


Afghan refugees forced back to Afghanistan via the Torkham “Zero Point” border crossing; the episode examines return numbers, alleged abuse during transit, lack of documentation, UN aid constraints, Taliban resettlement claims, and especially the impact on women and girls.
Liz Doucette, BBC chief international correspondent, reported from Torkham in August and describes what she saw at the border and in tent camps. Harun Rahmani, from the BBC Afghan team, tracks Taliban narratives about returns and departures.
Returns are “voluntary” in official framing but refugees describe coercion, police extortion, and destroyed homes; Pakistan/Iran deny abuse. UNHCR aid is curtailed because women can’t work. Taliban provides limited cash/land plans but independent absorption data is “patchy.” Women face education/work bans; Taliban offers “stay at home, get married” as the future.
UN distributing birth certificates/ID cards; tent village fears over no schooling; former security officer distrust of amnesty; reports of “ghost villages” after climate shocks; secret schools and madrasa “workarounds”; morality-police detentions and protests in Herat; risk of radicalization and IS infiltration concerns.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Explore the challenges faced by Afghan refugees returning home.
“It is the biggest forced migration in the world.”
Witness the crossing and initial experiences of Afghan returnees.
“We ended part two of this series at the Iranian border.”
Analyze the difficulties faced by returnees in resettling in Afghanistan.
“At the border, UN agencies are trying to help introduce some order.”
Understand the dire situation of women and girls in Afghanistan post-return.
“That's why once these refugees are taken to their relevant provinces, no one knows what will happen to them, how they can manage, how they can feed themselves.”
Exploring the challenges Afghan families face under Taliban rule.
“So I was taken by his candor, that they're recognizing that there's an issue.”
Discussing the fears and challenges faced by Afghan refugees.
“did so for their safety because of their work for the former government, security forces or NGOs.”
Investigating the impact of Taliban policies on women's rights.
“We know that it actually saved lives of many people.”
Analyzing the educational and job market challenges for women.
“And for the people who have been in Pakistan and Iran for decades, it is really, really difficult to adopt.”
Exploring the difficulties faced by returning migrants in Afghanistan.
“it's not just the women who are squeezed out.”
Examining the governance of the Taliban and its implications for Afghans.
“The new arrivals bring their own grievances and resentment towards the Taliban, which could add to the restive atmosphere that already exists in parts of the country.”
Explore the Taliban's assertion of improved security and the implications for Afghan society.
“Some say engage less, others engage more.”
Understand the lived experiences of Afghans facing violence and uncertainty under Taliban governance.
“Monday in Jalalabad, 10 bombs blasted restaurants and public squares wounding at least 66 people.”
Discuss the hostile conditions faced by women and journalists in Taliban-controlled Afghanistan.
“And aid agencies say you can travel the whole country, which is why you're getting influencers and vloggers going and saying, oh, isn't Afghanistan wonderful?”
Examine the ongoing deportations and struggles faced by Afghans abroad and their hopes for evacuation.
“Thousands of people stranded in Turkey now, in Qatar right now, in Pakistan, waiting to be evacuated to the Western countries because they were working with the NATO forces.”
Analyze the educational challenges facing Afghan boys and the broader implications for society.
“And the kind of ways he was criticized by some young boys that he met on the road, he said he could sense they saw him as this enemy, if you like.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Documentary Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Decisions made in Washington can affect your portfolio every day. But what policy changes should investors be watching? Washington Wise is an original podcast from Charles Schwab that unpacks the stories making news in Washington right now and how they may affect your finances and portfolio. Listen at schwab.com slash Washington Wise. That's schwab.com slash Washington Wise. If you are currently overpaying on software to run your business, remember this number, 10 ,000. That's the number of new businesses that join Odoo per month. Join Odoo today at odoo.com.
0:46That's O-D-O-O dot com.
1:06Since 2023, millions of Afghan refugees living in neighbouring Iran and Pakistan have returned to their homeland.
1:18It is the biggest forced migration in the world. More than six million people. That is the size of a small or a medium-sized country. No longer welcomed in their adoptive countries, they've been forced to return to a motherland some haven't even been to. Returns have to be voluntary, dignified and safe. Safe, I would say. All the refugees had stories of being abused on the way, which Pakistan and Iran deny. Dignified, I'm not sure. Voluntary, no. A UN official spelled out what awaits them at their final destination. The layer of precarity on top of a layer of poverty, on top of the dryness of the land and into a tinderbox of a sub-region.
