


The disappearance and eventual recovery of hiker Michelle Vanek on Mount of the Holy Cross, and how a pastor’s dream inspired an all-women rescue effort that led to finding her remains in 2024.
Scott Beebe, a Lutheran pastor and Vail Mountain Rescue Team volunteer; Ben Vanek, Michelle’s husband; Emily Brown, president of Vale Mountain Rescue Group (healthcare background, mountain medicine); Erica German, experienced river guide and whitewater rescuer.
Scott heard what he believed was Michelle’s voice in a 2 a.m. dream; Emily’s team re-examined the 2005 search through the lens of what women might notice; Erica felt “called” and later found Michelle’s body after seeing red items; DNA confirmed the remains were Michelle’s.
Michelle’s 2005 route mistake via Halo Ridge; her exhaustion and separation; the 2022 discovery of her boot near Lake Patricia; the 2024 search finding her red/black shirt, jacket, ski pole, and mitten.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
The story of Michelle Vanek's disappearance during a hike on Mount of Holy Cross in 2005.
“And I remember I woke up, sat up, looked at the clock, it was 2 o 'clock in the morning, and I'm thinking, what in God's holy name was that?”
Ben shares fond memories of his wife Michelle and details of their life together.
“exploring personal stories of faith from around the world.”
The extensive search efforts for Michelle over eight days and the emotional toll on her family.
“Michelle was a former competitive swimmer and a triathlete, and she was ready for a new challenge.”
Ben discusses his grief after Michelle's disappearance and a significant experience he had.
“Hundreds of volunteers joined the search for Michelle.”
Pastor Scott Beebe has a dream that inspires a renewed search for Michelle Vanek.
“And when you're laying in a large bed by yourself, it's sometimes hard to fall asleep.”
Emily Brown reflects on her role and the significance of involving women in the search efforts for Michelle.
“The boot lay in an area that had barely been searched before the snow came in in the days after Michelle disappeared.”
Learn about Emily's insights and the women's approach to Michelle's search.
“Emily is the president of Vale Mountain Rescue Group and the only woman on the board.”
Explore the difficult terrain and the team's determination during their search.
“This is the documentary from the BBC World Service.”
Hear about the team's strategies and their emotional experiences while searching.
“In the spot where Michelle had last been seen, this team of women tried to understand the choices she might have made all those years ago.”
Understand the emotional journey of the family after finding Michelle.
“So Haley and I went up there, and Haley, she was one and a half when Michelle went missing and died.”
Explore the transformative perspective of seeing nature through a loved one's eyes.
“But when you look at the mountain now, when I go up on Holy Cross now, I see it as beauty.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Documentary Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Scott Beebe: This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30Michelle Vanek: all in one place, so you can invest your way. Visit schwab.com to learn more.
0:39Michelle Vanek: The Documentary, home of the best documentaries from the BBC World Service. And I remember I woke up, sat up, looked at the clock, it was 2 o 'clock in the morning, and I'm thinking, what in God's holy name was that? It was a woman's voice, I believed it was Michelle's.
0:57Scott Beebe: Scott Beebe is a Lutheran pastor and part of the Vail Mountain Rescue Team in Colorado The voice he believed he heard belonged to Michelle Vanek a woman who had disappeared on Mount of the Holy Cross outside of Vail in 2005 Eight days of rescue and recovery efforts to find her were unsuccessful Nearly two decades after Michelle Vanek went missing Scott had a dream that would help inspire a new search for her. Michelle Vanik was 35 when she set out to climb Mount of the Holy Cross.
1:36Michelle Vanek: Vail was her place. She grew up skiing there. She grew up hiking there and spending summers and winters with her family there.
1:46Scott Beebe: Michelle's husband, Ben, remembers how much this part of Colorado meant to her.
1:51Michelle Vanek: I saw how important it is, that mountain, in that area. So I think that it was a natural fit for her to go hiking on that mountain.
