

4 Nov 2026 · 19m · 5 chapters

The episode argues that Apple’s “Apple Duo” foldable device is a category design failure, dubbed “Crack Gate,” after reports of cracked folds, display lines, and reliability issues. Guests claim the core problem isn’t just hardware defects but credibility: Apple’s brand promise is dependable, intuitive mainstream tech, and a premium-priced foldable that fails undermines that. They say Duo is form-factor innovation, not true category creation, and note Samsung delivered similar foldable tech about seven years earlier.
product innovation, experience innovation, and ecosystem support are insufficient; the device risks being an expensive “variation” rather than a new customer value proposition.
Newton, iPhone recovery after earlier missteps, and failed high-end goggles. Guests discuss operational recovery (replacements) vs trust and category recovery (root-cause transparency, new behaviors, developer/services/accessories).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on Apple's recent product launch and category design issues with the Duo.
“Where are we, Jono, with this Apple Duo product?”
Exploration of the importance of product reliability and user expectations for Apple's new devices.
“We should say a couple of things about Apple.”
Analysis of the challenges Apple faces with premium pricing and customer expectations.
“So it reminds me of, you know, car manufacturers, you know, like BMW.”
Reflections on Apple's innovation strategy and its need for category recovery and value creation.
“So that, even that excuse doesn't really play out in this case.”
A deep dive into the potential issues with Apple's new dual-screen device and its implications for the brand.
“are failing to solve what new behaviors because every new technology wave that matters encourages new behaviors so what new behaviors is the duo or you know the split screen the foldable device is that going to enable?”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Difference Engine | B2B Category Design | Private Equity | Venture Capital, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Welcome to The Difference Engine, the show for tech founders, investors and innovators.
0:11so here on the difference engine we love apple it's been one of the most pioneering firms and greatest category creators in the technology industry but has the launch of duo been a category design disaster you know you wait for a london bus and uh you wait forever three come up once you wait for some innovation from apple and they give you two screens but let's talk about apple's foldable crisis as some are calling it crack gate which is sort of funny we're going to look at the uh implications of this 1999 of your english pounds phone and the rest that's the entry level whatever your size of your wallet it's still premium hardware that's for sure but is this what apple needs to reassert its position as a category defining innovator the press launch was a bomb You know, hence they came up with the phrase crack gate scandal, referring to the crack in the fold of the dual screen.
1:08Where are we, Jono, with this Apple Duo product? We really need to consider what Apple needs to do to restore customer confidence, but much more so its innovation credentials. So these early reports of cracked screens, display lines as well, that's going to raise an immediate concern about product reliability, isn't it? But that's not the real problem. The real issue is credibility, because Apple's brand promise is built on making complex technology really dependable, sort of intuitive to work with, and ready for mainstream use. And in all of this, as Apple is still failing to deliver another device that's going to create a big ecosystem, the big ecosystems on which their valuation is based, we have to remember that product innovation here is not the same as category creation.
2:04A new device must change customer expectations and their behaviors and their experiences, and their first experience shouldn't be of a new product. It doesn't work very well. And again, just to make the point about this, Duo is not anything that is creating a new category for Apple. It's basically a form factor innovation, and it's a form factor innovation which their major competitor, Samsung, delivered over seven years ago. And also, I'm really interested in the way Apple have responded to this. They sort of dismissed Samsung when they launched it. And frankly, dismissing your competitors doesn't deliver you any form of differentiation.
2:45So Apple has got to demonstrate how Duo really enables meaningfully different experiences and creates a new form of customer value. If they don't get this right, Duo is really just an expensive, very expensive variation on existing products rather than any form of category defining innovation. We should say a couple of things about Apple. Apple tends not to be first into the market, but it tends to come a little bit later with a higher quality product, which, as you say, changes something about the paradigm. So if you think back to iPods, there were a bunch of MP3 players, et cetera, doing stuff.
3:25So, yeah, we do know that they come in late, but they normally get it right at the quality point. And that's part of the issue I feel here is with dual screens, you can change experience for users. And I understand that a lot of people in the Apple ecosystem have been changing their software for the form factor that is the duo. But it doesn't sound as though this one's gone correct. And as you said, this powerful ecosystem needs to be accompanied by a compelling product proposition. Their ecosystem, Apple's ecosystem, it's incredible. And it's their major significant competitive advantage. but you've got to have strong product propositions on which to build those ecosystems.
4:09So they have to deliver in three areas on this. And one is product innovation. So new hardware features, folding displays, hinges that work, thinner designs. Not sure they've really delivered on that, this one. There's this experience innovation. I'm not really seeing that being driven home, you know, new ways to multitask, you know, create content, use AI, of course, and actually interact with the device with this different form factor. And, you know, where are the developers, the services, the accessories, and the custom behaviors that are revolving around this new experience? I mean, it's all been cut short by the fact it appears that the technology, physical technology, is really, really not very good.