2:05It is a recipe for disaster. Under the broad brushstrokes lie millions of untold tragedies. We don't have a national picture of how are they absorbed. Some people are worried about their future and others are terrified. Amid the uncertainty, one thing is clear. The future faced by women and girls is particularly bleak. The option that the Taliban are providing is clear. Stay at home, get married, raise your children. That's it. No future at all. In the final installment of our series on the Afghan refugee crisis, we tracked the story from Zero Point, the border crossing where migrants take their first steps into an uncertain future.
2:50Amid an information black hole surrounding their plight, We examine the reality they face as they begin to rebuild their lives.
3:03Welcome to the documentary from the BBC World Service. I'm Krasi Ivanova-Twig, and this is the global jigsaw from BBC Monitoring, where we look at the world through the lens of its media, exploring the narratives, the propaganda and the disinformation. Radio Tehran.
3:35We ended part two of this series at the Iranian border. We start this episode at the Torkham crossing between Pakistan and Afghanistan. Liz Doucette, the BBC's chief international correspondent, was there in August. She later came to the studio to tell us what she saw. Torka, it's called Zero Point, the geographic location where one country ends and another begins. But the phrase now is so apt because literally people, not just crossing from one country to another, it's crossing from one life to another. And in the new life, so many are beginning with almost zero.
4:16It's entire families, three, four generations, and it was heartbreaking. Old men on crutches, women being helped along, little children, little boys carrying cages with parrots, little girls clutching chickens and roosters. They were bringing what they had to their new home, of which they knew nothing. But Afghans of all generations, not just little children, women, men in their 30s, 40s, said, I've never been to Afghanistan before.
4:49Over the past three years, every day, thousands of people are being pushed or are fleeing because they know they will be pushed over the border. Now, it is the biggest forced migration in the world. More than six million people. Everyone we spoke to said that they had no resources, that they had to sell everything they owned at a cut rate because they were under pressure to leave. Everyone we spoke to had a story of that they were mistreated. Police demanded money. Their home was destroyed. Pakistani authorities continued to deny that. All I can say is where we were, they all had a story of abuse.
5:27And we didn't go to the Iranian border crossings, but others who've reported from there say the same. Harun Rahmani from our Afghan team has been closely following the Taliban's narrative on this story. And their stats differ.
5:44The Taliban says that since they took over, 8 million people have returned. But we also have a figure about that 3.4 million have left the country since the Taliban took over. At the border, UN agencies are trying to help introduce some order. The UN started distributing birth certificate and ID cards for the refugees because the majority of them do not have any legal documents to prove their identity. This is the level of aid that the UN organization and the Taliban together are providing to the refugees apart from some other food and non-food aid. When a family comes, first of all, they can take refuge for, it's hoped, just a few days, but some stay longer because they have nowhere else to go, in this tented village put up right next to Torkom.
6:36In that tent city, they are full of fears about what awaits them in the coming days and years. We peeked inside the tent. It was full of women. I say to the oldest woman there, are you worried about the women and children because there's no school? And she turns around and with a sweeping gesture of her hand said, look, they're all women and girls. Of course I'm worried. Look at them. They're all girls. I worry that they will have to stay at home and will not be able to continue their education. So this is just one of the aspects of this new life in Afghanistan, a country mired in a deep humanitarian crisis where foreign aid has been steeply cut, where towns and villages are battered by the ravages of climate change, where there is a Taliban government with ever-expanding rules and restrictions on the lives of women and girls.
7:28What we know about the process of resettling these people is patchy. There's little independent information beyond the official narrative. And the Taliban are doing what any government would, create a positive spin on a tough situation. The Taliban saying that these are our brothers, they are coming back to Afghanistan, it is not a kind of pressure on us. They are most welcome. as the Taliban media reports. So they are registering the returnees. But a giveaway on the daunting nature of the task came when the government asked the neighbours to slow down the pace of deportations.
8:15In the first years, they were calling on Iran and Pakistan to send them in a gradual phase. But when Pakistan started mass deportation in 2023, Taliban created authoritative commission with the Ministry of Defence, Ministry of Interior, their intelligence agency, Ministry of Transport.
8:41If you look at Taliban-controlled media, there's a clear plan in place. Every returnees receive some 6 ,000 Afghani which is less than 100 pounds. They have decided to provide every family with 25 ,000 which is around 300 pounds. They are sending them to their provinces and they are also saying that they are distributing land plots for the eligible families.
