1. Podcasts
  2. The Documentary Podcast
  3. Syria’s justice in absentia
The Documentary Podcast

4 Oct 2026 · 42m · 16 chapters

Episode artwork

Syria’s justice in absentia

In short

The BBC World Service documentary examines Syria’s “justice in absentia” after Bashar al-Assad’s fall, focusing on trials held without Assad present, obstacles to accountability, and how Russia’s asylum and geopolitical interests affect extradition.

Guests and backgrounds

Krasi Ivanova-Twig (host; BBC Monitoring Global Jigsaw). Tess Malinda Heron (BBC Monitoring Middle East desk). Firas Feraz Kilani (BBC reporter in Syria). Claire Denning (BBC Russia team; OSINT tracking). Roger Lou Phillips (legal director, Syrian Justice and Accountability Centre; transitional justice expertise in Rwanda/Cambodia). Amalia Zatari (BBC Russian journalist; interviews on asylum). Svetlana Ganushkina (civil society NGO head in Russia; helps refugees).

Key claims

Assad was sentenced to death in Damascus on 11 Aug 2026 for murder, torture, and crimes against humanity; Russia has granted him asylum and is unlikely to extradite. Syrian domestic law lacks codified war-crimes provisions, so charges are framed as murder/torture/incitement rather than crimes against humanity/war crimes. Trials are criticized as “theatre,” rushed, and incomplete because many perpetrators remain free or integrated into the state.

Notable examples

Sednaya “human slaughterhouse”; chemical attacks (Ghouta 2013, Douma 2018); mass killings of Alawites (HRW: 1,400 in March 2025) and Druze (Suweda: ~2,000 killed, ~35 villages burned). Judge Fakhir al-Din al-Aryan defected from Assad-era justice; prosecutor Nuhal Mastri’s brother was killed in Daraa in 2011.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:07

Syria's Justice System and Accountability

Exploring the challenges of achieving justice in Syria post-Assad.

“The accused, Bashar al-Assad, not present.”
2:41

Historical Context of the Assad Regime

A brief history of the Assad family's rule in Syria.

“We ask, can victims of Assad's brutal reign find redress when some of the regime's most notorious figures remain beyond the reach of Syrian courts?”
3:26

The Crimes of Bashar al-Assad

An overview of the atrocities committed during the Syrian civil war.

“Western countries are not the international community.”
7:11

Assad's Fall and the Rebel Offensive

Account of the rebel offensive that led to Assad's departure.

“We hope that they will be given access to the area by the government.”
8:27

Aftermath: Where Are Assad and His Officials?

Investigating the whereabouts and lives of Assad and his officials post-fall.

“on the 8th of December, all Arabic news channels were reporting that there was something happening.”
12:41

Life of the Assad Clan in Exile

Insights into the lifestyle of the Assad family living in Russia.

“Given the catalogs of crimes tests described, it's not surprising.”
14:00

The Assad Family's Wealth and Impunity

Explore the economic disparity in Syria and the Assads' hidden wealth.

“The Russian ambassador to Iraq, he did an interview with a Kurdish-Iraqi outlet called Rudawah.”
17:36

Justice in Syria Post-Assad

Examine the challenges and efforts toward transitional justice in Syria.

“You were listening to the documentary from the BBC World Service.”
23:07

Key Figures in Syrian Trials

Discover the background of key individuals involved in the trials against Assad and his regime.

“Who are the people who are involved in the legal process?”
28:00

Media Portrayal of Syrian Trials

Explore how the Syrian media presents trials and justice efforts amid government narratives.

“And then there's also, I guess, a financial element.”
Show all 16 chapters
29:16

Public Reaction to Trials in Syria

Understand the emotional responses of Syrians to ongoing trials for war crimes.

“Videos of them blindfolded as well, which has gone repeatedly viral on social media because I think they know that those visuals are so powerful and symbolic for many people.”
31:01

Calls for Accountability and Urgency

Discuss the urgent calls from Syrians for accountability in the justice process.

“And for those who are there in person, it's even more meaningful.”
33:09

Challenges in Transitional Justice

Examine the challenges faced by Syrian authorities in delivering justice.

