

18 Nov 2026 · 1h 10m · 24 chapters

The episode argues that pain is not purely biomedical and is instead “biopsychosocial,” constructed by the brain using inputs from the body and environment. It explains why chronic pain differs from acute pain (chronic pain involves central sensitization and neuroplastic changes), and how beliefs, emotions, stress, attention, and social factors can amplify or reduce pain. It also uses “hurt vs harm” (pain experience vs tissue damage) to challenge MRI/damage-based assumptions, and highlights pacing as a key chronic-pain strategy.
Dr. Rachel Zoffness is a pain researcher/clinician and author of Tell Me Where It Hurts. She describes having chronic back pain since age 32 (disc rupture), with periods of improvement through learning pain science and self-management.
Holiday weight can “carry over” and contribute to inflammation/fatigue/brain fog/joint pain. Opioids are not a safe long-term solution for chronic pain and can increase pain sensitivity (opioid-induced hyperalgesia). Pain is shaped by emotions (amygdala/limbic system), thoughts/meaning, coping behaviors, and social context.
Phantom limb pain; two “tale of two nails” cases (one with little damage but intense pain; one with major embedded nail but mild pain); Usain Bolt competing with severe scoliosis and minimal pain.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Exploring the biopsychosocial nature of pain and the role of emotions.
“Pain is ultimately constructed by our brain, of course, with input from the body and of course, with inputs from our environment.”
Dr. Hyman shares his personal journey with chronic pain and its impacts.
“We're going to talk about pain and all the things in between.”
Discussion about misconceptions surrounding pain being purely biomedical.
“You know, other than depression is probably the biggest cause of disability.”
Exploring how emotions and beliefs influence the experience of pain.
“a psychological experience at the same time.”
Examining the opioid crisis and its connection to pain management practices.
“It sort of speaks to that idea that there's the physiological component and then there's the neurologic or psychological component, which are separate.”
Explore how opioids can worsen pain sensitivity and the consequences of their use.
“And we have seen what that has done to people.”
Learn the crucial difference between pain and tissue damage and its implications.
“That's one reason I like Timeline's MitoPure Gummies so much.”
Discover Usain Bolt's story and what it reveals about pain and damage.
“There was a little boy growing up in Jamaica and he loved to run and he was really fast.”
Understand the biopsychosocial model of pain and its implications for treatment.
“Yeah, and it sort of makes me think back to the dentist where I was like 20 years old and I was like, oh, you know, this is a sensation.”
Learn the key differences between acute and chronic pain and their implications.
“They stop having sex with their partners.”
Discover how neuroplasticity affects our perception and experience of pain.
“So the way I like to explain chronic pain in neurobiology is to ask you a question.”
Explore two compelling case studies that illustrate the subjective nature of pain.
“And what does that word mean, sensitive?”
Understand how the brain predicts pain based on context and past experiences.
“And these are from two medical journals.”
Learn about the concept of pacing to gradually regain activities after chronic pain.
“I kind of, you know, want to go back to the brain because a lot of it has to do with like our perception, But there's also like a phenomena that happens in the brain where we can learn that we're in pain, right?”
Discover how various factors can amplify or reduce pain levels.
“I want to get into the pain recipe in a minute.”
Learn how mood, attention, and stress affect pain perception.
“When our mood is low and we're depressed and miserable, our limbic system, our amygdala, sends a message to the pain dial amplifying pain volume.”
Discover the components that contribute to chronic pain experiences.
“Because I think, like we said at the top of the show, chronic pain is such a pervasive problem.”
Understand how to identify and alter your pain recipe for better management.
“they're this word that we mentioned at the beginning of the show.”
Explore the impact of fear on pain perception and the importance of education.
“I've never allowed it to inhibit what I'm doing unless, you know, I'm in like surgery and I can't, when I'm in the hospital bed.”
Learn how emotional health affects physical pain and healing.
“Like if our physical health is important, so too is our emotional health, especially now that we know that the parts of the brain that make emotions also make pain.”
Discover Sam's inspiring story of battling chronic pain and finding hope.
“I, I, I'm planning on going back skiing and back into tennis and doing all the things I love to do.”
Understand the importance of patient empowerment in pain management.
“Your book is Tell Me Where It Hurts, The New Science of Pain and How to Heal.”
Learn about the carryover effect of holiday weight gain and its long-term impacts.
“And every year, the average person gains about a pound between now and New Year's.”
Explore the benefits of the 10-Day Detox program for health improvement.
“The 10-Day Detox is a program that I recommend to all my patients when they need a reset.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On The Dr. Hyman Show, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Dr. Mark Hyman: There's something worth knowing before the holidays hit. It's called the carryover effect. And every year, the average person gains about a pound between now and New Year's. Now, a pound is nothing, but that's typically just a normal weight fluctuation. But the carryover effect, that's what can create problems over a long period of time. So researchers have found that for most people, holiday weight doesn't go away. It carries over to the next year and the year after that. So over time, you end up with more inflammation, more fatigue, more brain fog, more joint pain. Now, I want you to enjoy the holidays.
0:30Dr. Mark Hyman: I do. I promise. I certainly plan to. But what you do between the celebrations matters just as much as what you do during. So here's what I want to ask you. What if this year, instead of adding to your health deficit, you actually improved your health? The 10-Day Detox is a program that I recommend to all my patients when they need a reset. There's no calorie counting. There's no skipping meals. You can still eat as much as you want, but you'll be eating the right things. You're going to follow a guided plan that uses real whole foods to overcome food cravings, reduce symptoms like brain fog, bloating, fatigue, and joint pain.
1:03Dr. Mark Hyman: Right now, the 10-Day Detox is 30 % off. It's the biggest discount I offer all year. You can start before the holidays, or you can save it for January if you'd rather kick off 2027 strong. Either way, I'm going to leave the details below. Pain is ultimately constructed by our brain, of course, with input from the body and of course, with inputs from our environment. The word that describes what pain is, is that pain is biopsychosocial. We have some critical, fundamental ingredients that change the pain we feel. And one of those things is emotions. And here's the fundamental thing to know about the role of emotions in pain.
1:42we have established that the brain is the part of the body that ultimately constructs pain. And the part of the brain that make emotions also make pain.
1:54Dr. Mark Hyman: If you've been listening to this podcast for a while, you probably heard me talk about seed. The probiotic category is full of big promises and not always a lot of proof to back them up. But DSO-1 is different. It's the number one digestive health probiotic. And when you look at the science behind it, it's easy to understand why. There are three things that set it apart. First, it contains 24 unique probiotic strains to support the diversity of your gut microbiome. Second, its capsule-in-capsule technology help protect those strains through digestion to reach the colon where most other probiotics just die in your stomach acid.
2:27Dr. Mark Hyman: And third, DSO-1 has been clinically studied and is shown to reduce bloating, alleviate gas, and improve regularity. That's not just marketing, that's real clinical evidence. and that level of scientific rigor, it's exactly what led me to join Seed's clinical board and why I continue to recommend DSO-1 and take it myself even after all these years. Go to seed.com slash hymen and use the code 25hymen to get 25 % off your first month. That's S-E-E-D.com slash hymen and use the code 25hymen. Food can be medicine, but not all food is created equal. For years, I've encouraged my patients to eat more seafood.
3:02Dr. Mark Hyman: It's one of the best natural sources of EPA and DHA, the omega-3 fats that support brain and heart health. But I've always had one important question. How do we really know what's in the fish we're eating? That's why I recommend Seatopia. They source exceptional seafood from carefully selected regenerative aquaculture farms, including one in Southern Spain that I actually visited years ago. I was so impressed by what they were doing that I wrote about it. They independently test their seafood for what matters, omega-3 content, mercury, and microplastics. They don't just tell you their seafood is nutritious, they measure it.
3:36Dr. Mark Hyman: One tested serving of their king salmon delivered over 3 ,400 milligrams of EPA and DHA, and they published their laboratory results so you can see the data yourself. Fish oil supplements have their place, but whole seafood delivers omega-3s alongside complete protein and essential nutrients. And with individually portioned seafood delivered frozen to your door, eating well becomes easier even during the busy holiday season. Real food, quantified nutrition, verified quality. Go to Zootopia.fish slash hyman, that's H-Y-M-A-N, and use the code hyman for$50 off your first order of$200 or more. Machel, welcome to the podcast.