2:03Scott Beebe: Michelle was a mother of four and an accomplished athlete, but this was her first attempt at one of Colorado's mountains that stands over 14 ,000 feet, or a 14er as they are known locally.
2:17Michelle Vanek: It was her first 14er, probably wasn't the best 14er to pick, to go for a first 14er. But I think that her athleticism, her desire, her drive, and the confidence that was shown by her hiking partner led her to be comfortable going up on Holy Cross.
2:36Scott Beebe: From the BBC World Service, this is the documentary. I'm Jo Meek, and this is Heart and Soul, exploring personal stories of faith from around the world. A pastor's dream helped inspire a group of women to search again for missing hiker Michelle Vanik. Michelle's dream is the story of what drew them back to the mountain and what their search to bring her home meant to the family who loved her.
3:07Michelle Vanek: Here's a picture. I just found it so.
3:10Scott Beebe: I speak to Ben on the 21st anniversary of Michelle's disappearance. He's taken the day off work, and he'd been thinking of joining a memorial hike, but the weather has kept everyone off the mountain.
3:22Michelle Vanek: I have better pictures of her than that.
3:24Scott Beebe: As he looks through photographs of Michelle, he remembers a life together that began when they were teenagers, working as lifeguards at that local swimming pool.
3:34Michelle Vanek: She was funny, beautiful, smart, outgoing, athletic. she had a personality that other people were drawn to she was probably one of the best i'm going to say a mother figure and a wife and a friend and in my case best friend just all of those things rolled into one but she also had some fierceness to her too so she grew up in a household from like mixed religions. She was baptized Catholic. Half of her dad's side of the family were Catholic and her mom Christian based. And so she celebrated both. And after we got married, we did the same. We got married in a Catholic church, but we went to other churches and explored other ways of faith, but God and Jesus center of the life of our family.
4:29Scott Beebe: Together they were raising four children, two boys and two girls, in Lakewood, Colorado. Michelle volunteered at her church and with a charity supporting teenage mothers. In the summer of 2005, she was beginning to think about returning to work and finding time for adventures of her own. Michelle was a former competitive swimmer and a triathlete, and she was ready for a new challenge. A family friend offered to lead her up Mount of Holy Cross, near the place she knew so well from skiing. On Saturday the 24th of September 2005, Michelle left home before dawn.
5:10Michelle Vanek: I gave her a kiss, I told her I love her, I told her to be careful, and then off she went. And then the rest of my day revolved around taking care of the kids. It was a Saturday, so my oldest daughter was in a soccer game, so I took her to soccer while I was watching my youngest. Hayley was only a year and a half old.
5:31Scott Beebe: Michelle and her hiking partner had intended to take a well-worn route up Holy Cross. But instead, they mistakenly followed the longer, more strenuous off-trail approach known as Halo Ridge. After five miles, they reached a stone shelter on neighbouring Notch Mountain. Holy Cross still lay ahead. They still had to climb over three high points, each one over 13 ,000 feet high, picking their way across boulders in the thin mountain air. Her companion later told investigators that 400 vertical feet below the summit, Michelle was exhausted and out of water. She said she couldn't climb any higher. He said she encouraged him to go on, and so he pointed her towards the route down, saying that he would catch up after reaching the summit.
6:26Scott Beebe: When he came back down, he couldn't find her. Then I received a phone call around three
6:34Michelle Vanek: that the separation took place and that they couldn't find her. Search and rescue was called. Then myself, my father-in-law, my dad and my brother-in-law drove up to meet up with the search and rescue the next day. For me, it was, you know, obviously gut-wrenching and extremely nervous and you just kind of knew that something was not obviously right. And then the following days, it just escalated, kept getting bigger and bigger and led to being, I believe, and it still is, the largest search for a single hiker in the state of Colorado's history.
