


3 Nov 2026 · 46m · 20 chapters

Ad tech’s “server-side shift” as a response to Apple’s Safari tracking/identity clampdowns and the post–Google Ad Tech remedies environment, plus a related “auction flip” where pre-bid may become the final arbiter.
Tim Peterson (host; Digiday Executive Editor of Video and Audio). Seb Joseph (Digiday Executive Editor of News). Ronan Shields (Digiday Senior Ad Tech Reporter; reported on server-side/trusted server and pre-bid developments).
Apple’s Safari blocks ad-tech identity resolution tied to email-based identifiers like Unified ID 2.0, because the browser normally makes the calls to third-party ad tech. Industry is moving logic off-device via server-side/trusted server, but it may not be a durable workaround because Apple can still offset it. Trusted server is seen as panacea but may shift risk from browsers to publishers/users. Pre-bid’s “auction flip” could change header bidding dynamics so Google AdX bids into pre-bid.
iOS 27 Safari domain blocking (Trade Desk server domain); Google Ad Tech remedies (Judge Laney Brinkinma); prior “transaction ID” debacle affecting pre-bid; spyware delivered via ad-tech (referenced as Confiant/IB Europe/tag-certified); GPC/GDPR behavior in trusted server tests.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the recent changes in ad tech due to Apple's updates and the Google trial ruling.
“domains, including the Trade Desk server domain, which seemed to be breaking a lot of calls.”
Using Game of Thrones characters to illustrate roles in the ad tech landscape.
“Seb, who do you think I picked as Cersei?”
Identifying different characters in the ad tech world and their implications for the industry.
“been pretty quiet on that front since then.”
Exploration of trusted servers in the context of identity resolution and tracking issues.
“Even when, like, Jon Snow goes to Dragonstone and tries to be like, yo, there's the Night King and the White Walkers we got to worry about.”
Analysis of Apple's restrictions on tracking within its Safari browser and its implications.
“And it can also drop identifiers on your browser.”
Explore how Apple’s browser controls impact ad tech and server-side solutions.
“I think the way Apple sort of kind of phrased it in the blog post was that, you know, these firms are present, but they're invisible at the same time, which I thought was an interesting way to kind of frame it.”
Discuss the implications of server-side shifts on small publishers and ad tech firms.
“They can't rest control because Google and Apple, they own the browser, the mobile OS.”
Compare the advancements in CTV ad tech to the challenges in web advertising.
“I guess what I'm asking for is, given everything that we're talking to, given the trajectory that we're on, does publicists make a move for something like LiveRamp now versus what you did earlier this year?”
Analyze the role of browsers in protecting user privacy amidst ad tech evolution.
“you know, if you've got these sort of evolutionary leaps, right?”
Consider the trade-offs of free content on the web and its implications for users.
“And obviously, and this is always a recurring thing with Apple.”
Discussing the trust issues surrounding targeted advertising and the server-side shift.
“attack that was targeting, and I believe it was Al Jazeera journalists.”
Exploring the challenges of self-regulation in the ad tech industry amid concerns over user privacy.
“i don't know a newyorktimes.com a cnn.com you know a reputable site sure but if i'm going to a site that I don't know, but hey, Google is trying to democratize traffic with AI overviews and AI mode.”
Examining the complexities and challenges faced by publishers in the ad tech landscape.
“Yeah, well, obviously it's the sheer complexity of AppTank which just makes it almost impossible.”
Discussing the limited legal protections available to users in the context of targeted advertising.
“And in the United States right now, at least, I think there's only 20 states where there are those legal protections in place for GPC opt-outs.”
Analyzing the industry's response to privacy concerns and potential future regulations.
“only seem to have so many options right now if I care about these things.”
Introducing the upcoming discussion about changes in the pre-bid auction process.
“So that's bringing us up to that window where they want an exit now and they just want to get as many money running through the books, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.”
Detailing the new auction dynamics introduced by pre-bid and their implications.
“we're going to be talking trusted server.”
Critically assessing whether pre-bid is the best authority for managing ad auctions.
“And I know, obviously, their stock price dropped because people were assessing the impact of a search engine dropped and AI owed.”
Discussion about the evolution and impact of pre-bid solutions in ad tech.
Preview of discussions at the upcoming summit focusing on server-side advertising.