4:12Dr. Mark Hyman: Good to have you here. Thank you so much for having me. It's such a pleasure to meet you. We're going to talk about pleasure. We're going to talk about pain and all the things in between. I think your work is so important because pain is a huge problem. And it's why we saw the opioid epidemic. It's why so many people are limited in their lives, why there's so much disability and dysfunction. I have a very personal relationship to pain because I've been in pain most of my adult life, starting in my 30s at about 32. And that's when I had a rupture disc and experienced my first real episode of unbearable pain.
4:50Dr. Mark Hyman: And I would say pretty much for the last 34 or five years, I've been in pain. at some degrees less, some degrees more, but always there. Right now, I'm actually in the least pain I've been in in decades for a whole host of reasons that involve me working on it and doing things to help it. And a lot of the things that you talk about in your book, which is such an important contribution to the field, which is helping us understand what this whole phenomenon of pain is that so many people suffer from. And it's something I'm really grateful for you for doing your work on this, because a lot of people just sort of don't pay attention to pain and a lot of scientists don't.
5:27Your book, Tell Me Where It Hurts, is really about the sort of
5:30Dr. Mark Hyman: new science of pain and how to heal it. And that's something we all need to know more about because pain is such a big and often attractable problem. And my pain was really around my back. Again, a big problem for a lot of people is back pain. You know, other than depression is probably the biggest cause of disability. So I'm just grateful for your work. I'm so grateful to get that feedback. I did not know you had been in pain your whole life. I've been following along and I knew you had had episodes of pain, but you have come to the right place. I'm so glad we're having this conversation, you're also not alone.
5:58Like we have 1.9 billion people around the globe living with chronic pain and the estimates in the U.S. alone are up to 100 million. So chronic pain is a ubiquitous human problem. And beyond that, like when we think about it, who is going to escape pain? Pain is coming for all of us one day if it hasn't already. We are all pain patients. We just don't know it. And so this conversation about pain is long overdue.
6:27Dr. Mark Hyman: And I would say, you know, there's another piece about pain that I kind of encountered when I was very young. Somehow I got the idea there was this sort of mind-body phenomenon. And I was reading, you know, books way back, like by Ken Pelletier about mind is healer, mind is slayer. And I was just so fascinated with the power of the mind. I was reading this book by Bernie Siegel, who wrote Love Medicine Miracles about the power of the mind to heal cancer. And I had this kind of crazy the idea that I would go to the dentist and not actually get any anesthetic and had a bunch of cavities. And I was like, and I, and it was really, it was really an interesting practice.
7:04Dr. Mark Hyman: And I remember that very clearly, like I was able to associate the sensation from the emotion. So it was a really like profound example of, of pain being both a physiological experience and a psychological experience at the same time. And that a lot of times the way we experience pain is changed by the way we attach meaning to the pain or what we believe about the pain or what we feel about the pain. Even though I started off the podcast by saying I've been in so much pain, I'm probably one of the most active people I know. Riding my bike, I ran for years, I don't do it anymore, riding horses, skiing, you know, playing tennis, uh, working out.
7:47Dr. Mark Hyman: And I, I, I did it, all of it and live my life despite the pain and in some ways to help the pain and they'll do the less I do, the more pain I'm in. It's sort of an interesting phenomenon. So I think that, uh, that whole phenomena of the perception and the, and all that is, I want to get into that with you and we're going to get into that in a minute, but I want to start out by asking you about how you You opened the book, which is talking about this big lie, this fat lie we've been told about pain. And what's that lie? And why should we care? Yeah, I mean, you opened with a bang. I mean, I think you know more about pain than probably most doctors, let alone most people, just because you've experienced it.
8:26And also you've been reading about it for a really long time. But so one of the biggest lies, one of the biggest myths we've all been sold about pain is that it is a purely biomedical problem. And by that, I mean something to do just with anatomy and physiology that requires a purely biomedical solution, typically in the form of pills and procedures. Science has known forever that pain is never just about anatomy. It's never just about bones and body parts. Ultimately, what we know is that pain is constructed by the brain, of course. Right. And one of the reasons we know this is because of a condition called phantom limb pain.
9:08Phantom limb pain occurs when someone loses a limb, an arm or a leg, and they continue to have terrible pain in the missing body part. If you can have leg pain in a leg that is no longer attached to your body, that tells us pretty definitively that pain cannot be constructed just by our leg. Like I was treating a patient who had phantom hand pain. It was a child. He had found a firework in his parents' garage. it's a crazy story i tell it and tell me where it hurts but but ultimately ultimately his surgeon called me and said zafnus i need your help i have given this kid every pain medication under the sun the highest doses and he's still in pain so like if we can have pain in a hand that's no longer attached to our body why are we still looking at the body part when we're talking about treating pain pain is bigger than that it's broader than that and it's deeper than that yeah that's
10:04Dr. Mark Hyman: fascinating. So it's true. It sort of speaks to that idea that there's the physiological component and then there's the neurologic or psychological component, which are separate. And I always kind of like thinking about cold plunges. Cold plunges can be extremely painful, but they also are things people love. And so some people experience it as hell. Other people love to be in a cold plunge for four minutes. And I think it's how we relate to that experience that matters. And if we have fear about it, if we have anxiety about it, then the lens through which we interpret that pain is quite different.
10:42Dr. Mark Hyman: And for me, having had so much pain throughout so much of my life, I've learned to sort of navigate it. Sometimes I had to deal with the actual structural physiological things, like a disc herniation. Sometimes I had to deal with it from a psychological perspective. And It sort of taught me a lot about it, but I think it's not something you're right. We learn as doctors. Doctors don't know much about pain other than here, take these pain pills. You know, like it hurts to take Advil. It really hurts to take a narcotic. You know, like basically that's kind of it. Or do this nerve block or whatever the procedure or the drug we can use to mitigate the pain.
11:16Dr. Mark Hyman: But at the end of the day, it's a combination of these factors. Tell us what you've learned about that. Right. I mean, I want to just back up and say like your point is exactly dead on. Like Most of our doctors don't learn about pain. And that's because 96 % of medical schools in the United States have zero dedicated compulsory pain education, which is mind-blowing. Like when I did my research on pain education in America, I was just blown away. And like doctors that do learn about pain, exactly what you said. It's a very narrow biomedical model that focuses on anatomy and physiology and biochemistry.
11:52And to be clear, those things are very important when it comes to pain. They're very, very important. They're just not the entire story. And doctors want to understand pain. Like chronic pain is one of the biggest epidemics we have. It's one of the biggest problems we face. And doctors go into medicine to help and to heal. And we're not giving them the tools to do that. And they want it. So it's actually the reason I'm out here. It's the reason I'm writing Tell Me Where It Hurts. It's the reason I'm doing podcasts, despite the fact that I am not a natural public speaker. Like, I would rather be hiding in my room.
12:25You're doing great. You're doing great. So all of this information, I feel like healthcare providers want it. We as patients want it. Like there's no one who won't benefit from understanding the science of pain.
12:37Dr. Mark Hyman: Well, the thing that I do remember learning about pain back in the day was the pain scale, which was, you know. Oh, boy. And the little faces. And it turns out that that pain scale came from the Sackler family and the drug company that was making narcotics and oxycodone and oxycontin and all these horrible things. drugs. And that's where we as doctors learned about pain was from the drug companies who were selling something. And unfortunately, it took us down a really horrible left turn where doctors unwittingly were complicit in this opioid epidemic because they wanted to help people, and they didn't want people to suffer.
13:17Dr. Mark Hyman: And they were, quote, taught by the drug reps, which is how a lot of doctors after training learn about medicine, unfortunately. And Anna Lemke wrote a great book about this. It's called Drug Dealer MD. very controversial title, but she wrote about, this is like a well-known event at this point, that, you know, Pharma sent reps out into the world to tell doctors this big fat lie, another big fat lie, I guess it's the same one, that pain is a biomedical problem and it requires just medications and procedures and that opioids over the long term are a safe, simple solution for chronic pain. And of course, we know now that while opioids can be a great solution for acute pain, like short-term pain, they are actually not a safe solution for chronic pain, which is pain that's three months or longer.
14:00And we have seen what that has done to people. Like we have seen also what it does to the brain. Like over time, opioids actually make our brains more sensitive to pain, meaning we feel more pain with less provocation. And there's a name for this in science. It's opioid-induced hyperalgesia. Like it's well-known, it's well-documented, we've known about it for effing ever. But doctors were told that opioids were safe over the long term, and they just did their job. Like you said with the zero to 10 smiley face pain scale, if your patient's pain was over a five or whatever, if you weren't administering oxycodone, you weren't doing your job.
