impact

22:35 to 24:54

Ro Khanna emphasizes the importance of survivor voices in the push for justice.

“But what does it mean to take this aggressive action, to hold him in contempt?”

Transition to AI Discussion

24:54 to 25:55

Ari transitions to a discussion about AI and recent revelations from insiders.

“And I hope some of these people who haven't gotten justice for decades finally start to get some justice.”

Trump's Media Ban Announcement

25:55 to 28:00

Ari reports on Trump's claims of banning specific media outlets from the White House.

“I have that report and a fact check next.”

Access Restrictions to the White House

28:00 to 29:42

Discussion on the president's legal limitations regarding press access.

“to retaliate and restrict access to the entire White House grounds.”

AI Backlash and Copyright Theft

29:43 to 31:08

Exploration of allegations against AI companies for stealing data.

“Up ahead, we have revelations here about AI, your data, and what all those chatbots words are really based on.”

The Legal Implications of AI Training Models

31:09 to 33:32

Insights into the legal challenges faced by AI firms regarding copyright.

“drawing on things like the internet, newspapers, and copyrighted books.”

Concerns Over AI's Future and Efficacy

33:33 to 35:48

Analysis of potential problems with AI models and their societal impact.

“This new evidence tonight speaks to the idea that they might have a lot of stolen, plagiarized stuff.”

The Economic Model of AI and Its Issues

35:49 to 40:09

Discussion on the economic viability of the AI industry amid legal challenges.

“When this happened on the internet, they had literally taken a thousand percent reduction or three orders of magnitude reduction in the cost of the infrastructure before Google fully deployed everything.”

Protests at the Kennedy Center

40:10 to 42:02

Live report on protests surrounding the Kennedy Center amidst political tensions.

“What actual value is there to humanity from doing this?”

Protest at the Kennedy Center

42:02 to 44:26

Learn about the protest surrounding the Kennedy Center and its significance.

“They're going to link arms and surround the Kennedy Center.”

Protest at the Kennedy Center

44:34 to 46:21

Learn about the protest surrounding the Kennedy Center and its significance.

“You know that feeling when too many things fall through the cracks?”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Support for this podcast comes from Progressive, America's number one boat insurer. We've all made mistakes on the water, but there's one mistake you shouldn't make, being uninsured. With Progressive Boat Insurance, you can choose coverage for most mistakes you or other boaters could make, helping you float carefree all season long. Quote today, Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Number one rating based on 2024 filings with state departments of insurance. My name is Shannon Maldonado. I'm the founder of Yaoi, a gift shop from the lens of artists and handmade objects. I chose Shopify because when I was testing other platforms, it was definitely one of the most user-friendly.

0:35It was important to me to think about where we would be in the future. All of the tools for reading your sales, like planning inventory, they're just right there on your dashboard. For anyone starting a small business, the biggest thing I can tell you is it doesn't have to be perfect. Shopify can help you build upon it. Start your free trial on Shopify.com. Welcome to Beat. I'm Ari Melber, and we have the music because this midterm election season is underway. It is an actual election day. If you're counting, this is the first official day of in-person voting in the whole midterms. As we know, it's a collection of local races.

1:11So this is starting in Virginia and Minnesota, where voters can now turn out for the midterms if they choose to vote early. Other states will join in the coming days. So that's a neutral fact. The White House has had a problem with things being so local. They want more federal control. They've even lost a bid to have the post office federally interfere. Between the parties, all the polls show Democrats up. So the timing's not good for Republicans to have people start voting to potentially lock in gains that Republicans hope they might chip away at in the weeks ahead. The economic conditions are against the incumbents.

1:47people overwhelmingly vote against the incumbents when there are problems like this. Huge gas crunch. That hurts Trump and the Republicans. Wall Street Journal, owned by Rupert Murdoch, says everything's getting more expensive right now. We have GOP candidates who are basically fighting for their political lives, even in the kind of red areas where two years ago you wouldn't think this would be a competitive race, let alone something that they could lose. Republican John Kennedy in Louisiana is not up for reelection this cycle because the Senate, you know, goes a third, a third, a third. But he's keeping his eye on what's going on in his state saying this.

2:26This weekend, I'm going to Kansas, Nebraska and Iowa to help raise money and campaign for our very good candidates. So if you told me six months ago I was going to be having to spend my time in those three states, I wouldn't have believed you. Those ought to be fat guy layups for us. They are not layups. And he has a style of sort of saying what, of course, upsets Trump and what many Republicans have not said out loud as much. When you look at the economy here, though, the numbers already tell the story. People are not buying Trump's efforts to cast blame. And that explains the other developments we're seeing.

