

21 Oct 2026 · 39m · 18 chapters

Tech sovereignty in Europe—argues sovereignty is not inherent in where hardware sits, but in legal and operational control over data, access, administration, and compulsion. Uses AI/data-center examples to show “AI sovereignty” depends on governance, not silicon origin. Second segment: how language/category design shapes markets; warns founders against forcing themselves into analyst/VC “boxes” and against misleading recategorization (e.g., “labs,” “superintelligence”).
No named guests. Hosts are Paul and “Hey Paul” co-host (unnamed in transcript). They reference industry figures (Marc Andreessen, Tim Berners-Lee, Zelensky) and companies.
Physical location contributes but doesn’t constitute sovereignty; operational sovereignty can exist with foreign components. Sovereignty stacks include legal control, administrative control, data access, privileged access, operational independence, remote access, supply-chain exposure, compulsion risk, and auditability.
Beyond.pl AI factory in Poznan using US NVIDIA/Everpure hardware; Hertz renting Chinese cars with cameras; UK AI security certification access denied; “net zero” reframed as “net stupid zero”; Gartner Magic Quadrant positioning; Slack/Twitch/Roblox/Burb(on)/Instagram pivots; “NeoLabs/NeoClouds” and “AI superintelligence” naming debates; Character.AI bankruptcy after legal claims.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Exploring the meaning and implications of tech sovereignty in Europe.
“Of course, there's been a lot of talk recently about tech sovereignty.”
Distinguishing physical from operational sovereignty in tech infrastructure.
“So we Europeans, we think, should distinguish physical sovereignty from operational sovereignty.”
Discussing the relationship between AI and sovereignty and its complexities.
“Yeah, like the hardware carries a passport, right?”
Identifying key components that define operational sovereignty beyond hardware.
“It's not to say that physical location still matters.”
Examining the legal implications of technology ownership under EU laws.
“You know, I really don't think this is about whether a data center contains sovereign hardware.”
Explore dependencies and compulsion risks related to tech sovereignty.
“So one of the other things we see in everyday life is supply chain exposure.”
Discuss the nuances between strategic dependency and operational sovereignty in technology.
“in the example, this is the Polish example, does demonstrate the opposite.”
Understand the crucial legal distinctions in defining tech sovereignty.
“which prevents us from just garnering as much power as we want and rolling over everybody else.”
Discover how language shapes markets and influences company success.
“This segment of the show, we're going to talk about why language matters in category design.”
Analyze the negative impacts of poorly defined categories like net zero.
“It is something that's very close to my heart, because it just seems to have been a total cock-up in trying to get to a very valuable end.”
Examine the dilemmas tech founders face in categorizing their businesses.
“isn't this the sort of thing that that tech founders actually face daily with with the great Gartner Magic Quadrant trap.”
Learn from examples of companies that successfully pivoted their categories.
“As I remember when I saw them coming up from nothing on Holiday in Ireland.”
Learn how tech categories evolve and the significance of bold pivots.
“I don't think also we would be doomscrolling on bourbon, would we?”
Explore recent financial shifts and the struggles of emerging AI labs.
“Just look at the new wave of AI labs under five years old.”
Understand the emergence of NeoClouds and their impact on tech.
“In the last week, we've seen Firmus pull their IPO.”
Delve into the debates around AI companies using the 'labs' classification.
“to lump themselves with this category called neocloud.”
Learn the importance of true market creation over simply rebranding.
“And actually, on a side note, the bigger issue I think they'll face, because in their S1s they must declare everything that could be a problem, is insurance.”
Discuss the blurring lines between AI and intelligence and the term 'super intelligence'.
“And again, if you think about Slack, you can think about Slack, oh, it's a failed video game.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Difference Engine | B2B Category Design | Private Equity | Venture Capital, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Welcome to The Difference Engine, the show for tech founders, investors and innovators.
