


The documentary “BBC Conversations” episode “Renting is such a struggle” explores how rising rents, weak wage growth, housing shortages, and investor/vulture-fund speculation make independent living and saving for homeownership increasingly impossible. It links protests in Madrid with similar struggles across Europe and beyond.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Hear Marie Carmen's traumatic eviction experience due to rising rent.
“This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.”
Hear Marie Carmen's traumatic eviction experience due to rising rent.
“How difficult can it be to get somewhere to live?”
Young renters share their struggles and the impossibility of living alone.
“But as we'll hear later, rising rents and the shortage of affordable housing are not simply confined to Spain.”
Discussion on the factors contributing to the housing crisis in Spain.
“and something that's going on now, for example, is that we have many families living together in the same flat.”
Exploration of the growing difficulties for renters in Madrid.
“Big cities are seeing their populations growing, but there's not enough accommodation in there because Spain's not building enough, Jamie.”
Coverage of protests in Madrid and shared frustrations with housing.
“But again, the housing market is very expensive in Madrid and I have friends who have had to move 30 kilometres away from the city just to be able to buy a house.”
Voices from different countries share their experiences with the housing crisis.
“The protests in Madrid have drawn people from across Europe, sharing the same frustrations about rising rents and the lack of affordable housing.”
The episode concludes with a discussion on the struggles of renting globally.
“You may remember our first guest, Sandra, told us how rents had risen so much that she had to move back in with her parents.”
Guests share their personal stories about moving back in with their parents due to rising rents.
“She now rents a small room but previously lived with her parents.”
Discussion on how rent prices have skyrocketed in various cities, particularly in India.
“So at times it just feels like a fantastic.”
Guests explain the disparity between rising housing costs and stagnant wages.
“I think it's majorly the metro cities in India, Mumbai, Bangalore, Janai, these are like four metro cities and there are a few more that you can count in that.”
The impact of financial constraints on quality of life for young adults is discussed.
“I was struck by the word that you used there when you said disgusting.”
Guests discuss the complexities and frustrations of living at home with parents.
“Speaking of the same thing others said, we barely even have jobs.”
The struggle between wanting independence and relying on parental support is explored.
“I was then sort of, OK, that part of my life is over and doing them again.”
A discussion on potential solutions to the housing crisis, including government action.
“challenges you all face what's the solution then i mean is it rent controls is it governments building more houses?”
Despite geographical differences, guests share similar challenges in renting.
“And I think there needs to be a massive discussion somewhere about how new houses are being built, how quick we can get it done.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Documentary Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30goals, or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. If you are currently overpaying on software to run your business, remember this number, 10 ,000. That's the number of new businesses that join Odoo per month. Join Odoo today at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com.
1:00World Service.
1:05Hello, I'm James Reynolds. This time in the documentary, it's BBC Conversations. We bring people together to share their experiences of trying to live on the front line of the global housing crisis. How difficult can it be to get somewhere to live?
1:27They are inhuman. You can't make somebody live for seven years as I have done with a machete at my throat. And then they cut my throat and all just to make money at other people's expense. That's 87-year-old Marie Carmen Abascal, evicted from the Madrid home she'd lived in for seven decades. She was carried out on a stretcher after the company that owned the property more than tripled her rent. The case angered people across the country. It attracted global media attention and several hundred, mostly young, protesters gathered outside her building, sometimes clashing with the police. Mari Carmen has now been told that she can return to her apartment.
2:09And as we record this programme on Friday lunchtime, Spanish politicians are debating measures to help renters. But as we'll hear later, rising rents and the shortage of affordable housing are not simply confined to Spain. For our first conversation, my colleague Rahul Tandon brought together Jaime in Seville. He works with the city's tenants union and Javier and Sandra, they both live in Madrid. I am currently living at my parents. I moved back some time ago because after renting for a while, I realized that it would be impossible to combine renting with saving up money for a future housing purchase.
2:49If I wanted to rent an apartment by myself, it would definitely be more than 50 % of my salary, if not 60 or 70%. I rent a house with another three people. We are four people. I would like to live alone, but in Madrid that's impossible, unless you have a salary that's much higher than most people's. I would have to spend about 40 % more or less of my salary on the rent, only for a room. But luckily my parents helped me out with it, because otherwise I think that now it's impossible for a young guy to rent a room, not a house, a run, and save money at the same time for in a future buy a home. That's impossible here in Madrid.