14:40So man, if I had a trillion dollar budget to market to everybody the science of pain, we would never have had an opioid epidemic.
14:48Dr. Mark Hyman: Yeah, I know. It was a travesty, And hopefully we're coming out of that. I want to get into the meat of your work, which is starting out with sort of this distinction between hurt and harm. You can have significant damage to tissues without pain and a lot of pain without significant damage to tissues. So can you kind of help us understand what that's about? Yeah, I love this distinction between hurt and harm. Who doesn't love alliteration, right? So the difference between hurt and harm. Hurt, just to define our terms, hurt is pain, the subjective experience of pain, and harm is the damage that we experience.
15:22And they are two separate things. We have been told that they're one in the same, that they're linked, but that the truth of the matter is, and science bears this out, is that hurt or pain and harm or damage are not the same thing. So, for example, I just want to define, like if you stub your toe, the subjective pain you feel, your zero to 10 pain scale, that's your hurt. And when you see that toe start swelling and turning purple and red and it's throbbing, that's the harm. That's evidence of tissue damage. So I want to tell you a quick story that really illustrates the difference between hurt and harm.
15:58And I think it will undo some of the myths we've been told about what pain is and how it works.
16:02Dr. Mark Hyman: I'm pretty consistent about the things I do for my health, but I also know that the easier something is to work into my day, the more likely I am to stick with it. That's one reason I like Timeline's MitoPure Gummies so much. They taste great. And if you're tired of taking another pill every day, they make supporting your mitochondrial health easy. And that becomes especially important as we get older. Your mitochondria produce the cellular energy your body needs to function. And I'm not talking about the jittery kind of energy you get from coffee. I mean the energy your cells need to do their jobs.
16:30Dr. Mark Hyman: Over time, some of our mitochondria become damaged. And mitophagy, the natural process our body uses to clear them out, becomes less efficient. And Mitopure's clinically validated in uralithin A helps support that renewal process. In one clinical study, Mitopure increased mitochondria renewal by an impressive 39%. If you want to make Mitopure part of your own daily routine, the gummies are a simple way to stay consistent. Head to timeline.com forward slash Dr. Hyman to save up to 20 % off your first order of MitoPure when you subscribe and you save. This episode is brought to you by Rose Nutrition Liposomal Glutathione.
17:03Dr. Mark Hyman: You got a lot on your calendar this time of year. Making sure you're supporting your immune system is part of the plan. Every day, your body is loaded with more environmental stressors than it is designed to handle. Enter glutathione, a powerful antioxidant that supports natural detoxification, oxidative stress defense, skin health, and immune function. Glutathione is a tripeptide your body produces in nearly every cell, and its job is to keep those cells protected. This antioxidant helps you maintain healthy immune cell function and neutralizes free radicals, which is extra important this time of year.
17:31Dr. Mark Hyman: And since glutathione is highly sensitive to digestive breakdown, Roe uses liposomal delivery to support nutrient protection and enhance absorption. If you want to take a simple step to support your immunity this holiday season, start here. Go to roe nutrition.com and use the code Hyman for 20 % off site-wide. That's the code Hyman at R-H-O nutrition.com. So about 30 years ago, it's one of my favorite stories. There was a little boy growing up in Jamaica and he loved to run and he was really fast. And his dream was to one day be in the Olympics. But as he grew, something strange was happening to his spine.
18:09It was twisting into an S shape, and he was eventually diagnosed with scoliosis, which as you know is a very real condition where your spine starts twisting. But it didn't stop him. He continued to run, he continued to train, until he was fast enough to qualify for the Olympics. By the time he qualified for the Olympics, his spine was so twisted and so abnormal that his right leg was a full half inch shorter than his left leg, but he had very little pain. He competed in the Olympics. That man went on to win not one gold medal, but eight of them. Do you want to know who that person is?
18:54Dr. Mark Hyman: Bolt. That man is Usain Bolt. He is the fastest man alive. He has not had surgery for his scoliosis, if the myth that we've been sold was true, if damage and pain were one and the same, then that man should be relegated to a hospital bed watching the Olympics on TV like the rest of us mere mortals. Like the myths are not true. When we have hurt, when we have pain, we go looking for harm. We go looking for damage because we've been told that damage and pain are one and the same. That is not true. And scientists actually noticed that when patients came to their office, like back doctors noticed, that when patients came to their office, the amount of back pain they had was not correlated with the degree of damage that they were seeing on MRIs and back scans.
19:48So like some patients were coming in with really gnarly back scans, like deformed spines and very little pain. And other patients who were coming in had a lot of pain, but absolutely perfectly normal MRIs. And they were like, what could be going on? So scientists did a scoping study. They scanned the backs of thousands and thousands of people. And here's what we now know. The amount of damage we have, the things we see on the MRIs are not correlated to the amount of pain we have. so like there are literally hundreds of thousands of us walking around with slipped and herniated discs and absolutely no pain so like we we blame our pain on these the findings on mris and like the science doesn't bear up that that is actually the cause of pain so i know we're going to get to like what pain actually is and how it actually works but i feel like dispelling that myth myth
20:46Dr. Mark Hyman: is like the first step no it's true i mean honestly i have that experience personally if you look at my back on an MRI, it looks like a train wreck. I mean, the distraught collapse, there's osteophytes, there's arthritis. It's like, it's just a nightmare. And I'm sitting here pretty much in no pain. Um, it doesn't mean I haven't had pain in the past, but it's, it's, you know, it is usually correlated to something specific that sometimes you can find. And it's not that MRIs are always wrong because if they're correlated with the pain and they, you find the thing and it, it can be really helpful and it can tell you what's going on, but you're right.
21:20Dr. Mark Hyman: A lot of people walk around with x-rays that look terrible but have no symptoms. And I think people have lots of symptoms and normal x-rays. That's also true. So we know that to be true in medicine. So it begs the question, like, what's going on with these people and how does the body managing that? And when you look on the research on this, it's absolutely astounding. This is true of every single body part. The things you find on the MRIs absolutely positively do not predict the amount of pain we have, whether it's our back or our knee or, you know, our neck. So, but, but that's the thing we've been told.
21:54If you have pain in your neck or you have pain in your back, the first thing you will do is go to the doctor to look for damage. And that isn't where pain lives. Pain doesn't live in our back and pain doesn't live in our neck. Where does it live, Rachel? This goes back to the first question you asked me. Pain is ultimately constructed by our brain, of course, with input from the body and of course, with inputs from our environment. And so maybe this gets to the question of, well, what is pain? We've said what pain isn't. Let's say what pain is. Pain is never purely biomedical. It's never purely anatomical.
22:26Science has known this for decades. The word that describes what pain is, is that pain is biopsychosocial. And if your listeners remember literally nothing else from this conversation, I want them to remember this word. And that's what Tell Me Where It Hurts is all about. It unpacks this word. Pain is biopsychosocial. What does that mean? It means that if you imagine a Venn diagram with three overlapping circles, we have biological factors that contribute to pain. We have psychological factors that contribute to pain. And we have sociological factors that contribute to pain. And pain lives in the messy middle of those three domains of health.
23:05And like this has been known for many decades. It is not my pet theory. It has been out there. And pain science research has known this since 1965. So just to break that down a little bit, in the bio or the biological domain of pain, we have the things people have heard the most about. We have genetics and tissue damage, system dysfunction, diet, exercise, sleep. Like those are all very important when it comes to pain. But what I want us to notice is that if we only are focusing on the bio domain of pain, we are literally missing two-thirds of the pain problem. So the psychological domain of pain, of course, is fraught with stigma and misunderstanding.
23:48Understandably so. So many people, especially women and people of color, have been told pain is all in their heads, which is a big fat lie and never true. But in the psychological domain of pain, we have some critical, fundamental ingredients that change the pain we feel. And one of those things is emotions. And here's the fundamental thing to know about the role of emotions in pain. We have established that the brain is the part of the body that ultimately constructs pain. And the part of the brain that make emotions also make pain. Your listeners will have heard of the limbic system and the amygdala.
24:26Those are critical parts not just of the emotion machinery, but also the pain machinery. And what that means, Dr. Mark, is that 100 % of the sensory messages from our body filter through the brain's emotion machinery before they become the thing we call pain. And that's why our bodies feel worse during times of stress and duress. It's why, you know, it's why depression actually hurts. And everyone knows that emotions can change pain volume. And like in this psychological domain of pain, we also have thoughts and predictions and the meaning we assign to sensations, which is what you said right out of the gate.
