1. Podcasts
  2. The Documentary Podcast
  3. Female influencers
The Documentary Podcast

14 Jun 2025 · 23m · 15 chapters

In short

Female influencers discuss online misogyny, stalking, and real-world dangers, and how they respond while trying to change norms.

Guests (and backgrounds)

  • Sana Yousaf (Pakistan) was a teenage social media star whose 17th-birthday video preceded her shooting death in Islamabad; her case sparked debate about influencer safety.
  • Makhnoor Rahim (Lahore, Pakistan) fashion influencer.
  • Sabah Malik (Pakistan) comedian and cultural commentator.
  • Zenith Irfan (known as “Motorcycle Girl”) travels Pakistan by motorbike; started riding in her late teens.
  • Also referenced: Eva Maria Beristain (Mexico City, 10-year YouTuber interviewing marginalized people), Fatima Sotomayor (Peru, travel blogger), Aisha Perry-Iqbal (Los Angeles, former plus-size model; fashion/lifestyle/women’s rights).

Key claims

  • Abuse is both online and physical; women are policed for breaking “good woman” norms.
  • Victim-blaming and criticism can come from women as well as men.
  • Safety requires hypervigilance, limiting personal details, and building community.

Notable examples

  • Zenith: car following and abuse at traffic lights; harassment while riding; fear of stalking/attack.
  • Sabah: boys on a motorbike ran her off the road while hiking; later told it was because she wore a baseball cap.
  • Makhnoor/Sabah: death/rape threats and “hope you’re barren” comments; responding with humor or reposting “faces” of abusers.
  • Eva/Fatima/Aisha: inappropriate touching while filming; cartel intimidation in Latin America; advice to share GPS with trusted contacts and use self-defense/training.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:30

Context of the Discussion

The episode introduces the case of Sana Yousaf and the issues surrounding female influencers in Pakistan.

“Listen to Choiceology at schwab.com slash podcast or wherever you listen.”
1:19

Meeting the Influencers

Three female influencers share their backgrounds and challenges they face in their careers.

“This time in BBC OS Conversations, we bring together female influencers.”
2:06

Navigating Challenges on the Road

Zenith discusses the challenges of being a female motorcyclist in a male-dominated environment.

“You know, you're putting yourself in a position to make change.”
3:30

Fear and Public Spaces

Influencers share their fears and experiences related to harassment while traveling alone.

“When you're out there on the road, you have to always speak over your shoulder and be situationally aware.”
5:00

Confronting Online Abuse

Discussion about the online abuse female influencers face and how it affects their lives.

“their own to be able to be out there or occupy public spaces that men are so easily allowed to do.”
7:24

The Culture of Victim Blaming

The conversation highlights the societal issues that contribute to victim blaming and harassment.

“you know, hoping for solidarity or awareness, I didn't just face backlash from men.”
12:40

Humor as a Coping Mechanism

Influencers discuss using humor to deal with hateful comments they receive online.

“And I still have to agree with Sabah when she says they just can't see a woman happy, just following her passion and dream, you know.”
14:00

Challenges of Female Influencers

Explore the common challenges faced by female influencers globally.

“Sabah, Mahnoor and Zenith on the challenges of being an influencer in Pakistan.”
14:24

Humor as a Coping Mechanism

Influencers discuss using humor to deal with hateful comments they receive online.

“I'm Mark Lowen and this is BBC OS Conversations from the BBC World Service.”
15:08

Interview Introduction

Introduction to Frances Haugen and her impact on social media.

“Part of why I blew the whistle was I didn't want to lay in bed in 20 years.”
Show all 15 chapters
15:41

Online Abuse of Influencers

Discussion on the online and real-world abuse faced by female influencers.

“from living their lives under the social media spotlight.”
16:40

Coping with Threats and Violence

Strategies for dealing with threats and violence as female influencers.

“you have to think about before speaking about stuff online.”
17:54

Personal Experiences of Fear

Influencers share their most frightening moments in their work.

“That's where sensitivity becomes essential.”
20:41

Navigating Dangerous Situations

Insights into the dangers influencers face and how they navigate them.

“This year, I have four or five times of that in the last five months.”
22:30

Advice for Aspiring Influencers

Key advice for young women wanting to become influencers.

“So it's important to know that you are exposed to this type of situation.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Documentary Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Zenith Irfan: This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30Zenith Irfan: Listen to Choiceology at schwab.com slash podcast or wherever you listen.

1:00Zenith Irfan: Oh, oh, O 'Reilly! Auto Parts!

