1. Podcasts
  2. The Compound and Friends
  3. Statement Risk
The Compound and Friends

27 Jun 2025 · 1h 15m · 28 chapters

In short

The episode debates “statement risk” in investing—how investors’ experiences, analogies, and behavioral biases can distort risk thinking—and then pivots to trend following as a systematic way to reduce permanent capital loss and stay disciplined through drawdowns. The hosts also discuss a Bloomberg-style headline about a footwear startup designing a shoe “in orbit” using AI/blockchain to cut costs and emissions, as a side conversation.

Guests

Cole Wilcox, founder/CEO/CIO of Longboard Asset Management (alternative investment strategies), with 20+ years in investing; he grew up in Paradise Valley, Arizona (third-generation native). Hosts are Josh Brown and Michael Batnick (and their co-host Nicole appears in banter).

Key claims

Most stocks are losers over time; index funds help because they hold survivors. Experience can “color” future decisions, so systematic strategies help. Trend following aims to avoid “double zero” wipeouts by preserving capital and improving the odds of staying invested. Price is treated as the “truth” for signals (not narratives).

Notable examples

1997–2002 cycle; 2022–2023 drawdown; 2008 liquidity crisis; JetBlue as an example of “bottom fishing” constraints; NVIDIA’s volatility/ATR and stop-loss sizing; Vanguard’s lack of retail selling during 2023 bank runs.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:00

Exploring Crazy Ideas in Finance

Discussion on bizarre financial concepts and trends.

“So are you trend following pudgy penguins?”
2:10

Insights on Trend Following Research

Discussion of research on trend following in stock investments.

“You know the chart that we used a long time ago showing the distribution of returns for individual stocks and how few of them beat the index?”
4:00

Understanding Stock Market Dynamics

Exploration of the performance of stocks and their market behavior.

“And that's where that work kind of came from.”
6:40

Investment Strategies and Market Wisdom

Debate about the influence of personal experiences on investment strategies.

“they forget that they're buying a company and they really should just be saying, what is this company and how much is it going to earn and grow over time?”
9:05

Cole Wilcox of Longboard Joins

Hosts open the show with a disclaimer and introduce first-time guest Cole Wilcox, founder and CIO of Longboard Asset Management, and start chatting about his Arizona roots and early market experience.

“All opinions expressed by Josh Brown, Michael Batnick, and their castmates are solely their own opinions and do not reflect the opinion of Ritholtz Wealth Management.”
10:20

The Role of Systematic Strategies in Investing

Discussion on systematic investing and the importance of data-driven decisions.

“because I think you and I are the same age.”
14:00

The Impact of Historical Experiences on Investing

Learn how personal experiences and historical data shape investment beliefs and behaviors.

“Every time it worked historically like 10 out of 10, it was like the yield curve indicator.”
16:40

The Changing Nature of Market Cycles

Understand how market cycles have evolved and the role of information dissemination in shaping investor behavior.

“businesses change, the speed of the world is completely different than what it was in the era where it was phone calls and snail mail.”
21:41

Generational Shifts in Investment Strategies

Explore how younger generations are shaping the investment landscape and their unique approaches to investing.

“My son, who's 15, and all his friends have Robinhood accounts.”
23:21

Cole Wilcox's Investment Philosophy

Discover Cole Wilcox's approach to investing, focusing on diversification and trend-following strategies.

“But let's just set the table for the listeners.”
Show all 28 chapters
28:00

Understanding the Tradeoff in Investments

Learn about the key considerations in making investment decisions, including tradeoffs and personal circumstances.

“I think it depends on who you are, what your priorities are, where you're at in your life cycle.”
28:54

The Benefits of Trend Following

Explore how trend following works as part of a diversified portfolio and its advantages during market fluctuations.

“So a couple of things that attract me to trend following, and I agree with you.”
30:16

Price as Truth in Market Dynamics

Understand how price reflects market sentiment and the implications for trading strategies.

“There's all kinds of psychological studies that prove that this is not what the average person...”
31:24

Perspectives on Technical Analysis

Discuss the relationship between trend following and technical analysis, and the role of data in trading.

“There's a million different things you can look at.”
33:08

Aligning Fundamentals with Price Trends

Learn how price trends relate to fundamental business performance and the importance of long-term views.

“No, we're trying to get you into a fight.”
35:02

The Nature of Market Winners and Losers

Examine the characteristics of high-performing stocks and the approach to managing investments in different market conditions.

“Companies are solving problems in the world.”
36:42

Adapting Strategies to Market Evolution

Discuss the impact of changing market speeds on trend-following strategies and the constants in trend analysis.

“And a trend-following strategy is going to benefit from that.”
42:00

Understanding Stop Loss Strategies

Learn about the implications of volatility on stop loss strategies using NVIDIA as an example.

“So in other words, like you can't use a 10 % stop loss on like the William O 'Neill IBD thing.”
45:50

The Evolution of Trend Following on Stocks

Discover the significance of the 2005 paper on trend following and its implications for individual stocks.

“In quant circles, people refer to it as a landmark paper.”
48:34

Building a Trend Following Fund

Explore how the findings of the trend following paper led to the creation of a fund focused on individual stock trends.

“and then ultimately a better emotional experience.”
51:45

Comparative Analysis of Trend Strategies

Analyze how the fund compares to traditional multi-asset trend funds and its unique strategy.

“Yeah, that's kind of like VHS, you know, was the mutual fund structure.”
56:00

Analyzing Systematic Trend Strategies

Learn about the effectiveness and differences between various systematic trend strategies and their implications for investors.

“a much more consistent ride relative to just owning multi-asset trend standalone where you're happy once a decade.”
59:41

The Concept of Statement Risk

Understand statement risk in investing, particularly how it affects financial advisors and their clients' perceptions.

“How do you defend this thing for nine years with your client going, no, you're like, you just become chicken little.”
1:02:52

Trends in Asset Classes and Their Efficacy

Explore how different asset classes perform under trend-following strategies and the conditions that affect their success.

“Like if you're trend follower, multi-asset, you could literally be doing anything.”
1:05:48

The Potential of Sector-Based Trend Funds

Discuss the possibility and market demand for sector-specific trend-following funds and why they haven't emerged yet.

“versus doing bottom-up trend on idiosyncratic trends of individual companies where they're less efficient markets, you're going to get these monster trends that kind of come out of it.”
1:08:09

Future of ETFs and Mutual Funds

Learn about the potential changes in mutual fund structures, including the introduction of ETFs as share classes.

“Anything we didn't cover on the trend following side or anything that you think is like a big misunderstood piece of how this all works?”
1:10:00

Consulting Opportunities in Finance

Explore the potential for new consulting roles in finance, particularly in creating ETFs.

“But I can also lower costs because I'm expanding my total addressable potential market without increasing the cost burden.”
1:13:42

Show Closing and Staff Acknowledgments

Hosts reflect on the week’s content and thank the staff for their efforts.

“Fall has never looked or tasted this good.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Compound and Friends, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00So are you trend following pudgy penguins? I Saw an ETF filed maybe perhaps I swear to God. Yeah, so there was a there was a headline a tweet yesterday going around that it It sounded like a joke, but it was not a joke. It was like Sneaker discovery in space for the blockchain. Did you see this? Wait, what? We mean sneaker discovery in space of footwear startup is teaming up with two space companies. Okay, so let me read it over a A footwear startup is teaming up with two space companies to design a shoe in orbit as part of a mission to make artificial intelligence and blockchain less expensive and more eco-friendly than it is on Earth.

0:43Why does anyone need this? That's a Bloomberg article. I feel like I would need to be high to even understand what you just said.

0:51Downtown Josh Brown: Are you bullish on that, though, generally? Yeah, it sounds great. You got to see the specifics, but it sounds good. I've learned in the world that we live in today, the crazier, dumber the idea sounds, the better it's probably going to work out. The company's called the WeBlock chain. The degenerate economy. WeBlock. It's amazing. Unbelievable. What's the story? I always wanted to see the videos. What's the story with the bocce? It's the dumbest thing. Hold on. Let Josh explain. We're all avid croquet players. Oh, they're not bocce. They're croquet. These are not bocce. I always thought they were bocce.

1:21Downtown Josh Brown: Not bocce balls. What's the story? Curb Your Enthusiasm? No, dude. it's a visual motif we have behind us the same colors that are in the foreground can I ask you a question honestly Nicole stay here this is about to be insulting no it's not not to be a dick and most sentences that start that way are not great not to be a dick can you imagine if you designed the room that we record the show in no honestly It would be like It would be a college Like Bob Marley poster Blacklight poster Maybe Pam Anderson On the wall With one piece of tape missing She was my number one Right? Yeah Okay we'd be sitting on milk crates No style Yeah Speaking of style It'd be no aesthetic It'd be like an alien Some alien thing Would have to be there too Vic whatever It's a podcast Who gives a shit I'm not a stylist Josh is right Come on Like we gotta There's gotta be some zhuzh To what we're doing here Daniel back back me up as the in-house graphic artist what we're doing what we show on screen is important right okay there's got to be like a vibe to it yeah you're right it's a motif I'm here for it okay for sure do you have alternative suggestions no I'm all in I didn't ask it was eye-catching I always wondered you asked the right question I gave a good answer so you might not be aware of this let me tell you something that you don't know nothing escapes me nothing escapes my omnipotence.