3:07Republican Senate candidate in Iowa swerving away from Donald Trump, skipping a Trump-Vance administration-style presence, right? She could have been with the vice president. Usually that's a boost. Vice president in your party, way more famous than you. She's avoiding it altogether. There was a huge break we saw on TV where a Republican, not pushed by angry voters or responded to press questions, but a Republican chose to spend their own money and cut this ad trying to save their seat, basically, and explain to the Latino and other population in her district in Florida why she's not for what Trump's been doing lately.

3:52Mr. President, some of your immigration enforcement efforts have gone too far. In July, 50 % of the 50 ,000 people that were detained had no criminal record. Be careful what your advisors are telling you about immigration policy. The same Hispanics who helped you get to the White House in 2024 feel betrayed today. That is what we're seeing. And the midterms are one of those things that those of us in news, politics, people who follow civics say, oh, the midterms are coming. You might be in a community or, you know, conversations that have covered this for weeks or even months. For most people, the midterms are, as I mentioned, officially starting tonight in the states that allow the early voting.

4:33Definitely in the coming weeks as you get mail ballots and a lot of states use them, you kind of look at that and go, oh, right, this is coming. We are basically just over a month out. And this is a homestretch that is not what Republicans wanted, not what, as the senators said, they expected six months ago and not a gap they want people to start locking in with early votes. Meanwhile, Donald Trump is caught up in a ton of fights of his own making, but breaking the key vows he made on inflation, lowering prices, and of course, not starting new expensive wars. That's where we begin tonight. I want to bring in Che Comanduri, an Obama campaign veteran, and Maya Wiley, former STNY civil prosecutor, former mayoral candidate, and leader of the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights, where she serves as CEO.

5:22Welcome to both of you. Che, I mentioned that it goes from the kind of mood of midterms, and some of us follow it closely, to the actuality. You sort of say, when does it start? Well, as emphasized, this is local. Different states start when they choose. Tonight is the very beginning. In the next two weeks, we see a lot of ballots going out. What does that do to potentially start to lock in what is a very tough environment for Republicans? Yeah, voters are making up their minds. They're looking at the facts at the gas pump. They're looking at their own household bills. They're looking at all the really rather odd and strange things Donald Trump is doing.

6:06You know, the obsession with the Kennedy Center, the obsession with the ballroom, with putting his name on everything like he's Biff Tannen from Back to the Future, you know, saying, you know, I'm the greatest president of all time. And with all this like sort of WWE wrestling rhetoric, talking about communists and socialists that don't really match up the picture of the Democrats that are actually running in many of these states and districts. They look at all of those things and they see a Republican Party that needs to be replaced by somebody fresh and new. And, you know, James Carville said the most powerful word in politics is new.

6:47And the Democrats are presenting themselves as new. And the Republicans are presenting themselves as old. Quite literally, a 80-year-old president who is obsessed with the legacy of John F. Kennedy. You know, nothing could be more OK Boomer than that. OK Boomer, I'm reminded of, you know, James Carville in the in the famous War Room documentary when he says they're yesterday. It's like looking at an old calendar. It's like just yesterday. And Maya, while there are important policy and values debates in this country and Trump has sparked a lot of them, It is striking that the Democratic Party, where, as I mentioned, you ran as a candidate, has found its momentum, if you will, not so much on the values debates, which matter.

7:34Are we a country that just kills people in the streets? We've been covering that. Are we a country that allows this type of rank corruption, self-dealing? But politically, the Democrats seem to be finding their momentum on what Che mentioned, just rejecting an antiquated sclerotic Washington. Trump is old. Trump is out of touch. And the economy certainly could do better than this. What if you had a president and a Congress that even just got up every morning and worked on the economy, which Trump doesn't even claim to do? Maya. Well, look, I think it's very clear that you would rather be a Democrat than a Republican in this midterm cycle.

8:12That's what we're seeing for the reasons that you say, Ari. This is about the direction of the country, though. And, you know, we talk a lot about approval ratings and the low approval ratings for Donald Trump. I mean, but that's a stand in for the direction of the country and the party that's responsible for the direction of the country. That's what's happening in House races, in the Senate debates is what's the direction of the country. But I would also say there is a relationship between these two things and important things that Democrats are saying. For example, you know, you played the Representative Salazar clip on ICE and detention and mass deportations.

