1. Podcasts
  2. The Documentary Podcast
  3. Germany's rust belt revival
The Documentary Podcast

25 Oct 2026 · 49m · 23 chapters

Episode artwork

Germany's rust belt revival

In short

Dortmund and the Ruhr region’s shift from coal/steel to services, education, IT, startups, and cultural tourism—plus the social and political costs (jobs, unemployment, housing, crime, and a north-south divide).

Guests (backgrounds)

Katja Heuer, German academic journalist/author; Christina Reicher, urban planning/UNESCO cultural heritage chair; Jens Spitzkopf, co-founder/board member of ADESO (IT, Dortmund); Michael Karpov, engineer at autonomous-robot truck startup; Peter Glauner, CEO (European region) of Velo (water technology); Matthias Koska/Regina Zelta/Lauren Böhmann, Dortmund U leadership/art/digital lab; Kai Bandermann, local broadcast journalist (WDR); Markus Röse, tenants association housing spokesperson; Professor Rasmus Beck, Duisburg development agency CEO; Fabian (youth theater/acting background); Sebastian Heinske, youth housing for homeless teens in Essen; Boris Davidovsky, Borussia Dortmund communications; Alexander Kaluti, Dortmund mayor (CDU).

Key claims + examples

Phoenix Lake/Sea repurposed from steelworks, EU funding and a “vision” to transform brownfields; universities (English-taught science) and a technology park helped spawn ADESO (to ~1.5B revenue, ~11,000 staff). Startups build autonomous electric logistics robots; Velo rebuilt as “Velo Park” with climate-neutral smart factory and HealthCube. Industrial heritage preserved via Phoenix West and Dortmund U (former Union brewery) as a culture/education hub. Mixed outcomes: unemployment ~12%, youth NEET up 10%, housing “too little/too expensive,” big-company landlords, and AfD gains tied to perceived devaluation and lost community. A40 divides affluent south from poorer/more diverse north; solutions emphasized as school placement, neighborhood investment, and skills pathways. Steel transition discussed as “green steel” needing green electricity/hydrogen and policy to counter cheap imports. Football (Borussia Dortmund) framed as community cohesion (“connects people”).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:22

The Rise of Dortmund

Exploring Dortmund's shift from industry to modern economy.

“Hello and welcome to Dortmund, the city that was once the industrial powerhouse of Germany's rural valley, a place that earned its living from coal and steel and brewing beer.”
2:18

Phoenix Lake's Transformation

Discussing the redevelopment of the Phoenix Lake area.

“political costs that sometimes come with such a transition.”
4:12

Education's Role in Change

How education has fueled Dortmund's economic transformation.

“Christina Reicher was Head of Planning and Chair of Urban Design at the University of Dortmund.”
6:06

Tech Growth in Dortmund

The emergence and success of IT companies in Dortmund.

“TU, we call the Technical University TU Dortmund, they are now on the brink to be called an elite university.”
9:00

Innovations in Automation

Exploring autonomous vehicle technology and its impact.

“We are currently Germany's largest IT service provider.”
11:15

Legacy of the Old Industries

Reflecting on the nostalgia for Dortmund's industrial past.

“We've come to a quarter of north Dortmund where scores of mostly new businesses have their workshops and factories.”
14:00

Dortmund's Industrial Transformation

Explore how former industrial sites in Dortmund are being transformed into cultural attractions.

“up to high-rise buildings, up to treatment plants, up to stadiums.”
17:04

Cultural Revitalization at Dortmunder U

Learn about the role of the Dortmunder U in promoting culture and community engagement.

“So overall, this is really a remarkable sign of how these sites can be transformed, but also preserved.”
21:05

Community Perspectives on Change

Hear firsthand accounts of local residents reflecting on the changes in Dortmund and their impact.

“So we have some science going on here and some special formats like Science Night to attract young people to go into science and to maybe study it and to work on that.”
25:30

Economic Challenges and Opportunities

Discuss the mixed economic outcomes in Dortmund amidst revitalization efforts.

“and prosperity to many people in Dortmund and the surrounding cities.”
Show all 23 chapters
28:00

Housing Crisis in Dortmund

Explore the current challenges in the housing market of Dortmund.

“even in Dortmund and in the other cities, of course, as well.”
30:28

Political Reactions to Housing Shortage

Discuss the political landscape and responses to housing issues in Dortmund.

“The polling station, with the absolute maximum high number of voters for the AFD, was in the northwest of Dortmund in a suburb called Westerfühlde, which was one of the problem quarters and was seen by the city as such.”
31:58

Impact of Industrial Decline

Examine the effects of industrial decline on community and social cohesion.

“maybe kids go in the same kindergarten, you have some kind of community.”
33:25

Social Divisions in Urban Areas

Investigate the social divisions in northern and southern parts of cities.

“And we are investing in the neighborhoods, in the steel neighborhoods, or what means the transformation from their point of perspective.”
34:45

Youth Engagement Initiatives

Learn about initiatives aimed at engaging youth in community projects.

