‘Captain America: Brave New World’ Is Marvel’s Rock Bottom. Now What?

14 Feb 2025 · 1 h 9 min

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Podcast Summary: The Big Picture - Episode: ‘Captain America: Brave New World’ Is Marvel’s Rock Bottom. Now What?

Hosts

  • Sean Fennessey
  • Amanda Dobbins
  • Guest: Chris Ryan

Episode Description In this episode, Sean and Amanda are joined by Chris Ryan to review Marvel's latest film, *Captain America: Brave New World*. They discuss the film's numerous rewrites, its structural issues, Harrison Ford's involvement, and implications for the future of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), particularly as it approaches the end of Phase 5.

---

Key Topics Discussed

General Impressions of *Captain America

Brave New World*

  • Sean and Amanda express disappointment, describing it as a significant low point for Marvel.
  • Chris Ryan labels it one of the worst superhero movies, criticizing its failure to deliver as a coherent narrative.

Film Background

  • This film is the 35th entry in the MCU, directed by Julius Ona and written by a large team of writers.
  • Introduces Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie) officially as Captain America, following developments from *Avengers: Endgame* and *The Falcon and the Winter Soldier*.

Major Points of Critique

  • Weak Storytelling:
  • The plot attempts to tie up loose ends from various previous MCU films, creating a confusing experience for viewers unfamiliar with the backstory.
  • Amanda remarks on the lack of context and poor execution, questioning the need for extensive exposition.
  • Production Issues:
  • The movie appears poorly stitched together with noticeable seams from reshoots and rewrites.
  • Chris and Amanda highlight the film's lack of visual cohesion, comparing it unfavorably to earlier Marvel films.
  • Character Development and Performances:
  • Harrison Ford’s portrayal of President Thaddeus Ross is viewed as inadequate, with Chris questioning why he took the role.
  • The performances struggle to resonate due to weak writing, with Anthony Mackie's role as Captain America not fully realized.
  • Technical Aspects:
  • The effects are described as subpar, with fight scenes lacking excitement or clarity.
  • The cinematography fails to deliver the visual flair expected from a Marvel production.

Thematic Exploration

  • The film attempts to tackle themes of power, morality, and the complexities of American politics, but fails to convey them effectively.
  • Amanda and Sean note the disconnection in exploring weighty subjects while relying on typical superhero action tropes.

Future of the MCU

  • Sean predicts that the trajectory of the MCU may be at a crossroads, with future projects like *Thunderbolts* and *Fantastic Four* needing to succeed where *Brave New World* failed.
  • The episode closes with reflections on whether audiences will continue to support the MCU in light of declining quality, emphasizing the need for films to reestablish their cinematic identity.

---

Key Takeaways

  • *Captain America: Brave New World* is seen as indicative of a broader decline in the MCU's quality, struggling to balance narrative complexity with viewer engagement.
  • There is a growing concern about the sustainability of the superhero genre and the MCU's ability to maintain audience interest amidst a perceived drop in production values.
  • The discussion highlights a shift in viewer expectations, with a call for more thoughtful storytelling and engaging character arcs in future entries.

---

Conclusion This episode of *The Big Picture* serves as a critical examination of *Captain America: Brave New World*, reflecting broader concerns about the MCU's direction as it navigates the end of Phase 5. The hosts and guest articulate a mix of nostalgia, disappointment, and hope for the future of superhero cinema.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Hi, everyone. It's Amy Poehler, and I'm launching a new podcast called Good Hang. In preparation for that, I asked some of my friends to send in some videos and give me some advice. Just be yourself and the guests will come. Don't be the celebrity that this is their sixth thing they're doing. I love true crime and cooking podcasts. Is there any way you could combine the two? Well, everyone has an opinion and a podcast. So join me for Good Hang. It's rough out there. We're just trying to lighten it up a little.

0:36I'm Sean Fennessey. I'm Amanda Davin. And this is The Big Picture, a conversation show about America. A brave new world. This is America. Chris Ryan is here today for a State of the Union address. On this episode, we will talk about Captain America, Brave New World. It's a new film from Marvel. Amanda, are you excited about this conversation? I am thrilled to bring people behind the scenes. We decided to do this episode about 10 minutes ago. So we have seen the film. Yes. We saw it together. Yes. We had a lovely dinner beforehand. I was in a great mood. Where did we eat? Woodridge? Wood Ranch.

1:22Yeah, the Burbank Wood Ranch. You had ribs. I did. I love ribs. Yeah. We had the classic ribs, chicken pulled pork triumvirate. But we did not get to have dessert because there was a misunderstanding about what time the screening started. That's okay. We got there. We got our seats. We saw the film. So in a way, I'm as prepared as I need to be. And I thought maybe this would be a good idea to do kind of impromptu like this because this is a film that kind of like starts to escape the consciousness even as the stinger is coming to a close. So I wanted to talk about it as quick, as close to the actual experience as possible.

2:01I think your instincts were right. This is the 35th film in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. It comes to us from Julius Ona. It is written by roughly 19 people. Yes, including Malcolm Spellman, who worked on Falcon and the Winter Soldier, the TV series that previously featured Sam Wilson. So thank you for bringing that up. Sam Wilson, of course, has taken up the mantle of Captain America. You asked me during the film, when did that happen? I believe it was officially at the end of Avengers Endgame when Steve Rogers went back into the past to be with his beloved Haley Atwell. Well, and to that I say, who among us would not travel back in time to be with Hayley Atwell?

2:36I completely agree with you. That was also one of the scenes with the Captain America cute butt jokes. So, right? Sure, yes. Yeah, that was a movie. That's how you chart time in the MCU. Because he's dancing as an old man and he has a cute butt. There's like a recurring thing in it about him having a cute butt. They made a couple jokes about it. It's fine. Like, you know, I like humor too. I asked you before, and the movie started. Okay. I did ask you some questions during the film and we can get into why I needed to ask those questions later. There are a great many reasons why. But I don't want people like in my mentions being like, how dare you?

3:14I want I asked you to set the scene for me. And I asked you, when did he become Captain America? And I also asked you whether we would get to see him become Captain America in any meaningful way, whether there was a ceremony, some sort of medallion like the DJs. And, you know, I just want to say I think that that was a missed opportunity. He just sort of started doing it in this television series. Yes. Which aired, I think, in 2021. It was the second series that aired in the Marvel TV experiment after WandaVision. Yeah, after WandaVision. And Loki was right around this, too. Yeah, so they were roughly around the same time.

3:48Maybe it was third. And that show is relevant to this conversation for a variety of reasons. one of the challenges of this movie is that it's not so much an evolution of the Marvel story, but as a series of loose ends being tied up around a lot of other older Marvel stories, not just the 2021 TV show, not just, say, the recent film Eternals, which came out three years ago, but also significantly and almost primarily the 2008 movie The Incredible Hulk, directed by Louis Leterrier and starring Edward Norton and William Hurt. Now, neither of those men portray characters currently in the MCU that still exist.