25:10We also have our coping behaviors. When some people have pain, they sit, they stay at home, they stop moving, they stay inside, they stop engaging in their hobbies. Sometimes they stop having sex with their partners. Their life completely changes. And it turns out that the way we cope with pain actually changes the way pain feels. and our final domain of pain is the sociological domain of pain. And that's like everything else. It's socioeconomic status, access to care, race and ethnicity. It's social support or lack thereof. It's our history of trauma because, dude, the body keeps the score. And, you know, so like all of these things together end up creating the pain experience.
25:52Dr. Mark Hyman: Yeah, and it sort of makes me think back to the dentist where I was like 20 years old and I was like, oh, you know, this is a sensation. and I didn't have the emotional sort of content of it. It was just, I knew that this wasn't hurting me, that he wasn't doing any damage, that he was just changing a cavity or fixing a cavity. And so I could dissociate the terror of having the pain experience from the actual sensation. And so I was able to sit there and just breathe and not have it be a bad experience. I wouldn't probably do it that much now because I'm - I would not recommend that to any of your listeners.
26:29Dr. Mark Hyman: It was a really interesting kind of experiment as a 20-year-old to kind of see what would happen. And it really taught me a lot. Yeah. So what you're saying is that you were able to adjust the emotions, some of the ingredients in what I call a pain recipe. You were able to adjust your expectations and your emotions, and that helped pain volume go down. So I think that's the cool thing about pain and why I think it's so important to talk about this is because, you know, pain takes away power. That's just what it does. It makes us feel like our bodies and our lives are out of our control. And once we learn the science of pain and we learn the different ingredients that change the pain experience, what we're actually doing is taking our power back.
27:14And that's why this information is so fundamental.
27:16Dr. Mark Hyman: Another key thing you talk about is this idea between acute and chronic pain. And I think for me, as I'm thinking about them, acute pain is a signal to stop doing something right away. Like you put your hand on a fire, take it out immediately, right? However, chronic pain is almost a signal to do the opposite, is to not stop doing something. In order to actually help the pain resolve or improve or be mitigated, you actually may need to do things like move more or stretch more or do different things that actually are the opposite of what you initially would want to do because your meaning around pain is mostly around acute pain.
27:56Dr. Mark Hyman: And so you mentioned a lot of the things that people do when they have pain is they just stop doing their lives. They stop going out. They stop having sex with their partners. They stop living in response to this sensation when, in fact, they should do the opposite. So can you kind of help us understand that acute chronic distinction, why it's so important? Acute pain, like you said, is short-term pain. So that's pain that's three months or fewer. Like you go for a run, you break your ankle, any sort of sports injury, it's childbirth, it's an acute illness. That's acute pain. Chronic pain is a completely different animal, it turns out.
28:28And science says that neurobiologically, it works completely differently. So chronic pain is three months or longer or beyond expected healing time, whatever that means. Pretty nebulous definition. But what we know is that chronic pain actually changes our brain and our pain system. So like you said, with acute pain and acute injury and acute illness, I want you to stop, pay attention, rest, get help. Like you go for a run, you break your ankle. If you don't stop running, you are in for a world of problems. Acute pain is a message to stop. Pay attention. Check it out. Chronic pain is a different animal.
29:10So the way I like to explain chronic pain in neurobiology is to ask you a question. Is there any skill that you were bad at and you practiced it and over time you got good at it? It can be anything like an instrument, musical instrument or...
29:25Dr. Mark Hyman: Tennis. Tennis. So for me, it was the piano. And when I was a kid, my mom made me practice and I didn't want to. But over time, what I noticed was that eventually I could just sit at the piano and my fingers just magically knew what to do. Like I could even hear the music in my head without playing the song. What was happening? There is a process that your listeners have heard about called neuroplasticity. Neuroplasticity is the process by which the brain changes with time, exposure, input, and experience. So over time, here's what was happening. The pathways in our brain are like the muscles in our body.
30:06The more we use them, the bigger and stronger they get. So if you said to me, Zofnus, I want really big biceps. I would say, Mark, of course you do. Who doesn't want really big biceps? Go to the gym, lift weights, and over time with repetition, your muscles will get really big and strong. The same is true with the pathways in our brain. So the more I played the piano and the more you played tennis, the bigger and stronger the tennis pathway in your brain became, the bigger and stronger the piano pathway in my brain became. And that's why I was able to sit down at the piano and play the music without even looking at the sheet music.
30:46Here's the problem. It's all pathways in the brain that change with time and experience. It's not just the piano pathway, not just the tennis pathway. It's also the pain pathway. So the more we inadvertently practice pain, the bigger and stronger the pain pathway in our brain becomes. And when that happens, we say that our brains have become sensitive to pain. And what does that word mean, sensitive? Like dogs are sensitive to sound. So, you know, if a dog came into this room, it would hear faint sounds that you and I couldn't even hear. Like on the 4th of July, every dog in America is hiding under beds.
31:21So small bits of sensory input to a dog are amplified. When our brain and our pain system become sensitive, what's happening is that small bits of sensory data from the body are being amplified by a sensitive brain. So bigger output with less input. And that's what we have shown is happening with chronic pain. And it has a name in science. It's called central sensitization. Central sensitization is what it sounds like. So it's your central nervous system, your brain and your spinal cord have become hypersensitized or hyperprotective. So now your brain and your nervous system are protecting you and telling you you're in danger even when you're not.
32:01Dr. Mark Hyman: And so this chronic stuff has to be dealt with differently than the acute stuff. Exactly. I want to kind of look back a little bit on this story that you tell a lot, which I think sort of highlights how much the story or beliefs we have impact our perception of pain. And that's the tale of two nails. So can you tell us these case studies, which are quite interesting and how dramatically they illustrate this point that it's not actually necessarily what happens to us. It's the meaning that we make of what happens to us that causes a lot of the pain. Totally. Yeah. I love the Tale of Two Nails. And these are from two medical journals.
32:38So the first one, the first Tale of Nails, is from the British Medical Journal. And they reported that a construction worker was on a job site and he jumped off a plank straight onto a seven-inch nail. And that nail drove through his boot clear through to the other side. He was in terrible pain and his colleagues rushed him to the emergency room and the doctors gave him a bunch of good drugs, including fentanyl. And the good doctors removed his boot and they discovered that a miracle had occurred. The nail had passed between the space between his toes. There was no blood. There was no puncture wound.
33:17There was no tissue damage. But the pain was real. Dude was not faking. So what had happened? And his brain, aka his danger detector, which is what our brain is and what it's doing in every given moment, used all available information to decide whether or not to make pain and how much. Because that is pain's job, is to protect us. So his brain used knowledge of his dangerous work environment, memories of past pain experiences, data from his five senses, including this visual of this giant nail sticking out of the top of his boot. I actually have the picture and tell me where it hurts. You can see it.
34:00And it used emotions like panic and fear. and because his brain believed his body was in danger, it made pain to protect him. So you'll notice it's like a biopsychosocial recipe of ingredients. Okay, so tale of nails number two. Tale of nails number two. A second construction worker, most dangerous job there is, was on a job site using a nail gun and the nail gun accidentally discharged. The gun ricocheted backwards, clocked him in the jaw. He saw a nail go shooting across the room and bury in the wall across from him. He had a mild toothache, mild headache, continued on with work and life for about six days.
34:44At the end of six days, he turned to his wife and said, you know, I'm going to get this toothache checked out. Went to the dentist who took a scan of his patient's jaw and much to both men's surprise, discovered a four-inch nail embedded in his face. Four-inch nail. That's a pretty big nail.
35:04Dr. Mark Hyman: Also have the x-ray of that and tell me where it hurts. I went so far down this rabbit hole that I actually called the surgeon who removed the nail, who said he's the luckiest guy ever. What had happened? Because this is very big damage, very big danger, very little pain. How is that possible? If pain and damage are one and the same, shouldn't he be in terrible pain? Here's what happened. His brain, his danger detector, also used all available information to decide whether or not to make pain and how much. However, if you remember, he saw a nail go shooting across the room and bury in the wall across from him.
35:45His brain believed and predicted that he was safe. And so pain volume stayed low, even though danger was high. And I think this story is so important because it reminds us that the brain is a prediction machine and that pain ultimately is the brain's opinion of how much danger we are in in any given moment.