7:16Scott Beebe: Hundreds of volunteers joined the search for Michelle. For eight days, teams scoured the mountain. Then heavy snow brought the main operation to an end. They had found no trace of Michelle.
7:29Michelle Vanek: The hardest part was to explain to my kids that mom was not coming home after they called off the search. And then from that point forward, especially the first few years, it is one of those deals because there was no evidence, no body found that in the back of your mind that she would show up sometime. We actually came to the realization that she was never coming home. I would be in a crowded room feeling the most lonely person in that room. and then out of the corner of my eye catch a glimpse of somebody who had the same physique and think that was her for a split second. What I knew was that if there was a will for her to be home, she would have made it home because of her children.
8:19Michelle Vanek: She was a phenomenal mother.
8:22Scott Beebe: Ben cared for their four children whilst grieving for Michelle, still not knowing what had happened to her. The speculation about her disappearance made that time more painful, and he tells me he lost faith. Then in those early months, there was a moment when he felt her close again.
8:41Michelle Vanek: I did have an experience that I'll share with you, that I had a hard time sleeping for the first number of years, so I'd get up in the middle of the night, and the way that I would calm my mind and settle myself is I'd play online poker, because when you fixate on numbers, it just takes your mind away from your stresses and your emotional issues. I had this heavy smell and heavy presence of Michelle. Her perfume was right over me. It was so vibrant. You could smell it. And I got up from my chair, walked around the house and I couldn't smell it anywhere else. And I sat back down and within another minute, I got that smell again and I got a calm sense that somebody put their hand on my shoulder and I was really calm.
9:32Michelle Vanek: And so I went back to bed. And when you're laying in a large bed by yourself, it's sometimes hard to fall asleep. But I just went straight to sleep. And then the next morning, I called my little sister Jenny up. And Jenny and Michelle were best friends. I said, you'll never guess what happened. And I explained what happened to her. And she started crying. She said, that same thing happened to her. that night, the same night, she was up with her son Charlie rocking him to sleep. And she got a really big sense of a presence of somebody there with a calming hand on her shoulder. So yeah, we knew she was there.
10:11Michelle Vanek: She was there with us.
10:16Michelle Vanek: The aura around that mountain is, it's incredible. It's incredible.
10:23Scott Beebe: Mount of the Holy Cross takes its name from a cross-shaped snowfield that has inspired artists, poets and pilgrims. But the climb is long and demanding. A beautiful, beautiful corner of God's world. I've been up on the summit 15 times and been on the mountain 25 times looking for lost folks. But it's a very sacred place. Pastor Scott Beebe volunteers with the Vale Mountain Rescue Group and serves Mount of the Holy Cross Lutheran Church. There's a creek that runs beside his church, and it's an important place for Scott.
11:00Michelle Vanek: And this is beautiful Goward Creek. You can pretend you're Jesus and walk across the water and hardly get wet. I've always loved the water. I mean, being from Minnesota. And it's quiet. Wildlife come down and through here. Bear, fox, coyote, moose. I had a moose come up to the chapel and stick his nose right in the door. Yeah, it's just a quiet corner of the world, and I can come and sit and reflect and think about the past and hope for the future.
11:32Scott Beebe: For years, Michelle's family had lived in limbo without knowing where she was. Then, nearly 17 years after she went missing, in August 2022, two walkers found a hiking boot near a place on the mountain called Lake Patricia. The boot lay in an area that had barely been searched before the snow came in in the days after Michelle disappeared. Ben identified the boot as Michelle's. Search dogs found nothing more, but this raised new questions for the Vale Mountain Rescue Group. It was only a few months after this discovery that Pastor B.B. had a dream.