“because we know that there are other atrocities committed over the last two years against the Alawites and against the Druze.”
34:46

Asylum Process for Syrians in Russia

Learn about the asylum process for Syrians in Russia and its implications.

“And on the other hand, they don't want necessarily to rely on international processes and they are trying to make it a Syrian process.”
38:58

Frustrations of Syrian Regime Loyalists Abroad

Explore the challenges faced by Syrian regime loyalists living in Russia.

“You have on the one hand, these extreme luxury apartments in which senior Assad officials and Assad's family are residing in.”
42:01

Challenges of Achieving Justice in Syria

Learn about the long road to justice in Syria after years of conflict.

“You know the country for 14 years, it was separate islands everywhere.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Documentary Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30goals, or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. How many streaming subscriptions do you have? Is it the same for your business? Avoid it by having all your business on one platform. Try Odoo for free at odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com.

0:52The Documentary, home of the best documentaries from the BBC World Service.

1:0611th of August, 2026. Palace of Justice, Damascus, Syria. The accused, Bashar al-Assad, not present. The charges, murder, torture and crimes against humanity. The verdict, guilty. Sentenced to death.

1:30In Moscow, where Syria's former ruler now lives, the sentencing didn't make the news. You had a kind of two-line report from state news agency TASS on the day the verdict was passed, but it even forgot to mention that Assad is based in Russia at the moment. In Syria, there was jubilation outside the courtroom, but there is also concern about how justice can be delivered. People are saying this is not what due process and a fair and just trial looks like. And we don't want theatre, we want the real thing. They want this to be a Syrian enterprise, Syrian judges, Syrian prosecutors, Syrian defence, Syrian lawyers.

2:13Because there is a lot of frustration in Syria and a lot of trauma associated with international foreign powers intervening. The rebel offensive that removed Bashar al-Assad from power ushered in a new chapter for Syria, raising hopes for justice after decades of repression. But the scale and magnitude of the crimes of the former regime is staggering, and the task of investigating them enormous. In this episode, we assess the obstacles standing in the way of accountability, justice and closure. We ask, can victims of Assad's brutal reign find redress when some of the regime's most notorious figures remain beyond the reach of Syrian courts?

3:03Welcome to the documentary from the BBC World Service. I'm Krasi Ivanova-Twig, and this is the Global Jigsaw from BBC Monitoring, where we look at the world through the lens of its media, exploring the narratives, the propaganda, and the disinformation.

3:26Western countries are not the international community. That era has finished.

3:36We'll attempt to squeeze Syria's last 50 years into a nutshell. Here's Tess Malinda Heron from BBC Monitoring's Middle East desk. It goes back to 1970 when Bashar's father, Hafez al-Assad, seized power in a coup.

3:57And that started over five decades of the Assad family's brutal rule and iron fist on Syria. It was a tightly controlled police state marked by repressive tactics. And when he died, it was Bashar, who had trained as an eye doctor in London, came to power in 2000. For a short while, it seemed like things were looking up. He was billed as a reformer. He kind of slowly eased restrictions on the media. He freed some political prisoners. But it was a very short-lived period of reform. And very quickly, his rule became even more brutal than that of his father's. And when the uprising started in 2011, it quickly descended into civil war following Assad's brutal crackdown on the anti-government protests.

4:43So what are the crimes that the son Bashar al-Assad committed? The war lasted nearly 14 years and the crimes are so numerous that it's hard to summarise in one answer. But during the civil war, the UN estimates that over 580 ,000 people were killed. There's 13 million Syrians who were displaced both internally and abroad. We are talking estimates. The UN stopped counting the dead early in the civil war in January 2014. Its human rights chief recently cautioned that the figures are certainly an undercount of the actual number of killings. There was systemic torture in notorious detention centres, including Sednaya Prison, which was dubbed the human slaughterhouse, because just of the extent of torture and starvations and beatings, there was also many enforced disappearances during the war.

5:35So according to the UN, it was over 100 ,000 people who either went missing or were forcibly disappeared. To this day, many people don't know what happened to their loved ones. There is also the use of barrel bombs, which has been documented, which led to massive destruction and indiscriminate civilian killings.