36:10Dr. Mark Hyman: That's amazing. So basically the guy thought the nail went in the wall, didn't think it went in his face. And so he interpreted the set of facts very differently and didn't register that he actually hurt himself pretty badly. You got it. Like he was legitimately surprised. Like when they saw the scan of the nail in his face, like the dude who had been using the nail gun was like, how did that get there? I kind of, you know, want to go back to the brain because a lot of it has to do with like our perception, But there's also like a phenomena that happens in the brain where we can learn that we're in pain, right?
36:43Dr. Mark Hyman: But we can also unlearn pain. And you talk about this phenomenon of neuroplasticity, which is the ability of the brain to change things over time and learn new things. And how does that work with pain? I don't think of it as unlearning, to be honest, because I feel like the opposite of learning is sort of like forgetting, you know, and that's not something our brain can do. But the cool thing that our brain can do is just as our brains can become more sensitive to pain over time and more protective and hyperprotective, our brains can also become less sensitive over time. And one of the most important treatments for chronic pain, which is something that you have already said, is starting to do the things again.
37:25And again, with chronic pain, it's normal and natural to dial back on all the things. Like oftentimes we stop exercising, we stop engaging in hobbies. Sometimes we even avoid social activity. And of course, there's a whole spectrum of how we handle our pain. But one of the most important things for chronic pain is a skill, a strategy called pacing. And what pacing does, and I'll say what it is, but what pacing does is that it starts desensitizing a hypersensitive, hyperprotective brain. And it also helps our body get stronger. and like it is true that motion is lotion.
38:01Dr. Mark Hyman: Wait, motion is lotion? That's a good one. I never heard that. Yeah, totally. Motion is lotion. It's so important for our joints and our body parts. So I want to just say clearly what we're saying here today is not that pain is just in the brain. Data from the body is fundamentally important. Data from our environment is also fundamentally important. So what we're saying here today that pain is a mix of everything. So I want to say what pacing is and how it works when it comes to chronic pain because it lends itself to treatment. Pacing for pain is much like pacing for a marathon. So if you said to me, you know, Rachel, I would really like to run a marathon.
38:38I'm going to go outside tomorrow and run 26 miles. I would say, you know, Mark, that sounds like a bad idea. I don't think you should go outside tomorrow and try and run 26 miles. I don't think that would go well for you.
38:50Dr. Mark Hyman: Start with one. Yeah, exactly. Any athlete will tell you that if you want to run a marathon, you have to put together a pacing protocol. And a pacing protocol means we're starting with where you are. Like if you're starting from on the couch and you've been on the couch for a year, you're going to want to get out of bed and walk a little bit, maybe mix in a little bit of jogging. And like next week, you'll mix in a little more jogging and then you'll mix in some running. So when we pace for a marathon, we're slowly onboarding our brain and our body. We're getting stronger. And when it comes to pacing for pain, we're really doing the same.
39:26So in the back of the book, I have like literally an entire pacing protocol for pain. Not just pacing, but like everything else, all the other ingredients in the pain recipe that we're going to talk about here today. So when we pace for pain, usually what I do, my trick is I ask my patients to tell me any activity they used to love that pain has taken from them. So like I had a patient who said Irish dancing. I had a patient who said soccer. He like used to be a soccer pro and he couldn't play anymore. I had someone who said fudge making. Like it doesn't matter what the activity is. And then we figure out where we are and we create a stepped graded gradual protocol to help you slowly get back to the things and activities you love.
40:07It is possible. I've seen it a million times in the walls of my office and like every time it blows my mind.
40:14Dr. Mark Hyman: Yeah. I want to get into the pain recipe in a minute. I want to kind of talk about something that you discussed, which is the pain dial and what turns it up or down. It's kind of a metaphor. What is it and how does it work and what are you referring to? So when I first started studying pain, like I'm dating myself here, I started studying pain like 30 years ago at Brown University when I was working with a pain neuroscientist. And I understood that pain was biological and I understood sort of intuitively that pain was maybe, you know, emotional. but I couldn't quite understand how it worked. And so I've come up with a number of different metaphors that I think really sort of help us understand the nuances here and how these different ingredients work.
40:56So one of them is this concept of a pain dial. So if you imagine that you have in your central nervous system, your brain and your spinal cord, a pain dial, and it operates much like the volume knob on your car stereo. So many things can turn pain volume up, many things can turn pain volume down. And of course, one of those things is pain medication. And like, thank God for pain medication. We're no longer biting on wooden spoons during surgery, right? So like, no shame or blame in this game. But there are many other things that adjust pain volume also. So for the sake of description, we'll just talk about three.
41:34So three things that change pain volume. Stress and anxiety, our mood, like high or low, and our attention or what we're focusing on. And here's how this works. When stress and anxiety are high and our muscles are tight and tense and our thoughts are worried, the brain sends a message to the pain dial amplifying pain volume. We said mood was the second one. When our mood is low and we're depressed and miserable, our limbic system, our amygdala, sends a message to the pain dial amplifying pain volume. Thing three we said is attention or what we're thinking about and focusing on. Turns out when we're thinking about pain and focusing on pain and we've stopped engaging in all these other hobbies, our prefrontal cortex sends a message to the pain dial amplifying pain volume.
42:26But here's what's really rad, Dr. Mark and friends. The opposite is also true. The opposite is also true. So when stress and anxiety are low, our muscles are relaxed and our thoughts are calm, the brain sends a message to the pain dial lowering pain volume. This is one of the reasons doctors prescribe muscle relaxants. It's one of the reasons that Lamaze breathing actually works during childbirth. It's one of the reasons why meditation and mindfulness, as much as people might roll their eyes, has so much data showing that it can lower pain volume. Thing two we said was mood and emotions. When we are happy and experiencing joy and gratitude, the limbic system and the amygdala lower the pain dial.
43:15And finally, last but not least, attention. When we are distracted, our prefrontal cortex will lower pain volume. And we've all had this experience where we're so absorbed in some beloved activity that we briefly forget about our pain. That is not magic. That is our brain's pain dial.
43:37Dr. Mark Hyman: Fascinating. And that's why things like social connection reduce pain and social isolation increase pain. Oh, we should go down the rabbit hole with the social ingredients in the pain recipe. That science is so amazing. Let's talk about the pain recipe. Because I think, like we said at the top of the show, chronic pain is such a pervasive problem. It affects so many people. I personally have experienced this for so long. And I've had to learn myself my own pain recipe. Like, what do I do to manage my pain, to think about pain, to deal with my pain, to, you know, get rid of my pain. Like it's, you know, it's one of those things that it takes up an outsized portion of your brain if you don't have a way to navigate it.
44:13Dr. Mark Hyman: It's like, you know, it's like when you put your hand on a hot stove, that's the only thing you can think about, right? And unfortunately, chronic pain, it can't be like that. It has to be something that you navigate differently. And this pain recipe I'm so fascinated with because it includes a lot of the elements that I've used to regulate it. What do you mean by pain recipe? Yeah, so just as there's a recipe for brownies, there is always a recipe for pain. Always. So like, if you want brownies to come out well, you know that there are certain ingredients that you add in a certain order and you bake them at a certain temperature.
44:48Like the environment matters too. And the same is true for pain. So when my patients come to my office, the first question I ask them is, tell me what goes into a bad pain day. So I'm actually going to ask you, so I want you to think about it. So like what goes into a bad pain day? And my patients can usually tell me some combination of things that will predict a bad pain day. I can give you an example. Like they will say sitting, staring at my screen for too many hours. Not, not moving my body.
45:18Dr. Mark Hyman: Yep. Sleeping poorly. Check. Eating a crap diet. I don't usually do that. The other three, the first three definitely happen. High stress, like not protecting rest time and like saying yes to too many things and having too many things on my plate. Oh, me? I never do that. One of the things I've learned as a doctor is that the best health practices are usually the ones you actually stick with. And that's what I love about having a sauna at home. It's not just another wellness product designed for one person. It becomes part of your home and the whole family can use it. I might use my Sunlight Impulse with recovery in mind, while someone else in my family might use it to relax, unwind, or simply create some quiet time at the end of the day.
46:00Dr. Mark Hyman: And having it right there removes a lot of friction. You don't have to drive somewhere or make an appointment. You just walk in. And that's why I think Asana is such a unique holiday gift. It's not something that gets forgotten after the holidays. It becomes a wellness ritual for your family for years. Now, Sunlight has options for different spaces and budgets too. So visit sunlight.com and use the code HYMAN to save up to$2 ,100 plus get free shipping and other exclusive savings throughout the holiday season. Let me tell you a secret about doctors. We're skeptical of most supplements, and we should be.
