#define: props to astronomer (Friends)

25 Jul 2025 · 1 h 6 min

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Podcast Episode Summary: The Changelog: Software Development, Open Source - Episode #define: props to astronomer (Friends)

Episode Overview

  • Title: #define: props to astronomer (Friends)
  • Description: A fun and engaging game of obscure jargon, fake definitions, and playful banter featuring members of the Changelog++ community.

Key Participants

  • Hosts:
  • Jared
  • Adam
  • Guests:
  • Kyle Galbraith (Co-founder and CEO of Depot)
  • Jamie Tanna
  • Spencer Lyon
  • David E.

Episode Highlights

Introduction

  • The episode kicks off with a light-hearted discussion about the importance of faster builds in software development and introduces Kyle Galbraith, who emphasizes that current CI providers do not prioritize performance.

Game Segment

Pound to Fine

  • The game format involves the participants guessing or fabricating definitions for obscure technology-related terms.
  • The rules include scoring points for correct answers and for tricking others into selecting one’s fake definition.

Round 1

Myoclonus

  • Participants guess definitions for the term 'myoclonus.'
  • Correct Definition: Brief involuntary twitching of a muscle or group of muscles.
  • Key Moments:
  • Jamie and Adam struggle with their definitions, leading to humorous exchanges.
  • The round ends with several participants scoring points for identifying the correct definition.

Round 2

Eigengrau

  • The word 'eigengrau' is presented, defined as the dark gray color perceived in complete darkness.
  • Discussion: There’s a mention of the subjective experience of darkness and its implications.

Round 3

Klystron

  • The term 'klystron' refers to a device that converts the kinetic energy of an electron beam into radio frequency power.
  • Participants show their knowledge of subatomic particles, reflecting on the science behind the term's definitions.

Round 4

Google Autocomplete

  • Participants guess the autocomplete suggestions for the phrase "how does."
  • Discussion: They discuss trends in what people are curious about, ranging from practical inquiries like "how does Ozempic work?" to existential questions like "how does the world end?"

Round 5

Weird Flicks

  • Each participant creates a fake synopsis for the 1945 film "The Reckless Moment."
  • Key Points:
  • The game showcases creative storytelling and humor, with players attempting to outsmart each other.
  • The actual plot involves a housewife covering up a scandal, which is revealed late in the round.

Round 6

Acronym Round - WIMP

  • The final round features the acronym WIMP with definitions ranging from "worker initialized multiprocessing" to "weekly interacting massive particle."
  • Participants discuss dark matter and science concepts while trying to deduce the correct definition.

Final Scores

  • David emerges as the winner with 17 points, followed by Jamie with 8 points, and Spencer and Adam tying with 6 points each.
  • The episode ends with the promise of more entertaining content in the next round.

Key Takeaways

  • The episode effectively blends humor with educational content about technology and software development.
  • Engaging the audience through games and discussions fosters a sense of community among listeners.
  • The playful banter and competition keep the episode lively, while the discussions reflect on broader industry topics like CI performance and the impact of AI on code reviews.

Conclusion This episode of The Changelog successfully combines fun and intellectual engagement, making it a great listen for anyone interested in software development, open source, and the nuances of technology jargon. The dynamic interactions between the hosts and guests create an entertaining atmosphere while also providing valuable insights into the industry.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:14Welcome to ChangeLog and Friends, a weekly talk show about oversharing shower habits. Thanks to our partners at Fly.io, the public cloud built for developers who ship. We love Fly. You might too. Learn more at Fly.io. Okay, let's play.

0:42Well friends, it's all about faster builds. Teams with faster builds ship faster and win over the competition. It's just science. And I'm here with Kyle Galbraith, co-founder and CEO of Depot. Okay, so Kyle, based on the premise that most teams want faster builds, that's probably a truth. If they're using CI providers with their stock configuration or GitHub actions, are they wrong? Are they not getting the fastest builds possible? I would take it a step further and say if you're using any CI provider with just the basic things that they give you, which is if you think about a CI provider, it is in essence a lowest common denominator generic VM.

1:21And then you're left to your own devices to essentially configure that VM and configure your build pipeline, effectively pushing down to you, the developer, the responsibility of optimizing and making those builds fast, making them fast, making them secure, making them cost effective, like all pushed down to you. The problem with modern day CI providers is there's still a set of features and a set of capabilities that a CI provider could give a developer that makes their builds more performant out of the box, makes their builds more cost effective out of the box and more secure out of the box.

1:58I think a lot of folks adopt GitHub Actions for its ease of implementation and being close to where their source code already lives inside of GitHub. And they do care about build performance and they do put in the work to optimize those builds. But fundamentally CI providers today don't prioritize performance. Performance is not a top level entity inside of generic CI providers. Yes. Okay, friends, save your time, get faster builds with Depot, Docker builds, faster GitHub action runners, and distributed remote caching for Bazel, Go, Gradle, Turbo Repo, and more. Depot is on a mission to give you back your dev time and help you get faster build times with a one-line code change.

2:38Learn more at depot.dev. Get started with a seven-day free trial. No credit card required. Again, depot.dev.

2:51Welcome to another awesome episode of Pound to Fine, our game of obscure jargon, fake definitions, and expert tomfoolery. Our contestants checked their imposter syndrome at the door because they either know what these words mean or they're going to fake it until they make their peers think they do. Adam, you've played this game a lot. I've lost every time, Jared. You're going to win today? Oh, my. You feel good? Well, I'm not on video, so at least maybe in the clip, but my face is sad because I have not won yet, but maybe today, maybe. You did have a nice accolade. I think our last time we played, one particular listener said, your answers were always his favorite.

3:37Yeah. So that's kind of a win. You've got to win somewhere, right? That's as good as winning everything. Put that on a dagger. Okay, so for this particular game, we decided let's get some of our Changelog++ supporters, some of our diehard fans and our listeners, to hop on the mic and play with us. So I put out a call and asked if anybody had a good setup, if they were free this afternoon. And I can't remember what else I said. Likes playing silly games. and we got three respondents. They're all here today. So one of them you may know because he's been on the pod before. It's Jamie Tanna. Jamie, what's up, man?