8:53She's a Republican. She's a Latina who's saying in our community, we're seeing racism increase. I mean, that is what we're seeing in the data. Latinos are saying, we're experiencing racism. But it's also that the American public, we have people losing health care because the administration has decided to put billions of dollars into building the army it calls ICE to violate rights rather than to make sure people can see a doctor when they're sick. And those are also distinctions that we're seeing Democrats drawing that really relate to the actual lived experience of people because they do care about their rights and freedoms that does relate to the economy and whether they can participate in it.

9:34That's the point about people who are not criminals, who are contributing, who are feeling the impacts. But it's also about the choices that are about disinvesting in people's economic opportunities rather than in wars and lining the pockets of friends of the president and the president's family. All very, very well put. But, you know, Che, you mentioned that Trump's fixations are odd. The public is clearly over it. The old narrative of, oh, he's Teflon or he's kind of like the funny president, depending on where you sit. It doesn't work when people are hurting this much. I want to play for you something that I don't even know how you're going to respond to it, which is the president talking about how he has power and he could ban fishing.

10:17Take a look. I could have banned fishing. I'll tell you what, the power of this office is crazy. I could have banned fishing and driven Johnny right the hell out of business, okay? I think I'm going to do that, maybe just a quick order, just for a day or two until he calls me and he says, please, President, please, you're putting me out of business.

10:45Why would you ban fishing? That's a very, very odd thing that you would want to ban. I mean, there's a lot of other things that you could pick up that you would like to ban. Phishing just does not seem to me to be one of those things. What I actually think the reason he said that was he probably saw the video of Gavin Newsom phishing with Jake Tapper on the Rival Network. I think it was on CNN. And he had that in his mind. Gavin Newsom fishes. Let me take a shot at him. by saying I'm going to ban fishing. But it's just a very odd and circuitous way of getting there. And it also, you know, last I checked, Republicans liked fishing.

11:29You know, the rural voters, the red voters in parts of the country that vote Republican, big fans of fishing, big fans of going to Cabela and buying fishing gear. Yeah, I mean, it's also it's a subsistence activity for a lot of people. Maya and I are not going to get into the legal commerce cause jurisprudence under which you would have to try to defend a national fishing ban. But it it might fail in court if we wanted to waste enough time to test it. Maya, I'll show you the economy, as mentioned, Fox News poll. Has Trump made this economy worse? Overwhelming, 63 percent. And when you break it out, it's pretty striking that independents were so important in these elections.

12:14but also a quarter of Republicans see it that way. That might be regardless of what they've been told by their leadership. Yeah, I think there's no question that everybody in this country is paying a price, if you're not a billionaire or a friend of Donald Trump's, is paying a price for the direction of the country. And Republicans control all three parts of the federal government, right? They control Congress. They control the Senate. They control the White House. There's no question if you're very much upset about the direction of the country. There's only one place to place that blame. And that's why you're seeing that 26 percent Republican number.

12:53And when you're talking about the midterm elections, when you're talking about you were you were making the it's not a joke, actually, that part of what Donald Trump is saying is I in another way, I don't care about how you're making a living. I don't care about taking care of the issues that are bread and butter issues for you. I just care about my power and how I can use it if I just feel like using it some kind of way, like starting a war without congressional approval or, you know, any other things. We've got farmers that are committing suicide because of the conditions of soybean prices. This is not something to joke about, but it's also something where even if they don't vote against Republicans, will they turn out?

13:37Because it's a turnout election no matter what party you are in. And this is going to suppress their own voters. Absolutely. Very important points here. My thanks to Maya and Che for joining us here. Have a good weekend. There's been a lot of other news coming out today, including, you may have heard, President Trump claiming that he will ban entire press outlets, including MSNOW, from the White House. That is a developing story. We have a report and a legal fact check on that coming up tonight. You'll be able to hear me go right through the facts on that in a couple moments. We're also hearing deeper reports about what tech insiders say AI is doing, including stealing human creations, writing, labor.

14:22There's this AI shift we've been covering, and it's happening faster and faster. I've got that story and a great guest later in the hour. I wanted to mention that. But our next guest is a big one, Congressman Ro Khanna, and why he says he's got a bipartisan coalition to finish the job on Epstein, regardless of what Trump would like. We're back together in 90 seconds.

14:45My name is Shannon Maldonado. I'm the founder of Yaoi, a gift shop from the lens of artists and handmade objects. I chose Shopify because when I was testing other platforms, it was definitely one of the most user friendly. It was important to me to think about where we would be in the future. All of the tools for reading your sales, like planning inventory, are just right there on your dashboard. For anyone starting a small business, the biggest thing I can tell you is it doesn't have to be perfect. Shopify can help you build upon it. Start your free trial on Shopify.com.