12:10Michelle Vanek: The dream was real simple. It was nothing complex. It was simply, I don't want to be found by a guy. Guys got me into trouble. I don't want to be found by a guy. That's all it was. That's all it was. And I remember I woke up, sat up, looked at the clock. It was 2 o 'clock in the morning. And I'm thinking, what in God's holy name was that? It was a woman's voice. I believed it was Michelle's. And as a result, I got up the next morning, and I had the file box of the eight-day search. and so just for fun pulled out each day and I wanted to see who was in charge who was running the mission and where were people sent and the thing that struck me was it was run by one person who had complete control all eight days and what I found interesting was the the women on the team we had women on the team back then not a lot but they were relegated to what I call cooking casserole missions.
13:12Michelle Vanek: Hundreds of volunteers showed up. The women took the volunteers and, you know, they went up Fall Creek or some of the easy trails. Just keep people together, let them know that they're helping. But it was the guys that flew in the helicopters, guys on the horses. And I just thought, hmm, that's interesting. And it was after that, then I cornered two of our female leads, met them for coffee. And I said, I got this wild idea. You know, I told them about the dream. And I said, if I give you all the files, the maps, everything that took place during that eight day mission, would you do me a favor, get the women on the team, try and put yourself in Michelle's shoes.
13:52Michelle Vanek: So my name is Emily Brown. I have a background exclusively in healthcare, but have really gotten into mountain medicine in the last few years. And I do have this strong long intuition. I think I have spidey senses. I think I've been on this earth before. I can't describe it.
14:15Scott Beebe: Emily is the president of Vale Mountain Rescue Group and the only woman on the board. She's used to making sure her voice is heard, but she also trusts a quieter sense of knowing, her intuition. So Pastor Scott's dream got Emily thinking. What might the women on the team notice if they looked at Michelle's journey together.
14:37Michelle Vanek: I think dreams are your body's way of telling you something. So the more I thought about it with him, it made sense. And the more I got to know Michelle, it made a lot of sense. He brought me the box and then said, lead a team of women, go do it. And so I got a group together and we kind of started to piece some information together.
15:00Scott Beebe: Pastor Scott also told Ben about his dream.
15:03Michelle Vanek: A couple of things go through your mind. One is, is this real? Did she really come to him in a dream? And then the more you talk about it with the kids, the girls are like, yeah, that sounds like mom. She was this, could not be stopped. She was just so headstrong and was a leader and a fighter. And when she was a mom of four, She didn't back down. She was strong, resilient, courageous. And I almost felt like I was being pulled onto this mountain to come find her. It was like this energy of come get me, come get me.
15:43Scott Beebe: So Emily and the other women on the rescue team gathered and shared data and maps and they made a plan.
15:50Michelle Vanek: It wasn't really until the spring months of 2024 when we started to put pen to paper on maps and come up with a route and some ideas, but we didn't really know what we were going to do until we got out there. We felt like we just needed to go and hike her path and see what we would have done.
16:28Michelle Vanek: Sometimes we all need an extra helping hand, especially with a tricky business problem you've been putting off. Claude is the AI for just that. It's the collaborator that understands your entire workflow and thinks with you, not for you. And Claude isn't just for quick questions. Hand it a whole task, like turning a folder of scattered notes into a report, and it does the work and hands back something finished that you can open and edit. Claude can now draft a dock or deck right in front of you, And Claude Design now lives right inside Claude. Describe the website or prototype you're picturing, attach your design system, and it comes back in your own design language, ready to edit right on the canvas.
17:09Michelle Vanek: It works with your files and the tools you already use, like Gmail and Slack. And whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model, or strategizing your next business move, Claude extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter. For problems worth solving, Get started with Claude at claude.ai.solve. That's claude.ai.solve. And check out Claude Pro, which includes access to all of the features mentioned in today's episode. Claude.ai.solve.
17:41Scott Beebe: This is the documentary from the BBC World Service.
17:46Michelle Vanek: It's interesting, like, how everyone perceives different dates. because it's like I know the 24th was like her date of going missing but then like September 13th is my important date because that was the day we found her.