3:37So not a good situation in Madrid. Let's just go to Jamie who's in Seville. Is it any better there? It's very similar. So salaries here are lower and the rent is also lower. But it's the same feedback loop, right? So since you don't have a good salary, you cannot save up to buy a house in the future because now banks will ask you like 20 % of the housing cost in advance if you want a credit or a mortgage. For example, in my case, if I'm renting and living now with my parents, I'm back here again. If I wanted to rent, I would spend more than 50 % of my salary in rent, living by myself. I'm already in my 30s and I would like to live by myself and not with other people, so it's pretty much the same.
4:19The level of people that cannot afford paid rent, it's incredible and something that's going on now, for example, is that we have many families living together in the same flat. So they're sharing a flat and there's like three, four, five people in each room. This is something unbelievable in a society like ours. I guess there's not just one person, one institution or one cause. It's just a mix of things. So rent has been going up. There's global inflation. That's to start with. But then on top of that, inflation is affecting prices, but it's not affecting salaries. So salaries remain the same.
4:57That's on the one hand. On the other hand, Spain is clearly a tourism-oriented country, which is great. I think it's a good thing. But the problem is that short-term renting has become more lucrative than long-term renting. So there are a lot of apartments that are being rented for the short term. and living people without a possibility to rent. And then there's also these vulture funds that are buying not only apartments, but entire buildings to either rebuild them or resell them, whatever. It's a mix of things that are worsening a problem that was already there, that's been there for ages. You're living at the moment with your parents, but if you went back out to look to rent again, are there less apartments now than there used to be?
5:45I was checking the other day, and the cheapest apartment on Idealista, a website that's pretty common in Spain to look for apartments, the cheapest one I think was 750. It was far away from the city centre and if you see the apartment, it's a place that you would rent maybe for a short-term thing, not for a long-term. It's just crazy how much they've gone up. Jamie, one of the problems here, and Javier alluded to this before, was Madrid's population and I'm sure all big cities' populations are growing in Spain. But if you look in 2024, they added roughly about 140 ,000 people inside Madrid. And Spain is not building enough new housing either, is it?
6:28That is another problem. Big cities are seeing their populations growing, but there's not enough accommodation in there because Spain's not building enough, Jamie. Yes, I think the percentage of social housing being built every year is less than 1 % of the total. So it's a problem of not building enough, but also it's a problem of all the social housing that was built in the 80s and 90s that has now been privatized, either because the idea was like we have a 20-year only lease for these people or just because they have been sold by the institutions, the public institutions, to, for example, vulture funds.
7:07And this is one of the things from the Tenants' Union point of view that we are asking the government to do now. So, like, please stop this massive speculation coming from outside Spain into our housing market. Javier, can I go back to you? You said at the beginning that you are not from Madrid. If these rents keep going up, will you leave Madrid? Will it become too expensive for you? It's very complicated because I'm a journalist, so I have to stay in Madrid for work. But in the city centre, it will be impossible if this continues. in less than two years, for example, it would be impossible to live in the city centre alone if the rents continue growing up.
7:50Most of us are trying to find a house or an apartment that we can buy because that's sort of like the only option that we see for us to be able to live on our own or with our couples. But again, the housing market is very expensive in Madrid and I have friends who have had to move 30 kilometres away from the city just to be able to buy a house. We all want to build our own lives and I think that independence and being able to live not only with your family but by yourselves, not having to share an apartment. You want to build a life on your own. Sandra, Javier and Jaime in Spain sharing their experiences during our live weekday Outside Source programme.
8:34The protests in Madrid have drawn people from across Europe, sharing the same frustrations about rising rents and the lack of affordable housing. For our second conversation, then, we're going to hear from three people who've taken part. My colleague Rob Young brought together Tobias from Berlin, Aneska from the Czech Republic, and Steph from Ireland, who began by describing the protest camp. There's a makeshift encampment, essentially. There's a central tent where food is being distributed There's people bringing donations every day. It feels like a little city has popped up within Madrid. I think it's very telling that many people here are calling this a historic moment, which it truly is.