15:43You know that feeling when too many things fall through the cracks? Monday.com was built for that gap. The AI work platform where people and agents work side by side to deliver more together. Create your first Monday agent today at Monday.com.

16:06It's the midterm homestretch. We reported tonight the voting has begun in some places, and that makes this particularly bad timing for Donald Trump to watch his Epstein nightmare roar back to life in a big way. A bipartisan group of lawmakers say they now have enough support to do what they already did once successfully against Trump and force a House vote on what they view as the remaining Epstein files being withheld. This would be going over the speaker's head a second time for a version of a continuation, call it a sequel, to the now quite famous Epstein Files Transparency Act. Republican Tom Massey, who risks and lost his seat over fighting Trump on this and other issues, is still at it, showing everyone what it means to actually use your power in office, not just bow out.

16:53He is joined by Democrat Ro Khanna, and they're trying to compel the DOJ to finish, they say, the job they started. Khanna notes that they have four Republicans. Thomas Massey and I have defied history for a second time, securing 218 signatures on Epstein 2.0. Four Republicans broke with Donald Trump and Speaker Johnson. Epstein 2.0 will allow state attorney generals to prosecute people like Leon Black and the Epstein class, and it will allow survivors to get access to the Epstein files. We report a lot on how Congress is broken, on how little it gets done, and how few things pass in a bipartisan way.

17:39That's kind of the baseline. But when you zoom in on this issue, which involves Donald Trump and the late tardy effort to have some transparency and justice, both related to what this terrible-to-see-sex trafficker did and the claims by victims and others for having their sort of other day in court, They didn't get that with his untimely death. This is an area where the people I just mentioned, including Mr. Khanna, have had actual results. Todd Blanche did admit, in addition, at the DOJ, that there were pages of files they didn't release. For its part, the DOJ has said there are good reasons for that, even though they were late, which means on its face, they already broke part of the law.

18:25Trump's DOJ, though, has all kinds of headaches. I'm here to get justice for the Epstein victims, the survivors. There are still some documents out there. Now, the disagreement and the confusion is over what can be turned over and what can't. A court has ruled some of the grand jury transcripts cannot be turned over, which we would dispute that. On the Epstein files, do you believe the files contain no meaningful evidence of additional wrongdoing by others who were not charged so far? the Epstein files. Three and a half million pages have been released by this administration. If you want to keep talking about the Epstein files, go ahead.

19:06Congress had to pass a law requiring the disclosure of the Epstein files. We've got solutions. We just refuse to pass them. We're joined now by Congressman Ro Khanna, California Democrat, who's led this push and, as I mentioned, got bipartisan progress. Welcome back. Thank you, Ari. People are busy with a lot of different things out there. Can you walk us through in English what this new push would do? What's new about it? Well, when Thomas came to me and said we need to do an Epstein 2.0 act, I said to him, usually sequels don't work. Are you sure you want to try to do this? And he said, look, Ro, I don't have much time left in Congress.

19:49I owe it to the survivors that we do everything. The reality is three million files were released. We've seen prosecutions around the world. We've seen resignations here, but there's still three million files that haven't been released. And state attorney generals haven't been able to prosecute. And we know that this DOJ has not been able to prosecute. So what this bill would do very simply is it would require the release of the remaining files and say that you can't claim any process protections or any legal deliberation protections. And second, it would allow state attorney generals and survivors to get access to these files, either so they could prosecute or in the case of survivors, so they can just understand what happened to them.

20:40What new hook or power would invest in those state attorneys general? With the state attorney generals, they would be able to get the documents. So we worked very closely with New Mexico Attorney General Torres. He's actually thinking about bringing a case because of the Zorro Ranch, but he hasn't been able to get the Department of Justice to give them the documents. In fact, there are foreign governments that say that the Department of Justice isn't giving them the documents in order to be able to bring foreign prosecutions. We at least solve the issue with state attorney generals so that state attorney generals can get the evidence, get the files to be able to bring charges.

21:27And then it gives survivors the ability to bring a lawsuit that would be able to recover these documents. The Congress has had a lot of action on this, including using the leads from the files to do more of the investigative work, including, as you've advocated early on and as we've reported, work that was undone by the federal government. There are speculations on that, the power, the money. There's a whole range of conspiracy theories you're familiar with. But whatever the reason, there were avenues not pursued. And in that realm, recently, your committee here held Leon Black in contempt over these Epstein-related investigative subpoenas following these tracks.