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Digiday Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:09Hello and welcome to the DigiDay Podcast, a show for anyone wondering, is the online ad industry server-side shift a long-term solution? And is it the right solution? I am Tim Peterson, Executive Editor of Video and Audio at Digiday Media, and today I am joined by Digiday's Executive Editor of News, Seb Joseph, and Senior Ad Tech Reporter, Ronan Shields. Seb, Ronan, thanks for joining me. You're welcome, yeah. So let's get right into it. About a month ago, Ad Exchanger reports like, oh, hey, everyone, it looks like Apple and iOS 27 is blocking a bunch of ad tech domains, including the Trade Desk server domain, which seemed to be breaking a lot of calls.
0:54Not necessarily a huge deal at the time because a lot of people hadn't installed iOS 27, but it seemed to raise the hackles of the entire ad tech industry because it reminded everyone of the power of the browser and how much the browser can dictate what advertising companies can and cannot do. At the same time, a few weeks before that, Judge Laney Brinkinma handed down the remedies ruling in the Google Ad Tech trial. Not huge remedies in terms of Google having to divest its ad tech business, but things that created what seems like an opening for pre-bid to flip the auction dynamic by making the pre-bid server kind of the ultimate arbiter and have Google have to bid into pre-bid.
1:53So all of this seems to be amounting to this server side shift as a result of apple reminding everyone of how powerful the browser is you have a lot of companies in ad tech as well as organizations like iab tech lab saying hey we need to switch to the server and do everything server side so that the browser can't actually dictate what can happen here all of this made me think of game of thrones sub ronan did you each watch or read game of thrones yeah Yeah, I'm familiar. All right, so I picked four characters from Game of Thrones and their analogs here. Seb, who do you think I picked as Cersei?
2:40Oh, good question.
2:46Okay, so scheming, a real power behind the throne. Sorry, I'll keep quiet about it. That's an interesting one. So Cersei kind of the power hungry queen, but also the one primarily focused on Westeros as everyone knew it. So the villain, but kind of the villain, you know. Okay. So who would you Google? Google. I want Google. Google on Cersei. He kind of ad text boogeyman for a long time, but not the only boogeyman. Cause as everyone who watched the show, read the books, no, there are the white walkers. These who, and I think it was like the age of heroes or whatever was like kind of the original villain, the original threat to the people of Westeros.
3:42But that fight had taken place generations ago. it was easy to forget about the threat of the white walkers or think that they had gone dormant i see where this is going apple there you are exactly yes 12 years ago there's the whole ad blocker freak out when apple decided to allow yeah and then there is intelligent tracking prevention and so pre-covid apple was a big bad just like google if anything apple seemed to be more of the big bad than Google, but everyone kind of forgot about that or Apple just like got a bit quiet. There weren't, there were a whole bunch of ITP updates heading up into 2020, but it's been pretty quiet on that front since then.
4:32At the same time, Cersei is trying to rule Westeros, but also needs Westeros, whereas Because Apple, yeah, they have an advertising business, so to speak, but they don't seem to really care about advertising. And so just like the Night King and the White Walkers, they don't mind, it seems, who they would trample on their way to take it. We need to have this conversation in a year's time, because I wonder if we'll be thinking of the Apple as the White Walkers versus Baelish Littlefinger. because you look at like you know the fact that the ceo has made it very clear that advertising is going to be a big part of you know kind of how he defines his sort of tenure um you look at the fact that what was it 82 jobs i think apple related to apple ads that apple currently had on its jobs board as it sort of upends the industry so um it feels like every time you know over that kind of period where you talked about sort of apple zeroing on sort of third party cookies up until now it's kind of used the banner of privacy as its thing and its position it doesn't really care about advertising but each of those steps you could probably point to it something else it's done wrong and correct me if I'm wrong even a DSP story that we wrote many moons ago that has kind of like undermined some of that and kind of made you think actually it cares about advertising maybe more than it's letting on um and a lot of this stuff that it's been doing kind of paves the way for it to sort of secure a bigger slice of the market uh so yeah interesting apple going from the night king to little finger that's that's a fall i also heard it said too and i think that's a good observation tim because i've also heard it said that like trying to contact apple about any of these policy updates is like trying to contact the dead.