4:29In fact, one of those men is no longer alive. As actors. Yes. But the Hulk is still in the MCU and Thunderbolt Ross is still in the MCU. Yes. So, we've got a movie that is speaking directly to plot developments from a movie that came out 17 years ago and has been largely ignored. It's like pre-Tony Stark canon. Yes. and it is still a part of the MCU and that character still matters to the MCU because now Mark Ruffalo, of course, plays the Incredible Hulk. But Captain America Brave New World, well, let's just, we'll have it out right here. What did you think of the movie, Chris Ryan? I went into this as a pretty open mind, honestly, and like I was kind of willing to be surprised.

5:08I really enjoyed the last trailer and I thought this was one of the worst superhero movies I've ever seen, probably because it's not a superhero movie at all. It's trying to be a political thriller and like an espionage thriller, but I thought this was brutal. And it was like kind of, I couldn't tell if it was a catastrophe that had been stitched back together or perhaps like what they really want to be making right now, which is directorless slop that they assemble and like drawback breads to previous things that they need to do or whatever. I thought maybe this would be a really cool new step for them or an exciting movie.

5:46And instead, it seems like it's basically like a tax write-off for a bunch of other properties that they needed to get off their books. Amanda, what did you think? This sucked. Straight up. And I know everyone expects me to say that, but I also went in with an open heart in the sense of we got to go out to dinner on a weeknight and Harrison Ford was in this film. And typically, I have liked the Captain America movies more out of the, you know, Marvel firmament, I suppose. But I thought it made no sense. It was very clearly, like, tying up a bunch of things that I didn't even remember or had never seen.

6:27So in terms of having to do your homework before, it was, I don't know if you could have done enough homework to be able to follow what was going on here, but it felt sort of contextless, confusing, obviously like poorly executed. I thought, I mean, this CGI is like inexcusable, I think. And I also thought like the fight scenes were pretty lame if only just because I spent my time being like, well, that's not Anthony Mackie and that's not Anthony Mackie. You could see the cuts, you could see the doubles. I thought that I need exposition in movies like this. that like at some point, you know, you would like it to be deftly or any entertainingly done, but like, I, I guess I kind of need to know what's going on, but it was all boring exposition that still somehow did not explain to me what was going on.

7:22I didn't even really understand what it was trying to communicate in terms of like morals or ideas about superheroes, America, good, evil, natural resources or... Radiation. Yeah, you know, or hostages. Mm-hmm. And I didn't have a good time. This movie is quite poor. It is really one of the poorest in the history of the MCU. It's been quite a backslide since 2019 into, I think, not just a vague cultural irrelevance, because some of these movies still do make money, but a very overt discomfort with decisions that were made in the aftermath of Endgame, and then an attempt to kind of like unwind and rewind and refocus and reset.

8:16This movie, more than any other movie in the last five years, there was a lot of public awareness of reshoots, of restructurings, of recastings, of ripping it up and starting again. And even your common Marvel movie fan had a lot of awareness of this stuff going in. For example, Gene Carlo Esposito plays one of the heavies, sort of like the false flag heavy, like kind of a fake out of who we think the villain of the movie is going to be. He plays a character named Sidewinder who's in the Serpent Society. They shot the whole movie and then decided to add him to the movie. and so they just re-shot and re-edited significant parts of the movie to add this character to the movie who's like critically important to the whatever the story is in terms of like setting up who the actual villain of the story is and all this other stuff so you can see every stitch yes throughout the movie you can feel every awkward cut all that exposition you're talking about the way he vanishes in the middle of the second act and they're like you're done now the fact that he's barely in a frame with Anthony Mackie throughout the whole movie.

9:23But the fact that like the end of his shooting schedule like clearly coincided with like what they could get is what you see on screen. They can't have him be a part of the third act because he simply was not there. It was not available. Yeah. And it's a tricky thing, right? Obviously, I thought that Falcon and Winter Soldier was a mess, but actually was making an earnest effort to be about something. I thought it really fumbled the bag in its finale. it's like a really really misbegotten finale and this felt like an extension of the finale where it was sort of like you know that show made an effort especially in the first two episodes to really show Sam's life like show his sister show where he comes from I think he's from Louisiana yeah he's got like the fishing boat that he's got yeah and he's like it was like a character piece inside of a story about kind of power and the way that the Avengers could or could not reintegrate into a common society you know it wasn't high art but at least was trying that's some ideas though it was trying to be the whole forgotten cap thing with Carl Unleys, which gets brought up again in this film.

10:24Yes. So the Isaiah Bradley character who is a super soldier, serum taker, who then is wrongfully imprisoned and then is introduced in the story in that TV show, the movie, because it knows most people didn't watch the TV show, basically needs to like re-explain who he is by having, for example, in this movie, Danny Ramirez, who is the new Falcon, be introduced to Isaiah Bradley and then say, wait, you are this guy who did this thing and was wrongfully imprisoned for 30 years and so like when you're watching the movie whether you've seen the TV show or not you know that this is writing that is not even meant to like accomplish anything other than to fill in the gaps for people who don't know about the gaps I was telling her last night like there was an M Plus One article a little while ago about Netflix movies and about how Netflix kind of pushes writers sometimes to write their expository dialogue as if somebody's not actually looking at the screen so I felt like that was very very present in this film where you would be told where they were going they would arrive someone you would see a sign on the screen that says they've arrived where they are going and then they would be like here we are at Camp Echo and I was like I know I was listening two minutes ago like do you think that like how adults do you think your audience is that they wouldn't be able to sustain that and then Amanda made the right point it was like that's probably because they're stitching everything together from different shoots and from different storylines that they're like we have to like kind of even create a through line for ourselves as we're making this film.

11:53And whether it's intentional or not, even though we're close movie watchers in theory, like it feels very insulting when you're watching the movie to watch a character say a series of consecutive sentences that they never would. The way that the president portrayed by Harrison Ford in this movie talks is not how the president would talk. We know that that's not how the president would talk, where he would have to over enunciate something to what is essentially a vigilante hero who has made his way into the White House. Why would you give that person any information whatsoever? So the writing in this movie is absolutely dreadful.

12:24And some of it is a function of that stitching and some of it is just really bad. The performances are okay. No, they're not. They're not. They're really not okay. They're like Danny Ramirez and Harrison Ford are like charming enough. Yeah, they have like charisma. And Danny Ramirez is given like exposition duty and also like jokey Robin duty. Yes, he's very Robin in this movie. You know, he's like incredibly likable. He's charismatic as an actor for sure. Yeah, but like he has literally nothing to do. Yeah. Anthony Mackie, not an actor I've really ever loved, but I think - He's also played this part for like 12 years now.

13:00Yes. And the whole movie itself, you know, one of the themes of the movie is living up to expectations, you know, stepping in for somebody, you know, like when you go on leave, CR's got to sit in that chair. Yeah. And he's the whole time -

13:18We don't have to worry about that anymore. But in that time when he did, you know, when you sat in for Conclave, which some would say you were born to do, but nevertheless, people are thinking, what's Amanda thinking about Conclave? What does she think? What does she? We'll never know. Yeah. We'll never know. She's like Captain America back in time, slow dancing with her beau. That's right. So Steve Rogers was laid up in bed and Sam had to step up and fill in. And how'd you do? Falcon and the Papal Conclave I think I did okay You did great Sam's pretty hung up on this I think I did a deep Disney Plus TV series version of that Yeah You know And Chris Evans Is a complicated movie star Who's been catching a lot of strays here In recent times But he was a darn good Captain America He was very very good In what is actually a very boring character And he brought something I think very hard to describe But meaningful and it's cool that the movie knows that and is trying to address that but Anthony Mackie never quite rises to it and the writing really doesn't serve him well.