2:52You know the chart that we used a long time ago showing the distribution of returns for individual stocks and how few of them beat the index? Bessenbinder. No, no, no. This guy. You? That's your shit? Originally. Actually, did Bessenbinder he lifted it from you? He lifted it from us.

3:08Downtown Josh Brown: Did he credit you? Yeah. Because I'll find that son of a bitch. He's a good guy. He actually lives in Arizona. Oh, really? Okay. ASU. Shout out to ASU. So what gave you the impetus to look at that? What was the What was the question that you had in your mind that you said, I want to research this? It was kind of a random discovery, actually. We were doing this study on does trend following work on stocks, and we started to look at that. And then just looking at the data, it just seemed very weird that the distribution was so different than what we would learn in school. A kind of normal bell curve distribution type thing.

3:43I was like, wait a minute. This doesn't look anything like what I was taught.

3:48Downtown Josh Brown: We'll get into that today. I didn't realize that that was – I knew your paper, Does Trend Following Work? And then you followed it up, Does Trend Following Still Work? Yeah. We had another paper called The Capitalism Distribution. Okay. That was it. And that's where that work kind of came from. What did he do in his updating of your research that was different than what you guys did? The Bessenbinder? Yeah. He just took it – I think our data went back to in the late 80s, something like that. He took it back for the whole crisp data set to the 1950s or 30s, something. So the longer data set. So the goal of that is like to show people or the research shows people that most stocks end up being losers in the fullness of time?

4:32Downtown Josh Brown: Is that? So here's my interpretation. And it's objective. Most stocks are not worth buying and holding forever. Right? But most of the value creation of the United States and all stock markets are concentrated in the hands of a very few. We all know that. My only issue with the paper is that it assumes that people buy at inception and hold forever. And we know that's not good because most stocks eventually die, right? But that's not how most people invest. That's not how most people invest. There are still opportunities. I'm not here to like advocate for day trading or heavy trading, but there are opportunities to make money from the time, in between the time the company comes into the market versus the time they leave.

5:12You know what I mean? Yeah. I mean, I think index funds benefit from it, though. Sure. Because they own everything. Well, they end up with the survivors. Well, the whole conclusion of the paper, not wrongfully so, is index funds are probably the way to go. I mean, I think for the average person, that's probably true. I mean, the average person is better off doing that than, like, picking stocks based upon the math. Like, it's not good odds. for the average person. Pick a stock.

5:38Downtown Josh Brown: So don't be average. Don't be average. Just pick the best stocks. That's my whole philosophy. That's all I ever do. I mean, this is a life philosophy. Who picks the losers? That's why. Why would you pick the worst stocks? What the hell is wrong with you? I think there's a lot of people who first come into investing and their first instinct is to buy cheap stocks because buy low, sell high. Yeah. And they think that that's like going to be their edge is like they're going to buy the 52-week low list. It's maybe not the worst possible strategy, but it's got to be up there. It's up there. It might be the worst possible strategy.

6:16Downtown Josh Brown: Right, but that's the instinct because people think about, oh, in real estate, like you want to buy a building that's cheap and then you want value. I think in the stock market, if your starting point is, what are the cheapest stocks? Like absent everything, you're buying companies where there are chronic issues. A few of them are mispriced and will work, but most of them are cheap for a reason. Yeah, I think people, when they buy stocks, they forget that they're buying a company and they really should just be saying, what is this company and how much is it going to earn and grow over time? Because ultimately my performance in the stock is going to be dictated by that.

6:49That's so true. If you are going to bottom fish, you better be doing fundamental research. And be good at it too. Yeah, because they're just looking at, oh, it's down off the high. It's like, well, I don't know. Was it a good company back then? Is it a good company now? I don't know. That's what you should be focusing on. Warren Buffett said it. Most tournaments don't turn around.

7:05Downtown Josh Brown: Yeah, I agree with that. So I was on TV today. We were talking about JetBlue. It's a$4 stock. First of all, nobody could buy a$4 stock. Like institutions cannot buy them. There are people that will bottom fish and buy$4 stocks. But what happens is you immediately collapse the universe of potential investors to a tiny slice of people that operate in markets with a lot of capital. I'm buying it right now. I dare you. Well, if you've ever flown on JetBlue, you know why it's a$4 stock. I fly on JetBlue all the time. Totally understand it. I wish there was a stock of JFK Terminal 5. I would short it.

7:45Downtown Josh Brown: I just want to short the—just if I could short the terminal, I would. I can't believe you still fly JFK. Let's start the show. Nicole, let's go. Do we fly out of JFK as opposed to where? Just avoid it like it's AIDS. I have to fly in to come here because there's no direct. It's 20 minutes from my house. Where should I fly out of? LGA. 40 minutes from my house. Dude. Nope. You walk right through. No. You're wrong. No. So dumb. I know. I do that. All right. Come on, do it. Say the thing. The Coffee and Friends episode 197. All right. You mean it. Ladies and gentlemen, missed the call. Whoa, whoa, whoa.

8:20Stop the clock. Here's a word from our sponsor. When you need to build up your team to handle the growing chaos at work, use Indeed Sponsored Jobs. It gives your job post the boost it needs to be seen and helps reach people with the right skills, certifications and more. Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Listeners of this show will get a$75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. That's Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.

9:05Welcome to The Compound and Friends. All opinions expressed by Josh Brown, Michael Batnick, and their castmates are solely their own opinions and do not reflect the opinion of Ritholtz Wealth Management. This podcast is for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon for any investment decisions. Clients of Ritholtz Wealth Management may maintain positions in the securities discussed in this podcast.

9:27Downtown Josh Brown: All right, we are live. This is the number one investing show anywhere. I don't care what you've heard. I don't care what data you've seen. It's not true. We have a very special guest today. I'm so excited to introduce him to all of you. He is a first-time guest here on the Compound and Friends. His name is Cole Wilcox. Cole is the founder, CEO, and CIO of Longboard Asset Management, specializing in alternative investment strategies. Cole has over 20 years of investment experience building alternative investment portfolios. Cole, welcome to the show, dude. Thanks for having me. What part of Arizona are you from?

10:09It's Costale, Paradise Valley. You grew up there? Yeah, born there. You did? Third generation native.

10:13Downtown Josh Brown: Oh, wow. Okay. I want to talk to you about your initial market experience because I think you and I are the same age. 47. I'm 48. Yeah, I'm 48 in September. So I think we've like started investing in 97, 98, 99. Like that's my formative years, unfortunately, because I'm locked into that paradigm mentally now. But it seems like you probably had a similar experience that I did just in terms of like the stock market and what was happening in those early years. Do you find yourself to be ever defaulting back to, well, back in 1999, as often as I do? Because I struggle with that. not 1999, but the whole cycle.

10:56Yeah, yeah. If you've gone through that kind of boom bust multiple times.

11:00Downtown Josh Brown: 97 to 02. 97 to 02. Yeah. You had a bust, a boom, and a major bust after that. And you saw people get rich. You saw people completely get destroyed and the impact that it has on their lives. So I don't think you, that's embedded into your early DNA. Like those people who grew up as depression babies, like they experienced that. It's just – it affected how they think about life. For me, it affected how I think about risk, how I think about the risk that is involved in investing, and to be realistic about these sequences. Because I've lived through it. If you didn't live through that cycle, what came after that was the same.

11:37Downtown Josh Brown: Well, so here's the problem for me. So in 22, it looked very similar to the early stages of 2000, 2001. And we ended up with a 35 % bear market in the NASDAQ that I thought could be negative 70 % because I had had that experience. And, you know, there's this idea in the markets where like your experiences contribute to this like long-term market wisdom. And I think there is some truth to that. But also – I don't. Okay. So I want to hear why in a second. But they like – they can also negatively color the way that you look at things and you are looking for analogies all the time. Like this looks just like that.

12:16Downtown Josh Brown: So when I'm living through 2022 and I'm seeing the bubble, the IPO bubble burst, all I can think about is it's early. It's early. It's early. This is going to go way lower. And of course it doesn't. But I know exactly why I felt that way in that moment because I lived through it very early and it was formative. Yeah. Well, I think it's very natural for people to build those biases and their experiences build biases. and it's very dangerous to invest or reason by analogy in anything. It is a known thing. So I know that and I know my own personal biases. And that's why I focused on building systematic strategies because I'm just like any other human.

13:00I have those real things, but a systematic approach doesn't have that memory. Exactly. And that's the major benefit of it. It has that memory, but you're coding it in.

13:11Downtown Josh Brown: like it's a systematic approach based on historical volatility and returns the memory is there no opinions the opinion's not there yeah that well it's the it's the math is there it's like you just do what is statistically the most probable you don't talk yourself out of it you know after you do the math which is i think where the bias has come in well i think it's different this time when it's not different what are you but what are you saying you're saying that people don't have those biases i'm saying they're absolutely doing it hurts them so okay so no nobody disagrees with that. We all agree.