“especially in those areas where you have the most young children and people.”
37:03

Challenges in Youth Housing

Delve into the issues surrounding housing for homeless youth.

“So we have circus here, circus always works very well because it's challenging, it's intriguing but it's also easy to achieve first steps.”
41:40

Comparative Analysis of Dortmund and Essen

Assess the differences in urban transitions between Dortmund and Essen.

“and on the social challenges that you face?”
42:01

Essen vs. Dortmund: A Comparative Analysis

Explore the contrasting urban development strategies of Essen and Dortmund.

“Essen has now got almost the exact same number of people that it did in 2015.”
43:08

Addressing the Social Divide

Discuss strategies to bridge the social divide in post-industrial cities.

“it's kind of made it more obvious that it wants to transition and highlighted that and signposted it.”
44:26

The Challenges of Industrial Transition

Understand the implications of transitioning from traditional industries to new forms.

“what would you say to those critics or to people who fear this change maybe?”
45:45

The Future of Green Steel Production

Learn about the shift towards green steel and its requirements in Germany.

“So there is a big discussion about the re-industrialisation and this is the new future.”
47:18

Global Competition and Local Identity

Examine the impact of global steel prices on local employment and identity.

“You're changing the whole infrastructure, the whole supply chain.”
48:29

The Role of Borussia Dortmund in Community

Explore how the football club connects the community and its historical ties to steelworking.

“Entire neighborhoods, people work and live and have identities which are related to the steel production.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Documentary Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Decisions made in Washington can affect your portfolio every day, but what policy changes should investors be watching? Washington Wise is an original podcast from Charles Schwab that unpacks the stories making news in Washington right now and how they may affect your finances and portfolio. Listen at schwab.com slash Washington Wise. That's schwab.com slash Washington Wise.

0:55working together seamlessly. It's everything your business needs in one place, saving you time, headaches and serious money. Stop paying for missing pieces. Go to odoo.com. That's odoo.com to learn more.

1:13The documentary, home of the best documentaries from the BBC World Service.

1:22Katja Hoyer: Hello and welcome to Dortmund, the city that was once the industrial powerhouse of Germany's rural valley, a place that earned its living from coal and steel and brewing beer. I'm Katja Heuer, I'm an academic journalist and author, born in Germany and during my lifetime the city has undergone the most remarkable transformation. As the coal and steel industry has declined in the latter half of the 20th century, Dortmund successfully modernised, transforming its economy into a centre for innovation in services, technology and applied sciences. It's become for many a clean and desirable place to live.

2:01Katja Hoyer: So in this documentary from the BBC World Service, I'm looking at Germany's Rust Belt revival. And I want to find out how that transformation has happened and whether Dortmund has any lessons to offer other cities around the world that are dealing with de-industrialisation and its legacy. But I also want to investigate the social and political costs that sometimes come with such a transition. For people left out of this brave new world, and indeed those who regard the old industries as still being vital to the nation's prosperity.

2:35Katja Hoyer: So where to start? Well, Dortmund is now the largest city in the world region, with a population of more than 600 ,000. And many people, including the mayor, Alexander Kaluti, will point to the Phoenix Lake, or the Phoenix Sea, where steelworks once stood as epitomising the successful transition away from heavy industry. Phoenix Lake was actually a huge factory site. And every night you had a huge fire flame coming up. And Dortmund was really somehow illuminated by that. It was a symbol. It was massive. And it was turned down and then it was sold to China. And then we have this huge space. Okay, how can we use this area?

3:25How about creating an artificial lake with new houses and built a new quarter where people can live and work. Because now it's also quite fancy and quite expensive. A lot of footballers from the B4B are living there because they can't afford to live there. And it's actually really trendy. And this is a really, really clear example how Dortmund changed. I was involved in this project, developing the Phoenix Sea and transforming, let's say, the whole region into a post-industrial region for more than 16 years.

4:12Katja Hoyer: Christina Reicher was Head of Planning and Chair of Urban Design at the University of Dortmund. She's now holder of the UNESCO Chair in Cultural Heritage and Urbanism in Aachen. Can you just paint us a picture? What did it actually look like around here when you first saw the area? When I first saw the area, it looked a little bit like an empty, desolate landscape. Then somehow the first wonderful sketch appeared with a lake, and a lake which was surrounded with buildings, with landscape. And then the moment came and the city of Dortmund got financial support from the European Union and the former mayor went with this sketch to the public and said, this is the first idea to transform this useless brownfield into a new vision of Dortmund.

5:19And I remember this moment really very well.

5:23Katja Hoyer: Though Alexander Kaluti is the first mayor from the CDU party for 80 years, he pays tribute to the vision of his social democrat political opponents. Everything has to change. And I think they were absolutely intelligent, and I have to say they were social democrats, but we really owe them a lot because they were starting in focusing on education and science. And I think that is the new foundation of everything. Dortmund Universities, the Technical University and the University of Applied Science, they have a very high standard. TU, we call the Technical University TU Dortmund, they are now on the brink to be called an elite university.