4:14Hey, great to be back. Been a while. Here you are. You're here now. Are you good at making up fake definitions for real words? We're going to find out. I was going to say, that's perfect real time. No. Okay. Audio listeners only out there. He was like, not sure what to say. He's like, gosh, do I go for it or not? Because I'm going to be found out. Should I boast or what? We're also joined by Spencer Lyon from Orlando. Welcome, Spencer. Thanks. Happy to be here. Hopefully, I'm rooting to maybe extend Adam's losing streak. I don't know. We'll see if Jamie, David, and I can make it happen. I think the odds are in your favor.

4:58Three to one if you're just playing blind. That's true. It's true. There's also the spread because I do get to participate in kind of a strange way, but we should introduce David E. David Aja. Welcome, David. Thank you. Happy to be here. First time, long time. Happy to have you as well. So how this game works is we have 10 rounds if we need them all, but we also have a goal of 15 points, which you can score in multiple ways. So I will provide for each round a word with a couple of rounds that aren't quite standard. But a standard round is a word, which comes from the broad-ranging world of STEM.

5:41I've been extending it beyond STEM. There's some music. There's some video games. There's anything you might imagine a nerd would love in the mix. And these words are obscure and sometimes old and quite jargony. if you know the words definition, you submit to me that. If you submit that correctly right away, you get three points and you get to sit that round out because you know the definition. If you don't know the definition, you make one up, you submit that, and then I gather them all together and I read them along with the actual definition. And you all take your turns trying to identify which one is the correct definition for each person who guesses it correctly.

6:24At that point you get two points and for each person you trick into selecting your definition you get one point if nobody after the end of the round actually lands on the correct definition i your humble moderator get four points first one to 15 points wins any questions let's rock i guess i just explained that so well. There's no questions. Okay, let's start then. Hopping right in to round one, where the word for round one is myoclonus. Myoclonus. That's M-Y-O-C-L-O-N-U-S. Please submit to me your definitions for the word myoclonus now.

7:22do we get points for making jared laugh while reading that's the question in here yeah it would give you a pat on the back some cred some street no real official points but yes points by making my job harder i was gonna say and then you also have to watch people's faces out of their being read out to see if someone's like oh yeah that was that was my that was funny There are some social cues, yeah, that you can look out for. Unless you're me and I do nothing. I have a stone face here. There's no giveaways. This is poker to me. This is poker to me. There definitely is a giveaway in one of the rounds, and I'm looking forward to taking advantage of that.

8:03I have Spencer's, David's, and Jamie's, which means we're just waiting on Adam. Chucky. Yeah, I know. I'm sorry. I don't know how to describe it. I'm working on that. So one suggestion that we've had is to post all the definitions to you all and then read them once. And that cuts down on the people asking to repeat. Now, I think the asking to repeat is kind of funny, but it does get old. That's kind of the funny part. My fear with the reason I haven't done it is because there's a certain amount of tells, even in the text, whether it's misspellings or the way that I present things that can sometimes lead to you knowing whether or not it's real.

8:49So I'm curious, as we are here in the first round, what you all think about that. If you had some kind of tokenizer that stripped all the punctuation and things, that might be a way to quickly homogenize things a little bit. The misspellings thing is probably harder to catch. kind of like the spontaneity it's funny to hear as a listener right those reactions maybe it's not the best for game integrity but maybe for entertainment value it's a good choice the reason why i i would lean towards leaving it alone is because as a listener you don't get the advantage of being able to look at the sentences and so having them be repeated for you is actually helpful because you're like i don't remember what that one was either and so there's a camaraderie to that, you know?

9:37But I fully admit that it's not efficient at all, because you're like, can you say that one again? And it gets to be like, dude, I've said it six times, Adam, come on, stop. Oh, my name's in there? Well, you might be the most requester of them all. I've played the most, I've played the most. Yeah, I think no definitions in the chat make sense. There's been a few people that have said that something, not like a major complaint or anything. All right. I have all five definitions for myoclinus. That's your four as well as the correct definition. They are number one, a term that defines the family of different forms of life that undergo mitosis.

10:24Number two, an eye disorder that results in double vision. Number three, a pre...

10:34It's been a while since I've done this. Okay. Number three, a precursor to the monocle, an ancient Mayan scene aid used to magnify small objects. Number four, known as the sibling of restless leg syndrome. Sorry. Restless leg syndrome is serious. I know it is. I'm offending somebody. Known as the sibling of restless leg syndrome is when your muscles twitch and have sudden movements. Number five, the brief involuntary twitching of a muscle or group of muscles. There you have five definitions read perfectly. Each one. Nailed it. Edited in post. First try, first try. Yeah, I'm warming up still. I'm still warming up.

11:18And we are going to see if we can identify which one's real. We'll start with Jamie. What was the second one again? Second one was an eye disorder that results in double vision. yeah i'm gonna go with that one okay jamie takes double vision we're going out to david uh the fifth one the muscle one the muscle one okay david takes the muscle one we go to spencer i'm gonna stick with david here i'm thinking twitchy muscles but not necessarily restricted to the legs okay It goes beyond legs. Spencer takes number five. That's the muscle one. And now we go to Adam. Are you going to pile on? Are you going to spread it out?

12:01Are you going to? I don't know. I guess I'm going to do. I don't know. Well, did you mean to repeat any of them for you? That was it four or five that made you laugh? Which one made you laugh? The sibling of restless leg syndrome. I'm kind of liking that one. Not because it's unbelievable, just because I think it's - I'll pile on. I'll pile on. Okay. I'll pile on. So you have a pile on. That's early for a pile on. Nobody thought it was the sibling of restless leg syndrome, probably because I didn't read it very well. I apologize. Adam, you had that one, and then that was yours. You also misspelled known, so I was trying to overcome that.

12:37Ugh. I had to add the N in my head as I tried to read it, and so you really stumbled me right at the front. And then I thought, why does restless leg syndrome have a sibling? for the arms yeah that'd be like restless arm syndrome or what so you just got me with that one and you got nobody else probably because of that however Spencer also didn't trick anybody with his precursor to the monocle nobody picked that one that was Spencer's and Jamie didn't get anyone with a term that defines the family of different forms of life that undergo mitosis so it's not looking very good for me because those are three fake ones The other fake one that was selected was an eye disorder that results in double vision.