14:19There's a couple of things in watching this film that I was, so I know that like it would be easy to come here and be like fuck this movie and so I was really, really, really trying to like go into it and try and understand some of the choices that got made and the best excuse I can make for the way the film looks and the way that the action sequences play out is that they are essentially trying to move away from any kind of cinematic execution of these scenes and these set pieces and move into an almost entirely replica of the comic book experience. Now, anybody who reads comic books knows that different artists have different light schemes and work with shadow and have different conceptions of the characters and show them in these different ways.

15:04And this is the flattest possible way. It's lit in this overhead, like, you know, sort of fluorescence. All the furniture is kind of like set furniture that they have brought in from TV studio next door. When you're looking at, like, Harrison Ford on a destroyer in the war room, and the lighting in the background is like, it's like an eighth grade play version of, like, how you would kind of set decorate that. And it's kind of staggering because you're like, you are Disney and Marvel. Like presumably you could actually rent out an actual destroyer and shoot this on there, but it all looks so fake to a way that you're just like, you become so numb to it after a while.

15:47Like there's no excitement in exciting scenes. Did you get that? No, I think there's two things that you hit on that I think are important. One, the scenes that are not fight scenes, compare those scenes to the non-fight scenes in Black Panther. Look at how Black Panther is shot. Look at the way that images are framed. Look at the angle that he chooses to shoot actors from. Look at the way that he communicates villainy or heroism or ambiguity in a character or confusion. you might not like Black Panther because it has a lot of CGI fighting at the end and you find that incoherent but as a director there's a lot of choices being made in a movie like this it does feel like everybody was like okay we got four hours to get this in the easiest way possible let's just get it done yes exactly we gotta make sure that we Harrison Ford has to leave at four so before he leaves to go have some tea and sit on his porch let's get what we need from him and I gotta say like he's trying in this movie he's trying to give a performance he's way too old to be the president and to be a person who is like I mean Sleepy Harrison I know it's upsetting the text is true but it is true because Sleepy Thunderbolt yeah it's not quite Biden-esque but there is just something strange where even in his line deliveries he's trying to conjure the Air Force One right steeliness yeah And he can't quite get there anymore.

17:14And of course it happens to all. It's coming for us all. I got no beef with Harrison Ford. I love the man. He's given me so much as a movie fan. Yeah. But even somebody as gifted as him at making movies like this better than they have any right to be and using Clear and Present Danger and Patriot Games as clear models for what this movie wants to be or at least wants to remind you of and not being able to get it going, setting aside all of the Red Hulk stuff, which we can get into momentarily. I walked away from the movie thinking, why the hell did Harrison Ford do this? Like, why does he... I know money is nice and I know relevance is something that movie stars get addicted to and there's something fun about being part of a big project.

17:52But it just seemed like a huge waste of his time. We've only got like two more Harrison Ford movies left here and this is one of them and that just sucks. I think he's just in a real like I like to work mode. Yeah. Like he's made another season of 1923, you know. I mean, and it does seem like he has a lot of control, right? So like he can leave at four, you know, And he's not going to be there at 402 because they didn't get, like, the dogwoods or the cherry blossoms, you know, just so. Planes are expensive, you know? So, I mean, I know that you did the money. You waved away the money thing. But, like, aviation is an expensive hobby.

18:28I know. But, I mean, this is one of the five most successful actors in Hollywood for 30 consecutive years. Like, how much? I don't know. I'm not going to pocket watch Harrison Ford. I think guys get to like this is like why does Ridley Scott make two movies a year I think because they think if they stop like something's gonna happen yeah I just my thing is just like why this right of all the things why this well that's an indictment on Hollywood that like that there's not more material out there for these people to choose from and be like oh I'd like to make this like I'll be a judge in this movie rather than I'm Thunderbolt Ross and I have a Red Hulk inside of me invariably I can't do one of these MCU episodes without talking about what they're trying to get over the line story-wise in some detail while driving Amanda either to boredom or insanity.

19:13But this movie is trying to do a bunch of things that will be consequential in some way. I think it was more accounting for everything that had happened before. So there's like lip service paid to the Snap. There's lip service paid to Eternals. The Hulk, obviously. There's secret invasion stuff. There's Falcon and Winter Soldier. It's like wrapping up a lot of the street-level Marvel stuff that they've kind of set in motion that I think they are now going to get rid of. What was the finale of Falcon and Winter Soldier that you thought was... I don't want to misremember exactly what happened, but he, like, the same way that this movie has this very uncomfortable relationship to, like, whether torture methodology in political practice is, like, right or not right, it similarly had a sort of like ultimately we need to be on the side of the federal government like we may stand in the face of power but power also resonates like it's very you remember what I'm talking about there's just like a lot of stuff with Wyatt Russell's character in the show that like kind of goes up and down and then seems to have been like excised but put back in I mean there's ideas that you see in this movie about whether or not these black men feel like properly recognized by the government they're serving in that kind of get started in falcon when a soldier and are among the like more interesting ideas that they have actually tried to to reckon with and there's just something kind of staggering about it coming out now as like the american military and the federal government obviously go through the changes it's going through we're like wow like it's like things have we have come so we've gone so low in so little amount of time.

21:04Right. This is also a movie that it's like, we need to examine American politics's relationship to the military state, but also we're going to do so by having a guy with future technology blasting rockets through the sky all day long to be the good guy. It's all very unexamined. It's not so good to have the B-1 bomber or fighter jets, but if you're a guy who has Wakandan technology that can blow things up, that's cool. It doesn't It doesn't really have a point of view. The guy who has Wakandan technology who can blow things up is... Captain America. Captain America, who used to be Falcon. Correct.

21:44And the suit that made him Falcon was made of vibranium, which is the Wakandan thing. But that's not what's inside of the Celestial Island. Right, that's the new... Adamantium. Plutonium or whatever. We are fully spoiling now the movie. We didn't already fully spoil it? Not really. Is that a big reveal? Well, to me, the biggest reveal, or at least the most like that little tingly thing I get where I'm like, okay, at least they gave me this feeling I had was in the first act of the movie. It's revealed that the celestial that emerged from the earth at the end of Eternals, which was largely unremarked upon in all other Marvel movies, despite it being a world historical event.

22:27Inside of it, they have discovered a material and natural resource called adamantium. you were confused when you saw this Chris and I both very excitedly turned to you and said that's what's inside of Wolverine you know that's the precious metal that in Chris's defense that no that was like that was Chris had the very nice like hey that's daredevil moment that is normally for you of hey Wolverine's claws are made of adamantium because you knew I wouldn't know that or his bones I can't remember his skeleton and his claws so he was Wolverine constructed out of adamantium he was made into like a kind of super soldier by striker general striker who was portrayed famously in the Wolverine films by Brian Cox of succession okay but so adamantium was added to him yeah presumably from the celestial island his bones were fused with the adamantium yeah but where'd they get the adamantium we didn't know that was it like natural occurring in him I don't know the original origins.