22:12From the Times, a billionaire had refused to appear for the deposition. Folks might remember he sort of showed up but didn't participate, if I'm simplifying, or turn over the documents to the key panel. I'll mention, of course, Black's attorney denies any wrongdoing or knowledge of Epstein's criminal conduct. Certainly, as with with everyone implicated, there's got to be some process. He's not currently federally charged either. But what does it mean to take this aggressive action, to hold him in contempt? What is the committee trying to get? Look, I'm usually known to be pretty even tempered.

22:48But let me just say this about Leon Black. It is outrageous, the allegations against him. I mean, the fact that this guy still has buildings named after him at Dartmouth sickens me and it sickens a lot of the survivors. He refused to show up and testify in front of our committee. He refused to release any of the NDAs that he forced some of the women to sign. And, you know, I am not going to convict them in a court of public opinion. But let me just say this. There is I do not understand how there is not an investigation into him, given all the financial ties. With the brief time we have, let's let's finish that point.

23:34Then we don't know what he did, according to public evidence. We do know there are serious allegations, as mentioned, haven't been adjudicated criminally. But we also know in your committees, look at the fact that he paid what are exorbitant sums to Mr. Epstein that can't be justified by normal business accounting. Do you have a view or evidence on what those sums were for? I don't want to speculate, but I would just say that there's no explanation. And he refused to provide the committee with an explanation. And so the normal thing, Ari, you know, as a prosecutor, as a lawyer, the normal thing to do would be having investigation.

24:11No one is saying go indict him tomorrow. But how do you not open a federal investigation? How do you not have agents there? And the fact that this was unanimous in I don't know what else could be unanimous in this Congress, but he has offended James Comer as much as he has offended Garcia. These just were not good actors. And what happened is one of the greatest sex trafficking, sex abuse scandals in our history. And I think the reason that we came together is not Massey or me. I mean, yes, we've understood the procedure. It's the survivors and their stories and their courage. and they really have moved a lot of people finally in this country and in the Congress.

24:52And I hope this passes. And I hope some of these people who haven't gotten justice for decades finally start to get some justice. Congressman Khanna, again, you've been leading on this. You mentioned the survivors. And we wanted to hear from you, give you the platform. And obviously, Mr. Black and his representatives are welcome on here. We talked to everybody. We've talked to the Trump White House. Attorney General Blanche, also welcome. to address anything you've said tonight, but you've laid out some important stuff. So thank you. All right. Thank you for covering this story. Yes, sir. Appreciate it.

25:26Coming up tonight, new revelations on this sort of AI blowback we're seeing. Insiders from Microsoft, which funds one of the big AI companies, OpenAI, blowing the whistle on what they call theft. If you've ever looked at any of these chatbots, you might have noticed, gosh, where are they getting all these words? Insiders saying this is theft and should be dealt with accordingly. Really important. But next, we turn to the story I mentioned. Today, President Trump claims that he's banning three media outlets, including MSNOW, from the White House. I have that report and a fact check next.

26:08The following news out of the White House today, President Trump says that he's banning three news outlets, MSNOW, CNN, and Politico, from the entire White House. He posted about that online and then discussed it today at the Oval Office. That is the news of what the president is saying, and it is a serious escalation in a campaign to go after the free press. We also want to report that as of this moment, those are public statements. We're bringing them to you as news, what the president is saying. We have not seen the White House take action to execute any such ban as of this moment. We can report MS Now reporters are inside the White House doing their normal jobs that they do every day.

26:53If that were to change in response to government action, we will report that out as well. But the wider issue here is about the First Amendment to the Constitution, and that generally protects freedom of the press. For those asking, is this even legal? Can a president do this? Well, we have not only the Constitution, but legal precedents from during the Trump era. Indeed, prior to today's announcement, the Associated Press has been in a legal battle with President Trump about a related issue, access to parts of the White House and the president's claimed reason of wanting to retaliate or address their coverage of his administration, including specifically the AP's reporting decision to continue to refer to the Gulf of Mexico as the Gulf of Mexico and not as the Gulf of America, which is a term or name that Donald Trump proposed for that area.

Read the full transcript

27:50This made it through the federal appeals courts, which issued a ruling that speaks to both the president's ability to grant certain access, but also not to retaliate and restrict access to the entire White House grounds. Because this is relevant to today's news, we will go into some detail. It did allow the president to restrict the AP's access to places like the Oval Office or Air Force One or Mar-a-Lago, which is partly his home, although a place that the president does business, and those kind of spaces. But it did not allow the president to restrict entire access to reporting areas of a general use, like the East Room of the White House.