13:22Jamie guessed that. That was David. So one point to David for the eye disorder. I thought that was a good one. Double vision, mono. Myo. For like myopic. Yeah, exactly. There you go. So well played. However, once I read the actual definition, it seems like you guys knew what it was. the brief involuntary twitching of a muzzle or group of muscles that is myoclinous. So David, Spencer, and Adam all get two points each. So after round one, David's in the lead with three. Spencer and Adam tied with two. And Jamie and I not quite yet on the board. But there's lots of pound to find left to play. We move now to round two, where your word for round two is...

14:07Eigengrau. That's E-I-G-E-N-G-R-A-U. Eigengrau. Submit to me your definitions just as soon as you have them.

14:21Is restless leg syndrome a thing? Yes. I guess while we're here on the break, I thought I was on the money with that one because that's, I learned about that for a bit there. I thought I had it. And that's when I learned about myoclonus like this or whatever, however it's pronounced. Yeah. It's twitchy stuff. so I thought I had all the money, but maybe I was off a little. Because that's how I learned about it. Because for a bit there, I had this thing where I thought I had, like, I just had twitchies for a bit. It was when my thigh was a little off. And it was kind of caused from that because there's like a, when you have like a thyroid issue, you can also have like versions of arthritis, but it's not like full-on arthritis.

14:59It's kind of like arthritic things. And that's kind of a sibling to restless leg syndrome. Because they thought I had that. So they described several things and that was in my memory from that. Yeah. And that's why I described it that way. Yeah, it wasn't bad. I had never heard of restless leg syndrome. It's pretty bad. But yeah, it's just basically like your leg twitches uncontrollably. You can't stop moving it. Yeah, it's like it just moves without you wanting it to. And it's usually during sleep when you're trying to sleep. And so obviously your sleep sucks. I can see how that reads funny though.

15:30Especially since it says no, not versus known. Yeah. That's what got me first. So then I started thinking like siblings. It just got me giggling. Well, that win, y 'all. Somebody asked, who was it that asked? Was it David? Was there extra points for making Jared laugh? That was my question, but so far you're in the lead. You were in the lead. I got in the laugh round one. So you've got a fun speaker lined up for the weekend in Denver and then other activities. What else is happening in the live show? Well, we're going to do our Kaizen episode with Gerhard, and we're going to be launching Cutting Over Pipely to go live, so that'll be interesting.

16:10That's basically it. It's a two-parter, so an interview and then a Kaizen. Yeah, sounds great. Whatever else we make up on stage. We have all the definitions for Eigengrau. Number one, the dark gray color that people perceive in complete darkness rather than seeing pure black. Number two, when naming the beer Ziegenbach, his name was also in the running. It describes a patent pending process for mixing beer, so they considered it for the name of the beer. Number three, the deeply primal feeling of fear driven by a heightened increase of cortisol as if hearing the blood-curdling cry of a beast while on the hunt.

17:07These are amazing definitions. That's intense. Yeah, these are good. The imaginary counterpart to the eigenspace of a matrix for complex-valued matrices. And number five, from the German for singularly gray. There you have five definitions of eigengrau. David, we start with you. Sorry, could you remind me of the first one? Number one was a dark gray color that people perceive in complete darkness rather than seeing pure black. I mean, I think as appealing as Adam's beer definition. Hey, you can't out him like that. I don't think I did. I think that was all him. I'm going to go for the first one.

17:51Okay, the first one. Spencer what are you thinking I'm thinking number five The German word for singularly gray Okay So far we've got gray and gray Adam I gotta say those two definitions Make me think Something's in a shade of gray here So I'm thinking number five as well The German version of gray Piling on gray The German gray Jamie you gonna pile on I'm gonna go for the other gray okay so we're pile on gray we're gonna pile on the other gray so i'll go for one okay so number one we have david and jamie on one and we have spencer and adam on five both definitions about gray one of them is correct one of them is incorrect i'll tell you that much and the definition that is incorrect is literally true though from the german for singularly gray So that's just knowing the compound word, I suppose, and not the definition.

18:55The definition actually is the dark gray color that people perceive in complete darkness rather than seeing pure black. So that one was the actual definition. And David and Jamie both picked that. So David gets two. Jamie gets two. However, David was so close because he also knew from the German for singularly gray, that was his. So he also tricked two people. And so he scores four. That's a big round. Congrats, David. You must feel good about yourself. I do. I lived in Berlin for like half a year. And so in that time, I'm just like, yeah, that's enough. That's enough to put that word together.

19:31Eigen? Does Eigen mean singular? That actually, I just kind of went with the mathy, like Eigen vector value or whatever. Yeah. According to Wikipedia, Eigen grouse the German from intrinsic gray. and so maybe eigen means intrinsic also called eigenlicht eigenlicht i can't speak german dark light or brain gray it's the uniform dark gray background color that many people report seen in the absence of light the term eigenlicht dates back to the 19th century and has rarely been used in recent scientific publications so there you go how would they all be reporting it as great like there's no i'm sorry that's a philosophy yeah they think they're seeing black but they're not basically because it's just like well it's dark so it's you know it's black it's actually not black it's it's the absence of light it's eigengrout yeah it's interesting we have a cave here in texas that you can go to like as a tourist and go to the pitch part uh the pitch black part of it oh yeah so they'll take you deep enough that you know you're not in danger they'll turn the lights off and it literally is pitch black or what they call pitch black and so maybe i should go back there and test this eigengrout yes did you know this is actually eigengrout that's right this is not pitch black i'll correct them the tour guide you should you just yelled

20:58and be really angry yes all right well you should be really angry because you're getting whooped by David at this point, as is all of us, because he has seven points after two rounds. Wow. The rest of you all are tied with two. There's plenty of pound to find left to play. I'm still in the eigengrow with zero. Let's move now to round three, where your word for round three is klystron. That's K-L-Y-S-T-R-O-N. Please submit to me your definitions for the word klystron.

21:39so i was debating in my head whether i should just give david the two the three points for being correct because he was so close i decided to let him play because he wasn't exactly right but man you actually scored way more points because i let you play than you would have if i just given you came out on top i'm not mad about it that definitely paid off for you so good job.

22:06I do like the sound of that. It's clickety clackety. It sure is. It's really emphatic. I pressed enter and you all knew I pressed enter. During COVID, my partner and I, so we were living at her house and we're sharing an office, which was like, so it's a two bed Victorian house and so the office bedroom that we were sharing was not very big and we both had mechanical keyboards and it was the sort of time that at lunch we'd talk a little bit about work and I wouldn't even need to tell my partner what was going on that morning because she would know if I'd been arguing with people on Slack because it was very very clear in that small room you're just emphatically typing but how does she know you could have just been like in the flow state coding like create like a madman you know just really going after it i think she learned pretty quickly yeah yeah yeah many more pauses when you're coding to like think of the next thing when you're ranting you're just raving was she like who are you arguing with are you winning okay we're there five definitions for the word Clystron.