18:01Scott Beebe: Erica German is an experienced river guide and whitewater rescuer. She joined the Vail team seven years after Michelle went missing but she knew the mystery of Michelle's disappearance. She signed up to Emily Brown's all-female team and they set a date to search for Michelle. In August 2024, before the all-female team went out on their planned search together, Erica decided to go out on her own. But while she was on the mountain, another woman was reported missing.
18:33Michelle Vanek: I was already out there, so I was dedicated to my mission for the day. But that evening, we were asked for another team to go out the next morning for this other lady. and I just felt a calling, almost like, okay, I'm trying to find Michelle, but this other lady is missing and I just feel like she's already passed away and Michelle's going to help me find her.
19:03Scott Beebe: The next morning, after being flown onto the mountain, high on the ridge, a tiny patch of colour caught Erica's eye.
19:11Michelle Vanek: And my teammate that I was with that day had a set of binoculars and so I just called to him and was like hey can you look at this spot down here and see what you see and you know he came back to me and said I see it it's a body well Michelle definitely I felt like she led me to her and being able to find her so that she didn't have like the same thing happen. I feel like there was so many wild moments I had where you get goosebumps and the hair stands up on the back of your neck. Their cases were so similar. And after that, I just knew that I was going to find Michelle eventually.
20:06Scott Beebe: on the 20th of august 2024 the all-female rescue team set out together a helicopter was due to take them close to the place where michelle and her hiking partner had separated but strong winds prevented them from landing where they had planned we got dropped off in the very wrong part of the
20:24Michelle Vanek: mountain. And I think it was Michelle telling us, you got to be tired to come get me. You got to see what I was seeing and feel what I was feeling if you want to come find me. We were hiking over these huge boulders for two miles. It took like four hours to go, but felt like a football field. That terrain, it's very difficult to move in and you need a lot of skill set in being in a terrain where there is no trail. So it's physically exhausting being at that altitude for so long. And it's mentally exhausting because you have to be very careful about how you move. Michelle's time up there, that was her first time ever being in terrain like that.
21:11Michelle Vanek: And I look back at her route and how she got there. And it's just like, man, she did an incredible job for having never been in that terrain before.
21:22Scott Beebe: In the spot where Michelle had last been seen, this team of women tried to understand the choices she might have made all those years ago. First, they considered the directions Michelle was given. And then...
21:35Michelle Vanek: We all looked at each other and we said, go where you would want to go if you were alone. So we kind of scattered. So if she had started a little higher, if she had started a little bit lower, we kind of covered our bases. We all ended at the same spot and we all said we would go down. And at that moment, that's when the wind picked up and I just felt this like shiver over me. And it was her way of saying, yeah, you're right, I'm down here. And we all wanted to go down there, but we were running out of daylight. So we decided we'd come back.
22:06Scott Beebe: They marked places to search and made plans to return as a group. But Erica kept going back.
22:14Michelle Vanek: Every time I would do one of these hikes, I made a little post about it online and was like, hey, just out there search day. And that's when Zach Smith started talking with me every day. He would be like, did you find anything? And then decided to do a search day with him. And I was like, pretty sure I have a great idea of where she's at and I think I know how to get there.
22:41Scott Beebe: Zach Smith is another volunteer with Vale Mountain Rescue. On the 13th of September, 2024, he and Erica headed to Holy Cross together.
22:50Michelle Vanek: And right near the end of it, where we were like calling it as a day, was when he says, I see something red. I see some red plastic. I got closer and then I looked and I'm like, oh, it's a shirt. It's a red and black shirt. I yelled to Erica and she comes down and I look up. It's sort of a gully drainage and I see what looked to be a ski pole. And I say, I think there's a ski pole too. And that's where I saw her jacket. And then we both looked up and saw her ski pole. That was like really the moment for me picking the ski pole up and her mitten with that distinct pattern being on it. And I was just like, Zach, this is her.
23:40Michelle Vanek: We found her. And it was an unbelievable moment. Man, I'm like shaking just thinking about it again.
