1. Podcasts
  2. The Documentary Podcast
  3. The tyre scandal
The Documentary Podcast

12 Jun 2025 · 27m · 13 chapters

In short

The BBC investigates what happens to UK end-of-life tyres after garages collect them, arguing that a “black market” export route sends baled tyres to illegal, low-grade pyrolysis sites in India, causing toxic pollution, illness, and deaths.

Guests (people featured)

  • Paul Kenyon (BBC presenter/investigator).
  • Anna Meisel (producer).
  • Elliot Mason (World Rubber Recycling, Northamptonshire; tyre recycler family business).
  • “Charles” (anonymous insider broker/recycler; tracker experiment).
  • Peter Taylor (head of UK Tyre Recovery Association).
  • Janovi Mule (BBC Indian Languages; reports from near pyrolysis plants).
  • Sanjay Ishwant Pati (village resident; health and farming impacts).
  • Kalpesh Patil (local activist; describes tyre burning and a fatal explosion).
  • Georgia Elliot-Smith (Fighting Dirty; studied links to organised crime and diversion rates).
  • Lena Goodman (CEO, Tyre Stewardship Australia; describes Australia’s crackdown).

Key claims/examples

  • UK pays an environmental disposal fee, but much waste is diverted: UK government estimates ~50% exported to India (~25 million tyres/year).
  • Trackers in baled tyres show shipments bypassing legal recycling and going to rural pyrolysis clusters.
  • A January 29 explosion killed two children and injured workers; nearby families live in tin shelters.
  • Scientists (Imperial College London) warn of respiratory, cardiovascular, neurological disease and cancer risks.
  • Australia banned export of baled tyres in 2021 after audits found 100% of material went to wrong destinations.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:39

The Cost of Tyre Disposal

Exploring the fees and realities of tyre disposal in the UK.

“Most of us in the UK have a car and most of us at some stage need to get our tyres changed.”
2:49

Journey to a Tyre Recycling Facility

Paul visits a tyre recycling facility to uncover the recycling process.

“That£3, or around US$4, is a fee we all pay for someone to pick up our tyre waste and dispose of it responsibly.”
4:50

Profitability of Baling vs. Recycling

Discussion on why some recyclers opt for exporting tyres instead of recycling.

“The first thing that happens is he goes into this shredder over here, which has got a big grab on it, picks up the tyres and drops them into the shredder.”
6:46

Exporting Tyres: The Hidden Truth

Investigating the illegal export of waste tyres and its implications.

“dollars rather than the million or so for the recycling shredder.”
8:10

Tracking the Journey of Baled Tyres

Follow the attempted tracking of exported tyres to uncover their fate.

“He's baled loads of tyres and exported them.”
12:01

Pyrolysis Plants and Environmental Hazards

Exploring the conditions and dangers of unregulated tyre pyrolysis in India.

“And what about these pools of black water that we keep seeing?”
14:00

Arrival in Masami Village

The team arrives in the dusty village of Masami and begins observations.

“A couple of hours outside Mumbai, the team are nearing their destination.”
14:40

Local Residents' Health Concerns

Residents express health issues caused by pollution from nearby pyrolysis plants.

“I've seen the footage filmed at the time by Janavi and her cameraman.”
17:20

Explosion at the Pyrolysis Plant

A local activist recounts a devastating explosion at a pyrolysis plant.

“Earlier this year, on January the 29th, his worst nightmare suddenly became a reality.”
19:40

Environmental Risks of Pyrolysis Plants

Experts discuss the health risks associated with pyrolysis plants and local regulations.

“They also said that the mix of metals and toxic chemicals in tyres is of particular concern with this source of pollution.”
Show all 13 chapters
22:34

The Global Tyre Disposal Crisis

Discussion on the illegal tyre disposal practices affecting India from the UK.

“You can get up to three times more than if you sell them for recycling.”
25:41

Call to Action and Responsibility

Local garage owner reacts to the footage of pollution from UK tyres in India.