23:22Number one, a device that converts the kinetic energy of an electron beam into radio frequency power. Number two, the process of moving swiftly through water. Number three, the nickname for a grouping of subatomic particles, including the gluon and muon. Number four, a lesser used term in scientific vernacular to denote a grouping of potassium heavy entities and number five a subatomic particle with negative charge and spin these are all believable to this layman over here let's see what y 'all think starting with spencer i'm gonna have to hear those first two again jared sure thing number one a device that converts the kinetic energy of an electron beam into radio frequency power and number two the process of moving swiftly through water?

24:13Hmm. I think I'm going to go. There were two subatomic particles, so I'm drawn to one of those ones. And the question is which one? I think I'm going to go negative charge and spin. Number five. Number five, a subatomic particle with negative charge and spin. Locky in right there. Adam, to you. You know, five sounds pretty awesome, but... But? Not quite awesome enough. I really feel like there's something to number two. But there's a lot of people talking about protons and mixing and stuff like that and the potassiums. Right. Can you read number four for me again, just so I can have clear? That one was similar to five.

25:02Close. It's a lesser used term in scientific vernacular to denote a grouping of potassium heavy entities. Let's go with five. Five. The one that Spencer went with. That's right. He's got the points. I'm following him. All right. It's not been a winning strategy yet, but Adam and I are sticking together. It's going to pay off. You're going to have the same score. All right. Now to Jamie. I was hoping David would go first. You went first last time. What was number three? That was the other subatomic particle one. Yeah, the nickname for a grouping of subatomic particles including the gluon and muon.

25:37I'm not sure about the water one. As it came out, I was like, hmm, I don't know. But I also don't know any of these words. I think it's clear that none of us know what this definition is. So it's a guessing game at this point. Yeah. I think I'm going to, again, try and split the vote and go for number three, the other subatomic particle. Okay. so you're liking subatomic but you're going to go for the other subatomic all right david you are last to guess this round i i almost i feel it's like the the subatomic particle thing seems so obvious that it's almost like it feels like a trap q admiral aquar yeah whereas like i don't know if there's no So klystron for water doesn't sound right.

26:29The potassium thing is like, no, that doesn't work either. I don't know. What was the first one? That was the device that converts the kinetic energy of an electron beam into radio frequency power. The kinetic energy of an electron beam. Correct. Yeah, I don't know. You know what? I'm going to go for the... I was like, I mean... Yeah. This is that scenario when you're sold something and you just want the salesperson to sell it to you. Can you just tell me which one to pick, Jared? Tell me which one to pick. All I have is money. Somebody can give me a problem. Just tell me what I should buy. I'm going to go for the water one.

27:13The water one. Yeah, I don't know. I don't feel strongly about it, but yeah, that's what we're doing. But if you had to pick one, you're going to pick the water one. The process of moving swiftly through water. Adam did say there was something to that one. There was something special about that one. Wasn't there, Adam? Pretty special. Tell him what he won. He won one point for Adam. There you go. Because that was something special about that one. For a second there, Adam, I thought you were going to do the people are talking about thing. It's not like people are talking about. Everybody said this boat, it moves through the water with the Klystron.

27:48You don't even know. You're not. You're not talking about that water one. It's like, no, you're the first person to go. No one's not. Okay. So, yeah, Adam gets a point there. The pile-on was to the subatomic particle with negative charge and spin. Two points because Spencer and Adam both selected. That one goes back to David, so he's still scoring. That's why I didn't believe it. It was cool. I liked it. It was a good one. I like the gluon and the muon the most. Jamie liked that one as well, and that was Spencer's. So the subatomic particles was too good to be true. Neither of those was the right answer.

Read the full transcript

28:23It's Jerry on the board now. Which means I score four points because a klystron is a device that converts the connect energy of an electron beam into radio frequency power, often called a klystron tube, if you want to look up the actual thing. And there you go. Surprised you guys didn't know that. I didn't know that either, but I knew it before you guys did because I looked it up this morning. Vendor 1937. It's been around. Yeah, it's been out there. There's lots of YouTube videos. I watched them because I wanted to figure out how to pronounce it. And I'm not sure if I pronounce it right because I did see both clistron and clistron.

29:04Is it related at all to vacuum tubes or is that just like a completely separate technology? No, it's not. I don't know. It's a tube. I don't know. I'm not a physicist. I was attracted to that one too. I almost picked that one. It was close. People were talking about that water one. something special to it there's something about it there's something about that water one all right so we've all scored now we're all feeling good uh jamie didn't score that round but you are on the board so after three rounds david's still in the lead with nine i guess i move into second place with four wow that's the closest i've ever been to winning adam and spencer tied of course because they select the same one every time with three and Jamie win two.

29:48So David's still out to a resounding lead, but I think we can catch him. We moved out to round four. This is a special round. We call it Give It A Goog. Give it a goog. Give it a goog. Well, friends, I'm here with a new friend of mine, Harjot Gill, co-founder and CEO of CodeRabbit, where they're cutting code review time in half with their AI code review platform. So Harjot, in this new world of AI-generated code, We are at the perils of code review, getting good code into our code bases, reviewed, and getting it into production. Help me understand the state of code review in this new AI era. The success of AI in code generation has been just mind-blowing, like how fast some of the companies like Cursor and GitHub Copilot itself have grown.

30:36The developers are picking up these tools and running with it pretty much. I mean, there's a lot more code being written. And in that world, the bottleneck shifts to code review becomes like even more important than it was in the past. Even in the past, like companies cared about code quality, had all this pull request model for code reviews and a lot of checks. But post-gen AI, now we are looking at, first of all, a lot more code being written. And interestingly, a lot of this code being written is not perfect. So the bottleneck and the importance of code review is even more so than it was in the past.