0:09Hey Paul, what's on today's edition of The Difference Engine?
0:14Paul Maher: You and I are very aware of the power of language, so we're going to look at why words matter ever so much in category design. And talking of words, we're going to be talking about a very important word, and that word is sovereignty. What does sovereignty actually mean in the European context?
0:36This pod exists to talk about tech category. So if we want to create category leadership in Europe, I think we need to be clear about what we mean by sovereignty. Of course, there's been a lot of talk recently about tech sovereignty. Yeah, I mean, for the last two years, because for us Europeans, it really does matter. because we've got a boys' club of US AI companies hoovering up the world's available public and certainly private capital. And as we have mentioned, and this has been going on in the last few weeks, completely distorting the usual premises behind IPOs.
1:18Paul Maher: Yeah, there's a pylon going on, that's for sure. So speaking a little of old boys or young boys, a man who some might say looks more infantile, maybe babyish. Marc Andreessen is a hallowed founder of A16Z. This young man, well, man, has recently opined upon Europe. And I think he's slightly dissing us here. Just to quote him, Europe seems determined to be left behind. They seem enthusiastic about being left behind. Of course we do, Marc. They seem to really badly want that. 25 years ago, if you did a list of the 50 biggest tech companies in the world, a pretty significant number were European, probably 15 out of the top 50.
1:59Paul Maher: This is, it says Mr. Andreessen. Today, you're basically down to Spotify, which I love. I love Spotify. To finish off his bon mots about us Europeans, he said, I think they would, they being us, would be very happy if AI didn't happen inside the EU. I think they'd be very happy. They might, he might be right here. They'd be very happy if social media didn't exist. I think they'd be quite happy to shut up the internet. Mr Andreessen, may I remind you where the internet came from? It was a guy called Berners-Lee who went to school just up the road from me at the top of our road, just near Richmond Park.
2:33Paul Maher: And I'm sorry, the internet wouldn't exist as we know it, or the web certainly, without Tim Berners-Lee. Can I just correct my esteemed colleague here? He's actually talking about the World Wide Web, not the internet. Because sorry, Americans, we know you invented that back in the 50s with DARPA and DARPAnet and all that. While we're talking about sovereignty, we think we need to really distinguish between arguments about this. So we Europeans, we think, should distinguish physical sovereignty from operational sovereignty. And we believe treating the former as an inherent property of infrastructure is conceptually, shall we say, at the best, flawed.
3:17For instance, sovereign could describe the control regime around a data center, not, as it's often confused with, the nationality of the hardware sitting inside it. Yeah, like the hardware carries a passport, right? So the idea of inherent sovereignty in a data center is actually a fallacy because sovereignty is not a physical characteristic that can be embedded in a server or a GPU or a storage array or the building itself. a machine does not become sovereign because it's located within a particular national border just as foreign-made hardware does not automatically make an otherwise locally governed service non-sovereign right so so what matters operationally is who has authority access and control over the data and the systems processing it but just a step back the reason that
4:18Paul Maher: you're talking about data centers and the reason that we're somewhat exercised about Mr Andreessen talking about AI and whether Europe wants to be left behind is AI and sovereignty are very close bedfellows. It's no longer just about data sovereignty, it's about AI sovereignty. It's about power so there's an outfit called beyond.pl and they have a factory in a place that paul and i are very very fond of it's called posnan yes for those of you who might be following a certain large football club that might be having a few problems with the authority you'll be very familiar with the idea of the posnan because it's what we manchester city fans are currently doing to the football authorities.
5:09Anyway, in Poznan is beyond PL's AI factory, and the way they've handled this illustrates this distinction very well. Now, as you'd expect to an AI factory, the facility itself uses US origin, maybe not US manufactured, NVIDIA compute and ever-pure storage. Yet BeyondPL argues that the service can still be sovereign because the operating company is Polish, right? Not only is it Polish, it's subject to Polish law and an additional level EU law. And that it does not have access to customers' underlying data beyond infrastructure telemetry. This is murky, though. I disagree. I think it clearly illustrates that a sovereign claim rests not in the nationality of the silicon, but on the governance and operational control surrounding that silicon.