1:14Zenith Irfan: Hello, I'm Mark Lowen. Welcome to the documentary from the BBC World Service. This time in BBC OS Conversations, we bring together female influencers. Sana Yousaf was a rising social media star, Still only a teenager, her last video showed her surrounded by balloons and cutting a cake for her 17th birthday. But two weeks ago, she was shot dead at her home in Islamabad. Police made a swift arrest, but her death has ignited a fierce debate about women on social media and the safety of influencers in Pakistan and beyond. In our conversations this week, three female influencers in Pakistan discuss their experiences and how they deal with the daily abuse.

1:59Zenith Irfan: We also bring together women in Peru, Mexico and the United States to hear their perspective.

2:05Sabah Malik: You have to let people hate you. You know, you're putting yourself in a position to make change. You have to deal with negativity.

2:16Zenith Irfan: Between them, our first guests have hundreds of thousands of social media followers. My colleague Luke Jones brought together Makhnoor Rahim. She's a fashion influencer in Lahore. Sabah Malik, a comedian and cultural commentator in Pakistan. And Zenith Irfan, known as Motorcycle Girl on social media. She travels the country on her motorbike.

2:38Mahnoor Rahim: When I started a decade ago, I was very young. I started learning how to ride a motorcycle when I was 17, 18 years old. There weren't many women out there on the road. I did not have role models growing up where I can say that, you know, she shares the same skin color, the same language. So it was challenging to navigate through that. But I had one goal and that goal was to live up to my father's passion, to live up my passion of riding across the world on a motorcycle. I started a decade ago and realizing that this is taboo, realizing that this is going to be male-dominating. People will say things online, but I knew that if I were to stop here, I will silence not only myself, but many young girls who would look up to me.

3:25Mahnoor Rahim: You can say that 10 years later, you can see more women on the road, but it's still a little bit challenging when you are planning a trip. You have to think twice. When you're out there on the road, you have to always speak over your shoulder and be situationally aware. Is there someone following me? Am I safe? Is this the right time to go out? So these are questions that still linger. I would actually like to add on that, Zenith. I applaud your bravery and courage. Honestly, I have no idea how you do it because every time I think of traveling on my own or even going to the mountains, I have to think about it so much that it actually stresses me out.

4:04Mahnoor Rahim: what if somebody is following exactly what you said yeah yeah it is difficult it gets really hard even if you're being driven by a driver that you've never met before it's just doing simple things that should be feeling liberating for women or generally anybody are

4:22Zenith Irfan: getting harder by the minute I guess and is the fear with all of this that you would be a woman by yourself and a man might attack you or is it that you're a woman by yourself and you're doing things which women in Pakistan don't normally do?

4:37Mahnoor Rahim: Both actually. Yeah, I think it's both. But I would like Mahanu to continue. Yeah. It could be that somebody might be stalking you and you might get harassed, you might get attacked. It also could be because women who normally don't do this is mainly because they are not allowed to do it. They don't have independence or the agency of their own to be able to be out there or occupy public spaces that men are so easily allowed to do. That's the main thing, in my opinion.

5:10Sabah Malik: Sabah here. And I just want to add on that, that some of the content that actually all three of us make, but I'll say, you know, I've especially seen Manur and myself, is that we do take male behavior to task quite a bit. And we demand and we highlight And we talk about, you know, abusive structures and even the fact that women aren't seen in public so much. And so I think there is a little bit of like, you know, we know what we look like, and they know what we look like, but we don't know what they look like. So sometimes when I particularly put out a video that maybe gained traction, maybe it went viral, and it's a particularly fiery one, I have to be honest, there is like a feeling when I'm out in the wild where I'm like, well, I don't know who's seen it.

5:56Sabah Malik: and might have had a bad reaction to it because they know me and I don't know that.

6:02Mahnoor Rahim: Yes, that's very true because, you know, especially with the type of content I post, it's challenging a lot of ideologies. People have this, you know, certain type of passions that are only designed for women. So a woman is supposed to just be, you know, at home or maybe she can just do a job of a teacher or she can become a doctor, but then she also has to be a housewife. So, you know, we have to play a lot of roles. So all of a sudden you see a woman on a motorcycle and you're like, oh wait a minute we did not think of this we couldn't imagine that she could not only just ride but also do adventures so I do have to agree with Sabah that sometimes you know when I post something I have to be like when I go to the gym I come across people who say oh you know we follow your content and then I'm like oh okay so I hope my content did not offend him you know like uh was he offended by it or do you like it so you never know these things you know it's very challenging to navigate through this.