23:52Scott Beebe: Erica and Zach photographed what they had found. On the sheriff's instructions, they carefully gathered Michelle's belongings, including her backpack and camera, and carried them down the mountain. Then in October a team returned and later DNA testing confirmed that the human remains that were found in the same location were Michelle's A forensic anthropologist reported a spinal fracture was consistent with a fall 20 years on there were finally some answers For Ben and their daughter Hayley there were also Michelle's belongings to see and people to thank
24:32Michelle Vanek: Pastor Scott informed me that they were bringing down all the articles that they had found, and they wanted to know if I wanted to see them. So Haley and I went up there, and Haley, she was one and a half when Michelle went missing and died. We met the search and rescue team, and they sat down with us, and they showed us their route, the photos that they took, what they saw. and it was a real big sense of relief, peace that came over me. And I think for my daughter, she had no idea the vastness of what took place in order to do it and the amount of people and the love that was going through these individuals, especially all the women that were involved in it.
25:26and when they met, sorry, when they met, they hugged her and I saw my daughter cry, but almost like tears of joy,
25:44Michelle Vanek: a little sadness, but tears of joy. She was dumbfounded that these strangers would take this so passionately. It was amazing. So instant bonds were made. When I met Ben Vanek for the first time, the first thing he asked me was, do you feel like you felt Michelle's spirit at any moment? And I was just like, yes. I felt I was almost being led in a way. I still, anytime I go out on a missing person's search, I talk to Michelle. I almost say, hey, Michelle, are you there? Can you help guide me again? I feel like she was a very empowering person, even though I never met her. I've been a parish pastor for 41 years.
26:45Michelle Vanek: Never had this kind of experience. Hearing a voice in the middle of the night, that was new and different. But the thing I've learned about Michelle is she had a very deep, authentic spirituality. And how and why things have unfolded as they did, that is beyond my pay grade.
27:11Scott Beebe: Finding Michelle has brought Ben and his family some answers. The mountain remains part of Ben's daily life, but finding peace both with his faith and with the Mount of Holy Cross has been a long process.
27:25Michelle Vanek: When you're talking about faith and you're talking about this situation, initially I was extremely angry. I was mad. I was mad at God. I was mad at a lot of things. I was mad at the mountains. And you have to realize as I'm coming from my office to my house, I look at the mountains. So I drive that every day. And it took me years to become at peace with the mountains. When somebody goes through a tragedy like this, only those who have experienced it can understand the feeling that one exists in themselves about how to question your faith, how to question God. and then come back to that. Everybody takes a different journey.
28:10Michelle Vanek: But when you look at the mountain now, when I go up on Holy Cross now, I see it as beauty. So I see it almost through her eyes. The beauty of it, the peace, it just is awe-inspiring. This is God's nature. You know, so it brings me peace.
28:34Scott Beebe: you've been listening to the documentary i'm joe meek my co-producer is stephanie wolf and this is a naked production from the bbc world service
In 2005, Michelle Vanek, a 35-year-old mother of four, disappeared on Colorado's Mount of the Holy Cross, a rugged peak so steeped in symbolism that its snow-filled cross has become both landmark and legend. She was hiking with a friend when the pair split up and she vanished. Despite one of the largest search operations in state history, involving helicopters, dogs and hundreds of rescuers, no trace of her was found. But in 2024, an unexpected new chapter unfolded. Pastor Scott Beebe, an experienced search-and-rescue volunteer, dreamt that Michelle came to him, asking to be found "by women." Taking the dream as a kind of calling, he inspired an all-women rescue team to return to the mountain, guided by intuition, faith and a quiet determination to find her and bring her home. Jo Meek speaks to Michelle's husband, Ben Vanek, and to Pastor Scott Beebe, and meets Emily Brown and Erika German from the Vail Mountain Rescue Team who felt a closeness to Michelle on that mountain, decades on.