46:32Dr. Mark Hyman: Many of them aren't backed by strong science, and a surprising number of supplements don't actually contain the ingredients they claim to have on the label. So it means something when I tell you that I take Fatty 15 every day and I recommend it to my patients. From the moment I looked at the research, Fatty 15 was different. Over 150 peer-reviewed studies, over 60 patents, An excellent subco trust score of 9.88, which is almost 10. More than a decade of development. And the product itself is simple. One active ingredient, C15, that strengthens your cells to support healthy aging. Don't take my word for it.
47:06Dr. Mark Hyman: Look at the science. It's all published at discoverc15.com. That's what convinced me to take Fatty 15 every day. And it's what I'll convince you too. head to fatty15.com slash hymen today for an extra 15 % off your 90 day subscription starter kit. The discount will be applied automatically at checkout. So all together, and like what you can see about these ingredients, of course, they're this word that we mentioned at the beginning of the show. They're biopsychosocial. There's biological ingredients, there's psychological ingredients, there's social, and there are environmental ingredients because that's how pain works.
47:41So what's really amazing and important about a pain recipe is that A, everybody has one, and B, if you have a high pain recipe, you bet your ass that you have a low pain recipe. And a low pain recipe is really just the opposite of our high pain recipe. And there's a lot of power in writing it out. So when my patients come to me, we actually map out what their high pain recipe looks like. What are the ingredients that are going into making a bad pain day for you, Dr. Hyman. Like if poor sleep is one of those ingredients.
48:15Dr. Mark Hyman: Poor sleep, sitting too long, not moving, not exercising. Like, yeah. I mean, the least pain I'm in is when I move the most. It's such a paradox. So you think someone with chronic pain, you know, if you move more, it's going to hurt more. But in a way, it's like the thing that is my magic elixir. If I actually sit all day, I'm miserable. If I actually can get out and take a walk or ride my bike or work out or do yoga or whatever it is, I find myself dramatically less in pain. Right. So what you're saying is motion is lotion. Definitely. Right. But it makes sense that people who are in pain wouldn't want to move because typically the advice is if it hurts, don't do it.
48:59Oh, and that's true for acute pain, but it absolutely is the opposite when it comes to chronic pain. And I think the most important thing to say here is just as there's a recipe for high pain, there's always a recipe for low pain. And once we identify the ingredients in your high pain recipe, that's when we can start changing them. So if you say to me, you know, poor sleep is absolutely a predictor for high pain, I would say to you, Mark, that's rad. I'm going to give you a sleep hygiene protocol and we're going to work on your sleep. And as soon as your sleep hygiene gets better, you'll notice that pain volume will start going down.
49:34Or if you say to me, you know what, I've been eating a crap diet, and that's not true for you, but it is true of a lot of our listeners. Like, I know I haven't been eating well. Pain has been preventing me from cooking. I'm just like reaching for fast food. Then I know that we need to put together a nutrition protocol for your pain to help your body and help pain volume go down. If stress is one of the ingredients, we need some strategies for better managing stressors, even if that's like putting boundaries around work responsibilities. So there are always strategies we can use to change pain volume.
50:05And that injects so much hope into this equation. Because people with chronic pain are often told there is no treatment, there is no cure. And that is a load of horse shit. Excuse my language. That is absolute horse shit. There is a treatment for chronic pain. There is always hope. And the reason I'm saying this so emphatically is because suicidality in the chronic pain population is twice as high. And like, that is a serious and scary statistic. Of course you get it. So like the hope component of this cannot be overstated.
50:40Dr. Mark Hyman: So I wanted to sort of double down on this whole idea that, that happens to people with chronic pain, which is they, there's a fear component and the fear component inhibits them from living their lives and from engaging with life and from doing things that they believe will make their pain worse, but may not in fact be doing that. And I've been lucky in that I've never identified with my pain. I've never allowed it to govern my life. I've never allowed it to inhibit what I'm doing unless, you know, I'm in like surgery and I can't, when I'm in the hospital bed. I really think this is such a core aspect that I see in people is that it just, it creates a fear response.
51:22Dr. Mark Hyman: And that fear response is how they navigate what they decide to do in their lives or to not do. And that's really the initial block that has to get relief somehow. So I wonder how you work with people to help them understand that it's okay to start to do things. It's okay to move through experiences where you might have some discomfort initially in order to get to the other side of that. I actually think that this educational piece we're doing right now is the core of that. Like, if you don't understand what pain is, if you think that pain is telling you to stop doing everything, to stop moving, if you don't know that there's this recipe of ingredients that's probably amplifying the alarm, of course you're going to stop.
52:02Of course you're going to stay in bed. Because, you know, we are told that pain is an indicator of damage. This is like full circle. If you believe that pain is telling you that like, yeah, you better stay in bed because that chronic back pain means something dangerous and bad has happened to your back. Why would you move? Why would you go for a walk? Why would you start exercising? You reasonably believe that pain is a sign of danger. That isn't always true. And it takes undoing that myth in order to get people moving again. And I think knowledge is so powerful for that reason.
52:36Dr. Mark Hyman: It is. I think it's something that if you haven't kind of walked through that narrow passage in your mind of going past the fear to realize that it's okay to start to do things, to move your body, to exercise, to walk. It's amazing. And I found that I had an episode I've talked about before where I had a pretty serious major back surgery where I had fusion and I had an abscess. It was, it was a whole thing. And I, and I was on, um, you'd appreciate this. I was on like 48 milligrams a day of diluted, which is like the top, top, top, top amount of the most powerful pain medicine you can get. Basically it's like heroin.
53:18Dr. Mark Hyman: Uh, and it wasn't barely touching anything. And I, and I, I was basically navigating it after my surgery and got off the narcotics pretty fast. And my, my, um, my doctor was helping me get off the opiates because I did not want to be on them and I didn't really like it. Uh, and I don't have an addictive personality. So it wasn't like, I was like, oh great. I get to be on this. I, I, he's like, he saw, he never saw anybody come off it so fast. And I, and I was still in quite a bit of discomfort, but every day I would, you know, basically when I couldn't even walk, I would, I would get on the floor with my physical therapist and I would put a band around my knees and I would open my legs and just do a little bit of like activation of my muscles.
54:01Dr. Mark Hyman: Uh, I couldn't even do a bridge. I couldn't even like lift my hips up off the ground. I was in so much pain. So I w I would, I was able to sort of slowly with just the daily movement come out of this. And now it's almost two years later. I'm like, I'm doing so great because I moved through that and I, and it wasn't like it wasn't hurting while I was doing. In fact, the pain was pretty severe from for about eight or nine months after the surgery. And I wasn't taking anything, but I was able to still continue to do this movement practice and to eat well and do all the things I had to do to heal because I knew I'd get to the other side of it.
54:40Dr. Mark Hyman: But most people don't have that experience and don't know, like they're not a doctor like I am and don't understand what's actually happening and have all sorts of beliefs and fears about it. And your model really is helping people to kind of move past that and to actually realize that there is a way to think about it differently. There is a way to actually resolve this. And what's really interesting looking at some of the research and some of your studies and cases is that there are people who have been in severe pain, like 10 out of 10, and then get to zero when they were told they never could.
55:14Dr. Mark Hyman: So I wanted to sort of maybe share a few stories of hope around that, just to help people understand this is not just an abstract idea, but this is actually happening day to day when people lean into this approach. Totally. And also I want to address a really important point you made, and I'm glad you made it, which is when we talk about pain as a whole person problem, something that involves, of course, our body, but also our brain and also our environment, what we're saying is that pain requires a whole person solution. So like, sure, great. Yes, pain medications, especially for acute pain, but we also want a PT, a physical therapist, and maybe an OT.
55:54And like, by the way, great to get a therapist. I'm so tired of the stigma around this. Like if our physical health is important, so too is our emotional health, especially now that we know that the parts of the brain that make emotions also make pain. Like anxiety and depression are not only predictors of pain, they are pain amplifiers. Like when we take care of our emotional health, we are taking care of our physical health. So I love that you brought up the PT because they are, PTs are a very important part of our healing protocol. So like, let's welcome a multidisciplinary team when we're trying to heal from pain, whether it's acute pain or chronic pain.
56:33You asked about patient stories. I have to tell you, Mark, like I wanted to be a writer since the time I was six years old. And my favorite author of all time was a doctor named Oliver Sacks. Have you ever read his?