“there's been no Australian-style response.”
28:00

Reflections on the Tyre Scandal

Learn about the emotional impact and awareness surrounding the tyre scandal in India.

“I really, really feel guilty and I'm sorry for the local people in India.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On The Documentary Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30goals, or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. Imagine buying a toy for your kid, but it doesn't come with batteries. That sucks. But honestly, it's even worse when you buy business software. You end up with fragmented, disconnected systems that cost a fortune and don't talk to each other. Odoo completely changes that. Odoo comes fully complete, with all your business apps perfectly integrated and working together seamlessly. It's everything your business needs in one place, saving you time, headaches and serious money. Stop paying for missing pieces.

1:07Go to odoo.com. That's odoo.com to learn more.

1:15Welcome to the documentary from the BBC World Service. I'm Paul Kenyon and I'm investigating what happens to our vehicle tyres when we throw them away. You'd be forgiven for assuming they're all recycled. After all, we pay a small levy in the UK to make that happen. But it's not always the case. So I'm going to take you on a pretty wild journey into a little known black market that feeds off our tyre waste, causing huge environmental damage and even death.

1:49Most of us in the UK have a car and most of us at some stage need to get our tyres changed. I'm here. Let's see if Eddie's around.

2:06Eddie! How are you? How are you? Very good to see you. I need my ties changed. Yeah, sure, sure. Let's check it out. OK, just have a quick look. What do you make of them? I think this one's a bit worn, isn't it? Yeah, this one. Yeah. OK. Let me have a look at the other one, because it's always best to change two. Yeah, I think we need two new tyres.

2:32OK, I need the bill. We're just in the back office at the moment. Eddie's just preparing the bill. This is the total price. That's the tyre price, and then that's the environmental disposal fee. £3 per tyre, you see that's£6. I'm afraid you've got to pay because we've disposed the tyre. That£3, or around US$4, is a fee we all pay for someone to pick up our tyre waste and dispose of it responsibly. But we can reveal the awful truth behind our export of tyre pollution to the developing world and the untold damage it's causing to people's health. You're listening to the documentary on the BBC World Service with me, Paul Kenyon.

3:18But when they take it away, where does it go next? It goes to the big warehouse, but I've never been or never seen. Is the truth of it that most garages don't really know? Exactly. And this is like a secret. I like to find that myself. I'm off to discover where tyres go next. And believe me, it's a wild journey. So this is really a massive, unrecognised problem and something that the UK really does need to deal with. because the way in which it's being handled at the moment is hugely harmful. How many people in the industry know this is happening? I don't imagine there's anybody in the industry that doesn't know it's happening.

4:07We produce a staggering amount of waste tyres each year in the UK. Their disposal has always been challenging. Me and my producer, Anna Meisel, are on our way to meet one of the UK's biggest tyre recyclers to find out how they do it. I can see loads of deals of tyres further down here, where they're all stacked up.

4:32Elliot? Hi. Hi, Paul. Hi, Paul. Nice to meet you. Nice to meet you. Hi, this is Anna. Just tell us where we are. So we're in Rushton, Northamptonshire, World Rubber Recycling. Elliot Mason's family have run this place for more than 20 years. So this is a shredding machine, which I haven't seen one of these before. The first thing that happens is he goes into this shredder over here, which has got a big grab on it, picks up the tyres and drops them into the shredder. And out from there comes long strips of rubber. The strips are then fed into more steaming and groaning machinery. In short, Elliot's shredding equipment can make tyres into rubber crumbs of any size you fancy.

5:16And they're heaped into a pile like a mountain of licorice sweets higher than the house. The rubber crumb has a valuable second life, used for things like surfacing children's playgrounds and the soft floors of equestrian centres. So Elliot, the thing that strikes me here is the scale of this. It's a huge operation. How much have you invested? I would think to go and replace what we've got now with all new machinery, it would probably be somewhere two and a half to three and a half million. The profits used to be big enough to make the cost of shredding worthwhile, but not anymore. And now we're getting to the heart of things.