13:41No, I'm saying that I think that experience, experience and wisdom in life are great. I think in the market, it could be treacherous. I think it was Peter Bernstein's book who wrote about how, what's it Bernstein? I can't remember. In the 1950s, when the yields of bonds crossed above stocks, anytime they converged, it was a sell signal for stocks. Stocks got too expensive. Every time it worked historically like 10 out of 10, it was like the yield curve indicator. And then one time it just stopped working and it never worked ever again. And then forevermore, bonds yielded more than stocks. And I think that once you have that muscle memory, things change a lot over time.

14:17And especially if you have a traumatic experience early in your formative years, like you did and like you did, you see that every time stocks fall. And I think that, yes, there are positive lessons that you can learn from your own history. But I think people over-index what happens to them early in their career.

14:35Downtown Josh Brown: Experience overrated in investments. Totally, because people become experts on an earlier version of the world. I'm stealing that from somebody. I don't know who. And I think that's what happens. And it stays with you. Well, it's also the own internal ego. Like, you overemphasize your own personal experience, and that's all you know. If you're able to do backtesting and run research and look at 100 years of data, then you get all of these other lifetimes of experiences that you can contrast with your own personal. It extends the data set with which you can evaluate what you want to do. I think that's the issue is that people who don't have the data and can't do that research are not able to build a more balanced viewpoint of reality.

15:11Downtown Josh Brown: I think valuations to like where your experience is your worst enemy because companies have gotten better at being companies. And as a result, we are systematically paying higher and higher multiples for earnings. Like we just are. There's a lot of fundamental reasons why. There's a lot of macroeconomic reasons why. And a lot of people got anchored to the PE ratios they remember as being a stock market bottom. Or margins mean reverting. Margins were a very mean reverting series historically and then came the tech giants that just ripped that up so that doesn't exist anymore. How could you have known?

15:47And so when you see, I think the most wrong people on TV are when people say, I've seen this movie before. No, you haven't.

15:54Downtown Josh Brown: Yeah. So like, if you think about like an early 80s paradigm where the S &P bottoms at 10, right? It's like, well, stocks don't bottom until we get to 10. We were never gonna get to 10 times earnings. There's too much money that needs to be invested in stocks. And there's a different investor populace now with a higher risk appetite. And they're earlier in their investing careers and just they're not anchored to like those historical moments. So that's the thing where I have to check myself the most often. It's like, I think this because I lived through it, but it doesn't always have to be the same as things used to be.

16:33Downtown Josh Brown: And we're going to talk a little bit about cycles and stuff like that because I'd love to get your take on this concept. But in addition to the fact that the markets change, the people investing change, businesses change, the speed of the world is completely different than what it was in the era where it was phone calls and snail mail. So we should expect cycles to speed up. So this is where I want to start. Am I imagining that we're having one-month recessions and one-week bear markets, or do you feel the same way? I think it feels that way because of the news cycle and social media, and it speeds up how we feel about the markets.

17:15But I don't think it's any just different than the time that it's ever been. I just think the speed at which information gets diffused and reacted to is at just a higher amplitude than it used to be. The V-shaped recoveries are different, though. Like, that wasn't a feature of markets in the 80s and 90s as information took longer to disseminate amongst investors. I mean, I think it feels that way. In 1998, huge V-shaped recovery, right? We thought we were going out of business with long-term capital management. Less than six months later, we're back at new highs. Yeah. So flash crashes, even in this cycle, happened like 2010.

17:49Flash crash, market's down 8%, 10 % intraday. So it's been there the whole time. The quant crash, there's different things that you've seen different cycles that have happened. But I agree, it feels that way. I just don't think it is really different.

18:03Downtown Josh Brown: Does it matter who's in the marketplace? because one of the things I think I think is that if you have a huge wave of younger people who at the margin are controlling what stock prices do and they're not saddled with any of these baggage of two-year long bear markets like 2002, like they don't have that as part of their history or their experience. They are more willing to buy those dips and they're more willing to turn a dip into a V-shaped recovery because they can't imagine a scenario where the market spends two years pricing in bad news. So I've lived through that, but that's in an analog time.

18:42Downtown Josh Brown: And now everything is digital. And it's like, all right, here's the news. It's bad. I sell something the next day. OK, I guess I'll buy something else. I feel like it's who is in the market that's contributing to the V-shape more than anything else. Yeah, well, I think that the younger generation, despite the bad rep that they get with the degenerate economy and leveraged trading and daily options, I actually see investor behavior being far, the average young person who's a serious investor is a better investor than before. But they should be. They have more access to information. They see what works, what doesn't work.

19:15It's just a lot out there where their behavior on average, I think, is much better than young people of the 1980s.

19:21Downtown Josh Brown: They're more informed. The wake-up call to that was like, the response to the spring 2023 bank runs, right? They didn't budge. Like, Vanguard data, nobody sold anything. Like, I don't know who was selling, but it was not the retail regular investor. They just like lived through it. And they were just like, whatever. I don't think that you could have said that about prior errors in the financial crisis. People were actively selling stocks in 401ks. They just don't do it anymore. And I think it's because they've built on the experiences of the past. People learn lessons. They learn what happens when I panic and I do all these things to my long-term investments.

20:00Downtown Josh Brown: It looks stupid after. And now I don't think anyone does that anymore. No, and when it's, they don't do it because it's paid them not to do it. You know, we've been in a pro-label market. Buy the dip, you know, has worked. And until it doesn't work for them, I think you should expect them to continue to do that. They're not going to proactively change and like, oh, and now I need to think about what might happen in the next 1997 to 2002 cycle. I'm just going to react to what my personal experience is, which is buy the dip works. So we never had the 97 to 02 experience. But what we did have, we did have a 20-month bear market where their favorite stocks lost two-thirds of their value, and they didn't leave.

20:38They're still in the game. What is that, late 21? 2022 to the bottom of, it was October 23. It was January 22. That was when we topped. And we bottomed in October of 23. So that was almost two full years of pain. But they've had more pain, I think, also outside of the stock market. Think about the pain that they experienced in Bitcoin, right? Like multiple 60, they're just not like, they're not phased. They have the laser eyes. They're just locked in diamond hand owners of stocks for, for young people who are really serious about investing these days.

21:08Downtown Josh Brown: Yeah. I think that's, I think that's cool. Um, I like that the, the Gen Z's kind of kicked the door down during COVID. That was their moment where they all discovered investing all at once. Like it was an amazing thing. the amount of brokerage accounts that were opened in 2020 and 2021 broke every record we have on the books. And stayed open. They didn't leave. They didn't leave. But I'm just saying, like, I can't think of another time where an entire generation all started investing at once. And that's what they did. And they have the tools. Think about the tools. Like Robinhood. My son, who's 15, and all his friends have Robinhood accounts.

21:45They trade. They're investing. And they start so much younger. So much younger. And public. Shout out to public. sponsor the show. Screw Robinhood. Public. Right. I agree with that. Does the story— So you've been in this business for a while talking about systematic investing, removing the biases. Like, this is a good way to insulate yourself from the what should I do? Because we'll just listen to the market. Don't worry about your opinion. Your opinion, everybody else's opinion, it's in price. And there are trends. We follow them for better or for worse. It's not perfect. There's, like everything else, there's no perfect strategy.

22:19But does that story resonate more with investors today than it did in, say, the early 2000s when it was still sort of a novel approach? Oh, yeah, for sure. I think alternative investments in general, especially after 2008, because people saw the benefit of having alternatives. And 0 to 02 helped. 2008 really put the hammer down of you really should have these diversified portfolios with other risk management strategies, things that have low correlation. You can't just rely on stocks and diversification across a wide portfolio of stocks. It can all just go down at the same time. Your stocks and bonds can go down at the same time.

22:54Your stocks, bonds, commodities, and real estate can all go down at the same time. 2008 was really, really, you know, for those people. Everything broke. Yeah, there was no place to hide. Even gold. People forgot that gold rallied after. After, because in the liquidity crisis, everything, you know, is going down. It's just a giant sucking sound for liquidity.

23:12Downtown Josh Brown: So let's talk a little bit about your investing philosophy and how you actually invest. And then I have some questions based on that. But let's just set the table for the listeners. Who is Cole Wilcox, the investor? Well, Cole Wilcox, the investor, is somebody who believes in a diversification, right? You need to retain a diversified portfolio. I don't think trend following is the only thing that you should have in your portfolio. I think it's a piece of a well-thought-out strategy that is designed to compound wealth over time, protect you through all the different market cycles, knowing that you're probably not going to be very good at predicting what's going to come.

23:49So build something that can kind of get you through everything. And most importantly, and this is where I come at as an investor, the most important thing in investing is to remove the double zero from the roulette wheel of investing. You know, the O8. The wipeout. The wipeout where you've made all of these bets. You bet every number on the board, but you still lost because it hit double zero and they take all your chips. You have to build something that removes that because if you do it, then you've already won over the long term. You just have to run your strategy and do what you need to do.

24:22And I think that for what I do and our philosophy of trend following and kind of our approach is an excellent tool for removing that double zero from your portfolio. Why? How does trend following help you do that? Well, it's two ways. One of them is just the most important thing is avoiding permanent loss of capital in investing. And while the young people wouldn't agree with this because they only have their data set, I can go back 100 years, 200 years, look at the cycle of the stock market. There will be periods of time of absolute horrific pain as an equity investor. We have asset bull markets.

