


The episode examines why birth rates are falling worldwide, framing it as a “global baby bust” driven by financial pressures, delayed family formation, and changing social/technological habits. It argues that humanity is already below replacement level and that the decline accelerated around 2015. Guests include Recy and Sean, a Wyoming couple who both work full time and have decided not to have children due to high childcare costs, paycheck-to-paycheck living, housing and grocery pressures, and Recy’s polycystic ovarian syndrome. Anna Rotkir, director of the Population Research Institute in Finland, claims mobile phones/social media and more fragile partnerships contribute to childlessness, often unwanted, and that family policies can’t easily fix “family formation.” Susanna Mackay, Hungary’s Deputy State Secretary for Family Policy, discusses Hungary’s subsidy experiment, noting fertility rose then fell, with weak long-term assessment and the need to address poverty traps and high mortality. Examples: Finland’s baby box and welfare amid record-low fertility; Hungary’s Orban-era incentives (1.2 to 1.6 then back to 1.3).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Recy and Sean discuss their choice to not have children due to financial pressures.
“This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.”
Recy and Sean discuss their choice to not have children due to financial pressures.
“I know that we're making the right choice for ourselves.”
Examining global birth rate trends and the factors influencing them.
“I'm Rob Young and today I'm looking at the fall of the number of babies being born.”
Discussing Hungary's approach to increasing birth rates and family policies.
“Since the 1980s, rich countries have dramatically increased what they spend on things like child benefits, childcare and parental leave.”
Explore Hungary's prolonged low fertility rates and government targets.
“We have now had low fertility in Hungary for more than 40 years.”
Discussion on the criticisms of Hungary's family policy and economic factors.
“And there was many criticism from experts that the system lacked long-term stability and scientifically grounded impact assessment.”
Analyze how economic changes impact fertility rates in Hungary.
“employment rates in Hungary, in average income.”
Address the dual issue of fertility and high mortality in Hungary.
“Susanna Mackay, Deputy State Secretary at Hungary's Ministry of Social and Family Affairs.”
Recy and Sean share their personal decisions about not having children.
“thinking about what they might need to change their mind about not having kids and for the future?”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Documentary Podcast, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30goals, or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. Odoo, providing tools for businesses across industries into one fully integrated platform. Whatever your business needs, Odoo is committed to providing it. Learn more at odoo.com.
1:00Hello and welcome to the documentary from the BBC World Service. I'm Rob Young. Today, the global baby bust. Why birth rates are falling almost everywhere. It's partly down to financial pressures. I know that we're making the right choice for ourselves. We can't give, at this point, children the life that we both feel like they deserve. While governments have tried to reverse the trend, the results are mixed. You asked me about a crisis. Whatever world we use, this is happening. Humanity is already below replacement level and there are fewer babies born every year. That's coming up on Business Daily, exploring how work and money impact people around the world.
1:58And I try to make sense but I can't get you out of my mind This band is rehearsing in a basement in a town in Wyoming in the United States.
2:13The group is called Frin. The singer is Recy, on drums her partner Sean. They both work full time and perform two nights a week. What they don't have and have decided for now they won't have is children. The couple met as students on a film course at university. I sat down next to him in the theatre before an audition for a show and I said, OK, so are we going to be best friends now? And he said, sure. And then the rest was history. Sean, you, when you were younger, imagined that you might have a very big family. Is that right? Yeah. So I grew up in a family of six kids. So always had it on my mind that I would kind of continue that.
2:59Like both my parents came from big families as well. But currently, with the circumstances as they are, whenever we talk about the possibility of kids, it's like, well, it can't be right now. And probably not in the near future either. We've really started to enjoy our lives as just without children. You know, we have three or four dogs in our home that we love pretty much as children. Yeah, it's kind of something that has eluded us just from like financial reasons. Also, just like the culture of our time. Risi, just talk me through some of the financial difficulties you think there might be if children were to come along.
3:37Both of us have older sisters who have multiple children. and we've seen firsthand just how expensive it can be, especially if you are both working parents. Trying to afford child care is really difficult, and there's not a lot of support around us. We're both living a little bit paycheck to paycheck. It is very difficult to be able to pay for things like housing, along with groceries, with the rising grocery costs. trying to just fuel your vehicle to travel to and from work. What was it like when you came to this decision, Recy, that you wouldn't actively try to have a family? The emotions involved, there's two that you kind of go between.