6:17In our science departments, everything is taught in English. We don't speak German in that case anymore. So you get a very high-class education. But you're getting that for a very, very reasonable price. With science and education, also new ideas came into Dortmund. New thinking, new products came into Dortmund. And with the new products, also new companies established. And I think that was the impulse which supported the transformation of the whole city. And regarding the whole region, you can imagine that now we have 270 ,000 students here in the region. And this is an enormous potential. Dortmund really early was developing new technologies, IT technologies, logistic and so on, and was creating new jobs, new job opportunities, and job opportunities are the fundament of growth of population.

7:38The education infrastructure, the technical university of Dortmund, for example, where I myself studied computer science. And from that day on, I learned to love Dortmund.

7:53Katja Hoyer: Jens Spitzkopf from Brzezinski is a founder and board member of ADESO, an IT company that was born and is still headquartered in Dortmund. Dortmund was a very good ground to start an IT company because there are lots of students coming out of these universities year by year. And if you want to start a new company, then it's very, very useful to have those young people. That was really a push for us. The company's growth has been remarkable. We have been started as a company that builds software systems for banking area, for insurance companies, for automotive industry and so on. And this is what we started with and has been just two or three people starting Adesso.

8:47It was really founded out of nothing, so to say. Today it's a company with 1.5 billion revenue and more than 11 ,000 people working with Adesso. We are currently Germany's largest IT service provider. and we still produce software for our customers, but based on all the technology platforms that are in the world, that are used by our customers, it's basically artificial intelligence that drives our customers and therefore, of course, it drives ADESO itself. And so we ourselves are in a transformation currently, as our customers are too. So it's a very interesting time.

9:35Katja Hoyer: You once said that to achieve this kind of transformation here, it requires a symphony of progress, is how you put it, with lots of different players coming in, everybody vaguely on the same page as to where things are going. Yeah, the cooperation between the city, the business community and the university has really great potential to become a symphony of progress with the aim of enhancing the life quality and prosperity. That prosperity is enhanced by the local authority working to facilitate and to nurture emerging businesses. We have a huge technology park and I think it's one of Europe's biggest technology parks.

10:24And we give people space for a specific amount of time where you can try your own ideas without fearing that you get a huge debt and that you go bankrupt. And then we also connect them with research institutes, with companies, so that it's easier to go into business for them. We can't support them with money, but with logistics, with the infrastructure, And if you want to follow your dreams to be an entrepreneur, come to Dortmund because Dortmund is the space where you can put that into realisation.

11:14Katja Hoyer: So now it's remote controlled. We've come to a quarter of north Dortmund where scores of mostly new businesses have their workshops and factories. And here in a yard, we're looking at a prototype of a so-called autonomous vehicle made by the Ant Company. It's remotely operated and a kind of powerful flatbed mechanism that can lift and move loads as heavy as shipping containers and other huge piles of goods. Michael Karpov is the engineer in charge of it. We are a startup and we are producing autonomous electrical robotic trucks for warehouses and ports. And where does your company come into the existing market?

11:58Katja Hoyer: What does it do differently compared to older technologies? It would be autonomous. Firstly, it would be electric. And we hope we can save a lot of money and a lot of fresh air in warehouses because it's really important for workers inside buildings to not have diesel engines inside. And you're quite successful. I mean, you did third place in a group of something like 300 startups. So why come to Dortmund? You could have probably set this up anywhere, really. I would say it's like the most industrial area of Germany, so it's easier to find partners here and their productions. We can't predict that a lot of people will start their ideas here, and there are a lot of environment to do that.

12:46Katja Hoyer: And who else works on the site? I mean, we heard lots of different languages being spoken. What sorts of people come here and set up shop here? This company starts with some connections with Russian and Ukrainian people. So in this particular company with which we share our space, there are a lot of people from Ukraine, Kazakhstan and Russia. And currently you'd use a remote controlled sort of panel that the operator would carry around with them. Yes, we use a remote controller. And for more complicated environment, we use LiDAR and camera and microwave sensor to drive it autonomously. We can see this map in the computer and using this map we can plan the route and then the robot can follow this route.

13:34Katja Hoyer: But it's not just start-ups that can thrive in Dortmund. The Velo company started life here in 1872 making pumps. Always innovating, it's now at the cutting edge of the water business. Peter Glauner is the CEO for the European region. Everything which is water. It doesn't matter if it is drinking water, clean water, sewage water, grey water, whatever. We are producing, for example, pumps and systems for single homes, up to high-rise buildings, up to treatment plants, up to stadiums. We do complete irrigation projects, for example, in Morocco and in Egypt and in India to supply water to the people and, for example, to irrigate.

14:19Deserts deliver 5 ,000 litres per second.