9:15To some extent, as per the Taliban media outlets, they are managing well, but no one can criticize the Taliban and no one can complain. That's why once these refugees are taken to their relevant provinces, no one knows what will happen to them, how they can manage, how they can feed themselves. And even with land plots, a breadwinner who cannot feed his family how we can build a new home there. There's reaches of Afghanistan where there aren't correspondents, either Afghan or foreign, who are telling those stories. So we don't have a full picture yet of what it looks like. It's a mix. Any government would struggle with such a large number returning in such a short space of time.
9:58How difficult is it to absorb this influx? Anyone who follow the Taliban over the years or decades know that they are mindful about their international image. Over the past decades, they were involved in suicide attacks, killing and destruction of bridges. Now they need a new image. They are not only fighters, but a responsible government. So that's why whatever in the media, everything looks great.
10:32The Taliban are left on their own to absorb the influx of people. Very few international organisations remain on the ground to provide humanitarian assistance. Last year, several UNHCR offices, branches, were closed down because Taliban did not allow women to work in these branches. They were involved in welcoming and receiving the migrants. They stopped providing services for the migrants. We can see in Kabul or major provinces, they are demolishing a large number of homes and high-rise buildings just to expand the roads, to show to the world that they are building Afghanistan, while millions of people do not have shelter.
11:16The work of the UN Refugee Agency has been curtailed by the inability to employ women, and help from abroad is in short supply. Taliban are asking international communities to some extent to provide assistance for these people. But it is not enough. Taliban has not been recognised as official government of Afghanistan. So the number of the aid organisation has decreased because they are not allowing women to work. The international community lost its interest and there is a shortfall of international aid as well. Despite assurances from the government that they're working hard to resettle the migrants, in reality, there's little or no support to help them get back on their feet.
12:01We don't have a national picture of where do these 6 million people go? How are they absorbed? I spoke to one NGO in the Northwest and they said people came to the capital city. Then they went back to where grandfather, great-grandfather, great-grandfather, grandfather was born, to towns and villages. The villages were gone. what they call ghost villages in Afghanistan, that whole villages have been depopulated because of their climate shocks, either droughts or floods or poverty, lack of aid money. So everyone leaves the village. So they go to literally find nothing there. Another giveaway that the Taliban are struggling is a change in the tone Liz picked upon.
12:40Afghans are always described as stoic. They live with so little. But at a certain point, All of that breaks because it just simply becomes too hard. When the Taliban first came to power, you heard some of the senior officials who were given the jobs in the aid sector with no real expertise would say, God will take care of it. God will provide. You know, Afghans will find. And aid agencies said to me, they don't say that anymore, that they understand now the importance of humanitarian aid.
13:12When we sat down with the foreign minister of Afghanistan, Amir Khan Moutaki, I said to him, you have a real problem here. And the UNHCR said this to us. No country can handle this on their own. But it's harder for us to raise money for Afghanistan simply because of these draconian rules, in particular barring girls from anything beyond primary education. Women can't go to university. Many jobs are barred to them.
13:38And the foreign minister basically admitted that, that yes, this was a problem.
13:46When I said to him, this continues, you will have no women doctors, no women teachers. Is that the kind of country you want to represent? And he goes, no, this will be a real problem, in his words. He said, it's not a shortage now, but when there will be, we have to deal with it. So I was taken by his candor, that they're recognizing that there's an issue. But whether the edicts by the ultra-conservative emir will be lifted is quite another thing. Minister Motaki said, in the long run, their skills will help us. There'll be a benefit for Afghanistan. But what is the long run and how much pain and suffering will these families have to go through?
14:23Investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market. You can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything. Maybe you go for some free-range self-directed investing. or perhaps you pick up a few farm fresh trades while you peruse. You can even get help from a dedicated advisor. That's full service wealth management. Mix, match and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, you can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. Choiceology, an original podcast from Charles Schwab, is a show about the psychology and economics behind our decisions.
15:01Join host Katie Milkman, an award-winning behavioral scientist and author of the best-selling book, How to Change, as she shares true stories from Nobel laureates, authors, athletes, and everyday people about why we make the choices we do, and how to make better ones to help avoid costly mistakes. Listen to choiceology at schwab.com slash podcast, or wherever you listen.
15:26You are listening to the documentary from the BBC World Service. Many of the people who fled Afghanistan after the return of the Taliban in 2021 did so for their safety because of their work for the former government, security forces or NGOs. Do they fear that they would face persecution when they return? We spoke to one former security officer who underlined that some people are worried about their future and others are terrified. Because of particular concern and human rights groups have raised this, the UN continues to raise it. Some of the people who are being pushed out of Pakistan and Iran are high risk.