23:29There's some retconning going on here. This is an X-Men dog whistle. This whole thing is like, guess what, guys? We got X-Men and it's coming. So sit tight for another three phases until we give you X-Men. They said that with the fat head. Oh, yeah. When Beast was introduced at the end of Quantumania, that was also an X-Men dog whistle. There have been a number of these over the years. So full spoilers now for Brave New World? Full spoilers.

23:57Spoiler warning. When Tim Blake Nelson at the end of the film is like, I've looked at the statistical probabilities and there are other universes, that is the other realities that will eventually come into play in the next couple of dozen movies. He just refers to them as the others, but the expectation there is that... The others are... Like the Fantastic Four, they're in a different timeline than everything else, you know? And so when we watched this credit sequence... Which came after nine minutes of credits. Yeah, and we were squalled that I wasn't allowed to make sure my children were okay on my phone during that time.

24:33I think that's what the Disney person was saying to you, yeah.

24:41He said some things, and then you guys both muttered, like, secret wars? Secret wars. Secret wars, yes. And so the secret wars are all everyone is fighting all together? I'll give you a little bit of context. Okay. This is the second-to-last movie in phase five. Okay, Phase 5 has been tough sledding. The next movie is Thunderbolts, and then Phase 5 is over. Thunderbolts is another film that has been re-shot and re-written. Yeah, how are you feeling about Thunderbolts today, big guy? I'm pro-Thunderbolts. I know, I heard, I listened to the podcast. I'm where I was the other day when we recorded, which is I think it looks fine, it looks cool.

25:17My expectations were really low for this movie, they're higher for Thunderbolts, But to me, they're kind of like closing all business on this era. And now in phase six, which starts in July with the Fantastic Four movie, these are the movies that are in phase six. Fantastic Four, Avengers Doomsday, in which Robert Downey Jr. returns as Dr. Doom. Spider-Man 4 and Avengers Secret Wars, which is one of the biggest crossover event Marvel stories ever told. I think it was originally in the 80s. And redone by Hickman. And then redone in the 2010s. Um, those, those are big movies. All of those movies have to make a billion dollars.

25:55They all are huge movies with huge expectations. The expectations on the fourth Captain America movie on Thunderbolts, these are smaller things. It's almost like they're trying to get out all of the like mistakes that they made now so that they can get to the real stuff. So the reason to see this movie, if you're an idiot like me or just a huge fan of these movies is like, what are the little pellets that they've left on the ground for us? which is adamantium is one of them okay which is a different thing than he would have said six years ago when it would be well another reason to see this movie is that it might at least make gestures towards a kind of film that we like it might be a political thriller it might be you know like a sort of interstellar comedy it might be something you know and now the first captain america movie is a gary cooper war movie and then they have kind of like now arrived at like a flat slop exposition dump.

26:51So I think this just puts a tremendous amount of pressure on Fantastic Four being good. And I think it'll do really, I think it'll make a billion dollars or whatever. I think it'll be really big. I think people want to like these things, but this was like, we are truly in the, like it's closing time. The lights have gone on. The overhead lights are on and we are like, oh shit, I'm still up. And that's why when you said that everybody's like more optimistic, I was pushing back on that a little bit because I knew this was going to be bad. I don't think I thought it was going to be this bad. Yeah.

27:20But I had a really good feeling it wasn't going to work. And it's a coin flip on Thunderbolts. It might stink. We really don't know. Right, right, right, right. If they mess up the next five, it's kind of over. Like, it's over. And it doesn't mean that those movies won't still exist, but it just means that they take on a much smaller mind share. And then I think Hollywood is going to freak out because they've been able to depend upon these movies so deeply. I mean, Superman's part of this conversation, too. They still might be able to depend on this. it still might make 90 million dollars I might you know I could be wrong and I was wrong with Wolverine and Deadpool and Wolverine but like doesn't this feel like a movie that's gonna have a huge opening weekend and then a big drop in the second weekend because the word of mouth is gonna be pretty bad like even the people who love these movies I've never heard more groaning walking out of a comic book movie than I did last night I mean the theater was silent yeah and people were wearing like Magneto t-shirts no cheering no laughter no anything.

28:16That's not a good sign. No. There was a little bit of recognition when Sebastian Stan came on screen. Well, yeah. I mean, that is the one thing that Thunderbolts has going for it is that like the whole movie lit up when he filmed, he did his two hours or however long it took for him to make that one. And he, I think his, he's always been a fan favorite, Bucky, but I think particularly this like confirmation of him as a person who has entered a different stage of Hollywood success, being Academy Award nominated, being so critically acclaimed in the last few years. I think it's huge for Marvel to be associated with an actor like that.

28:54And they helped build him up to become an even more famous person. But I think he also just represents like an energy that people miss in the movies. And that scene, which I'm sure was a rewrite, and I'm sure like, it felt like they helicoptered him in at the last minute. And frankly, is it absolutely insane because he's either a congressman or running for Congress? He's running for Congress. And he's a former Soviet asset assassin. This is literally, so we walked out of the theater and you just kept yelling, he is a Soviet asset. You went full Mueller, she wrote. I mean, it's insane. This is Russian propaganda.

29:25But like, this man killed world leaders and he is in Congress. Well, what state does he represent? Florida. When, which one? Who did he, when did that happen? He, didn't he kill, which leaders? T 'Challa's dad? Which movie? Yeah. Oh, oops. Yeah. That's not good. The fucking king of Wakanda. Yeah. Oh, you don't want to do that. You don't want that. Yeah. You don't sleep at night if you do that. Yeah. Did he actually do that or did Crossbones do that? Your boy, Frank Gorillo. He gets blamed for it. I haven't seen, I can't remember the last time I watched Warner Soldier. Where are you at on Gorillo these days?

Read the full transcript

29:59Feeling good? What was he just in? Werewolves. Did you watch that? I didn't. Okay. See that one, Amanda? Werewolves? No. Okay. There's something else I wanted to talk about here. Who is the president at the end of this movie? Oh, we don't know. We don't know. We don't know. It's not Harrison Ford because, and now is the time to speak of Red Hulk. He, after one hour and 52 minutes, emerges as Red Hulk, even though they've been promoting the shit out of this movie being a Red Hulk movie. They made me wait a lot longer to see that sequence than I expected. He almost becomes Red Hulk on the boat. Yes.

30:33He does it a couple times. He bangs the fists like a few times. Yes. They tease it. It's like Kendrick at the Super Bowl, but not good. Yes, not like us, comes right up to the edge. The edges. Yeah. Well, we were discussing this with a movie like Companion in terms of giving away a lot in the trailers because the studios are nervous that people aren't going to show up and they were nervous about this movie and they want people to come. You got Harrison Ford. You got him to sign up to be Red Hulk. One, do you think it was a good idea that they did, that they put that at the center of the campaign of the movie?

31:07And two, did you think any of that stuff worked? I think that they didn't have a choice because I don't think anyone really is tracking what the Falcon to Captain America plot is. I don't think that Falcon and Winter Soldier was a warmly received show. I think it had some things to like, but I don't think anybody's like, ah, of course, I remember exactly what happened. So they needed some sort of world-destroying thing in the movie that was like, here's why you come. These movies are supposed to be super, super. You know, like you're supposed to see something that you would not ordinarily see.