6:08Paul Maher: To be discussed, because clearly the products are U.S. And as you'll know, there is a U.S. decree that anything that is sold by a U.S. company is subject to U.S. law. So this is a lawyer's field day, basically. Right. Of course it is. But if I was stupid enough to buy an American car, which most of the world doesn't, and drive it around in the UK, I would not be driving around in a piece of the sovereign USA. I don't know if you saw this week that there was a bit of a kerfuffle around Dutch army blokes. These guys are driving, as one might do to save a few quid, rather than own the car. You'd rent the car, wouldn't you, from a US company called Hertz.
6:54Paul Maher: That would be logical, right? So the cars they were driving, to your point about who owns what, were Chinese cars. And these Chinese cars are covered in lots and lots of cameras and lots and lots of devices that feed back to the mothership in China. And so it's quite handy if you want to see what the secret code is on an army barracks to watch somebody using a camera type in the numbers. So it does get extremely murky about who owns which bit of hardware. But back to sovereignty. Who has a sovereignty? So I think, I do genuinely think that, you know, this idea of governance and operational controls surrounding the silicon is really, really important because it exposes the weakness, I think, in the idea that sovereignty is inherent in physical infrastructure.
7:42And if sovereignty were inherent in a box, then European organizations could never operate genuinely sovereign infrastructures using globally sourced components, right? Even though it's probably a European company that supplied the machinery to make that silicon in the first place. If it was about these globally sourced components, it would make sovereignty dependent on constructing an entirely indigenous technology stack. It's something that's really currently unrealistic in Europe, given our dependency on technologies such as NVIDIA GPUs. And frankly, let's not beat Europe on this. It would make nonsense anywhere else in the earth, given the nature of the IT industry, which has been essentially multinational and global from the beginning.
8:31And, you know, that that would be enough, you might think. Yet that beyond PL example demonstrates that the operational question can be separated from the hardware supply chain. So I think the more useful question is not where does the box sit, but it is who can access, administer, control, compel, modify or extract the data processed by the box, which might come back to your Hertz example. Yeah, that's operational sovereignty.
9:02Paul Maher: It might be something that Mr. Zelensky recognizes right now. You bet he does. You can't beat a bit of national peril to sharpen your thinking. It's not to say that physical location still matters. Data residency requirements, jurisdiction, physical access, and obviously supply chain dependencies, given how we've created the global economy in the last few decades, and, of course, national security laws, can all create sovereignty risks. But location, bang on about this, location is only one component of a control environment. If you've got a server physically located in Europe, it can still be subject to operational dependencies outside Europe, while infrastructure containing foreign-made components can operate under European ownership, governance, access controls, and legal jurisdiction.
9:55And that's particularly important for cloud and AI infrastructures, because modern computing is inherently international.
10:02Paul Maher: despite the best efforts of others. So we know, we've talked about this before, that Acer, as I believe you pronounce it, the AI security guys in the UK, can only certify that AI is safe if they're given access. And recently, of course, they were denied access to that. So it may be international in nature, but really, and again, coming back to the Musk situation with Zelensky, it does really matter. Who has the controls? Yeah. So, you know, hardware, software, firmware, support, orchestration, supply chains, all cross national boundaries. Attempting to define sovereignty purely through the physical location or nationality of individual components, therefore just confuses sovereignty of the service with the origin of the technology, which is nonsense.
10:57And I think that beyond PL case makes the distinction concrete. You know, US customers were reportedly using the Polish AI factory, which is a data center in any other language, to deliver sovereign services to European customers. Now, that's seemingly paradoxical only if sovereignty is assumed to reside in the hardware itself. Under an operational definition, it's entirely coherent. American technology can participate in a sovereign European service when the relevant control, access and legal regime is European.