6:53Sabah Malik: There's a lot of push in Pakistan for conformity. There's this idea, exactly as Zinat says, of like how a good woman behaves. So even if you know, you're not being outwardly offensive, you know, you're not like flicking someone in the nose and saying, you know, I hate you. Just the fact that we are breaking norms can be taken as an offense.

7:16Mahnoor Rahim: I've also, you know, personally experienced being stalked or whatever, just for existing online as a woman in Pakistan. And when I spoke about it publicly, you know, hoping for solidarity or awareness, I didn't just face backlash from men. I was shocked to see how much of the criticism came from women as well. You know, and instead of support, I was met with blame. I was told to stay quiet or, you know, to be more careful, to not invite attention, which... That's your fault. It's to me sometimes. It's my fault. Yeah, then why were you out? Exactly.

7:50Zenith Irfan: Do you mind me asking about that, being stalked, the actual incident itself? What happened?

7:54Mahnoor Rahim: Yeah, I was just driving home one day and there was this car that started following me. And when I stopped at a traffic light, it was a painfully long one for some reason. The car stopped right next to me and their windows were rolled down and they were just hurling abuses. And I was trying to ignore them. My windows were up. My car was locked. And the funny thing is that it wasn't even, which is the first thing that people say that, what were you wearing? What did you look like? I was in a hoodie. It was wintertime and I was fully covered, okay, from head to toe. And I was just going home from gym.

8:32Mahnoor Rahim: So, yeah, that was a scary one. But I'm here.

8:36Sabah Malik: You know, Sabah, here again, I similarly was on my way to go hiking and I had on a baseball hat. I just this is a significant part of the story for some reason and two boys on a motorbike actually ran me off the road they were like chasing me and scaring me and you know slowing down so that my car would have to slam on the brake and then eventually once I was driven off the road they zoomed off and when I complained about this when I got home I was literally told well you were wearing a baseball cap so what did you expect who said that and I said I hate to say but it was my father and I said what the hell does that mean and he goes well you know it's because they don't see women doing that you're driving and you have a baseball hat on so it

9:26Mahnoor Rahim: probably made them angry that's really funny I'm sorry to say but that's also funny yeah

9:35Zenith Irfan: what about some of the online comments because that's what's happened in the real world but online I guess people can feel even more liberated to have a go at you if they want to

9:42Mahnoor Rahim: what has that been like we get hit all the time sorry keyboard yeah we get hit in the comments in the dm death threats rape threats threats like oh i hope this happens to you as well what did i even do to receive that kind of hate i'm just living i'm just existing in my own skin let me be but that never happens and at this point unfortunately this isn't about individual safety anymore. It's about the culture, a culture where women are conditioned to even silence each other or police each other instead of holding men accountable for their violence and entitlement. And it honestly reflects how deeply patriarchy has infiltrated even our sisterhood.

10:28Sabah Malik: I truly believe like just being like a happy, confident woman is really enough to really trigger people. And when you add the accessibility to seeing us do that online, it really upsets people. So one of the things that my content is kind of known for is that I do respond to hate comments. And a lot of the times like I try to make it funny, or I try to find a way that we're all laughing at this person. But it is the type of vitriol that like you would never imagine somebody would take it that far like yes death threats rape threats I've literally had someone tell me that they hope I'm barren so that my bloodline dies with me and this is because I criticized that Bollywood movie Animal that was about toxic masculinity like celebrating oh my god

11:18Mahnoor Rahim: I can't imagine I can't imagine Zenith here and I also want to add on to this because I have been a victim of online bullying and hate and just like Sabah just like you or you know what I do when I have someone put on a hate comment on my content I take a picture of them and I literally put it on my story and I say this is the face and these are the wild things this man has said you know the most surprising thing is sometimes they are these are 15 16 year old boys you know like they haven't even hit puberty which is so heartbreaking that they don't even know what this saying and when I post it 60 % of people who are following me always say and those are men ignore it why don't you just ignore it ignore it Zenith ignore it and I'm like why should I ignore it you know we are creating an environment where we let such comments slip away and then eventually you then get to see things that are happening around us then why are we always pointing the finger at the person who was the victim you know why are we victim blaming instead Instead of asking relevant questions as to why is this happening?

12:22Mahnoor Rahim: What are some of the triggers that allow such behavior in the first place? And even right now, when you go online, just a simple post will tell you that, oh, you know, she deserved this because she's an influencer. So we are just not influencers. You know, we are women who are trying to exist loudly when the world is trying to quiet us. You know, they all want to quiet us. And I still have to agree with Sabah when she says they just can't see a woman happy, just following her passion and dream, you know. This is very heartbreaking.