5:55The money's drained out of recycling our tyres because they're being rerouted somewhere else. In Elliot's office, over mugs of steaming tea, he tells us a shocking fact that few outside the industry know anything about. We would make more money if we switched off all the machines and just exported the tyres. And there is several of our competitors that have shredding machines that have done just that. What, just shut down? Just switched off the shredders and just bailing and exporting. That's because they can make more money out of bailing and exporting rather than recycling. Baling just means squashing tyres into giant blocks, a bit like bales of hay only made of rubber and weighing tonnes.

6:41The machinery to do it costs less than 70 ,000 US dollars rather than the million or so for the recycling shredder. Then they sell the bales without the bother of doing any recycling at all. But if it's more profitable, just explain to people why you won't do it, it'd be very easy just to bail up the tyres here and send them abroad. Because bales in particular are very difficult to track where they go and where they actually end up. The duty of care that we have means that we are responsible for the waste until it is no longer classed as a waste. So there's a good chance my tyres have been squashed into bales and sold to a broker who'll then sell them abroad.

7:28That's where the money is. The UK government estimates we export about 50 % of our waste tyres to India. That's a staggering 25 million of them a year. 350 ,000 tonnes, equivalent to the weight of the Empire State Building. But there are supposed to be strict rules around these exports. The UK is a signatory to the Basel Convention, which regulates the movement of hazardous waste from developed to less developed countries, or at least it's meant to. Together with a team of journalists from Source Material, a not-for-profit group specialising in climate and corruption, we decided to track exactly where our baled tyres are going.

8:15This guy has done an experiment. He's baled loads of tyres and exported them. My producer, Anna, and I found an insider willing to help. And he's put truckers in the tyres. Ah, so we can see the signals somewhere coming down from the satellite. Yeah, we can basically follow the truckers. We can see where exactly they want. Yeah. We meet our contact at the BBC offices in London. He wants to remain anonymous. It's a tight-knit industry and there's no shortage of criminal gangs. So these are his words spoken by an actor. We'll call him Charles. You would know, if you're a tyre recycler in the UK, you would know what's going on.

8:55And either you choose to partake or you do it properly, legitimately. So how many people choose to do it properly, do you think, realistically? Very few. So we had our suspicions through conversations with brokers that these tyres were going to pyrolysis. Pyrolysis. It's a word you're going to hear a lot. It involves cramming bales of tyres into something like a huge pressure cooker, where they're heated to a high temperature, around 500 degrees Celsius, without oxygen. The process reduces the tyres to their constituent parts, producing a little oil, which is used in the aviation industry, as well as steel.

9:37Fine when done in multi-million dollar facilities with tight regulation, but if it's not done properly it can be very dangerous indeed. Anyway, let's get back to Charles's experiment. We decided to put trackers in bales and send them in containers on an eight-week journey. The trackers emitted a digital signal from Charles's baled tyres and eventually we could see the route on our laptops. They'd been on an epic journey. Down the Atlantic and through the Straits of Gibraltar, across the Med, along the Suez Canal, and on to India. Remember, these could have been your waste tyres being sailed halfway round the world.

10:28So you can see the data from these trackers, and they're pinging up there on the map. And look, you can see that's the route they took. They get into India, and then they're supposed to be going to that recycling plant. Yeah, and if that had happened, then it would have been perfectly legal because it's fine to import tyres for recycling to India, but it's illegal to import them for the purpose of producing pyrolysis oil. But if you watched the tracker, it went straight past that recycling plant where it's supposed to go and off into the Indian countryside. An Indian cameraman followed the route.