14:23Katja Hoyer: And modernity also extends to how Velo operates as a business. We rebuilt our factory. It's called the Velo Park. And it's actually really a park. We have our smart factory, which is complete climate neutral. We have our innovation hub. We have a networking hub. And since last Friday, we opened our HealthCube. Our health cube is for our people. It's a fitness center in there. We have psychotherapy, we have physiotherapy, we have x-ray, we have MRT, we have everything in there to treat our people as our most valuable asset. But there are many people of the older generation in Dortmund who remember the former industries with some affection because of the sense of community and identity they provided.

15:08Katja Hoyer: For that reason, it's important to retain, respect and repurpose aspects of the industrial heritage. Identity is for such a region where you have so many, let's say, areas without an identity. It's so important and identity is a really key point of a successful urban transformation. formation. We've come out to Phoenix West and we're standing right next to a giant rusting hulk of a former industrial site that once housed the fastest blast furnace in Europe. Must be about a hundred foot high or so, full of pipings and chimneys and gantries and so on. And it just looks like something from a futuristic movie set.

15:59Katja Hoyer: It's really quite a sight to behold. and that's exactly why it's become a tourist site today for people who want to explore Dortmund's industrial heritage but also for those just seeking a nice day out because we are a little bit outside the city centre right now there's nature, we can hear birds and they've created a number of attractions out here for people to come and visit so there is now for example quite a spectacular skywalk which has been put on top of the former gas piping where tourists can go all the way up there and see the site from above, but they can also see the entire city from here and get quite a spectacular view of the lake and Dortmund's skyline.

16:39Katja Hoyer: There's also a new site, a light show of sorts, where you go into the former hall that once contained the gas blowers for the furnace, and you can see various different lighting displays, oceans, ancient Egypt, Klimt, the world's your oyster in there.

17:01Katja Hoyer: That's also been taken up by families. So overall, this is really a remarkable sign of how these sites can be transformed, but also preserved. And you can still see the history of what once took place here without that being entirely erased. One city centre building that's been preserved is the striking former brewery known as Dortmund the U, a place of entertainment, art, science and museum collections. My name is Matthias Koska. I'm working here as a general manager for human resources and for events. Thank you. My name is Regina Zelta and I'm the director of the Dortmund RU in kind of artistic matters.

17:45My name is Lauren Böhmann. I'm doing the artistic lead for the Co-Produktionslabor Dortmund, which is a small digital lab as part of the Dortmund RU.

17:53Katja Hoyer: We're sitting here in a tower with the most amazing views over the city. we can just see from in here what a landmark this is, how high this is visible from all around. And the Dortmunder U is a real landmark, I would say, for Dortmund people that come here recognize it immediately. It's a former brewery with a giant U on the top, unmistakable. Can you tell us a little bit about that? What does the U actually stand for and where are we? So the U at the beginning was more intended as an advertising sign for the Union Brewery, which was once the largest brewery in the world, but now it is really a sign for culture, for the city, for the people, for Dortmund.

18:36And our role is to fill this landmark with life.

18:42Katja Hoyer: As a city, Dortmund has undergone a huge transformation from coal and steel, from the old industries towards culture, education, IT, startup, and all of the kind of more modern industries. Does this building and what it stands for and the institution of the Dortmunder, you reflect that? It's the ultimate symbol of transformation, structural transformation, social transformation in the city. As a son of a coal miner, I might say when steelworks died and coal mines closed and breweries as well, and there were a lot of unemployed people and a lot of empty buildings. and we just didn't know what to do with these buildings and with these people, but we knew we had to do something.

19:32And there was a lucky decision to make this place a symbol for this cultural change of the city. We can say that Dortmund EU reflects Dortmund's ambitions to be open, to be forwarded in the kind of culture. and we can say it is really exceptional that in this tower there are different institutions with different focuses. For example, we have a collection of the Museum Ostwald with classical and contemporary art, a collection presentation, we have great or large exhibitions, education and workshops for use and we have a library and we have a movie theater

20:18Katja Hoyer: and we have a lot of place to be a meeting point for a lot of people. When we came in just now at the bottom of the tower, we were kind of met by booming music, really trendy young people everywhere. Is this just an ordinary day for you? What can people expect when they come to the Dortmunder U? From June to August, they can expect this every Wednesday and Friday. It means we're playing different kinds of music, inviting artists from all over the city and creating lineups. Today we have techno music, we have rock music, we have poetry slams as well inside and some cinema films we're presenting.

21:00We have some stuff for families on Sundays. so this is quite a good program I would say. So we have some science going on here and some special formats like Science Night to attract young people to go into science and to maybe study it and to work on that. We have a rooftop terrace. This is something like the very upper floor and you have a nice view all over the city and right now we're having rooftop parties.

21:34Katja Hoyer: With cultural places, museums, it can sometimes be quite hard to reach certain groups of people. So people may be disaffected with the way that things are going and are withdrawing or people who've only just arrived maybe from foreign countries and think this isn't for them maybe because they don't speak the language yet. With this digital art, you also approach different people because it's a new art form, also maybe interesting for young people or also digital natives. And we can reach out to them with a new visual aesthetic, with new topics, new really relevant questions and from there we also reach out to a new group i would say we've been talking to people on the street in dortmund about life here the picture is mixed for the in work and prosperous the city delivers a nice life oh there's a much to do in dortmund like interesting museums the zoo the lake also um we came in by bicycle today so we live about three kilometers to the east.