6:35So, you know, you could extend that. You need a Bran Stark in order to do that. Okay. So that's Cersei. That's the White Walkers. But then I thought, okay, who's the Daenerys Targaryen in this situation? The potential prince who was promised, the, you know, was, you know, So previous royalty is looking to come and retake Westeros, conquer Cersei, rule over, and bring back spring to where winter has come. Bronin, who do you think Daenerys is in this? Okay. I'm just terrible of names. I'm just clarifying. Daenerys is the mother of dragons. Mother of dragons, yep. Okay. Her preferred time, I believe.
7:24Okay. Oof. Okay. who's saying okay gonna restore rebuild i mean i'd say hurry up because i'm gonna jump in here in a second he's raising us yeah feel free sam i'm fine i'm trusted server right the iab yeah i was literally gonna get there you you got it quicker than me yeah no they uh oh okay well i mean shit this is i came up with this off the top of my head so everyone is free to say it is whoever Don't reveal the secrets, Tim. A lot of thoughts got into this. I think it's pre-bid. I think it's pre-bid because pre-bid, you know, with header bidding, the rise of header bidding, that was about Google.
8:05Google, again, is Cersei. Daenerys in the show really just cared about taking back Westeros from Cersei. Even when, like, Jon Snow goes to Dragonstone and tries to be like, yo, there's the Night King and the White Walkers we got to worry about. Daenerys is just like, yeah, cool, but I need to take out Cersei first and then we can get on that. Cersei's who I care about. Also, foreshadowing for later in this conversation, Daenerys, spoilers for anyone who hasn't read or who hasn't watched Game of Thrones, hopefully the books, if they ever come out, take a different turn. But the end of Game of Thrones, Daenerys makes a turn.
8:44She goes from the queen, the hero, the prince who was promised, turns on the Red Keep and King's Landing and burns all the citizens and eventually like has to be taken out because she turned villain. Pre-bid isn't about to turn villain. I don't know anything about that, but I think about the transaction ID debacle a little over a year ago where pre-bid decided, hey, actually, we're going to change up how transaction IDs are handled for privacy reasons, but then the buy side, the trade desk, a lot of folks freaked out about it. I think prebid walked that back, but it was kind of this question of if prebid's in power, is that who you want to be in power?
9:35Can you trust them with that power? Which then leaves us with Jon Snow. Who do you guys think Jon Snow is? yeah it's got to be it's got to be trusted server iab right that yeah absolutely choked yeah it didn't yeah yeah because john snow the one concerned with the white walkers trusted server seems to be held out there as the solution for the in a way more existential problem than google which is the problem of the browsers which includes google as well as obviously apple but even brave Firefox, DuckDuckGo, on down the line. So IB Tech Lab is Jon Snow in this analogy. Does that hold up? I think so.
10:26I think the reason why I went early with my guests on the IB and trusted service, because at least from the conversations that we're having in the initial aftermath of the Safari crackdown, trusted server has kind of been seen as this sort of almost like panacea to the kind of issue and yet i know ronan your piece touched on this earlier this week but um it does feel like that is a misappropriation of what the trusted server was designed for and that any attempt to kind of truly lean on it as a durable workaround to what Apple is doing misses the point entirely. I think if you read between the lines, you know, in terms of what Apple has kind of put out there, you know, about, you know, identity resolution writ large, it's pretty clear that it's not going to stop at the companies that it has already sort of targeted and more importantly, the mechanism that they use to do that.
11:30So whether it's happening via the Safari kind of browser itself or via the trusted server i think apple just does not want that stuff happening you know to its customers in any guys and we'll by hook or by quick find a way to to kind of offset that so the that was kind of my thinking of like you know the best intentions right but the you know i think it probably needs to be um more thought about whether or not this is the right course um for the trusted server to go down uh given that i feel like and i'm sure we'll get to this later on you know it's almost kind of delaying the inevitable right at least in terms of how we report on where you know kind of tracking is going and i think it is less about um you know identity per se versus you know kind of intent you know again i'm sure we'll kind of dig into that a little bit more right yeah because then it's becomes like does it is it just about intent or is oh now we get intent and identity even better let's jump the cpms because the web is dying anyway so we gotta like grab as much cash as we could
12:48so now that we've played my little game of game of thrones let's talk about like what's actually going on here. And so the big thing on the Apple front is this, it clamped down on how tracking can be done within the Safari browser when it comes to identity resolution, which is really just, you know, if you're using Safari, you go to a website, that website can collect a bunch of information from you. And it can also drop identifiers on your browser. Among the identifiers that it can drop or resolve are things like Unified ID 2.0, which is a way of tracking you that's connected to your email address.