16:06They are known to the Taliban. They have no right to take part in politics. Taliban are asking them just to come back, stay here. And they have issued them immunity cards as well, not to be harmed by the Taliban.
16:24But the assurances and immunity cards have done little to calm fears. When we spoke to this person, I said the Taliban offered an amnesty as soon as they came into power. And he said, I have no trust in that. I feel that my life is under threat. I can't even go outside. I spent all my day at home. I do not believe in their amnesty at all because many of my friends were killed. There are cases of killing, disappearance, torture, mistreatment. These cases are happening on a daily basis. The rights group Amnesty International has spoken out about arbitrary arrests, torture and extrajudicial killings under Taliban rule.
17:09We have cases of people that have been deported to Afghanistan and been killed by Taliban. We have cases of individuals who were deported to Afghanistan and been detained and disappeared. If Taliban capture them, they will brutally persecute them. And that's a dead sentence. Once the Western countries left Afghanistan, all countries just closed their borders. Even India, which was a close ally of Afghanistan, cancelled all the visas of the former security officials, despite the plight of Afghan migrants in Iran and Pakistan. We know that it actually saved lives of many people. You are listening to The Global Jigsaw from BBC Monitoring.
17:57The rights of women has been a major concern ever since the Taliban returned to power. Millions of girls missing out on education, Women prevented from working or enjoying basic freedoms most of us are taking for granted, like leaving the house or talking in public. Those on the receiving end say the country is becoming a prison for women. The option that the Taliban are providing, it's clear. Stay at home, get married, raise your children. That's it. No future at all. No work.
18:35The men are there providing for you, so why are you bothering yourself? No education, no employment at all. They are erasing totally the women from the streets. They are detaining them on a daily basis. Even a female staff member of the MSF were detained in Herod province only for not following the hijab and dressing code. And there were protests after that because of the detention of a large number of women by the Taliban authorities in the Herod.
19:09They crashed the protesters as well. They directly fired protesters. The local media outlets are not allowed to cover any kind of protest. We don't know what happened there. So there's a big information black hole about what actually happens to these people. It is the censorship of the media, and even it's not the traditional media outlets. I'm talking about the YouTubers as well, those who are active on social media. They have been detained because of the videos they were posting on social media. No one dared to put anything which is against the Taliban policy or rule. This information black hole has swallowed a whole chapter on what happens to women after their return.
19:55You don't know how they are managing. Some of them are just going to their relative houses in Kabul. And for the people who have been in Pakistan and Iran for decades, it is really, really difficult to adopt. With the current situation, it is only that the walls they are facing in Afghanistan, they will be confined totally. If they're going out regularly, they will be spotted by the morality police with vice and virtue and they will be stopped. why you are going every day on the same direction, what's your business, what are you doing. There's no doubt what the official line is on women, and members of the Taliban, who might disagree in private, begrudgingly oblige in public.
20:36There are divisions under the surface, and even examples of what you might call defiance. I've known some of these Talibs for a very long time because they were formerly part of the Mujahideen, which I covered in detail in the 90s. I had long conversations with some Talibs and privately they will say we are opposed to these edicts. We want girls to go to school and women to go to university. We understand that Islam gives these rights. It's not a Western imposition. And I put that to every Taliban spokesperson, including the foreign minister, when I spoke to them on the record. But they say there's this Arabic word, these bayat, they sign an oath of loyalty to the emir who's based in Kandahar, Hibatullah, Akunzada, and we can't ourselves undo the edict.
21:20And we do know that some of the most outspoken ones, for example, Abbas Tanikzai, who was the head of the political team negotiating with the Americans.
21:32He left Afghanistan because he had spoken out so often that girls should be educated, women should be educated, that he felt there was risks to his And so that's why when it comes, for example, to girls' education, they're trying to find what they call workarounds. So there are secret schools, and the Taliban know where some of the secret schools are. They're studying online. And I met one senior member of the Taliban who has his own madrasa. He's educating girls up to grade 12.
22:01But the madrasas teach about 70 % religion. They also teach math, sciences, English, etc. But you can't produce a doctor or a teacher out of a madrasa. They always give us these figures. Oh, there's three million girls in the madrasas. Yes, but you need educated women and girls. And so behind the scenes, they are looking at ways around this.