4:26One is almost a feeling of relief because this pressure, especially as a woman, It feels like you've been released of a pressure to take on a role that can be very taxing and can historically has prevented a lot of women from being able to pursue careers. There is this huge sense of grief and perhaps guilt that goes along with that. And I was aware from the time I was around 16 years old that it would be incredibly difficult for me to be able to reproduce and become pregnant because I have polycystic ovarian syndrome. So I've always kind of known that perhaps children were out of reach, but to really solidify it has been a little bit painful.
5:21And I love and cherish every child that's in my life. And sometimes you go over to a family member's house and you're holding their brand new beautiful baby and you think to yourself, man, am I missing out? Should I rethink this? And then you look at all of the other factors involved that goes into it. I know that we're making the right choice for ourselves. We can't give at this point children the life that we both feel like they deserve. That to me is a good reason not to pursue parenthood, not because you feel like you should do it or it's something that's expected of you, especially as a woman, but because you want to do it and also because you can give them the best life possible.
6:07And so for us, that's just not in the cards for us right now. Recy and Sean in Wyoming. We'll hear from them again later.
6:40about why we do the things we do and how to make better choices to help avoid costly mistakes. Each episode covers the latest research in behavioral science and dives into themes like the power of self-control, shaping your mindset for success, navigating new beginnings, and why starting over can feel so hard. Listen to choiceology at schwab.com slash podcast or wherever you listen.
7:12You're listening to the documentary from the BBC World Service. I'm Rob Young and today I'm looking at the fall of the number of babies being born. Recy and Sean's reasons for not having kids are not purely an American story. For the global population to replace itself, women need to have about 2.1 children each. It's about 2.2 now, so right on the line, and some demographers think we've already crossed below it. Since about 2015, the decades-long decline has quickened. Birth rates were falling because couples had fewer children. Some say they're now declining because there are fewer couples. So is this a crisis?
7:53Anna Rotkia is director of the Population Research Institute in Finland in Northern Europe. We are at unprecedented, unpredicted, rapid change levels. And for sure, we already see a crisis. I personally live in one of the most aged countries with a very low fertility and I have a hard time seeing the upsides, but I'm sure there are some. What do you think are the main reasons? Well, there are the concerns we have had, you know, for the last century, which are easy to understand. A stable income, finishing your education, having somewhere to live. These are always there. But the new thing is technological change and the changed environment where we spend our free time, get our values, meet and interact with peers, i.e.
8:45the phones and social media. We now know that this latest dip, which, as you say, is really quite global, is associated with the spread of mobile phones and social media. What is your sense of whether some of these social and technological factors are playing a bigger part in people's decision not to have children compared to the economic factors such as incredibly expensive housing, the precariousness of some modern forms of work, for example? Firstly, we have quite high ages at having the first child. And this means that any, for instance, unemployment or crisis, which is likely to signal to young adults, oh, wait, wait, wait, now it's uncertain, you should wait a bit.
9:30Well, they don't have many years to wait. In many countries, young adults spend at least two hours, often four or five, on social media of their free time. This means that the signals and the values and the people they interact with are online. And I really think we have underestimated how this changes our social fabric. And so is it the case that teenagers, people in their early 20s, don't want to have children? Of service that it's the right partner has become a more way more important challenge. And we know that the partnerships of young adults have grown more fragile. There is also a value change in Finland.
10:12People who say they don't want children at all has grown from around 4 % to around 12%. But it's it's still a minority. So both in Europe and globally, most people want to have a stable partnership, marriage, and most people want to have a child. And the kind of big trend now is growth in childlessness, most of it unwanted. And that's the key driver of fertility decline currently. You're having a baby! Wow! Is this a baby box? Yes, darling, this is the famous Finnish baby box. As this government video explains, for 80 years expectant mothers in Finland have been given a box by the state, a starter kit of clothes, sheets and toys.
10:56There's also a generous welfare system with free education and cheap health care. But the fertility rate is 1.3, close to the nation's record low. Anna Rotkja again. Finland and the Nordics have developed very generous family policies and they do work. The new challenge that we face during the last decades is family formation. The first steps, finding the right partner, settling down, feeling ready for parenthood. And these are not easily helped by these traditional family policies. How are we grappling with that? What do you think it potentially means for us? This future is partly already here.
11:38For some, it will mean family lineages die out, villages die out, regions depopulate, small languages for sure will die out much faster than they would otherwise. You asked me about a crisis. Whatever world we use, this is happening. Humanity is already below replacement level and there are fewer babies born every year. What do you think is needed? What does the government need to do? First, I don't think it's about persuasion. I think people, you know, have free choice. What governments can do is signal that if you want and can have a child, we are here to help you and protect you. And it's very often said nowadays that, oh, economic incentives don't work.