5:03And it appears that Apple has launched the duo at really a product innovation level. How exciting. Without demonstrating that the experience or the ecosystem benefits that we would associate with a category defining product. This is not the first time. So obviously, the poster child for Apple cocking it up, as I can remember, was the Newton, which was a terrible take on what I think then became the BlackBerry before they got it back with the iPhone. You know, they've also done the high-end goggles that didn't really fly. They really, they're having a bit of a bad run of things. And the ecosystem may be thinking, you know, are these the guys?
5:44I hear on Reddit that this product failed. And we'll come on to the premium price paradox here. This product fails at 70 ,000-fold. So it might be an exaggeration to say that one user opens the phone but certainly glances at the phone 70 times a day. But, you know, some of us do. And if you do, that's 1 ,000 days of use before, you know, things crack for a 2 ,000-pound product. Probably marginally more than your battery is going to last, isn't it? I mean, it's nuts, right? So it reminds me of, you know, car manufacturers, you know, like BMW. they have the base models and they have halo models uh at the top but this is supposed to be a replacement for your iphone and that's certainly what's justifying the price tag replacement for iphone i mean this sort of starts at the top end of the current iphone so it's a it's a super premium product right so if you're going to do a super premium product you're going to have exceptionally high customer expectations i mean this is this is not just about you know apple fanboys and girls queuing up for the latest piece of apple stuff this is this has to be something else entirely so it's not just about the use it's about there's an inherent promise of reliability durability quality and just confidence in the thing um you know it's not just a revenue opportunity for apple to sell a few more bits of hardware this is really really important This is, as you say, premium product.
7:16And so, you know, the fundamental category design principle is the customer experience has to validate the category promise. And we failed at the first hurdle, I feel, here. Yeah. And there are some other things to remember as we all get sort of sucked into the magic of tech is that unlike software problems, which you can, you know, correct through some rapid updates, you've got a whole re-engineering thing to go through here and that takes longer a lot longer than writing a few lines of code right so there's something bigger in the industry too is that if apple don't get this right the the the foldable category could just simply disappear one of those things that never really caught on and and may come back in the future using completely different materials.
8:13But I think if you're going to go out to the marketplace and do this failure, the next time Apple goes out, there's going to be questions. It's not going to be about the product. It's going to be, have Apple got it right this time? So that's not where you want your spotlight to be shone when you're trying to create a new category. And I guess that's the flip side of being a category king, which clearly Apple is, and Samsung to a certain extent is on the Android side. There's an expectation that you're going to keep hitting those highs. And this is where it stops being about category and comes back to brand damage.
8:51And we've said a million times, you know, your brand's not going to get you. It's not no replacement for being leading in a category. But this is when it goes the other way, when you are the category leader and you start having other people catch up, you have a few failures, then it becomes a real execution versus brand equity type issue. Yeah, and the danger here is Apple is, I think, going forward, going to be constantly caught between entering a new category or even product segment too early technically, but too late strategically. And that's a double negative whammy. and certainly as Chinese brands in particular get better and better and better, this is going to really put the pressure on.
9:41And what is sort of interesting is leadership at Apple has passed from somebody with a sort of business management background to somebody who is avowedly a technologist and somebody who's been really, really, really influential in building the technology that underpins the brand promise. In fairness to the new CEO, this may have been in development before he took the reins. I mean, you know, John Ternus is a long storied member of Apple and has been at Apple for like a quarter of a century, 25 years. So that, even that excuse doesn't really play out in this case. He's a top technical guy. He's come up the technical route.
10:25he's a guy who's who's you know strongly associated with the engineering excellence that apple for the most part has shown um now you know there's undoubtedly apple has amazing engineering resources but they also have fantastic supply chain and a great retail network um which is going to deliver operational advantages to any sort of company. So because that's all in place, acknowledging faults and replacing affected devices is, of course, if they want to retain category leadership, the right response. But operational recovery is not the same as restoring innovation leadership. and it can reveal a company that is on the downward part of the innovation curve.
11:23So, you know, what are they to do? Well, there's a lot to do. I mean, let's talk some positives. What can they do? Right. I think there's three levels to category recovery on this. And one is just the operational recovery, which we've just talked about. So replace those devices, honor the warranties, minimize the customer disruption. then there's trust recovery I think and that's identify the root cause you know what was it that caused this device to be launched fully commercially with these clear problems with the materials it was made of um you know communicate that transparently and demonstrate that replacements are reliable and that's probably going to you know that should be more than just dripping them out in the marketplace, that should show, they should really, really, really focus on however they deal with this repair to make sure that it's seen to be very, very robust indeed.