31:42I don't know if it makes a difference that he... I think it's annoying that it really only happens in the last 20 minutes of the movie. But it's not like I wanted to see Harrison Ford transform three more times. I will say there was a moment maybe about an hour in or 45 minutes in. I don't know. I mean, it was immediately apparent that this movie just did not work. I agree. Within the first scene. Yeah. It's a 10-minute exposition dump about what happened in the Hulk. Right. And then I think, like, I turned to you and I was just like, who wrote this? And you were, like, 45 people. And I was like, yeah, yeah, yeah.

32:17But, like... I think it's five story-by credits and three screenplay credits. I think it's, like, four or five screenplay credits. Yeah. Anyway, at some point before, like, my mood really got away from me, I was like, well, this stinks, but, like, at some point, Harrison Ford will be Red Hulk and, like, maybe I'll... Maybe that'll be fun. You know? Like, maybe I'll, like, that. I think I even thought like, oh, maybe they like saved all the CGI money for Red Hulk. They did not. They did not budget anything in terms of energy, time or resources to making that good. And that was a real bummer. I still have a part of my lizard brain that likes watching how two characters with different powers fight.

33:05Like I don't, I was nine years old once, and I thought that was cool to think about. Did you notice that he has as much ease and or difficulty fighting Red Hulk as he pretty much does red shirts that he comes across over the course of the movie? It's true, and it's historically a problem with all action movies. Arnold Schwarzenegger had this issue too, where he would be having trouble dispatching a normal man, but then dominating someone who was twice his size. But in this case, it's particularly egregious. I think part of that could be like, well, that's kind of the charm of Sam is that Sam is not super powered.

33:39Yeah, he talks about not taking the super serum. He doesn't take the super serum. He's a guy, which I think makes him kind of a, he's a good hero. Yeah, but I don't. It's not a good movie. I don't even think that they effectively communicated his powers visually or even how he fights or what his tools are. I mean, Wakanda, he's got wings. He can throw the shield. He can do other things. But the way that they're framing the Hulk versus Sam and some of that is like size discrepancy. Plus, you got like a CGI White House in there. So, you know, there's like perspective stuff. But you just don't see him.

34:18Like, I don't even know how he was fighting. I mean, I guess he was like throwing the shield or like flying around. But you don't. To your point about like, I like seeing people with different powers fight. I didn't really feel like I saw them fighting. Yeah, I think it was, again, I don't, I really don't have to spend time on this. I'm sorry. But it's more just like, what were the ways in which Sam determined Red Hulk's weaknesses? That's like reading, that's what reading comic books is, you know? Because like he just cuts him with his cape a bunch and then he finally gets him to remember the cherry blossoms and walking with Betty.

34:48Which are so ugly. The cherry blossoms? The fake cherry blossoms are so ugly. The ones at the end are deeply fake. I was just really upset. I do like a cherry blossom. I love a cherry blossom. And even by the way, like. That writing is terrible. A real life, like a practical fake cherry blossom, like made of like silk or, you know, materials or whatever, like can be very beautiful. But the CGI ones, two thumbs down. I tried to go back through my head and be like, what did I like about this movie? Like where was some stuff that was cool? Julius Ona, who I really don't know what to say about him as a filmmaker because his last two movies, I think, are this and the Cloverfield Paradox, which I remember.

35:30He made one in between called Loose. Okay. Which is a very strange and confrontational drama about race Okay. that I liked but I'm not sure was fully thought through. Do you remember this movie? I do remember it. I did not like it. I think what I remembered is that Octavia Spencer is in that? Octavia Spencer and it's Calvin Harrison Jr. It is. Who I think is doesn't usually work for me, the performances. Tim Roth and Naomi Watts play the adoptive parents of Kelvin Harrison Jr. That's right. And it's unclear if he is being singled out because he's a young black man with white parents or if he actually is up to trouble, basically.

36:20And the movie is a bit strange. I think it's an adaptation of a novel, but kind of it's kind of like kind of like the Cloverfield Paradox I'm like I don't what does this tell you about point of view I think Cloverfield Paradox also like got taken away from it at a certain point I only remember that because it was the night the Eagles won the Super Bowl it's when Cloverfield Paradox came out I remember at your house at your old house so I do think that some of the stuff that's like in quote unquote DC in the beginning of the movie with Isaiah Bradley's Manchurian Candidate moment and all that stuff with like the song and the flashing phones and the assassins is cool.

36:59And... Sort of, but even there, it's like... I mean, it's not... It takes them literally an hour and a half for someone to be like, it's mind control, which is like literally, that is a direct quote. You're so right. It's horrendous. And it was like, no shit. I heard the song the first time. Like, I've seen a movie before. Yeah. And I guess, you know, in a different world, like Ross's relationship to the leader, Samuel Stearns, right? Tim Blake Nelson's character, and him being like, I was going to die. I needed to stay alive so that I could be forgiven by my daughter. But then I double-crossed this guy and now he's feeding me poison and making me into the Red Hulk.

37:37It's kind of cool. It's not, it's really not well done. Yeah. It's really not. The idea though of like a president being beholden to a shadowy figure. Yeah. I think there's a lot of on paper stuff, as I said, that like we're doing Clear and Present Danger with the Hulk and a guy who can fly is, for me, I'm like, I would love to see that. Sure. They didn't make that movie. You know, they made a movie where Harrison Ford is the president and he embarks at people, but it doesn't really have any of that. And a lot of it goes to some of that physical production stuff that doesn't work. A lot of it goes to the fact that like the Mind Control one in particular, like the whole movie theater groaned when that happened.

38:13People were just like, are you serious? I'm deeply fascinated by like whether or not because a lot of these shows suffer from the same kind of like this feels like it was reshot or this feels like they had to like stitch this together. we are pretty much since the end of the Avengers run in this stretch of Marvel product that kind of is substandard professionally or falls short of ready-to-be-released kind of standards. Yeah. And I'm not like, you know, if you could get into like, are we sure Kevin Feige is the right person to be running this? I mean, relative to the bar that they set. Why can't they just like make a two-hour movie?

38:50Like, I don't understand why that's so hard and I don't understand why... It's payback for all the success that came on the first wave. The genius of the first 20 movies is that they somehow created this Jenga tower of movie storytelling, which had never been done before, where all the pieces fit. And it culminated in one of the biggest movie going experiences ever in the Infinity War and Endgame thing, which I was like, they fucking did it, man. This is super cool that they did this. And now they have to pay the piper, which is that every story that they do now has to be interconnected and has to make sense.

39:20and it's not feasible when they've gotten so big with all of the TV shows and all of the movies and they won't let a movie stand alone because the audiences won't accept that anymore. They will not accept a standalone story. But it's going all the way the other way where I feel like audiences are like the sort of it's hard to describe the atmosphere in that movie theater as people sat through all those credits and like the page after page after page of VFX artists salute to you guys. Sorry. Like I'm not trying to be disparaging. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And you're just like I can't believe I'm just so trained that I have to sit here and wait for this cutscene and then the stinger comes and it sucks so bad and it's almost like fuck you guys for waiting like you guys sat here for 10 minutes to see Anthony Mackie talk to Tim Blake Nelson about an unexplicit you know at least like when it happens in Doctor Strange like Charlize Theron shows up and you're like god damn Harry Styles showed up once and we're like alright well that was amusing at least and okay that brings me to my next point of discussion because this came up immediately after the movie ended which is that you guys started talking about how Madam Web was better or at least you liked it more I liked the experience of seeing Madam Web more than watching Brave New World you know last year was a really tough year for comic book movies there were three different Sony related Marvel stories Spider-Man related Marvel stories all of which were very bad and there was Deadpool and Wolverine which was a huge hit and the conversation that we were having was, is it better for a movie to be awful while accidentally amusing like Madam Web and to a lesser extent Craven the Hunter and the Venom movies or to just passively move the ball forward but be actively unfun to watch?