13:36And that seems to be the thing that Apple really didn't like and went after here. It was like being able to track people on the web and associate their browsing behavior to an email address right yeah apple's argument is that you know the person behind that just never really agreed to deal with the companies that are appending that data right and mostly have no idea that they exist so um you know when someone does that they just think they're giving it to the site owner and whereas behind the scenes you've got like third party companies that are you know also on the page and then using that to kind of match against everything else that that person is doing within the kind of browser.
14:16I think the way Apple sort of kind of phrased it in the blog post was that, you know, these firms are present, but they're invisible at the same time, which I thought was an interesting way to kind of frame it. Right. And Apple is able to do this because how things work, the browser makes the calls to the trade desk id5 whoever it is like a web page can say okay we're gonna load tags or ads from all these companies but then the browser actually has to make the calls to those companies fetch them back and then load them up on a person's browser which so then apple's in a position as the browser owner to say no we're gonna not we're not gonna make those calls so yeah now the industry is just like, all right, well, how do we make it so that the browser can't control these things, which seems to be this shift toward the server side of I go to a website in my browser, the browser makes the call to the website to get the information.
15:16And then the website has their own server, basically like a separate computer that can then make the calls outside of the web browser to share and collect all of that information, bring it back. Ronan, you've been reporting on this. Is this how things are going? How much are companies betting on the server as the solution here, going server side as the solution? I think they all are. Yeah. So some of the people I spoke to said, yes, you can do it. that sort of insulates you from, say, the latest policy whim from Apple. Apple could absolutely shut it down, but that would mean just the publisher's page doesn't load at all, which would be the absolute doomsday scenario.
16:05I think you're talking about real competitive concerns there. So I think maybe there's kind of a bit of a standoff happening. But to Seb's point, I mean, I think, I mean, look, big tech big tech and apple is a public listening company and obviously always going to be primarily motivated but i do have to think that they are probably a little bit concerned about how they see a safari user as their customer having a crappy user experience and they want to shut that down a bit and i'm not saying that's out of altruism that's just because if it becomes a garbage experience then customers are going to go somewhere else so but yeah apple has full control I know when we were preparing for this, one of the key questions was, can ad tech rest by control from these power brokers of Apple and Google?
16:59I would say absolutely no. They can't rest control because Google and Apple, they own the browser, the mobile OS. In the case of Google, they own the ad tech platform and the cloud infrastructure as well, if we want to go one step deeper. But with trusted server solution, yeah, they can gain a degree of autonomy, but they need to behave themselves with it to retain that autonomy. That's how I would parse it. Ronan, do you think this is like the control point though? That's been a moot point for a minute. And this is really about ad tech having to, and I guess more broadly, like the open web, having to sort of accept, you know, kind of something new, right?
17:46Like what, you know, a person wants to buy right now is kind of arguably worth more than who they are. And just really having to kind of accept that the kind of rampant tracking that, you know, kind of funded, you know, kind of the last various iterations of the open web or just like the open web up until now, you know, that's not going to be, you know, kind of that's not going to be what is used for the next kind of phase of it. Right. Like if, you know, a publisher can skip knowing that, you know, I drive an Audi, have two kids and support Liverpool if I'm reading a review of family SUVs. and they could use that to determine that I'm shopping for a cart.
18:29It's the idea that those kind of first-party signals essentially are going to be the thing moving forward and agentic will be the thing that kind of scales that and makes that more accessible. Is the server-side shift the best solution? Is it the thing that benefits everyone? Because I have some concerns about what it means as just a person using the web. But before we even get into that, are there losers of this or like folks who are going to struggle to make that shift, like smaller publishers or long tail ad tech firms?
19:10Definitely long tail ad tech firms. I think we're all in agreement. And I think anybody that's listening to this probably would say there's been a lot of dead weight in the industry for quite some time. so I think yeah definitely see a rapid consolidation if not just outright dying off said firms smaller publishers maybe smaller publishers will just be able to be so nimble and agile they can actually move to a business different business model that wouldn't but doesn't that has the current ad funded model on the internet has predominated on scale cpms etc etc so i think they might actually be so under the radar they could actually adjust pivot whatever word you want to use and find another way but i think big publishers yeah they're going to say big publishers your legacy publishers the names you would have seen in the newsstand back in the day i think they'll feel it a lot really really badly yeah despite the shift to service i do you Amid that shift, do you think ID resolution is still important?