56:45Dr. Mark Hyman: Oh yeah, of course. I loved him. Man who mistook his wife for a hat. The man who mistook his wife for a hat. And I wanted to be Oliver Sacks when I grew up. And so what I pitched to the publishers, the book was published by Hachette Grand Central. And what I pitched to them essentially was like a book on the science of pain written in the style of Oliver Sacks. And what made Oliver Sacks so amazing in my mind was that he would take some esoteric medical topic and tell you these luminous patient stories. And all of a sudden you were like, oh I'm interested in aphasia aphasia is cool like even if you've never heard of aphasia before and I sort of wanted to do the same thing with pain like pain is this aversive subject that no one wants to talk about but in my mind I thought like well maybe if I can tell some interesting stories it will sort of really illustrate and illuminate why there's so much hope around treating pain and also all the strategies that we can use to change it so I'm going to tell you a story that is very near and dear to my heart.
57:47This was one of my first chronic pain patients. And he came to me with chronic migraine and diffuse amplified body pain of unknown etiology, meaning he had pain all over his body, but at that point, no one really knew what it was or what was going on. And he was bedbound. He had been bedbound for four years and he had no life and no friends and no hope. And the most important detail of the story, Mark, is that this person was 16 years old. He was 16. He had been in bed. He had been in bed since age 12. I will never forget him. We're going to call him Sam for the sake of the story. I am anonymizing him and changing some details, of course, but we're going to call, we're going to call him Sam.
58:34And when Sam first came to my office, he had like long unwashed hair. He was pasty and pale and he sat on my couch and he rocked himself back and forth with the pain. And I remember thinking like he had been to Stanford and UCSF. And like, by the way, I teach at both of those places now because I feel like it's my mission in life to change the way we're talking about pain. But he was referred to me by Stanford. And I remember thinking like, who do I think I am? If Stanford can't make him better, like, why do I think I could? And I almost called his neurologist to say like, I can't do this. But instead, instead, I think of myself as a pain detective.
59:16And by that I mean, it's my job to figure out all the ingredients that are going into creating a high pain recipe so that I can help my patients change it. And I know that most professionals don't necessarily have that lens on pain. So I figured I would try. So I asked Sam some questions. I asked about his sleep and I learned that Sam was staying up playing video games till four in the morning and then sleeping until two. And he hadn't been going to school for four years. I asked Sam about food. Sam was on what I like to call a white food diet. The white food diet is quite popular. It wasn't tofu and cauliflower flour or fish.
1:00:00No, it was not. Sam was really into bread, pizza, pasta, cereal, but he just didn't like fruits and vegetables. And so he wasn't eating them. And I also asked Sam about his social health and Sam was completely isolated. He was not seeing anyone. I asked Sam about his physical activity. He was reading books and playing video games. That was the extent of it. So pretty quickly, I could see what his pain recipe was and, you know, met with his family. His parents came to my office. We had like a come to Jesus conversation. And slowly over time, we started changing the ingredients in his high pain recipe.
1:00:39So, you know, Sam started eating a fruit or a vegetable with every meal. I put him on a pacing protocol before we talked about what pacing means. So for Sam, what it meant for Sam, Sam's goal was to get back to soccer. He loved playing soccer. And like, did I think he could get there? I was not sure. But we put together a pacing protocol. And Sam's pain was so bad that week one, all he could do was stand outside on his porch in the sun. That's it. Week two, he walked to the corner mailbox and mailed a letter. Like his mom would literally give him some bills to mail. Week three, he was walking around the block.
1:01:17Week four, he was taking his dog to the dog park and like an on and on. And we put together also a pacing protocol for his social health. And what we noticed was that as his social health improved, as his mood improved, as he started moving his body and eating better and sleeping better, slowly over time, pain volume was going down. The more Sam did, the more he realized he could do. He did eventually go back to soccer. He did eventually go back to school. And I have to tell you, he showed up at my office, this kid formerly paralyzed by pain. He showed up at my office with a backpack and like a pencil case.
1:02:01He was grinning from ear to ear. I had like full body chills. He invited me to his high school graduation and he got on stage and he said, if you had told me four years ago, I'd be graduating high school. I never would have believed you. Like the program works. It works for, it works for even extreme cases. And, and I think these stories are so meaningful because they really remind us that, you know, even if you, even if you think that like you're the exception, you're the foregone conclusion, it's not going to work for you. there is hope and there are so many ingredients we can help you change.
1:02:36Dr. Mark Hyman: Yeah. Look at me. I, I, I'm planning on going back skiing and back into tennis and doing all the things I love to do. And, uh, you know, I think it's, it's never too late. Uh, and I think, I think, you know, unfortunately your work is not the kind of thing that, that most doctors learn about. And so it, it, it's a shame. And I think, you know, this is approached, these stories are so inspirational and they're so helpful and they help us sort of reframe our relationship to pain and understand that actually there's a pathway that's not necessarily straightforward but it involves a lot of different things dealing with the actual structural and biological factors dealing with the psychological factors and the and the obviously the environmental and social factors which play a huge role and that some of them we have more control over than others you know sometimes social isolation is not our choosing but if you were to sort of re-educate doctors, you want to change how they talk to patients who come in their office with pain.
1:03:31Dr. Mark Hyman: What would you tell them to say? Yeah, I mean, and that is what I'm doing. I'm teaching at Stanford and UCSF the next generation of medical doctors for that very reason. And I do think one of the most important things that I teach doctors is this concept of a pain recipe. It's extremely intuitive. Everybody knows that sleep is an important ingredient. Diet and nutrition is an important ingredient. Our emotional health, our social health, our environmental health, and of course, our biological health, our anatomy, our physiology, our brain chemistry. So I think presenting it this way creates a very clear picture.
1:04:03Like what we are not saying, we are not saying that pain is just emotional. We are not saying pain is all in our heads. And we are also not saying the opposite, that pain is just anatomical. So I think this creates sort of like a very robust, data-driven, evidence-based protocol for treating pain that everybody can get around.
1:04:23Dr. Mark Hyman: The beautiful thing about the pain recipe is that it implies there's ingredients like any recipe. And there's different ingredients for different people depending on what their particular pain is. And that's why it's such a beautiful model. And I think, you know, that's something most doctors can get their head around. And most people can get their head around that. It's about personalization. It's about figuring what's going on for you, what works for you, and then leaning into those things. And sometimes, you know, I find, for example, if I do saunas and cold plunges, it just helps a lot with my pain.
1:04:52Dr. Mark Hyman: so and i can kind of be pain free but if i just sit around all day or i'm like you know sitting on podcasts for hours all day then i'm like i have to go do something afterwards and kind of but but but at the end of the day what i've learned is as a pain patient essentially not just a doctor is that i've been active dialogue with my pain and i have to be an active relationship with it and actively manage it in a way that's not burdensome or onerous but that actually is liberating and allows me to become more free, more engaged in life, be able to do what I want, to be free, to actually, you know, even move through life when I'm a little bit uncomfortable, if I have to, but also to know how to actually dial the pain way down when I do all those things that are providing the right recipe for me.
1:05:37Dr. Mark Hyman: And so I think that's the message of hope. People have been told there's nothing else we can do by their doctor. What would you want them to understand before we close about their capacities to heal and about their brain and their body and this whole framework that you've developed? I think nothing bothers me more than when patients come to my office and they tell me like, oh, I Googled chronic pain or I Googled fibromyalgia and the internet says there's no treatment or cure. Like nothing makes me angrier. Or like they've been to a doctor and the doctor has said, you know, you've tried every medication, We've tried every procedure.
1:06:12We've done everything under the sun. I'm like, sorry, the best we can do for you is to just like learn how to live with your pain. And I feel like we're doing patients such a terrible disservice. Like everyone deserves, everyone deserves to understand pain. Every healthcare provider should be learning the biopsychosocial model of pain. Every patient, and by every patient, I mean every single one of us, deserves to understand the science of how pain works. Like I said this at the beginning, pain is coming for all of us one day. If it hasn't already, be it like, you know, childbirth or a bad back or just inhabiting an aging body.
1:06:50We are all pain patients and it's time for us to take power over pain.
1:06:54Dr. Mark Hyman: Amazing. Well, thank you, Rachel. Thank you for your work. Your book is Tell Me Where It Hurts, The New Science of Pain and How to Heal. It's out now. It came out in spring. Congratulations. patience and uh your website is zoffness.com which is yeah it's just my last name your last name i don't know how you got that uh and then your social media where people can find you is where did you say you don't know how i got my well i mean no no i don't know how you got like the website that's just your last name like no one else with that last name picked it this is great no no one else picked it so zoffness.com and on social media i'm at the real docs off on instagram and I'm Rachel Zofnitz pretty much anywhere else.