25:04We have bear markets. We have occasionally, once a generation, a depression. I don't know if that is going to happen now or next year, but it will eventually happen. The trend following does an excellent job of kind of removing the highly destructive permanent loss of capital in those massive drawdowns of 20 % to 60%. And more importantly— How does it do that? Well, by preserving capital. So it's a capital preservation strategy that as we kind of rotate, as trends change, we're rotating more into low correlated treasury bills and preserving capital and just reducing the drawdown, right? So if my drawdown is only 20, right, I only need a 30 % return to get back to new highs.

25:45If it's 50, I got to make 100 % return to get back to new highs. So you're putting yourself ahead of the game by playing very good defense in bad markets and just mathematically. The second part, I think, is even more important. It goes back to the behavioral aspect of it. You're getting invested and you're able to stay invested and stay disciplined because you don't lose so much money. You don't go down so much that you deviate from your plan. I can't tell you how many people I saw deviate from equities like Boomer Generation in 08. They just freaked out. I can't deal with the pain anymore. I'm concerned that stocks are going to go to zero and I move to bonds or I move to something else, which is super destructive.

26:23It was bad timing. It was a wrong time to panic. But going down, we know psychologically human beings just don't like losses. And the worse it gets, the more painful it is. And then that changes your behavior. And that's the worst thing you can do is deviate from a plan.

26:38Downtown Josh Brown: So we built a trend-following strategy in-house. Michael did most of the heavy lifting because that was the question we were trying to answer. How do we keep people from blowing out their entire portfolio in one of those types of market moments, which admittedly are rare? How do we make sure that people just don't throw everything away because of a moment like that? And to us, there's a lot of answers. We looked at a lot of other people's answers. But the real thing is like when you are in a slow crashing market before it becomes a fast crashing market, take some exposure off. And client by client, it varies how appropriate it is, how much you need to do that.

27:17Downtown Josh Brown: But the question is not, does a trend following strategy help investors hold on to their portfolio? The question is, what is the cost of it? Isn't that like the hardest part of what you do is like, hey, this ain't going to be free. There are going to be markets where because we're trend following, there might be a whipsaw. We might have to get out of something and then buy it back higher. What's the cost of that relative to other ways to hedge risk? Yeah. And for me, it's two kinds of costs. There's like real mathematical costs, like you actually cost you money. And then there's the emotional cost and the psychological cost of doing stuff where it's more in your head.

27:57It's not in your head, not really in your wallet over time. But they matter because if it's in your head, it affects what you do and then it affects your wallet. But that tradeoff of is it worth doing? What am I giving up? What am I gaining? What do I have to pay in fees? What am I getting in return? What's the value proposition there? That's the most important. you know, kind of a question. I think it depends on who you are, what your priorities are, where you're at in your life cycle. And you just got to, you know, for some people, I would say trend following will make any sense for them. You know, like the - If you're 20 years old, you should be buying more when this would trigger a sale.

28:31Yeah. And, yeah, it just doesn't matter.

28:36Downtown Josh Brown: It's the dollar amount that you're protecting. And how much time and duration you have. You know, maybe if you get whacked and you lose 50 % in a stock when you're 20, maybe that's a good thing. Good, buy more, keep buying. Or it's a good lesson for you to learn and kind of go through time so that you'll not do those kinds of crazy risky things in the future when you have more money and when you have no duration left to kind of figure it out. So a couple of things that attract me to trend following, and I agree with you. It works as part of a broader diversified portfolio. It works really well in concert with strategic asset allocation.

29:03Two things. Number one, it gives you the ability to ride a bull market, which is really hard. And especially if you are an advisor and you are telling your clients, this part of your portfolio is going to protect us to varying degrees from downside deviation. If that portion can't survive a bull market, it's dead. It's worthless. If the market is doubled and this thing is flat, clients will never stick with it. So it allows you to stay fully invested when the trend tells you to. Number two, and perhaps more important, is the buy back, buying back in. Trend following, we just experienced this. We bought back higher.

29:43It's not fun, but it doesn't matter that it, yeah, it doesn't feel good to buy back higher, but it's a lot better than waiting for a return to previous levels that just never happened. Right? So if you were a trend follower and you sold in December 2007 and you got back in in March or whatever, or April, May. This gives you the buy signal, objectively and unemotionally. And getting back in after you've sold is almost impossible. If it's discretionary.

30:11Downtown Josh Brown: Especially if you sold at a loss. Impossible. Psychologically, people don't do it. There's all kinds of psychological studies that prove that this is not what the average person... I mean, there are some maybe non-normal people that deviate from this. But for the general bell curve of the population, it's not going to happen. They shouldn't be doing it. They're just going to get themselves in trouble with it. I also think trend is the least bullshitty way of deciding whether or not I'm buying and staying long or I'm getting out. Meaning you could have all these formulas like we look at the Fed model of like earnings versus like what the yield is on a T-bill and all this shit.

30:52Downtown Josh Brown: You could have the economic indicators that are subjective. Price gives you everything. The economy changes. If you just focus on price to dictate whether or not you're buying and selling, you're pulling in the sum total of all of those other things. It's reflecting everyone's opinions about everything. How could it not be the least bullshitty way of doing it? Well, not only the least bullshitty, it's also engineering-wise just the principles of engineering is like the most elegant, right? It has the least amount of variables. It has the least amount of moving parts. It has the least degrees of freedom.

31:23So it's – and you're not going to like – there's a lot of different ways to come up with all these correlation here, there, and stories you can tell yourself. Magazine covers.

31:33Downtown Josh Brown: There's a million different things you can look at. But the price is the price. It's also your trade – you're investing and you're taking signals and you're doing something off of ultimately what is the fundamental principles of accounting. If it went up, you made money from an accounting world. If it went down, you lost money. Like that's what's going to determine whether or not your P &L was positive or negative. All the rest of the stuff is just a narrative that ultimately you can trade off of those narratives, but it's still going to come down to price and whether or not it went up or down as to whether or not you're, you know, with the value.

32:03Downtown Josh Brown: So we've always thought that way. When somebody makes a statement, price is truth, it's not the same thing as saying the price is right. The market overprices and underprices itself and assets every day. We're not saying price is the absolute correct price all the time. Price is always the truth of how people feel about the market because that's where they're buying and selling. It's what the market's expectations are at any point of what's going to happen in the future. But like any prediction market, the expectations can be wrong. They move. They can be right. They can be right, correct odds.

32:40They're just a representation of the odds. That doesn't mean that they're setting the odds correctly. Yes. Yeah. They're going to be wrong less times than you are if you're just making it up. I think prices are wrong.

32:50Downtown Josh Brown: Okay. Yeah. So do you believe in technical analysis in general? Or are there areas of technical analysis where you say, all right, I get that there are some people who focus on this, but I've been able to throw that out because it's not really important to what I do. I don't want to knock the technical side of it. No, we're trying to get you into a fight. No, trend following is technical analysis. Trend following is technical analysis. It's not pattern recognition. It's not like Ichimoku nonsense, but no offense, but it's technicals. To me, the trend following is… Oh, wait a minute. You don't consider yourself a technician.

33:23Downtown Josh Brown: You're a quant. I'm neither. I'm just like a pragmatic person who… An astrologer. What do you call yourself? Like you're disciplined. You don't tell people you're technical? No, I just… You're a trend follower. I'm just a trend follower. I'm just an investor. That's its own world, basically. It's a universe within technicals. It absolutely is. Right? Within the CMT, trend following is - But he's not looking for patterns. I understand. In my world, I think of market technicians, like, I have a pattern. Here's a chart. I think this is going to happen. It's like the William O 'Neill, CanSlim, you know, IB.

33:58There's no backtesting objectiveness, right, to these things. Like, I'm more like an actuary, right, where I can look at the probability distribution of all the data and say, hey, here's the actuarial distributions. I'm coming up with the math of what I'm doing based upon, you know, that. and probability distributions. I'm not like chart patterns or whatever. I'm not saying they're like related. It's kind of like cousins. Like, oh, look, there was a breakout. You can look at this chart. Because breakouts happen in uptrends. Yes. Obviously.

34:25Downtown Josh Brown: But where they're related is that it's a focus on the price. Yes. Versus a focus on the underlying business or who's the CEO or what products is the company about to launch. That's where they're related. That's true. But for me personally, I also come back to, at the end of the day, price trends are all going to come down to fundamentals. I mean, like over time, companies that grow their earnings, companies that grow their competitive advantage, companies that grow their earnings power are the ones where their equities are going to go up. We totally, you and I completely agree on that. It's not like magic where it's like, oh, there's a chart and it goes up.

35:01Like there's a reason that this energy or this fuel exists for these massive 50 bag or 100 bag. Companies are solving problems in the world. They're creating real value. The marketplace is rewarding those companies with superior profit margins or whatever it be for the value they create in the world. You can't divorce those two from one another. You will never see –

35:20Downtown Josh Brown: You can short-term but long-term, the voting machine versus the weighing machine. You're right. Yeah. If you zoom out even to a monthly basis, revenue – maybe not revenue. Net income, free cash flow, price follows that. It just does. Not every day, not always, but over time, they converge. Yeah. And that's – I'm different from a trend-following standpoint. Most people, when you think about trend as a category or trend following - I think about commodity traders and - Commodities, currencies - CTAs. CTAs, like that kind of world. That's the unit. They're multi-asset portfolio. It's long, short.