11:33Paul Maher: So let me just interject here with an example from this week, working with an open source company who has got to comply with these new EU laws in order for it to be regarded as sovereign. it has a bit of an issue because the technology we're talking about whilst it was developed in Scandinavia actually in the Nordics is actually now owned by a private equity company that private equity company is based in the states so it comes into a legal contention as to whether or not this is a wholly owned European entity because clearly the ownership resides in the US like I said before This is a lawyer's field day.
12:19You know, I really don't think this is about whether a data center contains sovereign hardware. It's about organizations examining an operational sovereignty stack. And that stack, which is where I get my clipboard out here. This is where the lawyers get the clipboards out and start reeling a big list off. First of all, which will please lawyers, right? Legal control. Which jurisdiction governs the operating entity and the service? Right? Ask that question. Second one, administrative control. So basically, who could administer the infrastructure? Right? Number two. Number three, data access. Who can access consumer data or customer data and under what circumstances?
13:06Right? Number three. Number four on my tick list here is privileged access. who controls the highest level credentials and management plans, right? Then it's about operational independence. Can the service continue without intervention from a foreign provider? You know, one would have thought that the European Air Forces might be quite interested in that. Well, kill switches and stuff on F-35s we keep hearing about. But what about remote access? Can suppliers of foreign entities remotely access or control the infrastructure might be of interest to the Dutch soldiers.
13:43Paul Maher: I think it's of interest to all of us. Anyone, I don't know, Zoom and other video services are available. I don't know if you've ever put a support call in, but let me tell you, the people that know exactly how that works and can remote access into your Zoom. They ain't in the UK, are they? They ain't in the UK, no. We see this in everyday life. So one of the other things we see in everyday life is supply chain exposure. So I'd ask what dependencies exist in the hardware, the firmware, the software, and the support, to your point, indeed. And I guess the last two are really compulsion risk. This is very live at the moment.
14:23Which governments could legally compel the operator, supplier, or service provider to disclose information? Now, we've got that with Apple and the UK courts at the moment. And lastly, I think auditability. And why that? Because, you know, this is really, really important. Can the operator actually demonstrate that these controls actually work?
14:49Paul Maher: So what you're saying is hardware origin is not irrelevant. It's very relevant. Yeah, right. We're getting loyally here. Just because it's not irrelevant doesn't mean it's highly relevant. But it's worthwhile thinking about NVIDIA's position. in the example, this is the Polish example, does demonstrate the opposite. A dependence on foreign technology can remain, can remain a strategic and supply chain vulnerability, even when the resulting service is operationally sovereign, right? So there's a difference between how we treat it and what might actually happen. But strategic dependency and operational sovereignty are different questions.
15:31and should be subject to different laws and different questions about vulnerability.
15:39Paul Maher: Yeah, but I've got to come back to, this sounds like a distinction without that much of a difference. That's the basis of law, Paul. That's why lawyers exist. Yeah, maybe I'm not a lawyer, but it seems like you can say what you want from a lawyer position about the notion of sovereignty, but actually he who controls the box controls the service as in starlink star shield the chinese cameras on the hertz stuff the you know and it's very well for the european controlled entity to be a protected characteristic or whatever the lawyer term is that um and then you know call us private equity owned companies non-european but really it's it's about the switch.
16:25But if you took that idea of sovereignty to any other example, that would lead you to believe that only the biggest countries should exist.
16:36Paul Maher: I think that's a working hypothesis. Small countries would have no right to exist. And I refer us back yet again to Mr. Andreessen's words. They seem enthusiastic about being left behind. There's an implied threat in that, isn't there? Yeah, but I think the distinction is crucial, because otherwise the industry risks creating a misleading binary so european hardware equals sovereign foreign hardware equals non-sovereign you know that definition would make european sovereignty effectively impossible um in the areas where europe does not have you know control of the complete technology stack it's worse than impossible it's it's a misleading fallacy right so i think a more defensible formulation of this is deep breaths.