9:16It has been such a huge amount of solidarity that we've seen with the people that are struggling with the housing crisis in Madrid. And the thing is, housing crisis, it's not only like an issue here. It's something that many of us are struggling with in our countries. And I think it's important to show solidarity and to cooperate together because it is a systemic issue that we must take on. What we are most struggling with in Prague is short-term contracts that we keep getting from the landlords. You have no certainty whether your contract will be renewed and how much are you going to be paying.
9:56So every year is like this insane amount of uncertainty and you keep waiting whether you're going to get another contract. How much are you going to be paying? Will you be able to pay for that? I had to move several times in my life, I think seven times in the last six years, actually. Many of us believe that housing shouldn't be like a speculation or like an investment, but it should be something like a basic right or like a certainty that you need in life. Now, Tobias, you're in the German capital, Berlin. The cost of housing was a big issue in the recent regional elections, which led to the left party winning.
10:30What is the situation in Berlin? Is rent rising rapidly there? Yes, well, it hasn't only been a problem and topic now at the elections, but for the past 10, 15, maybe 20 years. And when you look at the roots of housing problems in Berlin, then you can go back to the 90s and early 2000s, where the Berlin Senate back then gave away hundreds of thousands of public housing units to international investment funds and big corporations. And since then, the rents have almost been doubled in Berlin. and the city has lost almost 250 ,000 social housing units to private actors. It's a problem that affects basically everyone and it cuts across the political spectrum.
11:08And it's kind of the most common experience in Berlin that you pay every month a large share of your income to the big corporations. And I think in a whole Germany, you can see that People on average pay 166 euro every month just directly to the pockets of shareholders of these big corporations. I've been renting or I was renting for the last four years in a commuter town on the outskirts of Dublin. And at the start of this year in February, we were given a notice to Quish. That's a termination notice from our landlord. So we got a full legal six months notice. We got everything that we were entitled to.
11:46But it was this sort of situation that after four years of making this house my home, my landlord said, I'm selling your house. For me, I was paying 400 euros a month in a house share. So we were sharing between five. The total rent was about 2 ,600 euros per month. If I was going to move into some other house share, I could have tripled my rent. So this is where I find myself in this situation now where I'm living in a camper van in Dublin City with my kind of support network and my community, which ultimately led to me losing my job as well. So I'm kind of in this very weird and precarious situation where it feels like the only opportunity or the only option that I have right now is to fight this exact circumstance.
12:25So we, on paper, even though we have high wages and that we are a rich Western European nation, most people, most ordinary working people, are living in this chronic housing stress. This is not just my case, but this is a case of so many people, including pensioners, including workers, including old people, young people. Everybody is suffering the same way. Marie Carmen was like a symptom of this, I think, like wider crisis. Again, not only here, but everywhere. As Seth mentioned, like there are working families, there are single parents, families, you know, like a lot of people for whom renting is such a struggle and such a big uncertainty.
13:09And evictions are happening like all the time. Less people have such a huge amount of support or such community that stand up to them. But it's important to remember that, like, you know, our fight doesn't end with Marie Carmen, but we're kind of like aiming for a bigger systemic problem. Aneska, Steph and Tobias, who've all taken part in the Madrid protests. I'm James Reynolds. You're listening to the documentary from the BBC World Service.
13:45with the new Schwab teen investor account teens can gain hands-on investing experience and build positive money habits it's an account co-owned by you and your teen so you can monitor and engage with the account while your teen learns how to invest and manage money learn more at Schwab.com.
14:06You may remember our first guest, Sandra, told us how rents had risen so much that she had to move back in with her parents. Well, that is the focus of this, our final conversation. We brought together Bemi in Nigeria. She now rents a small room but previously lived with her parents. Priyanka in India shared a house with her mother-in-law in Goa after moving from Delhi. And Adam here in the UK previously rented but has now had to return to live with his parents. Rahul asked Adam if he was angry about having to move back. I'm definitely not angry because there's a lot of people I think would like to be in the position where they can move back with their parents.