20:22I guess what I'm asking for is, given everything that we're talking to, given the trajectory that we're on, does publicists make a move for something like LiveRamp now versus what you did earlier this year?
20:41Tough one, I think. It would be interesting. obviously the deal got cleared uh this week uh that's recording and we're recording on october 29 so recently anyway i think if moves like this had have been made clear um had it happened say six months beforehand i think that price tag that live rap i went to publicist for forgive me i can't quite recall it off the top of my head i think there'd be quite a few numbers skimmed off that um yeah but obviously it's the data onboarding part that is uh that's kind of as purposes saw that the the real value of that so you saw that that transaction as like being overwhelmingly web focused in terms of like web-based identity as opposed to having valuable application, more valuable application in like CTV.
21:38Because this like server-side shift is happening in the web. It's effectively already happened in connected TV where like you have server-side ad stitching. And you have like UID 2.0. I think Ramp ID like works in CTV. There's companies who have adopted these identities for streaming advertising. And so I don't know how much of this is kind of the web, maybe not catching up to CTV's advertising infrastructure, but at least beginning to mirror it. I don't know if that's for better or worse.
22:21Well, I think it's a typical thing, you know, if you've got these sort of evolutionary leaps, right? CTV didn't have the same legacy infrastructure problems, I think. So it was able to just move ahead. And then, yeah, I don't know. Maybe if we're going to use this analogy, there'll be a different technology that the open web will adopt. And then CTV will, you know, blah, blah, blah. And just that, it goes on and on and on. But what do I know? I could be wrong. We could all be wrong. Everyone could be wrong. But so one of my concerns as a person on the internet and a person who's also covered privacy for a long time at this point is I get why browsers are ad tech's boogeyman.
23:06But I also feel like browsers are users' best defense against at least the bad actors on the web. And so, Renan, you just had this piece talking about the server-side shift. And you talked with Matthew Roche from ID5. And he had this quote that honestly, like, alarmed me a bit. He said, going server-side is more resilient because you're not on the device anymore. So there's nothing the device can do to block you. I get that that's empowering for ad tech. but it's concerning for me where I then don't have the browser to be able to block and tackle for me and prevent tracking scripts pixels what have you from loading in my browser from I'm basically having to trust the website owner that they're gonna do the right things on their end to protect me.
24:08Absolutely. I agree with you. I mean, I look at my own inbox and I just see just the amount of just like a rub and I just like, stop, would you please? So I do get that. Trust me, I really, really do. But I guess there's also, you know, the whole sort of, you know, the societal contract of, well, hey, you are getting this for free. We do need to sustain a business to get it. And then And I know that's always a negotiation. So that would be, I guess, the counter to that. Yeah, I just think with AI and automation, though, increasingly, I think for consumer protection, we do need a bit more of these policies like Apple.
24:48And obviously, and this is always a recurring thing with Apple. You guys were called, you know, the ITP, IDFA rollbacks, you know, of what, the early 20s and the late 2010s. So, yeah, I feel like this is occasionally is Apple just pulling his foot down and kind of like trying to send some shockwaves throughout the industry to try and correct people, you know, correct some behaviors, which it sees as not being, you know, not being on. for protection of their consumers. I guess the thing that that industry has really struggled with is, and this is certainly from my reporting for said piece that went out last week, so many phone calls about it, but was that it's just Apple just doesn't engage with the industry.
25:41So I spoke to one contact who asked me to remain anonymous about this, but they said there was just the slightest modicum of back channel interaction with somebody at Apple to kind of let them know. It's very, very limited, not extensive in any way, shape or form. But to my point, everybody else said it was just like nothing, absolutely nothing. Years ago, Tech Lab apparently tried to get when the ITP, you know, Intelligent Tracking Prevention Software, I mean, apparently they tried to get to engage with them and it just didn't happen. They wouldn't respond. And it was just obviously what was it?
26:29It was John Willander who was seemingly Apple's public face of that. He has continued to be. He's the one who's writing like all the WebKit blogs. I think he's the one responding to the tweets. One interesting tip that I found out upon my reporting was that this is speaking with the source who said it. So there is an author that writes hacker thrillers, also called John Willander. So I couldn't confirm whether or not this was the same person. But they write, they've penned some novels, such as the title of one is called Identified. And the other one is about Submerged. and seemingly that's the only, some of the people that I spoke to, they said that was the only insight you could get into their actual thinking.
