


The episode argues that the Senate filibuster should be abolished because it blocks majority rule and, in practice, strengthens presidential power. David Frum (The Atlantic staff writer) traces the filibuster’s origins: 19th-century unlimited debate, then a 1917 rule after World War I opponents used endless amendments against Wilson’s plan to arm merchant ships; the 1957 Strom Thurmond 24-hour filibuster against the Civil Rights Bill of 1957; and 1975 reforms reducing the threshold to 60 while making filibustering easier via “I intend to filibuster.” Frum claims filibusters rose from ~3 per Congress (two-thirds era) to 85 (Bush), 158 (Obama), and now prevent Congress from checking presidents using executive action.
Glenn Galich, CEO of the Stupski Foundation and author of Control, Why Big Giving Falls Short; he discusses “big giving” control problems and donor tax-advantaged funds (over $2T, projected $18T by 2050).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Understand the origins of the filibuster and how it became a tool for obstruction.
“takes 60 votes to pass things, or most things, through the United States Senate.”
Explore how the filibuster has been used to stall significant legislative efforts.
“But in the 19th century, the Senate was small enough and informal enough that members could bring a kind of informal pressure on each other to say, you've talked enough, let's have a vote.”
Learn about the changes made to the filibuster rules and their implications.
“for more than 24 hours to stop the Civil Rights Bill of 1957 from coming to a vote.”
Analyze how the modern filibuster affects presidential authority and legislative power.
“to most of the time of the two-thirds rule, there were about three filibusters in every two-year Congress.”
Discuss the arguments for abolishing the filibuster and returning to majority rule.
“It takes 60 senators to stop the president, to stop the president from doing things that nobody wants him to do.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The David Frum Show, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:02Philanthropy has a control problem, and it's costing communities dearly. Billionaire donors get major tax breaks to park money in charitable funds. Today, there's over$2 trillion stockpiled in these accounts, growing to$18 trillion by 2050. Can you believe that? That's money that's just sitting there instead of being put to work in the communities we care about. I'm Glenn Galich, CEO of the Stupski Foundation and author of the book Control, Why Big Giving Falls Short. In Control, I take you inside the world of big giving to expose the fake rules that keep wealth with the wealthy rather than the people who need it most.
0:44But there's good news. We created this system and we can change it. Order your copy of Control, Why Big Giving Falls Short today.
0:59This episode is brought to you by Jira by Atlassian. Jira gives teams the context, visibility, and control to move work forward. Try it free at jira.com. That's J-I-R-A dot C-O-M.
1:20Hello, and welcome to the weekend edition of The David Fromm Show. I'm David Frum, a staff writer at The Atlantic. I want to talk to you this week about the evolution of the strange practice that it takes 60 votes to pass things, or most things, through the United States Senate. This rule, this practice, this custom, this habit will be a defining fact of the new Congress and a powerful resource for opponents of the American majority to stop the American majority from governing itself in Congress and in the United States Senate. We take this practice for granted. We don't think too hard about how it got there, but I want to talk to you today about how it happened and why it's so dangerous and what could be done about it.
2:00No one ever intended exactly to create this practice. In the 19th century, the Senate, unlike the House of Representatives, never got around to codifying any way to end debate in the United States Senate. Debate could go on forever. But in the 19th century, the Senate was small enough and informal enough that members could bring a kind of informal pressure on each other to say, you've talked enough, let's have a vote. Once the vote happened, it was decided by majority rule. Almost everything was in the 19th century. But this inability to end debate lurked as a kind of parliamentary weapon. And that weapon became very powerful in the debate about the entry into the First World War.
2:36American entry into the First World War began when President Wilson proposed to arm merchant ships so they could defend themselves against German submarines. Fierce opponents of U.S. entry into the war took advantage of the Senate's no-end-to-debate practice to offer amendment after amendment to stop the Senate from voting on President Wilson's measure to arm merchantmen. The vast majority of senators took offense at this, including the majority of Southern senators, who are much of the people most interested in entering the war, and they, for the first time, codified a way to end debate in the United States Senate by passing a rule that said, if two-thirds of senators then-president vote to end debate, debate ends, and there must be a rule.
3:11This is often remembered as the birth of the filibuster, but notice the senators weren't voting to empower one-third to stop the proceedings of the Senate. They were empowering two-thirds to hasten the proceedings along in a context where there had never been any way of doing that until 1917. But thus was born the rule that one-third of the senators present could stop the proceedings of the United States Senate just by refusing to let the debate end. And through the 20th century, this practice became a powerful tool in the hands of segregationists and white supremacists. Most things still continue to pass through the Senate by 50 votes.
3:44But if any government tried to bring about any civil rights measure or any anti-lynching bill, then the ability of one third of the Senate to bring the Senate to a halt would be deployed and the bill would die. The longest filibuster ever recorded was recorded in 1957, when Senator Strom Thurmond spoke for more than 24 hours to stop the Civil Rights Bill of 1957 from coming to a vote. And he was able to water down that bill enough so that when it did pass, the Civil Rights Bill of 1957 didn't accomplish that much, postponing the day of decision until 1964 and the great Civil Rights Act of 1964.
4:17When the Civil Rights Acts were passed through, a lot of the impetus behind the defense of the filibuster faded a little bit. But the Senate was becoming ever more bogged down in the potential for the filibuster. So in 1975, there was another revision. And this time, the number of senators required to end debate was reduced from two-thirds to three-fifths, 60 in the modern context. But as they reduced the number of senators necessary to end debate, the Senate traded that off by doing a new and quite ominous thing. The old rule, the old filibuster, had to be, you could bring the Senate to its end by continuing to debate, but you actually had to literally go to the fore of the Senate and debate, like Strom Thurmond, talk for 24 hours straight, interrupt the debate, force the majority to accommodate you.