14:44It is very frustrating though because you're sort of sacrificing a life which you want to live and there's just no way that that's a possibility at the moment and obviously as generations have passed, you're inspired by your parents you're inspired by the journey that they've lived and when that life that they've sort of played out in front of you is is not gone the way that you want out of your control just because financial circumstances aren't the same as they used to be it sort of leaves you quite dreamless you haven't really got anything that you're working towards that the goal would obviously be housing that's hard to get because of how out of reach it is so it's quite demotivating it's very very frustrating but i wouldn't say anger's at the forefront of my emotions I think it's just upsetting and frustrating if anything when I said whether you're angry or frustrated I was making a comment on your parents and living with them I'm sure they're a joy to live with it yeah it's blessed to be honest it's they I'm very very happy to be with them and they're supporting me in every way they can so no anger in the house nothing like that it's very positive it's just frustrating that this is how it's planned out I was thinking about my own kids and their comments about if they have to come and live with me and Bemi looking to the future you're renting that small room is it a possibility do you think for you to ever buy your own place or is that a distant dream now i actually thought of buying a place but the reality of things since i moved out it just feels like that dream it was like a distant dream yeah because the rate of things every apartment that is to my taste that looks like what i would love for a future It just feels like it's extreme to reach because these prices are not even going down anytime soon.
16:28So at times it just feels like a fantastic. And I'm sure, Priyanka, for you, you feel the same when it comes to Delhi. For people who don't know Delhi very well, I know it extremely well. So I know what you're talking about when you're talking about rent prices. Give us an example of how much those prices have been going up over the last few years. It's not just Delhi. I think it's majorly the metro cities in India, Mumbai, Bangalore, Janai, these are like four metro cities and there are a few more that you can count in that. I tried living in the other cities too and the prices are going higher.
17:02For example, if I was paying 20 ,000 rupees for a two-bedroom house earlier in a decent area and it's a decent space you know in the house i am actually paying like close to 35 and 40 000 now so it has double over the years yes and especially post covid because i've seen a trend especially in the major cities that people are obviously coming towards the major cities that's a very normal thing to do which is to come and earn money there because there's more demand there people who own the houses got this opportunity for asking for more prices yeah no that's that's the bit i really wanted to hammer in as well is that the prices are going up but it's nowhere near in line with income whatsoever so obviously there has been changes to income we have raised minimum wage quite a lot since i started working like 10 years ago but if you put these side by side to the percentage which housing is increasing by it's not even scratching the surface similar to that position obviously rents going up double is very similar to here as well and that is insane by the way going up by double in the space of about six years is disgusting but then obviously you're not getting double what you earned six years ago so i'm not sure where the expectation or where you're meant to fill that gap or to bridge that gap there's not really a way to do it you're just going to have to sacrifice things that you love in order to bridge that gap to actually save enough to get a house.
18:33But obviously, if you're sacrificing things you love, you're then sort of losing quality of life to then strive for a thing that you don't even know you can attain because it might go up even more. I was struck by the word that you used there when you said disgusting. Do you understand why landlords have to put up prices sometimes? You know, interest rates have gone up so much. No, absolutely. I mean, it's not an easy time for anyone. And obviously, the increase in rent is, I'm not going to use the word again, it is disgusting. And that's not targeted at landlords that's not targeted at housing associations anything like that it's it's more it is just so difficult as a young person now to sort of live independently and to actually have a goal in life because obviously if you want to rent you're then losing money and savings and then if you want to pay a mortgage you're then gonna have to save up for a deposit which you're then sacrificing more things to save up for so it's going to be interesting how how the future plays out for young people and how they're gonna sort of not actually enjoy life because enjoyment out of life is very subjective to each person.
19:31You might be able to spend zero pounds, zero pence and have the best day of your life. But a lot of what people are into do require funds and a lot of those funds are going to be used for housing. It's going to be interesting how people will sort of satisfy themselves in the future because it's not looking great. Speaking of the same thing others said, we barely even have jobs. At the end of the month, you are gathering kind of money that might not even reach to pay for rent. The least anybody would do is either find friends. If there's a particular location you have in your mind that you want to live in, at least you can do find people, gather together, split bill, besides having to go back to your parents' place.
20:09Because at times it can be very stressful to stay with parents, especially for those that do remote work. They just budge into your meetings. They want you to send you an errand. They don't care your age. So because of those little setbacks are the reasons why most of us want to be out. I had a friend that there were six of them sharing a two-bedroom apartment, six people in a two-bedroom. So how they did it, they had to find a demarcation in the city room, divide the city room into two, and two people stayed in the divided room of the city room, two people stayed in one room, two people stayed in another.