31:06You have to really understand this code in order to ship it. You can't just wipe code and ship. You have to first understand what the AI did. That's where CodeRabbit comes in. It's kind of like, think of it as a second order effect, where the first order effect has been Gen AI and code generation. Rapid success there now as a second order effect. There's a massive need in the market for tools like CodeRabbit to exist and solve that bottleneck. And a lot of the companies we know have been struggling to run, especially the newer AI agents. If you look at the code generation AI, the first generation of the tools were just tab completion, which you can review in real time.

31:39And if you don't like it, don't accept it. If you like it, just press tab, right? But those systems have now evolved into more agentic workflows where now you're starting with a prompt and you get changes performed on like multiple files and multiple equations in the code. And that's where the bottleneck has now become code review bottleneck. Every developer is now evolving into a code reviewer, a lot of the code being written by AI. That's where the need for CodeRabbit started. And that's being seen in the market like CodeRabbit has been non-linearly growing. I would say it's a relatively young company, but it's been trusted by 100 ,000 plus developers around the world.

32:13Okay, friends. Well, good. Next step is to go to coderabbit.ai. That's C-O-D-E-R-A-B-B-I-T.ai. Use the most advanced AI platform for code reviews to cut code review time in half, bugs in half, all that stuff instantly. You got a 14 day free trial, too easy, no credit card required, and they are free for open source. Learn more at coderebbits.ai.

32:42I went out to google.com in an incognito browser. I did not use a VPN. So yes, you can probably triangulate some stuff because I was too lazy, even though I knew that might happen. And I Googled how does, just those two words, how does. And then I hit space to make sure it knows that does is over. And I stopped and Google suggested some autocompletes. I have jotted down the number one autocomplete. And your job in this round is either to guess what Google autocompleted for me, or of course, come up with what you think it might autocomplete for most humans around the world. Please submit to me your autocompletes now.

33:24And this is, you Googled this like today? Correct. And to confirm, you're in, is that Omaha, Nebraska? Correct. well you can stereotype me and then you can guess some stuff feel free it's fine i was gonna say yep you have all of your false ideas about what we're like this corn grow no see we already know that we're not going to be asking google that you have to think of what we're ignorant of adam are you thinking or what are you doing over there i'm thinking okay because it looks like you're just staring at the camera just like deeply breathing. Oh, sorry.

34:05Am I breathing deeply? Maybe I'm excited. Oh, man. I think I'm excited. I'm self-conscious about my breathing. Who wants a little TMI? You want some TMI?

34:19That's not normally how that works. I don't know how to answer that. I know exactly how to answer that. No, the answer is no. but I'm going to hear it anyways, I'm sure. No, I will not tell. Okay, I'm keeping it. Okay. Wow, it worked. It worked. Can it be like a plus plus special? Yeah. Just bleep it for the regular people and we'll un-bleep it for plus plusers. Okay. I mean, this is a plus plus special right here. Okay. Change log plus plus. It's better.

34:51Well, we gave it a Goog and we tried to guess how people were Googling how does stuff. That's not even a good sentence. I'm going to roll with it. And here's what we came up with. Five potential autocompletes for how does. Number one, how does a bill become a law? Number two, how does farming work? Number three, how does astronomer make money? Number four, how does Ozempic work? And number five, how does the world end? How does the world end? Five full three. Yeah. We just took a dark turn there. Like a dramatic countdown. All right, Adam, you are first this round, my friend. Gosh, man, there's like two in there that were really good.

35:39Oh, which ones were they? I really have to ask you to read four of them again. Or three of them. These are the shortest ones ever. How do you not remember them? Okay, I'll read them. The middle three were the ones that stood out to me most to me. So like two, three, and four. Can you read those, please? Two, three, and four. Okay, number two is how does farming work? Okay, that was not the one. Number three, how does a astronomer make money? That was awesome. Okay. Number four, how does Ozempic work? Okay, listen, I think it's number four, but I'm going to give it to number three because, damn, that's a good answer.

36:10That is spot on. Whoever's that is, if it's not real, they're awesome. Okay. Forever friend. So that goes with number. Date of recording might be relevant for that particular answer. Right? Astronomer, yeah. inquiring minds want to know how does astronomer make money okay next up it's gonna be jamie so i was gonna say we've heard the middle three yeah how about number one and five yeah one of them was how does a bill become how does a bill become a law that was the first one and then what was the other one and the last one was how does the world end so there's your five so you got farming well in order you got a bill you got farming then you got astronomer then you have ozempic then you have the world i think ozempic i mean astronomer is like written perfectly how someone would search for it but yeah i think ozempic all right jamie picks ozempic david do you i'm gonna go with ozempic i think that yeah that seems right what are you guys trying to say

37:20it's very popular people want to know that's right that's true that's fair okay Spencer I'm torn I feel like Adam and I have hitched our wagons together and I got to give props to Astronomer I mean the reason I'm a plus plus subscriber I like to support things that bring me happiness and I like it and that answer brought me a bit of happiness so i'm gonna go for astronomer well played okay so spencer and adam hitched again and ride or die brother right to the bottom some people want to know how astronomer makes money i want to know how david makes money because he is scoring left and right that was his good job david and that's a funny backstory on that one because without the capitalized a i thought he was trying to say how do astronomers make money also i'm curious how do they and i'm like do you want me to pluralize for that and he's like no man i was like oh i get it i didn't get it no man yeah i was like astronomers yeah how do they make money i don't know so two points for him and then how does farming work well jamie already made a joke about that so that was his how's a bill become a law nobody cares spencer i mean come on nobody wants to know I mean, you had to have seen the video when you were in grade school.

38:42How does it become a law? For sure. Not my favorite schoolhouse rock, though, honestly. That is a good one. Conjunction, junction. Conjunction, junction. There it is. What's your function, you know? Hooking up words and phrases and clauses. Yes. All right. Meanwhile, Adam, the world ending one. Didn't you do that similar last time around? It was something about the end of the world. I don't know what else to say, okay? I don't know. He's got a little bit of vocabulary. he's got one thing on his mind does Adam have a doomsday device somewhere should we be worried I just don't have a good brain like you David because that was an awesome answer and I guess I'm just bland I could be more sparkling I'm just a little bland unfortunately well the correct autocomplete at least for my incarnino tab on this side of the earth is how does Ozempic work and Jamie and David both picked that.