22:27And I have to say, on this trip, we went to one of the more conservative, most impoverished districts in southern Afghanistan, where a tribal chief said, we want our girls to be educated. And then he stopped me to make sure I understood. He goes, and when I say educated, I'm talking about doctors and teachers. I'm not just talking about high school. Afghanistan is a different country and some of the Taliban recognize that and others are stuck back in another century. When it comes to the job market for the new arrivals, it's not just the women who are squeezed out. A large number of the people are jobless in Afghanistan.
23:02And finding a job is nearly impossible because they have classified the society, the top layer of society. There's the Taliban, the scholars, the second businessman, and then the lower rank. The most jobs are filled by the Taliban themselves. Even if you have the qualification, if a Taliban commander does not recommend you and say that he was a fighter with me and he fought against the US and coalition troops, they will not accept you. Even when the newcomers manage to find the job, it provides only the bare minimum, according to NGOs. After a year, many of them had found work doing very much manual labour below their skill set, but at least something that they can provide some money for themselves and inevitably they're all supporting families.
23:54Many of the people returning face another challenge, to be accepted by the local population. Over the past few years, there are reports that they are sending them to the north of Afghanistan, and there are anti-migrant sentiments. The local people are concerned about the demographic changes.
24:18There were some reports of disputes over land. As people are coming there in large numbers, it's causing concern for the local Tajiks, Uzbeks and Hazaras. Also, there has been a concern for distribution of Afghan national ID cards for the people who are not from the north of Afghanistan. And that might lead to a kind of chaos in the rebellion against the Taliban.
24:46And it wouldn't be the first time. The north has a long track record of standing up to the Taliban. Northern Afghanistan was the home to Northern Alliance who fought against the Taliban for a long time, even in mid-1990s. They were resisting, so the Taliban were not able to conquer all the country. There are some anti-Taliban armed groups who are active in the North carrying out attacks in Badakhshan and Baghdad, but they do not have control over any known geography. These groups have claimed responsibility for two attacks in Herat, in solidarity with the Herati women who have been detained, tortured and imprisoned by the Taliban.
25:29So they carried out attack on the morality police and they claim to kill several of them. The new arrivals bring their own grievances and resentment towards the Taliban, which could add to the restive atmosphere that already exists in parts of the country. And that's something the Taliban can't ignore. A lot of women, they're coming back to a life of greater restrictions. What will they do? Will they suffer in silence? Will they talk to other women in the same circumstances? The latest push from Pakistan has been students, men and women, going across the border to study medicine, dentistry. What happens when they come back and they suddenly find themselves with no future and now they're disgruntled?
26:11On the other side is those who go off to the rural areas, especially men who have to support their families. It's very much a male-dominated society where men feel the burden, they have to take care of their families. And the Taliban know because they themselves did this during the years of the republic. They wooed away some disgruntled youth to say, we will pay you more than the Afghan army come on our side. And the UN mentioned this to us, that over the long run, if you have too many people coming back, especially young men, there is a risk of radicalization. Isn't the Taliban worried about knock-on effects of the returns on stability inside the country?
26:47The only thing that they are a little bit concerned about is the infiltration of the IS among the refugees. Is that a real danger? It is a danger, but not a major danger for the Taliban. The IS still has a kind of presence in border areas of Afghanistan, and sometimes they are targeting top Taliban officials. The international community has tied itself in knots, searching for a pragmatic yet ethically defensible approach to the Taliban. But by shying away from engagement with Afghanistan's rulers, governments may be undermining their own ability to influence the group. Five years on, only Russia has formally recognized them.
27:29But China, India, Central Asian states, many Gulf states have de facto recognition because they have ambassadors, they're signing big investment deals. Afghanistan is rich in minerals, rare earth elements, and the Taliban travel to some of the regional capitals. But what they want is the seat at the United Nations. And so the foreign minister said to us, look at these Western countries. They are engaging to discuss migration issues, how to deport Afghans from Western countries. And so five years on is an inflection point. It gave many pause for thought. Some say engage less, others engage more.
28:04People just don't know what to do. I mean, forget about Western envoys. Islamic leaders from the world over, from the highest centres of Islamic scholarship, have gone to Kabul and Kandahar and said, you are violating the principles of Islam. And the Taliban leader said, no, no, no, they have this Urf, which is in Pashto, our community. This is our Islam. It's our community traditions and values. The Taliban have brought one positive change. The country is now safer because they are no longer fighting the government and bombing civilians. They are the government now. The Afghan population, especially the migrants and the people in Afghanistan, have been the victim of long-term rivalry between the competing ideologies, whether it was communism, Maoism, Islamism, liberalism.