17:20So sovereignty is not inherent in infrastructure. It exists through legal, technical, and operational controls governing that infrastructure. The location of the box contributes to sovereignty, but it does not constitute it.
17:35Paul Maher: That's the point. But isn't that a dangerous delusion, hallucination, if you will, if we're talking about AI, that too many European lawmakers want to believe, and the facts on the battlefield or on the in the Zoom calls would dictate otherwise. Well, if you want to live in a brutal world where power alone dictates, then you can. But civilization is based on laws, which prevents us from just garnering as much power as we want and rolling over everybody else. That's why this is a really, really important distinction. Take that, Mr Andreessen.
18:22Building a technology company is brutal. We know that. It's years of early mornings, late nights, working weekends, long hours, lost sleep and neglected loved ones. You keep going because of a relentless belief in what you're creating. At Hambleton Partners, our senior advisors have walked that path, experiencing at first hand the challenges that technology leaders face every day. We know selling your tech business isn't just a transaction. It's one of the most important life decisions you'll ever make. That's why we take a different approach to technology M &A. We combine deep transaction expertise with hard-won industry savvy, helping founders navigate every stage of the transaction process with empathy, insight and the confidence born of deep experience.
19:09When the time is right to explore what's next, work with advisors who understand every step of the journey. Hambleton Partners.
19:23This segment of the show, we're going to talk about why language matters in category design. We're going to dive briefly deep into the art war of category creation and why the language you choose can literally make or break your company.
19:42Paul Maher: Yeah, we could have renamed this segment um why language matters in your super category for reasons we'll get on to shortly so um recategorization uh really matters if you think about um what people um nowadays called suvs or rangies or temu rangies these are suvs shout out to all you jq drivers out there but originally they were just jeeps which actually came from general purpose vehicle did it not exactly so So that was a weird little acronym that morphed into a category of vehicle called SUVs. Sports utility vehicles. Speaking of the war, those nice guys that used to repair the flyboys who came back from being horrifically burnt, fighting for the country in their planes.
20:28Paul Maher: Originally, they were called plastic surgeons, named after the products they were using to reconstruct faces, etc. These days, who knew? These days, that's aesthetics. And of course, very current. We've got GLP-1s, a diabetes treatment. And very medical, very boring. Just for those of us who are from diabetes. Now, fat jabs. I guess we shouldn't really mention a well-known drug that was invented for heart conditions. Yes. Let's not rise to that, Jono. Okay. Hey! So, there you go. And then, you know, you've got apps, which are just applications, becoming common nomenclature. And what you and I called growing up watching TV, linear programming.
21:19Paul Maher: So we've recently talked about data sovereignty and AI sovereignty. And what's really interesting about category is, frankly, words define markets. Language matters. It is a war of words. Point is, words do redefine markets. Now, there is a dark side on to negative repositioning. It is something that's very close to my heart, because it just seems to have been a total cock-up in trying to get to a very valuable end. The idea of net zero. Which, clearly, of the two of us, you're the fan of. I'm absolutely a fan of that. Yes, indeed. Because I actually think that is where the economy will need to go.
22:11And our economic competitors are already way ahead in it. And they possibly have a form of sovereignty over green energy creation. Anyway, so what started as a clean energy crusade, I, to try and get the country focused on upgrading its entire economic infrastructure, turned politically toxic because it was primarily seen as a sort of rather lefty totalitarian exercise. Let's just call it an exercise. um the point is is that the right in particular weaponized the term and the whole category suffers collateral damage in that we're too busy talking about what needs to happen at a political level uh rather than talking about it in in the realm of reality and in the uk at least i don't
23:10Paul Maher: think this applies anywhere else that i know this wasn't really hard for the naysayers of net zero to do all they did was insert the word stupid so they're now um they will talk every time anybody mentions net zero in a positive way they'll refer to it as net stupid zero that's how little and how it needs to change to change a sentiment that's exactly the power of words yeah but isn't this isn't this the sort of thing that that tech founders actually face daily with with the great Gartner Magic Quadrant trap. Yeah, I've just lived through that this week. Absolutely nuts. Yeah, and we've dealt with this several times with clients, right, and trying to categorize themselves and fighting the Gartner Magic Quadrant sort of tractor beam.