39:38So two points each, that's two for Jamie on the round, four for David on the round. Other autocompletes that didn't quite make it as high, but we're still on the list. Number two was how does a HELOC work? A HELOC. That is confusing. Home equity line of credit. Very complicated, but sometimes useful investing vehicle. How does plan B work? how does zell work you know that thing where you can send money between banks i don't know i don't know how it works and how does hail form that's straight out of nebraska right there because you know we get hailed on in texas bro so much oh my gosh yeah i got a particularly orlando response in my how does so number one also ozempic okay number two Two, how does Lightning Lane work?

40:28The Disney World Fast Pass system. No one knows. Oh, no one knows. It's like magic. No one knows. It's dark magic. It's like magic you pay for, and then you don't know what happens. That's magic for them. Hilarious. All right. Well, after just four rounds, we have like a world record pace here. David with 13 points. He's in striking distance of a win after four rounds. You wonder why I created 10 rounds. and tied for second is me and Jamie with four. That's how far back we are. And tied in last is these two hitched together with three, Spencer and Adam. Can we go for a rule change and just like pull our points together?

41:09Just team up on him? Wow. I make the rules. So I could make up whatever I wanted to technically. I mean, it's our podcast, but he might not come back and maybe that's what we want. I don't know. We move now to round five. This is a new style round, even newer than the Google style round. This is called Weird Flicks, but okay. I've scoured the internet for one of the oldest, most obscure, weird movies. And I've grabbed the title, the year it was released, and the synopsis. A brief one-sentence synopsis of what the movie's about. Your job is to write your own brief one sentence synopsis and try to trick your friends into thinking yours is real.

41:54And of course, I guess if you know the actual movie and you tell me what it's about, you'll still get your three points. I think if I were you guys, I'd start teaming up against David. Just saying. Just saying. So just like the oldest possible movie is what we're going for? They're pretty old. So this first one, I have two of these rounds. The first one, this is in 1945. So it's an old movie. And the title of the movie is The Reckless Moment. The Reckless Moment. And your job is to come up with, or to know by having seen it, the synopsis of what that movie is about. So there you go. The Reckless Moment from 1945.

42:40And to confirm, is this the official one-line synopsis? this would be the one liner that is on the imdb page so it's not like a tagline it's a synopsis but imdb people wrote it not the movie creators i don't think what does adam have in his what's he watching behind us silicon valley silicon valley is it always on always well whenever we're recording i think he might turn it off in between but it's just loose different scenes yeah he's just i was trying to work it out from earlier i thought it was community but now I thought it would be cool if he would like do some different things, different episodes.

43:18Like it could be star Wars. It could be Silicon Valley. It could be predator, you know? And he's just like, no, only Silicon Valley all the time. You may change the, the show for you. You know, I wasn't watching different. No, we were just, we were very excited when you left. Cause we could actually catch up on a episode we missed. Yeah. This is a, that doesn't generate like a copyright problem from HBO. They're not like, no, it's obscure enough. Yeah, in the background enough, we don't ever get a takedown request, thankfully. Do I remember we talked about there maybe being like a changelog watch along of Silicon Valley?

43:53Do like episode a week? Yeah, that'd be cool. I'd never execute on that because I didn't want to rewatch it, I guess. Or be forced to. We also almost did a... So the last time we played this game, what was the... He Who Gets Slapped? Was that the name of the movie, Adam? Yes, yes. We actually were going to watch that in Denver as like a group activity. because it would be hilarious. But the joke is funnier than the reality, so we're not going to do it. Because it's public domain. John Henry found out it's in the public domain because it's like 1928. And so we're like, man, we could put it on a projector and watch it outside or something, but too lazy.

44:27I see David's guitar is in the back. You may even need to start thinking of a victory jingle you can play for us. We're closing in. Can you improv? Music? Not well, no. Not well. but you're definitely closing in on a win here it feels the hubris of asking has anyone ever won in 5 laughter you know there's a reason it feels hubris not that I can imagine or remember I can imagine it I can't remember it this is our 6th time playing isn't it I think this is round 6 and I think there may have been a win in 5 but that was back when we played less points I think we're going to 12 for a while and we extended it to 15.

45:12So you would have already won 4 or 12. And I think you're definitely on pace for the fastest W of all time or the greatest collapse in the history. Yeah, it's true. The greatest collapse in the history of Pound Define. All right, we now have everybody's entry for a plot synopsis of 1945's The Reckless Moment. Are you guys ready to hear what everybody had to say? All right. Number one, well-to-do Howard Douglas makes a careless decision to leave his bowler hat at home. Number two, the untold, untrue story of what Emperor Hirohito really told President Truman upon the Japanese surrender in World War II.

45:56Number three, the harrowing story of how the invasion at Normandy almost had to be called off. number four after discovering the dead body of her teenage daughter's lover a housewife takes desperate measures to protect her family from scandal number five with the keys to his new Plymouth Ben takes a drive to the lookout with his friends where he met Betty hold on I'm right or wrong where he met Betty this knockout that sits next to him

46:29how is this funny Jim

46:34try reading it in a transatlantic accent that might make it flow a little bit more naturally yeah exactly if i could ben takes a drive to the lookout with his friends where he met betty this knockout that sits next to him in chem class they hit it off well but when this mysterious woman shows up everything changes was that all one sentence ah no there's there's one break in there after chem class there was a there's a period okay five potential synopses for the reckless moment starting with jamie which one do you think is real so i'm wondering um emperor hero hito and normandy sound like they may be of the time period but also could be quite near to like already get a film out about like normandy or so i'm not sure the very long one sentence makes me wonder if it's either like not real or um the other two i'm not sure sound yeah i think a little bit too far-fetched which ones are far-fetched the one about the bowler hat and the Housewife scandal.

47:48The Boulder Hat one just sounds a little bit out there. My Housewife scandal sounds like it could be more contemporary. I can't imagine that sort of thing happening. In the 40s. So you've eliminated all five. Yeah, I think that's all five. One of which he wrote. I don't know about which one. That's his strategy. He's just trying to make sure he doesn't pick David's. Casting doubt why I believe. Yeah. So having said all that, what are you going to do? I think I'm going to go for Normandy. I think Normandy. Yeah. All right. That's number three, by the way. Jamie goes for Normandy. David. You said the movie came out in 45.