5:56And then finally, of course, the use of chemical weapons, which was widely documented during the war and which created a lot of international controversy. Back in 2012, President Obama had strong words about it. A red line for us is we start seeing a whole bunch of chemical weapons moving around or being utilized. That would change my calculus. A year later, chemical weapons were deployed against civilians in an attack attributed to the Assad regime. There was the use of sarin gas in Ghouta in 2013, where the US estimates that 1 ,400 people were killed, most of whom were civilians. scenes of horror in the rebel-held suburbs of Damascus.

6:41Scores of videos posted on the internet show something terrible has happened here. Experts have told the BBC that these appear to be symptoms of poisoning by chemical agents. There's almost no blood, but many are dead or dying. And then in 2018, there was the attack on Douma, which is also a suburb of Damascus and which was held by the rebels. and interestingly the organisation for the prohibition of chemical weapons had to wait two days in Damascus before it was allowed to enter the crime scene. We hope that they will be given access to the area by the government. It's a requirement of consent in situations like this.

7:22And by that point government forces had taken control of the area for at least 48 hours and many said at the time that they were trying to clean up the crime scene but governments around the world said that only Assad forces would have been capable of carrying out such an attack. And this is a pattern throughout the war of the Assad regime trying to conceal its crimes. Bashar al-Assad has always denied responsibility for these attacks. There was no order to make any attack. We don't have any chemical weapons. Even if we have them, we wouldn't use them. And we have never used our chemical arsenal in our history.

8:00There was also mass graves and instances of the regime moving bodies from different mass graves to try and cover up atrocities. Also instances of officers forging documents of inmates who died in detention to try and conceal what had happened. Then in December 2024, to the disbelief of those who lived the story, a major rebel offensive put an end to Assad's rule. Firas Kehlani, a senior BBC reporter himself from Syria, remembers every minute of it. At maybe 2 or 3 a.m. on the 8th of December, all Arabic news channels were reporting that there was something happening.

8:44We saw pictures for soldiers removing their military suits, throwing their weapons. So we knew I was just waiting on the other side of the borders. People were scared. I crossed the Lebanese border a few hours after he fled to Moscow and it was really one of the biggest shocks in my life because we couldn't find no security forces, no army, nothing. We couldn't believe that this moment would happen at any time.

9:15Seeing thousands of people celebrating in Damascus, Umayyad Square.

9:23shooting thousands and thousands of bullets to the air, celebrating. The Syrian TV was on the corner of the square. It stopped broadcasting. When Ahmad al-Shariq arrived to the Umayyad square with all those security guards, like the ones you see in videos released by extremists, we didn't know what to expect. People went to streets because they felt like, yeah, they look like extremists, but they are dealing with the civilians in a very nice way. It was a stunning development. Ahmed al-Shara, a man with a U.S. bounty on his head over his jihadist past, became president and would later even shake hands with Donald Trump in the White House.

10:05People said he's had a rough past. We all had rough pasts. But he has had a rough past, and I think, frankly, if you didn't have a rough past, you wouldn't have a chance. Assad and many of his generals vanished. Discovering their whereabouts takes painstaking open source investigative work. Claire Denning from our Russia team has been following the trail. Bashar al-Assad himself, the most notorious figure, he fled to Russia. On the 8th of December, Russian state news agency TASS released a report basically announcing that Assad had arrived in Russia for humanitarian reasons. Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov later confirmed Assad had been offered asylum purely on humanitarian grounds.

10:54We know from geolocation and plenty of OSINT investigations that many other officials are in Russia. On the 8th of December and after, the majority or the most important did with Assad. They kept flying from the Russian base in Latakia to Russia. So the biggest and the most important group is there, but others who managed to cross illegally to Lebanon, and we believe that there's still very big names of them there. We know that there are a lot of the wealthy people move with all their money to the UAE, and we saw pictures even for Bashar al-Assad's kids celebrating in the UAE. The New York Times did a lot of work investigating where Assad's clan and kind of associates had gone.

11:45And as part of the supporting evidence for one Assad official, they found that his wife had opened a Duolingo account in Russia and they managed to kind of use this as part of a way to track down someone. We also had a BBC investigation that was able to track down the head of the intelligence service under Assad, Hossam Lulka, and Russia. And they did that by scouring the abandoned properties of Syrian officials in the immediate aftermath of the fall of Assad. Equally interesting is what happened to Assad-era officials who didn't make it out. Some of the enforcers of the Assad government remain in Syria.