41:06Like, I was like, when is this going to end when I was watching Brave New World? Brave New World. So, it did give you adamantium. It did clarify the Eternals thing which was completely bizarre it did I guess close the book on Incredible Hulk it does how did it do that? why did I ask that? by making it clear that Thaddeus Ross is imprisoned and that he but he has closed the emotional loop with his daughter and they did give us a Red Hulk moment which even if it didn't come off that well is something that is like comic book lore and is exciting and then I think also doesn't explicitly state but makes it clear that Thunderbolts is an offshoot of a lot of the vision that Ross had as a leader because he brings to Mackie I want to restart the Avengers and that's clearly what's going to happen in Thunderbolts is they're going to restart the Avengers with all of these vigilantes.

42:05Presumably Sebastian Stan loses his congressional race. So the Thunderbolts will then become the new Avengers. Yes, but they're going to seem really B-team up against Fantastic Four and eventually X-Men and all the other characters were going to come in. Didn't you guys say on the watch at some point that they're going to then redo all the timelines so that the original Avengers can come back? I think they'll come back in different I mean, obviously, Downey's playing Doom, but I think they will bring Chris Evans back in some way because it's the same thing that happens in Deadpool and Wolverine where it's like, oh, here's all these different portals of reality that you can just have a constant kind of cavalcade of guest stars.

42:45Yes. So also say like they did a bunch of stuff that got you thinking about the future, which I guess is cool for you. I don't. I. It's not even cool for me anymore is what I'm saying. I get stopped being cool for me five years ago. But to your question of is it better to be like a bad but sometimes enjoyable movie that doesn't move the project forward versus quote unquote moving the project forward but not having any fun. I wholeheartedly vote for Madam Web you know because at least you get Dakota yeah and like Dakota Johnson being like dead eyed there's not anything weird in this movie or like personal at all nothing personal I mean there's plenty of weird just the character of leader is such a weird character but they didn't even like lean into that they almost seemed like they were like well we don't really know if we want to do this it's played straight if it had been a James Gunn movie it would have been like he would have had a fucking huge brain and it would have been sane and it would have been funny and these movies aren't funny anymore.

43:47The special effects are not good. The fight scenes are kind of dull. There's really no consequences to 80 % of the action set pieces. It's tough, man. I like these movies a lot. I used to like these movies like a fair amount and it's just sort of strange. I just, I wonder how long they can hold because when do you lose the essential 40 % of your audience? It's like, I don't really understand And I'm just going because they're fun movies. Well, we watched this happen with the TV shows, where the TV shows kind of started at a high, right? Where it was WandaVision, Loki, and this show to a lesser extent.

44:22And it was like flawed, maybe a little too long, but well-made for the most part, felt contained but with consequences. And then slowly but surely, they started just like clearly losing anybody who could be described as less than a super fan. And I stopped watching them. and I waited my whole life for this shit to happen and I just don't care I don't watch any of the shows anymore at all and I'm still in like you know I'm a more engaged elevated person there's a whole rung of people beneath me that is probably somewhere between me and you right you know where you probably if you were not doing the show wouldn't see one out of every five you would have maybe gotten seen like Endgame and Infinity War I think Phoebe I think my wife saw one yeah Eileen came with us to see Endgame yeah and I think I think they went and saw Logan it was sort of like the same way no Phoebe and I saw Logan they were kind of Barbenheimer-esque like everyone's seeing this we at least gotta go see it thing but once they start losing everybody below me the business is in trouble and now like they're in they're in danger of turning off the Midnight Boys Ringiverse squad because they're like this looks like shit yeah can we talk about that for a second like when does when does the production value and the like when does that break because it I thought this was the worst yet It is so noticeably awful.

45:42And, you know, I don't care for, like, the comic book aesthetic. You know, it's never going to look like beautiful, fine art to me. But it's just, they can't make it work. I mean, it's just gone down. I mean, if you go back and look at, like, Iron Man 3 looks like the fucking conformist. Totally. And the fight scenes at least, like, made sense. and you believed that someone, you know, they were connected to the story. Like, I just, if you're only going to these movies to see Red Hulk and Captain America fight, like, at this point, I don't even think the movies are delivering a positive experience, like a positive, like, fight.

46:24It feels like they're, it almost feels like there's a story right now about Disney realizes that they may be overpricing their parks experience, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah. But they're addicted to finding new ways of squeezing a hundred, a thousand or whatever out of people by offering like fast pass lightning scheme or whatever. And they're just like, we have to keep cranking it. Like there's no way to come back off of it. And when you watch this, you're kind of like, did you guys just decide we're all so stupid? We'll go see it no matter what. So why pay money for someone who's like, I have a point of view.

46:58This is what I want. I need you to build this set. I don't want to shoot in Hungary. You know, I want to shoot it in. I'm just, let's go, let's even like the slightly nicer version. It's not even that they're like, well, like maybe we don't have the ability. Like maybe, maybe like technology is not there what it is. It's not what it is. No, like at the scale that they're talking about. Watch Jurassic Park in 1993. I mean, I guess so. That's true. To me. Watch Rogue One 10, like 10 years ago. You know what I mean? Like it's like we can't make Disney can be. But at the scale that they're trying to do it.

47:26Yeah, I think there's. But the amount of time and the amount of stuff that they, like. It's really, really hard. and I don't know at what stage the previs and then having to close the effects relative to the reshoots. Because the reshoots are built in, but this was more reshoots than usual as I understand it. But whether or not the reshoots compounded on them to the point where there was just not enough money left to get the visuals. Just as a point of conversation, the directors of the Phase 4 movies are Kate Shortland, Destin Daniel Cretton, Chloe Zhao, John Watts, Sam Raimi, Taika Waititi, and Ryan Coogler.

47:57Regardless of what you think about those movies, that's a lot of directors with strong visions not all of those movies work all the time but there are images even CGI oriented images like the black and white stuff in Thor Love and Thunder which is a movie I think is terrible that stuff looks amazing you know there's stuff in the Raimi movie that is really cool this movie has none of that it doesn't have a shred of vision it doesn't have a shred of like wow or pop or daring like there's just nothing in it that makes you go like well at least there was a person who had an idea that was different from what we've seen in the other movies.

48:31I mean, I think there's shots in this where it looks like, and it's not a shot at him. It's like, I think Ford's reading off a prompter. Like, you know, he's like standing with Mackie here, but he's like not looking in Mackie's face. He's kind of looking over his shoulder. I'm like, I think he's probably... Or Mackie's not there. Yeah, and he's got to read a bunch of stuff that's like, all right, you guys just gave me this page, so I have to talk about what I decided to do in Harlem in 2008, The Hulk. is Harrison Ford outside at any point just when he gives the speech oh like the Rose Garden yeah but even that is like a set no he's in that the Japanese president's like palace for a second they're outside in that garden yeah you're right the whole idea is he's got to go into this bunker because there's been an assassination right so but he's like he is in the bunker for most of the time in one location yeah in one set that they built in like his trailer outside of 1920 whatever?