27:19I wasn't able to confirm the name of this person, but going through the author bio page, it looks to be the same person. But people have said that's literally as close as we can get to understanding what their thinking is, or these fictional novels. So I get your point around, like, we're getting these websites for free. We're getting access to information for free. I think that is valid point and valuable, but I never necessarily know the cost of a webpage that I'm loading, not from like a financial standpoint, but just, am I just getting the information or am I getting infected? Wired had a story, I think like two weeks ago about how there was this targeted spyware attack that was targeting, and I believe it was Al Jazeera journalists.
28:06And they did so via targeted advertising. And so that makes me think of like, okay, yes, we're getting these websites for free. You know what else we get for free? Bathrooms at public parks. But I don't necessarily know what I could be catching when I use a bathroom at a public park. Am I wrong? Like I'm trusting the parks department to be keeping those up. And luckily, where I live in North County, San Diego, we've really clean bathrooms. I see when I go running or surfing in the mornings, the folks cleaning those bathrooms each morning, they do a pretty good job. I used to live in LA. I would be at Venice Beach.
28:51Those people did not do a good job. Those bathrooms were a horror show. And then you have places like Tokyo, which famously have pristine bathrooms. But it's still me trusting that this bathroom I'm walking into is clean and I can walk out of it without having caught something that's really going to fuck me up. and it feels like with this server side shift i'm having to walk into public bathrooms blindfolded and trust that the bathroom is being upkept well and for if i'm going to i don't know a newyorktimes.com a cnn.com you know a reputable site sure but if i'm going to a site that I don't know, but hey, Google is trying to democratize traffic with AI overviews and AI mode.
29:52And so now it's pulling information from domains I'm not familiar with. If I click on any of those links to get that actual information, I don't necessarily have a relationship with that website to know, okay, if they're going to be sending out my information server side, who are they sending it to and what are they bringing back to my web browser that's my like ultimate concern here i'm not like trying to concern troll the situation but i don't feel like the industry has answered for that even like in iab tech labs comments about trusted server they seem to be pinning so much of that on you can trust the publisher well i can't i don't know that I can trust every publisher.
30:46Yeah, well, obviously it's the sheer complexity of AppTank which just makes it almost impossible. I mean, again, I don't think this is going to be a big news flash for anybody listening to this, but publishers are just so overwhelmed and under-resourced in general that, yeah, they just want as many bids as possible. And to that spyware infection case in which you referenced, uh tim which was the uh the confiant investigation um uh i actually did a few calls around that myself it's something i'm looking at ongoing um apparently that company was like it was a member of the the spyware company it was a member of ib europe okay it was tag certified as well um yeah there was all these um why is it every time like the industry is always calling for self-regulation and then when we get into these examples it's just can you all really regulate yourselves and which like again the server-side shift seems to be the industry saying let's just take care of it ourselves let's effectively self-regulate as opposed to let apple have any power here but i don't know that i trust the industry to look out for me as a user Well, yeah, to your point, it's certainly littered with bad historic examples.
32:07Then obviously, we all know Apple, was it a$400 trillion company? These are the ones that are making money, improving revenue year on year. And you don't exactly get that by being a nice guy. So I do get the kind of bully dynamic. But yeah, the industry sure as heck hasn't really painted itself in a good light. with this spyware example being a good example being a good recent example of it i just think there needs to be some explicit action taken on okay hey we're gonna if we're gonna take things out of the browser and move it server side here's what we're gonna do so that people have controls because like there's global privacy control trusted server honors that but it seems to only So I've done a test playing around with trusted server, building some dummy websites and dummy servers on the back end and vendors as well.
33:08if i have gpc enabled in a browser and the location for the visitor is in california which recognizes gpc as an opt-out under ccpa trusted server doesn't pass on any of the information that it would be collecting like ip address if i'm not in one of the 20 states that are listed for the gpc opt-out that stuff does get passed now again in you know trusted servers favor if i also did it where i had a page visitor who was located in the european union gdpr land everything was blocked trusted server didn't pass any of the information so it is there is our protections for people but those protections seem limited to where are there actually like legal protections in place.