48:35Mm-hmm. I think, sorry, what was, so it was Bowler Hats. Yes. Number two was President Truman. Sorry, President Truman did what? The untold, untrue story of what Emperor Hirohito really told President Truman upon the Japanese surrender in World War II. It's untrue and untold. It's untold and untrue. Now it's told, though. 45? Yes. All right. And then number three is the Normandy, which Jamie just picked. And number four— This is my way of backing into asking you to repeat all of them. Yeah. And number four—do you want the full sentences or just the summaries? My summary of the summary? The full sentence.

49:15Okay. Okay. Yeah, we're doing it. Sorry. All of them? No, just the last two. The last two. Okay. Number four was after discovering the dead body of her teenage daughter's lover, a housewife takes desperate measures to protect her family from scandal. And number five is with the keys to his new Plymouth, Ben takes a drive to the lookout with his friends where he met Betty, this knockout that sits next to him in chem class. They hit it off well, but when this mysterious woman shows up, everything changes. Okay. I think I'm going bowler hat. He's going bowler hat. Okay. Spencer. Adam, it's up to you, but I'm switching.

49:53I'm going with David. Bowler hat. Bowler hat it is. He's going with the bowler hat. No, I'm going with David. Let me clarify. I'm going with David. Are you apologizing? What's happening here? Are we breaking up? Yeah, he switched off Adam and on to David is what he's saying here. Well, no, it's Adam's choice. He can choose to follow me on David's bandwagon or not, but that's up to Adam. I got you. So it's up to you. if you want to pile on. Well, David wouldn't choose his own, but he only needs two points to win. That's right. And if he gets the right one, he gets one, right? If he gets it correct, he gets two.

50:26If he tricks you, he gets one more. David could be choosing his own. You know that, right? He could be presupposing a pile on. Both of us are suckers to follow him for those two points, but maybe we are. We're in the back. I don't know. And he's also going first, though, so he's kind of creating the current. to follow. I mean, he's created the pylon and you've fought for his trick. Jamie did go first, technically. Oh, sorry, Jamie went first. But David would want you to know that. David went first-ish. If I fall into this trap that David laid, he's playing checkers and we're playing chess here, so he can win.

51:04Oh, man. That's why we're going to lose right there.

51:12That's how confused he has, Spencer. I don't know, Jared. I feel like that last one needs one more read. What do you think? Okay. You're just trying to make sure we use the full two hours. That's right. With the keys to his new Plymouth, Ben takes a drive to the lookout with his friends where he meets Betty, this absolute knockout that sits next to him in chem class. Was it absolute there before? No, I had that. I just figured it needed to be there. They hit it off well, but when this mysterious woman shows up, everything changes. I'm going with that one. All right. So Adam picks his own. We'll just stop right there.

51:52I'm safe. I'm giving no points away. That's right. David and Spencer. I should say Spencer piled on with David onto the bowler hat. That was Jamie's bowler hat. Damn it. I was like, I was like the guy from England is not going to do a bowler hat. I thought it was on the nose, but all right. Yeah, you got me. And then he acted like it couldn't possibly be right, which made you want to pick it as well. Yep. He's a good actor. He is. And then Jamie went with the harrowing story of Normandy, and that was David's, giving David one point, but not a victory. He approaches the precipice. Meanwhile, Jared scores four points.

52:30Thank you very much, everybody. Because the correct synopsis of the reckless moment is after discovering the dead body of her teenage daughter's lover, a housewife takes desperate measures to protect her family from scandal. That sounded really spicy for 45. That's what I was thinking. Yeah. 1949. Did I do it wrong? 1949. I'm sorry. That might have ruined some World War II ones. Did I mess with World War II? I must have wrote that down wrong. I wrote down 45 as well. Let me see what I wrote down here. Yeah, 45. My bad, y 'all. I award everybody except for David one point for my mistake. Which is exactly why I made up a story about a car named Plymouth.

53:17So Jamie gets one. Because the Plymouth came out in 41-42. So with bonuses applied, he still has more than twice as much as anybody who's actually playing. David has 14 points. I have eight. Still not really playing. Jamie has seven. Adam and Spencer, even though Spencer broke off that hitch, they're still tied with four points each. four. It's fun here at the bottom. Woof.

53:43Right or die. Yeah. All right. We moved to round six. We get to play round six. I wasn't sure if there would be one. And this is back to a pretty normal round. It's another word. However, this word's an acronym, so it's slightly different because it's not just any old word. It's an acronym. So you have to come up with what the acronym stands for and then that thing described or defined. Okay? So the acronym is WIMP. W-I-M-P. That's the acronym, so you'll come up with what it stands for and then a definition of it.

54:21All right, so I looked it up. I remember Carol Lee, PhD, being quite dominant at this game as well, and it turns out she won after six rounds. You missed it. Pressure's on. Well, this is round six right here. so he can tie he had a chance and I have to go back and listen to the transcript or read the transcript and see if that went to 12 points or 15 oh yeah it's 15 points so it's apples to apples I have Jamie's and David's definitions which leads us with one person one one heavy breather

55:05are you trying to intimidate us just giving good audio for the edit give us a mid-90s rmb i'm just i you would just call back look that jason either either pull out a lightsaber or right yeah of course seduce us yeah what are you thinking like tony braxton or like the specific thing that was playing when i said that was wait a minute by ray j which is very like it's very in the chorus there's like a lot of um but also like some of some stuff by 112 i think features that oh yeah go to room 112 where the players dwell i remember them or at least i remember i'm zero informed by that smalls rapping about that i'm not sure if I remember them specifically.

55:54Okay, everybody's in. Five, what do you call them? What do you call the fulfillment of an acronym? Expansion. Five acronym expansions, thank you. With definitions for the acronym WIMP. WIMP. Number one. WIMP, worker initialized multiprocessing, a distributed computing execution strategy. Number two, weekly interacting massive particle, a hypothetical particle proposed as a candidate for dark matter. Number three, wrought iron manifold plateau, the culmination of the process for creating low-carbon iron alloys in which the maximum efficacy of the process is achieved. Number four, Windows Internet Management Platform, The Windows Internet Management Platform is a suite of tools used to manage the network's internet access at the enterprise level.

56:54And number five, Windows Image Management Package. The closed source proprietary answer to the popular open source image manipulation library, GIMP. So it's like GIMP, but for Windows, if I had to put it in my own words. Don't you smile like that, David. No, sir. No, sir. okay audio listeners you didn't see that smile okay i saw that smile that smile was that's mine stay away i'm sure david was i'm sure david was thinking but the new image management program is cross-platform oh i'm sure he was thinking i i i hate that you are correct that that is what i was thinking i have definitely run gimp oh didn't we interview the guy who built gimp one time we He sure did.