49:30I don't know. I think it's entirely possible that this is a speed bump and that things recover with maybe not even Fantastic Four specifically, but that the Avengers movies, because they're so too big to fail and the Russos know what they're doing with these big, you know, erector set movies where like all this stuff has to make sense together. I mean, they've done it. They've literally already done it before like multiple times. but it's also possible that they don't and that they don't do it fast enough to salvage all this new terrain that they have potentially to ply with the Fox acquisition which I never would have guessed.

50:08I just never would have guessed who would have gotten to this point. This could be seen as a wild overreaction to one really bad movie or not. I think it's the culmination of a kind of like there was a bunch of different places where you'd be like, well, it was COVID. Well, it was the strikes. Well, it was a changing of the guard and you got to like build up these new stories and they've had circumstances come in, Jonathan Majors, like all these things that have like affected how they were maybe trying to build things. But for me, I think it's repeated offenses of there just being too many cooks in the kitchen or like the directors or writers being removed where you're just like, the most nefarious cynical idea I have about this is that they are like preparing American audiences to accept AI versions of this stuff.

50:53and that they are essentially like, we are going to build an expectation. You guys have such low expectations of this that we can literally manufacture Sam Wilson stories like every three months with like digital. You might be right. He's right. You read the list of directors from phase four, all like people who know what they're doing. And we talked about no matter what, you know, there was something to hold on to. And my instinct was like, but does like, do Disney and Marvel want that? Like, do they actually want any individuality? did the experiment of hiring cool directors to like put their spin on these things yield what they wanted or do they just want more like gruel to feed out to people who are like yay comics it's so tricky i mean i think they just got really high on their own supply of thor ragnarok and black panther both being risky choices to go with taika waititi and ryan coogler and those movies being two of the best movies that they ever made and both huge hits for B-tier characters.

51:54So then they were like, we're feeling ourselves. We know what we're doing. We can do this over and over again. And now all of a sudden, it's Matt Shackman and the Russos and Daniel Destin Cretton coming in because John Watts doesn't want to make a fourth Spider-Man movie. So I think they've definitely tired of that strategy. You know, okay, let's pull back just a little bit before we close this. Cinematic universes has become something that did not really exist 20 years ago was not really a way we thought about movies. We did have like sequels to individual movies. We never had this thing where you'd have multiple characters crossing over and these huge skyscraper-esque constructions of storytelling.

52:36It's kind of infected and infested lots of different kinds of movies. The Fast and the Furious movies. Den of Thieves. Den of Thieves is aspiring to a cinematic universe. It is. It is for sure. Is this sustainable? It's obviously not really good. It's not really good for movies. It has been quite destructive for even the idea of sequels. It's kind of fucked up the idea of a fun sequel. Is it sustainable? Do you think it will continue to exist in the way that it does? Yes. Just because it's easier to get people's asses in seats with this? Yeah, absolutely. And also because I think for people who are making these things, and by the people who are making these things, I mean the corporations and not the filmmakers.

53:18like do they really care at some point whether they're giving you I mean I guess they sort of make more money from a movie but like maybe not and maybe it's easier to just like you know make 15 really inexpensive tv show type things that you can watch on your phone you know they they just want widgets right that they can slot in so movies are still a thing that when they work have the highest payout. I definitely think you're onto something here. I was thinking about this with Ballerina a lot. The John Wick story where you're just like, man, the first Wick is perfect. They never thought they would make a sequel.

54:00The sequels are cool. The fourth one is where they've just... But the fourth John Wick movie looks so beautiful compared to these movies. I think I would be way more open to the cinematic universe stuff if they put any emphasis on the cinema part. Yeah. And not everything on the universe. That is like the response to the like, why does it, maybe we don't have the technology question. It's like, you do. You just have to like kill Keanu Reeves in the process of making the movie to make it look great. And they're not going to do that, obviously. I find it to be very dispiriting as someone who is in this professional seat.

54:33And I used to wonder when I was a kid and I would read interviews with film critics and they would be so despairing. You would watch Siskel and Ebert talk about Halloween 5 on their show and they were miserable. They were like, I can't fucking believe I've got to choke down. Now it's fun to go back and watch that shit. I know, because that stuff seems quaint by comparison. But they were so mad at how American movies had been just completely diluted and reduced down to the stupidest fucking thing for a 13-year-old. They were so mad. And I was like, these guys don't get it. Like I'm 13. They don't get what's fun about going to the movies.

55:15And I'm in my 40s and I'm thinking about it. And you know what? I'm sure there's a 13 year old who's going to be like, Anthony Mackie is my favorite actor. And I love, I love that this guy came back. Yes. And I'm not taking that away from any of those kids. But in my position now, I'm like, so another 10 years of Marvel for me? Really? Yeah. And I'm sure you feel even worse. I mean, in some ways I don't feel as bad because for a long time, it's been like, do I have fun at one of these things or do I not have fun at one of these things? And most of the time I don't, but every once in a while, you know, they pulled it off and that's just going to be more of that.

55:53So to the 13 year old, I would say this isn't even fun, you know? And I guess if you're 13, if you're 13 and you have fun, like life's, life's hard. Good job, you, you know, for, but, but if you're like mostly interfacing with things as vertical video and you're like, you know what I mean? Your attention span is like... This movie really gets your attention with the five foot two Mossad agent in the film. What the fuck, dog? What happened there? Ruth aka Seraph. An Israeli born widow. Not widow, like in the widow program, the Rachel Price program. Yes. In the comics, she is a mutant and she is very clearly like an IDF soldier.

56:35And in this film, sort of retconned into being part of the widow program, I guess. Yeah. But like, what the hell was that character? Why does that character even in this movie? It's like the president seems to have two head security agents, right? I don't know. Because Rokamore plays the other one, right? But like, she was Secret Service. I guess she's like head of the Department of Defense detail. Again, like another thing where it's like, why is this character here? Yeah. No idea. What did it accomplish in the movie? Nothing. I mean, I guess they needed to have a woman in there. That's what it was.

57:08Yeah. Checking boxes. There's all these movies where you'd say your mileage may vary. There might be a person out there who's like, this is awesome. And maybe there is a 13-year-old out there who's just like, Sam Wilson is my favorite Avenger ever, and this is so cool. But man, I kind of wonder with this one whether people are going to be like, this just didn't do anything. This just didn't do anything for me. And I like these movies, and I want these stories. and I make it my business to know all about what's happening in these things and they're just like, just on a bare bones, like, fundamental, like, was this movie assembled well and put together well and did it look cool and did the action sing?

57:48And it's like, no, man, it didn't. I don't even think that's up for debate. Any closing thoughts? I think if you're 25 and you thought this was fun, I want you to ask more for your life. I think 13's okay, 25, you're still in a phase of discovery in your life but I think we could discover more I'll be very curious to see whether there's any like what's the delta between like a critical reception for this film and the box office and like is there just enough of a of a sustainable engine of like interest in these movies no matter what they are to go and like these are regardless of what you say familiar faces there is a Hulk there is Falcon who's been in these movies like people will probably I anticipate Bucky Barnes making an appearance.