34:05And in the United States right now, at least, I think there's only 20 states where there are those legal protections in place for GPC opt-outs. So again, I, as user, only seem to have so many options right now if I care about these things.
34:25Yeah. And there's no federal law coming anytime soon. I mean, I know, you know, anytime you talk about it um people are like oh well we've got the midterms and it's like the midterms keep coming you know it's uh yeah but to tim's point is it maybe incumbent on the industry at some point to get it shit together and do more than the bare minimum the baseline set by regulators in order to instill some sort of trust um because otherwise you know the browsers the platforms They will find a way to put their hand on the scale moving forward. They've done it. Over the last several years, I can only imagine that's going to happen even more so now, given everything that's happening to the agentic web and how people are trying to evolve the way they access information moving forward.
35:19I hear what you're saying, Seb, but how realistic is that? I'd say it was pretty realistic this time around, because otherwise what happens? There's not going to be a bloody industry to fucking save. Yeah, but I guess the point where I was coming at was like, when you think about it, you've got these companies that, let's say private equity pulled up a lot of players in that 2020 era. So that's bringing us up to that window where they want an exit now and they just want to get as many money running through the books, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. I just think there's a very excellent talent.
35:53how many of those companies have probably been missed that if they haven't made their exit now chances are it ain't happening they missed like no agreed i'm just i totally agree with you in terms of um what seems logical and right but i'm just wondering just i mean uh how many times does the industry do what's logical i get it it's just like when you have quotes like the one you referenced earlier and people kind of saying it with their chest like it's a bit like there's no uh self awareness as to kind of how this looks and will be perceived by people right um and privacy is only going to become you know an even kind of bigger issue moving forward and i just don't understand why the industry you know kind of hasn't you know kind of take heeded any of the lessons learned from itp to gdpr to ccp to att to even a deprecation of third-party cookies in chrome let's do you forget like it's like how many big fuck off kind of like warnings do you need before you get your shit together and appreciate you know there are a lot of kind of moving parts here but when you look at the kind of stakes right and how quickly um you know kind of things have shifted even 18 months from a sort of traffic and programmatic perspective it's uh it's worrying yeah because like to say the least apple gets knocked by the industry for wrapping itself in privacy as you know it's you know primary defense but who else is like then the industry should do that more than they actually have been doing so So anyways, this will be a conversation.
37:39I'll continue with Rowena Lamb, who is VP of product at IAB Tech Lab because for next week's episode, we're going to be talking trusted server. But I want to, before I let you guys go, also talk about this pre-bid side of things because this is another server side shift. Again, if Apple and IAB Tech Lab are the White Walkers and Jon Snow, this pre-bid Google server shift is Cersei and Daenerys fighting for Westeros. So Ronan, you were at the pre-bid summit where they announced this, what are they calling it, the auction flip? Yeah, they didn't announce it. I think they're waiting for the full, but they previewed it and then it got reported on.
38:26And so it's obviously that got amplified. When I spoke to certain people at pre-bid, they kind of suggested they're waiting for the final, final remedies ruling from the case. And then it will be announced. It was kind of previewed as an example and it got reported on. But I think we can trust that it probably won't change massively. So this sort of changing the flow of the auction. Yeah, and so the changing of the flow of the auction. So historically, like under header bidding, auction happens where a person goes to a website, bid requests, you know, get sent out, fetch bids through pre-bid. But then whatever the winning bid through pre-bid is, if the website is using Google Ad Manager as its ad server, that winning pre-bid bid gets sent to GAM.
39:20And Google's ad server can then say, okay, cool. Hey, Google AdEx, Google's Ad Exchange, you got any bids that can beat this? So pre-bid wasn't ultimately the last stop for the ad auction. What it sounds like pre-bid is looking to do is take advantage of the fact that Google needs to allow ad acts to compete in these header bidding auctions. And so pre-bid is going to flip things. Whereas, you know, with GAM, Google was the last stop for the bid. Pre-bid server is going to be the last bid. So bid, all the bids go through pre-bid server and google adx would have to bid into the pre-bid server that decides who actually gets the impression at the end of the day is that the correct summary of what this is yes um yeah more or less that's that's a generic flow of things um but i mean i have my own take on that um like one of the things that was said on stage um at the pre-bit summit was basically people were saying like look we've had the the remedies rulings from leone brinkhamer and um yeah sure google's probably gonna try and claw back a bit but if we listen to um their earnings yesterday.