12:29Some of them are hiding in plain sight. But some of them have also managed to strike deals with the new authorities and to be integrated into the new Syrian state. Given the catalogs of crimes tests described, it's not surprising. They don't want anybody to know anything about them. But what can you glean from those digital breadcrumbs you find about what kind of life does the Assad clan enjoy in Russia? Assad family members appear to be living a life of absolute luxury and impunity. Quite shortly after Assad fell, he was seen, according to reports, in this very, very fancy Moscow restaurant called Restaurant 60 in the Moscow City Luxury Ultramodern Skyscraper Complex.

13:24and his brother was seen in the same complex smoking shisha in a bar. So are they free to move around as they please? There was one photo showing Assad walking around Moscow with his family but generally we can say they're lying low. There was one video of the son of Assad, Hafez al-Assad, who posted it on Telegram and he was walking around in Moscow city centre and sort of talking about his experience of being in Russia.

13:57That video was quickly taken down, and since then he hasn't posted anything. The Russian ambassador to Iraq, he did an interview with a Kurdish-Iraqi outlet called Rudawah.

14:14He talked about the fact that Assad had been banned from all public and political activity by the Kremlin. So it seems that his stay is kind of conditional on his silence. It seems like the Assads live in a golden cage while also getting the cold shoulder from their host behind the Kremlin wall. They have more than enough cash to maintain an ostentatious lifestyle, as independent journalists in Moscow have been finding out. There's a Russian investigative outlet called the Dossier Center, and they released a report in which they said that the Assad clan had acquired about$47 million worth of properties in Moscow alone.

15:04But Assad's wealth is estimated to be much, much greater than that. According to a US intelligence report, it's estimated at$1 to$2 billion. Syria is currently in such a severe state of economic collapse and devastation that you have 90 % of the Syrian population living in poverty on around$2 a day. It really puts into perspective the level of impunity, the amount of resentment there must be towards this family. Let's pick up on that resentment. How did Syrians feel when the regime was overthrown? We in BBC Monitoring were watching it all happen in real time on social media and even on state TV where you could see in real time rebels entering the studio and taking over.

15:55and I think it was a real mix of elation, jubilation, relief and also just sheer disbelief and some of the most moving scenes were of rebels freeing inmates from Said Naya, the human slaughterhouse and some of the inmates in these prisons, they had no idea that Assad had gone. You had people entering the prison just looking for any trace of their loved ones. It's rare to find a house in Syria who doesn't have one of their beloved or a neighbor or a friend arrested and disappeared. My uncle and his son were arrested on one of the checkpoints and they disappeared. My close friend, he is one of the most important lawyers defending human rights in Syria.

16:40He was arrested and disappeared. I can count at least 20. I know them personally. Then the second day after the fall of Assad, I visited the prison of Sadnaya. We have to stop the car about two kilometres away from the prison. It's because of the people heading there walking. And you can see just the heads of people, thousands of them, trying to enter the compound to find their beloved. Tens of thousands of people disappeared. They couldn't find them. Decisions made in Washington can affect your portfolio every day. But what policy changes should investors be watching? Washington Wise is an original podcast from Charles Schwab that unpacks the stories making news in Washington right now and how they may affect your finances and portfolio.

17:30Listen at schwab.com slash Washington Wise. That's schwab.com slash Washington Wise. You were listening to the documentary from the BBC World Service. The fall of the Assad dynasty brought hope for many, but also existential worries for others. It's also important to note that I think among some, especially minorities and the Alawite minority to which the Assad family belongs. There was also a lot of fear and uncertainty of any reprisal attacks. The group that took power, HTS, is a jihadist rebel group that has links to al-Qaeda. The president himself, Ahmad al-Sharaf, fought with al-Qaeda. There was also some apprehension about what life would look like for these minorities under rebel groups.

18:22And there have been instances of mass killings since then, notably in March 2025 of the Alawite civilians.

18:32The Alawite sect is an offshoot of Shia Islam and bakes up around 10 % of Syria's population. Last March, 1 ,400 Alawites were killed, according to Human Rights Watch. The violence started after Assad loyalists, who refused to give up arms, ambushed government forces. Then groups aligned with the government descended on the coastal area. An attack happened by the Assad's remnants, if you like, they call it this way in Syria. They killed almost 400 of the new security forces and the retaliation was really bad. A few months later, Druze areas became the focal point of violence under the gaze of the new administration.