11:07Finally, after more than 1 ,000 kilometres, they arrived at a cluster of rudimentary industrial plants in the countryside. The cameraman sent up a drone to see inside and we got an expert to analyse the footage back in London. This looks to be a low-grade pyrolysis operation of the sort I thought had been already banned by the Indian authorities. That's the distinctive voice of Peter Taylor, head of the body that represents the tyre recovery industry in the UK. He suspected this was happening, but never had the proof, and he's visibly shocked. It's messy. There's detritus all over the place. We can see blackened yards containing what look like old boilers, every space stacked high with waste tyres.

11:57The surrounding area is covered in soot. And I think what we're looking at there is literally 100, 200 metres away. That's a village, isn't it? And no doubt the workers from that village are working these operations and not only subject to high levels of pollution in the workplace, but given the proximity of these homes, they will also be subject to really poor air quality as well. And what about these pools of black water that we keep seeing? These are oil spillages, I suspect, and perilous to human health. You're listening to The Documentary from the BBC World Service. We approached one of the companies.

12:38With the new Schwab Teen Investor Account, teens can gain hands-on investing experience and build positive money habits. It's an account co-owned by you and your teen, so you can monitor and engage with the account while your teen learns how to invest and manage money. Learn more at schwab.com. In that cluster of plants, they confirmed they were processing some imported tyres but said what they were doing wasn't dangerous or illegal. The tyre's paperwork said it was going to an Indian recycling company called Nine Corporation, the country's second biggest importer of UK waste tyres. We contacted Nine Corporation to ask them to explain, but they didn't respond.

13:22So we're going to have to find out for ourselves. Janovi Mule works for BBC Indian Languages in Mumbai, and she's agreed to travel to a cluster of pyrolysis plants just outside the city. In fact, we've been told there are around 2 ,000 pyrolysis plants in India and more than half of them are unregistered. In other words, no one's monitoring them. Some call it the Wild West of tyre recycling. We know from our research that British and European tyres end up at the place Janavie is about to visit. Hello, good morning. Good morning.

14:07This is Shahid. Hi, Shahid. And that is Ahmed. Ahmed. He's our driver. Good morning, everyone. Good morning. A couple of hours outside Mumbai, the team are nearing their destination. We are entering the village and the road has gotten very dusty.

14:29I can see there are pyrolysis plants. I can count up to 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 chimneys from here. I've seen the footage filmed at the time by Janavi and her cameraman. It shows tall, smoking chimneys, fields covered in thick, oily soot. people filthy with pollution. Our team reached the village of Masami. This is early morning. There are women and men going about their work. Then hens and chickens are running. It's a small street that leads to a few homes. I can see there is dried grass that is stocked up in front of a buffalo shed. Sir, what is your name? My name is Sanjay Ishwant Pati.

15:22I have a lot of problems with the farming. Basically, the dust problem is a major problem and smell. Sanjay is a former engineer who's returned to his childhood home to retire and grow mango trees. He can see the pyrolysis plants from the veranda of the home he shares with his ailing father. He's around 93 years old. He's having some throat problem, smelling problem. He's complaining about the heaching of eyes. like that. Every day you have to take to the hospitals. Sanjay has dug a small lake for irrigation during the parched summer months close to the pyrolysis plants. The water here has turned green and I can see some layer of chemical looks like an oil so there are no more fish in the pond and they can't really use this water for agricultural purposes as well.

16:19Word was getting around that the BBC were in town, and another frightened neighbour joined the team for tea. It's really affecting our children's health. They keep getting sore throat, cough, cold, runny nose. My son got a very itchy rash on his skin and was unwell for a month. They're worried that these makeshift factories are so badly constructed, eventually, under immense pressure and heat, one of them might explode. Janna V has arranged to meet a local activist who knows more than most, Kalpesh Patil. See, there are about 16 to 17 plants in the area. And it all began about five years ago, when there were just one or two.