40:48This is on October 28th. They issued earnings. And I know, obviously, their stock price dropped because people were assessing the impact of a search engine dropped and AI owed. But the one aspect of the business that didn't do well, again, the only declining area of the business is its network business, the GAM area of the business. I think they're really fine with letting it go i think they might protest but almost like shakespeare said uh he thinks they protest too much um yeah i just think they're very okay with losing it youtube cooking along nicely um you know however they're going to monetize gemini etc etc that's all well i'm sure you'll record many podcasts about that in future tim but i just think this is a part of the business they're really okay with letting it go so if pre-bid wants it yeah fine go ahead um i don't think they're going to lose too much sleep over it so should pre-bid get that position like is there any reason that pre-bid that there should be consideration given to whether pre-bid holding that power is the right one to be holding the power again i'm thinking of the transaction id stuff like a year ago yeah you know my question that was going to be what i asked ronan because i'm well like ronan you're you're close to it right but i think for me you know kind of having you know kind of reported on this since it began and that pre-bid kind of alternative solution thing being kind of floated that's always been the thing in the back of my mind like i understand it superficially but like are they the best arbiter of it well okay so pre-bid was set up what roughly a decade ago maybe nine years and it was a means of getting header bidding above the ground so i think it does do it has served a purpose just in terms of restoring elements of a parity to an otherwise as i said before extremely imbalanced relationship um should they be i mean i guess what they'll say is we just administer the specs i mean maybe you want to get a garrett mcgrath on the on the mic sometime he's the new incoming ceo of um of pre-bids um i'm sure he'd be happy to talk through their their part of it but i don't know are they good yeah sure because i don't know is there sure there's worse people out there um ringing in doors would it would it require much of a shift like in terms of how they operate now um i don't know i didn't speak to too many engineers i didn't ask kind of what the done time would be certain even just being the ultimate arbiter of it all like just that is a different that's a kind of shift in dynamic a shift in power influence as it were like yeah like was Daenerys going to be a better queen than Cersei or not well yeah yeah you know Peter Parker great responsibility becomes great power all of that like I just like how do you how do you fulfill all of that right when you're having to balance even more stakeholders and you've got even more sort of power it's just yeah it's a fascinating question maybe something we should be thinking about reporting wise as this thing sort of shakes out yeah i think it's also going to be really interesting for us to dig into so seb you and i will be at the digital programmatic marketing summit in early december we'll have a bunch of brands and agency execs in the room we'll have these behind closed doors town halls all the opportunities to talk to them i'm really interested and to hear how the buy side is feeling about the server side shift and what the pros and cons for advertisers is and also like are they going to be more or less willing to spend money with um any of these server-side restrictions or if there are server-side trade-offs yeah watch this space because like we have a story cooking in the background on this team oh yeah it was literally about to reference that thank you sir when's that story expected to drop oh no oh no we're putting ourselves under pressure um hopefully in time for uh dpms the first week of december tickets still available all right well folks check digiday.com for that story and for more of ronan's and seb's coverage of the server side shift which feels like it's become the big story in ad tech of 2026 Thanks for joining me.
45:40This was fun. Thank you. Thanks for having us.
45:50Thanks for listening to this episode of the Digiday podcast. If you enjoyed it, please leave us a rating and a review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you're listening. Get more from Digiday with our daily newsletter sent out each weekday morning. Visit digiday.com slash newsletters to sign up.
46:09Thank you.
Apple has reminded ad tech how much power the browser holds. Ad tech’s reaction: Get out of the browser.
With iOS 27, Apple’s Safari browser has begun blocking domains tied to identity resolution providers, such as The Trade Desk and ID5, that link people’s browsing to their email addresses. In response, ad tech firms and IAB Tech Lab are pushing to move ad calls server-side, including through the latter organization’s Trusted Server technology, which would limit the browser’s control over ad tech firms’ actions.
Meanwhile, the remedies ruling in Google’s ad tech antitrust trial has given Prebid an opening to flip the programmatic auction. Instead of Google’s ad server getting final say on the winning bid, Google’s ad exchange would have to bid into Prebid’s server.
But is the server-side shift a long-term solution? And is it the right one? Digiday’s executive editor of news Seb Joseph and senior ad tech reporter Ronan Shields joined the Digiday Podcast to hash out ad tech’s Game of Thrones amid the server-side shift.