1:07:33The website has a resources page that I've been putting together for about 15 years. So whether you have pain or you know someone who's living with pain or you love someone in pain, the resources page has like a lot of articles that mention the topics we've talked about here today. It has book recommendations. It has guided audio for pain. It has how to find a healthcare provider. You know, it has podcasts. I'll put this one up there. It has like a ton of resources and they're zero cost and they're for anybody who wants to learn more.
1:08:04Dr. Mark Hyman: Thank you. Thank you, Rachel. Thanks for your work and thank you for helping people like me not be in pain. I talk a lot about how important it is to take care of your health, but trust me, I also know how easy it is to put it on the back burner. We get busy, life gets in the way, and before you know it, another year has gone by. And one of the things I'm most passionate about is helping people understand that they have more control over their health than they might think. That's a big part of why I created my 10-Day Detox. It's something I've seen make a real difference in helping people rethink how they eat, support their bodies, and start building healthier habits.
1:08:37And I love seeing people go through the experience together.
1:08:41Dr. Mark Hyman: So this year, we're making it easier to get started. My Black Friday sale is happening now, and you can get 30 % off 10-Day Detox, my supplement stacks, and the Brain Shaping Academy. And on January 12th, my team and I are hosting a special 10-Day Detox group experience. We'll be going through it together, answering questions and helping you get the most out of the program. If you've been thinking about making your health more of a priority, I'd love to have you join us. You can get started now and save 30%. If you love this podcast, please share it with someone else you think would also enjoy it.
1:09:10Dr. Mark Hyman: You can find me on all social media channels at Dr. Mark Hyman. Please reach out. I'd love to hear your comments and questions. Don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to The Dr. Hyman Show wherever you get your podcasts. And don't forget to check out my YouTube channel at Dr. Mark Hyman for video versions of this podcast and more. Thank you so much again for tuning in. We'll see you next time on The Dr. Hyman Show. This podcast is separate from my clinical practice at the Ultra Wellness Center, my work at Cleveland Clinic, and Function Health, where I am Chief Medical Officer. This podcast represents my opinions and my guests' opinions.
1:09:40Dr. Mark Hyman: Neither myself nor the podcast endorses the views or statements of my guests. This podcast is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional care by a doctor or other qualified medical professional. This podcast is provided with the understanding that it does not constitute medical or other professional advice or services. If you're looking for help in your journey, please seek out a qualified medical practitioner. And if you're looking for a functional medicine practitioner, visit my clinic, the Ultra Wellness Center at ultrawellnesscenter.com and request to become a patient.
1:10:10Dr. Mark Hyman: It's important to have someone in your corner who is a trained, licensed healthcare practitioner and can help you make changes, especially when it comes to your health. This podcast is free as part of my mission to bring practical ways of improving health to the public. So I'd like to express gratitude to sponsors that made today's podcast possible. Thanks so much again for listening. When it comes to supplements, you only want the best for your body, the kind with the highest quality, cleanest, and most potent ingredients you can get. That's exactly what you'll find at my supplement store, where I've hand-selected each and every product to meet the most rigorous standards for safety, purity, and effectiveness.
1:10:43Dr. Mark Hyman: These are the only supplements I recommend to my patients, and they're also what I use myself. Whether you want to optimize longevity or reduce your disease risk, or you're looking to improve your sleep, blood sugar, metabolism, gut health, you name it, drhyman.com has the world's best selection of top quality premium supplements, all backed by science and expertly vetted by me, Dr. Mark Hyman. So check out drhyman.com because when it comes to your health, nothing less than the very best will do. That's drhyman.com, D-R-H-Y-M-A-N.com. There's something worth knowing before the holidays hit. It's called the carryover effect.
1:11:17Dr. Mark Hyman: And every year, the average person gains about a pound between now and New Year's. Now, a pound is nothing, but that's typically just a normal weight fluctuation. But the carryover effect, that's what can create problems over a long period of time. So researchers have found that for most people, holiday weight doesn't go away. It carries over to the next year and the year after that. So over time, you end up with more inflammation, more fatigue, more brain fog, more joint pain. Now, I want you to enjoy the holidays. I do. I promise. I certainly plan to. But what you do between the celebrations matters just as much as what you do during.
1:11:50Dr. Mark Hyman: So here's what I want to ask you. What if this year, instead of adding to your health deficit, you actually improved your health? The 10-Day Detox is a program that I recommend to all my patients when they need a reset. There's no calorie counting. There's no skipping meals. You can still eat as much as you want, but you'll be eating the right things. You're going to follow a guided plan that uses real whole foods to overcome food cravings, reduce symptoms like brain fog, bloating, fatigue, and joint pain. Right now, the 10-Day Detox is 30 % off. It's the biggest discount I offer all year. You can start before the holidays, or you can save it for January if you'd rather kick off 2027 strong.
1:12:26Dr. Mark Hyman: Either way, I'm going to leave the details below.
I’ve lived with back pain since a ruptured disc in my early thirties. More than thirty years later, I’m grateful to be feeling better than I have in decades.
I’m excited to be talking with Rachel Zoffness, PhD, a pain psychologist and author of Tell Me Where It Hurts. We explore how the body, brain, and environment work together to shape what we feel—and how understanding those connections can open up more ways to find relief.
Here’s what we get into:
Why your MRI may not tell the whole story about your pain
How chronic pain can make your nervous system more sensitive over time
What stress, mood, and attention have to do with turning your “pain dial” up or down
How to identify your personal “pain recipe,” including sleep, movement, and connection
What pacing looks like—and how it can help you gradually return to activities you love
A big thing I’ve learned from my own recovery is how much it matters to get back to doing what you love. Part of that has been learning to tune in to my body and recognize when I need to step away from work, move a little, or get some rest. If you’re living with pain, noticing what makes a day better or worse for you can be an important first step.
For more on understanding and managing pain, explore Rachel’s resources page, with articles, guided audio, and tools to help you find a provider.
Every week on the podcast, we explore ways to feel better and stay healthy as we age. To help you put those conversations into practice, I’m offering 30% off my 10-Day Detox, Brainshaping, and Foundational Supplement Stack. And there’s more to come: watch your inbox for Black Friday offers from familiar brands and a few new names I’m excited to introduce.
View Show Notes From This Episode
Sign up for Dr. Hyman’s Brainshaping Academy to learn how to nourish the biological systems that support your mental, emotional, and cognitive health https://drhyman.com/products/brainshaping?utm_source=dr_hyman_show&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=may_27&utm_content=link
Get Free Weekly Health Tips from Dr. Hymanhttps://drhyman.com/pages/picks?utm_campaign=shownotes&utm_medium=banner&utm_source=podcast
Sign Up for Dr. Hyman’s Weekly Longevity Journalhttps://drhyman.com/pages/longevity?utm_campaign=shownotes&utm_medium=banner&utm_source=podcast
Join the 10-Day Detox to Reset Your Healthhttps://drhyman.com/pages/10-day-detox
Join the Hyman Hive for Expert Support and Real Resultshttps://drhyman.com/pages/hyman-hive
This episode is brought to you by Seed, Seatopia, Timeline, Rho, Sunlighten, and Fatty15.
Make your microbiome part of your daily routine with seed.com/hyman and save 25% with code 25HYMAN.
Find a cleaner source of seafood. Check out seatopia.fish and use code HYMAN for free shipping on your first order.
Support healthy aging and get up to 20% off when you subscribe on top of the new starting price of $79 at timeline.com/drhyman.
Explore science-backed products at rhonutrition.com and use code HYMAN for 20% off the entire site.
Discover why so many people are using sunlighten.com. Use code HYMAN to save up to $2,100 today and free shipping.
Head to fatty15.com/HYMAN today and use code HYMAN for 15% off your 90-day subscription Starter Kit.
0:00 Pain Is Biopsychosocial
3:00 Mark Hyman’s Personal Pain Story
6:59 The Biomedical Pain Myth
13:40 Hurt and Harm Are Different
16:36 Usain Bolt and Damage without Pain
20:20 The Brain Constructs Pain
26:00 Acute Pain Versus Chronic Pain
30:50 The Tale of Two Nails
35:16 Neuroplasticity and Pacing
39:12 The Pain Dial
42:32 The Pain Recipe
56:31 Sam’s Recovery from Chronic Pain