28:33That ruling, noted the Oval Office and the Cabinet, were already quite restricted, indeed considered more invite-only than places that reporters show up and do their daily jobs, like the briefing room. The same ruling notes, because the White House has already basically, quote, opened those press facilities to bona fide Washington-based journalists, hard passes may not be denied arbitrarily or based on the content of the journalist's speech. The ending of that ruling, which shows a limit on what this president in office right now may do with regard to limiting journalistic access, is important because it follows a long line of First Amendment precedent.

29:12It states, regardless of party or ideology, that politicians, including the president, may not use or abuse government power, including access to general government reporting facilities, based on the views or content of what journalists do. Indeed, that is the core of the First Amendment. It predates and is designed to post-state any administration, including this one. And we will continue to report on this story as warranted. Up ahead, we have revelations here about AI, your data, and what all those chatbots words are really based on. Experts and insiders are saying it's a theft that has to be addressed.

30:05If you want him to take the threat of AI seriously, it's real simple. Tell him ChatGPT is about to release the Trump-Epstein files. I'll bet. I'll bet a hundred bucks. We'll get Pandora's stuff right back in that box. Jimmy Kimmel combining a bunch of issues there. Trump's Epstein problems back in the news tonight, this AI backlash and how these chatbots even work. And that brings us to the more serious part of this. There are new court documents which come out of a lawsuit we've been covering. The New York Times, one of the places that has sued AI for basically stealing its work. And so as this process continues, we're learning new things, including what looks like theft.

30:53Filings show the internal discussions from Microsoft, an early backer of this AI company, OpenAI, and the employees between these two companies discussing their methods to create the products we've all now heard about, like ChatGPT. That involves a process of using a lot of material for what they call training, drawing on things like the internet, newspapers, and copyrighted books. One Microsoft exec says it's an astonishing theft of unprecedented proportions, or the largest theft of labor in human history. That could sound hyperbolic, but even though we've long had theft and stealing, which is why copyright was actually in the actual Constitution, that's how far back it goes, just stealing somebody's intellectual property, we never had these kind of tools to do it this broadly and quickly.

31:46So that hyperbolic statement might be literally true. That could be bad news for the AI firms. Another employee said there was a hack to get around the Times paywall. And an open AI president, the leader there, said, ah, nice. This is damning. And this goes beyond the kind of general observation that obviously scraping the whole internet means you're taking a lot of stuff and goes into a bigger legal problem, knowingly taking copyrighted protected material. There's also what they call the loop of information and how that could be negative. We're seeing from the new evidence, they called it a doom loop.

32:24And that this next round of AI or generative AI might disrupt the employment of the very people who generated the data on which the model was trained. So that sounds like geek speak. Another way to put it is the models are, quote, a product that destroys its own supply chain. indeed if you've used these chatbots you may have found that when it comes to certain older stuff they paraphrase it well in writing that's kind of known as plagiarism what about newer stuff or the next stuff we haven't seen a lot of evidence they generate that because a lot of what they do is regurgitate what people already made and so far the companies have been doing that without paying the people for the copyrighted material that's why the times sued in the first place.

33:09We have an expert on this who knows these issues well. He is a tech insider who has always been quite independently warning about some of the downsides of tech. Roger Magnamee, an early Facebook and Google investor, he wrote Zut, waking up to the Facebook catastrophe. Welcome back, Roger. Ari, it's really great to be here. We hear that these are large language models that have a lot lot of stuff in them. This new evidence tonight speaks to the idea that they might have a lot of stolen, plagiarized stuff. Your thoughts. So, Ari, there are several aspects of this thing that are really worth paying attention to.

33:51The first, as you correctly pointed out, there are two potential felonies involved in what happened between OpenAI and the New York Times, right? The first is that they have hacked the New York Times to get around the paywall. And the second is that they did a mass theft of intellectual property with the explicit goal of creating a training set that would lead to an information utility that would compete directly with the people from whom they stole the copyrighted materials. We have lots and lots of case law why it's not okay to steal from somebody to sell to somebody else, especially not to sell back to that somebody.

34:34And this is, I think, of a piece with the larger issues in AI. I think we've been sold a bill of goods from the beginning, that there are four real problems, right? The architecture is dead end. For the exact reason you described, which is that it's guessing. What LLMs do, what chatbots do, is they guess based on a training set of historic information, they guess what the next word, next pixel, next idea might be. The problem with that is it's guessing. So it's going to be wrong. And it's going to be wrong somewhere between 1 % of the time and 90 % of the time. And in areas like legal, it's been like 80%.