19:15Outside the main hospital in Suweda city, The body bags look to be clear evidence of a mass killing, rotting in the baking sun for almost a week. The morgue, though, is full. The government went there to take control of the province and then the government troops retreated and then they allowed the Sinai tribes to attack. They killed almost 2 ,000 Druze people and they burned almost 35 villages. We saw it firsthand. I reported that we saw an ISIS cell at one of the entrances to the Sweda. There was a lot of jihadists, thousands of the tribes who have no rules. The best way you can imagine, like in the worst days of ISIS.

20:01You are listening to The Global Jigsaw from BBC Monitoring. The new authorities seem they are committed to delivering justice for Assad-era crimes as a means of bolstering their good guy credentials and earning legitimacy. A lot of their rule is built on just denouncing Assad and promising to deliver justice and accountability.

20:29And in many of Ahmad al-Shara's speeches, he focuses on Assad's crimes and what he subjected Syrians to for so long. They've created a commission for transitional justice, which is focused on exposing Assad's crimes and pursuing those responsible.

20:49And then there's the National Commission for Missing Persons. Some people estimate that it's 180 ,000 people who disappeared. It's building a national database to find out what happened. And that's going to be a massive task because, according to Syrian officials, there's more than 60 mass graves across the country. and it could take years to just exhume the remains and identify who was killed there.

21:17And then finally, these trials that we're seeing right now are just the first step in transitional justice. Some Syrian human rights activists have said that if we're going to proceed with transitional justice trials, then all groups who committed abuses during the war should face prosecution for human rights abuses. and that includes HTS, Shahra's group, because when they ruled their rebel enclave in Idlib during the war, they were accused of torture and executing inmates and cracking down on dissent. What is standing in the way of prosecuting the perpetrators for these crimes? What are the biggest difficulties in the process?

21:55There's many who fled to Lebanon, many in Moscow, and officials just roaming freely in Syria. And then there's also the legislation itself. Assad and his associates are being tried under the domestic penal law, which hasn't actually codified war crimes. Syrian authorities have argued that it could take a couple of years to pass through new legislation on war crimes and that there's a very urgent need to seek justice and accountability. Therefore, they're charging them with murder and torture and inciting killings.

22:34Many Syrians are also saying that it's almost insulting to the victims that these war criminals cannot be convicted of war crimes and crimes against humanity. Some even said that these trials have been kind of theatre to distract from other Assad-linked officials and businessmen who are quietly being reintegrated into the Syrian state. There is a lot of frustration over the accountability process only applying to these high profile figures and not to all of Assad's circle. Who are the people who are involved in the legal process? There are some really interesting figures involved.

23:17The judge himself, Fakhir al-Din al-Aryan, was actually a judge serving in the Assad regime and he publicly defected in 2013, which led to him being sentenced to death by the Assad authorities in absentia. He then served in the rebel enclave in Idlib trying to set up a parallel justice system. It's very symbolic of the dramatic reversal of power that a judge that was sentenced to death by the Assad authorities is now sentencing Assad himself to death. And then one of the prosecutors in the case, Nuhal Mastri, her brother was actually killed in a crackdown on protesters in Daraa in 2011.

23:59Tell us about the other people who have been sentenced. Of course, there's Bashar himself, but there's also his brother, Mahir al-Assad, who commanded the elite 4th Armored Division, which was accused of violent crackdowns on protesters in 2011. And Mahir al-Assad is also accused of being implicated in torture cases and of profiting from the multi-billion Captagon drug trade. And then there's Atif Najib standing trial in person. I think seeing him in the prison stripes is very symbolic. He cracked down on protests in Daraa in 2011.

24:43Which is widely viewed as the kind of cradle of the Syrian uprising.

24:50in. He's said to have overseen the arrest of schoolboys who had graffitied anti-Assad slogans and when the parents of these boys went to Najib himself, begged for mercy and asked for him to release their sons, he told them to forget about them and to go home and make new ones. Just to see him in that courtroom is very important to many Syrians who have personally suffered from his role in the civil war. Then there's also Assad's cousin, Wassiman Assad. And there's also the former grand mufti of Syria, Ahmed Hassoun, nicknamed the barrel mufti.