22:37It's a city where you have everything you need, sports, culture, shopping, but you're also close to the Sauerland, the green area, the forest. So it's easy to get there to the lakes, like for a holiday or for a weekend. Natürlich ist das gut. Die Luft ist erstmal viel sauberer. Ich bin 49 Jahre alt. Ich kenn das noch als Kind, dass die Luft hier nicht so berauschend war.

23:00Katja Hoyer: So what he was saying was that there is structural change and that this isn't necessarily a bad thing. He said he's in his mid-40s now and he remembers when he was a small kid that you couldn't even hang your white clothes out to dry because they were basically black and dirty by the time that you got them back in. But at the same time, this has also brought more problems with crimes, drug taking. He said you would have seen it walking around here, and we have. There are plenty of homeless people, people begging for money, going through bins to try and find bottles to get the deposit for, that kind of thing.

23:33Katja Hoyer: And he feels that that has also got worse. But he feels to some extent that this is inevitable. He said, what are we going to do, stick to these industries forever? They were always going to go to the countries like China, where they can do it for less money and be more profitable about that. And on the whole, there are new opportunities here for young people. He stood there and shrugged and said, well, we've still got beer and football, so that's something to hold on to. You're listening to Germany's Rust Belt Revival from the BBC World Service.

24:26Because at Schwab, you can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. Decisions made in Washington can affect your portfolio every day. But what policy changes should investors be watching? Listen to Washington Wise, an original podcast for investors from Charles Schwab to hear the stories making news in Washington right now. Host Mike Townsend, Charles Schwab's Managing Director for Legislative and Regulatory Affairs, takes a non-partisan look at the stories that matter most to investors, including policy initiatives for retirement savings, taxes and trade, inflation concerns, the Federal Reserve, and how regulatory developments can affect companies, sectors, and even the entire market.

25:14Mike and his guests offer their perspective on how policy changes could affect what you do with your portfolio. Download the latest episode and follow at schwab.com slash Washington Wise or wherever you listen.

25:30Katja Hoyer: The Rust Belt revival in Germany's former industrial heartland has delivered new industries and prosperity to many people in Dortmund and the surrounding cities. But the picture is mixed. Unemployment remains stubbornly high at around 12 % in cities such as Dortmund and neighbouring Essen. That's five points higher than the national average. And the number of young people not in education, employment or training has risen by 10%. What's more, these cities are literally divided by the A40 road, which separates the affluent south from the poorer north.

26:11Katja Hoyer: Kai Bandermann is a broadcast journalist on the local WDR radio and television networks. His own family history typifies the transition that's happened in the rural region. My two grandfathers were coal miners, so they actually were in the mines. My dad worked for the very big Dortmund steel company, Hirsch, which was a very dominating company of my youth. But my grandparents and my parents especially said, Kai, you should be better off. You shouldn't work in a steel company or go into a coal mine. Try to do something else, study, and they make it possible that I studied, so became journalist.

26:51And my son lives in Dortmund too. He's working for an IT company, which is situated in Hamburg. But he's working 100 % remote in Dortmund.

27:02Katja Hoyer: Can you describe the Dortmund that you grew up in? What was it like when you were a child? When I grew up, we have dust and dirt hanging around in the air. All these industrial sites who produce pollution of all kinds compare it with the of Dortmund of today. Clearer, cleaner, more green.

27:29Katja Hoyer: But I wanted to know from Kai what the main stories are that he's covering now. Twice or three times a week we report about problems around about housing. And now we're talking about heating that doesn't work. We talk about dirty vicinities of houses and that people have problems with their landlords and these landlords are not nice persons who live around the corner. but most of them here in Dortmund are big companies. It's big companies with hundreds of flats, even in Dortmund and in the other cities, of course, as well. I had a quick look at the local paper downstairs and even on the front page it talks about housing immediately.

28:09Katja Hoyer: What's happening with the housing market here, if you had to sum it up? It's too less, too expensive and too small what we have here in housing in Dortmund. Especially big families have problems. Families who look for a flat with four or five rooms because they have that number of children definitely have absolutely no chance to find something which is affordable. Students, singles, may find something if they have enough money, but the people feel left alone. They feel helpless against these big companies. Of course, tenants do have rights, but exercising them takes resources and time that a lot of people just do not have.

28:49Many people fear that they lose their flat in the end. So this housing crisis also brings people who have a lot of rights. But if I lose in court, if I have to leave this flat, where do I stay?

29:03Katja Hoyer: Markus Röse is the housing policy spokesperson for the Tenants Association in Dortmund. There are some new flats, obviously, but they often come very expensive for many people. The other issue is that we have a lot of problems with housing, which are in bad conditions still. Of course, it's much more profitable to just rent them for a high price and not doing anything with the flats than modernizing it or just repairing issues. So it was two directions. One, that we built less and the population grew. And on the same side, we got less flats because they were in these bad conditions and nobody was interested in investing in these flats.