35:53They're selling low correlation. Maybe they make money in a down market. But they're just trading trends. Like if you ask, well, why do these trends exist? Why do you make money? I really have a great answer for that. Like what's the DNA of corn? I just know it works. I don't know why. I just know it works. I don't know why. Why are you short sugar? Yeah, because it went down. I'm like, that's fine. It can be in the data. You're like, well, the math says it works. Look, it's worked historically. On the stock trend following side of it, it's like I can tell you I am supremely confident that the system of capitalism and the taking risk and innovation and the rest of it is going to create massive winners.

36:33There are going to be companies that get created and form public, and there are going to be huge winners, 50-bagger, 100-baggers. and that's going to leave behind, and they're going to create massive economic value, and that's going to leave behind these long-term trends. And a trend-following strategy is going to benefit from that. And it's like an ongoing system that would just pump out these things. I don't feel that same way or can't make that same argument for why is there going to be a mega trend in short corn. There are risk transfer markets, hedgers, speculators. I know there's this whole other argument about it.

37:06Downtown Josh Brown: demand of the underlying. There are mechanical issues with delivery. There's a lot more that's involved. There's a lot of stuff kind of going on. In the stock world, though, I don't know, it's just very simple. I'm confident that there are going to be massive winners. I'm also confident there's going to be a bunch of shitty companies and stocks that go to zero, and you have to do kind of both. And trend following is a fantastic mechanism for ensuring that you own those future winners without having to be very good at predicting them. And more importantly, or equally important, it's good about clipping aggressively the losers that are going to be destructive to your life.

37:42I mean, most people that are running businesses are not good businesses. Most businesses are bad businesses, mediocre managers, people that are diluting the shit out of shareholders. Like they're not, it's a minority of companies that actually are these great quality businesses that have real competitive advantages that grow and turn out to be mega wealth creators for shareholders.

38:04Downtown Josh Brown: So you mentioned looking at 100 or 200 years of data. Do you have to, in the way that you formulate your strategies or the way you execute, do you have to like update and account for the fact that as we talked about, everything is faster and the length of time that it might've taken for a bear market to become a bull market again in the 1970s is gonna be a very different length of time as it is now? Or can you like just look at the fullness of a data set that long and just say human nature is what it is and whatever would have worked in a back test historically would probably still work? I think it depends on what kind of trend follower, you know, like when you say there's different speeds at which people do trend following.

38:47If somebody might've been a short-term trend follower or maybe more like momentum guys, I would put in the short-term category. They're buying and selling, maybe they're average full-time swing traders.

38:56Downtown Josh Brown: Yeah, yeah. The stocks that we own in our process are held in duration for multiple years. We're capturing megatrends, things we own for a long period of time. And by being in stocks that make new highs and just sitting on our ass and waiting for them to kind of play out as they continue to do it and not interrupting the compounding of winners that you have kind of in your portfolio. So what I would say is, yes, market speeds change, stuff evolves over time. But a new high 100 years ago and the math of it is the same thing today. There's no difference between a new high 100 years ago and a new high today.

39:30So that's very important. And one of my weaknesses, and I think this is common amongst all discretionary traders, is the temptation to sell your winners, right? Because we know how hard they are to come by, so you want to lock in your gains. Josh is very good at it. Josh has been in Shake Shack for 11 years, NVIDIA for a decade. He's very good at that. I'm not. So I have all of these stocks today hitting my screen that are at 52-week highs, and I am fighting the very— You can't wait to sell them. I am fighting the very human urge to lock in profits, especially the way that we just had this V-shaped rally.

40:00So how do I know when the trend has changed? Like, what do you look for to know that the trend is broken? I mean, there's a lot of different ways. Tell me the answer. Anybody, you know, could do it. But, you know, somebody could run a very simple moving average, you know, 200-day moving average, you know, number or 300-day or 200-week, depending upon the speed and time frame that you're kind of looking at, that you don't have to be a rocket scientist to figure out what is a trend up, down, to get in, to get out. I love that answer.

40:29Downtown Josh Brown: What indicators other than moving averages are relevant to your work, if any? The only thing that really matters to us are new highs, new lows, and what's the kind of volatility of the stock. Because if you're - Average true range? Yeah, like average true range. I think that's a powerful tool that doesn't get talked about enough. Can you explain to the audience what average true range is and how a trend follower would utilize it? So an average true range is recognizing that different stocks have different volatility profiles. So if you kind of look back the last 90 days, there's 500 stocks in the S &P 500.

41:03Each one of those is going to have a different path traveled in that 90-day box. if we use volatility as a risk proxy, you know, and you want to have a portfolio kind of had equal risk between the two positions, then you wouldn't want to have the same amount of money invested. So it's a position sizing.

41:22Downtown Josh Brown: This particular position is an average true range, let's say, of five. This one is two and a half. You would want to own double the amount of the one with two and a half because you're lowering the volatility of the whole portfolio. Correct. And you'd have equal kind of proportional risk between the two positions. Also, if you think about a trend follower, it goes into the stop loss calculation. If you have a high volatility stock and you put the stop very close in a volatile stock, you're going to get chopped in and out of that. If you do the same stop loss and something has less volatility, it's not going to be as sensitive.

41:55So it has an effect also on the stop loss and how much you get whipsawed kind of in and out. So in other words, like you can't use a 10 % stop loss on like the William O 'Neill IBD thing. Because if I have 50 % volatility, I'm guaranteed to get stopped out in a 10 % stop loss. Maybe not necessarily in something as much lower of all.

42:14Downtown Josh Brown: So let's take a name like NVIDIA as an example. NVIDIA is a stock that can go for three months nowhere. And then it could go on a six month run where it makes a new high every week. Right? When it's trending higher, you look at a 21 day ATR. it's probably tight because the stock's not going up 8 % a day. It's going up a quarter of a point a day, but it's driving people crazy because it doesn't let them in. So it's got a low ATR. It's making highs. It's unfortunately too far above its moving average for that to be a useful stop. Like you talk about some of these in video rallies we've seen. There have been periods of time where it was 100 % above its 200 day.

42:54Downtown Josh Brown: Like what the hell are you going to do? That's your stop? Okay. Okay, so those are the types of stocks where you have to say to yourself, I better take a look at at least what its beta is or its average range so that I don't put a stop in that I get hit on tomorrow. That's the kiss of death for trend following. Yeah, the kiss of death, yeah, doing that. The kiss of death. The kiss of death. The kiss of death. All right. I'm looking at you. You taking a picture? That is a mouthful. All right. But you can, the other thing that you can do, and this is what we do, is you also have to remember you can be in a trade and volatility profiles change.

43:32You know, they're not static. They can be high. They can then rotate to low. You can adjust the position size through the cycle. So in that world where NVIDIA is way above its 200-day, you're like, well, the distance to stop, if my stop is a 200-day moving average, is very far away. And you're uncomfortable with that delta or the risk there. Well, you can take some of the position off to reduce the open risk. You don't have to change the stop loss or the robustness of it. You could just change how much you're exposed to it in order to be happier. You know, I like the answer that you gave earlier about, you know, you're like, I don't know, 200 a day or 100, whatever, whatever you like.

44:06I think people tend to overcomplicate the shit out of it. It doesn't, the more bells and whistles, the more inputs, you're not getting more precision. You're just getting more noise. It doesn't matter as, I mean, it matters if you're due too short term, it's not robust and you're just trading in and out. But if you get outside the noise factor, it doesn't really matter. What does matter is that you execute it consistently and robustly and take every trade and do it. That's the part where people mess it up, right? They just don't have the ability to get that disappointed.

44:36Downtown Josh Brown: Well, if you start cherry picking, all right, I'm about to get stopped out on this, but I think they have a big announcement coming Monday. Like if you start down that road, then you don't have a process anymore. You have what most investors have, which is just random. Dude, you can't ignore your intuition. Right. But I'm saying you have to decide at some point early on, especially if you're a professional, this is either science or it's an art project. Some art projects turn out really well. But if you're selling that as science, that's really bad. Yeah. I personally don't recommend trend-following strategies for average investor people.

45:12I think if you like the strategy—

45:13Downtown Josh Brown: All of our listeners are above average investors. Yeah. Thank God. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. We're safe. We're safe.

45:49Downtown Josh Brown: I want to talk about your does trend following work on stocks and then why you chose to update it in January of this year. In quant circles, people refer to it as a landmark paper. Do you know that? No. Okay. Because I was doing some homework. What is a quant circle? Because that sounds like not a good thing. In some circles where people talk about equity market research, there are people who have referred to your paper as landmark. So I threw that in there. Why was that? When did you first write, does trend following work on stocks? And why do you think there are people who look at that as a really important thing that you published?

46:30When did we do it? 20 years ago. 2005. 2005. Yeah. Was the publication of that paper. And for me, I was doing trend following and I was allocating, like running a hedge fund fund of funds. And I was investing with trend following managers. but they were multi-asset, you know, longshore currency commodity. That's the typical traditional trend-following thing, the CTA world that you see from. And I asked them, like, how come you don't do – there's all these massive trends. Here's the data of individual stocks. Why don't you – nobody in the entire industry, there's like hundreds of billions of dollars invested there.

47:04Nobody was doing trend-following on stocks.