28:52So they have made a lot of sacrifices. The Taliban now claim that they have ensured nationwide security, which is true because they themselves stopped carrying suicide attacks. Monday in Jalalabad, 10 bombs blasted restaurants and public squares wounding at least 66 people. And on the other hand, another factor which contributed to the civilian casualty was the coalition troops' air strikes. A coalition reconnaissance operation took place in Uruzgan province. We understand that there were some civilian casualties. The Taliban are no longer attacking, going through the traffic in Kabul now. I kept thinking about one of the moments where I was nervous and Afghans were really nervous was morning traffic when there were sticky bombs that were put on cars and there was a whole series of assassinations.
29:45People left home saying, I'm not sure if I'll be back home tonight. And it wasn't an exaggeration. Human rights activists, lawyers, judges, journalists were being assassinated in the early hours.
29:58I thought, you know, that threat has gone away. Bombings in the heart of the city, the people who did it, are now the ministers. And aid agencies say you can travel the whole country, which is why you're getting influencers and vloggers going and saying, oh, isn't Afghanistan wonderful? The city is open all night, all the shops, hairdressers, shops, everything. And you say, yeah, yeah, you really like those parks, but there's no women in those parks, by the way. Why don't you point that out? Because the Taliban don't allow women to go to parks. So on this visit, we got the permissions that we wanted.
30:28No Talibs came with us to mind us, if you like. But while foreign journalists and NGO workers can now move around without the risk of being killed, female reporters often experience hostility. There are some Taliban spokespersons who don't want to meet women, or they say, I won't be in the same shot as you. My colleague Yigita Lamai interviewed a deputy spokesperson in Kabul, and they had to look in different directions because he wouldn't look at her, and he didn't want her to be looking at him. We can't be pictured in the same frame and I can't sit across from him either because I'm a woman.
31:03The deportations from Iran and Pakistan are still ongoing. Hundreds of thousands of Afghans remain in limbo abroad, many of them in peril because they chose to work with the West in the last few decades. Thousands of people stranded in Turkey now, in Qatar right now, in Pakistan, waiting to be evacuated to the Western countries because they were working with the NATO forces. They are eligible, but all of a sudden, they were left behind and abandoned. They have nothing except to go back to Afghanistan and face the Taliban or whatever, actually waiting for them inside Afghanistan. Every day, every day, more than a thousand, sometimes tens of thousands are crossing that point and crossing all the others.
31:52And the world is hardly paying attention. If that was happening in Britain, in France, anywhere else in the world, they would be in the headlines. It just was staggering to see. The Taliban's treatment of women has drawn international condemnation. But there's another crisis that's largely overlooked. The boys growing up without proper education. It's a time bomb under the future of the country. The clock is ticking. A new country emerging. Girls not being educated beyond primary school. There's a concern about boys. What kind of education are they getting? Because they're getting a radical kind of jihadi Islamist education in some of those madrasas.
32:29A Western man working for one of the aid agencies said he'd never been called infidel. And the kind of ways he was criticized by some young boys that he met on the road, he said he could sense they saw him as this enemy, if you like. And so people are saying, raise issues of the girls, but don't forget the boys as well. Millions of people have been forced back to zero, swept into a social engineering experiment that locks out half the population and devastates the other half. Yet the world barely shrugs.
33:06This is the documentary from the BBC World Service. Thank you to Liz Ducet and Haroun Armani. This series was produced by Krista Shattery, Barry Sadeed, Elchin Suleimanov and me, Krasi Ivanova-Twig. The sound engineer was Nigel Dix. And if you want to find out more about BBC Monitoring, you can do so by visiting our website, monitoring.bbc.co.uk. And thank you for giving us your time.
33:43Thank you.
Why are millions of Afghans pushed into circular migration and what awaits them in Taliban-ruled Afghanistan? In this series, The Global Jigsaw explores one of the world’s largest and longest-running refugee crises - a story spanning decades and affecting nearly half of Afghanistan’s population. Once welcomed as guests and embraced in the spirit of Islamic solidarity in neighbouring Iran and Pakistan, Afghan refugees now find themselves facing restrictions, discrimination and deportation. In part three, we try to understand the reality awaiting the returnees amid the information black hole surrounding their story back home.
Find out more about BBC Monitoring on our website: https://monitoring.bbc.co.uk
Contributors: Haroon Rahmani, Lyse Doucet Producer: Kriszta Satori, Barry Sadid, Elchin Suleymanov Presenter: Krassi Ivanova Twigg Music: Pete Cunningham