35:09In medical, it's been alarmingly high. And that makes those products dangerous. The second problem is it's a general purpose software architecture. Silicon Valley is known for 35 years. The way to succeed is to make a product that solves a problem today and provides an immediate return on investment. When you make a horizontal product, you're telling the customer, you have to change everything you do to use this product. That turns out to be really disruptive and really expensive. And nobody has succeeded with that in 35 years. The third problem, and it's really a huge one, they have spent$1.4 trillion on the infrastructure for this.

35:47And they did it with the most expensive equipment on earth. When this happened on the internet, they had literally taken a thousand percent reduction or three orders of magnitude reduction in the cost of the infrastructure before Google fully deployed everything. These guys didn't do that. That was insane. And then the last point is there are 10 major companies globally with the same technology, the same training sets, pursuing the same use cases for the same customers. And that goes to some of the propaganda messaging around where we're headed on that. Before we get to that, it seems to matter more than the tech companies admit if the lawsuit is right if this evidence bears out that they essentially stole a lot of stuff to make the product because you can distinguish to say a very simple a very simple distinction would be if you make a xerox machine some people want to use it to do copyright infringement oh i'll steal your book and i'll sell it and we have ways of dealing with that but the machine itself has some value because it can copy anything.

36:49This seems different. Walk us through whether they have a problem if all of these models, as you call them, have inside them stolen all the stuff that makes them potentially valuable. So the core issue here is this notion that they want to create a public utility, like electricity, like water, that is all the world's information and packaged with intelligence. and the idea is that the whole world would then turn to this thing to answer all of their questions. Well, the problem is if you've stolen the raw material for that, that's a big issue and it really points to how bad the economic model of AI is.

37:30They stole literally hundreds of billions of dollars worth of value and in spite of that, this industry is losing so much money that as far as I can tell, there's not a single customer who pays more for their AI service than it costs the provider to provide that service. Right, that's the business. But before we... That's after they stole it. Yeah, I'll hold you back from the business issue because we'll be covering that, but that's like step three. To stay here on the earlier step from the new evidence, Roger, if somebody's big invention is they say, I got every movie you could ever want and I've got better tech to deliver to you than before.

38:09Oops, but I just stole all the movies. I didn't buy the rights to any of them. They don't have a very good product, do they? Well, they have a product for which they would likely go to prison, right? I mean, you're not allowed to steal in our country. That is against the law. And the notion that you're going to steal the raw material for a business and then resell it back to the people you stole it from would violate not just the law, but every moral issue that any of us would hold. I mean, that's obviously wrong. And the problem is this is not the only place where they've done that. We just had news today that OpenAI is creating a biology lab in their offices to synthesize various things.

38:55This is right after they admitted to everybody that, hey, we're worried that our technology can be used to make bioweapons. So they've literally, they're doing a Jurassic Park. They're going to go and create the environment for creating those weapons, which they claim this technology does for itself. The answer is no. The technology only— Last question for you. You've been around these battles. It was a big deal when the feds dealt with Microsoft back in the day. This administration is hands-off, D-rag, everything else. Do you think a different administration might look at all this and say, actually, it's not just up to the New York Times to fight this David and Goliath in civil court.

39:34but that there could be other enforcement actions. As you mentioned, the hacking alone appears felonious. Well, I would like to think so. But the reality is that most of the national Democrats are aligned fiercely defending the AI industry and its business practices, which suggests that they're more interested in aligning with financial power than they are with the benefits and the needs of their constituents. And that, I think, Ari, is the political problem we face in the country right now, that AI is one of those things where if you look at first principles, none of it makes any sense. I mean, ask yourself, let's assume it works.

40:10What actual value is there to humanity from doing this? Because the disruption is staggering. And, you know, there's data centers, which nobody likes. There's the theft of all this material, which nobody likes, right? There, obviously, I think we have had 100 people who've committed suicide after working with chatbots. You've had all these people who've had cognitive degradation because of using AI. They've had a loss of skills. Obviously, people coming out of computer science degrees can't get a job. I mean, the problems have piled up and the benefits are still entirely speculative. Yeah. Well, you know, you're a techie, but you don't always sound like a techie.