47:06Downtown Josh Brown: Meaning they would trend-follow an index. Stock index. Like the futures. Yeah. But you're talking that at the individual security level. The very specific individual security level. Well, I'll tell you why nobody did it because it probably took you forever. it's probably a huge project. It was a huge project, put the stuff together, whatever. But I mean, these are multi-billion dollar hedge funds. Like they can figure it out. It's not like with all these PhDs on staff. Like it wasn't, they definitely could do it. And they, I think it's just a bias where, you know, they're in the futures world.

47:32They're comfortable with these indexes. But I was like, so that was just a really untapped opportunity. Nobody had done the work and we saw it as an opportunity to go on like, let's do something that was new. Nobody needed another research paper to show you that trend following worked on corn. Like that had been, done so many times by so many people. And that's where it kind of came from. And I was kind of shocked that nobody had done it. And then we decided to turn it into an investable product. I'm more shocked that 20 years later, we're still the only firm that I know of in the world that's like actually running a fund and doing this.

48:05Downtown Josh Brown: So what happens after you publish this? What are the conclusions from the 05 paper? The 05 paper, I would say three conclusions. One, it was definitely a robust, It works effectively on individual stocks, and you can build a better stock market mousetrap. Better not meaning it makes more money than the stock market after all transaction costs. You're focused on risk-adjusted. The risk-adjusted returns. You can get the same or slightly better return than being a passive diversified equity investor, but do it with substantially less drawdown, substantially less volatility, correlation, beta, whatever, and then ultimately a better emotional experience.

48:43It's like your behavior is going to be better if you're in a stable or ride along the way. So that's kind of what I mean by better. It's not something that's going to like double the rate of return on the stock market. But if I get something with way less risk and a better emotional experience and get the same – and it doesn't cost me anything. It's like actually I'm getting the same thing as an index or better. That was my definition better.

49:03Downtown Josh Brown: What were the other two conclusions? That it was very, very uncorrelated to multi-asset trend following. Oh, wow. So you have$300 billion right now as an industry that's allocated to multi-asset trend. And this multi-trend following on stocks is very uncorrelated to that whole sector. And it has like three times the return. The last 10 years, the SG Trend Index, which is like the hedge fund index of the trade. Yeah, it's not great. 2%. Yeah. But people love it because it's – or they use it because it's the most negatively to non-correlated asset. So it's a great portfolio diversifier. and it has the potential to make money in a market crisis like once every 10 years.

49:46But in the last 10 years, you would have been much happier with us as running this trend following thing on stocks and the compound annual growth rate that you got. And we have lower drawdowns than this diversified multi-tastic thing. So it didn't look like the other funds that are in this basket. Yeah, it doesn't look like the other funds in the basket. It has the same style, same risk management, same philosophy, everything. But it's uncorrelated. So it makes a great diversifier. Like putting them together makes the investor experience of investing in trend. Like you're way happier with that experience than kind of the, I owned managed features or systematic trend for 10 years.

50:21I was happy in 2022 and I was angry every other year because of the underperformance drag and things like that. Are you SMA only or a mutual fund as well? We run a mutual fund and we offer SMA. People wanted to do an SMA, but our primary product is a mutual fund.

50:36Downtown Josh Brown: So you put the paper out and you built the fund based on the findings. So now that we know A, B, C, and D, here's how we would build the mousetrap that people could actually put money into. Yes. Okay. Now you did that in a time before active ETFs. There was really no such thing at that time. There was ETFs, but most active strategies are in mutual funds. If you were starting today, would you have built the product differently? would you start with an ETF? If I was doing it today, I would do an ETF. Okay. Only because, and we will, you know, you asked me what is the most exciting thing that I'm most excited about, you know, in the future is the, hopefully the coming potential of mutual funds being able to ETFs as a share class.

51:24I think it's gonna be great for the industry, levels the playing field.

51:27Downtown Josh Brown: Yeah. It's gonna be great for consumers. It's gonna lower price, increase access choice. The taxable ramifications. Yeah, all of the above. But I would do the ETF because that's obviously like the vehicle of choice. This is what people push the buy button for these days. Yeah, that's kind of like VHS, you know, was the mutual fund structure. The DVD is the ETF. And then like going even beyond that is streaming is like the next generation, maybe tokenization of stuff or whatever. So we're not there yet. There's an ETF for almost everything except for individual trend following stocks. As far as I know, there are ETFs that do trend following on large cap indexes and probably other indexes, but I don't think I've ever seen one on individual securities.

52:13I don't know of any company or any manager in the public world or even the private world that is doing systematic trend this way on individual securities.

52:21Downtown Josh Brown: Well, think about how many decisions you have to make to do this. Number one, you have to say, well, if I'm only buying stocks that are in uptrends, right? What if there are no stocks in uptrends? Like, that's a thing that's going to happen at some point. Um, what do I hold when I'm not in stocks? Like what's the, what's the default risk off position or positions? Three, is there going to be a sector cap? Like what if it's all tech stocks? Do I just own all the tech stocks and nothing else is an uptrend? Um, like you have to, you have to make each of those decisions along the way to come up with an idea, which requires a ton of testing.

52:56Downtown Josh Brown: And like a lot of companies are just going to default to doing something easier. Well, they're going to do something very simple in that way, or they're going to try to concentrate in one sector. can you get it down to 50 stocks? And it's like, well, I could if I knew which one of those 50 stocks are going to be the winners. The reason I have to do the Russell 3000 as a total starting point is because I don't know what the next big winner is going to be. You have to be where the momentum is. You don't know how many stocks that's going to be. You don't know what sectors. So you cap weighted at all or cap adjust?

53:22No, it's the opposite of that. So we've all weighed or we risk weighed each position. So we tend to have very small, equally dispersed positions across everything. The delta between our largest position and smallest position is not nearly as big as what you would see in a cap-weighted. In a healthy uptrend, how many stocks-ish would you own? You know, like 500. We tend to own about 20 % of the investable universe. Okay.

53:47Downtown Josh Brown: And then when you risk off, what does the portfolio look like? Is it like T-bills or less stock? How do you do that? Cash and T-bills. Okay. Have you ever experienced a reconstitution where your gut is telling you, oh my God, I really hope the rules let me sell because I want to sell right now? Every year. Okay. I mean, HIMSS. Do you think I really want to own that growth stock of HIMSS? Get out the growth stock? Right. But your rules are your rules and you have to just knuckle through it. That's like part of the deal. Yeah. If it's rules-based, it's rules-based. Or wait, we bought, I remember in the crazy COVID time, we bought GameStop, came into the portfolio, the breakout was like, that wasn't like - But on the flip side, when you have a quick trend change and HIMSS shrinks, get it?

54:31Yeah. You got to sell.

54:33Downtown Josh Brown: Got to sell. Yeah. Okay. What do you compare yourselves to when you're showing the fund to family offices or wealth managers? Like what box do you put yourself in? Systematic trend. Okay. But not because we do what everybody else is doing, a systematic trend, because we're doing something accretive that adds value that's low correlated to their existing strategies. So you're not showing yourself against the core long stock ETF. No, and it's like, it's not really, it's kind of a waste of time to talk to an investor who doesn't believe in trend, right? So first we want to like find people who have already invested in this space.

55:08I'm trying to convert people that this, like you're already converted, you have invested in the strategy, you like it, but you're not very satisfied maybe with the experience of this multi-asset trend, like the streakiness of it. But that's a great conversation for you.

55:22Downtown Josh Brown: It's like, look, I know you get why this is worth doing. You just might not have the right – you have the wrong boat. Or you have an insufficient kind of boat. I'm not saying multi-asset trend is bad. I'm saying it's kind of incomplete. If you put in this – there's the benefit of adding trend on stocks or what it is that we do is that you're going to get something as a 3x higher CAGR there. And it's very, very low correlated to what you're doing. but it still has all of the risk management, the trend diversity. And so those two component pieces blended together is going to give you a much smoother ride, a much more consistent ride relative to just owning multi-asset trend standalone where you're happy once a decade.

56:07Downtown Josh Brown: John, can we see chart one on screen? What are we looking at here? These are the 10 largest AUM systematic trend mutual funds. Okay. Okay. So this is the universe that you're comparing yourself to, basically. Okay. So I gather these look very different under the hood in terms of what they're doing. Why is yours so far away from all of theirs on the correlation matrix and on the returns matrix? The blue thing, the SG trend is the benchmark. So that's an index of like the 10 largest systematic trend hedge funds. And then the other ones are the mutual funds. They're trying to give you some return there.

56:44So you can see they're all very correlated to the index because they're all doing long, short, multi-asset trend. So some varying degrees, there's very little differences between them. Ours is over here. We don't do multi-asset. We're just doing specifically stock trends has had a much higher ability to generate a rate of return. And the way it makes money and when it makes money, how it makes money or loses money, underperforms, outperforms, is obviously just very different than if you have a portfolio. It's four asset classes, long, short. It's a totally different underlying. So it's so funny.