12:20Well, they have often been really small. If we really created a society where nobody would get economically worse off because they became a parent or had another child, then we can talk, do they work or don't they? Anna Rotkir in Finland. Governments have been trying to boost the number of children women are having. Since the 1980s, rich countries have dramatically increased what they spend on things like child benefits, childcare and parental leave. So what happens when a government really goes for it? Hungary in Central Europe is the perfect case study.
12:59We are living in such times when there are fewer and fewer children born in Europe. For the West, the answer is immigration. But we do not need numbers, we need Hungarian children.
13:13The former Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban a few years ago announcing tens of thousands of dollars in state subsidies for families having more children. Tax breaks for mothers subsidised mortgages. Hungary did then see an increase from 1.2 children per woman to 1.6 in 2021, but by 2025 the rate fell back to 1.3.
13:42The noisy election in April saw Viktor Orban removed after 16 years in power. Family policy was again part of his pitch. Elements of the subsidies are now being reviewed or reformed. Susanna Mackay is a demographer and a sociologist who's now the Deputy State Secretary for Family Policy in the new Hungarian government. We have now had low fertility in Hungary for more than 40 years. So since 1980 or 81, the number of deaths is higher in Hungary than the number of births. The previous government had a target to increase the fertility rate, 1.3 in the most recent data, to 2.1 average children. What is the new government's target?
14:29There was a target to increase the total fertility rate to 2.1, but this is a very natalistic target. And there was many criticism from experts that the system lacked long-term stability and scientifically grounded impact assessment. So it didn't integrate, for example, the poorest families and incentivized rather the middle class married tax-paying families through financial and credit instruments. For example, the housing policy in Hungary is really targeted towards ownership. But this is also a trap, finally, if you take an important loan and you can't pay it back, then you are in a trap which easily leads to poverty.
15:15So we would like to base the family policy rather on some classical instruments and not on loans. So there isn't a target then, the 2.1 target is gone. How will you know then if your policies work? Really, fertility is one aspect of democracy and of society. It's also important to take into account the well-being of children who have already been born and the families who have to raise the children. So how many children do people want? I think that if you see that people would like to have more children than they have, then you can build a family policy to close this gap. You may be successful, but this success is also closely linked to economic circumstances and global macroeconomic trends.
16:09That's fascinating. So you're saying that the increase in fertility from 2011 to 2021 may not at all be down to the cash handouts that the Orban government gave to households? I don't think that it didn't have any effect. The problem is indeed that we don't have any assessment of this family policy. So there was really much money. And what we know is that that fertility increase is very, very often linked to advantages, economic situation. And there was an increase in employment rates in Hungary, in average income. So there was really an important economic boom in the second half of the 2010s.
16:50Then came a decrease. So after the COVID period of 2020, there was a less advantageous economic situation and fertility rates began to decrease. So are you saying then that it isn't necessarily possible for the government to increase the number of children that Hungarians have, that Hungary is just going to have to get used to the fact that its population will fall? Here not only fertility is on the table but also the very high mortality rates which has to be decreased with adequate health care and the treatment of preventable causes of death. So it isn't just on fertility we have to work, but also on our very bad mortality situation.
17:39Susanna Mackay, Deputy State Secretary at Hungary's Ministry of Social and Family Affairs. So Hungary undertook an expensive experiment and it contested what it achieved. So back to Wyoming in the US.
18:01What are those bandmates and couple, Recy and Sean, thinking about what they might need to change their mind about not having kids and for the future? Affordability of housing is a huge thing. It's like policies that exist to pretty much to continue to keep housing as expensive as possible. New builds just are so difficult to be approved. So we end up in a crisis where there's just not enough houses being built for the amount of people that are living there. So the house prices obviously are going to go up because the demand is going up. We have four wonderful dogs that run the house. And we live in a community full of friends and wonderful folks and music and art.
18:42And it's been amazing. Making music has been amazing. and we have had one of the busiest summers of our lives traveling around all over the state. That's something that I think if we had kids right now, that's not something that we would be able to do. We couldn't be happier with the decisions that we're making and we never know what the future holds, but I think this has been the best decision that we could make for ourselves and we hope that other people find what works for them as well. Recy and Sean in Wyoming. That's it for this episode of the documentary from Business Daily with me, Rob Young.
19:23You can get more episodes on the BBC website at bbc.com and wherever you usually get your downloads.
Birth rates are falling across much of the world, raising questions about the future of ageing populations and economies. We look at why people are having fewer children, from the financial pressures facing couples in the US to changing social attitudes. We also examine government efforts to reverse the trend, including Finland's generous family support system and Hungary's costly incentives for larger families.