23:59Paul Maher: Yeah, but, you know, as you've had to deal with this week, there's that issue, which is, you know, as a growing company, do you force yourself into an existing box to fit the analyst grid, or do you stand your ground? And often we are called in when people are genuinely confused. Engineers are engineers. They tend to be, certainly if not the CEOs, or they can be founders or high up. Certainly most tech companies that we deal with have engineers in the higher echelons and they get confused, especially if they fall between two stools, so to speak, two or three or four of these Gartner magic quadrants and they feel ignored.
24:39Paul Maher: They feel like the analysts are ignoring them, and they sort of are ignoring them, because each analyst generally owns one of those magic quadrants. So in the actual fact behind the scenes, they're all in conflict. They only want their magic quadrant to win. How does that matter if you've got your category, you've got established customer problems that you're trying to solve, and you don't fit into the way of the world that our friends at Gartner, Forrester, IDC et al. advise? We've got a particularly strong view on that, haven't we, really? I mean, you know, lemming VCs. Yeah, the lemming VCs will want to know.
25:16Paul Maher: That's sort of one of the positive aspects, I suppose, of falling into an existing category, is it allows the VCs to categorize you and put you up against competitors. And these days, of course, it's not all winner plays all. There's plenty of money to be had by being the second, third, or fourth player in a category. Just look at the AI race that we've got at the moment and the funding that you can attract. But it's not really what category design is about. It's literally following the herd. That point is really that we would advise very strongly companies not to give up their distinctive vision, just to play word bingo for a bunch of VCs acting like 70s music managers looking for the next glam rock act, just because one or two of them have broken through.
26:13And what is interesting, while we're talking about glam rock, and in fact bands morphing, I mean, you know, the suite morphed from a heavy metal band to glam rock. Slade did pretty much the same. Skinhead rock to glam.
26:25Paul Maher: And U2, let's not forget U2. They started off as a Bay City Rollers tribute type. Did they? They did indeed. As I remember when I saw them coming up from nothing on Holiday in Ireland. But what you can do, rather than playing the game, is to stay distinctive and pivot. And that's totally valid. And there's some history in that, isn't there? Oh, my God. So where do we start? Let's start with Slack. We all use it. It is a pretty good product, I reluctantly admit. We started with it, used it for years, dropped it, started to go, it's okay. um so that started off really as a multiplayer game called glitch um and we know how that story ended uh slack is now predominant and it was bought out in the interim by benioff and salesforce for a whacking 28 billion back in 2021 i mean they really just spun out the internal messaging tool didn't they on that i mean that that was where they realized the value of sure and who can forget um justin tv that was just a guy live casting wasn't it indeed justin khan um but that morphed into twitch and that was acquired in 2014 way back in the day by amazon i don't remember roblox starting out as as roblox roblox interesting this was a you know very uh academic physics simulator and then of course they just figured that that would allow them to create 3d shapes and everybody of a certain age has watched their children create little worlds.
27:57Paul Maher: And it's the number one, perhaps the number one game in the world, certainly of its era. Amazing. I don't think also we would be doomscrolling on bourbon, would we? Well, we might be doomscrolling with the help of bourbon. I prefer scotch whiskey. I was going to doomscroll. Yeah, but I think I know what you're saying. You're talking about bourbon as in B-U-R-B-N. That's the one. That's the one. That's the check-in app, which morphed into Instagram. And now that's a product I really don't like, but there you go. So you can see that what we're saying here is having a category, being bold, and then pivoting, it's not a life sentence.