12:21And I think the big one from our point of view is category recovery. It's like, why does this product matter? And what new customer value does it create? Yeah. And it's almost like definition of a new customer, right? We're not talking about, But I mean, maybe Apple did get sucked in a little bit to the replacement cycle. But you've got to ask yourself, back to category design. It's very useful discipline for them to reimagine or rediscover now. What's the customer problem that the existing products fail to solve? What new behavior will this product that you're launching in 28 markets, by the way, fix?
12:57Yeah, but that's the new launch, right? So they're stuck in the middle. They've launched it in a few markets, bond. they've got a 28 market target to go out to it's got to be right before they do that and wall street will be breathing down their neck because all the analysts on wall street will be doing the numbers to see if this is actually going to significantly affect the numbers or the numbers they projected in summary right like this brand power that they've got right now it will accelerate adoption output more duos in people's hands but clearly that's an issue if the thing's not perfect and 70 ,000 folds I'm afraid does not cut it.
13:33You don't want customers paying premium prices feeling that they're beta testers. You know has it pushed its look too far Jono? We don't know I mean there's a serious cost of tactical catch-up here because you know there's loads of questions to be asked about category leadership you know so we keep going around to this because all I can see at the moment it's a new product that I'm not sure anybody wants who doesn't want who don't want to pay that amount of money and that doesn't actually work so you know what are the customer problems that existing products are failing to solve what new behaviors because every new technology wave that matters encourages new behaviors so what new behaviors is the duo or you know the split screen the foldable device is that going to enable?
14:22You know, is this innovation meaningfully different? Is a folding phone really, really that different? Does it change the game? And what are the complementary capabilities that increase its value? What can you actually do with it that increases its value? And, you know, actually, is this technology ready for full-scale deployment? Because at the moment, it doesn't look like it. We should say we're massive Apple fans, pretty much lifelong users at this point, or certainly adult life users. So we do wish them all the best. But unfortunately, must do better, I think. Yeah, yeah. And I think that the issue is that if you're going to go pause this product, go out again to 28 markets, don't think that marketing can compensate for a lack of meaningful customer benefits.
15:17or frankly, unreliable engineering. And the problem at the moment I see is the duo really risks being neither a better product or a genuinely different category. And to me, actually, it really suggests regression rather than progression. It's hard to say this really. I think the duo does represent a significant reputational risk. But the good news, Apple fans, is that one product failure does not prove Apple has lost its ability to innovate. The deeper concern for me is Apple's apparent reliance on brand equity these days and operational capabilities, which are unmatched, to compensate for what is clearly some unresolved engineering challenges.
16:12and frankly, guys, we've got to say this, insufficient differentiation. Sorry, Samsung basically did this seven years ago. So they had problems when they launched the phone. The last thing Apple should have had with this would be problems. But I also think that without a compelling ecosystem, the potential strategic rewards will not justify the risks. It's going to be an orphan tech child and, you know, another Newton. I generally think this could be another Newton. You know, they've got this fantastic brand, fantastic customer base, fantastic retail capabilities, but they are not going to guarantee future innovation leadership because all those pivot on the innovation leadership.
17:02If they just basically repair devices and restart the rollout, it could absolutely turn a manageable product crisis. And I'm sure they're going to manage the product crisis okay. The issue is a broader credibility problem, particularly at the price points. If they've got an underlying strategy problem that remains unchanged. So recovery, I think, probably three interconnected outcomes. They have to get back to an Apple reputation for robustness and reliability. And that's what we love about Apple is basically reliability. It all connects together. You can drop it. It generally works. There's got to be a differentiated customer value to restore relevance.
17:43And I just don't see any of that at the moment. And there has to be complementary ecosystem experiences to establish that sustained category leadership. and again they're going to have to work very very hard and making sure everybody understands that
18:04thank you for listening if you want to learn more about category design head to becategorical.com if you need help designing and dominating your category then get in touch contact details are in the show notes
18:25At age 30 MATT 05 In the world by a few thingsôture, get yourself yourself You all grew According to Chicago describes
18:51According to Chicago describes
Apple product launches have always generated enormous excitement and anticipation. Historically, the company’s innovations have sparked technological revolutions, reshaped markets and fundamentally changed the way we interact not only with technology, but with the world around us.
It is therefore no surprise that Apple’s new foldable phone, the Duo, has captured the world’s attention. However, with such high expectations comes equally significant risk. A misstep could result in widespread embarrassment, serious reputational damage and, more importantly, a crisis of Category leadership.
So, will the Duo reinforce Apple’s position as a Category-defining innovator, or is it a Category design disaster?
There is more information on how to design your category on our blog
Follow us on LinkedIn:
Want to create a podcast for your business or brand? Contact Flamingo Media to make it happen.