25:30Because he was accused of justifying the use of barrel bombs against civilians. And I'm sure many Syrians would like to see Bashar himself wearing a stripy outfit, but he's in a different country. So the death sentence in absentia, how does that affect the extradition process? Moscow wouldn't give him up, would they? I've been speaking with Roger Lou Phillips, who is the legal director of the Syrian Justice and Accountability Centre, who has years of expertise in transitional justice processes in Rwanda and in Cambodia, for example. And his take is that the capital punishment as a sentence does impact the likelihood of extradition.

26:14It's not necessarily contrary to the International Convention on Political and Civil Rights, as long as there's due process and as long as the sentence doesn't apply to a minor. In the European Convention of Human Rights, there's actually a ban on extraditing people to countries where they face the death penalty. Russia is no longer a party to the European Convention of Human Rights. Since 2022, Russia does have capital punishment, but it has moratorium on it. When it comes to extradition, I think is quite unlikely. But for Russia, the calculations, as you point out, will be completely different.

26:54Nothing to do with the legal basis on which a European country might say, well, no, we can't extradite because that means sending this person to a certain death. Russia has different reasons. Russia has a long relationship with Assad and for many years has been supporting his rule militarily and politically. It also has really critical strategic bases in Syria, so in Tartus and Humaymim Air Base.

27:28Russia will do, I think, everything it can to maintain access to those bases. And that involves getting along with the new authorities. But it seems like it's short of returning criminals. If Putin were to extradite Assad, what would it say to other leaders that Putin might in future want to make deals with? It would suggest that they're going to be betrayed. So I think from a reputational perspective, Putin has every reason to try to prevent any kind of extradition. And then there's also, I guess, a financial element. I don't think it's beyond assumption that there is some kind of financial benefit to Russia from Assad being there.

28:10And I think you could say potentially the same for the UAE or for other countries that have taken in Syrian generals. How is all of this reflected in the media in Syria, Tess? The trials, but also all the other issues and Moscow's cooperation or lack of cooperation when it comes to extraditing Assad. They've placed a lot more emphasis on the trials themselves and really portraying it as a victory for the Syrian people.

28:42They've not focused that much on the issues with the trials and the extradition, especially because from their side, Shara has also taken a pragmatic approach to Russia and meeting Putin and striking this deal on the future of the Russian bases.

29:02I think they've also been a bit careful about how much they want to condemn Russia and not returning Assad. And state media have also published a lot of videos of the arrests of Assad-era officials and officers, their prison stripes.

29:21Videos of them blindfolded as well, which has gone repeatedly viral on social media because I think they know that those visuals are so powerful and symbolic for many people. But it's also drawn some criticism because they're almost presented as clips from action movies sometimes. And people are saying this is not what due process and a fair and just trial looks like. And we don't want theatre, we want the real thing. And what about media in Russia? Is it at all talking about the justice in Syria? Russian state TV have been virtually silent on the verdict. You had a kind of two-line report from state news agency TASS on the day the verdict was passed, but it even forgot to mention that Assad is based in Russia at the moment.

30:08There has been commentary on Telegram among popular bloggers, but from officials, very, very little. In late August, the foreign ministry spokesperson Maria Zakharova was asked about Assad and potential for extradition.

30:31And she basically maintained that there was no political element to Assad being allowed to live in Russia. And Tess, what do people inside Syria make of these trials? I think for many, it's something that they never imagined they would see, even though Assad isn't present there. But it's for the first time breaking the cycle of impunity that for years just seemed, I guess, unbreakable. For many Syrians, especially those who suffered personally, it feels incredibly important to see this happening. And for those who are there in person, it's even more meaningful.

31:13We've had videos of people celebrating outside the courthouse in Damascus, holding up pictures of relatives who've been killed or disappeared during the war, and people crying after the death sentence was issued. But there's also frustrations. If you listen to the officials in Syria, they keep saying that it is a priority. But the problem is, for the Syrians, it's very slow. We witnessed the first bunch of sentenced to death. I know from officials in Syria that they have thousands of prisoners accused of committing atrocities against the Syrians. A bunch of them are very seniors, but the majority are not.