57:14Downtown Josh Brown: You reached that conclusion with data. We reached that conclusion with behavior. So we know a couple of things about our clients and like individual investors in general. The first thing that we know is, for the most part, the FOMO that causes an investor to abandon their strategy or fire their advisor is like 90 % about the S &P 500. meaning the COSP in Korea is up 30 % this year. My clients don't have FOMO about South Korea. They don't give a shit. It's not relevant. So the first thing I know if I'm building a strategy that's a risk management strategy for trend following is I'm not going to include long, short, neutral, whatever to asset classes that aren't relevant to the client's behavior because what we're trying to do is manage people's behavior.

58:05Downtown Josh Brown: So in the case of FOMO, we're trying to make sure that clients don't see the market galloping away from them and why aren't I more long? Okay. So right off the bat, I'm not interested in multi-trend. My clients don't know what corn is doing. They don't care what oil is doing. They're unaware of foreign markets for the most part on a granular basis. It's not important to them. I will get fired if the S &P has a 27 % year and I'm way underweight. 100 % I'll get fired. Yeah. So I already understand that very basic premise. So adding more bells and whistles to our strategy, oh, why don't we put Bitcoin in?

58:42Downtown Josh Brown: Why don't we put this in? Why don't we put that in? Right off the bat, no. Because that's its own world. This is about stocks. We're trying to manage people's behavior and psychology. Stocks. That's the first way that I thought about it. You're kind of doing a similar thing. It's like, look, yeah, there are a million things that you could trend follow, but we're doing stocks. Yeah, but our clients are all financial advisors. I mean, that's who we work with. I also ran a multi-asset. You've seen it up close. Yeah, fun. So, I mean, in 2012, we launched a multi-asset fund. We were a top-performing fund.

59:16I raised over a billion dollars for the fund and then watched it go from a billion to zero from 2016 to 2020. It didn't go to zero because the performance was pad or the strategy didn't work or didn't deliver low-correlated returns. is because of the relative underperformance, you know, of the S &P 500 to that thing, the statement risk for financial advisors. Yeah, statement risk is a really key thing. Defending it every year, year in and year out. It becomes impossible. Why are we on this? How do you defend this thing for nine years with your client going, no, you're like, you just become chicken little.

59:47And your clients don't want to hear it. And meanwhile, the advisor down the street's like, your advisor's an idiot. You know, he doesn't know what he's doing. He's got you in some high fee managed futures. Like, what is that?

59:58Downtown Josh Brown: But on the institutional side, statement risk is less or more because they're sophisticated and they can ride strategies through a bear market for that strategy, but maybe not as much as people would think. It's different. I think the psychology of what they're benchmarking against, they have their own psychological biases and things that are affecting that. But it's different than the kinds of emotions that are affecting. In the institutional world, my experience is there's a lot of hurting. As long as you're doing what XYZ down the street is doing, I'm cool with that. If you're all in the same club.

1:00:33If you're all investing in Bernard Madoff, I'm going to invest in Bernard Madoff. They're not even really thinking about what's the underlying due diligence. So if everybody says trend makes sense and go there and the consultants say that it's okay, they're going to stick it in.

1:00:45Downtown Josh Brown: Well, I was going to say part of what drives the hurting is fear of reputational risks. So if everybody believes in this manager, I'm not picking on anyone. If everyone's like, oh no, Bridgewater, that's like the way to do that for global macro, then everyone's in Bridgewater because no one's going to look like an asshole to their client, even if it goes down. And the decision-making, I think a lot of it is just like protecting career risk kind of thing. Like, I'm just going to do the thing because if we all invest in this and it doesn't work out, it doesn't matter because everybody's kind of getting fired.

1:01:20And they're not the owner of the capital. See, when you guys are working directly with the owner of your capital, and then you're working with the emotions of the owner of your capital, and you can't be in a state of conflict between you and your investors, the actual retirees. You won't survive.

1:01:38Downtown Josh Brown: We will not stick with an asset manager that forces us to apologize to clients every quarter. Why are you underperforming your peers? Why are you underperforming your benchmark? Why? Like, it's, we can't because we're, we're like here to have a career. Do you, do you notice better behavior? Speaking of behavior, do you notice better behavior amongst investors in your mutual fund versus your SMA? Because inside the SMA, they could be like, wait, why is he selling Nvidia? Or why is he selling Tesla? That's a good, that's a good question. Like, are they less likely to boot you if they don't see the underlying?

1:02:08Downtown Josh Brown: Because they don't see what you're doing in the mutual fund until 45 days after the quarter ends. But they could see what you're doing in the SMA daily. At the end of the day, I think it all comes down to did it work or did it not work relative to what they wanted at that. When we see redemptions and people leave is when you have a drawdown, you lose money. Maybe they recently invested and then the market goes down like, oh, I don't know about this. And then they kind of like short-term turnover. But for people who kind of are in it and stick with it, this strategy, well, I'll tell you this. Compared to a multi-asset trend, we have a lot higher retention rates and a lot higher customer client satisfaction.

1:02:44with this trend approach on stocks than we did with multi-asset. That is like, you know, obvious.

1:02:50Downtown Josh Brown: I think because it's easier to understand what you're doing. Like if you're trend follower, multi-asset, you could literally be doing anything. The portfolio could own like almost anything. Stocks is stocks. So I think that retention is like, people get what they're doing in that strategy. Yeah, but I think that if I, you know, stocks are stocks, but if I delivered a 2 % return, I don't think they'd be very happy with that. Are there certain asset classes that lend themselves better to trend following than others? And why do you think that is? Well, yes. So, well, asset classes, I don't know. Certain commodities or certain instruments.

1:03:26Downtown Josh Brown: I think that— Are there some that just flat out don't work? I mean, historically speaking, like cocoa didn't work for like 100— it was like very long decades and decades didn't work, and then it recently worked. But you would not have liked—you would have been better off without having cocoa for those decades prior. to that. Worked meaning it conforms to something that you could chart and you could— Like you made money trading it that way. I think cocoa just constantly was like a false signal trade. You just basically did nothing but be a money furnace if you were doing trend following on cocoa.

1:04:00For me, I think markets that have large risk premiums and that are not efficient create bigger trends. But trend following works better or best on anything where you'll get large outliers that come from it. Like the individual stocks. You can get a 50, 100, 100-fold return from an individual company. That's going to leave a trend. Speaking of large outliers, did you ever try crypto in your personal account, trend following on that? Because it works very well there. Well, I don't trend following crypto. I've just been like a diamond hand, a coddler of it. But it does work if you just bought the high and had like a – Carlos Zaratini from the Concretum group who we co-authored the paper with wrote another paper, not with me, but with his group that did trend following on like all of the coins and the efficacy of it.

1:04:53It's actually a great paper. I would imagine it worked very well. Yeah.

1:04:55Downtown Josh Brown: But that's part of the robustness. If you say this works here, the next question is, well, does it work international stocks? Yeah. Does it work small caps? Does it work crypto? though, is now a legitimate robustifier, if you will, if you're doing research, does this work? Yeah, but as an example, in our thing, the largest public company has the largest Bitcoin holdings is MSTR and MicroStrategy, and we've owned it for years. So our trend strategy picked up and had MicroStrategy in there. Probably have Coinbase right now. Coinbase, other ones that have exposure. But the point about trends is you should not do trend following on something that doesn't have the propensity to have those outlier movements.

1:05:40So if you think, why would I want to do trend following on the S &P, like the 500 largest, most diversified kind of thing, all the world's intelligence discounting the price on it, versus doing bottom-up trend on idiosyncratic trends of individual companies where they're less efficient markets, you're going to get these monster trends that kind of come out of it. if you're trying to create something that is a different return stream than a market index.

1:06:06Downtown Josh Brown: So I want to ask you one more question on this. Why do you think we haven't yet seen trend-following sector funds? Because it strikes me that that's a real opportunity that people would be interested in, just from a marketing standpoint. I don't know if it would work. But like if somebody said, okay, I love what you're doing. I really don't care to earn the return of the S &P 500 that way, but I'm really interested. Give me semiconductors, but I only want to own the ones that are going up and I want the risk management from trend following. Or give me biotechs that are trending or something. Like, why haven't we seen those yet?

1:06:44Downtown Josh Brown: And should I launch one? Maybe. Okay. But they didn't work, the sector rotation funds. They got blown up. Are you describing something else? I don't think I'm saying sector rotation. I'm saying picking individual stocks in those sectors. What'll happen is - You see what I mean? The trend following will work on all those sectors. Let's say you just created a platform, and I'm going to do trend following every sector. I'm just going to have the sector strategy. It owns top-performing stocks in each one of the sectors. But a separate fund for each. Yeah, separate fund for each one. So let's do tech stocks.

1:07:11Downtown Josh Brown: Give me trend-following tech stocks. That would be a hot product. Right now. At least right now. Yeah, right now. Well, that's all that matters. We'll worry about the future in the future. But thanks. So it would work. What will happen is you'll have huge dispersion of returns from strategy A to strategy Z, depending upon what was the best sector. So energy probably in the last decade would suck. Okay, stipulated. Tech would have been great. Same way if you just bought the sector straight up. If I just buy like the oil services stocks in a sector ETF. Yeah. Granted, it'll have great seasons. It'll have terrible seasons.