17:11You know, these people, they bring tyres from other countries, scrap tyres, mostly from Europe. and they burn them all night and release toxic gas when we are all sleeping. Earlier this year, on January the 29th, his worst nightmare suddenly became a reality. I heard a very loud noise. It was so loud, I can't describe it. My mother was working in a field and she witnessed the explosion. She called me and said it's huge and there's lots of smoke. I ran there straight away. The whole place was alight, throwing chemicals and carbon into the sky. Most worryingly of all, there was a family living inside the plant in a tin shed right next to where the explosion happened.

18:05Huge plumes of black smoke were rising in the air and there was fire too. Two women workers, one male worker and two small children suffered heavy burns.

18:20Janabies just sent me a video which was taken in the immediate aftermath of that explosion, the pyrolysis plant. And, yeah, there's a big crowd that's gathered around. They pulled the children out of that tin hut. There were some kids in there. And you can see they're really badly burned. They've got towels draped over them. And people are trying to help them and they look stunned and they're in tears. It's really disturbing stuff. And these are the two children who later died. Following the blast, a minister for the district of Wada promised the local government would take action. Seven pyrolysis plants have since been shut down.

19:02If they had listened, lives might have been saved. We want these companies evicted from our village. Otherwise, we will not be able to breathe freely. We will continue breathing polluted air. His instinct is not wrong. We consulted scientists at a leading British university, the Imperial College London. They told us that workers who have continued exposure to the atmospheric pollutants from these kinds of pyrolysis plants risk respiratory, cardiovascular and neurological diseases and certain types of cancer. They also said that the mix of metals and toxic chemicals in tyres is of particular concern with this source of pollution.

19:50Janavi and the team set off to inspect inside the cluster of pyrolysis plants where the people died. I can see old boilers and rickety piping under tin roofs. There are makeshift tin shelters where families are still living and I can see their children, they are picking up bits of tyres and playing in the dust. They are all covered in soot. The images that our team filmed are shocking. To think that the tyre I dropped off at my local garage at the start of this programme might be fuelling this crisis is quite chilling. And some of the pyrolysis plants are still operating, even though it's just a few weeks since explosion.

20:38The air around here smells of chemicals and it feels so stuffy. It's illegal in India to import tyres for pyrolysis from the UK or anywhere else in the world. We invited the owners of the plant that exploded to explain their side of the story, but they never got back to us. I'm getting out of here. It's really getting hard to breathe. Oh, God.

21:10Back in London, more than 9 ,000 kilometres away from the site of that fatal explosion, I've come to meet Georgia Elliot-Smith, who runs an environmental pressure group called Fighting Dirty and who's studied this issue closely. The problem with end-of-life tyres is that at the moment, The situation is such a wild west. We believe that about 70 % of the tyres entering India are being diverted for very low-grade disposal, essentially burning. It's a huge figure. For the UK alone, that would mean 17 million of our waste tyres go to makeshift pyrolysis plants in India every year. We're the second largest exporter to India after the United States.

21:57This is a global issue. Essentially, this is an illegal trade that's a race to the bottom in terms of cost. So the cost of disposing of waste tyres abroad is incredibly cheap. And we have evidence of links to organised crime as well. This is an incredibly profitable model of getting rid of UK waste to unregulated illegal sites where it's causing enormous harm to workers, local communities and the environment. The incentive to sell bale tyres abroad is obvious. You can get up to three times more than if you sell them for recycling. There's evidence that we've been able to very easily get hold of to demonstrate that these shipments are going to incredibly polluting sites and we believe that those exporters are aware and that they are actively utilising these loopholes and the poor regulation to make enormous profits.

22:58The fact is that the true destination of British tyres isn't properly checked at all. Why? Because tyres are classified as green waste, which means non-hazardous. Now the fascinating twist in all of this is that it's happened before. Another country's been through the whole thing and managed to sort it out. Melbourne, Australia, 2019. As the Australian Grand Prix got underway and Formula One cars burnt rubber on the starting grid, in a quiet office in another part of the city, Lena Goodman was grappling with the fact that Australia's waste tyres were disappearing, being sold to the developing world, mainly India.