31:55They are normal soldiers or security forces. We have one of them who we know executed almost 40 civilians in an area called Atadamon. Amjad Yusuf, he killed them and he threw them in a hole and then he threw tires and burned them all. This is documented by himself. So we have thousands of people. They might be not different from Amjad. People are asking why until now we don't see them on trials. So it's a lot of crimes. The rape, the torture, the bombardment. The Al-Azhar in the east of the country is almost destroyed completely. So it's a lot. In June, there were protests across the country. People calling for greater accountability.

32:38Some were saying that in every town in Syria, there are still Assad loyalists hiding in plain sight. And some were even calling for revenge attacks. There were these leaflets distributed in Latakia, which is the Alawite heartland, saying if you're an Assad loyalist, leave, or will come and take care of you. I think there's a real sense of urgency that these people need to get justice imminently. Syrians more or less trust that the government is, Ahmad Shahra, he's serious in getting them to justice. But this is not the whole story because we know that there are other atrocities committed over the last two years against the Alawites and against the Druze.

33:17So these kind of frustrations and concerns that people in Syria feel about the process, Do you see them reflected in observations from experts, especially people who have already observed similar processes happening with other countries? Yeah, these concerns are definitely echoed by international legal and rights groups, the fact that proceedings and investigations were being rushed, and also that not only the international laws around crimes against humanity and war crimes not embedded in the Syrian domestic legal system, but also the judges presiding over these trials don't actually have the technical expertise to prosecute those specific crimes.

34:01that could also be a violation of a very fundamental aspect of law. The new authorities in Syria, they've drafted a transitional justice law, but they're also showing that they want this to be a Syrian enterprise, Syrian judges, Syrian prosecutors, Syrian defense, Syrian lawyers, because there is a lot of frustration in Syria and a lot of trauma associated with international foreign powers intervening in the country and also a lot of distrust of the UN, ad hoc tribunals that could be set up by the UN Security Council or hybrid tribunals. But the Syrian government is sort of between a rock and a hard place because on the one hand, they have to satisfy the Syrian people's need for justice.

34:48And on the other hand, they don't want necessarily to rely on international processes and they are trying to make it a Syrian process. You are listening to The Global Jigsaw from BBC Monitoring. Russia granted asylum to a whole group of Syrians. We spoke about Bashar al-Assad and his family. Who are the other Syrians in Russia? In 2025, there was 38 people who got refugee status and over 1 ,700 people who got temporary asylum. These were kind of unprecedented numbers if you look back to Russia's asylum acceptance rate throughout the Syrian civil war, which was extremely low. Let's get some clarity about the asylum process in Russia with Amalia Zatari, a journalist with BBC Russian who is half Russian, half Syrian.

35:43Russia has never been very generous in granting asylum. Before the revolution in Syria, Russia granted asylum just for four Syrians. When Assad regime fell, many Syrians came to Russia because they feared the new authorities or had some connections with the Syrian army or they were Alawites. And Russia granted permanent asylum for 38 people. And all are Syrians. And 1 ,870 Syrians got temporary asylum. So everyone who got a permanent refugee status in Russia in the year after Assad's fall were Syrians, right? What's the difference between temporary and permanent asylum? permanent asylum you can travel with you can work with the temporary one you have to renew every year i spoke to a russian non-profit organization called гражданское содействие who helps refugees and migrants in russia some of these people who get this temporary asylum last year, they get refusals now.

37:04The head of this NGO, Svetlana Ganushkina, told me that people might get refusal or might be granted asylum for the absolutely same reasons. I also talked to one Arabic translator in this NGO, and he told me that one of these 38 people is Syrian military Atashe, who worked in Syrian embassy in Moscow. For those not on the upper ladder of the Syrian emigre community in Russia, there was no red carpet treatment. They are encountering some problems, for example, with enrolling their children to Russian schools, because Russian authorities made just recently this law very strict and now just children who know Russian language can be enrolled and they even implemented some kind of exams which small kids should pass before being enrolled in school and if they fail they lose this opportunity.