58:34Like this is a little bit of old sheet music. So I'll be very curious to see what this makes. But if there's any justice in the world, I don't think it'll make a lot because I'd like them to get better. Deadpool and Wolverine is a movie that I felt very comfortable saying is borderline dangerous to the future of Hollywood storytelling. But as you guys recall, because we saw it together, I laughed the whole time. I was like, this is really funny. It's stupid. Bone density. that was also a film that they let Ryan Reynolds make exactly to his own specifications that was the point I was going to make was I was like they didn't fuck with that too much there were certain things that they probably didn't let him do ultimately but he got to do his thing and he's mostly gotten to do his thing now I don't think Ryan Reynolds should get to do his thing all the time see 2025 news cycle but you know what I honestly I he's I don't I guess I'm not team Ryan basically listen listen, he just yelled at him.

59:33Yeah. You know? Okay. I think we need to have a little more, a deeper critical lens on what he's up to. Sure. And also is trying to like ruin this guy. Well, listen. Well, it goes much deeper than that in my opinion. Oh, okay. But I don't have any evidence to support those claims. So I will just say, examine the text and then think of the subtext. Did you examine the text? Did you read a lot of the court filings? I have read a lot of them and I wouldn't want to be texting with him, But I just like the basic, I mean, like the text that Justin Baldoni claims is like, oh, he's so nice to me. It's like the most like obsequious, annoying, like fake obsequious, annoying, trying to get what I want, like Hollywood thing of all time.

1:00:14So that's not a conversation I would want to be having. And I am taking no one's side in that circumstance. I'm just saying that there are powerful forces at work. Yes. What do you think about that? like Thunderbolt Ross akin to Red Hulks certainly Chris thanks for coming on board this train with us I thought it was going to be funnier I thought I would be funnier about it but then I got depressed this was a solemn and angry episode of the big picture I told you we should have flipped them yeah I know we couldn't listen we were pre-taping time and schedule and all sorts of things supporting Robert Wagner and his ability to participate in a draft episode which is coming next week um Also next week, we'll be talking about Paddington in Peru, and I'll be talking about the desecration of that cinematic universe.

1:01:03Do you want to come tomorrow? To the movie? Yeah, with Mia Knox. I think I'm going to M.J. Lenderman. Is it the same time? No, it's at 345. We'll also talk about another extended cinematic universe, Bridget Jones 4, Mad About the Boy. Yeah. That's the fourth film in the Bridget Jones story. And we're going to try. Christopher, have you read Bridget Jones? No. I don't know what you think you're doing where like men of a certain age have read Bridget Jones. I don't know a single man who's read that book. But Chris is like enlightened, you know? No, he's not. Chris watches Lioness and jerks off. What are you talking about?

1:01:44Chris is not reading Bridget Jones. This is my brother. This is my literal brother. I don't know, but you know, he's an Anglophile. It's like, it's very charming. I'm sure you're right. I don't want to take anything away from what they've accomplished. It's the most apoplectic that you've been since you came back. Have you ever seen a Bridget Jones movie? No. What in the fuck is wrong with you? I'm sorry. I just haven't. I haven't. I haven't. Remember how you'd never seen Singing in the Rain until you watched it with Knox? Yeah, that was great. Okay. You know, that's fine. And you want the third chair.

1:02:17I think you have really weird expectations of men. It's something we should explore more deeply in the future. I don't know whether it's like... are they weird or is it how everyone should be? And it's like, you're not. No, it's your fascistic tendencies that rise to the surface where you're like, this is how it is and I will accept no other truth. Because I'm dealing with an entire society of men being like, this is how it is all the time. No, over here, this is how it is. We're doing an episode about Bridget Jones, are we not? A secret. And you couldn't read the book. It's very light reading.

1:02:50It's breezy. I didn't read whatever this Captain America movie was based on. He's reading The Odyssey and Vineland. I am rereading Vineland. Book Club Vineland? Sure. But also, you could read Bridget Jones. You could read it tonight. You could read it yet. No. Okay. But we will talk about the movie on the show. And we're going to try to do something that might be a horrible idea and that might actually be offensive to Chris. But we're going to try to build the American-British movie canon. That's okay. I feel like you guys are really well-suited to do that. What Americans think are great British movies in the 21st century.

1:03:28I'm sure also that all of our British listeners will be thrilled by this. They'll want to assassinate us, but it's okay. We'll have fun. Well, don't spoil it. But that's what we're talking about. Yeah. American guys being like, snatch is really good. That's the thing. That will be like what I can contribute. But I think Amanda has a lot more text. I think also American women being like Bridget Jones Diary starring an American. I want you to know that I respect them. in my administration, they will have a seat. I just think you would kind of be charmed by the book. I think I would be too. It's not like, I'm not trying to be a dick.

1:04:02I literally barely can make it through like Mike Sandoz's six takeaways from a Super Bowl victory by Mike Sandoz. It's written in diary entry form. Like you actually could get through this. Yeah. I think the Turner Diaries is written similarly. Oh my God.

1:04:19I appreciate - I went to this fucking Marvel movie 40 minutes early because you're an idiot. And I didn't even say anything. I was like, I guess Sean is going to be a psycho. The one time you piped down and you should have said something. I was trying to be supportive. I was meeting you. I was very surprised that you weren't like, let's get a dessert. Where you were. I know, but I thought he was like being so crazy. I just didn't know. I got invited to Wood Ranch. Like this is like Sean's time. I'm going to do it. I don't understand why you can't meet me. Wood Ranch was Chris's idea. It was a good idea.

1:04:52I don't like, that's fine. so I met you where you were what does it matter if I read Bridget Jones just don't be a dick you guys should save this for the Bridget Jones episode well Yassi will be here so we won't be this fervid oh you guys don't really fight in front of Yassi we're working up to it I mean it's new work you know so okay well great job everybody thanks to Jack Sanders for his work and for staying till 4.49pm on a Wednesday Jack thank you this is a double session this is all time you get back tomorrow brother Thanks to our producer, Robert Wagner. What's future Jack going to do with his life?

1:05:27Maybe he should check out an early screening of Captain America Brave New World. Thanks for listening along and watching this show. And have you been watching The Big Picture on YouTube? Yes. And what do you think? Good experience? It's a good experience. Did you know The Watch is on platform, on video, on Spotify? I did because I listened to The Watch. We are coming to the Spotify platform soon. Okay. I can't say when. Join me. It may be... The Spotify Cinematic Universe. How does that affect my data saving? I don't know the answer to that question, and I won't even try to answer it. But we will see you next week.

From the publisher

Sean and Amanda are joined by Chris Ryan to review the utter mess that is ‘Captain America: Brave New World.’ They discuss its various rewrites, the ways the movie shows its seams, why Harrison Ford is even interested in taking roles like this, and what it means for the end of Phase 5 in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

Hosts: Sean Fennessey and Amanda Dobbins
Guest: Chris Ryan
Senior Producer: Bobby Wagner
Video Producer: Jack Sanders
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from The Big Picture

All 218 episodes
‘Captain America: Brave New World’ Is Marvel’s Rock Bottom. Now What?The Big Picture · 1 h 9 min
Listen in VO