23:45I'm the CEO of tyre stewardship, Australia and we are set up to essentially find solutions for tyres once they reach end of life. Lena was trying to understand why bale tyres were being exported for huge bucks. No one could categorically tell me what was happening to that material. Even legitimate operators who were sending that material overseas and working perhaps with brokers or third parties to send their material, they also didn't know. We were relying on the paperwork that said that it was going to certain destinations in India and once we prodded and checked, we realised that there were actually greater concerns with where that material was going.

24:27Prodding and checking Australian style meant not just planting trackers in tyres, no, it meant sending teams into the field to physically check where the tyres were going. They'd thought it was for recycling because that's what is said on the paperwork. But when they arrived to check, the facilities were shut. Sadly, when we sent auditors to a lot of the places we thought material was going to, nobody was there. What kind of proportion of tyres did they find were being used illegitimately, if you like? 100 % of the material was not going to the destinations that was on the paperwork. 100 %? Correct.

25:05Faced with incontrovertible evidence, the Australian government moved fast. they banned the export of all baled tyres in 2021. You do need to get rid of the tyres but you don't have to get rid of them by baling them and exporting them. You at least need to process that material. By processing the tyre you can be guaranteed that its use is going to be better than its use if it was baled. But despite UK recyclers handing reams of complaints and evidence to the British government about what's happening, there's been no Australian-style response. It is extremely frustrating. Peter Taylor from the Tyre Recovery Association is always knocking on the UK government's door.

25:52The government doesn't deliver. There is an inertia at the heart of government, and particularly it has to be said definitely at the present time, that needs somehow to be unblocked. Successive secretaries of state have just not been willing to give this issue the importance it deserves. So we went to the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, DEFRA, and asked them what was going on. We told them about the trackers. We explained how India can't be recycling all these tyres, it just doesn't have the capacity. We told them about the seams of toxic pollution caused by UK tyres. They told us they have strict controls over the waste we export and they say they want to protect our natural environment.

26:41So what about the Environment Agency, a body tasked with regulating and investigating waste-related crime in England and Wales? Well, they said they take all of this very seriously. So seriously, they've now launched a comprehensive review into shipments of waste tyres from the UK to India. It's due to report at the end of this month. Eddie, how are you? Very good to see you. Thank you for your way to... No, it's OK. Shall we go inside? I've got something to show you. Remember Eddie from the start of all this? He changed my tyres and said we should let him know if we ever discovered where they actually went.

27:22We showed him some of the footage from India. I don't think this is in UK, is it? No, so this is India. Oh, India. These are UK tyres being taken to this place in sort of mid-northern India. And these are pyrolysis plants. Look at the smoke. This is environmentally, honestly, this is a disaster. This is frightening. So what do you think about when we pay the levy that obviously you charge and all other garages charge to have them disposed up properly? If it's ending up a disaster, awful situations like this, I really, really feel guilty and I'm sorry for the local people in India. I can see you're concerned when you see those pictures and everybody should be, shouldn't they?

28:12Definitely. I'd be glad if some other people see this as well, other garages. How important is it to know this? Very important. I'm shocked what I'm seeing. I wasn't expecting to this scare. It's awful. It's really horrible. The documentary was presented by me, Paul Kenyon. The producer was Anna Meisel.

From the publisher

Every year the UK produces around 50 million tyres for disposal. They are supposed to be sent for recycling. Instead, big money is being made by diverting tyres to illegal and dangerous 'pyrolysis' plants where they are melted down to extract oil and steel. Together with a team of journalists from Source Material, a not-for-profit group specialising in climate and corruption, we follow the tyres from the UK to India using tracking devices. The team discovers just how large scale this largely illicit business has become. Earlier this year, a makeshift pyrolysis plant exploded near Mumbai, killing four people. It had been processing tyres from abroad. Reporter Paul Kenyon confronts a tyre trader in the north of England who admits to shipping his waste tyres to India for pyrolysis.

More from The Documentary Podcast

All episodes