12:50Sabah Malik: When I try to have a good time with it is when they'll say something like, because sometimes if they say something just really dumb, I can like crack a joke off of it. For once, this guy was like commenting, calling me fat and ugly, because men truly believe the biggest insult they can give you is by saying they're not attracted to you. Whereas I think most of us are like, well, thank God, you know, at least that's one less thing we have to worry about. but this guy was calling me I think like fat and ugly like over and over again and then I just opened up his profile I took a look at him came back and I was like you know what I'm so sorry for your loss you seem to not have a neck and that must be tough for you because he was literally just like a block of head and shoulders and then he removed his dp his display photo and like that's just one of the things where it's funny but yeah I like doing that I like mentioning that like you know make like your hairline and recede that's one of my favorite ones men will always try to find community with other men like by posting hateful comments right so they'll start something with like fellas like this is what this woman is saying and let's bash her so I always like to reply to them like who are you talking to and I promise you they will almost always delete it because they're so embarrassed because they're out there just trying to find friends and nobody wants to be their friend.

14:14Zenith Irfan: Sabah, Mahnoor and Zenith on the challenges of being an influencer in Pakistan. But as we'll hear shortly, the situation for female influencers is not much different wherever you are in the world. I'm Mark Lowen and this is BBC OS Conversations from the BBC World Service.

14:37Zenith Irfan: Investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market. You can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything. Maybe you go for some free-range self-directed investing, or perhaps you pick up a few farm-fresh trades while you peruse. You can even get help from a dedicated advisor. That's full-service wealth management. Mix, match, and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, you can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more.

15:08Sabah Malik: Part of why I blew the whistle was I didn't want to lay in bed in 20 years. having seen another million people die. I know that I could have done something when I had a chance.

15:16Zenith Irfan: This week on The Interface, we're talking to Frances Haugen. The Facebook whistleblower who leaked the documents that changed how the world saw social media. And now she is the subject of Aaron Sorkin's latest movie, The Social Reckoning. So join me, Thomas Germain. And me, Jess Maddox, for The Interface. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

15:41Zenith Irfan: in our last conversation shared how they deal with the online and real-world abuse they receive from living their lives under the social media spotlight. You don't have to look far on any social media channel to see that wherever there's online content, there are unpleasant or abusive comments. But when that content is generated by women, negative comments are often personal, misogynistic, or threaten violence. To discuss how they deal with this, we brought together three women with social media careers in three different countries. Eva Maria Beristain is based in Mexico City. She's been a YouTuber for 10 years, specialising in interviewing people on the margins of society.

16:24Zenith Irfan: Fatima Sotomayor is a travel blogger from Peru who has spent the past nine years travelling the world. And Aisha Perry-Iqbal is in Los Angeles, a former plus-size model, she posts about fashion, lifestyle and women's rights.

16:39Sabah Malik: There are a lot of things that you have to think about before speaking about stuff online. One, being not white and two, being a woman, especially, you know, being an immigrant in this country with everything that's going on currently at this moment in LA. Just with all of the hate that's online, I do have to be cautious but I just feel that it's so important to speak my truth and to stand up for women that I don't actually mind if people are sending me threats and stuff online it feels like there's a cause that goes with it and it's something that comes with it it is unsettling obviously but you just have to learn if you're going to be a public facing front facing person in a movement that needs change, you're going to have to put up with certain things.

17:29Mahnoor Rahim: As a woman, it doesn't mean you're not afraid. It means that you have to feel the fear and keep going anyway. I really feel passionate about the topics I present in my channel. Normally, I go into these places with no protection at all. You know, the only defense that I have is a connection I can build with the people I interview. So for me, connecting is not optional. It's more a matter of survival most of the times. That's where sensitivity becomes essential. And to be honest, sensitivity, it's a quality I associate deeply with being a woman. But I also do have training in martial arts in case I need it.

18:14Zenith Irfan: Wow. Have you ever had to use it?

18:16Mahnoor Rahim: Not really, not yet. After all of these years in this job, I've learned to block toxic people. And those who come at me with hateful messages. For me, it's like, that gives me peace because I want to have a really safe community and take care of the girls and boys that are in my community. And also about, like, learn some self-defense because I also feel really unsafe in some countries, for example. and I want also to film that process.

18:56Zenith Irfan: Could I ask all three of you, could you tell me about perhaps the most frightening, most terrifying moment that you have experienced in your work?