1:07:43Downtown Josh Brown: This is his life. But what if I said, I want to own the sector. The sector is clearly in favor, but I want the extra return that comes with only owning the best stocks in that sector on a trend basis. It's just weird to me that nobody did this yet. Yeah, we definitely could do it. We could do it for you as a custom SMA if you want. Okay. Why do you think it hasn't been done? Just we haven't gotten there yet? Or the interest isn't there? I mean, we don't even have another fund other than us that's doing trend on individual stocks. It's crazy, right? All right. So you're still like a pioneer. It's still early.

1:08:14Downtown Josh Brown: Still early. Okay. Anything we didn't cover on the trend following side or anything that you think is like a big misunderstood piece of how this all works? Thoughts on the mayor? Anything? Anything about the socialist paradise we're about to build in New York City? Lovely. Yeah. It'll be great. What could go wrong? Any parting thoughts on trend following? The parting thoughts on trend following is I know there's a lot of investors in trend following today that understand the non-correlated benefits of it and have it in their portfolios. But I also know that they're not 100 % satisfied with the experience of owning trend.

1:08:54Downtown Josh Brown: Call me. got it yeah exactly dude this is this is so much fun did you have fun on the show today yeah it's great yes all right um we always end the show by asking people what they look forward to uh your answer is etfs is a share class of existing mutual funds isn't that already legal or they didn't approve it yet not yet not to my knowledge i think it's still in well why vanguard does it currently they have an exception they had an exception from the uh sec and and then they're But they're the only ones that have been able to do it so far. But everybody's lobbied. Everybody's filed the application.

1:09:28Kind of like when everybody filed the Bitcoin. They're lining up. They're like, well, wait, wait, wait. So it's a hurry up and wait situation.

1:09:34Downtown Josh Brown: You think that's going to happen now? I do. I think in this administration, it's going to happen. Why does this matter? As somebody who operates a mutual fund, what will you be able to do as soon as this happens? Well, it's a cost savings. You can launch an ETF on the same wrapper. I don't have to start a new fund, take on all the extra capex associated with all the operational expenses. So by being able to have a share class of an existing fund, I can take that operational scale, offer my product and services to ETF buyers only, new generation of people. But I can also lower costs because I'm expanding my total addressable potential market without increasing the cost burden.

1:10:09And I'm able to transition, you know, like why was it good for Disney? You know, it had all this content when DVDs came around because it gave them a whole new market with the existing content. They didn't have to go create new movies. They just were able to put it up here.

1:10:22Downtown Josh Brown: You know what I would do if I were a finance person without a job right now, looking for like, what's the next opportunity? I would set myself up as a consultant to open-end mutual fund companies. I would be like the conversion guy. Like, pay me, consulting fee. I'll come in. I'll show you how we can create ETFs as a share class of your existing funds. And it'll be a project basis, how you pay me. I feel like somebody could start that business right now and make themselves a couple million bucks a year. What do you think about that? Yeah, I mean, I think there's a need, just like there's a need for AI consultants to show people how to kind of do it.

1:10:56Downtown Josh Brown: Like if somebody called you up and said, all right, are you ready for this? The SEC is about to let you create a share class. And you were like, well, I have some questions. That person quoted you a fee. I'll tell you what, hire me. I'll help you do this. You pay it. I'm sure that McKenzie is going to be making millions off of this, you know, for people giving them like a whole deck like they do within New York City, where like I saw this presentation here and it was like about millions of dollars to show them they should get containers, like trash cans. It was crazy. Yeah. Okay. Michael, what are you looking forward to?

1:11:25I am looking forward to no more travel until Future Proof in September. Shutting it down. You were just in Chicago this week?

1:11:32Downtown Josh Brown: Yep. Done. Those overnight trips are - They kill you, right? Yeah, I'm tired. It's a lot of turnaround. The Lake Como I'm going to, which we talked about this. Yeah, when are you going? Last week of July. So, and first week of August. Okay. I'm leaving this coming week. so I'll let you know I'll let you know if I come across anything I think you should know about how long are you going for? two weeks two weeks how are you able to do all right I'm going six nights I'm going for six nights are you staying on the lake? yes we're staying at the Mandarin Oriental so what town is that in? Mandarin Oriental should cop my room for plugging him on the show what town is that in?

1:12:11I don't know I don't know

1:12:12Downtown Josh Brown: all right so I want to check out like all the hotels I'm not staying at I'm staying I think I'm staying at a good one, but I want to like make sure that I see everything. Yeah, there was send me that. There was another one we were going to say. I can't remember the name of it, but it was like, really, I found out you had to wear like a dinner jacket and be super formal to go to dinner. I'm like, I don't want to. Oh shit. Is that where I'm staying? You might be staying there. It's a beautiful place. But then I found out that it was real. Okay. Going to be like, eh. All right. After the trip, I'll send you my itinerary.

1:12:38Downtown Josh Brown: I'll let you know what we did. Are you flying into Milan? Flying to Milan. Spent a few days there. All right. Well, you and I have the same thing that we're looking forward to. So that's mine for today. I want to thank the staff this week. You guys absolutely crushed it. We did some amazing stuff. Michael had Dave Nottig on the Unlocked channel if you're a financial advisor. We are putting out extremely high quality conversations on the Unlocked. Make sure you check out Dave Nottig talking with Michael Batnick about how AI will affect the financial advisory world. world. I had Rick Edelman on earlier this week.

1:13:15Downtown Josh Brown: If you missed that, that was a good one on crypto and Rick's recommended allocation. And we did a whole Animal Spirits. We did everything. We did it all. Guys, thank you so much for watching. Thank you for listening all week. We appreciate you. Like and subscribe. We'll see you soon. All right. That was like the dress rehearsal. I just wanted you to get a sense of like the getting used to it. One, two, three, a break, and then we'll be back.

1:13:48Downtown Josh Brown: Fall has never looked or tasted this good. Sweet Green's fall harvest menu is back with seasonal favorites dressed to impress and made to be devoured. Warm roasted sweet potatoes, crisp apples, maple glazed Brussels, and crave-worthy flavors in the autumn harvest bowl, maple glazed salmon plate, and roasted bacon Brussels side. the season's most desirable menu has returned to Sweetgreen, featuring fall's best dressed. Make your move. Order on the Sweetgreen app.

From the publisher

On episode 197 of The Compound and Friends, ⁠⁠⁠⁠Michael Batnick⁠⁠⁠⁠ and ⁠⁠⁠⁠Downtown Josh Brown⁠⁠⁠⁠ are joined by Cole Wilcox, Founder, CEO and CIO of Longboard Asset Management to discuss: all things trend following, using systems to overcome emotion, technical analysis, Nvidia, the new generation of investors, and much more!

This episode is sponsored by Public. Find out more at: https://public.com/compound

Sign up for The Compound Newsletter and never miss out: ⁠⁠⁠⁠thecompoundnews.com/subscribe⁠⁠⁠⁠

Instagram: ⁠⁠⁠⁠instagram.com/thecompoundnews⁠⁠⁠⁠

Twitter: ⁠⁠⁠⁠twitter.com/thecompoundnews⁠⁠⁠⁠

LinkedIn: ⁠⁠⁠⁠linkedin.com/company/the-compound-media/⁠⁠⁠⁠

TikTok: ⁠⁠⁠⁠tiktok.com/@thecompoundnews⁠⁠⁠⁠

Public disclosure: All investing involves the risk of loss, including loss of principal. Brokerage services for US-listed, registered securities, options and bonds in a self-directed account are offered by Public Investing, Inc., member FINRA & SIPC. Public Investing offers a High-Yield Cash Account where funds from this account are automatically deposited into partner banks where they earn interest and are eligible for FDIC insurance; Public Investing is not a bank. Cryptocurrency trading services are offered by Bakkt Crypto Solutions, LLC (NMLS ID 1890144), which is licensed to engage in virtual currency business activity by the NYSDFS. Cryptocurrency is highly speculative, involves a high degree of risk, and has the potential for loss of the entire amount of an investment. Cryptocurrency holdings are not protected by the FDIC or SIPC.

*Rate as of 3/5/25. APY is variable and subject to change.

**Terms and Conditions apply.

Investing involves the risk of loss. This podcast is for informational purposes only and should not be or regarded as personalized investment advice or relied upon for investment decisions. Michael Batnick and Josh Brown are employees of Ritholtz Wealth Management and may maintain positions in the securities discussed in this video. All opinions expressed by them are solely their own opinion and do not reflect the opinion of Ritholtz Wealth Management.

The Compound Media, Incorporated, an affiliate of ⁠⁠⁠⁠Ritholtz Wealth Management⁠⁠⁠⁠, receives payment from various entities for advertisements in affiliated podcasts, blogs and emails. Inclusion of such advertisements does not constitute or imply endorsement, sponsorship or recommendation thereof, or any affiliation therewith, by the Content Creator or by Ritholtz Wealth Management or any of its employees. For additional advertisement disclaimers see here ⁠⁠⁠⁠https://ritholtzwealth.com/advertising-disclaimers⁠⁠⁠⁠. Investments in securities involve the risk of loss. Any mention of a particular security and related performance data is not a recommendation to buy or sell that security. The information provided on this website (including any information that may be accessed through this website) is not directed at any investor or category of investors and is provided solely as general information.

Obviously nothing on this channel should be considered as personalized financial advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any securities. See our disclosures here: ⁠⁠⁠⁠https://ritholtzwealth.com/podcast-youtube-disclosures/
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from The Compound and Friends

All episodes