20:42This is just how people are like finding a way to manage the rent challenges. Very rightly, you said about living with parents, obviously, you're then going to be used obviously for chores, for help, etc. And I feel like that's something that not a lot of people who have moved back in or haven't moved out of their parents house have spoken about is the fact that you're I'm 26 years old so I'm aware I'm not I'm not really old I'm not really young either but at the age of 26 it's sort of you are looking at an independent life that's I have had an independent life I've lived away in the past and now obviously there's things that you thought you grew out of which I'm now doing again and it's I'm not sure if it's stunting my growth into an adult, but it surely does feel like it because I'm doing things that I was doing when I was 16, 17 years old.
21:31I was then sort of, OK, that part of my life is over and doing them again. And it's sort of like I said, it feels like your development into adulthood does certainly get affected by living at home as well. And that's definitely something that I haven't heard many people talk about in the past. But when you're living with your parents, I'm going to say it how it is. it is easier in a lot of ways and i think in that sense that easiness of life makes you drop your guard and with the cost of living crisis going on living with your parents is not a great formula to sort of prepare a young adult for the actual adult world that is a really interesting point that you made is your mom still doing your washing yeah i mean she offers to do it so i'm gonna take the offer but that's like i said that's a frustration point in this house and if there is ever an argument it's washing it's it's small things like that which you never expect to have these sorts of conversations with people at 26 you just get on with it so we're not going to ask you what the state of your bedroom is either we will leave that immaculate between you between you and your final thoughts from all of you it's been really interesting you've given us real insight into the challenges you all face what's the solution then i mean is it rent controls is it governments building more houses?
22:43Is it subsidies for people on low income so that, you know, they can move out of their parents' homes? What would you like to see, Priyanka, that would make your life easier? I mean, I think it will be a mix of all. Government should take responsibility of ensuring that the people, you know, of the citizens of their country should own the house, considering how the rental, you know, go high. But I feel like what's lacking is the intention behind it. owning a house for the citizen. I don't think it's one of the big topic or the goal of when they preach for, you know, at the time of election. So all the efforts that you just said about, you know, controlling the rent, you know, doing providing subsidies and whatnot can actually be done if it's in their will, but I don't think so.
23:29So I would really like our government to kind of put this in there, something that they should target to. But I kind of don't have a very high hoping on it. The UK is an interesting place in terms of housing. So an easy solution, obviously subsidised rent would be a good idea. But then you've got to remember that landlords have increasing prices as well. I think a lot of the issues lie in house building. There's a lot of houses being built, not enough. And I think a lot of the struggles in the UK is actually planning actually to to secure the land to actually build houses seems to be a massive issue itself so there sort of needs to be a a rethink on how the planning is actually done in this country to build housing because a lot of the time you wait in two three four five years to actually get those planning permissions in that time cost is increasing because each plan that gets released is is a cost plans will change those will increase costs again which just makes everything more expensive it's very old-fashioned, I think is a good way to put it.
24:30And I think there needs to be a massive discussion somewhere about how new houses are being built, how quick we can get it done. Because at the moment, I'm not aware of many other countries that are so slow to do it than here. For my country, those new houses are coming with exorbitant prices. If at all there could be subsidy along the way, it will favour a lot of us. And finally, the jobs, I keep emphasising, If we don't have jobs, how do we want to pay for these things? So we should actually create jobs. So, yeah, everything comes to play eventually. Bemi, Adam and Priyanka sharing common experiences despite living on three different continents.
25:10Our thanks to them and to all of our guests this week. I'm James Reynolds. You've been listening to the documentary from the BBC World Service.
We bring people together from around the world who are struggling to find somewhere affordable to live. We hear from Spain where the eviction of an 87-year-old woman has led to widespread protests, highlighting the country’s housing crisis. Young people in Ireland, Nigeria and India share their experiences of the difficulties they face finding a home, and 26-year-old Adam in the UK tells us about moving back in with his parents. “It leaves you quite dreamless, you haven’t really got anything you’re working towards,” he explains.