29:48The land is too expensive. We have to make the land as cheap as possible. Best would be that the city of Dortmund, for example, gives it for free to invest it. That would be my personal opinion. We have to solve this land problem. The market doesn't work, then people won't find housing and have to do something else. For example, leave Dortmund, go into more rural areas where housing, living is still more affordable. But then it's away from Dortmund.

30:18Katja Hoyer: Do you see that reflected in the political landscape at all? How do people respond to that? Definitely, definitely. The AFD in Dortmund doubled its seats in the local parliament at the last local election. The polling station, with the absolute maximum high number of voters for the AFD, was in the northwest of Dortmund in a suburb called Westerfühlde, which was one of the problem quarters and was seen by the city as such. Still, people react like this. The AfD, or Alternative for Germany, is a far-right populist party that has just won a significant victory in the state election in Saxony-Anhalt, promising, apart from other things, the deportation of migrants.

31:09Katja Hoyer: Dortmund's mayor Alex Kalluti takes a strong line against the AFD, joining a protest of more than 3 ,000 people outside Dortmund City Hall to voice opposition to an AFD event earlier this year. And he rejects the argument that migrants are the reason for a housing shortage. There was, after all, the equivalent of social housing in the city, but much of it disappeared when the heavy industries closed down. Dortmund had a long tradition of industry housing. So we had a lot of settlements which were built by the industry companies, which were, let's say, not so expensive, which were not for making profit for the people working in the factory.

31:53So you had a little of social glue. The people you are working with, you are living with, maybe kids go in the same kindergarten, you have some kind of community. Now, of course, we lost this big industry, which maybe combined many people. And now you go through settlements and maybe some people say, yeah, I lived here for 40 years. In that time, I knew everybody. Now I don't know anybody. If people experience the whole structural change, not as a personal win, they not only want to stop it, they want to some kind of turn back the time. You have to explain why we have to transform.

32:31Katja Hoyer: Professor Rasmus Beck is CEO of DBI, the local development agency of the neighbouring city of Duisburg, where I was able to contact him. And I think where people feel over a long period that their contribution no longer counts, that their work is being devalued or that their living conditions are going down, a vacuum is more or less created. The persistent lack of prospects erodes trust in institutions. And when the impression arises that transformation means, above all, the loss of industry, fewer jobs, less security and the loss of identity, it becomes politically some kind of vulnerable. And when industrial jobs disappear and unemployment remains high and neighborhood feels left behind, the answer cannot be nostalgia.

33:21The answer has to be a clear pathway towards the future. And so the political response must be people who have to find new jobs should get new skills. And we are investing in the neighborhoods, in the steel neighborhoods, or what means the transformation from their point of perspective.

33:39Katja Hoyer: Amid the transition, cities in the rural still grapple with stubborn problems of municipal debt, child poverty and integration, especially, as city planner Professor Krista Reicher explains, in the northern quarters of these cities. The A40 is nowadays regarded as a kind of social dividing line. The southern areas and parts of the city, we have the wealthy and richer population. They are well educated and have a good access to higher education. In the northern part, you have the younger population. you have a lot of poor people and you have people with migration past and so on. And this is somehow a huge problem.

34:32And the big challenge is to mix up these social neighborhoods because mixture and the accessibility of education is the key element of a successful future in the region, especially in those areas where you have the most young children and people.

35:02Next station, Dortmund-Oestl. Ausstieg rechts.

35:27Katja Hoyer: famous and large steel empire, but also a really important coal centre with the Zollfine coal mine being one of the largest and also considered one of the most beautiful coal mines in the country. It was once the fifth largest city in Germany with over 700 ,000 people living there, but it's today slipped behind Dortmund in more ways than one. A lot of money and effort have been put into rebuilding a very educational and cultural scene that's very vibrant lots of companies some of the biggest in germany have moved to essen and are headquartered there including the two largest energy companies eon and rwe but in other ways the city is struggling with that transition we're seeing the social costs in particular being significant and social workers and teachers are trying to deal without working with young people in particular

36:29Katja Hoyer: so this is a summer camp where kids from 7 to 14 can come daily for a week during the summer holidays it's called future city and across some repurposed industrial buildings and a spacious park area groups are busy on their various activities my name is fabian and i studied acting so I'm coming from professional theater but more and more we move to really working with young people so it's giving them space on stage or outside in building in performing in doing circus where they can find themselves find their talents and are not only judged by school grades we are located in the north of Essen and it's a lot younger here the population more diverse, a little more challenging but for us it's important that we have a mix it's not only for them, also here in this project now they're coming from all over and I think this is important that they meet that they're not, ah, you're a kid from the north you're a kid from the south, no, you're a kid And what sorts of activities do you do with them here that brings out their talents and gets them to engage with one another?