40:52And we say that sometimes as a compliment, Roger. Thanks for joining us tonight on this big story. It is always a pleasure to be with you, Ari. You covered this brilliantly. Thank you very much. Respect. Appreciate that. We'll check back with you because this was a big one today. We're fitting a quick break, but we have news coming out of the Kennedy Center, one of these Fridays where there's a lot going on. Protesters showing up. You can see live pictures. This is what the protests and the pushback looks like. People are awake. They're alive. Midterm voting just started. And I'll bring you this story from the ground next.

41:35Live protest at the Kennedy Center where people are pushing back as Trump has clashed with the courts and talked about demolishing the entire center this week. MS Now's Michelle Schnell is at the protest. What do we see? Yo, Ari, I'm here outside the Kennedy Center. It's called the Hands Around the Kennedy Center demonstration. The idea here, what's going to happen in just a few minutes from now. This sea of people around me, you can see there are a ton of people here. Organizers had expected 950 people. I can tell you, folks did turn out. They're going to link arms and surround the Kennedy Center.

42:13The idea is to show support for this institution, for this monument here in Washington. And of course, it comes amid a ton of uncertainty about the Kennedy Center's future. First off, you can see right behind me, that tarp is still on the wall. It's covering the area where President Trump's name initially was until a judge has ordered it to be taken off. That tarp has been up all summer, not showing the president's name no longer there. We're also wondering what's going to happen with the future of the Kennedy Center. Earlier this week, the Kennedy Center board, which is now stacked with Trump loyalists, they had ordered it to be closed for renovations.

42:48But just what that means is right now very much so in question. We've heard from the president who said essentially if his name isn't put on that wall, then he'll rip it down. I've talked to a lot of folks who are here protesting. The two main ideas I'm hearing, they see this as an assault on the arts, and they see this building, the Kennedy Center, as not belonging to the president or Washington politicians, but belonging to them, the people. They also see this as an assault on a building that was dedicated to a slain president. So things are starting to get underway in just a few minutes now.

43:15We are, again, waiting for this human chain as Americans continue to show their First Amendment rights, recognize those, and protest against the changes that we're seeing at the Kennedy Center. Thank you. Great report. Clearly a live action moment out there. We'll keep an eye on it. Keep it locked here on MS Now.

44:12We'll be right back.

44:26or with promo code SXM. Outdoor deterrence requires a SimpliSafe Active Guard outdoor protection plan starting at$49.99 a month. Visit simplisafe.com slash licenses for alarm license information. Tennessee 2012. You know that feeling when too many things fall through the cracks? Monday.com was built for that gap. The AI work platform where people and agents work side by side to deliver more together. Create your first Monday agent today at monday.com.

44:57Snoring, gasping for air during sleep, daytime sleepiness. I'm Shaquille O 'Neal, and this shouldn't be anybody's experience. Ask your doctor about ZepBound or Zepitide, the first and only FDA-approved prescription medicine for moderate to severe obstructive sleep apnea in adults with obesity. ZepBound is a prescription medicine used with a reduced-calorie diet and increased physical activity to help adults with moderate to severe obstructive sleep apnea, OSA, and obesity to improve their OSA. ZepBound is approved as a 2.5, 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5, or 15 milligram injection. ZepBound contains trisepatide and should not be used with other trisepatide-containing products or any GLP-1 receptor agonist medicines.

45:37It is not known if ZepBound is safe and effective for use in children. Don't share needles or pens or reuse needles. Don't take if allergic to it, or if you or someone in your family had medullary thyroid cancer, or if you've had multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2. Tell your doctor if you get a lump or swelling in your neck. Stop ZEP bound and call your doctor if you have severe stomach pain or a serious allergic reaction. Severe side effects may include inflamed pancreas or gallbladder problems. Tell your doctor if you experience vision changes before scheduled procedures with anesthesia.

46:06If you're nursing, pregnant, plan to be, or taking birth control pills, taking ZEP bound with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Side effects include nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting, which can cause dehydration and worsen kidney problems. Talk to your doctor. Call 1-800-545-5979 or visit zetbound.lily.com.

From the publisher

September 18, 2026; President Donald Trump says he is banning MS NOW, CNN and Politico from the White House. He did not cite specific reports that prompted the decision and suggested other news organizations could face similar action. The Trump administration has taken no formal action at this time. MS NOW’s Ari Melber reports. Plus, Rep. Ro Khanna, who is leading the push for a second Epstein Files Transparency Act, joins.

To listen to this show and other MS podcasts without ads, sign up for MS NOW Premium on Apple Podcasts.


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

More from The Beat with Ari Melber

All 320 episodes
Trump Claims To Ban MS NOW, CNN, Politico From WHThe Beat with Ari Melber · 42 min
Listen in VO