28:33Paul Maher: You can pivot. Words matter, but it's an evolving narrative. Yeah, it definitely is a narrative, which sort of brings us right up to today's bleeding edge. And in the last week, there's been lots of financial bleeding around this area. It's the rise of NeoLabs and NeoClouds. Just look at the new wave of AI labs under five years old. Anthropic, 11 Labs, Stability, XAI. They're just not software vendors. They're research powerhouses. And that means they're actually redefining an intelligence infrastructure. Or are they just renamed software houses? But I think just a little side note here. One of the 10, so the 10 I'm thinking of, all the ones you mentioned, plus isomorphic cradle and convergence.
29:19Paul Maher: These are all the really hot, the massively funded, oh, we've just announced a new funding round for a crazy amount of money. The one outlier, and maybe it's the canary in the coal mine, is Character AI, who, of course, recently just went, and I can't say the word I'm thinking of, but wrong. And they obviously have folded, gone into bankruptcy after law claims, some of which allegedly claim that this product has led to the deaths of young people. So, you know, it's not all upside in Neo Labs. In the last week, we've seen Firmus pull their IPO. I mean, that was a multi, multi-billion pound IPO because basically the people that would have backed that have suddenly realized it's massively overvalued.
30:06And of course, that went something up, as you might say. and that also sent CoolWeave into a spin, you know, with the CEO expressing, shall we say, his displeasure all over the media.
30:21Paul Maher: Yeah, well, you see, that's Neo Labs, hot as hell, although, as I said, maybe, you heard it here first. Well, hot as hell and cool as the grave within a few days. Yes, a character would say that. But then you have NeoClouds, and this is really hot. Like, if you listen to certain other podcasters, we won't name them, some of whom have got stakes in these companies. You've got Together AI, you've got Modal, you've got Fireworks, hint, hint, and Nscale, which of course has got Mr. Clegg, our former Deputy Prime Minister on board. And he fought very shy of talking about his 18 million pound payday that he's going to get from that because he wouldn't sully himself.
31:02Paul Maher: It's a horrible thing to think of terrible, disgusting merchants. But these guys are hot as hell. And what have they done? They've created a category called neoclouds. Again, is there anything new here? One might argue no, but well done to them for categorizing themselves and all as a herd, and it helps their joint valuation as far as investors are concerned to lump themselves with this category called neocloud. One might say it's a whole new layer of the tech stack uh other of us would say maybe not they're just making sun uh making hay while the sun shines and talking about making hay perhaps we should talk about um the war of the words around super intelligence and neolabs super intelligence so like obviously um somebody that we all know and some love i think uh has just coined the phrase that we shouldn't talk about AI, superintelligence is the phrase that we should all be using.
32:04Would this be a man whose wife might come from the internet domain country.si? Hold on a second now. And whose friends might have been in a buying frenzy. Allegedly. Allegedly. .si suffixes in the weeks running up to that announcement.
32:26Paul Maher: I see where your crazy hypothesis is here. So you're saying that.ai might be replaced if somebody, I don't know, influential, decided that the TLD, the top level domain, as they call it, should be not.ai, but.si, which happens completely coincidentally to be Slovenia. Amazing coincidence, isn't it? Just amazing. Allegedly. Allegedly, amazing coincidence. The problem is, from a category point of view, super anything is not a category. No, it's not. It's not different. It's not different. It's just better. We don't like better. We like different. So we have to balance this with the fact that once a category goes viral, or in this case is mandated, it's hard to stop it sticking.