37:38So we have circus here, circus always works very well because it's challenging, it's intriguing but it's also easy to achieve first steps. Then what is very important, someone who can really build. With wood, they build a tree house. They wanted to build here a big wooden TV where live performance can happen in it.

38:02Katja Hoyer: The performances, including speaking out in the little arena, which is the so-called parliament here, is key. Children are encouraged to express themselves and engage with one another. out of that. We make like a democratic election. They really have to make the cross and vote for their most urgent question of the day. Why is the playground closed? Very practical things too. Why is there racism and big things? And then we have it. And then we go to a parliament and discuss that and discuss who could help, who is against us with our opinion. I think we have to agree that this is a new society where we are living in.

38:43We cannot pretend that it's somehow a system we had before where, yeah, they're Protestant and Catholics and that's it. And let's only see how they know. There are so many more religions and they believe in different things. So let's look for our common ground.

39:05Katja Hoyer: We've just arrived at a workshop where one of the projects is coming to fruition and they're building a television set complete with stage and places for the protagonists to hang out and relax. They've just been discussing whether it should just be for children, i.e. child-sized, or whether it should be for adults too. and I think the important bit is that they're all kind of talking to each other and negotiating who does what and trying to find a way of actually making this project come to pass. What are you making this TV from? What materials are you using? Mostly wood, I think, and also we're going to spray with black colour so it has a black colour.

39:47Katja Hoyer: So when you go away after this project, what do you feel you will have learned from it, about maybe making new friends or kind of skills maybe that you've used? We learned many things here in the last days. Well, in the parliament, when we have new ideas for the rules of the future city, we vote if we actually want to get these rules enforced or not. And we also sometimes do little shows or just a warm-up for the day. We all hope for a bright future where we have lots of friends and there's not much conflict, if any conflict at all. And well, we all just hope that everything is going to turn out good in the end.

40:41Katja Hoyer: Also working with young people in Essen is Sebastian Heinske. His job involves taking care of and housing teenagers who have become homeless. So most of the young people are between 14 and 18. It's usually because either there's something going on in the family, kind of some breakup or something where they find themselves homeless, but there's also others that have been in care of some sort or in supporting mechanisms since the age of two or three. The biggest problem is the housing market. You need a very specific type of space. You need quite a small, practical sort of space, and that's something that lots of people are looking for.

41:23Katja Hoyer: So they need up to 100 each year because they're handing these over to people when they turn 18 and then they need other places for other people to move into. Given the 2015 refugee crisis and how big a political topic it is, do you see an impact of that on the housing market and on the social challenges that you face? It was certainly a increase in people who needed to live space. So it's not so much a question of the refugees coming in that was potentially an issue in 2015, but when you look at how the numbers overall have developed, Essen has now got almost the exact same number of people that it did in 2015.

42:05Katja Hoyer: So the question is rather, why is there less space for the same amount of people than there was? And perhaps the answer to that is what's happening with the property here, that you've got investors doing different things with it, People see it as a form of capital investment rather than living space for people, that kind of thing. So there is this cliche maybe or a stereotype or an idea that Dortmund has managed the transition more successfully than Essen. Do you have any ideas or thoughts on that yourself? Yeah, um vielleicht erstmal eine scherzhafte Hypothese aufzustellen. Dortmund hat den besseren Fußballfein als Essen.

42:50Katja Hoyer: So Sebastian was joking that Dortmund has many advantages over Essen, not least the football club, which is much more successful. But kind of joking aside, Dortmund has got an airport, it's got a university as Essen does as well, but maybe made more of a point of highlighting these things, including the cultural center, the U, but the football museum as well. it's kind of made it more obvious that it wants to transition and highlighted that and signposted it. But it seems to have the same problems nonetheless, and Sebastian has lived in both cities. As to the north-south divide, which is still very stark, and Dortmund has got the same issue still in that it's also not been able to fully overcome that social divide.

43:33Katja Hoyer: I asked Christa Reicher what could usefully be done, finally, to heal that social divide. On the one hand you have the politicians, on the other hand you have urban planning and urban development. And if there is a good alliance between these key players, then it works. For example, the decision what school is built in what region and in what district. It is a big impact for this kind of social issue, but it's a political decision. And somehow there is a lag between the political decision and what is needed in the different neighborhoods. But I see in this region that there is a good relationship, creating good pathways for the future.

44:25Katja Hoyer: And what would you say to those that are saying, you know, this change is going way too fast, too far, it's costing too much, the identity of the region is being eroded. what would you say to those critics or to people who fear this change maybe? My answer would be don't be afraid about change you cannot stop change in the former times when we stopped this coal production and steel production there was a strong lose of job opportunities and so on and people were afraid. Nowadays somehow the condition changed because industrialization is now regarded with another view. For example the topics we have nowadays like defense, how to strengthen our independency in the time of increasing wars and so on, how to strengthen defence industry.

45:29This kind of re-industrialisation and steel production plays a completely other role. And with these conditions, nobody will stop this industrialisation as it has happened years ago. So there is a big discussion about the re-industrialisation and this is the new future.