19:06Sabah Malik: There was actually like one follower who I think had been following me for a long time. I can't remember exactly what topic was, but it was definitely in the realm of violence against women. I spoke about something online and I had had such an awful message and the person, I don't even know if it was a man or a woman because there wasn't like any real information on their page, but they had information about like my personal life, things that I hadn't put online or things that I didn't think were that obvious and that really like stunned me and then I scrolled up and I saw that they had been messaging me for like a long time and that was probably the first time that I've like instantly blocked someone I'm a little bit different to the girls in here I don't really block people when they're when they're saying kind of mean things because I just I feel that to push your narrative and the things that need to be said out into the algorithm you have to let people hate you you know you're putting yourself in a position to make change you have to deal with negativity but that really was very weird for me so it definitely made me check myself on how open I am and you know maybe not to slip up so much on where my locations are like right as the time that I'm in them and this is obviously how people have been murdered.

20:35Mahnoor Rahim: For me it's sad to admit but being harassed or touched inappropriately. It's something that I experience way too often. This year, I have four or five times of that in the last five months. For example, on my last trip to Thailand, I was filming an important local festival when a foreigner, a German man, touched my butt inappropriately. And it was scary, especially because I confronted him and I didn't know how he would react. That's the most terrifying part. To be clear, I don't think this happened because I am an influencer. I think it's because I am a woman. In fact, sometimes having a camera health helps me a lot because the people hold back a bit more when they know they could be caught in a video.

21:30Mahnoor Rahim: In Latin America, most of us women here have suffered some kind of abuse ranging from inappropriate toshin to rape. And you're always at risk, I think. But the most dangerous thing for me was when I spoke to a cartel that managed a street where I wanted to do some interviews.

21:54Zenith Irfan: A drugs cartel.

21:55Mahnoor Rahim: Yeah. And, well, you have to ask permission to be on the streets, you know, like they rule. And it was really intimidating, you know. there are usually big groups of men they are armed so you really have to get in there and command respects you really have to be confident and strong so I think for me that was one of the most dangerous experiences I had.

22:30Zenith Irfan: Can I just ask all three of you would you what would you say to young women wanting to do what you do?

22:38Mahnoor Rahim: This is a reality in all the world. So it's important to know that you are exposed to this type of situation. So to know where you are traveling, to contact people there, to investigate a lot about the city you are going to, maybe to know some self-defense or sport that you can use in a really hard situation, to have some contact that you can always call in any moment by WhatsApp to, I don't know, maybe you need some help. And send your GPS location always to your friends.

23:19Sabah Malik: I just want to add by saying, isn't that so sad that we have to live in the world thinking like this, that we have to be hypervigilant. You have to make sure you know someone. Like, we can't just get on a flight and go travel somewhere like most men can in the world. As much as this is a really hard conversation, I do want to tell young women that you deserve to enjoy your life. You deserve to be happy and safe. And there are people like us on this call who are using our voices to make change and to move these things forward so you can feel that way. I think the most important thing for women is to find community, to feel safe with other women, and to also find community with men that they trust and feel safe with.

23:59Sabah Malik: Because, you know, there are men that are with us and want us to be safe and support us. It's not an overall arc that every man in this world is just abusive and dangerous. But also on the flip side, it is something that you need to be aware of, that you need to be vigilant and safe, especially when posting online, posting your location after you leave wherever you are, not giving out any real specifics about your personal life. I know we're in a day and age now where people overshare and they're very, that's how they become viral. But being aware of what you're sharing online and that could be detrimental to your safety.

24:48Sabah Malik: And unfortunately, even though it's horrible to say this, it is something that we have to think about. So speak your truth, stand up for what you believe in, but also be aware.

24:59Mahnoor Rahim: I don't like the way the world works, but I believe that by having to push harder, group more and go further, just to get the same respect, we are unknowingly being made stronger.

25:14Zenith Irfan: Eva Maria in Mexico City, Fatima in Peru and Aisha in Los Angeles. Thanks to them and all our guests this week for sharing their experiences. I'm Mark Lowen and you've been listening to the documentary from the BBC World Service.

From the publisher

After the fatal shooting in Pakistan of a teenage social media influencer, Sana Yousaf, we bring together female influencers around the world to share their experiences. Sana’s death has ignited a fierce debate about women on social media and the safety of influencers. We hear from three women in Pakistan. Between them, they have hundreds of thousands of followers on Instagram, TikTok and YouTube but face abuse every day. Zenith Irfan is the first woman to ride a motorbike solo across Pakistan, Mahnoor Rahim is a fashion influencer, and Sabah Malik is a comedian and cultural commentator in the country. We speak to female influencers in the US, Mexico City and Peru who share advice on how they stay safe. This episode of The Documentary, comes to you from BBC OS Conversations, bringing together people from around the world to discuss how major news stories are affecting their lives

More from The Documentary Podcast

All episodes