4:59But you had to be there and do it yourself. Once the Senate reduced the number of senators necessary from two-thirds to three-fifths, It also allowed senators simply to say, I intend to filibuster. And that brought the Senate to a stop. And then they created another thing, which was intended to speed things up, but instead slowed things down, but they created a separate crack and said, well, while we're stopping debate on the thing that the two-fifths of the senators want to stop, other business can go forward. The result of this was to make the filibuster easier to use and thus more common. The Brookings Institution, in its study of the history of the filibuster, says that through to most of the time of the two-thirds rule, there were about three filibusters in every two-year Congress.
5:39In the George W. Bush era, the early 2000s, there were 85 filibusters per two-year Congress. In the Obama era, there were 158 filibusters per two-year Congress. In other words, the minority in the Senate was simply able to stop the Obama administration from doing very much. Now, by then, a generation had passed and people thought that it had always been there and they began developing rationalizations as to why the filibuster was a good thing. No one quite ever intended for it to be this way. It was never planned. It's not in the Constitution. It's not in the laws. It's in the rules of the Senate or even more the practices of the Senate.
6:13No one intended quite to do it, but there it was. And then the minority of the time who were Republicans began developing rationalizations. And it has to be said that while some of these rationalizations, you may like them, you may not like them, but they're all made up. The authors of the Constitution were very able to write requirements for supermajority into the Constitution when they want them. It takes two-thirds of senators present to convict on an impeachment. It takes two-thirds of the House or Senate to expel a member. It takes two-thirds of each House to override a presidential veto.
6:43It takes two-thirds of senators present to ratify a treaty. Similarly, for constitutional amendments and changing the Constitution itself. When the authors of the Constitution thought more than half were needed, they said so. They never said it should take more than half the senators to pass a measure through the Senate. That's just something that has grown up through time. I think before deciding what to do, we need to understand what is the practical effect of the filibuster in today's context. People will defend the filibuster in terms of somehow protecting minorities. That's not what the filibuster does in today's context.
7:13What today's filibuster does is it enhances the power of the president. As the number of filibusters per two-year cycle has ramped up and up and up and up, presidents have given up legislating. President Trump seems to have entirely abdicated from it. They have instead acted by executive action, as President Trump did in tariffs and other things, executive action, and then defied Congress to do anything about it. So it isn't just that it takes 60 senators to do something. It takes 60 senators to stop the president, to stop the president from doing things that nobody wants him to do. That Congress's ability to police the president is broken by the filibuster rule.
7:47And that's going to be very ominous for the two years ahead. President Trump is going to refuse to do things. He's going to use executive actions. And he's going to say to the Senate, so long as he has 41 senators willing to do his bidding, And he surely has that. He can stop the Senate from overriding his issues in any way. And this is all extremely dangerous because at the same time as the modern filibuster was being developed, the Senate did something else or Congress did something else. The Congresses of the 1970s and 1980s delegated great grants of power to the president, including, for example, the power to impose emergency tariffs.
8:17But they bracketed or they conditioned those powers on a series of defenses for Congress, including something called the legislative veto, the right of the Congress to override the president. The Supreme Court struck down those congressional countermeasures one by one, including ruling the legislative veto over unconstitutional, but it left the delegations intact. So we're in a situation where enormous power has been delegated to the president. He can act by executive action, and it takes 60 senators to stop him from doing the things he wants to do. So the function of the filibuster is not to protect the minority of Americans, it's to protect the power of the president to act in arbitrary and high-handed ways.
8:54And boy, is there a president who's ready to do that. So while I applaud all the ingenious workarounds for the filibuster, some of them I like more, some of them I like less, I think the new Congress has to take the matter by its hands and seize on a hint offered by President Trump himself. He's called for the abolition of the filibuster. Find some Republicans, at least one or two, who are willing to go along with the president's stated wish and break it, break it now and forever and go back to the way the Constitution was supposed to operate, which is by majority vote. Alexander Hamilton wrote in Federalist 22, to give a minority a negative upon the majority, which is always the case where more than a majority is requisite to a decision, is in its tendency to subject the sense of the greater number to that of the lesser.
9:38In this case, the lesser is just one man, one arbitrary man, who has used powers that were never intended to be his, who has taken advantage of delegations with the breaking of the countermeasures to those delegations, and who's threatening the liberties, freedom, prosperity, and security of all Americans. The filibuster must go. Thanks so much for watching. See you soon on The David Frum Show.
10:18Philanthropy has a control problem, and it's costing communities dearly. Billionaire donors get major tax breaks to park money in charitable funds. Today, there's over$2 trillion stockpiled in these accounts, growing to$18 trillion by 2050. Can you believe that? That's money that's just sitting there instead of being put to work in the communities we care about. I'm Glenn Galich, CEO of the Stupski Foundation and author of the book Control, Why Big Giving Falls Short. In Control, I take you inside the world of big giving to expose the fake rules that keep wealth with the wealthy rather than the people who need it most.
11:01But there's good news. We created this system and we can change it. Order your copy of Control, Why Big Giving Falls Short today.
In this week’s Saturday episode of “The David Frum Show,” The Atlantic’s David Frum discusses the history of the Senate filibuster and why it may be time to kill the outdated practice.
Sign up for David Frum’s newsletter alert.
Get more from your favorite Atlantic voices when you subscribe. You’ll enjoy unlimited access to Pulitzer-winning journalism, from clear-eyed analysis and insight on breaking news to fascinating explorations of our world. Atlantic subscribers also get access to exclusive subscriber audio in Apple Podcasts. Subscribe today at TheAtlantic.com/Listener.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices