1. Podcasts
  2. The Documentary Podcast
  3. Navi Pillay
The Documentary Podcast

22 Oct 2026 · 22m · 11 chapters

In short

Profile of 85-year-old South African human rights lawyer Dr Navi Pillay, Nobel Peace Prize winner, tracing her life from apartheid-era activism to major international legal roles, including Rwanda and later UN work on occupied Palestinian territory; it also covers controversy over her findings and Israel’s criticism.

Guests (speaking)

Becky Milligan (host); Kamini Pillay and Isfari Pathar (daughters); Nazreen Rajab Boodlender (niece); Agnes Callamard (Amnesty International Secretary General); Ravina Shamdasani (former UN spokeswoman); Jessica Newworth (colleague/friend).

Key claims

She was first non-white woman to open a law practice in Natal; helped secure Robben Island prisoner rights (1973); UN High Commissioner for Human Rights (2008–2014); chaired 2021 UN inquiry concluding genocide in occupied Palestinian territory (Israel rejects); Nobel award drew Netanyahu accusations of bigotry/antisemitism.

Notable examples

Nuremberg anniversary conference phone call announcing Nobel; Robben Island/Nelson Mandela; Rwanda tribunal rape/genocide jurisprudence; alleged “hit list” document from apartheid security police; online Scrabble habit.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:38

Introducing Navi Pillay

The narrative begins about Navi Pillay and her recognition at a conference.

“If you see an Norwegian number calling, please pick up.”
4:05

Navi Pillay's Early Life and Career

Discussion of Navi's upbringing, education, and early legal career.

“The Nobel Committee is honouring the South African human rights lawyer for her tireless pursuit of human rights, promoting peace and international law.”
5:42

Family and Activism

Insights into Navi Pillay's family life and her activism against apartheid.

“Navi Naidu was born in 1943 in Durban, South Africa.”
14:00

California's New Law and Disinformation Rumors

Discusses California's law for kinfluencers and rumors about disinformation bots.

“There's a new law in California that gives kinfluencers the right to be forgotten and it could impact adults too.”
14:31

Navi Pillay's Early Life and Activism

Explores Navi Pillay's life during the anti-apartheid movement and her husband's arrest.

“saw government crackdowns on the growing anti-apartheid movement.”
16:52

Navi's Historic Appointment

Details Navi Pillay's appointment as the first non-white woman judge in South Africa.

“Nelson Mandela was elected South Africa's first black president.”
17:47

Navi's Role in International Justice

Covers Navi's significant role at the UN International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda.

“It would take her away from home for years.”
19:38

Navi's Human Rights Advocacy

Discusses Navi Pillay's influence and her controversial findings regarding Israel.

“It was the first judgment that really defined rape and concluded that the crime of genocide was committed to various means, including the systematic rape of a Tutsi woman.”
20:44

Criticism and Recognition

Examines the backlash against Navi Pillay and her achievements, including the Nobel Prize.

“And the criticism has only intensified after the announcement this week that she's been awarded the Nobel Peace Prize.”
22:26

Personal Insights on Navi Pillay

Navi's colleagues and family share their perspectives on her dedication to human rights.

“The song was Shakira's It's Time for Africa.”
Show all 11 chapters
23:11

Navi's Love for Scrabble

A light-hearted look at Navi Pillay's passion for online Scrabble amidst her busy life.

“at home, but my daughter will be going to a Catholic primary school.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Documentary Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30We do the things we do and how to make better choices to help avoid costly mistakes. Each episode covers the latest research in behavioral science and dives into themes like the power of self-control, shaping your mindset for success, navigating new beginnings and why starting over can feel so hard. Listen to choiceology at schwab.com slash podcast or wherever you listen. Imagine buying a toy for your kid, but it doesn't come with batteries. That sucks. But honestly, it's even worse when you buy business software. You end up with fragmented, disconnected systems that cost a fortune and don't talk to each other.

1:12Odoo completely changes that. Odoo comes fully complete, with all your business apps perfectly integrated and working together seamlessly. It's everything your business needs in one place. saving you time, headaches and serious money. Stop paying for missing pieces. Go to odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com to learn more.

1:37The documentary, home of the best documentaries from the BBC World Service. If you see an Norwegian number calling, please pick up. The call went unanswered. Typical. My mother, she's not very tech savvy. Who is? I think she'd accidentally put her data roaming off. We've all done that. Even if she's sitting at home with the phone next to her, she misses calls sometimes. Show a bit of respect. She's your mum. And our subject this week. 85-year-old Dr Navi Pillay, a former UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, didn't pick up because she was at a conference to mark the 80th anniversary of the Nuremberg judgment.

2:28A very auspicious place to eventually find out what the man on the end of the phone was trying to tell you. One of the colleagues looked at his phone and just said, oh my gosh, oh my gosh, Nabi Pili has just been attributed the Nobel Peace Prize. So the entire room erupted in screams and joy and clapping. Agnes Calamon, Secretary General of Amnesty International, was there. Navi had just stepped out. She was trying to call her daughter. So we rushed outside and she looked at us with big eyes. We told her she needed to sit down and she didn't. And then we told her and she said, no, no, you're joking.

3:15You must be joking. We said, no, no, no, it's all over the place. But being a lawyer and a judge, I still want to verify, you see. She thought we were joking for a good 30 minutes. So that was the moment we heard that she got the prize. We were in the Nuremberg Tribunal, in the exact room where the judgment was delivered that condemned the Nazi leaders is really seen as the birthplace of international criminal law. So imagine being there and being told you have the Nobel Peace Prize. The beauty of that day, I think, will remain in my head forever. Welcome to the documentary from the BBC World Service.

4:02This is Profile with me, Becky Milligan. The Nobel Committee is honouring the South African human rights lawyer for her tireless pursuit of human rights, promoting peace and international law. She's delighted, although someone else was having a bit of a bad hair day. The Nobel Prize was given out today to a liberal person who works at the United Nations who nobody has ever heard of. I've never heard of the person. Yes, President Donald Trump. But luckily for you, Navi was in a generous mood. Thank you very much. Thank you very much. If you clap a little bit more, I may share this prize with Trump.

4:46Kind. Her daughters, Kamini Pillay and Isfari Pathar. She has the most spectacular, dry sense of humour. Ah. That is quintessential my mum. And if he didn't know who she was before, he knows who she is now. So who is this woman nobody's heard of? Her legal career spans over 60 years. She's been hailed a crusader of justice, a human rights pioneer, but also denounced as a bigot and anti-Semitic by the Israeli government, even a Hamas proxy. So not always an easy ride. My mother will always, no matter how controversial it is, if it's the right stance to take, that's what she's going to do. Not frightened?

5:34Fearful? She's dauntless. I think she's pretty much dauntless.

5:42Let's go back to the beginning. Navi Naidu was born in 1943 in Durban, South Africa. Her father, Narensemi Naidu, was a bus driver and her mother, Santama, stayed at home raising their eight children. The family had originally immigrated from South India in the 1890s, her grandfather an indentured labourer on a sugar plantation. Nazreen Rajab Boodlender is Navi's niece. My mother talks about their childhood. Navi lived in a township called Clarewood, which was impoverished. It was a poor, primarily Indian area because under apartheid we were segregated. Our neighbourhoods were segregated according to race.

6:28It was a struggle to survive under apartheid rule. Here is Navi talking about her childhood to the BBC's Outlook in 2013. There were always difficulties with money. I used to hear them talking about certain jobs reserved for whites. So even when he applied, he couldn't get those jobs. So as a child, and like every other child growing up under apartheid South Africa, you really became aware of social and economic as well as political issues. And racism. Well, just how angry people seem to be with us, just our colour, very insulting. and I was truly hurt by this, felt that there was something wrong.

7:11As children, my father would drive us to the beach and on the way we would see these very nice houses. The beaches, of course, were segregated so we couldn't go to the nice beaches which were closer and we couldn't go to any of the parks. They were reserved. So on the one level you accept this as a very young child and in your teen years you begin to realise that there's something wrong with this system. I wished I'd been white. Navi went to Clarewood High School. Her parents hadn't received any formal schooling, so her mum prioritised a good education for her daughters. She said, I want you girls to be educated so that you will never be subordinate to a man.

7:58It was very unusual. All around us, for instance, at high school, my friends were just forced into early marriages. My parents were criticised. They were doing something very revolutionary amongst their circle. So very meekly they would say, but our girls want to continue to school. Nazreen again. The teachers at her school she's often talked about were excellent and worked very hard for their students. They recognised very early on that Navi was a A strong student was a smart and principled young woman. Her head teacher asked the community to dig into their shallow pockets to help her go to university.

8:42She'd already decided what her subject was. Law. When I was six years old, I was given money to take to my father. And on the way, I was robbed. This money was, it's my father's one month's salary. And at that time, it was five pounds. and there was a court case and I had to be a child witness and stood up in the courtroom. Her daughters, Kamini, and then Isfari. She thought that that was just the absolute best thing on earth. She loved it. She fell in love with the law. She was not intimidated by the courtroom. And I think that was the turning point. And for a five-year-old to say how much she loved being in the witness box is actually, it's hysterical and also just totally endearing.

9:34She understood back then that the law can work in your favour when you are in the right, and that has stuck with her her entire life. At what was then called the University of Natal, she put her head down and worked hard. Demonstrations against the South African government's strict apartheid policies. When she wasn't working, she was beginning to become more involved in anti-apartheid politics, going on marches and protests.

10:09But she was a student and it was the 60s. Getting on down at a university bash in 1962, she met a young lawyer, an anti-apartheid activist. He was a tall, dark, handsome man in his suit. Her unjotty Anthony Pillay, better known as Gabby, asked her to join him on the dance floor. They both loved music and loved to dance. They could dance for hours. Yes, they got attached pretty quickly. She doesn't talk about my dad too often, but when she does, when she reminisces about him, it's actually really sweet. And you can see the love that they had for each other when she talks. In 1965, Navi graduated and they tied the knot.

10:58Two years later, aged just 25, Navi was the first non-white woman to open her own law practice in her home province of Natal. Her work was mostly pro bono, defending anti-apartheid activists, political prisoners and domestic violence victims. And she started making a name for herself. But away from work and politics, the couple decided to start a family. Navi wasn't able to have children. The doctors said it was stress-related. So they adopted two daughters, Isvary in 1973 and Kamini in 1976. Life in South Africa as children was pretty similar to their mothers. We grew up when apartheid was still in full effect, so we went to segregated schools.

11:47We had to go to segregated beaches. We lived in a segregated neighborhood. With one difference. Both my parents were activists. We had a lot of close family friends that were activists. It feels like it was almost every weekend that there was a clandestine meeting because those were banned under the apartheid laws for people to gather and to discuss politics. but we understood it was all about freedom and fighting for freedom and basic humanity, dignity and of course human rights. They had all the usual kids books but also less typical reading material. Isri and I giggle about this but we had our story books like Charlie and the Chocolate Factory and Beatrix Potter next to copies of The Life and Times of Che Guevara and General Castro.

12:42for example. So those revolutionary and Martin Luther King and of course Nelson Mandela, whatever literature was available then and footage of him. So it was all very front and centre in our home. Navi was dedicated to the cause of human rights, but she was also a regular mum. She, you know, did things that no one would ever know about or understand. When we were younger, she would keep us home on a rainy day and bake cookies or come home early from work, bake cookies, and when she picked us up from school, there'd be these gorgeous chocolate chip cookies ready for us in the car and all our friends.

13:25Investing with Schwab is like spending a Saturday at a great farmer's market. You can fill your reusable tote with a bit of everything. Maybe you go for some free-range self-directed investing, or perhaps you pick up a few farm fresh trades while you peruse. You can even get help from a dedicated advisor. That's full service wealth management. Mix, match and change your mind whenever you want. Because at Schwab, you can invest your way. No matter your goals or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. This week on The Interface, millions of kids have grown up on camera with their childhoods turned into content.

14:00There's a new law in California that gives kinfluencers the right to be forgotten and it could impact adults too. And an attack on Russian data centers started a rumor that all the evil disinformation bots had been deleted from the internet. But the truth might actually be a lot scarier. For our take, join me, Jess Maddox. And me, Thomas Germain, for The Interface. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

14:30The late 1960s and early 70s saw government crackdowns on the growing anti-apartheid movement. New laws were introduced. The police had the power to detain suspected political activists without trial, indefinitely, in solitary confinement. Life for the couple was becoming more perilous and then in 1973, Navi's husband, Gabby, was arrested. When they detained my husband, all the threats were about what they were going to do to me. And he was really terrified that they meant it. Our house was watched all the time and we were denied passports. The kids were still very young. Here's Isfury again. She tried to shield us from as much of that stress as possible.

15:19He wasn't held too long. I think it was approximately six months, and she worked tirelessly to get him released. After five months, he was back home, but being held in solitary confinement took its toll. His career stalled. He turned to alcohol. The couple would end up divorcing after 30 years. In 1990, he died. It was only later when When Archbishop Desmond Stutu's Truth and Reconciliation Commission began its work, the press published this document that the security police had compiled, and I was shocked to see that I was on their hit list as well. In 1973, she won a landmark victory, securing greater rights for the prisoners on Robben Island, including Nelson Mandela.

16:11It was front page news. In the 1980s, she took two law degrees, both at Harvard. First a Masters, and then in 1988, she became the first ever South African to receive a doctorate in Juridical Science, Harvard Law School's most advanced law degree. In 1990, what had seemed an impossible dream... Nelson Mandela's first steps back to freedom. ...became reality. Nelson Mandela was released. The majority of South Africans, black and white, recognise that apartheid has no future. It would take four years, but in 1994, history was made. Nelson Mandela was elected South Africa's first black president.

17:02Apartheid was over. It was Saturday morning when Navi's phone rang. Luckily, she did pick up this time. And the person at the other end said, hold on for the president. And I thought, yeah, yeah, president, it must be my brother playing the fool. But it was President Mandela. Navi was appointed the first non-white woman judge in what was then the South African High Court. And he said to me, this appointment gives me great joy. and of course I was overjoyed but just felt I would never let this man down. She didn't stay long. Less than a year later she was appointed a judge on the UN's International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda.

17:50It would take her away from home for years. Did you ever not resent it but just think, for God's sake, where are you, Mum? Did you ever feel that kind of sense of, I want her to be my mum? No. She sat my sister and I down and you could see as huge as this was, she was questioning whether it was the right move for her to make. And the only thing that was stopping her was us. And she sat us down. She was very emotional about it. You know, she explained that this could be she was like, it's going to be at least four years because that's what the initial appointment was. She wanted us to be OK with it.

18:33There was no way that we were going to say to her, no, you need to stay here and be our mom. We understood she needed to be there. We had heard firsthand testimony from witnesses, witnesses saying the entire families of 400 killed, fathers speaking about his wife and children killed. We listened to many witnesses who described sexual violence, and yet there wasn't a single charge in any of the indictments on the sexual violence. Her niece, Nazreen Rajab Boodlender. I remember talking to her about it. And although she's very focused and determined and very clear about the law, she's also, you know, very much a human being who feels for the issues that are coming before her as a judge.

19:26So she would tell me how she would cry. She would weep at the evidence that she was having to hear from all of these women, women after women after women who had been raped in the most humiliating public way. Amnesty International's Agnes Callumar. It was the first judgment that really defined rape and concluded that the crime of genocide was committed to various means, including the systematic rape of a Tutsi woman. So that sexual violence was an integral part of genocide. Navi was by now an international human rights star. From 2008 to 2014, she was the UN's High Commissioner for Human Rights.

20:12Then, in 2021, she chaired a UN commission of inquiry on occupied Palestinian territory. It published its explosive conclusions in 2025. Israel had committed genocide against the Palestinians. The Israeli government rejects all the findings. Israeli ambassador to the UN, Daniel Meron. Israel categorically rejects the libelous rant published today by this Commission of Inquiry. And the criticism has only intensified after the announcement this week that she's been awarded the Nobel Peace Prize. The Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called her a bigot and anti-Semitic. Her friend and colleague Jessica Newworth.

21:01worth. There's nothing wrong with people disagreeing. But in this particular instance, it was just so brutal. It was so rude and offensive and personally destructive and unjustified. I mean, I just can't think of anyone who would be more impartial than her. She served as a judge. She's done this so many times. So I think some deference is due, and at the very least, some kind of respect, you know, just for her as a person, which you would expect all government. Navi's former spokeswoman at the UN, Ravina Shamdasani. The politics, of course, she's not blinding to the politics, but she doesn't let the politics influence her decision in the way that a judge wouldn't let, well, a good judge, a good independent judge would not let politics interfere in the conclusion, the legal conclusion that they arrived at.

21:57And Navi Pillay has not backed down. She recently said she believes the Israeli Prime Minister will be prosecuted. The dispute is not going away. Ravina says while her former boss is a formidable legal force, she's also a party queen. There for all to see at her leaving do. She walks down the stairs and we're all screaming and cheering and clapping as if we were at a football stadium. And we did a flash dance for her. The song was Shakira's It's Time for Africa. And it was so much fun. She was dancing more than anyone else, I think. We started doing the Macarena. It was a really fun event. And as she was then leaving, she gets in her car and she's driving out and the whole office is following her out, cheering the way.

22:48many of us with tears in her eyes. Navi is 85 and there are no signs that she's slowing down, driven as she is by her dedication to human rights. Her daughter, Kamini. It is actually her lifeblood, international humanitarian law and human rights. It's just somehow, it's her lifeblood. It's what keeps her going. It's more than a passion. We're a-religious at home, but my daughter will be going to a Catholic primary school. And so I've asked mom, I said, well, how do I explain religion to her? And my mother turned to me. I mean, this was just about a month ago. And she turned to me and she said, our religion is human rights.

23:28That's what you say to Kyra. Both daughters are so proud of their mom. There's no limit to this pride. It's going to be with us for a very, very long time. We're excited for her. We are thrilled, you know, for this recognition that she's receiving. It's wonderful. Oh, just a little P.S. If you're trying to get hold of Navi, and yes, she isn't picking up again, it might not be because she's in an important human rights conference. The one thing, though, that you cannot kind of interrupt in her life is her love for online Scrabble. and when she's busy with an online Scrabble game, you can talk to her, she won't hear you.

24:13There could be a crisis, she won't know what's going on and there have been occasions where she has deliberately snuck off and after a while we've wondered, well, where's mom? And you'd find her hiding in a room or even the bathroom playing Scrabble on her tablet.

24:37Thank you for listening to Profile. This episode was presented by Becky Milligan and the producers were Tom Gillett and Bethan Ashmead-Latham. The sound engineer was Neil Churchill and the production coordinator was Maria Ocondele. The editor was Justine Lang.

From the publisher

Navanetham 'Navi' Pillay has been awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for 2026. The 85 year old South African jurist and former UN Human Rights chief initially thought the news was a joke. Born in Durban, South Africa, to a Tamil family, her grandparents had come to South Africa as indentured labourers to work in the sugarcane fields. Born under apartheid rule neither of her parents were educated and her mother fought for her daughters to attend school where Navi's teachers saw her potential. The community then raised money enabling her to attend university. In 1967 she was the first woman to establish a law practice in Natal Province defending apartheid activists and political prisoners. She made international news in 1973 when she secured greater legal rights for the prisoners on Robben island including future president, Nelson Mandela. Once president, Mandela appointed Pillay the first non white woman judge in the South African High Court. Soon after she was made a judge on the UN’s International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda. She became UN High Commissioner for Human Rights and then in 2021 she chaired a UN Commission which accused Israel of genocide in Gaza. Israel has said awarding Pillay the Nobel Prize legitimised "anti-Israel hatred" and and both the US and Israel have since issued sanctions on the International Criminal Court. But elsewhere she has received congratulations from across the human rights community. Nobel Committee chair Jorgen Watne Frydnes, said she had been instrumental in ensuring that war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide are prosecuted.

More from The Documentary Podcast

All episodes