33:16Paul Maher: Yeah, I'm not sure we're going to win that one whilst a certain person's in power. But let's talk about labs a second, because other folks associated with said individual are rowing about the use of the word labs by Anthropic, by OpenAI, etc. And their objection is that AI companies are actually building products. And these guys have got a lot of imminent IPOs, certainly Anthropic and OpenAI are rumoured to be IPOing soon. But if they use the category of labs and claim to be doing research, as laboratories do, then maybe they can absolve themselves from some of the responsibility the rest of us in tech have to do for the damage that their product could cause.
34:00Paul Maher: It's just science. It's labs. It's scientific. Yeah, what we didn't know. And actually, on a side note, the bigger issue I think they'll face, because in their S1s they must declare everything that could be a problem, is insurance. The insurance companies, they've got a lot to say about risk. And so there are this little ruse to call yourself a lab and say what you're doing is research. And it's all, you know, it's probabilistic. It's not deterministic. In the real world, you see that the markets are now balking at the bond issues of CoreWeave, who you mentioned, and Oracle, because they are so leveraged up to the hilt with AI.
34:39Paul Maher: Very bubbly stuff at the moment. I mean, anybody who thinks It isn't. It's deluding themselves. And I don't think, I haven't worked with a few people in the insurance industry, they're not renowned for their humor. I don't think they're going to see the word lab, despite your illusions, as reassuring. I think quite the opposite. And I think this could be a major problem that they've gotten themselves into these guys by calling themselves labs. So what's the advice for founders here? Yeah, what's the takeaway? Let's try and break this down into stuff that, dear listeners, you can think about. So I reckon on the general subject of positioning, you've got to realize that recategorization is not just marketing.
35:23If you're trying to recategorize as just some sort of marketing slogan, you're going down the wrong path. If you're going to recategorize, you have to create a new market. Now, you know, from the arrival of SUVs to data sovereignty to loads and loads of other paradigmatic shifts we can talk about, the reality is whoever defines the language defines the value.
35:52Paul Maher: Right. And I know this is we're giving out hopefully valuable advice here. I know a lot of category folks worry about analyst grids and certainly founders do. But just don't compress your company into anybody else's magic quadrant box just to satisfy buzzword obsessed VCs. Build the value, build your category, they'll come to you. Yeah, be brave. And talking about being brave, the one thing I've always learned about being in business is just keep going. And again, if you think about Slack, you can think about Slack, oh, it's a failed video game. No, it wasn't. It was the precursor to something very big.
36:32um you know twitch you know was uh you know basically a guy streaming his daily life but the platform he built again was the precursor to something very big and your initial idea isn't the whole of the journey it's just the starting line yeah and talking about neo clouds
36:53Paul Maher: very hot at the moment uh the ai revolution is not just about building models there's value to be built on those models and bless the neocloud guys uh rebuilding cloud infrastructure is the claim why not build it from the silicon up but we really have to talk about super intelligence and i think we actually have to be pragmatic and i quite like i actually do quite like um the term my god never thought i'd hear you say that let me say why because increasingly the idea of there being intelligence and artificial intelligence just blurs into one things i mean you know I work with people who appear to be half man, half co-pilot.
37:30So there is a melded intelligence. So why shouldn't this whole thing be called super intelligence? So I really don't object to it on that front. And I think, frankly, in a time like this, it may be smarter to comply and just go with it, at least for now. But that's not the end of it. The skill is to make this Uber category work for you.
37:59Thank you for listening. If you want to learn more about category design, head to becategorical.com. If you need help designing and dominating your category, then get in touch. Contact details are in the show notes.
38:25you
Who controls our tech?
Technological sovereignty is about far more than just geography. It’s a story of power, politics, law, ownership, and innovation. In this episode, we explore the forces that shape tech sovereignty in an increasingly connected and unstable world.
Also in this episode, we’ll look at the emerging terms ‘Labs’ and ‘Superintelligence’ to ask why language matters.
00:36 What do we mean by sovereignty?
18:22 Why language matters
There is more information on how to design your category on our blog
Follow us on LinkedIn:
Want to create a podcast for your business or brand? Contact Flamingo Media to make it happen.