38:13What local media and investigative outlets have reported is that most of these people who got refugee status were high ranking senior officials who managed to strike a deal with the Russian government. And then the people who got temporary asylum, many of them were maybe working on the air bases with Russian forces. Many of them speak Russian, maybe they are involved in some way with the Russian presence in Syria. But some of them also may have been fleeing some of the violence that was happening in the Alawite heartland. And they may have fled to the Russian air bases and then been evacuated from there.

38:53It is a bit of a mix. And that is also reflected in how they've been treated since they arrived. You have on the one hand, these extreme luxury apartments in which senior Assad officials and Assad's family are residing in. But on the other hand, you have people housed in temporary accommodation. There have been reports of not having good access to health care or food. There was a local outlet in Omsk that reported on the Syrian general who was living in a very, very small rural area of Russia. He was showing the reporters around his house where he had a potato patch and was growing roses and was talking about how he was just going to try to integrate into Russian society and kind of be a regular guy there.

39:42The lives of these regime loyalists abroad are still more comfortable compared to most people back in Syria. There's a lot of frustration and anger about all these officials having fled. But I think that a lot of people are also just preoccupied, still grappling with the consequences of the war and trying to rebuild their homes. It's a mammoth task of rebuilding the whole country. In June, we witnessed a spike in protests across the country just over power cuts and rising fuel prices. And there's also among some some fears that we might be seeing the same Assad era tactics re-emerging. The Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, which is a war monitor, has documented dozens of cases since Assad fell of people dying from mistreatment or torture while in detention under the new authorities.

40:32There's also concerns about not repeating the same kind of patterns of human rights violations, repression and corruption as what we saw under Assad. Of course, it's really concerning. But I think it is also important to note that these criminal trials and this transitional justice process has attracted criticism. And that criticism has been expressed vocally by Syrians. They've been protesting. And that reality was unthinkable under Assad. We wouldn't want to be naive about the situation, but it is a change happening. And I guess there is unprecedented justice process going ahead. There's never, ever been in history people who were responsible for chemical weapons being used, being put on trial and held to account for violating international law.

41:22I think there are things that we can hold on to despite the messiness and the complications of the current situation. Delivering justice promptly would be an almost impossible job for the most seasoned politicians. And Ahmed al-Shara is still a newcomer. A country like Syria, full of ethnicities, different sects and religions. There's a lot of Christians, there's Druze, Alawites, Ismailis, Kurds, Arabs. You can't control it. And he's trying. A few weeks ago, he changed some of the commanders from here to there, from here to there. He might give them at some points stronger positions in the hierarchy.

41:58but they lost their faction. You know the country for 14 years, it was separate islands everywhere. So the country is shattered. It needs a lot of time. I still believe he is trying, but I don't know if he's going to succeed. And the country is still very weak and the future is not clear. Achieving justice for crimes of this scale could take many years, if not decades. Examples from the past, whether in Cambodia, the former Yugoslavia, Rwanda or Guatemala, suggest that for millions of Syrians, there might be a long way ahead.

42:39This is the documentary from the BBC World Service. Thank you to Claire Denning, Tess Malinda-Heron, Feraz Kilani and Amalia Zatari. Claire and Tess joined the production team for this edition, alongside Krista Chattery and me, Krasivan Overtwig. The sound engineer is Hal Haynes. And if you want to find out more about BBC Monitoring, our department, you can do so by visiting our website, monitoring.bbc.co.uk. And thank you for listening.

43:19Thank you.

From the publisher

With perpetrators in exile, closure is out of reach. As Syria’s new authorities seek to hold figures of the former regime accountable, questions remain over the fate of Bashar al-Assad. The former president and members of his inner circle were granted asylum in Russia after a rebel offensive drove him from power in 2024. The transition ushered in a new chapter for Syria, raising hopes for justice, after decades of repression. The Global Jigsaw assesses the obstacles standing in the way of accountability, justice and closure. Can victims of Assad’s brutal reign find redress when some of the regime’s most notorious figures remain beyond the reach of Syrian courts?

Find out more about BBC Monitoring on our website: https://monitoring.bbc.co.uk/

Contributors: Tess Mallinder Heron, Clare Denning, Feras Kilani, Amalia Zatari Producer: Clare Denning, Tess Mallinder Heron, Kriszta Satori Presenter: Krassi Ivanova Twigg Music: Pete Cunningham

More from The Documentary Podcast

All episodes