45:54Katja Hoyer: So running counter to the transition away from heavy industry is a new emphasis on preserving Germany's own steel production. In Duisburg, 23 kilometers from here, 20 ,000 people are still employed in well-paying jobs making steel. Asmus Beck. Right now we have the capacity of about 13 million tons in two steel mills, and they do that in blast furnaces. There's also another one with an electrical oven. So we have three steel infrastructures in Duisburg, which makes it by far the biggest steel cluster in Europe. Europe should not become fully dependent on imports. The raw steel production is less the foundation of our whole industrial base.

46:39I mean, look into the car industry, the machinery, the rail, the bridges, all the infrastructure Germany is good in building that and exporting it, the availability of high-tech steel is crucial. About 80 % of the whole German steel production is used regionally.

46:58Katja Hoyer: Given Germany's low-carbon ambitions, the transformation in question now is not away from steel production, but towards the production of green steel. But of course, the transformation to the green steel production, which means you have to not only implement a new technology, you implement a whole new process of steel production. You're changing the whole infrastructure, the whole supply chain. You don't need coal anymore. This transformation requires several things we don't have right now. We need a huge amount of green electricity. Where does it come from? With that electricity, we want to produce hydrogen.

47:38And this green hydrogen production is not ready yet. It is not ready yet for an industrial scale. Also in Germany, the money is limited.

47:48Katja Hoyer: Another central problem is the cost of steel production in Germany. Having dismantled many steel mills in places such as Dortmund and Essen and sent them to China, the market is now flooded with cheap steel produced partly in those Chinese factories. If you look to China, they are having a raw steel production of about 1 billion tons, and about 10 % of these 1 billion tons, which is about 100 million tons, just goes into the global markets with very, very low prices. And of course, this needs some kind of political reaction. Otherwise, we're going to lose the steel industry or at least we're going to lose relevant parts of the steel industry.

48:29Entire neighborhoods, people work and live and have identities which are related to the steel production. People ask, what will become of my job? What is about my heritage? My grandfather was a steelworker. My father was a steelworker. I am a proud steelworker. And if I could have a dream, maybe my children. Will my children still be able to live here? No.

49:00Katja Hoyer: Well, we can't leave Dortmund without paying tribute to the city's world-famous football club, Borussia Dortmund, celebrated in a magnificent stadium and equally impressive football museum. The club was formed in 1909 by local working class men. Boris Davidovsky is part of the club's communications team. All of them had some sort of connection to either steelworking or their families were part of the steelworker. so pretty much founded out of hard-working class, I would call it, and this is pretty much still today the crucial part of the DNA, what the club is about. As we're speaking today, we're actually over 245 ,000 members officially registered as a club member, and what that brings is a completely different connection between the club, its members, and the people supporting the club, whose opinion we actually value.

50:02Katja Hoyer: Does this also say something about community cohesion because the club's got this motto, Borussia Verbinded, Borussia Connects People? In our stadium, it's basically a mirror to society. So people from all walks of life are either sitting or standing side by side, most of the time not even knowing each other. And it's true that transition has brought in people from all over the world, including the city's mayor, Alexander Kaluti. I mean, look at me. I have migrant background. My father's family is from Jerusalem. They're Palestinians. I have been brought up in southern Germany. I'm living for 11 years now in Dortmund.

50:47And still, they elected me as their mayor. They don't judge you on your history or on your family history. They don't judge you on your social status. They see who you are.

51:02Katja Hoyer: But I'd like to leave the final word to lifelong Dortmunder Kai Bandermann. I'm proud. I'm proud of what's happening. Not everything is working. Dortmund is not what you call a beautiful or a nice city. If you want to come to Dortmund and want to see a nice architecture, don't come to Dortmund or just a few places. But with years of pain and of declining, But after these painful years, we have these new kind of jobs, good looking, better looking housing. The environment is getting better and better. So you're not in danger if you go out and take a deep breath. So that changed from my youth, definitely.

51:42And so, yes, made this turnaround that makes me proud.

51:48Katja Hoyer: You've been listening to Germany's Rust Belt Revival, presented by me, Katja Heuer, and produced by Susan Marling. It's a Just Radio production for the BBC World Service.

From the publisher

On location in Dortmund, in Germany's Ruhr region, historian and author Katja Hoyer reports on the dramatic transformation that has taken place in the city in the last 20 years. Once known for its heavy industry, especially steel production, Dortmund realised the future lay elsewhere. The city would instead become a centre for hi tech industries, for start-ups, for logistics and it would attract talent to make that happen. Investing in two world class technical universities was a huge help together with the efforts of local government to support new businesses with access to workspace and useful contacts. The city cleaned up its act with new parks and lakes and a river free of pollution. The cultural centre Dortmunder U, the famous football club Borussia Dortmund plus a concert hall helped to turn the city into an attractive place to live. Yet in neighbouring Essen, people have been left behind in this transformation. What can Dortmund and its neighbouring cities teach the world about the process of deindustrialisation ?

More from The Documentary Podcast

All episodes