57:44He also made Cockroach DB. Oh, that's right. A talented fella. Yeah. He talked a lot about Gimp, too, because I didn't have a clue until I re-interviewed him. You didn't have a clue? Did not get it that dot. No, I think I did up until the day before. In my research, I didn't know it until then. It was a surprise to me. So the plan for the call, and then the call was different because of it. All right. Here we go. This is not Gimp. This is Wimp. Okay. five definitions of wimp i've read them all and i won't read them again unless you ask me to and david gets to go first so david you're right here man this is the game is in your hands all you have to do is identify the actual wimp windows so windows there's gimp for windows there yeah i'm gonna ask you to repeat just like the you don't have to do the definitions just the things yeah The summaries.

58:37I will summarize. So number one is the worker initialized multiprocessing. That's a distributed computing execution strategy. Number two is the weekly interactive massive particle, a hypothetical particle for dark matter. Number three was wrought iron manifold plateau. And number four was the Windows Internet Management Platform, whereas number five was the Windows Image Management Package. that's your wimp five wimps wrought iron manifold plateau i wish i knew more about iron working i think i'm going to go for two so weekly interacting massive particle okay david goes for number two and now we move to spencer that also is going to be my choice i know what it looks like guys I had it circled on my notepad I was going to go for number two that just says David's name you just circled David's name David

59:45alright but it does make me feel better about my choice knowing that David had already picked it so thank you David alright Jamie did you write anything down I mean much as number five is like really selling it to me. I think I'm going to go for the multiprocessing. The worker-initiated multiprocessing. Okay, number one. Just go for something different. There you go. And Adam.

1:00:18On my virtual notebook here, I have also circled number two as a very plausible answer. Uh-huh. independently is that what you chose spencer that's what david's what i chose well more importantly it's what david chose yes get getting the band back together yeah you might as well pile on i mean if your eyes are all wrong i do win though oh no i don't i only have 12 i'm feeling like number four i'm feeling number four is good what's that one jared windows internet management platform that's right it's missing a pilot that. You're not going to guess that one, are you? Of course. It's the same play.

1:01:03I don't know. I don't understand you sometimes. All right, Adam. Adam picked his own again. So he gets zero points for picking his own. I'm too scared of David.

1:01:19I don't want to, though. I don't want to pick that one. It's a cop out. I should have more fun. We'll go with number two. Which one are you doing? We'll go with number two. Yeah, let's have more fun. Whoever earned that answer gets it, whatever it is. Fair. It's a pile on. That's the best answer. Dark matter. Come on, dark matter. All right. Well, David, Spencer, and Adam all piled on. They followed David to the weekly interacting massive particles. He's so excited. Look at David. He's pumped. He knows. He knows. He's like, yeah. And that is the correct definition for WIMP. It's a weekly interacting massive particle.

1:01:54So David scores two. Spencer gets two. Adam gets two. Jamie picked worker initialized multiprocessing. That's David's. Ugh, this guy. You just can't do wrong. You can't do wrong. So above and beyond, he gets three points. Didn't even need that many. Gosh. And he wins with 17 points. Oh, my gosh. Congrats, David. Thank you. Thank you. That's so good. tied for the fastest win in pound define history perhaps the largest margin of victory when second place was me with eight i'm not even playing guys yeah so actual second place was jamie with seven a full 10 points behind david and then spencer and adam with six and one of those points was gimme's that's right so david as is our new tradition that i'm just making up right now uh you must improvise us a song no i'm just kidding

1:02:58i just mistook you from matt ryer for a moment there no we will not have you to do that however you can uh say anything you like you could promote anything you like you have a moment to just say whatever you want man go for it sure uh i guess i'll uh i'll plug the some stuff from the the open source stuff from the company I work for. So the company I work for is Posit.co. We make software for data scientists and scientific computing. A couple of things that might be interesting to check out, there's a project called Quarto, which is a sort of literate programming environment that lets you render R and Python code into websites, all kinds of documents.

1:03:36And we're also building an editor for data scientists called Positron. So check that out at positron.posit.co. Very cool. We will link up all those things. Posit.co, corto.org, and positron.posit.co. Positron.posit.co. There you go. We'll link those up in the show notes so you don't have to read them out loud and type them into your browser if you're driving or something like that. That's it. That's pound to find. This has been a fun one. I wouldn't say it's been a competitive one, but it's had a lot of laughs. And of course, these are our changelog++ people. So I think we have 11 minutes. Is that fair, Jamie?

1:04:15You got 11 minutes to the top of the hour. All right. So if you are one of us, if you are a Plus Plus member, stick around for a bonus round. Right after we say goodbye, Adam, any final words before we hit our bonus round just for the Plus Plus people? You know, if you're a Plus Plus subscriber, it's better. It's been better for years. That's it. All right. Bye, friends. Bye, friends. Bye, friends.

1:04:39Okay. so the guys did stick around and we played a pretty epic bonus round. The winner? I don't want to spoil anything, but I will tell you it's the person you are least likely to guess. If you're not a ChangeLog++ member, join us why don't you? Make the ads disappear, get closer to the metal with cool bonuses like this one, get some free stickers, plus that warm fuzzy feeling you get from directly supporting something you enjoy. Learn more at changelog.com slash plus plus. If you're hearing this right after it drops, then I'm road tripping to Denver for our big live show and Pipely launch. If you can't make it, no big deal.

1:05:18We are recording everything and we'll start shipping those episodes next week. Have yourself a great weekend. Send the change log to a friend or three who might dig it. And let's talk again real soon.

1:05:49All right, you have entered bonus round. The scores are wiped out. It's zero to zero to zero to zero. Take that, David. Jubilee. Yes. We've all got a chance. Anyone's game. Anyone's game. Anybody's got a chance. And this is the most freeform round we have. It's called How Do You Do, Fellow Humans? Game on.

From the publisher

Welcome back to #define, our game of obscure jargon, fake definitions, and expert tomfoolery. This time we're joined by three Changelog++ members, to see who has the best vocabulary and who can trick everyone else into thinking that they do.

More from The Changelog: Software Development, Open Source

All 232 episodes
#define: props to astronomer (Friends)The Changelog: Software Development, Open Source · 1 h 6 min
Listen in VO